Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Electric Cars- A Scientfic Analysis

2018, A Scientific Look into Electric Cars in the 21st century

Running head: Electric vehicles: A scientific analysis Electric vehicles: A scientific analysis Bevan Watson Downingtown West High School 2018 Word Count: 1295 1 Electric vehicles: A scientific analysis 2 Introduction The debate between electric vehicles and internal combustion engine vehicles (ICEV) has existed since the invention of the electric vehicle in the mid-19th century. The question remains: Are electric cars a viable alternative to gasoline vehicles, in the western world? Research on this has been extensive, but it is clear vehicles powered by electric motors are scientifically superior to traditional vehicles and are not a feasible alternative to the ICEV. Functionality of different electric vehicles The definition of an electric vehicle is "an automobile that uses one or more electric engines." This meaning leaves lots of room of interpretation. The first type of electric vehicle and the most common is the Plug-in Lithium Ion battery. The Li-ion battery is a rechargeable battery, with extensive battery life. The only drawback of these batteries is the length of charge, and their lack to operate in mildly-extreme temperatures. According to Aishwarya Panday, a technology researcher in Pilar, India "It is appreciable to characterize the Li-ion battery to compute the SOC even in case of temperature variation dynamically. Li-ion battery has a significant effect of temperature on its performance and various parameters. Under optimal temperature, range batteries behave as prescribed, but outside battery cell experiences severe loss of capacity."(Panday, Bansal, Srinivasan 2018) Amid this restriction, Li-ion electric vehicle has shown an advantage (over ICEVs) to consumers in certain sectors, specifically the city. According to Dr. Eckard Helmers, a professor of University of Applied Sciences Trier in Birkfield, Germany, "In the next years, electric cars will be mostly small- or mid-size cars due to Electric vehicles: A scientific analysis 3 two main reasons: First, the weight limits the range of operation, which is a factor of suitability for daily use. Second… Larger and expensive cars need bigger and more expensive batteries"(Helmers and Marx 2014). Not only are electric cars limited in body size, but also driving distance. According to David Petechuk, a renowned environmental writer, "Electric cars are only able to travel approximately 100 miles (106.9 km) before they need to be recharged. Furthermore, this recharging takes a considerable amount of time compared to the relatively quick refueling that takes place at a local gas station" (Tulloch, Nagel, Petechuk 2006). Scientifically, plug-in electric cars are more suited for drivers in cities, where small cars are beneficial, and driving distances tend to be shorter. Hybrid Vehicles are another type of electric vehicle. A hybrid vehicle has an electric motor but also has a gasoline engine. The most common type of hybrid vehicle is the plug-in hybrid electric vehicle (PHEV), which contain a Lithium-Ion battery, and a standard internal combustion engine. The gasoline engine starts when the electric motor runs out of energy, or it is used to recharge the battery while the car is running. According to Petechuk, "While many of these combinations result in a longer drive range and improved performance, the need for two engines add weight and size to a vehicle." (Tulloch, Nagel, Petechuk 2006) Although the weight of two engines and battery does affect the range of a car, the additional electric engine compensates for the excess weight. Although these engines are capable of driving for longer distances without refueling, they are not always reliable. According to PJ Savagian, the fuel consumption benefits are limited by the underlying constraints of the base hybrid systems and vehicles. Even with incremental electric power and speed improvements, the PHEV's lack of full-performance, all-electric capability requires engine operation under normal speed and load Electric vehicles: A scientific analysis 4 conditions, regardless of available battery energy. ( Tate, Harpster, Savagian 2008). All the facts point to this conclusion; therefore electric vehicles are superior to hybrid vehicles and are a better option going forward. Engine model/ efficiency A top selling point of an automobile is the efficiency of its engine because the amount of fuel to go the x distance on y fuel can drive up the price of operating a vehicle, over time. Efficiency can also affect how long a vehicle lasts. According to Panday, [hybird electric vehicles]provides a more extended driving range and easy refueling (recharging) with reduced liquid fuel consumption and toxic emissions. Thus, PHEV is a means to reduce the energy demand and replacing the liquid fuel consumption by storing electrical energy in sizeable onboard rechargeable batteries with high fuel economy and better energy efficiency"(Panday, Bansal, Srinivasan 2018). While the price of buying a PHEV is higher than the average ICEV, the cost of refueling an ICEV exceeds that of a PHEV. (According to Helmers, "Auto Motor Sport reported 23.5 kWh/100 km in the electrical mode/100 km in the ICE modus for the [BEV] Opel Ampera...A [Hybrid] Toyota Prius plug-in consumes 3.4 L petrol/100 km in ICE mode according to an ADAC test and 21.8 kWh/100 km in the electrical mode, respectively." (Helmers, Marx 2014). According to the US energy information administration, the average Liter per 100 Kilometers of ICEV is 23.5 miles per gallon [10 L/km], (Annual Energy Review 2012). Therefore, although they have cost restrictions, Hybrid vehicles have optimal performance and efficiency. In BEV's, the efficiency standard is different. Since BEV's have no ICEV to serve as the backup, so in order to extend the life of a Lithium-Ion battery, the EV must have an efficient Electric vehicles: A scientific analysis 5 engine. According to EnerGuide.be, an omission that focuses on energy emissions in Brussels, "Most electric vehicles cover between 80 and 100 kilometers with 10 kWh. Their low energy loss makes means that they are not very energy intensive. While petrol or diesel engines convert a maximum of 35 % of this energy into driving force, an electric car reaches 90 % and more." (How much power does an electric car use? 2018). Since Lithium- Ion batteries do not have an unlimited lifetime; this is a crucial factor. Although Plug-in BEV's may drive up an electricity bill, their high efficiency makes them the best option, over ICEVs and PHEVs. Mobility Many people buy a particular type of car for a specific reason, whether it be occupational, recreational, or other. PHEV engines are mobile can be installed in a variety of vehicles. According to Wlodzimierz Choromanski, a professor at the Warsaw University of Technology, multifunctional steering wheel used in a car designed for both able-bodied people (of different ages) and disabled people (with paralysis of lower limbs). The design of the steering wheel provides all the functions of driving (including implementation) only with the help of upper limbs. This also applies to the accelerator and brake functions, using special rings." (Choromanski, Kozlowski Grabarek 2015) This type of drivetrain could not be manufactured with an ICEV engine, giving an advantage to the electric car industry. Also, the Lithium-Ion battery is "reusable," in a sense. According to Egoitz Martinez-Laserna an expert in Control Systems Engineering and Electrical Engineering, "the concept of giving a second life to electric vehicle batteries simply consists of reusing the batteries that do not meet any longer the requirements of automotive applications, but which could still be used on less-demanding grid-connected energy storage applications" (E. Martinez-Laserna, I. Gandiaga, E. Electric vehicles: A scientific analysis 6 Sarasketa-Zabala, J. Badeda 2018). If Lithium-Ion batteries can be used for other applications or sold for profit, this drives down the price of replacing the battery, giving the BEV a longer life. An ICEV engine is not recyclable outside its particular model. The BEV is superior to the ICEV in scientific mobility. Conclusion The plug-in electric vehicle is superior to the internal combustion engine vehicle in the areas of engine functionality, efficiency, mobility. Hybrid cars may appear to be the best option, but restrictions in the area of energy and cost efficiency make BEV’s a more reliable option. Going forward, electric are cars a viable alternative over gasoline vehicles, as demonstrated in the superiority they exhibit in the necessary areas. Electric vehicles: A scientific analysis 7 References Automobile. (2011). In D. S. Blanchfield (Ed.), ​Environmental Encyclopedia​. Retrieved from Science In Context database. Choromanski, W., Kozlowski, M., & Grabarek, I. (2015, October). The concept of functional evaluation of innovative driver interface (HMI) on the example of multifunctional steering wheel in an electric car. ​Vibroengineering Procedia​, ​6​, 223+. Retrieved from Academic OneFile database. Helmers, E., & Marx, P. (2012). Electric cars: technical characteristics and environmental impacts. ​Environmental Sciences Europe​. Abstract retrieved from Springer open database. How much power does an electric car use​. (2018, August). Retrieved from https://www.energuide.be/en/questions-answers/how-much-power-does-an-electric-car-use/212/ Martinez-Laserna, E., Gandiaga, I., Sarasketa-Zabala, E., Badeda, J., Stroe, D.-I., Swierczynski, M., & Goikoetxea, A. (2018). Battery second life: Hype, hope or reality? A critical review of the state of the art. ​Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews​, ​93​, 701. Retrieved from Academic OneFile database. Panday, A., Bansal, H. O., & Srinivasan, P. (2016). Thermoelectric modeling and online SOC estimation of Li-Ion battery for plug-in hybrid electric vehicles. ​Modelling and Simulation in Engineering​. Retrieved from Academic OneFile database. Electric vehicles: A scientific analysis 8 Tate, E., Harpster, M., & Savagian, P. (n.d.). The electrification of the automobile: From conventional hybrid, to plug-in hybrids, to extended-range electric vehicles. ​SAE Int. J. Passeng. Cars - Electron. Electr. Syst​. :https://doi.org/10.4271/2008-01-0458 Tulloch, D., Nagel, M. C., & Petechuk, D. (2002). Will a viable alternative to the internal combustion engine exist within the next decade. In ​Science in Dispute​ (Vol. 1, pp. 67-75). Retrieved from Global Issues in Context database. U.S. Energy Information Administration. (2012, September). ​Annual energy review​. Retrieved from US eia website: https://www.eia.gov/totalenergy/data/annual/showtext.php?t=pTB