Review Article
Review Article
Review Article
Submitted to:
Dr. Shweta Narayan
Assistant Professor,
Department of Psychology,
Christ (Deemed to be University),
Delhi NCR Campus
Submitted by:
Priyanshi Prajapati
2 BAPENG-B
23213735
Date of submission:
30th March,2024
INTRODUCTION TO SLEEP
Sleep is a complex process that involves both behavioral and physiological changes.
Understanding these changes can help improve our overall health and well-being. According
to scientific standards, sleep is defined based on a person's behavior and related physiological
changes that occur in the brain. The behavioral criteria include slow or no mobility, slow eye
arousal threshold, impaired cognitive function, and a reversible unconscious state. The
It is crucial to differentiate sleepiness from fatigue, as the latter can be a consequence of the
former. Moreover, sleep is divided into two states: non-rapid eye movement (NREM) and
rapid eye movement (REM) sleep. These states alternate in cycles, with adults experiencing 4
NREM sleep accounts for 75 to 80 percent of sleep time in adults and is divided into 4 stages
(NREM stages 1 to 4) according to the traditional Rechtschaffen and Kales (R-K) scoring
manual or 3 stages (N1, N2, N3) according to the recent American Academy of Sleep
Medicine (AASM) manual. Slow-wave sleep dominates the first third of sleep, while REM
REM sleep accounts for 20 to 25 percent of total sleep time. During REM sleep, there are
rapid eye movements in all directions, diminished or absent muscle activity in the chin EMG,
phasic swings in blood pressure and heart rate, irregular respiration, and phasic tongue
movements. A few periods of apnoea or hypopnoea may arise during REM sleep. The EEG
tracings during REM sleep are characterized by fast rhythms and theta waves, sometimes
our overall health and well-being. By being aware of the behavioral and physiological
changes that occur during sleep, we can take steps to improve our sleep quality and wake up
This study provides in-depth insights into the global healthcare challenges related to sleep
loss and sleep quality. Sleep is a fundamental aspect of our health and well-being, and
disruptions in sleep patterns can have serious consequences on both physical and mental
health. To address this issue, it is important to increase awareness among patients and
healthcare providers about the long-term effects of sleep loss and poor sleep quality.
Furthermore, the study emphasizes the need for consistent theoretical and operational
definitions in sleep research to ensure that results are reliable and can be compared across
studies. By developing standardized definitions, we can better understand the causes and
consequences of sleep disorders, and identify effective prevention and treatment strategies.
In conclusion, this study highlights the urgent need for healthcare providers and
strategies, we can improve the quality of life for millions of people around the world who
Article 2- Changes in sleep pattern and sleep quality during COVID-19 lockdown
The objective of this study is to conduct an extensive online survey to investigate the impact
of the COVID-19 lockdown on people's sleep experience, routines, physical activity, and
symptoms of anxiety and depression. As governments worldwide implemented lockdowns to
curb the spread of the pandemic coronavirus infection, many individuals were confined to
their homes, disrupting their regular life routines, including their circadian cues. Furthermore,
the pandemic has brought new stressors, altered roles, and uncertainties about health and
The COVID-19 lockdown has caused significant changes in people's sleep patterns, such as
alterations in sleep schedules, decreased quantity and quality of sleep, and elevated rates of
emotional symptoms. However, it is still unclear from these cross-sectional results whether
sleep deterioration leads to psychological distress, or vice versa. Therefore, this study aims to
provide a deeper understanding of the impact of the lockdown on people's sleep patterns and
By conducting the survey, the study hopes to gain valuable insights that can help individuals,
Article 3- Sleep disturbances during pregnancy and adverse maternal and fetal outcomes: A
disturbances and maternal complications as well as adverse fetal outcomes. The data used for
the study was pooled from studies involving more than 50 million pregnant women and
analyzed a broad range of sleep disturbances such as poor sleep quality, extreme sleep
duration, insomnia symptoms, and significant sleep disorders including RLS, S-SDB, and
OSA.
The study provides detailed information about the association of each specific sleep
disturbance with maternal complications and adverse fetal outcomes. The study's findings
suggest that pregnant women with sleep disturbances are at a higher risk of developing
maternal complications and adverse fetal outcomes. The study further emphasizes that
healthcare providers should identify and manage sleep disturbances in pregnant women
In addition, the study performed subgroup analyses and meta-regression to explore sources
of heterogeneity, assess study design, and examine study quality to determine their effects on
the results. The study found that the effects of sleep disturbances on maternal complications
Additionally, the study found that the quality and design of the included studies did not affect
the overall results. Overall, this study provides valuable insights into the importance of
identifying and managing sleep disturbances during pregnancy. Its findings highlight the need
for healthcare providers to pay more attention to sleep disturbances during antenatal clinical
care and encourage pregnant women to seek help if they experience sleep disturbances.
Article 4- The effect of caffeine on subsequent sleep: A systematic review and meta-analysis
caffeine consumption on nighttime sleep. The analysis reveals that caffeine intake can have
several detrimental effects on sleep, including reducing total sleep time, delaying sleep onset,
increasing wakefulness after falling asleep, decreasing sleep quality, and disrupting sleep
architecture.
The extent of the negative impact on sleep depends on the amount of caffeine consumed and
the time of day it is consumed. The study shows that the closer to bedtime caffeine
consumption occurs, the more significant the reduction in total sleep time. The final dose of
impact of caffeine on other sleep outcomes remains unclear. Therefore, further research is
needed to determine the relationship between caffeine dose and timing of intake for other
sleep outcomes.
Overall, the study provides valuable evidence-based guidance for individuals who consume
caffeine. By being mindful of the amount and timing of caffeine consumption, individuals
Article 5- The future of sleep health: a data-driven revolution in sleep science and medicine
Over the past few years, multi-modal sensors and technologies have revolutionized the
monitoring of physical activity, sleep, and circadian rhythms. This has made it possible to
accurately monitor sleep at a large scale for the first time. With vast amounts of multi-sensor
data being generated, the potential applications are numerous, ranging from large-scale
coaching individuals with chronic conditions. However, despite these developments, several
significant challenges must be overcome to realize the full potential of these technologies.
interpretation. To address these challenges, we have brought together experts from numerous
The study aims to introduce state-of-the-art sleep-monitoring technologies and discuss the
opportunities and challenges from data acquisition to the eventual application of insights in
clinical and consumer settings. Furthermore, it aims to explore the strengths and limitations
of current and emerging sensing methods, with a particular focus on novel data-driven
technologies such as Artificial Intelligence. By doing so, it would be easy to unlock the full
potential of these technologies and revolutionize the way we monitor and understand sleep .
S. Author, Title Methodology Finding F
No. Country, I
Year
Aim Objective Design Sample Tools Strength Limitation
1. Kathy L. Sleep The study aims To identify the Concept Scientific Rodger’s This Traditionally, no P
Nelson Quality: to clarify the features of sleep analysis literature Evolutionary evolutionary empirical e
An meaning of the quality that can from Method process (qualitative or t
USA Evolution concept of sleep be useful for the electronic produced a quantitative) s
ary quality. nursing databases more clear and investigations g
2021 Concept discipline on the (CINAHL, applicable were used to r
Analysis vital connection PsycINFO, conceptual clarify the a
between health PubMed, definition of meaning of a
and good And sleep quality. concepts. The b
quality sleep. JSTOR) lack of c
30 titles empirical c
and investigation to f
abstracts clarify concepts, i
were results in certain q
analyzed. limitations in
the
methodology of
concept
analysis.
2. Ravi Changes The study aims The findings of Quantitat 1024 Online There are no This study has S
Gupta, in sleep to examine the this research ive completed Survey using conflicts of limitations. It C
Sandeep pattern modifications in can provide research responses a interest. was an internet- l
Grover and sleep sleep patterns valuable method (958 valid questionnaire based survey s
quality that occurred insights into the responses) The use of with self- c
India during during the effects of statistical reported s
COVID- lockdown lockdown on analysis. criteria, s
2020 19 period. sleep, thereby resulting in d
lockdown contributing to some unaware d
the existing participants s
body of being included. R
knowledge in Cross-sectional d
this area. data may have s
been affected by l
recall and l
response bias. n
Lastly, 1%-2% o
of the data was
missing.
Researchers
should exercise
caution when
generalizing the
results beyond
the sample
population.
Future research
should address
these limitations
by exploring
factors that
contribute to
response bias
and missing
data.
3. Qingdon Sleep The study aims To assess the Systemati 120 studies Meta- The study helps The meta- M
g Lu disturban to assess the risk of sleep c review with Analyses of in assessing the analysis was a
Xiaoyan ces correlation disturbances on 58,123,250 Observational consistency of limited to a
Zhang during between sleep maternal and Meta- pregnant Studies in findings across publications p
Pregnanc disruption and fetal outcomes, analysis women Epidemiology different written in d
China y and complications establish the (MOOSE) studies, English, and d
adverse in expectant links between populations, and there is the p
2021 maternal mothers, as well sleep issues and Preferred settings, possibility of n
and Fetal as fetal negative Reporting enhancing the unidentified e
outcomes outcomes that outcomes, and Items for generalizability articles in other o
:A may be investigate Systematic of results databases. o
systemati unfavorable. other potential Reviews and beyond any Several factors, p
c review risk factors. Meta- single study. such as the H
and meta- Analysis It also identifies severity of sleep p
analysis (PRISMA) patterns or disturbances, s
trends that may comorbidities s
not be evident with other d
in individual medical and p
studies alone. psychiatric a
disorders, and t
year of t
publication, v
were not m
controlled in f
some cross-
sectional
studies.
4. Carissa The The study aims This study Systemati 24 studies Preferred The method First, three T
Gardiner effect of to investigate presents new c review Reporting used focuses on studies utilized v
caffeine insights Items for a narrow activity e
the effect of
2023 on regarding the Meta- Systematic research monitors to g
caffeine on the
subseque impact of analysis Reviews and question; measure sleep, i
characteristics
Australia nt sleep: caffeine on the Meta- involves a which resulted s
of night-time
A quality of Analyses search for in an o
sleep, intending
systemati subsequent (PRISMA) evidence that is overestimation c
to identify the
c review sleep. The comprehensive of sleep and an c
time after which
and meta- research sheds International and systematic; underestimation w
caffeine should
analysis light on the Prospective selects and of wake time. m
not be
potential effects Register of evaluates all Second, the n
consumed
of caffeine Systematic relevant limited studies o
before bedtime.
consumption on Reviews articles; and that administer c
sleep and (PROSPERO) synthesizes data caffeine over c
provides in a clear, several days t
valuable explicit, make it difficult t
information that systematic, and to determine c
may contribute rigorous way. whether its i
to the effect changes m
development of with repeated d
health and exposure. e
wellness Third, various e
strategies. factors can b
influence c
caffeine’s half- a
life, including d
medication, e
lifestyle s
choices, health
conditions, etc.
Fourth, meta-
regression
analyzed only
the final dose
amount and
timing for
caffeine
administered
multiple times
in a day.
5. Ignacio The The study The study Review Not Five-Step The study The research I
Perez- future of introduces the explores the Article mentioned Digital Sleep leverages study lacks a
Pozuelo sleep state-of-the-art strengths and Framework expertise across specificity as it t
health: a in monitoring limitations of neuroscience, fails to provide i
2020 data- technologies. It current and clinical details t
driven discusses the emerging medicine, regarding the o
United revolutio opportunities sensing bioengineering, number and p
Kingdom n in sleep and challenges methods with a electrical nature of the d
science from data particular focus engineering, articles s
and acquisition to on novel data- epidemiology, evaluated. d
medicine the eventual driven computer Additionally, s
application of technologies, science, health, the paper m
insights in such as AI. and human– neglects to r
clinical and computer address the s
consumer interaction to reliability and c
settings. discuss the validity of the t
digitization of introduced e
sleep from an measure, i
interdisciplinary thereby creating t
perspective. room for o
skepticism and m
questioning. d
h
o
i
o
a
SUMMARY
The paper undertakes a thorough examination of the notion of sleep quality from an
researchers seek to clarify the intricate nature of sleep quality and its evolutionary
implications.
Key Points:
elements could comprise sleep duration, continuity, efficiency, architecture, and subjective
generations.
3. The functions of sleep are explored in the article, with a focus on its evolutionary
consolidation, immune response, and emotional regulation. It is emphasized that the quality
5. The implications of inadequate sleep quality on physical and mental well-being from an
evolutionary standpoint are deliberated in the article. Disturbances in sleep quality have the
has the potential to influence clinical methodologies for evaluating and dealing with sleep
issues. Healthcare professionals are encouraged to take into account the unique variations in
sleep behaviors and quality in the broader scope of evolutionary adaptations when addressing
sleep-related concerns.
7. Prospects for the Future: The analysis of the concept emphasizes the necessity for further
quality and its impacts on health and overall well-being. It is recommended that
In summary, the concept analysis provides valuable perspectives into the intricate nature of
sleep quality through an evolutionary lens. By acknowledging the evolutionary roots and
beneficial purposes of sleep, we can enrich our comprehension of its importance for human
health and develop strategies to encourage optimal sleep quality in contemporary societies.
Article 2- Changes in sleep pattern and sleep quality during COVID-19 lockdown
1. Against the backdrop of the global COVID-19 pandemic and widespread implementation
of lockdown measures, this study aims to comprehend the alterations in sleep patterns and
2. Employing both quantitative and qualitative methods, the research evaluates changes in
sleep patterns during the lockdown. Data collection methods such as surveys, questionnaires,
or wearable sleep-tracking devices might have been utilized to gather information on sleep
3. The article deliberates on how the upheaval brought about by the pandemic, encompassing
alterations in daily routines, heightened stress levels, modified work setups (e.g., remote
work), and decreased physical activity, could have impacted individuals' sleep patterns.
Observable shifts in sleep timing, irregular sleep-wake cycles, and variations in total sleep
4. The examination delves into the subjective realm of sleep quality during the lockdown
period. Factors like anxiety, uncertainty, social isolation, and excessive exposure to
difficulties initiating sleep, frequent awakenings, and overall dissatisfaction with sleep.
5. Recognizing that the repercussions of the pandemic on sleep patterns and quality may
differ among demographic groups and individuals with distinct socioeconomic backgrounds,
occupations, and living circumstances, the article acknowledges that vulnerable populations,
such as frontline healthcare workers, might encounter exacerbated sleep disturbances due to
6. Essential for guiding public health initiatives and individual-level approaches to enhance
sleep hygiene and mental well-being, comprehending the shifts in sleep patterns and quality
during the COVID-19 lockdown is imperative. The article may propose strategies for stress
7. Pointing towards potential future research avenues, the study may underline the importance
In conclusion, the article offers insights into the modifications in sleep patterns and quality
triggered by the COVID-19 pandemic and lockdown measures. Grasping these alterations is
vital for addressing the broader ramifications for public health and well-being in times of
crisis.
Article 3- Sleep disturbances during pregnancy and adverse maternal and fetal outcomes: A
This systematic review and meta-analysis aims to explore the correlation between sleep
disruptions in pregnancy and their effects on maternal and fetal well-being. By extensively
analyzing existing literature, the authors seek to offer insights into the possible repercussions
Key Points:
1. Study Objective: The primary goal of this study is to investigate the link between sleep
disturbances during pregnancy and unfavorable maternal and fetal outcomes. Sleep
disruptions encompass a range of issues like insomnia, sleep apnea, restless legs syndrome,
pooling data from various studies to evaluate the overall impact of sleep disturbances on
maternal and fetal health outcomes. This approach enables a thorough synthesis of existing
disturbances during pregnancy and adverse maternal outcomes. These may involve a
4. Fetal Outcomes: Sleep disruptions during pregnancy are also associated with negative fetal
outcomes, such as low birth weight, intrauterine growth restriction, and an increased
5. Biological Mechanisms: The article explores potential biological mechanisms that underlie
the observed correlations. Disruptions in hormonal regulation, like elevated cortisol levels,
and changes in immune function may contribute to the adverse outcomes seen in both
routinely assess pregnant women for sleep problems and offer suitable interventions, like
7. Limitations and Future Research: Despite providing valuable insights, the meta-analysis
acknowledges limitations in the included studies, such as variations in how sleep disturbances
quality in pregnancy.
In conclusion, this systematic review and meta-analysis emphasize the substantial influence
of sleep disturbances on maternal and fetal health during pregnancy. Addressing sleep quality
as part of prenatal care is vital for optimizing outcomes for both mothers and babies.
Article 4- The effect of caffeine on subsequent sleep: A systematic review and meta-analysis
This systematic review and meta-analysis examine the influence of caffeine consumption on
the quality and duration of subsequent sleep. Through a comprehensive synthesis of existing
research, the authors seek to offer insights into the association between caffeine consumption
and various aspects of sleep. The primary aim of this research is to assess the impact of
reported by participants and objective measures such as sleep onset latency, total sleep time,
and sleep architecture. The study utilizes a systematic review and meta-analysis approach,
from eligible studies to facilitate more robust conclusions. Various forms of caffeine intake,
including coffee, tea, energy drinks, and caffeine-containing medications or supplements, are
considered in the analysis. Different doses and timing of caffeine consumption are also taken
into consideration to evaluate their distinct effects on subsequent sleep. The meta-analysis
participants' subjective evaluations of factors like sleep satisfaction, perceived sleep depth,
such as sleep onset latency, wake after sleep onset, total sleep time, and sleep efficiency, are
integrated into the analysis to provide more detailed insights into the physiological impacts of
caffeine on sleep architecture. The findings from the systematic review and meta-analysis
indicate that caffeine consumption disrupts both subjective sleep quality and objective sleep
parameters. Commonly observed effects following caffeine intake include increased sleep
onset latency, decreased total sleep time, and changes in sleep architecture, particularly when
consumed in the evening or close to bedtime. The implications of these findings for clinical
especially in the hours preceding bedtime, to mitigate potential adverse effects on subsequent
sleep. Healthcare providers may also consider assessing patients' caffeine consumption as
part of sleep evaluation and management strategies. The study acknowledges limitations such
subsequent sleep. In conclusion, this systematic review and meta-analysis offer evidence of
the detrimental effects of caffeine consumption on subsequent sleep quality and duration.
Understanding these effects can guide recommendations for moderating caffeine intake to
Article 5- The future of sleep health: a data-driven revolution in sleep science and medicine
propelling advancements in the field of sleep science and medicine. It offers a glimpse into
the prospective landscape of sleep health research and clinical practice by employing cutting-
edge technologies and extensive data analytics. The authors anticipate a shift in approach
related ailments.
Introduction to Data-Driven Sleep Health: The article initiates a discussion on the concept of
sources, including wearables, electronic health records (EHRs), genetic data, and
environmental information, to acquire holistic insights into sleep patterns and their
implications on health.
Quantified Self and Wearable Technology: The rise of wearable gadgets capable of
monitoring sleep metrics such as duration, quality, and stages has empowered individuals to
monitor their sleep patterns continuously. The article explores the potential of utilizing this
Big Data Analytics and Machine Learning: Developments in big data analytics and machine
from vast sleep datasets. These methodologies can aid in discovering new biomarkers,
identifying risk factors for sleep disorders, and creating predictive models to assess individual
Genomics and Sleep Genetics: The integration of genetic data into sleep research holds
promise in unraveling the genetic underpinnings of sleep disorders and individual differences
in sleep characteristics. Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) and polygenic risk scores
(PRS) can provide insights into the heritability of sleep-linked traits and guide personalized
treatment approaches.
environmental elements such as light exposure, noise pollution, temperature, and air quality
environments.
Clinical Applications and Precision Sleep Medicine: Data-driven insights have the potential
sleep profiles and genetic inclinations can optimize treatment outcomes and enhance patient
compliance.
Challenges and Ethical Considerations: The article acknowledges hurdles related to data
privacy, data accuracy, and algorithmic partiality in the utilization of data-driven strategies in
sleep health. Ethical concerns, such as ensuring fair access to data and addressing potential
methodologies in shaping the future of sleep health research and clinical care. Through the
sleep science and medicine is on the brink of a data-driven revolution that pledges to enhance
In summary, the article offers a convincing overview of the possibilities and obstacles linked
and clinical practice. Embracing this paradigm shift stands to unlock fresh insights into sleep
1. Nelson KL, Davis JE, Corbett CF. Sleep quality: An evolutionary concept
Manjunatha N, Nebhinani N, Gaur N, Kumar N, Dalal PK, Kumar P, Midha PK, Daga
R, Tikka SK, Praharaj SK, Goyal SK, Kanchan S, Sarkar S, Das S, Sarkhel S, Padhy
Avasthi A. Changes in sleep pattern and sleep quality during COVID-19 lockdown.
PMCID: PMC7597722.
DOI: 10.4103/psychiatry.IndianJPsychiatry_523_20
3. Qingdong Lu, Xiaoyan Zhang, Yunhe Wang, Jinqiao Li, Yingying Xu, Xiaohong Song,
Sizhen Su, Ximei Zhu, Michael V. Vitiello, Jie Shi, Yanping Bao, Lin Lu, Sleep disturbances
during pregnancy and adverse maternal and fetal outcomes: A systematic review and
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.smrv.2021.101436.
(https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1087079221000216)
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.smrv.2021.101436
4. Carissa Gardiner, Jonathon Weakley, Louise M. Burke, Gregory D. Roach, Charli Sargent,
Nirav Maniar, Andrew Townshend, Shona L. Halson, The effect of caffeine on subsequent
sleep: A systematic review and meta-analysis, Medicine Reviews, Volume 69, 2023, 101764,
(https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1087079223000205)
5. Perez-Pozuelo, I., Zhai, B., Palotti, J. et al. The future of sleep health: a data-driven
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41746-020-0244-4