Weld Repair After PWHT ASME Sec VIII Div.1
Weld Repair After PWHT ASME Sec VIII Div.1
Weld Repair After PWHT ASME Sec VIII Div.1
23 Aug 2011
Page 1 of 6
07-1400
Rev 2
Case ____
Section VIII, Division 1
Weld Repair Without Subsequent PWHT Using the Gas Tungsten Arc Welding
Process
Inquiry: In addition to the Shielded Metal Arc Welding Process, may the Gas
Tungsten Arc Welding Process be used to deposit weld metal for weld repairs to
P-No. 1 Group Nos. 1, 2, and 3 materials and to the weld metals used to join
these materials after the final PWHT but prior to the final hydrostatic test, without
additional PWHT?
Reply: It is the opinion of the Committee that in addition to the Shielded Metal
Arc Welding Process, the Gas Tungsten Arc Welding Process may be used to
deposit weld metal for weld repairs to P-No. 1 Group Nos. 1, 2, and 3 materials
and to the weld metals used to join these materials after the final PWHT but prior
to the final hydrostatic test, without additional PWHT, provided all other
requirements of UCS-56(f) are met.
This Case number shall be shown on the Manufacturer’s Data Report.
07-1400
23 Aug 2011
FOR INFORMATION ONLY - NO CHANGES TO THIS PAGE Page 2 of 6
2011a SECTION VIII — DIVISION 1
UCS-12 BARS AND SHAPES (b) Shells of pressure vessels may be made from electric
resistance welded pipe or tubing listed in Table 1A of
(a) Approved specifications for bar and shape materials
Section II, Part D in nominal diameters up to 30 in. (750
of carbon steel are given in Table UCS-23. A tabulation
mm) provided the material is manufactured by the open-
of allowable stress values at different temperatures are
hearth, basic oxygen, or electric-furnace process [see
given in Table 1A of Section II, Part D.
UG-16(d)].
(b) Bolt materials as described in UCS-10 may be used
as bar materials.
(c) Parts made from bars, on which welding is done, UCS-28 THICKNESS OF SHELLS UNDER
shall be of material for which a P-Number for procedure EXTERNAL PRESSURE
qualification is given in Section IX, QW-422 (see UW-5).
(a) Cylindrical and spherical shells under external pres-
sure shall be designed by the rules in UG-28, using the
applicable figures in Subpart 3 of Section II, Part D and
DESIGN the temperature limits of UG-20(c).
UCS-16 GENERAL (b) Examples illustrating the use of the charts in the
figures for the design of vessels under external pressure
The rules in the following paragraphs apply specifically are given in Appendix L.
to the design of pressure vessels and vessel parts that are (c) Corrugated shells subject to external pressure may
constructed of carbon and low alloy steel and shall be used be used in pressure vessels in accordance with PFT-19 of
in conjunction with the general requirements for Design Section I.
in Subsection A and with the specific requirements for
Design in Subsection B that pertain to the method of fabri-
cation used. UCS-29 STIFFENING RINGS FOR SHELLS
UNDER EXTERNAL PRESSURE
UCS-19 WELDED JOINTS Rules covering the design of stiffening rings are given
in UG-29. An example illustrating the use of these rules
When radiographic examination is required for butt is given in Appendix L.
welded joints by UCS-57, joints of Categories A and B
(see UW-3) shall be of Type No. (1) or No. (2) of Table
UW-12. UCS-30 ATTACHMENT OF STIFFENING
RINGS TO SHELL
UCS-23 MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE STRESS Rules covering the attachment of stiffening rings are
VALUES given in UG-30.
Tables 3 (for bolting) and 1A (other materials) in Section
II, Part D give the maximum allowable stress values at UCS-33 FORMED HEADS, PRESSURE ON
the temperature indicated for materials conforming to the CONVEX SIDE
specifications listed therein.2 Values may be interpolated
for intermediate temperatures. (See UG-23.) For vessels Ellipsoidal, torispherical, hemispherical, and conical
designed to operate at a temperature below −20°F (−29°C), heads having pressure on the convex side (minus heads)
the allowable stress values to be used in design shall not shall be designed by the rules of UG-33, using Fig. CS-1
exceed those given in Table 3 or 1A in Section II, Part D or Fig. CS-2 of Subpart 3 of Section II, Part D. Examples
for 100°F (40°C). illustrating the application of this paragraph are given in
Appendix L.
--```,``,,`,``,`,,,,,,`,,,`,,```-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
168
Copyright ASME International (BPVC)
Provided by IHS under license with ASME eader.htm` Licensee=BP International/5928366101, User=Rodery, Clay
No reproduction or networking permitted without license from IHS Not for Resale, 07/06/2011 17:01:24 MDT
07-1400
23 Aug 2011
FOR INFORMATION ONLY - NO CHANGES TO THIS PAGE Page 3 of 6
2011a SECTION VIII — DIVISION 1
or lack of postweld heat treatment and including other but in no case more than 400°F /hr (222°C/h). During the
restrictions listed below. heating period there shall not be a greater variation in
Except as otherwise specifically provided in the notes temperature throughout the portion of the vessel being
to Table UCS-56 and Table UCS-56.1, all welds in pressure heated than 250°F (140°C) within any 15 ft (4.6 m) interval
vessels or pressure vessel parts shall be given a postweld of length.
heat treatment at a temperature not less than specified in (3) The vessel or vessel part shall be held at or above
those Tables when the nominal thickness, as defined in the temperature specified in Table UCS-56 or Table UCS-
UW-40(f), including corrosion allowance, exceeds the lim- 56.1 for the period of time specified in the Tables. During
its in those Tables. The exemptions provided in Table the holding period, there shall not be a greater difference
UCS-56 or Table UCS-56.1 are not permitted when post- than 150°F (83°C) between the highest and lowest tempera-
weld heat treatment is a service requirement as set forth ture throughout the portion of the vessel being heated,
in UCS-68, when welding ferritic materials greater than 1⁄8 except where the range is further limited in Table UCS-56.
in. (3 mm) thick with the electron beam welding process, (4) During the heating and holding periods, the fur-
or when welding P-No. 3, P-No. 4, P-Nos. 5A, 5B, and nace atmosphere shall be so controlled as to avoid exces-
5C, P-No. 10, and P-No. 15E materials of any thickness sive oxidation of the surface of the vessel. The furnace
using the inertia and continuous drive friction welding shall be of such design as to prevent direct impingement
processes. Electroslag welds in ferritic materials over 11⁄2
of the flame on the vessel.
in. (38 mm) thickness at the joint shall be given a grain
(5) Above 800°F (425°C), cooling shall be done in
refining (austenitizing) heat treatment. Electrogas welds in
a closed furnace or cooling chamber at a rate3 not greater
ferritic materials with any single pass greater than 11⁄2 in.
than 500°F /hr (280°C /h) divided by the maximum metal
(38 mm) shall be given a grain refining (austenitizing) heat
treatment. For P-No. 1 materials only, the heating and thickness of the shell or head plate in inches, but in no
cooling rate restrictions of (d)(2) and (d)(5) below do not case more than 500°F /hr (280°C /h). From 800°F (425°C)
apply when the heat treatment following welding is in the the vessel may be cooled in still air.
austenitizing range. (e) Except as permitted in (f) below, vessels or parts of
The materials in Table UCS-56 are listed in accordance vessels that have been postweld heat treated in accordance
with Section IX P-Number material groupings of QW-422 with the requirements of this paragraph shall again be
and also listed in Table UCS-23. postweld heat treated after welded repairs have been made.
(b) Except where prohibited in Table UCS-56, holding (f) Weld repairs to P-No. 1 Group Nos. 1, 2, and 3
temperatures and /or holding times in excess of the mini- materials and to P-No. 3 Group Nos. 1, 2, and 3 materials
mum values given in Table UCS-56 may be used. Interme- and to the weld metals used to join these materials may
diate postweld heat treatments need not conform to the be made after the final PWHT but prior to the final hydro-
requirements of Table UCS-56. The holding time at tem- static test, without additional PWHT, provided that PWHT
perature as specified in Table UCS-56 need not be continu- is not required as a service requirement in accordance with
ous. It may be an accumulation of time of multiple postweld UW-2(a), except for the exemptions in Table UCS-56, or
heat treatment cycles. as a service requirement in accordance with UCS-68. The
(c) When pressure parts of two different P-Number welded repairs shall meet the requirements of (1) through
groups are joined by welding, the postweld heat treatment (6) below. These requirements do not apply when the
shall be that specified in either of Tables UCS-56 or welded repairs are minor restorations of the material sur-
UHA-32, with applicable notes, for the material requiring face, such as those required after removal of construction
the higher postweld temperature. When nonpressure parts fixtures, and provided that the surface is not exposed to
are welded to pressure parts, the postweld heat treatment the vessel contents.
temperature of the pressure part shall control. (1) The Manufacturer shall give prior notification of
(d) The operation of postweld heat treatment shall be
--```,``,,`,``,`,,,,,,`,,,`,,```-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
178
--```,``,,`,``,`,,,,,,`,,,`,,```-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
(2) The circumferential soak band width may be varied away from the nozzle or attachment weld requiring PWHT,
provided the required soak band around the nozzle or attachment weld is heated to the required temperature and held
for the required time. As an alternative to varying the soak band width, the temperature within the circumferential band
away from the nozzle or attachment may be varied and need not reach the required temperature, provided the required
soak band around the nozzle or attachment weld is heated to the required temperature, held for the required time, and
the temperature gradient is not harmful throughout the heating and cooling cycle. The portion of the vessel outside of the
circumferential soak band shall be protected so that the temperature gradient is not harmful.
(b) The procedure in paragraph (a) may also be used to postweld heat treat portions of vessels after repairs.
6.4.3.7 Local Area Heating of Double Curvature Heads or Shells. Postweld heat treatment is performed by heating a
local area around nozzles or welded attachments in the larger radius sections of a double curvature head or a spherical
shell or head in such a manner that the area is brought up uniformly to the required temperature and held for the
specified time. The soak band shall include the nozzle or welded attachment. The minimum soak band size shall be a circle
whose radius is the widest width of the weld attaching the nozzle, reinforcing plate, or structural attachment to the shell,
plus the nominal thickness as defined in paragraph 6.4.2.7, or 50 mm (2 in.), whichever is less. The portion of the vessel
outside of the soak band shall be protected so that the temperature gradient is not harmful.
6.4.3.8 Heating of Other Configurations. Postweld heat treatment performed by local area heating of other
configurations such as “spot” or bulls eye” local heating not addressed in paragraphs 6.4.3.2 through 6.4.3.7 is permitted
provided that other measures (based upon sufficiently similar documented experience or evaluation) are taken that
consider the effect of thermal gradients, all significant structural discontinuities (such as nozzles, attachments, head-
to-shell junctions), and any mechanical loads which may be present during PWHT. The portion of the vessel outside of the
soak band shall be protected so that the temperature gradient is not harmful. The soak band shall include a circle that
extends beyond the edges of the attachment weld in all directions by a minimum of the nominal thickness defined in
paragraph 6.4.2.7 or 50 mm (2 in.), whichever is less.
641 --```,``,,`,``,`,,,,,,`,,,`,,```-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
(c) The Manufacturer shall give prior notification of the repair to the user or to his designated agent and shall not
proceed until acceptance has been obtained. Such repairs shall be recorded on the Data Report.
(d) The total repair depth shall not exceed 38 mm (1-1/2 in.) for P-No. 1 Gr. Nos. 1-3 materials and 16 mm (5/8 in.) for
P-No. 3 Gr. Nos. 1-3 materials. The total depth of a weld repair shall be taken as the sum of the depths for repairs made
from both sides of a weld at a given location.
(e) After removal of the defect, the groove shall be examined, using either the magnetic particle or liquid penetrant
examination methods in accordance with Part 7.
(f) In addition to the requirements of Section IX for qualification of Welding Procedure Specifications for groove welds,
the following requirements shall apply.
(1) The weld shall be deposited by the manual shielded metal arc process using low hydrogen electrodes. The
electrodes shall be properly conditioned in accordance with Section II, Part C, SFA-5.5. The maximum bead width shall be
four times the electrode core diameter.
(2) For P-No. 1 Gr. Nos. 1-3 materials, the repair area shall be preheated and maintained at a minimum temperature
of 95°C (200°F) during welding.
(3) For P-No. 3 Gr. Nos. 1-3 materials, the repair weld method shall be limited to the SMAW half bead weld repair and
weld temper bead reinforcement technique. The repair area shall be preheated and maintained at a minimum
temperature of 175°C (350°F) during welding. The maximum interpass temperature shall be 230°C (450°F). The initial
layer of weld metal shall be deposited over the entire area using 3 mm (1/8 in.) maximum diameter electrodes.
Approximately one-half the thickness of this layer shall be removed by grinding before depositing subsequent layers. The
subsequent weld layers shall be deposited using 4 mm (5/32 in.) maximum diameter electrodes in such a manner as to
ensure tempering of the prior weld beads and their heat affected zones. A final temper bead weld shall be applied to a
level above the surface being repaired without contacting the base material but close enough to the edge of the underlying
weld bead to ensure tempering of the base material heat affected zone. After completing all welding, the repair area shall
be maintained at a temperature of 205°C (400°F) to 260°C (500°F) for a minimum of 4 hr. The final temper bead
reinforcement layer shall be removed substantially flush with the surface of the base material.
(g) After the finished repair weld has reached ambient temperature, it shall be examined using the magnetic particle or
liquid penetrant examination methods in accordance with Part 7. If the examination is by magnetic particle method, only
the alternating current yoke type is acceptable. For P-No. 3 Gr. No.3 materials, the examination shall be made after the
material has been at ambient temperature for a minimum period of 48 hr to determine the presence of possible delayed
cracking of the weld. In addition, welded repairs greater than 10 mm (3/8 in.) deep in materials, and in welds that are
required to be examined using the radiographic method in accordance with Part 7, shall be examined using the
radiographic method in accordance with Part 7.
(h) The vessel shall be hydrostatically tested after making the welded repair. Alternatively, for P-No. 1
Group Nos. 1-3 materials,
6.4.6 POSTWELD HEAT TREATMENT OF NONFERROUS MATERIALS
the gas tungsten arc
6.4.6.1 Postweld heat treatment of nonferrous materials is normally not necessary nor iswelding it desirable. Except as
process may be
required in paragraphs 6.4.6.2, 6.4.6.3, and 6.4.6.4, postweld heat treatment shall not be performed except by agreement
used with the
between the purchaser and the Manufacturer. The temperature, time and method of heat treatment shall be covered by addition of
agreement. filler metal.
6.4.6.2 If welded, castings of SB-148, Alloy CDA 954 shall be heat treated after all welding at 620°C - 640°C (1150°F
- 1200°F) for 1.5 hr for the 25 mm (1 in.) of cross section thickness plus 0.5 hr for each additional 25 mm (1 in.) of section
thickness. The material shall then be air cooled.
6.4.6.3 Within 14 days after welding, all products of zirconium Grade R60705 shall be heat treated at 500°C - 610°C
(1000°F - 1100°F) for a minimum of 1 hr for thicknesses up to 25 mm (1 in.) plus 0.5 hr for each additional 25 mm (1 in.)
of thickness. Above 430°C (800°F) cooling shall be done at a rate not greater than 280°C/hr (500°F/hr) divided by the
maximum metal thickness of the shell or head plate in inches but in no case more than 280°C/hr (500°F /hr). From 430°C
(800°F), the vessel may be cooled in still air.
--```,``,,`,``,`,,,,,,`,,,`,,```-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
6.4.6.4 Postweld Heat Treatment of UNS Numbers N08800, N08810 and N08811 Alloys.
(a) Pressure boundary welds and welds to pressure boundaries in vessels with design temperatures above 540°C
(1000°F) fabricated from UNS No. N08800 (Alloy 800), UNS No. N08810 (Alloy 800H), or UNS No. N08811 (Alloy 800HT)
shall be postweld heat treated. The postweld heat treatment shall consist of heating to a minimum temperature of 885°C
(1625°F) for 1.5 hr for thicknesses up to 25 mm (1 in.), and for 1.5 hr plus 0.04 hr/mm (1 hr/in.) of thickness for
thicknesses in excess of 25 mm (1 in.). Cooling and heating rates shall be by agreement between the purchaser and
Manufacturer. As an alternative, solution annealing in accordance with the material specification is acceptable. Postweld
heat treatment of tube-to-tubesheet and expansion bellows attachment welds is neither required nor prohibited.
642
Copyright ASME International (BPVC)
Provided by IHS under license with ASME pe.class Licensee=BP International/5928366101, User=Rodery, Clay
No reproduction or networking permitted without license from IHS Not for Resale, 07/06/2011 17:02:23 MDT