BESE-132B3E
BESE-132B3E
BESE-132B3E
Guidance and
Indira Gandhi
Counselling
National Open University
School of Education
Block
3
CAREER DEVELOPMENT
UNIT 9
Nature of Work and Career Development 5
UNIT 10
Occupational Information 29
UNIT 11
Career Patterns 52
UNIT 12
Career Development of Girls in India 66
EXPERT COMMITTEE
Prof. Neerja Shukla (retd.) Dr. Swati Patra
NCERT, New Delhi SOSS, IGNOU
Prof. Jessy Abraham Dr. Eisha Kannadi
JMI, New Delhi SOE, IGNOU
Prof. M.C. Sharma (retd.) Dr. Gaurav Singh
SOE, IGNOU SOE, IGNOU
Prof. N.K. Dash Dr. Elizabeth Kuruvilla
SOE, IGNOU SOE, IGNOU
PROGRAMME COORDINATION
Prof. Saroj Pandey Dr. Gaurav Singh
SOE, IGNOU SOE, IGNOU
Material Production
Prof. Saroj Pandey Mr. S.S. Venkatachalam
Director A.R. (Publication)
School of Education School of Education
IGNOU, New Delhi IGNOU, New Delhi
October, 2017
© Indira Gandhi National Open University, 2017
ISBN-978-93-???????????
All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form, by mimeograph or any other
means, without permission in writing from the Indira Gandhi National Open University.
Further information on the Indira Gandhi National Open University courses may be obtained from the
University’s Office at Maidan Garhi, New Delhi-l10068.
Printed and published on behalf of the Indira Gandhi National Open University, New Delhi by Director,
School of Education, IGNOU, New Delhi.
Laser Typeset by Tessa Media & Computers, C-206, A.F.E.-II, Okhla, New Delhi.
Printed at:
BESE-132: Guidance and Counselling
Block Introduction
Career development is an important and life long process in an individual’s life.
It is influenced by a number of factors like family, personal values, interests,
aptitudes and society. There are four Units in this Block titled, Career
Development.
In Unit 9: Nature of Work and Career development, we explore our need for
work and then describe in detail the various aspects related to work. We focus on
the motivation to work and the way work affects our way of life. We have then
discussed the concept of career development. This is followed by discussion of
different theories of career development and their implications for career
counselling and the process of career development of students.
Traditionally career development has been referred with respect to men. Most of
the earlier theories on career development were based on studies conducted on
men. Career counselling in schools is mostly geared to meet the needs of boys.
Unit 12: Career Development of Girls in India brings to focus the significance
of career development of girls. The different roles played by women in society,
their work participation, their educational pursuit, and socio-cultural factors
affecting their academic achievement and occupational aspirations are some of
the points for discussion. Studies on career development of women have started
emerging in the 1980s. We have included discussion on career development of
women in this Unit. We have further discussed the role of teachers and parents
in promoting the career development of girls.
4
Nature of Work and Career
UNIT 9 NATURE OF WORK AND CAREER Development
DEVELOPMENT
Structure
9.1 Introduction
9.2 Objectives
9.3 Motivation to Work
9.3.1 Psychological Needs
9.3.2 Social Needs
9.3.3 Economic Needs
9.4 Work Affects Way of Life
9.5 Concept of Career Development
9.6 Super’s Theory of Career Development
9.7 Roe’s Theory of Personality Development and Career Choice
9.7.1 Description of the Occupational Groups
9.7.2 Levels of Each Group
9.7.3 Roe’s Proposition on the Origin of Needs and Interests
9.7.4 Modes of Child Rearing
9.8 Holland’s Theory of Vocational Personalities and Work Environment
9.8.1 Six Model Environment
9.8.2 Vocational Choice as an Integration between Major and Secondary Assumptions
9.9 Ginzberg’s Theory
9.9.1 The Major Periods of the Vocational Development Process
9.9.2 General Concept of the Theory
9.10 Social Learning Theory of Career Development
9.11 Social Cognitive Theory of Career Development
9.12 Let Us Sum Up
9.13 Unit-end Exercises
9.1 INTRODUCTION
In order to understand the nature of work we should not only look at the economic
returns it brings, but also the totality of the work situation. Nature of work also
needs to be understood in terms of its surroundings, both physical and social,
and the activity to be performed. These characteristics of the work affect different
individuals differently. People actually differ in terms of their needs which make
them see the work in different ways. The needs of the individuals are satisfied by
work which makes him/her happy and motivated. If these needs are not satisfied,
the persons are unhappy.
9.2 OBJECTIVES
After going through this unit, you should be able to:
• describe the different motives for which people work;
• indicate the ways in which attitudes and values of the people are influenced
by the job they take up;
• indicate the way in which work affects the life-style of the individuals;
• explain the term career development;
• discuss the significance of career development in the present day context;
• explain the career development process;
• describe and compare the different approaches to career development as
explained by different theorists;
• apply the understanding of career development to practical situations of
career counseling;
• appreciate the relationship that exists between one’s present status of career
development vis-à-vis different theories of career development; and
• critically examine the different career development theories.
However, different individuals are differentially affected by the work they are
doing. It depends on their own self-concept which will influence his/her
expectations from self, and others’ expectation from him/her.
Identity: Work gives an identity to the individual, especially in the present day
society, where people are known more in terms of work. The existence of the
individual, his/her life style, his/her environment, all are influenced by the work
he/she engages in.
Status of the individual: The work gives social status to the worker. The status
which a job offers varies from one occupation to another occupation. It may be
high in case of professions, managerial and such occupations. Semi-skilled and
unskilled jobs confer a lower social status on the worker. However, the satisfaction
of the individual from his/her job and the status depends on his/her own pattern
of needs acquired in his/her typical environment.
Check Your Progress
Notes: a) Write your answers in the space given below.
b) Compare your answers with those given at the end of the block.
1) Answer the following questions in brief.
i) Why meaning of work varies from person to person?
.......................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................
ii) What are the psychological needs satisfied by work?
.......................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................
iii) What happens if independence on the job is denied?
.......................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................
7
Career Development 9.3.3 Economic Needs
Present income: The satisfaction with the present income level is affected by
the level of the aspiration of the person and the parity between his/her income,
and that of others who are similar to him/her in education, income and experience.
Workers feel satisfied when they get income similar to that of fellow colleagues.
But if s/he feels that s/he is not being treated fairly and is given lesser income
than others similar to him/her in experience and competence s/he feels dissatisfied.
Job security: Workers are not simply satisfied with a job that provides satisfactory
income and helps them to maintain a social status at par with people similar to
them in education, age and experience. They would like to be ensured of a future
income too.
The jobs involving high accident rates or those offering seasonal employment
leave the employee insecure about future income. The jobs which offer pension
or other post-retirement benefits will be preferred by those whose financial
resources are limited to salaries. The retired persons may also likely to take up a
job which requires less physical effort and responsibility to earn income and be
able to retain the job.
The difference between the various levels is clear. The higher the person on
these occupational levels of hierarchy, higher will be the income, prestige and
the responsibility.
8
Nature of Work and Career
Check Your Progress Development
Notes: a) Write your answers in the space given below.
b) Compare your answers with those given at the end of the block.
2) Answer the following questions in brief.
i) Why are some people not satisfied by their income?
.......................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................
ii) How does the status of different occupations vary?
.......................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................
iii) What is the difference between the time structuring of professional
and other workers?
.......................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................
Social Climate
The social situation determines the people with whom one may come in contact
with. The limited number of people available from same type of occupation,
interest and hobbies tend to change the person in ways similar to that of the job.
Even after entering a career, it is not that a person does not change jobs or remain
in the same position. Within his/her area of specialization, they may keep acquiring
more education, or training even after entering a job.
Importance of career development lies in the fact that the process is somewhat
irreversible. Once a child has grown into adolescence his/her interests, abilities,
values, etc. have already been influenced in certain directions. Choices have
already been made which will direct the future career. Therefore these early or
timely decisions have to be made consciously and objectively. In order to help
children plan consciously and base their educational and vocational choices on
factual information, it is important that they have access to career related
information which will help them plan judiciously. It is not only career information
they need but also information related to the educational and personal
development, so that they get opportunity to develop and be able to choose from
a repertoire of choices.
Super had elaborated this process of career development and defined the process
further right up to decline stage. The stages of development defined by Super
(1953) are as follows:
– Growth stage (up to 14 years)
– Exploration (15-25 years)
• Tentative
• Transition
• Trial
– Establishment (25-45 years)
• Trial
• Advancement
– Maintenance (45-65 years)
– Decline (66 onwards)
10
Growth Stage Nature of Work and Career
Development
In Super’s theory of career development, the growth stage corresponds to
psychological life stage of childhood and pre-adolescence. The development of
abilities, interests and attitudes takes place at this time.
The exposure to different types of people, occupations and activities helps them
to acquire experiences and information which influence differentiation of his/
her abilities, interests etc. However his/her choices are fantasy based.
Exploration stage
This stage begins with the tentative stage of choices. Here the boys and girls
consider the feedback they receive from environment i.e., school, parents, teachers
and peers, etc. This feedback helps them to translate their own self-conception
into a choice later on. Super’s contribution to career development theory is
particularly related to the conception of career development process as
development and implementation of the self-concept. As the individual comes
in contact with the information about occupations; his/her own capacities, interests
and values come in sharper focus. His/her self-concept becomes more realistic
in terms of his/her own characteristics and resources available. In the transition
stage they try and test their general preference in a career and finalize it into a
specific choice. Having decided on a specific career in their trial stage, one takes
appropriate training and finds a position in the chosen field of work.
Establishment Stage
Depending on the reality of their self-concept – those with unrealistic self-concept
may flounder for long time before establishing in a career and advancing in it.
Thus the trial stage continues into the establishment period. The trial leads to
finally settling down in a career with commitment to stay and advance in it.
Maintenance Stage
This stage begins around the age of 45 years. By this time most of the individuals
have got a status and position as a worker. If the person’s self-concept is in line
with the job he/she holds, the person feels satisfied and happy, otherwise there is
frustration and dissatisfaction with one’s career. Next stage is the decline stage,
characterized by the deterioration in the energies of the individual. Here main
task is to adjust to this new situation of reduced work activities but work continues.
You will read about the stages of career development in detail in the next Unit.
3) Organization: These are the managerial and white collar jobs in business,
industry and government. The occupation is concerned primarily with the
organization and efficient functioning of commercial enterprises and of Govt.
activities. The quality of person to person interaction is very formal
(Industrialists, Bankers, Financial Executives, Cashiers).
12
8) Arts and Entertainment: These occupations include those concerned with Nature of Work and Career
Development
the use of special skills in the creative arts and in entertainment. The focus
in them is on a relationship between one person (or an organized group)
and a more general public. The interpersonal relation is important but neither
so direct nor of the same nature as that in group 1&2 (Adapted from Roe
and Klos 1972). Creative artists, performers of skill, athletes, designers,
conductor of music, interior decorators etc., are placed in this group.
Roe further divided each group into six levels. The levels are based on degree of
responsibility, capacity and skill. Though these criteria are not exactly correlated
but whenever there are marked differences, level of responsibility is decisive.
Responsibility includes not only the number and difficulty of the decisions to be
made but also how many different kinds of problems must be coped with. So the
dimension is essentially continuous with a variety of responsibilities.
• The intensity of these needs and of their satisfaction, and their organization,
are the major determinants of the degree of expressed motivation.
a) Emotional concentration on the child: This could take the form of being
either over-protective or over-demanding. The over-protective parent will
fully and quickly satisfy the child’s lower needs but may hesitate in gratifying
the higher order needs of love and esteem, at the same time will reward
behavior that is socially desirable. This type of interaction will make the
child to over emphasize the immediate or quick gratification of physiological
demands. For the satisfaction of higher order needs he/she exhibits a
dependency on others and a willingness to conform to socially desirable
behavior. These higher order needs could be a need to be loved, esteem, or
a sense of belongingness. The over demanding parents have many similarities
to over-protective parents. The over-protective parents will gratify the
physical needs promptly and adequately. The over-demanding parents lay
down conditions of conformity to their values, and social achievement in
return for the love offered to the child. The child’s needs of self-actualization
are indulged in if they are in accordance with parental aspirations for the
child.
Roe then hypothesized that people have two basic orientations either toward
or not toward persons. These orientations were dependent upon childhood
experiences, and they in turn affected the vocational choice.
Check Your Progress
Notes: a) Write your answers in the space given below.
b) Compare your answers with those given at the end of the block.
3) Mention the various stages of career development given by Super.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
15
Career Development
4) Briefly describe Roe’s Classification of Occupational Groups.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
This theory is based on the assumption that, since vocational interest is one of
the aspects of personality, the description of an individual’s vocational interest
is also a description of an individual’s personality. Here personality traits are
identified by preferences for school subjects, co-curricular activities, hobbies
and work, and vocational interests can be viewed as an expression of personality.
Nature
This theory is structural – interactive in nature. It means that it provides explicit
links among various personality characteristics and corresponding job titles.
According to Holland, the description of different structural-interactive
approaches includes:
• The choice of an occupation is an expression of personality and not a random
event, although chance plays a role.
• The members of an occupational group have common personalities and
similar histories of personal development.
• Because people in an occupational group have similar personalities, they
respond to any situations and problems in similar ways.\
• Occupational achievement, stability and satisfaction depend on congruence
between one’s personality and job environment.
Its focal point is personality and its typology. He contends that each individual,
to some extent, resembles one of six basic personality types. Just as there are six
types of personalities, there are six types of environments, which, like
personalities, can be described according to certain characteristics. Environments
are characterized by the people who occupy them. For example, the personality
type of persons in a theatre differs from persons working with computers.
16
Similarly teachers working at primary level differ from their counterparts working Nature of Work and Career
Development
at colleges/universities.
Assumptions
This theory is based on four assumptions. They are:
• “In general, most persons can be categorized as one of six types: realistic,
investigative, artistic, social, enterprising or conventional.”
• “There are six kinds of environments: realistic, investigative, artistic, social,
enterprising or conventional.” .
• “People search for environments that will let them exercise their skills and
abilities, express their attitudes and values, and take on agreeable problems
and roles.” This assumption is well expressed in the saying “Birds of a
feather flock together.”
• “Behavior is determined by an interaction between personality and
environment.”
People search for environments that will let them exercise their skills and abilities,
express their attitudes and values and take on agreeable problems and roles.
Realistic types seek realistic environments. Social types seek social environments
and so on. To a lesser degree, environment also searches for people through
friendship and recruiting practices. The person’s search for environment is carried
on in many ways, at different levels of consciousness, and over a long period of
time.
The Tentative Period: This occurs between the ages of approximately 11 to 18.
It is divided into various stages which differ in their vocational developmental
tasks:
– The Interest Stage: This stage comes around age 11-12, when the child is
beginning to recognize activities s/he likes or dislikes. Again the choices
are made primarily because of the intrinsic pleasure of engaging in them.
These choices may also reflect identification with the father or mother, though
still in an ambivalent stage. This facilitation in choice may be related to the
physical and emotional changes in adolescence
– The Capacity Stage: This stage occurs usually between the ages 12 to 14.
It follows the interest stage and the child exhibits more of reality orientation
by introducing the idea of ability into vocational consideration. For example,
if earlier the child expressed the desire to become an architect purely because
he enjoys being in well made buildings, now he would evaluate whether he
has the capacity to pass the entrance test for architectural course, can put in
the required effort etc. In other words, children begin to assess their ability
to perform well in the areas of interest rather than parent identification as an
influence on vocational choice, and a corresponding increase in the influence
of other, more distant models.
– The Value Stage: This stage occurs during the 15th and 16th years. It is
marked by a distinctive change in the children’s approach to vocational
choice. This is when a child realizes the potential of a vocation to satisfy
more than the need for status, earning money and owning material
possessions. It becomes evident to him/her that he/she would follow different
life styles if he/she becomes a pilot or a sales executive.
– The Transition Stage: This stage marks the end of the tentative period.
Occurring at about age 17, this stage is marked by more maturity and
calmness as compared to the previous stages. At this point the person cannot
back away from the necessity of making a concrete and realistic decision
about vocational future, and also responsible for the consequences of the
decisions. This stage is also crucial for the heightened awareness of the
day-to-day matters. The person understands more about the financial rewards
that the work offers, kind of preparation necessary for various careers is
studied and the awareness of the different life circumstances of careers is
sharpened.
– The Realistic Period: The realistic period takes place from age 18 to varying
ages. This period is more varying in its timing than the others, due to different
training periods that different careers require. While biological maturity
exercises a strong influence on the development of the child during the
tentative period, it has no bearing on the progress during the realistic period.
This is possible as the rate of biological change slows markedly by age 18
or 19. The realistic period is further divided into three stages:
– The Crystallization Stage: During this stage the student is finally in the
process of becoming committed to one specific choice. Even in case of
crystallization it is possible that a student may have a change of mind later
on, due to various reasons.
– The Specification Stage: This is the final stage of the realistic period. It is
the final point of career development, and for some this stage never truly
arrives. The person here makes the final commitment by seeking a job in
the specific vocation or going in for further specialization in the chosen
vocational field.
The other sphere is with regard to the timing of the crystallization stage. There
may be a wide range relating to the surfacing of crystallization. In some it may
surface towards the end of the tentative period, and in some it may materialize
only in the mid or late twenties.
22
Ginzberg also mentions that there may be deviant patterns in the development Nature of Work and Career
Development
which differ from the normal process. Some of the probable reasons could be
severe emotional disorders, limited exposure of the child to different activities,
unusual personal and financial circumstances etc.
Another significant concept of the theory is the child’s ability to identify with
suitable models at appropriate times during the career development process. This
identification with adults at the various stages of vocational development gives
a direction to students and help by making it easier to follow realistic mode.
Another important feature of the theory is that two basic personality types exist
with respect to work; the work oriented type and the pleasure oriented type. This
does not imply that people have either this or that kind of personality, but that
one mode is more characteristic of an individual’s approach to life. The work
oriented individual can be identified by the ability to delay gratification, nothing
or very little can distract him/her in the pursuit of his/her career goals. Whereas
the pleasure oriented person is unlikely to postpone gratification for work and is
susceptible to distraction by other alternatives that may seem reasonably attractive
e.g., a vocational course or another opportunity away from his main line of work.
In a combination mode of the two principles individual can be either active or
passive problem solvers. The active people tackle the problems, making efforts
to solve them. On the other hand, passive people are reactive; things happen to
them, they react to them, rarely emitting problem solving responses.
Secondly, the theoretical framework can also be used by the teacher to anticipate
problems that might be encountered by the students at predicted stages of
development. This would help the teacher to develop preventive procedures to
encounter the problems. For example, in the interest stage the teacher could
encourage the parents and the child to devote time to various activities, give the
child adequate exposure before s/he can narrow down her/his interests to two or
three. Similarly, in the capacity stage he can caution the parents and students
against reading more than required in a test or a sports performance etc.,
emphasizing that ability has to be measured with that of others in the same field.
23
Career Development
Check Your Progress
Notes: a) Write your answers in the space given below.
b) Compare your answers with those given at the end of the block.
8) List the four variables which bear a significant influence in the process
of vocational choice.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
9) What is the essential difference between the crystallization stage and
the specification stage?
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
10) Explain in one line the work oriented person and pleasure oriented person
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
3) Learning experiences
Instrumental, associative and vicarious learning experiences and the
consequences of the actions taken influence the career choices of individuals.
Thus, the cognitive framework provided in the theory has focused on:
The two theories differ in some aspects. While Krumboltz and associates focus
on choice behavior, Lent and associates are concerned with the interlocking
process of interest development, choice, and performance. In social cognitive
theory, self-efficacy mechanism has a crucial role in career choice and
development, where as in Krumboltz theory the role of self-efficacy is relatively
minor. The two models also differ in their role of goal setting in career
development process. In Lent’s model, goals play a prominent role, while
Krumboltz does not give importance to goals in career decision making ( Lent,
Brown & Hackett, 1994, pp85-87).
Roe’s theory attends to all important aspects of vocational selection. The factors
in the early environment that dominate the development of needs are underlined.
Individual motivation is seen as largely the result of the strength of needs, which
is the outcome of the degree of deprivation in combination with his genetic
structure. Ultimately the level of responsibility and complexity that an individual
achieves in his vocation is the product of his genetic inheritance, which helps in
discerning differences in intelligence and in the ways people attempt to manipulate
various aspects of their environment.
Ginzberg and his associates have proposed a theory which is closely related with
the broader theoretical structure of developmental psychology. They have
developed the idea of career development which depicts the vocational choice
process as a specific behavior. The theory gives an overall view of the
development, particularly of the adolescence with special emphasis on vocational
selection, in the early or late twenties. The suitability of the final choice
corresponds to the adequacy with which the various developmental tasks are
accomplished by the students along the way. Lastly, we discussed the social
learning theory of career development and social cognitive theory of career
development. We have discussed the similarities and differences of these two
theories.
28
Nature of Work and Career
UNIT 10 OCCUPATIONAL INFORMATION Development
Structure
10.1 Introduction
10.2 Objectives
10.3 Collecting Occupational Information
10.4 Classification and Filing
10.4.1 Classifying Occupational Information
10.4.2 Characteristics of a Good Filing System
10.4.3 International Standard Classification of Occupations (ISCO-08)
10.4.4 National Classification of Occupations – 2015 (NCO-2015)
10.4.5 Industrial Classification
10.4.6 Guidance Code Number
10.5 Updating Occupational Information
10.6 Dissemination of Occupational Information
10.6.1 Tools
10.6.2 Methods
10.6.3 Activities
10.6.4 Emerging Trends
10.7 Evaluation of Occupational Information Material
10.8 Mobilising Resources for Setting Up Occupational Information Service
Programme
10.9 Let Us Sum Up
10.10 Unit-end Exercises
10.1 INTRODUCTION
You have been already familiar with the term Occupational Information as one
of the guidance services (Unit 6: Guidance Programme).
10.2 OBJECTIVES
After going through this unit, you should be able to:
• explain the term Occupational Information;
• describe the need for collecting, classifying, updating and disseminating
Occupational Information;
29
Career Development • list different sources of occupational information and different activities
for dissemination of Occupational Information;
• describe different components of Occupational Information;
• compile, organize, revise and disseminate Occupational Information; and
• review Career Literature.
Occupational Information does not include the study of abilities, aptitudes and
other characteristics of individuals, workers, job seekers or students. Occupational
information service serves the following purposes:
a) To develop a broad and realistic view of life’s opportunities and problems
at all levels of training.
b) To create an awareness of the need for accurate and valid occupational
educational and personal-social information.
c) To provide an understanding of the wide scope of educational, occupational
and social activities in terms of broad categories of related activities.
d) To assist in the mastery of techniques of obtaining and interpreting
information for progressive self-direction.
e) To promote attitudes and habits which assist in making career choices and
adjustment.
f) To provide assistance in narrowing choices progressively to specific activities
which are appropriate to attitudes, abilities and interests manifested.
Sources
Kinds of occupational information needed for career planning may be classified
as quantitative and qualitative. Quantitative information implies occupational
distribution trends and employment opportunities. Qualitative information implies
nature of work performed, qualifications required, conditions of work and the
returns to the worker.
Sources are basically of two types. They are primary sources and secondary
sources that regulate employment. Primary sources of occupational information
may include employer of an organization, employee in an organization,
government organizations, agencies or official bodies.
30
Some of them are listed below: Occupational Information
Secondary sources are thus called because they collect information published by
the original sources. One advantage of secondary source is that information
regarding different occupations and organization is available at one place itself.
However, the veracity of the information needs to be verified by the guidance
personnel.
Types
a) Career Fiction: An account portrayed through the experiences of one or
more fictional characters of an occupation which may encompass duties,
qualifications, preparations, conditions, nature of work and advancement.
b) Biography: An account of the life of a man or woman successful in a given
field of endeavour portraying the problems the subject faced in preparing
for and advancing in his or her career.
c) Occupational Monograph: It offers extensive coverage of all phases of an
occupation including details, comprehensive analysis of related occupations.
d) Occupational Brief: It covers the various types of specializations in an
occupational field in general terms. It is not as extensive as monograph but
yet describes all job opportunities.
e) Occupational Abstract: It is a concise summary of a job in an occupational
area citing the duties and nature of employment in general terms. It may be
in narrative or outline form.
f) Occupational Guide: It presents general information about various phases
of an occupation but doesn’t describe any specific job.
g) Job Series: It offers broad coverage of an entire occupational area giving
brief accounts of all job opportunities in the field. It may be in book, manual
or article form.
h) Business and Industrial Descriptive Literature: It gives an account of
specific industry of business and the major occupations are represented in
it.
31
Career Development i) Occupational or Industrial Description: It describes the principal
opportunities of an occupation in an industry or occupations in several
industries.
j) Recruitment Literature: It is in the form of recruitment procedures, nature
of work, financial benefits helpful to students and youth who seek
employment.
k) Poster or Chart: These are pictorial and schematic portrayal of occupational
information in the direction of catching the attention of target groups and
sustaining the same.
l) Article or Reprint: An account of an occupational phase of an occupation
or person performing the occupation.
m) Community Survey, Economic Report and Job Analysis: It is an account
of accurate, highly statistical, comprehensive report made as a result of
local, national or industrial studies.
n) Audio-Visual Material: These are in the form of motion pictures, still
pictures, video films, audio-tapes, audio skits, video skits, etc.
Methods
You may employ the following methods to collect occupational information.
1) You may call on both primary and secondary sources personally to the
possible extent or depute someone who can do the job.
2) You may address letters to both primary and secondary sources requesting
them to procure you occupational information.
3) You may contact both primary and secondary sources on telephone and
collect required information.
4) You may cull out occupational information from newspapers, periodicals,
magazines, journals, websites etc.
5) Combination of two or three strategies indicated above may be employed
for deriving better results.
Check Your Progress
Notes: a) Write your answers in the space given below.
b) Compare your answers with those given at the end of the block.
1) State whether the following statements are true or false.
i) Occupational Information includes the study of abilities, aptitudes
and other characteristics of individual workers, job seekers or
students. (T/F)
ii) Occupational Information includes pertinent and usable facts about
occupational trends and supply of and demand for labour. (T/F)
iii) Information relating to employment opportunities forms part of
quantitative type of occupational information. (T/F)
iv) Occupational Information is immensely useful in counseling
process. (T/F)
32
Occupational Information
2) Match the following under ‘A’ with that of items under ‘B’.
A B
i) Occupational Monograph a) Covers various specialization in
an occupation
ii) Occupational Brief b) General information about
various phases of an occupation.
iii) Occupational Abstract c) A phase of an occupation.
iv) Occupational Guide d) A concise summary of a job.
v) Article or Reprint e) Extensive coverage of all phases
of an occupation.
Conceptual framework
ISCO – 08 is designed on the basis of two main concepts: the concept of job, and
the concept of skill. ISCO -08 has defined these terms as follows.
A job is defined as “a set of tasks and duties performed, or meant to be performed,
by one person, including for an employer or in self employment”.
Occupation is defined as a “set of jobs whose main tasks and duties are
characterized by a high degree of similarity”.
Skill is defined as the ability to carry out the tasks and duties of a given job.
ISCO-08, has used two dimensions of skill to arrange occupations into groups.
These are skill level and skill specialization.
Skill level is defined as function of the complexity and range of tasks and duties
to be performed in an occupation. Only four broad skill levels are defined in
ISCO-08.
34
Skill specialization is considered in terms of four concepts: Occupational Information
Skill level 1
Occupations classified at Skill Level 1 include office cleaners, freight handlers,
garden labourers and kitchen assistants.
Skill level 2
Occupations classified at Skill Level 2 include butchers, bus drivers, secretaries,
accounts clerks, sewing machinists, dressmakers, shop sales assistants, police
officers, hairdressers, building electricians and motor vehicle mechanics.
Skill level 3
Occupations classified at Skill Level 3 include shop managers, medical laboratory
technicians, legal secretaries, commercial sales representatives, diagnostic medical
radiographers, computer support technicians, and broadcasting and recording
technicians.
Skill level 4
Occupations classified at Skill Level 4 include sales and marketing managers,
civil engineers, secondary school teachers, medical practitioners, musicians,
operating theatre nurses and computer systems analysts.
Classification Structure
ISCO-08 has arranged occupations into one of 436 unit groups. Each unit group
is made up of several ‘occupations’ which have similarity in skill level and skill
specialization. Unit groups are arranged into minor groups, minor groups into
sub-major groups, and sub-major groups into major groups based on skill level
and skill specialization.
36
Code Scheme Occupational Information
ISCO-08 provides a code number, a title and brief description for each group
classified at the four skill levels. The code number for each group is denoted as
follows:
a) Major group - One digit
b) Sub- major group - two digit (comprising the major group code plus
one digit)
c) Minor group - three digit (comprising the higher level code plus
one digit)
d) Unit group - four digit (comprising the higher level code plus
one digit)
Let us take major group 2: professionals as an example from table: 3 to illustrate
the code scheme. This major group is divided into six sub-major groups, twenty
seven minor groups and 92 unit groups each with a title and description as
mentioned earlier.
The following are the six sub-major groups in major group 2 with their code
number.
21. Science and Engineering Professionals
22. Health Professionals
23. Teaching Professionals
24. Business and Administration Professionals
25. Information and Communication Technology Professionals
26. Legal, Social and Cultural Professionals
You may have noticed that in the sub-major group, ‘Teaching Professionals’ is
given the code number 23 (2 digit) in which 2 indicates the major group and 3
indicates the serial order in the sub-major group.
The sub-major group is further divided into minor groups (3 digit) and unit groups
(4 digit) as given below.
23 Teaching professionals
231 University and Higher Education Teachers
2310 University and Higher Education Teachers
232 Vocational Education Teachers
2320 Vocational Education Teachers
233 Secondary Education Teachers
2330 Secondary Education Teachers
234 Primary School and Early Childhood Teachers
2341 Primary School Teachers
2342 Early Childhood Educators
235 Other Teaching Professionals
37
Career Development 2351 Education Methods Specialists
2352 Special Needs Teachers
2353 Other Language Teachers
2354 Other Music Teachers
2355 Other Arts Teachers
2356 Information Technology Trainers
2357 Teaching professionals Not Elsewhere Classified
This is a comprehensive classification of the sub-major group 23: Teaching
Professionals. In this classification you have seen that the sub-major group 23:
Teaching Professionals is divided into five minor groups and each minor group
is further divided into one or more unit groups. As you can see, there are twelve
occupations listed at the four digit level unit groups. Now let us see the description
of the tasks of one of the occupations at the unit group level.
The NCO 2015 has classified occupations into nine divisions in tune with skill
levels as defined in Table 10.4.
You may have noticed that skill level is not defined for Division 1 comprising of
Legislators, Senior Officials, and Managers.
39
Career Development Coding Structure
Based on the ISCO-08 and the factors impacting skill and labour environment in
India, the NCO 2015 coding framework was created.
• The first digit of NCO-2015 represents the Division (Major Group in ISCO)
• The first two digits of NCO-2015 represent the Sub-Division (Sub-Major
Group in ISCO)
• The first three digits of NCO-2015 represent the Group (Minor Group in
ISCO)
• The first four digits of NCO-2015 represent the Family (Unit Group in
ISCO)
• A decimal is introduced after the first four digits in order to create a
distinction between the Families and individual Occupations.
• The first two digits after the decimal of NCO-2015 represent the different
occupations that can be combined under the given Family.
• The last two digits after the decimal of NCO-2015 represent the availability
of a QP NOS for the job role (QP means Qualification Pack or sector specific
competency framework. NOS means National Occupational Standards)
• The value of the last two digits would depend on two scenarios:
i) If QP NOS is available, then the value of the last 2 digits after the
decimal will be between 1-99 (arranged sequentially).
ii) If QP NOS is unavailable, then the value of the last two digits after
decimal will remain 00. Coding structure is illustrated in Table – 7
below.
40
Table 10.7: Coding Structure Occupational Information
Here, the first digit ‘2’ in the code stands for Division (Professionals), ‘23’ stands
for sub-division (Teaching professionals), ‘233’ stands for Group (Secondary
Education Teachers), and ‘2330’ denotes Family. Therefore, the occupation code
for the job title: Senior Secondary and Secondary School Teacher, Arts is
‘2330.0100’ (8 digits). The first two digits after the decimal in the occupation
code represent the different occupations under the same Family. The last two
digits (00) after the decimal in the occupation code indicate that QP NOS is not
available for the given occupation title (senior secondary and secondary school
teacher, Arts).
Occupation codes for other job titles under the same family (2330) are given
below:
2330.0200 Senior Secondary and Secondary School Teacher, Science
2330.0300 Senior Secondary and Secondary School Teacher, Commerce
2330.0400 Language Teacher, Senior Secondary and Secondary School
2330.9900 Senior Secondary and Secondary School Teachers, Other
Source: NCO-2015, Vol. 1, PP. 15-65 GOI, www. ncs.gov.in
41
Career Development Table 10.8: ISIC Rev. 4 Sections, Divisions, Descriptions
Section Division Description
A 01-03 Agriculture, forestry and fishing
B 05-09 Mining and quarrying
C 10-33 Manufacturing
D 35 Electricity, gas, steam and air conditioning
supply
E 36-39 Water supply; sewerage, waste management and
remediation activities
F 41-43 Construction
G 45-47 Wholesale and retail trade; repair of motor
vehicles and motorcycles
H 49-53 Transportation and storage
I 55-56 Accommodation and food service activities
J 58-63 Information and communication
K 64-66 Financial and insurance activities
L 68 Real estate activities
M 69-75 Professional, scientific and technical activities
N 77-82 Administrative and support service activities
O 84 Public administration and defence; compulsory
social security
P 85 Education
Q 86-88 Human health and social work activities
R 90-93 Arts, entertainment and recreation
S 94-96 Other service activities
T 97-98 Activities of households as employers;
undifferentiated goods- and services-producing
activities of households for own use
U 99 Activities of extraterritorial organizations and
bodies
As you can see from table -8 , Education comes under ‘Division 85’ in ‘Section
P’. Let us examine the detailed structure and coding scheme for the ‘Description’
Education.
The ‘Group’ code is a three digits number. For example, the ‘Group’ code for
secondary education is 852, the first two digits represent the ‘Division’ 85
Education, the third digit represents the hierarchical order in the ‘Group’. There
are two classes under Group 852. General secondary education is represented by
the numerical code 8521 and Technical and vocational secondary education is
represented by the numerical code 8522. In both cases the fourth digit represents
the class in the hierarchical order.
Uses
Having gone through the different types of Occupational Classifications, let us
examine the uses of such classifications:
– ISCO and ISIC serve as model for countries developing or revising their
national classifications of occupations.
– ISCO and ISIC provide an understanding of occupation/job descriptions
and economic activities prevalent at an international level.
– NCO and NIC provide a national picture of occupational classifications
and economic activities in alignment with the ISCO and ISIC.
– Employment exchanges use these data for registering employment seekers
– NCO and NIC provide data for international comparison. These data can
be used for studying the socio-economic development taking place in the
country.
– NCO and NIC are used by the government agencies, industry associations
and researchers for administrative, analytical and research purposes.
– Counselors can use the classification of occupations for career counseling.
– Counselors can use the occupation descriptions to make the students aware
of the tasks and duties involved in an occupation.
– Counselors can make students aware of the skill level needed for various
occupations.
In the guidance code number, first interest area code is written, followed by the
educational level code. These codes are used in the case of educated freshers and
these are not used in the case of occupationally set or semi skilled categories of
students or unemployed youth.
The following educational levels are assigned code numbers indicated against
them.
Post-Graduate – 1
Graduate – 2
PUC/+2 – 3
Matric – 4
Middle – 5
Others – 6
44
The following codes are allotted to interest areas. Occupational Information
With the world wide web/internet available today, you can gather information
from any part of the country or the world at the click of a mouse. Another important
highlight that would emerge out of this is the need for professionals to develop
software in this regard . You need to develop yourself professionally in taking up
this challenge.
Activities
1) Collect 15 wanted advertisements from newspapers and attempt to
prepare a note in the context of updating available information.
2) Collect, compile and update any kind of data related to occupational
information from the world wide web.
10.6.1 Tools
Occupational information is collected and updated using the following as tools:
a) Career Fiction
b) Biography
c) Occupational monographs
d) Occupational Brief
e) Occupational Abstract
f) Occupational Guide
g) Job Series
h) Business and Industrial Descriptive Literature
i) Occupational and Industrial Descriptive Literature
j) Recruitment Literature
k) Posters
46
l) Charts Occupational Information
m) Article of Reprint
n) Community Surveys, Economic Report or Job Analysis
o) Audio Visual Aids
p) Computer
10.6.2 Methods
You may employ any of the following methods to disseminate occupational
information.
1) Delivering class talk, career talk, address by Non-Governmental
Organizations, Parent Teacher Associations, Teachers Associations and
similar gatherings.
2) Display of career literature of different kinds for the benefit of students,
unemployed youth, non-governmental organizations, employer’s
associations, parents and community members at large.
3) Screening career films on need based topics for the benefit of different
target groups.
4) Arranging discussions so as to interact with different target groups in the
context of placing world of work before them.
5) Conducting Mock Interviews in order to prepare candidates either for
admission to specialized courses or for entry into different occupations.
10.6.3 Activities
You may conduct the following activities in order to disseminate occupational
information which you have studied in the unit titled: Group Guidance.
i) Class talk:A talk-addressed to students in school/colleges/universities
intending to apprise them about ‘Planning’.
ii) Career talk: A talk intended to place world of work before a group of
students in schools/colleges/universities or unemployed youth in
employment exchanges. These talks should be need-based and target
oriented.
iii) Career Conference: This is generally intended for students pursuing their
studies in classes like X, XII, Final Year Graduation or Final Year Post
Graduation.
iv) Career Exhibition: This involves display of career literature for the benefit
of students pursuing their studies in High School/Colleges/University.
v) Career Film Show: You may screen films relating to different career so as
to place before a group of students/unemployed youth realities prevailing
in a particular occupation or group of occupations.
There are a good number of video films on variety of topics in the context
of occupational information which are precise and at the same time provide
comprehensive information.
47
Career Development vi) Career Visit: You may arrange visits to nearby industrial establishments
for a group of students to enable them to access information of variety of
occupation, making them observe while employees are on their jobs and at
the end seek clarifications from the authorities concerned. You should
carefully plan and monitor the entire range of activities starting from student
leaving the school for visit till such time they return home safely.
This can be done by raising relevant issues in terms of When? Where? Who?
Why? and How? which have direct bearing upon copy-right date of book/material,
geographical limitation, quality of authorship, purpose and modus operandi of
collection and presentation of factual information respectively.
Criteria
Occupational literature can be evaluated in terms of the comprehensiveness of
the content, presentation of textual and tabular material and availability of the
latest data in tune with the international and national level data. Tabular and
graphic materials should be accompanied by a well integrated discussion. Tabular
material should be set up-in proper form.
3) Money: This is a crucial input for the effective conduct of various activities
in the context of any endeavour and more so in the case of occupational
information service programme. In order to mobilize this input you need to
bring about awareness among all those who are in a position to make
contributions financially. Apart from this you need to make them appreciate
the importance of the activities in the context of their own professional
development so that the programme becomes need based and sustainable.
Mobilising resources of both internal and external kinds have to be carried out in
a systematic and planned manner and it should be converted into a sort of
movement to the extent that resources get generated, organized and channelized
in the form of Human Resource Development. This is possibly achieved by
harnessing human, financial and material resources and deriving strategies for
the management of the same with governmental and non-governmental support,
resulting out of development of forward and backward linkages among guidance
personnel and schools, colleges, universities, non-governmental organizations
and community centres and community at large.
51
Career Development
UNIT 11 CAREER PATTERNS
Structure
11.1 Introduction
11.2 Objectives
11.3 Understanding Career Patterns
11.3.1 Career Patterns and Other Related Terms
11.4 The Relationship of Career Patterns with Life Stages
11.5 Types of Career Patterns
11.6 Determinants of Career Patterns
11.7 Career Maturity
11.8 Vocational Success
11.8.1 Vocational Adaptation
11.9 Teacher’s Role in Career Planning
11.9.1 Facilitating Career Exploration
11.9.2 Providing Career Information
11.9.3 Providing Career Literature
11.9.4 Providing Role Models
11.9.5 Providing Individual Assistance
11.10 Role of Parents
11.11 Let Us Sum Up
11.12 Unit-end Exercises
11.1 INTRODUCTION
After going through the unit on Nature of Work and Career Development, you
are now aware of the concept, nature, approaches and theories of career
development and the role of work in our daily life. This Unit will deal with the
concept of career patterns, which refers to sequence of occupations in the life of
an individual or a group of individuals. This sequence will be analysed in order
to ascertain the major work periods which constitute a career. This sequence
may differ considerably, or it may be in the same field with or without vertical
movement. The word “career” is to be distinguished from other interchangeably
used words such as vocation, job, or profession. Career patterns are developmental
in nature. They must be understood in terms of life stages. Many genetic, social,
economic and environmental factors influence the determining of career patterns.
They take various shapes. These are called types of career patterns. With
experience, they start stabilizing and career maturity takes its shape. Gradually,
these career patterns lead to vocational success and vocational adjustment. Life
adjustment process, to a large extent, depends upon vocational adjustment.
Therefore, the career planning is very important for everybody, and sooner one
realizes this, better it is. Hence, the role of teachers is very important in the
planning of career of students.
52
Career Patterns
11.2 OBJECTIVES
After going through this Unit, you should be able to:
• describe the concept of career patterns;
• distinguish the term career patterns from other related terms such as vocation,
job, profession;
• classify the various career patterns;
• distinguish between career patterns and life stages;
• describe the determinants of career patterns;
• distinguish between career patterns and career maturity;
• identify different types of career patterns;
• differentiate between vocational success and vocational adjustment and their
relationship with career patterns;
• identify factors affecting career patterns, vocational success and vocational
adjustment; and
• describe the role of teachers in the planning of careers of students.
The above discussion would have made clear the minute differences among the
word career and the commonly inter-changeably used terms in this field.
Students at this stage also want to be self-sufficient, so they take up many side
jobs. The role of guidance and counselling is very important at this stage. The
adolescent starts exploring different vocations to decide which occupation s/he
would like to follow. S/he even works as apprentice to learn about the area in
which s/he is interested. Here the question arises that a person not only wants to
earn, but also likes to take up a job which is psychologically satisfying and is
also meeting parental status or ambitions. Hence social norms, personal and
psychological needs are related to the selection of an occupation. An individual’s
career does not exist in a vacuum. The various spheres are interrelated and a full
understanding of careers must be seen in the context of individual’s other
activities, beliefs, social status, intellectual level and so on. Self-examination,
role tryout and occupational exploration take place in school, in leisure activities
and part time work. This stage has the following three sub stages:
ii) Transition – At the age of 18-21 years, reality considerations are given
55
Career Development more weight as the youth enters the labour market or professional training
and attempts to implement a self-concept.
iii) Trial – This starts approximately at the age of 22-24 years. A seemingly
appropriate field having been located, a beginning job in it is found and
tried out as a life role.
The Establishment Stage (25-45): As the career pattern becomes clear, effort is
put forth to stabilize it to make a secure place in the world of work. For most
persons these are the creative years. Establishment includes establishing a family,
a home and a role in the community as well as making a place in the world of
work by establishing a practice, building a business or developing a work history.
At this stage a person wants to make a name for oneself. He tries to become an
important part of the world of work to get recognition and to serve and contribute
meaningfully to the society at large. In this process of self-adjustment, he moves
toward self-actualization by getting professional maturity, and in addition,
contributes towards cultural and moral heritage. At domestic front too, he plays
an important role of fulfilling his responsibilities to initiate his wards towards
the world of work and social life.
The Maintenance Stage (45-65): Having made a place in the world of work,
the concern now is to hold on. Maintenance is the process of holding one’s own
place in the family, keeping the home intact, keeping up appearances in the
community, and seeing that the business/profession continues to flourish. At this
stage, it has generally been seen that a person has gained a lot of experience in
one’s profession. Therefore, the individuals attempt to maintain what they have
achieved for which they would try to innovate, acquire new skills or look for
new challenges. Though, it is difficult to achieve anything spectacular at this
stage. An individual actively moves toward the goal of self-actualization as all
other needs are more or less fulfilled. Money is used as a means towards the
process of self-realization.
The Decline Stage (65 plus): As physical and mental powers decline, work
activity changes, and in due course ceases. New roles must be developed, first
that of selective participant, and then that of observer rather than of participant.
Decline manifests itself not only physically (in decreased energy and stamina)
and vocationally, but also in other respects, as in the lessening of family
responsibilities and restriction of roles in the community. Decline stage has two
main sub stages:
i) Deceleration (65-70): The pace of work slackens, duties are shifted and
the nature of work is changed to suit declining capacities. Many find part-
time jobs to replace their full time occupations.
ii) Retirement (70- +): As with all specified age limits, there are great variations
from person to person. But complete cessation of occupation comes for all
in due course; to some easily and pleasantly, to others with difficulty and
disappointment, and to some only with death, (Super, et. al. 1957).
Initial work period: This period begins with the first part-time or summer work
experience at about the age of 14. The adolescent is introduced directly to the
world of work as a part-time participant. This period matches with the exploratory
stage.
The trial work period: This period is a replica of the stage of establishment. It
is just like an entry into the regular labour market. It happens during the age 16-
25 years. It continues until a suitable work position is attained, usually after
considerable changing of jobs. The person finds a type of work, where he feels
satisfied and provides for success ahead.
The stable work period (35-60/5): At this stage individuals find a work position
which is more or less permanent in nature. If they change the work for better
prospects, in rare cases, they once again enter the trial period.
The retirement period (60-65+): The retirement period is a replica of the decline
stage.
Above mentioned factors are all determinants and not the processes. The process
is the interaction among the determinants. The interaction between the individual
and society results in self-observation generalizations. These are self-precepts.
In self-concept theory these precepts are viewed as organized self-observations
or self-concepts (Super and others, 1953). Social learning, experiential learning
and interactive learning are the processes involved in the formation of self-concept
in general and occupational self-concept in particular.
The young boys and girls are in great need for career related information. Besides
opening their eyes to the world of work, information motivates them in choosing
and preparing for the work also. The dissemination of career information should
begin at the elementary school stage. Here the teacher should integrate career
information inputs into teaching of subject matter. He/she can explain the
relationship of various subject contents with variety of work as well as the career
options in his/her teaching subject. The school teacher at all stages should promote
the development of positive attitudes towards education as preparation to careers
and decision-making. They should also help them develop values appropriate to
future careers.
63
Career Development The role models can be provided at all stages of school education and are effective
in promoting career development.
i) They should consider them as individuals who have the right to develop
and enjoy in this world. They should bring them up in such a way that they
are equipped with positive qualities.
ii) Specially in the case of girls the parents should understand the importance
of education. They should change their mind-set of educating girls only for
acquiring suitable grooms or procuring employment in case of eventuality.
The career patterns in India are changing. New careers are merging with new
developments on the rise. New services are coming up. Things, which were not
heard earlier, are becoming popular, especially in the urban sectors.
These days, careers which were side business earlier, have become full-fledged
professions of educated persons. For example, art-craft, clay modeling, flower
arrangement, interior decoration, coaching centres or private tuition. Opening
private or so called public schools, textile designing, opening computer
institutions, fast food joints, super markets, running chartered buses, property
64
dealing, magazine publishing, private firms, making films, cassettes, jewellery Career Patterns
crafting etc. have become career choices for many people.
65
Career Development
UNIT 12 CAREER DEVELOPMENT OF
GIRLS IN INDIA
Structure
12.1 Introduction
12.2 Objectives
12.3 Career Development of Girls: Salient Features
12.3.1 Home Maker Role for Women
12.3.2 Work Role Perceptions
12.3.3 Women’s Participation in Work
12.3.4 Factors Influencing the Work Participation of Women
12.3.5 Educational Participation of Women
12.3.6 Values and Motivation
12.3.7 Intelligence, Academic Achievements and Occupational Aspirations
12.3.8 Cultural and Environmental Factors
12.3.9 Career versus Non-career Women
12.4 Theories of Career Development of Women
12.5 Career Patterns of Women
12.6 Career Problems of Girls
12.7 Role of Teachers
12.8 Role of Parents
12.9 Let Us Sum Up
12.10 Unit-end Exercises
12.11 References and Suggested Readings
12.12 Answers to Check Your Progress
12.1 INTRODUCTION
Today, careers for women have emerged as one of the most significant areas of
concern for those who advocate education for women, equality and nurturing
human resources for national goal. Woman is a case of underdeveloped human
potential in our country. The dramatic increase in interest to develop this potential
through education and work has taken place since the declaration of the year
1975 as the International Women’s Year, United Nations Decade for Woman
(1975-1985) and 1990’s as SAARC Decade of the Girl Child (1991-2000) A.D.
and submission of National Perspective Plan for Women 1988-2000 A.D. to
Government of India. Still in India fewer women are working. Only 27% of
working age women are working in paid jobs in 2015-16 when compared to
43% in 2004-05. According to Global Gender Report 2015, India was ranked
136 among 144 countries on the economic participation and opportunities index
(Varma,2017).
12.2 OBJECTIVES
After going through this Unit, you should be able to:
66
• understand the career development of women; Career Development of
Girls in India
• list out the salient features of the career development of girls;
• identify the different types of career patterns of women;
• understand career problems of women; and
• visualize your role as a teacher and parent in promoting career development
of girls.
Today, women are in conflict with traditional thinking and learning, and with
their new interests, aspirations and explorations. The resulting changes further
influence to a considerable extent the career patterns of women.
The type of work performed by women workers is one of the most important
aspects to be considered from the point of view of their career development.
The following could be said about women’s work participation:
i) Women are behind men in work participation.
ii) Participation of rural women in work is more in comparison to urban women.
iii) Women are generally engaged in unskilled work as agricultural or other
labour. Their percentage is, however, more than men. Some of them are
also engaged in home based industries, small business activities and services.
iv) Public sector employs more women than private sector.
v) Women are concentrated in community, social and personal services, which
is the direct extension of their feminine role at home.
3) To Prove Self-worth: There are a few women who have the desire to achieve
and prove their worth. They pursue higher education, excel in performance,
have increased occupational aspirations and join the careers not the jobs.
Most of these women are found in non-traditional careers. They also work
hard to reach the top positions in hierarchy.
5) Dissatisfaction with Home Making Role: Most of the middle class and
upper middle class women suffer from isolation. It is not possible for most
of them to participate in social-recreational or other outside home activities.
Husband and children, away at place of work or study, do not provide
sufficient emotional satisfaction when they are at home. Emergence of
household gadgets has made household chores easy and time saving. Thus,
in order to fulfill their needs, these women take up work outside their homes.
6) Small Family Size: In a small family with one or two children, after the
children leave school for higher education, women find more leisure time.
Some of them engage themselves with some earning activities at home
while others look for paid employment. However, employment at this stage
is sometimes difficult due to high and ever increasing unemployment rate.
69
Career Development 7) Increased Job Opportunities for Women: With government’s conscious
efforts towards women’s development, educational and job opportunities
for women have expanded rapidly in the recent past. These opportunities
exist mainly in clerical, sales and service occupations, where a large segment
of educated women get employed.
8) Change in Social Attitudes and Values: There has been a gradual change
in social attitudes and values towards women’s development in the country
since independence. This evolution has encouraged women to develop their
potential in education and career.
70
12.3.7 Intelligence, Academic Achievements and Occupational Career Development of
Girls in India
Aspirations
Women’s attitudes towards career and their career aspirations are likely to be
shaped in the early years of development. It is presumed that higher education,
intelligence and better achievements stimulate the individual occupationally.
However, studies have shown that the women’s attitudes towards career could
not be linked with their intelligence, academic achievement and history of
achievements in other school activities as is the case with the men. Men during
their school/college days verbalize about their vocational goals and are found to
be concerned with the extrinsic rewards of the work. They are also concerned
about the future and prestige in careers while girls pursuing school education or
even higher education hardly speak out their concerns for careers. At the most
they talk about non-career type work which hardly speaks about their interests or
aspirations. Even the achievers don’t seem to be planning for higher level
occupations. The situation is still worse for the girls from lower socio-economic
background and other disadvantaged sections of the society. For these girls, the
chances of pursuing higher education or career goals are much reduced even if
they are highly intelligent or can excel educationally. In brief, it is the higher
need for self-approval which is related to social approval in the role of wife and
mother which determines women’s concern for marriage and family and not the
career.
71
Career Development
12.4 THEORIES OF CAREER DEVELOPMENT OF
WOMEN
We have discussed different career development theories in Unit 9. Researchers
formulated these theories based on studies conducted on the work experience of
men. Attempts to formulate theories of women’s career development began in
the 1980’s. Hackett & Betz (1981), Gottfredson (1981), and Astin (1984)
improvised earlier career theories to accommodate factors that influence the career
development of women. We would briefly discuss each of these theories here.
a) Performance accomplishments
Information about successful performance of a task tends to increase efficacy
expectations regarding the specific task. Studies have shown gender
differences in access to information (i.e. if a task has been successfully
accomplished) and the interpretation of successful task accomplishments.
Women are more likely to attribute the successful accomplishment of a
task to external factors such as task difficulty (low level of difficulty) or
luck rather than internal factors such as ability or effort. Increase in efficacy
level is not likely to happen if successful performance accomplishments
are attributed to external factors (difficulty level of the task or luck).
b) Vicarious learning
The second source of information relevant for developing self-efficacy
expectations is observing other people succeeding in their tasks. In general,
men have more opportunities for vicarious learning experiences related to
career tasks. For women, the vicarious learning experiences relevant to career
tasks are fewer as the availability of women role models in non-traditional
jobs is comparatively less. Therefore, we can say in general, vicarious
learning experiences as a source of information pertinent to increasing
efficacy expectations is less available to women.
c) Emotional arousal
Task performance of individuals can be affected by high levels of anxiety
and stress (emotional/physiological arousal). According to Bandura, anxiety
is induced when individuals perceive themselves as lacking in efficacy
expectations regarding a given task performance. Studies indicate that
anxiety responses in women are likely to reduce their perception of self-
efficacy regarding a specific task.
72
d) Verbal persuasion Career Development of
Girls in India
When individuals are persuaded or encouraged to do a specific task, it
facilitates the development of efficacy expectations. In other words, lack of
encouragement or discouragement regarding a specific task functions to
decrease or fails to increase efficacy expectations. In traditional gender-
role socialization women are often discouraged from pursuing non-
traditional career path that are considered masculine and not gender
appropriate task behavior. Therefore, verbal persuasion as a source of
information relevant to developing self-efficacy expectation is less available
to women.
Hackett & Betz proposed a model depicting the postulated effects of traditional
female socialization on career related self-efficacy expectations (p.333), which
is given below.
Fig. 1: A model depicting the postulated effects of traditional female socialization on career-related
self-efficacy expectations.
The theory has implications for career development of women. The theory implies
that career counselors should help women design interventions to work on the
four sources of information to develop their self-efficacy expectations.
73
Career Development Sociopsychological model (Astin 1984)
According to Astin, the psychological and sociological (culture and environment)
factors interact and thus influence the choice of career and work behavior of
individuals. Astin’s model has the following four factors which are inter-related:
a) work motivation
b) work expectations
c) sex-role socialization and
d) structure of opportunity
Work motivation: Work is important for individuals as it fulfils the basic needs
of survival, pleasure (pursuing one’s interests through work) and contribution
(need to be useful to family and society and the recognition it brings to the
individual). Astin found that both men and women shared same basic needs
(survival, pleasure and contribution) that motivated them to work.
Work expectations: This refers to the individual’s perception about his/her (i)
ability to perform a job, (ii) the availability of the job and (iii) the kind of job that
fulfils his/her needs.
Sex-role socialization: Astin’s view is that work expectations are different for
men and women. This is because of the differences in the gender socialization
experiences of girls and boys. Gender stereotypical roles are reinforced in boys
and girls through play, family orientations and schooling process. Such
internalized gender- appropriate role and behavior can be expanding (choosing
from a wide range of work options) or restricting( choosing from the gender
stereotypical work options). In case of women, gender socialization experiences
restrict their work options.
The theories discussed here, point out that gender socialization experiences create
strong internal barriers to the career development of women. Gender stereotypical
notions restrict their work options. The findings of these studies have implications
for career counselling of girls. Career counselors should help girls to expand
their career options through suitable interventional strategies.
The above patterns show one thing clearly that the women’s career orientations
and career motivations are different from those of men and are based on their
needs, aspirations and attitude towards career and marriage. In fact, the career
patterns of women are determined by their cultural and educational backgrounds.
Gender – biases
Gender-bias is common everywhere whether it is at home, educational institutions,
place of work or society in general. These biases create barriers both structural
and attitudinal in women’s career development.
75
Career Development i) Gender-biases at Home: The feeling of difference between the boy and
the girl is introduced first in the family. Here the gender-bias begins from
conception of a child. The uninvited and unwanted girl child who is deprived
of proper food, love and care in comparison to the male child; whose
education is of secondary importance and who is not allowed to play or
participate in any activity except the household chores and sibling care,
grows into a female adolescent with expected feminine behaviour and
marriage goals. Hence her physical, personal, social and emotional
development is restricted. Her bringing up does not prepare her for higher
education or vocational training or employment.
ii) Educational Institutions: After home, the place which affects children’s
behaviour is school. Here children face gender-bias in almost all the aspects,
for example, gender-bias in textbooks, curriculum transaction, allocation
of subjects, SUPW activities; participation in some of the co-curricular
activities etc. Once inculcated, these behaviours become part of children’s
lives. In colleges and universities also, the biases are further propagated. In
this way, the quality of girls education does not match with that of
educational, vocational and personal development. Even the teacher training
programmes both in-service and pre-service seemed to ignore desensitization
of teacher against gender-biased behaviour till recently. The revised curricula
of teacher education of different universities have introduced a new course
‘Gender School and Society’ recently.
iii) Place of Work: Employers often don’t accept women as workers like men.
They even hesitate to employ women. A woman seeking employment is
viewed as a future wife and mother who will have primary responsibility
towards her home and family and not work. In comparison to a man she is
less preferred in employment and is paid less. She is also not given required
leave for homemaking and child rearing by employers other than public
sector. Above all she may sometimes face sexual harassment at work.
ii) Economic Problems: When there is no one to feed the family and educate
the male ‘sought after’ child, how can the parent afford to enroll the girl
child in a school? Who will take care of siblings, perform household chores,
earn and contribute to family income? In the families where they can afford
education, it is the boys who get this benefit.
At places where the institution or training facilities for girls are available, the
courses offered to girls are traditional which lack in market value. Sometimes 77
Career Development the girls have to opt for such courses due to their earlier educational preparation.
It has been found that due to the universalization of elementary education policy,
more and more girls are crossing 8th standard and reaching high school. But
these girls are weak in science and mathematics, therefore, they go for softer
options, which don’t require science and mathematics, that is, joining home
science courses such as tailoring, cooking, bakery, etc. and not the technical and
engineering courses.
Dual Role
When a woman decides to take up a career she has to do so while performing all
the duties of housewife, mother and daughter-in-law, etc. In fact, she is taught
from the beginning that her career is of secondary importance and her first priority
is to look after her home.
Role Conflict
Most of the working women, especially well educated, suffer from role conflict.
Like her family and society, she considers her role of housewife and mother
equally important to her career. Neglecting one at the cost of other or feeling of
neglecting one at the cost of other adds strains in women’s relationship with her
husband and family. The result is many women feel compelled to leave the job
to get rid of this painful situation. This not only stops their career development
but sets a bad example for young girls.
Fear of Success
It is seen that women generally prefer the occupations which are extension of
their household duties such as teaching, nursing, secretary, personal assistant,
social worker, etc. This is also the reason that the work which women do is not
held in high esteem as the work which men do. The occupational preference of
women for ‘typical’ women’s fields suggests two motives operating behind:
Firstly, girls think of marriage and societal approval before they plan for career.
Secondly, the women are highly conditioned to avoid success. They perhaps feel
secure if they opt for more traditional occupations than for non-traditional ones.
It is generally believed that the more successful a man is in his job, he will make
a desirable husband, the more successful a woman is, most people are afraid she
may not be a successful wife.
However, there are other contingency factors and difficulties which women face
in making career choices. These are:
i) The girls receive very little orientation towards career choice while the
question of career choice is emphasized for boys.
78
ii) Parents, teachers and significant others are more likely to emphasize salary Career Development of
Girls in India
and status in boy’s career choice while for girl’s emphasis on career is even
missing. Also, the jobs available to them are of poor status and remuneration.
iii) The options open to girls are considerably more restricted than for men and
they are forced to consider their role as a home maker before making career
selection.
iv) Women are more influenced by what they think men and society in general
will accept as a woman’s job and vice-versa.
v) The girls have fewer opportunities for vocational training and higher
education.
vi) Very often girls wait for marriage before choosing or joining any job as
marriage and husband’s home takes priority over career.
vii) Although, approximately all types of courses and occupations are open to
women, they frequently lack awareness of these opportunities and the
financial support for their education and training.
viii) Above all, girls also lack information about their abilities and interests, and
awareness of skills in them which are the motivating factors to make career
decisions. Most of the girls, still believe that girls are weak in science and
mathematics and they are better in social sciences and home science subject.
ix) The girls also lack positive role models to identify with and develop their
career potential. The above influences though come from a variety of sources
both internal and external but sometimes decidedly create problems in girls’
career development.
80
The role models can be presented in many ways: Career Development of
Girls in India
1) Ideally, women guest speakers selected as role models should be invited to
the school to talk to the girls about their work achievement and how they
established themselves. There is no comparison to presentation of live role
models with other methods as the girls can interact with them and may
clarify their personal doubts and difficulties.
2) Teacher can talk about successful women workers in traditional and non-
traditional occupations.
3) The files on achievements of girls and women in various fields, such as,
toppers in academic and co-curricular activities, award recipients, leaders,
social workers, writers, eminent researchers, defence and police services,
etc. could be maintained and displayed. Even the girls could be asked to
collect and file such type of material.
4) Pictures of successful alumni with their achievements could be displayed.
These women could also be invited to the school to interact with the students.
5) Special achievements of women staff members may be highlighted through
display or in school assembly.
6) Mention may be made about local women achievers and achievers from
disadvantaged sections of the society.
The role models can be presented at all stages of school and college education
and are effective in promoting career development among girls.
i) They should consider their daughters as individuals who have also the right
to develop and enjoy in this world. They should bring up their daughters in
such a way that they are equipped with positive qualities of both the gender.
ii) It is urgently required that the parents should understand the importance of
education for their daughters. They should change their attitude of educating
girls only for acquiring suitable grooms or procuring employment in case
of eventuality. The parents’ interest in daughter’s development is very crucial
for her career development.
iii) Parents should change the traditional belief of great economic value of male
children in comparison to female children who are considered as economic
burden or ‘Parayadhan’. Instead of early marriage they should educate their
daughters. Now the girls are given free education, uniform, stipends and
other benefits by the government to promote their development. The parents
should avail detailed information about these schemes which are also
publicized on media and use the assistance for the benefit of their daughters.
iv) Rural parents and economically weaker parents are required to understand
that their daughters should not be used to subsidize their brother’s education
through work. Rather both boys and girls can pursue education through
distance and other alternative modes while earning for the family.
v) The government has initiated many schemes for girls and women for their
education, vocational training, skill development, self-employment etc. The
government also provides loans to women who want to start their own
economic activity. These programmes cover all types of women population,
rural/urban, illiterate/literate/highly educated, tribal, scheduled castes and
backward classes. The parents should encourage their daughters to get benefit
from these schemes.
vi) The parents who favour their daughters’ education should go one step further
and should allow them to choose the courses and careers for which they are
suitable and are interested. They should not perpetuate the traditional gender
role based career engagement for their daughters.
82
vii) The child rearing in our culture is generally-recognized as mother’s privilege Career Development of
Girls in India
and responsibility. Mothers who themselves have been socialized in a
traditional way with all the gender biases perpetuate the same while rearing
their children. It is the mothers who need to change their attitudes and
outlook. They should not treat male and female children differentially to
teach them gender appropriate behaviour. Then only a girl child can realize
her potential as an individual.
84
Samuel H. Osipoco (1983): Theories of Career Development, The Ohio State Career Development of
Girls in India
University, Prentice Hall Inc., Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey.
Super, D.E. (1957): The Psychology of Careers, Harper, New York.
Super, D. (1953): A theory of vocational development, American Psychologist
(8), 185-90.
UN (2008). International Standard Industrial Classification of All Economic
Activities Revision Department of Economic and Social Affairs. Unstats.un.org
(retrieved on 2/7/17).
Varma,S(2017) Why Fewer Indian Women are working. Delhi: Sunday Times of
India, 17thSeptember, 2017p.24.
10) Work oriented can delay gratification in the interest of vocational pursuit.
Pleasure oriented can be easily distracted from the pursuit of his career.
Unit 10