1 2 3 4 Title Does not reflect Reflects Reflects Reflects variables/concepts of variables/concept of the variables/concepts variables/concepts of the readings and does study but overused interesting and new the readings, catchy, not catch attention interesting, and new Lead Does not introduce the Introduction is not clear Introduction presents Introduction presents topic and does not link to the stand, cites references to stand, cites references to topic support claims to the support claims to the topic topic, draw insights from has been read Content Premises were not Some premises were Premises drawn were Premises drawn were drawn from the readings drawn from readings but appropriate and appropriate, discussed not reacted on discussed with some in full, and directly details addresses stand Closure Presents an illogical Presents an illogical Presents a logical Presents a logical explanation of findings explanation for findings explanation for findings explanation for findings and does not address and addresses a few and most of the and addresses all or contents from the concepts from the premises were most of the premises in readings readings addressed the readings and offered new dimensions. Application Not based on readings Based on readings but Based on readings but Based on readings and somewhat irrelevant incomplete complete Grammar and spelling Very frequent grammar More than 10 errors Only five or less errors All grammar and and spelling or both spelling are correct errors Total number and Less than 200 words Less than 200 words More than 500 words, 200-500 words, composition of words and poorly written with some complete and well- complete and well- inconsistencies written written