Public Revenue Management 6
Public Revenue Management 6
Public Revenue Management 6
Chapter 6
Public Revenue Managemen
t
Chapter contents
Defining revenue
Determining revenue needs
Revenue forecasting process
Forecasting methods
Treasury Management
PFM Reforms
1 Public financial management Sunday, September 6, 2020
2.1 Defining revenues
Revenues are inflows or receipts from a
ll
internal and external sources.
Do not include refunds, proceeds from
debt
issuance and disposal of assets.
can be generated from
delivery of services for which mon
ey is due
delivery of tangible goods to purch
asers
from whom payment is expected
sources for which no commensurate
benefit
is expected. tax
2 Public financial management Sunday, September 6, 2020
2.1 Defining revenues
Sources
Taxes
Income, consumption, and property
Non tax revenues
License and permits
Intergovernmental revenue
Charges for services
Fines and forfeits
Miscellaneous revenue
3 Public financial management Sunday, September 6, 2020
2.2 Determining revenue needs
revenue requirement estimates are ba
sed
on expected or proposed expenditure
plan
revenue forecast should be made well
ahead of budget approval to permit
evaluation of its adequacy
4 Public financial management Sunday, September 6, 2020
2.2 Determining revenue needs
the following factors should be taken int
o
account:
Inflation rate factor
r
Community growth and development
Expanded and new programs
Population characteristics and trends
Nature and components of the tax base
stability of revenue over the business
cycle
tax efforts
5 Public financial management Sunday, September 6, 2020
2.3 Revenue forecasting process
Types of forecasts(based on length of cove
rage)
Long-term forecasts-include a wider range
of
internal and external macro-problems that
must be
examined. Factors such as population, age,
income
structure, and employment and their impac
t on
governments tax capacity are assessed
Medium-term forecast-used to tackle
problems
such as expected budget gaps or revenue sh
ortfalls
before they become a crisis.
Short-term forecast-relate to formulation of
annual budget.
6 Public financial management Sunday, September 6, 2020
2.3 Revenue forecasting process
Preliminary guide to revenue forecasti
ng
Fees and charges should be evaluat
ed to
assess the extent to which they cover
costs
of services they intend to provide
policy should be developed to limit o
ne-time
revenue
identify major unpredictable revenu
e sources
adopt a clear policy on revenue dive
rsification
7 Public financial management Sunday, September 6, 2020
2.3. Revenue forecasting process
Preliminary guide to revenue forecasti
ng
monitor the periodic analysis of maj
or
revenue sources
understand and evaluate revenue sou
rces’
rate and base and impact of potenti
al changes
periodically examine tax and fees ex
emptions
prepare revenue manual on revenue
sources
that indicate factors affecting them
8 Public financial management Sunday, September 6, 2020
2.3. Revenue forecasting process
Step 1
Step 7 Compare forec
Update forecasting ast
model with actual
Step 6
Select base year
Step 2
Step 5
Assess revenue
Select bes
t growth trend
forecasting
method
Step 3
Articulate critical
assumptions
Step 4
Evaluate validity
of assumptions
9 Public financial manageme Sunday, September 6, 2020
nt
2.4 Forecasting methods
Methods
1. Qualitative techniques
Expert opinion/jury of executive
Naiive Forecasting
Delphi method
2. Quantitative methods
Time series projection methods
Trend analysis
Moving average method
10 Public financial managemenSunday, September 6, 2020
t
2.4 Forecasting methods
1. Qualitative techniques
relies on the judgment of experts to tran
slate
qualitative information into quantitative
estimates
(a) Expert opinion/jury of executive
involves pooling of views of group of e
xperts on
expected future revenue and combining t
hem into
a revenue estimate
11 Public financial manageme Sunday, September 6, 2020
nt
2.4 Forecasting methods
(a) Expert opinion/jury of executive
Allows the pooling of expertise knowledge in t
he
forecasting process, but accuracy of forecast de
pends on the
care and experience of the people providing th
e inputs
b) Naïve Forecasting: The revenue of the most re
cent
prior year is expected to be realized next period
c)Delphi method
- Involves converting the views of a group of ex
perts, who do
not interact face-to-face, into a forecast through
an
iterative process.
- Is used for eliciting the opinions of a group of
experts with
the help of a mail survey.
12 Public financial manageme Sunday, September 6, 2020
nt
2.4 Forecasting methods
(b) Delphi method
STEPS
1. questionnaire sent by mail to a group of
experts
2. response received are summarized witho
ut
disclosing the identity of the experts, an
d sent
back to the experts- reasons for extreme
views expressed in the first round.
3. process may be continued till a reason
able
agreement emerges in the view of the ex
perts.
13 Public financial manageme Sunday, September 6, 2020
nt
2.4 Forecasting methods
2. Quantitative methods
2.1 Time series projection methods
(a)Trend Analysis
The analyst calculates the rate of change
for one
time period to the next or an average
rate of
change. This rate will then be applie
d to the
most recent revenue yield to compute
the
revenue for the next year
14 Public financial managemenSunday, September 6, 2020
t
2.4 Forecasting methods
a)Trend Analysis
Change (Δ) = P2-P1
P1 where P1 the base
period, and
P2 the following period
Average rate of change =Σ(Pn-P1/P1)
n , where
P1 the
base period, Pn indicates each following peri
od, and ‘n’
total periods in the data set
Forecast may be done at the lowest growth ra
te, highest
growth rate or at the average growth rate
15 Public financial manageme Sunday, September 6, 2020
nt
2.4 Forecasting methods
E.g. Consider the following data for of six fiscal years of a city governme
nt (in
Eth Birr).The city uses trend analysis for its annual revenue forecasting k
eeping
year Revenue (Actual) (millions)
1999 85800
2000 86800
2001 88800
2002 90300
2003 95500
2004 97600
year 1999 as the base year.Two forecasted revenue levels, the lowest and
average levels are used for the purpose
Required: Forecast the revenue of years 2005, 2006, and 2007 using the two
levels of growth rate(lowest and highest)(Round to nearest hundred)
Public financial managemenSunday, September 6, 2020
16 t
2.4 Forecasting methods
2.4 Forecasting methods
Solution
Trend Analysis
Sol:Yr 2000 growth rate= 86800-
85800/85800
Forecasts
Yr 2005 at lowest growth rate
97600+(.011x97600)
Yr 2005 at highest growth rate
97600+(.057x97600)
18 Public financial managemenSunday, September 6, 2020
t
2.4 Forecasting methods
(b) Moving average method
the forecast for the next period
represents a simple arithmetic avera
ge or
a weighted arithmetic average of th
e last
periods
19 Public financial managemenSunday, September 6, 2020
t
2.4 Forecasting methods
b)Moving Average Method
This allows the number of past period
s
to be added. For a 3 yr Moving Avera
ge,
the collections of three years (20000,
25000, 30000) will be added and the
total will be divided by 3
When the next yr’s figure is
available(45000), add the recent 3
amounts and divide it by 3
20 Public financial managemenSunday, September 6, 2020
t
2.5 Treasury Management
21 Public financial managemenSunday, September 6, 2020
t
2.5 Treasury Management
Treasury Functions
Treasury encompasses the major
functions of cash & liquidity mgt and
financial risk mgt.
Within these two broad categories
there are several functions such as;
Cash Mgt, Mgt of govt bank accoun
ts,
Debt Mgt, Risk Mgt, ……….
22 Public financial managemenSunday, September 6, 2020
t
2.5Treasury Management
…., Administration of Foreign Grants and Aid, an
d
Financial Assets mgt.
1.Cash Mgt
This includes,
a)Accurately forecasting timing and amount of ca
sh
flows
b)Control of cash flows
c)Centralizing cash balances in Treasury Single
Accounts
d)Arranging funding to cover temporary and long
er
term cash short falls
23 Public financial managemenSunday, September 6, 2020
t
2.5Treasury Management
2.Liquidity Mgt: This function includ
es:
Providing the ability to take advantage
of
opportunities as they arise, for timely
investments, or new acquisitions
Funding for future projects and acquisit
ions
Serving as a financial buffer against an
unexpected decline in revenues
Meeting the need for collateral against
borrowing or debt issuance
Funding cash- intensive activities, such
as
research and development
24 Public financial managemenSunday, September 6, 2020
t
2.5Treasury Management
3.Risk Mgt: This function includes
Identification of key risks, including ris
ks
that arise from financial markets, extensi
on
of credit and the ability to obtain financin
g
Development of alternative risk mgt
strategies and their implementation
Development of infra structure to
monitor risks and report on compliance
with policies and performance reporting
25 Public financial managemenSunday, September 6, 2020
t
2.5Treasury Management
4. Treasury aspects of Aid Mgt:
Foreign grants must be budgeted whether t
hey
are given as grant or in kind.
Minimum requirements for good mgt of gran
ts :
a) Expenditure financed with grants must be
submitted to the same scrutiny and prioritizati
on
as other expenditures
Transactions relating to grants must be
accounted for and data collected and recorded
at
the central level
26 Public financial managemenSunday, September 6, 2020
t
2.5Treasury Management
5.Debt Mgt: General Issues:
- only one government authority should
be
authorized to borrow.
-Regulations should provide for the
amount
of borrowing
- The objectives of the debt management
policy should be clearly stated and made pu
blic.
-Set borrowing objectives in conformity
with fiscal targets.
27 Public financial managemenSunday, September 6, 2020
t
2.5Treasury Management
6)Mgt of Govt bank accounts:
a)Treasury must be responsible for
supervising all central government bank
accounts, including any extra-budgetary
funds.
b)When commercial banks are involved
in
revenue collection or expenditure
payments, the banking arrangements mu
st
be negotiated and contracted by the
Treasury.
28 Public financial managemenSunday, September 6, 2020
t
2.5Treasury Management
7.Mgt of Govt Financial Assets: Government
financial assets consist of shares in enterprises,
loans granted by the government, payments of
guarantees not honored by debtors, etc.
a)Keep records of all such assets and authorize
disbursements and track payments.
b)Get financial information on enterprises in w
hich
the government has shares, monitor the dividen
d
payments, and deal with the financial aspects of
privatization.
29 Public financial managemenSunday, September 6, 2020
t
Public financial management 30