International Journal of Innovative Scientific & Engineering

Technologies Research 7(1):1-6, Jan-Mar., 2019

© SEAHI PUBLICATIONS, 2019 www.seahipaj.org ISSN: 2360-896X

Assessment of Health, Safety and Environment Procedures

in Technical Colleges’ Workshops in Rivers State
*Okwelle, P. Chijioke (Ph. D) & Normakoh, Josephine

Department of Vocational and Technology Education

Rivers State University, Port Harcourt, Nigeria
*Corresponding Author: [email protected]

ABSTRACT
This study assessed the Health, Safety and Environment Procedures in Workshops in Technical Colleges
in Rivers State. The study adopted a descriptive survey design. A sample of 50 teachers/instructors and
300 students in the five Technical Colleges were selected randomly, making a total sample size of 350
respondents. The instrument for data collection was a structured questionnaire validated by three experts
and the reliability of the instrument was ascertained using the test retest method to obtain a reliability
coefficient of 0.89. Data collected were analyzed using the statistical mean. The findings of the study
revealed among other things that the level of awareness and observance of Health, Safety and
Environment procedures in technical colleges in Rivers State is very low. It was recommended therefore
that teachers in technical colleges should be sponsored to attend short term Health, Safety and
Environment Procedures courses with the aim to equip them with the much needed knowledge and skills
necessary to be safety conscious and educate their students on safety procedures while in the workshop.
Keywords: Health, Safety, Environment, Workshop, Technical College

INTRODUCTION
Technical colleges are institutions that provide secondary level education in technical and vocational
education and training (TVET). According to Federal Republic of Nigeria (2013) in its national policy on
education, TVET is used as a comprehensive term referring to those aspects of educational process
involving, in addition to general education, the study of technologies and related sciences and the
acquisition of practical skills, attitudes, understanding and knowledge relating to occupations in various
sectors of economic and social life. Okwelle and Okeke (2016) stressed that one of the feature of TVET is
its orientation towards the world of work and the emphasis on the curriculum on the acquisition of
employable skills. Specifically, technical colleges are post primary schools in Nigeria, designed to
prepare individuals to acquire practical skills, basic scientific knowledge and attitude required as
craftsmen and technicians at sub-professional levels (Akpan, 2003). These colleges are regarded as the
principal vocational institutions that give full vocational training intended to prepare students for entry
into various occupations as artisans and craftsmen. Given the practical nature of technical colleges, where
the emphasis is on the acquisition of work related skills, the need for workshops where practical skills are
taught is pertinent.
Workshops according to Umar (2010) refers to infrastructural facility containing tools, equipment,
utilities and spaces for conducting technological and technical instructional activities.
Similarly, Baba (in Amenger, 2013) refers to workshop as a room or building where tools and machines
are used for making or repairing things. Some workshops contain machines, hazardous chemicals and
other equipment which could be harmful to humans if not properly handled. Since these workshops are
set up to teach students who may not have prior knowledge of the operations of these machines, the
tendency for accidents and “near misses” to happen becomes inevitable. Supporting this, Nick (in

1
 Okwelle & Normakoh.…. Int. J. Inno. Scientific & Eng. Tech. Res. 7(1):1-6, 2019

Amenger, 2013) asserted that frequent accidents in the workshops lead to loss of confidence by the
students and staff thereby discouraging learning and production processes. This underscores the need for
a well-articulated Health, Safety and Environment plan which takes into cognizance the need for students
and teachers alike to observe safety standards and procedures in the use of these workshops. Such plans
should also ensure some safety equipment is put in place in these workshops to reduce the impact of
accidents when they happen. Health, Safety and Environment (HSE) refers to measures put in place to
ensure employers and employees in work places stay physically healthy, free from danger or harm (injury
or damage) and the environment in which they work sustains the quality of life of the people and
activities located within its confines (Nigeria Institute of Safety Professionals, 2015).
Health as a component of HSE is a state of being free from illness or injury. World Health Organization
(WHO) in Business Dictionary (2017) defines health as a "State of complete physical, mental, and social
well-being, and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity." Health is a dynamic condition resulting
from a body's constant adjustment and adaptation in response to stresses and changes in the environment
for maintaining an inner equilibrium called homeostasis. On the other hand, safety is referred to a state of
being free from danger or harm (injury or damage)(NISP, 2015). Similarly, Parsha and Bansal (2008)
defined safety as the art and science of identifying, evaluation and controlling work place hazards. They
further stated that safety is the state of being certain that adverse effect will not be caused by some agents
under defined condition. Furthermore, environment refers to all that surrounds humans on earth. Nick in
NISP (2015) defined the environment as everything around a living being especially the circumstances of
life of people or society in their life conditions. It comprises the set of natural, social and cultural values
existing in a place and at a particular time, that influence in the life of the human being and in the
generations to come. In this context, it is not only the space in which life develops, but it also includes
living beings, objects, water, soil, air and the relations between them as well as intangibles like culture. In
the same vein, New Age International (2015) defines environment literally means surrounding and
everything that affect an organism during its lifetime is collectively known as its environment. In another
words environment can be said to be the sum total of water, air and land interrelationships among
themselves and also with the human being, other living organisms and property.
Workshops in technical colleges generally are filled with potential hazards due to the nature of training
being carried out. Electrical activities for example expose students and teachers alike to electric shock
which can lead to injury, lose of property or death. Similarly, some fire related machines for welding,
combustible materials and chemicals and machines could lead to fire outbreak. The onus therefore is on
the teachers and students in technical colleges to ensure they observe safety procedures while in the
workshop. This view was shared by Bulama, Quahha,Tika and Gayus (2010) when they observed that
the prevention of accidents in a college workshop is the duty of every staff and student working in the
workshop. For a technical education teacher as a safety manager ensuring the safety of others including
human as well as the facilities is of particular importance. This is because he is like a captain of a ship, he
direct, coordinates and organizes the affairs of the workshop. This paper, therefore, assessed the level of
awareness and compliance on HSE procedures by both teachers and students in workshops in technical
colleges in Rivers State.
Statement of the Problem
Activities in workshops in technical colleges involve the use of people (students and teachers/Instructors),
machines, materials, chemicals and the environment. Most of these machines, chemicals and materials are
dangerous and harmful to human health, safety and the environment if not properly handled. This exposes
both students and teachers to the risk of being injured while working in the workshops or in worst case
scenario, death. Successive governments over the years have not paid attention to proper funding of
technical colleges in Rivers State and the nation at large (Okwelle & Okeke, 2016). This has led to
inadequate provision of safety facilities in these colleges. Safety equipment such as fire extinguishers and
personal protective equipment (PPE) are either not enough or unavailable. This problem is further
compounded by the fact that most facilitators in workshops do not have the necessary safety training even
though they have the technical know-how in the use of machines and materials. Consequently, they and
the students are exposed to accidents that lead to injury, damage of property and in worst cases fatality.

2
 Okwelle & Normakoh.…. Int. J. Inno. Scientific & Eng. Tech. Res. 7(1):1-6, 2019

An effort to determine the status of health, safety and environment procedures in workshops in technical
colleges in Rivers State prompted this study.
Purpose of the Study
The purpose of the study was to assess the health, safety and environment procedures in workshops in
technical colleges in Rivers State. The specific objectives of the study are to:
1. Find out if there are safety equipment in workshops in technical colleges in Rivers State
2. Ascertain the level of safety consciousness among students and facilitators in workshops in
technical colleges in Rivers State.
3. Find out the extent to which Health, Safety and Environment procedures are observed in technical
colleges in Rivers State.
Research Questions
1. What is the safety equipment available in workshops in technical colleges in Rivers State?
2. What is the level of HSE consciousness among students and facilitators in workshops in technical
colleges in Rivers State?
3. What is the extent of observance of HSE procedures in technical colleges in Rivers State?

METHODS
This study adopted a descriptive survey design. The area of study is Rivers state of Nigeria. The
population of the study was 100 teachers/Instructors and 1500 students in the four technical colleges in
Rivers State. These include Government Technical College, Eleogu, Government Technical College,
Ahoada, Government Technical College Tombia, and Government Technical College, Port Harcourt. A
sample of 50 teachers and 300 students in the five technical colleges were selected randomly, making a
total sample size of 350 respondents. The instrument for data collection was a self-made questionnaire
titled “Assessment of Health, Safety and Environment Procedures in Workshops in Technical Colleges
Questionnaire.”The instrument was structured on a 4-point rating. The instrument was validated by three
experts and the reliability of the instrument was ascertained with the test retest method and using the
Pearson Product Moment Correlation statistics to obtain a reliability coefficient of 0.89. The collected
data were analyzed using the mean statistics. Mean responses up to and above 2.50 were accepted and
mean responses of 2.49 and below were rejected.

RESULTS
The analysis of data in relation to each of the research questions are presented in Tables 1- 3
Research Question 1: What is the safety equipment available in workshops in technical colleges in
Rivers State?
Table 1: Mean Response for Safety Equipment Available in Workshops in Technical Colleges
S/N ITEMS MEAN DECISION
1 Fire extinguishers are available in workshops 1.80 Disagree

2 Personal Protective equipment are worn by 2.41 Disagree

teachers/Instructors and students when working in
the workshop
3 Electrical installations are fitted properly with 2.37 Disagree
cautions signs on them in workshops.
Grand Mean 2.20 Disagree

The results in Table 1 revealed that most of the respondents disagreed that there are fire extinguishers in
their workshop (1.80). Item 2 showed that majority of the respondents also disagreed that every teacher
and student has his/her personal protective equipment when working in the workshop (2.41). Item 3 in the
table revealed that majority of the respondents agreed that electrical installations in the respondents’
workshop are fitted properly with caution signs on them. With a grand mean of 2.20 therefore, the answer

3
 Okwelle & Normakoh.…. Int. J. Inno. Scientific & Eng. Tech. Res. 7(1):1-6, 2019

to research question one is that there is not enough safety equipment in workshops in technical colleges in
Rivers State.
Research Question 2: What is the level of HSE consciousness among students and facilitators in
workshops in technical colleges in Rivers State?
Table 2: Mean Response on the Level of HSE Consciousness among Students and Facilitators in
Workshops in Technical Colleges
S/N ITEMS MEAN DECISION
4 Students and teachers/Instructors are aware of 2.63 High Level
areas of possible hazards in workshops.
5 Students and teachers/Instructors are aware of 2.28 Low Level
HSE procedures in work place.
6 Teachers/Instructors and students keep record of 2.45 Low Level
accidents and near misses in the workshop

Grand Mean 2.45 Low Level

The results in Table 2 revealed that item 4 with a mean score of 2.63 showed that students and
teachers/instructors in workshops are aware of areas of possible hazards in their workshops to a high
level. Item 5 with a mean score of 2.28 revealed that the level of awareness on HSE procedures is low
among students and staff using technical workshop. Item 6 with a mean score of 2.45 however showed
that the level to which teachers/instructors and students keep record of accidents and near misses in
workshops is low. With a grand mean of 2.45 therefore, the answer to research question two is that the
level of HSE consciousness among students and facilitators in workshops in technical colleges in Rivers
State is low.
Research Question 3: What is the extent of observance of HSE procedures in technical colleges in Rivers
State?
Table 3: Mean Responses on Extent of Observance of HSE Procedures in Technical Colleges
S/N ITEMS MEAN DECISION
7 Teachers/Instructors ensure the use of 2.73 High Extent
personal protective equipment in the
workshops
8 There is periodic sensitization on safety 2.36 Low Extent
procedures to be adopted before using
the workshop.
9 There is enforcement of penalty for 2.70 High Extent
students who use the workshop without
their safety equipment.
10 Teachers/Instructors ensure there are 2.18 Low Extent
caution signs for harmful chemicals and
equipment in workshops
Grand Mean 2.49 Low Extent

Item 7 in Table 3 showed that teachers/instructors ensure the use of personal protective equipment in the
workshops in technical colleges to a high extent. (2.73). Item 8 also showed that with a mean score of
2.36 the extent to which sensitization on safety procedures to be adopted before using the workshop is
low. Item 9 further revealed that the extent of enforcement of penalty for students who use the workshop
without their safety equipment is high. Finally, item 10 showed that the extent to which teachers ensure
there is caution signs in college workshops for harmful chemicals and equipment is low. With a grand
mean of 2.49 therefore, the answer to research question three is that the extent of observance of HSE
procedures in technical colleges in Rivers State is low.

4
 Okwelle & Normakoh.…. Int. J. Inno. Scientific & Eng. Tech. Res. 7(1):1-6, 2019

Summary of Major Findings

The findings of the study are summarized as follows:
1. There is not enough safety equipment in workshops in technical colleges in Rivers State.
2. The level of HSE consciousness among students and facilitators in workshops in technical
colleges in Rivers State is low.
3. The extent of observance of HSE procedures in technical colleges in Rivers State is low.

DISCUSSION
The findings of the study on research question one revealed that there is shortage of safety equipment in
technical colleges in River State. They do not have fire extinguishers and they do not have adequate
personal protective equipment for everyone carrying out activities in the workshop. This is in line with
the findings of Bulama,.Quahha, Tikaand Gayus (2010). The result of the findings on research question
two also revealed that the level of HSE consciousness among teachers and students in technical colleges
in Rivers State is quite low. Students and teachers alike have little or no idea on what HSE procedures are
and so they do not observe these procedures. They are also not conscious of their activities that portend
danger and hazard in the workshops. This is in consistent with the findings Greenshield in Akpan (2003)
that most college students are ignorant or unaware of the safe method of working and have inadequate
knowledge of environmental hazards in workshop.
The findings on research question three further revealed that the extent of observance of HSE procedures
in workshops in technical colleges in Rivers State is low. There are no strict enforcement of the use of
personal protective equipment, periodic pep talk on safety procedures to be adopted are not given to
students and caution signs are not placed on places, chemicals or equipment that have potential to cause
hazard. This is in contrast with the Factories Act of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (1990) which states
that all safety rules and regulations in workshops and workplace must be enforced to the later to ensure
the safety of the students, teachers/instructors and facilities. This finding is also in line with the assertion
of Okon (2011) that enforcement of safety practices in technical colleges is the responsibility of all
stakeholders in technical college administration. A committed technical education teacher strives to
ensure that all safety rules and regulations are strictly obeyed.

CONCLUSION
The need for a careful consideration of safety procedures in workshops in technical colleges is borne out
of the fact that activities carried out in these workshops and the equipment used for such activities pose
great threat to humans, property and the environment. Even though there is no proper record of incidence
of accidents in technical workshops in Rivers State, there is a consensus among teachers/instructors and
students in these workshops on the need for the enforcement of safety procedures. This is largely due to
the hazards these people are faced with daily in their workshops. This underscores the need for Health
Safety and Environment procedures in workshops in technical. Unfortunately, most of these workshops
have insufficient safety equipment and in places where they are available, there is no strict enforcement in
the use of these equipments by both students and teachers/instructors alike. This is largely due to the low
level of awareness among teachers in technical colleges on standard HSE procedures in workplace or
workshops as is the case here.

RECOMMENDATIONS
Based on the findings of the study, the following recommendations were made:
1. The Government and other concerned agencies should provide adequate safety equipment in
workshops in technical colleges to reduce the incidence and impact of accidents on students and
teachers alike.
2. Teachers in technical colleges should be sponsored to attend short term HSEcourses with
institutions such as the Nigerian Institute of Safety Professionals. This will equip them with the
much needed knowledge and skills necessary to be safety conscious and educate their students on
safety procedures while in the workshop.

5
 Okwelle & Normakoh.…. Int. J. Inno. Scientific & Eng. Tech. Res. 7(1):1-6, 2019

3. Teachers/instructors using workshops in technical colleges should ensure they educate students
on safety procedures before practical works are carried out in this workshops every day.

REFERENCES
Akpan, A. C. ((2003). The quality of training received in electricity and electronics programme by
technical college graduates in Akwa Ibom State. An Unpublished M.Ed Thesis. Department of
Vocational Teacher Education, University of Nigeria, Nsukka
Amenger, M. (2013).Workshop Management Techniques Needed for Improving the Teaching of
Electrical Technology in Technical Colleges in Benue State. Unpublished M.Ed Dissertation,
University of Nigeria, Nsukka
Bulama, K. H., Quahha, D. W., Tika T.J. & Gayus R. N. (2010). Role of technology and vocational
education teacher as a safetymanager in technical colleges. The Nigerian Academic Forum. 19 (2)
1-6
Business Dictionary (2017) What is health? Definition and meaning. Accessed on 6th November, 2017
from www.businessdictionary.com/definition/health
Ezeji, S.C.O.A. (2005). A guide to preparation industrial art laboratories and facilities planning.
Unpublished Lecture Notes for M.Ed Programme. VTE Development, UNN.
Federal Republic of Nigeria, (2013). National Policy on Education (6th edition) Abuja: NERDC
Press.
Federal Republic of Nigeria, (1990). The laws of the federation of Nigeria. Factories Act (CAP
126
Nigeria Institute of Safety Professionals (2015) General HSE training manual. Handbook for General
HSE training.
New Age International (2016). Definition of environment. Accessed on the 6th of November from
www.newagepublishers.com/samplechapter/001773.pd
Okon, O. E. (2011). Safety practice skills required by metal work students of technical colleges for
effective operation in the workshop in Akwa Ibom State. Unpublished M.Ed Dissertation.
Department of Vocational Teacher Education, University of Nsukka.
Okwelle, P. C. & Okeke, B. C. (2016). An overview of the role of technical vocational education and
training (TVET) for national development of Nigeria. African Journal of Historical Sciences in
Education, 12(1), 167 - 182.
Umar, M.A (2010). Planning school workshops for effective practical instructions as a tool towards
sustainable development in Nigeria. Nigeria Vocational Journal, 14, 1-6.
UNESCO (2007). Technical and vocational education. Retrieved November 2nd, 2017, from
http://www.unesco.org/