Six Sigma Control PDF

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 74

SIX SIGMA

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 409


APPROACH TO CONTROL

Standardize and Establish Hand Off,


Quality Control &
Document Ongoing Evaluating Summarize Key
Process Change
Effective Project Results Learnings and
Management
Methods Monitoring Draft Future Plans

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 410


CONTROL PHASE
Till now you may have

• Described your ‘Y’ and got the direction of action.


• Isolated your critical Xs.
• Optimized the process by deciding on the level of these Xs.

IN THE CONTROL PHASE YOU DEAL


WITH HOLDING THE GAINS THROUGH
CONTROL OF Xs.

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013


SOME WAYS TO MAINTAIN/CONTROL
YOUR NEW PROCESS CAN BE BY
 Standardizing : Put it in audit checklist, quality
plan, documented procedure etc.
 Fool-Proofing : To ensure that it can be done in
no other way except how you want it to be done.
 Have Advance Warning Systems : If
something goes wrong, it tells that to you NOW
What you would as such come to know of it over
a period of time.
e.g. : Control Charts
Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013
IN A NUT SHELL
Your Process may be:
AFFECTED BY CAN BE M AINTAINED BY

 Initial Setup  FPI in between the checks

 Equipment/  Parameters feedback system


machine settings

 Fixtures  First approvals, monitor the assignable causes


 Tooling  Tool approval, Fool-Proofing of mating parts, FPI,
Audit checks
 M an  Training and Fool-Proofing

 M aterial  Certification before use

 M aintenance  PM schedules, FPI check after each maintenance

 Environment  Control environment and PM of environment


controlling equipment

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013


Audit Questions

 Self-Audits are an effective method to check the status of the


implemented processes in standards/specification documentation.
 The following table comprises potential questions.
 Questions may be open (yes/no answer not possible) or closed.
− Open questions have the advantage that the respondent must provide a
description of the controls known to him or of the current course of
action. Disadvantage: specialized knowledge of the subject is needed to
understand and analyze the answer.
− Closed questions are easy to evaluate; however, keep in mind that the
respondents will say “Yes” when in doubt. It is very difficult to say “No”!
 The questions used in the following example are formulated such
that the answer “Yes (Always)” means that a process is performed
based on the specified methods.
 The specification documentation/standards must be optimized, if the
process has errors, regardless of whether all questions were
answered with “Yes”.

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 414


QC PROCESS CHARTS DEFINITION
 QC Process Charts are a tool that helps you document PDCA for
your process.

PLAN/DO CHECK ACT


Corrective
Flowchart Indicators Actions

Plot time on each order; If time exceeds 2 hours,


should be 2 hours; alert Sam immediately;
check for special causes organize investigation

Count errors If more than 1 per order,


stop process, contact
Sam

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 415


QC PROCESS CHART FEATURES
The middle column
The plan is
describes what you will
typically
check in the process to
captured as a
monitor its quality.
flowchart.

PLAN/DO CHECK ACT


Corrective
Flowchart Indicators
Actions The third
column
Plot time on each order; Alert Sam immediately; describes how
should be < 2 hours; organize investigation the process
check for special causes
operators
should react
depending on
what they find
If more than 1 per order,
Count errors
stop process, contact
in the
Sam measures.

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 416


QC PROCESS CHART USES

− Combine the Plan for doing a job with the Check and Act
phases of PDCA.

− Monitor implementation.

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 417


EXAMPLE - QC PROCESS CHART
The Plan for Doing the Work Checking the Work Act: Response to Results
Flowchart Key Process Indicators Corrective Actions
Admin
Employee Support HR Fin Serv Mgmt

Incurs expense &


does activity

Completes white
expense form
and yellow
timesheet
100% Inspection for standards: Correct form or return to employee.
1. Received by 5 pm Tues (on-site)Discuss corrections with employee.
Receives form; or 5pm Wed (by mail) Provide training if needed.
checks coding 2. Operational definitions of
of expenses expenses used
3. Complete information provided
4. Columns added and summary
completed
Copy to HR; copy
saved for invoicing; Receipts behind form, stapled in
original + receipts upper left corner.
to FS

HR does 100% Inspection for Correct form or return to employee.


Records data • Proper use of time coding Vac, Discuss corrections with employee.
Leave, and Holiday expenses Provide training if needed.
used
Prepares monthly
report
Enters data into FS responsible for If unclear about budget codes, check
spreadsheet 1. All charges allocated with manager
2. Proper use of budget codes

Correct?
If incorrect:
1. Work with Admin Support to
resolve
Resolve 2. Track common areas of problems
discrepancies Issues check and report to manager monthly

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 418


QC PROCESS CHARTS: PLAN

The Plan for Doing the Work

Flowchart Detail on
Key Tasks
Most often, people use For each key
either an activity step in the
flowchart or a operation, show
deployment flowchart how the task
here. should be done,
or provide a
reference to a
document that
describes the
step.

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 419


QC PROCESS CHART: CHECK
Checking the Work
Monitoring Method for
CTQ Standards Recording Data
Identify in a word or For each CTQ, describe For each CTQ, describe
phrase the character- any important target, how the monitored data
istics to be monitored in numeric limits, should be recorded.
each critical step. tolerances, or
specifications to which a (e.g., checklist, run
(e.g., elapsed time, process should conform chart, control chart,
completeness, if it is running well. scatter plot, etc.)
presence of errors, or a
physical characteristic (e.g., “8 hrs. from Describe, if necessary,
such as temperature or receipt”; “all boxes who should record the
pressure.) checked”; “120°–135°F,” data and how.
etc.)

These standards may


come from customers,
regulatory policies (ISO)
or process knowledge or
expertise.
Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 420
QC PROCESS CHARTS: ACT
Act: The Response to Negative Results
Procedure Procedure
Damage
for Process for Systems
Control
Adjustment Improvement

Who should do What must be Who in the


what with the done to gain organization
output of the sufficient needs what
defective understanding data in what
process? of this process that form in order to
the operators make a sound
What should be know what decision
done for those adjustments regarding new
who received the and accommo- systems or
defective output? dations are remedies at
routinely deeper levels
What necessary to in the
adjustments prevent a organization
should be made recurrence of this (e.g., changes
to assure that problem? in basic
there will be no designs or
defectives in the policies)?
next iteration?

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 421


STANDARDIZATION
− Making sure that important elements of a process are performed
consistently in the best possible way.
− Changes are made only when data shows that a new alternative
is better.
− Documentation is key
> Making sure documentation is up to date and used
encourages ongoing use of standardized methods.
− Discussion
> What images come to mind when you think of process
standardization?

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 422


BENEFITS OF STANDARDIZATION
 Standardization helps us compete more
successfully in the marketplace by providing:
− Increased reliability
− Reduced costs
− Improved employee performance
− Increased safety
− Processes that remain in control
− Continuous improvement
− Flexible practices that allow for quick response to customer
needs

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 423


USES FOR STANDARD PRACTICES
1. Reduce variation among individuals or groups (and so make
process output more predictable)
2. Provide “know-why” for operators and managers now on the job
3. Provide a basis for training new people
4. Provide a trail for tracing problems
5. Provide a means to capture and retain knowledge
6. Give direction in the case of unusual conditions

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 424


TRAINING
− When you have completed the documentation, you need to make
sure that everyone using a common process is trained in the new
methods.

− Even experienced
employees need
to be trained
in the new methods.

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 425


PLANNING FOR TRAINING
 Don’t try to develop a single training session to teach people
everything they may ever need to know about the job.
− Focus on the most critical aspects of the job.
− When you make changes to a process, explain the reasons
behind the changes; people resist change for change’s sake.
− Combine up-front training with performance support.
− Don’t expect everyone to learn everything at once; provide job
aids.
− Remember that most learning will occur on the job.

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 426


Control Chart Basics

All processes have natural variations (general causes), some


also have additional, unnatural variations (special causes).

Based on statistical principles, control charts make it possible


to identify unnatural (=non-random) patterns and thus provide
process improvement opportunities.

Control charts have upper and lower intervention limits, which


represent the natural variability of the process.

Intervention limits are +/-3 sigma limits of the respective


measured input or output variables.

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 427


Purpose of Control Charts

• A control chart is an "instrument" to classify process dispersion.

Ho Ha
natural variation non-natural variation
general causes special causes
controlled uncontrolled
managed unmanaged
expected variation unexpected variation

• Using control charts makes sense only for processes that are
not completely out of control.

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 428


Components of a Control Chart

Upper intervention limit

X-Bar Chart for KVOP


615
UCL=613.6
Mean line
Sample Mean
605

X=599.1

595

585 LCL=584.6

0 10 20
Sample Number

Lower intervention limit


Sequence of measurements

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 429


SPC Procedure

• Selection of appropriate measurement category


• Definition of the point within the process (chart) where the
measurement is taken
• Specification of the control chart type
• Creation of a baseline to determine rational subgroups (-> for
mean value maps)
• Specification of sample size
• Specification of measurement method / criteria
• Measurement system capacity
• Feasibility study to determine the intervention limits
• Creation of the forms to enter the measurements
• Definition of procedures
• Training the testers

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 430


Sampling

• Sample size
• Single value chart: Natural sample size 1.
• Variable chart (for mean values) : 5, if possible and suitable.
• Attribute chart: 30 or more, depending on (defect) percentage
(Rule of thumb: Defect should occur five times)

• Sampling frequency
• Not too frequently.
• Not too infrequently.
• Generally: The more frequently, the better.
• On-line measurement systems permit real-time process control.

• Rational subgroups
• Attempt to capture the process while it is consistent. (Goal: as little
dispersion as possible within the subgroup).

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 431


Analysis of Patterns on Control Charts

• Everything outside of the upper and lower intervention limits


indicates "out of control".
• Aside from that, we are looking for unusual patterns.
• Rules for "out of control":
• One measurement point outside of the 3 sigma limits
• Seven consecutive points above/below mean value line
• Six consecutive point upwards/ downwards
• Fourteen subsequent measurements going up or down
• You should only use controls the operator can also use for
intervention.
• The tests refer to hypothesis testing. All existing controls
carry an a risk of 0.3%.
• What are the hypotheses?

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 432


Using Control Chart

• Only if necessary!
• Does Control Chart make sense?
• A process that is critical and that cannot be "secured".
• Do not hesitate to remove Control Chart once it is no longer
useful (a control chart that is never out of control is of no
value).
• If there is little knowledge about the process: Control Chart for
the (critical) output variables.
• If the process is known: control chart for the (critical) input
variables.

• Objective: Monitoring and control of inputs and (long-term):


Elimination of the necessity for Control charts on the output.

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 433


Selection of SPC Charts

Data

Attribute data (number of classification) Variable data (measurement)

Number Classification

Defects per unit Defective parts

Constant Variable Constant Variable


Sample Sample size Sample size
sample sample sample sample
size <6 >6
size size size size = 1

_ _
Xi chart
C chart U chart NP chart P chart X, R chart X, S chart
(Individual map)

Poisson distribution Binomial distribution Normal distribution

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 434


Out-of-Control Action Plan or Reaction Plan
Control Charts Detect
Variation due to Special Causes
We , now, have to
 Identify the Special Causes
 Fix them
 Prevent them
Keep using Control Charts
- Whenever you get an alarm (for Special Cause),
- Identify the Special Cause in a systematic manner Out-of-Control
Action Plan
- Fix it, Verify, Record
( OCAP )
- Periodically analyse compiled records to decide
- Chronic Special Causes
- Preventive action for those

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 435


How to Prepare the OCAP :

1. Identify the different Out-of Control Signals on your Control


Chart
2. For EACH Out-of Control Signal, Work out the Cause-&-
Effect Diagram
3. For each Out-of Control Signal,
a) Work out the list of possible causes
b) Prioritize the causes as per their occurrence
4. Prepare a table of out of control situation, check points and
counter measures

5. For each Out-of-Control occurrence verify the causes. In case of


new cause update the table.

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 436


Poka-Yoke

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 437


“Defects arise because errors are made; the two have

a cause and effect relationship…. Yet errors will not

turn into defects if feedback and action take

place at the error stage”

Shigeo Shingo

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 438


Poka-Yoke systems create a process in which a

worker cannot create an error.

Parts and/or process are designed so that desired

results are inevitable.

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 439


Poka-Yoke Systems
TYPES OF ERRORS

1. Forgetfulness : Forgetting a step or a part


Safeguard : Checklist, Visual Standard Operating Procedure

2. Errors due to Misunderstanding :Not very familiar with the


required operation
Safeguards :Continuous Training, Visual SOP

3. Errors in Identification : Problems in identification or clearness


of required steps or parts.
Safeguards : Training, Visual Training, Standardization

SixCopyright
Sigma Rockwell Automation 2000
GB Material Oct 2013 440
Poka-Yoke Systems
TYPES OF ERRORS

4. Errors due to Lack of Experience : New Employees


Safeguard : Skill Building & Training, Work Standardization

5. Errors due to Lack of Standards : No clear way to perform the


task or job
Safeguards: Standard Operations, Visual Instructions

6. Errors due to Machine Readability : Machine out of spec


Safeguards :TPM , Critical Parts List, Maintain Equipment
History List

Copyright Rockwell Automation 2000 441


Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013
Poka-Yoke Systems
TYPES OF ERRORS

Keep in Mind :

Mistakes Happen for many reasons, but almost all


can be prevented if we take the time to identify
WHEN & WHY they happen and take steps to
prevent the recurrence of theses errors and
mistakes by using a systematic approach to
Mistake Proofing aimed at eliminating foreseeable
errors.

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 442


Poka-Yoke Systems

POKA-YOKE STRATEGY

Errors

Have About to
Happened Happen

Prevention
Actions

Detection Prediction
Warning

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 443


Poka-Yoke Systems
ELEMENTS OF PROCESS

y Information
y Material
y People
y Methodology / Procedure

The four elements of process determine whether a output is


correctly manufactured or not.
Defect Free Processes are a result of Controlled Standards of
Operation in each of these principle areas.

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 444


Poka-Yoke Systems

ERRORS AND DEFECTS

Two Arguments :

y Errors are Inevitable !! Humans always will make mistakes.

y Errors can be Eliminated : Any kind of mistake people do can


be eliminated one way or another !!

Where Do You Stand?

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 445


Candidates for Poka-yoke in a process

 Inputs

 Outputs

 Feedback

 Results

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 446


Poka-Yoke Should be Considered When:

 Worker Vigilance is Required

 Mis-positioning is Likely

 SPC is Difficult

 External Failure Costs Far Exceed Internal


Failure Costs

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 447


Let’s Look at Some Applications Of

POKA-YOKE

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 448


What is the poka-yoke here?

The beveled corner of the


diskette pushes a stop in the
disk drive out of the way
allowing the diskette to be
inserted. This feature, along
with the fact that the diskette
is not square, prohibit
incorrect orientation.
Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 449
There are three poka-yokes in this electronic door lock.

1. Throwing the switch on one door locks them all


2. Doors automatically lock when car exceeds 18 mph
3. No door will lock if switch is activated with door
open
Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 450
If the batteries or electrical system failed while this bathyscaph was
submerged, how would you ensure it could return to the surface?
The ballast are held in place with electromagnets, which fall off if
power is lost allowing the bathyscaph to ascend

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 451


Engineering change form requires different signatures depending on the nature
of the change being considered. Sometimes engineers would get too many
signatures, and sometimes not enough.

The revised form identifies the nature of the change in the columns and
indicates unnecessary signatures in gray. Creating forms that help the user fill
them out correctly is a part of mistake-proofing.

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 452


Poka-Yoke Systems
POKA-YOKE
8 MAIN PRINCIPLES

 Build Quality into the process


 All inadvertent errors and defects can be eliminated
 Stop Doing it wrong and start doing it right - now !!!
 Do not think up excuses, think about doing it right
 A 80 % chance of success is good enough - Focus on implementation
 Attack defects and errors as a team
 Ten Heads are better than one - Brainstorm ideas, Discuss, Think
 Seek out the root cause, use the 5 Whys

Copyright Rockwell Automation 2000 453


Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013
Poka-Yoke Systems

POKA-YOKE

Human Errors are usually inadvertent. Poka-Yoke devices


help us to avoid defects before they occur, even when
human errors are made.
Poka-Yoke is a tool that builds Quality into the process
and shifts the attention from detection and inspection to
building it right the first time.

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 454


Using Poka-Yoke Systems

Types of Poka-Yoke Systems

• Poka-Yoke Regulatory Functions


1) Control Methods
2) Warning Methods

• Poka-Yoke Setting Functions


Setting function types and examples
1) Contact methods
2) Fixed value methods
3) Motion-Step methods

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 455


Using Poka-Yoke Systems

Detection Measures for Poka-Yoke Systems

1) Various Detection Measures


2) Detection Method Functions
3) Contact Detection Methods

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 456


Using Poka-Yoke Systems-Example

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 457


The 5S Process
Workplace Organization and Standardization

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 458


5S is: A systematic approach to organize and
standardize the workplace

Objectives of 5S are:
1. Promote Safety
2. Improve Work Flow
3. Better Product Quality
4. Reduce Inventory Waste
5. Give People Control of Their Workplace

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 459


History
5S was originally developed within the Toyota Production
System and consisted of 4S’s
• Seiri – cleaning up
• Seiton – organizing
• Seiso – cleaning
• Shitsuke - discipline

We have adapted the process into 5S’s


•Sort
•Shine
•Set in Order
•Standardize
•Sustain
Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 460
5-S Implementation
Benefits

Foundation of all other activities


• Discipline to follow standard work
• Reduce Variation
• Expose problems
• Safe working areas
• Waste reductions
• Improve Efficiency
• Space reduction

• Productivity
Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 461
The 5S Ideals
• Retrieval of data within 1 minute
• Retrieval of tools and supplies within 1 minute
• Organized workplace
• Problems and waste are clearly visible
• Deviations from standard are clearly visible
• Standard procedures are easily understood and
visually clear
• Everybody sticks to the rules
• 5S involves and effects everybody
• Performance is visible and understood by
everybody
Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 462
With 5S the idea is to go from this

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 463


To This

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 464


STEP 1

Understanding the Current Condition

1. How close to 5S are we today?

2. How does our work flow today?

3. What does the area look look like today?

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 465


How does our work flow today?
Spaghetti Diagram

Raw
Material Tool Crib
WIP

WIP

Component Shelves
= Worker
Finished
Goods
Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 466
Create a display of the information

The beginning of our 5S process

5S Workplace Scan Checklist - 100 pts. Max. - 85 points Min. Pass


Violations Points
5 or more 0
Rated By: 3 or 4 1
2 2
1 3
0 4

Area Department Date Score


Pre-event Post-Event On-Going
What is needed vs. what is not needed
Only needed equipment, tools, furniture, supplies etc. are present
Walls, bulletin boards, etc. have only needed items
Sort Uneeded items are present in aisleways, corners, shelves, etc.
Uneeded inventory, supplies, parts, or materials are present
Safety hazards, (electrical cords, etc,) on floor or work area
Equipment demonstrates good ergonomics

A place for everything and everything in its place


Correct places for items are visually obvious
Items are in the correct places
Set in Aisleways, workstations, equipment locations are visually indicated
Order Items have not been put away after use
Height and quantity limits for stored items are obvious

Clean to inspect
Floors, walls, stairs, and surfaces are free of oil, dirt, and grease
Equipment is clean and free of oil, dirt, and grease
Shine Cleaning materials are easily accessible
Lines, lables, signs, and other visuals are clean and unbroken

Maintaining the first 3S's


Necessary information is visible
Standards are known and visible
Standardize Checklists exist for all cleaning and maintenance
Items can be located in 30 seconds or less

Making it stick
Assocaites have been trained in 5S
Associates know what they are responsible for to maintain 5S
Sustain Evidence is present that associates are following 5S process
O/C's and Managers are providing needed 5S support
O/C and Managers are following up on positive and negative
Follow-up and CI are being done at least monthly

TOTAL POINTS

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 467


Step 2 5-S Implementation
SORT

Determine sorting Talk to area workers


criteria Move items to holding
area
Designate holding
area Update Workplace
Scan display with
Identify person pictures
responsible for holding Use Disposition
area Guidelines for sorted
items.

Copyright
Six Sigma Rockwell AutomationOct
GB Material 2000
2013 468
Determine sorting criteria

1. If it is not bolted to floor, move it to the


HOLDING AREA

2. When it in doubt, MOVE IT OUT


Target items that:
• are safety hazards

• items you have to walk to or search for

• stored items that are not used

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 469


Item Disposition Guidance
Directions •Determine the category each tagged item belongs
•Determine required action, record on tag and Unneeded Items Log
•Take action
Category Action
Obsolete •Sell
•Hold for depreciation
•Give away
•Throw away
•Return to supplier
Defective
•Throw away
•Repair
Scrap •Remove to proper location

•Throw away
Trash / garbage
•Recycle

Unneeded in this area •Remove to proper location

Used at least once per day •Carry with you


•Keep at place of use
•Store in area
Used about once per week
•Store where accessible in plant
Used less than once per month
•Store in distance place
Seldom used
•Sell
•Give away
•Throw away

Use unknown •Find out use


•Remove to proper location

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 470


Step 3 5-S Implementation
SHINE

• Clean everything
• Inspect through cleaning

• Prevent dirt, grime & contamination from


occurring

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 471


Step 4 5-S Implementation
Set in Order

Results
•No Searching, Bending, or Stretching

•A place for everything, and everything is in its


place

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 472


SET IN ORDER

Guidelines for deciding where to put items


The more frequently used, the closer it should be to its
point of use

Every item should have A designated location and be labeled,


shadowed, or color coded

Make everything easy to get and to properly put away

Get items off the floor

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 473


Step 5 5-S Implementation
STANDARDIZE

There is a place for everything and


everything is in its place
How do we make sure that our changes stick?

• Only needed items are in the area

• Everything needed has a place and is in that place

• Everything needed can be located and returned easily

• Everything is cleaned and inspected regularly

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 474


STANDARDIZE

Key Actions
1. Attain 3’s Conditions

2. Make Things Visual

3. Make Temporary Lines and Signs Permanent

4. Use Color Coding

5. Assign Responsibility to Maintain

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 475


Step 6 5-S Implementation
SUSTAIN

Conditions for Sustaining


• Development of new awareness skills

• Management support
• Ongoing communication
• Make 5-S a part of daily work
• 5 minute 5-S
• 30 minute weekly 5-S meeting with
targets
• Total Employee Involvement
Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 476
SUSTAIN
Audit the System Regularly –
Establish the minimum standard
Make Everyone Accountable
5S Workplace Scan Checklist - 100 pts. M ax. - 85 points M in. Pass
Viola tions Points
5 or more 0
Ra te d By: 3 or 4 1
2 2
1 3
0 4

Are a De pa rtme nt Da te Score


Pre -e ve nt Post-Eve nt On-Going
W ha t is ne e de d vs. w ha t is not ne e de d
Only needed equipment, tools, furniture, supplies etc. are present
W alls, bulletin boards, etc. have only needed items
Sort Uneeded items are present in aisleways, corners, shelves, etc.
Uneeded inventory, supplies, parts, or materials are present
Safety hazards, (water, oil, coolant, etc,) on floor or work area
Machine guards are in place and in good condition

A pla ce for e ve rything a nd e ve rything in its pla ce


Correct places for items are visually obvious
Items are in the correct places
Se t in Aisleways, workstations, equipment locations are visually indicated
Orde r Items have not been put away after use
Height and quantity limits for stored items are obvious

Cle a n to inspe ct
Floors, walls, stairs, and surfaces are free of oil, dirt, and grease
Equipment is clean and free of oil, dirt, and grease
Shine Cleaning materials are easily accessible
Lines, lables, signs, and other visuals are clean and unbroken

Ma inta ining the first 3S's


Necessary information is visible
Standards are known and visible
Sta nda rdize Checklists are completed for all cleaning and maintenance
Items can be located in 30 seconds or less

Ma king it stick
Operators have been trained in 5S/TPM
Operators know what they are responsible for to maintain 5S/TPM
Susta in Evidence is present that operators are following 5S/TPM process
O/C's and Managers are providing needed 5S/TPM support
O/C and Managers are following up on positive and negative
Follow-up and CI are being done at least monthly

TOTAL POINTS
Comments on specific items:

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 477


DISPLAYING BEFORE & AFTER DATA
Before After Good

 Add more data to an existing run


chart or control chart. }Improvement
} Remaining Gap
Step 4 changes Target
 Prepare new Pareto charts for implemented

those you created in


Before After
Step 2. Make scale and dimensions
the same so you can more
accurately judge degree of } Improvement

improvement.
A1 A2 A3 A4 A2 A1 A3 A4
 Draw new frequency plots on the
same scale as the original plots.

Before After

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 478


RECALCULATE PROCESS SIGMA
Step Units Opportunities BEFORE AFTER BEFORE
1 40 2 x 40 = 80 61 17 846
Yield = 1–
2 40 1 x 40 = 40 37 1 960
3 40 3 x 40 = 120 113 12 = 1 – .88
4 40 1 x 40 = 40 34 0
= 12%
5 40 4 x 40 = 160 142 8
6 40 1 x 40 = 40 38 0 Sigma = 0.3
7 40 2 x 40 = 80 69 3
8 40 4 x 40 = 160 143 37 AFTER
9 40 1 x 40 = 40 37 0 86
Yield = 1–
10 40 2 x 40 = 80 64 5 960

11 40 2 x 40 = 80 72 2 = 1 – .09
12 40 1 x 40 = 40 35 1
= 91%
960 846 86
Sigma = 2.8

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 479


LOOPING BACK TO PREVIOUS STEPS
 If you followed your plan
but failed to get the desired
results, you need to retrace
your steps.
− Look for flaws or gaps in
your analysis.
− Review gap with
your manager.
− Pick up with that
step and start
again if necessary.

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 480


IMPORTANCE OF CLOSURE
− Recognize the
considerable time and
effort that went into the
initiative.
− Capture the learnings
from the initiative:

> About the problem or process being studied.


> About the improvement process itself.

− Share the learnings—The Knowledge Network.


− Hand over responsibilities for standardization and monitoring to
the appropriate people.

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 481


PROJECT CLOSURE
− Improvement must be continuous, but individual initiatives and
project teams come to an end.
− Learn when it’s time to say goodbye.
− Effective project closure weaves together the themes of:
> Project purpose.

> Improvement methods.

> Team skills and structures.

− Develop managerial systems to capture learnings and enable


the organization to address system issues.
− Documentation and recognition are two critical aspects of
project team closure.
− Celebrate!

Six Sigma GB Material Oct 2013 482

You might also like