Banker - Customer Relationship
Banker - Customer Relationship
Banker - Customer Relationship
Lesson 5
Banker – Customer Relationship
LESSON OUTLINE
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
– Introduction The objectives include:
– Meaning of a banking company (a) Providing knowledge of various legal
– Who is a customer? provisions affecting bankers
– Relationship as debtor and creditor (b) Awareness about legal cases decided on
the subject
– Banker as trustee
(c) Precautions which a bank should undertake
– Bailee/ bailor to avoid legal liability
– Lesser/ lessee (d) Understanding the rights and liabilities of a
– Banker as agent customer and a bank in regard to various
situations in their relationship
– Obligations of a banker
– Pass book and statement of account
– Garnishee order and attachment order
– Rights of a banker
– Various types of customers
– Various deposit schemes
– Other aspects of deposit accounts
– Closing of a bank account - termination of
banker-customer relationship
– Insurance of bank deposits
– Nomination
– Lesson Round Up
– Self Test Questions
121
122 PP-BL&P
INTRODUCTION
The relationship between a banker and his customer depends upon the nature of service provided by a banker.
Accepting deposits and lending and/or investing are the core banking businesses of a bank. In addition to its
primary functions, it deals with various customers by providing other services like safe custody services, safe
deposit lockers, and assisting the clients by collecting their cheques and other instruments as an agent and
trustees for them. So, based on the above a banker customer relationship can be classified as under:
Debtor/Creditor
Creditor/Debtor
Bailee/Bailer
Lesser/Lessee
Agent/Principal
From the above diagram it can be seen that different types of relationship exists between a banker and
customer.
Features of Banking
The following are the basic characteristics to capture the essential features of Banking:
(i) Dealing in money: The banks accept deposits from the public and advance the same as loans to the
needy people. The deposits may be of different types - current, fixed, savings, etc. accounts. The deposits
are accepted on various terms and conditions.
(ii) Deposits must be withdrawable: The deposits (other than fixed deposits) made by the public can be
withdrawable by cheques, draft or otherwise, i.e., the bank issue and pay cheques. The deposits are
usually withdrawable on demand.
Lesson 5 Banker – Customer Relationship 123
(iii) Dealing with credit: The banks are the institutions that can create credit i.e., creation of additional
money for lending. Thus, “creation of credit” is the unique feature of banking.
(iv) Commercial in nature: Since all the banking functions are carried on with the aim of making profit, it is
regarded as a commercial institution.
(v) Nature of agent: Besides the basic function of accepting deposits and lending money as loans, bank
possesses the character of an agent because of its various agency services.
WHO IS A CUSTOMER?
The term ‘customer’ of a bank is not defined by law. Ordinarily, a person who has an account in a bank is considered
is customer. Banking experts and the legal judgments in the past, however, used to qualify this statement by laying
emphasis on the period for which such account had actually been maintained with the bank. In Sir John Paget’s
view “to constitute a customer there must be some recognizable course or habit of dealing in the nature of regular
banking business.” This definition of a customer of a bank lays emphasis on the duration of the dealings between
the banker and the customer and is, therefore, called the ‘duration theory’. According to this viewpoint a person
does not become a customer of the banker on the opening of an account; he must have been accustomed to deal
with the banker before he is designated as a customer. The above-mentioned emphasis on the duration of the bank
account is now discarded. According to Dr. Hart, “a customer is one who has an account with a banker or for whom
a banker habitually undertakes to act as such.” Supporting this viewpoint, the Kerala High Court observed in the
case of Central Bank of India Ltd. Bombay vs. V.Gopinathan Nair and others (A.I.R.,1979, Kerala 74) : “Broadly
speaking, a customer is a person who has the habit of resorting to the same place or person to do business. So far
as banking transactions are concerned he is a person whose money has been accepted on the footing that banker
will honour up to the amount standing to his credit, irrespective of his connection being of short or long standing.”
For the purpose of KYC policy, a ‘Customer’ is defined as :
– a person or entity that maintains an account and/or has a business relationship with the bank;
– one on whose behalf the account is maintained (i.e. the beneficial owner);
– beneficiaries of transactions conducted by professional intermediaries, such as Stock Brokers, Chartered
Accountants, Solicitors etc. as permitted under the law, and
– any person or entity connected with a financial transaction which can pose significant reputational or other
risks to the bank, say, a wire transfer or issue of a high value demand draft as a single transaction.
Thus, a person who has a bank account in his name and for whom the banker undertakes to provide the facilities as
a banker, is considered to be a customer. It is not essential that the account must have been operated upon for
some time. Even a single deposit in the account will be sufficient to designate a person as customer of the banker.
Though emphasis is not being laid on the habit of dealing with the banker in the past but such habit may be
expected to be developed and continued in figure. In other words, a customer is expected to have regular dealings
with his banker in future.
An important consideration which determines a person’s status as a customer is the nature of his dealings with a
banker. It is evident from the above that his dealings with the banker must be relating to the business of banking.
A banker performs a number of agency functions and tenders various public utility services besides performing
essential functions as a banker. A person who does not deal with the banker in regard to the essentials functions of
the banker, i.e.. accepting of deposits and lending of money, but avails of any of the services rendered by the
banker, is not called a customer of the banker. For example, any person without a bank account in his name may
remit money through a bank draft, encash a cheque received by him from others or deposit his valuables in the Safe
Deposit Vaults in the bank or deposit cash in the bank to be credited to the account of the Life Insurance
Corporation or any joint stock company issuing new shares. But he will not be called a customer of the banker as
124 PP-BL&P
his dealing with the banker is not in regard to the essential functions of the banker. Such dealings are considered
as casual dealings and are not in the nature of banking business.
Thus, to constitute a customer the following essential requisites must be fulfilled:
(i) a bank account – savings, current or fixed deposit – must be opened in his name by making necessary
deposit of money, and
(ii) the dealing between the banker and the customer must be of the nature of banking business.
A customer of a banker need not necessarily be a person. A firm, joint stock company, a society or any separate
legal entity may be a customer. Explanation to Section 45-Z of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, clarifies that
section “customer” includes a Government department and a corporation incorporated by or under any law.
Since the banker-customer relationship is contractual, a bank follows that any person who is competent to contract
can open a deposit account with a bank branch of his/her choice and convenience. For entering into a valid
contract, a person needs to fulfill the basic requirements of being a major (18 years of age or above) and possessing
sound mental health (i.e. not being a lunatic). A person who fulfils these basic requirements, as also other requirements
of the banks as mentioned below, can open a bank account. However, minors (below 18 years of age) can also open
savings account with certain restrictions. Though any person may apply for opening an account in his name but the
banker reserves the right to do so on being satisfied about the identity of the customer.
By opening an account with the banker, a customer enters into relationship with a banker. The special features of
this relationship impose several obligations on the banker. He should, therefore, be careful in opening an account in
his name but the banker reserves the right to do so on being satisfied about the identity of the customer. Prior to the
introduction of “Know Your Customer (KYC)” guidelines by the RBI, it was the practice amongst banks to get a new
customer introduced by a person who has already one satisfactory bank account with the Bank or by a staff
member who knows him properly. Most of the banks preferred introduction to be given by a current account holder.
Different practices of various banks were causing confusion and sometimes loss to the bank on not opening
“properly” introduced account when any fraud took place in the account. A new customer was also facing difficulty
in opening an account if he was a new resident of that area. To overcome all these problems and streamline the
system of knowing a customer, RBI has directed all banks to adopt KYC guidelines.
Though the relationship between a banker and his customer is mainly that of a debtor and a creditor, this relationship
differs from similar relationship arising out of ordinary commercial debts in following respects:
(i) The creditor must demand payment. In case of ordinary commercial debt, the debtor pays the amount on
the specified date or earlier or whenever demanded by the creditor as per the terms of the contract. But in
case of deposit in the bank, the debtor/ banker is not required to repay the amount on his own accord. It is
essential that the depositor (creditor) must make a demand for the payment of the deposit in the proper
manner. This difference is due to the fact that a banker is not an ordinary debtor; he accepts the deposits
with an additional obligation to honour his customer’s cheques. If he returns the deposited amount on his
own accord by closing the account, some of the cheques issued by the depositor might be dishonored and
his reputation might be adversely affected. Moreover, according to the statutory definition of banking, the
deposits are repayable on demand or otherwise. The depositor makes the deposit for his convenience,
apart from his motives to earn an income (except current account). Demand by the creditor is, therefore,
essential for the refund of the deposited money. Thus the deposit made by a customer with his banker
differs substantially from an ordinary debt.
(ii) Proper place and time of demand. The demand by the creditor must be made at the proper place and in
proper time as prescribed by a bank. For example, in case of bank drafts, travellers’ cheques, etc., the
branch receiving the money undertakes to repay it at a specified branch or at any branch of the bank.
(iii) Demand must be made in proper manner. According to the statutory definition of banking, deposits are
withdrawable by cheque, draft, order or otherwise. It means that the demand for the refund of money
deposited must be made through a cheque or an order as per the common usage amongst the bankers. In
other words, the demand should not be made verbally or through a telephonic message or in any such
manner.
BANKER AS TRUSTEE
Ordinarily, a banker is a debtor of his customer in respect of the deposits made by the latter, but in certain
circumstances he acts as a trustee also. A trustee holds money or assets and performs certain functions for the
benefit of some other person called the beneficiary. For example, if the customer deposits securities or other
valuables with the banker for safe custody, the latter acts as a trustee of his customer. The customer continues to
be the owner of the valuables deposited with the banker. The legal position of the banker as a trustee, therefore,
differs from that of a debtor of his customer. In the former case the money or documents held by him are not treated
as his own and are not available for distribution amongst his general creditors in case of liquidation.
The position of a banker as a trustee or as a debtor is determined according to the circumstances to the each case.
If he does something in the ordinary course of his business, without any specific direction from the customer, he
acts as a debtor (or creditor). In case of money or bills, etc., deposited with the bank for specific purpose, the
bankers’ position will be determined by ascertaining whether the amount was actually debited or credited to the
customer’s account or not. For example, in case of a cheque sent for collection from another banker, the banker
acts as a trustee till the cheques is realized and credited to his customer’s account and thereafter he will be the
debtor for the same account. If the collecting banks fails before the payment of the cheque is actually received by
it from the paying bank, the money so realized after the failure of the bank will belong to the customer and will not
be available for distribution amongst the general creditors of the bank.
On the other hand, if a customer instructs his bank to purchase certain securities out of his deposit with the latter,
but the bank fails before making such purchase, the bank will continue to be a debtor of his customer (and not a
trustee) in respect of amount which was not withdrawn from or debited to his account to carry out his specific
instruction.
The relationship between the banker and his customer as a trustee and beneficiary depends upon the specific
instructions given by the latter to the farmer regarding the purpose of use of the money or documents entrusted to
126 PP-BL&P
the banker. In New Bank of India Ltd. v. Pearey Lal ( AIR 1962, Supreme Court 1003), the Supreme Court observed
in the absence of other evidence a person paying into a bank, whether he is a constituent of the bank or not, may
be presumed to have paid the money to be held as banker ordinarily held the money of their constituent. If no
specific instructions are given at the time of payment or thereafter and even if the money is held in a Suspense
Account the bank does not thereby become a trustee for the amount paid.
In case the borrower transfers to the banker certain shares in a company as a collateral security and the transfer is
duly registered in the books of the issuing company, no trust is created in respect of such shares and the banks’
position remains that of a pledge rather than as trustee. Pronouncing the above verdict, in New Bank of India vs.
Union of India (1981) 51 Company Case p. 378, the Delhi High Court observed that a trustee is generally not entitled
to dispose of or appropriate trust property for his benefit. “In the present case the banker was entitled to dispose of
the shares and utilize the amount thereof for adjustment to the loan amount if the debtor defaults. The banker’s
obligation to transfer back the shares can arise only when the debtor clears dues of the bank was not considered
as trustee.
BANKER AS AGENT
A banker acts as an agent of his customer and performs a number of agency functions for the convenience of his
customers. For example, he buys or sells securities on behalf of his customer, collects cheques on his behalf and
makes payment of various dues of his customers, e.g.. insurance premium, etc. The range of such agency functions
has become much wider and the banks are now rendering large number of agency services of diverse nature. For
example, some banks have established Tax Services Departments to take up the tax problems of their customers.
OBLIGATIONS OF A BANKER
Though the primary relationship between a banker and his customer is that of a debtor and creditor or vice versa,
the special features of this relationship, impose the following additional obligations on the banker:
“The drawee of a cheque having sufficient funds of the drawer in his hands, properly applicable to the payment must
compensate the drawer for any loss or damage caused by such default.”
a party to a suit, certified copy of the entries in his book will be sufficient evidence. The Court is also
empowered to allow any party to legal proceedings to inspect or copy from the books of the banker for
the purpose of such proceedings.
(iii) Under the Reserve Bank of IndiaAct,1934. The Reserve Bank of India collects credit information from
the banking companies and also furnishes consolidated credit information from the banking company.
Every banking company is under a statutory obligation under Section 45-B of the Reserve Bank. The
Act, however, provides that the Credit information supplied by the Reserve Bank to the banking companies
shall be kept confidential. After the enactment of the Reserve Bank of India (Amendment) Act, 1974,
the banks are granted statutory protection to exchange freely credit information mutually among
themselves.
(iv) Under the Banking Regulation Act, 1949. Under Section 26, every banking company is requires to
submit a return annually of all such accounts in India which have not been operated upon for 10 years.
Banks are required to give particulars of the deposits standing to the credit of each such account.
(v) Under the Gift Tax Act, 1958. Section 36 of the Gifts Tax Act, 1958, confers on the Gift Tax authorities
powers similar to those conferred on Income- Tax authorities under Section 131 of the Income Tax Act
[discussed above (i).]
(vi) Disclosure to Police. Under Section 94 (3) of the Criminal Procedure Code, the banker is not exempted
from producing the account books before the police. The police officers conducting an investigation
may also inspect the banker’s books for the purpose of such investigations (section 5. Banker’s
Books Evidence Act).
(vii) Under the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999, under section 10. Banking companies dealing in
foreign exchange business are designated as ‘authorized persons’ in foreign exchange. Section 36, 37
and 38 of this Act empowers the officer of the Directorate of Enforcement and the Reserve Bank to
investigate any contravention under the Act.
(viii) Under the Industrial Development Bank of India Act, 1964. After the insertion of sub-section 1A in
Section 29 of this Act in 1975, the Industrial Development Bank of India is authorized to collect from or
furnish to the Central Government, the State Bank, any subsidiary bank, nationalized bank or other
scheduled bank, State Co-operative Bank, State Financial Corporation, credit information or other
information as it may consider useful for the purpose of efficient discharge of its functions. The term
‘credit information’ shall have the same meaning as under the Reserve Bank of India Act,1934.
(b) Disclosure permitted by the Banker’s Practices and Usages. The practices and usages customary
amongst bankers permit the disclosure of certain information under the following circumstances:
(i) With Express or Implied Consent of the Customer. The banker will be justified in disclosing any
information relating to his customer’s account with the latter’s consent. In fact the implied term of the
contract between the banker and his customer is that the former enters into a qualified obligation with
the latter to abstain from disclosing information as to his affairs without his consent (Tourniers vs.
National Provincial and Union Bank of India). The consent of the customer may be expressed or
implied. Express consent exists in case the customer directs the banker in writing to intimate the
balance in his account or any other information to his agent, employee or consultant. The banker
would be justified in furnishing to such person only the required information and no more. It is to be
noted that the banker must be very careful in disclosing the required information to the customer or his
authorized representative. For example, if an oral enquiry is made at the counter, the bank employee
should not speak in louder voice so as to be heard by other customers. Similarly, the pass-book must
be sent tot the customer through the messenger in a closed cover. A banker generally does not
disclose such information to the customer over the telephone unless he can recognize the voice of his
customer; otherwise he bears the risk inherent in such disclosure.
Lesson 5 Banker – Customer Relationship 129
In certain circumstances, the implied consent of the customer permits the banker to disclose necessary
information. For example, if the banker sanctions a loan to a customer on the guarantee of a third
person and the latter asks the banker certain questions relating to the customer’s account. The
banker is authorized to do so because by furnishing the name of the guarantor, the customer is
presumed to have given his implied consent for such disclosure. The banker should give the relevant
information correctly and in good faith.
Similarly, if the customer furnishes the name of the banker to a third party for the purpose of a trade
reference, not only an express consent of the customer exists for the discloser of relevant information
but the banker is directed to do so, the non – compliance of which will adversely affect the reputation
of the customer.
Implied consent should not be taken for granted in all cases even where the customer and the enquirer
happen to be very closely related. For example, the banker should not disclose the state of a lady’s
account to her husband without the express consent of the customer.
(ii) The banker may disclose the state of his customer’s account in order to legally protect his own
interest. For example, if the banker has to recover the dues from the customer or the guarantor,
disclosure of necessary facts to the guarantor or the solicitor becomes necessary and is quite justified.
(iii) Banker’s Reference. Banker follows the practice of making necessary enquires about the customers,
their sureties or the acceptors of the bills from other bankers. This is an established practice amongst
the bankers and is justified on the ground that an implied consent of the customer is presumed to
exist. By custom and practice necessary information or opinion about the customer is furnished by the
banker confidentially. However, the banker should be very careful in replying to such enquiries.
Precautions to be taken by the banker. The banker should observe the following precautions while giving
replies about the status and financial standing of a customer:
(i) The banker should disclose his opinion based on the exact position of the customer as is evident from
his account. He should not take into account any rumour about his customer’s creditworthiness. He is
also not expected to make further enquiries in order to furnish the information. The basis of his opinion
should be the record of the customer’s dealings with banker.
(ii) He should give a general statement of the customer’s account or his financial position without disclosing
the actual figures. In expressing his general opinion he should be very cautious—he should neither
speak too low about the customer nor too high. In the former case he injures the reputation of the
customer ; in the latter, he might mislead the enquirer. In case unsatisfactory opinion is to be given, the
banker should give his opinion in general terms so that it does not amount to a derogatory remark. It
should give a caution to the enquirer who should derive his own conclusions by inference and make
further enquiries, if he feels the necessity.
(iii) He should furnish the required information honestly without bias or prejudice and should not misrepresent
a fact deliberately. In such cases he incurs liability not only to his own customer but also to the
enquirer.
(c) Duty to the public to disclose : Banker may justifiably disclose any information relating to his customer’s
account when it is his duty to the public to disclose such information. In practice this qualification has
remained vague and placed the banks in difficult situations. The Banking Commission, therefore,
recommended a statutory provision clarifying the circumstances when banks should disclose in public
interest information specific cases cited below:
(i) when a bank asked for information by a government official concerning the commission of a crime and
the bank has reasonable cause to believe that a crime has been committed and that the information in
130 PP-BL&P
the part of the customer to examine the correctness of the entries in the Pass Book is a fault on his part and thus
renders as an evidence of settled and accepted account. The implied obligations on the customer to examine the
Pass Book have not been supported in many other judicial decisions in England and India. For reference, we may
cite the cases of Keptigalla Rubber Estate Co. vs. National Bank of India (1909) and Chatterton vs. London and
Country Bank. In the absence of such obligation on the customer, the entries in the Pass Book cannot be treated
as a conclusive proof of their accuracy and as settled account,. The customer is competent to point out the
mistakes or omissions in the Pass Book at any time he happens to know about them. Thus the entries in the Pass
Book do not form the conclusive evidence of their correctness accuracy. The entries erroneously made or wrongly
omitted may be either advantageous to the customer or the banker. Both the parties may, therefore, indicate the
mistakes or omissions therein and get them rectified. The legal position in this regard is as follows:
according to Section 72 of the Indian Contract Act which states that “A person to whom money has been paid or
anything delivered by mistake or under coercion, must repay or return it.”
Garnishee Order
The obligation of a banker to honour his customer’s cheques is extinguished on receipt of an order of the Court,
known as the Garnishee order, issued under Order 21, Rule 46 of the code of Civil Procedure, 1908. If a debtor fails
to pay the debt owed by to his creditor, the latter may apply to the Court for the issue of a Garnishee Order on the
banker of his debtor. Such order attaches the debts not secured by a negotiable instrument, by prohibiting the
creditor the creditor from recovering the debt and the debtor from the making payment thereof. The account of the
customer with the banker, thus, becomes suspended and the banker is under an obligation not to make any
payment from the account concerned after the receipt of the Garnishee Order. The creditor at whose request the
order is issued is called the judgement- creditor, the debtor whose money is frozen is called judgement- debtor and
the banker who is the debtor of the judgement debtor is called the Garnishee.
The Garnishee Order is issued in two parts. First, the Court directs the banker to stop payment out of the account
of the judgement- debtor. Such order, called Order Nisi, also seeks explanation from the banker as to why the funds
in the said account should not be utilized for the judgement- creditor’s claim. The banker is prohibited from paying
the amount due to his customer on the date of receipt of the Order Nisi. He should, therefore, immediately inform
134 PP-BL&P
the customer so that dishonour of any cheque issued by him may be avoided. After the banker files his explanation,
if any, the Court may issue the financial order, called Order Absolute where the entire balance in the account or a
specified amount is attached to be handed over to the judgement- creditor. On receipt of such an order the banker
is bound to pay the garnished funds to the judgement- creditor. Thereafter, the banker liabilities towards his customer
are discharged to that extent. The suspended account may be revived after payment has been made to the
judgement- creditor as per the directions of the Court. The following points are to be noted in this connection:
II. The amount attached by the order. A garnishee order may attach either the amount of the judgement debtor with
the banker irrespective of the amount which the judgement-debtor owes to the creditor or a specified amount only
which is sufficient to meet the creditor’ claim from the judgement-debtor. In the first case, the entire amount in the
account of the customer in the bank is garnished or attached and if banker pays any amount out of the same which
is in excess of the amount of the debt of the creditor plus cost of the legal proceedings, he will render himself liable
for such payment. For example, the entire to the credit of X, the principal debtor, Rs. 10,000 is attached by the
Court while the debt owed by him to his creditor Y is only Rs. 6,000. If the banker honours the cheque of the
customer X to the extent of Rs. 5,000 and thus reducing the balance to Rs. 5,000 he will be liable for defying the
order of the Court. On the other hand, if he dishonours all cheques, subsequent to the receipt of the Garnishee
Order, he will not be liable to the customer for dishonouring his cheques.
It is to be noted that the Garnishee Order does not apply to the amount of the cheque marked by a bank as a good
for payment because the banker undertakes upon himself the liability to pay the amount of the cheque. On the
other hand, if the judgement debtor gives to the bank a notice to withdraw, it does not amount withdrawal, but
merely his intention to withdraw. The Garnishee Order will be applicable to such funds. In the second case, only the
amount specified in the order is attached and the amount is excess of that may be paid to the customer by the
banker.
For example, X is customer of SBI and his current account shows a credit balance of Rs. 10,000. He is indebted to
Y for Rs. 5,000. the latter applies to the Court for the issue of a Garnishee Order specifies the amount (Rs. 5,000)
which is being attached, the banker will be justified in making payment after this amount, i.e., the balance in the
customer’s account should not be reduced below Rs. 5,000. Usually in such cases, the attached amount is
transferred to a suspense account and the account of the customer is permitted to be operated upon with the
remaining balance.
III. The order of the Court restrains the banker from paying the debts due or accruing due. The word ‘accruing due’
mean the debts which are not payable but for the payment of which an obligation exists. If the account is overdrawn,
the banker owes no money to the customer and hence the Court Order ceases to be effective. A bank is not a
garnishee with respect to the unutilized portion of the overdraft or cash credit facility sanctioned to its customer and
such utilized portion of cash credit or overdraft facility cannot be said to be an amount due from the bank of its
customer. The above decision was given by the Karnataka High Court in Canara Bank vs. Regional Provident Fund
Commissioner. In his case the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner wanted to recover the arrears of provident
fund contribution from the defaulters’ bankers out of the utilized portion of the cash credit facility. Rejecting this
claim, the High Court held that the bank cannot be termed as a Garnishee of such unutilized portion of cash credit,
as the banker’s position is that of creditor. For example, PNB allows it as customer to overdraw to the extent of
Rs. 5,000. The customer has actually drawn (Rs. 3,000) cannot be attached by a Garnishee Order as this is not a
debt due from the banker. It merely indicates the extent to which the customer may be the debtor of the bank.
The banker, of course, has the right to set off any debt owed by the customer before the amount to which the
Garnishee Order applies is determined. But it is essential that debt due from the customer is actual and not merely
contingent. For example, if there is an unsecured loan account in the name of the judgement-debtor with a balance
of Rs. 5,000 at the time of receipt of Garnishee Order, such account can be set off against the credit balance in the
other account. But if the debt due from the judgement- debtor is not actual, i.e., has not actually become due, but
is merely contingent, such set off is not permissible. For example, if A, the judgement- debtor, has discounted a bill
of exchange with the bank, there is contingent liability of A towards the bank, if the acceptor does not honour the bill
Lesson 5 Banker – Customer Relationship 135
on the due date. Similarly, if A has guaranteed a loan taken from the bank by B, his liability as surety does not arise
until and unless B actually makes default in repaying the amount of the loan.
The banker is also entitled to combine two accounts in the name of the customer in the same right. If one account
shows a debit balance and the other a credit one, net balance is arrived at by deducting the former from the latter.
IV. The Garnishee Order attachés the balance standing to the credit of the principal debtor at the time the order is
served on the banker. The following points are to be noted in this connection:
(a) The Garnishee Order does not apply to: (1) the amounts of cheques, drafts, bills, etc.., sent for collection
by the customer, which remain uncleared at the time of the receipt of the order, (2) the sale proceeds of the
customer’s securities, e.g., stocks and shares in the process of sale, which have not been received by the
banker. In such cases, the banker acts as the agent for the customer for the collection of the cheques or
for the sale of the securities and the amounts in respect of the same are not debts due by the banker to the
customer, until they are actually received by the banker and credited to the customer’s account. But if the
amount of such uncleared cheque, etc., is credited to the customer’s account, the position of the banker
changes and the garnishee order is applicable to the amount of such uncleared cheques. Similarly, if one
branch of a bank sends its customer’s cheque for realization to its another branch and the latter collects
the same from the paying banker before the receipt of the Garnishee Order by the first branch, the amount
so realized shall also be subject to Garnishee Order, even though the required advice about realization of
cheque is received after the receipt of the Garnishee Order. Giving this judgement in Gerald C.S. Lobo v.
Canara Bank (1997) 71 Comp. Cases 290, the Karnataka high Court held that the branch which collects
money on behalf of another branch is to be treated as agent of the latter and consequently the moment a
cheque sent for collection by the other branch has been realized by the former, the realization must be
treated as having accrued to the principal branch.
(b) The Garnishee Order cannot attach the amounts deposited into the customer’s account after the Garnishee
Order has been served on the banker. A Garnishee Order applies to the current balance at the time the
order is served, it has no prospective operation. Bankers usually open a new account on the name of
customer for such purpose.
(c) The Garnishee Order is not effective in the payments already made by the banker before the order is served
upon him. But if a cheque is presented to the banker for payment and its actual payment has not yet been
made by the banker and in the meanwhile a Garnishee Order is served upon him, the latter must stop
payment of the said cheque, even if it is passed for payment for payment. Similarly, if a customer asks the
banker to transfer an amount from his account and the banker has already made necessary entries of such
transfer in his books, but before the intimation could be sent to the other account-holder, a Garnishee
Order is received by the banker, it shall be applicable to the amount so transferred by mere book entries,
because such transfer has no effect without proper communication to the person concerned.
(d) In case of cheques presented to the paying banker through the clearing house, the effectiveness of the
Garnishee Order depends upon the fact whether time for returning the dishonoured cheques to the collecting
banker has expired or not. Every drawee bank is given specified time within which it has to return the
unpaid cheques, if any, to the collecting bank. If such time has not expired and in the meanwhile the bank
receives a Garnishee Order, it may return the cheque dishonoured. But if the order is received after such
time over, the payment is deemed to have been made by the paying banker and the order shall not be
applicable to such amount.
(e) The Garnishee Order is not applicable to:
(i) Money held abroad by the judgement- debtor ; and
(ii) Securities held in the safe custody of the banker,
(f) The Garnishee Order may be served on the Head Office of the bank concerned and it will be treated as
136 PP-BL&P
sufficient notice to all of its branches. However, the Head Office is given reasonable time to intimate all
concerned branches. If the branch office makes payment out of the customer’s account before the receipt
of such intimation, the banker will not be held responsible for such payment.
This section makes it obligatory for every person to whom such notice is issued to comply with such notice. In case
of a banking company, it shall not be necessary for any pass book or deposit receipt or any other document to be
produced for the purpose of any entry, endorsement, etc., before payment is made. After making payment as
required under this section, the banker shall be fully discharged from his liability to the assessee to the extent of
the discharged from his liability to the assessee to the extent of the amount so paid. But if he fails to make
payment, he shall be deemed to be an assessee in default in respect of the amount specified in the notice and
further proceedings may be taken against him for the realization of such amount. The banker should, therefore,
comply with such order. His obligation towards his customer is reduced to that extent.
RIGHTS OF A BANKER
Right of Appropriation
In case of his usual business, a banker receives payments from his customer. If the latter has more than one
account or has taken more than one loan from the banker, the question of the appropriation of the money subsequently
deposited by him naturally arises. Section 59 to 61 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 contains provisions regarding
the right of appropriation of payments in such cases. According to Section 59 such right of appropriation is vested
in the debtor, who makes a payment to his creditor to whom he owes several debts. He can appropriate the
payment by (i). an express intimation or (ii) under circumstances implying that the payment is to be applied to the
discharge of some particular debt. If the creditor accepts such payment, it must be applied accordingly. For
example, A owes B several debts, including Rs. 1,000 upon a promissory note which falls due on 1st December,
1986. He owes B no other debt of that amount. On 1-12-1986 A pays B Rs. 1,000. The payment is to be applied to
the discharge of the promissory note.
If the debtor does not intimate or there is no other circumstances indicating to which debt the payment is to be
applied, the right of appropriation is vested in the creditor. He may apply it as his discretion to any lawful debt
actually due and payable to him from the debtor (Section 60) Further, where neither party makes any appropriation,
the payment shall be applied in discharge of each proportionately (Section 61).
In M/s. Kharavela Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. Orissa State Financial Corporation and Others [AIR 1985 Orissa 153 (A)],
the question arose whether the payment made by the debtor was to be adjusted first towards the principal or
interest in the absence of any stipulation regarding appropriation of payments in the loan agreement. The Court held
that in case of a debt due with interest, any payment made by the debtor is in the first instance to be applied
towards satisfaction of interest and thereafter toward the principal unless there is an agreement to the contrary.
In case a customer has a single account and he deposits and withdraws money from it frequently, the order in
which the credit entry will set off the debit entry is the chronological order, as decided in the famous Clayton’s
Case. Thus the first item on the debit side will be the item to be discharged or reduced by a subsequent item on the
credit side. The credit entries in the account adjust or set-off the debit entries in the chronological order. The rule
derived from the Clayton’s case is of great practical significance to the bankers. In a case of death, retirement or
insolvency of a partner of a firm, the then existing debt due from the firm is adjusted or set-off by subsequent credit
made in the account. The banker thus loses his right to claim such debt from the assets of the deceases, retired
or insolvent partner and may ultimately suffer the loss if the debt cannot be recovered from the remaining partners.
Therefore, to avoid the operation of the rule given in the Clayton’s case the banker closes the old account of the firm
and opens a new one in the name of the reconstituted firm. Thus the liability of the deceased, retired or insolvent
partner, as the case may be, at the time of his death, retirement or insolvency is determined and he may be held
liable for the same. Subsequent deposits made by surviving/ solvent partners will not be applicable to discharge the
same.
retain the goods and securities owned by the debtor until the debt due from him is repaid. It confers upon the
creditor the right to retain the security of the debtor and not the right to sell it . Such right can be exercised by the
creditor in respect of goods and securities entrusted to him by the debtor with the intention to be retained by him as
security for a debt due by him (debtor).
Lien may be either (i) a general lien or, (ii) a particular lien. A particular lien can be exercised by a craftsman or a
person who has spent his time, labour and money on the goods retained. In such cases goods are retained for a
particular debt only. For example, a tailor has the right to retain the clothes made by him for his customer until his
tailoring charges area paid by the customer. So is the case with public carriers and the repair shops.
A general lien, on the other hand, is applicable in respect of all amounts due from the debtor to the creditor. Section
171 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, confers the right of general lien on the bankers as follows:
“Bankers… may, in the absence of a contract to the contrary, retain as a security for a general balance of
account, any goods bailed to them.”
by the customer as a trustee in respect of his personal loan. But if the banker is unaware of the fact that the
negotiable securities do not belong to the customer, his right of general lien is not affected.
(g) Banker possesses right of set-off and not lien on money deposited. The banker’s right of lien extends
over goods and securities handed over to the banker. Money deposited in the bank and the credit balance
in the accounts does not fall in the category of goods and securities. The banker may, therefore, exercise
his right of set-off rather the right of lien in respect of the money deposited with him. The Madras High Court
expressed this view clearly as follows:
The lien under Section 171 can be exercised only over the property of someone else and not own property. Thus
when goods are deposited with or securities are placed in the custody of a bank, it would be correct to speak of
right of the bank over the securities or the goods as a lien because the ownership of the goods or securities would
continue to remain in the customer. But when moneys are deposited in a bank as a fixed deposit, the ownership of
the moneys passes to the bank and the right of the bank over the money lodged with it would not be really lien at
all. It would be more correct speak of it as a right to set-off or adjustment.” (Brahammaya v. K.P. Thangavelu Nadar,
AIR (1956), Madras 570)
Right of set-off
The right of set-off is a statutory right which enables a debtor to take into account a debt owed to him by a creditor,
before the latter could recover the debt due to him from the debtor. In other words, the mutual claims of debtor and
creditor are adjusted together and only the remainder amount is payable by the debtor. A banker, like other debtors,
possesses this right of set-off which enables him to combine two accounts in the name of the same customer and
to adjust the debit balance in one account with the credit balance in the other. For example, A has taken an
overdraft from his banker to the extent of Rs. 5,000 and he has a credit balance of Rs. 2,000 in his savings bank
account, the banker can combine both of these accounts and claim the remainder amount of Rs. 3,000 only. This
right of set-off can be exercised by the banker if there is no agreement – express or implied – contrary to this right
and after a notice is served on the customer intimating the latter about the former’s intention to exercise the right of
set-off. To be on the safer side, the banker takes a letter of set-off from the customer authorizing the banker to
exercise the right of set-off without giving him any notice. The right of set-off can be exercised subject to the
fulfillment of the following conditions:
(i) The accounts must be in the same name and in the same right. The first and the most important condition
for the application of the right of set-off is that the accounts with the banker must not only be in the same
name but also in the same right. By the words ‘the same right’ meant that the capacity of the account-
holder in both or call the accounts must be the same, i.e., the funds available in one account are held by
him in the same right or capacity in which a debit balance stands in another account. The underlying
principle involved in this rule is that funds belonging to someone else, but standing in the same name of the
account – holder, should not be made available to satisfy his personal debts. The following examples,
make this point clear:
(a) In case of a sole trader the account in his personal name and that in the firm’s name are deemed to be
in the same right and hence the right of set-off can be exercised in case either of the two accounts is
having debit balance.
(b) In case the partners of a firm have their individual accounts as well as the account of the firm with the
same bank, the latter cannot set-off the debt due from the firm against the personal accounts of the
partners. But if the partners have specially undertaken to be jointly and severally liable for the firm’s
debt due to the banker, the latter can set-off such amount of debt against the credit balances in the
personal accounts of the partners.
(c) An account in the name of a person in his capacity as a guardian for a minor is not be treated in the
same right as his own account with the banker.
Lesson 5 Banker – Customer Relationship 141
(d) The funds held in Trust account are deemed to be in different rights. If a customer opens a separate
account with definite instructions as regards the purpose of such account, the latter should not be
deemed to be in the same right. The case of Barclays Bank Ltd. v. Quistclose Investment Limited may
be cited as an illustration. Rolls Rozer Ltd .borrowed an amount from Quistclose Investment Ltd. with
the specific purpose of paying the dividend to the shareholders and deposited the same in a separate
account ‘Ordinary Dividend No. 4 Account with Barclays Bank Ltd. and the latter was also informed
about the purpose of this deposit. The company went into liquidation before the intended dividend
could be paid and the banker combined all the accounts of the company, including the above one.
Quistclose Investment Ltd., the creditors of the company, claimed the repayment of the balance in the
above account which the bank refused. It was finally decided that by opening an account for the
specific purpose of paying the dividend a trust arose in favour of the shareholders. If the latter could not
get the funds, the benefit was to go to the Quistclose Investment Ltd. and to the bank. The banker was
thus not entitled to set-off the debit balance in the company’s account against the credit balance in the
above account against the credit balance in the above account. The balance held in the clients’
account of an advocate is not deemed to be held in the same capacity in which the amount is held in
his personal account.
(e) In case of a joint account, a debt due from one of the joint account- holders in his individual capacity
cannot be set-off against an amount due to him by the bank in the joint account. But the position may
appear to be different if the joint account is payable to ‘ former or survivor’. Such an account is deemed
to be primarily payable to the former and only after his death to the survivor. Thus the former’s debt can
be set-off against the balance in the joint account.
(ii) The right can be exercised in respect of debts due and not in respect of future debts or contingent debts.
For example, a banker can set-off a credit balance in the account of customer towards the payment of a bill
which is already due but not in respect of a bill which will mature in future. If a loan given to a customer is
repayable on demand or at a future date, the debt becomes due only when the banker makes a demand or
on the specified date and not earlier.
(iii) The amount of debts must be certain. It is essential that the amount of debts due from both the parties to
each other must be certain. If liability of any one of them is not determined exactly, the right of set- off
cannot be exercised. For example, if A stands as guarantor for a loan of Rs. 50,000 given by a bank to B,
his liability as guarantor will arise only after B defaults in making payment. The banker cannot set- off the
credit balance in his account till his liability as a guarantor is determined. For this purpose it is essential
that the banker must first demand payment from his debtor. If the latter defaults in making payment of his
payment of his debt, only then the liability of the guarantor arises and the banker can exercise his right of
set-off against the credit balance in the account of the guarantor. The banker cannot exercise this right as
and when he realizes that the amount of debt has becomes sticky, i.e., irrecoverable.
(iv) The right may be exercised in the absence of an agreement to the contrary. If there is agreement – express
or implied – inconsistent with the right of set-off, the banker cannot exercise such right. If there is an
express contract between the customer and the banker creating a lien on security, it would exclude
operation of the statutory general lien under Section 171 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. In Krishna
Kishore Kar v. Untitled Commercial Bank and Another (AIR 1982 Calcutta 62), the UCO Bank, on the
request of its customer K.K. Kar, issued guarantee for Rs. 2 lakhs in favour of the suppliers of coal
guaranteeing payment for coal supplied to him. The customer executed a counter- guarantee in favour of
the Bank and also paid margin money Rs. 1.83 lakhs to the Bank. After fulfilling its obligations under the
guarantee, the Bank adjusted Rs. 76,527 due from the customer under different accounts against the
margin money deposited by the customer in exercise of its lien (or alternatively the right of set-off). The
High Court held that the bank was not entitled to appropriate or adjust its claims under Section 171 of the
Contract Act in view of the existence of the counter- guarantee, which constituted a contract contrary to the
142 PP-BL&P
Individuals
Accounts of individuals form a major chunk of the deposit accounts in the personal segment of most banks.
Individuals who are major and of sound mind can open a bank account.
(a) Minors:
In case of minor, a banker would open a joint account with the natural guardian. However to encourage the habit of
savings, banks open minor accounts in the name of a minor and allows single operations by the minor himself/
herself. Such accounts are opened subject to certain conditions like (i) the minor should be of some minimum age
say 12 or 13 years or above (ii) should be literate (iii) No overdraft is allowed in such accounts (iv) Two minors cannot
open a joint account. (v) The father is the natural guardian for opening a minor account, but RBI has authorized
mother also to sign as a guardian (except in case of Muslim minors)
(b) Joint Account Holders:
A joint account is an account by two or more persons. At the time of opening the account all the persons should
sign the account opening documents. Operating instructions may vary, depending upon the total number of account
holders. In case of two persons it may be (i) jointly by both account holders (ii) either or survivor (iii) former or
survivor In case no specific instructions is given, then the operations will be by all the account holders jointly, The
instructions for operations in the account would come to an end in cases of insanity, insolvency, death of any of the
joint holders and operations in the account will be stopped.
Lesson 5 Banker – Customer Relationship 143
Firms
The concept of ‘Firm’ indicates either a sole proprietary firm or a partner- ship firm. A sole proprietary firm is wholly
owned by a single person, whereas a partnership firm has two or more partners. The sole-proprietary firm’s account
can be opened in the owner’s name or in the firm’s name. A partnership is defined under section 4 of the Indian
Partnership Act, 1932, as the relationship between persons who have agreed to share the profits of business
carried on by all or any of them acting for all. It can be created by an oral as well as written agreement among the
partners. The Partner- ship Act does not provide for the compulsory registration of a firm. While an unregistered firm
144 PP-BL&P
cannot sue others for any cause relating to the firm’s business, it can be sued by the outsiders irrespective of its
registration. In view of the features of a partnership firm, bankers have to ensure that the following requirements are
complied with while opening its account:
– The account is opened in the name of the firm and the account opening form is signed by all the partners
of the firm.
– Partnership deed executed by all the partners (whether registered or not) is recorded in the bank’s books,
with suitable notes on ledger heading, along with relevant clauses that affect the operation of the account.
– Partnership letter signed by all the partners is obtained to ensure their several and joint liabilities. The letter
governs the operation of the account and is to be adhered to accordingly.
The following precautions should be taken in the conduct of a partnership account:
– The account has to be signed ‘for and on behalf of the firm’ by all the authorized partners and not in an
individual name.
– A cheque payable to the firm cannot be endorsed by a partner in his name and credited to his personal
account.
– In case the firm is to furnish a guarantee to the bank, all the partners have to sign the document.
– If a partner (who has furnished his individual property as a security for the loan granted to the firm) dies, no
further borrowings would be permitted in the account until an alternative for the deceased partner is arranged
for, as the rule in Clayton’s case operates.
Companies
A company is a legal entity, distinct from its shareholders or managers, as it can sue and be sued in its own name.
It is a perpetual entity until dissolved. Its operations are governed by the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956. A
company can be of three types:
– Private Limited company: Having 2 to 51 shareholders.
– Public company: Having 7 or more shareholders.
– Government company: Having at least 51per cent shareholdings of Government (Central or State). The
following requirements are to be met while opening an account in the name of a company:
– The account opening form meant for company accounts should be filled and specimen signatures of the
authorized directors of the company should be obtained.
– Certified up-to-date copies of the Memorandum and Articles of Association should be obtained. The powers
of the directors need to be perused and recorded to guard against ‘ultra vires’ acts of the company and of
the directors in future.
– Certificate of Incorporation (in original) should be perused and its copy retained on record.
– In the case of Public company, certificate of commencement of business should be obtained and a copy of
the same should be recorded. A list of directors duly signed by the Chairman should also be obtained.
– Certified copy of the resolution of the Board of Directors of the company regarding the opening, execution
of the documents and conduct of the account should be obtained and recorded.
Trusts
A trust is a relationship where a person (trustee) holds property for the benefit of another person (beneficiary) or
some object in such a way that the real benefit of the property accrues to the beneficiary or serves the object of the
Lesson 5 Banker – Customer Relationship 145
trust. A trust is generally created by a trust deed and all concerned matters are governed by the Indian Trusts Act,
1882.
The trust deed is carefully examined and its relevant provisions, noted. A banker should exercise extreme care
while conducting the trust accounts, to avoid committing breach of trust:
– A trustee cannot delegate his powers to other trustees, nor can all trustees by common consent delegate
their powers to outsiders.
– The funds in the name of the trust cannot be used for crediting in the trustee’s account, nor for liquidating
the debts standing in the name of the trustee.
– The trustee cannot raise loan without the permission of the court, unless permitted by the trust deed.
Clubs
Account of a proprietary club can be opened like an individual account. However, clubs that are collectively owned
by several members and are not registered under Societies Registration Act, 1860, or under any other Act, are
treated like an unregistered firm. While opening and conducting the account of such clubs, the following requirements
are to be met:
– Certified copy of the rules of the club is to be submitted.
– Resolution of the managing committee or general body, appointing the bank as their banker and specifying
the mode of operation of the account has to be submitted,
– The person operating the club account should not credit the cheques drawn favouring the club, to his
personal account.
Local Authorities
Municipal Corporation, Panchayat Boards are local authorities created by specific Acts of the state legislature.
Their constitution, functions, powers, etc. are governed by those Acts. Bankers should ensure that accounts of
such bodies are opened and conducted strictly as per the provisions of the relevant Act and regulations framed
there under. The precautions applicable for company or trust accounts are also applicable in the case of these
accounts, in order to guard against ultra vires acts by the officers of the local authority operating the account.
Co-operative societies
Co-operative societies are required to open accounts only with these banks which are recognized for this purpose
(under the Co-operative Society Act). The following documents should be obtained while opening their account:
– Certificate of registration of the society under the Co-operative Society Act.
– Certified copy of the bye-laws of the society.
– Resolution of the managing committee of the society prescribing the conditions for the conduct of the
account.
– List of the members of the managing committee with the copy of the resolution electing them as the
committee members.
Deposits - General
Deposits of banks are classified into three categories:
(1) Demand deposits are repayable on customers’ demand. These comprise of:
146 PP-BL&P
Demand Deposits
(a) Current account:
A current account is a running and active account that may be operated upon any number of times during a working
day. There is no restriction on the number and the amount of withdrawals from a current account. Current accounts
can be opened by individuals, business entities (firms, company), institutions, Government bodies / departments,
societies, liquidators, receivers, trusts, etc. The other main features of current account are as under:
– Current accounts are non-interest bearing and banks are not allowed to pay any interest or brokerage to
the current account holders.
– Overdraft facility for a short period or on a regular basis up to specified limits – are permitted in current
accounts. Regular overdraft facility is granted as per prior arrangements made by the account holder with
the bank. In such cases, the bank would honour cheques drawn in excess of the credit balance but not
exceeding the overdraft limit. Prescribed interest is charged on overdraft portion of drawings.
– Cheques/ bills collection and purchase facilities may also be granted to the current account holders.
– The account holder periodically receives statement of accounts from the Bank.
– Normally, banks levy charges for handling such account in the shape of “Ledger Folio charges”. Some
banks make no charge for maintenance of current account provided the balance maintained is sufficient to
compensate the Bank for the work involved.
– Third party cheques and cheques with endorsements may be deposited in the current account for collection
and credit.
(b) Current Deposits Premium Scheme:
This is a deposit product which combines Current & Short deposit account with ‘ sweep-in’ and ‘sweep-out’ facility
to take care of withdrawals, if any. Besides containing all features of a current account, the product is aimed at
offering current account customers convenient opportunity to earn extra returns on surplus funds lying in account
which may not normally be utilized in the near future or are likely to remain unutilized. The automated nature of
facility for “Sweep In or Sweep Out” of more than a specified limit of balance to be maintained and creating fixed
deposits for desired period, would save lot of operational hassles and add-on value in such accounts. Thus, with
this facility the customer shall be able to deploy his funds which in ordinary current account were not attracting any
interest.
Lesson 5 Banker – Customer Relationship 147
Sweep out from current to short deposits may be automatically when balance in the account is more than a
specified limit or weekly or on specific days which may be on 1st & 16th of every month or once within a month as
prescribed by an individual bank.
(c) Savings Account
Savings bank accounts are meant for individuals and a group of persons like Clubs, Trusts, Associations, Self Help
Groups (SHGs) to keep their savings for meeting their future monetary needs and intend to earn income from their
savings. Banks give interest on these accounts with a view to encourage saving habits. Everyone wants to save for
something in the future and their savings should be safe and accessible anytime, anyplace to help meet their
needs. This account helps an individual to plan and save for his future financial requirements. In this account
savings are completely liquid.
Main features of savings bank accounts are as follows:
– Withdrawals are permitted to the account-holder on demand, on presentation of cheques or withdrawal
form/letter. However, cash withdrawals in excess of the specified amount per transaction/day (the amount
varies from bank to bank) require prior notice to the bank branch.
– Banks put certain restrictions on the number of withdrawals per month/quarter, amount of withdrawal per
day, minimum balance to be maintained in the account on all days, etc. A fee/penalty is levied if these are
violated. These rules differ from bank to bank, as decided by their Boards. The rationale of these restrictions
is that the Savings Bank account should not be used like a current account since it is primarily intended for
attracting and accumulating savings.
– The Bank pays interest on the products of balances outstanding on daily basis. Rate of interest is decided
by bank from time to time.
– No overdraft in excess of the credit balance in savings bank account is permitted as there cannot be any
debit balance in savings account.
– Most banks provide a passbook to the account-holder wherein date-wise debit credit transactions and
credit balances are shown as per the customer’s ledger account maintained by the Bank.
– Cheque Book Facility Accounts in which withdrawals are permitted by cheques drawn in favour of self or
other parties. The payees of the cheque can receive payment in cash at the drawee bank branch or through
their bank account via clearing or collection. The account holder may also withdraw cash by submitting a
withdrawal form along with Pass Book, if issued.
– Non-cheque Book Facility accounts where account holders are permitted to withdraw only at the drawee
bank branch by submitting a withdrawal form or a letter accompanied with the account passbook requesting
permission for withdrawal. In such cases third parties cannot receive payments.
– Almost all banks which provide ATM facility, give ATM cards to their accounts holder, so that they avail
withdrawal facility 24 hours and all days at any place.
(d) Basic Savings Bank Deposit Account
With a view to making the basic banking facilities available in a more uniform manner across banking system, RBI
has modified the guidelines on opening of basic banking ‘no-frills’ accounts’. Such accounts are now known as
“Basic Savings Bank Deposit” Account which offers the minimum common facilities as under:-
– The account should be considered as a normal banking service available to all;
– No requirement of minimum balance;
– Facilitate deposit and withdrawal of cash at bank branch as well as ATMs;
148 PP-BL&P
Term Deposits
(a) Recurring Deposits or Cumulative Deposits :
In Recurring Deposits accounts, a certain amount of savings are required to be compulsorily deposited at specified
intervals for a specific period. These are intended to inculcate regular and compulsory savings habit among the low/
middle income group of people for meeting their specific future needs e.g. higher education or marriage of children,
purchase of vehicles etc. The main features of these deposits are:
– The customer deposits a fixed sum in the account at pre-fixed frequency (generally monthly/quarterly) for
a specific period (12 months to 120 months).
– The interest rate payable on recurring deposit is normally the applicable rate of fixed deposits for the same
period.
– The total amount deposited is repaid along with interest on the date of maturity.
– The depositor can take advance against the deposits up to 75% of the balance in the account as on the
date of advance or have the deposits pre-paid before the maturity, for meeting emergent expenses. In the
case of pre-mature withdrawals, the rate of interest would be lower than the contracted rate and some
penalty would also be charged. Similarly, interest is charged on advance against the deposits, which is
normally one or two per cent higher than the applicable rate of interest on deposits.
Lesson 5 Banker – Customer Relationship 149
1 per cent lower than that applicable to the period elapsed. Banks also may grant overdraft/ loan against
the security of their fixed deposits to meet emergent liquidity requirements of the customers. The interest
on such facility will be 1 per cent - 2 per cent higher than the interest rate on the fixed deposit.
(d) Special Term Deposits
Special Term Deposit carries all features of Fixed Deposit. In addition to these, interest gets compounded every
quarter resulting higher returns to the depositors. Now-a-days, 80% of the term deposits in banks is under this
scheme.
Higher Interest payable to Senior Citizens:
Persons who have attained the age of 60 years are “Senior Citizens” in regard to the payment of higher interest not
exceeding 1% over and above the normal rates of term deposits. Each bank has prepared its own scheme of term
deposits for senior citizens.
(e) Certificate of Deposit:
Banks also offer deposits to attract funds from corporate companies and banks and other institutions. One such
important deposit product offered by banks is called as Certificate of Deposit (CD) . Special features of a Certificate
of Deposit (CD):
1. Certificate of Deposit is issued at a discount to mature for the face value at maturity
2. Minimum amount for a CD is Rs. 100,000.00 (Rupees One lakh only) and multiples thereof
3. Minimum and maximum period a CD with banks are 7 days and 365 days respectively
4. CDs differs from Banks’ Fixed Deposits (FDs) in respect of (i) prepayment and (ii) loans. While banks
allows the fixed deposit holder the facility to withdraw before maturity (prepayment) and if required allows
the fixed deposit holder to avail of a loan, both of them are not permissible in case of certificate of deposits.
i.e., In case of Certificate of Deposits prepayment of CDs and loans against CDs are not allowed.
sweep earns lower interest rate due to the pre-mature payment of that portion of the term deposit. However,
the remaining amount of the term deposit continues to earn the original interest rate.
Main Advantages of Flexi-Deposits to a Customer Are :
– Advantage of Convenience: The customer opens only one account (savings or current) under the scheme
and need not come to the bank branch each time for opening term deposit accounts or for pre- paying/
breaking term deposit for meeting the shortfall in the savings /current account.
– Advantage of Higher Interest Earning: The customer earns higher interest on his surplus funds than is
possible when he opens two separate accounts: savings and term deposits.
– Withdrawals through ATMs can also be conveniently made.
Exclusive Features:
– Complete Liquidity.
– Convenience of Overdraft.
– Earns a higher rate of interest on deposit, without the dilemma of locking it for a long period.
– At the time of need for funds, withdrawals can be made in units of Rs.1,000/- from the Deposits by issuing
a cheque from Savings Bank Account or through overdraft facility from Current account.
– Flexibility in period of Term Deposit from 1 year to 5 years.
tenure. Get an annual payout of more than Rs.1 lac (depending upon the prevailing interest rates) for the next 4
years and fulfill the dream of seeing the child graduate from a great college.
Eligibility
Child Education Plan can be opened for only minors (1 day to 18 years) under a Guardian (natural / court appointed).
The minor needs to have a Savings Account with a bank
(c) Insurance-linked Deposit Schemes
Some banks have designed certain schemes which provide personal accidental insurance to the savings bank
depositors free of cost or at a nominal rate under group insurance scheme. These marketing strategies are adopted
for a limited period during a special deposit mobilization campaign so as to have an edge over in the competitive
position. This gives an attraction to the new depositors and a few people tend to shift their accounts from one bank
to another. For example : HDFC is giving free personal accidental insurance to its depositors with certain conditions.
One Regional Rural Bank is providing free accidental insurance to a new depositor during the first year and,
thereafter, the bank charges Rs. 5 for Rs. 50,000 personal accident insurance. Recently, Standard Chartered Bank
launched a savings account with cricket as the theme. Account-holders will score ‘runs’ for the transactions, which
can then be redeemed for gifts such as tickets for cricket matches played in India, autographed cricketing merchandise
or sporting equipment from Nike.
(d) Deposit Schemes for a particular type of Segment clients:
Banks have special deposit schemes for senior citizens, school going children and women. Some banks pay more
interest if the term deposit is in the name of a woman. Some concessions in regard to minimum balance requirements
and service charges are given to a particular segment client like salaried persons, army personnel.
Such accounts also serve the requirements of foreign nationals resident in India. NRO accounts can be maintained
as current, saving, recurring or term deposits. While the principal of NRO deposits is non-repatriable, current
income and interest earning is repatriable. Further NRI/PIO may remit an amount, not exceeding US $ 1 million per
financial year, out of the balances held in NRO accounts/ sale proceeds of assets /the assets in India acquired by
him by way of inheritance/legacy, on production of documentary evidence in support of acquisition, inheritance or
legacy of assets by the remitter, and an undertaking by the remitter and certificate by a Chartered Accountant in the
formats prescribed by the Central Board of Direct Taxes vide their Circular No. 10/2002 dated October 9, 2002.
(b) Non-Resident (External) (NRE) Accounts
The Non-Resident (External) Rupee Account NR(E)RA scheme, also known as the NRE scheme, was introduced
in 1970. Any NRI can open an NRE account with funds remitted to India through a bank abroad. This is a repatriable
account and transfer from another NRE account or FCNR(B) account is also permitted. A NRE rupee account may
be opened as current, savings or term deposit. Local payments can be freely made from NRE accounts. Since this
account is maintained in Rupees, the depositor is exposed to exchange risk. NRIs / PIOs have the option to credit
the current income to their Non-Resident (External) Rupee accounts, provided the authorized dealer is satisfied
that the credit represents current income of the non-resident account holders and income tax thereon has been
deducted / provided for.
(c) FCNR (B) Scheme
Non-Resident Indians can open accounts under this scheme. The account should be opened by the non-resident
account holder himself and not by the holder of power of attorney in India.
– These deposits can be maintained in any fully convertible currency.
– These accounts can only be maintained in the form of term deposits for maturities of minimum 1 year to
maximum 5 years.
– These deposits can be opened with funds remitted from abroad in convertible foreign currency through
normal banking channel, which are of repatriable nature in terms of general or special permission granted
by Reserve Bank of India.
– These accounts can be maintained with branches, of banks which are authorized for handling foreign
exchange business/nominated for accepting FCNR(B) deposits.
– Funds for opening accounts under Global Foreign Currency Deposit Scheme or for credit to such accounts
should be received from: -
– Remittance from outside India or
– Traveller Cheques/Currency Notes tendered on visit to India. International Postal Orders cannot be
accepted for opening or credit to FCNR accounts.
– Transfer of funds from existing NRE/FCNR accounts.
– Rupee balances in the existing NRE accounts can also be converted into one of the designated
currencies at the prevailing TT selling rate of that currency for opening of account or for credit to such
accounts.
Advantages of FCNR (B) Deposits
– Principal along with interest freely repatriable in the currency of the choice of the depositor.
– No Exchange Risk as the deposit is maintained in foreign currency.
Loans/overdrafts in rupees can be availed by NRI depositors or 3rd parties against the security of these
deposits. However, loans in foreign currency against FCNR (B) deposits in India can be availed outside
India through correspondent Banks.
154 PP-BL&P
Board laying down a transparent policy in this regard and the customers being notified of the terms and
conditions of renewal including interest rates , at the time of acceptance of deposits.
(ii) While opening accounts as described above, the customer should be made aware that if at any point of
time, the balances in all his/her accounts with the bank (taken together) exceeds Rupees Fifty Thousand
(Rs. 50,000) or total credit in the account exceeds Rupees One Lakh (Rs. 1,00,000) in a year, no further
transactions will be permitted until the full KYC procedure is completed. In order not to inconvenience the
customer, the bank must notify the customer when the balance reaches Rupees Forty Thousand (Rs.
40,000) or the total credit in a year reaches Rupees Eighty thousand (Rs. 80,000) that appropriate documents
for conducting the KYC must be submitted otherwise operations in the account will be stopped.
List of documents to be obtained by banks for opening an account
Features to be verified and documents that may be obtained from customers Features Documents
Accounts of individuals
– Legal name and any other names used (i) Passport (ii) PAN card (iii) Voter’s Identity Card/ Aadhar Card
– Correct permanent address (iv) Driving licence (v) Identity card (subject to the bank’s
satisfaction) (vi) Letter from a recognized public authority or
public servant verifying the identity and residence of the
customer to the satisfaction of bank (i) Telephone bill (ii)
Bank account statement (iii) Letter from any recognized
public authority (iv) Electricity bill (v) Ration card (vi) Letter
from employer (subject to satisfaction of the bank) (any one
document which provides customer information to the
satisfaction of the bank will suffice)
Accounts of companies
– Name of the company (i) Certificate of incorporation and Memorandum & Articles of
– Principal place of business Association (ii) Resolution of the Board of Directors to open
– Mailing address of the company an account and identification of those who have authority to
– Telephone/Fax Number operate the account (iii) Power of Attorney granted to its
managers, officers or employees to transact business on its
behalf (iv) Copy of PAN allotment letter (v) Copy of the
telephone bill
Accounts of partnership firms
– Legal name (i) Registration certificate, if registered (ii) Partnership deed (iii)
– Address Power of Attorney granted to a partner or an employee of the
– Names of all partners and their addresses firm to transact business on its behalf (iv) Any officially valid
– Telephone numbers of the firm and document identifying the partners and the persons holding
partners the Power of Attorney and their addresses (v) Telephone bill
in the name of firm/partners
Accounts of trusts & foundations
– Names of trustees, settlers, beneficiaries (i) Certificate of registration, if registered (ii) Power of Attorney
and signatories granted to transact business on its behalf (iii) Any officially
– Names and addresses of the founder, the valid document to identify the trustees, settlors, beneficiaries
managers/directors and the beneficiaries and those holding Power of Attorney, founders/managers/
– Telephone/fax numbers directors and their addresses (iv) Resolution of the managing
body of the foundation/association (v) Telephone bill
158 PP-BL&P
Some close relatives, e.g. wife, son, daughter and parents etc. who live with their husband, father/ mother and son,
as the case may be, are finding it difficult to open account in some banks as the utility bills required for address
verification are not in their name. In such cases, banks can obtain an identity document and a utility bill of the
relative with whom the prospective customer is living along with a declaration from the relative that the said person
(prospective customer) wanting to open an account is a relative and is staying with him/her. Banks can use any
supplementary evidence such as a letter received through post for further verification of the address.
Specimen signature
Specimen signature of the customer is obtained on the account opening form in the presence of the bank staff and
it is attested by an authorized bank officer on the form itself. A customer is recognized mainly by his/her signature
on the cheques/vouchers and these are compared with the specimen signature on record to verify the genuineness
of the customer’s signature.
Power of Attorney
A power of Attorney is a document duly stamped as per Stamp Act and given by a customer to his banker,
authorizing his attorney or agent named therein to operate the account. The banker should ensure that the document:
– gives specific authority to the named person to operate the named account on behalf of the customer,
– is properly stamped and notarized,
– is valid and not time barred,
– does not contain conditions or limitations on the authority of the attorney,
– binds the principal for all the transactions done by the attorney.
The Power of Attorney is then registered in the branch’s documents and the attorney’s signature is recorded in the
account for its operation.
A ‘Mandate’, which is a simpler and a general purpose version of the Power of attorney, is a simple authority given
in writing to the banker by a customer, authorizing a named person to operate the account temporarily for a
specified period.
The banker is also competent to terminate his relationship with the customer, if he finds that the latter is no
more a desirable customer. The banker takes this extreme step in circumstances when the customer is
guilty of conducting his account in an unsatisfactory manner, i.e. if the customer is convicted for forging
cheques or bills or if he issues cheques without sufficient funds or does not fulfill his commitment to pay
back the loans or overdrafts, etc. The banker should take the following steps for closing such an account:
(a) The banker should give to the customer due notice of his intention to close the account and request
him to withdraw the balance standing to his credit. This notice should give sufficient time to the
customer to make alternative arrangements. The banker should not, on his own, close the account
without such notice or transfer the same to any other branch.
(b) If the customer does not close the account on receipt of the aforesaid notice, the banker should give
another notice intimating the exact date by which the account be closed otherwise the banker himself
will close the account. During this notice period the banker can safely refuse to accept further credits
from the customer and can also refuse to issue fresh cheque book to him. Such steps will not make
him liable to the customer and will be in consonance with the intention of the notice to close account
by a specified date.
The banker should, however, not refuse to honour the cheques issued by the customer, so long as his
account has a credit balance that will suffice to pay the cheque. If the banker dishonours any cheque
without sufficient reasons, he will be held liable to pay damages to his customer under Section 31 of the
Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. In case of default by the customer to close the account, the banker
should close the account and send the money by draft to the customer. He will not be liable for dishonouring
cheques presented for payment subsequently.
C. Termination by Law: The relationship of a banker-customer can also be terminated by the process of law
and by the occurrence of the following events:
(a) Death of customer: On receiving notice or information of the death of a customer, the bank stops all
debit transactions in the account. However, credits to the account can be permitted. The balance in
the account is given to the legal representative of the deceased after obtaining the letters of administration,
or succession certificate, or indemnity bond as per the prescribed procedure, and only then, the
account is closed.
(b) Bankruptcy of customer: An individual customer may be declared bankrupt, or a company may be
wound up under the provisions of law. In such an event, no drawings would be permitted in the account
of the individual/company. The balance is given to the Receiver or Liquidator or the Official Assignee
and the account is closed thereafter.
(c) Garnishee Order: We have already discussed in paragraph 3.4.3. that after receiving a garnishee
order from a court or attachment order from income tax authority, the account can be closed as one of
the options after taking the required steps.
(d) Insanity of the customer: A lunatic/person of unsound mind is not competent to contract under
Section 11 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. Since banker-customer relationship is contractual, the
bank will not honour cheques and can close the account after receiving notice about the insanity of the
customer and receiving a confirmation about it through medical reports.
or was merged with another bank. The Deposit Insurance Corporation of India was established by an Act of Parliament
to insure the deposits in the banks and the scheme of deposit insurance was introduced with effect from January 1,
1962. The Corporation was renamed as Deposit Insurance and Credit Guarantee Corporation with effect from July
15, 1978.
NOMINATION
While opening accounts and accepting deposits, bankers need to ensure certain procedures and precautions. For
example KYC norms. Similarly, at the time of repayment of deposits banks should be careful and repay the amount
as per banks’ policies and the guidelines of the RBI.
As per the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, a depositor of a bank (including cooperative banks) may nominate one
person as nominee of the depositor/s. The nomination is to be made in a prescribed manner. In the event of the
death of the depositor, the deposit may be returned to the nominee. The nominee, is entitled to receive the deposit
in case of the death of the depositor. A minor can also be nominated as nominee. However in case a minor is
appointed as nominee, banks should request that a person be appointed to receive the deposit on behalf of the
minor. Commercial banks are governed by the provisions of Banking Companies (Nomination) Rules 1985, and for
Co-operative banks provisions of Co-operative Banks (Nomination) Rules 1985 are applicable. Banks get valid
discharge if they make payment to the nominee. Depositors should avail the facility of nomination and nominate a
person.
Lesson 5 Banker – Customer Relationship 161
Nomination facility is also available in case of articles kept in safe deposit lockers and also in safe custody with
banks. As per the provisions of the Banking Regulation Act,1949, any person who keeps any article in safe deposit
locker and/or in safe custody, may nominate one person as his nominee to receive the article in the event of the
death of that person. The nomination is to be made in a prescribed manner. In the event of the death of the bank’s
customer, the nominee is entitled to receive the articles kept in safe custody or remove the contents of locker, and
the bank gets a valid discharge.
Settlement of claims
A banker should be careful while making payment of deposit amount, when he receives a claim. When a depositor
dies, a claim would be received by the banker either from the nominee or legal heirs of the depositor.
CASE STUDY
why she had moved, and said that under no circumstances should the bank tell Mr. C where she now lived.
The bank changed the address on all of Mrs J’s accounts but, by accident, it also changed the address on the joint
account she held with Mr. C. This was because the bank had “linked” the accounts for the members of the
household on its computer system (which is a common practice these days), but had unfortunately not removed
the link before making the address change.
A few weeks later, Mr. C went to the bank to ask for a loan. While the member of staff was getting his details up on
the computer screen, Mr. C saw that the joint account had a different address. Realizing that, that was probably
where Mrs J had moved to, Mr. C went round there, broke down the front door, and severely assaulted Mrs J.
Mrs. J was in hospital for several days. She was very badly bruised and had suffered some internal injuries.
Some weeks later, after Mrs J had recovered sufficiently, she complained to the bank about what it had done. It
wouldn’t at first accept that it had done anything wrong. But it soon became clear that the facts were not in dispute.
It had been responsible for letting Mr. C find out Mrs J’s new address. It apologized, and offered her Rs.30,000. But
Mrs J did not think this was adequate compensation, so she came to the Redressal Authority.
Complaint upheld
When Mrs J brought her complaint to the Redressal Authority , she sent some photos taken when she was in
hospital. These showed some of the injuries caused by Mr C and the Authority thought that her suffering merited a
payment far in excess of Rs. 30000.
Mrs J had not asked for any particular amount. She had simply said that she wanted more than Rs. 30,000 but would
leave it to the Authority to come up with a suitable figure. The Authority suggested to the bank that it should consider
increasing its offer substantially, say ten-fold. It did this and Mrs J was happy to accept the increased payment. She
also said that she would not now move her accounts to another bank, as she had initially threatened to do.
Questions
1. Was the Bank in default by recording the new address of Mrs J in the account jointly with her husband
without specific instruction in that regard.?
2. Are the bank staff responsible for failure to maintain secrecy about the new address of Mrs. J. ?
3. What safeguards the bank staff should have taken for maintenance of secrecy about the new address of
Mrs J to prevent access by the outsiders. ?
4. Can Mrs J legally accept the compensation from bank in the present context and refrain from criminal
justice against Mr C?
LESSON ROUND UP
– The relationship between a banker and his customer depends upon the nature of service provided by a
banker.
– On the opening of an account the banker assumes the position of a debtor.
– He is not a depository or trustee of the customer’s money because the money over to the banker
becomes a debt due from him to the customer.
– A banker acts as an agent of his customer and performs a number of agency functions for the convenience
of his customers. For example, he buys or sells securities on behalf of his customer, collects cheques on
his behalf and makes payment of various dues of his customers, e.g.. insurance premium, etc.