Standard: Normalisation Renault Automobiles Service 60201 Section Normes Et Cahiers Des Charges

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 16

STANDARD

01 - 70 - 000 / - - -

ANTI-CORROSION PROTECTION
APPROVAL PROCEDURE

Normalisation Renault Automobiles


Service 60201
Section Normes et Cahiers des Charges
RENAULT 01 - 70 - 000 / - - -

This document is to be considered as a whole the parts of which must not be separated.

©REGIE NATIONALE DES USINES RENAULT S.A. 1995.


No duplication permitted without the consent of the issuing department.
No circulation permitted without the consent of RENAULT.

DATE CREATED

July 1993 --- This issue originates from draft NC 92 206 / - - A.

REVISION

REFERENCED DOCUMENT

© REGIE NATIONALE DES USINES RENAULT S.A. 1995 Page 1/15


RENAULT 01 - 70 - 000 / - - -

1. SUBJECT AND SCOPE

The subject of this procedure is the approval of anti-corrosion protection coating applied to
mechanical and RMU (Repetitive and Multi-User) parts, whether these are elementary or
assembled parts or accessories and body mechanisms.

This standard:

- COMBINES information so as to avoid multiple tests,

- CONSTITUTES complete files for specification authors,

- ENABLES rapid decisions to be made by limiting the required just-in-time tests.

A part if said to be ELEMENTARY when NO operation is performed after the anti-corrosion


protection coating has been applied; the part is delivered to RENAULT and fitted as such
(appendix 1).

An ASSEMBLED part consists of several elementary parts combined AFTER the anti-corrosion
protection coating has been applied, according to mechanical processes (riveting, bolting, crimping,
etc.) and/or welding. Constituent elementary parts may receive different types of anti-corrosion
protection; the assembled part is delivered to RENAULT and fitted as such (appendix 2).

Elementary parts and assembled parts must meet the requirements:

- of STANDARD 01-71-002,

- or of PURCHASE SPECIFICATION 47-01-003,

these requirements are FUNCTIONAL and depend on the position of the elementary part or the
assembled part on the vehicle; these are mission profile-related, i.e. related to the attacks
undergone by the surfaces in contact with the natural environment.

From the technical viewpoint, RENAULT's major counterparts for any proposal for a new protection
or approval of a protection for an elementary part or an assembled part is:

PRODUCT ENGINEERING DEPT.

Department 0852 : Materials Engineering Department (DEMAT) (1)


Department 0878P : Body Engineering Department (DEC) (2)

Any other RENAULT Department contacted by an outside Supplier MUST inform the above-
mentioned departments with a view to concerted action, if required.

Any proposal for protection of a part requested by RENAULT Department MUST have the approval
of the above-mentioned Departments.

This procedure in compliance with the provisions of Standard 00-10-001, offers complete hygiene in
the definition of products and supports RENAULT's strategy within the framework of QCDP
(Quality/Cost/Lead times/Product).

This procedure DOES NOT APPLY to large forgings or castings subject the Purchase
Specification 47-03-006.

(1) Department 0852 : Boulogne Billancourt - Tél. 41 04 41 68


(2) Department 0878P: Centre Technique de Rueil - Tél. 47 77 46 70
(Rueil Engineering Centre)

© REGIE NATIONALE DES USINES RENAULT S.A. 1995 Page 2


RENAULT 01 - 70 - 000 / - - -

2. APPROVAL OF NEW ANTI-CORROSION PROTECTION

The approval of a NEW ANTI-CORROSION PROTECTION is related to the association of:

- a PRODUCT (Formulator),

- an application PROCESS (Applicator).

The following are considered as new anti-corrosion protection systems:

- a NEW COMPOSITION of the protection,

- a NEW STAGE in the protection application process (e.g. finishing).

Approval of a new anti-corrosion protection is granted by RENAULT:

- for ONE PRODUCT (one formulator) implemented via one application PROCESS (one
applicator, one line).

The procedure for approval of a new protection is illustrated in the general block diagram of
appendix 3.

2.1. PHASE 1: PRESENTATION OF A NEW ANTI-CORROSION PROTECTION

In as much as possible, the presentation to RENAULT of a new anti-corrosion protection (a)* shall be
made by the following two partners:

- the product FORMULATOR,

- and the application process APPLICATOR.

Any presentation of a new anti-corrosion protection MUST MANDATORILY be accompanied by a


TECHNICAL-ECONOMIC FILE containing the following information:

a) Definition of the anti-corrosion protection: nature, composition, limits of use (brittlization,


penetration through interstices and hollow bodies, compatibility with other products, etc.), etc.

b) Definition of an anti-corrosion protection process: number of steps, implementation


parameters affecting final behaviour of the anti-corrosion protection, etc.

c) Test experimental results: the tests are performed on reference parts; the latter depend on
the method of application of the protective product: a SCREW for BARREL applied treatments
and a LUG for RACK applied treatments.

The tests requested depend on the reference part and the nature of the anti-corrosion protection.

The reference parts and the tests are defined in appendix 4.

d) Cost: the cost of the anti-corrosion protection is based on the industrial production of the
reference part corresponding to the application method (appendix 4).

.( )*: references to the various steps of appendix 3.

© REGIE NATIONALE DES USINES RENAULT S.A. 1995 Page 3


RENAULT 01 - 70 - 000 / - - -

On completion of presentation (b), a DECISION is given:

- the anti-corrosion protection is considered OF NO INTEREST to RENAULT

→ procedure HALTED

- the anti-corrosion protection is considered INTERESTING to RENAULT

→ procedure CONTINUED.

2.2. PHASE 2: APPROVAL OF A NEW ANTI-CORROSION PROTECTION

The excess treated reference parts, conserved by the Applicator, is sent to RENAULT
Department 0852; this consists of a minimum of:

- 250 screws and flat surface parts for barrel treatment,

- 150 lugs and 25 flat specimens for rack treatment.

RENAULT performs tests on these reference parts in order to (c):

- CONFIRM the results of the technical file presented by the Formulator and the Applicator
during phase 1,

- VALIDATE the anti-corrosion protection according to the position on the vehicle, on


RENAULT's LARDY Engineering Centre Corrosion Circuit (CTL),

- DRAW UP a PRODUCT APPROVAL SHEET (d) for the anti-corrosion protection resulting
from additional tests to define the behaviour of the protection when this is subjected to various
aggressions (knowledge of maximum functionalities).

From the results of all the tests performed, the utilization range for the new anti-corrosion protection
is included in a FUNCTIONAL UTILIZATION TABLE (d).

The PRODUCT APPROVAL SHEET and the FUNCTIONAL UTILIZATION TABLE, drawn up
under the responsibility of Department 0852, are circulated to Department 0878P and the
PURCHASING Departments involved in protection of parts against corrosion.

3. APPROVAL OF A NEW APPLICATOR


APPROVAL OF A PROCESS MAJOR MODIFICATION

The implementation of an APPROVED product (known Formulator) in a NON-APPROVED


application line (other line, other site of known Applicator or other Applicator) is the joint
RESPONSIBILITY of the Formulator and the Applicator.

RENAULT MUST be informed of any major MODIFICATION to the application process of an


APPROVED product-process (known Formulator and Applicator).

In both cases, APPROVAL by RENAULT is granted by Department 0852 after inspection of the
TECHNICAL FILE submitted by the Formulator and the Applicator. This technical file must contain
the results of the SAME tests as those requested on presentation of a new protection. The
functional characteristics to be obtained must be identical to those approved on initial presentation,
and shall be defined by RENAULT.

The list of RENAULT (e) APPROVED PRODUCTS-PROCESSES shall be managed by


Department 0852. Any change or update of this list shall be circulated to Departments 0878P and
PURCHASING Departments 0628, 0753 and 0755.

.(e) reference to corresponding step of appendix 3.

© REGIE NATIONALE DES USINES RENAULT S.A. 1995 Page 4


RENAULT 01 - 70 - 000 / - - -

4. APPROVAL OF ANTI-CORROSION PROTECTION FOR AN ELEMENTARY PART

The sequence of the steps for the approval of an anti-corrosion protection for an ELEMENTARY
PART is illustrated in the general block diagram of appendix 5. This agrees with the Product
Quality Assurance PROCEDURE (Product Quality Assurance: H-QFE 002).

The definition of FUNCTIONAL REQUIREMENTS for an elementary part is the responsibility of the
Design Office Department REQUESTING the part (a)*; in as much as the resistance to corrosion is
concerned, this department is the most competent to:

- know the POSITION and ENVIRONMENT of the part on each vehicle and/or engine,

- propose a system of CODIFICATION for the anti-corrosion protection as per


Standard 01-71-002 or Purchase Specification 47-01-003.

In the event of difficulties or doubt concerning the definition of the codification of the anti-corrosion
protection, Departments 0852 and/or 0878P may be consulted for their recommendations and
opinions (participation in a RENAULT Internal Technical Commission).

NOTE: The requirements SPECIFIED be the Standard and the Purchase Specification mentioned
above apply to AMBIENT aggressions undergone by the OUTSIDE surface of the parts;
the Design Office in charge must also allow for the INTERNAL surface of the part which
may be in contact with vehicle fluids (coolant, oils, etc.).

Via the PURCHASING Department concerned by the elementary part, the functional requirements
shown on the drawing are SUBJECTED to the part Supplier. the latter (b):

- PROPOSES one or several anti-corrosion protection to meet the requirements,

- INDICATES the selected Applicator to produce the corrosion protection.

The PURCHASING Departments concerned by the elementary port (c) GIVE A DECISION on the
Supplier's product-process proposal using the documents in its possession and drawn up by
Department 0852:

- PRODUCT APPROVAL SHEET,

- FUNCTIONAL UTILIZATION TABLE,

- list of APPROVED PRODUCTS-PROCESSES.

If the PRODUCT-PROCESS proposed:

- IS NOT APPROVED by RENAULT (d): it MUST follow the approval procedure for a new
anti-corrosion protection (paragraph 2) or a new application process (paragraph 3) for
APPROVAL or REJECTION. The PURCHASING Departments concerned inform the Supplier
and requesting Design Office Departments, 0852 and 0878P,

- IS APPROVED by RENAULT and MEETS the functional requirements (including the friction
coefficient in cases of bolts, nuts and screws) (e): the PURCHASING Department concerned
by the elementary part starts the Product Quality Assurance PROCEDURE and informs the
Requesting Department of this. Departments 0852 and/or 0878P participate in the
SUPPLIER'S TECHNICAL COMMISSION and the I.S.A.C. (Initial Sample Approval
Commission) for parts initially considered critical in terms of resistance to corrosion. Such
participation is not mandatory for bolts, nuts and screws or simple fastening type parts, since
the reference parts used for Product-process approval (chapters 2 and 3) are considered
sufficiently representative.

.( )*: references to the different steps of appendix 5.

© REGIE NATIONALE DES USINES RENAULT S.A. 1995 Page 5


RENAULT 01 - 70 - 000 / - - -

- IS APPROVED by RENAULT but DOES NOT MEET the functional requirements (f). For bolts,
nuts and screws and if the friction coefficient requirement is not complied with, another anti-
corrosion protection MUST be proposed; in other cases, the PURCHASING Departments
concerned by the elementary part MUST REQUEST from the Supplier of the part to propose
another anti-corrosion treatment meeting the protection requirements.

However, if for reasons of technical impossibility or excessive cost, another anti-corrosion


protection connot be applied, the behaviour of the elementary part is EVALUATED in the
actual configuration on the vehicles, on the LARDY corrosion circuit (g) . Departments 0846
(vehicle corrosion tests), 0852 and 0878P give a decision on the behaviour of the elementary
part after the test.

If the behaviour of the elementary part is considered ACCEPTABLE (b), Department 0878P
informs the Purchasing Department concerned with the elementary part, so as to rapidly begin
the Product Quality Assurance PROCEDURE, and draws up an EXEMPTION for this part.
The exemption is circulated by Department 0878P to the Requesting Design Offices, 0852 and
the Purchasing Departments.

If the behaviour of the elementary part is considered UNACCEPTABLE (i), the Supplier of the
part MUST PROPOSE another anti-corrosion protection.

Compilation of data concerning the elementary parts approved by RENAULT is the


RESPONSIBILITY of the PURCHASING Departments: easily accessible DATA BANKS, in which
each part is identified by its Supplier(s), its anti-corrosion product(s) and its (their) application
process(es).

5. APPROVAL OF AN ANTI-CORROSION PROTECTION FOR AN ASSEMBLED PART

The procedure for the approval of an anti-corrosion protection for an ASSEMBLED PART is given
in the general block diagram of appendix 6; the procedure is comparable to that for elementary
parts.

As for an elementary part, the definition of the FUNCTIONAL REQUIREMENTS for an assembled
part is the responsibility of the DESIGN OFFICE Department REQUESTING the part (a)*; this
Department defines the CODIFICATION of the resistance to corrosion requirement according to
Standard 01-71-002 and Purchase specification 47-01-003. Participation of Departments 0852
and/or 0878P in the RENAULT Internal Technical Commission can assist in defining this
codification.

Via the PURCHASING Department involved with the assembled parts, the functional requirements
of the drawing are SUBMITTED to the Part Supplier. The latter (b):

- INDICATES the GRADE of all non-protected elementary parts and the PRODUCT-PROCESS
for all protected elementary parts constituting the assembled part (intrinsic resistance to
corrosion of each elementary part),

- JUSTIFIES the resistance to corrosion of the assembled part (risk of local damage to the
protection of an elementary part due to assembly and inter-compatibility of the protections on
elementary parts).

To evaluate the risks of local and/or galvanic corrosion, Department 0852 MUST participate in
the Supplier's Technical Commission.

.( )*: references to the different steps of appendix 6.

© REGIE NATIONALE DES USINES RENAULT S.A. 1995 Page 6


RENAULT 01 - 70 - 000 / - - -

Department 0852 and the PURCHASING Departments involved by the assembled part (c), GIVE A
DECISION on the product-process proposals of the Supplier using the documents in their
possession:

- PRODUCT APPROVAL SHEET,

- FUNCTIONAL UTILIZATION TABLE,

- list of APPROVED PRODUCT-PROCESSES.

If the PRODUCT-PROCESSES for the elementary parts proposed:

- ARE APPROVED by RENAULT and the assembled part MEETS the functional
requirements (d), the PURCHASING Department concerned by the assembled part starts the
Product Quality Assurance PROCEDURE and informs the requesting Design Office.
Departments 0852 and/or 0878P participate in the Initial Sample Approval technical
Commission (I.S.A.C.) for parts which have previously been judged critical in terms of
resistance to corrosion,

- * ARE APPROVED by RENAULT, but the assembled part DOES NOT MEET functional
requirements (e),
** or ARE NOT APPROVED by RENAULT (all or some) and the assembled part MEETS or
DOES NOT MEET the functional requirements (f), the behaviour of the assembled part is
EVALUATED in the actual configuration aboard the vehicle on the LARDY Corrosion Circuit (g).
Departments 0846 (Vehicle Corrosion Tests), 0852 and 0878P give a decision on the
behaviour of the assembled part, after the test.

If the behaviour of the assembled part is considered ACCEPTABLE (h), Department 0878P
informs the PURCHASING Department concerned by the assembled part for rapid starting of
the Product Quality Assurance PROCEDURE and draws up an EXEMPTION for this
assembled part. The exemption is circulated by Department 0878P to the requesting Design
Offices, Department 0852 and the Purchasing Departments. Moreover, for product-processes
not approved by RENAULT, the approval procedure for a new anti-corrosion protection
(chapter 2) or a new application process (chapter 3) is implemented by Department 0852.

If the behaviour of the assembled part is considered UNACCEPTABLE (i), the Supplier of the
assembled part MUST PROPOSE another protection for the non-satisfactory elementary parts.

Compilation of the data related to assembled parts approved by RENAULT is the RESPONSIBILY
of the PURCHASING Departments: easily accessible DATA BANKS, in which each part is
identified by its Supplier(s), its anti-corrosion protection product(s) and its protection application
process(es).

© REGIE NATIONALE DES USINES RENAULT S.A. 1995 Page 7


RENAULT 01 - 70 - 000 / - - -

APPENDIX 1

DEFINITION OF ELEMENTARY PART

ELEMENT 1 ELEMENT 2 ELEMENT n

ASSEMBLY

PART A OR PART B

ANTI-CORROSION
TREATMENT

ELEMENTARY
PART
(A or B)

© REGIE NATIONALE DES USINES RENAULT S.A. 1995 Page 8


RENAULT 01 - 70 - 000 / - - -

APPENDIX 2

ASSEMBLED PART DEFINITION

ELEMENT 1 ELEMENT 2 ELEMENT n

ANTI-CORROSION ANTI-CORROSION ANTI-CORROSION


TREATMENT A TREATMENT B TREATMENT X

ASSEMBLY

ASSEMBLED
PART

© REGIE NATIONALE DES USINES RENAULT S.A. 1995 Page 9


RENAULT 01 - 70 - 000 / - - -

APPENDIX 3

APPROVAL OF A NEW
ANTI-CORROSION PROTECTION

© REGIE NATIONALE DES USINES RENAULT S.A. 1995 Page 10


RENAULT 01 - 70 - 000 / - - -

APPENDIX 4

TECHNICAL-ECONOMIC FILE

1. BARREL TREATMENT

1.1. REFERENCE PART

Screw H M8x1,25 class 8.8, length 55, tolerance 6 g, Part N° : 7 703 001 169.

1.2. COST OF ANTI-CORROSION TREATMENT

Price for the treatment of ONE TONNE of reference screws.

1.3. TESTS ON REFERENCE SCREWS

The treated reference screws must be obtained from an industrial production run (minimum one
barrel). In as much as possible, and at the same time as the screws, some parts offering a flat
surface (dia. > 10 mm) must also be treated.

Screws not used during the tests and the flat surface parts are conserved by the Applicator with a
view to be used during phase 2.

The tests below must be performed for:

- purely metallic anti-corrosion treatments,

- purely organic anti-corrosion treatments,

- mixed anti-corrosion treatments: metallic under-layer and organic-based finishing of fine or


medium thickness.

a) Thickness of protection on head and threads of a minimum of 5 screws.

b) Corrosion resistance to salt spray (ME 1058): time of appearance of WHITE corrosion and
RED corrosion, WITHOUT and AFTER thermal shock for 1 h at 120 °C for a minimum
of 10 screws in each case; in addition, aspect of 3 other screws after 400 h salt spray
WITHOUT thermal shock, but AFTER scratching of the treatment down to the support on the
flatside of the screw head.

c) Geometrical check after protection on a minimum of 10 screws, with use of ring gauge (as per
Standard 01-30-018).

d) Friction coefficient for a minimum of 10 screws (as per Standard 01-50-005).

1.4. PRESENTATION TO RENAULT

The screws subjected to the tests MUST accompany the technical-economic file.

© REGIE NATIONALE DES USINES RENAULT S.A. 1995 Page 11


RENAULT 01 - 70 - 000 / - - -

APPENDIX 4 (continued)

1.5. REFERENCE SCREW SUPPLIER

The reference screws can be obtained from:

Société VALOIS Industrie


100/102 rue de Villiers
92309 LEVALLOIS PERRET
Tél. 47 58 10 26
(FOURMIE manufactured screws)

2. RACK-APPLIED TREATMENT

2.1. REFERENCE PART

LUG support assembly


Part N°: 7 700 785 711

2.2. PROTECTION COST

Price for the treatment of 1 000, 5 000 and 10 000 reference lugs.

2.3. TESTS ON REFERENCE LUG

Reference lugs treated must be obtained from an industrial production (several subsequent runs).
In as much as possible, and at the same time as the lugs, a minimum of 25 flat test specimens
of 10 cm × 20 cm in mild steel sheet must also be treated.

The lugs not used during the tests, together with the flat test specimens, are conserved by the
Applicator with a view to a possible phase 2.

2.3.1. Mainly metallic protection

The tests below must be performed for:

- purely metallic anti-corrosion treatment,

- mixed anti-corrosion treatment: metallic under-layer and organic-based finish, of thickness less
than 5 µm.

a) Thickness of anti-corrosion treatment on 5 lugs minimum.

b) Resistance to salt spray (ME 1058): time of appearance of WHITE corrosion and RED
corrosion, WITHOUT and AFTER thermal shock for 1 h at 120 °C for a minimum of 10 lugs in
each case; in addition, aspect of 3 other lugs after 400 h salt spray WITHOUT thermal shock,
but AFTER damaging of the anti-corrosion treatment down to the support in the flat area of
the lug.

© REGIE NATIONALE DES USINES RENAULT S.A. 1995 Page 12


RENAULT 01 - 70 - 000 / - - -

APPENDIX 4 (continued)

2.3.2. Mainly organic anti-corrosion treatment

The tests below must be performed on:

- purely organic treatments,

- mixed treatments: metallic under-layer and organic-based finish, of thickness more


than 10 µm.

a) Thickness of anti-corrosion on a minimum of 5 lugs.

b) Cyclic corrosion resistance test 3C (ME D 17 1686): full panel APPEARANCE and
DELAMINATION of organic film on either side of the scratch after 9 corrosion cycles,
WITHOUT and AFTER thermal shock for 1 h at 120 °C for a minimum of 10 lugs in each case.

2.4. PRESENTATION TO RENAULT

The lugs having undergone the tests MUST accompany the technical-economic file.

2.5. REFERENCE LUG SUPPLIER

The reference lug can be obtained from:

Société MOINE
8 rue Charles Pathé
94300 VINCENNES
Tél. 43 74 58 48

© REGIE NATIONALE DES USINES RENAULT S.A. 1995 Page 13


RENAULT 01 - 70 - 000 / - - -

APPENDIX 5

ELEMENTARY PART APPROVAL

© REGIE NATIONALE DES USINES RENAULT S.A. 1995 Page 14


RENAULT 01 - 70 - 000 / - - -

APPENDIX 6

ASSEMBLED PART APPROVAL

© REGIE NATIONALE DES USINES RENAULT S.A. 1995 Page 15

You might also like