Rothenberger 2006 en

1
Decentralised Composting for

Cities of Low- and Middle-
Income Countries
A Users’ Manual
Eawag / Sandec Waste Concern

Silke Rothenberger Iftekhar Enayetullah
Christian Zurbrügg A. H. Md. Maqsood Sinha
2
Publisher: Waste Concern, House - 21 (Side B), Road - 7, Block - G,

Banani Model Town, Dhaka-1213, Bangladesh; and
Eawag, P.O. Box 611, 8600 Duebendorf, Switzerland
Copyright: 2006 - Published texts and figures may be reproduced

freely for non-commercial purposes only (except when reproduction
or translation rights are explicitly reserved), provided that mentions
is made of the authors and this publication.
Circulation: 1000 copies (to be ordered from www.sandec.ch or

www.wasteconcern.org)
ISBN 978-3-906484-36-5
3
Foreword
This book is about converting organic waste into resource - a partnership - based and decentralised approach to waste
composting. It is based on actual ground level experience of Waste Concern-our partner organisation in implementing several
decentralised composting projects in Dhaka as well as replication in Bangladesh and other Asian cities.
Solid waste management has become a major environmental problem for the fast growing towns and cities of low and middle-
income countries. Most urban local bodies in the developing countries are cash - strapped and unable to provide satisfactory
waste management services. In most cities not even 50 percent of the generated waste is collected. The present solid waste
management system in developing countries is based on the "end of the pipe" solution, i.e., collection - transportation - crude
dumping of waste with limited recycling of inorganic waste, mainly by the informal sector.
The physical composition of solid waste of the developing countries consists mostly of organic matter, which is biodegradable.
When organic waste remains uncollected in the streets, drains or when disposed in open crude dump sites, it poses three
major environmental problems: firstly, ground and surface water pollution through leachates; secondly, spread of disease
vectors from open and uncovered waste dumped in crude dump sites; and thirdly, emission of methane which is a major green
house gas due to anaerobic condition in the dump sites.
In order to avoid the solid waste - triggered environmental hazards, use of compost needs to be promoted. One of the
sustainable approaches is to look at waste as a resource, not as a problem. This manual demonstrates that it is possible to
turn waste into jobs and opportunity for the poor, and improve food security.
This manual provides step - by - step guidelines on how to initiate a decentralised composting project in a developing country.
It is our hope that this resource book on composting and solid waste management will prove to be indispensable to
communities and practitioners alike, especially for the urban local bodies, private sector and NGOs.
Larry Maramis
Deputy Resident Representative
United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), Bangladesh
4
Foreword
Urban solid waste management is considered to be one of the most immediate and serious environmental problems
confronting urban governments in developing countries. The severity of this challenge will increase in the future given the
trends of rapid urbanisation and growth in urban population.
Inadequate collection and disposal of waste poses a serious health risk to the population and is an obvious cause of
environmental degradation in most cities of the developing world. With growing public pressure and environmental legislation,
the waste experts are being called upon to develop more sustainable methods of dealing with municipal waste. One step in
improving the current solid waste situation is enhancing resource recovering activities. Recycling inorganic materials from
municipal solid waste is often well developed by the activities of the informal sector. Reuse of organic waste material however,
often contributing to more than 50% of the total waste amount, is still fairly limited but has interesting recovery potential.
Coupled with approaches to reduce reliance on landfill as a disposal route, biological treatment is increasingly becoming
adopted as a standard requirement for the vast majority of biodegradable wastes. This book deals with such urban organic
municipal wastes from households, commercial activities, institutions, as well as gardens and parks. It describes approaches
and methods of composting on neighbourhood level in small - and middle - scale plants. It considers issues of primary waste
collection, composting methods, management systems, occupational health, product quality, marketing and end - user
demands.
The existing physical plan and socio-economical situation of many cities in low -and middle-income countries strongly favours
the implementation of decentralised composting systems.
• Decentralised composting systems are less technology dependent. Low cost, locally available materials and simple
technology can be used.
• In contrast to decentralised composting systems, centralized options require technical machinery of high capital cost as
well as high maintenance costs and a high degree of specialized skills is also required, and so they are prone to a higher
risk of failure.
• Decentralised options are labour-intensive, generate employment and- given the low labour costs - are more cost-effective.
Such options enhance income and job opportunity for the poor, socially deprived, informal workers and small entrepreneurs
and provide ideal opportunities for public - private partnerships.
• Decentralised options are well suited for the waste stream, climate, and social and economic conditions of low - and
middle-income countries.
• Decentralised waste management enhances and improves environmental awareness of the beneficiaries. Source-
segregation by the residents reduces the volume of solid waste earmarked for disposal effectively and increases the value
of recyclables.
• Decentralised systems reduce the cost incurred for the collection, transportation and disposal of waste by the municipal
authority.
This manual serves to create and contribute towards an enabling environment in order to promote, replicate and strengthen
decentralised composting worldwide.
François Muenger
Senior Water and Sanitation Advisor
Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation (SDC)
5
Table of Contents
Introduction 7
Launching a Collection and Composting Scheme 9
Activity 1 Determine the opportunities and threats for your composting project 9
Task 1 Identifying Stakeholder Interests 13

Activity 1 Identify project stakeholders 13
Activity 2 Identify environmental legislation and land use regulations 14
Activity 3 Identify potential marketing options 15
Task 2 Assessing Target Community Interests and Land Availability 19

Activity 1 Organise a community meeting 19
Activity 2 Conduct a structured survey using a questionnaire 20
Activity 3 Assess land availability and visit proposed sites 21
Task 3 Data Collection 25

Activity 1 Determine the solid waste generation 25
Activity 2 Analyse the solid waste composition 26
Activity 3 Assess topography and road conditions 27
Task 4 Preparing a Business Plan and Financial Projections 31

Activity 1 Develop an appropriate management model 31
Activity 2 Determine the viability of the project: Benefit - Cost Analysis 34
Activity 3 Develop the contract for involved partners 38
Task 5 Development and Design of Collection System 41

Activity 1 Select the most appropriate vehicles 41
Activity 2 Select the appropriate waste collection system 43
Activity 3 Calculate the number of vehicles required 44
Activity 4 Community participation and mobilisation for waste collection 44
Activity 5 Organise and introduce fee collection 45
Activity 6 Try to promote source segregation 45
Task 6 Design and Construction of Composting Facility 49

Activity 1 Plan and decide on the composting plant layout 49
Activity 2 Plan the required key features 50
Activity 3 Plan staffing requirements 54
Activity 4 Plan additional equipment and expendables 54
Task 7 Operating and Maintaining a Composting Facility 57

Activity 1 Operation and monitoring 57
Activity 2 Trouble shooting 66
Activity 3 Control the quality of compost 67
Task 8 Marketing of Compost 71

Activity 1 Assess potential customers and competitors 71
Activity 2 Develop a marketing strategy 71
Activity 3 Define your product 73
Activity 4 Create a market map 75
6
Annex
Annex 1 Overview - Timetable for Planning and Implementation 81
Annex 2 Basics of Statistical Analysis for Community Surveys 82
Annex 3 Questionnaire for Community Surveys 83
Annex 4 Layouts of Two Composting Plants 85

4A: Windrow - composting system, layout plan 85
4B: a) Box - composting system, layout plan 86
4B: b) Box - composting system, cross section view 87
4C: Details of box composting system 88
Annex 5 Template for Both a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) and a Final Contract
Between the Involved Parties 90
Annex 6 Analysis of Waste Generation and Physical Composition as Conducted by

Waste Concern in Bangladesh 93
Annex 7 The Science of Composting 98
Annex 8 Compost Quality Standards 100
Annex 9 Templates for Compost Monitoring 101

Template 1 Monitoring Table for Single Windrow 101
Template 2 Temperature Monitoring Table for Several Windrow (in ºC) 102
Template 3 Temperature Graph for Composting 103
Template 4 Final Quality Control Sheet for Compost 104
Annex 10 Preliminary Compost Application Guide 105
Annex 11 Definitions and Glossary 106
Annex 12 Authors and Reviewers 108

7
Introduction
All human actions have one or more of these seven causes: chance, nature, compulsion, habit, reason, passion, and
desire. (Aristotle)
Solid waste generation and management is an issue of Sandec (Water and Sanitation in Developing Countries), a
increasing concern in many developing countries, as it is department of the Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic
one of the most immediate and serious environmental Science and Technology (Eawag), complemented the
problems confronting local governments. Waste, if just experience of Waste Concern with more general research
dumped on a landfill site, is a misplaced resource causing findings and specific data from other composting schemes
further environmental problems. Integrated waste of similar scale and nature in India, Indonesia, Sri Lanka,
management focuses on recycling and reuse of different Vietnam, Burkina Faso, and Chile. Detailed information
waste types: biodegradable waste composting is but one regarding specific cases is given in text boxes, and
option. However, experience has shown that many reference is made to further case study documents for each
composing schemes have failed in the past on account of chapter.
inappropriate technologies, lack of markets for the product
and weak business models. In Europe legislation has This document attempts to synthesise the experience
already proceeded as far as to restrict biodegradable waste worldwide, and to provide guidance on key aspects the
disposal to landfill sites. These landfill directives compel authors consider to be “generally valid”. Mention should be
actions towards an integrated organic waste management, made that this handbook is not a recipe to be followed
in which composting and biogas production from organic blindly. Case-specific, local aspects, such as political and
waste play an important role. Upcoming environmental social systems, geography and climate, etc., should always
legislation in developing countries also allow the be integrated in project planning. For a specific local city or
development of clear organisational structures, formation of country context, certain aspects and issues may obviously
verified partnerships and application of business models be more or less relevant, however, the needs have to be
which are favourable to composting schemes. systematically analysed for each individual project – a fact
that this handbook cannot take into account.
This handbook
Expected users of this handbook
• provides assistance in setting up decentralised
composting schemes to mitigate the problem of This manual has been prepared for use by local non-
municipal organic solid waste management in cities of governmental and community-based organisations (e.g.
developing countries, resident initiatives) and relevant persons in urban local
governments. Private organisations or entrepreneurs
• is mainly concerned with systems suited to interested in organic waste recycling may also benefit from
neighbourhoods - primary waste collection systems this book. It may also help development agencies and other
and composting plants with capacities up to five tons government sectors in planning waste management and
per day, composting programmes. It can be used as a basic source
of information when negotiating with municipal authorities or
• provides insights into the prevailing challenges of advocating improved organic waste management strategies
decentralised composting schemes, and recommends or policies.
measures to avoid such problems through improved
strategic planning, organisational, institutional, and
operational procedures.
This document benefits largely from the experience of Waste

Concern, a research-based NGO in Dhaka, Bangladesh.
Experience, which is derived from nine years of operation of
a community-based pilot composting plant in Dhaka, as well
as the initiation and support of 38 replications in 18 towns in
Bangladesh by February 2005. Waste Concern’s experience
reveals that community-based composting plants can be
financially viable and sustainable provided that:
a) legal and institutional conditions for establishing such
schemes are considered,
b) suitable financial and management models are taken
into account, and
c) appropriate technologies are applied and a sound
operation ensured.
8
Structure of this handbook
This manual can either be read from beginning to end or

used as guidance on specific topics. The reader is led step
by step though the planning, implementing and operational
stages of a decentralised composting scheme. The authors
have tried to generalise to a certain extent the experience
acquired. Special emphasis is placed on the following
“Tasks”:
Task 1: Identifying Stakeholder Interest
Task 2: Assessing Target Community Interests and Land
Availability
Task 3: Data Collection
Task 4: Preparing a Business Model Plan and Financial
Projections
Task 5: Development and Design of Collection System
Task 6: Design and Construction of Composting Facility
Task 7: Operating and Maintaining a Composting Facility
Task 8: Marketing of Compost
Each “Task” is divided into a comprehensive section and

activities to allow frequent success rating and progress
assessment.
The Annexes contain further information on special issues,

such as scientific aspects of composting, blueprints of
facilities, contract templates, monitoring tables and
guidelines.
The authors invite the readers to contact them for further

information and clarification or to share their experiences on
composting with them.
9
Launching a Collection and Composting Scheme
Strong reasons make strong actions. (William Shakespeare)
Photograph 1.1: Common street scene in developing countries: micro Photograph 1.2: A vision becomes reality. Former micro dump has been
dumps converted into a small composting site
Before starting a composting initiative, you must have a Knowing your environment
clear vision of your objectives. If you have clear answers to
the questions below, it will be easier to convince others to The composting scheme will always be embedded in a
support your initiative. These questions may be asked by complex and rapidly changing environment impossible to
decision-makers or other stakeholders concerned with the control and difficult to predict. However, the better your
project. Having clear answers available can help formulate understanding of the external factors influencing your
a common vision with important stakeholders, thereby initiative, the better you can adapt and react to changes.
giving additional momentum to the start-up phase of a Figure 1.1 lists some of the external factors influencing a
composting scheme. business or project environment. These can easily be
adapted to a composting initiative.
What are the driving forces behind a new collection and

composting scheme? Activity 1: Determine the opportunities and threats
What do you strive to attain with the initiative? What is for your composting project
your vision?
The “windows of opportunities” method allows collection
• a clean neighbourhood? and analysis of the external and internal factors influencing
• poverty alleviation? your initiative. Recollect the past in relation with the factors
• business opportunity and income generation? listed in Figure 1.1 and determine their influence on your
decisions or initiative. Which external factors have led to
• reduced environmental pollution and increased your success, and which have caused failures?
resource protection?
• improved soil and nutrient management? Such a past-oriented analysis allows predicting possible
future forces and their effects on composting and compost
sales. Which forces are opportunities and which threaten
Since the visions of initiators may vary, general project your initiative? Bearing all these forces in mind, find ways to
design considerations are necessary. Seeking clear influence them to your advantage. Determine their influence
answers to the aforementioned questions is the first and on your business and develop scenarios on how to adapt
foremost step to successful implementation of a composting and react if they come into play.
project. A vision can be formulated on the basis of available
information of the current solid waste and prevailing Copy the matrix of figure 1.2 on a big sheet of paper and
environmental situation. enter the factors that have influenced your business/ project
in the past (left side). Which factors contributed to a success
• Should the project comprise solid waste collection and or a failure?
composting, or should it concentrate on composting
alone? Then, fill in factors that may influence your business in the
future (right side). Which of them are opportunities to the
• From which partners and types of partnerships could the project, which ones threaten your project?
project benefit?
10
Figure 1.1: Factors influencing a business environment. These factors are hardly ever static but constantly changing. They may affect
your business directly or indirectly
Examples:
• Technological innovations: They strongly influence your project. Technical development can open up opportunities.
Sound and appropriate technology ensures high quality of your product and long-term success of your project.
• Changes in farming practices: In the past most farmers adapted their practices after introduction and promotion of
chemical fertilisers. Now, the application of compost requires a change of these practices, which implies a certain effort.
This fact can be considered a threat, but it is a threat that can be reduced by certain activities. (e.g. through training
courses)
• Climate is a natural force which may already have caused a failure of a composting project. (e.g. by heavy rainfall
saturating the composting windrows). Such climatic condition may pose a threat. Although, you cannot change the
prevailing climatic condition, you can adjust your technology (e.g. by roofing your composting site or providing a
drainage system).
• Competing products: Cow dung or poultry manure may be competing products to compost, especially if they are
abundantly available at a low price. Such competing products pose a considerable threat. Given such a situation it may
be tough to influence the market unless you are able to provide compost at lower prices or with a better quality.
The following chapters provide guidance for project

implementation with clearly structured tasks, explanations
and activities. However, this handbook alone is not enough
to convey the necessary skills needed. Communication
skills, structured thinking as well as clearly defined
objectives and a flexible strategy will certainly help to gain
the support of other stakeholders.
Figure 1.2: Matrix to evaluate factors which determine success,

opportunities, failures or threats of a business or project. List any factor
having an influence on your project today and order them according to
the matrix
Task 1
Identifying Stakeholder Interests

Identifying Stakeholder Interests : Task 1
Assessing Target Community Interests and Land Availability : Task 2
Data Collection : Task 3
Preparing a Business Plan and Financial Projections : Task 4
Development and Design of Collection System : Task 5
Design and Construction of Composting Facility : Task 6
Operating and Maintaining a Composting Facility : Task 7
Marketing of Compost : Task 8
13
Task 1: Identifying Stakeholder Interests
Partnership means sharing risks and benefits. (Anonymous)
For project implementation, it is essential for you to be Activity 1: Identify project stakeholders
informed about the stakeholders and their interests. The
needs and aspirations of various stakeholders have to be Municipal stakeholders will first have to be identified to
identified. Their willingness to accept and participate in an assess their interests. A first overview of municipal solid
improvement programme, involving waste collection and waste management and responsible stakeholders may be
composting, will depend on the priority given to solid waste, obtained from secondary data such as newspapers and
awareness, and social cohesion of the community as well reports. A stakeholder analysis helps to assess the key
as on affordability and willingness to pay for the waste stakeholders for project success, their roles and level of
services rendered. All parties can benefit from a stakeholder participation during project implementation and operation. It
analysis. Sound data from the beginning contributes to assists in understanding the different and conflicting
developing appropriate partnerships at a very early stage. interests, as well as the potential for cooperation and
Partnership also means the sharing of benefits and risks of coalition with other stakeholders. A first overview can be
a project, since awareness of the concerns and ideas of obtained with an analysis like shown in figure 1.3.
others may prevent many pitfalls on the way to a successful Stakeholders are identified and arranged in a triangular
composting project. matrix showing the three important organisational sectors
(private, public and non-governmental).
Furthermore, to attain a long-term success and avoid legal
proceedings from opponents and pressure groups, it is Table 1.1 contains a list of typical stakeholders, and the way
important to also consider the legislative framework (e.g. to assess and compare them. This list does not claim to be
environmental laws and land use regulations). exhaustive, as other stakeholders may be relevant in your
specific situation. The potential impacts describe the
After undertaking the three subsequent activities, you will positive (+) or negative (-) influence of a stakeholder on the
be informed about: project. By formulating these positive and negative
• relevant stakeholders involved in your project influences in the column Remarks this table will already
• potential project partners allow a first risk assessment.
• potential communities for project implementation
Two strategies for collection of relevant information from
• potential composting sites in these communities stakeholders are briefly described as follows:
• potential risks for your project and possible mitigation
strategies Firstly, the parties are invited to a meeting where the project
is presented and upcoming questions are discussed and
answered. Such an open discussion already reveals the
interests and concerns of the different stakeholders. It is
essential that all this information is treated with the same
importance, and that all stakeholders are allowed to express
their opinion. These statements should not be commented on
by the initiator, as the objective of this meeting is to collect
information and not to defend the idea behind the project.
Secondly, if not all stakeholders can be convened, consider

individual meetings with selected stakeholders. Give a short
presentation of your project and allow time for questions
and answers. This is more time-consuming but contributes
to a more effective information exchange. Stakeholders may
give important hints regarding project development or name
other helpful organisations and potential partners.
Figure 1.3: Triangular matrix for a first determination of potential

stakeholders
14
Table 1.1: Matrix for a stakeholder analysis
Stakeholders What are their interests? Assess the potentially Remarks

What are their concerns? positive (+) or
negative (-) impacts
Ministry of the Environment Reaching targets
Elected local representatives Timely delivery of visible services
Municipal authority (waste department) Reaching targets
Operational control
Municipal department responsible for parks Treating the park trimmings
and green areas Using the compost
Fertiliser associations Promoting fertiliser
Developing new products
Community organisations Improved access to SWM services
Improved health and opportunities
Financial burden
Women and children in the communities More time for other activities
concerned Job opportunities
Men in the communities concerned Improved health
Job opportunities
Waste pickers and sweepers of the Decreased access to recyclables
informal sector Job opportunities
NGOs / CBOs Improved hygiene situation
Job opportunities for the poor
Improved well being in the neighbourhood
Donor agencies Short-term disbursement of funds
Visible poverty alleviation
Waste Concern has developed a list of ten main questions Activity 2: Identify environmental legislation and
relevant to launching a composting scheme. These land use regulations
questions need to be answered by all stakeholders. The list
of questions below can also provide guidance to both the Since national regulations vary significantly, they need to be
mixed stakeholder meeting and the individual meetings. examined on a case-by-case basis. Prior to starting a
1. Collection: Does a primary house-to-house collection composting project, the laws and regulations that might
exist in the municipality? influence the project, need to be examined thoroughly to
avoid delays or even cancellation of the project. If
2. Source Segregation: Are the stakeholders familiar
necessary, seek advice from a lawyer, an NGO or the
with any waste segregation initiatives?
municipal authorities.
3. Support: Does the municipality show commitment to
waste management projects? • Environmental laws–Determine the existence of a general
4. Land Availability: Is land for a composting site legislation supporting or prohibiting waste recycling and
available in the urban areas? reuse.
5. Road Conditions: How are the road conditions in the • Solid waste management rules and regulations –
proposed areas? Determine the existence of a general guidance
supporting or prohibiting waste recycling and reuse.
6. Community Awareness: Is the community aware of
waste management problems? • Land use regulations and urban planning strategies –
Determine the existence of regulations regarding the
7. Knowledge: Do the stakeholders know of any construction and operation of waste treatment plants.
composting activities or technologies?
In some cases, the setting up of such plants in residential
8. Composting Experience: Are persons or institutions areas is prohibited.
already familiar with composting? • Agricultural laws – Determine whether agricultural waste
9. Compost Demand: Is there a potential demand for reuse is regulated in any way (e.g. quality certificates,
compost and by whom? What fertilisers are used? Is reuse limitations, pollution control).
compost already sold? Are marketing activities • Trade laws and regulations – you may have to register
available? the product if you want to market compost.
10. Data Availability: Do stakeholders have reliable data
on the amount of waste generated and its composition?
15
Activity 3: Identify potential marketing options • Primary sources, providing firsthand information,
originate from key informants such as existing and
This activity is only the first step of the development of a potential customers, competitors, decision-makers or
marketing strategy for compost. Though Task 8 (Marketing experts. Although collection of this kind of data can be
of Compost) is at the end of this book, we recommend costly and time-consuming, it can also be the most
reading it after finalising this Task. Task 8 introduces the 4 valuable, as it is the most up-to-date and specific
Ps of marketing (Product, Price, Place, and Promotion) and information you can obtain.
provides additional structured information how to analyse
• Data from secondary data sources has already been
markets and elaborate a strong marketing strategy. This
collected by others. It originates from trade journals,
knowledge should be kept in mind when reading the
government publications, statistics, reports from local and
following chapters of this handbook.
external development agencies or NGOs or even surveys
conducted by other companies. This data can provide
The main objective of a waste collection and composting
valuable information on your customers’ needs and
project is an environmentally friendly and socially
business environment.
acceptable removal of waste. Composting is one treatment
option among many, and only viable if a sound financing
Potential customers must either need or want (or both)
system is guaranteed. Such financing systems may consist
compost, and be capable and willing to pay for it. Mention
of subsidies, user fees, and income from the sale of
should be made that not all these components are
compost or a combination of all the options mentioned.
necessary to qualify for a potential customer, however, the
However, the demand for compost is of key importance.
ability to pay for compost is essential.
There are many markets for compost beyond its typical use
as soil amendment or fertiliser. However, identification of
these markets and how they should be approached have to • Where could compost potentially be used and for what?
be thoroughly clarified. At this stage of the project, only • Who are your potential customer groups and what are
general questions on the potential marketing options need their compost needs?
to be answered to determine whether composting can be a • What assumed potential quantities might each customer
financially viable project. group need (potential market demand)?
Different customers and marketing options for the final • How much are they able and willing to pay?
products of the composting scheme should be identified • What are the existing alternatives to compost and how
during stakeholder analysis. A composting scheme can much do they cost (e.g. manure, soil, sludge)?
have revenues from the sale of compost and recyclables,
and potential incomes from both sources need to be Prepare a list of potential customers and visit them.
assessed. A market study is not difficult to conduct but Investigate their needs regarding compost quality and
requires some planning and time. You need to collect quantity required, as well as their willingness to pay. The
information on: following box contains an overview of potential customer
groups known to require compost. The customer groups can
A. Your existing customers and potential customer be divided into bulk markets which demand high amounts
groups and are not willing to pay high prices and cash markets
to maintain and improve your product and service, to which pay higher prices but require less amounts of
guide your promotional efforts and develop new compost. However, the list is not complete, since the local
compost products or new services (e.g. delivery, context may reveal several additional niche markets.
advice on use).
Typical compost customer groups
B. The competition and competing products
Bulk market
to help you assess the probabilities of success and • urban and peri-urban agriculture (farmers)
failure, give you ideas to improve your products and/or
• rural agriculture
services, and find a way to increase your share of the
market or to reach other customer groups. • viticulture (wine)
• green space management (parks, zoos, sport arenas)
C. The environment
• forestry
comprising economic, social, political, and natural • landfill rehabilitation, mining rehabilitation
forces influencing the composting business. Collecting
information on the environment allows you to stay Cash market
abreast of and respond to particular trends or events
• horticulture (flowers and trees)
affecting your business. Awareness of a drop in
interest rates or new waste management policies is • home gardening
important to assess their positive or negative effects • vegetable gardening
on your business. • hotels and company premises
The information necessary for your analysis can be • landscaping, land development
collected from two main types of data sources: • fertiliser companies (retailers)
• industrial use (biofilters)
16
Figure 1.4 shows average compost market figures from customer group can be established from your stakeholder
Switzerland. In this case, agriculture demands 67% of analysis. They constitute the basis for assessing the overall
produced compost and is the main market for compost. potential market demand.
However, compost has a low value in the agricultural sector
and only little profit can be gained. Consider your own situation and think whether compost
could either be sold by your own distribution network or
through retailers, which take over distribution of the product
(e.g. a fertiliser company). In the latter case, the partner
would be the bulk customer of the composting scheme. In
some cases, the end user could also be a bulk customer,
e.g. if the municipality is interested in the product and willing
to pay for it. Both strategies have inherent advantages and
disadvantages. The decision is strongly dependent on
compost demand and location of the different potential
customer groups.
With this information, it is possible to judge if a composting
scheme is feasible in your local context. All potentials and
risks influencing the project should be known to allow
development of mitigation strategies to tackle potential
risks. Be aware that markets are very dynamic. It is crucial
for a business to keep track of market developments in
order to remain competitive.
The current conditions may sometimes be unfavourable for

setting up a composting scheme, such as the lack of
Figure 1.4: Average distribution of compost to different customer
groups. Assessment of 13 Swiss compost producers (from Schleiss demand for compost due to the availability of other cheaper
(2002): Compost Marketing in Switzerland) fertilisers, constant water shortages or lack of land. In such
cases, other waste management options must be
An example of how to characterise a potential compost developed.
customer group is given in table 1.2, with focus on the
horticulture market segment in an urban setting. It describes Now, you are invited to have a closer look at Task 8 of this
its compost use and most typical requirements regarding handbook.
compost quality and quantity. Such fact sheets for each
Table 1.2: Example of a compost customer fact sheet

Customer Group: Horticulture/Nurseries
Geographic location Urban and peri-urban area, frequently along roadsides and on vacant plots.
Uses Compost is used as soil substrate and potting mixture for container plants such as trees, flowers, ornamental
plants, and seedlings.
Quantity As aforementioned, compost alone is not recommended for use as soil substrate, however, mixed with sand
and/or soil it gives an excellent potting mix. Potting soil typically is amended with 5 - 40% of compost (by
volume).
Quality Seedlings require well-matured and finely sieved compost. Less mature compost can be used as mulch for
adult plants.
Ability to pay This customer segment usually draws a regular but not necessarily high income from a continuous and
reliable market. Thus, the ability to pay is assumed to be average.
Willingness to pay Willingness to pay is dependent on the level of awareness and knowledge on how to use compost. Self-made
compost by the nurseries or animal manure may compete with your product and reduce willingness to pay.
Purchasing behaviour Seasonal fluctuations in purchase are generally expected.
Competing products used Self-made compost, animal manure, peat, subsoil.
Estimated potential X number of nurseries have been identified in the city. The annual demand of a nursery is estimated at Y tons
of raw compost. Data is based on local business statistics and own observations. (multiply the X value with
the average of all Y values.
Task 2
Assessing Target Community Interests and Land Availability

19
Task 2: Assessing Target Community Interests and Land Availability
Structures influence processes, processes change structures (Anonymous)
After identifying the potentials, risks and relevant Activity 1: Organise a community meeting
stakeholders and deciding to go ahead with the
implementation of the composting activities, focus is placed To establish a composting unit with community support,
on selecting the target community for the composting organise meetings in the community with the largest
scheme. If the decision-makers propose several locations possible number of different stakeholders such as:
for the composting site, these should be visited and the
project presented to the community and beneficiaries. The • Members of the community, male and female, as well as
most appropriate way is to hold a question and answer youth and children
meeting to allow all participants to state their opinions and • NGO representatives, active in this community
concerns about the project (Task 1).
• Political and administrative representatives of the
community
After finalising the subsequent activities you will be aware
of: • Existing waste workers (collectors and recyclers)
servicing the area
• how to approach and inform the community • Municipal waste management staff.
• how to evaluate the willingness of the community to
participate in the project Announce a community meeting and invite all interested
parties. Make sure that all the interested stakeholders are
• ideas and concerns of the beneficiaries
able to attend the meeting (see Table 1.2 (Matrix for
• local conditions in the target area stakeholder analysis) in Task 1). Openly discuss the
• community willingness to cooperate and to what extent advantages and disadvantages of the existing waste
management system at the meeting.
• important criteria required to identify potential
composting sites in these communities.
• What problems have been identified in relation to waste
To conclude, you know whether this community offers a management? What causes the problems? Who sees
suitable location for your composting scheme. them as important?
• Do stakeholders see any opportunities and potentials for
Participatory approaches have been widely applied in the improvement of the waste management system?
fields of water, environmental sanitation, hygiene, and • Is there a tradition of community-based action, and what
waste management. Experience has shown that community are the opinions on this approach?
involvement can lead to wide-ranging benefits:
• Are primary stakeholders aware of the need to change
• If people understand a problem, they are more willing to the common practices with the new approach and
solve it. technology?
• Communities can and should determine their own • Which problems are seen as high priority? Do the
priorities in dealing with the problems they face. priorities of stakeholders differ?
• People solve their own problems best in a participatory • Is composting a known practice? What information is
group process. necessary?
• The enormous depth and scope of acquired community • Is land available within the community for the composting
experience and knowledge can be used to bring about site in the community?
changes and improvements.
The next step is to present the scope and idea behind the
Programmes with community involvement therefore aim at project. Share the vision with the community but also inform
involving all members of a society in a participatory process them on how waste management and composting can be
of assessing their own knowledge, investigating their own managed in practice. Describe the tasks and duties awaiting
environmental situation, visualising a different future, the community if a composting plant is set up. Allow
analysing constraints to change, planning for change, and questions and provide open answers and clear
implementing change. Their interest and motivation to explanations. Do not defend the project, as it may show
participate and contribute influence the organisational setup signs of weakness.
of the project (see Task 4).
20
• will determine whether the residents regularly pay their

Important Questions
contributions for door-to-door waste collection.
Make sure the following issues have been raised during • will determine whether the waste collectors perform their
the meeting. Reflect on the answers voiced by the assigned jobs regularly and adequately.
different stakeholders: • will also raise the environmental awareness of other
community members.
• Do community members have the required confidence
and skills to engage effectively in participatory If the community agrees to share the aforementioned
processes and partnerships? responsibilities, go on to the next assessment step.
• Are traditional institutional structures available, have
they been used in the past and could they be used
again? Will women be represented? Activity 2: Conduct a structured survey using a
• Who makes decisions in the community, and how will questionnaire
local power structures be affected by the project?
• To what extent is the community interested in A community meeting, like the one previously described, is
contributing labour and engaging in operation and the first step to acquiring knowledge of the needs and
maintenance? Will this affect its status? Will it priorities of the beneficiaries. This rather qualitative
contribute to its income? information has to be further quantified. This additional
information (e.g. satisfaction with the current collection
• How will the project increase the responsibilities and system or willingness to pay for an improved system) allows
workload of certain groups? Which groups need you to design your collection service and composting
support and what kind? system. Remember that the first priority of the community is
• Will some groups be excluded from or negatively most probably a reliable waste collection service. If the
affected by the project (e.g. waste pickers?). How can community is satisfied with the service, it is far more likely
this effect be overcome? to support additional measures like composting.
• Have all the target community members, particularly
those affected by poverty or disadvantaged by their To obtain conclusive results regarding future system design
status in society, been able to voice their opinions? and to avoid biased answers, the survey should cover a
certain number of households randomly selected from
• Have the different needs of women, men, older and among all income groups of the community. Furthermore, it
younger people, and those with different abilities been is important to consider the gender issue. Make sure that
taken into account? you obtain a balance of women and men who are
• Have women and men expressed their views on the interviewed.
siting of the plant and possible institutional
arrangements for operation and maintenance? The calculation of the adequate number of households for
• Has the issue of financial costs for the households a survey is quite complex and time consuming. Table 2.1
been raised? provides already calculated sample sizes under pre-
defined sampling errors for household surveys. This table
• If user charges pose a problem for poorer households, can give guidance on the number of households to be
what arrangements have been suggested to overcome assessed to obtain reliable results. However, selection of
this problem? sample size and acceptable sampling errors depend on the
• Have women and men different responsibilities time and manpower available for such a study. For more
regarding household budgeting? Have they been background information about statistical analysis have a
taken into account when assessing willingness and look at Annex 2.
ability to pay?
Independent from the organisational set up, the

responsibilities and roles of the local community should be
clarified. Experience reveals that a committee selected by
the attending community members helps to establish
ownership and responsibilities in the community.
The committee
• will be the authority through which the community can
present its ideas and objections during project
implementation and operation.
• will subsequently discuss all issues with the project
coordinator and/or service provider and with the
responsible municipal person to find a feasible solution.
21
Table 2.1: Calculation of adequate sample sizes for household Analyse the completed questionnaire by counting the
surveys answers given and express them as a percentage of the
total number of answers. If you did not have the means to
Required sample size allowing a 95%
confidence level do a comprehensive survey with the number of households
suggested in Table 2.1 randomly divide the questionnaire in
Total number of Low Medium Still
two groups and analyse them separately. If the results diver
households in the acceptable
community from each other significantly, additional interviews are
sampling sampling sampling
error error error
required. The box contains possible results of such a
survey.
100 50 50 49
250 152 110 70 Example:
500 217 141 81 The results obtained indicate that 80% of the interviewed
750 254 156 85 households feel that local pollution is caused by
1,000 278 164 88 overflowing public bins as a result of the public emptying
services not being frequent enough and a lot of waste is
2,500 333 182 93
being left behind. The questionnaires also reveal that
5,000 357 189 94 about 60% of the households interviewed favour a house-
10,000 370 192 95 to-house collection, while 40% would prefer to place their
25,000 378 194 96 bins in front of the house at a certain time. 90% of the
households are willing to pay an additional fee for that
50,000 381 195 96
service.
100,000 383 196 96
1,000,000 384 196 96 This information will allow you to adapt your project to
100,000,000 384 196 96 community needs. Firstly, the collection must be improved.
Secondly, composting will be justified, as it will clearly
reduce the amount of waste in the temporary public
If the total number of household lies between two given values,
choose a sample size between the corresponding sample size storage and prevent them from overflowing. Thirdly, the
values (interpolation). results also clearly reveal that cooperation with the
municipal workers is essential, as they are responsible for
The relevant questions for a household survey may differ emptying the public storage bins and waste transportation.
from one case to another. Yet, the following nine questions The households in the community will also judge your
provide guidance through this task. They can be revised performance by the cleanliness of the area!
and detailed allowing a categorisation of answers. Annex 3
shows a questionnaire for a community survey related to In some cases, the household-favoured system may not be
solid waste management. clearly defined. Consult the “Committee” or invite the
community to another meeting to discuss the results and
1. Are you satisfied with your current solid waste jointly decide on a system. A consensus at this stage of the
management system (temporary storage and collection) project avoids problems during implementation.
in your community?
2. Does the municipal administration provide a solid waste
management service in your area? Activity 3: Assess land availability and visit
3. Do you think the current waste management system in
proposed sites
the area pollutes the local environment?
During the first community meeting, the important aspect of
4. Which factors (caused by inappropriate waste disposal) land availability has to be discussed with the attending
are responsible for local environmental pollution?
stakeholders. Either the municipal decision-makers have
5. Who collects and disposes of your household waste? already proposed plots or the community itself proposes
6. What improvements of waste collection system would land for the composting site. However, since land use,
you like to see applied? especially for waste treatment purposes in residential areas,
7. If your waste is collected directly from your house, how is always a very sensitive issue, give special attention to
should it be collected? that issue.
8. How often and at what time do you want your waste to
Given the often prohibitive prices of land in urban areas, it
be collected?
is essential to conclude special agreements to obtain this
9. You may have to pay a fee if your waste is collected land at low rents or even free of charge. Ideally, the
directly from your house. How much are you willing to
municipal authority should make land available as the future
pay monthly for the system?
waste collection and composting services will contribute to
22
municipal service delivery. Experience shows that suitable After finding an appropriate plot for the composting site, a
plots of land can be found in almost all communities. written and signed agreement with the responsible persons
should be established. Experience with existing decentra-
Listen to the proposals of the stakeholders, as they are lised composting plants has revealed that there will always
familiar with the local conditions. However, the following be people who do not agree with the composting activities.
areas are also worth a closer look if they have not been The various reasons range from fear that nearby land will
discussed already: drop in value, fear of odour and vermin or other financial
and political interests. Hence, a written agreement such as
• privately owned land belonging to organisations a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) is important to
• unauthorised micro dump sites (which have to be ensure the continuity of the project. Formulation of the MoU
cleared, but residents will appreciate a change) strongly depends on local conditions and on the decision-
makers. A generalised template for a MoU is shown in
• corners in a green area (park or strip along a road)
Annex 5. The template provides guidance on aspects to be
• unused public spaces. mentioned and discussed. But it needs to be adapted to the
particular local conditions.
Organise a visit to these sites with the stakeholders
(municipal officers and/or Community Action Committee). Further reading
During the visit, focus on the following important selection
criteria and discuss them with the stakeholders. GTZ (2005): Improvement of Sanitation and Solid Waste
Management in Urban Poor Settelments, GTZ, Eschborn,
Germany (order or download from www.gtz.de/solid-waste-
• Proximity to the waste generation source to ensure management)
frequent delivery of sufficient fresh waste at low cost. This
is especially relevant when determining the number of
staff and vehicles required for the waste collection
service.
• Water supply is a prerequisite for a composting site. The
water should meet the chemical quality standards (low in
toxic compounds, heavy metals and salinity).
• An electricity supply is desirable as it facilitates some
composting steps, however it is not essential.
• Sites should not be located at the edge of wetlands or
flood plains.
• Roads for waste delivery and pickup of residues should
be well maintained and easily accessible throughout the
year.
• Densely populated neighbourhoods and areas where
adjacent land users may object to a composting plant
should be avoided.
• Adequate green buffer zones (for building a fence or
planting trees), separating the composting plant from the
neighbourhood should be available.
• Composting plants should be located downwind
(considering the prevailing wind direction) from
residential areas.
• The land of the composting site should be located on a
slight slope and the soil shold be appropriately grades to
avoid water logging and facilitate proper drainage.
A composting plant with a daily capacity of three tons using

a windrow composting system requires a site with an area
of about 1000m2. A composting site using the box technique
requires about 800m2 of land. Task 6 (Design and
Construction) will give detailed information on the most
efficient way to set up the composting plant. However, it is
important to consider the individual local conditions.
Task 3
Data Collection
25
Task 3: Data Collection
We can have facts without thinking but we cannot have thinking without facts (John Dewey)
The activities of Task 2 have provided information on reliable information, the number of households (sample
perceptions and needs of the community concerned, while size) surveyed is equal to the sample size identified in
Task 3 mainly concentrates on technical information Activity 2 of Task 2 (community survey). This activity
necessary for the composting project. The data collection requires additional time and staff and has to be planned
concentrates mainly on technical aspects of solid waste thoroughly.
generation and management. One could argue that this
technical information is also relevant from the start, but it is Organise a one-week survey of a sufficient number of
easier to obtain technical information if the local social households randomly selected in the community. Inform the
relationships are well understood and first contacts households about the purpose of the survey and ask them
established. to collect their waste in the bags or bins provided and
collected by the survey staff. If possible, ask for municipal
After finalising the activities of Task 3 you will be familiar support and involve public workers in the study.
with:
Prepare a short form, defining each surveyed household
• the amount of waste generated in the selected with an identification number, address and the number of
community household members. Ensure that each collected bag is
• the waste components and other important waste labelled with the identification number.
characteristics
• the natural environment of your community Discard the waste on the first day without weighing it
because you do not know how many days the waste has
Knowledge of all these aspects is important when been waiting to be collected. If there is not a regular
selecting the right waste collection vehicles and planning collection service is a good idea to discard the waste of the
the design of the composting scheme. second day also because residents may be taking
advantage of the collection service to clean out their yards.
Include the weekend and at least one day before and after
the weekend in case there is a significant difference in
Activity 1: Determine the solid waste generation generation rate at the weekends.
If you are lucky, you will find reliable data on community Collect the waste bags from the households on a daily basis
waste generation in evaluation reports of NGOs, and take them to a central point where they are weighed
consultants or municipalities. In some cases, the separately. (Since the waste analysis continues with Activity
information from neighbouring communities may also be 2, do not dispose of the waste!). Calculation of the average
relevant if the standard of living does not significantly differ waste generation per household can be simplified by adding
from the one in the selected community. However, using all the measured weights and dividing the result by the
“per capita” waste generation figures from secondary data number of households (sample size). By dividing the result
along with average household size will be less reliable than with the average number of household members you will
information from first hand waste analyses. Secondary data obtain the per capita waste generation.
is often of a more aggregate nature and does not include
the local determining factors. Hence, it is advisable to
conduct a own study for the target community.
The main questions to be answered are:
• How many households does the community comprise?

• How much waste is generated totally?
capwaste: per capita waste generation (kg/ day)
• What is the average daily waste generation rate of a
household in the project area? hhwaste: average waste generation of one household
(kg/day)
• How much organic biodegradable material is contained in
hh: number of households surveyed
this waste?
hm: average number of household members
• How much recyclable material is contained in the waste?
What types of recyclable material are present?
A direct measurement of the average household waste

generation is necessary if such data is not available. A first
rough estimate can be done by assessing the existing
collection service, if already available. To obtain more
26
Caution: The survey merely reflects the waste generated • The chemical waste composition covers information on
by the community over one week only. Waste generation carbon and nitrogen content.
and composition may vary considerably depending on
holidays or seasons. Though you can use the gathered 1. Analysing the physical waste composition
information to go ahead with the project, it is advisable to
conduct an additional survey during a different season. Determination of waste composition is conducted with the
same waste like collected under Activity 1. However, it is not
necessary to analyse the total amount of collected waste.
Future projections
Only 100 kg of waste is analysed. This amount is obtained
The procedure for data collection and calculation focuses through the so called quartering technique:
on the current situation. It is likely that the quantities of
waste will increase in the coming years as the population Pile the waste of all bags into a large heap and mix it
rises and habits change. However, this change should not thoroughly. Divide it into four quarters and keep just one
be of concern unless large numbers of people are moving quarter. If this amount is still too large, repeat the mixing and
into the neighbourhood. Annex 6 provides a brief divide it again until only 100 kg of mixed waste are left. This
introduction on how to calculate future projections. representative sample is then sorted into three fractions,
namely:
After collecting all this information, you will certainly want to a. organic waste (biodegradable waste)
know how many households can be covered by the project.
Given your planned composting plant size (e.g. three tons b. recyclables with market value (e.g. glass, plastic,
per day) and the aforementioned information, you can metal)
easily calculate the number of households covered by the c. inorganic waste and residuals
plant.
Weigh the different fractions and calculate the relative
municipal waste composition. Annex 6 provides examples
of all these calculations. The examples base on an existing
case in Bangladesh. Furthermore, it describes an
alternative technique for reducing the waste to be
hhs: number of households serviced assessed.
capacity: intended plant capacity (kg/day) Density and moisture are two important waste parameters
hhwaste: average waste generation of one household and need to be assessed. They are relevant for designing
(kg/day) the collection containers and vehicles.
bio: biodegradable fraction (% of household waste
generation, wet weight) Density
Loosely fill the collected waste into a container of known
Example: Your aim is to set up a plant of three-ton organic volume (10–50 litre) and weight. Weigh the container and
waste processing capacity per day. Based on your survey, register the result. The density can be calculated using the
the average household waste generation rate is three kg following equation:
per day with a biodegradable fraction of 75 %. Based on
the following calculations, the number of households you
will service is approx. 1330:
Collection of additional organic waste from special waste Waste density in developing countries usually varies
producers (e.g. markets) will reduce the amount of between 0.4 and 0.6 kg/l and is strongly dependent on the
households serviced by the given plant capacity. organic waste fraction and moisture. The higher the
moisture or organic waste fraction, the higher is the waste
density.
Activity 2: Analyse the solid waste composition Moisture
Waste characteristics can be generally divided into two Moisture can be measured rather easily: take a
groups: representative sample of the mixed waste collected (e.g. 10
kg) and register the weight (mstart). Spread the waste on a
• The physical waste composition provides information plastic sheet in the sun and let it dry for 24 hours. Make sure
on waste contents such as organic and inorganic waste that neither animals nor rain disturb the drying process.
or recyclables. Furthermore, it includes moisture content Reweigh the dried waste, register the result and let it dry for
and density. This information facilitates the decision on another 24 hours. Repeat the procedure until the weight is
vehicle design or sorting efficiency. almost constant (mend). The loss in weight is equal to the
27
moisture content and can be calculated as follows: Activity 3: Assess topography and road conditions
The choice of waste collection vehicle is also dependent on

local topography and road conditions. No general
recommendations are possible as the choice mainly
depends on the local conditions and cultural backgrounds.
However, the following three examples illustrate the
importance of that issue:
• If the community is located in a hilly area, handcarts and

rickshaws are unsuitable as the loaded vehicles become
too heavy for the collectors. This is especially relevant if
the composting site is uphill from your community.
Significance of the moisture content for composting is • If the settlement structure is very scattered, a motorised
explained in Task 7. rickshaw bridges the collection distances much faster
than a handcart.
2. Analysing the chemical waste composition • If the roads are not paved but merely covered with sand,
the wheels have to be stronger and wider. This simple
Now focus is entirely placed on the organic fraction of the measure avoids time losses due to stuck vehicles.
sorted waste. In an efficient composting process, the
carbon/nitrogen ratio of the waste should range between The types of vehicles used for transporting goods and waste
25:1 and 40:1. This variation indicates a possible variation already indicate the types of locally available vehicles.
in waste compositions. Carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) Further information on advantages and disadvantages of the
measurement of the organic waste fraction is expensive different vehicles is provided in Task 5.
and requires professional equipment and knowledge.
Initiators are often unable to finance such expensive
preliminary analysis. This handbook will thus provide Further reading
guidance on how to assess the C and N content through Agency for Environment and Energy Management (ADEME)
visual examination. The table below contains examples of (1998): MODECOMTM - A method for characterization of
organic waste and their typical range of C/N ratio.
domestic waste. ISBN 2-86817-355-1
Table 3.1: Waste types and their C/N ratios
Agency for Environment and Energy Management (ADEME)
Waste Type C/N “Green” “Brown” (1998): MODECOMTM - A method for characterization of
Ratio* High in High in domestic waste. Addenda to the MODECOMTM
Nitrogen Carbon methodological guide. ISBN 2-86817-355-X
Cow/chicken manure 2-4 X
Vegetable waste 11-13 X
Grass cutting 15 X
Fruit waste 20-49 X
Household waste 34-80 X X
Leaves 40-80 X
Park waste: twigs/ branches, 200-800 X
wood chips, saw dust
* read: C/N ratio ranges from 2:1 to 4:1
On the basis of this table, characterise type and amount of

waste surveyed in the target community. Household waste
mainly contains kitchen and garden waste. As shown in the
table, the C/N ratio of this waste is often already ideal for
composting. However, in some cases or during certain
seasons, the incoming organic waste either needs a carbon
or a nitrogen supplement prior to composting. Task 7
(Operation and Maintenance) and Annex 7 (Science of
Composting) provide additional information on waste mixing
ratios.
28
Task 4
Preparing a Business Plan and Financial Projections

Development and Design of a primary Collection System : Task 5
31
Task 4: Preparing a Business Plan and Financial Projections
Taking calculated risks is quite different from being rash (George S. Patton)
The data collected in Task 3 contributes to the development transformed into compost can contribute to generating a
of an appropriate management model in Task 4. certain income for the city. Although this model assumes
Furthermore, it also provides guidance on determining that decentralised composting is managed entirely by a
financial viability of the business or project and the setting dedicated municipal team, cooperation with residents is
up of a contract with potential project partners. indispensable.
After finalising the activities under Task 4 you will have 2. Municipally owned – community operated
learned to:
In this model, the decentralised composting schemes are
planned and implemented by the municipality, however,
• develop an appropriate management model to
their operation and maintenance is handed over to the
implement the composting project
benefiting community. Ideally, the community is invited to
• assess the financial viability of your project by come forward with own proposals and to participate in the
calculating the benefit-cost ratio planning and implementing processes. Apart from
• set up a contract or agreement with your project composting, this model often comprises primary waste
partners collection and is frequently applied in low-income urban
areas. In many instances, an intermediary, such as an NGO
or a composting advisor, is required to provide or develop
the technical composting and management skills within the
Activity 1: Develop an appropriate management community. The main incentive behind this model is to
model reduce secondary collection or transport costs by reducing
and treating waste as close to its source as possible.
There is a wide range of different solid waste management Furthermore, it improves primary waste collection without
models and business partnerships. The four management significantly increasing municipal operation efforts and
models for decentralised composting schemes described in creates local employment opportunities. The operation and
this book proved to be applicable in various countries. Their maintenance costs are covered by additional service
usefulness is, however, strongly dependent on local charges paid by households and by the profits from the sale
conditions and cultural backgrounds. All the models of compost. This model requires a written contract between
described are based on some degree of partnership municipality and community or, alternatively, with an NGO
between the municipality, the community and/or private as intermediary.
entrepreneurs. Any partnership model applied should,
however, be based on common objectives, balanced power, 3. Municipally owned – privately operated
clear agreements, mutual trust and understanding.
As in the previous models the municipality plans and
Therefore, make sure to crosscheck the models described
implements decentralised composting programmes.
before developing the most appropriate for your needs.
Composting plants are constructed on municipal land and
the system is owned by the municipality. Operation and
All models described below have in common the
maintenance of these schemes is, however, contracted out
municipality’s benefits from an overall cost reduction of their
to the private sector or NGOs by open bidding. The call for
waste management activities (mainly transportation and
tenders already stipulates the rights and responsibilities of
disposal) through a more decentralised reduction and
the future operator and forms the basis for a later contract
treatment of waste.
between the partners. The contract regulates the duration of
the arrangement, required maintenance, rents, sharing of
1. Municipally owned – municipally operated profits, and waste collection fees. Operation and
Decentralised composting schemes of this kind are management costs have to be covered by the private
planned, implemented and operated by a municipal division. contractor through the revenues of the project. The aim of
The schemes form an integral part of the existing municipal such a project is to raise additional capacity in solid waste
solid waste management system. The thrust for its management (SWM) by involving third parties like the
implementation comes from an integrated municipal policy private sector, thereby contributing to additional know-how
for improved urban solid waste management. Such a policy and finances to improve the entire solid waste management
foresees a clean and hygienic urban environment as a system. Depending on contract design and the local
result of the reduction or recycling of waste as close to its compost market conditions, this model has the potential to
source of generation as possible. Cost recovery for the foster profit-seeking projects in SWM. Waste Concern
composting schemes is not a prerequisite, but desirable. promoted this model during a UNICEF-supported
The major aim is to achieve benefits for the entire solid programme in 14 towns of Bangladesh. The municipality
waste management system by lower transport costs, tendered primary waste collection and composting schemes
improved landfill management and reduced quantities of in defined communities. The private operators received
waste to be handled. Furthermore, organic waste permission to use existing composting plants for five years
32
without paying rent or sharing the revenues from waste

ALM – A municipal-community partnership in
collection and composting. However, without the
Mumbai, India
involvement of funding agencies, rental rules and
regulations have to be included in the contract. A slightly different example for a municipal-community
partnership is found in Mumbai where the municipality
4. Privately owned – Privately operated has been successfully assisting neighbourhood schemes
known as Advanced Locality Management (ALM). The
This decentralised composting model is based on a profit-
municipality of Mumbai supports community initiatives
seeking approach, which presupposes that the income from
(involving groups of approximately 250 households each)
waste collection fees and compost sale is sufficient to cover
to improve the living conditions in their own
all the costs of a decentralised composting plant. Land and
neighbourhoods. For many of them, waste management
infrastructure are financed and managed by the private
is a central aspect. The programme provides non
sector. However, if the private company still requires a
monetary services to the active neighbourhoods. For
permit to collect waste from defined municipal areas, it
example, the community advisor discusses community
cannot act independently but has to conclude an agreement
plans with the neighbourhoods and organises temporary
with the municipality. In Khulna, Bangladesh for instance,
cleaning equipment or designates abandoned open
the private organisation RUSTIC constructed a composting
spaces as waste collection or composting sites. Of the
plant on private land to process 20 tons of waste per day.
670 registered ALMs, roughly 280 collect and compost
The Municipality of Khulna granted a permit to collect waste
their organic waste. An additional fee paid by participating
from households and markets. Prior to the construction of
households finances waste collection, and the compost
the plant, RUSTIC had to apply for an environmental
is, in turn, sold directly to the neighbourhood at a low
clearance certificate from the Department of Environment. A
price.
possible variation of this model allows a private
entrepreneur to set up a composting plant on public land.
Though the municipality provides the land, the full financial
and operational responsibility remains with the private
entrepreneur. The municipality grants a long-term lease for
that land (e.g. ten years) to ensure a long-term operation
and, thus, appropriate returns on investments.
Table 4.1 lists these models and briefly describes their

advantages and disadvantages.
Table 4.1: Management models for decentralised composting
Options Characteristics Main Actor(s) Role of City Government or Advantages Constraints
Municipality
Model 1 Integrated into the existing Municipality Introduces recycling and Composting is an alternative treatment Financial constraints due
municipal SWM system and composting into the SWM policy. system, which can be integrated into the to the low priority given
Municipally owned -
focused on reducing waste Implementing agency. existing system (waste collection, to SWM projects.
Municipally operated
which otherwise has to be transport, disposal).
Operating efficiency and
transported and disposed of in All composting sites can be centrally marketing potential may
landfills.
controlled. not be fully exploited.
Cost reduction through lower
City gains valuable soil conditioner to Lack of coordination
transport and disposal costs.
maintain parks and green areas. between departments
regarding the use of the
compost product.
Model 2 Benefiting community is Municipality Introduces recycling and Alleviates the municipal burden of SWM Lack of community
involved in the management of composting into the SWM policy. through community inputs. awareness and interest.
Municipally owned - Local community
primary waste collection and
Community operated Implementing agency. Improvement of solid waste Need for a reliable
composting. NGOs
Supports communities in finding management scope through voluntary informal leader among
Non-profit seeking model. participation. the community.
composting sites and develops a
Cost reduction through lower proper system for waste collection Clear contracts ensure reliable Highly complex
transport and disposal costs. and disposal of residues. partnerships with community groups. management.
Provides support funds for Creates new jobs in the
construction of composting plants neighbourhoods.
and the setting up of a primary
waste collection.
Model 3 Benefiting community is partly Municipality Introduces recycling and Alleviates the municipal burden of SWM Lack of community
Municipally owned - involved. composting into the SWM policy. through private sector participation. awareness and interest.
Private sector or
Privately operated Profit seeking model is possible. NGO Implementing agency. Provision of additional funds and know- Need for a reliable and
Requires at least full cost Selects composting sites, how through private investors. skilled partner with sense
recovery (from fees and constructs plants (investments); Clear contracts ensure reliable of entrepreneurship.
compost sales). develops a proper system for partnerships with private entrepreneurs. Complex management.
Cost reduction through lower waste collection and disposal of Creates new jobs in the
transport and disposal costs. residues. neighbourhoods.
Contracts out the operation and
maintenance. Monitors
performance of contractors.
Model 4 Profit-seeking enterprise based Private sector Introduces recycling and Alleviates the municipal burden of SWM Lack of private land for
on ideal compost market composting into the SWM policy. through private sector participation. composting activities.
Privately owned -
conditions. Income is Transparent regulations for public -
Privately operated Provision of additional funds and know- Lack of vital compost
generated through compost
private partnerships. how through private investors. markets if compost is not
sale and collection fees.
Cooperates in supplying raw Clear contracts ensure reliable a well-known product.
waste and disposal of residues. partnerships with private entrepreneurs.
Can create employment and business
33
34
Activity 2: Determine the viability of the project: collection fee to the entrepreneur. Additional revenues
Benefit-Cost Analysis are generated through the sale of compost. All
investments are made in the first year before operation
The purpose of a benefit-cost analysis is to assess the starts. The income and operation cost from year one
financial viability of the composting scheme. This activity is are constant over the total project period of 5 years.
very important for project planning. If a detailed benefit-cost
analysis is done thoroughly as part of the feasibility study, (a) Determine a time frame for your project (e.g. 5 -10
appraisal is facilitated and potential financial risks can be years)
determined. You should be conservative. All projects have
In this example the project period is five years, which is
certain risks and using too favourable assumptions can lead
determined by the contract between the municipality and
to a failure. If you have no experience with financial issues,
the private entrepreneur. In other instances the project
ask for help to facilitate that activity.
period can also be set according to the expected lifetime of
the equipment.
The benefit-cost analysis should be undertaken only after a
project is found to be feasible on technical, environmental
and social considerations. The investments made on (b) Determine annual project revenues
projects do not usually yield immediate return, as the return The revenues are usually determined for each year of
is generated over a number of years. Similarly, the costs operation and for different revenue types. They are based
incurred on the project may be spread over a number of on your market analysis and your marketing strategy (Task
years. Simply subtracting the costs from the revenues of 1, Activity 3). The forecast of sales revenues is a critical
each year does not allow a reliable judgement of the factor in the calculation because it strongly influences the
financial viability of the project over several years. There is final result. Again, you should be conservative when
the need for converting future costs incurred and revenues estimating the sales revenues.
to be received to a common base called “present value”.
The net present value calculation (NPV) and the benefit- In the case of decentralised composting, usually, there are
cost ratio (BCR) have proven to be suitable methodologies two typical revenue types: revenues from the sale of
for determining the viability of composting schemes. The compost and revenues from waste collection fees. But there
calculation of the BCR provides additional quantitative might be other income types such as income from the sale
information on the viability of a project. The following of recyclables or potted plants or income from carbon
methodology for NPV is derived and adjusted from Jewell credits in the framework of the Clean Development
(An Integrated Approach to Business Studies) and the ADB Mechanism (CDM).
Handbook for the Economic Analysis of Water Supply
Projects. In this simplified case is assumed that the revenues are
constant over the calculated period. (see Table 4.2) In a
The financial benefit-cost analysis includes the following different case, the collection fees might increase over years
steps: or the number of households served might vary. In reality,
the compost prices might also need to be adjusted to
(a) Set a time frame for your project (e.g. 5 -10 years) accommodate the market behaviour.
(b) Determine annual project revenues
Table 4.2: Annual revenues of a decentralised composting plant
(c) Determine project costs
processing 3 tons biodegradable waste per day
(d) Calculate annual project net benefits
Item Tk US $
(e) Determine the appropriate discount rate
(f) Calculate the financial net present value (NPV) Sale of compost 750 kg/day @
600000 12000
(g) Calculate the benefit-cost ratio (BCR) Tk. 2.5/kg (320 days/year)
To be able to calculate NPV and BCR, consult the results of Monthly fee for house-to-house
waste collection service from
the previous tasks and activities and link this information 408000 8160
3400 households @ Tk. 10/
with actual or assumed costs and revenues. (For instance: household
the waste collection fees that residents are willing to pay,
market prices for compost, costs of purchasing technical Total Revenues/ year 1008000 20160
equipment, salaries, etc.)
Note: 1 US $ = Tk. 50
The calculation steps are illustrated by a simplified
example of the benefit-cost analysis for a decentralised (c) Determine project costs
composting plant similar to those established in
Bangladesh. It is assumed that the plant is managed by It is necessary to differentiate between cost types to
a private entrepreneur who uses his privately owned calculate the Net Present Value (NPV) or Benefit-Cost Ratio
land and his own financial resources. The plant has the (BCR) for a new project. Investment costs usually occur at
capacity to process three tons of biodegradable waste the beginning of a project, while annual operation costs go
per day collected from 3400 households (approx. 3.5 along with the daily activities. Financial sources for initial
tons incoming waste). Households pay a monthly investments can be manifold, e.g. the municipal budget,
development agencies or commercial loans. Depending on
35
the financing mechanism additional annual costs for maintenance. Table 4.3 (investment costs) and 4.4
repayment of loans and interest (capital costs) need to be (operational costs) show how costs can be determined and
considered in the calculation. summarised. Capital costs are not considered in this
Operation costs are often divided into fixed costs (e.g. fixed example.
monthly rents or repayments of loans) and variable costs Note that this calculation does not consider costs for
(e.g. irregular maintenance costs, fuel, additives or promotion and marketing of compost. Your might need to
electricity) but a detailed explanation of these aspects consider additional cost for promotion campaigns, depending
cannot be covered by this handbook. Further helpful on the marketing strategy you follow. At the start of the project
literature is listed at the end of this chapter. costs are higher than once a market is established. In any
In this example the operating cost comprises all costs case, the costs for promotion should not be underestimated
including salaries of waste collectors and workers, and need to be included in the budget of the annual
electricity and water, costs of additives and technical operational cost of a composting plant (Table 4.4).
Table 4.3: Investment costs of a decentralised composting plant processing 3 tons biodegradable waste per day
Item Tk US $
Purchase of land: 5 katha @ Tk. 150000/katha 750000 15000
Construction of roofed sorting platform: 360 sq.ft @ Tk. 120/sq.ft 43200 864
Construction of roofed composting shed with drainage facility: 2142 sq.ft @ Tk. 120/sq.ft 257040 5140
Construction of office, bathroom, toilet and storage for recovered recyclables 120 sq.ft @ Tk.
60000 1200
500/sq.ft
Construction of roofed screening area and packaging area: 95 sq.ft @ Tk. 120/sq.ft (additonal 445
11400 228
sq.ft are not roofed – no additional costs)
Purchase of 3 rickshaw vans @ Tk. 15000/rickshaw van 45000 900
Water & electricity connection 50000 1000
Shovels, buckets, balance, protection gear, overalls for workers etc. 50000 1000
Total Investment Cost 1266640 25332
Note: US$1 = Tk. 50; 1 katha = 720 sq.ft.
Table 4.4: Annual operational cost of a composting plant processing 3 tons biodegradable waste per day
Item Tk US $
Salary of 6 workers @ Tk. 2000/month x 12 months 144000 2880
Salary of 3 van drivers @ Tk. 1500/month x 12 months 54000 1080
Salary of 6 waste collectors @ Tk. 800/month x 12 months 57600 1152
Salary of plant manager @ Tk. 5000/month x 12 months 60000 1200
Maintenance costs for equipment (annual) 10000 200
Electricity and water consumption (annual) 5000 100
Additives for composting process (annual) 12000 240
Total Operational Cost 342600 6852
Note: US$ 1 = Tk. 50

36
(d) Calculate annual project net benefits The calculation of the present value (PV) is given by the
formula:
The annual project net benefit is the difference between
revenues and costs for each year. They are calculated for
each year of the operation period. Table 4.5 shows the
annual net benefits for the decentralised composting plant
in US$. The high costs at year 0 are the total investment
costs of the project. As there are no revenues in that year,
the annual net benefit is negative.
where
Table 4.5: Calculation of annual net benefits of a decentralised A is the annual revenue/cost
composting plant (calculation in US$) r is the discount rate (local interest rate)
Year Annual Annual cost Annual net n the year when the revenue/ cost occurs
revenues benefit
The calculation of present values for a whole project is quite
0 0 25332 - 25332 daunting. Therefore, practitioners developed discount factor
tables, which can easily be used in the day-to-day work. The
1 20160 6852 13308
factor is calculated by setting A = 1 currency unit, thus, the
2 20160 6852 13308 discount factors are applicable for all values of all
currencies. Table 4.6 shows a selection of discount factors
3 20160 6852 13308 of different discount rates for periods up to seven years. As
described above, the selection of the discount rate depends
4 20160 6852 13308
on the interest rates of the local market.
5 20160 6852 13308
(e) Determine the appropriate discount rate

The annual net benefits shown in (d) do not present the real
benefit of the project, as time is not considered. It is
necessary to adjust the revenues and costs, which occur in
the future. The method used for converting future cash flows
(costs and revenues) to present value is known as
discounting. Discounting future costs and revenues
enables us to give them an appropriate weight in our
present decision (see Box). Usually, the discount rate is
determined according to the local interest rates for loans.
The discount rate chosen should be close to the rate
prevailing in the market to reflect the scarcity of resources.
Why discounting?
Suppose your friend offers you a US$ 100 gift today or
after one year. You certainly would choose to get the gift
right away. There are different reasons for that: You may
feel the risk that your friend may change his mind over the
year, or you want to use the money now for buying some
books or CDs you recently saw in a shop. You may even
want to put the money to a bank account to gain interest
for a later purchase. In all cases you have more benefits
from the gift if you get it today rather than after one year.
These examples show us that the value of money
decreases with time. The longer you have to wait the
lower is the present value for you.
37
Table 4.6: Discount factors for selected discount rates
Year 6% 8% 10% 12% 14% 16% 18% 20%
1 0.9434 0.9259 0.9091 0.8929 0.8722 0.8621 0.8475 0.8333
2 0.89 0.8573 0.8264 0.7972 0.7695 0.7432 0.7182 0.6944
3 0.8396 0.7938 0.7513 0.7118 0.6750 0.6407 0.6086 0.5787
4 0.7921 0.7350 0.6830 0.6355 0.5921 0.5523 0.5158 0.4823
5 0.7473 0.6806 0.6209 0.5674 0.5194 0.4761 0.4371 0.4019
6 0.7050 0.6302 0.5645 0.5066 0.4556 0.4104 0.3704 0.3349
7 0.6651 0.5835 0.5132 0.4523 0.3996 0.3558 0.3139 0.2791
(f) Calculate the financial net present value (NPV) and add them up. Divide the sum of discounted revenues
(a) by the sum of discounted cost (b) to determine the BCR.
Based on this information it is possible to calculate the net
If the BCR is greater than one, the project is viable. The
present value (NPV). The NPV is the sum of the
BCR partly quantifies the viability of the project. In the
discounted revenues minus the discounted costs. If the
example shown in Table 4.8 the BCR is 1.38. That means
sum of discounted revenues exceeds the investments, than,
investing 1 US$ today, you will get 1.38 US$ in return after
the NPV is positive and the project is viable. Table 4.7
five years.
shows the calculation for the described example that we
have been considering.
Table 4.7: Net present value calculation for a decentralised Table 4.8: Benefit-cost ratio calculation for a decentralised
composting plant (calculation in US$) composting plant (calculation in US$)
Year Annual Annual Annual Discount NPV Year Annual Annual Discount Annual Annual BCR
revenues cost net factor revenues cost factor discounted discounted = (a/b)
benefit (discount (discount revenues costs
rate 16%) rate 16%)
0 0 25332 - 25332 1 - 25332 0 0 25 332 1 0 25332
1 20160 6852 13308 0.8621 11473 1 20160 6852 0.8621 17380 5907
2 20160 6852 13308 0.7432 9890 2 20160 6852 0.7432 14983 5092
3 20160 6852 13308 0.6407 8526 3 20160 6852 0.6407 12917 4390
4 20160 6852 13308 0.5523 7350 4 20160 6852 0.5523 11134 3784
5 20160 6852 13308 0.4761 6336 5 20160 6852 0.4761 9598 3262
Sum of NPV 18243 (a) 66012 (b) 47767 1.38
A positive NPV indicates a profitable project, meaning that In any case it is advisable to repeat the calculation with
the project generates sufficient funds to cover all costs and changing variables in order to assess possible sensitivities
expected repayments under the assumed conditions. It can of your calculation. For instance:
run independently and is expected to generate profits. The • vary the number of households who pay for the service or
higher the NPV the more the profit that can be generated. A
negative NPV indicates that a project is not financially viable • assume increasing salary costs over time or
under the assumed conditions. Such projects must seek for • assume you have to take a loan and need to pay interest.
additional income (e.g. subsidies) or for cost reductions to
become financially viable. Of course, the outcome of the
NPV calculation strongly depends on the chosen discount
rate. If the discount rate is high, the revenues must be
higher to achieve a positive NPV.
(g) Calculate the benefit-cost ratio (BCR)

Finally, calculate the benefit-cost ratio. Similarly to the NPV,
determine the discounted revenues and costs for each year
38
Activity 3: Develop the contract for involved

partners
Once you have selected the appropriate business model

and have completed the benefit-cost analysis, you may get
the approval to set up the decentralised composting
scheme. It is crucial that the partnership is defined in the
form of a memorandum of understanding or contract. In
some countries, it is not common to sign contracts.
Nevertheless, as long as private investments are involved,
a contract provides a certain level of security. Furthermore,
a contract clarifies the rights and duties of the relevant
partners and helps to avoid future quarrels. The set up of
contracts needs know-how and extensive negotiations
among stakeholders. The sample contract shown in Annex
5 is derived from a case in Bangladesh and further
generalised. It can act as guidance but does not claim
completeness or applicability in all cases.
Further reading
Coad, Adrian (2005): Private Sector Involvement in Solid
Waste Management – Avoiding Problems and Building
Successes. Published by CWG – Collaborative Working
Group on Solid Waste Management in Low- and Middle-
income Countries (order: booklet with CD: www.skat.ch or
full version: www.gtz.de)
Asian Development Bank (1999): Handbook for the

Economic Analysis of Water Supply Projects, Economics
and Development Resource Centre. Though the focus is on
water supply, many aspects are also relevant for SWM.
(download from: http://www.adb.org/publications/year.asp -
ADB Publications Catalogue)
Jewell, Bruce, R. (2004): An Integrated Approach to

Business Studies. 4th Edition. Pearson Education Limited,
Harlow, UK.
GTZ (2005): Improvement of Sanitation and Solid Waste

Management in Urban Poor Settlements, GTZ, Eschborn,
Germany (order or download from http://www.gtz.de/en
themen/umwelt-infrastruktur/abfall/2841.htm
Task 5
Development and Design of Collection System

41
Task 5: Development and Design of Collection System
Technology is dominated by two types of people: those who understand what they do not manage, and those who
manage what they do not understand. (Putt’s Law)
After choosing the organisational setup of the composting • Since waste can be corrosive and abrasive, ensure
scheme and partners, you can focus on technical aspects of protective measures for metal surfaces (e.g. paint)
the scheme. Guidance of this handbook now shifts from particularly for containers.
planning to implementation. • The volume of the vehicle is limited by waste density and
travel distance. The denser the waste, the heavier it
As mentioned several times in previous chapters, the becomes! A person cannot push or pull the same load as
success of a composting scheme is closely linked to a motorised vehicle, e.g. 2 m3 waste of 0.5 t/m3 density
successful waste collection. Customers (households) must weigh 1 ton! This is already above the limit that a person
be satisfied with the service provided. Waste should be can push or pull on most surfaces.
collected daily or at least every alternate day to prevent • The service area determines the volume and number of
odour emissions and facilitate waste separation. trips the vehicle has to cover.
Task 5 focuses on the waste collection system and then • Select good quality vehicles even though they are more
Task 6 reviews the composting system. You can skip Task 5 expensive. You will save money in the long run, as these
if you are in the comfortable position of already running a vehicles need fewer repairs.
well-organised waste collection service or receiving the • Check the availability of spare vehicle parts on the local
waste from a primary collection service for which you are market. Place special attention to the wheels and
not responsible. bearings, as they are the most important part of the
vehicle.
After finalising the activities of Task 5, you will be informed • Determine whether women or men are responsible for
about: waste collection. Some vehicles may be unsuitable for
women others for men.
• the most appropriate vehicles and the number required • The storage containers of the vehicles should be covered
• how to ensure the participation and support of the to avoid the waste from falling out and protect it from
community served excessive rainfall.
• how to promote waste segregation at source (in the • If you promote source segregation, plan different
household) compartments on your collection vehicle.
Activity 1: Select the most appropriate vehicles
Selection of the most appropriate waste collection vehicles for

a specific collection area is an important task. Well-designed
waste collection vehicles contribute to increasing waste
collection efficiency and collectors’ safety. As mentioned in
Task 2, several factors, such as topography, settlement
structure or road conditions, have to be considered. Vehicles
already used for transport of goods on the local market offer
an indication of the types of vehicles which could be used for
your collection scheme. Remember that your scheme will be
responsible for primary waste collection. Activity 1 assumes
that the composting plant will be located in or close to the
area where the waste collection will take place. Thus the
collection vehicles will generally be small and suited to the
transport of waste for shorter distances.
During selection, the following aspects should be taken into

consideration:
• Road conditions and settlement structure: The vehicles

may have to travel through narrow lanes.
• Type of household waste collected: If the sand content is
Photograph 5.1: The manual handcart with a grid container and broad
high, the container should be constructed with a strong
wheels was adapted to the local sandy road conditions and high sand
grid instead of a closed metal sheet to allow the sand to fraction. The sand falls through the grid, thus reducing the weight of
fall out. waste (AGRESU – GTZ GmbH, Maputo, Mozambique)
42
Table 5.1 is compiled from various sources. It summarises different vehicle types and their characteristics.
Table 5.1: Comparative characteristics of waste collection vehicles
Parameter Manual Animal Cart Rickshaw Tractor Fixed Bed Tipper Truck Compactor Container
Handcart Van Trailer Truck Truck Truck
Range < 2 km < 5 km < 10 km < 15 km Unlimited Unlimited Unlimited Unlimited
Speed Very slow Relatively slow Slow Moderate Fast Fast Fast Fast
Road size Narrow Moderate Narrow Moderate Wide Wide Wide Wide
suitability
Volume per 0.5 m3 2 m3 2-3 m3 4 m3 8 m3 10 m3 12 m3 20 m3
vehicle
Labour 1 Collector 1 Driver 1 Driver 1 Driver 1 Driver 1 Driver 1 Driver 1 Driver
requirements
2 Labourers 1 Labourer 2 Labourers 3 Labourers 2 Labourers 2 Labourers
Investment Very low Low Low Relatively low Moderately High Very high Very high
costs high
Maintenance Very low Low Low Relatively low Moderately High Very high Very high
costs high
Service life 5 years 5 years 10 years 10 years 5 years 5 years 5 years 5 years
Trips/day 2 2 3 2 2 4 3 3
Source : Ogwa,1988
Photograph 5.2: Rickshaw with front loader and containers in which Photograph 5.4: Horse cart capable of pulling up to eight rectangular
waste is separated into three fractions (CEE Kalyan Nagar Residence containers (container exchange system) (Community Organisation,
Association, Bangalore, India) Agaki, Ethiopia)
Photograph 5.3: Rickshaw with a covered collection container and back Photograph 5.5: Moto-rickshaw for long-distance waste collection. The
doors (Waste Concern, Waste Collection and Composting Scheme, tailboard is often higher to prevent the waste from falling out (CEE
Mirpur, Dhaka, Bangladesh) Kalyan Nagar Residence Association, Bangalore, India)
43
Activity 2: Select the appropriate waste collection Table 5.2: Comparison of various solid waste collection models
system
Description House-to- Kerbside Block Communal
House Collection Collection Collection
The outcome of the community survey should already
Collection
reveal the collection system favoured and affordable by the
community. Different collection models are possible: Householder No Yes Yes Yes
cooperation in
• House-to-house collection carrying refuse
bins
There are two basic types. In back-door or yard collection Householder No No Optional Yes
the waste collector enters the garden or courtyard and cooperation in
carries the waste bin to the collection vehicle. After emptying refuse
emptying, the collectors return the bin to its original bins
location. This method is not culturally acceptable in many Need for Optional Yes Optional No
scheduled
places. In front door collection the collector rings the bell
service
or sounds a signal outside and waste is brought out to
Susceptibility to None High None Very high
him by a member of the household. This collection model
scavenging
is very effective and suitable for source segregation, but
Average crew 3-5 1-3 1-3 1-2
is also most labour-intensive and time-consuming. size (portable)
Furthermore, it requires at least one household member
2-4
to be present during collection.
(stationary)
• Block collection/Bell collection Trespassing Yes No No No

complaints
A vehicle follows a predetermined route at fixed intervals; Level of service Good Good Fair Poor
it stops at selected locations where a bell is rung.
Collection costs Very high High Medium Low
Households bring out and hand over their waste
containers to the collection crew. Source: UNCHS (Habitat), Refuse collection vehicles for developing
countries, p. 10, 1988
• Kerbside collection
This type of collection system requires regular service
and a fairly exact collection schedule. The households
have to be instructed to put their (ideally closed) waste
bin in front of their house just before the regular collection
schedule. This will prevent rummaging by waste pickers
or animals.
• Communal collection bins

This widely used system requires the households to bring
their waste to a communal bin, which is emptied into
large trucks. This system is inappropriate for composting
as waste may be stored for over several days in the
households before being brought to the container and so
the waste becomes partly decomposed and compressed.
Table 5.2 is drawn from a UNCHS publication. It summarises

and compares the different waste collection models.
No matter which collection system you choose, inform the

households about its organisation and how they can
contribute to its smooth and efficient operation. A regular and
reliable waste collection service motivates many households
to cooperate. Here the Community Committee (see Task 2)
is an important communication partner. Motivation will
generally lead to greater improvements than strict
regulations or even threats of punishment, whose
enforcement is beyond your competence. Hence, you rely
on voluntary cooperation. Photograph 5.6: House-to-house collection requires the presence of a
household member (Waste Concern, Dhaka, Bangladesh)
44
Activity 3: Calculate the number of vehicles Experience also reveals that such a calculation provides
required only preliminary indication of the number of collection
vehicles required. This calculation will certainly have to be
How many vehicles are required to collect the waste in your adapted after the first operational experience. Be prepared
service area? To be able to answer this question, some to reorganise collection or to add an additional collection
assumptions and calculations are necessary: crew to the team.
• Firstly, determine the volume your vehicle can carry. The Investment in an additional reserve vehicle in the event of a
aforementioned table provides guidance on this subject. breakdown is highly recommended. Such breakdowns are
very likely, especially if maintenance of the collection
• Secondly, decide on collection frequency and model
vehicles is neglected. Ensure frequent checks and
(daily, every alternate day, house-to-house, kerbside,
maintenance of all moving parts. Check the condition of:
block collection, street bin collection) as they influence
the time required.
• bearings (greasing necessary?)
• Thirdly, assess time required for one collection team to fill
• wheels and handles (air pressure, fixed?)
the selected vehicle given a certain household density.
This indicates the number of trips of one team per day. • brakes (functional?)
Add time required to travel from the composting plant to • container (cleaning new point, necessary?)
the collection area and back. A map of the community
• engine (if any)
could be very useful here. Photograph 5.7 illustrates how
a community organisation in Bangalore has structured
the service area.
• Finally, calculate the number of collection teams
necessary to cover the entire area. The calculation is
based on the time required for each collection trip and the
daily working hours of each collection team.
Table 5.3 will help to structure and calculate your data. It

exemplifies the planning of a house-to-house waste
collection system in a rather flat area. The following
assumptions are the bases for the calculation:
Table 5.3: Example of the calculation of the vehicle demand
Parameters
Collection frequency & model daily, house-to-house

Photograph 5.7: Solid waste collection zones and routes in a municipal
Average waste generation 0.6 kg/cap = 3 kg/household district of Bangalore (CEE, Bangalore, India)
Waste density 350 kg/m3
Volume of vehicle 1 m3
Activity 4: Community participation and mobilisation
Collection time per vehicle 3 hours for waste collection
Time to and from composting area 15 + 15 minutes
Since details on community participation and mobilisation
Coverage 100 households could fill yet another book, this handbook provides merely
Labour requirement (1 team) 2 persons some suggestions on how to mobilise the community.
Further reading on community mobilisation is listed at the
Result: end of this section.
One team can cover two trips per day (8 hours).
This is equal to a total of 200 households per day. Community mobilisation for a waste collection and
composting scheme generally aims at:
Total number of households
700
in the project area
• raising the awareness of people regarding the benefits of
Result: a cleaner neighbourhood and compost production
Three teams can cover too little • explaining how waste can be turned into a resource
600 households • explaining how the scheme is organised and what each
Four teams can cover too much individual is expected to do
800 households
• encouraging people to come forward with ideas and
Final decision: initiatives, and to make complaints
Start with four teams to allow a reserve capacity and a • enhancing willingness of the households to pay for the
certain operational flexibility. new service
45
The results of the community survey in Task 2 provide an 3. Ensure accountability and transparency.
important basis for community mobilisation.
People want to know what happens with their money.
• Contact the community leaders and the Community Provide annual information on use of the money
Committee and inform them about the latest decisions through information campaigns. As accountability is so
and future objectives. Present the results of your survey important, introduce a receipt system. When receiving
and explain why a specific collection system will be the monthly waste fee, collectors hand out numbered
applied. receipts, thereby providing residents with proof of their
• Contact households directly or during a community contribution. The fee collector has to report to the plant
meeting using short and simple information leaflets. manager or to the accountant by handing over the fees
Inform them about the launching of the collection system, and duplicates of the receipts.
i.e., days and times they should expect the waste
collectors. Distribute practical collection schedules for the
households to display close to their waste bins. Activity 6: Try to promote source segregation
• If the scheme creates new jobs, try to recruit the staff
from among the community members, even if you have to The most labour-intensive and tedious task of the
provide additional on-the-job training. The more local composting process is waste separation. It can be facilitated
people are involved, the more the new service will be if households of the community agree to segregate the
accepted. waste, putting biodegradable (or “wet”) waste into a different
container from the one used for other wastes (see Task 7).
Community mobilisation is a never-ending job, as interest Recyclables are more easily sorted and of higher quality
since they are less polluted. However, implementation of
and participation have to be maintained through regular
source segregation requires long-term preparation and
information. Beneficiaries tend to take the service for
vehicle modification (two compartments in the container).
granted once it is established and smoothly running.
Remind them of the efforts and work required to keep up the
If at-source segregation is being considered, this will require
service and operation (e.g. inform the community at least
an intensive and long-lasting publicity and follow-up
once a year of the latest developments of the collection and
campaign in order to achieve a satisfactory degree of
composting scheme). School visits and open days may help
segregation, unless there are significant financial
to raise the local profile of the scheme.
incentives. The European experience shows that in many
cities source segregation could only be implemented by
accompanying measures such as an incentive tax
Activity 5: Organise and introduce fee collection according to the “polluter-pays-principle”. That means that
households pay fees only for residual waste collection;
Studies have revealed that fee collection can be a tedious organic waste and recyclables are collected at no cost to
and time-consuming task. Inefficient fee collection, which the domestic generator. In this way more effective
can harm the viability of the collection and composting segregation results in lower fees. Such accompanying
scheme, is mainly caused by the low level of acceptance of measures require an overall enforcement of existing solid
the scheme by the households. This clearly indicates the waste management laws and regulations, and greatly
importance of a preliminary study and involvement of the depend on the political environment and the level of
community in the planning process. If the majority of the environmental awareness among the general public.
households are willing to pay, other households will follow. Hence, do not expect too much success at the beginning,
There will always be households stating that they are as the scheme is dependent on the awareness of the
already charged for such a service and, therefore, refuse to households and their voluntary participation. The following
pay additional fees. Others claim that they do not trust the three activities will raise the awareness of the community:
fee collectors or do not have the amount ready. However, the
collection rate can be increased by three simple measures: • Prepare and distribute leaflets among the households
describing the benefits of source segregation and
guidelines helping residents to differentiate between
1. Introduce periodic fee collection (e.g. monthly). inorganic and organic waste.
Although it is more expensive to collect each month, • Affix posters with basic information to your collection
the regularity of the collection and the smaller amount trucks.
to be paid (compared to a bi-annual collection) should • Organise an open-house event, inviting the community to
produce a better response. the composting plant. Explain on site why source
segregation greatly contributes to enhancing the
2. Officially appoint fee collectors. operation of the composting plant. However, make sure
Inform households about the responsible fee collector, that your composting plant is in excellent condition when
who could be the waste collectors, an employee of the you invite the community!
scheme or a voluntary community member, depending
on the social network. However, according to
experience, waste collectors are quite capable of
collecting the fees efficiently, as they visit the
households regularly and are known to the inhabitants.
46
Further reading
UNCHS (Habitat) (1988): Refuse Collection Vehicles for
Developing Countries, Nairobi (out of print but available on
request from www.sandec.ch)
Rouse, J.R. & Ali, S.M. (2002): Vehicles for People or

People for Vehicles, Loughborough University, ISBN: 1
84380 012 8, Loughborough (download from:
http://wedc.lboro.ac.uk/publications/catalogue.htm)
UNDP & Ministry of Urban Development, Government of

India (1993): Community based solid waste management –
Project Preparation
Pfammatter & Schertenleib (1996): Non-Governmental

Refuse Collection in Low-Income Urban Areas, EAWAG/
SANDEC, Duebendorf, Switzerland (download from:
www. sandec.ch)
GTZ (2005): Improvement of Sanitation and Solid Waste

Management in Urban Poor Settlements, GTZ, Eschborn,
Germany
Ogawa. H. (1988): “Selection of Appropriate Technologies

for SWM in Asian Metropolises’ a paper published in
Regional Development Dialogue, Volume 10, No. 3,
UNCRD, Nagoya, Japan.
Task 6
Design and Construction of Composting Facility

49
Task 6: Design and Construction of Composting Facility
For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for nature cannot be fooled.
(Richard Feynman)
This section describes a composting plant and its various 1.2), whereas windrow composting schemes need sufficient
components. Since local conditions strongly influence final area for a proper setup. In any case they should be
composting plant design, the descriptions and illustrations protected from unauthorised access and public view. Table
provided should be used merely as guidelines and 6.1 provides an overview of possible criteria to facilitate
recommendations. Local construction experts should be selection of the most appropriate technology.
consulted and the usage of materials adapted to the local
context, but always related to the key functions of each
component.
Activity 1: Plan and decide on the composting
Task 6 gives guidance on design and construction of a
plant layout
composting facility processing three to five tons of (mixed)
household waste per day. You will learn: A composting plant comprises an operation area and a
“green” buffer zone. The buffer zone, formed by a belt of
• how much space is required by a composting facility bushes and trees surrounding the operation area, improves
the visual appearance of the composting plant (see
treating three tons of waste per day
photograph 6.6). The operation area is divided into different
• fundamental construction rules for the two composting zones. It contains space for waste unloading and sorting,
processes presented composting, maturing, sieving and bagging of the compost,
• useful construction material and equipment including storage space for compost and recyclables. These
zones must be arranged so as to ensure efficient workflow
• how to divide the available space into functional
of the composting process.
compartments to enhance the workflow.
Annex 4 contains two layouts of typical composting plants
Task 6 describes the design of composting plants applying similar to the ones operated in Bangladesh. Annex 4A
the following two techniques: provides an example of a windrow composting plant, and
Annex 4B a composting plant applying the box technique.
• Windrow Composting Table 6.2 indicates the minimum space requirements for the
• Box Composting different workflow units within the premises of a composting
plant. Additional space should be allocated for a caretaker’s
The choice of a composting technology is dependent on office and sanitary facilities for the workers. Take into
several criteria, such as space availability near the housing account that the final setup of the site is strongly dependent
area served. Box composting units require limited space on the local conditions.
and can be placed even along roadsides (see Photograph
Table 6.1: Matrix for selection of the most appropriate technology

Constraining Criteria Windrow Box Explanation
Composting Composting
Box composting requires less space than

Space is limited X
windrows.
Windrow composting requires less investment in
Long-term availability of land is not ensured X
stationary infrastructure.
Windrow composting is less expensive due to
Financial constraints for initial investments X
lower infrastructural requirements.
Box composting requires less manpower than
Labour is hard to find X
windrow composting.
Box composting is less labour-intensive than
Working with waste is perceived as “dirty work” X
windrow composting.
50
Table 6.2: Required space for a composting plant processing three water supply is not continuous. A further useful feature is a
tons of waste per day rainwater harvesting system. The roof of the composting
Type Required Area Required Area Roof
shed and other facilities can be specially designed to collect
Windrow Box rainwater from the rooftops. During the rainy season, water
Composting Composting can be collected in a tank to bridge water shortages during
the dry season. The storage volume is dependent on the
Composting area
length of the dry season and on the daily water demand.
Sorting area 40 m2 40 m2 yes Rainwater can be used for the composting process, for
Storage of rejects 30 m2 30 m2 yes cleaning and washing of the composting plant and for
watering of the green belt. Figure 6.1 shows a rainwater
Storage of
10 m2 10 m2 yes collection and storage system at a composting site. A guide
recyclables
for capacity calculation and design is available on Sandec’s
Composting pad 400 m2 360 m2 yes webpage: Rainwater Harvesting at the Co-Composting Site
Maturation area 150 m2 150 m2 yes in Kumasi, Ghana.
Screening and http://www.sandec.ch/Publications/PublicationsHome.htm#SWM
35 m2 35 m2 yes
bagging area
Compost storage
25 m2 25 m2 yes
area
Sub-total
690 m2 650 m2
composting area
Facilities
Office 16 m2 16 m2 yes
Sanitary facilities 10 m2 10 m2 yes
Tool shed 10 m2 10 m2 yes
Water supply point 4 m2 4 m2 no
Additional space
requirements
Vehicles parking area 30 m2 30 m2 no

Figure 6.1: Diagram of a water storage system combining water storage
Green buffer zone and rainwater harvesting
50 m2 50 m2 no
(trees/bushes)
Total area 810 m2 770 m2
These composting schemes can be scaled up or down

depending on the local conditions. Since both composting
systems are modular, the composting area can be extended
to five tons of waste per day. To protect the workers from
difficult and unhygienic working conditions, this capacity
should not be increased beyond that amount as the system
is still based on manual work. If more waste has to be
treated, a higher degree of mechanisation (causing higher
investment and operational costs) will have to be
considered. However, higher capacities are unnecessary,
as the decentralised composting sites seldom cover more
than 3000 households.
Photograph 6.1: Rainwater harvesting system at the co-composting

pilot plant in Kumasi, Ghana. The small “first flush tank”, behind the
Activity 2: Plan the required key features main tank, collects the first incoming rainwater, diverting dust and dirt
from the roof. (Sandec)
The following key features have to be considered during
planning and construction regardless of the type of Both windrow and box composting operations should
composting scheme chosen: be conducted under a roof to protect the compost piles
from excessive rain and sun. Simple light structures with
vertical steel angles, mild steel pipes or wood or bamboo
On-site water supply is a basic infrastructural requirement poles can be used to support the roof. Photograph 6.1 and
on a composting site. Since it is used for hygienic purposes Figure 6.5 illustrate two types of roof constructions. To allow
and for watering the compost heaps, a reliable water supply easier workflow during composting, the minimum distance
should be ensured, such as a standpipe on the site. An between the pillars should be three meters. Corrugated iron
additional water storage tank is, however, advisable if the sheets, bamboo thatch or any other locally available roofing
51
material can be used. Depending on the soil bearing

capacity, special attention should be given to construction of
the foundation to avoid settlement and cracks in the
structures. Jute or specially designed compost fleece is
suitable in semi-arid and arid regions to protect the compost
from excessive evaporation. Since compost requires
oxygen for decomposition, the cover must be permeable to
air. Photograph 6.2 illustrates the use of a compost fleece Figure 6.3: Sorting on a platform. Waste is delivered onto the platform.
on small windrows. Workers stand upright and sort out organic waste and fill it into
wheelbarrows below. Advantage: no further need for shoveling and no
direct contact with the waste
Figure 6.4: Sorting on a sorting table with hinged table top. Waste is
shoveled onto a table and rejects are sorted out. Remaining organic
waste is filled into a wheelbarrow by lifting the table top. This system is
suitable for waste with a very high biodegradable fraction such as waste
from fruit and vegetable markets
The storage areas for rejects and recyclables should be

roofed and possibly enclosed to prevent roaming animals
from entering the site. The area has to be accessible to
Photograph 6.2: A composting fleece protects compost piles from
trucks, as the rejects have to be collected frequently. A
excessive sun and rain if no roof is available. The fleece also prevents covered container for rejects, easily picked up and replaced
the compost from being rummaged by animals. (Sandec, Community by a truck, is a good alternative to a storage room. The
Composting, Switzerland) necessary storage volume is determined by the collection
frequency. The required amount of storage space can be
The sorting area consists of a sealed concrete surface calculated by the following equation:
where waste is sorted into organics, inorganic recyclables
and rejects. The sealed surface facilitates cleaning after
sorting is completed. Since the waste delivered may be high
in moisture, the area should be slightly sloped (1%) to avoid
leachate ponding. A drainage system collects leachate and
cleaning water to be reused for watering composting
windrows (see Annex 4C). wastetot total waste amount (kg)
wasterecyclable recyclables (kg)
In Bangladesh, sorting is conducted on the floor with rakes wasteorganic organic waste (kg)
and shovels (see Photograph 7.1 in Task 7). In other densityrejects density of rejects (kg/m3) varies between
contexts, construction of a sorting table or platform allowing
people to stand upright could be appropriate. Three sorting 300 and 600 kg/m3
options are illustrated in Figures 6.2 to 6.4. More
sophisticated sorting systems with conveyor belts are not The area required for the storage zone for recyclables is
recommended for such small-scale composting facilities, as dependent on the inherent properties of the materials.
they require significantly higher investment and operational Paper and cardboard for instance only have to be bundled
costs. and piled, while plastic and glass are collected in old bags.
Each plant should have a lockable office equipped with

basic furniture to allow the supervisor to keep the
monitoring and accounting records. It also provides a
sheltered area for breaks and for storing personal
belongings. Sanitary installations, such as toilets and
washing facilities, are essential. After handling waste and
compost, the workers should wash and change their clothes
Figure 6.2: Sorting on the ground. Organic waste is filled into buckets before leaving the workplace. Small equipment, such as
and carried to the windrow or box sieves, shovels and rakes, should be stored in the tool
shed. Such facilities require approximately 40 m2, and all
should be roofed and fitted with lockable doors for security
reasons.
52
Specific features of the windrow composting area

The composting area is preferably a concrete slab slightly
sloped (1%) towards one side to allow excessive water from
the compost heaps to flow into a drain. Along the lower end
of the slab, a drainage channel for leachate collection leads
to a collection point. An area of 360m2 is sufficient to hold
seven parallel windrows (see Annex 4A and 4B).
Triangular aerators significantly enhance windrow

composting. If possible they should be constructed of a
material that is resistant to natural degradation. Aerators
made of bamboo and plastic are described here. The
advantage of the bamboo aerator is its low price and
availability. However, bamboo is not entirely resistant to Photograph 6.4: Piled waste around short plastic aerators (Waste
degradation and has to be replaced frequently. To construct Concern, Bangladesh)
bamboo aerators like shown in photograph 6.3, bamboo
strips are nailed lengthwise onto triangular wooden frames Specific features of the box composting area
(maintaining equal gaps). The plastic model is made of
perforated plastic panels. This model is more expensive but The layout of a box composting system is illustrated in
also more resistant to natural degradation and has a longer photograph 6.5, Figure 6.6 and Annex 4B. Box composting
service life. The sides of a triangular aerator measure 0.6 m requires less space but more construction efforts and higher
and the entire length of an aerator is 2.7 m. As can be seen investments than windrow composting. A plant processing
in the schematic layout of Annex 4A about 36 aerators are three tons of organic waste requires about 24 boxes (1.45 m
necessary for a windrow composting plant that processes wide, 6 m long and 1.2 m high). The front side of the box is
about three tons of sorted organic waste waste. closed by means of removable wood panels, which can be
removed for emptying the box (see Figure 6.6). Since the
distance between the boxes is 0.75 m, the total space
requirements are lower than for the windrow technology. The
slab on which the boxes are built should be sealed and slope
towards one side. Leachate collection channels leading to
the edge of the composting floor are located between the
boxes and discharge into a central collection point. To
improve the oxygen supply to the pile, the box wall contains
gaps between the bricks. The perforated base of the box
should be resistant to corrosion and thus is equipped with
small PVC pipes or a coated metal grid. This base ensures
better aeration and drainage of excessive water from the pile
(see details in Annex 4C). Finally, perforated PVC pipes (see
details in Annex 4C) are placed vertically inside the box to
provide additional oxygen exchange within the compost
Photograph 6.3: Bamboo aerator; side length of triangular frame 0.6 m,
length 2.7 m (Waste Concern, Bangladesh) material.
Figure 6.5: Cross section of a typical three-ton composting plant (box composting) with details of roof, floor, compost box, and drainage system (Waste
Concern, Bangladesh)
53
Photograph 6.5 and Figure 6.6: Box composting plant and close-up model of a compost box with plastic door at the front end facilitating emptying
(Waste Concern, Bangladesh)
Useful additional composting plant features

Apart from compost production, the composting plant can
promote among the citizens the idea of resource
conservation and recycling. A series of additional
composting plant features are presented here to illustrate
how a composting plant can raise environmental
awareness:
Kiosk: A small, square-shaped structure with a light roof

can be set up within the premises of a composting plant.
The kiosk can be used as a sales and display point for
compost products or potted plants raised on compost. A
kiosk like that shown in Figure 6.7 can help promoting
organic farming and agricultural use of compost to visitors
of the site.
Photograph 6.6: Nursery and organic farming unit in a composting plant
in Dhaka, Bangladesh (Waste Concern, Bangladesh)
Figure 6.7: Example of a kiosk replicated in 14 towns in Bangladesh Figure 6.8: Composting plant with an integrated plot for organic farming
(Waste Concern, Bangladesh) for promotion. (Waste Concern, Bangladesh)
Organic farming demonstration site: If sufficient land and Wastewater reuse system: A significant amount of
staff are available, a small plot inside the composting plant wastewater is generated during composting and the
can be used as demonstration unit for organic farming or as cleaning of the facility. Instead of discharging the
a nursery for pot plants. The core idea is to encourage the wastewater into drains, it can be reused for new compost
owner of the composting plant to maintain, as far as piles to maintain the moisture balance and enhance the
possible, the facility clean and green. A clean and pleasant decomposition process. Wastewater from the drainage
environment near a composting plant can change negative system can be collected in a small covered storage tank
perceptions of waste treatment and the use of compost can below ground level. By mixing this wastewater with fresh
be directly demonstrated to visitors. Furthermore, a nursery
creates an additional source of income (Figure 6.8).
54
Table 6.3: Staff required for a three tons/day composting plant
Windrow Box Requirements

Technique Technique
Manager/ Engineer 1 1 Graduate with management skills and willing to work with waste.
Responsible for monitoring mass flows, keeping records on plant
performance and accounting. Strategic planning and marketing if not
conducted by an external agent (e.g. NGO or company).
Collection workers (part-time) 4 4 Basic mechanical skills, responsible for maintenance and minor repairs.
Composting workers (full-time) 6 4 At least one worker should be literate, responsible for temperature monitoring
and recording.
Lab staff (optional) 1 1 Graduate with chemical background.
Marketing staff (optional) 1 1 Graduate in marketing and/or agricultural economics.
water from the pipes or rainwater tank, scarce water Table 6.4: Additional equipment and expendables
resources can be extended and conservation promoted.
Items Windrow and Box
Technique
Energy efficient lighting system: If the compost plant is
Sorting
connected to the electricity grid, an energy-efficient lighting
Sorting table (if favoured) 2
system should be fitted to set a good example of energy
Buckets 6
conservation and to reduce operational costs in the long
Shovels 6
run.
Rakes (long or short handle) 6
Composting
Watering pots 2
Activity 3: Plan staffing requirements Thermometer 2
Sieving (two alternatives)
Generally, the staff of the composting plant needs to be Flat frame sieve (Photograph
willing to work with waste. Such a commitment ensures long- 2
7.14, mesh size 8 and 16 mm)
term capacity building and increases know-how within the Sieving drum (Photograph 7.15,
plant. Selection of staff strongly depends on local habits and 1
mesh size 8 and 16 mm)
values (culture, religion, gender, perceptions) and has to be Bagging
discussed in detail (e.g. if women can be involved in waste Bags (woven plastic bags, their Depending on
handling). Experience reveals that composting plants often size is dependent on market requirements
provide interesting job opportunities for underprivileged and availability)
poor people. Formalised waste collection, sorting and Equipment for sealing bags Depending on
composting ensures long-term employment and the requirements
opportunity to get trained on the job and specialised in Miscellaneous
composting. However, some of the workers should be Brooms 6
literate, as the composting process requires reliable Baskets 6
monitoring and recording activities (e.g. temperature, weight Uniforms, gloves, boots and Two sets for each worker
and moisture measurements). Furthermore, the composting face masks
business also offers jobs for dedicated engineers, which
have the overall responsibility of management and
operation. Table 6.3 describes jobs, necessary skills and the
average number of required staff for a composting plant Further Reading
processing three tons of waste per day. Diaz, L. et al. (1993): Composting and recycling municipal
solid waste, ISBN 0-87371-563-2. This comprehensive
book covers all aspects of solid waste collection,
Activity 4: Plan additional equipment and characterisation and recycling. Chapters 6, 7 and 8 focus on
expendables composting and markets for compost.
Additional equipment and expendables, as shown in Table Haug, R.T. (1980): Compost Engineering, Principles and
6.4 guarantee workers’ safety and promote efficient process Practices, ISBN 0-250-40347-1. This book is more suitable
performance. Most of the equipment is also illustrated in the for technicians and engineers which seek more information
photographs in Task 7 (Operation and Maintenance). Apart about the process engineering of composting.
from the sieving equipment, most of the expendables must
be replaced frequently (e.g. monthly or annually) and Chiumetti A., Chiumetti R, Diaz L., Savage G., Eggerth L.
considered in project budgeting. The waste collection (2005): Modern Composting Technologies, BioCycle,
equipment is not considered here. Emmaus, USA, (ISBN 0-932424-29-5).
Task 7
Operating and Maintaining a Compostion Facility

57
Task 7: Operating and Maintaining a Composting Facility
By the work one knows the workmen. (Jean de la Fontaine, 1621 - 1695)
Composting comprises various steps starting from waste

After finalising the activities of Task 7 you will have been
sorting until the final bagging of the compost product. Task
informed about:
7 gives guidance for the operation and maintenance of a
composting plant including aspects of quality control and
• the different steps of a composting process
trouble shooting. The composting process can be divided
into nine steps which are shown in Figure 7.1 below. Waste • the required quality criteria for input material and
from households arriving at the composting plant is sorted additives
into several fractions. The organic fraction enters the • how to measure important process parameters such
composting process. It is mixed with additives if necessary as temperature and moisture
and piled into the composting system. The composting
• how to maintain the compost plant
process has to be monitored by different parameters
(temperature, moisture). Finally, the mature compost is • which are the typical problems of the composting
screened and prepared for selling. Residues from sorting process and how to solve them
and screening are recycled or disposed of. • the most important quality criteria and how to control
them.
Activity 1: Operation and monitoring
Operational safety and health protection for workers should

be the priority concern. Workers should be obliged to wear
protective gear like uniforms, gloves and boots at any stage
when they are handling waste and compost.
Step 1: Sorting
Compost quality is mainly determined by the quality of the
input material. Hence, the sorting of the waste plays a vital
role. Substances which are not biodegradable need to be
separated from the biodegradable fraction. Sorting is
especially crucial with regard to hazardous materials. They
must be removed before the composting piles are formed.
Otherwise they will contaminate the entire pile and severely
compromise the final compost quality. Figure 7.2 shows the
classification of typical domestic waste and gives guidance
regarding which materials are suitable for composting.
If households are willing to segregate their waste at source

it saves a tremendous amount of time and costs for the
composting scheme. Moreover, it increases the quality of
both biodegradable waste and recyclables. Hence, the long
term goal should be the introduction of source segregation
of waste in households.
Figure 7.1: Flow chart showing composting process steps and material
flows
58
Figure 7.2: The quality of compost strongly depends on the input material. If source segregation cannot be implemented waste separation prior to
composting is necessary
Sorting of incoming waste

• As soon as the mixed household waste arrives at the
composting site, it is separated manually into
biodegradable material, recyclables, and rejects.
• Manual sorting can be done in different ways: on the
ground with a small rake (as practised in Dhaka,
Photograph 7.1) or on a sorting platform or table (see
Figures 6.2, 6.3 and 6.4). Workers must wear protective
gloves, boots and masks as they are in close contact with
the waste.
• Rejects and recyclables are sorted into different buckets
and/or baskets. Recyclables are stored for sale in a shed.
Rejects are either disposed of in nearby municipal waste
bins or temporarily stored on-site before being
transported to the landfill. Photograph 7.1: Sorting of incoming mixed household waste. Consider
the local habits: some prefer sorting on the ground, other prefer a table
• The biodegradable waste fraction is further processed or platform. (Waste Concern, Bangladesh)
inside the plant.
• After having finished the sorting process, the sorting Step 2: Mixing
platform is cleaned. No waste should remain overnight on The ratio of carbon (C) to nitrogen (N) - also called C/N ratio
the sorting platform as it can attract vermin and cause - is very important for the biological degradation of organic
smell. waste. Both C and N are feedstock for micro-organisms
responsible for the degradation of the organic matter. While
It depends on your local market which materials can be sold carbon is important for the cell proliferation, nitrogen is the
as recyclables. In most cases at least a market for paper nutrient source. Annex 7 provides additional information
and cardboard already exists. In other cities industries about the biological processes during composting. The text
processing glass, plastic or aluminium can be found. Check explains the effects of a too high or a too low C/N ratio in the
the local market for prices and retailer networks. Generally, composting process and how problems can be avoided.
industries only accept bulk delivery. If space is limited, it
might be more suitable to find a reliable middleman instead The first assessment of the waste composition described in
of storing big amounts of recyclables on the composting Task 3 (Data Collection) already revealed the general
site. characteristics of the local solid waste. Generally one can
classify “green” materials as being high in nitrogen and
59
“brown” materials as high in carbon. The input material

should have a carbon/ nitrogen ratio of 25:1 to 40:1 to allow
most rapid and efficient degradation of the organic material.
The wide range of the C/N ratio already indicates that a
certain variation of waste components is possible. It is
recommended to keep incoming “brown” waste (i.e. from
parks) separate from “green” household waste and to add it
later depending on the composition of the household waste.
For a start, these “green” materials and “brown” materials
are mixed in equal volumes. This ratio may need to be
adjusted if the composting process is not satisfying. For
instance, if the waste is very wet with little structure (e.g.
kitchen or restaurant waste) the fraction of “brown”
materials has to be increased (not only to correct the C:N
ratio, but also to reduce the moisture content and to
encourage the movement of air) Table 3.1 (in Task 3) Photograph 7.3: Thoroughly mix the waste before piling it onto the
indicates that household waste is already close to the ideal aerator (Waste Concern, Bangladesh)
C:N ratio and normally needs just little additional “brown”
material high in carbon. Step 3: Piling the Waste or Filling the Box
In Task 6 you already decided which composting system is
In practice, the ideal combination of wastes for composting
most appropriate for your requirements:
must be determined by trials. It takes some time to learn the
specifics of your local waste. Over time, the plant manager
• The Windrow Composting Method or
will get a keen sense of how to mix the different incoming
waste types and when to add wood chips or animal manure. • The Box Composting Method.
Laboratory tests of your waste can assist in finding the ideal
ratio but are not crucial. This previous decision determines the further handling of
the waste. Steps 1 and 2 described above are the same for
both systems, but the further handling of waste varies for
each system. Thus step 3 describes separately the
operation of the two systems.
Alternative 1: Preparing the windrows on aerators

The sorted organic waste is loosely heaped onto the
bamboo or plastic aerators (see Photographs 7.4 and 7.5)
and formed into long piles (windrows) as shown in
Photograph 7.6. The composting piles have a width of 1.6 m
and a maximum height of 1.6 m. The length depends on the
space available and the amount of incoming waste, but 2 to
3 m is generally recommended. The waste of 2 to 3 days
can thus be accumulated on one aerator. It is not
recommended to take more than three days to build a
windrow because this would lead to inhomogeneous
decomposition. The windrow shown in Photograph 7.6 has
a volume of approximately 5 m3 and holds about 4 tons of
organic waste from two days of collection. This windrow
Photograph 7.2: Wood chips or saw dust is an ideal carbon source if the design allows sufficient oxygen supply and optimal heat
waste is too wet and too high in nitrogen (Waste Concern, Bangladesh) generation, maximising the decomposition rate of the
waste. The aerators and the restricted height and width
The right waste mixture in a nutshell: ensure sufficient oxygen supply and prevent the pile from
overheating. (Heat is developed in a compost pile that has
• An efficient composting process needs a C:N-ratio
the right conditions of C:N ratio, moisture content and air
within the range of 25:1 to 40:1.
supply because huge numbers of bacteria are actively
• Wood chips or sawdust (high C) or manure (high N) feeding on the waste. More information about the
may be mixed with the organic waste to optimize the composting process can be found in Annex 8.)
C:N ratio. Wood chips can also increase the pile
porosity, thereby improving aeration.
• Organic screening residues from previous piles can be
added to fresh piles as a carbon source. As the
screening residues already contain micro-organisms,
they also accelerate the start-up of the composting
process.
60
Photograph 7.4 and 7.5: The waste is piled around and onto the aerator Photograph 7.7: The windrow is turned weekly to improve the aeration
(height 1.5 m) (Waste Concern, Bangladesh) of the pile. The steam indicates the high temperature and water loss
during the composting process (Waste Concern, Bangladesh)
Photograph 7.6: Fresh organic waste on the aerator with the bamboo Photograph 7.8: A windrow after 40 days of composting and being
rack at the base (Waste Concern, Bangladesh) turned several times. The volume reduction is obvious (Waste Concern,
Bangladesh)
Windrow Composting Method Box Composting Method

In contrast to the typical windrow method the waste is The box is constructed with perforated walls, a perforated
piled onto a triangular wooden or plastic rack allowing a bottom grid and vent-pipes allowing air circulation through
passive aeration of the compost pile. The additional the waste. (see Photograph 6.5 and Annex 4B) In contrast
aeration from the bottom of the pile allows micro- to the aerator method, the sorted organic waste is daily
organisms to decompose the organic waste efficiently spread into the boxes in layers of 20 cm. The construction
through a better oxygen supply and improved temperature of the box in combination with the layer technique ensures
control. Within 24 hours the micro-organisms within the sufficient aeration and additional turning is not necessary.
waste start to multiply and generate heat. Pile Air is supplied to the organic material through holes in the
temperature increases to 55 - 65°C which is optimum for walls and through the perforated vertical pipes embedded
aerobic composting. To enable the micro-organisms to in the pile. The perforated bottom of the box additionally
obtain sufficient oxygen, the pile is additionally aerated by acts as drainage for excessive water. As in the windrow
turning the waste from time to time (approximately once a system, the temperature within the mass increases within
week). High temperature leads to water losses through a few days up to 60°C, ensuring that the final compost
evaporation, so additional water must usually be added product is free of viable pathogens or weed seeds.
with each turning. After 40 days of composting the Typically, a box is filled within 5 - 7 days and the waste in
temperature has decreased, indicating a slowing down of the box decomposes aerobically for 40 days before it is
the process. As less oxygen is demanded, the raw removed from the box. As with the windrow technique, the
compost can be removed from the aerator and piled again compost needs another 15 days of maturing.
for the maturation phase without a central aerator. For
another 15 days mesophilic micro-organisms further
stabilise the compost leading to the final mature compost
product.
61
Alternative 2: Filling the composting boxes • Turning ensures that all biodegradable material gets in
The sorted organic waste is loosely spread in layers of 20 contact with air, thus avoiding “anaerobic zones” causing
cm into the box, around the vertical aeration pipes. If one unpleasant odour.
box is not sufficient, the remaining waste has to be spread in • Water losses can better compensated for during turning,
a second box. Assuming an input load of 3 tons or 5 m3 of ensuring a more even distribution of the added water.
organic waste per day and a box system as described in
Task 6, two boxes are filled within 5 to 6 days. The boxes • Turning allows the less composted outer layer of the
receive one layer of waste per day. Every time a layer is windrow more chance of getting inside the pile, ensuring
added it is loosely mixed with the previous layer using a fork a better hygienisation (killing of fly eggs and pathogenic
or shovel. When the box is full the waste is left for 40 days microorganisms) of the final compost. The waste should
to go through a thermophilic composting process similar to be thoroughly mixed before it is re-piled.
the windrow system. Frequently measure the temperature • The mechanical stress on the material favours a high
inside the box following the procedure described below in degree homogenisation of the entire waste material
Step 5 (Temperature control). For measuring the moisture leading to an accelerated process and an end product
weekly dig several holes into the compost and check the with a finer structure.
moisture content according to the description of Step 6
(Moisture control) later in this chapter. If the material is too
dry spray water over the compost and level the material Step 5: Temperature Control
again. After 40 days one side of the box is opened and the Provided that the C:N ratio, the aeration and the moisture
fresh compost is removed from the box and stored as a pile content are all within the optimal range, the micro-
for further maturation. Apart from Step 4 (Turning of organisms multiply exponentially. This microbiological
Windrows) all steps below are the same for both aerator activity results in a temperature increase to 65 – 70°C within
composting method and box composting method. 1 to 2 days. (see Annex 7) Temperatures above 70°C need
to be avoided as they are too high for even thermophilic
Step 4: Turning of Windrows bacteria and so inhibit the microbiological activity.
One of the important factors during the composting process Temperatures above 80°C are lethal to most soil micro-
is to ensure sufficient supply of air. Within a few days, organisms and the process comes to a halt. Although
aerobic micro-organisms exponentially proliferate, composting will occur at temperatures below 65°C, a
consuming an enormous amount of oxygen. A lack of temperature of around 65°C favours rapid composting and
oxygen likely favours the growth of anaerobic organisms ensures the destruction of weed seeds, insect larvae, and
which cause unpleasant odours. Furthermore, anaerobic potential plant or human pathogens. Therefore, it is
conditions slow down the degradation process resulting in a preferable for the temperature of the composting pile to stay
longer composting period. Thus, attention must be given to at around 65°C for at least three days. After the first week,
ensuring an adequate air supply. the temperature gradually decreases and the
decomposition process slows down. The process moves
The bamboo or plastic aerators already increase the into the mesophilic phase (45 - 50°C) and other micro-
oxygen supply by passive aeration through the bottom. organisms take over the transformation until the waste
Turning the material frequently as shown in Photograph 7.7 material is transformed into fresh compost.
provides additional oxygen to the system as the waste
comes into contact with fresh air. The system described
here is based on manual turning like shown in Photograph
7.7. The composted material is removed from the aerators
with rakes, taking care not to damage the aerators. The
presence of steam is a good indicator of the effectiveness of
the composting process. Initially the material should be
turned 2 to 3 times per week as the composting process is
very active with a high oxygen demand and reaching
temperatures up to 70°C. When the temperature starts to
drop, the pile still needs to be turned every 10 days. In total
5 to 8 turnings within 40 days are necessary.
Turning has several advantages over a system that blows

air into a static pile of biodegradable material (Static forced
ventilation system):
• It helps to keep the pile temperature within the optimum
range of 60 – 65°C: If the temperature becomes too high
the material remains spread out on the floor for about
fifteen minutes during the turning process before it is re-
piled (see Step 5 below, temperature control).
62
How to measure the temperature:

• Use an alcohol thermometer and attach a string to the top • Then carefully lower the thermometer into the hole with
of the thermometer. (Do not use mercury thermometers the string
as the mercury can pollute the entire compost pile if they
• Leave the thermometer in the compost for about 1 minute
break during measurement. Mercury belongs to the
then pull the thermometer out by the string and
group of heavy metals and is classified as a hazardous
immediately record the temperature.
substance.) If available, a digital thermometer with a stick
probe is preferable. (see Photographs 7.9 - 7.11) • Record the temperature trends twice a day at three points
within the pile – the top, middle and bottom of the pile or
• If you use an alcohol thermometer for measurement,
the box. A template for recording temperature is given in
firstly push a hole into the compost down to the required
Annex 9.
depth within the pile using a broom handle or an
appropriate stick. • Record the ambient air temperature as well.
Photograph 7.9: Temperature measurement with an alcohol thermometer Figure 7.3: Temperature curve showing the two composting phases:
(Waste Concern, Bangladesh) thermophilic phase with frequent turning, maturation (mesophilic) phase
with occasional turning
Photograph 7.10 - 7.11: Two types of thermometers: Alcohol thermometer and electronic thermometer with stick probe (Sandec, Switzerland)
63
Step 6: Moisture Control • Wear protective gloves when testing the moisture
(squeeze test) for hygienic reasons and in case there
Microbes take up nutrients only as dissolved ions in a film of
are sharp materials in the compost.
water. Thus, the moisture content of the waste plays an
important role. To ensure rapid decomposition, maintain the • Add water during turning with a sprinkler until optimal
moisture content in the composting piles at a level of 40 to moisture content is reached.
60%. Ideally, water is only added during turning as the
• The box system needs less water as the material is not
material is spread out on the floor. Photograph 7.12 shows
turned.
the watering of a freshly made windrow in which the water
content in the outer layer was too low. • In some cases compost produce excessive water
(leachate) in the beginning of the process. This
leachate can be collected and reused for watering the
next pile.
Step 7: Maturing / Curing

After about 40 days, the material in the piles has a colour
like soil and the pile temperature has fallen below 50°C.
This indicates that the process has entered the curing or
maturing phase. Other micro-organisms and small insects
like caterpillars and bugs re-colonise the still immature
compost. Slowly, they further break down the more complex
organic materials like cellulose while producing substances
somewhat like topsoil. Additional three weeks are
necessary to ensure that the compost is mature and
suitable for direct application to plants (photograph 7.13).
Photograph 7.12: Watering of a completed compost windrow (Waste During this phase the compost needs less oxygen and less
Concern, Bangladesh) water. The temperature constantly goes down to the
ambient temperature.
Figure 7.4 describes a quick test for moisture measurement.
Take a handful of compost and squeeze it hard. If only a few • Remove the fresh compost from the aerator or empty the
drops of water appear the moisture content is in the optimal box.
range. If no drops emerge the moisture content is below • Pile the fresh compost in the maturing area. The piles can
40%, indicating that the nutrient provision is hampered. be moved closer together and piled higher (to a
Consequently, the composting process slows down. Often, maximum height of 1.5 m) to save space.
the temperature of the waste pile decreases though the
process is not finished, because the water content is too low. • Turning is no longer necessary.
Adding water raises the temperature of the composting pile • Only little watering is necessary, if the piles are very dry.
and the decomposition process continues. (see also Step 7
below: maturity test) If the moisture content is too high, the • During the rainy season, keep the compost under a roof
pile tends to become anaerobic and produces unpleasant to prevent it from getting soaked. Rain might leach
odors. valuable nutrients from the compost.
• Continue daily temperature monitoring until the compost
is at the ambient temperature. If the temperature of the
compost rises when water is added to it, the compost is
not mature and needs additional days for final curing.
• The presence of white or grey colour indicates the
presence of fungi, which are important micro-organisms
for the composting process. Their appearance also
indicates that the pile is still in the mesophilic phase.
• Mature compost appears dark brown, has an earthy smell
and a crumbly texture.
Figure 7.4: Testing of Moisture Content: Protect your hand with a glove.
Take a handful of compost and squeeze it in your fist. A: If no water is
squeezed out, the compost is too dry; B: If many drops can be squeezed
out, the compost is too wet; C: If few drops can be squeezed out, the
moisture content is ideal (CPIS,1993)
64
Photograph 7.13: Fresh compost rests in a pile for an additional three

weeks for maturing. (Waste Concern, Bangladesh)
Photograph 7.14: Manual flat frame sieve (0.8 m x 1.4 m) on which
Step 8: Screening workers ‘rub’ the compost through a wire mesh (5 mm mesh size).
(Waste Concern, Bangladesh)
The mature compost has a rather coarse texture. The
particle size of the compost strongly depends on the size
and the composition of the input material and the turning
frequency. In many cases finer compost is required and so
the compost must be screened. The screening is done
either by using a flat frame sieve (see Photograph 7.14) or
a rotating drum sieve (see Photograph 7.15 and 7.16). Each
size and type of sieve with its particular mesh size is suited
for a particular throughput and application. In any case they
need to be adjusted to the local conditions and compost
structure.
• The frame sieve (a rectangular wooden frame with a wire

mesh stretched across it) is propped up in a sloping
position. The raw compost is thrown onto the sieve and
rubbed through the mesh.
• A manual rotating drum sieve is more expensive but can
have a higher throughput. It also protects the workers Photograph 7.15: Manual rotating drum sieve with rectangular drum (15
from close contact with the compost. mm mesh size). Compost is shovelled into the hopper which is feeding
the rotating drum sieve. (CompoSieb, jbsART, Switzerland)
• There are four different grades of compost, which may be
referred to as coarse, medium, fine and superfine.
Screens with four centimetre square openings are used
for the medium grade of compost and a one centimetre
mesh is used for fine grade of compost.
• Compost should be virtually free of all foreign matter such
as pieces of plastic or broken glass. Small inorganic
particles, which were missed during the initial sorting,
should be sent to the disposal site together with other
residues.
• Coarse organic material which has not been completely
composted normally remains in the screening residues.
This material is a valuable carbon source and should be
mixed with fresh incoming waste. It already contains
micro-organisms that can accelerate the decomposition
of the incoming material.
Photograph 7.16: Motor driven rotating drum sieve for larger amounts of
compost (20 tons/day). (Terra Firma, India)
65
The screening process generates two fractions: the • Store the mature and screened compost in a dry and
compost and the screening residues. The particle size and covered place. Rainwater would leach out valuable
amount of the compost is determined by the mesh size of nutrients.
the sieve through which is passes. For instance, a sieve
• The storage of compost should not be for longer than two
with a 10 mm mesh size produces:
years as the nutrient value of the product and the organic
• fine compost (1 mm up to 10 mm) and matter content slowly decrease over time.
• screening residues containing both coarse organic • Compost is usually sold in bulk or in bags of different
material and inorganic residues (> 10 mm). sizes (e.g. 5 kg, 10 kg, 40 kg). Some bulk purchasers
may like to use a coarser grade of compost if the price is
If required, several screens with decreasing mesh size can attractive.
be put in a row allowing the production of several compost
• Pack the compost into bags only just before it is to be
qualities. However, in most cases one compost quality - fine
sold.
(1-10 mm) - is sufficient.
• The bags should be waterproof but permeable to air as
compost is still a “living” material requiring air. Woven
Step 9: Storage and Bagging polypropylene bags proofed to be very suitable for
compost.
Depending on your customers you might store compost in
bulk (delivered loosely) or pack it in bags of different • Label the bags. The label should indicate the name and
volumes. If compost reheats above ambient temperature origin of the product, the weight, the date of packing and
after the screening process it still is not completely mature. the average nutrient content of the compost.
In this case sprinkle little water and let the compost rest for
another week. Check the temperature again before you
start bagging it. The compost should be relatively dry when
it is bagged to avoid transporting large amounts of water
with the compost (moisture content < 40%).
Photograph 7.17: Compost is filled in woven polypropylene bags, which Photograph 7.18: The storage place should be dry and covered by a
protect compost from excessive rain but allow penetration of air.(Waste roof. (Waste Concern, Bangladesh)
Concern, Bangladesh)
66
Activity 2: Trouble shooting
The following table summarises problems during composting and recommends solutions to solve them.
Table 7.1: Possible problems during composting and recommended solutions
Situation Requirements / Possible solutions
1. Raw Material Composition
Large amounts of sand and stones • improve public awareness to reduce the proportion of inert materials in waste
• adapt collection vehicle (e.g. by fitting mesh floor) to reduce the sand content
• remove organics from the mixed waste instead of removing the residues from the
organic waste (inverse selection)
• pre-screening of waste at the composting site with fine mesh size
Large amount of household • improve public awareness to initiate source segregation

hazardous waste • provide separate collection for hazardous materials
2. Composting Parameters
Nitrogen deficiency
• add manure (cow, chicken, buffalo) or urea
(high C/N value)
Carbon deficiency • add wood chips, dry leaves or saw dust
(low C/N ratio)
Too high temperature during • turn pile

thermophilic phase (> 70°C) • water pile if necessary
Too low temperature during • check moisture content, if necessary add water
thermophilic phase (< 30°C) • check C/N ratio, add “green” material if necessary
High moisture content (> 70%) • turn pile, spread out pile before reforming and leave to dry
• add sawdust or wood chips for absorbing moisture
Low moisture content (< 40%) • spread waste and sprinkle sufficient water
Odour development (anaerobic • insufficient oxygen!!! Turn the pile more often
conditions) • if waste is very sticky and compact, mix in coarse material like wood chips to increase
aeration
• if heap is too wet turn it and let dry before re-piling
• avoid composting meat and fish leftovers
3. Climatic Influences
Hot and humid climate or high • protect waste from getting soaked, use roofed area for composting and maturing
rainfall season • cover piles with tarpaulin or composting fleece
Hot and arid climate or extended • use roof to protect compost from direct sunlight
dry season • cover with tarpaulin or composting fleece to avoid excess evaporation
• water more frequently. Collect rainwater and store for dry season if possible
Frequent strong winds • check moisture more frequently as evaporation will be increased
• cover with composting fleece
4. Vectors
Excessive flies, insects • cover heap with 2 inch layer of coarse compost
• make sure to receive fresh organic waste (not older than 2 days)
Rodents and other animals • protect piles with barrier and fencing (fine meshed chicken wire)
• cover it with compost fleece held down by stones (see Photograph 6.2)
67
Activity 3: Control the quality of compost • Maturity is the most important aspect for horticulture and
vegetable production. Compost should be stable, which
First and foremost, the quality of compost is controlled best means that it does not release substances (e.g. ammonia
by controlling the quality of the incoming waste that is to be or acidic substances) which can hamper plant growth.
composted. Only biodegradable waste should enter the The application of immature compost causes root
process, to avoid visible pieces of plastic or sharp broken damage, nutrient loss and therefore a reduction in yield.
glass in the final product. But also invisible pollutants like Unfortunately, maturity is difficult to measure; it requires
heavy metals must be avoided. An effective separation of more than one test to assess maturity. The four indicators
waste before composting also facilitates the process steps below allow a rough on-the-spot check of maturity:
like turning and screening. Hence, if you need to improve
appearance: dark brown, soil like material, no insects
the quality, start with a better control of the input material
or larvae visible
and improve the process control.
earthy smell
Secondly, process control, as discussed above, is a crucial if you dig into the compost (storage) heap, the
factor for good quality compost. Maintain high temperature temperature should not exceed ambient temperature
to inactivate pathogens and weed seeds. An optimum
moisture content during composting ensures the maturity of pH 7 ± 0.5
compost and its benefit to plant growth. Complete and
precise monitoring reports can improve the confidence of • Non-toxicity means the absence of substances which
inspectors and customers in the quality of the final product. could harm plants and human beings. Apart from the
In European countries quality is mainly controlled by above mentioned visible pollutants, many toxic
evaluating monitoring reports once the quality has been substances are invisible. The absence of toxic
proved to be good by a certified laboratory. In addition, substances (e.g. organic chemicals or heavy metals) is
quality inspectors are authorised to make unannounced particularly crucial for the application of compost for food
spot tests. production as many plants are able to take up these
substances. Heavy metals play a particular role. Once,
Finally, the product needs to be frequently analysed to heavy metals are detected in the compost, they hardly
provide important information about the nutrient contents can be eliminated again. Mixed municipal solid waste can
and invisible pollutants like heavy metals. Figure 7.5 below contain heavy metals, but the organic fraction is low in
provides an overview of the most important physical, heavy metals. Hence a contamination can largely be
chemical and biological quality criteria, which are briefly avoided by separating the organic waste from other
introduced and discussed in this handbook. Annex 8 shows residues prior to composting.
examples of compost quality standards from selected
countries. • Balanced nutrient content is defined by each customer
differently according to the individual needs. Hence,
different products are available on the market. Pure
compost contains a balanced mixture of Nitrogen,
Phosphorous, Potassium, Calcium and other essential
micronutrients. It cannot compete with artificial fertilisers
in terms of nutrient content but is especially beneficial
due to the high content of organic matter and the
presence of useful micronutrients. If higher nutrient
contents are required, enrichment with other fertilisers is
an option. This aspect is briefly discussed in Task 8
(Marketing of Compost) where the nutrient values of
different compost products are shown.
Who can assist in quality analysis?

Figure 7.5: Selected quality criteria for compost
Apart from the on-site testing methods that have been
described above, additional chemical analyses from
• Visible pollutants can be easily detected by the end- laboratories are necessary to determine the nutrient
user. Each piece of glass or plastic shows the user the contents. However, it is not justifiable to establish an own
origin of the material and causes a loss in confidence in laboratory purely for such analyses. Agricultural laboratories
the product. Especially glass or metal pieces pose harm typically have the equipment for soil analyses which is also
to the users and should be strictly avoided. Pre-sorting suitable for compost analysis. National Agricultural
the incoming waste and avoiding crushers before the Research Institutes or Universities could be contacted for a
composting process result in most of the cases in clean start. For instance in Bangladesh, there are several
and good quality compost. possibilities:
68
• Soil Resources Development Institute (SRDI),

• Bangladesh Council for Scientific and Industrial
Research (BCSIR) of the Government of Bangladesh,
• Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology
(BUET) and
• Soil Science Departments of any university.
Further reading
The web page provides a comprehensive list of C:N ratios
of waste types including food processing waste which is
also suitable for composting.
http://compost.css.cornell.edu/onfarmhandbook/apa.taba1.html
Center of Policy and Implementation Studies (CPIS) (1993),

“Enterprises for the Recycling and Composting of Municipal
Solid Waste: Volume 1, Conceptual Framework’, Jakarta,
Indonesia
Task 8
Marketing of Compost
71
Task 8: Marketing of Compost
To know the road ahead, ask the ones coming back (Chinese Proverb)
If your composting activities are based on a business Knowing your competitors

approach with little or no external support, assessment of
In addition to knowing your customers, you must also be
potential markets and customers are key elements for
informed about your competitors and the competing
launching a compost business. Yet, even if composting is
products on the market. Familiarise yourself with the
accepted as a treatment option within a SWM strategy and
characteristics of the competing products (quality, price,
receives additional subsidies from institutions, a demand for
etc.), the methods used by competitors to sell their products
the product should be identified. Before starting compost
and reason why customers buy their products. It will help
production, determine for what purpose the compost will be
you understand not only the needs of your potential
used and decide on the target customers. When asked
customers but also how to establish your marketing plan.
“who are your customers?” or “who will buy your product?”
many entrepreneurs or project coordinators either have no
Typical competing products for compost are:
clear idea or they assume that “everyone” will. Such
assumptions can lead to wrong decisions and pricing • fertile soils mined and transported to the end user (peat,
policies, incorrect marketing strategies and finally to red soil, etc.),
business failure. A market demand study aims at identifying • chemical fertilisers,
compost customers, usages and their demands in terms of
• animal waste (chicken manure, cow dung, etc.),
both quality and quantity.
• raw municipal refuse,
A preliminary survey of potential compost markets is • human faecal sludge (from pit latrines and septic tanks)
described in Task 1, Activity 3. Task 8 will therefore focus and wastewater sludge,
on compost marketing strategies, product design and • nutrient-rich wastes from industrial processing (neem
quality requirements. After having finalised the following cake, brewery and distillery waste), and
activities you will know:
• mined decomposed landfill material.
• how to apply the “4 Ps” when marketing your compost
product To compare products, determine the amount of compost
required to replace the competing product.
• how to approach and relate with potential customers
1. Make a list of the competitors
• about some potential sales strategies and which may
2. Quantify and characterise them
be the most suitable for your business
3. Classify them into different categories according to their
• about the important quality criteria to ensure satisfied
competing products or targeted customer groups
customers and long-term sales
4. Collect detailed information on them and their products
(e.g. products, prices, sales volume, distribution
networks, other services)
Activity 1: Assess potential customers and
5. Use direct surveys or collect information indirectly by
competitors studying the customers or secondary sources
Potential customers must either show a need or a want (or 6. Answer the following questions:
both) for compost, including the ability and willingness to • What advantages do competitors have over your
pay for it. Consult the fact sheets developed during Task 1. business or project?
Note that not all criteria are necessary to qualify as a • What lessons can you learn from them?
potential customer; however, the ability to pay for compost
is vital. The following questions help to structure an • What advantages do you have over your competitors
assessment of customers. or competing products?
• Where could compost potentially be used and for what

purposes? Activity 2: Develop a marketing strategy
• Who are your potential customer groups and what are After having obtained a comprehensive view of the compost
their different needs? market demand and condition, it is far easier to develop a
• What are the potential quantities each customer group marketing strategy. The sale of compost faces several
would require (potential market demand)? obstacles which threaten the development of a successful
overall composting and recycling approach:
• What is the ability and willingness to pay of your
potential customers? • There is an apparent lack of awareness and yet there are
numerous reservations regarding compost. Compost
often has a negative image due to its input material
(waste) and sometimes bad quality
72
• There is a great lack of knowledge on compost benefits 1. Product

and application
• The nutrient value of compost is often compared with that Product features must be adapted to the needs of the
of chemical fertilisers targeted groups to ensure continuous - or even increasing -
sales. Product features are for example:
• Compost has to compete with low-cost traditional
products like manure • Purpose and benefit of the product (e.g. fertiliser, soil
• The long distances between production (composting conditioner)
plant) and application (fields and gardens) prevents the • Quality (e.g. maturity)
sale of compost
• Packaging (e.g. bulk or packed products)
• Inadequate or unfair regulations and policies (e.g.
subsidies for chemical fertilisers) hinder the composting • Additional services (e.g. free delivery)
approach.
Using the Marketing Mix

Many marketing professionals rely on the so-called “4 Ps” of the Marketing Mix to help developing a company’s sales
strategy:
Product: Relates to features, benefits, quality, packaging, presentation but also service and abstract messages such
as image or principles.
Example: Compost is produced from organic solid waste and is hence an environmentally friendly and high-
quality product. Compost is high in organic matter and, therefore, an important soil amendment for
agriculture and horticulture.
Price: Is dependent on your customers’ financial circumstances, on compost demand and the prices of competing
market products. However, it is also determined by your production costs and expected profit margin.
Example: Compost has to compete with commercial fertilisers and other natural manures. The market price
will range somewhere in between these two products, however, production costs have to be covered.
Place: Can be regarded as a link between your product and your potential customers.
Example: You have decided to market the compost via a retailer who has already established a distribution
network for other agricultural products. Customers can purchase the compost locally at low transport costs.
Promotion: Supports and influences the perceptions and judgements of your potential customers to ensure the sale of
your product.
Example: Your compost has an official quality label. The customer opts for your product as he/she trusts
the label or is aware of your company’s good reputation, promoted by advertisements.
The “4 Ps” are required both for market demand analysis and for sales activities. The four elements generally have to be
skilfully combined to ensure the sale of your product. Product features and Price are closely interrelated but are also
greatly influenced by your customers or market. Willingness to pay is determined not only by the compost price or its
affordability but also by its handling characteristics. Hence, awareness of potential customers, their attitude towards and
experience with the product as well as their personal values should form an integral part of a successful product policy. The
components “Place” and “Promotion” are less influenced by customer behaviour but help facilitate the sale of the product.
A marketing strategy is needed to tackle these product- Customer needs have been identified in the market demand
specific obstacles. The risks and opportunities identified in analysis. Yet, the product may also include an extended
the “window of opportunity” analysis should be taken into product feature or information for the customer. Packaging
consideration (see Introduction). for example should be of appropriate size for easy use,
indicate nutrient content of the compost or provide
Marketing professionals focus on four main parameters to application guidance for different plants. This is an
attain a successful marketing strategy: Product, Price, additional benefit to the customer and can promote
Place, and Promotion. These are the so-called “4 Ps” of repeated purchase of your product.
the Marketing Mix. The following section describes each
element and aspect to be considered in detail. After-sales service provided with the product is a further
benefit as it also includes an important product feature and
may offer an advantage over competitors. Many fertiliser or
73
composting companies provide compost consultancy

services, thereby also allowing a detailed analysis of
customers’ needs and product acceptance.
Product quality is another key feature in gaining satisfied

and loyal customers (see also Task 7). Compost quality
criteria can be divided into visible and easily controlled
quality criteria or invisible criteria difficult to assess by the
customer. Table 8.1 contains selected quality criteria
classified into customers’ assessments: A B C
Table 8.1: Compost quality criteria and the possibility to be assessed Photograph 8.1: A: Mature compost, B: ground compost and C: amended/
by customers granulated compost
Factors possible to be Factors impossible to be Table 8.2 shows a comparison of nutrient contents of two
assessed by customers assessed by customers types of compost which are produced from solid waste.
Colour Nutrient content (NPK)
Table 8.2: Comparison of nutrient contents in different composts of
Smell Degree of maturity in Waste Concern
terms of chemical
Visible foreign matter constituents Compost Products of
(plastic, glass, wires) Waste Concern
Suitability for plants (pH, Nutrient Conventional Enriched
Degree of maturity salt content) concentration compost compost
assessed by colour and
(OM, N, P, K in %)
smell Inactivation of weed seeds
Organic matter (OM) 35 – 40% 30%
Freedom from pathogens
Nitrogen (N) 1.0 – 2.0% 7%
Heavy metal content Phosphorus (P) 0.4 – 4.0% 7%
Potassium (K) 0.5 – 2.6% 14%
Since the customer is not in a position to assess the most
important compost quality criteria (e.g. nutrient content) by PH 7.8 7.5
its appearance, he has to trust the information provided by
Source: Waste Concern (2001)
the producers. Ways to gain customer confidence include
intensive process monitoring and quality control conducted
Annex 8 provides additional information on quality issues.
by independent laboratories. A compost quality label can
The tables with the different national quality standards can
also generate customer confidence. However, it will have to
be used as guidance for your compost quality. However,
be introduced and awarded by an independent regional or
they differ significantly as the standards relate to the
national organisation acting as a control institution.
respective local conditions.
What is enriched compost?

Packaging of the product has to meet several prerequisites
Compost exhibits a natural nitrogen content of 1-2%,
regarding the sales process and needs of producers and
which is low compared to chemical fertilisers or even
customers. Different market segments for compost call for
animal manure. To compete with such products and to
different packaging features, e.g. while agricultural
meet customer requirements, compost can be enriched
applications require bulk deliveries, horticultural
with additives (e.g. urea, potash or poultry manure) to
applications favour bagged products.
obtain a balanced NPK ratio. However, prior to starting
with compost enrichment, a detailed market demand
analysis should be conducted to ensure regular sales, as
investment and production costs for the enrichment may Activity 3: Define your product
be quite high. Answer the following questions:
Example: Waste Concern promotes the sale of nutrient- What are the needs of your potential customers
enriched compost. It sells mature compost with a nitrogen regarding amount and quality of compost?
content of 2% in bulk to a fertiliser manufacturing What needs can you cover with your production?
company (Map Agro). The company grinds the compost (Concentrate on a few markets with high potentials).
and blends it with different additives to adapt the NPK How can you adapt your production process in order for
content to the different needs of farmers. your product features to meet your customer
requirements?
How can you make your customers trust in compost
quality–how can it be made attractive to your
customer?
74
What service can you provide together with your compost when he/she needs it and pay for it when funds
compost product? become available.
Example: Product diversification versus market Table 8.3: Terms of payment for the sale of compost
concentration
Terms of Payment
Waste Busters, Pakistan
Direct payment Credit
Waste Busters produces compost from organic waste. It has
developed a range of products suited to different market Advance payment Short-term credits Long-term credits
segments. “Offering a variety of different composts increased our Cash payment Grace period Profit-dependent
sales and developed a larger target market. In addition to Invoice payment Payment period payment
compost, we also provide:
composted mulch material Households, Farmers after
Dealers
dealers harvesting
topsoil amendment
nutrient-rich fertiliser-grade compost
Preliminary pricing should already have been determined
and potting media
when establishing the business plan of the composting
We sell it directly to our customers.” project (see Task 4). However, these factors have to be
based on the prevailing conditions and adapted accordingly.
(Pervez (2002) in Ali, M. Sustainable Composting, WEDC, 2004 )
Waste Concern, Bangladesh 3. Place
Waste Concern produces compost from pre-sorted solid waste “Place” can be defined as a link for product transfer
and sells the sieved material to two fertiliser companies in between buyer and seller. If the link to your customer is
Bangladesh. The fertiliser company amends the compost with strong enough, and better than his link to rival suppliers, the
nutrients and sells it to farmers through their own distribution
customer will more likely buy your product. There are
network and regional branches.
several sales or distribution strategies that can link a
Hence, Waste Concern adapted the entire composting process customer to your product. The “Place” in the sales strategy
and final bulk product to the requirements of their two main
comprises two main aspects – location and distribution:
customers.
(Rytz, I. (2000), Sandec Report) “Location” refers to your customer’s geographic

location and your composting site.
It is crucial for your business to be located in an optimal
2. Price geographical position in relation to staff availability, supply
of raw materials, cost of land and, certainly, location of
Product pricing is a core issue facing all companies, as customers. Assuming that compost is produced in urban
many aspects have to be taken into consideration. For a areas, certain market segments, such as households or
self-sustained business activity, cost coverage is ultimately nurseries, may be located nearby. However, since the bulk
the most important factor. Hence, product price is market is located in peri-urban or even rural areas, distance
dependent on the specific production costs. However, a is one of the main criteria for the sale of compost, especially
producer will add a profit margin to provide for further as it is a material that is required in large quantities.
investments or technological improvements. The margin is, Distribution strategies will therefore have to be
nevertheless, limited as the prices of competing products developed. The markets for compost can roughly be divided
and the willingness and ability to pay of the customers into:
have to be taken into account. If the price per unit fails to
cover all costs and to yield a profit for future investments, Local markets (e.g. households, nearby nurseries)
the business will eventually collapse. In other words, if you
realise that your production costs are much higher than the Regional markets (e.g. nurseries, farmers, peri-urban
current market prices for the product, and that you are area)
unable to reduce these costs or introduce mechanisms for National markets (e.g. rural agricultural market,
cross-subsidies (from other products or other income), you landscapers, industries)
should think about changing your business activity. International markets (export to countries in need of
organic fertilisers)
The terms of payment required in order to accommodate
the ability and willingness to pay of a customer is a further The bulky nature of compost and its low market price
important factor. (see Table 8.3) Assuming you sell the generally do not allow the serving of national or international
compost directly to the end users, their income should be markets. However, several examples prove that a national
taken into consideration. While a household buying small distribution strategy can be successful thanks to already
quantities will be able to pay cash directly, a farmer ordering existing distribution networks.
larger quantities to prepare his/her field will only be able to
pay after harvesting when he/she has generated a cash Development of a distribution strategy and selection of
income from the sale of the crop. In the latter case, a credit distribution channels are dependent on the available
should be granted as it allows the farmer to profit from capacity of your organisation (e.g. staff, means of transport).
75
Activity 4: Create a market map
A visual representation of the location of your business in

relation to the sources of raw materials and staff, the
transport network and customers (markets) can be useful,
as it will help you select your customers and adapt your
distribution strategy.
• Buy or draw a map of your city and its surrounding area

• Mark the location(s) of your compost production unit(s)
• Locate and indicate the organic waste sources (e.g.
vegetable markets and households)
• Locate your customers and indicate the distance to your
customers. Use different colours for each market segment
Figure 8.1: Alternative Distribution Channels for Compost
• Assign demand or quality requirements to each customer
Direct sales are suitable if customers are located nearby • Compare the demands and distribution costs of the
and known to your organisation. If your customers require different locations.
large compost quantities, direct delivery may be suitable if
you have access to transportation. As transport costs are Such a map can also help to optimise transport routes to
relatively high, you need to decide whether to include enable serving more than one customer during one trip. The
transport costs in the compost price or charge the customer distribution network or process should be marked in a
additional costs for delivery. separate map to keep the maps as simple as possible.
Another strategy consists in concentrating on compost Consider the following questions:

production and handing over the sale and distribution to
• When is the appropriate time for distribution and
a specialised company, such as a transport company,
delivery?
trade agent or retailer. Retailers may even change some
product features or the packaging, thereby, creating a new • Where do you need to deliver, where are the places of
product. You lose your direct link to the end user and the trade?
retailer becomes your direct customer. Some organisations • What are the available means of transport? How much do
involved in waste collection and composting combine both they cost?
strategies. They sell compost directly to nearby customers
• Which packaging (if any) is appropriate?
but also supply retailers on the regional or even national
market. They are thus able to focus on their core business
of waste collection and treatment. The box below contains
two examples of different sales strategies practised in India
and Bangladesh.
Example: Local versus national sales strategy
Local sales strategy of Kalyana Nagar Residents National sales strategy of Waste Concern,
Association, Bangalore, India Bangladesh
(supported by the Centre of Environment Education (CEE))
The Association produces up to ten tons of compost from Waste Concern, an NGO in Bangladesh, produces 300
35 tons of waste per year from neighbouring households. tons of compost per year in Central Dhaka. Its market is,
The compost site is located in a low and middle-income however, mostly based in rural areas far from Dhaka. It
household area, some houses having their own garden. solved its transport problems by joining forces with Map
The residents are informed through awareness Agro Ltd., a pesticide and fertiliser company, and with
campaigns of the benefits of compost and are so willing to Alpha Agro Ltd., a marketing company specialising in
buy it for their garden. Furthermore, households purchase agricultural products. These companies have already
compost to keep public places green. Hence, the scheme established national distribution networks to sell their
concentrates on the local market, thereby allowing agricultural products in the distant rural markets.
distribution of compost through its own waste collectors Furthermore, they are already well known by the farmers
after receiving the order from the households (Zurbrügg, and enjoy their trust and confidence. From the sale of
Drescher 2002). compost to this distributor, Waste Concern is still able to
make a profit and does not have to invest in distribution.
MAP Agro Ltd. purchases compost from Waste Concern at
a rate of Tk 2.5 per kg. After grinding, blending and
packaging, Alpha Agro Ltd. sells the final product at a price
range of Tk 6 to Tk 8 per kg (US$ 1 = Tk 50) (Rytz, 2001).
76
arranged with several farmers to significantly lower

distribution costs. Finally, the vegetable market could serve
as transfer point for compost. Farmers who come to the
market to sell their products will be able to buy and transport
compost back to their villages.
4. Promotion
A product does not sell by its mere presence! The potential
user has to be informed of its existence and be aware of its
benefits. The purpose of promotion is to inform the
customers and stimulate product demand. Information will
raise awareness of the market and is particularly useful in
Figure 8.2: Example of a simple map, illustrating the distribution of
turning “ability to pay” into “willingness to pay”. Promotion is
customers and provision of raw material a vast field that cannot be covered in the context of this
handbook. However, experience reveals that demonstration
Figure 8.2 exemplifies a typical situation in an urban setting, nurseries or demonstration farms can often be very effective
with households, farmers, nurseries, and vegetable in promoting compost. Farmers can see directly the effect of
markets. The decentralised composting plant is located in compost on plants and how it is used. Table 8.4 contains an
an urban setting surrounded by houses. The organic waste overview of possible starting points for promotion
originates from households and a nearby vegetable market. campaigns and promotion tools.
Households buy the compost directly back from the plant;
however, demand is limited. The nurseries are scattered in Typical pitfalls in the commercialisation of compost
the urban area at a distance of 1 to 2 km from the compos-
ting plant. They require an individual supply, as they need it You must observe the golden rule of marketing - customers
at short notice. Some households may be interested in should always be satisfied! Learn from the successes and
buying the compost from nurseries. In this case, the failures of competitors within the entire marketing field.
nurseries could act as retailers for the compost. The peri- However, avoid the “me too!” strategy where you try to copy
urban farmers are located very close to each other along a someone else. If you do not come up with new ideas, you
little stream they use for irrigation. As their demand is of will always lag behind your competitors. Table 8.5 gives
seasonal nature, a fixed distribution date should be some usefull hints.
Table 8.4: Type of promotion campaigns and tools
Tool Description
Direct contact/ Face-to-face selling is the most direct contact to the customer. It allows the seller to inform a customer and to
customer react directly to perceptions and behaviour. This method is very time-consuming and staff-intensive. It may be
service a suitable approach when starting up a business and penetrate a new market.
Word-of- One customer recommends and praises a product to another on the basis of his/her own experience. This is
mouth often the most important communication method with customers and also less time-intensive than face-to-face
advertising selling. However, if your product is unsatisfactory, even for a short period, the word-of-mouth strategy can also
be powerful in lowering the reputation of your product and business.
Advertising Advertising uses mass communication media such as newspapers, television, radio, billboards etc. It is less
time-intensive, but should be conducted professionally and requires considerable financial resources.
Internal The employees of an organisation can also act as links to potential customers. Encouraging employees or
distribution associated organisations to use and promote compost in their own environment can help to spread the
information and raise awareness (e.g. among associated NGOs, community associations, schools, and clubs).
Training Training can also be classified as a face-to-face sales strategy; however, it goes beyond the mere sale of a
product. It is also time-intensive but has a significant impact on a specific target group. This is especially true
for the sale of compost. Training farmers on compost application sells an additional service along with the
product. The farmers acquire a broader knowledge of compost and its effects, which will in turn be spread to
other neighbouring farmers. Hence selection of farmers to be trained is one of the most vital tasks if conducting
training courses.
Free samples Free compost samples allow farmers to test the product without taking great financial risks. In combination with
a training course, this may be a very effective promotion strategy for compost. However, farmers should be
informed that free samples are only distributed once, since compost is a valuable product that has to be
purchased.
Exhibition Exhibitions in trade fairs that attract specific target groups are generally cost-intensive. NGOs often have the
opportunity to participate in congresses or religious festivals where they can present their activities and
products.
Packaging As already mentioned, packaging serves several purposes. For promotional purposes, it plays a key role as it
also transfers messages beyond the printed information. In addition to a trade name, colour, cleanliness, stability
of the packaging or even condition of the truck for bulk delivery, it can also indicate quality and build confidence.
77
Table 8.5: How to avoid marketing pitfalls
Product Promise only product features you can actually offer. “It is commonly known that a satisfied customer will only
tell one person about a product, but an unsatisfied customer will tell ten”!
Price You may try to enter a market with a low-price compost product to win customers from your competitors.
However, BEWARE: a low price is often associated with low quality and could damage your reputation.
Furthermore, it will be rather difficult to raise your price at a later date to cover production costs.
Place When first selling compost, concentrate on easily accessible markets. Calculate the exact costs and benefits
of your distribution options. It is generally cheaper to hand over compost distribution to an expert than to run
your own transport fleet.
Promotion The desire for effective promotion entails the risk of overspending. Choose appropriate promotion activities
and concentrate on those that target your specific market segments. Public relations and the raising of general
awareness for the compost product could possibly be conducted in collaboration with your competitors.
Further reading
Tyler, R.W. (1996): Winning the organic game. The compost
marketer’s handbook. ISBN 0-9615027-2-X. The book is
mainly focused on compost markets in America, however it
describes the principles of marketing and introduces many
market sectors which are also relevant for developing
countries.
Skat Consulting (2002): Building sustainable supply chains

to bring affordable technologies and services to rural areas
- Workshop report on distribution chains (in French
language) and Resource CD (English, German), Niamey,
St. Gallen. (www.skat.ch)
Waste Concern (2001): “Research Report on Application of

Compost on Soils of Bangladesh” field experiment report
prepared for the Sustainable Environment Management
Programme (SEMP), of the Ministry of Environment and
Forest and UNDP.
78
Annex
Overview – Timetable for Planning and Implementation : Annex 1
Basics of Statistical Analysis for Community Surveys : Annex 2
Questionnaire for Community Surveys : Annex 3
Layouts of Two Composting Plants : Annex 4
Template for Both a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) and
a Final Contract Between the Involved parties : Annex 5
Analysis of Waste Generation and Physical Composition as
Conducted by Waste Concern in Bangladesh : Annex 6
The Science of Composting : Annex 7
Compost Quality Standards : Annex 8
Templates for Compost Monitoring : Annex 9
Preliminary Compost Application Guide : Annex 10
Definitions and Glossary : Annex 11
Authors and Reviewers : Annex 12
81
Annex 1: Overview – Timetable for Planning and Implementation
This timetable assumes a composting project can be implemented within one year. Such a timetable could be used as
orientation and planning of the tasks necessary. Of course, it can be enlarged or more detailed, depending on the local
condition of each case.
Task Months Months
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3
Identifying interests of
1 stakeholders in SWM and
composting
Assessing target community
2 interests and land
availability
3 Data collection
Preparation of a business
4 model plan and financial
projections
Development and design of
5 collection system, land
acquisition
Design and construction of
6
composting facility
Operation and maintenance

7
of facility
Market analysis and
8
marketing of compost
82
Annex 2: Basics of Statistical Analysis for Community Surveys
To obtain conclusive results regarding future system design and to avoid biased answers, the survey should cover a certain
number of households randomly selected from among all income groups of the community. Calculation of sample size (n) is
based on general statistical methods like the ones described by Salant, (1994) and Rea, (1997) and on the equation below:
where N stands for population size, y for sampling error, p for the true proportion set as 0.5 and tp is equal to 1.96 for 95%
confidence level.
Sampling errors represent the differences in the results one obtains when looking at a portion or sample of a population
instead of the entire population. If you were to question every single person in a population, the sampling error should be
zero, provided that all person questioned answered truthfully. Similarly, if you were to collect and analyse all the waste
generated in one population, the sampling error should be zero, provided that all your measurements and analyses are
correct.
If the resulting sample population size exceeds 50% of the total population, the required sample size can be reduced to 50%
of the population size.
As the calculation is quite time consuming Table 2.1 provides already calculated sample sizes under pre-defined sampling
errors for household surveys. This table can give guidance on the number of households to be assessed to obtain reliable
results. However, selection of sample size and acceptable sampling errors depend on the time and manpower available for
such a study.
Table 2.1: Calculation of sample sizes for household surveys
Required sample size allowing a 95% confidence level

± 5% ± 7% ± 10%
Total number of households in the community
Sampling error Sampling error Sampling error
100 50 50 49
250 152 110 70
500 217 141 81
750 254 156 85
1,000 278 164 88
2,500 333 182 93
5,000 357 189 94
10,000 370 192 95
25,000 378 194 96
50,000 381 195 96
100,000 383 196 96
1,000,000 384 196 96
100,000,000 384 196 96
If the total number of household lies between two given values, choose a sample size between the corresponding sample size values
(interpolation).
Further Reading
Rea Louis, M. and Parker, R. A (1997): Designing and Conductiong Survey Research- A Comprhensive Guide, 2. Edition,
Josse-Bass Inc. Publishers, San Francisco
Salant, P. and Dillmann, D. A (1994): How to conduct your own survey. Jon Wiley & Sons Inc., Toronto
83
Annex 3: Questionnaire for Community Surveys
Apply this questionnaire for an anonymous survey among a target community. It assesses the existing waste management
practices and the improvement wished by the community members. Depending on the local conditions some changes may
be necessary (see indications in the table below).
Is there any service provided by the city corporation for

1. YES NO
solid waste management in your area?
1.1 If YES, are you satisfied with the present waste removal (a) Very good
system: (b) Good
(c) Ok/medium
(d) Not satisfactory
1.2 If YES, how often do the city corporation workers collect (a) Every day
the waste? (b) Once in two days
(c) Once in three days
(d) Weekly
(e) Other frequency………………….
(f) Irregularly
(g) Don’t know
(h) Not applicable
2. Are you satisfied with your current solid waste

disposal system in your community? YES NO
If NO, what are the problems you are facing for disposing a) No waste container in the area
of your waste? (b) Container is quite far away
(c) Container is not in a convenient place
(d) Container is not in the way of movement
(e) The area around the container is dirty
(f) No one is at home to hand over the waste
3. Do you think the current waste disposal system in the

YES NO
area is polluting the local environment?
If YES, identify the reasons: (a) As there is no container nearby, wastes are dumped here &
there and create nuisance.
(b) Waste is left on the road and in green areas.
(c) Waste is not collected regularly and containers overflow.
(d) Scattered waste around the container is not collected.
(e) Wastes are left in the drain.
4. How much money are you currently spending for

waste disposal or waste collection per month?
5. How many persons live in your household?
6. What is the total monthly income of your household?
7. Who disposes of your household waste? (a) Servant

(b) Family member
(c) Waste is collected by workers of the city corporation from
the house
(d) Waste is collected by a locally-recruited person from the
house
8. Which system do you prefer for removal of your (a) A collector will collect the waste from the house.
household waste? (b) The collector will come to a certain place at a certain time,
you will give him the waste
(c) You yourself will put the waste in the container
(d) You will leave your waste container at a certain time by the
roadside and the collector will collect it from there.
84
9. If, in future, your waste is collected directly from your a) Everyday

house, then how often should it be collected? (b) Once in two days
(Remember that a more frequent service will be more (c) Once in three days
expensive.)
(d) Other……….
10. If, in future, your waste is collected directly from your Here no categories can be prepared as it strongly depends on
house and you have to pay additionally for it, how the local conditions. Two options are possible: let the interviewed
much are you ready to pay monthly for the service? person state any amount or suggest ranges, starting with the
highest and reducing the amount stepwise until the respondent
indicates willingness to pay such a sum.
11. When would you prefer for your waste to be collected? (a) Morning (before 9.00)
(b) Morning (after 9.00)
(c) Noon
(d) Afternoon
(e) Evening
85
Annex 4: Layouts of Two Composting Plants
Both layouts are designed for a composting plant treating up to five tons incoming mixed household waste and composting
three tons of organic waste. The layout supports the workflow of the composting process. Waste is delivered directly to the
sorting platform from where it is transferred either to the composting area, the recycling storage or the storage of rejects. The
screening area is nearby as well as the storage area for compost.
4A: Windrow - composting system, layout plan

86
4B: a) Box - composting system, layout plan

87
4B: b) Box - composting system, cross section view

88
4C: Details of box composting system
a. Schematic air supply and drainage system (cross section). Important features: aeration gaps in the box walls, one
front wall is open but blocked with removable wooden slats, vertical vent pipes, perforated bottom grid and drainage
system (Waste Concern, Bangladesh)
b. Drainage channels (layout plan) and dimensions of vertical pipes (right)

89
c. Bottom level drainage grid construction with PVC pipes of the compost box
d. Bottom level drainage grid construction with MS rod grid (birds view)
90
Annex 5: Template for Both a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) and a Final Contract Between the
Involved Parties
For developing a MoU only consult the parts Introduction, Part A (Scope of Cooperation) and Part B (Project Period)
For the final contract add Part C and Part D which shall define the detailed tasks and responsibilities of the parties involved
(the gaps to fill in are in italic letters). In any case seek advice from a solicitor helping to adjust the MoU to the local legal
conventions.
Memorandum of Understanding (MoU)/ Contract
between
Function of Person, Division and Company/ Municipality.
and
Initiator (person or organisation)
This Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) on Implementation of “Project Name” is made this Date at Location/City between:
Function of Person, Division and Company/ Municipality (hereinafter referred to as the FIRST PARTY) and represented in this
document by the Function of Person or his authorized nominee. Address
AND
The initiator (hereinafter referred to as the SECOND PARTY) and represented in this document by its Project Coordinator of
the “Project Name”, with legal address of Address.
The subject of agreement is the cooperation of the mentioned parties in the implementation of the “project name”
Brief background information on relevant solid waste management programmes (national or municipal) to justify the project.
WHEREAS the “Project Name” (hereinafter referred as the Project) aims at demonstrating that urban solid waste can be
made of benefit by recycling and resource recovery (composting).
WHEREAS the SECOND PARTY is desirous to implement the project, using garbage generated in the municipal areas of
(enter the area/ community you want to work with) and the FIRST PARTY is willing to accord permission for the same;
WHEREAS name and function of main responsible person of the SECOND PARTY grants the SECOND PARTY his kind
permission for use of size of area (e.g. 800 m2) of land and the operation of the project.
Now, THEREFORE in consideration of the agreed premises stated above the FIRST PARTY and the SECOND PARTY
mutually agree as follows
A. Scope of Co-Operation
The programme of co-operation between the FIRST PARTY and the SECOND PARTY includes the following:
1) The proposed land is only be used for the project and not for any other purpose. The land is used for a composting plant
with a capacity of treating number tons of mixed household waste/ day.
2) The project’s emphasis is on recycling and resource recovery (composting) in the aforesaid area/ community.
3) Conducting training and awareness raising activities on proper solid waste management, recycling, resource recovery in
the aforesaid area/ community.
4) Annual documentation of the project’s activities, costs and benefits

91
B. Project Period
The term of the MoU shall be for a period of number years from the date of its signing. This MOU represents and constitutes
the entire agreement between the parties and may be modified due to change of circumstances or due to any unforeseen
factor by mutual consent of the parties.
C. Responsibility of the First Party
5) The FIRST PARTY shall closely co-operate with the SECOND PARTY enabling them to fulfill the objectives mentioned
above.
6) The FIRST PARTY shall allow the SECOND PARTY to implement the project on size of area e.g. 800 m2 vacant land.
Insert a definition of area/ address of area shall be provided for number years without any rental fee. (or define the fee
agreed on)
7) The FIRST PARTY shall allow the SECOND PARTY to use the lands for number years from the signing date of this
MOU.
8) The officials of the FIRST PARTY shall have the power to visit and inspect the project site any time as they wish.
9) The FIRST PARTY shall have the power to terminate the project within a 30 days notice if any of the terms of this MOU
are breached and no compensation will be given to the SECOND PARTY. SECOND PARTY shall have no right to
challenge the order/decision of the FIRST PARTY to any court.
10) If possible, The FIRST PARTY shall allow to take water and electricity connection from the nearby facilities to the
SECOND PARTY. In this regard necessary permission from name institutions have to be arranged by the SECOND
PARTY. Also connection charges and the operating cost shall be borne by the SECOND PARTY.
11) The platform, water reservoir and roofed infrastructure for the composting purpose can be constructed in the project site
and the layout design shall have to be approved by the FIRST PARTY.
12) The FIRST PARTY contributes once with number and currency to the start up of the project. (this issue needs to be
discussed as in many cases a contribution is not granted.)
D. Responsibility of the Second Party
13) The SECOND PARTY shall establish a composting plant with a capacity of treating number tons of mixed household
waste/ day on the land designated by the FIRST PARTY.
14) The SECOND PARTY shall bear all the expense of the total project including cost of rickshaw vans for the waste
collection, construction and operation of the project and appointment of people.
15) The SECOND PARTY shall bear all the expense of the project for resource recovery (composting) and recycling and
door to door solid waste collection.
16) The SECOND PARTY may be allowed to collect fees for the improved door-to-door waste collection service from the
household (the fee will not exceed number and currency/ month/ household). The SECOND party has no legal means
to force the households to pay the fee but can rely on the support from the FIRST PARTY helping to settle the dispute.
17) The SECOND PARTY shall provide necessary security and guard for the project during the project period.
18) The SECOND PARTY shall provide visual protection of the composting plant by planting saplings and fast growing
bushes along the borders of the plot. The compost produced can be used for that purpose.
19) The SECOND PARTY shall keep the revenues from the waste collection fees and the compost sale to cover the
operation and maintenance of the composting scheme. If there is any other income generated from the project, it shall
also contribute to the maintenance of the plant.
92
20) The SECOND PARTY shall conduct an awareness raising workshop for the community. Furthermore, the SECOND
PARTY shall be responsible conducting a training programme for the party taking over the management and operation
of the scheme in the long run.
21) The SECOND PARTY shall hand over the project to the FIRST PARTY, a Community Based Organisation (CBO) or
another party signing responsible after number years of operation. The contract can be prolonged for another fixed
period of time, if all parties involved agree.
In WITNESS HEREOF, the parties have made this Memorandum of understanding in two originals containing 3 (three) pages
each and signed at the day and year first written above.
Date and Place
Name
Function Name
for and on behalf of Function
FIRST PARTY for and on behalf of
SECOND PARTY
Witnesses:
Name Name
FIRST PARTY SECOND PARTY
Name
FIRST PARTY Name
SECOND PARTY
Note: This format is based on actual MoU/Contract documents used by Waste Concern in different projects in Bangladesh.
93
Annex 6: Analysis of Waste Generation and Physical Composition as Conducted by Waste Concern in
Bangladesh
Municipalities and city corporations in Bangladesh mainly generate domestic, commercial and industrial solid waste.
However, no reliable data is available on the daily amount of waste generated in the jurisdictional areas of the municipalities
or city corporations. Studies show that (Cointreau, 1982) the countrywide waste generation rate in the cities and towns of low-
income countries varies between 0.4 kg/cap/day and 0.6 kg/cap/day. The difference in rates between small towns and large
cities is primarily dependent on the commercial activity of the two - large cities have higher waste generation rates due to
their greater commercial activity.
According to studies conducted by the National Environmental Engineering Research Institute (NEERI) of India, waste
generation rates are lower in smaller towns and higher in large cities. The rates that were measured varied between 0.2
kg/cap/day and 0.5 kg/cap/day. The following table shows the waste generation rates in some Indian cities with 100000 to
more than 5000000 inhabitants.
Table 6.1: Per capita waste generation rates in Indian cities
Population range Average per capita waste generation rate (kg/day)

100000 - 500000 0.21
500000 - 1000000 0.25
1000000 - 2000000 0.27
2000000 - 5000000 0.35
5000000 + 0.50
Source: Report of the Committee constituted by the Honorable Supreme Court of India. Solid Waste Management Rules in Class 1 Cities
of India, India 1999.
An analysis of major solid waste categories in cities of developing countries indicates that the residential waste fraction of the
total refuse ranges between 60 and 80 percent. According to domestic waste accounts for 75 percent of the total waste
generated in Indian cities.
Cointreau. S.J.( 1982), “Environmental Management of Urban Solid Waste Management in Developing Countries: A Project
Guide”, The World Bank: Washington, D.C.
The following waste densities were observed at different stages of the waste management chain in Bangladesh:
Table 6.2: Waste density at different points
Point of collection chain Average waste density (kg/m3)

Pick-up point/communal bin (primary collection) 350 - 450
On truck (secondary collection) 600
Landfill site (compacted) 1100
Since waste density varies according to season and municipal area, secondary data should be used with reasonable care.
Determine at which point of the collection chain measurements were made. The following assessment guideline focuses on
primary collection data and can be applied either in one area or for the entire city.
1.1 Assessment procedure for solid waste generation and physical composition
Main objectives of a waste generation and composition study:

• To determine the volume required for on-site storage, primary collection and transfer facilities.
• To identify potentials for solid waste recycling and resource recovery.
Data collected from the survey can be used to:

• Determine the daily residential waste generation rates in kg/cap/day, and in kg/m2/day for commercial and institutional
waste.
• Calculate the waste density.
• Determine the waste composition in percentage by weight.
94
1.2 Selection of sampling area and timeframe of the survey
(a) Select residential areas with different socio-economic population groups (low, middle and upper income groups).
(b) Select the number of households for each residential area in compliance with Table 2.1 in Annex 2 of this Handbook.
(c) Identify a predominantly business area with a large number of shops and offices.
(d) Select up to 50 shops and offices to assess the business area.
Collect the waste generated in these areas once a day at a fixed time for eight successive days to allow for weekly variations
(the first-day’s sample has to be discarded as it may contain waste accumulated over two or more days).
1.3 Equipment required
• One handcart or rickshaw van of 1.0 cubic meter capacity for waste collection.
• A number of sacks or bags for sample collection (old rice or potato sacks can be used but also plastic bags are suitable).
The number of required sacks can be calculated as follows, but the amount can be significantly reduced if the households
are willing to use the bags a second time:
• Weigh 10 empty sacks to determine the average weight of one empty sack.
• Tape or rope to tie the neck of the sack/bag to prevent the waste from falling out.
• Sufficient labels to tie to the bags to identify the area where the sample was collected.
• 1 scale to weigh the sample in the sack.
• Sufficient recording sheets.
• Shovels, gloves, masks.
• 1 container of known volume (20 – 50 litres) and weight to measure the waste volume and also for use as a weighing
container.
• 4-6 buckets for waste sorting.
• 1 plastic sheet for waste analysis (4-6 m2).
Table 6.3a: Data sheet to record the daily waste generation rate (kg) from households
ID No. of Family Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5 Day 6 Day 7 Total
house size (kg) (kg) (kg) (kg) (kg) (kg) (kg) (kg)
1
2
3
...
Total family Mass daily Mass daily Mass daily Mass daily Mass daily Mass daily Mass daily
Total Total waste
members waste waste waste waste waste waste waste
1.4 Method of waste collection and analysis
Repeat the steps below every day throughout the study.
• Provide sacks/bags to the selected households, explain the aim of the study and ask the households to store their waste
in the sacks/bags provided.
• Collect the sacks/bags from the houses and shops/offices every day according to the predetermined collection route label
the bags. For efficient collection, the workers may have to collect the sacks/bags and deposit them at certain points prior
to loading them onto the truck.
95
• Repeat the above step for each sampling area.

• Weigh each sample sack/bag assigned to the households and record the weight in the data sheets (Table 6.3a). A second
data sheet should be used for shops and offices (Table 6.3b).
• Randomly select 25 bags from those collected in each sampling area and record the household or shop/office number
given to these bags in the data sheets for volume measurement (Tables 6.4 and 6.5).
• Open these bags and empty the contents into the container of known volume until it is full. The container will then be
emptied onto a plastic sheet. Count the number of times the container is filled. Repeat this process until all the 25 bags of
each sampling area are emptied. They are recorded for the subsequent volume estimation.
• Separate the waste into different waste types on the plastic sheet (e.g. organic waste (biodegradable waste), recyclable
waste with a market value, inorganic waste and residuals). Table 6.5 suggests different waste sorting fractions. The number
of separated waste fractions is dependent on the focus of the study and interest in recyclables. Select the categories that
suit your purpose. The separated waste will be transferred into different buckets for weighing.
• Measure the weight of each waste type and record it in the data sheet (Table 6.5).
• Properly dispose of all the waste into the public container and clean the equipment for the next day.
Calculate the generated per capita/daily waste using the sum of all measurements:
For the example it is assumed that 50 households got assessed. The total number of family members is 300 and the total
amount of waste measured over 7 days is 1800 kg. This results in a daily per capita waste generation of 0.85 kg/ cap*day.
Table 6.3b: Data sheet to record the daily waste generation rate (kg) from commercial places
Floor area
ID No. of of the resp. Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5 Day 6 Day 7 Total
shops or shop or (kg) (kg) (kg) (kg) (kg) (kg) (kg) (kg)
offices*
office (m2)
1
2
3
...
Total Mass daily Mass daily Mass daily Mass daily Mass daily Mass daily Mass daily Total
Total
area waste waste waste waste waste waste waste waste
Table 6.4: Data sheet to record the waste volume of 25 randomly selected bags
Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5 Day 6 Day 7 Total

Number of buckets
filled
Daily total volume
96
Calculate the daily volume of the 25 bags using the following equation:
Sum up the mass of the daily amount of waste in the 25 randomly selected bags using the results of Table 6.3a (refer to the
ID No. of the bags).
The daily density is calculated according to the following equation:
The density is measured in kg per litre but often expressed in various units. The units shown below have the same value.
In literature often the unit kg/m3 is used thus leading to different values. Examples are shown in Table 6.2 and the
transformation is shown below.
Calculation can be repeated at the end of the measuring campaign by adding the daily results and determining the average
of the entire measuring campaign.
Table 6.5: Data sheet to record the physical waste composition (25 randomly selected bags)
Total Waste fraction

Waste fraction Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5 Day 6 Day 7
weight (%)
Vegetable & fruit a a/A * 100

Bones b b/A * 100
Paper & Cardboard c
Textile
Plastic
Grass & Wood
Leather/Rubber
Metals
Glass & Ceramic
Miscellaneous
Total A 100
97
Future projections
For the following calculation you require the current number of population in the project area (pop) and the per capita waste
generation (capwaste). In the event of population growth, first calculate the future population projected (popfut) with the
following equation with r = annual growth rate and n = number of years:
For example, the equation with a growth rate of 3 % and a projection of 5 years is as follows:
Use the following equation to predict the total waste generation (wastetot):
If assuming a future increase of per capita waste generation (capwastefut) (e.g. by a change of consumption patterns),
calculate the future waste generation (wastetot) using the following equation:
98
Annex 7: The Science of Composting
Basics of composting
In natural environments, the slow decomposition of organic matter by different microorganisms and invertebrates produces a
black-brown earthy material called humus – a valuable component of good soils. Composting runs along the same lines, but
is accelerated by optimised and controlled process parameters like input material, temperature, moisture, and pH. This
distinguishes composting from natural decomposition. The quality of the input materials, and certain biological and physical
parameters have a major influence on the quality of the compost and on the occurrence of operational problems with the
composting facility. A properly constructed compost pile can be compared to an interactive biological and ecological system.
It contains various microorganisms dependent on the nutritional and environmental condition of the pile. It is important for
composters to understand the physical, chemical and biological processes involved in the decomposition of biodegradable
organic material. Any well managed compost heap contains water and air in the pore spaces between the solid particles as
shown in Figure 7.1.
The solid material is the biodegradable waste, the moisture
inside and outside of the waste is the liquid part and the air in
the gaps between the solid particles the gaseous phase. All
three constituents play a key role in the composting process,
as the main activity of microorganisms can be observed at the
interfaces of these three phases. Microorganisms can only
make use of dissolved nutrients found in the liquid phase.
However, they require oxygen for their metabolism, which they
draw from the air in the gaps.
Aerobic “hot” composting
The composting process can be divided into three phases:

1.Degradation phase
2.Transformation phase
Figure 7.1: Compost contains solid, liquid and gaseous phases
3.Synthesis or maturation phase
– all play an important role during composting
As natural microorganisms such as bacteria, actinomycetes, fungi, and some protozoa are already present in organic waste,
the degradation phase starts directly after piling. These aerobic microorganisms degrade carbohydrates and amino acids
present in food and yard waste into simpler compounds, carbon dioxide and water. Under favourable conditions, they multiply
exponentially and generate a large amount of heat as a result of oxidative processes. The temperature within the heap rises
to over 60°C. If high temperatures are maintained for one week, and all of the material experiences such temperatures (the
cooler outer layer being relocated to the warm interior as a result of the turning process) pathogens and weed seeds are
destroyed during this phase. To ensure a favourable environment for aerobic microorganisms, it is important to control the
oxygen supply during this phase. After about one month, the process slows down and temperatures drop slightly. Different
species of fungi become predominant in the compost pile and develop a white or grey colour just under the surface of the
compost heap. Fungi are important for the decomposition of proteins and cellulose substances. During this phase, the
compost process has to be controlled and adjusted frequently to ensure optimum conditions for the microorganisms.
After about eight weeks, the temperature drops to 30 - 40°C and the compost heap enters the transformation phase. The
heap becomes populated with various invertebrates, such as mites, millipedes, beetles, earwigs, earthworms, slugs, and
snails. As the material is a nutrient source to them, they continue the degradation process and cut down the coarse compost
material into a crumbly soil-like substance. Though the material looks like compost, it is not yet stabilised and certain chemical
substances (e.g. nitrite) may inhibit plant growth if applied directly to the flora.
The compost heap enters the synthesis or maturing phase when the insects abandon the compost. Ongoing chemical and
biological processes transform nitrite to nitrate and slowly link the short-chained humic substances into stable and nutrient-
rich humus. Depending on the local conditions (e.g. temperature and input material), the compost is mature after 3-6 months.
Main factors influencing the composting process are listed and explained below:
Carbon and nitrogen content
These elements are essential for growth and cell division of the microorganisms. Microorganisms can only degrade the
organic carbon present in the waste if they have enough nitrogen for growth. If nitrogen is lacking, or if the C:N ratio is high,
the composting process is inhibited. The ideal carbon:nitrogen ratio to start composting ranges between 25:1 and 40:1 (i.e.
25-40 parts carbon to 1 part nitrogen in terms of dry weight). This allows rapid and efficient degradation of the organic
material. Since carbon availability also plays a decisive role, the organic carbon of fine sawdust is more rapidly available than
that of coarsely shredded wood or coconut shells.
99
Graph 7.1: Temperature and processes during composting
As the determination of C:N ratio requires costly laboratory analysis, practitioners have developed a standard procedure for
determining mixing ratios. In practice, the ideal combination of different feedstock types requires practical tests and
experience. Some organic input material is high in carbon, some in nitrogen. Examples of “green” and “brown” waste are
given in Table 7.1 of Task 7. It is generally advisable to start a mixing ratio with one part “green” and one part “brown” waste.
Depending on process performance, adjustments may have to be made for every new compost pile.
Oxygen
Microorganisms can either degrade organic waste aerobically (with oxygen) or anaerobically (without oxygen). Composting
is an aerobic degradation process which is faster than anaerobic digestion. To allow aerobic microorganisms to be active in
the pile, sufficient oxygen should be maintained in the system. Air can be introduced into the pile by turning the material
frequently or by allowing air to penetrate the pile through active or passive ventilation. In active ventilation, air is blown or
drawn through the compost pile. Passive ventilation takes advantage of natural air diffusion through the pile, which can be
enhanced by ventilation structures such as perforated pipes, triangular bamboo racks or openings in the walls of compost
bins. If the oxygen supply in the pile is limited, proliferation of anaerobic microorganisms is enhanced. These species should
be avoided during the composting process, as they produce malodorous gases such as hydrogen sulphide and ammonia.
Moisture
As microorganisms can only take up nutrients for their growth from the liquid phase of the material, it is important that an
adequate moisture content is maintained in the pile. The ideal moisture content throughout the pile should range between 40
and 60 percent by weight. Higher moisture levels slow down decomposition and promote anaerobic degradation, as air
spaces in the pile are filled with water and can no longer be supplied by oxygen. A moisture content below 40 percent causes
the microorganisms to slow down their activity for lack of nutrient supply. Moisture can be controlled best if the compost piles
are covered by a roof to protect them from direct sun and excessive rain. If composting is conducted outdoors, the piles
should be designed as steep as possible and covered by canvas, composting fleece or gunny bags. The cover protects the
pile from both excessive evaporation and excessive water infiltration during rainfall. An optimum moisture level is reached if
the composting material feels damp to the touch; i.e. if a few drops of liquid are released while squeezing a handful of material
(see Figure 7.4 in the main part).
Size and Structure

The surface area of the organic material exposed to microorganisms is another factor determining the composting rate.
Shredded and chipped waste material, or otherwise reduced in size, is degraded more rapidly - a fact especially important
when processing wood and other materials that degrade slowly. Particles which are too fine should be avoided as they reduce
permeability and so restrict air circulation in the compost pile.
Temperature
In aerobic decomposition, heat is generated as a result of microbial activity in the pile. Different groups of organisms become
active with increasing temperature in the pile. With adequate levels of oxygen, moisture, carbon and nitrogen, compost piles
can heat up to temperatures in excess of 65°C. However, higher temperatures begin to limit microbial activity. Temperatures
over 70°C are lethal to most soil microorganisms and stop the composting process. Although composting will also continue
at lower temperatures, high temperatures should be maintained to accelerate composting and destroy weed seeds, insect
larvae and potential plant or human pathogens likely to be present in the waste material.
100
Annex 8: Compost Quality Standards
Comparison of compost quality standards for compost used in agriculture from Switzerland, India and Great Britain (2006)
Criteria Switzerland India Great Britain

Association of Swiss Indian Institute for Soil PAS 100 (BSI)
Compost Plants (ASCP) Science and
Apex-Standard*
(04 Task Force)
Indicators for Maturity/ Stability
pH < 8.2 6.5 – 7.5 7.5 - 8.5*
Organic Matter < 50% > 16% Corg 30 - 40%*

NO3-N/ NH4-N ratio >2 —-
C/N ratio > 21:1 20:1 15:1 - 20:1*
Dry weight > 50% 75 – 85% 65 - 55%*
feedstock unrecognisable, except dark brown

Decomposition —-
for wood no odour
planting tests (cress, salad,

Plant compatibility 20% below control
beans, ...)
< 15 mg CO2-C per 100 g TOC/ < 16 mg CO2/g organic matter/
Respiratory Test —-
day day
Indicators for Nutrients
Phosphorous (P2O5) > 0.7% 0.5 – 0.8% 25 - 40 mg/l*
Potassium (K2O) - 1-2% 0.5 - 0.7%*
Total Nitrogen > 1% DS** > 0.8% DS 0.7 - 1.0%*

NO3-N > 40 mg/kg WS —- 15 - 120 mg/l*
NH4-N > 300 mg/kg WS —- 1 - 5 mg/l*
Indicators for Pollution
< 1%, no visible plastic, glass or < 1% inert material and foreign < 0.5% of total air-dried sample
Impurities
metal matter by mass
Cadmium (mg/kg DS) 1 5 1.5
Chromium (mg/kg DS) 100 50 100
Copper (mg/kg DS) 100 300 200
Lead (mg/kg DS) 120 300 200
Nickel (mg/kg DS) 30 50 50
Mercury (mg/kg DS) 1 2.5 1
Zinc (mg/kg DS) 400 500 400
* Apex is a voluntary standard, launched by three of the UK’s biggest waste management firms.
** DS = dry solids
101
Annex 9: Templates for Compost Monitoring
Template 1: Monitoring Table for Single Windrow
Pile No: Waste type

Start Day: Original Volume
Day Temperature Moisture (A,B,C) pH Notes

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
End Date: End Volume:
A: moisture is right (60%); B: too dry, C: too wet (see Task 7, Operation)
102
Template 2: Temperature Monitoring Table for Several Windrows (in °C)
Ambient
Pile No
Temperature
Start Date
Day
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
End Date
Template 3
Mark the days, when the compost is turned with a different sign
103
104
Template 4: Final Quality Control Sheet for Compost
Compost Sample Pile No:
Date of Sampling
Laboratory
Date of Analysis
Further Information:
Value Unit* Method
Moisture %
Organic Matter %
NO3-N
NH4-N
Total N
Total C
C/N Ratio
P2O5
K2O
Mg
Heavy Metals
Cadmium
Chromium
Copper
Lead
Mercury
Nickel
Zinc
* the unit of the measurement depends on the standard analysis requirements of the respective country.
__________________________________________
Date, Signature
105
Annex 10: Preliminary Compost Application Guide
Compost is most commonly used as soil conditioner or fertiliser. Though compost cannot compete with chemical fertilisers as
regards nutrient content, it has several significant advantages if combined with other fertilisers. Compost can be regarded as
a long term source of nutrients. Agricultural studies showed that within 4-5 years compost releases:
• 40% of its nitrogen
• 100% of its phosphorus
• 100% of its potassium
• 100% of its magnesium
Graph 10.1 shows the differences of nutrient release between artificial fertilisers and compost. It becomes clear that compost
is a long term source of nutrients and can only partly substitute artificial fertilisers over the year.
If applied correctly at the right dose, compost

• improves the soil structure due to the higher organic matter
content
• improves the water retention
• improves the soil biology and plant resistance to diseases
• buffers “acidic” soils due to the mineral combination
• is foremost a valuable phosphorous source.
The time of application and amount vary according to soil type,

crop and purpose. However, it can generally be said that
compost is applied most effectively before planting to improve
soil structure and allow a slow release of nutrients.
The amount of compost applied is dependent on the nutrient

Graph 10.1: Artificial fertiliser and compost show different nutrient
release patterns demand of the respective plants, the general nutrient balance
of the field and soil characteristic of the area. Application is
based on nutrient dose and not on total amount of compost. Hence, the nutrient content of the compost should be known to
ensure the appropriate application rate for compost.
The following example illustrates the correlation: One ton of compost with 1.2% nitrogen content contains 12 kg nitrogen
per ton of compost. Considering the aforementioned release rate of 40% over four years, only 4.8 kg nitrogen are available to
plants. To cover a nitrogen demand of 200 kg nitrogen per hectare, a farmer needs to apply approx. 41 tons of compost per
hectare.
With conventional compost containing 1% nitrogen, 0.3% phosphorus and 0.9% potassium, the following application is
recommended. However, it is important to consult national rules and recommendations as soil type and climate influence the
nutrient release.
Table 10.1: Recommended application rates for composts

Crop/ Culture Dose Area Time and type of application
1 hectare = 10 000 m2
1 acre = 4047 m2
Agriculture/Horticulture
Cereals 30 tons hectare Every 2-3 years during land preparation for
new crop season
Vegetables 20 tons hectare Every 2-3 years during land preparation for
new crop season
Greenhouse (Vegetables & 100 kg 100 m2 Very mature compost as cover before
Flowers) planting
Landscaping/Forestry
Forestry 3 – 5 kg Per tree Before planting
Fruit tree 100 tons hectare Every 3 years
Lawn 100 kg 100 m2 Final land preparation or top dressing
Note that since enriched compost contains much higher nutrient contents, lower compost quantities are required.
106
Annex 11: Definitions and Glossary
This document adheres to the definitions of terms as described in the Indian Solid Waste Management rules 2000. Additional
terminology is based on the following publications which are also available online:
• International Environmental Technology Centre (1996): International Source Book on Environmentally Sound
Technologies for Municipal Solid Waste Management. pp. 421-427 http://www.unep.or.jp/ietc/estdir/pub/msw/index.asp
• The Global Development Research Center - Urban Environmental Management
Anaerobic digestion refers to the process by which biodegradable waste components are biologically decomposed
under controlled conditions by microorganisms in the absence of oxygen
Animal manure refers to the excreta of animals together with whatever bedding material is needed to follow good
husbandry practices
Backyard composting refers to the diversion of biodegradable waste such as food scraps and yard trimmings from the
municipal waste stream through on-site controlled decomposition of organic matter by
microorganisms (mainly bacteria and fungi)
Biodegradable waste refers to waste which can be naturally degraded - aerobically or anearobically. (i.e. vegetables,
wood, grass, leaves, manure, food processing waste)
Biogas a mixture of gases, predominantly methane (CH4) and carbon dioxide (CO2), produced by
anaerobic digestion
Bio-methanation see anaerobic digestion
Brown waste refers to biodegradable waste types which are high in carbon. Typical examples are wood
chippings, saw dust, twigs and leaves
Communal collection a system of collection in which individuals bring their waste directly to a central point from which
it is collected.
Compost is a stabilised organic product produced by a controlled biological decomposition process
inasmuch as the product may be handled, stored and applied to land according to a set of
directions for use
Composting refers to the process by which biodegradable waste components are biologically decomposed
under controlled conditions by microorganisms (mainly bacteria and fungi) under aerobic
conditions
Composting facility refers to an offsite facility (i.e. not at the point of generation of the waste) where the
biodegradable waste components are biologically decomposed under controlled conditions by
microorganisms (mainly bacteria and fungi)
Curing allowing partially composted materials to sit in a pile for a specified period of time as part of the
maturing process in composting
Dry waste a term used in India for all municipal solid waste which is not biodegradable
Feedstock refers to any biologically degradable organic material used as an ingredient in the production of
compost
Garden waste leaves, grass clippings, yard trimmings and other organic garden waste. Sometimes also
referred to as yard waste
Green waste refers to biodegradable waste types which are high in nitrogen. (i.e. cow or chicken manure,
vegetable waste, grass cuttings)
Informal sector the part of the economy characterised by the labour of self-employed individuals, often waste
pickers, waste collectors and traders. This private sector is usually small-scale, labour-intensive,
largely unregulated, with unregistered manufacturing or service provision
Inorganic waste refers to waste composed of material other than plant or animal matter, such as sand, dust,
glass, metals.
Inert waste refers to waste which does not react with other components or the environment.
Itinerant waste buyer a person who buys (or barters) reusable and recyclable materials from households and
businesses or on the street
Leachate liquid (which may be partly produced by decomposition of organic matter) which has seeped
through a landfill or a compost pile, accumulating a load of microorganisms and other possibly
harmful dissolved or suspended materials
107
Market waste primarily biodegradable waste, such as leaves, skins, and unsold food discarded at or near food
markets
Municipal Authority refers to a Municipal Corporation, Municipality, Nagar Palika, Nagar Nalim, Nagar Panchayat,
Municipal Council, or any other local body which has been entrusted with the responsibility for
providing solid waste management services
Municipal solid waste all solid waste generated in a municipal area apart from industrial and agricultural waste. In also
(MSW) generally excludes hazardous waste, construction and demolition debris, and other special
wastes, unless they enter the municipal waste stream.
Sometimes defined to mean all solid waste a city authority accepts to manage in some way
Municipal solid waste refers to the flow of MSW to be managed, starting with generation and collection and ending with
stream disposal of any residues to land
Non-governmental the World Bank defines NGOs as “private organisations pursuing activities to relieve suffering,
organisation (NGO) promote the interests of the poor, protect the environment, provide basic social services, or
undertake community development. In wider usage, the term NGO can be applied to any non-
profit and non-government organisation. NGOs are typically value-based organisations
depending, in whole or in part, on charitable donations and voluntary services. Although the NGO
sector has become increasingly professionalised over the last two decades, principles of altruism
and voluntarism remain key defining characteristics
Nursery is a business which grows seedlings for ornamental plants and trees. They are often located at
the outskirts of cities along the main roads. Main customers are private house owners with
gardens but also municipal authorities buying plants for parks and green road dividers.
Organic waste has two meanings.

Firstly, the term is used to refer to easily biodegradable waste material of animal or plant origin,
such as food and yard waste. Wood and paper are sometimes included although they are not
easily biodegradable.
Secondly, synthetic products from raw oil like plastics are often classed as organic materials
(chemical literature) but they are not biodegradable.
Pathogen refers to an organism capable of causing disease (in sufficient numbers)
Putrescible usually used to refer to biodegradable material such as food waste and other organic wastes
rapidly decaying
Source segregation refers to the practice of avoiding the mixing certain types of waste by discarding them into
different containers. For example, biodegradable waste could be discarded into one container (to
provide a good feedstock for composting) and other wastes could be put into a different
container, to be collected and treated differently. This is done in such a way that the materials
are never mixed. At source segregation needs to be done at household level and needs
significant efforts in awareness raising and education.
Separation refers to a separation of already mixed waste into different fractions (e.g. biodegradable waste,
plastic, glass, etc.). Waste separation is a very time consuming and tedious job as manual labour
can hardly be avoided.
Vermicomposting is a process where biodegradable waste components are biologically decomposed and fed to
earthworms to produce vermicompost, which is the castings of the earthworms
Waste collection refers to the process of picking up waste from households, businesses or a collection point,
loading it into a vehicle, and transporting it to a processing, transfer or disposal site
Waste pickers a person who earns an income by picking recyclable materials from the waste stream, usually
either from the street, from containers or from waste disposal sites.
Wet waste a term used in India for organic waste, especially biodegradable food waste, cooked or uncooked
Windrow refers to a long low triangular line of material (i.e. hay or biodegradable waste) designed to
achieve the best conditions for curing or drying
Yard waste see garden waste
108
Annex 12: Authors and Reviewers
Iftekhar Enayetullah
a civil engineer-urban planner, is Co-founder and Director of Waste Concern. He has been working and also conducting
research in the fields of solid waste management, industrial pollution control, environmental management and clean energy for
more than fifteen years. He is actively involved in planning, designing and implementation of several decentralised waste
management projects in Bangladesh as well as in Sri Lanka and Vietnam. Recently, he is also involved in designing and
implementation of Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) based waste management and energy projects.
Silke Rothenberger
is an environmental engineer with a background in economy working in the Department of Water and Sanitation in Developing
Countries (Sandec) of the Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology (Eawag). She has experience in the fields
of rural water supply, urban sanitation and solid waste management in Africa and Asia and the Middle East. Her main research
interest is the interrelation between technical and socio-economic systems focusing on integrated approaches and resource
recovery.
A. H. Md. Maqsood Sinha

an architect-urban planner is Co-founder and Executive Director of Waste Concern. He has been working and conducting
research in the fields of solid waste management, sustainable development, clean energy and municipal services planning for
more than eighteen years. He is involved in planning, designing and implementation of several waste management and
recycling projects in Bangladesh as well as in Sri Lanka and Vietnam. Recently, he is also involved in designing and
implementation of Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) based waste management and energy projects.
Chris Zurbrügg
is the Director of the Department of Water and Sanitation in Developing Countries at the Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic
Science and Technology. His research interests focus on the urban environment in cities of the developing world in particular on
the challenges with regard to solid waste management, environmental sanitation and water supply. In addition to the technical
issues of this domain his interest have comprised the economic, institutional and social issue surrounding sustainable solutions
for improving health and wellbeing of the urban population by improved environmental services and infrastructure. His research
experience is based on projects in a multitude of low and middle income countries in the Asian, African and Latin American
regions.
The authors would like to give special thanks to the experts who have contributed their expertise and time to review
and evaluate this handbook. Their comments and contributions were highly appreciated.
Adrian Coad
has spent most of his professional life in solid waste, much of it as a consultant working in Asia, Africa and the Middle East. He
also enjoys teaching and writing, and has edited or written a few publications, including workshop reports and publications on
private sector participation and healthcare waste management. He is very much aware of the importance of the human element
in all attempts to improve waste management, and is looking for answers to challenges in the fields of motivation and
supervision.
Daniel Hoornweg
is a senior environmental engineer working in the Urban Development Division of the World Bank and coordinator for the East
Asia and Pacific Region. He is the co-author of two World Bank publications on composting.
and
Sandra Spies
is coordinating the programme “Partnerships in Recycling Management” of the German Technical Cooperation. She works in
the context of pro-poor solid waste management and informal sector activities and is supporting several GTZ waste
management projects. Most of her overseas experience took place in Latin American countries.
Special thanks to Sylvie Peter (Sandec) for her support and linguistic revision of this book.
Layout and graphic design by Yvonne Lehnhard, Lydia Zweifel and Md. Tarek Haider.

Rothenberger 2006 en

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Rothenberger 2006 en

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Rothenberger 2006 en

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

1

Decentralised Composting for

Eawag / Sandec Waste Concern

Publisher: Waste Concern, House - 21 (Side B), Road - 7, Block - G,

Copyright: 2006 - Published texts and figures may be reproduced

Circulation: 1000 copies (to be ordered from www.sandec.ch or

Task 1 Identifying Stakeholder Interests 13

Task 2 Assessing Target Community Interests and Land Availability 19

Task 3 Data Collection 25

Task 4 Preparing a Business Plan and Financial Projections 31

Task 5 Development and Design of Collection System 41

Task 6 Design and Construction of Composting Facility 49

Task 7 Operating and Maintaining a Composting Facility 57

Task 8 Marketing of Compost 71

Annex 1 Overview - Timetable for Planning and Implementation 81

Annex 2 Basics of Statistical Analysis for Community Surveys 82

Annex 3 Questionnaire for Community Surveys 83

Annex 4 Layouts of Two Composting Plants 85

Annex 6 Analysis of Waste Generation and Physical Composition as Conducted by

Annex 7 The Science of Composting 98

Annex 8 Compost Quality Standards 100

Annex 9 Templates for Compost Monitoring 101

Annex 10 Preliminary Compost Application Guide 105

Annex 11 Definitions and Glossary 106

Annex 12 Authors and Reviewers 108

This document benefits largely from the experience of Waste

Structure of this handbook

This manual can either be read from beginning to end or

Each “Task” is divided into a comprehensive section and

The Annexes contain further information on special issues,

The authors invite the readers to contact them for further

Launching a Collection and Composting Scheme

Strong reasons make strong actions. (William Shakespeare)

What are the driving forces behind a new collection and

The following chapters provide guidance for project

Figure 1.2: Matrix to evaluate factors which determine success,

Identifying Stakeholder Interests

Task 1: Identifying Stakeholder Interests

Partnership means sharing risks and benefits. (Anonymous)

Secondly, if not all stakeholders can be convened, consider

Figure 1.3: Triangular matrix for a first determination of potential

Table 1.1: Matrix for a stakeholder analysis

Stakeholders What are their interests? Assess the potentially Remarks

The current conditions may sometimes be unfavourable for

Table 1.2: Example of a compost customer fact sheet

Competing products used Self-made compost, animal manure, peat, subsoil.

Assessing Target Community Interests and Land Availability

Task 2: Assessing Target Community Interests and Land Availability

Structures influence processes, processes change structures (Anonymous)

• will determine whether the residents regularly pay their

Independent from the organisational set up, the

A composting plant with a daily capacity of three tons using

Task 3: Data Collection

The main questions to be answered are:

• How many households does the community comprise?

A direct measurement of the average household waste

The choice of waste collection vehicle is also dependent on

• If the community is located in a hilly area, handcarts and

* read: C/N ratio ranges from 2:1 to 4:1