Emily May's Reviews > Call Me by Your Name
Call Me by Your Name
by
I should probably issue a warning that this is a book I usually wouldn't like. I think. A summer romance up to its neck in purple prose and wandering introspection sounds like a nightmare. And yet, there was something so beautiful, awful, intoxicating and sad about Call Me by Your Name. Maybe I like it because - and I hate to admit this - there is a part of me that recognizes something of myself within it.
Either you have been this kind of person, perhaps still are this kind of person, or you have not, are not, and this book will seem overwritten and alien. I, unfortunately, have experienced that deep, all-encompassing infatuation with another person. I don't personally call it love; not anymore. Instead, it's a feeling of overwhelming, almost feverish, obsession with their existence-- their body, their laugh, and everything they do or say.
I’m not proud of it and I don’t think it’s healthy. But I do think this book captures it in all its intensity and sadness. Call Me by Your Name, for me, stands apart from other romances because it doesn't follow the usual formula of two people meet, cliche flirtations and angst ensue, and then finally they end up together. It's not a spoiler to say this isn't that kind of story; if you're reading it for the warm fuzzies then you're going to be disappointed.
It is about seventeen-year-old Elio, who falls into a deep romantic and sexual obsession with the twenty-four year-old Oliver when the latter becomes a summer guest at Elio's parents' Italian villa. If there was ever a perfect place to set a heady novel of this kind, then it must be the cliffs of the Italian Riviera. I can feel my cold heart melting just thinking about it.
We stay inside Elio's mind as he fantasizes romantically and sexually about Oliver. Aciman builds a novel based on innermost thoughts and the most painful of emotions. It is sometimes almost too much and I wanted to look away as Elio feels like he can’t get close enough; feels like he wants to crawl inside Oliver's skin. It’s an intoxicatingly romantic, intimate, physical, miserable experience.
There is one moment when Elio's wise father comforts him: “Right now there’s sorrow. I don’t envy the pain. But I envy you the pain.” Which I thought was deeply sad, though also perfect. It might not be my usual choice of book, but I think Call Me by Your Name is one that will stay with me. Sometimes it is the exceptions to my rules that I find myself remembering the most.
Blog | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram | Youtube
by
“He came. He left. Nothing else had changed. I had not changed. The world hadn't changed. Yet nothing would be the same. All that remains is dreammaking and strange remembrance.”
I should probably issue a warning that this is a book I usually wouldn't like. I think. A summer romance up to its neck in purple prose and wandering introspection sounds like a nightmare. And yet, there was something so beautiful, awful, intoxicating and sad about Call Me by Your Name. Maybe I like it because - and I hate to admit this - there is a part of me that recognizes something of myself within it.
Either you have been this kind of person, perhaps still are this kind of person, or you have not, are not, and this book will seem overwritten and alien. I, unfortunately, have experienced that deep, all-encompassing infatuation with another person. I don't personally call it love; not anymore. Instead, it's a feeling of overwhelming, almost feverish, obsession with their existence-- their body, their laugh, and everything they do or say.
I’m not proud of it and I don’t think it’s healthy. But I do think this book captures it in all its intensity and sadness. Call Me by Your Name, for me, stands apart from other romances because it doesn't follow the usual formula of two people meet, cliche flirtations and angst ensue, and then finally they end up together. It's not a spoiler to say this isn't that kind of story; if you're reading it for the warm fuzzies then you're going to be disappointed.
It is about seventeen-year-old Elio, who falls into a deep romantic and sexual obsession with the twenty-four year-old Oliver when the latter becomes a summer guest at Elio's parents' Italian villa. If there was ever a perfect place to set a heady novel of this kind, then it must be the cliffs of the Italian Riviera. I can feel my cold heart melting just thinking about it.
We stay inside Elio's mind as he fantasizes romantically and sexually about Oliver. Aciman builds a novel based on innermost thoughts and the most painful of emotions. It is sometimes almost too much and I wanted to look away as Elio feels like he can’t get close enough; feels like he wants to crawl inside Oliver's skin. It’s an intoxicatingly romantic, intimate, physical, miserable experience.
There is one moment when Elio's wise father comforts him: “Right now there’s sorrow. I don’t envy the pain. But I envy you the pain.” Which I thought was deeply sad, though also perfect. It might not be my usual choice of book, but I think Call Me by Your Name is one that will stay with me. Sometimes it is the exceptions to my rules that I find myself remembering the most.
Blog | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram | Youtube
3005 likes · Like
∙
flag
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Call Me by Your Name.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
December 13, 2017
– Shelved
December 26, 2017
–
Started Reading
December 29, 2017
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 80 (80 new)
message 1:
by
Christina
(new)
-
rated it 2 stars
Dec 23, 2017 08:03AM
I think you're gonna be disappointed by this one :(
reply
|
flag
I'm so glad you're reading it. I have genuinely become emotionally attached to it, definitely my favourite read of the year.
I just read this and had pretty much the same experience with it - I was very aware of all the reasons I wouldn’t ordinarily like a book like this, but Aciman somehow sold it to me. Intoxicating is a good word for it.
I felt the same about this book! It sounds like nothing original and yet there is this depiction, an ideal one, of being a teenager, of the first love that affects the rest of life in some way, of summer nights... Beautiful.
This book captured adolescent longing like nothing else. In fact the last time I read such an intense portrait of infatuation was Scott Spencer's "Endless Love" (forget the movie, the book is superb).
I haven’t read this yet but the movie is absolutely fantastic. I agree that the feelings Elio feels aren’t healthy but it seems like both the book and film capture them completely and honestly. I can’t wait to read this!
This sounds beautiful, though I think I'm still recovering from a situation like this, so I'm not sure it would be healthy to read it right now...
You should know that there are a lot of books that I have read because of your good reviews and I am thankful for that. I will definitely give it a read!
Just came home from the cinema.. Oh shuckles, the movie is so delicate, politely- erotic (?) its fantastic!! Def one of the most intriguing films ive seen and perhaps my most favorite ever. Im buying the novel now! Thanks for the review.
Beautiful prose. Utterly transported to a place I have never been and back to feelings that a certain age we have all had. Remarkable book.
I am that reader that thought it was overwritten and alien :). However, I finally related to Elio throught his "perfect night" in Rome, I was soooo jealous.
Sometimes it is the exceptions to my rules that I find myself remembering the most.
Yes...
Wonderful review, Emily :)
Yes...
Wonderful review, Emily :)
I agree Emily
I found myself crying at times and putting the book away for a while . It is raw and honest and beautiful and so so sad at times .
The movie was beautiful as well .
I found myself crying at times and putting the book away for a while . It is raw and honest and beautiful and so so sad at times .
The movie was beautiful as well .
Great review. But you have a slight misquote. His dad actually says “I don’t envy the pain. I envy you the pain.” Beautiful. The second half of the book, starting in Rome, was perfect.
Such a beautiful book, it evokes all the senses you can visualise everything. The way he writes means that you can feel the angst of Elio and believe their love. Will definitely be recommending to friends 😀
Yes, this book was beautifully written but I found it very disturbing. I both loved it and hated it.
I couldn't describe it better that you did. A beautiful, uncomfortable and sad story. If you've been there somehow, you will understand what the book is about.
Such a beautiful story...the language of it, the agony, the beauty, the sadness, wize...so lively...love't every page of this novel!
I am so thankful for the beautiful movie. Had I not seen it, I might never have read this book. This intoxicating and beautifully written story will stay with me forever......
I enjoyed it. Some people may be upset at a same sex relationship between a 17 year old boy and a 24 year old man, or possibly the occasional graphic language, but please move out of your comfort zone and give this book a read.
What a beautiful review. You’re right—I think what makes this book so downright sad is that all of us, even those of us who typically turn our nose up at sappy romance novels, see a little bit of ourselves in the obsessive and unhealthy love affair. I saw so much of myself in this exquisite novel.
It amazes me that you rate this schoolboy account of a crush, tale of sexual awakening more than a classic novel Wide Sargasso Sea.
Fiona wrote: "It amazes me that you rate this schoolboy account of a crush, tale of sexual awakening more than a classic novel Wide Sargasso Sea."
I am constantly amazed by different people's interpretations of books, but I think that's what makes this site (and the world) interesting.
I am constantly amazed by different people's interpretations of books, but I think that's what makes this site (and the world) interesting.
I wish people who posted reviews would keep quotes and complete details to the reader to experience.
Courtney wrote: "I wish people who posted reviews would keep quotes and complete details to the reader to experience."
I think you are probably just looking for a summary/blurb of the book and not reviews. That's fine, but this is a site where people come to review books.
I think you are probably just looking for a summary/blurb of the book and not reviews. That's fine, but this is a site where people come to review books.
Courtney wrote: "I wish people who posted reviews would keep quotes and complete details to the reader to experience."
Then don't read reviews.
Then don't read reviews.
Early on I had also thought I would soon get tired of the “purple prose and wandering introspection.” But then I fell in love with it. Excellent review.
I’m with ^ Ryan. Because the prose was balanced out with gems like “Whoever said the soul and the body meet in the pineal gland were fools. It’s in the asshole, idiot.” I mean, come on. Elio is also hilarious during his coming of age. I loved it too. :)
Great review. I saw the movie before I read the book but the latter made me tear up. It was beautiful but sad. It was heartbreaking but breathtaking. And I both loved and hated it.
"Look me in the face, hold my gaze and call me by your name."
"Look me in the face, hold my gaze and call me by your name."
I agree with Lilet^ I saw the movie and the phone call and recognition on his face brought me to tears. Just started the book I already know it will be better than the movie. I thought the story was exquisite! Emily thank you for the wonderful review. I agree and I liked your personal touch of your review.
Beautiful review. It says everything about this book without spoiling anything. Dealing with those emotions of sadness and pure joy.
I only saw the movie and have no intentions of reading the book. Not because I didn't like the movie, I loved it but I cried so much during and after the movie that I can't go through that emotional pain again. I met someone after I saw the movie and that intoxicating infatuation was just like the one Elio has and that infatuation led to nothing. This infatuation still lingers, six months after. Great review by the way, I teared up again.
I truly agree with you. I cried every other page of the book because it reminded me so much of a similar period in my life. It captures really well that overwhelming sadness of starting something with an expiration date and also the uncertainty and fear that come with some gay relationships. Great review.