Tesla Final Project
Tesla Final Project
Tesla Final Project
Tesla
Final Project
Justine Fournier
ECO-201
Tesla
With the growing concerns of climate change and renewable energy sources, it comes as
no surprise that Tesla is making strides toward being a champion of renewable energy in an
effort to reduce a reliability on fossil fuels. In order to determine if Tesla has growth potential
in the market it will be necessary to evaluate core microeconomic principals. “Today, however,
there is a growing recognition that achieving security and climate stability will require a massive
development of renewable energy projects” (Sterzinger, 2007 P.82). Tesla’s innovations will be
analyzed in this paper in order to identify the current trends in demand as well as the price
elasticity of demand and how they effect the supply and demand conditions that impact how the
company’s renewable energy revolutions are industrialized. Tesla’s motor vehicle and
renewable energy market structure will be analyzed alongside the costs of production, entry
barriers and market shares. An analysis will be made in order to provide recommendations for a
History
When people think of Tesla, the first person they think of is the company’s fascinating
CEO, Elon Musk. Tesla was founded in 2003 by Martin Eberhard and Marc Tarpenning. The
two American entrepreneurs named their company after the famed inventor Nikola Tesla whose
most notable inventions include the application of electric power (Schreiber & Gregersen, 2014).
The Silicon Valley partners designed their first high performance electric car. The TZero “built
by AC propulsion, could leap from zero to 60 in under 4 seconds” (Baer, 2014). The
entrepreneurs knew they were onto something and began their journey to developing the fastest
electric car ever made. Musk began his relationship with the partners as a financial contributor
In 2008 Tesla released their first flagship sports car. It is considered to be one of the best
innovations of 2008 by Time Magazine. “Electric cars were always environmentally friendly,
quiet, clean — but definitely not sexy. The Tesla Roadster has changed all that. A battery-
powered sports car that sells for $100,000 and has a top speed of 125 m.p.h. (200 km/h), the
Roadster has excited the clean-tech crowd since it was announced in 2003” (Hamilton, 2008).
Tesla carried their innovations on to the next series of Roadsters that would set them apart from
the rest of the motor industry. They decided to push past sustainable transportation with the
Vehicle Innovations
Tesla currently has 3 vehicles in production, all of which boast the newest self-driving
technology. “Self-driving vehicles will play a crucial role in improving transportation safety and
accelerating the world’s transition to a sustainable future. Full autonomy will enable a Tesla to
be substantially safer than a human driver, lower the financial cost of transportation for those
who own a car and provide low-cost on-demand mobility for those who do not” (All Tesla Cars
Being Produced Now Have Full Self-Driving Hardware, 2016). The Model S is a sedan,
designed to be the “safest, most exhilarating sedan on the road” (Model S, n.d.). The Model X is
an SUV designed to be the “most capable sport utility vehicle in history” (Model X, n.d.). The
Model 3 is designed to “combine real world range, performance, safety and spaciousness into a
premium sedan than only Tesla can build. Our most affordable car yet, Model 3 achieves 215
miles of ranger per charge while starting at only $35,000 before incentives” (Accelerating
Operational Innovations
their new mission of sustainable energy, Tesla has to ensure that they are able to keep up with
the demand of lithium ion batteries. In order to do this, Tesla partnered with Panasonic and
broke ground in 2014 on a Gigafactory in Nevada, “By 2018, the Gigafactory will reach full
capacity and produce more lithium ion batteries annually than were produced worldwide in
Tesla has several products in the works to move forward with their sustainable energy
initiative. Such innovations include “Tesla’s plans for total clean energy integration – a one-step
carbon reduction process that involves pairing solar panels with [your] Tesla electric vehicle
(Richardson, 2016). Combining the work force of the newly acquired SolarCity and the
efficiency of Panasonics made shingles and tiles, Tesla’s plans for a durable and attractive
alternative to bulky solar panels further drives their enterprise (Richardson, 2016). The roof tile
technology is easily paired with Tesla’s Powerwall 2.0, a solution for solar storage for both
The demand for renewable energy continues to be a growing concern for many
Americans as well as citizens around the globe. Perhaps the easiest lifestyle change a person can
make toward becoming less dependent on fossil fuels is to purchase a hybrid or electric car.
“Production of these fossil fuels is expected to rise, approximately doubling the amount of use of
each fossil fuel. As world population continues to grow and the limited amount of fossil fuels
begin to diminish, it may not be possible to provide the amount of energy demanded by the
world by only using fossil fuels to convert energy” (Riddell, n.d.). It is necessary to analyze the
supply and demand trends in order to fully comprehend how Tesla can maintain success in an
RENEWABLE ENERGY MARKET ANALYSIS 5
ever evolving automobile industry. Using the price of elasticity of demand, we can evaluate
Tesla’s pricing and revenue trends to evaluate their impact on consumer responsiveness.
In the graph below we see that Tesla has experienced a steady growth in sales in the last
five years.
Figure 1. Tesla’s Revenue and Cost of Goods Sold (COGS incl. D&A) data for the past 5-years.
Adapted from TSLA Annual Income Statement – Tesla Motors Inc. Annual Financials. (n.d.).
The graph shows that Tesla’s initial entry into the market was not profitable as their
operating costs broke even with their sales. However, their sales trend over the following years
shows an increased profit. The increased sales show a correlation with the market demand for
electric vehicles. “The overall global market saw a growth rate of ~76%, - with overall EV
registrations rising around 2-fold a year between 2012 and 2014” (Ayre, 2015). Tesla’s launch
of the more affordable Model 3 provides an insight to the demand for electric vehicles. Since
the Model 3 is in its development stages, customers are only able to put a down payment of
vehicles for its 2018 release. “Within days of launch about 400,000 people paid $1000 each for
RENEWABLE ENERGY MARKET ANALYSIS 6
a car they will receive in 2018 – In addition to the $400 million wired to Tesla, this represents an
With the advancement of technology, the motor industry is poised to have a significant
effect on the demand for renewable energy. “Existing Lithium-oxygen batteries draw in air to
ever needing to let oxygen to return to its gaseous form…The end result is faster charging and
more efficient batteries, due to lower heat wastage” (Woods, 2016). As the technology
advances, the availability of resources will make the price of vehicles more elastic over time.
“The prices of EVs will decrease as the technologies involved become mainstream and
economies of scale come into play with higher production numbers” (Pikkarainen, 2016).
Compared to the use of combustion powered vehicles and despite the many advancements
made in the electric vehicle technologies; the purchasing of electric vehicles (EVs) is largely
elastic. “55 percent of electric vehicle buyers are between 36 and 55 years old and nearly 21
percent have an average household income of $175,000 or more” (Gorzelany, 2014). It would
seem that based on the income of EV consumers, Tesla vehicles are more elastic. This illustrates
the determinant of luxury vs. necessity. The determinant of share of budget is also illustrated by
the average household income. Here we know that the cost of an EV will have a significant
Based on the mass availability of new and used combustion vehicles readily available, the
illustrates the elasticity of EVs. As mentioned earlier, the more time that passes the less
expensive the technology becomes. This means that EVs will become less expensive to
RENEWABLE ENERGY MARKET ANALYSIS 7
purchase, thus illustrating the determinant of the passage of time. Finally, we look at the
determinant of the definition of the market. 2016 brought 8 new electric vehicles including the
BMW i3, Fiat 500e, Ford Focus Electric, Nissan Leaf, Volkswagen e-Golf, Chevrolet Spark EV,
Smart Fortwo Electric Drive and Mitsubishi i-MiEV (8 Cheapest Electric Cars, n.d.). The
determinant of the definition of the market further illustrates its elasticity as there are a wide
variety of options in the market. The pricing of each of the above models comes in just under
The Model 3 has been Tesla’s primary model. It experienced a significant price decrease
between 2012 and 2015. The correlation between the drop in price of this model in relation to
the rise in sales revenue show the vehicles have become more elastic to Tesla’s customers. See
the following graph to illustrate the relationship between the price change in the Model 3 and
Figure 2. Tesla Model Price vs Sales Revenue. Adapted from TSLA Annual Income Statement –
have-changed-over-time-photos-2016-9/#tesla-garnered-a-lot-of-attention-in-2008-when-it-
released-its-very-first-electric-car--the-wildly-sexy-tesla-roadster-1.
Cost of Production
Over time, there are various costs of production that Tesla incurs that impact their
profitability. Three of the discretionary fixed costs of production that have a major impact on
Tesla’s profitability are Research and Development and Selling, General and Administrative.
Research and development costs have also seen over a 50% increase (Tesla Company Financials,
2017). Given Tesla’s recent ventures into alternative energy sources for the home in conjunction
with the vehicle, it is logical to acknowledge that the R&D costs would increase as the company
expands into new enterprises. Finally, Tesla’s Sales, General and Administration costs have also
seen similar increases, congruent with the company’s increase in revenues (2017). Despite the
increasing costs, Tesla’s has experienced a great increase in sales, which has offset the
aforementioned costs. Since fixed costs don’t change with the Tesla’s output, then these costs
Tesla’s committed fixed costs include rent, insurance and property taxes. These costs are
generally not effected by sales. However, the Gigafactory operations plant building construction
project is a result of increased future sales. Other property locations include California, the
Netherlands, the UK and China, totaling over 6.5 million square feet of property (Kimyes,
2016). The variable costs associated with the cost of production include cost of revenue, labor,
RENEWABLE ENERGY MARKET ANALYSIS 9
materials and shipping costs. The costs are connected to sales and will fluctuate as sales do.
Since Tesla’s sales have been steadily increasing overtime, so too have the variable costs. The
costs of revenues, or cost of sales have also experienced growth the past 5 years, steady with
over 50% increases (Tesla Company Financials, 2017). Since variable costs depend on a
planned level of output, Tesla relies on expected sales in order to budget for these costs. Both
the fixed and variable costs effect short run decisions, while only variable costs effect long run
decisions.
Despite Tesla’s increased revenues, they have not yet begun to experience
growing its customer base and product development. “Tesla badly needed this positive outcome
after 13 quarters of unprofitable results to reassure investors… keeping the Model 3 on schedule
could be a precursor to even better days ahead” (Glinton, 2016). Tesla was finally able to report
a profitability after the 2016 third quarter. “The Tesla third quarter results reflect strong
Overall Market
In the electric car market as of March 2016, Tesla takes 30% of the overall share. With
the market consideration of preorders for Tesla models, the company has overcome the expected
sales of all other competitors (Shahan, 2016). “Tesla is, of course, growing fast and is clearly
production constrained, with thousands or tens of thousands of people in line for the Tesla
Model X, and hundreds of thousands for the Tesla Model 3. It is in the lead in many respects,
and it seems like no one is eager to really bring competitive products to give Tesla a run for its
Figure 3. Tesla Market Share Adapted from Tesla Takes 30% Of US Electric Car Market In
March, Brings In 30x More Model 3 Reservations Than Entire US Electric Car Market TSLA
electric-car-market-in-march-brings-in-30x-more-model-3-reservations-than-entire-us-electric-
car-market/
In the overall automotive market, Tesla holds a much lower market share among its
competitors. The market shares of electric vehicles take up only 1% of the overall market. “US
electric car sales continue to climb to new heights in 2017. Growing 59% year over year
(YoY), approximately 12,000 electric cars were sold across the country in January, accounting
for approximately 1% of US auto sales” (Electric Car Sales, 2017). Since Tesla only
RENEWABLE ENERGY MARKET ANALYSIS 11
manufactures plug in electric vehicles, Tesla’s total market share is much lower than its
Figure 4. U.S. Vehicle Sales Market Share by Company, 1961-2016 (February 6, 2016)
2014
One of the prime barriers of entry into the electric vehicle market is cost. There are very
high costs associated with developing a vehicle that can compete against some of the more
successful incumbents in the industry. Barriers aren’t limited to new car companies; they can
also include existing car companies trying to introduce a new model. “The higher the capital
requirements, the higher the barriers to entry…When there are high barriers to entry, then you
don’t see new entrants, and you don’t see innovation. It’s really that new entrants are what
drives innovation” (Stringham et al, 2015). Upon entry, Tesla was a new entrant with
innovations that had not yet been seen in the market. With their unique revolutions on
alternative renewable energy solutions, they stand apart from other automakers in the industry.
In order to stay current and avoid technology becoming obsolete, Tesla must continue to
innovate. Technology obsolescence is another barrier to market entry. “Not only are the car
making giants fighting for leadership in this strategically-crucial area, but so are the technically-
RENEWABLE ENERGY MARKET ANALYSIS 12
savvy and automotive-oriented nations of the US, Germany and Japan” (Nathan, 2014). As fossil
fuel powered vehicles dominate the automotive industry, electronic technology has yet to be
perfected to a point where it can compete with the incumbent technology in terms of distance
and longevity. It is the fear of obsolescence by consumers that make technological innovations
crucial to market entry. Patents for new technology therefore become yet another barrier to the
market. “Patents serve to act as legal barriers to entry against other potential firms who may
want to enter the industry and protect the market power of the incumbent. In this case, the
patented technology gave Tesla Motors Inc. a huge edge in the electric car industry with close to
An example of a failed entrant into the electric vehicle market is Fisker automotive.
There were many factors that influenced the failure of the Fisker Karma. Since the Department
of Energy set up a fund dedicated toward clean energy vehicle production, Fisker applied for a
$169 million loan and were eventually granted $529 million in order to expedite vehicle
production. The only vehicle to be designed by Fisker, the Karma, was introduced in 2008 with
a starting order price of $100,000 per car. The company only ever produced and delivered 2,000
vehicles, which had all missed the deadline set by the DOE. Straight off, the vehicles had
software and component flaws that lead to expensive and complicated repairs. After the DOE
pulled funding due to internal auditing on other unrelated funded projects, Fisker quickly ran out
of capital (Bennett, 2013). Other factors that lead to the failure of Fisker include the actual cost
vs. sales of the Karma. “Fisker spent a stunning $900,000 for each vehicle it produced… Then
they sold them to dealers for an invoice price of just $70,000” (Koetsier, 2013). Because of the
large scale of design flaws and the DOE’s flawed underwriting process, Fisker declared
bankruptcy in 2013.
RENEWABLE ENERGY MARKET ANALYSIS 13
The electric car market is an oligopoly market as there are very few global competitors,
the ease of entry into the market is low and the market competition manufactures electric cars.
In order to confirm that the electric automotive industry is an oligopoly, we must calculate what
percentage their share makes up in the market. Tesla’s 4 top competitors are Chevy (GM),
Nissan, Ford and BMW. Using the data displayed earlier in figure 3 we can demonstrate that the
top 5 competitors make up 84% of the market. Chevy(GM) makes up 19% of the PEV market.
Nissan makes up 11% of the market. Ford makes up 18% of the market while BMW makes up
7%. Because Tesla seems to be dominating the electric vehicle market at roughly 30% market
share, and given the markets low ease of entry, potential for competition is limited. Due to the
ownership of patent technology and a necessity of innovation for entry into the market, the
Recommendation
It may not seem like EVs will ever be inelastic as long as there are combustion vehicles
available. In order for Tesla to continue their trend of success they will need to stand out among
the rest of the EV manufacturers. Increasing the price of their vehicles may result in a decline of
sales. Providing more cost efficient vehicles is an obvious solution to being more successful and
conjunction with a Tesla model, as described in the history section above, should continue to be
researched and developed in order to stay ahead of the technology curve. As shown in figure 2,
Tesla’s decrease in price has shown a direct correlation with the increase in revenues. It is
therefore recommended that Tesla control costs in order to keep low prices and promote
increased revenues.
RENEWABLE ENERGY MARKET ANALYSIS 14
In order to maintain its domineering presence in the electric vehicle market, Tesla will
need to continue to provide new and innovative technology to stay ahead of the rest of its
competitors in the market. With their proven ability to patent technology and introduce
revolutions in the renewable energy market, Tesla should be able to take advantage of its unique
position in the market. In order to control the cost of production, Tesla’s gigafactory should be
able to meet the growing demand for alternative energy. Since the gigafactory is still in
production, it will be necessary to evaluate how the in house production of batteries will effect
Tesla’s overall production costs in comparison to their revenues. With Tesla’s partnership with
Panasonics and their patented lithium ion battery, Tesla is poised to maintain market dominance
with its integration to home energy solutions. In order to maintain consumer favorability, the
References
http://www.autobytel.com/hybrid-cars/car-buying-guides/8-cheapest-electric-cars-
127654/
https://www.tesla.com/model3
All Tesla Cars Being Produced Now Have Full Self-Driving Hardware. (2016, November 30).
produced-now-have-full-self-driving-hardware
Ayre, J. (2015, March 31). Electric Car Demand Growing, Global Market Hits 740,000 Units.
growing-global-market-hits-740000-units/
Baer, D. (2014, November 11). The Making Of Tesla: Invention, Betrayal, And The Birth Of
the-origin-story-2014-10
Bennett, Dashiell, (April 24, 2013) The Real Lesson of Fisker Auto’s Failure, Retrieved
automotive-failure/315946/
Cava, M. D. (2016, November 18). Tesla shareholders approve deal to buy SolarCity. Retrieved
solarcity-deal-xxxx/94020994/
Ding, Jerry, (June 14, 2014) Tesla’s Contrarian Economics, Retrieved February 4, 2017 from
https://worldetude.wordpress.com/2014/06/14/teslas-contrarian-economics/
RENEWABLE ENERGY MARKET ANALYSIS 16
Electric Car Sales (Monthly Reports). (2017, February 04). Retrieved February 19, 2017, from
http://evobsession.com/electric-car-sales/
Glinton, S. (2016, October 26). Tesla Surprise: It's A Profit. Retrieved February 19, 2017, from
http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/10/26/499525293/tesla-surprise-its-a-
profit
Gorzelany, J. (2014, April 24). Electric-Car Buyers Younger And Richer Than Hybrid Owners.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/jimgorzelany/2014/04/22/electric-car-buyers-younger-and-
richer-than-hybrid-owners/#26616911ad32
Hamilton, A. (2008, October 29). Best Inventions of 2008. Retrieved January 12, 2017, from
http://content.time.com/time/specials/packages/article/0,28804,1852747_1854195,00.htm
Koetsier, John, (April 17, 2013) The sad long story of Fisker Automotive, ‘the largest VC-
http://venturebeat.com/2013/04/17/the-sad-long-story-of-fisker-automotive-the-most-
tragic-vc-backed-debacle-in-recent-history/
Muoio, D. (2016, September 12). Here's how Tesla's cars have changed over the years. Retrieved
over-time-photos-2016-9/#there-are-also-reports-that-tesla-is-working-on-an-electric-
truck-and-another-suv-that-would-be-dubbed-model-y-10
RENEWABLE ENERGY MARKET ANALYSIS 17
Muoio, D. (2016, October 31). Tesla just unveiled its new at-home battery — here's what you
panel-roof-the-next-solar-shingles/
Musk, E., & Wheeler, J. (2016, September 30). Tesla Third Quarter 2016 Update [PDF]. Tesla
4CW8X0/3099703499x0x913801/F9E5C36A-AFDD-4FF2-A375-
ED9B0F912622/Q3_16_Update_Letter_-_final.pdf
Nathan, Stuart, (March 17th, 2014) Barriers to electric car uptake, Retrieved February 4, 2017
from https://www.theengineer.co.uk/issues/march-2014-online/barriers-to-electric-car-
uptake/
Pikkarainen, J. (2016, November 6). What Tesla’s new Gigafactory means for electric vehicles.
gigafactory-means-for-electric-vehicles/
Richardson, L. (2016, December 14). Tesla’s Solar Panel Roof: Solar Glass Tiles are the New
panel-roof-the-next-solar-shingles/
Riddell, A., Ronson, S., Counts, G., & Spenser, K. (n.d.). Towards Sustainable Energy: The
current Fossil Fuel problem and the prospects of Geothermal and Nuclear power.
https://web.stanford.edu/class/e297c/trade_environment/energy/hfossil.html
Schreiber, B. A., & Gregersen, E. (2014, September 10). Tesla Motors. Retrieved January 12,
Shahan, Zachary, Tesla Takes 30% of US Electric Car Market in March, Retrieved February 4,
market-in-march-brings-in-30x-more-model-3-reservations-than-entire-us-electric-car-
market/
Sterzinger, G. (2007). The Economic Promise Of Renewable Energy. New Labor Forum, 16(3),
80-91. doi:10.1080/10957960701636695
Stringham, E.P., Miller, J.K, Clark, J.R, Overcoming Barriers to Entry in an Established
Industry: Tesla Motors (December 23, 2015). Retrieved February 4, 2017 from
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/283001846_Overcoming_Barriers_to_Entry_in
_an_Established_Industry_Tesla_Motors
Tesla Company Financials, (2017, February 3). Retrieved February 4, 2017 from
http://www.nasdaq.com/symbol/tsla/financials?query=income-statement
Tesla Motors Inc. (2017, January 28). Retrieved January 28, 2017, from
http://www.marketwatch.com/investing/stock/tsla/financials
Tesla Motors, Inc; Fixed costs and variable costs, (2016, February 2). Retrieved February 4,
U.S. Vehicle Sales Market Share by Company, 1961-2016. (2016, February 6). Retrieved
company-1961-2014
Woods, B. (2016, July 25). Breakthrough battery tech could make electric cars more efficient.
could-make-electric-cars-way-more-efficient
RENEWABLE ENERGY MARKET ANALYSIS 19
Yadigaroglu, I. (2016, June 1). The trends driving electric vehicle development. Retrieved