Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 2 views

    Basic Materi Prof. Wayan 3 - 3 Revising Manuscript

    Uploaded by

    Icut cnm
    Revising the manuscript

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Basic Materi Prof. Wayan 3 - 3 Revising Manuscript

    Uploaded by

    Icut cnm
    2 views16 pages
    Revising the manuscript

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Revising the manuscript

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    2 views16 pages

    Basic Materi Prof. Wayan 3 - 3 Revising Manuscript

    Uploaded by

    Icut cnm
    Revising the manuscript

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    of 16

    REVISING a MANUSCRIPT

    Author Editor Reviewer


    START

    Basic requirements met?


    Submit a [Yes]
    paper
    1. Assign
    reviewers
    Publication [No]
    Collect reviewers’
    Review and give
    recommendation

    Process recommendations

    [Reject] Make a
    REJECT
    decision
    Revise the [Revision required]
    paper
    [Accept]

    ACCEPT
    2. Review Process Submission of Paper

    Editorial Office Assessment

    Appraisal by the Editor-in-Chief (EIC)

    EIC Assigns an Associate Editor

    Invitation to Reviewers

    Response to Invitations

    Review is Conducted

    Journal Evaluates the


    Reviews

    The Decision is
    Communicated

    Next Steps
    2.1 Initial review by editorial

    Why?
    How To Get Your Article Published
    Need
    manuscripts
    with a good
    probability of
    acceptance.
    • Many journals use a system of initial editorial review.
    • Editors may reject a manuscript without sending it for review
    Editors may reject a manuscript without sending it for review
    Content
    • Paper is of limited interest and is a routine application of well-known
    phenomena
    • The work presented in the article is out of the scope of the journal
    • Novelty and significance are not immediately evident or sufficiently
    well-justified
    Preparation
    • Failure to meet submission requirements
    • Incomplete coverage of literature
    • Unacceptably poor English
    2.2 Reviewing as a procedure
    • Nearly every manuscript requires revision.
    • Keep in mind that editors and reviewers mean to help you improve your
    article
    • Do not take offense.
    • Minor revision does NOT guarantee acceptance after revision.
    • Do not count on acceptance, but address all comments carefully
    • Revise the manuscript by considering one by one of the reviewers
    comments
    2.3 Revision after submission
    Carefully study the comments and
    prepare a detailed letter of response.
    ▪ Cut and paste each comment by the reviewer. Answer it directly, do not miss
    any point. Give page and line number
    ▪ State specifically what changes you have made to the manuscript considering
    the comment. With different color.
    ▪ Provide a scientific response to the comment you accept
    and polite rebuttal to the point you think the reviewer is wrong.
    2.4 Letter of Response
    CLARIFICATION for the REVIEWERS:

    I appreciate much for your corrections and suggestions for improving the
    contents of our article. I have included some information considering your
    ideas and made some corrections in the texts. The corrected parts are
    indicated by red color in the text File. I am pleased to provide you some
    clarifications referring to your suggestions and comments as follows:
    REVIEWER #1
    This is a very good work helpful for the wood workshop. A few
    editorial corrections are given in the table below. A couple of
    clarifications are also sought which may be included suitably in the
    revised version. The references/ reference pattern have not been
    checked by me. I am sure that the editorial team will look into that
    aspect.
    Section/Line no. Comment/query and Clarifications
    Abstract
    Line 14 Replace “Development of new” with : Machining aspects with
    Line 14 It was replaced
    Line 15 Replace “8 mm was studied.” With : 8 mm were studied.
    Line 15 It was replaced
    Line 16 Replace “chips formation” with: chip formation
    Line 16 It was replaced
    Line 16 Replace “milling the pine” with: milling pine
    Line 16 It was replaced
    Line 23 Replace “chips were increased and granule chip was reduced.” With: chips
    increased and granule chips were reduced.
    Line 23 It was replaced
    Introduction
    Dapatkan
    REVIEWER #2Modul
    Lengkap dengan
    Question 1:
    Cara Mengklaim
    Title of the article may be modified to reflect the purpose of the study.
    Answer 1 :
    E-Sertifikat 30JP
    I belive that the title “THE CHIPS GENERATED DURING UP MILLING AND DOWN MILLING
    OF PINE WOOD BY HELICAL ROUTER BITS” reflects the content of our manuscript and
    would
    Unlock provide opportunity
    Full Version to attract the reader’s attention.
    Modul
    by Claiming
    Question 2: e-Certificate
    30 Training
    References areHours
    to be cited completely along with name of journal, volume no, issue no, page
    numbers etc.
    Include:
    Answer 2:
    E-Certificate, Advanced Modul, International
    The
    Reputable Journalwere
    references Article,listed and were written completely. Some references have only volume and
    Recording.
    page numbers without issue number. The references were corrected:
    Chen WF, Lai HY (2002) A comprehensive engineering model for the design, manufacture and
    https://ebizmark.shop/
    assembly of helical carpenter shapers. Journal of Engineering Manufacture, 216 : 1493-1504
    BENEFIT E-CERTIFICATE
    FLASH SALE
    ONLY Rp189.000!
    https://ebizmark.shop/
    Harga Normal Rp175.000
    FLASH SALE
    Rp 99.000!
    https://ebizmark.shop/
    Thank You!

    You might also like