Susan (on hiatus)'s Reviews > A Flicker in the Dark

A Flicker in the Dark by Stacy Willingham
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
78596144
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: net-galley, mcmillan, from-publisher

Where’s My Lighter?

Have you ever been to a concert where everyone has their lighters raised but you?

Do they even do that anymore? I digress, but the book title brings back memories of a different kind.

This one is receiving rave reviews but I’m so sure...

I was a little bored in the beginning before the book picked up at around the fifty percent mark. And while others loved the prose, there was a little too much inner hand wringing by the main character for my taste.

However, I loved the premise and overall idea.

Chloe as the daughter of a convicted serial killer has her life on track (sort of) and is a practicing psychologist engaged to a handsome professional. She’s grown up since her father landed in prison twenty years ago.

But, as we know, there’s no Happily Ever After in thrillers without hurdles to jump. Chloe’s past returns to haunt her as copycat disappearances and murders begin plaguing her small hometown again.

I thought this was an intriguing Who is Doing it, and as mentioned, the pace accelerated somewhere around the middle keeping me flipping the pages.

One of my favorite things in thrillers are scandalous characters. The more lurid the better if they’re written with humor or tongue in cheek.

When they’re not, and I’m asked to take them seriously without a realistic approach being adopted, the book loses panache for me. I feel that happened here which is partly why I didn’t rate it higher.

3.5 Stars rounded up.

Many readers loved this and I think I may be in the minority so I hope it’s a hit for you.

Thank you to Macmillan and Minotaur Books, the author, and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this!
95 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read A Flicker in the Dark.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 17, 2021 – Shelved
September 9, 2021 – Started Reading
September 14, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 50 (50 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Jayme Sorry you didn’t enjoy it more and hope you love your next! Terrific review!! ❤️


Susan  (on hiatus) Jayme wrote: "Sorry you didn’t enjoy it more and hope you love your next! Terrific review!! ❤️"

Thank you Jayme!


Michael David (on hiatus) Great review, Susan! Rounding up seems generous in your case.


Susan  (on hiatus) Michael wrote: "Great review, Susan! Rounding up seems generous in your case."

Thank you Michael, I think you're right.


message 5: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Great review, Susan! I found your thoughts very useful! I have this on my tbr, but may adjust my expectations just a bit going in. :)


Lori (on hiatus, life is crazy busy)) Great review Susan! I hope your next read is exceptional!


Susan  (on hiatus) Yun wrote: "Great review, Susan! I found your thoughts very useful! I have this on my tbr, but may adjust my expectations just a bit going in. :)"

You may love it. Sometimes, I hesitate being less than positive in case I turn off someone who may see things a different way. Thank you for your thoughts Yun!


Susan  (on hiatus) Lori wrote: "Great review Susan! I hope your next read is exceptional!"

Thank you Lori!


MarilynW Wonderful review, Susan! I'll be starting this one in a couple of days 🥰


message 10: by Jen (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jen It's cell phones with their flashlights on now Susan, believe it or not!

I also ended up in the 3.5 rounded up camp for this one, though for different reasons. But I definitely understand yours as well, and why you felt the way you did. Hope the next one is a hit for you!


Susan  (on hiatus) Jen wrote: "It's cell phones with their flashlights on now Susan, believe it or not!

I also ended up in the 3.5 rounded up camp for this one, though for different reasons. But I definitely understand yours a..."


Thank you Jen, that shows you how long it's been since I've been to a concert. On my way to look for your review - I'm interested to see what you think.


message 12: by Pat (new) - rated it 4 stars

Pat Great and honest review Susan! I also hate inner hand wringing. I hate the whole guilt trip thing where people cling to their guilt like a comfort blanket even when they could not possibly be held responsible for whatever it is! 🥰


Ceecee Very good review Susan and really honest. 💖


message 14: by Maureen (new)

Maureen Great review Susan, fair and honest!


Holly  B (slower pace!) I don't feel like this one would be for me. A fair and helpful review Susan! hope your next is a 5 star!


message 16: by Catherine (last edited Sep 18, 2021 05:53AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Catherine (alternativelytitledbooks) - so very behind! Great review Susan! I’m interested to see which side of the fence I’ll land on with this one!


message 17: by Susan (on hiatus) (last edited Sep 18, 2021 06:11AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Susan  (on hiatus) Pat wrote: "Great and honest review Susan! I also hate inner hand wringing. I hate the whole guilt trip thing where people cling to their guilt like a comfort blanket even when they could not possibly be held ..."

Thank you and I agree! It's one of those where some readers loved the writing style, but I thought "Too much inner dialogue".🌺


message 18: by Susan (on hiatus) (last edited Sep 18, 2021 06:11AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Susan  (on hiatus) Catherine wrote: "Great review Susan! I’m interested to see which side of the fence I’ll land on with this one!"

It's interesting how differently we all react to the same book. Thank you Catherine!🌺


message 19: by Canadian Jen (new)

Canadian Jen A fair review, Susan. Hopefully the next one will give you a flicker of joy :)


message 20: by Susan (on hiatus) (last edited Sep 18, 2021 06:11AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Susan  (on hiatus) Holly wrote: "I don't feel like this one would be for me. A fair and helpful review Susan! hope your next is a 5 star!"

Thank you Holly. I had a fair bit of luck with five star reads, but it's been a while...🌺


message 21: by Susan (on hiatus) (last edited Sep 18, 2021 06:11AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Susan  (on hiatus) Maureen wrote: "Great review Susan, fair and honest!"

Thank you Maureen!🌺


Susan  (on hiatus) Ceecee wrote: "Very good review Susan and really honest. 💖"

Thank you Ceecee! At times I gloss things over, but I somehow couldn't this time. I was generous with the rating though.😸🥰


Tina I enjoy the true and honest opinions of a book so much! Another good review Susan!


JaymeO Great review, Susan! I’m looking forward to reading this one!


message 25: by L.A. (new) - rated it 4 stars

L.A. Excellent honest review, Susan! I miss the lighters😂


message 26: by Jasmine (new) - added it

Jasmine Great review, Susan!


Susan  (on hiatus) Tina wrote: "I enjoy the true and honest opinions of a book so much! Another good review Susan!"

Thank you so much Tina - I was wondering if I was a bit harsh but compared to another book I was reading simultaneously, I enjoyed the other one more even though it had overall ratitngs.🌺


Susan  (on hiatus) Jasmine wrote: "Great review, Susan!"
Thank you Jasmine 🌺


Susan  (on hiatus) L.A. wrote: "Excellent honest review, Susan! I miss the lighters😂"

It's been a long while lol. Thank you L.A.!🌺


Susan  (on hiatus) JaymeO wrote: "Great review, Susan! I’m looking forward to reading this one!"

I hope you like it JaymeO, many people did!🌺


message 31: by Sue (new)

Sue Gerhardt Griffiths Great review, Susan! 'Scandalous characters', I'm in 😅


Kat Wonderful review, Susan! I'll keep all your observations in mind when I read this!


Kaceey Fabulous review Susan! Scandalous characters definitely make a thriller thrilling!🤣💖


message 34: by Colleen (new) - added it

Colleen Scidmore Great review! I also love scandalous characters..they make stories more fun!


Susanne Nice review Susan! Sounds good


Meredith (Trying to catch up!) Sorry this didn't work for you, Susan. I am glad it got better for you, but I understand why you didn't love it. I hope you love your next thriller!


Melissa (Always Behind) Wonderful review, I need to get to this one. You make some very good points about its shortcomings.


ReadAlongWithSue recovering from a stroke★⋆. ࿐࿔ I’ve seen this one around. I’m tempted. But with those shortfalls I’m concerned I’d feel like you. Great review!


Susan  (on hiatus) Susanne wrote: "Nice review Susan! Sounds good"

Colleen (Colleensreadingadventures) wrote: "Great review! I also love scandalous characters..they make stories more fun!"

Kaceey wrote: "Fabulous review Susan! Scandalous characters definitely make a thriller thrilling!🤣💖"

Kat wrote: "Wonderful review, Susan! I'll keep all your observations in mind when I read this!"

Sue wrote: "Great review, Susan! 'Scandalous characters', I'm in 😅"

Thank you Sue, Kat, Kaceey, Colleen, and Susanne! I didn't see your comments until now but I appreciate your support all the same. Much thanks!🌻😸🥰


Susan  (on hiatus) Meredith wrote: "Sorry this didn't work for you, Susan. I am glad it got better for you, but I understand why you didn't love it. I hope you love your next thriller!"

Thank you Meredith!🌺


Susan  (on hiatus) Melissa (LifeFullyBooked) wrote: "Wonderful review, I need to get to this one. You make some very good points about its shortcomings."

I hope you like it, thank you Melissa!🌺


Susan  (on hiatus) Sue wrote: "I’ve seen this one around. I’m tempted. But with those shortfalls I’m concerned I’d feel like you. Great review!"

Thank you Sue!🌺


Melissa ~ Bantering Books Ha! They use the flashlights on cell phones at concerts now, Susan. And I still don't ever turn mine on. :) Great review too! :)


Susan  (on hiatus) Melissa wrote: "Ha! They use the flashlights on cell phones at concerts now, Susan. And I still don't ever turn mine on. :) Great review too! :)"

Thank you Melissa! I have such great memories of those old concerts lol!


Emilie Agree with this review 100%!!


Margaret M - (having a challenging time and on GR as much as I can) Excellent review Susan. Happy New Year


DeAnn I found the first half slow too Susan! Great review!


Susan  (on hiatus) Emilie wrote: "Agree with this review 100%!!"

Thank you Emilie!


Susan  (on hiatus) Margaret wrote: "Excellent review Susan. Happy New Year"

Thank you Margaret, Happy New Year to you too!


Susan  (on hiatus) DeAnn wrote: "I found the first half slow too Susan! Great review!"

Thank you DeAnn, I was trying to like it but...


back to top