Temperature and Enthalpy Measurement Validation of Differential Scanning Calorimeters
Temperature and Enthalpy Measurement Validation of Differential Scanning Calorimeters
Temperature and Enthalpy Measurement Validation of Differential Scanning Calorimeters
1
E2253 − 16
4.4 The enthalpy of three (or more) specimens (nominally 6.1.1.4 A means of sustaining a test chamber environment
representing the maximum, midpoint and minimum of the of an inert purge gas at a rate of 10 to 50 mL/min 6 10 %.
range of the test method) are measured in triplicate (or more). NOTE 2—Typically, 99+ % pure nitrogen (or other inert gas, such as
A fourth blank specimen, containing no analyte, is also argon or helium) is employed when oxidation in air is a concern. Unless
measured in triplicate. the effects of moisture are to be studied, the use of a dry purge gas is
recommended, especially for operation at subambient temperatures.
NOTE 1—Repeatability is determined by performing a sufficient number
of determinations to calculate statistically valid estimates of the standard 6.1.2 Temperature Controller, capable of executing a spe-
deviation or relative standard deviation of the measurement. cific temperature program by operating the furnace(s) between
4.4.1 Calorimetric linearity and bias are determined from selected temperature limits at a rate of temperature change
the best-fit (linear regression) straight-line correlation of the constant to 61 % or at an isothermal temperature constant to
results from measurements of the three (or more) specimens. 60.5°C.
4.4.2 Calorimetric detection limit and quantitation limit are 6.1.3 Data Collection Device, to provide a means of
determined from the standard deviation of the blank determi- acquiring, storing, and displaying measured or calculated
nation. signals, or both. The minimum output signals required for
4.4.3 Calorimetric repeatability is determined from the re- differential scanning calorimetry are heat flow, temperature,
peatability measurement of the three (or more) specimens. and time.
6.1.4 Containers, (pans, crucibles, vials, lids, closures,
4.5 The temperature validation of a differential scanning seals, etc.) that are inert to the specimen and reference
calorimetric apparatus is performed at three temperatures using materials and that are of suitable structural shape and integrity
indium, bismuth, and zinc metal melts as an analyte (see to contain the specimen and reference in accordance with the
Section 7). specific requirements of the test method.
4.5.1 The melting temperature of three (or more) materials
representing the maximum, midpoint, and minimum of the 6.2 Balance, of 100 mg or greater capacity to weigh
temperature range of the test method are measured in triplicate specimens and containers to 61 µg.
(or more) (see Note 1). NOTE 3—A balance of this high precision is required so that weighing
imprecision is not part of the overall method imprecision.
4.5.2 Temperature linearity and bias are determined from
the best-fit (linear regression) straight-line correlation of the 7. Reagents and Materials
results from the temperature measurements at the three (or
more) temperatures. 7.1 Indium (In) Metal, 99.99+ % purity, preferably a certi-
4.5.3 Temperature repeatability, detection limit and quanti- fied reference material for which the melting temperature and
tation limit are determined from the standard deviation of the enthalpy of fusion are known.
replicate temperature measurements. 7.2 Bismuth (Bi) Metal, 99.99+ % purity, preferably a cer-
tified reference material for which the melting temperature is
5. Significance and Use known.
5.1 This test method may be used to determine and validate 7.3 Zinc (Zn) Metal, 99.99+ % purity, preferably a certified
the performance of a particular DSC apparatus. reference material for which the melting temperature is known.
5.2 This test method may be used to determine and validate
8. Calibration and Standardization
the performance of a particular method based upon a DSC
temperature and enthalpic measurement, or both. 8.1 After turning the power on, allow the instrument to
equilibrate for at least one hour prior to any measurements.
5.3 This test method may be used to determine the repeat-
ability of a particular apparatus, operator, or laboratory. 8.2 Perform any cleaning and calibration procedures de-
scribed by the manufacturer in the apparatus Operator’s
5.4 This test method may be used for specification and
Manual.
regulatory compliance purposes.
8.3 If not previously established, perform temperature and
6. Apparatus heat flow calibrations according to Test Method E967 and
Practice E968 respectively, using the same purge gas, purge
6.1 Differential Scanning Calorimeter (DSC)—The essential
gas flow rate and heating rate (here 10°C/min) to be used for
instrumentation required to provide the minimum differential
validation experiments.
scanning calorimetric capability for this test method includes:
6.1.1 DSC Test Chamber, composed of: 8.4 If not previously established, obtain the instrument’s
6.1.1.1 Furnace(s), to provide uniform controlled heating or elapsed time conformance using Test Method E1860.
cooling of a specimen and reference to a constant temperature
or at a constant rate within the applicable temperature range of 9. Procedure for Determining Calorimetric Repeatability,
the test method. Detection Limit, Quantitation Limit, Linearity, and Bias
6.1.1.2 Temperature Sensor, to provide an indication of the 9.1 This process involves characterizing, in triplicate, a
specimen temperature to readability required. blank and three (or more) test specimens taken to represent the
6.1.1.3 Differential Sensor, to detect a heat flow difference low, medium and high extremes of the range over which
between the specimen and reference. performance is to be validated.
2
E2253 − 16
NOTE 4—The details of this procedure are written using indium as an these two points as T1 and T2. Construct a linear baseline
analyte. For validation of an enthalpic method, test specimens represent- between the two points (see Fig. 1).
ing the range of that method shall be used, and steps 9.2 to 9.7 replaced
with the enthalpic method procedure. 9.9 Integrate, as a function of time, the heat flow described
9.2 Prepare three (or more) indium test specimens covering by the constructed baseline and the melting endotherm. Record
the enthalpy or mass range of the tests. Nominal mass values this value as enthalpy (∆Qmax(1), in mJ).
might be 1, 10, and 20 mg. Measure the mass of each of these 9.10 Repeat steps 9.3 through 9.9 for the medium mass test
specimens to the nearest 1 µg and record as Mmin, Mmid, and specimen from step 9.2. Use the same integration limits (T1 and
Mmax. Enclose each test specimen within clean specimen T2) determined in step 9.8. Record this value as enthalpy
containers and lids. Also prepare a blank specimen that (∆Qmid(1) , in mJ).
contains no analyte but otherwise is similar to the specimens NOTE 7—Loading and unloading of the specimen is required to
prepared above. determine analytical repeatability. If only instrumental repeatability is
NOTE 5—Most thermoanalytical methods cover 1.5 to 2 decades of being determined, the specimen may be left in place between determina-
range. The mass values selected should be approximately equally distrib- tions.
uted over the anticipated range. Other masses and mass ranges may be
used but shall be reported. 9.11 Repeat steps 9.3 through 9.9 for the small mass test
specimen from step 9.2. Use the same integration limits (T1 and
9.3 Load the largest specimen into the instrument chamber,
T2) determined in step 9.8. Record this value as enthalpy
purge the chamber with dry nitrogen (or other inert gas) at a
(∆Qmin(1), in mJ).
flow rate of 10 to 50 mL/min 6 10 % throughout the
experiment. An empty sample specimen container is loaded in 9.12 Repeat steps 9.3 through 9.9 for the blank test speci-
the reference position. men from step 9.2. Use the same integration limits (T1 and T2)
determined in step 9.8 (see Fig. 2). Record this value as
9.4 Erase any thermal history in the test specimen by
enthalpy (∆Qo(1), in mJ).
heating the specimen to 180°C, then cool at 5°C/min to 120°C.
NOTE 8—Observe and record the sign of the value for ∆ Qo. It may be
The thermal curve need not be recorded. positive or negative.
9.5 Equilibrate at 120°C for one minute. 9.13 Repeat steps 9.5 through 9.9 two more times for the
9.6 Heat the test specimen at 10°C/min through the indium large mass specimen. Remove the specimen from the DSC
melting transition to 180°C and record the thermal curve. sample chamber and reload it between each determination.
NOTE 6—Other heating rates may be used but shall be reported. Record these values as enthalpy (∆Qmax(2) and ∆Qmax(3), in
9.7 Cool the test specimen to 120°C at 5°C/min, then cool to mJ).
ambient temperature at any convenient rate. The thermal curve 9.14 Repeat steps 9.5 through 9.9 two more times for the
need not be recorded. medium mass specimen. Remove the specimen from the DSC
9.8 Construct a baseline for the melting endotherm by sample chamber and reload it between each determination.
selecting a point on the curve immediately before and another Record these values as enthalpy (∆Qmid(2) and ∆Qmid(3), in
immediately after the endotherm. Record the temperatures of mJ).
3
E2253 − 16
9.15 Repeat steps 9.5 through 9.9 two more times for the 9.22 Compare the slope (mean enthalpy of fusion) from step
low mass specimen. Remove the specimen from the DSC 9.20 to the accepted reference value for enthalpy of fusion as
sample chamber and reload it between each determination. in calculation of Eq 7 (see Practice E968). Report this
Record these values as enthalpy (∆Qmin(2) and ∆Qmin(3), in percentage value as the Calorimetric Bias (Bias).
mJ).
10. Procedure for Determining Temperature
9.16 Repeat steps 9.5 through 9.9 two more times for the
Repeatability, Detection Limit, Quantitation Limit,
blank specimen. Remove the specimen from the DSC sample
Linearity, and Bias
chamber and reload it between each determination. Record
these values as enthalpy (∆Qo(2) and ∆Qo(3), in mJ). 10.1 This process involves characterizing, in triplicate, three
(or more) test materials taken to represent the low, medium,
9.17 Calculate the mean (Q), standard deviation (s) and
and high extremes of the range over which performance is to be
relative standard deviation (RSD) for the enthalpy from the
validated.
replicate determinations made on each of the three mass
specimens (see Practice E1970). Record these values as Qmax, NOTE 10—The details of this procedure are written using indium,
Qmid, Qmin, smax, smid, smin, and RSDmax, RSDmid, and RSDmin, bismuth, and zinc as analytes. For validation of other temperature ranges,
test specimens representing the range of that method shall be used and
respectively. Calculate the mean and standard deviation for the 10.2 to 10.26 replaced with the temperature method procedure. Materials
enthalpy determination of the blank. Record these values as Qo with sufficiently high temperature accuracy are presented in Table 1. The
and so respectively. mass of reference materials shall be selected to approximate equal
enthalpies. Where practical, analytes with approximately equality tem-
9.18 Using the standard deviation for the enthalpy of the perature spaced transitions shall be used.
blank (so) from step 9.17, determine the instrument detection
limit (DL) and quantitation limit (QL) as in calculations 11.2 10.2 Prepare three (or more) indium test specimens.
and 11.3. Report DL and QL. 10.2.1 Into a tared specimen container, weigh a single 9 to
11 mg of the indium reference material. Seal the specimen
9.19 Calculate the pooled relative standard deviation for the container.
enthalpy of fusion from the RSDmax, RSDmid, and RSDmin,
obtained in step 9.17 (see Practice E1970). Report this value as
the Calorimetric Repeatability value (r). TABLE 1 Melting TemperaturesA
9.20 Using the three (or more) mass values from step 9.2 as Metal Symbol
Melting Temperature,
the independent (X) values and the three (or more) mean °C
Indium In 156.598
enthalpy values from step 9.17 as the dependent (Y) values, Tin Sn 231.928
determine the least square (linear regression) best fit values for Bismuth Bi 271.442
the slope (m) in mJ mg-1, and intercept (b) in mJ (see Practice Lead Pb 327.502
Zinc Zn 419.527
E1970). Aluminum Al 660.32B
NOTE 9—The units of mJ mg-1 for slope are equivalent to the units of A
Mangum, B.W., Furukawa, G.T., “Guidelines for Realizing the International
J g-1. Practical Temperature Scale of 1990 (ITS-90)”, United States National Institute of
9.21 Calculate the Percent Linearity (L) of the enthalpy of Technology (NIST) Technical Note 1265, 1990.
B
Should aluminum be used as a reference material, specimen containers other
fusion data from the values in step 9.20 and the calculation of than aluminum shall be used for all test materials.
Eq 5.
4
E2253 − 16
10.2.2 Repeat 10.2.1 for two additional indium test speci- 10.9 Display the thermal curve for the melting endotherm
mens. with heat flow on the ordinate (Y-axis) and specimen tempera-
ture on the abscissa (X-axis). Determine the extrapolated onset
NOTE 11—The test 10 mg specimen from 9.2 may be used for this
purpose. temperature for the indium melting endotherm as T(In1) to two
places to the right of the decimal point.
10.3 Prepare three (or more) bismuth test specimens.
10.3.1 Into a tared specimen container, weigh a single 4.8 to 10.9.1 Construct a baseline by connecting a straight line
5.8 mg of the bismuth reference material. Seal the specimen from a point on the thermal curve immediately before and
container. another immediately after the melting endotherm.
10.3.2 Repeat 10.3 for two additional bismuth test speci- 10.9.2 Construct a tangent at the point of maximum rate of
mens. change on the leading edge of the melting endotherm. Extrapo-
late this line to the baseline in 10.9.1.
10.4 Prepare three (or more) zinc test specimens.
10.4.1 Into a tared specimen container, weigh a single 2.4 to 10.9.3 The temperature of intersection of the baseline (in
2.8 mg of the zinc reference material. Seal the specimen 10.9.1) and the tangent (in 10.9.2) is taken as the extrapolated
container. onset temperature (see Fig. 3).
NOTE 12—The masses for indium, bismuth, and zinc specimens in steps 10.10 Load a bismuth specimen (or material with the
10.2 to 10.4 are selected to provide approximately the same melting mid-range transition temperature) from 10.3 into the instru-
endothermic peak (valley) heights. ment chamber, purge the chamber with dry nitrogen (or other
NOTE 13—The temperatures of the materials selected in steps 10.2 to inert gas) at a flow rate of 10 to 50 mL ⁄min 6 10 % through-
10.4 should be approximately equally distributed over the anticipate out the experiment. An empty specimen container is loaded in
temperature range. Other materials and masses may be used but shall be
reported. the reference position.
10.5 Load an indium (or material with the lowest transition 10.11 Equilibrate at 250°C for one minute.
temperature) specimen into the instrument chamber, purge the 10.12 Heat the test specimen at 10°C/min through the
chamber with dry nitrogen (or other inert gas) at a flow rate of bismuth melting transition to 290°C and record heat flow and
10 to 50 mL ⁄min 6 10 % throughout the experiment. An specimen temperature (see Note 14).
empty sample specimen container is loaded in the reference
position. 10.13 Cool the test specimen to ambient temperature at any
convenient rate. The thermal curve need not be recorded.
10.6 Equilibrate at 120°C for one minute.
10.7 Heat the test specimen at 10°C/min through the indium 10.14 Display the thermal curve for the melting endotherm
melting transition to 180°C and record the thermal curve. with heat flow on the ordinate (Y-axis) and specimen tempera-
ture on the abscissa (X-axis). Determine the extrapolated onset
NOTE 14—Other heating rates may be used but shall be reported. temperature for the bismuth melting endotherm as T(Bi1) to
10.8 Cool the test specimen to ambient temperature at any two places to the right of the decimal point (see 10.9.1 to
convenient rate. The thermal curve need not be recorded. 10.9.3).
5
E2253 − 16
10.15 Load a zinc (or material with the highest transition 11.2 Detection Limit (DL) is given by:
temperature) specimen into the instrument chamber, purge the DL 5 3.3 s o (1)
chamber with dry nitrogen (or other purge gas) at a flow rate of
DL 5 3.3 s (2)
10 to 50 mL ⁄min 6 10 % throughout the experiment, An
empty sample specimen container is loaded in the reference where:
position. DL = detection limit, mJ or °C, and
10.16 Equilibrate at 400ºC for one minute. so = blank enthalpy standard deviation, mJ, and
s = temperature standard deviation, °C.
10.17 Heat the test specimen at 10ºC/min through the zinc NOTE 16—To express the Detection Limit in terms of mass of analyte,
melting temperature to 440ºC and record the heat flow, the value for DL may be divided by the slope value m from 9.20.
specimen temperature and time (Note 14). 11.3 Quantitation Limit (QL) is given by:
10.18 Cooling the test specimen to ambient temperature at QL 5 10 s o (3)
any convenient rate. The thermal curve need not be recorded.
QL 5 10 s (4)
10.19 Display the thermal curve for the melting endotherm
with heat flow on the ordinate (Y-axis) and specimen tempera- where:
ture on the abscissa (X-axis). Determine the extrapolated onset QL = quantitation limit, mJ or °C.
temperature for the zinc melting endotherm as T(Zn1) to two NOTE 17—To express the Quantitation Limit in terms of mass of the
places to the right of the decimal point (see 10.9.1 to 10.9.3). analyte, the value for QL may be divided by the slope value m from 9.20.
11.4 Percent Linearity (L) is given by:
10.20 Repeat steps 10.5 through 10.19 two more times each
for the low, medium, and high temperature materials. Remove
the specimen from the DSC sample chamber and reload with a
L5 F~ ?
100 % 3 Largest δY !
m 3 M max1b
? G (5)
6
E2253 − 16
where: 12.6 Example calculation for Calorimetric Bias:
n = number of replicate determinations. ~ 28.58 mJ mg21 2 28.305 mJ mg21 ! 3 100 %
Bias 5 (15)
12.2 Example calculation for Detection Limit: 28.58 mJ mg21
L5 F 100 % 3 4.261 mJ
28.305 mJ·mg21 3 15.68 mg12.6284 mJ G (14)
15.1 detection limit; differential scanning calorimetry; en-
thalpy; linearity; precision; quantitation limit; range; repeat-
ability; thermal analysis; validation
5 F 426.2 mJ
446.451 mJG5 0.954 %
SUMMARY OF CHANGES
Committee E37 has identified the location of selected changes to this standard since the last issue (E2253 – 11)
that may impact the use of this standard. (Approved April 1, 2016.)
7
E2253 − 16
ASTM International takes no position respecting the validity of any patent rights asserted in connection with any item mentioned
in this standard. Users of this standard are expressly advised that determination of the validity of any such patent rights, and the risk
of infringement of such rights, are entirely their own responsibility.
This standard is subject to revision at any time by the responsible technical committee and must be reviewed every five years and
if not revised, either reapproved or withdrawn. Your comments are invited either for revision of this standard or for additional standards
and should be addressed to ASTM International Headquarters. Your comments will receive careful consideration at a meeting of the
responsible technical committee, which you may attend. If you feel that your comments have not received a fair hearing you should
make your views known to the ASTM Committee on Standards, at the address shown below.
This standard is copyrighted by ASTM International, 100 Barr Harbor Drive, PO Box C700, West Conshohocken, PA 19428-2959,
United States. Individual reprints (single or multiple copies) of this standard may be obtained by contacting ASTM at the above
address or at 610-832-9585 (phone), 610-832-9555 (fax), or [email protected] (e-mail); or through the ASTM website
(www.astm.org). Permission rights to photocopy the standard may also be secured from the Copyright Clearance Center, 222
Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, Tel: (978) 646-2600; http://www.copyright.com/