NaOH Alkali
NaOH Alkali
NaOH Alkali
DE PARIS
Ecole Doctorale 364 : Sciences Fondamentales et Appliques
Nattribu par la bibliothque
|__|__|__|__|__|__|__|__|__|__|
T H E S E
pour obtenir le grade de
Docteur de lEcole des Mines de Paris
Spcialit Science et gnie des matriaux
prsente et soutenue publiquement par
Mlle Magali EGAL
le 8 Dcembre 2006
STRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF CELLULOSE / NAOH
AQUEOUS SOLUTIONS, GELS
AND REGENERATED OBJECTS
Directeur de thse : Tatiana Budtova et Patrick Navard
Jury :
M. Jacques Desbrires Rapporteur
M. Volker Ribitsch Rapporteur
M. Jonathan Marshall Examinateur
M. Michel Pierre Examinateur
Mme Tatiana Budtova Examinateur
M. Patrick Navard Examinateur
Table of contents
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 1 -
T TA AB BL LE E O OF F C CO ON NT TE EN NT TS S
RESUME DU TRAVAIL DE THESE ..
INTRODUCTION ...
Rsum du Chapitre I
Etat de lart : La cellulose et sa dissolution dans des solutions aqueuses dhydroxyde de sodium
CHAPTER 1.
STATE OF THE ART: CELLULOSE AND ITS DISSOLUTION IN ALKALINE HYDROXIDE AQUEOUS SOLUTIONS ...
I.1- Cellulose: structure, morphology and treatment ...
I.1.1- Generalities ...
I.1.2- Chemical structure of cellulose ..
I.1.3- Crystalline structures of cellulose ..
I.1.3.1. Cellulose I or native cellulose
I.1.3.2. Cellulose II
I.1.3.3. Cellulose III ...
I.1.3.4. Cellulose IV ..
I.1.4- Supra-molecular structure of cellulose .
I.1.4.1. Micro-fibrils
I.1.4.2. Wood and cotton cellulose fibres ..
I.1.5- Extraction of cellulose and activation
I.1.5.1. Manufacture of cellulosic pulp ...
I.1.5.2. Activation of cellulose .
I.2- Cellulose dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
I.2.1- Xanthation in viscose process
I.2.2- Action of alkaline hydroxide solutions on cellulose fibres ..
I.2.2.1. Introduction on mercerisation process and cellulose dissolution .
I.2.2.2. Formation of alkali-celluloses
I.2.2.3. Hydration of alkali ions
I.2.2.4. Mechanism of mercerisation ..
I.2.3- Influence of additives on cellulose dissolution .
I.2.3.1. Influence of zinc oxide (ZnO) .
I.2.3.2. Influence of urea and thiourea ...
I.2.3.3. Other additives .
I.3- Conclusions .
REFERENCES
Rsum du chapitre II
Matriaux et mthodes exprimentales .
CHAPTER II
MATERIALS AND METHODS
II.1- Materials ..
II.1.1- Cellulose samples ...
II.1.1.1. Avicel cellulose
II.1.1.2. Borregaard cellulose ..
II.1.1.3. Other cellulose samples
II.1.2- Solvents and additives ...
II.1.2.1. Alkali hydroxides .
II.1.2.2. Additives ..
II.1.2.3. Surfactants ..
II.1.3- Other components used in sponge manufacture ..
5
17
21
23
25
25
26
27
27
28
29
29
29
29
30
32
32
33
35
36
37
37
40
41
43
45
45
46
49
50
51
57
59
61
61
61
61
62
62
62
62
62
62
Table of contents
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 2 -
II.1.3.1. Reinforcing fibres
II.1.3.2. Adhesion promoters ...
II.1.3.3. Na2SO4,10H2O crystals .
II.1.3.4. Carrageenan
II.2- Solutions preparation ...
II.2.1- Drying of steam exploded cellulose .
II.2.2- Dissolution procedure .
II.2.3- Storage .
II.2.4- Filtration
II.3- Methods
II.3.1- Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) .
II.3.1.1. Main principles
II.3.1.2. Temperature measurement ..
II.3.1.3. Melting temperature measurement ..
II.3.1.4. Melting enthalpy measurement
II.3.1.5. Calibration and experimental conditions .
II.3.1.6. Software for peak deconvolution: PeakFit 4.12 ..
II.3.2- X-ray diffraction
II.3.3- Rheology ..
II.3.3.1. Semi-dilute cellulose solution ...
II.3.3.2. Dilute cellulose solution .
II.3.4- Microscopy ...
II.3.4.1. Optical Microscopy (OM) ...
II.3.4.2. Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) .
II.3.5- Mechanical property: tensile tests
II.3.5.1. Tensile tests on films of regenerated cellulose ..
II.3.5.2. Tensile tests on regenerated cellulose + reinforcing fibres .
II.3.5.3. Tensile tests on sponges (regenerated cellulose + fibres + porophores) .
II.3.6- Other methods .
II.3.6.1. Density measurement
II.3.6.2. Water absorption
II.3.6.3. Shrinkage .
REFERENCES
Rsum du chapitre III
Structure des solutions aqueuses de NaOH et de cellulose/NaOH avec et sans additifs. Limite de
dissolution de la cellulose
CHAPTER III
STRUCTURE OF AQUEOUS NAOH AND CELLULOSE-NAOH SOLUTIONS WITH AND WITHOUT ADDITIVES. LIMIT OF
CELLULOSE DISSOLUTION .
III.1- Bibliography: phase diagram of aqueous sodium hydroxide solution ...
III.1.1- Phase diagrams .....
III.1.1.1. Binary phase diagram ...
III.1.1.2. Ternary phase diagram
III.1.1.3. Methods for building phase diagrams. The limits of the DSC analysis .
III.1.2- State of the art on the structure of NaOH aqueous solutions .
III.1.2.1. Pure sodium hydroxide
III.1.2.2. Sodium hydroxide hydrates .
III.2- Structure of cellulose solvents: NaOH/water, NaOH/urea/water and NaOH/ZnO/water ..
III.2.1- NaOH/water binary system ..
III.2.1.1. DSC melting thermograms of NaOH/water solutions ..
III.2.1.2. Peak at lower temperature: melting of the eutectic mixture
III.2.1.3. Peak at higher temperature .
III.2.1.4. Proportions between NaOH and water ..
III.2.1.5. Conclusions on the phase diagram and structure of NaOH/water solutions ...
III.2.2- NaOH/urea/water ternary system
III.2.2.1. Urea/water binary phase diagram ..
III.2.2.2. NaOH/urea/water ternary phase diagram .
III.2.3- NaOH/ZnO/water ternary system
III.2.3.1. Viscosity of dilute NaOH/ZnO/water solutions ..
62
63
63
63
64
64
65
67
67
69
69
69
71
72
74
74
75
76
77
77
78
79
79
80
81
81
83
84
85
85
85
85
86
87
91
93
93
93
94
95
97
97
98
101
101
101
102
105
105
107
108
108
113
118
119
Table of contents
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 3 -
III.2.3.2. NMR study ..
III.2.3.3. DSC results
III.2.3.4. Conclusions on the NaOH/ZnO/water system ..
III.2.4- Conclusions on the structure of cellulose solvents: NaOH/water, NaOH/ZnO/water
and NaOH/urea/water ...
III.3- Structure of cellulose solutions in NaOH/water, NaOH/ZnO/water and
NaOH/urea/water
III.3.1. Cellulose/NaOH/water ternary solutions
III.3.1.1. DSC results on Avicel/NaOH/water
III.3.1.2. Peak at low temperature. Limit of cellulose dissolution ..
III.3.1.3. Peak at high temperature .
III.3.1.4. Influence of cellulose origin on the structure of cellulose/NaOH/water
solutions ..
III.3.1.3. Conclusions .
III.3.2. Cellulose/NaOH/urea/water solutions .
III.3.2.1- DSC results on Avicel/NaOH/6%urea/water .
III.3.2.2. Peak of NaOH eutectic .
III.3.2.3. Peak of urea eutectic
III.3.2.4. Peak of free ice melting
III.3.2.5. Conclusions
III.3.3. Cellulose/NaOH/ZnO/water solution ...
III.3.4. Conclusions on the structure of cellulose solutions in NaOH/water with and without
additives ..
III.4- Influence of freezing on the thermal properties of the cellulose/NaOH mixtures
III.5- Conclusions .
REFERENCES
Rsum du chapitre IV
Ecoulement et glification des solutions aqueuses de cellulose/NaOH : Influence des additifs ..
CHAPTER IV
FLOW AND GELATION OF AQUEOUS CELLULOSE/NAOH SOLUTIONS: INFLUENCE OF ADDITIVES .
IV.1. Influence of ZnO and urea on the flow behaviour of cellulose/7.6NaOH aqueous
solutions
IV.1.1. Influence of the presence of ZnO or urea in the solvent on the flow of
cellulose/7.6NaOH aqueous solutions ...
IV.1.2. Conclusions
IV.2- Gelation and dissolution of cellulose in the presence of ZnO
IV.2.1. Influence of the preparation conditions on gelation of cellulose/7.6NaOH/water
solutions in the presence of ZnO
IV.2.2. Influence of ZnO concentration on gelation and cellulose dissolution ..
IV.2.3. Dissolution of cellulose in a solvent with a constant molar ratio ZnO:NaOH=1:10 .
IV.2.4. Influence of the presence of ZnO on gelation kinetics .
IV.2.5. Influence of ZnO on cellulose intrinsic viscosity ...
IV.2.6. Discussion on the influence of ZnO on gelation of steam exploded cellulose in
7.6NaOH aqueous solutions
IV.2.7. Conclusions
IV.3. Gelation and dissolution of cellulose in the presence of urea; comparison between
urea and ZnO
IV.3.1. Influence of the preparation conditions on cellulose dissolution and gelation in the
presence of urea and of urea concentration .
IV.3.2. Influence of cellulose DP and origin on the dissolution and gelation in the presence
of urea and ZnO .
IV.3.3. Discussion on the influence of urea on gelation and dissolution of steam exploded
cellulose in 7.6NaOH aqueous solutions and comparison with the role of ZnO .
IV.3.4. Conclusions ...............
IV.4. Influence of freezing on rheological properties of cellulose/NaOH aqueous solutions
IV.5- Tests on gelation and dissolution of cellulose in other alkali solvents: KOH and NaOH
120
121
125
126
127
127
127
128
132
132
134
135
135
136
137
137
138
138
139
140
144
147
149
151
153
153
159
160
161
163
165
165
167
169
171
172
172
175
179
181
181
Table of contents
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 4 -
with other additives
IV.5.1. Testing cellulose dissolution in potassium hydroxide ..
IV.5.2. Addition of surfactants ..
IV.5.3. Other additives: salts and oxides
IV.5.3. Conclusions
IV.6. Conclusions ...
REFERENCES
Rsum du chapitre V
Proprits mcaniques dobjets rgnrs prpars partir de solutions aqueuses de cellulose/NaOH
CHAPTER V.
MECHANICAL PROPERTIES OF REGENERATED OBJECTS PREPARED FROM CELLULOSE-NAOH AQUEOUS
SOLUTIONS
V.1. Summary on sponge preparation: viscose and NaOH processes ...
V.1.1. Viscose process ..
V.1.2. NaOH process .
V.2. Properties of sponges prepared with the NaOH process ..
V.2.1. Wet samples made from regenerated 5cellulose/7.6NaOH aqueous solutions, without
reinforcing fibres and porophores .
V.2.1.1. Tensile stress results .
V.2.1.2. Influence of regeneration bath parameters
V.2.1.3. Influence of solution thermal treatment ..
V.2.1.4. Influence of additives .
V.2.1.5. Conclusions
V.2.2. Wet samples made from regenerated 5cellulose/7.6NaOH aqueous solutions with
reinforcing fibres without porophores .
V.2.2.1. Influence of added reinforcing fibres ...
V.2.2.2. Influence of fibres treatment on the rupture stress ...
V.2.2.3. Influence of freezing on rupture stress and adhesion between fibres and
matrix ...
V.2.2.4. Influence of the thermal history of fibre treatment with 8%NaOH aqueous
solution on the mechanical properties of wet regenerated samples .
V.2.2.5. Conclusions .
V.2.3. Wet samples made from regenerated 5cellulose/7.6NaOH aqueous solutions with
reinforcing fibres and porophores ...
V.2.3.1. Rupture stress ..........................................................
V.2.3.2. Absorption ...
V.2.3.3. Shrinkage ....
V.2.4. Conclusion on the role of the freezing step ....
V.3. Conclusions
REFERENCES
CONCLUSIONS
APPENDIXES
183
183
185
187
188
189
190
193
195
197
197
199
201
202
202
203
203
205
205
206
206
207
208
211
213
213
214
215
217
219
221
222
223
227
Rsum du travail de thse
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 5 -
R
R
E
E
S
S
U
U
M
M
E
E
D
D
U
U
T
T
R
R
A
A
V
V
A
A
I
I
L
L
D
D
E
E
T
T
H
H
E
E
S
S
E
E
CONTEXTE DE LETUDE
La cellulose est un polymre naturel de la famille des polysaccharides. Elle est forme lors de la
photosynthse. La cellulose est le principal constituant des parois cellulaires des vgtaux et peut
donc tre extraite de lherbe, des feuilles, des tiges (essentiellement la paille), des arbres. Le coton
est trs pur en cellulose, jusqu 98% de la composition totale. Pour la prparation des ptes de
cellulose, le bois reste la source majoritaire dautant plus que les arbres sont aussi exploits dans
ce but. La cellulose est biodgradable sous laction des bactries.
Mais la cellulose est difficile mettre en oeuvre. Elle ne peut tre fondue car elle se dgrade avant
davoir atteint une fusion. Pour fabriquer des fibres, des films ou des objets tridimensionnels, la
cellulose doit tre soit dissoute dans des solvants directs, soit transforme chimiquement et tre
ensuite mise en forme.
Actuellement, le procd industriel le plus couramment utilis pour mettre en forme des objets
en cellulose pure est le procd dit viscose . La cellulose est dabord active par une solution
aqueuse de 18-20% dhydroxyde de sodium (NaOH) afin de faciliter la pntration du solvant. Le
sulfure de carbone (CS
2
) ragit alors avec les chanes de cellulose et forme le xanthate de
cellulose, soluble dans NaOH dilu. Le mlange ainsi obtenu est appel viscose et peut tre
mis en forme. La viscose est ensuite rgnre afin de retrouver la cellulose. Des objets varis
sont ainsi obtenus : fibres, films minces et objets tridimensionnels. Ce procd est trs efficace et
totalement matris. Cependant, lutilisation du CS
2
et le dgagement des composs soufrs issus
des ractions chimiques le rendent fortement polluant. A lheure actuelle, les rejets en phase
aqueuse (oxydes de soufre) sont totalement recycls tandis que les rejets atmosphriques (H
2
S) ne
reprsentent plus que 10% du CS
2
utilis. Mais les rglementations environnementales deviennent
de plus en plus contraignantes et les techniques de traitement de la pollution sont coteuses.
Rsum du travail de thse
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 6 -
Pour des raisons la fois conomiques et environnementales, les fabricants de produits finis
cellulosiques cherchent des alternatives pour mettre en forme la cellulose, le but tant de
supprimer ltape de transformation de la cellulose par le CS
2
et de trouver un solvant direct de la
cellulose non polluant et peu coteux.
Depuis le XIX
e
sicle, les industriels utilisent des solutions aqueuses dhydroxyde de sodium,
diffrentes concentrations, afin de modifier laspect et les proprits des fibres de cellulose. Dans
lindustrie textile, par exemple, les traitements la soude permettaient damliorer la brillance des
tissus ou labsorption des colorants.
En 1939, Sobue [SOB1939] montra que 7-10% de NaOH/eau pouvait tre un solvant direct de
la cellulose. De nos jours, plusieurs quipes de recherche dissolvent directement la cellulose dans
des solutions aqueuses dhydroxyde de sodium (7-10%NaOH/eau, en dessous de 0C) mais les
proprits des produits finis sont souvent infrieures celles obtenues par le procd viscose .
Le problme est que ni la dissolution de la cellulose dans 7-10%NaOH/eau, ni les proprits des
solutions cellulose/NaOH/eau ne sont bien comprises.
Deux partenaires industriels ont particip ce projet de recherche. Innovia Films Ltd, en
Grande-Bretagne, qui fabrique des films cellulosiques pour lemballage et Spontex, en France,
produisant des ponges cellulosiques.
Le but de ce travail est dexplorer la possibilit de prparer des films et ponges cellulosiques par
le procd soude tout en approfondissant les aspects plus fondamentaux de la dissolution de la
cellulose dans les solutions aqueuses peu concentres dhydroxyde de sodium. Le premier objectif
tait donc de comprendre la structure des solvants de la cellulose solution dhydroxyde de
sodium avec ou sans oxyde de zinc ou ure et la structure des solutions de cellulose dans ces
mmes solvants. Ensuite, nous avons tudi les proprits rhologiques des solutions de cellulose
en dterminant leur comportement lcoulement et les conditions de glification, en temps et en
temprature. Linfluence des additifs, ZnO et ure, fut galement tudie. Pour finir, nous avons
test mcaniquement des objets de cellulose rgnre et tudi linfluence des conditions de
prparation des chantillons et notamment linfluence de ltape de conglation (solution de
cellulose restant 20 heures -20C) et des bains de rgnration.
Problmatique 1 : Les films obtenus partir du procd soude sont moins rsistants que les
films produits partir du procd viscose . Au cours des essais exprimentaux sur le
procd soude , il apparat que seulement une assez faible quantit de cellulose peut tre
dissoute dans les solutions NaOH/eau. Pour des raisons lies la fois aux proprits
mcaniques et la faisabilit conomique du procd, il faut augmenter la quantit de
cellulose mise en solution. La question est donc de dterminer la concentration maximale de
cellulose qui peut rellement tre dissoute dans une solution donne de NaOH/eau.
Etude exprimentale : Ltude des proprits thermiques des solutions de cellulose permettra de
mieux comprendre la structure des solutions de cellulose et les interactions qui interviennent
Rsum du travail de thse
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 7 -
au cours de sa dissolution entre les chanes de cellulose, les molcules de NaOH, leau et les
additifs.
Problmatique 2 : Pour la fabrication des films, les solutions de cellulose doivent tre les plus
homognes possible, toutes particules fibres non dissoutes, impurets dun diamtre
suprieur ~8m doivent tre filtres pour viter la dchirure du film au moment de son
tirage. En outre, il se pose un problme de glification lors du procd pour la fabrication
des films, et ce dautant plus que la concentration en cellulose est leve. Les solutions de
cellulose dans la soude sont des systmes instables qui glifient, dautant plus rapidement que
la temprature est leve au dessus de la temprature ambiante. De ce fait, si un dbut de
glification se produit avant la mise en forme du film, le morceau de gel devient alors un
point de rupture du film.
Plan dexprience : Nous tudierons en dtail les proprits rhologiques des solutions de
cellulose afin de (i) connatre leur comportement lcoulement, (ii) dterminer les conditions
de glification et (iii) tudier linfluence dadditifs tels que oxyde de zinc et ure sur la
rhologie des solutions de cellulose/NaOH/eau.
Problmatique 3 : Les ponges prpares partir du procd soude doivent tre congeles
plusieurs heures -20C pour avoir des proprits assez proches de celles des ponges
viscose . Un procd avec un sjour prolong trs basse temprature nest pas viable
conomiquement. Il est donc ncessaire dtudier linfluence de la conglation sur les
proprits finales dobjets de cellulose rgnre.
Plan dexprience : Une ponge cellulosique est en fait un composite poreux ayant une matrice
de cellulose rgnre et des fibres de renfort de cellulose naturelle (coton, lin, bois). Ltude
de la rsistance la rupture et de linfluence de la conglation sur les proprits mcaniques se
fera tape par tape, c'est--dire sur la matrice de cellulose rgnre seule, puis sur le
composite matrice+fibres et pour finir sur le produit fini matrice+fibres+porophores, crant
la macroporosit ncessaire aux proprits dabsorption.
Ces trois problmatiques industrielles structurent notre thse, ainsi que ce rsum, en constituant
les chapitres III, IV et V. Le chapitre I est consacr ltude bibliographique tandis que le
chapitre II prsente les matriaux et mthodes utiliss tout au long de cette tude.
Une brve description des expriences ralises et des rsultats obtenus est prsente ci-dessous.
Rsum du travail de thse
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 8 -
I- LITTERATURE : LA CELLULOSE ET SA DISSOLUTION DANS LES SYSTEMES
HYDROXYDE ALCALIN/EAU
La cellulose est un polymre linaire constitu dunit anhydroglucose (AGU). Les groupes
hydroxyles prsents sur chaque motif, et donc tout au long de la chane, sont facilement
accessibles pour crer des liaisons hydrogne intra- et intermolculaires. Par ces liaisons
hydrogne, les chanes de cellulose ont une forte tendance sagrger pour former des
arrangements cristallins trs ordonns. Ils sont au nombre de quatre : la cellulose I, ou cellulose
native, la cellulose II, la cellulose III et la cellulose IV. Les structures cristallines II, III et IV
sobtiennent par traitement chimique, seule la cellulose I se trouve dans les membranes des
cellules vgtales ltat natif. Les chanes de cellulose native sorganisent dabord sous forme de
micro fibrilles qui sagglomrent leur tour dans les macro fibrilles pour donner finalement la
fibre de cellulose.
Lorganisation des fibrilles (diamtre, densit, texture) varie suivant lorigine de la cellulose
(coton, bois), ce qui explique des diffrences de comportement au contact des solvants
[CUI2006] par exemple. Lors de lextraction de la cellulose, des traitements chimiques et
mcaniques sont galement appliqus pour sparer la cellulose des autres constituants du bois
(lignine, hmicelluloses). Ces traitements modifient la structure des fibres de cellulose et
influent donc sur les proprits de ces dernires.
Comme nous lavons expos dans le contexte de ltude, la soude, relativement concentre, est
utilise depuis de trs nombreuses annes pour modifier les proprits des textiles (brillance,
absorption des colorants), et ce, grce au gonflement des fibres de cellulose puis leur
transformation de la cellulose I la cellulose II : cest le phnomne appel mercerisation
[MER1903]. Il apparat galement que la mercerisation peut se produire plus faible
concentration en NaOH (~9%) si la temprature est faible. Davidson [DAV1934] et Sobue
[SOB1939] montrent que la cellulose peut tre dissoute dans la soude mais dans un domaine de
temprature et de concentration en NaOH trs troit (7-10%NaOH/eau, en dessous de 0C).
Les solutions de cellulose obtenues ne sont pas stables et glifient dans le temps et en fonction de
la temprature [ROY2003]. Dautres systmes alcalins comme KOH/eau et LiOH/eau sont
galement tudis. Si le premier ne permet quune faible solubilit de la cellulose, le deuxime est
trs efficace mais beaucoup plus cher que la soude. La plupart des tudes se consacreront donc
la dissolution de la cellulose dans la soude, solvant alcalin efficace et peu onreux.
Peu de temps aprs la dcouverte de la mercerisation, lajout dadditifs fut tudi pour amliorer
laction de NaOH sur les fibres de cellulose. Loxyde de zinc est dj mentionn cette poque
[MER1903] et apparat dans la littrature de faon sporadique [DAV1937] [WO 02/22924]. Par
contre, aucune explication sur son rle nest propose. Lajout dure est tudi depuis seulement
quelques annes [LAS1998] [ZHO2000] mais de faon trs dtaille. Non seulement il est montr
que lure amliore nettement la dissolution de la cellulose et la stabilit des solutions [ZHO2000]
mais certains auteurs tentent galement dexpliquer ces phnomnes [CAI2005] [CAI2006].
Rsum du travail de thse
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 9 -
II- MATERIAUX ET METHODES EXPERIMENTALES
La dissolution de la cellulose dans NaOH/eau, avec ou sans additif, seffectue -6C pendant
deux heures sous agitation. Une fois prpare, les solutions peuvent tre gardes un mois environ
+5C. Nanmoins, avant chaque prlvement, elles devront tre re-homognises car les fibres
non dissoutes sdimentent.
Ltude des proprits thermiques des solutions peut se diviser en deux parties, ltude des
solvants NaOH/eau, ure/eau, NaOH/ure/eau et NaOH/ZnO/eau et celle des solutions
de cellulose. Afin de dterminer les temprature et enthalpie de fusion de chaque composant
prsent dans la solution, nous avons utilis un appareil DSC 7 (PERKIN-ELMER) permettant de
descendre basse temprature (-65C), les vitesses de refroidissement et de chauffe utilises tant
de 1C/min. La corrosivit des solutions (prsence de soude) a ncessit lutilisation de capsule
inox plaque en or. Dans la plupart des cas, les tempratures et enthalpies de fusion ont t
calcules directement par le logiciel de DSC. Dans le cas de pics superposs, une dconvolution
de pics tant ncessaire, nous avons utilis le logiciel PeakFit 4.12.
Pour dterminer la structure des solvants, nous avons galement effectu des analyses de
diffraction de rayons X (XPERT-PRO de PANalytical) et des analyses de RMN. Ces dernires
ont t ralises lInstitut Fraunhofer Glm, en Allemagne.
Les proprits rhologiques des solutions semi dilues de cellulose (de diffrents DP, traitements
et origines) dans 7,6NaOH/eau, avec ou sans additif (oxyde de zinc et lure, diffrentes
concentrations) ont largement t tudies laide dun rhomtre Gemini (BOHLIN) quip
doutils cne plan et dune platine Peltier. Cette dernire permettant des variations rapides de la
temprature, nous avons pu dterminer le point de glification en fonction de la temprature et
du temps. Le comportement lcoulement a galement t tudi par des mesures de viscosit
en fonction du taux de cisaillement.
Quant ltude des solutions dilues de cellulose, elle a t effectue en utilisant un viscosimtre
capillaire Ubbelohde quip dune burette automatique de dilution (Lauda).
La rsistance la rupture de films de cellulose rgnre, de composites cellulose rgnre +
fibres de renfort et de produits finis (cellulose rgnre + fibres de renfort + porophores crant
la porosit) a t mesure laide dune machine ZWICK Z2.5, en mode de traction. Les
chantillons sont dans leur tat humide et la mesure seffectue lair ambiant.
Pour finir, tout au long de cette tude, des observations microscopiques ont t ralises que ce
soit au microscope optique ou au microscope lectronique balayage (MEB, SEM en anglais).
Rsum du travail de thse
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 10 -
III- STRUCTURE DES SOLUTIONS DE CELLULOSE ET LIMITE DE DISSOLUTION
Nous prsentons tout dabord quelques aspects thoriques sur les diagrammes de phase binaires
et ternaires et lutilisation des thermogrammes de DSC pour les construire. Une construction trs
prcise des diagrammes de phase partir des pics de fusion obtenus par DSC ncessite de trs
nombreux essais variation de la masse m de lchantillon et de la vitesse de chauffe v afin de
pouvoir extrapoler les rsultats m=0 et v=0. Le but de notre tude tant seulement de connatre
les phases prsentes dans le systme, leur composition et leur proportion, nous avons ralis les
mesures pour une seule vitesse de chauffe et une seule masse.
Ltude de structure des solvants et des solutions de cellulose a essentiellement t base sur des
analyses de DSC. Les systmes ont t refroidis trs basse temprature (-65C) afin quils soient
totalement cristalliss, puis remonts lentement (+1C/min) temprature ambiante en
enregistrant les pics de fusion des diffrents composants.
Dans un premier temps, nous avons analys des solutions aqueuses dhydroxyde de sodium
contenant entre 0 et 20% en poids de NaOH. A partir des thermogrammes de fusion, nous avons
pu tracer la partie du diagramme de phase 0-20%NaOH/eau qui correspond parfaitement celui
trouv dans la littrature [PIC1893] [ROL1964]. Dans ce domaine de concentrations en NaOH,
le systme forme un mlange eutectique compos dun hydrate de sodium NaOH,5H
2
O et de
quatre molcules deau. Cette adquation entre lexprience et la littrature nous a permis
dutiliser une mthode de calcul, base sur les enthalpies de fusion, permettant de dterminer la
proportion de chaque phase en solution.
Pour une solution de 7,6%NaOH/eau on aura tout dabord cristallisation de leau libre puis du
mlange eutectique NaOH,5H
2
O+4H
2
O quand la temprature diminue, les tempratures de
fusion tant respectivement -4C/-5C et -33,4C.
Lanalyse du systme 0-100%ure/eau montre un comportement eutectique simple, le mlange
eutectique tant compos de 1ure+8H
2
O.
Laddition de 0-25% dure dans une solution de 7,6%NaOH/eau ne modifie ni la temprature ni
lenthalpie de fusion de leutectique NaOH,5H
2
O+4H
2
O : lure ne ragit pas avec NaOH. Par
ailleurs, quand la concentration en ure augmente, le pic de fusion du compos ure se dcale
vers les plus hautes tempratures, tandis que celui de leau libre se dcale vers les basses
tempratures. Les deux pics se rejoignent pour une concentration totale en ure de 18%. Un tel
systme est en fait compos de leutectique NaOH,5H
2
O+4H
2
O et de leutectique ure+8H
2
O.
Il ny a plus deau libre. Tant quil y a suffisamment deau pour les deux mlanges eutectiques, ils
se forment indpendamment. Si leau vient manquer, chaque NaOH sentoure de ses 9
molcules deau puis leau restante entoure lure, lure en excs restant dans son tat pur.
Lors de sa dissolution en milieu fortement basique, loxyde de zinc ragit avec OH
-
pour former
des hydroxydes de zinc. Ces ractions chimiques provoquent donc une modification des
solutions et par consquent des changements au niveau du diagramme de phase NaOH/eau. Plus
la quantit en ZnO augmente, plus les temprature et enthalpie de fusion de leutectique
Rsum du travail de thse
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 11 -
NaOH diminuent. On a ainsi dtermin que trois NaOH pour un ZnO ne participent plus
leutectique et que les composs de zinc forms lors de la dissolution sont fortement hydrats
(jusqu 25H
2
O).
La structure des solvants NaOH/eau, NaOH/ure/eau et NaOH/ZnO/eau tant dsormais
connue, nous y avons ajout la cellulose afin de dterminer quelles interactions ont lieu lors de sa
dissolution.
Lajout de 0,5-7,6% de cellulose dans une solution de 7,6-9% de NaOH/eau nentrane pas de
diminution de la temprature de fusion de leutectique NaOH : la prsence de cellulose ne
modifie pas le diagramme de phase du solvant NaOH/eau. Par contre, lenthalpie diminue
proportionnellement la quantit de cellulose ajoute et atteint zro quand la quantit de
cellulose est gale la quantit de NaOH prsent en solution. Nous en avons donc dduit que (i)
la dissolution de cellulose dans NaOH ncessite au moins quatre molcules de NaOH qui se lient
une unit anhydroglucose (AGU) et (ii) la limite de dissolution de la cellulose est atteinte quand
m
cell
=m
NaOH
.
Quant la temprature de fusion de la glace libre, elle augmente lgrement avec la cellulose, ce
qui sexplique par un changement de lenvironnement molculaire de leau d la prsence de
cellulose. Lenthalpie de leau libre reste constante quand la concentration en cellulose augmente
ce qui signifie que la quantit deau libre en solution est constante. Nous en avons donc conclu
que les NaOH lis la cellulose sont entours des 9 molcules deau formant initialement le
mlange eutectique.
Des analyses DSC similaires ont t ralises sur des solutions de cellulose dans NaOH/eau
contenant 6% dure. Les valeurs denthalpie de fusion de leutectique NaOH suivent la mme
courbe que celles obtenues prcdemment pour des solutions de cellulose dans NaOH/eau, sans
ure. La prsence dure ne permet pas daugmenter la limite de dissolution de la cellulose qui
reste telle que m
cell
=m
NaOH
, chaque AGU sentourant au minimum de 4 NaOH et 36 molcules
deau.
Quant au pic de leutectique ure , il ne change ni en intensit, ni en temprature. Nous en
concluons donc que les chanes de cellulose ne ragissent pas avec lure.
Nous avons vu que lajout de ZnO dans le solvant diminue ou supprime la temprature de fusion
de leutectique NaOH . Lors de lajout de cellulose, ce pic napparat pas, il nest donc pas
possible de dterminer ni la concentration limite en cellulose pouvant tre dissoute dans une
solution donne de NaOH/ZnO/eau, ni la quantit de NaOH li chaque AGU.
La dernire section de ce chapitre concerne linfluence de la conglation sur la structure des
solutions, modification structurale pouvant tre dtecte par une analyse thermique.
Aprs un sjour prolong -28C, un pic apparat 0C, temprature de fusion de la glace. Ceci
signifie quune certaine quantit deau a cristallis de manire tout fait indpendante. Dun point
de vue thermodynamique, cette eau pure ne peut provenir ni du mlange eutectique
Rsum du travail de thse
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 12 -
NaOH,5H
2
O+4H
2
O libre en solution ni de leau initialement libre. La seule possibilit est que
cette eau pure provienne de leau lie la cellulose. A partir des enthalpies de fusion, nous avons
pu calculer quune molcule deau par AGU a t dtache. Mais tant donn que cette eau est
dgage dans un systme en quilibre thermodynamique, elle cristallise immdiatement et
indpendamment des autres constituants du systme, donnant ainsi un pic la temprature de
fusion de leau pure.
Des rsultats tout fait quivalents ont t observs pour des solutions de
cellulose/NaOH/ZnO/eau.
IV- ECOULEMENT ET GELIFICATION DES SOLUTIONS AQUEUSES DE
CELLULOSE/NAOH. INFLUENCE DES ADDITIFS
Ltude bibliographique a montr que dune part la cellulose ne se dissout que dans des
conditions prcises de concentration en NaOH et de temprature [SOB1939] et que dautre part,
une fois dissoute, les solutions ne sont pas stables et glifient en fonction du temps et de la
temprature [ROY2003]. Il apparat galement que lajout dadditifs tels que ure et oxyde de zinc
amliore la dissolution de la cellulose et la stabilit des solutions [ZHO2000]. Le but de ce
chapitre est donc dtudier le comportement des solutions lcoulement ainsi que dterminer les
conditions de glification, et ce en faisant varier de nombreux paramtres tels que DP,
concentration et origine de la cellulose, temprature et additifs.
Les solutions ont t tudies (i) en rgime semi dilu en mode continu afin de mesurer la
viscosit des solutions en fonction du taux de cisaillement, (ii) en mode dynamique pour
dterminer le point de glification et (iii) en rgime dilu pour mesurer la viscosit intrinsque de
la cellulose dans diffrents solvants. Paralllement aux rsultats rhologiques, de nombreuses
observations microscopiques (microscope optique) ont t effectues pour avoir des donnes
qualitatives sur la dissolution des fibres de cellulose.
Par les mesures de viscosit en fonction du taux de cisaillement, nous avons montr que le
comportement lcoulement des solutions de cellulose explose la vapeur est identique dans
les trois systmes de solvant tudis 7,6%NaOH/eau, 7,6%NaOH/6%ure/eau et
7,6%NaOH/0,7%ZnO/eau. Ce ne sont pas des solutions molculairement disperses. Leur
comportement se rapproche plutt de celui dune suspension. Ce rsultat concorde bien avec le
rsultat prcdent savoir quen solution les chanes de cellulose sont entoures dune grande
quantit de molcules dhydroxyde de sodium et deau.
Les observations microscopiques ont montr que la prsence doxyde de zinc ou dure amliore
la dissolution de la cellulose puisque la quantit de fibres non dissoutes diminue. Les mesures de
viscosit intrinsque dans les diffrents solvants ont rvl que cette amlioration de la
dissolution des fibres est due une amlioration de la qualit de solvant de la faon suivante
7,6%NaOH/eau est moins bon que 7,6%NaOH/6%ure/eau qui est moins bon que
7,6%NaOH/0,7%ZnO/eau.
Rsum du travail de thse
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 13 -
Par ailleurs, quel que soit le solvant utilis, la viscosit intrinsque de la cellulose diminue quand la
temprature augmente. Ceci signifie que les chanes de cellulose se contractent et que la qualit du
solvant diminue. Par consquent les interactions cellulose-cellulose sont favorises ce qui conduit
la glification des solutions en rgime semi dilu et la compactisation des molcules en rgime
dilu.
Pour des solutions de mme concentration en cellulose et en NaOH, la dtermination du point
de glification en fonction de la temprature donne ncessairement lordre suivant
T
gel
(cellulose/NaOH/eau) < T
gel
(cellulose/NaOH/ure/eau) < T
gel
(cellulose/NaOH/ZnO/eau).
Lajout de ZnO dans 7,6%NaOH/eau est dautant plus efficace (augmentation de la temprature
de glification) que sa concentration est leve, jusqu 1,5% qui correspond la limite de
solubilit de ZnO dans 7,6%NaOH/eau. Au-del de cette valeur, les proprits restent
constantes. Nous en concluons donc que ZnO amliore la dissolution de la cellulose et la stabilit
des solutions seulement sil a dabord t dissout dans NaOH. Ceci signifie que ce sont les
complexes forms entre NaOH, ZnO et leau qui permettent damliorer la dissolution des fibres
de cellulose et de retarder la glification. Par ailleurs le mcanisme de glification semble tre le
mme avec ou sans ZnO, qui agit donc uniquement en empchant les interactions cellulose-
cellulose qui apparaissent plus haute temprature.
En ce qui concerne lajout dure dans 7,6%NaOH/eau, nous avons constat que nos rsultats ne
correspondaient pas ceux trouvs dans la littrature. Nous avons donc prpar des solutions de
cellulose de diffrentes origines (diffrence dessence darbre, de traitement des fibres, de DP)
dans 7.6NaOH/eau contenant de 6 20% dure. Nous avons alors mesur les modules G et G
en fonction de la temprature afin de dterminer le point de gel. La temprature de glification et
la concentration optimale en ure varient suivant la cellulose utilise. Une solution de cellulose
explose la vapeur atteint sa temprature maximale de glification 40C pour une
concentration en ure de 6% tandis quune solution de cellulose irradie par un faisceau
dlectron atteint sa temprature maximale presque 60C pour une concentration en ure de 12-
15%. La stabilit des solutions dpend donc fortement de lorigine de la cellulose.
A lheure actuelle, les raisons de telles diffrences restent une question ouverte mais ces rsultats
expliquent pourquoi nous trouvons des rsultats diffrents de ceux rapports dans la littrature.
V- PROPRIETES MECANIQUES DOBJETS REGENERES A PARTIR DE
SOLUTIONS DE CELLULOSE/NAOH/EAU
Ce chapitre concerne la fabrication dobjets cellulosiques par dissolution directe de la cellulose
dans des solutions aqueuses dhydroxyde de sodium. Nous prsentons tout dabord le procd
viscose actuel puis le nouveau procd soude . Ce dernier ncessite une tape de
conglation des blocs dponge afin dobtenir des proprits du produit fini proches de celles
obtenues pour les ponges viscose . Etant donn que ce sjour prolong basse temprature
rend ce procd conomiquement non viable, il est important dtudier linfluence de la
Rsum du travail de thse
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 14 -
conglation sur les proprits des ponges et de savoir sur quel lment du produit (matrice,
fibres) elle intervient.
Lessentiel de cette tude porte sur des tests de traction permettant de mesurer la rsistance la
rupture des ponges. Une ponge est en fait un matriau composite constitu dune matrice de
cellulose avec des fibres de renfort et de trous. La matrice est compose de cellulose rgnre,
provenant de la solution de cellulose dans NaOH/eau, et de fibres de renfort, ensemble de fibres
de coton, de lin et/ou de bois. Les trous sont forms suite la fusion de cristaux de sel
Na
2
SO
4
,10H
2
O.
Afin de comprendre o et quand agit la conglation, nous avons prpar puis test des
chantillons (i) de matrice de cellulose rgnre seule, (ii) de matrice de cellulose
rgnre+fibres de renfort et (iii) de matrice+fibres+porophores crant la porosit.
Les tests de traction sur la matrice de cellulose rgnre seule montrent que les conditions
utilises initialement (conglation -20C et rgnration dans leau +70C) sont trs
dfavorables la rsistance la rupture. Les meilleures proprits mcaniques sont obtenues
lorsque la solution de cellulose/NaOH/eau est traite temprature ambiante que ce soit au
moment de la glification mais galement lors de la rgnration dans leau. Nous remarquons
toutefois quune rgnration en milieu acide donne de bonnes proprits mcaniques mais ce
mode de rgnration convient essentiellement lors de la fabrication de film mince et non lors de
la fabrication dobjet tridimensionnel telles que les ponges. La conglation nagit donc pas sur la
rsistance mcanique de la matrice de cellulose rgnre. Les chantillons congels de cellulose
rgnre rvlent de nombreuses empreintes en forme daiguille dues la cristallisation puis la
fusion de leau.
Lajout de fibres de renfort augmente la contrainte la rupture mais le rsultat reste mdiocre.
Ladhsion entre la matrice et les fibres est donc amliorer. Les observations microscopiques
ont montr quau cours de la conglation, les fibres de renfort, de DP lev, ont gonfl au
contact de la soude. Dans un premier temps, nous avons pens que ce gonflement pouvait
permettre une certaine pntration de la solution de cellulose et donc amliorer ladhsion
fibres/matrice. Cette hypothse sest rvle fausse, la conglation nintervenant pas au niveau de
ladhsion fibres/matrice.
Lajout de promoteur dadhsion na pas donn de rsultats satisfaisants.
Finalement, nous avons prpar et test les produits finis : matrice de cellulose rgnre + fibres
de renfort + porophores crant la porosit. Cest ce stade seulement que nous avons vu
linfluence de la conglation sur les proprits des ponges. Outre lamlioration de la rsistance
la rupture, la conglation des ponges entrane galement une augmentation de labsorption en
eau et une diminution du rtrcissement des ponges, compar des ponges quivalentes
nayant pas subit dtape de conglation. Ceci est en adquation avec les observations
microscopiques qui rvlent une porosit plus importante des ponges congeles, conduisant
une meilleure absorption.
Rsum du travail de thse
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 15 -
Nous avons galement observ que, aprs un premier schage lair ambiant, un grand nombre
de pores se sont ferms ce qui explique un retrait non ngligeable des chantillons congels ou
non.
Le manuscrit se termine par des conclusions gnrales et des annexes qui donnent une
description dtaille de quelques techniques et rsultats exprimentaux.
- 16 -
Introduction
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 17 -
I
I
N
N
T
T
R
R
O
O
D
D
U
U
C
C
T
T
I
I
O
O
N
N
Cellulose is a natural polymer which is the structural substance present in all plants, allowing their
stalk and their protection. This polysaccharide is created by the photosynthesis from carbon
dioxide and water, using the sunlight as the energy source. Cellulose can be extracted from grass,
leaves, stems, tree trunks and brunches. Wood is the most often used source since trees are
planted especially for this purpose. Nevertheless, properties of the wood pulp strongly vary as a
function of age and growing conditions of trees and these parameters are difficult to control
when timber comes from the wild. Moreover, it is interesting to note that pulp manufacturers
plant sufficient trees to at least replace what they use.
At the end of the life cycle, cellulose degrades readily under bacterial action forming compost or
peat and ultimately degrades further producing methane, carbon dioxide and water. The loop is
closed.
The major problem of cellulose is that it is degrading before melting. Consequently, to process
cellulose and make fibres, films or 3D objects, cellulose has to be either dissolved in direct
solvents or derivatised and then processed.
The most common industrial process of making shaped pure cellulose objects is called the
viscose process: after cellulose activation with aqueous 18-20%NaOH, the carbon disulfide
(CS
2
) is reacting with cellulose chains to form the cellulose xanthate which is then dissolved in
dilute sodium hydroxide. At this stage, the mixture is named the viscose and can be shaped.
Finally, cellulose is regenerated and various final products can be obtained: fibres, films or tri-
dimensional objects. This process is very efficient and totally mastered, but it is very polluting:
because of the use of CS
2
and the numerous chemical reactions, sulphured products are released
creating pollution in atmosphere and in aqueous phases. Although the major part of the pollution
is treated in the plant some pollutants are still released. Moreover, technologies for pollution
treatments are very expensive. Thus for economical and for environmental reasons,
manufacturers of pure cellulose products have been trying to find alternative routes to shape
cellulose. There is a continuous search on environmentally friendly cellulose processes.
Introduction
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 18 -
NMMO, for example, is a good cellulose solvent, but these solutions are not easy to prepare and
to process in the case of film and tri-dimensional object. This solvent is now used in the fibre
manufacture, called the Lyocell process.
For a long time, sodium hydroxide aqueous solutions at various concentrations were used in
cellulose processing, especially to change aspects and properties of cellulose fibres: in the textile
industries. For example, NaOH was largely used to increase the degree of lustre and to improve
the absorption of dyes. In 1939 Sobue showed [SOB1939] that (7-10)%NaOH aqueous solutions
can be a direct solvent of cellulose. Nowadays, several research teams directly dissolve cellulose
in sodium hydroxide aqueous solutions (7-10%NaOH below 0C) but the properties of final
products are often inferior to the ones of similar products made from viscose process. One of
the problem is that neither cellulose dissolution in 7-10%NaOH, nor the properties of
cellulose/NaOH/water solutions are well understood.
This work has two different goals, the first is the fundamental understanding of the behaviour of
the mixing of cellulose in NaOH-based aqueous solutions, and the second is to apply this
knowledge to the manufacturing of films and sponges.
The first goal of the work was to understand the structure of cellulose solvent aqueous solution
of sodium hydroxide with and without ZnO or urea and of cellulose solution in these solvents,
and then to determine how NaOH reacts with the polymer chains. From this fundamental aspect
we can determine the maximal cellulose concentration that can be dissolved in NaOH/water.
The study of the rheological properties of cellulose solutions by determining the flow behaviour
and the conditions of the occurrence of gelation, in time and in temperature, gave information on
the gelation. The influence of additives on rheological properties was also investigated.
The second goal was to investigate two aspects of the manufacturing of objects from this
process. In the case of the preparation of films, the difficulty lies in the amount of cellulose that
can be dissolved in the cellulose solution. The higher is the better, but this causes extreme
difficulties during processing due to gelation. The results obtained above explained why. The
second process is the manufacturing of sponges where a freezing step was shown to be
important. We thus studied the mechanical properties of regenerated objects and the influence of
preparation conditions and especially the influence of the freezing step (keeping cellulose
solution at -20C for 20 hours) and the influence of regeneration baths.
Two industrial partners supported this thesis. Innovia Films Ltd, in Great Britain, is a
manufacturer of cellulose films for wrapping and packaging and Spontex, in France, is a company
producing cellulose sponges.
Introduction
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 19 -
The thesis is divided into five chapters.
The first one gives generalities on cellulose as well as a description of the different techniques
used for its extraction and its activation. We also present the state of the art concerning the
swelling and the dissolution of cellulose in sodium hydroxide/water and the influence of
additives such as zinc oxide or urea on the cellulose solubility.
In the second chapter, materials (cellulose, solvents and additives) and methods (DSC, rheology,
optical and electron microscopy, rheology, viscometry, x-ray scattering) used in this work are
described.
The next three chapters concern the results and their discussion.
Chapter III investigates, using DSC analysis, the structure of the various solvents used in this
study as well as the structure of cellulose solutions in these solvents. As the NaOH/water binary
system is described in details in literature, it enables to check the validity of the methodology
used to calculate NaOH/water phase diagram below 0C at NaOH concentrations used for
cellulose dissolution. The same methodology was applied on other solvents urea/water,
NaOH/ZnO/water and NaOH/urea/water and on cellulose solutions. We also determine the
amount of cellulose that can be dissolved in sodium hydroxide/water and we study the influence
of additives on this limit of cellulose dissolution.
Chapter IV focuses on the rheological properties of cellulose/NaOH/water solutions with and
without additives. The experiments in steady state mode were used to describe the behaviour of
cellulose/NaOH/water solutions under shear. The oscillatory mode allows examination of the
conditions for the occurrence of gelation.
Chapter V tackles the mechanical properties of regenerated wet cellulose samples. The tensile
tests were performed on regenerated pure cellulose and cellulose with the reinforcing fibres and
porophores. The influence of regenerating bath parameters and of the freezing step on the
mechanical properties was studied. We investigated how to improve the sponge manufacture
process while keeping in mind the necessity to have costs as low as possible.
Finally, a general conclusion summarizes the main results of this work and presents some
prospective aspects.
- 20 -
Rsum du chapitre I Etat de lart : La cellulose et sa dissolution dans des solutions aqueuses dhydroxyde de sodium
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 21 -
R RE ES SU UM ME E D DU U C CH HA AP PI IT TR RE E I I
E ET TA AT T D DE E L L A AR RT T: : L LA A C CE EL LL LU UL LO OS SE E E ET T S SA A D DI IS SS SO OL LU UT TI IO ON N D DA AN NS S
D DE ES S S SO OL LU UT TI IO ON NS S A AQ QU UE EU US SE ES S D D H HY YD DR RO OX XY YD DE E D DE E S SO OD DI IU UM M
Les polysaccharides sont des matriaux naturels, renouvelables et biodgradables. Par consquent
leur utilisation dans lindustrie, en tant que matire premire ou en tant quadditif, se dveloppe.
La cellulose, par exemple, est le constituant principal des vgtaux ; sa production naturelle est
donc considrable. Par contre, elle est difficile mettre en uvre et doit subir de nombreux
traitements avant de se retrouver dans le produit fini.
La cellulose ne peut pas tre fondue comme la plupart des polymres et ne peut tre dissoute ni
dans leau ni dans la plupart des solvants. Sa dissolution ncessite lemploi de solvants forts,
souvent dangereux et polluants. De nombreux travaux de recherche portent donc sur la mise en
solution de la cellulose dans des solvants peu coteux, efficaces et non dangereux pour
lenvironnement.
Le but de ce chapitre est de faire un tat de lart sur la cellulose et sa dissolution en milieu alcalin.
Dans un premier temps, nous prsenterons la cellulose du point de vue de son organisation
molculaire et structurale. Limportant rseau de liaisons hydrognes permet non seulement de
nombreuses combinaisons donnant ainsi quatre structures cristallines diffrentes mais galement
une trs forte cohsion entre les chanes, rendant difficile la pntration des solvants. Nous
verrons que lorganisation supramolculaire des chanes de polymre dpend de lorigine de la
cellulose (coton ou bois par exemple). Il existe galement diffrentes mthodes dextraction, de
traitement et dactivation des fibres pour prparer les pulpes de cellulose. Tous ces aspects
influenant sur les proprits des pulpes de cellulose rendent difficile luniversalit des rsultats et
des interprtations.
La deuxime partie de ce chapitre aborde deux techniques de dissolution de la cellulose.
La premire intervient dans le procd viscose , procd actuel de fabrication de films minces
ou dobjets tridimensionnels base de cellulose. Il sagit dune dissolution indirecte : la cellulose
est dabord transforme chimiquement avant dtre dissoute puis mise en forme et enfin
rgnre (retour la structure de la cellulose). La succession de ractions chimiques et
lutilisation de sulfure de carbone (CS
2
) comme solvant de la cellulose le rendent trs polluant.
Ceci a conduit les industriels trouver une alternative ce procd.
Rsum du chapitre I Etat de lart : La cellulose et sa dissolution dans des solutions aqueuses dhydroxyde de sodium
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 22 -
Une deuxime mthode de dissolution des fibres de cellulose est alors tudie. Il sagit, cette fois,
dune dissolution directe de la cellulose dans une solution peu concentre (7-10%) dhydroxyde
de sodium/eau. La soude fut dabord utilise comme agent de gonflement des fibres de cellulose
avant dtre utilise comme un solvant direct de la cellulose. Nous rapportons dans cette partie de
nombreux travaux effectus sur les solutions de cellulose/NaOH/eau. Si les premiers traitent
essentiellement des conditions de dissolution de la cellulose (concentration en NaOH,
temprature, additifs), les suivants cherchent davantage expliquer les phnomnes observs
(gonflement irrgulier des fibres, mcanisme de transformation de la cellulose I la cellulose II,
glification des solutions de cellulose, rle des additifs sur la dissolution des fibres et leur
influence sur la glification).
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 23 -
C
C
H
H
A
A
P
P
T
T
E
E
R
R
I
I
I- I
S ST TA AT TE E O OF F T TH HE E A AR RT T
: : C CE EL LL LU UL LO OS SE E A AN ND D I IT TS S
D DI IS SS SO OL LU UT TI IO ON N I IN N A AL LK KA AL LI IN NE E H HY YD DR RO OX XI ID DE E A AQ QU UE EO OU US S
S SO OL LU UT TI IO ON NS S
The general goal of our work is to determine the structure of cellulose solutions in aqueous
sodium hydroxide and to understand the mechanisms of cellulose dissolution and gelation of
solutions. So flow behaviour and gelation properties were investigated as well as the influence of
additives (urea and zinc oxide) on cellulose dissolution and kinetics of gelation. In order to
understand all this, it is necessary to know and understand the structure and properties of
cellulose itself and to review what is known in literature about cellulose behaviour in aqueous
alkaline solutions. Thus, there will be two main parts in this chapter: Cellulose: structure,
morphology and treatment and Cellulose dissolution in aqueous alkali hydroxide solutions.
In the first part, the structure of cellulose and its polymorphs are briefly presented in order to
describe the crystalline structure of cellulose and to better understand specificities of cellulose
materials. For example, we will see how the network of hydrogen bonding changes depending on
polymorph of cellulose I and II which explains differences in stability and reactivity. The supra-
molecular structure of cellulose of different origins is shown to emphasize the complexity of fibre
arrangement. These two points have a great interest because supra-molecular structure and
hydrogen bonding have to be broken to dissolve cellulose. Finally, different treatments of
cellulose are described because we will use microcrystalline cellulose and steam exploded cellulose
and thus we must know what their specificities are.
In the second part, the first section concerns the current industrial process to dissolve cellulose:
the viscose process. It is still used by our partners but as this process generates some pollution,
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 24 -
an alternative route to dissolve cellulose must be found. The others sections deal with another
cellulose solvent based on NaOH aqueous solution. Varying the nature of alkali, the
concentrations, and the temperature enables to better understand what happens when alkali
hydroxide aqueous is added to cellulose fibres. Some explanations on mercerisation mechanism
are given. Finally, the action of some additives to improve cellulose dissolution will be described.
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 25 -
I.1- CELLULOSE: STRUCTURE, MORPHOLOGY AND TREATMENT
Cellulose is one of the many polysaccharides present in nature (part I.1.1-). Its chemical structure
is relatively simple (part I.1.2-) but the arrangement of chains in crystalline (part I.1.3-) and in
supra-molecular structures is very complex and depends on the origin of cellulose (part I.1.4-).
The synthesis of cellulose is difficult; nowadays only chains with about ten units can be obtained.
So native cellulose is used as a raw material, after treatments to extract it from plants and activate
it (part I.1.5-).
I.1.1- Generalities
Polysaccharides are the most abundant organic polymers available world-wide. Photosynthesis
produces approximately 1.5 10
12
tonnes of cellulose, starch and other natural polymers, whereas
the annual production of petroleum polymers is 7-8 times lower. The economical interest of
cellulose as a raw material is thus evident. Humans use 5.10
8
tonnes per year of cellulose as wood,
cotton, paper, textile, wrapping films
Plants are natural composite materials and chemical complexes of cellulose, lignin,
hemicelluloses, and other chemicals. The main ingredients are as follows:
o Cellulose is the main component of plant cell walls. It is the structural substance, which
allows protecting and stalking. Cellulose content varies from 30% to 50% depending on the
source, for example, in straws, hard- and softwood, early- and latewood, algae. Cotton is the
purest natural form of cellulose that reaches more than 98% of the whole composition.
Cellulose represents around 50% of the whole biomass. It can also be produced by some
bacteria and found in skeleton of sea animals (tunicin).
o Lignin is the encrusting substance solidifying the cell wall since lignin resists strongly to
compression. One of its important chemical properties is hydrophobicity. Consequently, cells
become impermeable and can transport water and mineral salts. Lignin is a group of chemical
compounds formed by carbon rings. The proportion of lignin varies from 15% to 30%
depending on species and represents about 20% of the whole biomass.
o Hemicelluloses are the matrix substances and provide a linkage between cellulose and lignin.
Hemicelluloses are shorter chains of polysaccharides. They can be divided into 3 groups:
xylans, mannans, and galactans. Their contents vary from 20% to 30%.
o Other compounds consist of a wide variety of chemicals as resins, fats, silica crystals,
proteins In spite of their small content, extraneous compounds significantly influence the
final properties and characteristics of cellulosic materials.
People have used cellulose in a natural state for several thousand years. However, its processing
and use as a raw material in the chemical industry started 150 years ago, with the discovery of
cellulose derivatives, and has ever since been studied. Although the chemical structure of
cellulose is well-known, there are still many debates concerning its crystalline structure, i.e. the
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 26 -
way in which the cellulose molecules are packed in crystals and how these crystals are assembled
into microfibrils, fibres, cell walls or other cellulose morphologies.
I.1.2- Chemical structure of cellulose
Cellulose is a linear syndiotactic homopolymer of -(14)-D-glucopyranose units in
4
C
1
conformation (Fig.I.1-1).
Non-reducing end group Anhydroglucose unit Reducing end group
(n = value of DP)
O
OH
OH
HO
OH
HO
OH
OH
OH
H
O
Reducing end group with
a hemiacetal function
Reducing end group with
an aldehyde function
#
Fig.I.1-1: Molecular structure of cellulose (on the top) and
the reaction occurring on the reducing end group (on the bottom)
# indicates the anomeric carbon C(OR)(OR)
Cellulose is based on glucose units having taken the shape of 6-membered rings, called pyranoses
or glucopyranoses. They are connected by a single oxygen atom (acetal linkages) between the C1
of one pyranose ring and the C4 of the next ring. During the chemical reaction forming the acetal
linkage, a molecule of water is given off. Consequently, the glucose units in the cellulose polymer
are referred to as anhydroglucose units. The spatial arrangement, or stereochemistry, of these
acetal linkages is very important: when the hydroxyl group at C1 is on the same face of the ring as
the C6 carbon, it is said to be in the configuration where all functional groups are in equatorial
positions. This causes an extended conformation cellulose molecular chain (a semi-rigid
conformation), making it a good fibre-forming polymer.
Each of the anhydroglucose units possesses hydroxyl groups at C2, C3 and C6 positions, capable
of undergoing the typical reactions known for primary and secondary alcohols. Because of these
reactions, a lot of cellulose derivatives, such as methylcellulose (-CH
3
groups substitute -OH
groups), can be obtained.
The two chain ends are chemically different. The non-reducing end has a D-glucopyranose unit
in which the anomeric carbon atom (indicated by # in the Fig.I.1-1) is involved in a glycosidic
linkage, whereas the reducing end has a D-glucopyranose unit in which the anomeric carbon
atom is free. The cyclic hemiacetal function is in equilibrium with an aldehyde function (as shown
Fig.I.1-1), which gives rise to reducing properties, so that the cellulose chain has a chemical
polarity. Determination of the relative orientation of cellulose chains in the three-dimensional
structure has been and remains one of the major problems in the study of cellulose.
#
#
#
#
1
2
3
4
5
6
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 27 -
Because of the equatorial positions of the hydroxyls on the cellulose chain, they protrude laterally
along the extended molecule. This positioning makes them readily available for hydrogen
bonding with the ring oxygen atoms. This hydrogen bonding has a strong tendency to aggregate
chains and to form highly ordered structural entities. Since the chains are usually longer than the
crystalline regions, they are thought to pass through several different crystalline regions, with
areas of disorder in between. The inter-chain hydrogen bonds in the crystalline regions are
strong, giving the resultant fibres good strength and insolubility in most solvents. They also
prevent cellulose from melting. In the less ordered regions, the chains are further apart and more
available for hydrogen bonding with other molecules, such as water. Most cellulose structures can
absorb large quantities of water.
I.1.3- Crystalline structures of cellulose
The hydroxyl groups present in the cellulose macromolecule are likely to be involved in a number
of intra- and intermolecular hydrogen bonds, which may give rise to various ordered crystalline
arrangements. Four main polymorphs of cellulose have been found and they are named as
cellulose I, II, III and IV. Their brief description is given in the following sections and their
crystalline parameters are shown in Tab.I.1-1.
Unit cell (, )
Type
Chains
number in
a unit cell a b c
I
I
II
III1
IV1
IV2
1
2
2
2
2
2
6,74
7,85
8,10
10,25
8,03
7,99
5,93
8,27
9,05
7,78
8,13
8,10
10,36
10,38
10,31
10,34
10,34
10,34
117
90
90
90
90
90
113
90
90
90
90
90
81
96,3
117,1
122,4
90
90
Tab.I.1-1 [ZUG2001]: The parameters of crystalline unit cell of cellulose polymorphs
a, b and c correspond to the axes of unit cell;
, , are the angles between b and c, a and c, a and b , respectively.
I.1.3.1. Native cellulose or cellulose I
Studies on crystalline structure of cellulose started almost one century ago and have generated
many debates. In his recent paper, Zugenmaier [ZUG2001] reported a historical development of
the structure determination of native cellulose. By various techniques, such as X-ray and electron
diffractions, NMR, molecular modelling studies, the global structure has been defined and only
the fine structure is expected to be improved.
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 28 -
Fig.I.1-2 [ZUG2001]: Representation of the model of cellulose I a) onto the a-b plan,
b) intrasheet (100) of molecules through the centre of the unit cell to demonstrate the hydrogen bonding.
a and b axes represent the unit cell vectors as a<b; c is the third axis of the unit cell and corresponds to the fibre axis;
is the angle between a and b
The natural cellulose crystal is metastable and called cellulose I. Cellulose I has a parallel
crystalline structure [ELL1962][GAR1974][SAR1974][MAC1990] and is composed of two
distinct crystalline forms I
and I
, which
has a monoclinic unit with two chains. Fig.I.1-2 represents (a) the typical arrangement of parallel
chains of cellulose I composed of the monoclinic unit of cellulose I
and I
phase
whereas cellulose of higher plants (woody tissues, cotton, ramie etc.) consists mainly of the I
phase.
I.1.3.2. Cellulose II
The crystalline structure of cellulose II is obtained when the native cellulose is either mercerised
(alkaline treatment) or regenerated (dissolution and then precipitation). Cellulose II has an
antiparallel crystalline structure organised in a monoclinic unit with two chains (Fig.I.1-3a)
[SAR1974][KOL1976][STI1976]. After many controversies, in 90s, Isogai et al. [ISO1989] and
Raymond et al. [RAY1995] demonstrated that all hydroxyl groups of cellulose II (in C6) are
oriented gauche-trans (gt), e.i. O61-C61 is positioned gauche to O51-C51 and trans to C41-C51
(Fig.I.1-3b). They also revealed that the central chain is shifted as compared with the cellulose
chains at the origin of the unit cell [RAY1995]. Moreover, cellulose II has a complex network of
hydrogen bonds inside and between molecular layers, which was precisely analysed by Langan et
al. [LAN1999]. These numerous hydrogen bonds induce a greater stability of cellulose II as
compared with cellulose I.
a) b)
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 29 -
Fig.I.1-3 [ZUG2001]: Representation of the model of cellulose II a) onto the a-b plan,
b) intrasheet (010) of molecules through the origin of the unit cell.
a and b axes represent the unit cell vectors as a<b; c is the third axis of the unit cell and corresponds to the fibre axis;
is the angle between a and b
I.1.3.3. Cellulose III
Liquid ammonia treatment of cellulose gives another polymorph: cellulose III. It can be divided
into cellulose III
I
and III
II
obtained from cellulose I and cellulose II respectively. The
transformation of cellulose I to III
I
and of cellulose II to III
II
is reversible. The unit cell for both
cellulose III
I
and III
II
structures is the same but the meridional reflections differ. The chains
arrangement corresponds to the one of the initial cellulose, that is to say parallel for cellulose III
I
and antiparallel for cellulose III
II
[SAR1976]. In 2001, Wada et al. [WAD2001] reported that the
unit cell of cellulose III
I
contains one chain and has a volume twice as small as the one of the
model proposed by Sarko et al. [SAR1976].
I.1.3.4. Cellulose IV
Heating of cellulose III produces the crystalline structure of cellulose IV, thermodynamically
stable. As well as for cellulose III, the two allomorphs IV
I
and IV
II
originate from cellulose I and
cellulose II respectively. The unit cell is orthogonal [GAR1985].
I.1.4- Supra-molecular structure of cellulose
I.1.4.1. Micro-fibrils
The chemical structure of cellulose (part I.1.2-), with a significant network of intra- and
intermolecular hydrogen bonds, generates chain aggregations and highly ordered structures.
In the plasma membrane of cells, enzymes called cellulose synthetases synthesise cellulose
molecules by glucose addition, the degree of polymerisation DP (= number of anhydroglucose
units) reaching several thousand units. As several molecules are synthesised simultaneously in the
same area, they grow in a parallel way [Web site 1]. These parallel cellulose molecules create
hydrogen bonds between them to form the basic crystalline arrangement of cellulose into the
micro-fibrils (Fig.I.1-4). Micro-fibrils have a diameter in the range of 2-20 nm depending on
a)
b)
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 30 -
cellulose origin, and are agglomerated into fibrils. The latter have diameters in the range of 60-
360 m and the arrangement of micro-fibrils also depends on cellulose source.
Cellulose fibres
Macro-fibrils
Micro-fibrils
Cellulose molecules:
glucose chains
Fig.I.1-4 [Web site 2]: Supramolecular structure of cellulose
I.1.4.2. Wood and cotton cellulose fibres
Wood can be divided into two main classes: hardwood (or deciduous wood) that is generally
composed of packed cells with thick walls (Fig.I.1-5) and softwood (or coniferous wood) usually
composed of large cells with thin walls. As we saw previously (part I.1.1-), cells contain cellulose
and also high proportions of lignin, hemicelluloses, etc.
Cotton is a seed hair, unicellular and thus very pure in cellulose. The cotton hair is practically
cylindrical and contains a central canal known as lumen (Fig.I.1-6). When the hair has been
removed from the seed, the cell collapses into a flat ribbon which twists into an irregular spiral
band [MAR1941].
Despite the differences in their origin, the morphological architecture of fibres presents some
similarities: the organisation in layers of fibrils (Fig.I.1-7). On the other hand, the fibrillar texture
and density change according to species [KLE1998].
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 31 -
Fig.I.1-5: Wood is composed of dead cells.
Cellular walls are a composite material of cellulose fibres
and lignin.
Fig.I.1-6: Cotton flower and cotton fibre cross-section.
The blue circle shows a mature cotton fibre, with a thick
and well-developed wall. The red circle shows an
immature cotton fibre with a thin and poorly developed
wall.
Fig.I.1-7 [KLE1998]: Scheme of the morphological architecture of a cotton and delignified spruce fibres:
(A) cotton fibre (B) delignified spruce wood fibre
C = cuticle (rich in pectins and waxes) ML = middle lamella (mainly lignin)
P = primary wall
S1 = secondary wall (winding layer)
S2 = secondary wall (main body)
R = reversal of the fibril spiral T = tertiary wall
L = lumen W = wart layer
The so-called primary wall (P) forms when cells are individualised and it follows their growth
[AIT1988]. In this primary wall, fibrils of about 10nm in diameter are positioned crosswise to a
layer of about 50nm thickness. In his review, Klemm et al. [KLE1998] reported that this
crosswise positioning possibly impedes a swelling of the inner secondary wall (S).
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 32 -
When the cell has reached its definitive size, the secondary wall grows with fine lamellae inside
the cell. The secondary wall consists of many lamellae of cellulose, which are not separated from
one another by non-cellulosic substances but represent dense and less dense areas of a cellulose
fibre. This wall can be divided into two layers S
1
and S
2
.
The thickness of the S
1
layer is about 100nm and 300nm in the case of cotton and spruce
pulp fibre respectively. The fibrils are aligned parallel and densely packed. The angle between
the microfibril and the cell axis is large (50-70), and the direction of helix may be opposite in
subsequent S
1
layers. This structure in S
1
is called crossed fibrillar texture. Moreover, the S
1
layer can strongly impede swelling of the S
2
layer.
The S
2
layer is the thickest within the layers of secondary wall and contains most of the
cellulose mass. It is a compact region in which a high degree of parallelism of microfibrils
exists. The S
2
has a small microfibrils angle to the cell axis (10-30). In wood, despite this
microfibrillar orientation in S
2
, there are lamellae transitions on its inner and outer surfaces.
Several lamellae show a gradual shift of microfibril angles between S
1
and S
2
and between S
2
and S
3
[HON2001]. In cotton, there are some areas in the secondary wall where cellulose
fibrils change from right-hand to left-hand, and vice-versa, at frequent intervals. One type of
reversal (R) is that in which one set of spiral strands ends and a second system running in the
opposite direction begins (Fig.I.1-7A); the ends of the strands overlap at the reversal
[MAR1941].
The inner layer, closest to the fibre lumen, named S
3
for cotton or T for wood, is comparably
thin and has the fibrils aligned in a flat helix as in the layer S
1
.
I.1.5- Extraction of cellulose and activation
I.1.5.1. Manufacture of cellulosic pulp
The manufacture of cellulosic pulp consists of extracting cellulose fibres from the biomass. All
methods induce a progressive impoverishment of the cell wall, i.e. a decrease of the amount of
lignin, hemicelluloses and other compounds, in order to obtain a high proportion of cellulose. As
a result, individualised cellulose fibres are obtained with given morphological, optical and
mechanical characteristics, depending on the source. Pulps can be classified according to the
extraction technique.
o Mechanical pulps
Wood is crushed in order to tear out fibres. With this technique, the yield is significant since pulp
keeps all components of wood lignin, cellulose and hemicelluloses. The use of steam, high
pressure or chemical agents allows obtaining pulps with different properties. As the resistance of
these mechanical pulps is relatively low, they are especially used for newspapers and magazines.
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 33 -
o Chemical pulps
In this technique, only chemical products are added to separate fibres by dissolving lignin.
According to the compound used, different types of pulp are obtained:
The two alkaline processes: (i) the so-called sulphate or Kraft process and (ii) soda
process. These two processes are relatively similar but the former is cheaper and thus
more often used.
The acid process: so-called sulphite process.
These processes are suitable for soft- and hardwood. The main principle consists in cooking
chips in a chemical reactor with white liquor, a liquid composed of chemicals. Cooking is
occurring from 130C to 180C, under pressure, during 2-5 hours depending on wood species.
After this treatment, chips are in suspension in black liquor, a liquid containing chemicals and
dissolved lignin. After defibration, fibres become individualised and flexible. Then, washing and
bleaching steps are following.
An important feature of the alkaline processes is the recovery and the re-utilisation of the
chemicals in the digester liquor and washings after digestion. This serves the double purpose of
economy and elimination of the trouble of disposing of a polluting effluent [GRA1958]. Pulps
obtained from alkaline process have a good mechanical resistance and thus can be used as they
are in wrapping. Despite of a difficult bleaching, these alkaline pulps are also used for printing
paper.
From sulphite process, pulps have lower mechanical properties, especially in tear strength, but
they are light and easy to bleach. However, for environmental reasons, they are rarely used,
except for very refined papers.
o Mi-chemical pulps
Fibres are obtained from moderate chemical and mechanical treatments. They are especially used
in flute papers since fibres are individualised but some lignin is still present. The presence of
lignin rigidifies fibres and induces a high quality of compression resistance.
Other than from wood, pulps can be made of:
Straw: in specific papers with high transparency and rigidity
Cotton and flax: in very resistant papers as bank notes and cigarette papers
Recycled cellulosic fibres: in newspapers and cardboards.
I.1.5.2. Activation of cellulose
As we saw previously, the density of hydroxyl groups in cellulose molecules is quite high. In this
sense, it should not be surprising if cellulose were completely water-soluble. However, this has
never been realised owing to a very high intra- and intermolecular hydrogen bonds in natural
cellulose. These bonds prevent the dissolution of cellulose fibres in aqueous solvents. A so-called
activation of cellulose improves its dissolution by breaking down intramolecular hydrogen bonds,
by decreasing the DP (degree of polymerisation) of cellulose molecules, by removing some layers
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 34 -
of cellulose fibres and by purifying cellulose. Two examples of treatments to activate cellulose are
given below.
o Microcrystalline cellulose
Microcrystalline cellulose (MCC) is a purified and partially depolymerised cellulose. This cellulose
is obtained by a controlled hydrolysis with a diluted mineral acid solution, at ~105C. The fibrous
structure is thus broken and gives a particular structure. In addition, the DP is lowered down to
200. This change of morphology is due to the preferential hydrolysis of cellulose chains in
amorphous region. So MCC cellulose has a high degree of crystallinity. Further filtration of
cellulose suspension enables to purify the sample. The process is schematically shown in Fig.I.1-8
Fig.I.1-8: Process to obtain microcrystalline cellulose
1- Roll of -cellulose; 2- Chipping; 3- Acid hydrolysis;
4- Filtration and washing to remove impurities and chemicals;
5- Drying on a fluidised bed; 6- packaging
Conditions to produce microcrystalline cellulose, which stay trade secrets, considerably influence
the quality of the final cellulose pulp.
o Steam exploded pulp
The steam explosion method has the potential ability to destroy the inner and outer structure of
any material. The destruction of the inner structure of cellulose corresponds to the breakdown of
O3-HO5 intramolecular hydrogen bonds, which seems to be the key for producing alkali-
soluble cellulose, as demonstrated by Kamide et al. [KAM1984] with solid-state cross-
polarisation/magic angle sample spinning
13
C NMR (CP/MAS/
13
C NMR). The destruction of
the outer structure corresponds to the removing of primary wall of cellulose fibres, which
prevents swelling of secondary wall and thus fibre dissolution.
The steam explosion apparatus was originally designed by Sawada [SAW1985] and the explosion
process is schematised Fig.I.1-9 [YAM1990].
Stage 1: Cellulose is stored at room temperature.
Stage 2: In order to obtain a weight ratio water/cellulose of 1/1, one weight part of cellulose
is immersed in 20 weight parts of distilled water at 25C for 15h; then the excess water is
removed by centrifuging (2000rpm, 5min)
Steam explosion: 200g (dry base) of the so-prepared cellulose is put into the vessel heated at a
desired temperature. The vessel is closed. Then a saturated water vapour controlled to a given
steam pressure P is introduced into the vessel for a given treatment time t (15-300s).
Controlling the time enables to control the final DP.
Stage 3: The vapour input valve is closed and the valve connected to the discharging nozzle is
abruptly opened. Thus the treated cellulose is discharged.
Stage 4: Treated sample is thoroughly washed with water.
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 35 -
Fig.I.1-9 [YAM1990]: Schematic representation of the steam explosion process.
Yamashiki et al. [YAM1990] reported that soft wood pulp is very sensitive to steam explosion
treatment because of the high porosity of fibres. On the other hand, hard wood pulp necessitates
higher pressure to be completely soluble in 9%NaOH/water. Finally, the morphology and
solubility of cotton linter do practically not change after steam explosion treatment.
I.2- CELLULOSE DISSOLUTION IN ALKALINE HYDROXIDE AQUEOUS SOLUTIONS
Cellulose is not a thermoplastic polymer. Thus, cellulose melting is not possible and dissolution is
a necessary step to process cellulose. Because of intra- and intermolecular hydrogen bonds, the
penetration of solvent is difficult and it has to be strong enough to break them. Different types
of solvent can be used; they are largely described and classified by Klemm et al. [KLE1998]. The
oldest process to dissolve cellulose is named viscose process: cellulose is chemically
transformed before being dissolved, this is the xanthation step. But as this process is polluting, an
alternative route is to dissolve cellulose in alkali hydroxide aqueous solutions. After describing the
current industrial process (part I.2.1-), we will present the first studies on this new solvent of
cellulose (part I.2.2.1). Our work was based on these data concerning experimental conditions:
concentrations, temperature, additives. Several authors investigated cellulose/alkali hydroxide
aqueous solutions (parts I.2.2.2 and I.2.2.3) in order to understand the dissolution mechanism.
Some hypotheses are given concerning the mechanism at the level of fibres and microfibrils (part
I.2.2.4), but there are practically no literature dealing with the mechanism at the molecular level.
Concerning additives, it will be shown that the influence of the proportion between NaOH and
urea or thiourea or zinc oxide was studied in details (part I.2.3-). However, the mechanism of the
action of these additives still remains unclear, despites a rather large amount of publications.
Pure cellulose
(Pulp, cotton)
Wetted cellulose
(Pulp, cotton)
Water
Stocked at Troom
Water content = 10%
Water content = 100%
Steam Explosion
As-steam-treated
cellulose
(Pulp, cotton)
Water content = 200%
Water content = 10%
Washed steam-treated
cellulose
(Pulp, cotton)
P = 15 bars
t = X sec.
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
Stage 4
Washing
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 36 -
I.2.1- Xanthation in viscose process
The viscose process was discovered in 1892 by Cross, Bevan and Beadley and allowed spinning
of viscose fibres. Still nowadays, the step of xanthation of this process is a method widely used in
industry to dissolve cellulose. This process can be divided into three main chemical steps, which
are identical in most of the industrial viscose processes (Fig.I.2-1).
Fig.I.2-1: Scheme of viscose process
(1) formation of alkali-cellulose, (2) xanthation (3) dissolution
(1) Cellulose, prepared from either wood pulp or, less commonly, cotton linters, is treated with
17-20% sodium hydroxide (NaOH), at a temperature in the range of 18-25C, to convert
cellulose to alkali-cellulose.
Cell-OH + NaOH Cell-O
-
,Na
+
+ H
2
O
Cellulose fibres are swelling and become more accessible to other reactants. Then the alkali
cellulose is aged under controlled conditions of time and temperature (between 18 and 30C)
in order to depolymerise the cellulose to the desired degree of polymerisation (DP). The
molecular weight obtained determines the viscosity of viscose solution and cellulose
concentration.
(2) After this maturing step, carbon disulfide (CS
2
), in gas or liquid state, is added to the solution
of alkali-cellulose to react with hydroxyl groups and generate the xanthation reaction:
S
Cell-O
-
,Na
+
+ CS
2
Cell-O-C
S
-
,Na
+
The resulting product is a substance called cellulose xanthate.
(3) Then this alkaline cellulose xanthate is dissolved in dilute sodium hydroxide (~2.7 wt%) and
forms a viscous solution called viscose.
S S
-
,Na
+
Cell-O-C + NaOH + H
2
O Cell-O-C OH + H
2
O
S
-
,Na
+
S
-
,Na
+
(1)
(2)
(3)
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 37 -
The large xanthate substituents on the cellulose force the chains apart, reducing the
interchain hydrogen bonds and allowing water molecules to solvate and separate the chains.
After obtaining viscose, industrial processes vary. The next steps can be: filtration and then
spinning to obtain fibres or thin films, addition of reinforcing fibres and porophores then
moulding to obtain sponges (see Chapter V), etc.
The last step of processes is called coagulation: cellulose is precipitating in regeneration baths
(water, acid or base). The final regenerated cellulose is obtained and CS
2
and sulphured
compounds formed during chemical reactions are going out.
However, viscose process involves some pollution: in the atmosphere, because of CS
2
and H
2
S,
and in water, because of the reducing agents (containing sulphur compounds) which decrease the
oxygen amount in water. Optimisation and improvement in the viscose process result in a total
recycling of the pollutant compounds in the aqueous phase and in a decrease of pollutant
compounds in the atmosphere. Nowadays the quantity of the latter is only 10% of CS
2
used
initially. Unfortunately, technologies for pollution treatment are very expensive. Thus for
economical and for environmental reasons, it is very important to find new cellulose solvents.
The purpose of research laboratories is to step away from the chemical modifications of cellulose
by CS
2
. NMMO, for example, is a good cellulose solvent, but these solutions are not very easy to
prepare and to process. That is why it is interesting to look for alternative routes.
I.2.2- Action of alkaline hydroxide solutions on cellulose fibres
For a long time, it was known that strong alkaline aqueous solutions act on cellulose. Indeed, at
the end of 19
th
century, Mercer [MER1903] discovered that cellulose fibres are swelling in
aqueous solutions of sodium hydroxide and that was drastically changing the properties of the
fibres. Several years later, in 1939, Sobue showed that cellulose can be dissolved in a narrow
range of temperature and concentration of NaOH [SOB1939].
I.2.2.1. Introduction on mercerisation process and cellulose dissolution
Mercerisation is a process, which John Mercer developed between 1844 and 1850. Cotton cloth is
immersed in a strong caustic alkaline solution, and then washed, in order to improve the lustre
and smoothness, for example. Mercerisation also increases the ability to absorb dye, improves the
reactions with a variety of chemicals, the strength and elongation of fibres and the stability of
form. This type of cotton is often compared to silk and is especially used to produce high-quality
fabrics. But this process tended to shrink the cotton cloth. In 1889, Horace Lowe improved this
technique by keeping the material under tension whilst being mercerised and he applied a more
thorough washing process to remove the caustic soda. Thus the mercerisation became a viable
textile process.
During mercerisation, alkaline solution acts on cellulose chains by changing the fine structure,
morphology and conformation of cotton. The native cellulose I crystalline form is transformed
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 38 -
into cellulose II, resulting in a variation in fibre strength and lustre as well as adsorption
properties. In addition, soda fills up almost entirely the central cavity (the lumen) of cotton fibres.
So, the ribbon-like cotton fibres become perfectly cylindrical and loose their convolutions
inducing a smoother and shinier texture [MAR1941]. In mercerising, a decrease in length of
cotton hair is accompanied by an increase in diameter: cellulose fibres are swelling.
According to Mercer [MER1903], mercerisation also occurs at low NaOH concentration
(~9%NaOH) and the properties of cotton are improved. The lower the temperature, the more
effectively the soda acts on the fibrous material. This reveals that the term of mercerisation was
very wide and corresponded to all changes in cellulose fibres due to the action of alkaline
hydroxide aqueous solutions. Several conditions of temperatures and NaOH concentrations are
reported depending on material (cotton, ramie, flax, yarn or cloth) and on process. The most
often used conditions are 18-32% NaOH concentrations at 25-40C. It is important to note that
hardly few minutes (from 20s to 3min) are enough to obtain mercerisation of cellulose.
Nowadays, the term of mercerisation essentially represents the action of concentrated alkali
hydroxides on cellulose.
The NaOH concentration and temperature conditions to swell cellulose fibres are relatively well
determined and slightly change depending on cellulose origin. In 30s, Davidson defined optimal
conditions to dissolve modified cotton. As illustrated Fig.I.2-2, a decrease of temperature
improves hydrocellulose dissolution in sodium hydroxide solutions [DAV1934]
(hydrocellulose was obtained by cellulose hydrolysis with strong acids).
Fig.I.2-2 [DAV1934]: Hydrocellulose solubility versus
NaOH concentration and solution temperature
The maximum solubility is 80% and it occurs at NaOH concentration of 10%, at 5C.
Moreover, the solubility increases when the chain length decreases. Consequently, authors
concluded that unmodified cellulose cannot be dissolved because of the large length of the
macromolecules. But, in 1939, Sobue et al [SOB1939] showed that it is possible to dissolve
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 39 -
cellulose, from natural ramie fibres, in a narrow range of phase diagram: between NaOH
concentrations of 7% and 10% at low temperature (-5C/+1C).
In the 80s-90s, cellulose dissolution in 7-10%NaOH/water was largely studied. Kamide et al.
[KAM1984] revealed that regenerated cellulose can be dissolved in NaOH/water and that the
dissolution depends on the degree of breakdown in O3-HO5 intramolecular hydrogen bonds.
They also showed that the cellulose solubility depends on the DP, the concentration and the
crystallinity of cellulose samples. Some years later [KAM1990], the authors also compared the X-
ray diffraction peak intensities of cellulose I (I
1
) and Na-Cell I (I
2
) as a function of cellulose
concentration in 9%NaOH/water. Fig.I.2-3 represents the results obtained. It appears that up to
9% of steam exploded cellulose (DP being ~340), there is no peak of cellulose I and no peak of
Na-cell I. This means that 9%NaOH/water totally dissolves cellulose when its concentration is
inferior to 9% and that the total dissolution of cellulose I (C
cell
< 9%) in 9%NaOH aqueous
solution gives a solution without conversion of cellulose I to Na-Cell I.
Fig.I.2-3 [KAM1990]: The cellulose concentration dependence of I1 and I2
for cellulose/9%NaOH aqueous system at 4C.
More recently, it was shown that a ground Borregaard cellulose with a DP of 550 is swelling in a
heterogeneous way in contact with a 9%NaOH/water solution [ROY_PhD]: some cellulose
fibres remain non-swollen and non-dissolved, some others are partly dissolved and some others
are swollen with balloons. The formation and the reason of the appearance of these balloons
were largely studied in our laboratory these three past years, on different native cellulose fibres
(cotton, wood) in mixtures of NMMO/water [CUI2006a] and in NaOH/water with or
without additives (ZnO and urea) [CUI2006b]. In good solvent of cellulose, the dissolution is
occurring in four phases. First, the cellulose fibre swells by ballooning, with cellulose being totally
dissolved inside the balloons. This phase gives the beaded structure often observed in relatively
bad cellulose solvent. Secondly, the balloons continue to swell until the burst of the membrane.
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 40 -
Then the unswollen sections (between two balloons) are dissolved from the surface to the centre
of the fibre. Finally, the scraps of the membrane are then dissolved. At this stage, all cellulose is
dissolved [CUI2006a]. In a worse cellulose solvent, the dissolution of cellulose fibres is stopping
at one of these phases. This is the case when 7.6%NaOH/water is used at -5C to dissolve native
cellulose fibres; the balloons are formed but do not burst [CUI2006b]. This paper also revealed
that the presence of urea increases the quality of the alkaline solvent by a faster balloon
formation, with a larger expansion. On the other hand, the presence of ZnO increases the
swelling kinetics but decreases the size of balloons.
When cellulose is dissolved, even partly, in 9%NaOH/water, the solutions obtained are not
stable. Gelation is occurring and the gel time decreases when the temperature increases
[ROY2003].
I.2.2.2. Formation of alkali-celluloses
Mercer [MER1903] listed the influence of NaOH concentrations on cellulose fibre swelling:
3.2% NaOH is without action
6.5% NaOH acts only very slightly and at very low temperature
10% NaOH increases the effect which remains most marked at the lowest temperature
18.8% NaOH greatly increases the effect on cellulose.
This seems to be the outline of the cellulose/NaOH/H
2
O phase diagram (Erreur ! Source du
renvoi introuvable.) plotted by Sobue et al [SOB1939]. Fig.I.2-4 shows the presence of five
different forms of alkali celluloses, or Na-Cell (I, II, III, IV or Q and V).
Fig.I.2-4 [SOB1939]: Phase diagram of the system cellulose/NaOH/water, cellulose being natural ramie fibres.
This graph reveals zones of different sodium celluloses as a function of NaOH concentration and temperature.
The unbroken hatching indicates the regions in which the sodium cellulose concerned is optimally formed.
The formation of these Na-Cell compounds depends on the temperature (from -20C to 100C)
and NaOH concentration (from 0% to 45% by weight) but the boundaries of the various regions
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 41 -
are defined more or less distinctly. For example, below 0C and at about 8 wt% NaOH
concentration, is the location of what the authors called the alkali cellulose Na-Cell Q, Q as
Quellung (swelling in German). Its X-Ray diffraction pattern is very characteristic and reveals a
highly disordered state and a swelling in layers [SOB1939].
Sobue et al. [SOB1939] also investigated the composition of alkali celluloses from the correlation
between two methods: the solid-phase analysis and the examination of volumes. The latter is
based on the difference between the volumes of Na-Cellulose unit cell, determined from X-ray
diffraction patterns, and of cellulose unit cell. This difference in volume can be used as a
measurement for the quantity of the substance incorporated into the lattice by substituting the
required volume for NaOH (32.6
3
) and for H
2
O (29.7
3
). Their conclusions are reported
Tab.I.2-1.
Sodium celluloses Most probable composition Molecular weight Density
Na-Cell I C6H10O5 1NaOH 3H2O 256 1.51
Na-Cell III C6H10O5 1NaOH 2H2O 238 1.51
Na-Cell II C6H10O5 1NaOH 1H2O 220 1.6
Na-Cell V C6H10O5 1NaOH 4.5-5H2O 283-292 1.41-1.46
Na-Cell IV C6H10O5 1H2O 180 1.48
Tab.I.2-1 [SOB1939] : Most probable compositions of sodium celluloses
and the molecular weights and densities calculated therefrom.
I.2.2.3. Hydration of alkali ions
In 1941, Marsh [MAR1941] published a review of different works concerning cellulose swelling
in aqueous solutions of alkaline hydroxides as lithium, sodium, and potassium but also rubidium
and caesium. It appears that all alkaline hydroxides can act on cotton hairs and that the maximum
of swelling is reached at a certain hydroxide concentration depending on the nature of metallic
ion (Fig.I.2-5).
Fig.I.2-5 [HEU1925]: Change in volume of cotton hairs in five alkalis
Swelling is measured in terms of volume percentage between swollen and dried fibres.
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 42 -
An increase of the atomic force of the metallic ion Li < Na < K < Rb < Cs leads to a
decrease of swelling. Bigger is the alkali ion, more difficult is its penetration into cellulose fibres
[PET1948] but more uniform is the swelling [SRE1993]
The shape of the swelling versus alkali concentration curves can be explained by the size of
hydrates [FRE1983]. For low alkaline hydroxide concentrations, a lot of water molecules form
hydrated ion pairs (Fig.I.2-6). The hydrodynamic diameter of this system is too large to easily
penetrate into the macromolecular structure of cellulose. Thus the swelling is relatively low.
When ion concentration increases, the number of water molecules decreases to form solvated
dipole hydrates. The hydrodynamic diameter decreases and ions can penetrate into amorphous
and then well-organised domains. The maximum of swelling is reached.
Low-concentrated
solutions
Concentrated
solutions
Pair of separated ions
Pair of hydrated ions
Solvated hydrated dipole
Hydrated dipole
Fig.I.2-6: Various forms and the corresponding hydrodynamic diameter
of hydrates as a function of ion concentration
Another explanation is based on the necessity of the presence of water to swell cellulose
[LEG1952]. If NaOH concentration is too low, the number of Na
+
is insufficient to bring water
molecules into cellulose chain in order to cleave hydrogen bonding. If the NaOH concentration
is too high, the hydration of alkali ions is insufficient to break hydrogen bonding [KUO2005].
Investigating the solubility of oxycellulose (Oxycellulose being obtained after the action of
an oxidant agent on cellulose) in these alkaline hydroxides, Davidson [DAV1936] showed that
they follow the same order as previously for swelling: KOH < NaOH and LiOH, solubility being
less than 5% and 85-90% respectively (Fig.I.2-7).
Due to considerations of cost and efficacy, only caustic soda is used as alkali in mercerisation, to
change the aspect of cellulose fibres, and is considered for a potential use to dissolve cellulose.
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 43 -
Fig.I.2-7 [DAV1936]: Oxycellulose solubility versus
alkali concentration and type of ion, at 5C.
I.2.2.4. Mechanism of mercerisation
It is known that the sodium hydrate size depends on the NaOH concentration [PIC1893] and
that the cellulose dissolution region is very narrow (Fig.I.2-4). In 1990, from an X-Ray diffraction
analysis, Kamide et al. [KAM1990] proved that NaOH penetrates into the cellulose chains
inducing swelling of fibres. Thus we can think that there is an optimal size of sodium hydrate at
which it can penetrate into cellulose fibres. This hypothesis has been mentioned by Yamashiki et
al. [YAM1988], but the problem with this paper is that the molar ratios do not seem correct.
Nevertheless, according to them, Na
+
does not play an important role in the dissolution of
cellulose. The main parameter is to have a specific structure of alkali hydroxide, which is formed
at 9%NaOH. Na
+
and OH
-
ions, surrounded by their solvation cages, break the intra- and
intermolecular hydrogen bonds in the solid structure of the cellulose. Sodium hydrates interact
with the cellulose chains and give various Na-Cell compounds depending on the experimental
conditions as it appears on the phase diagram (Fig.I.2-4) [SOB1939]. If sodium hydroxide is then
removed from the mixture, the alkali cellulose transforms into cellulose II.
As we saw previously (partI.2.2.1), the irreversible transformation from cellulose I, with a parallel
crystalline structure, to cellulose II, with an antiparallel crystalline structure, at room temperature,
is named mercerisation. Okano, Sarko and Nishimura [OKA1984] [OKA1985] [NIS1987a]
[NIS1987b] studied in details the mechanism and the molecular changes of this transformation
and mentioned the complex Na-Cell I as the first intermediate component. This complex has an
antiparallel structure [OKA1985], very similar, in the chain conformation, to the structure of
cellulose II [NIS1991a]. The structure of Na-Cell Q, mentioned by Sobue [SOB1939], was not
analysed extensively because of temperature conditions (below 0C).
A proposed mechanism of mercerisation is schematised on the Fig.I.2-8.
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 44 -
Fig.I.2-8 [OKA1985]: Possible mechanism of mercerisation
The raw material is native cellulose, or cellulose I, which has a parallel crystalline structure. In
a fibre of cellulose, there are a large number of crystallites in which the chain directions are
parallel but the crystallites are distributed along the fibre axis with equal probability for up
and down directions, as represented in the Fig.I.2-8 1
st
pattern. French et al. [FRE1987]
reported that the convention used by the most authors is that the cellulose chain direction is
defined by the vector from C4 to C1, i.e. from the non-reducing to the reducing ends. If the
angle between the vector C4-C1 and the c-direction (fibre axis) of the unit cell is acute, the
chain is called up, if not, it is called down. Let us note that Gardner and Blackwell
[GAR1974], for example, interchanged this notation.
It was demonstrated that the accessibility of OH groups depends on the crystallinity of
cellulose [TAS1994]. Consequently, highly crystalline cellulose is difficult to mercerise
[CHA1976]. Thus, to begin the mercerisation it is necessary to have an amorphous phase in
the cellulose or some imperfections in the crystalline morphology. During the first step of the
mercerisation, the alkali solution enters the amorphous regions that exist as the interface
regions between the crystallites, where the polymer chains are arranged along both directions
up and down. The penetration of NaOH/H
2
O causes swelling of cellulose fibres
[OKA1984] and in these swollen regions, the polymer chains are expected to be relatively
mobile. Thus very little lateral movements of chain segments enable the formation of an
antiparallel soda-cellulose, the Na-Cell I [OKA1985]. In terms of energy and entropy, the
formation of Na-Cell I is favoured and thus the crystalline regions of cellulose I gradually
diminish in size while the crystallites of Na-Cell I increase simultaneously [PET1948]
[NIS1987a]. Furthermore, as the amount of amorphous regions does not increase during the
conversion steps, the authors concluded on a crystal-to-crystal phase transition occurring
without an intervening amorphous state [OKA1984]. This shows that the conversion from
the parallel cellulose I to antiparallel Na-Cell I proceeds through a side slip of polymer chains
and not a reversal of those.
Na-Cell I contains one NaOH molecule per anhydroglucose unit (AGU) and has a twofold
helical chain conformation with a repeat unit of 10.1. Fig.I.2-9 schematises the various
possibilities of interactions between the cellulose chains and the Na
+
ions. Practically all
authors [KAM1985] [NIS1991a] [TAK1991] [FIN1995] [ISO1997] agree that Na
+
breaks the
intermolecular hydrogen bonds O2_HO6 and that the most probable location of the Na
+
ion is on the OH at C2. The carbon C3 is more resistant to the complexation with the
sodium hydroxide.
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 45 -
Fig.I.2-9 [FIN1995]: Interaction between Na
+
and the cellulose chain.
When the initial conversion step is completed, the Na-Cell I is free to absorb more NaOH
and convert to Na-Cell II, with a threefold helical chain conformation with a repeat unit of
15.4.
Finally, after NaOH has been washed out of the structure, the cellulose chains again revert to
a twofold helical conformation (lower energy structure without NaOH), cellulose II
polymorphic form. Later, Nishimura and Sarko [NIS1991b] added the Na-Cell IV as an
intermediate compound between the Na-Cell II and the cellulose II.
I.2.3- Influence of additives on cellulose dissolution
I.2.3.1. Influence of zinc oxide (ZnO)
Mercer [MER1903] reported that the mercerisation can begin at low NaOH concentrations
(8.5%-9%NaOH) when the temperature is decreased below 0C. He added: It is a remarkable fact,
however, that the addition of zinc oxide to a lye containing 9%NaOH will enable it to mercerise at ordinary
temperature. () it is ineffective if the solution is heated.
In the last part of his article, Davidson [DAV1937] showed that ZnO improves oxycellulose
dissolution and that unmodified cotton can be dissolved at 5C, at a relatively high
ZnO/NaOH ratio (Fig.I.2-10 and Tab.I.2-2). He added that precipitation of zinc oxide takes
place if the ZnO/NaOH ratio is too high and especially for concentrated-cellulose solutions.
The last paper talking about the addition of ZnO into cellulose/alkali hydroxide aqueous
solutions is a Polish patent [WO02/22924]. It revealed that in order to improve the stability of
cellulose solutions, zinc oxide content has to be at least 0.1wt% (0.01N), NaOH concentration
being inferior to 10wt%.
Davidson [DAV1937] also investigated the influence of ZnO on cellulose dissolution in
potassium hydroxide (KOH). As ZnO is difficult to dissolve in KOH, only one ZnO/KOH ratio
was studied and was equal 0.14. Author showed that the addition of ZnO increases the
percentage of oxycellulose dissolved but dissolution remains very low.
Chapter I State of the art: cellulose and its dissolution in alkaline hydroxide aqueous solutions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 46 -
Maximum dissolution
ZnO/NaOH
(moles)
NaOH
(N)
NaOH
(%)
ZnO
(%)
%
dissolved
0.0 2.5 10 0 5.2
0.05 2.5 10 1.0 14.5
0.10 2.5 10 2.0 39.2
0.178 2.75 11 4.0 70.1
0.229 2.75 11 5.1 82.6
Tab.I.2-2: Values of NaOH and ZnO concentrations obtained
at the maximum dissolution of cotton linter for a given
ZnO/NaOH ratio, from Erreur ! Source du renvoi introuvable..
Fig.I.2-10 [DAV1937]: Cotton linter solubility, at -5C, as a
function of NaOH concentration and the ZnO/NaOH ratio
Unfortunately, no article gives any explanation concerning the action of ZnO on cellulose
dissolution. We only know that when ZnO is dissolved in alkaline solution, new compounds are
formed. In the literature, it is stipulated that, depending on NaOH concentration, the dissolution
of ZnO in NaOH gives several zinc hydroxides. The determination of the compounds formed
between NaOH and ZnO is not easy and the conclusions differ from one paper to the other. But
most of authors agree that at high pH (~12), the main species are Zn(OH)
3
-
, Zn(OH)
4
2-
and
Zn
2
(OH)
6
2-
[DIR1954] [REI1975].
I.2.3.2. Influence of urea and thiourea
In 1998, Laszkiewicz [LAS1998] reported that the addition of 1% urea in 8.5% NaOH at 5C
improves the solubility of bacterial cellulose having an initial DP of 680. The fraction of
dissolved cellulose is 48.6% with 1% urea and 17.8% without urea. Some years later, a research
group in Wuhan University in China reported that cellulose is totally dissolved in NaOH with
urea [ZHO2000] [ZHO2002a] [ZHO2004] or thiourea [ZHA2002] [WEN2004] and both
additives are removed out completely from the cellulose during the coagulation and washing.
Zhou et al. [ZHO2000] investigated the influence of NaOH/urea solvent composition on
cellulose dissolution. They concluded that the optimal NaOH/urea/water ratios to dissolve
cellulose at 0C are 6/4/90 and 8/2/90. According to them, cellulose solutions in these solvents
are stable and did not form a gel with temperature increase. They also studied the influence of
cellulose molecular weight on the dissolution for different NaOH/urea solvent compositions and
for different cellulose samples (Fig.I.2-11). From their papers, we calculated the DP of each
sample with M
/162, where M
= Tp Cp Ro T
E
. .
CpE represents the sample calorific capacity. E = S or L if
the sample is in solid or liquid state respectively.
II.3.1.3. Melting temperature measurement
A melting thermogram reveals the melting temperature Tf and gives the melting enthalpy H.
In the case of a pure substance, melting is isothermal. Tf is determined at the onset of the peak
and corresponds to the intersection between the straight line
= Tp Cp P
S
. (CpS is the calorific
capacity of the sample in solid state) and the straight line of peak increase. The melting thermogram of
distilled water is an example (Fig.II.3-4).
Chapter II Materials and methods
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-73-
-20 -10 0 10 20
TC
P
Endothermic
reaction
Exothermic
reaction
Fig.II.3-4: Melting thermogram of distilled water
Heating rate = +1C/min
In the case of a binary system where the two components are not miscible, the DSC
thermograms reveal two peaks. The first one allows defining the solidus, it is sharp and the
melting temperature is determined as in the case of a pure substance: at the onset of the peak.
The second peak allows defining the liquidus, the melting occurs in a range of several degrees and
Tf is determined at the end of the peak and corresponds to the intersection between the straight
line
= Tp Cp P
L
. (CpL is the calorific capacity of sample in liquid state) and the straight line of peak
decrease. The melting thermogram of 7.6% NaOH aqueous solution is an example (Fig.II.3-5).
-50 -40 -30 -20 -10 0 10
TC
P
Fig.II.3-5: Melting thermogram of 7.6%NaOH aqueous solution
Heating rate = +1C/min
= Tp Cp P
S
.
T
f
= Tp Cp P
S
.
T
f(end)
= Tp Cp P
L
.
Chapter II Materials and methods
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-74-
II.3.1.4. Melting enthalpy measurement
Integrating the melting peak gives the melting enthalpy. It can be shown that the enthalpy of
transition can be expressed as follows:
KA H = H is the enthalpy of transition
A is the area under the curve
K is the calorimetric constant
The calorimetric constant K varies from instrument to instrument and depends on experimental
conditions. K can be determined by analyzing a well-characterized sample with known enthalpies
of transition [PUN1994].
II.3.1.5. Calibration and experimental conditions
Before quantitative measurement, the calorimeter has to be calibrated to obtain the calorimetric
constant K and to determine an exact temperature scale. This calibration is performed by using
very pure substances with well-known melting enthalpies and with melting temperatures near the
experimental conditions.
s
s
A
H
K
=
HS is the melting enthalpy of the well-characterized pure substance
AS is the area of DSC melting peak of this well-characterized pure substance
In studies of an ordinary polymer or metal, indium is the most often used as a reference; its
melting temperature is 156.6C. As our experiments are performed between -60C and +20C, it
is better to use a reference substance with a melting temperature below 0C. Moreover,
calibration has to be performed in more or less the same conditions as the experiments, that is to
say in the same capsules and with the same heating rate.
Stainless steel gold-plated screwed capsules have been used because of the corrosive action of
high concentrated NaOH-water solutions on aluminium capsules. These stainless steel capsules
(Perkin-Elmer B018-2901 and B018-2902) withstand an internal pressure of 150 atmospheres
and temperature up to +400C. To carry out a perfect capsule locking, a gold-plated copper
seal is added and capsule is locked with wrenches.
The stainless steel capsules have a high thermal resistivity: heat flows are slow. Thus, in order to
be near the thermodynamical equilibrium, it is necessary to apply low heating and cooling rates.
So heating and cooling rates were equal to 1C/min for all experiments of this work.
DSC apparatus was calibrated with n-decane (to determine K) and distilled water (to fix the
temperature scale). The melting temperature of n-decane is -29.66C; its melting enthalpy is
202.090J/g. The melting temperature of distilled water is naturally considered as being 0C.
Moreover, in order to check the temperature scale, n-dodecane with a melting
temperature at -9.65C was analysed.
Chapter II Materials and methods
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-75-
II.3.1.6. Software for peaks deconvolution: PeakFit 4.12
Each solid phase present in a system gives a melting peak when its melting temperature is
reached. As enthalpy is a function of weight (enthalpy unit = J/g), each melting peak depends on
the amount of the corresponding solid phase. Thus, we can deduce that measurement of melting
enthalpies gives information on the contribution of each phase in the system.
In the case of a mixture, several peaks may appear and each of it has to be characterised. Fig.II.3-
5 shows the melting peaks of the NaOH/water eutectic mixture and of water in
7.6%NaOH/water solution (such thermograms will be explained in chapter III); here both peaks
are well separated from each other and can be easily characterised. For the case of urea/water
solution, the situation becomes more complicated (Fig.II.3-6a) and with the increase of urea
concentration, water peak is practically hidden inside melting peak of urea/water eutectic
mixture (Fig.II.3-6b). In order to obtain melting enthalpies of each peak, a peak deconvolution
program was used: PeakFit 4.12 from Systat. An example of similar thermograms treatment with
this program can be found in literature [PRA1995].
DSC thermograms and peaks deconvolution
6% urea aqueous solution
0
0,2
0,4
0,6
0,8
1
1,2
1,4
-30 -25 -20 -15 -10 -5 0 5 10
TC
H
e
a
t
f
l
o
w
(
W
/
g
)
experimental points
eutectic peak
ice peak
sum
DSC thermograms and peaks deconvolution
20% urea aqueous solution
0
0,2
0,4
0,6
0,8
1
1,2
1,4
-30 -25 -20 -15 -10 -5 0 5 10
TC
H
e
a
t
f
l
o
w
(
W
/
g
)
experimental points
eutectic peak
ice peak
sum
a)
b)
Fig.II.3-6: DSC melting thermograms and peaks deconvolution for a) 6% urea + H2O and b) 20%urea + H2O
Chapter II Materials and methods
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-76-
First of all, the equations describing the peak shape must be chosen. On DSC thermograms
(Fig.II.3-6a), the melting peak of water (at higher temperature) is very asymmetric and can not be
defined by simple Gaussian or Lorentzian functions. Several functions were tested and an
Exponentially Modified Gaussian function (EMG) was chosen because of the best fit and
possibility to vary the asymmetric coefficient (Eq.1).
(
(
+
|
|
\
|
|
|
\
|
+ =
3
3
3
2
2
1
3
1
2
3
2
2
3
0
. 2 . 2 2
exp
2 a
a
a
a
a
a x
erf
a
x a
a
a
a
a
y Eq. 1
Where x corresponds to the temperature and where the coefficients a
0
, a
1
, a
2
and a
3
are adjustable
parameters:
a0 is the peak area
a1 is the peak centre
a2 is the peak width (>0)
a3 is the distortion (0)
Fig.II.3-6 reveals the comparison between experimental points and calculated curves. The fit is
good, the same result was obtained for other thermograms. Thus, the choice of the EMG
function is correct and will be used in the following for peaks deconvolution.
Such deconvolutions were performed for all experiments. After having fitted the four variables,
the software calculates the percentage of each peak in comparison with the total area. As DSC
analysis gives the total enthalpy, we can determine the contribution of each phase and calculate
the melting enthalpies of the different compounds.
II.3.2- XR diffraction
In our study, X-rays diffraction was only used to check:
If the solid phase, which crystallises in binary system containing more than 30% of urea +
water (see Chapter III), is pure urea.
The nature of cellulose samples tested in this work. Are they cellulose I or cellulose II?
The diffractometer system was a XPERT-PRO (from PANalytical). The electron voltage was
40kV, the current was 30mA and the anticathode was made of Cu, so the wavelength K
1
was
1.5406 . The diffraction patterns were obtained by a continuous single scan from 5 to 60 with
0.04 steps.
The preparation of samples consisted in deposing the material (in liquid or solid state) on the
holder. Pure urea and cellulose samples were in solid state pellets and fibres respectively.
Moreover, as experiments were carried out at room temperature, the 70%urea+water sample was
a mixture of crystals and solution. It was the only sample for which the surface was difficult to
prepare. The surface has to be very smooth and in the continuity of the borders of the support.
Chapter II Materials and methods
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-77-
When the surface is irregular, the diffraction peaks can be slightly shifted in comparison with the
theoretical ones. If the studied sample is unknown, translation of some peaks can induce serious
mistakes in the determination of nature, crystallographic structure, and elementary unit of crystal.
In our case, the components present in the samples were known, so the irregularity on surface of
the 70%urea+water sample was not a problem.
The diffraction spectrum consists in a network of peaks or spots (depending on the detector
nature). Each trace corresponds to a series of lattice planes (hkl), which is characteristic of the
crystallographic structure. So, the crystalline parameters can be determined from the Braggs law:
n d
hkl
= sin 2
dhkl is the length between two consecutive lattice plane and
1
2
c
l
b
k
a
h
d
hkl
+ + =
h, k and l represent the Miller indexes of the considered lattice plane and a, b and c
represent the parameters of crystalline unit.
is the angle between the sample surface and the incident ray.
is the wavelength of X-rays used.
n diffraction order
i incident radiation (hkl) lattice plane
d scattered radiation Braggs angle
For native cellulose and cellulose II, the lattice parameters are given in Appendix I.
II.3.3- Rheology
The flow and gelation of semi-dilute and dilute cellulose solutions were studied using different
rheological methods. They are briefly described in this section.
II.3.3.1. Semi-dilute cellulose solution
Rheological measurements of semi-dilute cellulose solutions were performed on a:
StressTech rheometer (Reologica Instruments) equipped with a thermobath to control the
temperature. The tested solutions were equilibrated at a given temperature for 30 minutes
before starting the viscosity versus shear rate measurements.
The geometry used was a Couette double gap, it is made of two concentric cylinders (both
gaps = 2mm). The volume of cellulose solution was about 24ml.
Chapter II Materials and methods
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-78-
Gemini 150 rheometer (Bohlin Instruments) equipped with a Peltier temperature control.
With such a temperature control, temperatures can vary in a quick and accurate way, up to 60
degrees per minute in the interval from -30C to 180C. The sample remained 60s at
temperature before measurement.
The geometry used was a cone and plane (60/2), made of stainless steel. About 3ml of
solution was placed on the plate in order to fill the gap perfectly (Fig.II.3-7). A solvent trap
was used to avoid evaporation.
Fig.II.3-7: Scheme to fill the gap between cone and plate correctly
Steady state mode
The measurements of viscosity (Pa.s) versus shear rate (s
-1
) were performed in isothermal mode
at different temperatures from 0C to +40C. The shear rate varied from 0.05s
-1
to 100s
-1
.
Oscillatory mode
The storage modulus G and the loss modulus G were measured as a function of time or of
temperature.
The kinetics of gelation was studied at various constant temperatures from +10C to +40C.
To be in linear regime (Appendix 2), the frequency was fixed at 0.1Hz and the stress at
0.01Pa.
The gelation temperature was determined from a sort of an express method where G and
G were measured as a function of temperature. Keeping the experimental conditions always
the same, this method allows a quick comparison of the gelation process of different cellulose
solutions.
Temperature varied from +10C to +80C with a heating rate of +5C per minute. We chose
a rapid heating rate in order to neglect the influence of time.
The rheometer was in the auto-stress mode: it fits stress during the measurement to maintain
a constant strain of 1%.
The frequency was fixed at 1Hz.
II.3.3.2. Dilute cellulose solution
The intrinsic viscosities of cellulose solutions were studied using an Ubbelohde capillary
viscometer equipped with an automatic dilution burette (from Lauda). The viscometer was
immersed in a water bath at different constant temperatures from +12C to +40C.
The initial concentration of a cellulose solution was 0.5% obtained with 10 times dilution of a 5%
cellulose solution. In order to obtain the viscosity versus cellulose concentration dependence, 7
or 8 dilutions were made. The relative viscosity
rel
is calculated as a ratio between the kinematic
viscosities of the solution
Solution
and the solvent
Solvent
(Eq. 3):
Chapter II Materials and methods
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-79-
Solvent
Solution rel
= Eq.2
The intrinsic viscosity [] is determined as follows:
|
|
\
|
=
c
rel
c
1
lim ] [
0
Eq.3
where c represents the polymer concentration.
The intrinsic viscosity is the viscosity of solution at infinite dilution and is usually obtained when
plotting
|
|
\
|
=
c
rel
red
1
dependence as a function of concentration. Graphically, the intrinsic
viscosity corresponds to the point of intersection between the straight line passing through the
reduced viscosity points
red
and the y-axis
For a given polymer in a given solvent, a decrease of the intrinsic viscosity means that the
intramolecular links are favoured and the solvent quality decreases.
II.3.4- Microscopy
II.3.4.1. Optical Microscopy (OM)
The observations of cellulose solutions were performed with a transmission optical microscope
Leitz Metallux 3 with unpolarised light in order to observe the swelling of cellulose fibres and the
state of cellulose dissolution.
Qualitative observations of cellulose solutions were carried out at room temperature.
Cellulose + solvent (solvent being 7.6NaOH/water or 7.6NaOH/0.7ZnO/water or
7.6NaOH/6urea/water) fresh solution was placed between two glass plates. In this case,
solution had been prepared before the observation and the results were time-independent.
The study of cellulose dissolution mechanism was performed at -6C: the optical microscope
is equipped with a LINKAM TMS 91 hot stage. A few dry cellulose fibres were placed
between two glass plates slightly shifted (Fig.II.3-8). The solvent contained in a pipette was
introduced by capillary forces between the two plates. The whole process of swelling and
dissolution was recorded with CCD camera on DVD recorder and then analysed.
Solvent
Cellulose
fibres
Fig.II.3-8: Samples preparation for optical microscopy at -6C.
Chapter II Materials and methods
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-80-
II.3.4.2. Scanning Electronic Microscopy (SEM)
Scanning Electronic Microscopy (SEM) was used to observe the porosity of regenerated cellulose
samples and the reinforcing fibres (cotton and fluff) in their initial state and after treatment in
NaOH solutions. SEM has two main advantages in comparison with optical microscopy: to
obtain greater magnification (up to 150000 times instead of ~1000 with OM) and to observe
irregular samples because of an important depth of field.
Electron gun sends an electron beam to the sample surface. When the electron beam strikes the
target, it is reflected and the resulted incident radiation is picked up by the SEM sensors. This is
repeated very rapidly on several points until covering the whole sample surface. In other words,
the electron beam scans the whole sample and data are analysed to build the picture.
A non-conducting material reflects very badly the electron beam and it is very difficult to obtain a
picture. So, either the sample is covered by very fine gold particles or the microscope is used with
the environmental mode. Indeed, the latter allows observing non-conducting samples due to the
presence of a gaseous atmosphere in the microscope chamber. A Peltier temperature control is
used for monitoring the relative humidity in the microscope chamber.
The instrument used was a Philips XL-3000 Scanning Electron Microscope.
Environmental mode
The temperature was fixed at +8C and the chamber pressure at 2.5 mbar, giving a relative
humidity around the sample of approximately 30%. The voltage was fixed at 15kV and a GSE
detector was used.
The samples were placed in the vacuum chamber, without other treatment.
The problem of environmental mode is a relatively low resolution.
High vacuum mode
This mode allows obtaining greater magnification with a good resolution because of high vacuum
in the microscope chamber. Samples have to be metallised with gold particles.
SE detector was used and voltage was fixed at 12kV or 15kV depending on experiments.
Chapter II Materials and methods
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-81-
II.3.5- Mechanical property: tensile test
The mechanical properties of regenerated cellulose films, of regenerated cellulose + reinforcing
fibres and of final product (regenerated cellulose + re-enforcing fibres + porophores) were
studied using the tensile mode on a ZWICK Z2.5 machine (Fig.II.3-9).
The experiments were performed at room temperature. The sample was fixed between two
holders or grips (see Fig.II.3-9b). The lower grip stayed immobile and the higher grip moved
until rupture. The tensile force was measured. The rupture force F was considered as being 80%
of maximal tensile force. On the forthcoming graphs, one point corresponds to 3-4
measurements at least. Error bars show the standard deviations.
G
G
S
(a) (b)
Fig.II.3-9: Picture of the Zwick Z2.5 machine and scheme of the tensile test.
G: grips; S: specimen of regenerated cellulose; F: the tensile force.
The rupture stress F
R
is determined as follows:
S
F
F
R
=
FR is the rupture stress (daN/cm)
F is the tensile force when rupture appears (daN)
S is the initial specimen section (cm)
Units were chosen to easily compare with the Spontex values.
II.3.5.1. Tensile test on films of regenerated cellulose
Tensile tests were performed on films of regenerated cellulose. This means that cellulose
solutions were prepared from the previous procedures (part II.2-), then underwent various
thermal treatments and finally they were placed in a regeneration bath to obtain the final
products. After regeneration, cellulose has the crystalline structure of cellulose II, as expected.
Chapter II Materials and methods
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-82-
The procedure was as follow:
1. Cellulose solution was prepared from the procedure described above (part
II.2-). Cellulose was the B389 or B407 pulp and the solutions consisted in
5cellulose/7.6NaOH/water, 5cellulose/7.6NaOH/0.7ZnO/water or
5cellulose/7.6NaOH/6urea/water.
2. Cellulose solution was stored at +5C up to the disappearance of air
bubbles.
3. About 10g of the solution was poured in a plastic Petri box (=10cm).
4. Petri box was kept at various temperatures:
20 hours at +25C
1.5 hours at +70C
1.5 hours at +70C, then 20 hours at +25C
20 hours at -20C
20 hours at -20C, then 20 hours at +25C.
5. Immediately after the thermal treatment, a non-solvent was added (water or
1N acetic acid) into the Petri box at the temperature of regeneration (+5C,
+25C or +70C for water and +25C for acetic acid).
NB: In order to make the regenerated sample as homogeneous as possible
(in terms of thickness, surface, without holes, etc), the non-solvent was
carefully added ON the sample. Putting the sample in the regeneration bath
induced cracks and holes.
6. Regeneration bath was changed several times until it becomes pH neutral
(checked with a pH-paper).
After regeneration, tensile dumbbell-like specimens were cut. The dimensions were:
Effective length = 17mm
Width = 5mm
Thickness = 1-1.5mm
After the preparation of the specimen, it was immediately put back
into regeneration bath to avoid drying in the air. The specimens were
removed from the bath just before performing the tensile test. As the
experiment lasted for about one minute, it was not necessary to take
into account the humidity of ambient air.
The speed of the top grip is fixed at 5mm/min.
17mm
5mm
Chapter II Materials and methods
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-83-
II.3.5.2. Tensile test on regenerated cellulose + reinforcing fibres
In order to approach industrial conditions, but varying different parameters, reinforcing fibres
were added to cellulose solution. The fibres were either cotton with a length of 20mm or fluff.
Reinforcing fibres, cotton and fluff, have high DP (>1100). The dissolved cellulose + reinforcing
fibres system was regenerated in water before mechanical tests.
The sample preparation was as follows:
1. Cellulose solution was prepared from the procedure described above (part
II.2-). Cellulose was the B389 or B407 pulp and the solutions consisted in
5cellulose/7.6NaOH/water.
NB: Stirring lasts 1.5 hour instead of 2 hours, according to the Spontex
procedure.
2. 0.2g of AP surfactant was added to the 100g cellulose solution and mixed
10 minutes.
3. 2g of reinforcing fibres (cotton or fluff) were impregnated with
8%NaOH/water at T
room
or at -6C (20 hours). These fibres were added to
the 100g solution (still at -6C) and mixed for 1.5 hour, at -6C.
4. The system of dissolved cellulose + fibres was poured in a mould and
different thermal treatments were applied:
a. 2 hours ageing at +5C and then 20 hours freezing at -20C
b. 20 hours freezing at -20C (without ageing)
c. 20 hours gelation at +25C
d. 2 hours gelation at +70C
5. Immediately after the thermal treatment, water at 70C or 25C was added
on the cellulose system.
6. Regeneration bath was changed several times until it becomes pH neutral.
After regeneration, two types of specimens were cut:
o tensile dumbbell-like specimens, as previously
o tensile parallelepiped specimens (for practical purposes). The dimensions were:
Effective length = 20mm
Width = 10mm
Thickness = 2-2.5mm
The speed of testing is also fixed at 5mm/min
Chapter II Materials and methods
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-84-
II.3.5.3. Tensile test on sponges (regenerated cellulose + fibres + porophores)
To reproduce the Spontex conditions, porophores were added to the previous system. The
porophores are crystals of Na
2
SO
4
10H
2
O, which melt above +40C.
A large quantity of crystals was included to the cellulose system in the amount of 3 to 4 times of
the weight of cellulose/fibres/NaOH/water system. In order to avoid an important temperature
increase of cellulose during the addition of porophores, Na
2
SO
4
was cooled down at +5C,
before being added to the system.
In this study, only fluff was used because of a better homogenisation with solution. Cotton fibres
are enrolling and sticking around the mixer.
The sample preparation was as follows:
1. Solution of cellulose + fluff fibres was prepared as previously: steps from 1
to 3.
2. Na
2
SO
4
crystals were pre-cooled at +5C, added to cellulose solution +
reinforcing fibres and mixed about 15 minutes.
3. The system of cellulose solution + fibres + porophores was poured in a
mould and different thermal treatments were applied:
a. 20 hours freezing at -20C (without ageing)
b. 20 hours gelation at +25C
4. Immediately after the thermal treatment, water at +70C was added on the
cellulose system.
5. Regeneration bath was changed several times until it becomes pH neutral.
After regeneration, tensile parallelepiped specimens were cut. The dimensions were:
Effective length = 20mm
Width = 25mm
Thickness = 10mm
The speed of testing is fixed at 300mm/min, to be near the Spontex procedure.
Chapter II Materials and methods
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-85-
II.3.6- Other methods
Several methods were used to analyse the properties of sponges. Thus regenerated samples
consisted of cellulose + fluff fibres + Na
2
SO
4
crystals.
II.3.6.1. Density measurement
The density is one of the main properties of sponges since it influences all their properties
(rupture stress, water absorption). The density is in g/dm
3
.
w
d
V
m
d =
d represents the density of the sponge (g/dm
3
)
md is the weight of the dry sample (g)
Vw is the volume of the wet sample (dm
3
)
To determine the density, a piece of wet sponge was cut and the volume was measured. The
sample was placed in an oven at 105C during 2 hours until a constant weight and then in a
dessicator during 15 minutes to cool down without trapping the ambient humidity. Finally, the
sample weight was measured.
II.3.6.2. Water absorption
The absorption capacity represents the quantity of water that a sponge can absorb.
d
d w
m
m m
Abs
) (
.
=
Abs. is the absorption capacity
mw represents the weight of wet sample
md is the weight of dry sample
The sample weight in dry state was measured and then it was placed in distilled water at room
temperature during a few minutes. The sample was taken at an extremity and drained during 1
minute. Finally the sample was weighted to obtain the wet weight.
II.3.6.3. Shrinkage
Shrinkage represents the percentage of surface loss between a wet sample, which has never been
dried, and a sample dried for 2 hours in the oven and then swollen in water again.
w
dw w
A
A A
Shr
= .
Shr. is the shrinkage of the sponge sample
Aw is the surface of a never-dried-wet sample
Adw is the surface of a dried-and-swollen again
sample.
To determine the shrinkage, the surface areas of never-dried-wet and of dried-and-swollen
samples were measured.
Chapter II Materials and methods
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-86-
R RE EF FE ER RE EN NC CE ES S
[DEA1995] DEAN J.A. The Analytical Chemistry Handbook. New York: McGraw Hill, Inc. (1995),
p15.1-15.5
[NAV1980] NAVARD P., MONASSE B. Analyse calorimtrique diffrentielle compensation de puissance
(DSC). Ecole des Mines de Paris, Sophia-Antipolis, France (1980), 39 p.
[PRA1995] PRANKERD R.J., ELSABEE M.Z. Thermal analysis of chiral drug mixtures: the
DSC behavior of mixtures of ephedrine HCl and pseudoephedrine HCl enantiomers.
Thermochimica Acta (1995), 248, p.147-160
[PUN1994] PUNGOR E. Chapter 15: differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) In: A Practical
Guide to Instrumental Analysis. Boca Raton, Florida: CRC Press (1994), 400p.
[ROY2003] ROY C., BUDTOVA T., NAVARD P. Rheological properties and gelation of
aqueous cellulose-NaOH solutions. Biomacromolecules (2003), 4, p.259-264
[WIN1986] WINTER H.H., CHAMBON F. Analysis of linear viscoelasticity of a crosslinking
polymer at the gel point. J. Rheol. (1986), 30 (2), p.367-382
[YAM1990] YAMASHIKI T, MATSUI T, SAITOH M., OKAJIMA K, KAMIDE K, SAWADA
T. Characterisation of cellulose treated by the steam explosion method. Part 1: Influence of
cellulose resources on changes in morphology, degree of polymerisation, solubility and solid
structure. British Polymer Journal (1990), 22, p.73-83
[YAM1996] YAMANE C, SAITO M, OKAJIMA K Seni gakkaishi (1996), 52 (6), 310-317
Traduit du japonais - Mthode de prparation industrielle de cellulose-solution aqueuse de soude caustique
haute solubilit
Rsum du chapitre III Structure des solutions aqueuses de NaOH et de cellulose/NaOH avec et sans additifs.
Limite de dissolution de la cellulose
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-87-
R RE ES SU UM ME E D DU U C CH HA AP PI IT TR RE E I II II I
S ST TR RU UC CT TU UR RE E D DE ES S S SO OL LU UT TI IO ON NS S A AQ QU UE EU US SE ES S D DE E N NA AO OH H E ET T D DE E
C CE EL LL LU UL LO OS SE E/ /N NA AO OH H A AV VE EC C E ET T S SA AN NS S A AD DD DI IT TI IF FS S. .
L LI IM MI IT TE E D DE E D DI IS SS SO OL LU UT TI IO ON N D DE E L LA A C CE EL LL LU UL LO OS SE E
Ce chapitre prsente une tude dtaille des proprits thermiques des solvants dune part et des
solutions de cellulose dautre part, tude base essentiellement sur des analyses de DSC.
Lobtention des thermogrammes de fusion allant de -65C +10C permet de dterminer les
tempratures et enthalpies de fusion de chaque phase prsente dans le systme, de tracer les
diagrammes de phase et de dterminer les interactions ayant lieu dans les solutions.
La premire partie de cette tude a port sur lanalyse de solutions NaOH/eau ayant des
concentrations en NaOH comprise entre 0 et 20%. Le trac du diagramme de phase dans ce
domaine de concentrations en NaOH a t effectu partir des tempratures de fusion obtenues
par DSC et correspond parfaitement celui rapport dans la littrature [PIC1893] [ROL1964].
Entre 0 et 20%NaOH, quand tout le systme est solide (T<-33,4C), nous sommes en prsence
(i) dun mlange eutectique comprenant un hydrate de sodium NaOH,5H
2
O et 4 molcules deau
et (ii) de glace libre. La temprature de fusion de leutectique est constante (-33,4C) pour toute
concentration en NaOH tandis que celle de leau diminue quand la concentration en NaOH
augmente. Quant lenthalpie dun composant X, sa valeur est proportionnelle la quantit de
composant X cristallis dans le systme. En effet, les fractions deutectique et de glace
dtermines partir du diagramme de phase par la rgle des segments inverses correspondent aux
fractions calcules partir des enthalpies de fusion (f
eut
=H
eut, X%NaOH
/H
eut, pure
et f
ice
=H
ice,
X%NaOH
/H
ice, pure
). Cette mthode de calcul partir des enthalpies de fusion tant valide par
ltude des systmes binaires NaOH/eau, elle sera utilise non seulement pour les autres systmes
de solvant mais galement pour les solutions de cellulose.
Avant dtudier le systme ternaire NaOH/ure/eau, il nous a fallu dterminer le comportement
du systme binaire ure/eau et tracer son diagramme de phase. Il savre que ce dernier a un
comportement de mlange eutectique simple. Leutectique est constitu de 1 ure et 8 molcules
deau, ce qui correspond une concentration en ure de 29,4%, il fond -11,4C.
Dans le systme ternaire, la concentration en NaOH est fixe 7,6% et celle de lure varie entre
0 et 25%. Il apparat que la temprature de fusion de leutectique NaOH ne diminue que trs
lgrement et que son enthalpie de fusion est constante quelle que soit la concentration en ure.
Ceci signifie que lure ne ragit pas avec les molcules de NaOH. Une augmentation de la
Rsum du chapitre III Structure des solutions aqueuses de NaOH et de cellulose/NaOH avec et sans additifs.
Limite de dissolution de la cellulose
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-88-
concentration en ure entrane un dcalage du pic de fusion de lure vers les plus hautes
tempratures et celui de la glace libre vers les plus basses tempratures. Ils se rejoignent pour un
systme constitu de 7,6%NaOH et 18%ure, ce qui signifie quil ny a plus deau libre en
solution. En effet, cette composition, il y a tout juste assez deau pour former simultanment et
de faon indpendante les deux mlanges eutectiques NaOH+9H
2
O et ure+8H
2
O. Au-del de
cette concentration, il ny a plus suffisamment deau pour les deux eutectiques qui rentrent alors
en comptition. Le pic de leutectique NaOH tant toujours constant pour des concentrations
en ure suprieures 18%, ceci signifie quil est prioritaire sur lure, probablement du fait de sa
forte polarit. Lure en excs cristallise donc dans sous forme pure.
Nous avons trouv dans la littrature [DIR1954][REI1975][BEN1999] que la dissolution de
loxyde de zinc a lieu en milieu basique par raction des ions OH
-
avec ZnO pour former des
hydroxydes de zinc. Ces ractions chimiques entranent une modification de la solution et il nest
donc pas tonnant de constater que la prsence doxyde de zinc dans le systme NaOH/eau
modifie le diagramme de phase : les temprature et enthalpie de fusion de leutectique NaOH
diminuent proportionnellement la quantit de ZnO prsente en solution. Nous en avons conclu
que chaque ZnO ragit avec 3 NaOH qui ne participent plus leutectique. Les complexes ainsi
forms sont fortement hydrats puisquils peuvent tre entours jusqu 25 molcules deau,
valeur dtermine partir du pic de glace libre.
Lajout de cellulose dans NaOH/eau ne modifie pas les tempratures de fusion du mlange
eutectique NaOH+eau et de la glace libre : la prsence de cellulose ne modifie pas le diagramme
de phase du solvant NaOH/eau.
Par contre, lenthalpie de fusion du mlange eutectique diminue proportionnellement la
concentration en cellulose et atteint zro quand la masse de cellulose est gale la masse
dhydroxyde de sodium. Nous en avons donc conclu que la limite de dissolution de la cellulose
dans NaOH/eau est atteinte quand m
cell
=m
NaOH
et que la dissolution de la cellulose ncessite au
moins quatre molcules de NaOH qui se lient chaque motif de polymre (AGU). Le rapport
entre lenthalpie de fusion de leutectique dtermine pour une concentration en cellulose donne
et lenthalpie de fusion de leutectique pur (H
eut, Y%cell
/H
eut, pur
) permet de calculer la fraction
deutectique qui a cristallis dans le systme et den dduire la quantit de NaOH li la cellulose,
et ce, pour chaque concentration de cellulose. Les rsultats montrent que pour des concentrations
en cellulose suprieures 1,5-2%, le rapport NaOH/AGU est gal 4. Par contre, pour de
faibles concentrations en cellulose, le rapport NaOH/AGU peut atteindre 20, ou encore 50
partir de mesures de turbidit [KUO2005]. Cette transition autour de 2% de cellulose correspond
la transition rgime dilu / rgime semi-dilu rapporte dans la ref. [ROY2003]. Il nest certes
pas tonnant de trouver des valeurs un peu plus importantes en rgime dilu d la diminution
de lencombrement strique mais un tel cart entre les deux types de solutions (4/20 ou
encore 4/50) reste, lheure actuelle, une question ouverte.
En ce qui concerne le pic de fusion de la glace libre, son enthalpie reste constante quelle que soit
la teneur en cellulose. La quantit deau libre en solution nest pas modifie par la prsence de
Rsum du chapitre III Structure des solutions aqueuses de NaOH et de cellulose/NaOH avec et sans additifs.
Limite de dissolution de la cellulose
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-89-
cellulose, ce qui signifie que les 9 molcules deau cristallisant dans le mlange eutectique
NaOH+eau sont galement lies la cellulose.
Chaque AGU est donc entoure dun minimum de 4NaOH et 36H
2
O.
Une analyse similaire a t effectue sur des solutions de cellulose dans 7,6NaOH/6ure/eau. Les
thermogrammes de DSC ainsi obtenus donnent des rsultats tout fait semblables aux
prcdents, savoir (i) pas de diminution des tempratures de fusion (eutectique NaOH,
eutectique ure et glace libre), la prsence dure ne modifie le diagramme de phase du solvant,
dans les domaines de concentrations tudis, (ii) pas de variation des enthalpies de fusion de la
glace libre et de leutectique de lure, la quantit deau libre en solution reste constante et la
cellulose ne se lie pas avec lure mais (iii) diminution de lenthalpie de fusion du mlange
eutectique NaOH+eau proportionnelle la teneur en cellulose, la cellulose pige une certaine
quantit de NaOH. De plus, la courbe enthalpie de leutectique en fonction de la concentration
en cellulose pour des solutions de cellulose dans 7,6NaOH/6ure/eau se superpose celle
obtenue pour des solutions de cellulose dans 7,6NaOH/eau. Ceci signifie que la limite de
dissolution de cellulose est atteinte pour m
cell
=m
NaOH
, que la dissolution de la cellulose ncessite
au moins quatre NaOH entour de ses 9 molcules deau. Lure ne permet pas daugmenter la
quantit de cellulose pouvant tre dissoute dans un systme NaOH/eau donn.
Nous avons vu que la prsence doxyde de zinc diminue la temprature de fusion du mlange
eutectique NaOH+eau, il y a donc modification du systme de solvant. Les thermogrammes de
fusion des solutions de cellulose/NaOH/ZnO/eau ne rvlent pas le pic de fusion de
leutectique, il nest donc pas possible de dterminer la quantit de NaOH li la cellulose. Par
ailleurs, lenthalpie du pic de fusion de la glace libre reste constant mme aprs ajout de cellulose :
comme prcdemment pour les solutions de cellulose/NaOH/eau et cellulose/NaOH/ure/eau,
les solutions de cellulose/NaOH/ZnO/eau ont la mme quantit deau libre quelle que soit la
concentration en cellulose.
Pour finir, nous avons tudi linfluence dune tape de conglation sur les proprits thermiques
des solutions de cellulose/NaOH/eau, avec ou sans ZnO. Dans les deux cas, un sjour prolong
-28C entrane la cristallisation deau pure, dont la temprature de fusion est de 0C. Dun point
de vue thermodynamique, ces molcules deau ne peuvent pas se dtacher du mlange eutectique
NaOH/eau. De plus, tant donn que leau libre a dj cristallis dans le systme, la seule
possibilit est que cette eau pure soit dtache de la cellulose. A partir des rapports
denthalpies de fusion, nous avons pu dterminer que dans les deux cas, cellulose/NaOH/eau et
cellulose/NaOH/ZnO/eau, une molcule deau par AGU est dtache lors dun sjour prolong
-28C.
Cette analyse approfondie nous a permis de dterminer la structure des solvants NaOH/eau,
ure/eau, NaOH/ure/eau et NaOH/ZnO/eau et celle des solutions de cellulose dans ces
mmes solvants.
-90-
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-91-
C
C
H
H
A
A
P
P
T
T
E
E
R
R
I
I
I
I
I
I
III- III
S ST TR RU UC CT TU UR RE E O OF F A AQ QU UE EO OU US S N NA A
O OH H A AN ND D
C CE EL LL LU UL LO OS SE E/ /N NA AO OH H S SO OL LU UT TI IO ON NS S W WI IT TH H A AN ND D
W WI IT TH HO OU UT T A AD DD DI IT TI IV VE ES S. .
L LI IM MI IT T O OF F C CE EL LL LU UL LO OS SE E D DI IS SS SO OL LU UT TI IO ON N
. .
Chapter III is devoted to a detailed study of the structural organisation of cellulose in the
aqueous sodium hydroxide solutions with and without additives. The main goal is to understand
what are the proportions between cellulose and solvent molecules linked to it and, as a
consequence, what is the limit of cellulose dissolution in aqueous sodium hydroxide solutions.
The role of additives like ZnO and urea that are known to help cellulose dissolution is
investigated. The changes in cellulose/NaOH solutions induced by freezing are also considered.
Most of the study is performed using DSC technique accompanied by viscometric measurements.
This chapter is divided into four main parts.
In the first part, entitled Bibliography: phase diagram of aqueous sodium hydroxide solution,
we will first describe some theoretical aspects concerning binary and ternary phase diagrams, and
especially how to build them from DSC analyses. Then, we will review the literature on the
structure of NaOH/water: it is known that several sodium hydrates can be formed depending on
NaOH concentration. The number of water molecules surrounding sodium hydroxide ions
increases when the NaOH concentration decreases. The authors of two papers [PIC1893]
[COH1960] gave the composition of sodium hydrates and the melting temperatures of different
compounds formed.
The second part concerns the structure of cellulose solvents: NaOH/water, NaOH/urea/water
and NaOH/ZnO/water. As the NaOH/water system was known, we shall compare our DSC
results obtained in the region of 0-30%NaOH with the literature and thus validate the
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-92-
methodology used. Then urea/water binary system will be studied and its phase diagram will be
built. This was the necessary step in the understanding of the structure of NaOH/urea/water
ternary system. Finally, the influence of zinc oxide on NaOH/water solutions will be
investigated.
The third part concerns the structure of cellulose solutions in NaOH/water, NaOH/urea/water
and NaOH/ZnO/water. We will study the influence of the addition of cellulose in the solvents
studied in the previous part. This will allow us to understand the structural organisation of
cellulose solutions and to determine the limit of cellulose dissolution in NaOH/water and in
NaOH/urea/water. A large part of this study is performed on Avicel cellulose; other cellulose
samples will be tested to study the influence of cellulose origin on the structure of solutions.
The last part deals with the influence of freezing on the thermal properties of cellulose/NaOH
mixtures.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-93-
III.1- BIBLIOGRAPHY: PHASE DIAGRAM OF AQUEOUS SODIUM HYDROXIDE
SOLUTION
III.1.1- Phase diagrams
III.1.1.1. Binary phase diagram
Let us consider two components that are completely miscible in the liquid state but with their
solid phase fully immiscible [KON2001]. The melting point of the first component is always
lowered when adding a second one. This can be shown on a temperature versus mixture
composition diagram (Fig.III.1-1, graph). From such a binary phase diagram, at constant
pressure, the following parameters can be measured:
the compositions of solid and liquid phases from solidus and liquidus curves, respectively
the relative amounts of each phase in the whole system from level rule or level principle.
Three examples are given on Fig.III.1-1 for a, b and c systems.
The eutectic point, named e, is where the two solubility/melting curves of the solid phases meet
(Fig.III.1-1, graph). The composition x
2e
of the eutectic point is fixed at a given pressure. The
eutectic crystal is a mixture of the crystals of both components that were formed simultaneously.
Its morphology is very fine.
At either side of e and below T
e
, there are the crystals of the eutectic mixture plus an excess of
pure 1 or 2 crystals (depending on the composition of the initial mixture see Fig.III.1-1, table)
that have slowly crystallised upon cooling.
Component 1 Component 2
x2c x2a
d
q
r
Fig.III.1-1 [KON2001]: Binary phase diagram under constant pressure (left-hand graph)
Explanation on how to read such a diagram (right-hand table)
X-axis corresponds to component 2 fraction in the mixture.
Tm1 = melting temperature of a pure first component
Tm2 = melting temperature of a pure second component
Te = melting temperature of eutectic component
x2e = eutectic composition
Explanation
System a b c
Composition x2a x2e x2c
Temperature
T1 The whole system is
a liquid (l) with the
composition x2a
The whole system is
a liquid (l) with the
composition x2e
The whole system is
a liquid (l) with the
composition x2c
T3 There are two
phases:
A liquid phase (l)
composition d,
quantity r/(r+q)
A solid phase (s1)
pure component 1,
quantity q/(r+q)
There are two
phases:
A liquid phase (l)
composition d,
quantity r/(r+q)
A solid phase (s2)
pure component 2,
quantity q/(r+q)
Te The liquid (l)
crystallises to form
the eutectic
compound,
composition x2e, very
fine crystals of pure
components 1 and 2
T4 Two crystals:
Pure solid 1,
eutectic compound
composed of fine
crystals of
components 1 and 2
only eutectic
compound
Two crystals
Pure solid 2, eutectic
compound
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-94-
III.1.1.2. Ternary phase diagram
The representation of the equilibrium diagrams of a ternary system needs a three dimensional
model. Two dimensions are required to show the variation in composition, and a third dimension
is needed for the temperature variable. The latter is often drawn on the vertical axis and the
former on the horizontal plane (Fig.III.1-2). The three-dimensional model is a right-angled prism,
the sides representing the three binary systems [HUM1953].
Generally, isothermal cross-sections are useful to study the equilibrium of a ternary system. But
vertical cross-sections are interesting to reveal how a binary system is affected by the addition of
a third component.
Fig.III.1-2 represents the liquidus surface of a ternary phase diagram of three components A, B,
and C. These components are fully miscible in the liquid state and making two by two eutectic
mixtures. We can see that the addition of a component to the binary liquid phase decreases the
melting temperatures of the binary eutectic.
Example:
In the front of this figure, the diagram of the binary system containing the components A and B
is represented; the component C is not present, C
C
= 0%.
When the component C is added at a constant concentration C
C
=X%, the binary phase diagram
of components A and B is determined by the red plane. We can see that all the melting
temperatures decrease, even the eutectic one: T
0
mA
becomes T
mA
, T
0
mB
becomes T
mB
, and Te
AB
becomes Te
AB
(C
C
=X).
T
mA
(C
C
=X)
T
mB
(C
C
=X)
Te
AB
(C
C
=X)
X
X
A
B
C
AB
AB
AB
A
B
C
Fig.III.1-2 [KON2001]: Ternary isobaric phase diagram
showing the melting-point depressions of each of the
components caused by the addition of the other two to
the liquid phase.
T
0
mA, T
0
mB, and T
0
mC: melting temperatures of pure
components A, B, and C respectively;
eAB: the eutectic mixture of components A and B; TeAB its
melting temperature; eAB its projection on the base triangle;
TmA and TmB: the melting temperatures of components A and
B, when X% of the component C is added;
TeAB(CC=X): the melting temperature of eutectic eAB when
X% of the component C is added to A and B components;
Q: the quadruple point for the considered pressure; Q its
projection on the base triangle.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-95-
Fig.III.1-3 [HUM1953]: Vertical cross-section of a ternary phase diagram
containing the components A, B and C.
The concentration of C is constant and equals 5%,
A and B concentrations vary from 0 to 95%.
Fig.III.1-3 is a vertical cross-section of a ternary phase diagram, where the concentration of C
remains constant (here C
C
=5%) and where A and B concentrations change. Consequently, the
points x and y represent two systems containing 5%C+95%B and 5%C+95%A respectively. The
point l on the liquidus curve shows that a system containing 5%C+50%A is exactly on the
liquidus surface at the temperature concerned. However, the point s is not the solidus point
corresponding to the liquidus point l. The reason for this is that all points on this figure represent
systems containing 5%C, but there is no reason why a liquid containing 5%C should be in
equilibrium with a solid containing the same percentage of C.
Thus, such a diagram only shows the phases present in the system at different temperatures. This
is the aspect which is interesting in our study of solvent systems. But such a diagram cannot be
used to deduce the compositions of mixtures in equilibrium with one another. Vertical sections
are thus easily misleading, because after working with binary phase diagram, there is an instinctive
tendency to imagine that horizontal lines may be drawn to give the compositions of various
phases.
In ternary systems, compositions of different phases can be determined by studying the
isothermal sections. This will not be described because a complete investigation of ternary
solvent system is not our topic.
III.1.1.3. Methods for building phase diagrams. The limits of the DSC analysis
The building of phase diagrams can be divided into two parts:
A) The first one consists in plotting the liquidus and solidus curves.
For example, the liquidus can be easily determined by solubility measurements.
Another classical method is the use of calorimetry, where a large amount of material is slowly
heated or cooled in order to be always in equilibrium conditions. Temperatures and heat
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-96-
exchanges are then used to build the phase diagram. It is a very slow method requiring a lot of
sample, but it is the only exact manner to plot the phase diagrams.
Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) is often used to measure enthalpies of phase transitions
and their corresponding temperatures (part II.3.1) and thus to build phase diagram (Fig.III.1-4).
It is a very fast method, using only a very small amount of material. The drawback of it is that
several corrections must be applied if one wishes to have correct temperature values. Outside the
classical calibration corrections, one major difficulty is to obtain a correct temperature for the
melting of material phases like crystalline ones. To be correct, all measurements should be done
by extrapolating the data to zero heating or cooling rate and to zero mass. This is very time
consuming and usually it is not done. However, without such measurements there are some
difficulties in exploiting the DSC data. We give below (Fig.III.1-5) one example where we show
that we are making an error when using DSC to plot the liquidus if we are not using the
extrapolation at zero mass and zero heating rate.
Te
Fig.III.1-4: Solid/liquid equilibrium in a binary eutectic-forming system as observed by DSC.
Curve 1: Melting of pure components 1 and 2; Curve 2: Eutectic melting;
Curve 3: Melting of a mixture with an excess of solid 2 (in comparison with the eutectic composition)
T
T
3
T
4
T
1
T
2
Sample 1, with a mass m1
Sample 2, with a mass m2
Fig.III.1-5: Example of DSC traces showing the error when the extrapolation at zero mass
and heating rate is not used
For the samples of two different masses (m
2
> m
1
), the end of the melting peaks is shifted
towards higher temperatures for a higher-mass sample, both for a pure substance melting at a
single temperature or for a substance having a large melting peak. This is due to the time needed
for heat transfer inside the sample, considering that on a DSC trace such as the one shown here
(Fig.III.1-5), the horizontal axis that is usually labelled as the temperature axis is in reality a time
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-97-
axis. Each time that a substance is melting at a single temperature, the temperature is constant,
while time is flying. In the Fig.III.1-5, while points T
3
and T
4
are given in the DSC trace as two
different temperatures, the sample is in fact staying for a certain time between these two points at
the temperature T
3
, which is the melting temperature.
This will have a small impact on our data since it will slightly shift all temperatures of the liquidus
at high water content of the mixtures by less than 1C. The lower is the water content, the
smaller is the peak of the melting of ice, and the smaller is the error. The real and DSC-
determined liquidus shapes are as shown below in Fig.III.1-6.
It must be noted that the values of the enthalpy of the peaks measured by DSC do not depend
on mass or heating rates.
T
A= 100%
B= 0%
%A
%B
real liquidus
liquidus measured by DSC
Fig.III.1-6: Real and DSC-determined liquidus,
when the extrapolations at zero mass and heating rate are not used
In our study, the goal was not to plot very exact phase diagrams that would have taken a lot of
time, but to understand the structure of cellulose solutions and proportions between the
components. For this reason, we did not use the extrapolation technique to measure precisely
temperature, but we always used the same range of heating rates and masses. As we will see later,
this had no influence on our work.
B) The second one consists in determining the nature of the crystalline solid phases; X-Ray
diffraction analysis is the most often used method.
III.1.2- State of the art on the structure of NaOH aqueous solutions
III.1.2.1. Pure sodium hydroxide
Anhydrous sodium hydroxide is a white and translucent solid, strongly hygroscopic. Thus it easily
catches the humidity of atmosphere and, in that case, also absorbs carbon dioxide. Also called lye
or caustic soda, sodium hydroxide is a strong chemical base and, thus, its aqueous solutions
violently react with acid.
We saw previously (part I.2.2) that cellulose can be dissolved in relatively low NaOH
concentrated solutions, at low temperature.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-98-
The anhydrous sodium hydroxide has two crystalline structures and , at low and high
temperature respectively. However, as far as NaOH is strongly hygroscopic, NaOH is essentially
found as hydrated forms. In the forthcoming, crystalline structures of anhydrous sodium
hydroxide will not be described, only the sodium hydroxide hydrates will be detailed.
III.1.2.2. Sodium hydroxide hydrates
Several papers [PIC1893][COH1960][ROL1964] report the formation of stable sodium hydrates
in which the number of water molecules depends on the NaOH concentration and on the
solution temperature.
In 1893, Pickering [PIC1893] identified 8 hydrates of sodium hydroxide:
The monohydrate (NaOH,H
2
O)
The dihydrate (NaOH,2H
2
O)
The trihydrate (9NaOH,28H
2
O which can also be written NaOH,3.11H
2
O). Pickering
[PIC1893] as well as Rollet and Cohen [ROL1964] are doubtful concerning this formula
but experiment of solubility for the former and thermal analyses for the latter do not
allow to make a choice between the NaOH,3H
2
O and NaOH,3.11H
2
O formulae.
The 3.5hydrate (NaOH,3.5H
2
O)
Two tetrahydrates (NaOH,4H
2
O and NaOH,4H
2
O )
The pentahydrate (NaOH,5H
2
O)
The heptahydrate (NaOH,7H
2
O)
Pickering [PIC1893] also investigated other alkaline hydroxides as KOH and LiOH and plotted
the liquidus curves for these three binary systems.
Some years later, Antropoff and Sommer [ANT1926] added the part of liquidus concerning the
anhydrous sodium hydroxide.
From thermal analyses and solubility studies, Cohen-Adad [COH1960], Rollet et al. [ROL1964]
checked the Pickering results, which turned out to be very precise [PIC1893]. They added the
solidus curves and thus completed the binary phase diagrams for NaOH/water, KOH/water,
LiOH/water, RbOH/water, and CsOH/water.
Fig.III.1-7 represents the NaOH/water binary phase diagram, plotted by Rollet and Cohen-Adad,
with the well-determined NaOH hydrates in crystallised states.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-99-
Te
E
E
Te
Fig.III.1-7 [COH1960]: Binary phase diagram of NaOH/water system
with stable and metastable NaOH hydrates in crystallised state.
Y-axis corresponds to the temperature and X-axis to the mixture composition given in NaOH
weight percentage (x=0% corresponds to pure water on the left of the graph)
As we can see, this phase diagram is complex: it contains stable and metastable hydrates and
several eutectic mixtures. We can note that:
o x=24% corresponds to the stable crystalline sodium hydrate NaOH,7H
2
O
o x=31% corresponds to the metastable crystalline sodium hydrate NaOH,5H
2
O
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-100-
The points E and E (in the detailed part of the Fig.III.1-7) correspond to eutectic mixtures,
formed by ice and sodium hydrates NaOH,7H
2
O and NaOH,5H
2
O, respectively. According to
Rollet and Cohen-Adad [ROL1964], NaOH,7H
2
O is a stable hydrate obtained after a rapid drop
in temperature, in liquid air or dry ice, followed by an isothermal step at a higher temperature,
and NaOH,5H
2
O is a metastable hydrate, obtained when the temperature decreases relatively
slowly and that the thermal analysis is performed just after the crystals formation. They also
reported that the NaOH/water binary system forms the metastable equilibria very easily.
When ions are in solution, they have different solvated forms depending on their concentration:
in a concentrated solution, the two ions form a hydrated dipole, whereas in a dilute solution, they
are separated (Fig. I.2-6).
In the case of sodium hydroxide in water, Bartunek [BAR1954] determined the existence of
separated ions for NaOH concentrations inferior to 6% and Yamashiki [YAM1988] observed
separated ions for NaOH concentration around 9%. But whatever the concentration limits are,
the ions Na
+
and OH
-
are surrounded by a cage of water molecules. In 1949, Bockris
[BOC1949] defined a primary and a secondary cage of solvation. In the primary cage of
solvation, water molecules are strongly linked to the ions Na
+
and OH
-
(but it is not a covalent
link). In the secondary cage of solvation, water molecules are less linked to the ions and thus can
be easily exchanged with the free solvent molecules.
Different techniques (NMR, ultrasonic velocity, ionic mobility) were used to measure the
number of water molecules in different cages but the results are not in agreement. According to
Yamashiki [YAM1988], from
23
Na and
1
H NMR and ultrasonic velocity measurements at +4C,
for a 9% NaOH solution, the primary and secondary cages contain 8 and 23 water molecules
respectively (Fig.III.1-8), that is to say 31 water molecules on the whole. From
23
Na NMR, Kunze
[KUN1985] determined a total of 22 water molecules for a 9% NaOH concentration at 30C.
The comparison between these two figures is not totally possible because the temperature is very
different and we know that the structure of hydrates is strongly dependent of temperature. But
these results give an idea on the significant hydration state of Na
+
and OH
-
ions.
Fig.III.1-8 [YAM1988]: Schematic representation of a 9% (w/w) NaOH aqueous solution at +4C
Na
+
and OH
-
ions are in the centre of the cage,
the grey part represents the primary solvation cage
and the white part is the secondary cage.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-101-
The cage structure and the number of water molecules linked to the ions determine the diameter
of the sodium hydrate. This parameter has been thought to be important for the cellulose
dissolution since the sodium hydrates must penetrate into the cellulose fibres.
III.2- STRUCTURE OF CELLULOSE SOLVENTS: NAOH/WATER,
NAOH/UREA/WATER AND NAOH/ZNO/WATER
The goal of this part is to precisely investigate the structure of solvent systems and to plot their
phase diagrams. Binary systems NaOH/water and urea/water will be first studied and then
ternary systems NaOH/urea/water and NaOH/ZnO/water will be investigated in order to
observe the influence of the addition of a third component. The knowledge of phases present in
solution and of the proportions between the species in this or that phase allows a better
understanding of the interactions between urea and NaOH and/or water, and between ZnO and
NaOH and/or water.
We should like to remind here (see also part II.2) how the proportions between the
components will be given in the following.
The notion of concentrations will be used only for binary solvents, like NaOH/water or
urea/water. In all other cases we shall use and show in the notations the amount of
grams of the substance in 100 g of solution. In other words, Xcellulose/YNaOH/water
means that in 100 g of solution there are X grams of cellulose, Y grams of NaOH and
(100XY) of water. Another example is as follows: Xcellulose/YNaOH/Zurea/water
means that in 100 grams of solution there are X grams of cellulose, Y grams of NaOH, Z
grams of urea and (100-X-Y-Z) grams of water. For the binary systems concentration in
weight per cent, calculated as % 100
water i
i
M M
M
Y
+
= (M
i
and M
water
being component i
and water weights, respectively), coincides with the amount of grams Y of this
component in 100g of solution: Ycomponent/water.
III.2.1- NaOH/water binary system
The binary phase diagram of NaOH/water system has been largely studied in literature (part
III.1.2.2). This part revisits it in order to validate our experimental results as well as the
methodology used to calculate the composition of each phase.
III.2.1.1. DSC melting thermograms of NaOH/water solutions
Thermal analyses with DSC consist in determining melting peaks for pure NaOH/water
solutions (pure means without urea, without ZnO and without cellulose). We used a
concentration of NaOH varying from 7.6wt% to 20wt%. The DSC thermograms are given on
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-102-
7.6 -33.2 -5.4
8 -33.2 -5.9
9 -33.6 -7.7
12 -33.5 -11.7
20 -33.3 no peak
NaOH, %
Tm (onset)
eutectic peak, C
Tm (end)
ice peak, C
Fig.III.2-1; the corresponding melting temperatures are reported in Tab.III.2-1 and the melting
enthalpies in Tab.III.2-2 and Tab.III.2-3.
The phase diagram of NaOH/water solutions (Fig.III.1-7 and Fig.III.2-2) shows that at low
sodium hydroxide concentration (<30%NaOH in water) a eutectic mixture and ice should melt at
lower and higher temperatures, respectively [PIC1893][COH1960]. In the following sections,
each peak is analysed in order to find the type of the melting compound and its composition.
0
0,4
0,8
1,2
1,6
-50 -40 -30 -20 -10 0
TC
Heat Flow (W/g)
20%
12%
9% 7.6%
8%
Fig.III.2-1: DSC melting thermograms of NaOH/water solutions.
CNaOH = 7.6%, 8%, 9%, 12% and 20%
Curves are shifted vertically for a better visibility.
Tab.III.2-1: Melting temperatures determined from DSC thermograms (Fig.III.2-1)
III.2.1.2. Peak at lower temperature: melting of the eutectic mixture
The melting temperature of the peak at low temperature is around -33.4C. The temperature
variation with the NaOH concentration is not negligible, but it is due to the inherent difficulty of
finding the proper beginning of melting with the DSC technique (part II.3.1). In addition, the
melting temperatures have not been measured at heating or cooling rates and mass of sample
extrapolated to zero, which induces a small temperature error (see part III.1.1.3). The peak
corresponds to the melting of the eutectic mixture. It is in the range of temperatures given in the
literature (-34C [COH1960]).
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-103-
A) What is the molecular composition of the eutectic mixture which crystallises during the
DSC experiments?
The peak at higher temperature disappears when the NaOH concentration is 20%. This means
that only eutectic is present in the solution, in agreement with the NaOH/water phase diagram
described in ref. [PIC1893][COH1960]. Fig.III.2-2 also represents NaOH/water phase diagram
and indicates the terms used in this report. Thus 20%NaOH/80%H
2
O in weight per cent is
the composition of the pure eutectic. Taking into account the molar weight of water and sodium
hydroxide, 18 and 40, respectively, we can also write:
m
NaOH
= 20% (m
NaOH
+ m
H2O
)
40 = 0.2(40 + n
H2O
* 18)
n
H20
~ 9
Thus, the eutectic mixture, melting at -33.4C, has a total composition of 1NaOH and 9H
2
O in
moles.
B) What is the structure of this eutectic mixture?
Let us consider the detailed structure of the eutectic, which is a mixture of two crystals.
In a recent paper [ROY2001], it is reported that the eutectic mixture is composed of the stable
crystalline sodium hydrate NaOH,7H
2
O and water. But, in fact, the melting temperature of the
eutectic containing the stable hydrate + water is -29C whereas the melting temperature of the
eutectic containing the metastable crystalline hydrate NaOH,5H
2
O + water is -34C [COH1960],
see Fig.III.1-7. In addition, Rollet and Cohen-Adad [ROL1964] reported that a low decrease of
temperature leads to the formation of metastable sodium hydrates. Because we used stainless
steel capsule, the temperature decrease rate is low (part II.3.1.5) which confirms the formation of
the eutectic metastable crystalline hydrate NaOH,5H
2
O + water.
From X-Ray diffraction pattern obtained by Roy [ROY_PhD], it is not possible to discriminate
both hydrate crystals since the experimental diffracting angle was 16.4, value very close to
literature data: NaOH,7H
2
O at 16.22 and NaOH,5H
2
O at 16.26 and 16.53 [MOO1994].
We conclude that the peak at low temperature corresponds to the melting of the eutectic mixture
composed of two crystals: the crystalline hydrate NaOH,5H
2
O and ice, the composition being
NaOH,5H
2
O + 4H
2
O, in order to obtain the ratio 1NaOH/9H
2
O.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-104-
Liquid
E
Eutectic compound
NaOH,5H
2
O + 4H
2
O
f
hyd.
f
ice
hydrate+ice
L+ice
Tx
~-34
Solidus
f
liq.
f
eut.
f
ice
X%
Liquidus
H
2
O
Fig.III.2-2: Detailed part of NaOH/water phase diagram (Fig.III.1-7 [COH1960]) for 0-31% NaOH concentrations
fice : fraction of free ice, fliq: fraction of liquid
at T~-34C, fliq = feut with feut: fraction of the eutectic compound, function of the NaOH concentration
fhyd and fice fractions of sodium hydrate and ice, respectively, in the eutectic compound
On the Fig.III.2-2, the left-hand axis of the phase diagram corresponds to water. At the right-
hand side, the vertical line corresponds to the crystalline pentahydrate NaOH,5H
2
O having a
molar weight of 130g/mol. The composition of this crystalline hydrate is 30.8%NaOH and
69.2% water, in weight per cent.
For information, the level rule applied on this part of the binary NaOH/water phase diagram
enables to determine the proportion of each phase present in the eutectic mixture. Knowing that
the NaOH concentration at the eutectic point is 20%, we obtain:
o Hydrate fraction = f
hyd
= 20/30.8 = 65%
o Ice fraction = f
ice
= (30.8-20)/30.8 = 35%
The eutectic compound is a mixture of 35% ice and 65% crystalline NaOH,5H
2
O hydrate, in
weight per cent.
To conclude, the eutectic mixture can be defined:
o By the nature of crystals: NaOH,5H
2
O and ice, with one mole of NaOH,5H
2
O and
four moles of water
o By the proportion of crystals: 65% sodium hydrate + 35% H
2
O
o By the proportion of components: 20% NaOH + 80% H
2
O
Its melting temperature is ~33.4C.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-105-
III.2.1.3. Peak at higher temperature
The melting peak at higher temperature changes with NaOH concentration (Fig.III.2-1). Higher
is the NaOH concentration; lower are the melting temperature and the intensity of the peak. This
peak disappears at 20% NaOH. It corresponds to the melting of free ice. In agreement with the
phase diagram, this peak is very large because of the gradual melting of crystallised water.
III.2.1.4. Proportions between NaOH and water
The peak at low temperature (-33.4C) corresponds to the melting of the eutectic mixture
containing 20% NaOH. Thus the DSC thermogram of the 20%NaOH solution gives the melting
enthalpy of pure eutectic: H
eut, pure
= 187 J/g (Tab.III.2-2).
The peak at higher temperature corresponds to the melting of free ice. The melting enthalpy of
pure crystallised water: H
ice,pure
= 358 J/g (Tab.III.2-3) was measured with distilled water. This
value is in the acceptable agreement with the data of literature (333.5 J/g [WEA1983]).
Applying the level rule on the NaOH/water phase diagram, it is possible to calculate the fraction
of eutectic mixture f
eut, calc.
and the fraction of free ice f
ice, calc.
at any NaOH concentration (X% on
the graph Fig.III.2-2). When the NaOH concentration C
NaOH
is lower than 20%, we obtain:
20
. ,
NaOH
calc eut
C
f = Eq. 1
20
20
,
NaOH
calc ice
C
f
= Eq. 2
Since we know the melting enthalpies of the pure eutectic H
eut,pure
and pure ice H
ice,pure
, it
comes that the experimental fractions of eutectic f
eut,exp.
and ice f
ice,pure
, at any NaOH
concentration, are:
pure eut
NaOH eut
eut
H
C H
f
,
. exp ,
. exp ,
) (
= Eq. 3
pure ice
NaOH ice
ice
H
C H
f
,
. exp ,
. exp ,
) (
= Eq. 4
The fractions, determined from DSC thermograms and calculated from the phase diagram, are
compared Tab.III.2-2 and Tab.III.2-3 for the eutectic and ice peaks, respectively.
CNaOH %
Heut,exp.(CNaOH), J/g
DSC
feut,exp.
Eq.3
feut,calc.
Eq.1
7.6 72 0.39 0.38
8 73 0.39 0.40
9 83 0.44 0.45
12 111 0.59 0.6
20 187 = Heut,pure 1 1
Tab.III.2-2: Melting enthalpy of eutectic mixture Heut,exp.(CNaOH) determined from DSC thermogram (Fig.III.2-1;
fractions of eutectic in NaOH+water solution at a given NaOH concentration CNaOH from 7.6% to 20%,
determined from DSC feut,exp. and calculated from phase diagram level rule feut,calc.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-106-
CNaOH %
Hice,exp.(CNaOH), J/g
DSC
fice,exp.
Eq.4
fice,calc.
Eq.2
%
0 358 = Hice,pure 1 1
7.6 197 0.55 0.62 11
8 188 0.53 0.60 12
9 173 0.48 0.55 13
12 133 0.37 0.4 7
Tab.III.2-3: Melting enthalpy of free ice Hice,exp.(CNaOH) determined from DSC thermogram (Fig.III.2-1);
fractions of free ice in NaOH+water solution at a given NaOH concentration C
NaOH
from 0% to 13%,
determined from DSC fice,exp. and calculated from phase diagram level rule fice,calc..
Column 5 is the relative difference between the two experimental and calculated values.
Tab.III.2-2 and Tab.III.2-3 show that fractions calculated from phase diagram level rule and
determined from DSC thermograms coincide within the experimental errors, in agreement of the
phase diagram plotted in Fig.III.2.2. The NaOH and water mixtures behave as normal eutectic-
type mixtures. All the components are fully identified, at all concentrations under consideration;
their state (crystalline or liquid) and fractions are known from the phase diagram.
Thus the experimental data obtained and methodology used can be applied for the analysis of
urea/water binary system as well as for the analysis of ternary phase diagrams
NaOH/urea/water, NaOH/ZnO/water, cellulose/NaOH/water solutions and we will apply the
same consideration to four-body mixtures (cellulose/NaOH/water/urea).
Revision of the previous work
In the previous work on NaOH/water solutions [ROY_PhD][ROY2001], the comparison of
experimental and calculated ice fractions gave differences superior to 20%, even reaching 64%. In
order to explain this discrepancy, the presence of a third phase amorphous water was
suspected.
Fig.III.2-3: Scheme of two different calculations of melting enthalpy of ice.
The red area is the correct one.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-107-
However, from the phase diagram (Fig.III.2-2), it is not possible to have three phases and the
thermograms used by Roy [ROY_PhD][ROY2001] were re-examined. It turned out that the peak
area of the ice was strongly underestimated due to error on the base line. The enthalpy was
calculated as a blue area shown on Fig.III.2-3 while the peak is larger: it starts at low temperature
(shown by on Fig.III.2-3), just at the beginning of the peak of the eutectic mixture, in
accordance with the phase diagram. The real enthalpy values are greater than the ones measured
by Roy (area in red is larger than in blue).
We can note that in our case (Tab.III.2-3), the relative difference between experimental and
measured values is about 10%. The fraction of free ice calculated from phase diagram and
determined from enthalpy measurements are in good agreement, within the experimental errors.
This means that there is no third component like amorphous water.
III.2.1.5. Conclusion on the phase diagram and structure of NaOH/water solutions
The mixture of sodium hydroxide and water in the 0-31%NaOH range is a simple solution of
two components: NaOH and water. They are miscible in liquid state and immiscible in solid
state. In our experimental conditions, sodium hydroxide and water form a eutectic mixture
composed of the sodium pentahydrate and water molecules in the following proportions:
NaOH,5H
2
O+4H
2
O. This eutectic mixture crystallises around 33.4C.
Consequently, at very low temperature (T<-33.4C), the NaOH/H
2
O mixture is composed of
two crystalline phases (Fig.III.2-4):
o The crystalline hydrate: NaOH,5H
2
O
o Ice in two locations:
free ice forming rather large crystals (if C
NaOH
< 20%)
ice with the crystalline hydrate in the form of tiny crystals to form the eutectic
mixture.
From the phase diagram, the calculations of the fractions of the various components presented at
a given composition and temperature show a good agreement with the experimental data. The
system is at equilibrium at all moment in the experimental conditions that have been used.
It is thus possible to schematically represent the structure at temperatures below -33.4C as
below:
Eutectic
mixture
Fig.III.2-4: Scheme of the structure of crystallised NaOH/water system at CNaOH<20% and temperature below -33.4C.
Note that the shape of the eutectic crystals is not known. It is presented here in the form of spheres for the sake of drawing.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-108-
III.2.2- NaOH/urea/water ternary system
The aim of this section is to understand how NaOH and urea are reacting when they are mixed
in aqueous solutions. Firstly, we will determine the 0-100%urea/water binary phase diagram.
Secondly, NaOH/urea/water ternary system will be investigated: NaOH concentration being
fixed at 7.6wt% and urea concentrations varying from 0% to 25%. A section of the phase
diagram will be drawn.
III.2.2.1. Urea/water binary phase diagram
DSC experiments consist in determining melting peaks for urea/water solutions, urea
concentrations varying from 0% to 100%. This study is divided into two parts: from 0% to 30%
of urea and from 30% to 100%.
From 0% to 30% of urea
DSC melting thermograms of 0-30%urea aqueous solutions are represented on the Fig.III.2-5.
The melting temperature and enthalpy of each peak are reported in the Tab.III.2-4 and Tab.III.2-
5, respectively. In the Tab.III.2-4, the term solidus (DSC) corresponds to the onset of the peak
at low temperature and the term liquidus (DSC) to the end of the peak at higher temperature,
both determined with our DSC analyses. The measurements of the liquidus are reported in
literature from the data on urea solubility in water [RAB1978][WEA1983]. We can note that
DSC values and Handbook values are relatively close and differ because of the difference in
the method of determination.
0
0,4
0,8
1,2
1,6
2
-16 -12 -8 -4 0 4
TC
H
e
a
t
F
l
o
w
(
W
/
g
)
6%
30%
20%
16%
12%
8%
Fig.III.2-5: DSC melting thermograms for urea/water solutions
Curea = 6%, 8%, 12%, 16%, 20%, and 30%
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-109-
%urea solidus
(DSC) (DSC) (Handbook)
6 -11,3 0,8 -1,9
8 -11,3 -0,4 -2,6
12 -11,4 -1,3 -4,0
16 -11,2 -2,9 -5,4
20 -11,6 -4,5 -7,0
30 -11,2 -11,4
40 -11,4 0
50 -11,4
60 -11,4 39 35
70 -11,5 64 56
80 85 80
100 137 135
liquidus
Tab.III.2-4: Temperatures of solidus and liquidus curves.
DSC values correspond to the melting temperatures obtained by DSC experiments.
Handbook values correspond to solubility temperatures reported in handbooks [RAB1978][WEA1983]
The urea/water DSC thermograms (Fig.III.2-5) are similar to the NaOH/water DSC
thermograms (Fig.III.2-1). Apart for 30% urea, all DSC thermograms reveal two melting peaks
more or less well-separated:
o The first one, at low temperature, has the same position whatever is the urea
concentration from 6% to 30%. At the onset of the melting peak, the temperature is
about -11.3C (Tab.III.2-4, column 2). This peak should correspond to the melting of a
eutectic mixture.
o The second one, at higher temperatures, is shifted towards low temperatures when urea
content increases (Tab.III.2-4, column 3 and 4). We deduced that this peak probably
corresponds to the gradual melting of free ice.
The peak of free ice disappears at about 30% of urea. This means that the eutectic mixture
should contain 30% of urea in the whole.
From these data, the 0-30%urea part of the phase diagram can be drawn.
We can see here the effect of the phenomena described in part III.1.1.3 concerning the influence
of using non-zero heating rate and mass. The peak at high water content is finishing above 0C.
The error here is about 1C.
30% of urea
As the molar masses of urea CO(NH
2
)
2
and water are 60g/mol and 18g/mol respectively,
30% of urea in weight corresponds to a molar ratio n
H2O
/n
urea
= 7.8. Thus, the total eutectic
composition is probably 1 urea and 8 H
2
O. This can be checked using the above-described
methodology in the case of NaOH/water binary system.
Melting enthalpies of urea eutectic mixture and ice are reported in Tab.III.2-5. Since the two
peaks overlap, the enthalpy of each peak was deconvoluted with PeakFit software, described in
the part II.3.1.6. All the thermograms with their deconvolution treatment are shown in the
Appendix 3.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-110-
DSC
% urea Total eutectic ice
0 358 = Hice,pure
6 325 51 275
8 323 67 256
12 319 111 208
16 311 155 156
20 308 212 96
29,4 290 = Heut,pure
30 291
Enthalpies
PeakFit
Tab.III.2-5: Melting enthalpies of eutectic mixture and free ice.
The total enthalpy was determined with DSC software from the thermogram.
Eutectic and ice enthalpies were calculated with PeakFit software as described in part II.3.1.6
The calculated and measured fractions of eutectic mixture and free ice are compared in order to
check the existence and the composition of the urea/water eutectic mixture. Calculations were
performed with the hypothesis that eutectic mixture is reached at 29.4% urea, which corresponds
to the composition 1 urea + 8 water molecules.
The equations are described below and values are reported in the Tab.III.2-6.
4 . 29
. ,
urea
calc eut
C
f = Eq. 5
pure eut
urea eut
eut
H
C H
f
,
. exp ,
. exp ,
) (
= Eq. 6
4 . 29
4 . 29
. ,
urea
calc ice
C
f
= Eq. 7
pure ice
urea ice
ice
H
C H
f
,
. exp ,
. exp ,
) (
= Eq. 8
% urea
feut,exp.
Eq.6
feut,calc
Eq.5
%
fice,exp.
Eq.8
fice,calc.
Eq.7
%
6 0,17 0,20 15 0,77 0,80 4
8 0,23 0,27 16 0,72 0,73 2
12 0,38 0,41 6 0,58 0,59 2
16 0,53 0,54 2 0,44 0,46 4
20 0,73 0,68 8 0,27 0,32 16
Tab.III.2-6: Comparison of fractions of eutectic mixture and free ice,
determined from DSC thermograms feut,exp. and fice,exp. and calculated from
phase diagram level rule (eutectic having 29.4%urea) feut,calc. and fice,calc.
Tab.III.2-6 shows that fraction of eutectic mixture and free ice calculated from phase diagram
and measured from DSC thermograms are similar within the experimental errors. This is
validating the hypothesis of a eutectic mixture containing 29.4wt% of urea, which corresponds to
a molar urea/water ratio of 1/8. This eutectic melts at -11.4C. But knowing the exact structure
of eutectic mixture needs an X-Ray diffraction analysis, as we will see below.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-111-
From 30% to 100% of urea
DSC analyses were also performed on 30-100%urea/water solutions. Typical thermogram is
represented on the Fig.III.2-6 and the melting temperatures are reported in the Tab.III.2-4.
For urea aqueous solutions, two peaks are seen. The first one is still at -11.4C, as in the case of
0-30%urea/water solutions; thus corresponding to the melting of the same eutectic mixture. The
second one is shifted towards higher temperature. Pure urea gives a single peak at 137C.
TC
~ -11
Fig.III.2-6: Scheme of DSC melting thermograms for urea aqueous solutions with 30% < Curea < 100%.
In order to check the crystalline structure of the component which melts at high temperature for
an aqueous solution containing more than 30% of urea, and thus the composition of the eutectic
mixture, we carried out X-Ray diffraction analyses.
We tested pure urea and the 70%urea/water system. X-ray diffraction patterns were compared
and are represented on the Fig.III.2-7.
0
20000
40000
60000
80000
100000
120000
10 20 30 40 50 60
2Theta ()
I (cts)
100% urea
70% urea
Fig.III.2-7: X-Ray diffraction patterns for pure urea and for a 70%urea aqueous solution.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-112-
The two patterns of 100%urea and 70%urea show the same diffraction peaks. Nevertheless, we
can note a slight shift of some peaks, especially at high value of 2 Theta. This could be explained
by an irregular surface of the 70%urea/water sample. We concluded that the peak at higher
temperature corresponds to the melting of pure urea.
Consequently, the eutectic mixture contains two crystals: pure urea and ice, without crystalline
hydrate. The urea/water binary system has a simple eutectic behaviour.
Conclusion on the urea/water binary phase diagram
DSC and X-Ray scattering enable us to draw the whole urea/water binary phase diagram
(Fig.III.2-8).
-20
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
% urea
T
C
Eutectic compound
extrapolation
pure ice
pure urea
Literature data
Fig.III.2-8: Binary phase diagram of urea/water system
The urea/water system has a typical eutectic behaviour:
o The eutectic compound is a mixture of two crystals: pure urea + ice. Its melting
temperature is -11.4C and its composition is 1 urea + 8H
2
O.
o From 0% to 29.4% of urea, the liquidus corresponds to the melting of pure ice.
o From 29.4% to 100% of urea, the liquidus corresponds to the melting of pure urea.
At low temperature (<-11.4C), the system has two crystalline phases but the structure and the
size of urea and ice crystals depends on the urea concentrations.
o Below 29.4%urea, the system is composed of pure urea and ice in two locations: free ice
and ice with pure urea to form the eutectic mixture (Fig.III.2-9a).
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-113-
o 29.4% is the eutectic composition; the system only contains the eutectic mixture, i.e.
crystals of pure urea and crystals of ice (Fig.III.2-9b).
o Above 29.4%urea, the system is composed of ice and urea in two locations: free urea and
urea with ice to form the eutectic mixture (Fig.III.2-9c).
a)
b)
* eutectic mixture
c)
Fig.III.2-9: Schematic structure of crystallised urea/water system below -11.4C,
a) Curea<29.4% ; b) Curea=29.4% ; c) Curea>29.4%
III.2.2.2. NaOH/urea/water ternary phase diagram
Now, as NaOH/water and urea/water binary phase diagrams are known, the NaOH/urea/water
ternary system can be investigated. The compositions of mixtures studied were in the range from
7.6NaOH/6urea/water to 7.6NaOH/25urea/water. In other words, 100g of solution
7.6NaOH/Zurea/water contained 7.6g of NaOH, from Z = 6 to 25 g of urea and from 86.4 to
69.4 g of water, respectively. DSC melting thermograms were plotted and are represented on the
Fig.III.2-10. In this range of urea concentrations, five melting peaks are seen. A given
NaOH/urea/water system reveals some of them depending on the urea concentration.
0
0,5
1
1,5
2
2,5
-50 -40 -30 -20 -10 0
TC
H
e
a
t
F
l
o
w
(
W
/
g
)
0 urea
12 urea
6 urea
18 urea
20 urea
14 urea
25 urea
Fig.III.2-10: DSC melting thermograms for 7.6NaOH/Z urea/water solutions (Z= 0, 6, 12, 14, 18, 20 and 25).
DSC traces were shifted for a better visibility
*
*
*
1
2
3
3
3
4
4
1
5
5
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-114-
Appendix 4 shows the DSC thermograms for 7.6NaOH/Z urea/water solutions (Z= 6, 12, 14,
and 18) with deconvolution treatment.
Peak n1
The peak n1 corresponds to the melting of the metastable eutectic mixture NaOH,5H
2
O+4H
2
O
(named NaOH eutectic mixture in the following). Tab.III.2-7 column 3 shows that as soon as
urea is added, the melting temperature is depressed from about -33.4C in binary NaOH/water
solution, without urea to about -35.6C with urea. This slight decrease of eutectic melting
temperature in ternary system compared with a binary system is due to the presence of the third
component (part III.1.1.2). On the other hand, we can note that this melting peak remains
constant for all urea concentrations studied because the NaOH/water eutectic mixture is never
crystallizing in presence of a liquid.
Peak n2
This peak appears at about -30C but it is not always present. This one corresponds to the
melting of the stable eutectic mixture NaOH,7H
2
O+2H
2
O studied previously (part III.1.2.2). It
seems, but we do not know why, that the presence of urea in a 7.6NaOH/water makes easier the
crystallisation of this stable eutectic.
With the DSC7, it is not possible to obtain only a stable NaOH eutectic mixture. Consequently,
its pure melting enthalpy is unknown. In the next parts, we will use the same enthalpy for both
eutectic melting, i.e. 187J/g. The low intensity of the peak of the stable eutectic in comparison
with the one of metastable eutectic mixture (Fig.III.2-10 for 7.6NaOH/water solutions
containing 14, 18 and 25 grams of urea) will not bring a lot of error.
7.6NaOH/
Z urea/water
Heut NaOH,
J/g
Tm NaOHeut
(onset)
Tm ureaeut
(peak)
Tm free comp
(end)
0 72 -34.2 - -6.9
6 72 -35.9 -25.7 -8.6 free
12 71 -36.0 -20.6 -12.5 ice
14 70 -35.5 -19.2 -12.9
18 71 -35.3 -17.3 -16.3
20 74 -35.5 -17.8 -14.1 free
25 69 -35.6 -18.5 -6.2 urea
Tab.III.2-7: Melting enthalpy of NaOH eutectic and melting temperatures of NaOH eutectic, urea eutectic, free
compounds (ice and urea) for 7.6NaOH / Z urea / water solutions (Z= 0, 6, 12, 14, 18, 20, and 25)
The melting temperature of the NaOH eutectic is taken at the onset of the peak, the one of the
urea eutectic at the maximum of the peak (the onset is impossible to be measured) and the one of
ice at the end of the peak to determine the liquidus (with the same comments concerning the
drawback of using a finite mass of sample and a finite heating rate).
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-115-
As the melting enthalpy and the melting temperature of NaOH eutectic mixtures (Tab.III.2-7
column 2 and 3) remain constant with an increase of urea concentration, we can conclude that
urea neither disrupt the formation of NaOH eutectic nor modify its composition, which
is still 1NaOH+9H
2
O. During the time of experiment, urea does not react with NaOH.
Consequently, the species in solution are:
NaOH eutectic mixtures, in metastable and/or stable state.
Urea compounds which remain to be determined
and water
Peaks n3 and n4
The peak n3 appears as soon as urea is added but its location changes depending on urea
concentration. This peak should correspond to the melting of a urea compound whose the nature
has to be determined.
The temperature of the melting peak n4 decreases when urea concentration increases from 0 to
14 g of urea in 100 g of solution. This peak could be attributed to the gradual melting of free ice.
From DSC data obtained we may assume that urea does not react with NaOH molecules and
does not modify the NaOH eutectic. Thus we can expect that in solution in the presence of
NaOH urea and water behave as in the binary system: they form a eutectic mixture containing 1
urea and 8 water molecules. In that case, the peaks n3 and n4 should represent the melting of
urea eutectic mixture and the melting of free ice, respectively.
Plotting the melting temperature of the peaks as a function of urea concentration (Fig.III.2-11)
shows that these two peaks n3 and n4 are joining at 7.6NaOH/18urea/water. If our hypothesis
is correct, this means that at this composition there are the two NaOH and urea eutectic mixtures
coexisting but there is no free water in solution.
Calculation to determine the nature of the urea compound
Let us consider a solution containing 7.6g NaOH + 18g urea + 74.4g water. For 100g of mixture,
we have:
M
H2O
=18g/mol; 74.4 g H
2
O 4.13moles of water in the whole solution
M
NaOH
=40g/mol; 7.6 g NaOH 0.19 moles of NaOH which corresponds to 0.19 moles of
NaOH eutectic mixture.
M
urea
=60g/mol; 18 g urea 0.3 moles of urea in the solution
The NaOH eutectic mixture is not modified by the addition of urea and it contains 1NaOH and
9H
2
O molecules
0.19*9 = 1.71 moles of water molecules are trapped in the NaOH eutectic mixture.
It remains 4.13-1.71 = 2.42 moles of free water.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-116-
(i) The urea eutectic mixture is composed of 1urea and 8H
2
O molecules
0.3*8 = 2.4 moles of water are trapped in the urea eutectic
It only remains 0.02 moles of free water in the whole solution.
(ii) After the formation of NaOH eutectic mixture, 100g of solution contains:
18 g of urea
2.42 mol*18 = 43.56g of free water
Consequently, the local concentration of urea is [18/ (18+43.56])*100 = 29.2g which corresponds
to the composition of the urea eutectic mixture.
These calculations allow concluding that:
Both NaOH and urea eutectic mixtures are formed independently and thus are
competing for water
At 7.6NaOH/18urea/water there is no free water, only NaOH and urea eutectic
mixtures.
Peak n5
For a 7.6NaOH/20urea/water solution, we can observe a small peak at the end of the eutectic
peak. For a 7.6NaOH/25urea/water solution, we can guess that there is a peak at about -6C.
These two phenomena are reproducible. Since this peak cannot be due to NaOH, it is due to the
melting of strongly depressed urea. This is the clear sign that upon competing with water, NaOH
is winning over urea.
Conclusion on the 7.6NaOH/urea/water ternary phase diagram
From the melting temperatures reported in the Tab.III.2-7, we can draw a part of the ternary
phase diagram of the 7.6NaOH/urea/water system (Fig.III.2-11).
The figure shows the crystalline phases present in the system at a given temperature and a given
urea concentration, with 7.6g of NaOH in 100g of solution. It is not possible to calculate the
proportion of each phase from such a phase diagram, as we saw in the theoretical part of this
chapter (part III.1.1.2).
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-117-
-60
-50
-40
-30
-20
-10
0
0 5 10 15 20 25
mass of urea in 100g of solution
TC
Fig.III.2-11: Ternary phase diagram for 7.6NaOH / (0-25)urea / water solution
full triangle: melting of NaOH eutectic mixture; open triangle: melting of the urea eutectic mixture;
full square: melting of free ice; open square: melting of free urea
We saw that NaOH and urea are forming both their normal eutectic mixture with water
NaOH,5H
2
O+4H
2
O and urea+8H
2
O respectively. This means that they are not interacting but
they are competing for water. In 100 g of solution:
at m
urea
< 18 g, there is enough water for both compounds to feel independent.
at m
urea
= 18 g, there is no free water in solution, all water molecules are linked either to
the NaOH eutectic mixture or to the urea eutectic mixture.
at m
urea
> 18 g, there is not enough water for both eutectics. Because of a strong polarity
of NaOH (pairs of ions), the water molecules surrounding the Na
+
and OH
-
ions in
solution are more strongly linked to NaOH molecules than water molecules surrounding
urea molecules. Consequently, the NaOH eutectic mixture is thermodynamically easier to
form than the urea eutectic mixture. This explains that the melting peak of NaOH
eutectic mixture appears for all the urea concentrations studied and that, at urea
concentrations higher than 18 g in 100 g of solution, pure urea is present in the system.
NaOH, urea and water behave as in their binary situations.
All is liquid
NaOH + urea + water
Ice + liquid
Crystalline urea + liquid
Everything crystallised
Liquid +
+ Crystalline urea: in urea eutectic
+ Ice: in urea eutectic and free ice
+ Crystalline urea: in urea eutectic and free crystals
+ Ice: in urea eutectic
+ Crystalline urea: in urea eutectic
+ Ice: in NaOH and urea eutectics and free ice
+ Crystalline urea: in urea eutectic and free crystals
+ Ice: in NaOH and urea eutectics
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-118-
III.2.3- NaOH/ZnO/water ternary system
The goal of this section is to understand how sodium hydroxide and zinc oxide are reacting when
they are put together in water.
From literature [LIU1998], we know that ZnO can be dissolved in acid or strongly basic aqueous
solutions (Fig.III.2-12). Moreover, dissolving ZnO, in solid state (s), induces some reactions with
OH
-
to form zinc hydroxyl ions; the major species at high alkalinity are Zn(OH)
3
-
and Zn(OH)
4
2-
(Fig.III.2-13) [DIR1954] [REI1975] [BEN1999], according to the following equilibrium
equations:
Zn(OH)
3
-
ZnO
(s)
+ H
2
O + OH
-
Zn(OH)
4
2-
ZnO
(s)
+ H
2
O + 2OH
-
Fig.III.2-12 [LIU1998]: Influence of pH on solubility of tin and zinc
Fig.III.2-13 [REI1975]: Graph of fraction f of Zn(II) existing as
Zn
2+
, Zn(OH)
-
, Zn(OH)2, Zn(OH)3
-
, and Zn(OH)4
2-
over a range of pH at 25C.
As soon as ZnO is added to a NaOH/water solution, the above reactions occur to totally
dissolve ZnO crystals. Consequently, the structure of the alkaline solutions should be modified
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-119-
by the presence of ZnO. In the forthcoming sections, we will compare the two aqueous solvents
NaOH/water and NaOH/ZnO/water by viscosimetry, NMR, and DSC.
The mixtures that we used contained up to 20 g of NaOH (without ZnO, this corresponds to the
eutectic mixture) and up to 1.84 g of ZnO in 100 g of solution.
III.2.3.1. Viscosity of dilute NaOH/ZnO/water solutions
We measured the viscosity of the NaOH/water and NaOH/ZnO/water solutions during their
dilution with water with an Ubbelohde capillary viscometer (see description in II.3.3.2). The
initial compositions were 12 g of NaOH and 1.1 g of ZnO in 100 g of solution. As water is the
solvent, ZnO concentration decreases upon dilution in the same way as NaOH concentration
and the ratio ZnO/NaOH is constant. That is why, on Fig.III.2-14, the relative viscosity is
plotted versus NaOH concentration.
1
1,2
1,4
1,6
1,8
2
0 5 10 15
NaOH concentration (g/cm3)
r
e
l
a
t
i
v
e
v
i
s
c
o
s
i
t
y
(a)
1
1,2
1,4
1,6
1,8
2
0 5 10 15
NaOH concentration (g/cm3)
r
e
l
a
t
i
v
e
v
i
s
c
o
s
i
t
y
(b)
1
1,2
1,4
1,6
1,8
2
0 5 10 15
NaOH concentration (g/cm3)
r
e
l
a
t
i
v
e
v
i
s
c
o
s
i
t
y
(c)
1
1,2
1,4
1,6
1,8
2
0 5 10 15
NaOH concentration (g/cm3)
r
e
l
a
t
i
v
e
v
i
s
c
o
s
i
t
y
(d)
1
1,2
1,4
1,6
1,8
2
0 5 10 15
NaOH concentration (g/cm3)
r
e
l
a
t
i
v
e
v
i
s
c
o
s
i
t
y
(e)
1
1,2
1,4
1,6
1,8
2
0 5 10 15
NaOH concentration (g/cm3)
r
e
l
a
t
i
v
e
v
i
s
c
o
s
i
t
y
(f)
Fig.III.2-14: Relative viscosity versus NaOH concentration, comparison of
NaOH/water solution ( ) and NaOH/ZnO/water solution (----)
(a) 12C; (b) 15C; (c) 20C; (d) 25C; (e) 30C and (f) 40C.
Initial compositions: 12NaOH/water and 12NaOH/1.1ZnO/water where NaOH/ZnO=cst for all measurements.
Whatever the temperature is, from +12C to +40C, the relative viscosities of the mixtures
versus NaOH concentration curves are not linear. This means that the solvents are not simple
solutions but that some intermolecular associations and interactions take place, in agreement with
the fact that there is a complex solvation of the NaOH ions [BAR1954] [KUN1985] [YAM1988].
We can note that the relative viscosity of NaOH/water is the same as NaOH/ZnO/water,
within the experimental errors. We can conclude that the formation of zinc hydroxyls, during
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-120-
ZnO dissolution in NaOH/water, does not significantly influence the main non linear effect of
viscosity due to the interactions between NaOH and water.
III.2.3.2. NMR study
This work was performed in the group of Dr Hans-Peter Fink in the Fraunhofer Institute in
Glm, Germany. The full report is in Appendix 5.
1
H and
23
Na nuclei were analysed by NMR in NaOH/water with compositions of (6-
10)NaOH/water, with or without the addition of (0.2-1.5)g of ZnO. Temperature was varied
between -20C and 20C. Two parameters were studied, the chemical shift and the spin lattice
time T1 which expresses the mobility of the nuclei, influenced by the environment.
The purpose of the work was to investigate the hydration behaviour of the Na
+
ions influenced
or not by temperature variation and the presence of ZnO.
23
Na
The relaxation time T1 of
23
Na decreases with temperature due to the variation of viscosity and
with NaOH concentration (also due to the viscosity increase). Addition of ZnO is slightly
decreasing the relaxation time, this effect being more pronounced with increasing ZnO
concentration and solution temperature (Fig.III.2-15 and Appendix 5).
The chemical shift for
23
Na is increasing with decreasing temperature or increasing NaOH, also
due to viscosity changes. The chemical shift is not affected by the presence of ZnO.
6 7 8 9 10
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
20 C
10 C
0 C
-10 C
-20 C
NaOH concentration [%]
2
3
N
a
r
e
l
a
x
a
t
i
o
n
t
i
m
e
T
1
[
m
s
]
0,0 0,4 0,8 1,2 1,6
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
2
3
N
a
r
e
l
a
x
a
t
i
o
n
t
i
m
e
T
1
[
m
s
]
ZnO concentration [%]
20 C
10 C
0 C
-10 C
-20 C
for the lyes for 8% lye with ZnO
Fig.III.2-15: Results of
23
Na relaxation times
1
H
The experiments with
1
H show that the relaxation time T1 decreases with increasing NaOH
concentration, which may reflect either a change of viscosity/mobility or a difference in the
free/bound water mole fraction. There is no influence of the addition of ZnO.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-121-
Conclusion on the NMR analysis
The conclusion of the authors is that there is no change in the hydration of Na
+
ions in the
temperature/concentration range explored since any change should give non linear characteristic
of the relaxation times or the chemical shifts as a function of NaOH concentration. Only linear
regimes were found.
As far as ZnO is concerned, the experiments do not show any influence of the addition of this
compound. There is no major change like the formation of a complex between ZnO and NaOH.
This is in agreement with the viscosity measurements reported above.
III.2.3.3. DSC results
As ZnO reacts with OH
-
to form
zinc hydroxyl ions and as ZnO is not soluble in water, the
number of Na
+
/OH
-
ion pairs should decrease. Consequently, the formation of the NaOH
eutectic mixture should be disrupted by the addition of ZnO and DSC thermograms should
reveal a smaller melting peak of NaOH eutectic than the one of NaOH solutions without ZnO.
Fig.III.2-16 shows DSC thermograms for 20NaOH/(0-1.84)ZnO/water solutions. Without
ZnO, this NaOH concentration corresponds to the eutectic mixture and there is no free water
crystallising. This figure shows a constant decrease of melting temperature (measured at the onset
of the peak) and of melting enthalpy of the NaOH eutectic peak when ZnO concentration
increases (Tab.III.2-8), and no melting of ice.
DSC melting thermogram for
20% NaOH + ZnO aqueous solutions
0
0,4
0,8
1,2
1,6
-50 -40 -30 -20 -10 0
TC
H
e
a
t
f
l
o
w
(
W
/
g
)
+1.84 ZnO
+1.1 ZnO
+0.7 ZnO
without ZnO
Melting temperature
-36
-35
-34
-33
0 0,5 1 1,5 2
ZnO
T
C
Melting enthalpy
150
160
170
180
190
0 0,5 1 1,5 2
ZnO
H
,
J
/
g
Fig.III.2-16: DSC melting thermograms for 20NaOH /x ZnO/water solutions (x= 0, 0.7, 1.1, and 1.84).
This melting peak corresponds to the melting of the metastable NaOH eutectic mixture.
The changes of this NaOH eutectic peak (melting temperature and melting enthalpy) versus ZnO concentration are
represented on inset graphs.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-122-
Peak of the NaOH eutectic mixture
Melting temperature
If we look at the melting temperature of the eutectic peak (Fig.III.2-16 and Fig.III.2-8), we can
note that the decrease is constant when ZnO concentration increases. This means that the
NaOH eutectic mixture is crystallising in the presence of liquid which contains at least ions
involving Zn. According to the equilibrium reactions of ZnO dissolution in alkali solutions and
Fig.III.2-13, these ions could be Na
+
/Zn(OH)
3
-
and 2Na
+
/Zn(OH)
4
2-
.
Melting enthalpy
The constant decrease of melting enthalpy (Fig.III.2-16 and Tab.III.2-8) confirms that some
NaOH molecules react with ZnO. According to the literature [DIR1954] [REI1975] [BEN1999],
at pH>12, the major species in solution are Zn(OH)
3
-
,Na
+
and Zn(OH)
4
2-
,2Na
+
(Fig.III.2-13),
thus one or two NaOH should be linked to ZnO.
The number of NaOH having participated to the ZnO dissolution can be determined from the
decrease of the peak since these NaOH molecules cannot participate to the crystallisation of the
eutectic mixture NaOH,5H
2
O+4H
2
O:
pure eut
ZnO eut
eut eut in not NaOH
H
m H
f f
,
. exp ,
.
) (
1 1
= =
ZnO NaOH
ZnO NaOH
eut in not NaOH
m M
M m
f ZnO NaOH
=
/ Eq. 9
where m
NaOH
=20g, m
ZnO
is the mass of ZnO in solution, M
NaOH
=40g/mol and M
ZnO
=81.4g/mol.
The results are reported in the Tab.III.2-8.
xZnO in
20NaOH/water
Tmeut
(C)
Heut (J/g)
NaOH/ZnO
Eq.9
H2O/ZnO
Eq.11
0 -33.3 187=Heut pure
0.7 -34.3 178 2.8 14
1.1 -34.5 171 3.2 20
1.84 -35.2 157 3.5 25
Tab.III.2-8: Melting temperature and enthalpy of the NaOH eutectic peak (columns 2 & 3)
as a function of ZnO concentration in 20NaOH/xZnO/H2O solutions (x= 0, 0.7, 1.1, and 1.84),
columns 4 & 5 give the calculated ratios NaOH/ZnO and H2O/ZnO necessary to dissolve ZnO.
We see that about 3NaOH are linked to each ZnO whereas the literature is suggesting a value of
one and two.
From these values, an extrapolation of the eutectic melting enthalpy to zero gives a limit of ZnO
dissolution in 20NaOH/water at about 12g ZnO in 100g of solution. This concentration
corresponds to a calculated molar ratio (eq.9) NaOH/ZnO=3.4. This result does not correspond
to our solubility experiments since we measured that ZnO can be dissolved in NaOH up to a
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-123-
maximal molar ratio NaOH/ZnO=10 (i.e. about 4g of ZnO in 100g of solution containing 20g
of NaOH).
Peak of free ice
We know that the 20NaOH/water solution without ZnO is only composed of the NaOH
eutectic and that there is no free water. In that case, the DSC melting thermogram has just one
melting peak at -33.4C.
Dissolving ZnO in highly basic solution induces reaction with NaOH. So water molecules
initially surrounding NaOH should be released and thus should crystallise as free water. This is
not the case since no melting peak of free ice appears on the DSC thermograms of solutions
containing ZnO (Fig.III.2-16). All the water molecules present in solution are linked to other
species that prevented them to freeze as ice.
We also studied mixtures with a lower NaOH content (12NaOH/water), where the melting peak
of free ice was observed when ZnO is added. For the 12NaOH/ZnO/water solutions, the
NaOH eutectic could not crystallise most probably because the lowest temperature of the DSC
oven was not low enough to induce crystallisation. Consequently, only the melting peak of free
ice appears (Fig.III.2-17) and we can note that its melting temperature and enthalpy remain
constant at all ZnO concentrations. This means that the quantity of free water is always the same,
even after ZnO addition.
0
0,2
0,4
0,6
0,8
1
1,2
-50 -40 -30 -20 -10 0
TC
H
e
a
t
f
l
o
w
(
W
/
g
)
without ZnO
+ 0.22 ZnO
+ 0.64 ZnO
+ 1.1 ZnO
H (J/g)
124
120
121
121
Tm = -33.5C
H = 108 J/g
Tm (C)
-11.3
-11
-11
-10.8
Fig.III.2-17: DSC melting thermograms of 12NaOH/xZnO/water solutions (x=0, 0.22, 0.64, 1.1)
with melting enthalpy and temperature of free ice.
The melting peak of NaOH eutectic does not appear because the temperature of the cooler was not low enough.
We will calculate in the following how many water moles are surrounding the ions involving
ZnO. This calculation will be performed for the 20NaOH/ZnO/water solution since it was the
only one showing a decrease of the NaOH eutectic peak, thus allowing calculating the number of
NaOH moles involved in a reaction with ZnO.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-124-
The total number of moles of water n
tot.w
in solution is:
18
80 100
2
.
ZnO
O H
ZnO NaOH
w tot
m
M
m m
n
=
|
|
\
|
=
The number of moles of water linked to NaOH to form the eutectic mixture n
eut.w
is:
5 . 4
) (
9
,
. exp ,
.
=
|
|
\
|
=
pure eut
ZnO eut
NaOH
NaOH
eut w eut
H
m H
M
m
f n
where m
NaOH
=20g, m
ZnO
is the mass of ZnO in solution, M
H2O
=18g/mol, M
NaOH
=40g/mol and
M
ZnO
=81.4g/mol.
According to the dissolution reactions, whatever the zinc hydroxyl ion formed is, one water
molecule reacts with one ZnO and thus cannot participate to the eutectic crystallisation:
ZnO
ZnO
ZnO w dissol
M
m
n n = =
.
Thus we can determine how many water molecules n
surr.w
are surrounding the ion pairs. These
water molecules are not free and can not participate to the melting peak of free ice.
w eut w tot w dissol w surr
n n n n
. . . .
= +
5 . 4
) (
18
80
,
. exp ,
.
= +
pure eut
ZnO eut
ZnO
ZnO w surr
H
m H
m
n n Eq. 10
Thus, if Eq.10 is divided by n
ZnO
, the ratio H
2
O/ZnO is obtained and corresponds to the quantity
of water necessary to dissolve ZnO in alkali solutions.
ZnO
ZnO w surr
n
n n
ZnO O H
+
=
.
2
/ Eq. 11
The values are reported in the Tab.III.2-8. We can note that the number of moles of water linked
to ZnO increases with ZnO content.
If we assume that 25 moles of water per ZnO is necessary for the ZnO dissolution in
NaOH/water, it is possible to calculate the dissolution limit since the number of water molecules
surrounding ZnO has to be equalled to the number of water molecules not crystallised in NaOH
eutectic mixture. We obtain the following equation:
w ZnO w eut w tot
n n n
. . .
= Eq. 12
where n
ZnO.w
is the number of water molecules involved in ZnO dissolution
ZnO
ZnO
M
m lim
25 = and
n
eut.w
the number of water molecules crystallised in NaOH eutectic mixture
eut NaOH
n
.
9 =
( )
|
|
\
|
= =
ZnO
ZnO
NaOH
NaOH
ZnO with NaOH tot NaOH
M
m
M
m
n n
lim
4 . 3 9 9
.. . .
, where n
NaOH.with.ZnO
represents the
number of NaOH molecules involved in ZnO dissolution, 3.4 being the ratio NaOH/ZnO
determined from the extrapolation of melting enthalpy.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-125-
Substituting these expressions in the Eq.12 gives:
ZnO
ZnO
ZnO
ZnO
NaOH
NaOH
O H
ZnO NaOH
M
m
M
m
M
m
M
m m lim
25
lim
4 . 3 9
lim 100
2
=
|
|
\
|
O H
NaOH
NaOH
NaOH
O H ZnO
ZnO
M
m
M
m
M M
m
2 2
100
9
1 6 . 5
lim
=
|
|
\
|
Thus, g m
ZnO
2 . 4 lim = in 100g of 20NaOH aqueous solution.
This calculation suggests that ZnO can be dissolved in 20NaOH/water solution up to about
4.2g. This concentration corresponds to a 0.052mol of ZnO in 0.5mol NaOH. The calculated
limit of ZnO dissolution is reached when NaOH/ZnO=10 which corresponds to our
experimental data, with the assumption that 25 moles of water are necessary for dissolving ZnO.
III.2.3.4. Conclusion on the NaOH/ZnO/water system
Intermolecular interactions take place in NaOH/water and NaOH/ZnO/water systems which
are reflected by the non-linear dependence of the relative viscosity upon dilution. It seems that
ZnO does not influence the structure of the NaOH/water complexes, at least seen from
viscometric measurements and NMR analyses.
On the other hand, DSC analyses reveal significant changes in NaOH/water system when ZnO
is added:
During dissolution, ZnO reacts with NaOH to form zinc hydroxides, NaZn(OH)
3
and
Na
2
Zn(OH)
4
according to literature. As a consequence, some NaOH molecules are not
anymore able to form the NaOH eutectic mixture and its melting peak decreases. About
3NaOH/ZnO is involved in the dissolution.
The quantity of water crystallizing as free ice does not change with the addition of ZnO:
the melting enthalpy of free ice remains constant. Some water molecules are involved in
the dissolution reactions 1H
2
O/ZnO and some other are surrounding the ions in
solution. The total ratio H
2
O/ZnO increases up to 25, when ZnO concentration
increases from 0 to 1.8g in 100g of solution.
From these results we also determined that ZnO needs not only Na
+
/OH
-
ions but also a large
quantity of water to be dissolved. With the assumption that 25 water molecules are needed for
dissolving one molecule of ZnO, the limit of ZnO dissolution is reached for a NaOH/ZnO
molar ratio equals to 10, value in agreement with our solubility experiment.
Finally, the NaOH eutectic mixture is crystallising in presence of a liquid containing zinc
hydroxides, some sodium hydroxide and water molecules. That is why the NaOH eutectic
melting temperature decreases when ZnO content increases. This may also explain why, in some
cases, the NaOH eutectic peak does not appear when we analyse solutions containing ZnO.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-126-
III.2.4- Conclusions on the structure of cellulose solvents: NaOH/water,
NaOH/urea/water and NaOH/ZnO/water
The NaOH/water binary phase diagram obtained from DSC experiments is in agreement with
the ones reported in literature [PIC1893] [COH1960] [ROL1964].
The NaOH/water and urea/water binary systems have both typical eutectic behaviours:
o Below the eutectic composition (NaOH content lower than 20g and urea content lower
than 29.4g, in 100g of solution), free ice is crystallising and its melting temperature
decreases with the increase of NaOH or urea concentrations.
o The eutectic mixture is melting at a constant temperature for all concentrations. For
sodium hydroxide aqueous solutions, the eutectic mixture is composed of NaOH,5H
2
O
and 4H
2
O and melts at -33.4C. For urea aqueous solutions, the eutectic compound is a
mixture of 1urea and 8H
2
O, it melts at -11.4C.
o At concentrations higher than the eutectic composition, the components that are
crystallising are NaOH,5H
2
O and urea for sodium hydroxide aqueous solutions (from
20g NaOH to 31g NaOH in 100g of solution) and for urea aqueous solution (higher than
29.4g of urea in 100g of solution) respectively. Their melting temperature increases with
the increase of NaOH and urea concentrations.
The 7.6NaOH/urea/water ternary system has a particular behaviour. Actually, the two NaOH
and urea eutectic mixtures are forming independently and are competing for water molecules.
Because of the strong polarity of sodium hydroxide, NaOH is attracting water more than urea.
In the NaOH/ZnO/water ternary system, some NaOH and water molecules react with ZnO to
dissolve it and to form zinc hydroxides. The NaOH molecules not involved in ZnO dissolution
are crystallising in eutectic mixture. Its melting temperature decreases with the increase of ZnO
content because the NaOH eutectic is crystallising in presence of liquid containing zinc
hydroxides and its surrounding molecules (water and probably NaOH).
We determined that during dissolution ZnO is trapping about 3NaOH and 25 water molecules.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-127-
III.3- STRUCTURE OF CELLULOSE SOLUTIONS IN NAOH/WATER,
NAOH/UREA/WATER AND NAOH/ZNO/WATER
III.3.1- Cellulose/NaOH/water ternary solutions
III.3.1.1. DSC results on Avicel/NaOH/water
The goal of this part is twofold: (i) to determine the concentration limit of cellulose that can be
dissolved in sodium hydroxide and (ii) to propose a mechanism of cellulose dissolution by
determining the amount of NaOH and H
2
O linked to cellulose. To do this, we will use
microcrystalline cellulose, pure and of low DP.
In part III.2.1-, we studied the NaOH/water solvent from DSC analyses. We described the
methodology used to determine the fraction of each compound present in the system from its
melting enthalpy and we plotted the phase diagram. We will base our research on the same
technique and approach.
Most of the studies were performed on cellulose/7.6NaOH/water systems. Cellulose content
was varied from 0 to 7.6g in 100g of solution. In order to check the influence of NaOH
concentration, cellulose/8NaOH/water solutions were also tested. In all cases studied the
condition of being inside the domain of the phase diagram [SOB1939] where cellulose can be
dissolved in NaOH/water was fulfilled.
An example of DSC melting thermograms for solutions of different cellulose concentrations is
given in Fig.III.3-1. Melting temperature and enthalpy of each peak for the curves shown and for
some other cellulose concentrations are presented in Tab.III.3-1. The analysis of the peak at
lower and higher temperatures is discussed below.
0
0,4
0,8
1,2
1,6
-40 -30 -20 -10 0
TC
Heat Flow (W/g)
7.6
0
0.5
4
5
2
Fig.III.3-1: DSC melting thermograms of Avicel cellulose/7.6NaOH/water solutions.
Cellulose content is indicated on the graph. 0 corresponds to a 7.6NaOH/water solution without cellulose.
Curves are shifted vertically for a better visibility.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-128-
eutectic peak ice peak Avicel
X g in a 100g solution Tm (onset), C Heut, J/g Tm (end), C Hice, J/g
0 -32.9 72 -5.1 195
0.5 -34.9 50 -4.8 205
1 -33.7 43 -4.1 200
2 -33.5 41 -4.3 205
3 -33.2 30 -3.9 210
4 -33.4 29 -3.7 209
5 -33.5 22 -3.9 217
7.6 No peak - -3.8 178
Tab.III.3-1: Melting temperatures and enthalpies of the peaks at lower and higher temperatures
for Avicel/7.6NaOH/water solutions.
eutectic peak ice peak Avicel
X g in a 100g solution Tm (onset), C Heut, J/g Tm (end), C Hice, J/g
0 -33.2 74 -5.9 187
1 -34.6 52 -5.9 180
3 -33.9 34 -5.2 175
5 -33.8 25 -4.7 178
Tab.III.3-2: Melting temperatures and enthalpies of the peaks at lower and higher temperatures
for Avicel/8NaOH/water solutions.
III.3.1.2. Peak at low temperature. Limit of cellulose dissolution
Whatever are the concentrations of Avicel cellulose and of the solvent, the melting temperature
of the peak at lower temperature is constant (Tab.III.3-1 and Tab.III.3-2), within the
experimental errors. It practically coincides with the melting temperature of the eutectic mixture
in pure aqueous sodium hydroxide solution of 7.6NaOH/water and 8NaOH/water (without
cellulose) but with a systematic shift of about 1C towards lower temperatures. This means two
things. First, the same eutectic mixture NaOH,5H
2
O + 4H
2
O is present in cellulose/sodium
hydroxide aqueous solutions in this region of temperatures and cellulose concentrations, in (7.6-
8)NaOH/water, owing to the fact that the temperature shift is very small. The presence of
cellulose is not perturbing the composition of solvent system. Second, because of the addition of
cellulose, the molecular environment of the NaOH eutectic mixture has changed, even slightly.
Consequently, crystallization and melting of the eutectic mixture are disrupted which induces a
slight shift in the melting temperature. A similar behaviour was observed after the addition of
urea in NaOH/water solution (see part III.2.2.2). Moreover, we will see in the next paragraph
that this change due to the presence of cellulose is also visible in the melting peak of pure water.
The results obtained mean that we are not here in the presence of a ternary phase diagram where
each of the components makes eutectic mixtures two by two. Cellulose does not form either
covalent bond or eutectic mixture with water and NaOH. Nevertheless, the presence of cellulose
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-129-
is drastically changing the amount of the NaOH/water eutectic mixture. The influence of
cellulose concentration on the eutectic peak can be seen from the variation of enthalpy values:
the enthalpy decreases down to zero with the increase of cellulose concentration (see Fig.III.3-1
curve in bold corresponding to m
cell
=7.6g does not show any eutectic peak at -33.4C). This
means that cellulose interacts with sodium hydroxide. The higher is the cellulose concentration,
the smaller is the amount of eutectic mixture that can crystallise and then melt at -33.4C. Since
NaOH is present only in the eutectic mixture, the decrease of its melting enthalpy allows the
calculation of the number of NaOH molecules linked to cellulose and thus not able to participate
to NaOH,5H
2
O crystal fraction of the eutectic mixture.
The eutectic melting enthalpies (Tab.III.3-1 and Tab.III.3-2) enable (i) to determine the limit of
cellulose dissolution and (ii) to calculate how many NaOH are linked to the cellulose, for all the
cellulose concentrations.
Limit of cellulose dissolution
Fig.III.3-2 represents the dependence of eutectic melting enthalpy on cellulose concentration, for
cellulose/7.6NaOH/water solutions.
The fact that H
eut
is reaching zero at a certain Avicel cellulose concentration means that all
sodium hydroxide molecules have been trapped by the cellulose chains. This corresponds to the
dissolution limit since there is no more NaOH molecules able to solvate any additional cellulose
chain that could be brought in the mixture. At this dissolution limit, we can calculate the
proportion between cellulose anhydroglucose unit (AGU) and NaOH molecules. In this case, in
100g of cellulose/NaOH/water solution, there are 7.6g of cellulose and 7.6g of NaOH when the
eutectic peak disappears. As the molar mass of NaOH is 40 while the molar mass of an
anhydroglucose unit is 162, it gives that four NaOH molecules are associated to each AGU.
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
0 2 4 6 8
m(cell), g
Heut, J/g
Fig.III.3-2: Eutectic melting enthalpy (J/g) versus cellulose concentration
for the Avicel cellulose/7.6NaOH/water system.
The dashed line is given to guide the eyes.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-130-
The other data obtained for Avicel/8NaOH/water solutions (Tab.III.3-2) as well as the ones
reported in the ref. [ROY2001], where Avicel cellulose was dissolved in 9%NaOH/water, give
very similar results. In order to compare the results for all these systems and to avoid the
influence of NaOH concentration, we plotted reduced melting enthalpy versus reduced cellulose
concentration (Fig.III.3-3). The reduced eutectic enthalpy corresponds to the enthalpy of the
eutectic peak at X% of cellulose, H
eut,X%cell
, divided by the one at m
cell
=0, H
eut,0cell
. The reduced
cellulose concentration corresponds to the cellulose weight divided by the one of NaOH.
0,0
0,2
0,4
0,6
0,8
1,0
1,2
0 0,5 1
m(cell)/m(NaOH)
reduced enthalpy
0,0
0,2
0,4
0,6
0,8
1,0
1,2
0 0,5 1
m(cell)/m(NaOH)
reduced enthalpy
Fig.III.3-3: Reduced melting enthalpy versus reduced cellulose concentration mcell/mNaOH
for Avicel/7.6NaOH/water ( ) and for Avicel/8NaOH/water ( ).
Inset: the results for Avicel in 9%NaOH/water from [ROY2001] were added ( )
The lines are given to guide the eyes
For the three systems studied, the decrease of the reduced melting enthalpy is reaching zero at
m
cell
/m
NaOH
=1.
This means that the maximum Avicel cellulose concentration for having a proper dissolution
is equal to the sodium hydroxide concentration in weight per cent. At this concentration, all
the NaOH molecules are associated with the cellulose. Consequently, the dissolution of
further added cellulose should not be possible. Above this concentration, cellulose can not
fully dissolve and could form cellulose aggregates.
Number of NaOH and H
2
O molecules linked to cellulose
Tab.III.3-1 and Tab.III.3-2 allow the calculation of the proportion between AGU and NaOH for
the other cellulose concentrations. The fraction of eutectic linked f
eut.linked
to cellulose is as follows:
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-131-
cell eut
cell X eut cell eut
linked eut
H
H H
f
% 0 ,
% , % 0 ,
Eq. 13
Thus the amount of eutectic (or NaOH) linked to cellulose, in moles, is given by
cell
AGU
NaOH
NaOH
linked eut NaOH
m
M
M
m
f AGU n /
,
= Eq. 14
The amount of NaOH molecules linked to one anhydroglucose unit as a function of reduced
cellulose concentration m
cell
/m
NaOH
for the system Avicel/7.6NaOH/water and for
Avicel/8NaOH/water is shown in Fig.III.3-4. At m
cell
/m
NaOH
> 0.4 the proportion between
AGU and NaOH molecules is constant and equal to the limit of cellulose dissolution which is
four NaOH per AGU. At low cellulose concentrations, m
cell
/m
NaOH
< 0.25, up to 20 NaOH
molecules seem to be linked to one anhydroglucose unit. The change of the slope in Fig.III.3-4 as
well as in Fig.III.3-3 may be caused by the transition of cellulose solution from the dilute to semi-
dilute state. In ref. [ROY2003], the overlap concentration for Avicel in 9%NaOH/water was
reported to be C
cell
1%. Fig.III.3-4 shows that the slope changes at C
cell
1.5-2% (here
C
cell
=m
cell
). It may be possible that due to the sterical hindrance caused by the transition from
dilute to the semi-dilute state, the number of NaOH molecules linked to cellulose strongly
decreases.
0
5
10
15
20
25
0 0,5 1
m(cell)/m(NaOH)
nNaOH / AGU
0
20
40
60
0 0.5 1
m
cell
/m
NaOH
n
NaOH
/ AGU
Fig.III.3-4: Number of NaOH molecules linked to one anhydroglucose unit (AGU), calculated from melting enthalpy data,
versus cellulose/NaOH weight ratio for cellulose/7.6NaOH/water ( ) and cellulose/8NaOH/water ( )
Inset: the same data (squares) and the ones from ref. [KUO2005] for NaOH concentrations of 4.5, 6.2 and 7.9%.
The dashed line is given to guide the eyes.
The same proportion between NaOH and anhydroglucose unit corresponding to the limit of
cellulose dissolution, four NaOH per AGU, can be obtained from the study of Avicel solubility
in NaOH aqueous solutions of different concentrations [KUO2005]. Using turbidimetry, authors
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-132-
measure the amount of undissolved cellulose as a function of cellulose and NaOH concentration.
We recalculated their data as the weight of NaOH per one gram of dissolved cellulose, converted
the obtained figures into mole ratios and plotted together with our data as a function of
m
cell
/m
NaOH
. The result is presented in the inset of Fig.III.3-4 : at higher cellulose concentrations,
the results of ref. [KUO2005] coincide with the ours and show that at least 4 NaOH molecules
are needed to dissolve one AGU. At low cellulose concentrations, m
cell
/m
NaOH
< 0.25, the
amount of NaOH linked to one anhydroglucose unit calculated from ref. [KUO2005] is twice
higher than obtained by us using DCS technique. In general, it is not clear how and why so many
NaOH molecules can be bound to one anhydroglucose unit. However, this is not an artefact
since the proportion (20-50)NaOH per one AGU at cellulose concentrations around 1-2% was
obtained independently by different methods.
III.3.1.3. Peak at high temperature
Fig.III.3-1, Tab.III.3-1 and Tab.III.3-2 show that the temperature of the melting peak at higher
temperatures is slightly increasing when increasing the cellulose concentration. Again, this change
is small, as in the case of the eutectic peak. This increase of the melting temperature of ice with
increasing cellulose concentration reflects the fact that the molecular environment of the
crystallizing water is changed when cellulose is trapping NaOH.
The proportion between water, NaOH and cellulose molecules can be calculated as follows. In
cellulose/NaOH/water solutions, H
2
O is present in three forms or compounds:
as a free water frozen to ice below the liquidus curve,
in the eutectic mixture that is not linked to cellulose and
in the mixture linked to cellulose through NaOH.
As far as the amount of free water is not changing with adding cellulose (see H
ice
in Tab.III.3-1
and Tab.III3.-2), it means that the number of water molecules linked to NaOH that are bound to
cellulose is the same as in the eutectic mixture. The number of water molecules linked to one
anhydroglucose unit is then straightforward to calculate: it is a product of n
NaOH
x 9; n
NaOH
calculated according to Eq.14 and nine being the amount of water molecules in the eutectic
mixture.
III.3.1.4. Influence of cellulose origin on the structure of cellulose/NaOH/water solutions
This part is a preliminary quantitative study on the influence of cellulose origin on the structure
of cellulose/NaOH/water solutions. The nature of cellulose pulp highly influences the cellulose
dissolution and the stability of solutions. Using DSC analysis with the methodology described
previously, it should be possible to determine the limit of cellulose dissolution and thus how
many NaOH and water molecules are linked to the cellulose chain for other cellulose than Avicel.
The cellulose samples used in this part are:
steam-exploded Borregaard cellulose with a DP of 407 (B407)
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-133-
irradiated Lenzing cellulose with a DP of 307 (L307), before the irradiation treatment it is
called Solucell 1175 (part II.1.1)
regenerated Lenzing cellulose II with a DP of 198 (L198
II
), this cellulose also comes from
the Solucell 1175.
Fig.III.3-5 represents the DSC melting thermograms of 5cellulose/7.6NaOH/water solutions,
cellulose being L198
II
, L307 and B407. The results were compared with the one of Avicel
cellulose (DP170), described above. The values of melting temperatures and enthalpies are listed
in Tab.III.3-3.
0
0,2
0,4
0,6
0,8
1
-40 -30 -20 -10 0
TC
Heat flow (W/g)
Avicel
B407
L307
L198II
Fig.III.3-5: DSC melting thermograms of 5cellulose/7.6NaOH/water solutions.
Cellulose origins are indicated on the graph.
Curves are shifted vertically for a better visibility.
eutectic peak ice peak
5cellulose/7.6NaOH/water
Tm (onset), C Heut, J/g Tm (end), C Hice, J/g
Avicel -33.5 22 -3.9 217
L198II -33.7 / -29.2 33 -4.7 187
L307 -34.1 24 -5.3 226
B407 -33.8 30 -5.6 189
Tab.III.3-3: Melting temperatures and enthalpies of the peaks at lower and higher temperatures
for cellulose of various origins in 5cellulose/7.6NaOH/water system.
First of all, we can note that a peak appears at -29.2C, especially for the L198
II
cellulose solution.
This peak corresponds to the melting of the stable NaOH,7H
2
O+2H
2
O eutectic mixture (see
part III.1.2.2 above). We assume that the melting enthalpies of the stable and the metastable
eutectic mixtures are relatively close which enables to determine the total melting enthalpy, H
eut
,
of eutectic mixtures, stable and/or metastable.
Each DSC melting thermogram reveals a peak at low temperature, -33C/-34C, corresponding
to the melting of the metastable NaOH,5H
2
O+4H
2
O eutectic mixture. The temperature is
approximately the same for each cellulose pulp. On the other hand, its enthalpy is changing from
one cellulose origin to another. According to the enthalpy values, it seems that cellulose pulps can
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-134-
be divided into two groups: Avicel/L307 and L198
II
/B407. At the same cellulose concentration,
the former is trapping more sodium hydroxide (lower enthalpy) than the latter. It clearly means
that L198
II
and B407 are not dissolved well.
Concerning the peak at higher temperature, we can see that the melting temperature of ice
decreases when the cellulose DP increases. Let us note that for pure 7.6NaOH/water solution,
without cellulose, the ice melting temperature is -5.1C. This decrease is again the sign that
cellulose of higher DP are not fully dissolving (for Avicel, the higher the cellulose concentration,
the lower the melting temperature of the ice).
Moreover, regarding the values of enthalpies, the two previous cellulose groups are appearing
again.
It would have been very interesting to perform the same analyses as previously for
Avicel/NaOH/water solutions on cellulose of different origins, treatments and DP. We could
determine:
If some cellulose is more or less easily accessible to fix NaOH and water.
If the amount of linked and free NaOH and water molecules is a significant parameter
influencing the dissolution, solution properties and gelation.
III.3.1.5. Conclusions
DSC experiments and careful analyses of experimental data allowed understanding the
thermodynamic behaviour and structure of cellulose/sodium hydroxide aqueous solutions at
temperatures below 0C, in the region of cellulose dissolution.
It was possible to determine the limit of cellulose dissolution in NaOH/water as being at least
four NaOH molecules per one anhydroglucose unit (corresponding to equal cellulose and NaOH
concentrations in weight). Water molecules forming the eutectic mixture in solution are still
around the NaOH linked to the cellulose. If the concentration of cellulose is higher than this
limit, it will not be dissolved. Because cellulose can be dissolved only in a narrow range of sodium
hydroxide concentrations, from 7 to 10%, this means that maximal amount of cellulose that can
be dissolved in NaOH/water solutions is 10%.
This result is compatible with what is found experimentally when trying to prepare
cellulose/NaOH/water solutions for processing. It is a strong limitation if one wishes to use
such a solvent in commercial applications since the amount of polymer is rather low. It has two
bad side effects. One is the cost of processing. The second is the fact that the properties of the
final products are strongly correlated with the amount of polymer material in the solution. In
addition, this dissolution limit in NaOH/water was determined for a low DP cellulose sample.
Increasing the molecular weight is decreasing the ability to dissolve cellulose. As shown in the
Chapter IV, a lot of insoluble parts are present in the solutions with higher DP pulps.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-135-
III.3.2- Cellulose/NaOH/urea/water solutions
III.3.2.1. DSC results on Avicel/NaOH/6urea/water
Let us first recall the main conclusions of the ternary NaOH/urea/water mixtures:
When adding urea to a NaOH/water mixture, both the melting of water and the melting
of the urea/water eutectic that is crystallizing are changed because of the presence of the
NaOH/water liquid mixture that will form the NaOH eutectic.
At a certain urea concentration (18g in 100g of solution), the melting peaks of urea
eutectic and ice are joining. There is no more free ice; there are only NaOH and urea
eutectic mixtures.
NaOH and urea are both forming their normal eutectic mixture meaning that the
components are not interacting.
In this part, we will investigate a set of Avicel cellulose solutions in 7.6NaOH/6urea/water,
cellulose concentrations being from 0 to 5g in 100g of solution. In other words, a 100g solution
contains X g of cellulose (X varying from 0 to 5), 7.6g of NaOH, 6g of urea and the rest being
water. An example of DSC melting thermograms is represented on Fig.III.3-6 and melting
temperatures and enthalpies are reported on Tab.III.3-4. The main features of these DSC melting
curves are similar to the ones reported in literature [CAI2005]
0
0,2
0,4
0,6
-40 -30 -20 -10 0
TC
Heat Flow (W/g)
5
3
Fig.III.3-6: DSC melting thermograms of Avicel cellulose/7.6NaOH/6urea/water solutions.
Cellulose content is indicated on the graph.
Curves are shifted vertically for a better visibility.
The addition of cellulose does not change the shape of the thermograms as compared to the case
without cellulose. The DSC melting curves present three peaks. They were described in part
III.2.2.2:
The peak at the lowest temperature, at about -35C, corresponds to the melting of the
NaOH/water eutectic mixture,
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-136-
The next one, at about -25C, corresponds to the melting of the urea/water eutectic mixture,
The peak at the highest temperature, at about -7C, corresponds to the melting of free ice.
As far as the melting peaks are not well separated, the PeakFit software (see details part II.3.1.6)
was used to determine the melting enthalpy of each compound crystallised and melted in the
system.
NaOH eutectic peak urea eutectic peak ice peak Avicel, X g in
100g of solution Tm (onset), C Heut, J/g Tm (peak), C Hurea, J/g Tm (end), C Hice, J/g
0 -35.9 72 -25.7 30 -8.6 160
1 -35.8 41 -24.8 34 -7.2 176
3 -35.7 35 -24.0 29 -6.5 175
5 -35.6 22 -23.7 26 -6.4 172
Tab.III.3-4: Melting temperatures and enthalpies of the peaks for different contents of cellulose in 7.6NaOH/6urea/water
In order to calculate the proportions between the interacting compounds, each peak will be
considered separately.
III.3.2.2. Peak of NaOH eutectic
Taking into account the experimental errors, we can say that whatever the concentration of
cellulose is, the melting temperature of the NaOH/water eutectic mixture is similar to the one
obtained for a pure 7.6NaOH/6urea/water (without cellulose). This means that the addition of
cellulose into an aqueous solution of sodium hydroxide and urea does not disrupt the formation
of the NaOH/water eutectic mixture, as it was in the case of cellulose/NaOH/water solutions.
As previously seen for cellulose/NaOH/water solutions without additives, there is a decrease of
the eutectic melting enthalpy with cellulose concentration: during the dissolution process,
cellulose is trapping some NaOH molecules that can not participate anymore to the
crystallisation of the eutectic mixture. Fig.III.3-7 represents reduced melting enthalpy versus
reduced cellulose concentration for cellulose/7.6NaOH/water (taken from Fig. III.3.2) and for
cellulose/7.6NaOH/6urea/water solutions.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-137-
0,0
0,2
0,4
0,6
0,8
1,0
1,2
0 0,5 1
m(cell)/m(NaOH)
reduced enthalpy
Fig.III.3-7: Reduced melting enthalpy of the NaOH eutectic versus reduced cellulose concentration
for Avicel / 7.6NaOH / water ( , Fig.III.3-2) and for Avicel / 7.6NaOH / 6urea / water ( )
The full line is given to guide the eyes.
Whatever the solvent system is, the decrease of the eutectic melting enthalpy is the same.
The addition of urea does not change the interactions between cellulose and NaOH. This
is a very important result.
III.3.2.3. Peak of urea eutectic
Whatever the concentration of cellulose is, the peak of the urea/water eutectic mixture is seen
(Fig.III.3-6). We can note that the melting temperature of urea eutectic is increasing with
cellulose content (Tab.III.3-4). An explanation of this increase of melting temperature is a change
in the molecular environment of urea and water due to the addition of cellulose.
The values of the melting enthalpy of the urea eutectic are scattered, but we can assume that
there is no influence of the cellulose content on the melting enthalpy of the urea eutectic peak.
The enthalpy of the urea eutectic does not depend on cellulose concentration. The
addition of cellulose does not change the urea-water interactions and cellulose does not
interact with urea.
III.3.2.4. Peak of free ice
We can note that the melting temperature of ice is increasing with cellulose content (Tab.III.3-4).
An explanation of this increase of melting temperature is a change in the molecular environment
of water due to the addition of cellulose.
Since the melting enthalpy of free ice is approximately constant for all cellulose concentrations,
we conclude that the amount of free ice remains the same with and without cellulose.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-138-
III.3.2.5. Conclusions
Three main facts are obtained from these series of experiments and their interpretations:
1. NaOH and urea do not interact when mixed together with water; their eutectic mixtures
are independent (part III.2.2.2).
2. Urea and cellulose do not interact when mixed with NaOH and water (urea-water
eutectic is not changed).
3. The interactions between NaOH hydrates and cellulose are not changed by the addition
of urea (the decrease of the eutectic peak of NaOH with cellulose content is the same
with or without urea)
This clearly challenges the use of urea as a promoter for cellulose dissolution and, as will be seen
in the next chapter, as a retardation agent for solution gelation. We will elaborate hypothesis on
the influence of urea in the Conclusion part of this chapter.
III.3.3- Cellulose/NaOH/ZnO/water solutions
As far as we did not have enough time to test all cellulose concentrations in 7.6NaOH/0.7ZnO
aqueous solutions, we only performed experiment on solution containing 5g of cellulose Avicel.
The DSC thermograms are represented on Fig.III.3-8 and melting temperatures and enthalpies
are reported in Tab.III.3-5.
0
0,2
0,4
0,6
-40 -30 -20 -10 0
TC
Heat Flow (W/g)
without ZnO
with 0.7 ZnO
Fig.III.3-8: DSC melting thermograms of 5Avicel /7.6NaOH/water and
of 5Avicel /7.6NaOH/0.7ZnO/water solutions.
Curves are shifted vertically for a better visibility
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-139-
NaOH eutectic peak ice peak
Tm (onset), C Heut, J/g Tm (end), C Hice, J/g
7.6NaOH/water -32.9 72 -5.1 195
5Avicel/7.6NaOH/water -33.5 22 -3.9 217
7.6NaOH/0.7ZnO/water - - -5.5 186
5Avicel/7.6NaOH/0.7ZnO/water - - -4.9 181
Tab.III.3-5: Melting temperatures and enthalpies of the melting peaks for 5Avicel/7.6NaOH/water
and for 5Avicel /7.6NaOH/0.7ZnO/water.
As far as the temperature of DSC apparatus does not decrease enough to obtain the melting peak
of the NaOH eutectic in the presence of ZnO (Fig.III.3-8), we cannot conclude either on the
amount of NaOH linked to cellulose or on the limit of cellulose dissolution when ZnO is present
in the solvent system.
Nevertheless, the DSC thermogram shows the melting peak of free ice.
As in the case of cellulose/NaOH/water solution, the melting temperature of free ice slightly
increases when cellulose is added. This was previously explained by some changes in the
molecular environment of the crystallizing water when cellulose is trapping NaOH.
Regarding the melting enthalpy of free ice, we can see that it does not change within the
experimental error. This means that the amount of free water remains the same with and without
cellulose and, thus, that cellulose traps NaOH surrounded by the water molecules forming the
eutectic mixture.
III.3.4- Conclusions on the structure of cellulose solutions in NaOH/water
with and without additives
In NaOH/water and in NaOH/urea/water, the addition of cellulose does not change the melting
temperatures of the eutectic mixtures and of free ice, or very slightly only showing some changes
in the molecular environment due to the presence of cellulose. Cellulose does not modify the
phase diagrams of solvent systems.
On the other hand, the enthalpy of the NaOH eutectic is decreasing proportionally to the
cellulose concentration and is reaching zero when the ratio m
cell
= m
NaOH
. This means that
cellulose can be dissolved in 7-9NaOH/water as well as in 7.6NaOH/6urea/water if at least four
NaOH are linked to each anhydroglucose unit. Consequently, in these two solvents the limit of
cellulose dissolution is reaching when m
cell
= m
NaOH
.
For all the cellulose contents from 0 to 7.6, the melting enthalpy of free ice remains constant.
The amount of free water does not change with the addition of cellulose and thus each
anhydroglucose is surrounded by at least 36 water molecules initially forming the NaOH eutectic.
We saw in the study of solvents that the addition of ZnO in NaOH/water decreases the melting
temperature of the NaOH eutectic. As we work in the limit of the DSC apparatus, the addition
of cellulose leads to the disappearance of this peak. Thus it is possible neither to determine the
limit of cellulose dissolution nor the amount of NaOH linked to each AGU.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-140-
For cellulose/NaOH/ZnO/water, only the melting peak of free ice appears and its enthalpy
remains constant, within the experimental errors, when cellulose is added. The amount of free
water stays the same whatever the cellulose content is.
III.4- INFLUENCE OF FREEZING ON THE THERMAL PROPERTIES OF THE
CELLULOSE/NAOH MIXTURES
In his PhD thesis, Roy [ROY_PhD] showed that after freezing of cellulose/NaOH/water
solution at -20C for 8 hours, a pure substance melting around 0C appeared after thawing.
Freezing seems to be an important step in the preparation of sponges from cellulose/NaOH
aqueous solutions, as it will be shown in details in Chapter V. That is why the transformations
occurring in the solution during freezing should be studied and understood.
The temperature of the new melting peak at 0C suggests that pure water appears in the system
during freezing. The enthalpy value of this peak varied from experiment to experiment and was
not reproducible. We decided to examine again this phenomenon, trying to find a way to obtain
reproducible results. We know that non-dissolved fibres or at least non dissolved parts of fibres
are present in cellulose/NaOH/water solutions and that these fibres precipitate relatively rapidly
after the solution preparation. This is varying cellulose concentration in the supernatant. In order
to always have the same cellulose solutions in the measuring cell, we homogenised the mixture
right before all the experiments and solution was taken and immediately put into the DSC cell.
5g B342 cellulose was dissolved in 7.6NaOH/water and in 7.6NaOH/0.7ZnO/water as
described in Chapter II, total solution weight being 100g. After homogenisation, about 20mg of
the solution were put into DSC caps. Three thermal treatments were performed:
The temperature decreased down to -28C, there was no isothermal step and the
temperature immediately increased up to 10C.
The temperature decreased down to -28C, a 2 hours isothermal step was performed
at -28C, and then the temperature increased up to 10C.
The temperature decreased down to -28C, a 20 hours isothermal step was performed
at -28C, and then the temperature increased up to 10C.
The results obtained after freezing and thawing were reproducible (Fig.III.4-1 and Fig.III.4-2).
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-141-
0
0,2
0,4
0,6
-30 -20 -10 0
TC
Heat Flow (W/g)
0H at -28C
20H at -28C
2H at -28C
Fig.III.4-1: Melting DSC thermograms for 5B342 cellulose/7.6NaOH/water solutions after freezing at -28C and
immediate thawing (0H) and after keeping solution at -28C for 2 hours (2H) and 20 hours (20H)
(each experiment was performed twice on different solutions)
0
0,2
0,4
0,6
-30 -20 -10 0
TC
Heat Flow (W/g)
0H at -28C
20H at -28C
2H at -28C
Fig.III.4-2: Melting DSC thermograms for 5B342 cellulose/7.6NaOH/0.7ZnO/water solutions after freezing at -28C and
immediate thawing (0H) and after keeping solution at -28C for 2 hours (2H) and 20 hours (20H)
(each experiment was performed twice on different solutions)
Time at -28C,
hours
Tm1, C
of free ice
H1, J/g
of free ice
Tm0,C
of water released
H0, J/g
of water released
0 -5.5 156 - -
2 -5.0 160 - -
2 -5.2 162 - -
20 -5.5 144 0.7 1.8
20 -5.4 147 0.2 2.3
Tab.III.4-1: Temperatures and enthalpies of melting peaks of free ice and of water released
for a 5B342 cellulose /7.6NaOH/water solution, after freezing and keeping for 0, 2 and 20 hours at -28C.
Chapter III Structure of aqueous NaOH and cellulose/NaOH solutions with and without additives. Limit of cellulose dissolution
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
-142-
Time at -28C,
hours
Tm1, C
of free ice
H1, J/g
of free ice
Tm0,C
of water released
H0, J/g
of water released
0 -5.5 155 - -
2 -5.5 156 0.6 Very low
2 -5.2 153 0.8 Very low
20 -5.6 147 -1.3 / 0.7 1.8
20 -5.4 145 0.4 / 1.0 1.9
Tab.III.4-2: Temperatures and enthalpies of melting peaks of free ice and of water released
for a 5B342 cellulose/7.6NaOH/0.7ZnO/water solution, after freezing and keeping 0, 2 and 20 hours at -28C.
During freezing and keeping the solution at -28C for several hours, a phase separation is
occurring.
A 5B342 cellulose/7.6NaOH aqueous solution left at -28C for 20 hours reveals a single and
sharp peak at 0C (Fig.III.4-1). We can say that pure water appeared. These results are in
agreement with the ones obtained by Roy [ROY_PhD].
We can note that this peak is not present after 2 hours at -28C.
A 5B342 cellulose/7.6NaOH/0.7%ZnO aqueous solution left at -28C for 20 hours reveals
two melting peaks, at -1.3C and 0.7C in the first experiment and at 0.4C and 1C in the
second experiment (Fig.III.4-2). The presence of ZnO does not prevent the phase separation
but it seems that two liquids are released separately: probably pure water, as in the case of
cellulose in pure NaOH/water, and a very dilute liquid containing NaOH and/or ZnO in
water.
Moreover, after only 2 hours at -28C, we can see that the phase separation is also occurring
since the melting peaks are present but the enthalpies are too low to be quantified. It seems
that the presence of ZnO in the solvent system makes easier the occurrence of phase
separation.
In the case of cellulose/7.6NaOH/water, we determined that a 20hours isothermal step at -28C
induces a release of pure water. Consequently, using the melting enthalpies of the released water
(Tab.III.4-1) and of pure crystallised water (H
ice pure
= 358J/g), the amount of released water per
one AGU can be calculated.
100
18
162
/
.
.
cell
released water
AGU released water
m
f
n n
=
where
pure ice
released water
released water
H
H
f
.
.
.
= s
A: a constant
E
a
: the activation energy (J/mol)
R: the constant of perfect gas = 8.32 J/mol/K
T: the absolute temperature (K)
The activation energy can be calculated from the slope E
a
/R of the lines ln versus 1/T.
Fig.IV.1-2 shows the results for pure water, for aqueous sodium hydroxide solutions, with or
without 0.7ZnO, and for cellulose solutions 1.7 B342 cellulose/7.6NaOH/water, 1.7 B342
cellulose/7.6NaOH/0.7ZnO/water and 2.8 B342 cellulose/7.6NaOH/0.7ZnO/water. Let us
note that it is not possible to determine E
a
for 2.8 B342 cellulose/7.6NaOH/water solution since
the flow is not Newtonian anymore. This second behaviour will be discussed in the forthcoming.
Nevertheless, if we compare 1.7 B342 cellulose/7.6NaOH/water (Fig.IV.1-2, full symbols) with
1.7B342 cellulose/7.6NaOH/0.7ZnO/water (Fig.IV.1-2, open symbols), the presence of 0.7ZnO
in the solvent does not change the viscosity-temperature dependence, within the experimental
error (Fig.IV.1-2, table).
-8
-7
-6
-5
-4
-3
-2
0,0031 0,0032 0,0033 0,0034 0,0035 0,0036 0,0037
1/T
l
n
water
NaOH
NaOH+ZnO
1.7 B342
2.8 B342
0.8 B500
Fig.IV.1-2: Viscosity versus inverse temperature for water, pure solvents (7.6NaOH/water and 7.6NaOH/0.7ZnO/water)
and for cellulose/7.6NaOH/water, cellulose/7.6NaOH/0.7ZnO/water.
Solid lines correspond to solutions in 7.6NaOH/water, dashed lines to solutions in 7.6NaOH/0.7ZnO/water.
Content and DP of cellulose are indicated on the graph
The values of the corresponding activation energy E
a
(kJ/mol) are given in the Tab.IV.1-1.
Chapter IV Flow and gelation of aqueous cellulose/NaOH solutions: Influence of additives
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
- 155 -
An increase of cellulose concentration as well as of DP of cellulose leads to an increase of the
activation energy E
a
. As the activation energy is expressing the difficulty of motions of polymer
chains and so is connected with the density of entanglements, the increase of the activation
energy with concentration and DP of cellulose was an expected result. This phenomenon
observed for steam exploded cellulose solutions is in contradiction with the results obtained for
Avicel cellulose solutions [ROY2003]. There, the authors showed that the activation energy was
independent on the cellulose concentration and concluded that cellulose/NaOH aqueous
solutions are not real solutions.
Comparing 1% DP950 cellulose in NMMO/water [GAV2005] with 0.8 B500 (DP500) cellulose
in 7.6NaOH/water shows a large difference with respectively 48kJ/mol and 22.6kJ/mol. This
latter value is close to the one of the solvent (19kJ/mol). It suggests either that NMMO/water is
a complexing solvent that is hampering strongly the motion of the cellulose chains or that the
interactions between the solvent and cellulose in the case of NaOH solutions are weak, leading to
a collapsed state, in a sense similar to what [ROY2003] found.
With the increase of cellulose concentration and, as we will see, temperature, the cellulose
solutions behave in a different way. The flow is non-Newtonian; the shear rate increase leads to a
more or less pronounced decrease of viscosity (Fig.IV.1-4) which is characteristic of a
pseudoplastic behaviour. The flow index n was calculated in the shear-thinning region as
follows:
n
A
= .
Where