Focus: Ultrasonic Testing of Anchor Bolts
Focus: Ultrasonic Testing of Anchor Bolts
Focus: Ultrasonic Testing of Anchor Bolts
Vol. 13,
19, No.
No. 1
1
FOCUS
foundation and the bottom of the base a top nut with 75% or more thread
plate is more than 2× the bolt diameter, engagement is acceptable (Garlich and
as demonstrated in Figure 2 (Garlich and Thorkildsen 2005, p. 80).
Thorkildsen 2005, p. 32). For nuts with less than full thread
Cantilever sign engagement, it should be noted on the
inspection report that the ultrasonic
Ultrasonic Inspection Procedure scanning area will be reduced because
Each state department of transportation
the transducer cannot get as close to the
should have a specific ultrasonic inspection
edge as it could in the case of full thread
Chord Chord-pole Pole procedure, not just a reference to ASTM
connection engagement (Figure 5).
E114. A common problem is that these
inspection procedures and reports do not
have all the information that both the Preparation for Inspection
technician and engineer need to know. Preparation of the anchor bolts for the
The result could be misleading or cause inspection requires the top surface of the
Anchor bolt incomplete inspection results, and in a bolt to be ground smooth, flat, and level.
Base plate worst-case scenario, a cracked anchor bolt That would require having an electrical
could be missed. generator on site and two different types
Foundation As an example, a procedure that calls for of grinders. The generator would need to
a 0°, 5 MHz, 0.5 in. (12.7 mm) diameter have enough running wattage to run the
transducer might be limited to a 1 in. grinders. For bolts where the nuts have
Figure 1. Diagram of cantilever sign. (25.4 mm) diameter and larger anchor full thread engagement, an angle grinder
bolts. Bolts smaller than 1 in. (25.4 mm) is needed. But if the nuts have less than
may require a different transducer and full thread engagement, a technician
day, stood next to a highway sign with nuts reference standard. The following sections would need a rotary tool grinder with a
that are not in firm contact with the base illustrate examples of other things the small-diameter grinding stone. If the top
plate, you will see the sign rocking back inspection procedure might not tell a surface of the bolt has not already been
and forth. practitioner. ground smooth, it is recommended that
Another reason why anchor bolts crack the product marking as defined by ASTM
could be the stress put on them if the F1554 be noted on the report, as seen in
Transducer for the Inspection Table 1 (ASTM 2018, paragraphs 18 and
standoff distance between the top of the
Typically, the transducer required is 0°,
S3). While grinding, look for cracks on the
5 MHz, and 0.5 in. (12.7 mm) in
top of the bolt (Figure 6).
diameter, but the procedure might not
Anchor bolt specify that a cable connection on the top TABLE 1
will be needed. A transducer with the cable ASTM F1554 product markings*
Top nut
connection on the side might not be able Color Blue Yellow Red
Projection distance
Top nut
to properly sit on top of the bolt being
Stamp AB 36 AB 55 AB 105
Base plate tested if the nut has 75% or less thread
engagement (Figure 3). Grade 36 55 105
Leveling Full thread engagement is when the * ASTM 2018, ASTM F1554-18: Standard Specification
Leveling nut
nut Standoff end of the bolt is even with or above the for Anchor Bolts, Steel, 36, 55, and 105-ksi Yield
distance Strength, ASTM International, West Conshokocken, PA.
outer face of the nut. The percentage of
thread engagement should also be reported.
This can be solved with basic math. As an
Foundation In addition to the grinding disks and
example, if a top nut is 2 in. (50.8 mm)
small-diameter grinding stones, the
tall but the anchor bolt is 0.5 in. (12.7 mm)
technician will also need some cutting
Figure 2. Diagram of anchor bolts
below the top surface of the nut, that
wheels. On some structures, the anchor
and nuts, and standoff and projection equates to 1.5 in. (38.1 mm), or 75% of
bolt nuts have covers on top. If the erection
distance. the threads engaged (Figure 4). Typically,
The following article is the first of a two-part series on nonde- of aerospace structures and systems is determined by using
structive testing (NDT) for the aerospace industry. These articles some level of nondestructive testing (NDT) both during
have been excerpted from Aerospace NDT, an ASNT Industry manufacturing and throughout the life cycle of the vehicle.
Handbook (2014), for which I served as technical editor. Avionics are generally the aviation electronics,
Part 1 is a brief introduction to structure, design, and material computers, and software that govern guidance and control,
selection considerations for aerospace structure taken from the communication, navigation, weather, weapons, and
chapter written by Joe Gabris. Because of the serious consequences anticollision systems. Systems may be broken into many
of a failure in aircraft and aerospace systems (loss of human life categories, such as propulsion, environmental control,
and/or significant cost), NDT plays a significant role in the hydraulics, and armament. Some typical components of
design and material selection decisions that must be made. aircraft structure are illustrated in Figure 1.
Part 2, which will be published in April, will focus on NDT Aerospace vehicles are commonly segregated into four
of composites, which are now widely employed in aircraft and categories: aircraft, spacecraft, missiles, and rockets. The
spacecraft structures. This article will touch on the key NDT intended use or mission of the air vehicle provides the basis
methods that are selected for applications in the aerospace for system and structure design.
industry.
—Richard H. Bossi, Technical Editor of Aerospace NDT, an
ASNT Industry Handbook
Nondestructive Testing Overview
Nondestructive testing, inspection, evaluation, and
characterization (NDT, NDI, NDE, and NDC) are all
Background terms that relate to using processes that check for quality
Aerospace vehicles include air vehicles, spacecraft, rockets, and and suitability for service without altering the product being
missiles. Ensuring the integrity of the vehicle structure and examined. NDT and NDI are usually used synonymously
associated avionics and systems is essential when considering for the examination and measurement process and for
manufacturing costs, the value of items that are transported, comparisons to specification-based accept/reject criteria.
and human safety. NDE and NDC are terms that are used for relating the
The structure is the aerospace vehicle’s frame, which carries nondestructive measurements to fitness of the object for
the loads during initiation of flight, during execution of the service. In aerospace applications, the consequences of failure
mission, and in some cases during recovery of the vehicle. of a component are often dire in terms of risk to life or cost.
Aerospace structure is commonly divided into (1) primary Thus, NDT, in all its forms, becomes a very fundamental part
structure, the failure of which will cause loss of life or loss of every aerospace product.
of the vehicle, and (2) secondary structure. The integrity
TABLE 1
begins with the primary design of the vehicle followed by the
The importance of nondestructive testing (ASNT 1959) manufacture and assembly of the first several air vehicles that will
To ensure product reliability be used in the certification process. During primary design, the
basic external applied loads are established, which allows calculation
To prevent accidents and save human lives
of internal element loads. External loads are then distributed
To make a profit for the user (add value) into the allowable internal element loads that will meet strength
To ensure customer satisfaction and to maintain the manufacturer’s good requirements. Factors of safety are determined for the primary
reputation structure that serves as the major load path. With this knowledge,
To aid in better product design selection of material and geometry of the structure may be defined
and the parts sized for the aircraft structure. Initial sizing is
To control manufacturing processes
based upon static loads, but fatigue loading becomes the primary
To lower manufacturing cost consideration in the final design of the structure. Systems design
To maintain a uniform quality level occurs in parallel with structure design, and as the general shape
and size of the structure is refined, so are the systems. Although
systems do not carry primary structural aircraft loads, system parts
and construction geometry, (5) integration of new fabrication are designed and sized based on reliable functioning of the system
and assembly processes, (6) exploration of tooling concepts for for the life of the vehicle.
fabrication and assembly, and (7) performing effects of anomalies After parts are sized, initial vehicle weights are adjusted and
study programs. power plant requirements for lift, thrust, and range are refined.
This phase may last several years, with the results of the various Production drawings (or models) are then completed. During
analytical and laboratory testing reported to the design team to this period of sizing and design, NDT engineers develop process
create a refined definition of all aspects of the air vehicle. Prime specifications that establish requirements for the various test
contractors of the vehicle typically partner with subcontractors of methods, including the acceptance/rejection criteria for features
systems and propulsion systems to ensure a parallel initial design or anomalies that may be detected by the selected NDT method.
phase to be integrated in the overall air vehicle. NDT plays an These criteria are established by testing or analysis and coordinated
important role during the initial design phase, where there is a great with the structural and materials engineers. NDT engineers work
deal of interaction with structural and design engineers on activities. with the design engineers to identify the NDT process specifications
This can include: and acceptance criteria to be called out on the engineering drawings
l Evaluation of various inspection methods to provide the optimum
and models. NDT engineers also participate in the evaluation
inspection for the material/geometry. and qualification of subcontractors that will perform NDT on
l Determination of the type, size, and effects of anomalies that can
production and test parts. Close communication between the NDT
be found in a material or geometry. Where inspections cannot be engineer and quality assurance NDT specialists is necessary early
performed, structural engineers will have to assume an anomaly in the design process to develop the NDT philosophy and provide
could be present in their analysis, which can result in heavier adequate time to plan NDT activities before the fabrication of
structure to compensate. parts. Some of the NDT activities that require advance planning
l Evaluation of specimens for material property tests (before,
are (1) development of detailed inspection techniques, (2) design of
during, and after testing). associated tooling for NDT equipment and to hold objects during
Structural and design engineers use the results of these studies NDT operations, (3) identification and procurement of NDT
to determine allowable loads, refine design geometries, select equipment, (4) design and fabrication of reference standards, and
fabrication processes, and develop in-service inspection concepts (5) determination of inspection sequence during the manufacturing
during the primary design phase. NDT personnel involved in and assembly process.
these activities need to be knowledgeable about the variety of test A critical design review (CDR) is normally performed when
techniques and alternatives that may be applied, as well as the most of the structural design has been established and at the early
consequences of variations in their application. stages of fabrication. As fabrication of parts begins, raw material
manufacturers perform NDT on raw material and starting stock for
Primary Design and Fabrication key structural components as required by engineering drawings and
The primary design and fabrication process has also been known as models. After raw material is fabricated into parts and assembled,
the full-scale development (FSD) or the engineering manufacturing NDT is performed at various stages to verify that discontinuities
development (EMD) phase of an aircraft program. This phase do not exceed the acceptance criteria. Typically, the first few fully
6 7 8
9 10 11
12 13 14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
ACROSS DOWN
4. Radioscopic inspection technique by which computer analysis 1. The adjustment of an NDT instrument using an appropriate
of the radiation passing through an object at many orientations reference standard, to obtain or establish a known and
(projections) about the object is used to construct virtual two- reproducible response.
dimensional slices or three-dimensional representations of a 2. Hollow spot, depression, or cavity.
component (two words). 3. Scale for temperature based on 32 °F as the freezing point
5. Photometric brightness of a light source defined by the density of water and 212 °F as the boiling point of water at standard
of its luminous intensity, measured as luminous flux per unit solid atmospheric pressure.
angle per unit area in a given direction. 6. The ratio of apparent image size of an object viewed through an
11. Material or object used to reduce intensity of, or exposure to, optical system to its actual size.
penetrating radiation. 7. Ability of a material to regain its former shape after removal of
13. Device that measures exposure to, or dose rate of, ionizing applied stress.
radiation. 8. Instrument that provides enlarged images of small objects.
15. Decrease in energy or signal magnitude in transmission from one 9. Permissible deviation or variation from exact dimensions or
point to another. standards.
16. Penetrating electromagnetic radiation emitted when the inner 10. Planar discontinuity, generally an area of unbonded materials.
orbital electrons of an atom are excited and release energy. It may be encountered in wrought products, such as plate, or in
18. For film, semi-logarithmic graphical representation of the composite laminate materials.
relationship between optical density and the logarithm of relative 12. In welding, a single bead of weld metal along the entire joint or
exposure. Also called sensitometric curve, hurter and driffield curve, the process of laying down that bead.
H & D curve, or density curve (2 words). 14. Reflection and refraction of radiation caused by interaction with
19. A response to a nondestructive test that requires interpretation to material it strikes or penetrates.
determine its relevance. 17. Single addressable point in a raster digital image. The image from
20. Particle of light, hypothesized to explain those behaviors of light a conventional computer is an array of these, and each has a
in which its behavior is corpuscular (such as little particles), rather numerical value.
than wavelike.
21. Image grayscale or signal levels from a test object that constitute
the intensity variations from which a discontinuity is detected.
10. delamination 6. magnification 19. indication 13. dosimeter
17. pixel 9. tolerance 3. fahrenheit 18. characteristic curve 11. shielding
14. scattering 8. microscope 2. void 21. background 16. X-ray 5. luminance
12. pass 7. elasticity 1. standardization 20. photon 15. attenuation 4. computed tomography
Down Across
Professional Connections allow companies to showcase their business cards. Check out the
various products and services on display each issue to see what may be of value to you.
TCI, Inc.
2020 Independence Commerce Drive, Suite E & F
Matthews, NC 28105
Ph: (704) 321-7272 Fax: (704) 321-3052
Kirsten Groenewald spends her career manager assistant and NDT technician. I received additional
in the office, lab, and the fabrication on-the-job training and through FlawTech’s employer-
and machine shop overseeing the based SNT-TC-1A program, I have obtained my Level II
quality, safety, and compliance of certifications in MT and PT. I am currently working on
flawed specimens for the purpose of obtaining my Level II for UT.
nondestructive testing for FlawTech. Q. Can you describe the work that you do?
She holds Level II certification in A. I am the quality assurance manager and operations manager
MT and PT through her employer- for FlawTech. I provide oversight to quality and safety
based SNT-TC-1A program, as well related project scopes, ensuring that work is performed in
as associate’s degrees in topography compliance with the applicable quality assurance procedures,
and civil engineering, and an work instructions, and delivery schedules. I maintain our
associate’s degree in nondestructive nuclear safety-related quality assurance program that is in
examination from Central Piedmont accordance with 10CFR50 Appendix B and ASME NQA-1,
Community College. which includes performing and hosting vendor/supplier
audits. A large part of my day includes quoting and cost
Q. How did you first become involved in NDT? estimating. I also provide technical support to customers,
A. I started my college education by completing an associate’s which includes reviewing procedures, recommending
degree in topography. At that time I was an aspiring products, and offering technical assistance on our products.
architect; I wanted to design neighborhoods. In addition I also assist as needed with MT, PT, and UT inspections.
to topography, I completed an associate’s degree in civil Q. What is your typical working environment?
engineering technology, gaining additional certificates
A. I spend the majority of my time in an office, lab, or in our
specializing in project supervision, construction materials
fabrication and machine shop. We have about 20 employees
testing, and survey fundamentals. It was at this time that I
involved in manufacturing and machining and about five
was introduced to NDT and was instantly fascinated with
administrative/office personnel.
the industry. Fulfilling my curiosity, I enrolled in a few
classes and later graduated from the program. Q. Is your work focused on a particular field?
A. FlawTech manufactures flawed specimens for the purpose
Q. Can you tell us about your certification and training/
of NDT testing. We provide service to the nuclear,
education?
petrochemical, aerospace, automotive, medical, and
A. I completed the associate’s degree program in nondestructive
transportation industries and to educational institutions.
examination from Central Piedmont Community College
We primarily use UT, MT, PT, and VT at our facility. We
in June 2014. This gave me the required classroom and
manufacture a very large number of items, so inspection can
training hours for MT, UT, PT, VT, RT, and ET. I was hired
range from a small bolt to a huge forging.
at FlawTech in September later that year as their operations