Academia.eduAcademia.edu

The Curious Case of Hello Kitty: Locating the Global Feline Icon

This paper was submitted as part of an "Asia and Hollywood" module at Tembusu College, National University of Singapore. The paper explores the global phenomenon of arguably the most famous Japanese export,Hello Kitty, and offers a socioeconomic examination of its global appeal, especially in the West. Hello Kitty is known in most parts of the world as the ubiquitous feline without a mouth. In the Western hemisphere alone, the billion dollar feline empress of “kawaii” (cute) adorns more than 50,000 products ; is a float at Macy’s annual Thanksgiving Parade in New York, and ‘in 2002, 83% of American 18-23 year olds recognised Kitty’ . “Kawaii” is ‘small, soft, infantile, mammalian, round, without bodily appendages, without bodily orifices (e.g. mouths), non-sexual’ . However, the West’s attraction to “kawaii” has underlying connotations of orientalism, for Edward Said argues that the ‘Orient exists for the West, and is constructed by and in relation to the West’ . Charges of Kitty’s “Japan- domination” are also problematic for she is merely a metonym of Japan-ness, stereotyped by her kawaii-ness on the international stage. In this essay, I will explore Japan’s capitalization of cuteness to the West, and in turn, their responses to “kawaii”. The notions of Hello Kitty as a global product, and representational, will also be problematicised.

The Curious Case of Hello Kitty: Locating the global feline icon Hello Kitty mania is Japan’s greatest cultural export to the world for the ubiquitous feline without a mouth has garnered strong followings around the world. In the Western hemisphere alone, the billion dollar feline empress of “kawaii” (cute) adorns more than 50,000 products Retrieved from: http://san-x.cupped-expressions.net/p/beyond-hello-kitty.html; is a float at Macy’s annual Thanksgiving Parade in New York, and ‘in 2002, 83% of American 18-23 year olds recognised Kitty’ Retrieved from: http://www.japanreview.net/review_hello_kitty.htm. “Kawaii” is ‘small, soft, infantile, mammalian, round, without bodily appendages, without bodily orifices (e.g. mouths), non-sexual’ Kinsella, Sharon. (Eds.). (1995). “Cuties in Japan”
 in Moeran, Brian, Scov, Lise. (Eds.). Women, Media and Consumption in Japan. Chapter 6. USA: Hawaii University Press. P 7.. However, the West’s attraction to “kawaii” has underlying connotations of orientalism, for Edward Said argues that the ‘Orient exists for the West, and is constructed by and in relation to the West’ Said, Edward. (Eds.). (1979). Orientalism. UK: Vintage Books. P 12.. Charges of Kitty’s “Japan- domination” are also problematic for she is merely a metonym of Japan-ness, stereotyped by her kawaii-ness on the international stage. In this essay, I will explore Japan’s capitalization of cuteness to the West, and in turn, their responses to “kawaii”. The notions of Hello Kitty as a global product, and representational, will also be problematicised. The Occidentalist roots of Hello Kitty In the 1970s, Japan’s obsession with “kawaii” fanshi guzzu (fancy goods) that appropriated the West’s “refined” lifestyles grew. Since English associations were popular with the Japanese then, Kitty fanshi guzzu allude to Japan’s (positive) occidentalist desires in images of a fantasised and idealised West ‘The symbols and images of the West packaged by depato [department store] for domestic consumption do not necessarily reflect the reality of any part of the Western world. More often they are blurred refractions, decontextualized fragments of various Western traditions and practices that have been culled and then altered to fit the Japanese cultural context and the expectations of Japanese consumers.’ Tanka, Akio. (Eds.). (1995). Tokyo as a City of Consumption: Space, Media and Identity in Contemporary Japan. Master’s Thesis. University of British Columbia. P 129.. Peter Lawrence, an anthropologist, accounts this to Japan’s ‘desire for the material culture of the European, and hence for economic and social equality with” the Occidental Carrier, G, James. (Eds.). (1995). Occidentalism: Images of the West. USA: Oxford University Press. P 38.. The names “fanshi guzzu” (in katakana, a Japanese syllabary that incorporates foreign words) and “Hello Kitty” already signify the aping of the West. In fact, the official narrative for Kitty’s specifies her birthplace to be Britain rather than Japan. Disney also ‘had a big influence both on Japanese animation and comics’ Kinsella, Sharon. (Eds.). (1995). “Cuties in Japan”
 in Moeran, Brian, Scov, Lise. (Eds.). Women, Media and Consumption in Japan. Chapter 6. USA: Hawaii University Press. P 22. by introducing ‘the modern cute aesthetic into Japan’ Ibid.. The style of “fanshi guzzu” is also borrowed in a ‘European or American- style, dreamy, frilly and fluffy’ Ibid. P 8.. Yuko Yamaguchi, the creator of Hello Kitty, explains that ‘there was an idea that if Kitty-chan spoke English, she would be very fashionable’ Retrieved from: http://www.japansociety.org/resources/content/2/0/5/4/documents/gross national cool.pdf. Thus, the goods were also adorned with ‘cute slogans (that) were more often written in fractured English or pseudo-French than in Japanese’- ‘a toilet bowl called petit etoile’ Kinsella, Sharon. (Eds.). (1995). “Cuties in Japan”
 in Moeran, Brian, Scov, Lise. (Eds.). Women, Media and Consumption in Japan. Chapter 6. USA: Hawaii University Press. P 8.. The Capitalistion of “kawaii” As can be seen from such merchandising, Hello Kitty’s branding rather than traditional ancillary media products, creates her primary narrative. From a Hello Kitty Statue of Liberty to a Bank of America credit card to Forever 21 shirts and even Swarovski diamond rings, Hello Kitty’s icon of cuteness has been capitalized into a global product. Sharon Kinsella argues that a ‘good cute design repersonalises’ Kinsella, Sharon. (Eds.). (1995). “Cuties in Japan”
 in Moeran, Brian, Scov, Lise. (Eds.). Women, Media and Consumption in Japan. Chapter 6. USA: Hawaii University Press. P 9. ‘what capitalist production processes de-personalises’ Ibid.. Hello Kitty successfully captures this irony by mass-producing (and exploiting) the affect of cuteness. This affect transcends the material of provoking consumerism, as emotions and meanings are also attached to Kitty. Therefore, ‘cuteness, with all its baggage of capriciousness, is probably the single most powerful force capitalism has to marshal consumer troops for the system’s reproduction’ Gabriel, Ben. (Eds.). (2012 Feb 16). “I have no mouth but I must scream”. The New Inquiry, “Essays & Reviews”. [Retrieved] Oct 2012 [from] http://thenewinquiry.com/essays/i-have-no-mouth-but-i-must-scream/. Wherein lies the difference of Kitty’s cuteness from Disney, the consumption of Hello Kitty is driven by the meanings of ‘commodified junk’ Ibid. (which) she gets slapped’ Ibid. onto, rather than Kitty herself. This concretises her lack of (explicit) potential for malice attributed to most media products like Disney animations, as animations of her like “Hello Kitty’s Furry Tale Theatre” garnered lackluster ratings. Strikingly, her “global” domination is only possible through the reaches of the West, where the Japanese feline has to be “localized”. A most poignant example of capitalisation of cuteness across borders comes from the American superpower of mass production, McDonald’s. Their “Hello Kitty Love of Millennium Meal Package” played with ‘nationalistic tricks of identification’ by donning ethnic costumes like “ ‘Love of Kyoto’, in a Japanese kimono; ‘Love of Beijing’, in Mandarin dress; ‘Love of Seoul’, in a traditional Korean garment; ‘Love of Penang’, in Malay batik” and even includes space in “ ‘Love of Future’, in a silver astronaut outfit’ Ko, Yu-Fen. (Eds.). (2000). Hello Kitty and the Identity Politics in Taiwan. Postcolonial Studies,Volume 6, Issue 2, 2003.P 12. Retrieved from http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/13688790308106#preview. McDonald’s “Love of Millennium” Photo retrieved from http://ihearthellokitty.com/2010/01/06/hello-kitty-x-mcdonalds-2000-mcsweet-millennium-love-plush/, Hello Kitty Statue of Liberty series Photo retrieved from http://www.flickr.com/photos/leisurelygrass/5219837386/ Orientalist commodification of Cute as Cool Kitty’s Japan-ness became cool and fashionable for the West, just as the latter did for Japan. However, the West’s exotic desirability for Kitty fetishises her “kawaii-ness” into a metonym for Japan. As Sanrio’s head of marketing for Asia, Shunji Onishi, said, fans ‘know Kitty is from Japan. That’s why they like it’ Retrieved from http://www.japansociety.org/resources/content/2/0/5/4/documents/gross national cool.pdf. Pamela Bonnell further argues that Kitty’s Japan-ness incremented Kitty’s trademark cuteness into a ‘weird cult status’ Retrieved from http://uninterpretative.blogspot.sg/2011/05/hello-kitty-everything-introduction.html. The global flattening of affect is thereby regressed into a generic “cool”. It is interesting to note how Westerners “localise” Kitty’s stereotype of cuteness through incongruously violent products like guns, and counter-cultural expressions of punk-rock in goth get-ups, tattoos and Dr. Marten boots. Therefore, Hello Kitty’s value seems to come from her subversion of Western-ness through “kawaii”. Hello Kitty assault rifle Photo retrieved from http://www.kittyhell.com/2007/12/16/hello-kitty-assault-rifle/ Hello Kitty-fied Goth get-up Photo retrieved from http://www.flickr.com/photos/yoyosuicide/3423515516/, Hello Kitty tattoo on a punk Photo retrieved from http://www.bodyartdiary.com/hello-kitty-tattoo-scribble-on-the-forehead.html, Hello Kitty x Dr Marten boots Photo retrieved from http://fashionindie.com/hello-doc/. Kitty’s subversiveness is also apparent in the West’s high Art and fashion’s adulation of her product iconography, which is now an expression of Japanese ‘gross national cool’ Retrieved from http://www.japansociety.org/resources/content/2/0/5/4/documents/gross national cool.pdf. Even celebrities like Lady Gaga and Katy Perry reinforce their own brandings of “quirky cool” with the famous feline. As a critical response to the commodification of “kawaii” in Japan by the likes of Hello Kitty, the Superflat Arts movement in Japan critiques the ‘shallow emptiness of Japanese consumer culture’ Retrieved from http://www.artnet.com/Magazine/features/drohojowska-philp/drohojowska-philp1-18-01.asp by deliberately flattening “kawaii” cartoon characters. The West values its postmodernity in subverting the Western canon of high art- the juxtaposition of Takashi Murakami exhibits at the Palace of Versailles in 2010 against classical pieces, and collaborations with renowned couturier, Louis Vuitton. America’s Next Top Model x M.A.C fashion spread Photo retrieved from http://www.gabrielleteare.com/blog/2009/03/07/hello-kitty-for-mac/, Lady Gaga on the album cover of a limited-edition box-set of “The Fame” Photo retrieved from http://www.jackfroot.com/2011/12/everyone-loves-hello-kitty-except-charlize-theron/lady-gaga-hello-kitty-dress/, Katy Perry at the BIRT Awards in London in 2009 Photo retrieved from http://www.shoppingblog.com/blog/2180920. Takashi Murakami exhibit at the Chateau de Versailles in 2010 Photos retrieved from http://wenhb.wordpress.com/2010/09/10/takashi-murakami-at-the-chateau-de-versailles-exhibition-recap/. Takashi Murakami for Louis Vuitton Photo retrieved from http://naked-glory.blogspot.sg/2011/01/trans-cool-tokyo-contemporary-art.html, Yaoyi Kusamai for Louis Vuitton Photo retrieved from http://wearethemarket.com/todays-headlines-25-louis-vuitton-yayoi-kusama-lord-finesse-mac-miller-apc-nike/yayoi-kusama-louis-vuitton-windows-unveiling/ Through these interplay of superficial cross-cultural influences, Hello Kitty’s identity becomes rather ambiguous. She conjures the illusion of a “global product”, yet she appeals to both sides because ‘an Occidentalist view of the West seems to require an Orientalist view of the East’ Tanka, Akio. (Eds.). (1995). Tokyo as a City of Consumption: Space, Media and Identity in Contemporary Japan. Master’s Thesis. University of British Columbia. P 144.. “Kawaii’s” transnational capability relies on such preconceptions of her hybridity of East-and-West, as Shunji said, ‘Hello Kitty is Western, so she will sell in Japan. She is Japanese, so she will sell in the West’ Retrieved from http://www.japansociety.org/resources/content/2/0/5/4/documents/gross national cool.pdf. In fact, Japan’s embracing of the Western-affirmed identity of ‘gross national cool’ Ibid. has underlying connotations of self-exoticisation Self-exoticisation is defined as ‘a shift in the positioning of the gaze that sees the self, for it is the appropriation of the Western gaze that renders one's tradition so much more "exotic."… even appreciation of "native" tradition tends to demand the perspective of a non-native.’ by Akio Tanaka. Tanka, Akio. (Eds.). (1995). Tokyo as a City of Consumption: Space, Media and Identity in Contemporary Japan. Master’s Thesis. University of British Columbia. P 144. in a bid for kokusaika (internationalization). The appropriation of the Western gaze shows that ‘the gaze that exoticizes Japan is not simply that of a foreign tourist; instead it is a paradoxical gaze of the native Japanese who self-consciously appropriates the tourist gaze’ Ibid.. The Trans-Cool TOKYO travelling Arts exhibition shows how Japan identifies with this label of coolness. Photo Retrieved from http://documentations.blogspot.com/2010/11/trans-cool-tokyo-8q-singapore-art.html Ultimately, ‘her fractured identity makes her more than a nation but less than truly international’ Gabriel, Ben. (Eds.). (2012 Feb 16). “I have no mouth but I must scream”. The New Inquiry, “Essays & Reviews”. [Retrieved] Oct 2012 [from] http://thenewinquiry.com/essays/i-have-no-mouth-but-i-must-scream/, even as her mould continually encourages such perceptions of global-ness. The elevated ‘assumption that Kitty is representational’ Ibid. complicates her ‘material existence’ Ibid.. Since she is inherently a commodity and nothing more than an object, the meanings produced out of Kitty are essentially empty. The globalization of Kitty is further compromised by her ‘metonymic capacity to evoke amorphous meanings’ Ibid. despite her mouthless form. Most importantly, she demonstrates the epitome of frivolous consumption born out of pure consumerist fandom. Consumption needs a source and Hello Kitty, in her plethora of culturally shaped meanings, provides a well of reproductions for consumers to choose from. For example, an artist, Christal Sih, hyperbolises the almost-religious state of consumerism that characterises Kitty fandom, with a Kitty mock-shrine. Copyright 2011 by Christal Sih. Reprinted with permission. (1191 words) (125 words for pictures) hoi Yik Heng National University of Singapore Centre for English Language Communication IEM1201F- Asia & Hollywood