Kristin (KC)'s Reviews > Don't Believe It

Don't Believe It by Charlie Donlea
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4971692
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: mystery, thriller
Read 2 times. Last read May 21, 2018 to May 24, 2018.

*4 Stars* for shock-value

Well, that was a fun and twisty little shocker of a read!


I have to admit, after not entirely loving this author’s previous novel, The Girl Who Was Taken, I went into this one a bit unsure of what to expect.

However, this book proves that each novel an author produces should be treated as an isolated body of work, because there were so many elements of this book that completely blew me away!

Don’t Believe It presents a layered story with exhilarating turns that keep the reader second guessing, as a good mystery should. But it doesn't stop at one—the twists keep coming—like the waves of an ocean, and every time you think you’ve got it figured out you're knocked back off your feet again.

This story is constructed in a true crime documentary fashion that is being filmed in real-time. We follow the producer as she sells the show, the crime her show will feature, the convict who claims she’s been wrongfully accused, along with all the interviews and flashbacks in-between as this murder-mystery unfolds.

For me, this author’s core strength lies in his plot design, scattering clues with subtle but distinct indications as he masterfully leads the reader in all the wrong directions. The reveals are shocking and tremendous, but the groundwork applied beforehand will fully back them up.

The various characters are intriguing, sheltering side stories that branch away from the main focus only to gradually manifest into something deeper.

Although I appreciate that this book really delves into the behind-the-scenes politics of making documentaries, some of it grew tedious and caused certain areas to drag. I wanted more focus on the characters themselves, and less inconsequential narrative. But the shocking twists and turns were worth the wait.

If, like me, you are a fan of the hit true-crime documentary Making a Murderer, along with the Serial podcast, and would like see how investigating such a case would play out in fiction, I’d suggest giving this one a go!

*Traveling Sister read! Thanks, ladies :-)

*Arc kindly provided via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review*
202 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Don't Believe It.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
May 9, 2018 – Shelved as: to-read
May 9, 2018 – Shelved
May 21, 2018 – Started Reading
May 24, 2018 –
78.0% "Love when the last quarter of book heats up like this!"
May 24, 2018 – Shelved as: mystery
May 24, 2018 – Shelved as: thriller
May 24, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 56 (56 new)


Patty ~ Wrapped Up In Reading Book Blog Hope it's a good one! 💖💖💖


Kristin (KC) Patty Belongs To Kellan~Jesse~Lautner~Miller~Jack~Racer~Rafe~Liam~Prince Nicholas~Hayes~Simon~Gianluca & Archer wrote: "Hope it's a good one! 💖💖💖"

So far, so good, patty! ☺️


Norma I finished yesterday & I’m really excited to hear what you thought of it! 💕


Kristin (KC) Norma * Traveling Sister wrote: "I finished yesterday & I’m really excited to hear what you thought of it! 💕"

Oh, I hope you enjoyed! I’m almost at the halfway mark—been reading this in bits and pieces, which I hate doing—but so far it’s really good!


Meredith (Trying to catch up!) Glad you enjoyed this too! Wonderful review, Kristin!


Norma So glad that you enjoyed it Kris & wonderful review! Loved reading this one with you!


Kendall Wonderful review KC!! I loved it too 😊❤️


message 8: by Canadian Jen (new)

Canadian Jen Terrific review!


Sarah Joint Loved reading this one with you and love your review!


Kristin (KC) Meredith wrote: "Glad you enjoyed this too! Wonderful review, Kristin!"
****Thanks, Meredith! :-)

Norma * Traveling Sister wrote: "So glad that you enjoyed it Kris & wonderful review! Loved reading this one with you!"
****thanks, Norma! I loved reading with you, as well! Glad you enjoyed :-)

Kendall wrote: "Wonderful review KC!! I loved it too 😊❤️"
****Yeah, so glad u loved! Thanks, Kendie :-)

Jen wrote: "Terrific review!"
****Thanks so much, Jen!

Sarah wrote: "Loved reading this one with you and love your review!"
****Thank u, Sarah! Loved reading this w u, too :-)


Julie Fantastic review, Kristin!! I love shocking conclusions!!


message 12: by JanB (new)

JanB Great review Kristin, glad this was such a terrific sister read!


Melisa Yeah, Kris! Love your review👏👏👏


Holly  B (slower pace!) Great review Kris!


message 15: by Kristin (KC) (last edited May 25, 2018 07:25AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Kristin (KC) Julie wrote: "Fantastic review, Kristin!! I love shocking conclusions!!"

***Thanks, Julie! Same here :-)

JanB wrote: "Great review Kristin, glad this was such a terrific sister read!"

***Thanks, Jan! Everyone enjoyed :)

Melisa wrote: "Yeah, Kris! Love your review👏👏👏"

***Haha, thanks, Melis! <3

Holly wrote: "Great review Kris!"

***Thanks so much, Holly! :D


Marialyce Glad this was a good one even if it did drag a bit., Kristin.


message 17: by Natalie (new)

Natalie Great review Kris!


Kristin (KC) Marialyce wrote: "Glad this was a good one even if it did drag a bit., Kristin."

***Thanks, Marialyce! The twists were great :-)

Natalie wrote: "Great review Kris!"

***Thanks, Nat! 😊


Mackey Terrific, well written review. I completely agree about each book being judged on its own merit. Every author has their ups and downs and some books are amazing, some... not so much.


message 20: by Mary Beth (new)

Mary Beth Great review, Kris! Enjoyed reading this with you.


message 21: by Melissa (new)

Melissa Ooooh . . . intriguing review, Kris! I myself am a Serial junkie (when are we getting a third season?!) and was obsessed with Making a Murderer, so I'm definitely going to have to consider this one. I should have gotten my stuff together and read it with the sisters. Hahahahaha. 🤣


Mackenzie - PhDiva Books Love the review, Kristin!!! I had so much fun on our first sister read together :) I can't wait for more!


Kristin (KC) Mackey wrote: "Terrific, well written review. I completely agree about each book being judged on its own merit. Every author has their ups and downs and some books are amazing, some... not so much."

***It’s so true! Thanks, Mackey :-)

Mary Beth *Traveling Sister* wrote: "Great review, Kris! Enjoyed reading this with you."

***Same here, Mary! 😊

Melissa wrote: "Ooooh . . . intriguing review, Kris! I myself am a Serial junkie (when are we getting a third season?!) and was obsessed with Making a Murderer, so I'm definitely going to have to consider this one..."

***Ohh, a fellow Serial and MaM fan! I was hooked on both. Looking forward to the next season of MaM, as well. I think you might enjoy this. For me it was all about the twists and delivery. I’ll be curious to see what you think 😊

Mackenzie - Traveling Sister wrote: "Love the review, Kristin!!! I had so much fun on our first sister read together :) I can't wait for more!"

***Me, too, Kenzie! Lots of good conversation :-)


message 24: by Jaline (new) - added it

Jaline I loved your review, Kristin!! This sounds very intriguing to me. :)


Kaceey Fantastic review Kristin! Loved this one too!😊


Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader I loved your review, Kris, and I loved reading and discussing with you!


Kristin (KC) Jaline wrote: "I loved your review, Kristin!! This sounds very intriguing to me. :)"

***Thanks, Jaline! It was definitely a twisty journey!

Kaceey wrote: "Fantastic review Kristin! Loved this one too!😊"
***Thanks, Kaceey! So glad you loved :)

Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader & Traveling Sister wrote: "I loved your review, Kris, and I loved reading and discussing with you!"

***Same here, Jennifer! Was a fun sister read :-)


message 28: by Tina (new)

Tina Glad it turned out so well. Great review Kristin!


Joanna Elm This one already on my TBR list, Kristin. Your review makes me want to read it asap!


Kristin (KC) Tina wrote: "Glad it turned out so well. Great review Kristin!"

***Thanks so much, Tina! 😊

Joanna wrote: "This one already on my TBR list, Kristin. Your review makes me want to read it asap!"

***It’s a very twisty, shocker of a read, Joanna! Hope you enjoy when you get to it 🤗


message 31: by Diane S ☔ (new) - added it

Diane S ☔ Terrific review, Kristin. I liked this better than his first too.


Kristin (KC) Diane S ☔ wrote: "Terrific review, Kristin. I liked this better than his first too."

Thanks, Diane! Maybe they’ll just keep getting better! 🤞🏻


message 33: by Victoria (new) - added it

Victoria Plot design is where so many thrillers fail for me, after so many accolades you finally got me to hit To Read with this review! I feel like a judge on The Voice. 🤩


Kristin (KC) Victoria wrote: "Plot design is where so many thrillers fail for me, after so many accolades you finally got me to hit To Read with this review! I feel like a judge on The Voice. 🤩"

That made me laugh out loud, Victoria! 😂 The struggle is real for the *judgers* of books! I really hope you’ll enjoy this one. As I mentioned in my review, there were areas of monotony where I was tempted to skim—but the twists were executed to perfection. No holes, no slips—tight and well-done! I look forward to your thoughts if you get to this one :)


message 35: by Candace (new) - added it

Candace Excellent review, Kristin! My public library has it in processing. I'll read it later in the year.


Kristin (KC) Candace wrote: "Excellent review, Kristin! My public library has it in processing. I'll read it later in the year."

Thanks, Candace—I hope you enjoy, when u get to it! Definitely has some crazy twisty 😊


message 37: by KAS (new)

KAS Fantastic review, Kristin! Glad you really enjoyed ;) xox


Susanne Great review Ms. Kris! Glad you liked this - wishing I had read it with you all!!


Kristin (KC) KAS wrote: "Fantastic review, Kristin! Glad you really enjoyed ;) xox"

***Thanks so much, Kas! 😊

Susanne wrote: "Great review Ms. Kris! Glad you liked this - wishing I had read it with you all!!"

***Me too, Suze! Would have enjoyed hearing your thoughts on this one :-)


Larry H Terrific review, Kristin! I finished this last night--I loved it a bit more than you, but I totally agree with the points you've made.


message 41: by Kristin (KC) (last edited May 28, 2018 03:52PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Kristin (KC) Larry wrote: "Terrific review, Kristin! I finished this last night--I loved it a bit more than you, but I totally agree with the points you've made."

Thanks, Larry! I’m so glad you loved this one and I’ll have to go read your review :D


Brenda ~The Book Witch Excellent review, Kristin! I loved our discussion on this one!


message 43: by Svetlana (new)

Svetlana fantastic review Kristin! I really enjoyed reading your review! 👌🏽👌🏽


message 44: by Kristin (KC) (last edited May 29, 2018 01:42PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Kristin (KC) Brenda - Traveling Sister wrote: "Excellent review, Kristin! I loved our discussion on this one!"

***Me too, Bren! Loved all of our theories and moments of “shock”! (Although some knew what was happening early in)

Svetlana wrote: "fantastic review Kristin! I really enjoyed reading your review! 👌🏽👌🏽"

***Thanks so much, Svetlana! ❤️☺️


message 45: by Christine (new)

Christine Fantastic review!


Kristin (KC) Christine wrote: "Fantastic review!"

Thank you, Christine! This was a unique read :-)


Sherri Thacker Great review. Just started it and hard to put it down


Kristin (KC) Sherri wrote: "Great review. Just started it and hard to put it down"

Get ready for some surprises! ;)


Nazanin Fantastic review, Kristin! Glad you liked it!


message 50: by Kristin (KC) (last edited Jul 18, 2018 07:47AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Kristin (KC) Elyse wrote: "Author has written three books from what I can see have you read all of them or do you know which book most think is a favorite- if I want to try this author? I sometimes like a good quart room dra..."

Hi, Elyse! Sorry, I’m only just now seeing your comment. Don’t worry about typos! ☺️
So I’ve read two by this author—the other one is The Girl Who Was Taken, and I enjoyed Dont Believe It more.

I don’t believe any of them have court room scenes, but they each had their own technical elements.

In “Girl Who Was Missing”, it was in depth forensic science talk—which I found interesting, and in this one here it’s the true crime documentary and all the research that goes into it being played out for us. Which was fun! And then then there’s the twist, which blew me away ;-)


« previous 1
back to top