Unit Iv Notes
Unit Iv Notes
Unit Iv Notes
4.1 General
Analysis and design process of a damaged structure has to be based on its actual existing
condition. Before taking it up, the in situ properties of material used and its structural
sizes have to be determined based on field investigations and measurements. Whereas,
in case of new structures, option of alternative standard materials and structural sizes
are open and the design process could be adopted to get the optimum results based on
loads as per its design use.
Basic principles of analysis and design of a distressed structure are same as in case of
new structures. However, these require extra inputs based on sound and experienced
engineering judgment of the structure and its materials.
4.1.Reserve Strength
It is essential to halt its further deterioration and undertake strengthening, if required, for
additional anticipated loads. The repaired structure comprises of parent as well as new repair
material. The repairs can be termed as active or passive depending on the load sharing
mechanism of repair material and parent material. The passive repairs are those, which are
applied on existing loaded structural members and can share only a part of subsequent
additional loading. Whereas, in active repairs, the repaired structural member is initially
unloaded to relieve it of loads before the application of repairs. This is done basically to
ensure that the repair material and the parent material share the loads jointly.
The structural members can be repaired or strengthened for resisting excess shear and flexure
by providing additional steel reinforcement, carbon fibre wraps/mesh, section enlargement,
external pre-stressing, steel plate bonding etc. The sharing of load between old and new
materials need to be incorporated in the analysis and design. The type of stresses acting on
the repair system.
The behaviour of the repaired composite structure is difficult to model due to unpredictable
stress relieving and degree of integration with the existing structure. It will be necessary to
make some rational assumptions based on sound engineering judgment.
The procedure detailed in the following sections can be followed for assessment, evaluation
and design of repaired structures.
The documents related to foundation conditions, soil report, analysis, design, execution and
maintenance of work shall be gathered. As built architectural /structural drawings are essential for
analysis and design. It is necessary to check and validate the sizes of structural members duly making
allowances for the finishes and damages. The diameter and location of reinforcement can be
validated using available non-destructive bar locator (Cover meter/bar locator, etc). The structural
system can be developed based on the validated available structural/architectural drawings.
Wherever such informations are not available, drawings based on actual measurement are to
be developed.
4.3 Mechanical Properties of Materials
The steel reinforcement is relatively consistent in quality. The mechanical properties can be
assessed based on the details available in the drawings or by exposing reinforcement at few
places and taking samples for testing. The losses of cross-sectional areas due to effect of
corrosion etc. need to be ascertained.
The assessment of mechanical properties of concrete is rather elaborate and requires detailed
investigations. The strength of the concrete can be evaluated by non-destructive methods like
Ultrasonic Pulse Velocity Tests (UPV), Rebound Hammer Test etc. in conjunction with core
test. Using the results of NDE investigations and methods of interpretation, the strength of concrete
can be evaluated with certain degree of confidence.
The condition survey of the structure will give an idea regarding extent of damage to concrete
due to spalling, original construction defects, loss of strength due to exposure to high temperature
and damage to reinforcement due to corrosion/fire. This can be done based on the field
measurements. The observation of the structure can be mapped on a suitable format and the
results incorporated in the analysis of structure.
Based on building use, its region of location and the related structural/architectural drawings,
the design loads shall be worked out based on the applicable standards for earthquake and
wind (refer IS: 875- Part 1 to 5 and IS: 1893). The loading as per original building use and
also due to its changed use in the past and future, shall be ascertained and appropriately
considered in the design process.
These may necessitate structural modification. These could be identified based on the period
of construction of the building and the then prevalent codal practices.
The configuration of the building in plan and elevation provide adequate information regarding
structural dynamic response in the event of earthquakes etc. The locations of stress
concentration need to be identified based on analysis of as constructed structure. These
points of stress concentrations are to be examined in detail. The deficiency if any, in the
original construction should be identified. Particular attention must be given to the non-structural/
structural cracks in the structure to identify the cause of distress including improper construction
joints / separation joints, if any.
Analysis and design of the building shall be done taking into consideration of:
d. The theoretical model may be checked to compare the analytical results with the actual
observations.
e. The structural safety and load transfer shall be ensured at all the stages of repair.
a. The removal of concrete during repair may reduce the effective size of the structural
member and consequently affect its stiffness. Also the stability of the structure
may be endangered due to transfer of load to adjoining members.
c. In case of indeterminate the beam / slab element, it may be safe to assume the
member as simply supported in the design and proceed accordingly. It would also
give flexibility during execution of repair work.
1 General
Selection of repair material is one of the most important tasks for ensuring durable and trust
worthy repair. Though, the pre-requisite for a sound repair system is the detailed investigation
and determining the exact cause of distress, yet an understanding of the process of deterioration
of the repair materials (such as concrete and other auxiliary materials i.e. plastics, resins, etc)
under service conditions is vital. Of course, availability of materials of relevance, equipment
and skilled labour have to be explored before deciding upon the repair material.
The analogy for selection of repair material is similar to repairing of a torn garment with sound
fibre/fabric but of similar performance characteristics (i.e. pre-shrunk and similar fibre/fabric)
as that of the original garment. Had the patch repair been done with un-shrunk or dissimilar
fibre/fabric, it would have inflicted a greater damage to the repaired garment due to its pulling
away on a subsequent shrinking after washing. Exactly this is applicable to selection of materials
for repair of concrete/plaster. Also, the selection of the repair material has a chemical angle
and the manufacturer’s literature normally highlights the composition of the material rather
than performance characteristics. Since, cementitious products have a tendency to shrink
and hardening with age, it is essential that the repair material for repairing concrete or plaster
should be of non-shrink type and compatible with parent material.
Besides being of compatible properties, repair materials for cement concrete/mortar shall
also be easy to apply and require no attention after the repair has been applied. The essential
parameters for deciding upon a repair material for concrete are :
It is well known that the cementitious repair materials shrink with passage of time. Most of
the shrinkage generally takes place in the initial period from the time of casting to 21 days.
Therefore, cementitious repair material in its original form, if used for repair to concrete/
mortar, is likely to get either delaminated due to de-bonding or develop shrinkage cracks on
its surface due to shrinkage strains and stresses. Shrinkage cracks so developed in the repair
patch would allow the easy access of atmospheric air and water, which could be harmful for
concrete and reinforcement.
It is, therefore, essential that the low shrinkage property of repair material shall be looked
for
while selecting a material for concrete repair. Cementitious materials need additional non-
shrink compounds to be effective in achieving the desired property. Therefore, the
formulation of the patch mortar incorporates, in the cement matrix, several special
chemicals
to mitigate the shrinkage. Using low cement content and low water cement ratio will also
reduce the drying shrinkage.
It is desirable that the repaired structure shall be put to use at the earliest possible to reduce
the down time of plant, machinery, building or road. It is, therefore, essential that repaired
patch shall harden in the minimum possible time. However, in exceptional cases, it could also
be essential to have the slow setting property as a desirable property for repair material.
Such situation could be where more working time is required to work on repair materials or
the repair process is intricate that more working time is required.
5.2.3 Workability
The repair material is to be applied by the field workers and hence its acceptability by them
is very important. The property desired by the field workers is good workability. Hence
optimum workability is to be achieved without sacrificing the other desirable properties by
use of suitable additives/admixtures.
The bond strength of repair patch with the substrate is essential to have a successful repair
system. If it is felt that the bond strength of the repair material with the base material is
inadequate or less than the strength of the base material, then some other suitable means
could be explored to improve bond strength between repair material and substrate. These
could be use of:
• Adhesive,
• Surface interlocking system, and/or
• Mechanical bonding
A variety of adhesives, in the range of epoxies, polymer modified cement slurries including
unmodified polymer applications are available. The selection depends upon available open
Time for bonding etc, which are being specified for different applications. Surface interlocking
system and methods of mechanical bonding are, however, detailed out in the subsequent
chapter on Repair Methods.
5.2.9 Alkalinity
In case of RCC, it is important to maintain the alkalinity of concrete around
reinforcement with its pH above 11.5 from corrosion protection point of view. In this
context, it is necessary for the repair material to have chemical characteristics such that it
does not adversely affect the alkalinity of the base concrete at a later date. The chemical
characteristics of the repair material and its after effect on the pH of RCC shall be
examined beforehand. In addition, the pH of reinforcement protection applications,
bonding coats and that of the repair material must also be similarly alkaline. This would
ensure inbuilt compatibility.
5.2.11 Aesthetics
It is desirable that colour and texture of the repair material should match with the
structure and give aesthetically pleasant appearance. If need be, this could be
achieved throughappropriate finishes.
5.2.12 Cost
Economics is important while considering various options for repair materials but
cheaperrepair material should not be selected at the cost of performance characteristics.
5.3.1.1 Cements:
Cement paste, being a binder in concrete or mortar holds fine aggregates, coarse
aggregates and other constituents together in a hardened matrix. Cement forms one of
the most basic material used for not only in new construction but also as repair material.
Therefore, selection of the appropriate type of cement for new construction as well as
repair work is important and determines the final efficacy and durability of the structure. The
portland cements generallyconsist of Tricalcium silicate (3CaO.SiO2), Dicalcium Silicate
(2CaO.SiO2), Tricalcium aluminate (3CaO. Al2O3.Fe2O3) and tetracalcium aluminoferrite
(4Cao.Al2O3). These minerals are more often denoted as C3S, C2S, C3AF, C4A
respectively.
5.3.1.2 Mineral Additives
Fly Ash (FA), Silica Fume (SF), Rice Husk Ash (RHA), Ground Granulated Blast
Furnace Slag (GGBS) and metakaoline, which have good pozzolanic properties are
being used as mineral additives in concrete and mortars with certain advantages in
regard to their impermeability, resistance to leaching, resistance to chloride & sulphate
attack and better crushing strength. As already explained, the pozzolanic reaction results
in reduction of free lime and pH of hydrated cement paste. Such additives are to be
used with caution, while repairing flexural structural members requiring protection of
reinforcement againstcorrosion.
5.3.3.1Fields of Application:
1. Structural repairs to RCC: PMM/PMC are used to make up the
damaged/lost cover concrete due to their better bond with substrate,
including the reinforcement.
2. Ultra Rapid Hardening Polymer Modified Shotcrete:
Ultra Rapid Hardening Polymer Modified Shotcrete system can be
classified in to two categories:
One, which uses a polymerizable monomer that reacts with Ordinary
Portland cement at ambient temperature. This system is used as repair
and protective material for concrete structures with leaking and
flowing water. It uses magnesium acrylate monomer and its setting
time can be controlled within few seconds or less.
Second, which uses ultra rapid hardening cement concrete with SBR
latex and is often used for urgent construction and repair works.
3. Polymer Ferrocements:
For the purpose of improving the flexural behaviour and durability of
conventional ferrocement, polymer-ferrocements have been developed using
latex modified mortars instead of ordinary cement-sand mortars. Use of SBR
and EVA modified mortars is found to be very effective in improving their
flexural behaviour, impact resistance, drying shrinkage and durability.
Incorporation of short fibres such as steel and carbon fibres in the latex modified
mortars is found to be further effective in improving such characteristics.
4. Bond Coats (Structural Adhesives) and Grouts: Polymer modified cement mortars
as well as slurries are used as bond coats and grouts due to their very good
adhesivequalities on cementitious as well as metallic surface.
5.3.4 Epoxies
Epoxies also come in the category of polymers but in the case of epoxies, the
polymerization process takes place when two materials called the epoxy resin and hardener
come in contact by thoroughly mixing in specified proportion. The epoxy resin materials have
good mechanicalstrength, chemical resistance and ease of working. These are being used in
civil engineering for high performance coatings, adhesives, injection grouting, high
performance systems, industrial flooring or grouting etc.
5.3.4.1 Precautions to be taken:
Epoxies are generally toxic in nature and these require lot of care in their handling.
The special care required to be taken during their mixing and applications are as
under:
I. They should not come in contact with the skin. Workers should be provided
with rubbergloves.
II. The utensils/ equipments used for the mixing resin and hardener should
be cleanedimmediately after their use.
III. The pot life of the mixed epoxy is generally very limited, ½ to 2 hours. It
should be finally applied as adhesive within pot life period. Therefore,
material should be prepared just sufficient to cover the area within the
pot life period as recommended by themanufacturers.
IV. The epoxies are generally used as an adhesive to act as bond coat
between the old concrete and repaired concrete. The epoxies have a glass
transition range at temperatures at 60 to 80o C depending upon the epoxy
type. Therefore, they should not be used inthe exposed environment.
V. Epoxies have much higher bond strength than other polymers, but at the
same time,these are costlier.