Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Concatenation of conspiracies blurbs

2021, A Concatention of Conspiracies: "Irish" William Blake and Illuminist Freemasonry in 1798

Sometimes conspiracies are real or even "benevolent," as the Irish nationalist William Drennan wrote in 1791. His work to utilize "illuminist" Freemasonry to gain Irish independence placed the movement in the international context of conservative versus liberal debates on the alleged role of radical Freemasonry in revolutionary plots. Drennan wrote that "such schemes are not to be laughed at as romantic, for without enthusiasm nothing great was done." While the reactionary Abbé Barruel warned about the "concatenation of conspiracies," his English translator Robert Clifford targeted the United Irishmen as the most dangerous seditionists. But the visionary artist William Blake-an advocate of enthusiasm-sympathized with the Irish rebels and infused support for their cause into the imagery of his greatest works. He also knew that the angel harp-the nationalists' main symbol-was "no gentle harp." When he revealed that "they give the oath of blood in Lambeth," he possibly wrote from personal experience in an oath-bound secret society. EDITORIAL REVIEWS: This handsomely illustrated and accessible book presents a cosmopolitan version of the connections that bind together Freemasonry, the United Irishmen, and William Blake. It supplies a richly contextualized account of the swirl of ideas that animated radicalism in the revolutionary 1790s.

Marsha Keith Schuchard, A CONCATENATION OF CONSPIRACIES: “IRISH” WILLIAM BLAKE AND ILLUMINIST FREEMASONRY IN 1798 (Alexandria, VA: Plumbstone Academic Press, 2021). ABSTRACT: Sometimes conspiracies are real or even “benevolent,” as the Irish nationalist William Drennan wrote in 1791. His work to utilize “illuminist” Freemasonry to gain Irish independence placed the movement in the international context of conservative versus liberal debates on the alleged role of radical Freemasonry in revolutionary plots. Drennan wrote that “such schemes are not to be laughed at as romantic, for without enthusiasm nothing great was done.” While the reactionary Abbé Barruel warned about the “concatenation of conspiracies,” his English translator Robert Clifford targeted the United Irishmen as the most dangerous seditionists. But the visionary artist William Blake—an advocate of enthusiasm—sympathized with the Irish rebels and infused support for their cause into the imagery of his greatest works. He also knew that the angel harp—the nationalists’ main symbol—was “no gentle harp.” When he revealed that “they give the oath of blood in Lambeth,” he possibly wrote from personal experience in an oath-bound secret society. EDITORIAL REVIEWS: This handsomely illustrated and accessible book presents a cosmopolitan version of the connections that bind together Freemasonry, the United Irishmen, and William Blake. It supplies a richly contextualized account of the swirl of ideas that animated radicalism in the revolutionary 1790s. --Professor Kevin Whelan, Director, Notre Dame Gateway Project, Dublin. Based on in-depth research into a great variety of sources, this new, exciting, ground-breaking contribution by Marsha Keith Schuchard brilliantly integrates history and insightful interpretations. The book provides innovative perspectives on events and contexts that had hitherto received little or no attention in conventional historiography of the period. To wit, a new Irish-English-Scottish outlook on the influence of such figures as Barruel and Robison on literature and politics in the British Isles, and on the international ramifications thereof; or, surprisingly but convincingly, the important role of Illuminist Freemasonry in Irish independence movements—with support for the Irish struggle by William Blake, of whom the author is a renowned specialist. A Concatenation of Conspiracies will be a reference volume for a long time to come. --Professor Antoine Faivre, author of Western Esotericism: A Concise History. A Concatenation of Conspiracies is the latest of Keith Schuchard’s explorations into the lesser-known milieus of William Blake, on this occasion, focusing upon the radical underworlds of the 1790s. In her account, individuals, societies, meetings, spies, Masonic brotherhoods, United Irishmen, and mystical millenarians, are uncovered in proximity to Blake, begging the question again and again, he must have known, been there, responded to, what Schuchard has reconstructed; at a time, as William Godwin described, “when terror was the order of the day.” No student of Blake can afford to neglect Schuchard’s pioneering work. --Michael Phillips, Emeritus Fellow, the University of York. Marsha Keith Schuchard’s monograph assiduously explores millenarian movements in late eighteenth century London, Edinburgh, Dublin, and Avignon, and perceptively discusses the relationships among them. Of particular interest here are Masonic lodges, many of which could appear to the outsider as if they held fundamentally similar beliefs, yet could be radically different in orientation, as Schuchard shows. This is especially true of the “illuminated” and non-illuminated lodges. Schuchard also differentiates among the various Masonic rites and identifies the leading figures in different branches. Much information is gleaned from the anti-revolutionary writers such as the Abbé Barruel and John Robison. Of special interest is Emanuel Swedenborg, whose refusal to found a movement was studiously ignored by his followers. Much attention is given throughout to the similarities between the thought of some of these figures and groups to William Blake’s, correspondences that, in the absence of documentary proof, must remain speculative, but which may lead to discoveries to come. --Morton D. Paley, Emeritus Professor, University of California, Berkeley.