Italy has one of the lowest birth rates in the world and involuntary childlessness is becoming an increasing reality. After several unsuccessful attempts, some prospective parents embark on the road to having a child through assisted...
moreItaly has one of the lowest birth rates in the world and involuntary childlessness is becoming an increasing reality. After several unsuccessful attempts, some prospective parents embark on the road to having a child through assisted procreation, a road that requires time, patience and money and is not without difficulties and pitfalls.
In the Italian context this situation is worsened by the fact that not being able to have children is a taboo not to be discussed openly. Those who have had recourse to assisted procreation often do so in secret. Moreover, Italy boasts one of the most restrictive laws in the field of assisted reproduction (the so called “Legge 40”) and the Catholic Church condemns these treatments. In an age where almost anything is considered possible, having children is not always as easy, obvious and “natural” as it seems, and infertility is becoming a serious social problem. However, it is indicative that in publishing and – often anonymously – on blogs and Internet forums, the subject has begun to be discussed. These are symptoms of a problem that exists and is finally beginning to emerge and be addressed. In my paper, I will consider some theoretical issues in sociology related to the consequences of childlessness after IVF treatment. I will be looking at texts by Lisa Corva (Confessioni di un’aspirante madre, 2005) and Eleonora Mazzoni (Le difettose, 2012) which both deal with a quest for motherhood through assisted procreation. With references to Gayle Letherby (Mother or Not, Mother or What? Problems and Definition of Identity, 1994; Other than Mother and Mothers as Others: the Experience of Motherhood and Non-Motherhood in Relation to “Infertility” and “Involuntary Childlessness”, 1999; Challenging Dominant Discourses: Identity and Change and the Experience of ‘Infertility’ and ‘Involuntary Childlessness’, 2002), James H. Monach (Childless: No Choice. The Experience of Involuntary Childlessness, 1993) and Karen Throsby (When IVF Fails. Feminism, Infertility and the Negotiation of Normality, 2004), among others, I will investigate issues related to the female protagonists’ desire for motherhood in these novels, and their negotiation with “normality” and female identity when IVF fails.