BRITISH FORUM FOR ETHNOMUSICOLOGY
AND
ROYAL MUSICAL ASSOCIATION
RESEARCH STUDENTS’ CONFERENCE
12-14 JANUARY 2021
1
12TH
JAN
9-9:30
9:30-9:45
10-11:30
Plenary
Sessions
Chairing
Session
Katharine
Ellis
Welcome
Address
Chair:
Matthew
MachinAutenrieth
Zoom host:
Katharine
Ellis
BFE-RMA Research Students’ Conference
University of Cambridge (12th – 14th January 2021)
Programme
Zoom Room 3
Zoom Room 4
Zoom
Room 5
Zoom Room 1
Zoom Room 2
Panel Session 1A
Compositional Processes
from a Cross-cultural
Perspective (1)
Chair: Chulei Wang
Zoom host: Ross Cole
Panel Session 1B
Music Pedagogy 1
Chair: Roxanna
Albayati
Zoom host: Jacob
Olley
Panel Session 1C
Music on Screen
Chair: Ivan
Mouraviev
Zoom host:
Alexandra Leonzini
Panel Session 1D
Performance Studies
Chair: Berenice
Beverley Zammit
Zoom host: David
Cotter
Petra Zidaric Györek
The reception of Arab
traditional vocalization
zaghareet in the selected
composition by Samir
Odeh Tamimi
Anna Wright
Conservatoire students
of the past: the first
year’s intake, 1893-4, at
the Royal Manchester
College of Music
Toby Huelin
Soundtracking the
City Break: Library
Music in Travel
Television
Claire Elizabeth Ruckert
Applied
Psychophysiology,
Performance Anxiety, and
the Conservatoire
Musician
Kevin Leomo
Composing Liminality
Luan Shaw
Uncovering hegemony:
Instrumental teacher
Conor Power
Hymn To The Fallen:
Constructing
Can Li
Acoustics Analysis of 19th
Century Violin Vibrato –
education in
conservatoires
Peter Nagle
Véronique Walsh
Congregations and
Immersion learning,
Pilgrimages: Transforming imitation, and diversity
Atmosphere between
of knowledge in West
Performance and
Javanese traditional
Installation
dance transmission
11:4512:45
13:3015:00
BFE-RMA Research Students’ Conference
University of Cambridge (12th – 14th January 2021)
Programme
American Values in
Based on German
Saving Private Ryan
Violinists Ferdinand
David and Louis Spohr
Charis Richardson
Tracing musical
trends in dystopian
film
Caoimhe Ní Riain
Reading Between the
Lines: A Case Study
Exploring the Efficiency
of Prescriptive Notation
Within Performance.
Panel Session 2C
Music and Politics 1
Chair: Eirini
Diamantouli
Zoom host:
Alexandra Leonzini
Panel Session 2D
Gustav Mahler: New
Perspectives on his life
and works
Chair: Vanessa Carlone
Zoom host: David
Cotter
Publisher
Q&A
Chair: Nuria
Bonet
Zoom host:
Katharine
Ellis
Panel Session 2A
Music and Gender 1
Chair: Jessica Ward
Zoom host: Ross Cole
Panel Session 2B
Critical Opera Studies 1
Chair: Peter Asimov
Zoom host: Jacob
Olley
Alice Masterson
‘Little Girl Blue’? The
Leo Geyer
Mediation of Janis Joplin’s Opéra-ballet: the Ballet
Posthumous Career
Russes’s Secret
Lilian Holland
“Deep Inside, We’re All
Just PYNK”: Theorising
Brown Jouissance in the
Asli Kaymak
Guillaume Tell in
London: Hofer’s Female
Army
Ekaterina Pavlova
Auferstanden aus
Ruinen: Cultural
Heritage, Identity and
Politics in the Postwar Rebirth of the
Staatsoper Unter den
Linden
Maho Naito
The Sequence of the
Middle Movements in the
Second Symphony of
Gustav Mahler
Genevieve Robyn Arkle
Performances of Labelle
and Janelle Monáe
James Barker
‘Another bed I shouldn’t
crawl out of’: Pleasure and
precarity in the country
music one-night stand
15:1516:45
17:0018:30
18:30
Postdoc Panel
Chair:
Francesca
Vella
Zoom host:
Katharine
Ellis
RMA
Keynote
Chair:
Barbara
Kelly
Zoom host:
Katharine
Ellis
Social Event:
Virtual ‘Jam’
Session
BFE-RMA Research Students’ Conference
University of Cambridge (12th – 14th January 2021)
Programme
Listening to Mahler,
Jacqueline Georgis
Hearing Wagner: The
“Free Jazz Mod
allusions to Richard
Paludan”: Denmark’s Wagner’s Music Dramas
experimental protest in Gustav Mahler’s Songs
music
and Symphonies
Ana Beatriz Ferreira
Through the Lens of
a Dictatorship: Joly
Braga Santos and the
Estado Novo
Alice Verti
The ironical exegesis of
Mahler’s Seventh
Symphony: a
“Rezeptionsfrage”?
13TH JAN
9-10:30
9-12:00
(composition
workshops)
Plenary
Sessions
Zoom Room 1
Zoom Room 2
Panel Session 3A
Music, Community and
Wellbeing
Chair: Eric Petzoldt
Zoom host: Nicky
Swett
Panel Session 3B
Hip Hop and EDM
Chair: Steve Wilford
Zoom host: Lucy
Walker
Victoria Parsons
An Army in Conflict:
The Changing Musical
and Cultural Identity of
the Salvation Army in
Australia
Hannah Gibbs
Investigating the impact
of gamelan participation
on wellbeing: plans for
collaborative research
with Good Vibrations
Mohamed Haseeb
Where Spices Love
Music, Emotion and
Vigour: A Voyage to the
Kolkkali Performance of
Mappilas of Malabar
Samson Tosin Onafuye
‘God and Grime’:
Exploring the early
History and
development of
Gospel Grime.
BFE-RMA Research Students’ Conference
University of Cambridge (12th – 14th January 2021)
Programme
Zoom Room 3
Zoom Room 4
Zoom Room 5
Panel Session 3C
Postcolonial
Approaches
Chair: Matthew
MachinAutenrieth
Zoom host: Peter
Asimov
Aniarani Andita
Colonial history
and contemporary
perceptions of
Ivan Mouraviev
Western classical
‘You have to feel it’:
music in
Sound systems,
Indonesia: the
affect, and theories of cases of Jakarta,
sub-bass experience
Bandung, and
Yogyakarta
James Rushworth
Sampling and East
Sara Speller
Asian Identity within (Un)familiar faces:
contemporary
exploring the
Electronica
exotic everyday of
Parade
Anhad Arora
Orientalist
Flowers in Robert
Schumann’s
Myrthen
Panel Session 3D
Musical Nationalisms
Chair: Ross Cole
Zoom host: Katharine
Ellis
Composition
Workshop (runs
for three hours)
Chair and Host:
Richard Causton
Boris Hei Yin Wong
“The Day It Rained on
Our Par5ade”: School
Marching Band in the
Singapore Story
Little Hunt, by
Cydonie Banting
Emma Townsend
From the Tropics to the
Snow (1964): Exploring
emotions of white
masculine nationbuilding in Australian
government film scores
of the mid-1960s
Thomas Heywood
An Ethical Critique of
Vaughan Williams’s
Appropriation of Folk
Song
Adrenaline, by
Ignacio Mañá
Mesas
Postcard-sized pieces,
by Sophie Stone
Vā yuvē ra
by Saman Samadi
10:45-12:15
BFE-RMA Research Students’ Conference
University of Cambridge (12th – 14th January 2021)
Programme
Panel Session 4A
Panel Session 4B
Panel Session 4C Panel Session 4D
Compositional Processes Music and Gender 2
Digital
Traditional
from a Cross-cultural
Chair: Nuria Bonet Musicology and
Taxonomies
Perspective (2)
Zoom host: Lucy
Media 1
Chair: Ross Cole
Chair: Ruixue Hu
Walker
Chair: James
Zoom host: Steve
Zoom host: Nicky
Barker
Wilford
Swett
Sarah Jillian Cox
Zoom host: Peter
The changing voice
Asimov
Christina Lynn
Ju-Lee Hong
of Anastasia
“Classifying
Locating Taoism in the
Robinson, 1715-1720 Allison Noble
Operations”:
European Avant-Garde:
Musical Ones and Constructing and
Isang Yun's Images
Helen Doyle
Zeros: Examining manufacturing identities
(1968)
A Woman’s Work is
Genre’s Role
in country music (PRENever Done:
within Music
RECORDED)
Jia Cao
Establishing the
Streaming
Combining elements
Structural Network of Platforms
Irfan Rais
from the ancient
the Dublin Feis Ceoil
Proposing a descriptive
Chinese and
Hannah Gibson
musical grammar for
contemporary art music Barbora Vacková
Irish Country
contemporary trad/folk
worlds: some critical
“Could You Call Us
Music’s Authentic music (PREreflections on the
Women Comrades?” Aesthetics: Social RECORDED)
hybridizing of
Careers, Lives and
Media as
compositional methods, Professional
Impression
Eduardo Roque dos Reis
aesthetics and playing
Experience of
Management
Falcão
techniques
Women Composers
The Goan song
in Communist
Sureshkumar P.
collector Agapito de
Marta Riccardi
Czechoslovakia
Sekar
Miranda: Digital media
Eschewing teleology: an
Audience
and personal
alternative approach to
Experience in
songbooks, new
musical development
Film-with-Livechallenges for cultural
Orchestra
representations (PREConcerts:
RECORDED)
Towards a Theory
BFE-RMA Research Students’ Conference
University of Cambridge (12th – 14th January 2021)
Programme
13:15-14:45
Panel Session 5A
Ecomusicology and
Environment
Chair: Matthew
Machin-Autenrieth
Zoom host: Jacob
Olley
Jennie Tiderman-Österberg
Affective sensations
when vocalizing kulning
– the herding calls of the
North
Rowan Bayliss Hawitt
Temporal Affect as
Ecocritical Discourse:
Sounding Multiple
Temporalities in the UK
Folk Music Scene
Joshua O. Brew
Towards an ecological
sustainability: role of
Ghanaian traditional
music
Panel Session 5B
Critical Opera
Studies 2
Chair: Nicky Swett
Zoom host: Lucy
Walker
Kerry Bunkhall
‘In every creature, a
spark of God’:
Empathy in Janáček’s
From the House of the
Dead
Lola Salem
‘C’est un sujet qui
peut être encore
utile’: female opera
singers and the
question of
retirement at the
Académie Royale de
Musique in Paris
(1750s-1760s)
of aLiveness
(PRERECORDED)
Panel Session 5C
Piano and
Chamber Music
Chair: Hannah
Roberts
Zoom host: Juan
Liu
Sevastiana Nourou
The influence of
Ignaz Moscheles’
«pianoforte
soirees» on the
piano recital,
concert
programming and
on the formation
of the canon of
music
Anna Belinszky
Playing with the
limits of
expression: the
Kreisler character
Lea Luka Tiziana
in the original
Sikau
version of
The Artist is Sleeping: Brahms’s Piano
Presence and the
Trio in B major
Disembodiment of
(1854)
Panel Session 5D
Music in England and
Scotland
Chair: David Cotter
Zoom host: Steve
Wilford
Samuel Teague
Piercing Through the
‘Gloomy Silence’:
Musicians’ Livelihoods
in Civil War and
Commonwealth
England (c.1642-1660)
Philip Boardman
From extraordinary
success to no
considerable results:
Victorian music
entrepreneurialism and
the Crystal Palace Brass
Band Competition
1860-1863
Meg Hyland
The Missing Herring
Gutters in Gaelic Song
Scholarship
BFE-RMA Research Students’ Conference
University of Cambridge (12th – 14th January 2021)
Programme
Voice in Marina
Abramovic’s Opera 7
Deaths of Maria Callas
15:00-16:30
17:00-18:30
Off the
Beaten
[academic]
Track:
Career
Paths after
PG Study
Zoom
host and
Chair:
Katharine
Ellis
Backup:
Ekaterina
Pavlova
BFE
Keynote
Chair:
Simon
McKerrell
Zoom
host:
Katharine
Ellis
Tihamér Hlavacsek
Music and
Identities in the
Piano Works of
Karl Goldmark
(PRERECORDED)
19:00-20:30
Panel Session 6A
Music and Religion 1
Chair: Dunya Habash
Zoom host: Jacob
Olley
Jon Snyder
Influences from
Outside: The
Introduction and
Growth of Choirs in
Reformed, Mennonite,
and Quaker Churches
Robert Girling
Expressing change:
Music and theurgy in
early Coptic literary texts
Samuel Tandei
Reconstructing the
uneasy nexus between
‘western art music’ and
Christianity
Panel Session 6B
Cultures of the 18th
and early 19th
Centuries
Chair: Nuria Bonet
Zoom host:
Katharine Ellis
Ellen Stokes
A Musical Favourite:
Salieri at the Court of
Emperor Joseph II
Sarah Miller
Performing Seduction
Mozart’s Cherubino
as a Cicisbeo (PRERECORDED)
Riccardo La Spina
“An anxiousness to
appear original” –
The Early Critical
Reception of Rossini
in Spain (1818-1819)
(PRE-RECORDED)
BFE-RMA Research Students’ Conference
University of Cambridge (12th – 14th January 2021)
Programme
Panel Session 6C Panel Session 6D
Beyond the
Music in South
Soundscape
America
Chair: Joseph V. Chair and Zoom host:
Nelson
David Cotter
Zoom host: Juan
Liu
Pablo Victor Marquine da
Fonseca
Anne Greenwood
Claudio Santoro,
Pitch, Timbre, and Música viva, and the
Change in
Emergence of German
Myanmar
Modernism in Brazilian
Teashops
Music
Charalambous Chara
Limassol Carnival
Serenades: A nontradition tradition
Stephen Meyer
Presentation Title:
Tangomania in Paris
(1911-1914) and the
consolidation of tango
as a national symbol of
Argentina
Caetano Maschio Santos
“Maldita Corona”: the
political aesthetics of
migration in Haitian
migrants’ (musical)
responses to the Covid19 pandemic in Brazil
14TH
JAN
9:3011:00
Plenary
Sessions
Zoom Room 1
Zoom Room 2
Zoom Room 3
Panel session 7A
Ethnographic Archives
Chair: Vineet Gairola
Zoom host: Jacob Olley
Panel Session 7B
Music Pedagogy 2
Chair: Apolline
Gouzi
Zoom host:
Ekaterina Pavlova
Panel Session 7C
Music and
Identity
Chair: Matthew
MachinAutenrieth
Zoom host:
Nicky Swett
Christina Homer
Negotiations and
Representations: An
Ancient Mexican Musical
Instrument Collection in a
“Glocal” Museum
Chen Chen
Between Theater and
"Digital Archive"
of lüju Fans: Cultural
Memory and Remediation
of a Chinese Regional
Opera in the Digital
Age (PRE-RECORDED)
Fengyi Zhang
Cultural Dissonance
in Popular Chinese
Piano Tutor Books
(PRE-RECORDED)
Alex Ho
Mind the Gap:
Reflecting and
Reimagining
Lauren Farquharson
Transnational
The British College of Chinese Identity
Accordionists creation through
of an Educational
Composition
Environment for
Accordionists in
Chrysi Kyratsou
Britain during the 20th “I decided to stay
century (PREhere because of
RECORDED)
music”: Sensing
sonically a
(possible) new
home
Mary-Jannet Leith
“The Harmony of
United Parts”:
Robert Bremner’s
mission to
BFE-RMA Research Students’ Conference
University of Cambridge (12th – 14th January 2021)
Programme
Zoom Room 4
Zoom Room 5
Panel Session 7D
Music and Politics
2
Chair: Emma
Townsend
Zoom host:
Alexandra Leonzini
Joanne Cusack
(Re)shaping Image
and Performance:
The impact of
commercial Irish
dance shows on
women musicians
(PRE-RECORDED)
Rose Campion
We Built this City on
Rock ‘n’ Rubab: The
Institutionalisation of
Music Integration
Programmes for
Migrants in Germany
(PRE-RECORDED)
Alex Gibson
Stay Woke:
Conspiracy theory
and consciousness in
Lecture-Recitals (1)
Chair: Katharine
Ellis
Zoom host: Juan Liu
Teng Chen
Singing and Inheriting
Classics: Popularised
Traditional Chinese
Poems
Helen Anahita Wilson
Sounding the
Cosmogram: a Tantric
approach to Karnatic
rhythm
11:3013:00
(Panel
8C:
11:30–
13:30)
Panel Session 8A
Music and Religion 2
Chair: Tadhg Sauvey
Zoom host: Jacob Olley
Phyllida Martignetti
Erzulie O!: The
compositional techniques
associated with the
worship of the deity,
Erzulie, in Haitian Vodou
Ihsanul Ihthisam
Cosmopolis of language
performances: circulation
of sufi texts and sounds
across the Indian ocean
Zen Kuriyama
The Primacy of Prime:
Rachmaninoff’s All-Night
Vigil and the Theology of
the First Hour (PRERECORDED)
Panel Session 8B
Digital Musicology
and Media 2
Chair: Madison
Miller
Zoom host:
Ekaterina Pavlova
Raymond Sookram
Playing in the
Paracosm:
Imagination,
Hyperreality and the
Video Game
Experience (PRERECORDED)
Mark Higgins
From syncopated
rhythms to robotic
riddim: technology
and the evolution of
dubstep (PRERECORDED)
Juan Bermúdez
Which Music?
Nobody Plays…
Nobody Knows
improve Scottish
Psalmody in late
eighteenth-century
London
Panel Session 8C
Analysis (2 hour
session)
Chair: Katharine
Ellis
Zoom host:
Nicky Swett
Roberta Vidic
The Canons and
Counterpoints of
Costanzo Festa
Andrew Robinson
Giovanni
Bassano’s
instrumental
diminution figures
Leo Charlier
Scriabin's Poem of
Ecstasy:
temporality and
formal affordance
BFE-RMA Research Students’ Conference
University of Cambridge (12th – 14th January 2021)
Programme
hip-hop music (PRERECORDED)
Panel Session 8D
Socialist Realism
and Exoticism
Chair: Matthew
Machin-Autenrieth
Zoom host:
Alexandra Leonzini
Eirini Diamantouli
Nikos Skalkottas’
‘turn to tonalism’ and
the influence of
Socialist Realism in
Greece
Céleste Pagniello
Alexander Pushkin,
the New Soviet
Canon of Classics,
and the
Establishment of
Early Soviet Ballet
Cole Bendall
Inventing the exotic
Ruixue Hu
Estonian: the
A Prismatic Model reception to Veljo
of Orbital
Tormis’ Raua needmine
Tonality with
Lecture Recitals (2)
Chair: Nuria Bonet
Zoom host: Juan Liu
María Fernanda del Peón
Pacheco
With Tiger Claw:
Rewriting the myth of
genre in piano
performance through
the endemic
performative practices
of Baja California Sur.
Ellen Falconer
A prelude, a grazioso and
an étude walk into a bar:
Casella’s debt to
Chopin
BFE-RMA Research Students’ Conference
University of Cambridge (12th – 14th January 2021)
Programme
14:0015:30
Panel Session 9A
Music in North Africa
and Middle East
Chair: Jacob Olley
Zoom host: Alexandra
Leonzini
Lauren Braithwaite
Unveiling musical
freedoms: A critical
analysis of creative
processes in Afghan
music education
Hugo Hadji
The economic circuit of
Raï music, from the 1980s
to the challenges of the
Covid-19 pandemic
Eric Petzoldt
Jauk Elmaleh’s Dakka
Jazz and the Casablanca
jazz scene of the 1950s
and 1960s
Towards an
Ethnomusicological
Approach to TikToks
Musicking (PRERECORDED)
Panel Session 9B
Queer Musical
Methodologies
Chair: George
Haggett
Zoom host:
Ekaterina Pavlova
Cathal Twomey
Unable or Unwilling
to Love: Chastity and
(Non-)Desire in
Seventeenth-Century
Venetian Opera
Jam Orrell
‘Whatever hurts, it’s
all mine’: hearing
embodiment in
SOPHIE’s It’s Okay
to Cry
Dylan Price
Britten and Place:
Constructing a Queer
Ecomusicology
Cases from
Bruckner’s Sixth
Symphony
Panel Session 9C
Plan ‘C’: COVID
& Creativity
(PRERECORDED
PANEL)
Chair: Jerry
Zhou
Zoom host:
Katharine Ellis
Theme I: Creative
Pedagogy: Teaching
and Community
Music Making in
Times of COVID
See Ning Hui;
Ye Ya Jie; and
Tian Ke-Xin
Theme II:
Composition &
Musical Expression
in Times of COVID
Khetsin (Pleum)
Chuchuan; Jerry
Panel Session 9D
Music Theory and
Knowledge from a
Cross-Cultural
Perspective
Chair: Nicky Swett
Zoom host:
Matthew MachinAutenrieth
John Moore
“You know too
damn much”: music
theory knowledge as
a para-musical
component in the
construction of
identities
James Shufflebotham
Gravitonicity:
towards a Model of
the ‘Gravitation’ in
Music
Patrick Huang
Harmony of the
Spheres of Ancient
Yue Zhuo;
Taratawan
(Tuntun) Krue;
and
Kawirat (Tintin)
Saimek
Theme III: Virtual
Presence as a
Performer in Times of
COVID
Ng Xin-Yu
(Nicole); and
Zé Kouyaté
(Gaio)
16:0017:30
EDI
Training
Session
Chair:
Matt
Dicken
Zoom
host:
Katharine
Ellis
BFE-RMA Research Students’ Conference
University of Cambridge (12th – 14th January 2021)
Programme
Greece and Early
China: A Comparison
on Selected Texts
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Welcome from the BFE-RMA Student Conference ChairS .................................................................... 3
About the Faculty of Music, Cambridge ................................................................................................ 5
British Forum for Ethnomusicology and Royal Musical Association Conference Code of Conduct ....... 6
RMA Keynote Speaker .......................................................................................................................... 7
Abstract ............................................................................................................................................ 8
Biography .......................................................................................................................................... 8
BFE Keynote Speaker ............................................................................................................................ 9
Abstract .......................................................................................................................................... 10
Biography ........................................................................................................................................ 10
Plenary Training Sessions .................................................................................................................... 11
Postdoc Panel ................................................................................................................................. 11
Off the Beaten [Academic] Track: Career Paths After PG Study...................................................... 11
'An Audience with... a Publisher' .................................................................................................... 13
EDI Session .......................................................................................................................................... 13
Equality, Diversity and Inclusion in Music Studies: Discussion Session Hosted by the EDIMS
Network and the LGBTQ+ Study Group .......................................................................................... 13
Mentoring Sessions............................................................................................................................. 15
Themed Panels ................................................................................................................................... 16
“Gustav Mahler: New Perspectives on his Life and Works” ............................................................ 16
Plan ‘C’: COVID & Creativity ............................................................................................................ 16
Queer Musical Methodologies ........................................................................................................ 17
Individual Abstracts in Alphabetical Order.......................................................................................... 19
Composition Workshops ..................................................................................................................... 68
2
WELCOME FROM THE BFE-RMA STUDENT CONFERENCE
CHAIRS
The Faculty of Music, University of Cambridge, in collaboration with the British Forum for
Ethnomusicology and the Royal Musical Association are delighted to welcome you to the Research
Students’ Conference 2021. This is not quite the conference that we originally had in mind when we
set out to host it. Given the unprecedented times we are living in, we have needed to move the
conference online. However, we have put together a programme that we hope still offers delegates
plenty of opportunity to interact with each other in a friendly and accessible way. Alongside live and
pre-recorded paper presentations and themed panels, we have pre-recorded lecture recitals, and
composition workshops. We are also delighted to be able to host a number of plenary training
sessions, live through Zoom, including a postdoctoral panel, a panel about non-academic careers, an
EDI in music studies discussion panel and a Q&A with publishers. We are also pleased to welcome Dr
Thomas Hilder as the BFE keynote and Dr Emily MacGregor as the RMA keynote.
We have five Zoom ‘rooms’ that will function as our conference spaces for the three days. The
access links will be embedded in the final PDF programme and will also be sent around via email
ahead of the conference. Each Zoom room will be started and looked after by a technical host and
presenters will be introduced by a chair. The online format has also brought with it certain
advantages, such as a number of international speakers who will be joining us for the event. For this
reason, we have scheduled a series of late panels on the second day. We have opted to organise the
conference fully in house in order to keep the event free, so please bear with us if there are any
technical hiccups! We hope that you enjoy the event and that, despite the circumstances, it is a
rewarding and intellectually stimulating experience. We look forward to hearing about the
fascinating postgraduate research going on in music studies.
Finally, as the committee chairs we would like to thank the BFE, RMA and Faculty of Music at
Cambridge for grants to support the conference, which have enabled us to keep the registration
free. We would also like to thank Cambridge University Press for its continued support. We would
also like to thank our local arrangements committee for all the hard work they have put in, especially
over the past few months: Dr Michelle Assay, Dr Nuria Bonet, Dr Richard Causton, Matt Dicken, Ellen
Falconer, Dunya Habash, Patrick Huang and Dr Francesca Vella. And we would like to thank Mustafa
Beg (IT Manager at the Faculty of Music) for his support with the technical logistics, as well as the
administrative team at the Faculty.
We hope you enjoy the conference!
Dr Matthew Machin-Autenrieth
University of Aberdeen
BFE Conference Liaison
Prof. Katharine Ellis
Faculty of Music, University of Cambridge
1684 Professor of Music
3
Take 30% OFF titles in
Music from Cambridge
Greek Tragedy and Myth
Jason Geary
The Idea of Nature
Thomas Grey
Wagner and the Rise of
Modern Mythology
Stefan Arvidsson
Gender and Sexuality
Chris Walton
Part II Aesthetics
Critical Responses
Barbara Eichner
The Ring in Theory and Practice
Arnold Whittall
Form and Structure
J. P. E. Harper-Scott
The Bayreuth Concept and the
Significance of Performance
Roger Allen
Placing the Ring in Literary History
David Trippett
Specters of Nazism
Tash Siddiqui
The Ring in Cinematic and
Popular Culture
Adrian Daub
Nancy November is Associate Professor in Musicology at the University of
Auckland. Recent publications include Beethoven’s Theatrical Quartets: Opp. 59,
74, and 95 (2013); a three-volume edition of fifteen string quartets by Beethoven’s
contemporary Emmanuel Aloys Förster (2016); and Cultivating String Quartets in
Beethoven’s Vienna (2017). She is the recipient of an Alexander von Humboldt
Foundation Fellowship; and two Marsden Grants from the New Zealand
Royal Society.
Notable Productions
Barry Millington
Part III Interpretations
Characters in the “World” of the Ring
Mark Berry
9781108422581: November: PPC: C M Y K
Epilogue
ure of Rhythm
ollins
Part IV Impact
Cover image: Detail from set design by Max Brückner (1836-1919)
for Act III of Twilight of the Gods by Richard Wagner (1813-1883),
performed in Bayreuth in 1896. Bayreuth, Richard-Wagner-Museum
(Photo by DeAgostini/Getty Images).
Cover design: Andrew Ward
Renaissance Polyphony
Cover illustration: Gentile Bellini (1429–1507) Procession on
St. Marks’s Square (Piazza San Marco) in Venice – 1496.
Series cover design: Sue Watson
Bizet’s
Edited by Mark Berry
and Nicholas Vazsonyi
Cover image: DLI Collection, Battle of Vittoria, 1813.
Acc No: 2386. Reproduced by permission of the
Trustees of the former DLI and the DLI Collection.
Cover design: Andrew Ward
Music in Context
C ambridge Introductions to M usic
Instrumental Music
in an Age of Sociability
Haydn, Mozart and Friends
W. Dean Sutcliffe
Edited by Richard Langham Smith
Fitch is a composer and musicologist specializing in Renaissance
and Clair Fabrice
Rowden
polyphony and its performance. His monograph Johannes Ockeghem:
topic in more depth
Masses and Models remains the only full-length monograph in English on
the composer, and he has published widely on Obrecht, Agricola, other
composers of that generation, and the Eton Choirbook. His compositions
have been performed by leading soloists and chamber ensembles and
broadcast internationally. He has been a reviewer with Gramophone for
over 25 years.
Fabrice Fitch
Renaissance
Polyphony
Music behind the Iron Curtain
Fitch 9780521899338 PPC. C M Y K
Each book in this series focuses on a topic fundamental to the study of music at
undergraduate and graduate level. The introductions will also appeal to readers
who want to broaden their understanding of the music they enjoy.
• Contain textboxes which highlight and summarise key information
• Provide
on specialised
Opera
onhelpful
theguidance
Global
Stagemusical terminology
• Thorough guides to further reading assist the reader in investigating the
Edited by
Kenneth Womack
WAGNER’S DER RING
DES NIBELUNGEN
‘Cambridge University Press is to be congratulated for formulating the idea of an
“Introductions to Music” series.’ Nicholas Jones, The Musical Times
Carmen Abroad
IN CONTEX T
elphick
Cambridge Introductions to Music
BEATLES
THE CAMBRIDGE COMPANION TO
Renaissance Polyphony
Carmen Abroad
This engaging study introduces Renaissance
polyphony to a modern audience. It helps readers of all ages and levels of experience make sense
of what they are hearing. How does Renaissance
music work? How is a piece typical of its style
and type; or, if it is exceptional, what makes it so?
The makers of polyphony were keenly aware of
the specialized nature of their craft. How is this
reflected in the music they wrote, and how were they regarded by their patrons
and audiences? Through a combination of detailed, nuanced appreciation of
musical style and a lucid overview of current debates, this book offers a glimpse
of meanings behind and beyond the notes, be they playful or profound. It will
enhance the listening experience of students, performers and music lovers alike.
Edited by Nancy November
Fitch
Longbottom
Cambridge Introductions to M usic
THE EROICA
SYMPHONY
IN CONTEX T
Listening for Leitmotifs:
Concept, Theory, Practice
Christian Thorau
9781107519473: Berry and Vazsonyi: CVR: C M Y K
ous Rhythm and Dance
h and South America
F. Nielsen
The Ring as a Political and
Philosophical Drama
Anthony Arblaster
THE
THE CAMBRIDGE COMPANION TO
The Beatles
aw of Balinese Rhythm
illey
ic Structures in Latin American
ribbean Music
Manuel
Part I Myth
Introduction
Mark Berry and Nicholas Vazsonyi
This Companion provides orientation for those embarking on the study of
Beethoven’s much-discussed Eroica Symphony, as well as providing fresh insights
that will appeal to scholars, performers and listeners more generally. The book
addresses the symphony in three thematic sections, on genesis, analysis and
reception history, and covers key topics including political context, dedication,
sources of the symphony’s inspiration, ‘heroism’ and the idea of a ‘watershed’
work. Critical studies of writings and analyses from Beethoven’s day to ours are
included, as well as a range of other relevant responses to the work, including
compositions, recordings, images and film. The Companion draws on previous
literature but also illuminates the work from new angles, based on new evidence
and a range of approaches by twelve leading scholars in Beethoven research.
Womack
ic Thought and Practice
ndian Subcontinent
Kippen
Edited by Mark Berry, Royal Holloway, University of London,
and Nicholas Vazsonyi, Clemson University
MUSIC
THE CAMBRIDGE COMPANION TO THE EROICA SYMPHONY
sical Rhythm of Agbadza Songs
ocke
Edited by Russell Hartenberger
and Ryan McClelland
November
Rhythm in Global Musics
An essential Companion for those both familiar and unfamiliar with Der Ring
des Nibelungen. It provides a concise introduction to both the composer and
the work. Subsequent chapters focus on musical topics such as “leitmotif” and
“structure” as well as popular culture, Nazism, notable stage productions and
critical analysis of the work.
THE CAMBRIDGE COMPANION TO
WAGNER’S DER RING DES NIBELUNGEN
in Contemporary Rap Music
l Ohriner
RHYTHM
Berry and Vazsonyi
ic Influence in the
evolution
de Clercq
MUSIC
THE CAMBRIDGE COMPANION TO
THE CAMBRIDGE COMPANION TO RHYTHM
Rhythm in Jazz and
r Music
ythm
allenge of “Swing”
w W. Butterfield
Hartenberger and McClelland
sts in time. From clapping
sponses of musicians and
ance of the musical beat.
time through a variety of
e topic, incorporating the
nd performers, and considering
.
Music behind
the Iron Curtain
Weinberg and his Polish Contemporaries
daniel elphick
For a full list of books in this discount, please visit
www.cambridge.org/BFE/RMA2021
ISSN
1478-5722
VOLUME 16
|
NUMBER 2
|
Quarterly
from
2020
New to
Cambridge
in 2020
New to
Cambridge
in 2020
Follow Cambridge Music on Twitter! @CambUP_Music
To find out more about Music from Cambridge,
visit www.cambridge.org/music
JUNE 2019
New publisher for the
RMA Journals from 2020
Cambridge University Press is delighted
that from January 2020 the Journal of the
Royal Musical Association and the Royal
Musical Association Research Chronicle
have been published in partnership with
the Press. The RMA’s two international
journals have joined a distinguished list
that includes twelve of the principal titles
in music and four in the performing arts.
Cambridge University Press and the Royal
Musical Association are working together
to ensure the continued excellence of these
two field-leading journals, both now and in
the future.
ABOUT THE FACULTY OF MUSIC, CAMBRIDGE
With its 19 academic and research staff, 10 affiliated lecturers, approximately 200
undergraduates and 75 postgraduate students, the Faculty of Music lies at the heart of a
vast network of musical study, research and practice. As a highly rated research centre, our
areas of special expertise include medieval and renaissance music, early modern music,
nineteenth-century music, opera, popular music, ethnomusicology, performance studies,
composition, and scientific approaches to music: research students, postdoctoral fellows,
college lecturers and distinguished international visitors work on a dizzying variety of topics.
The Faculty hosts the Cambridge Centre for Musical Performance Studies (CMPS), which
supports the work of the vast and unrivalled performance community in Cambridge and
provides a platform for practice-based research into musical performance and the Centre
for Music and Science (CMS). And our facilities are among the best in the country, including
a fully professional concert hall, a music library, and the Centre for Music and Science with
its purpose-built studio and music computing facilities. Period instruments and a Javanese
gamelan are available for student use. All this is complemented by the libraries, practice
rooms and other facilities available in colleges, as well as by the University Library—one of
the world’s great libraries, housing over seven million volumes. But more than anything it is
perhaps the larger musical environment that makes Cambridge so special.
Share your conference with us!
Use #CamMusSC2021 and tag us @CamUniMusic, @royalmusical
5
BRITISH FORUM FOR ETHNOMUSICOLOGY AND ROYAL
MUSICAL ASSOCIATION CONFERENCE CODE OF CONDUCT
The BFE and RMA are committed to delivering harassment-free conferences for everyone,
regardless of sex, gender identity and expression, sexual orientation, disability, physical
appearance, race, age, disciplinary affiliation, or religion or belief.
We do not tolerate harassment of conference participants in any form. Conference
participants violating these rules may be sanctioned or expelled from the online conference
at the discretion of conference organisers, and in accordance with the relevant policies of
the host institution (with additional consequences for BFE/RMA membership at the
discretion of the BFE Committee or RMA Council).
Harassment includes offensive verbal and written comments related to sex, gender identity
and expression, sexual orientation, disability, physical appearance, body size, race, age,
disciplinary affiliation, or religion or belief. It also includes intimidation, stalking, following,
harassing photography or recording, sustained disruption of talks or other events and
unwelcome sexual attention. Note that any online behaviour is subject to the same
standards of conduct as campus-based events.
Participants asked to stop any harassing behaviour are expected to comply immediately. If a
participant engages in harassing behaviour, conference organisers may take any action they
deem appropriate, including warning the offender or asking them to leave. This can include
a ban from further online conference and social sessions, as well as future online and
physical conferences and events.
If you are being harassed, notice that someone else is being harassed, or have other
concerns, please contact a conference organiser or session chair, who will be ensure that
the offence is dealt with or otherwise help participants feel safe for the duration of the
event.
This policy is based on the British Forum for Ethnomusicology conference code of conduct
and adapted for the online context.
6
RMA KEYNOTE SPEAKER
DR EMILY MACGREGOR
British Academy Postdoctoral Fellow in Music
at King’s College, London
Keynote Address
Tuesday, 12. January at 17:00
Chaired by Prof. Barbara Kelly
A Symphony in a Suitcase:
Genre and the Politics of Community and Exclusion
in (and beyond) 1933
7
ABSTRACT
On 21 March 1933, Kurt Weill fled Berlin, having heard he was on a Nazi blacklist following a wave of
arrests of prominent intellectuals that coincided with late February’s Reichstag fire. In his suitcase was
a completed draft of the opening movement of his Second Symphony. Caught up in the political
maelstrom of Berlin 1933 and tossed out again, Weill then completed his symphony in exile on the
outskirts of Paris in 1934. Yet despite prestigious performance platforms befitting a serious symphonic
work (the Amsterdam Concertgebouw under fellow exile Bruno Walter; the Carnegie Hall in New
York), critics denigrated Weill’s symphony as a collection of ‘expanded songs’ lacking any so-called
symphonic essence, and it was poorly received in both contexts. Reviewers refused to acknowledge it
as a ‘true symphony’, but the subtext was even graver: Weill, a Jewish, socialist composer
internationally famed for his popular theatre works with Brecht, was not deemed the right kind of
composer to be writing symphonies.
This central question, provoked by Weill’s symphonic reception, of the ‘right’ kind of
symphonic composer, and, underlying it, the complicity of the symphonic genre in shaping the
boundaries of hegemonic groups and value systems, has motivated my enquiries over the past few
years. These have centred on the symphony in the politically tumultuous year 1933—from Weill to
Florence Price—and the frequent stories from that time of both musicians and their music crossing
borders. In this paper, I argue broadly that symphonies and the written discourse around them can
illuminate colliding and changing political notions of selfhood and of space in the transnational
contexts of the early 1930s, thus suggesting new directions for scholarship on the symphonic genre.
The symphony’s history is entangled with a notion of selfhood oriented by Enlightenment and
nineteenth-century German-language philosophy and aesthetics (Bonds, Notley). Centring my
discussion on the transatlantic reception of Weill’s Symphony No. 2, and then concluding with
attention to Price’s Symphony in E minor, premiered in Chicago 1933, and now experiencing a longoverdue rehabilitation on recent concert programmes (see e.g. Brown, Ege, Shadle), I explore in
different settings how the symphonic genre is embroiled in mechanisms that policed (and still police)
ideas about subjectivity, constructions of race, and the politics of inclusion and community.
BIOGRAPHY
Emily MacGregor is a British Academy Postdoctoral Fellow in Music at King’s College, London.
Previously, she held a Marie Curie Global Fellowship at Harvard University (2016-18) and Royal
Holloway, University of London (2019), after completing her DPhil in Music at Oxford University in
2016. Her research focuses on the music and cultural history of Germany and North America in the
first half of the twentieth century. She has recently completed the manuscript of her first monograph
titled The Symphony in 1933, and is currently co-editing a volume with Arman Schwartz and Emily I.
Dolan titled Sonic Circulations 1900-1950 on music, science, and technology in the first half of the
twentieth century. Her new British Academy-funded book project at KCL explores music, technology,
and the experience of exile and diaspora in New York from 1930 to 1945. She has held visiting
fellowships at the Freie Universität in Berlin (DAAD) and at the Library of Congress, and her articles
are published in The Musical Quarterly, Critical Quarterly and Journal of Musicological Research. In
2019 she was awarded the RMA’s Jerome Roche Prize for a distinguished article by a scholar at an
early stage of their career.
8
BFE KEYNOTE SPEAKER
DR THOMAS R. HILDER
Associate Professor in Ethnomusicology
Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU)
Keynote Address
Wednesday, 13 January at 17:00
Chaired by Dr Simon McKerrell
Imagining Music Scholarship as Radical Care:
Stories of Research, Pedagogy, and Activism
9
ABSTRACT
This talk is a call for care, pedagogy, activism. I ask pressing questions about what it means to be a
music scholar in 2021, thinking through Black Lives Matter, #MeToo, decolonising academia,
pandemics, bullying, and brave spaces. While in a neoliberal imagination the contemporary
academic is presented as a free intellectual, entrepreneurial agent, they/she/he lives as an
embodied human, shaped by intersectional discriminations and privileges, and accountable to
different communities. I offer a holistic and relational view of a scholar as researcher, teacher, and
administrator with a multitude of responsibilities, potentialities, and vulnerabilities. Drawing on
feminist, Indigenous, and queer methods, I share autoethnographic stories of my own journey from
graduate student to associate professor, a path that led me via three European countries – the UK,
Germany, and Norway – and multiple academic institutions. First, I recall moments from my work on
Sámi Indigeneity and LGBTQ+ creativities and ask questions about the ethics of research as we learn
the trade of our disciplines. Why do we choose certain research projects, who do they benefit, what
are our obligations? Sharing scenes from the classroom, I then reveal my own call to teaching as I
began to look for emancipatory spaces within the neoliberal university. What legacies do we impose
on students, what do students need today, what is the knowledge we are morally compelled to
share? Finally, I trace my acknowledgement of the failures of the academy and my collaborative
attempts to transgress academic structures and build new spaces, such as the LGBTQ+ Music Study
Group, while being mindful of the co-option of social justice in the academy. What institutional
practices perpetuate abuse, how do we hack the system in order to resist injustice, how do we build
communities of radical care in a mental health pandemic? The talk offers a polyphony of voices who
urge us to imagine – through the body, the environment, the spiritual – new musical and scholarly
worlds.
BIOGRAPHY
Thomas R. Hilder is a writer, teacher, researcher, musician, activist, and associate professor in
ethnomusicology at NTNU. His experiments in scholarship, pedagogy, and outreach explore musical
performance, community, activism, well-being, virtuality, and the body, shaped by feminist, queer,
and postcolonial perspectives. He is author of “Sami Musical Performance and the Politics of
Indigeneity in Northern Europe” (2015) and co-editor of “Music, Indigeneity, Digital Media” (2015).
In 2016 he co-founded the international LGBTQ+ Music Study Group and currently acts as chair. At
the Department of Music at NTNU he runs the EDI group RILM. And he is chair of Trondheim’s queer
choir Kor Hen.
10
PLENARY TRAINING SESSIONS
POSTDOC PANEL
This panel will offer an overview of current postdoc opportunities available to PhD students and
early career researchers in music in the UK, Europe and the USA. Three speakers will each give short
presentations, followed by 30 minutes for Q&A.
Charlotte Bentley is currently a Research Fellow at Emmanuel College, Cambridge, and in 2019-20
she was a Teaching Fellow in Music Analysis, History and Philosophy at the Reid School of Music,
University of Edinburgh. Charlotte’s work explores transnational operatic networks in the nineteenth
century, and she is currently preparing a monograph about opera in New Orleans between 1819 and
1859.
Marco Ladd is a Research Fellow of Emmanuel College, Cambridge, having received his PhD in Music
History from Yale University in 2019. He is currently working on a book about film music in Italy
during the silent era; his work has been published in Opera Quarterly.
Vanessa Paloma Elbaz is a Research Associate on the ERC-funded project Past and Present Musical
Encounters Across the Strait of Gibraltar. A former Fulbright Senior Research Scholar, TALIM and
Posen Fellow, she received her PhD from Université Sorbonne Paris Cité. She is also an
internationally known performer of Sephardi musical repertoire.
Francesca Vella (Chair) is a British Academy postdoctoral fellow at the Faculty of Music, University of
Cambridge. She gained her PhD from King’s College London. Her work has focused on Verdi and
Italian nation-building, operatic mobility, early radio, and vocal celebrity culture. Her book
Networking Operatic Italy is forthcoming with the University of Chicago Press.
OFF THE BEATEN [ACADEMIC] TRACK: CAREER PATHS AFTER PG STUDY
Postgraduate study, whether at master’s or doctoral level, can lead to many kinds of career. In this
session a consultant, a librarian, an ethnomusicologist and sound archivist, a publisher and a radio
producer will talk and answer questions about how they got into their respective lines of work, and
how they get the most out of them. We’ll talk about the qualities that individual and collaborative
research, thesis design and preparation can bring to high-level employment in the creative industries
and the knowledge sector. Also questions of work-life balance, career progression,
entrepreneurship, and the move towards portfolio careers and progressive self-reinvention. Finally,
we’ll address strategies for personal and skills development in the time you don’t spend doing your
thesis research.
Some of the session will comprise conversation between the participants, but most will be built from
delegate questions, which you are welcome to send to Katharine Ellis (
[email protected]), panel
chair, before 5 January.
11
Panellists
Naomi Belshaw: Consultancy for Composers and Artists
Naomi has over a decade of experience having worked in various roles across the music industry
from Classical Account Manager for PRS for Music, Grants and Programmes Manager for PRS
Foundation and PR Executive and PR Manager at WildKat PR; also lending her insights to other
independent projects. Naomi has thus garnered a uniquely broad perspective of the music industry
with a wealth of experience in funding, publishing, licensing, royalties, PR, marketing and more.
Naomi works currently part-time at WidKat PR and also runs her own consultancy offering hourlypaid consultancy and long-term support to composers and artists.
https://naomibelshaw.com/
Chris Banks: Assistant Provost (Space) & Director of Library Services, Imperial College London
Chris wanted to be a detective before realising she could become a “musical detective”. She studied
music at Goldsmiths, gaining a B.Mus and then, whilst working part time at Foyles Bookshop and
then Travis & Emery, an M.Mus in Historical Musicology. She worked at English National Opera as
Assistant Librarian, then spent over 20 years at the British Library years in a variety of curatorial and
strategic roles in Music Collections, including as its Head. Since 2007 she has worked as University
Librarian / Director in HE, first at the University of Aberdeen and now at Imperial College London.
She sings with the London Philharmonic Choir.
Dr Victoria Cooper: Cooper Digital Publishing Ltd and Immersive Publishing Ltd
Victoria Cooper served as Senior Commissioning Editor for music and theatre books at Cambridge
University Press, publishing a wide range of titles, from monographs to student introductions and
popular titles for enthusiasts. Victoria recently moved into the development of digital projects,
founding her company, Cooper Digital Publishing Ltd, established to produce ebooks, apps and
digital products in the areas of the arts, fashion, and business. Victoria and James Fairclough recently
launched a new venture—Immersive Publishing Ltd—which will partner the new innovations of
augmented reality (AR) with the printed page, to create AR activated books in topics throughout the
book-selling industry.
Dr David Fay: Production Team, BBC Radio 3
David Fay is an Assistant Producer at BBC Radio 3, currently acting as a Producer and working on
programmes such as Essential Classics, In Tune and Record Review. His PhD (University of Bristol,
2015) combined semiotics with cultural history, reframing music analysis to focus on real life
listeners and the meanings they might generate from their listening experiences. Listening to music
is his real passion; he has written extensively about it including as the classical music columnist for
the Big Issue. He grew up in Nottinghamshire but now lives in North London, and loves cricket,
cycling, cooking and eating.
Dr Janet Topp Fargion: Head of Sound & Vision, The British Library
Dr Janet Topp Fargion is an ethnomusicologist with particular research interests in South Africa, the
Swahili Coast and ethnomusicology methodologies. From 1994 – June 2020 she has been Lead
Curator of World and Traditional Music at the British Library, with responsibility for recordings and
related materials documenting musical traditions from all around the world. She has is author of
Taarab Music in Zanzibar in the Twentieth Century: a story of ‘old is gold’ and flying spirits (Ashgate
Publishers, 2014). She was co-curator, with Dr Marion Wallace (the British Library’s Lead Curator,
Africa Collections) for the British Library’s major exhibition West Africa: Word, Symbol, Song
12
(October 2015 – February 2016). As of June 2020 she has moved to the broader role of Head of
Sound & Vision.
'AN AUDIENCE WITH... A PUBLISHER'
'An Audience with... a Publisher' will feature Kate Brett (Cambridge University Press) and Heidi
Bishop (Routledge). This is an exciting opportunity to ask experienced academic editors any
questions you might have about publishing. You will be able to submit questions to them in advance
or during the session.
Please use this form to submit questions: https://forms.gle/r1pCpfrDbLNLTA6V8
Dr Kate Brett has worked for Cambridge University Press for over 25 years. She commission books
on popular music, jazz, traditional music and world music, and western musical repertoire from the
Middle Ages to the present day.
Heidi Bishop worked on the Ashgate music series for 15 years and now continues to work for
Routledge. She commissions books on music education research, teaching and practice, popular
music, music and culture, theory and analysis, aesthetics, psychology of music, screen music, music
and gender, sociology of music, music and politics, classical music and opera from 1800 up to the
present day, and contemporary music.
EDI SESSION
EQUALITY, DIVERSITY AND INCLUSION IN MUSIC STUDIES: DISCUSSION SESSION
HOSTED BY THE EDIMS NETWORK AND THE LGBTQ+ STUDY GROUP
Part I - EDIMS
This student panel will be introducing the EDIMS (Equality, Diversity and Inclusion in Music Studies)
network and their working group, EDIMS Students & ECRs:Transitions. This will be followed by the
proposal of their plan for a community-driven online forum for UGs, PGs and ECRs in music studies,
where issues of diversity and inclusion in music academia can be addressed and discussed, and also
an interactive Q&A session, where they will collect suggestions and feedback from students as to
what is expected from the network, the working group and the online forum.
Biographies
Chamari Wedamulla, Kingston University
Chamari Wedamulla is a researcher in music education from Sri Lanka. As a music teacher in special
needs schools in the UK and overseas, her research focuses on interdisciplinary and inclusive music
teaching practices. She is currently studying her PhD in special music education and music therapy at
Kingston University. She is also a committee member of the EDIMS network (Equality, Diversity &
Inclusion in Music Studies) and the lead for the EDIMS working group, Students & ECRs: Transitions.
Niki Moosavi, Royal College of Music
13
Niki Moosavi is a fourth year undergraduate cellist at the Royal College of Music and the Diversity
Officer of the Student’s Union. She is a core member of the RCM’s Diversity Action Group and is
focusing on decolonising the curriculum and having more inclusive artistic programming. She
organised the first ever Black History Month concerts at RCM and has successfully implemented
curriculum changes in the vocal and chamber music syllabuses requiring study and performance of
works by underrepresented composers. Whilst at school, Niki wrote a paper comparing the
oppression of Shostakovich and Pussy Riot and has since been passionate for EDI in music.
Nellinne Ranaweera, Royal Northern College of Music
Nellinne Ranaweera is currently an independent scholar and Music Educator. She was awarded her
PhD in Music Psychology for the thesis entitled The role of leisure activities in the wellbeing of
musicians at Royal Northern College of Music, Manchester without amendments. Her thesis
explored the role of leisure activities in the wellbeing of musicians. Nellinne is also a Music educator
based in Stoke-on-Trent, UK for piano in the conventional and Suzuki methods and
Theory of music.
Nathan Holder, (https://www.nateholdermusic.com/about)
Nate Holder BA (Hons), MMus is a musician, author, speaker and music education consultant based
in London. He is an advocate for decolonising music education and has been writing, speaking and
consulting on the subject for the last five years. He has written three books called, 'I Wish I Didn't
Quit: Music Lessons', and 'Why Is My Piano Black and White' and 'Where Are All The Black Female
Composers'.
Dr Diljeet Kaur Bhachu
Dr Diljeet Kaur Bhachu is a Scottish-Indian researcher-activist-musician based in Glasgow and
Edinburgh. Diljeet is an activist with the Musicians’ Union (MU) and University and Colleges Union
(UCU). She is also the current vice-chair of the MU’s Scotland/Northern Ireland regional committee,
the STUC Black Worker’s Committee, and sits on the MU Equalities committee. She began her first
term as a member of the MU’s Executive Committee in January 2020 and is also an EDIMS appointed
researcher.
Part II – LGBTQ+
Student members of the LGBTQ+ Music Study Group will introduce its wider activities alongside the
RMA's LGBTQ+ Music Study Group, including its new mentoring scheme. They will discuss how the
study groups can collaborate with and learn from EDIMS in pursuit of a more intersectional
landscape for LGBTQ+ musicology.
The session will be convened by George K. Haggett, who is a second-year PhD student at the
University of Oxford, working on medievalism in contemporary opera. He has also worked in
university chaplaincy and is actively interested in inclusive models of pastoral care, especially for
trans students. He is a committee member of the LGBTQ+ Music Study Group and produces its
podcast, Bent Notes.
Jam Orrell is a musician and researcher based in the UK. She studied historical viola and viola
d'amore at the Royal Academy of Music and previously studied at the University of Oxford. Her
research focuses is in queer musicology, primarily looking at the experiences of trans and non-binary
musicians in Classical Music. She is currently applying for PhD programmes, looking at the
construction of trans identities in pop music.
14
MENTORING SESSIONS
We are delighted to be able to offer mentoring sessions for presenters in the conference where
students will have an informal space in which to discuss postdoctoral careers and life in academia.
Presenters have been sent information on how to sign up to the sessions. The mentors will be:
Charlotte Bentley is currently a Research Fellow at Emmanuel College, Cambridge, and in 2019-20
she was a Teaching Fellow in Music Analysis, History and Philosophy at the Reid School of Music,
University of Edinburgh. Charlotte’s work explores transnational operatic networks in the nineteenth
century, and she is currently preparing a monograph about opera in New Orleans between 1819 and
1859.
Annika Forkert is a Lecturer in Music at the Royal Northern College of Music. A musicologist
specialising in 20th-century British music, modernism, and female composers, she has worked in
different early career positions since her PhD in Music in 2014 (Royal Holloway, London). She
currently works on a monograph about composer Elisabeth Lutyens and conductor Edward Clark.
Marco Ladd is a Research Fellow of Emmanuel College, Cambridge, having received his PhD in Music
History from Yale University in 2019. He is currently working on a book about film music in Italy
during the silent era; his work has been published in Opera Quarterly.
Jacob Olley is a Leverhulme Early Career Fellow at the Faculty of Music, University of Cambridge. His
current research project is entitled ‘Debating Music in the Ottoman Press, 1876-1928’. He was
previously a Research Associate on the DFG project ‘Corpus Musicae Ottomanicae: Critical Editions
of Near Eastern Music Manuscripts’. He completed a PhD in music at King’s College London in 2017.
Vanessa Paloma Elbaz is a Research Associate on the ERC-funded project Past and Present Musical
Encounters Across the Strait of Gibraltar. A former Fulbright Senior Research Scholar, TALIM and
Posen Fellow, she received her PhD from Université Sorbonne Paris Cité. She is also an
internationally known performer of Sephardi musical repertoire.
Francesca Vella is a British Academy postdoctoral fellow at the Faculty of Music, University of
Cambridge. She gained her PhD from King’s College London. Her work has focused on Verdi and
Italian nation-building, operatic mobility, early radio, and vocal celebrity culture. Her book
Networking Operatic Italy is forthcoming with the University of Chicago Press.
Stephen Wilford is a Research Associate within the Faculty of Music at Cambridge and a Junior
Research Fellow of Wolfson College Cambridge. Stephen’s work focuses upon North African musics,
particularly those of Algeria, and spans a range of traditional and contemporary styles. He is
currently a member of both the national committee of the British Forum for Ethnomusicology, and
the Ethnomusicology-Ethnochoreology committee of the Royal Anthropological Institute.
15
THEMED PANELS
“GUSTAV MAHLER: NEW PERSPECTIVES ON HIS LIFE AND WORKS”
The Gustav Mahler Research Centre Student Network is pleased to submit this application for a
themed session titled ‘Gustav Mahler: New Perspectives on his life and works.’ The study of Gustav
Mahler remains to be one of the more popular areas of musicological study, and yet there is still a
great need for a rethinking of the approaches to Mahler scholarship. The members of the GMRC
Student Network are establishing themselves as the next generation of Mahler scholars that
endeavour to rethink current scholarship and create new and innovative areas of research for the
study of Gustav Mahler’s music. Founded earlier this year, the GMRC Student Network is a
community of PhD and Early Career Researchers from a range of European universities and Higher
Education institutions, whose work and interests centre around Gustav Mahler’s œuvre. The RMA
student conference acts as a privileged space for three of the founders of our organisation to share
their research and present the latest developments in the field, as well as raise awareness to the
existence of our organisation and the importance of rethinking current approaches to Mahler
research.
While the session is undoubtedly held together by the common thread of Gustav Mahler, it
is our vision that the session will offer a diverse set of perspectives into the study of the composer’s
works, and demonstrate the range of critical approaches that can be undertaken in contemporary
Mahler Research. Each paper would contribute to distinct areas of the latter, namely philology and
orchestration, issues of intertextuality and aesthetics, and history of reception. In her paper, Naito
shall tackle the well-known, yet murky philological issue of the order of the movements in Mahler’s
Second Symphony, retracing each stage of the compositional process from a variety of textual
sources and taking into account structurally decisive aspects of the orchestration. Arkle’s research
centres around the complex network of intertextual references and allusions across Mahler’s Songs
and Symphonies, focusing on the currently undocumented allusions to Richard Wagner’s Parsifal
across his compositions. Finally, Verti’s paper offers a commentary on the Seventh Symphony’s
controversial history of reception highlighting the evolution of its ironical exegesis, from the very
first reviews to the analysis of contemporary scholars. We also kindly request for our session to be
chaired by our Network co-founder Vanessa Carlone.
PLAN ‘C’: COVID & CREATIVITY
How can we preserve and even enrich our creative practices in the Post-COVID ‘new normal’? This
session will present some practical answers from the Western and Eastern worlds, based on case
studies in the following three thematic areas:
- Creative Pedagogy: Teaching and Community Music Making in Times of COVID
- Composition & Musical Expression in Times of COVID
- Virtual Presence as a Performer in Times of COVID
Nine pre-recorded short student video presentations will be accompanied by a brief introduction
and a few comments by each of the participants, followed by a panel discussion. The session
provides a lively platform for students and recent graduates (now enrolled in postgraduate
programmes around the world) from three educational institutions with a strong history of
16
collaboration (Cardiff University, Princess Galyana Vadhana Institute of Music, Bangkok, and Raffles
Institution, Singapore) to present their ideas. And it will introduce creative projects catalysed by
COVID-19 that will continue long after the lockdown is over. The aim is to inspire others and to
create a platform to for exchanges of ideas and future collaboration. The session is sponsored by the
Royal Musical Association’s Southeast Asia Chapter.
Theme I: Creative Pedagogy: Teaching and Community Music Making in Times of COVID
See Ning Hui (Raffles Institution/Royal College of Music, London)
Ye Ya Jie (Genevieve) (Cardiff University)
Tian Ke-Xin (Raffles Institution/New England Conservatory of Music, Boston)
Theme II: Composition & Musical Expression in Times of COVID
Khetsin (Pleum) Chuchuan (PGVIM, Bangko/Iceland University of the Arts)
Jerry Yue Zhuo (Cardiff University)
Taratawan (Tuntun) Krue (PGVIM, Bangkok/Goldsmiths University, London)
Kawirat (Tintin) Saimek (PGVIM)
Theme III: Virtual Presence as a Performer in Times of COVID
Ng Xin-Yu (Nicole) (Royal College of Music, London)
Zé Kouyaté (Gaio) (Cardiff, Bath Spa and Bristol Universities)
QUEER MUSICAL METHODOLOGIES
In their editorial statement for the winter 2016 issue of Women’s Studies Quarterly, Matt Brim and
Amin Ghaziani pose a question: ‘what if a high-profile academic conference in 1990 had ushered in
an enterprise called “queer methods” rather than “queer theories”?’. 1 The question, they suggest, is
a ‘surprisingly plausible’ one if we consider that the methods of queer theory have always been, to a
certain extent, queer. The papers in this panel draw in different ways upon the methodologies of
this subdiscipline that came of age almost thirty years ago.
Queer musicology has confronted the latent hegemonies of gay and lesbian studies in more recent
years. From the materialities of voice expounded by trans musicologists to the intersectional inroads
and renewed emphases on embodied knowledge of queer of colour critique, new voices have
brought with them new methodologies. In this panel, student members of the LGBTQ+ Music Study
Group explore queer ways of doing music studies along some of the lines of twenty-first-century
queer politics. Grassroots communities are reflected back in the faces of baroque stock characters,
trans femme voices etch power into vulnerability, and queer ecologies sound out a new
hermeneutics of difference.
The music heard in these papers spans four centuries, but each in their own way reconnects
with the present. While Cathal Twomey finds models of asexual desire familiar to twenty-first
century asexual communities in seventeenth-century Venetian opera, Dylan Price brings pressing
issues of class- and climate-consciousness to bear on the queer spaces and bodies of Britten. Jam
Orrell in turn reaches into the past to take stock of past conceptions of ‘disembodied’ trans music,
1
Matt Brim and Amin Ghaziani. 'Introduction: Queer Methods'. Women's Studies Quarterly 44, no. 3/4 (2016):
14.
17
asking how a trans femme artist can transcend the discursive boundaries which history has drawn
around her. This panel takes as read diversities of gender and attraction—the queerness of its
makeup—and offers a glimpse of the breadth and depth of queer musical methodologies
undertaken by research students today. Yet for all of our nascent ways of doing things we are, in
Wayne Koestenbaum’s queerest of pitches, still ‘musical’.2
2
Wayne Koestenbaum, 'Queering the Pitch: A Posy of Definitions and Impersonations', in Queering the Pitch:
The New Gay and Lesbian Musicology, ed. Philip Brett, Gary C. Thomas, and Elizabeth Wood (New York; London:
Routledge, 1994).
18
INDIVIDUAL ABSTRACTS IN ALPHABETICAL ORDER
Colonial history and contemporary perceptions of Western classical music in Indonesia: the cases
of Jakarta, Bandung, and Yogyakarta
Aniarani Andita, Royal Holloway
Under Dutch colonialism, Western classical music had been publicly performed in the Indonesian
archipelago since the early nineteenth century. Up to Indonesian independence in 1945, these
performances mostly took place in cities such as Batavia (now Jakarta), Bandung, Yogyakarta, and
Surabaya, and were mainly reserved for the Europeans. Since independence, classical music has
been practiced by Indonesians in various ways. Yet, how this contemporary practice relates to the
history remains under researched. My research explores this issue, by taking on Jakarta, Bandung,
and Yogyakarta as case studies.
During my fieldwork in the three cities between November 2019 to March 2020, I surveyed
audiences and interviewed performance producers and musicians/composers of classical music. I
particularly pay attention to how they discuss classical music, e.g. what words do they use to
describe classical music, and what sorts of images that they have in mind when they hear the term
“Western classical music.” As an Indonesian myself, I see this paper as a start of a wider discussion
about how our perceptions –what we think we know—about Western classical music might be
informed by the history of classical music performances which intertwines with that of Dutch
colonialism. Furthermore, I explore how I try to navigate my subjectivity and position as a
researcher, as I must constantly reflect on my own experience both as an Indonesian and a classical
musician trained in the West.
Listening to Mahler, Hearing Wagner: The allusions to Richard Wagner’s Music Dramas in Gustav
Mahler’s Songs and Symphonies
Genevieve Robyn Arkle, University of Surrey
It is known that, throughout his life, Gustav Mahler cultivated a keen interest in both the music and
aesthetics of Richard Wagner; so much so that in 1894 he wrote to his sister Justine claiming that he
felt Wagner ‘belonged a little bit to my family.’ Yet, while research into Mahler’s relationship with
Wagner’s works are becoming more prominent in the field of Mahler Studies Research, discussions
of the musical legacy of Wagner’s dramas on Mahler’s songs and symphonies are still very much in
their infancy. This paper, therefore, aims to fill a gap in the current research by offering an insight
into the Wagnerian allusions and references in Mahler’s works, specifically focusing on Mahler’s
allusions to passages of Wagner’s final music drama, Parsifal.
This paper will begin by more broadly considering the Wagnerian allusions and references
that have already been established in Mahler’s works, before presenting a detailed discussion of the
appearance of two motives from Wagner’s Parsifal, the Heilandsklage [‘Saviour’s Lament’] and the
Waldesrauschen [‘Nature’s Healing’,] in Mahler’s songs and symphonies, references which have not
been discussed in any literature to date. By investigating these allusions through the lens of topic
theory and musical semantics, this paper intends offer an original perspective on Mahler’s works in
light of these Wagnerian and Parsifalian themes, and demonstrate the necessity of reevaluating
Mahler’s compositions in light of his intimate relationship with the music and aesthetics of Richard
Wagner.
19
Orientalist Flowers in Robert Schumann’s Myrthen
Anhad Arora, University of Oxford
This paper investigates the motive of the Orientalist flower in Robert Schumann’s “Liederkreis”,
Myrthen, Op.25, the marital book gifted to Clara Wieck on their wedding day, 12th September 1840,
arguing that an appraisal of the significance of Orientalist floral motives is central to an
understanding of Schumann’s collection. Setting a broad range of Orientalist poetry – from Goethe’s
West-östlicher Divan through Heine’s ‘Die stille Lotosblume’ to Friedrich Rückert’s Östliche Rosen –
Myrthen presents a significant engagement with the Orientalist flower in its myriad forms: as the
cultural practice of Blumensprache, laid out in Goethe’s accompanying notes to the Divan, the Noten
und Abhandlungen zum besseren Verständnis des Divans (1819); as a symbolic topos of imaginative
possibility; and as an interactive metaphor for the inner poetic essence of Oriental devotion. The
paper concludes by advocating a mode of appraising Orientalist Lieder that returns to primary
literary sources in order to shed light on how the venerable cultural history of the Orient in the
nineteenth-century German-speaking imagination informed the production, symbolic content and
direction of Robert Schumann’s Liederheft. Consequently, a close study of Myrthen not only offers
the opportunity to interrogate the place of Orientalism in this intimate marital context, but also to
shape our understanding of Schumann’s Lied Orientalism as a textual phenomenon that aims to
effect rapprochements between Orient and Occident.
‘Another bed I shouldn’t crawl out of’: Pleasure and precarity in the country music one-night
stand
James Barker, Newcastle University
Songs about one-night stands in country music often negotiate between moralistic censoriousness
around sexuality and the consequences of gendered power dynamics that impact casual sexual
encounters. In the 1960s and 1970s, artists such as Loretta Lynn and Dolly Parton lambasted the
social double-standards between men and women: men could have sex freely, but women had to
bear the consequences (‘ruined’ reputation, abandonment and pregnancy); one-night stands
became a dangerous manifestation of men’s mistreatment and neglect of women. Nevertheless
one-night stands also held the potential for sexual fulfilment, for example in Merrilee Rush’s ‘Angel
of the Morning’. In the genre of country music, social stigma and isolation were represented as the
risks taken for the possibility of sexual pleasure.
More recent country songs exploring one-night stands still reckon with this legacy. This
paper will analyse Miranda Lambert’s 2016 single ‘Vice’ to explore how the one-night stands
referred to in the song are represented as a source of pleasure, free from moral censoriousness; yet
are also represented as a coping mechanism for loneliness and heartache. This analysis will use a
queer theoretical framework (José Esteban Muñoz; Michael Cobb) around ideas of intimacy and
ways of relating to suggest a way to navigate the limits of reductive discourses of sexual
(im)propriety and sex positivity. By representing sex as neither inherently ‘ruining’ nor inherently
liberatory, Lambert’s ‘Vice’ articulates the complex psychological and relational dynamics within
these experiences.
20
Temporal Affect as Ecocritical Discourse: Sounding Multiple Temporalities in the UK Folk Music
Scene
Rowan Bayliss Hawitt University of Edinburgh
In recent years, the British folk music scene has borne witness to multiple projects and
collaborations which take the natural world and (anthropogenic) landscapes as their point of
departure. Building on an extensive history of political and environmental folksong, these
contemporary eco-conscious folk musicians are particularly attentive to the fact that they are
negotiating the parameters of human-nature relationships at the point of a climate emergency.
Much like the rhetoric around this climate emergency, such ‘ecological’ folk music often
demonstrates both an understanding of the past and aspirations for the future. Questions of time
and how humans and nonhumans alike experience it are therefore recurrent tropes in contemporary
folk music in the UK; quotidian ‘clock’ time, ‘deep’ or ‘geological’ time, and nonlinear temporalities
are intertwined with musical time in this repertoire. While much literature has addressed the
relationship between time and music (e.g. Kramer 1988; Taylor 2016), musical understandings of
time from an ecocritical perspective remain virtually non-existent. This paper will utilise musical and
discourse analyses alongside perspectives from critical time studies to comprehend how British folk
music can index temporalities within and beyond the human scale. Drawing on case studies from
across the UK, I suggest that understanding how time acts as a tool of power and informs our
relationality to the natural world is central to uncovering folk music’s contribution to ecocritical
discourse.
Playing with the limits of expression: the Kreisler character in the original version of Brahms’s
Piano Trio in B major (1854)
Anna Belinszky, Liszt Ferenc Academy of Music (Budapest, Hungary)
In the early 1850s, Johannes Brahms signed several of his works as Johannes Kreisler, explicitly
referring to the literary figure of E. T. A. Hoffmann. His correspondence with his friends, including
Clara Schumann, Joseph Joachim and Julius Otto Grimm, also demonstrates his identification with
Kreisler and, through him, with certain artistic and aesthetic principles of early German romanticism.
Although this fact is often remembered in the Brahms literature, only a few studies have examined
the musical implications of this identification in detail.
Fantasy, creativity, improvisation, the artist’s self-discovery, playing with the limits of expression or
the inexpressible, and experimenting with fragments and sketches are all recurring motives in
Hoffmann’s musical writings and Brahms’s early pieces. Being one of the composer’s most
conflicting works, the early version of Brahms’s Piano Trio in B major shows meaningful impacts of
this Kreisler character and the diverse musical principles it represents. In my presentation I argue
that a parallel reading of Hoffmann’s texts and Brahms’s music can open up new perspectives in
understanding the trio, especially some of its most distinctive parts that Brahms revised or cut out
from the music when he rewrote it in 1889. Connecting the trio’s unusual compositional techniques,
ideas and extra-musical references, I introduce possible ways to understand Hoffmann’s effect on
Brahms’s musical thinking.
21
Inventing the exotic Estonian: the reception to Veljo Tormis’ Raua needmine
Cole Bendall, University of Edinburgh
In what he described as his “broader view” of musical exoticism, Ralph P. Locke (2007) notes a
historic “blinkered scholarly response” to the paradigm and suggests that exotic elements can be
defined on wider terms of representation and process. Exoticism is, in essence, a preoccupation with
different music from other spaces, with all the well-known, problematic issues encountered therein.
I make the case that such exotic approaches could be found in Western reception to creative works
(art, literature and music) from Soviet republics: in particular, the Estonian SSR. While art and music
in Soviet borderlands often saw reduced restrictions compared to that in Moscow, the spaces these
works occupied often limited them to discussing their identity and locality, therefore amplifying the
dualist rhetoric of the East-West dichotomy.
Using aspects of postcolonial and reception theory, this paper explores responses to Veljo
Tormis’s (1930-2017) most well-known choral work, Raua needmine (Curse upon Iron, 1972) as a
case study. The work invokes traditions from Estonian folklore and shamanism to construct an
allegory of the evils of war and has, particularly in the USA and Europe, been considered a fierce
polemic of the actions of the Soviet Union. Understanding Raua needmine and its reception
illustrates a complex and hybrid range of judgements of Tormis’s style and Estonian choral music in
the 20th century – much of which can be both restated and contested.
Which Music? Nobody Plays… Nobody Knows Towards an Ethnomusicological Approach to TikToks
Musicking
Juan Bermúdez, University of Vienna (Austria)
New technologies and media have not only become an integral part of our lives, but also an
inseparable part of our ethnographic work. Musicians use social media and other digital technologies
to represent and market themselves, but also other stakeholders construct and participate in the
discourse around these musical practices via these media. Yet, digital natives are experiencing new
media in a more intense and more confidential way, perceiving them as an extension of their own
reality. This has enabled them not only to construct new mixed and virtual identities, but also to
make increasingly clearer the interrelation and interconnectedness between physical and virtual
multi-local spaces, and to act more fluidly in their musical practices and knowledge constructions.
This appropriation of the virtual worlds, as well as the development of new virtual platforms,
provided new spaces to develop new forms of musical practices.
I am going to present my work on virtual music practices exemplified on the app TikTok, in
order to discuss methodological and theoretical possibilities and challenges of musical
ethnographies in virtual worlds. Proposing to conceive our musical practices as auditory expressions,
that different interacting physical and virtual identities perform and experience in asynchronously
networked multi-local spaces, I suggest that a digital performance can be, aside from a
representation of reality, an integral part of it, and likewise, contribute to the construction of an
extended lived world.
22
From extraordinary success to no considerable results: Victorian music entrepreneurialism and the
Crystal Palace Brass Band Competition 1860-1863
Philip Boardman, University of York
The July 1860 Crystal Palace Brass Band contest brought brass bands out of their heartlands to
London in unprecedented numbers, The Times describing the success of the contest as ‘quite
extraordinary’3. Such was the scale of this landmark event that it was repeated in successive years.
However, the termination of the contest in 1863 has stood in stark contest to its presumed triumph
and no cogent explanation has been established for its failure after four short years. The
entrepreneur organising the contests, Enderby Jackson, had already displayed an aptitude for
managing large-scale brass-band events in the decade preceding the 1860 contest. Jackson made full
use of his talents and contacts to bring these remarkable working-class musical ensembles to the
emergent national attraction that was the Crystal Palace. However, Jackson’s manipulation of
publicity and managerial style obfuscated easy analysis of each contest. Moreover, Jackson later
sought to protect his legacy by conjuring a smokescreen in his memoirs to obscure the real reasons
for the failure of the Crystal Palace Contests after 1863. This article will examine previously
unconsidered letters, surviving documentation, and other sources that case doubt on whether the
contest series was ever an extraordinary success. In doing so it will provide insights into the
organisation and working methods of the Victorian impresario that was Enderby Jackson.
Unveiling musical freedoms: A critical analysis of creative processes in Afghan music education
Lauren Braithwaite, University of Oxford
Institutional music education in Afghanistan is increasingly recognised as a space in which the
country’s gender inequalities and social power imbalances are being challenged through the
promotion of values such as democracy, freedom, and human rights. These neoliberal principles
were at the forefront of a collection of patriotic song videos released by the Afghanistan National
Institute of Music (ANIM) on the 100th anniversary of Afghanistan’s Independence in August 2019.
One song in particular, Azadi (‘Freedom’), presents the image of a female pianist gradually losing her
headscarf over the duration of her solo, thus contributing yet another unveiling spectacle to the
discourse of the female body as a marker for assessing liberation in Afghanistan (Fluri, 2009).
However, by looking beyond the banal signifiers of freedom, gender equality, and women’s rights
presented in Azadi’s music video, this paper will argue that the discursive practices of music
education in Afghanistan actually enact and reproduce patriarchal dominance, gender inequality,
and power imbalances. Through an analysis of three nodal points in the creative process—
composition, rehearsal, and performance—this paper suggests that familiar tropes of men as
agentive producers and women as submissive reproducers (Green, 1997) can be observed and which
destabilise the neoliberal claims made by the audio-visual ‘text’. This assertion problematises the
view that actors within the field of music education in Afghanistan are disrupting social realities and
contributing to tangible change in social practices. Finally, this paper will discuss the implications of
this analysis for critically assessing social change assertations made by educational institutions in
(post)-conflict zones.
3
The Times, July 12, 1860
23
Towards an ecological sustainability: role of Ghanaian traditional music
Joshua O. Brew, University of Pittsburgh (USA)
Ghanaian traditional music and its material music cultures depend primarily on the environment in
its creation and performance processes-- but are these practices environmentally friendly? All
Ghanaian traditional musical instruments are made from plants and animal resources; however,
Ghanaian researchers and musicians seem indifferent about the natural ecosystems which make
music-making possible. The situation is evident in the scanty literature on Ghanaian traditional
music's role in environmental protection and sustainability. This study, thus, aims to focus on how
the music tradition ameliorates or aggravates the environment. It seeks to investigate further the
role of Ghanaian traditional music and musicians in addressing the sustainability of the ecology
during the current global climate crisis. Through an ethnographic method of data collection, the
findings will be interpreted and framed within the concepts of Music sustainability and ecomusicology.
‘In every creature, a spark of God’: Empathy in Janáček’s From the House of the Dead
Kerry Bunkhall, Cardiff University
On the manuscript of Janáček’s final opera, From the House of the Dead (1928), he inscribed the
phrase, ‘In every creature, a spark of God.’ Telling the tale of inmates in a Siberian prison, the opera
exposes the audience to the harsh realities of violence and imprisonment. The semiautobiographical book on which the opera is based, Dostoevsky’s 1862 novel Notes From the House
of the Dead, shows the main character’s understanding of the rich life tapestries of the inmates and
the inequalities of the justice system. Although the opera delves into the darkness, claustrophobia
and grit of life in a Siberian prison, Janáček sheds a light on the inner humanity of the complex and
dangerous inmates.
Focussing on the portrayal of the troubled inmate Skuratov, this paper considers how
Janáček ignites the ‘spark of God’ through creating the audience’s sense of empathy for the
prisoners. As the audience is subjected to a traumatic monologue detailing Skuratov’s crimes which
bears witness to his descent into madness, this characterisation offers a prime example of Janáček’s
mastery of emotion and psychology. This will be investigated through exploring his techniques of
musical realism, his characteristic ‘speech melody’, motivic development and his relationship with
the original subject matter. Each of these factors contributes to Janáček’s instilling of empathy in the
audience, creating a sense of connection on a human level.
“We Built this City on Rock ‘n’ Rubab: The Institutionalisation of Music Integration Programmes for
Migrants in Germany”
Rose Campion, University of Oxford
In response to the influx of forced migrants granted asylum in Germany since 2015, many
governmental institutions have promoted the two-way process of ‘integration’ as the best approach
for incorporating these individuals into society. In addition to initiatives in housing and job
placements, many communities are increasingly turning to music and the arts to foster cultural and
social cohesion. While music possesses limited functionality as a ‘universal language’ for facilitating
cross-cultural communication, aspects of these community music programmes do seem to succeed
in bringing people together across linguistic and cultural divides.
24
Based on an ethnography conducted in North-Rhine Westphalia, this presentation will
explore the methods by which amateur music programmes create spaces where this so-called
‘integration’ can transpire. To uncover the means by which these norms and values of inclusion
emerge, I will apply aspects of institutional theory to one such programme: a monthly jam session
hosted at a migrant resource centre. Comparing this case against models of institutionalisation
(Giddens, 1984; Scott, 1995) illustrates how such programmes legitimise their organisational goals
through the act of collective music-making. This point where individual actions and institutional
structures converge exposes the ways participatory music projects can foster not only localised
relationships, but broader societal change as well.
Combining elements from the ancient Chinese and contemporary art music worlds: some critical
reflections on the hybridizing of compositional methods, aesthetics and playing techniques
Jia Cao, Durham University
In this paper, I critically explore the compositional methods behind two of my recent compositions.
The pieces have been selected to represent my personal development as a performer-composer
committed to research-through-composition, addressing different yet related compositional
techniques. I elucidate how features of harmony, structure and melodic-rhythmic patterning have
been generated and manipulated, revealing how my compositional thinking has progressed. In
particular, I focus on my attempts to integrate Chinese and Western instrumental techniques and
sonorities, a major theme in my work, also considering how my approaches in this area have drawn
from and differed from those of other composers. The presentation is split into two sections. In the
first section, I assess the methods behind my piece “Interrupted Dream” (2018), for mezzo-soprano,
flute, violoncello and piano, considering how the aforementioned theories have been realized in
conjunction with the hybridization of elements from kunqu opera and various Western sources and
contemplating the challenges of achieving logical structure and coherent relationships between
thematic materials. In the second section, I introduce my more recent work, “Before and After”
(2019), for piano trio (piano, violin and cello), examining the same theoretical applications and my
new efforts at hybridization, specifically honing in on my experiments in transferring playing
techniques and sonorities from the erhu and guzheng to Western stringed instruments. In addition
to reflecting upon compositional methods from first conception to complete products, this paper
also touches upon salient issues surrounding notation, recognizing that processes of hybridization
also necessarily shape how music is represented.
Limassol Carnival Serenades: A non-tradition tradition
Charalambous Chara, University College Cork
Limassol Carnival is the only known carnival in the world that includes serenades within its
celebrations. Originated in the Ionian islands, a serenade is a romantic love song or a poem that is
traditionally sung by men only in a waltz rhythm. Additionally, it is accompanied by guitars,
mandolins and accordions. As a music genre, it also has signs of Italian influence. Even though a
serenade is a love song, the Limassol Carnival Serenades serve a different meaning and purpose.
Despite the fact that both traditions keep similar foundations, the Limassol Carnival Serenades
through their lyrics and melodies, glorify the city, its carnival, indulgence and dancing.
In this paper, I demonstrate the importance of the tradition, not only for the city of Limassol
but for the island itself. I conduct in-depth interviews with serenaders to investigate whether the
25
Limassol Carnival Serenades should be considered as a traditional music genre of Cyprus or a
folkloristic aspect of it. Through fieldwork and archival research in folklore, tradition, festivalisation
and identity, I aim to call attention to the cultural importance of the Limassol Carnival Serenades.
Additionally, I situate the case within research on other festivals to find any similarities or
differences regarding identity and the sociocultural stability that prevails in the country.
Conclusively, the main aim of the research is to develop, preserve and promote the tradition both
locally and abroad so that it could act as a starting point for further research in the future.
Scriabin’s Poem of Ecstasy: temporality and formal affordance
Leo Charlier, University of Oxford
This paper aims to understand the temporal and metaphysical implications of the Poem of Ecstasy,
by means of the collisions between different organising forms and the kind of listening or attention
they specify. Scriabin studies are often caught between untangling the self-propagated orpheic
mythology surrounding the composer and his personal beliefs, and a taxonomic inquiry into
technical aspects of the harmonic and formal organisation of his works, which has earned
accusations of "formalism". I employ a methodology based on drawing together the work of Caroline
Levine (2015) in literary and sociological criticism, and Eric Clarke's perceptual ecology (2012), using
their common adoption of the concept of "affordance" as a starting point for understanding how
formal structures contribute to the perception of time in the Poem, and their relation to teleology.
A selective analysis of the piece reveals the collision of a number of forms with different,
interacting properties; for instance,"sonata form" has little valency in compared to more powerful
organising forms, which nullify or override the potential characteristics of a large-scale tripartite
structure. More broadly, this foregrounds complex relationship between reception history, musical
form, and social practice in the construction of generic categories, and has potential implications for
an approach to analysis which questions rigid binaries such as intra- vs. extra-musical, and the
ontology of "form" as a category.
Between Theater and “Digital Archive” of lüju Fans: Cultural Memory and Remediation of a
Chinese Regional Opera in the Digital Age
Chen Chen, The Chinese University of Hong Kong
Lüju (lü opera) of Shandong province as the major regional operatic genre and folk tradition in China,
nowadays, has been transformed and reinvented as cultural heritage, educational and propaganda
tools of the party-state, attractions of cultural tourism, and trigger of nostalgic desires of both
cultural practicers and experiencers. In this sense, lüju theaters, museums, state-owned/private
troupes, and educational institutes have become the sites of memory, entangling with multiple
actors and forces from political entities, cultural economy, and local initiatives. Those memory
institutions perform as vehicles for renewing cultural past and forming collective memories of the
society.
In this new cultural realm, the voices of individuals, who are the lüju fans, are rarely
inscribed into the memory sites and official historiographies. Intending to anchor their voices,
the lüju fans, especially the young generation, turn to cyberspace. They built "digital archives" upon
the Internet, through remediating and recollecting memories and resources of lüju from various
established mediums, including oral transmissions, novels, opera films, recordings, and theatrical
materials. Therefore, lüju fans' actions have formed "digital cultural memory" of lü opera, enacting
26
intersubjectivity lying in their online interactions. This article draws on insights from memory studies
and media studies to excavate the amnesias, entanglements, and contestations between memory
institutions and digital archives of lüju fans. Online activities of lüju fans in refashioning the cultural
past of a folk tradition are not merely inscribing its cultural memory in the present, but also
generating new circulation to the future.
Singing and Inheriting Classics: Popularised Traditional Chinese (Lecture Recital)
Teng Chen, University of Southampton
“Everlasting Classics” is a very successful poem-music culture program that has aired on Chinese
Central Television since February 2018. The guiding principle of the show is to "bring the classics into
the public eye and revitalise tradition”, with the traditional aesthetics and rhythms of ancient poetry
as its core appeal. The show has benefitted from the judicial utilisation of mass communication and
a diverse variety of music forms that has further strengthened its appeal. What are the reasons
behind this traditional show’s runaway success at this point in modern history?
This essay will delve into the theoretical basis behind this trend of cultural regression with
the help of ethnomusicology and the theoretical framework of hermeneutics, discussing the
relationship between poems and songs in ancient China. It will also attempt to interpret the
historical significance of The Book of Poetry from which we have gleaned how the ancient Chinese
people constructed and strengthened their inner spiritual worlds, infusing their epistemology,
cosmology, and ideology with traditional music. This paper will also discuss the standing of singing
poetry in broader social terms, its return in today’s context, and the potential rejuvenation of
Chinese culture in the future. The author holds that poetry-music can be a conduit between a
nation's spiritual and cultural identities when integrated into its social practices. At the end of the
presentation, I will demonstrate my own attempt at the aforementioned “integration of poetrymusic” with a famous poem (written by Wang Wei around AD730~741) accompanied by Guqin.
The changing voice of Anastasia Robinson, 1715-1720
Sarah Jillian Cox, Royal Birmingham Conservatoire
Anastasia Robinson (c1695 – 1755) was one of few English singers whose success in the early days of
Italian opera in London rivalled that of the imported Italians. However, in most modern
encyclopaedias her name is generally found as a mere footnote to the powerful men around her,
such as her importance to the development of Handel’s London operatic career, or in the context of
her notorious affair with, and secret marriage to, the nobleman and military leader, Lord
Peterborough. When mentioned in her own right, she is often dismissed as a secondary singer owing
to an unnamed illness which Burney (1789) claims damaged and altered her voice from Soprano to
Contralto.
This paper explores the vocal profile and abilities of Robinson during her career in opera in
London from 1715 to 1720. Through an analysis of the range, tessitura and complexity of roles
written for her around the time of her voice change, it reveals that, not only did Robinson not suffer
from vocal damage, but also that her voice change coincided with a change of teacher. Building
on Gackle’s research (2011) into female pubertal voice change, and drawing upon both the evidence
in the vocal scores themselves and biographical details (which indicate the likelihood that she was in
her mid-to-late teens at her debut), this paper reveals not only that Robinson’s voice change was
27
normal given her age, but also that once again Burney’s colourful opinions of singers from before his
own lifetime should finally be laid to rest.
(Re)shaping Image and Performance: The impact of commercial Irish dance shows on women
musicians
Joanne Cusack, Maynooth University
This paper analyses the impact of Irish dance shows on women musicians in Irish traditional music.
The creation of Riverdance and success of Michael Flatley’s subsequent Irish dance shows (Lord of
the Dance (1996), Feet of Flames (1998), Celtic Tiger (2005)), led to the increased consumption and
commercialisation of Irish traditional music and dance. As these commercial shows often included
women musicians in a prominent and more visible role, performers became more susceptible to the
pressures of the commercial industry. Although some scholarship has emerged in the area of gender
and Irish dance (e.g. Ó Cinnéide 2002; Wulff 2007; O’Flynn, 2009), few have critically engaged with
the impact of Irish dance productions on women musicians’ image and performance. Bearing in
mind the new opportunities provided to women by these commercial shows, the implications for
women musicians and the roles available to them is significant. Positioning the research in a
postfeminine framework, the paper engages with the lived experiences of musicians who have
performed in Irish dance shows and builds on the work of Kristen J. Lieb’s (2018) Lifecycle Model and
Judith Butler’s (1990-) theory of gender performance as an additional form of analysis. The research
aims to demonstrate how women musicians might benefit from performing with these shows, while
at the same time be negatively impacted by the performance requirements and expectations
pertaining to this commercial music industry.
Nikos Skalkottas’ ‘turn to tonalism’ and the influence of Socialist Realism in Greece
Eirini Diamantouli, University of Cambridge
This paper explores Nikos Skalkottas’ engagement with stylistic accessibility after his return to
Greece from Germany in 1933. I consider the composer’s self-proclaimed efforts to establish a more
accessible, tonal musical style in terms of the influence of Russian post-Revolutionary cultural
discourses and in particular through the lens of the politicised artistic doctrine of Socialist Realism. I
bring into critical view Skalkottas’ stylistic volte-face upon returning from Germany to Greece, as
characterised by a shift of focus from Schoenbergian modernism to tonal works, many based on
Greek folk songs. Notwithstanding the practical and financial motivations of this shift, I argue that
the Revolution and the cultural discourses that were subsequently promoted across Europe should
be incorporated into our discussions of the various factors that meaningfully affected Greek music
and indeed Skalkottas’ ‘turn to tonalism’. While the influence of the Russian Revolution has been
well-documented with regard to other aspects of cultural and political life, it remains neglected in
considerations of the musical sphere and within Skalkottas scholarship. Referring directly to
Skalkottas’ compositions as well as to his published and unpublished writings, I highlight the
composer’s engagement with Russian Revolutionary theory and practice, teasing out latent
connections and references which challenge established narratives regarding Skalkottas’ creative
trajectory, as expounded by Manolis Kalomiris and John G. Papaioannou for example. In this way, my
paper contributes to a more nuanced understanding of the meaningful and transformative impact of
the Russian Revolution on Greek musical culture in the early twentieth century.
28
A Woman’s Work is Never Done: Establishing the Structural Network of the Dublin Feis Ceoil
Helen Doyle, Dublin Conservatory of Music and Drama
Letters exchanged in the Evening Telegraph between patriot, scholar and author, Terence O’Neill
Russell and musician, composer, educator and writer, Dr Annie Patterson in September 1894
identified the neglected the state of Irish music and proposed an initial concert series to promote
public interest. Six months later, a preliminary meeting of interested parties in Patterson’s home
moved that a General Committee, drawn from the National Literary Society, Gaelic League and
Dublin’s professional musicians, be formed. A subsequent circular declared ‘time has now come
when it is felt that a strong movement should be set on foot to awaken a widespread interest in the
matchless music of our country’ and that preliminary work would concern organisation of a national
musical festival, or Feis, to be held before long in Dublin.
A complex structural network encompassed an elected Executive Committee and multiple
sub-committees, concerned with areas such as finance and musical programming. In addition,
regional sub-committees and a Ladies’ Committee featured. In its first decade, over 16,000 entrants
participated in competitions, an unmatched level of involvement in music-making in Ireland;
additionally, public interest was demonstrated by attendance at concerts, lectures and exhibitions. It
is, therefore, clearly apparent that the organizational foundations of the Feis Ceoil enabled its
development into a far-reaching and well-supported association. This paper endeavours to provide
an overview of those systems and structures, with a particular emphasis on the Ladies’ Committee,
thus demonstrating the Feis Ceoil’s development as a constitutionally bound Association, and the
role of women within it.
A prelude, a grazioso and an étude walk into a bar: Casella’s debt to Chopin (Lecture Recital)
Ellen Falconer, Royal College of Music
While not stingingly obvious, Italian pianist-composer Alfredo Casella (1883-1947) is greatly
indebted to Fryderyck Chopin (1810-1849). While a wealth of scholarship exists on the Polish icon,
conversely little exists on Casella, and even less on the specific impact Chopin had on him. While
Chopin’s works have shaped our very definition of what it means to compose, express and perform
pianistically (Samson, 1994), little can be said of his legacy in, and influence on, Casella’s music, or
Modern Italian music generally.
This lecture-recital explores the influence of Chopin on Casella’s piano works. Specifically, I
investigate Casella’s Graziosio from Deux contrastes Op. 31 (1918), and Studio sulle quinte from Sei
Studi Op. 70 (1944). These two works are homages to Chopin, both borrowing from Prelude in A
major, No. 7 Op. 28. The presentation discusses two aspects of Casella’s manner of homaging: how
his compositional style borrows and quotes from Prelude in A major; and how his expression and
interpretation lend from approaches to performing Chopin (Casella, 1947). Various methods of
homage will be discussed, including quotation, borrowing and collaging, as well as where these
various features occur in Casella’s works. The practical part of this presentation will demonstrate
how Chopin’s music can illuminate possible entryways into understanding Casella’s works – a
challenge performers face when tackling little-known and under-performed repertoire. This lecturerecital will show the compositional and stylistic similarities between the composers, but also the
tactile and expressive borrowings in Casella’s works that are indebted to Chopin (Waterhouse,
1965).
29
The British College of Accordionists creation of an Educational Environment for Accordionists in
Britain during the 20th century
Lauren Farquharson, Dundalk Institute of Technology
Academic output on the classical accordion is to date limited. My research aims to add to this output
by investigating the institutionalisation and professionalisation of the accordion in Britain during the
20th century. Throughout the British College of Accordionist’s (BCA) existence from 1935 to the
present, their fundamental objective has and continues to encompass the professionalisation and
institutionalisation of the accordion. This presentation will provide a clear context on the BCA’s
development of examinations by showcasing its development from a five-grade series (including
diplomas) in 1936 to an eight-grade series across both practical and theoretical examinations by the
close of the 20th century. Furthermore, insight will be provided on their creation of an educational
environment for accordionists through college activities such as summer and weekend schools.
Lastly, the BCA’s creation and dissemination of an educational syllabi to aid teachers and students in
raising their professional standards and examination participation will be discussed. This
presentation will be conducted through analytical engagement with the BCA archives and the BCA
syllabi dating from 1936-1999.
Through the Lens of a Dictatorship: Joly Braga Santos and the Estado Novo
Ana Beatriz Ferreira, Cardiff University
José Manuel Joly Braga Santos (1924-1988) is widely recognised as one of Portugal’s most
important composers of the second half of the twentieth century, yet little is known about his life
and his music in the UK. Most of his active years as a composer happened in a country under a
dictatorship; Joly was born two years before the coup d’état of 28 May 1926 which brought
Portugal’s First Republic to an end and instituted the so-called Ditadura Nacional (National
Dictatorship). After a countercoup in July of that year by the most conservative and authoritarian
wing of the new regime, the high-ranking army officer Óscar Carmona declared himself President
and immediately assumed dictatorial powers. With the new constitution of 1933, Portugal was
declared a ‘unitary, corporatist republic’. This was the start of Estado Novo (New State), an
authoritarian, autocratic and corporatist political regime which became western Europe’s most longlived dictatorship, enduring until overthrown by the military coup of April 1974 in Portugal’s
Carnation Revolution. This paper aims to place Joly in a broader context by considering
what it meant to be a composer in Portugal during this period, and by assessing his contribution
against the background of the Estado Novo dictatorship. It will be argued that an appreciation of this
political background, the genesis of its cultural ideals and their implications on art and culture, brings
a new understanding to the development of Joly’s career path and his compositional choices.
“Free Jazz Mod Paludan”: Denmark’s experimental protest music
Jacqueline Georgis, Yale University
In early June of 2020, thousands around the globe took to the streets to denounce police brutality.
Encouraged by Black Lives Matter (BLM) protests taking place in the U.S. over the killing of George
Floyd, individuals from Iceland to South Africa came together in an international display of solidarity.
Music was at the forefront of these protests, uniting strangers under a common soundtrack. As the
BLM protest movement touched down in Denmark, it coincided with a local protest organization:
30
Free Jazz Against Paludan (FJMP). Founded by musicians from Copenhagen’s community of
Christiania, FJMP uses music to spearhead an unconventional, non-violent fight against anti-Islam,
anti-immigrant rhetoric and Denmark’s far-right political party leader, Rasmus Paludan.
In this presentation, I consider the impact of a less discussed street protest music genre: free
jazz. While the power of communal song and chant was reinvigorated during the summer of 2020,
protesters in Denmark turned to a different kind of emotional intensity through the experimental,
improvisatory spirit of free jazz. Drawing on Denmark’s history of music and protest, beginning with
communal singing practices of fællessange, I examine the ways in which Denmark’s political and
social norms have shaped the very nature of protest in Denmark. I argue that FJMP may best
encapsulate the country’s past musical and social movements, and illustrate how free jazz becomes
a musical vehicle to express political dissent and solidarity among Danes and non-ethnic Danes. This
paper draws from virtual ethnography, bibliographic research and music video analysis of protests
organized by the FJMP.
Opéra-ballet: the Ballet Russes’s Secret
Leo Geyer, University of Oxford
The significant and numerous innovations of the Ballet Russes has instilled a legacy that continues to
underpin much of the creative practice of the modern stage. Indeed, some theorists argue that
European art can be justifiably divided into the period before and after the Ballets Russes. Arguably,
some of their most impressive work is in hybrid and interdisciplinary practice, notably sharing the
dramatic delivery between song and dance. These ‘contemporary opera-ballet’ advances resulted in
some of the Ballet Russes’ most innovative and influential productions including Pulcinella, Renard
and Les Noces. But what led them to this hybrid art? Scholars including Taruskin, Caddy, Mazo and
Watkin have presented various radically opposing surmises ranging from Futuristic superimposition,
biomechanic theatre practice, hidden choir boys and lampooning parodies. However, there is a
compelling line of inquiry to suggest the Ballet Russes were inspired by the almost forgotten revival
of the French baroque opéra-ballet, yet there is no statement from impresario Diaghilev to support
this. This paper will explore the creative thinking behind the Ballet Russes’s first hybrid production,
Rimsky-Korsakov’s Le Coq d’Or reimagined as an opera-ballet (1914) and propose some ideas as to
why Diaghilev sought to keep the influence of archaic French forms a secret.
Investigating the impact of gamelan participation on wellbeing: plans for collaborative research
with Good Vibrations
Hannah Gibbs, University of York
This presentation will outline the aims, objectives, and impact of my PhD research at the University
of York, researching wellbeing and facilitation of community performance for participants with
complex needs. The nationwide organisation Good Vibrations, has been active for almost 20 years,
giving disadvantaged members of the community access to music making, and bringing Gamelan
workshops into prisons and secure hospitals. The are numerous articles and studies detailing
observations of the benefits of these groups and workshops, qualitatively supporting the positive
effects of participation, including social cohesion and improved social behaviours, positive emotions,
improved mental health and relief from trauma, and improvements in learning and self-perceived
ability. However, there is a scarcity of quantitative research which measure these effects empirically.
My PhD aims to empirically research participants experiences in the community groups of Good
31
Vibrations, through comparisons of self-report ratings on wellbeing and flow state, and physiological
measures, from skin conductivity to breathing rates.
In this presentation I will outline one existing framework for psychological wellbeing that is
especially applicable to the Gamelan ensemble, which forms the contextual foundation of my
research. I will then outline the reasoning behind my methodology, by outlining the supporting
literature, and particularly the reasons for physiological measurements being used alongside selfreports. My research will support further use of community Gamelan with a diverse spread of
individuals with complex needs, where they would otherwise have restricted access to play music,
and limited options for musical participation.
Stay Woke: Conspiracy theory and consciousness in hip-hop music
Alex Gibson, University of Bristol
This paper tracks a history of warnings in African-American expressive culture about the necessity of
‘staying woke,’ looking especially at how this manifests as a ‘paranoid style’ (Hofstadter, 1964) in
hip-hop music. Whilst ‘Golden Era’ hip-hop (1986-92) produced fairly direct reflections of popular
suspicions - especially the notion of government involvement in the crack and AIDS crises (Turner,
1993) - the late 1990s saw these discursive threads develop into distinct conspiratorial aesthetics,
with gangsta rap playing on the idea of gangs and police forces as rival criminal conspiracies, and
conscious rap developing a ‘conspiracy rap’ sub-genre focusing instead on mystical and allencompassing conspiratorial narratives. Despite these aesthetics apparently falling out of style in the
2000s, a period of intense commercialisation in hip-hop music, conspiratorial ideas would
unerringly re-emerge in tracks responding to major social crises, most notably the September 11
attacks and Hurricane Katrina. As such, I argue that conspiracy theory is essential to understanding
how hip-hop artists and audiences conceive of the music’s political role and function. Finally, I briefly
analyse the music of contemporary superstars Kanye West and Kendrick Lamar, focusing on the shift
towards interiority, revivalism and nostalgia in their use of conspiracy theory. I use Raymond
Williams’ notion of a ‘structure of feeling’ to help explicate the historically shifting meaning of
conspiratorial discourses in hip-hop and their relation to notions of social, racial, and political
consciousness.
Irish Country Music’s Authentic Aesthetics: Social Media as Impression Management
Hannah Gibson, Queen’s University Belfast
In the book ‘Creating Country Music: Fabricating Authenticity’ Richard A. Peterson (1997) outlines
how authenticities were constructed in US country music from the 1930s through to the 1990s. One
definition of authenticity is that the culture or figure within a culture is believable, but also original.
The originality of new aesthetics means the ‘authentic’ is continually renewed (Peterson, 1997: 220).
This renewal and constant negotiating of aesthetics can be considered a form of impression
management (Goffman 1959) on a macro scale. Where television programming such as Keepin’ ‘er
Country (BBC Northern Ireland) actively seeks out ‘embarrassing’ cultural intimacies (Herzfeld, 2016)
of the Irish country music scene to show the general public, social media has acted as a tool, both
individually and collectively by Irish country artists, to restore impressions among insiders and new
fans, in an attempt to give additional impressions. This paper will argue how young Irish country
music artists are managing impressions of contemporary Irish country music through social media
32
engagement, and examine how signifiers of authenticity emerge and transform through this social
media presence.
Expressing change: Music and theurgy in early Coptic literary texts
Robert Girling, University of Liverpool
Very little is known about the music of Ancient Egypt. However, the early Christians native to Egypt,
the Copts, offer some valuable insights into the last stages of this civilisation. Music is understood
by scholars to form a central part of the Coptic ethnoreligious identity, from its prevalence in the
liturgy of the modern Coptic Church to the appearance of Greek hymns in Coptic papyri as early as
the Third Century (Moftah, Robertson & Roy, 1991). While the music of the early Copts is still
relatively inaccessible due to their oral musical tradition, musicological scrutiny has yet to turn its
attention to the main resource used by Coptologists: the literary texts.
A comprehensive overview of how the Copts wrote about music may be achieved by
compiling and categorising the musical references evidenced in the surviving literary texts from the
time. The study has found that, rather than documenting musical practices, the Copts’ used musical
references as a literary device to indicate or effect change. In this paper, I will be exploring by
means of a lexicographical study how the Copts used music to indicate theurgic change, and
specifically how vocal and instrumental references represent the active and passive roles in this
process.
Pitch, Timbre, and Change in Myanmar Teashops
Anne Greenwood, University of Berkeley
In this paper, I use the soundscape of a Myanmar teashop to put forward the notion of what I term
“refractive listening,” a type of listening in which sounds’ functions, meanings, and associations
change as they move between areas with different sonic density. In doing so, this paper adds crucial
historical and ethnographic dimensions to the notion of a soundscape in order to push back against
universalist notions of hearing/listening and attempt to add nuance to the concept of fidelity.
Additionally, this paper makes a methodological intervention by putting efforts to “remap” sound
studies in conversation with recent work on timbre, noise, and distortion (Eidsheim 2015;
Birenbaum Quintero 2019).
First, this paper presents an analysis of a recorded teashop soundscape that highlights
distinctive sounds found in a teashop setting and positions them in relation to the broader
soundscape of contemporary urban Myanmar. Here, my analysis foregrounds the elements of pitch
and timbre so as to relate these sonic features to local gender norms and these sounds’ changed
function within the space of the teashop. Next, I compare descriptions of sound in teashops as they
are presented in English and Burmese literary works so as to elucidate the ways producing or
perceiving sound can be used to mark individuals as “in-the-know” or not. Finally, I draw upon
material collected in interviews with members of the Myanmar diaspora in order to present
individuals’ narratives of change as shaped by the shared listening practices found in teashops in the
late 1980s.
33
The economic circuit of Raï music, from the 1980s to the challenges of the Covid-19 pandemic
Hugo Hadji, SOAS, University of London
Since the late 1970s Raï has been the signature popular music of Algeria, playing a significant role in
identity formation both nationally and in the diaspora. The genre became commercially successful
for a short time on the world music scene in the 1990s, after which it went back to being primarily
produced and consumed in Algeria and the Maghreb region.
Recognising the large gaps of knowledge — the last substantial research dating back to the 1990s —
this paper aims first to document the practices as well as the current state of Raï’s economic circuit
which has undergone important changes since the 1980s. Based on fieldwork in Algeria, this paper
will discuss the different entities — studios, distributors, performance sites — that compose the
circuit, their interrelations and the social positioning of the actors involves in them.
Subsequently, looking at the reactions, innovations, and methods employed by today’s Raï actors
concerning the current context of Algeria, the paper will analyse the constant interplay with Algerian
institutions, as well as the impact of the Internet on the economic circuit structure and operation.
Finally, as for many musical and cultural industries throughout the world, the Covid-19 pandemic has
disrupted the economic circuit and production of Raï. The paper will therefore conclude by looking
at the immediate impact of the crisis and its potential long-term effects.
Where Spices Love Music, Emotion and Vigour: A Voyage to the Kolkkali Performance of Mappilas
of Malabar
Mohamed Haseeb, Mangalore University, India
Mappilas, the Muslim community of the southwest coast of Kerala evolved as a result of the pre and
post-Islamic Arab contacts. Kolkkali is a group performing art with sticks practiced mainly by the
Mappila fisherman community. Among the Mappila art forms, Kolkkali belongs to a special category,
because kolkkali is a mixture of music, movement, physical strength and emotional stability. More
resemblance to the martial art kalarippayattu. The first part beginning with a Mappila song
(Mapilappattu) and a simple body movement known as ‘marinjadi minkkali’ and ended with an
intricate step ‘ozichil mutt’. The pattern of body movements varied in accordance with the rhythm of
Mappila songs and oral commands (vayitari). Indeed, kolkkali was a source of inspiration in the anticolonial struggle and played a key role in the socialization process of Mappila community. Kolkkali,
reiterated the self-confidence of the Mappilas and acted as a psychological weapon during the time
of Mappila revolt. This is an attempt to understand the tradition and changes that happened in
kolkkali by analyzing its different steps which are recorded by Arnold Adriaan Bake in 1938. Also
made a comparative study about the kolkkali performance of 1938 and 2020, by analyzing the socioeconomic condition of the Local fisherman community during the past and the present. This paper
makes use of a musical lens to explore contemporary political conditions existing in Kerala, just one
year before the celebration of the hundredth anniversary of Mappila rebellion 1921.
“The Day It Rained on Our Parade”: School Marching Band in the Singapore Story
Boris Hei Yin Wong, The Chinese University of Hong Kong
Since Singapore gained independence from Malaysia in 1965, the formation of brass bands in
schools had been considered a “high priority” by the government, with the aim to “engender group
discipline, esprit de corps and a sense of national identity.” The School Band Movement was
34
therefore launched in 1966 to also compensate for the lack of marching bands to be deployed in
national ceremonies. While the historical overview on the School Band Movement demonstrates the
practical level of using the marching band to serve Singapore’s social and political needs, this paper
argues that there is another level of ideological and metaphorical conceptualization. Sociological
studies on Singapore’s national identity construction suggest that during the country’s early years of
independence the rhetoric of survival had been used by the state leaders in their political
imperatives. With the understanding of the brass band as a metaphor of power, this paper portrays
Singapore’s ideology of national identity through a discourse analysis of the state’s interpretations
on the marching band. I suggest that the brass band was conceptualized as a manifestation of the
ideology of survivalism, which was partly yet largely constructed from the event during the National
Day Parade in 1968 when the marching band students had to perform in an unexpected heavy
rainstorm. The event, with the conceptualization attached to the brass band since then, was
constructed as a significant historical episode in the Singapore Story, and in turn inspired
interpretations in many cultural forms.
An Ethical Critique of Vaughan Williams’s Appropriation of Folk Song
Thomas Heywood, University of Oxford
Treitler noted that the most frequent declaration in twentieth-century musical thought was that the
Western classical tradition had reached a ‘state of exhaustion’ and required ‘inspiration from
previously untapped resources’, yet this conviction had also been prevalent in nineteenth-century
England. In An Introduction to the Study of National Music (1866), Engel promoted the cliché that
‘the English’ were an inherently unmusical people, and in 1873 Schmitz cemented this reputation
with Das Land ohne Musik. RVW and his contemporaries were not the first generation to respond to
this stigma, but they were the first to do so by appropriating English folk music. They viewed this as a
method of ensuring ‘authentic’ national traits pervaded their works, and the results continue to be
admired by performers, audiences, and critics. There remains, however, the question of whether it
was right to assume another culture’s music, placing it in alien contexts.
Characterisations of RVW often contain uncritical acclamations of his ethical righteousness, noting
he was a strong defender of human rights and believed he had a duty to express the lives of others
using his music. However, it may be argued the composer—whether through naivety or conscious
intent—was unjust in his dealings with rural working-class communities. In this presentation I
suggest he abused his position of power as a highly-educated and widely-recognised figure by
appropriating vulnerable peoples’ cultural capital and by subsequently commodifying and corrupting
it for the benefit of his own community, the urban elite leisure class of the early-twentieth century.
‘From syncopated rhythms to robotic riddim: technology and the evolution of dubstep’
Mark Higgins, University of Bristol
Dubstep is a musical movement that emerged in south London in the early 2000s. With its roots in
UK garage, it was originally characterised by a syncopated, “skippy” rhythmic vocabulary. Ten years
later, after migrating to the US, the sound had mutated into an aggressive, lurching, mechanical
musical style known as “riddim”. This paper explores dubstep’s paradigmatic evolution through the
relationship between music creators and their technology. Drawing from the work of Anthony
Giddens, as well as the metaphysics of Graham Harman and Timothy Morton, I frame the artist and
their audio workstation environment as existing in a “duality of structure”, which can be thought of
35
as a single “dubstep producer-object”. I show how changes in the audio workstation environment
result in changes to the object as a whole, which can be observed in the resultant musical output.
I demonstrate this through changes in the musical sensibilities of the London-based artist
Loefah as he migrated to a more “sophisticated” DAW platform. I then look at the trajectory of these
changes inherited in a later track by the American artist Skrillex. Finally, I use the young, Los Angeles
based producer Moonboy as a case study, showing how the paradigm that informs the riddim
subgenre is, from a creative angle, entirely dependent on the duality of structure between artist and
technology. In this way, I reveal the diffusion of creative agency in today’s electronic dance music
and the extent to which music creation epistemologies have become embedded in technology.
Music and Identities in the Piano Works of Karl Goldmark
Tihamér Hlavacsek , Royal College of Music
The Hungarian-born composer, Karl Goldmark (1830-1915) was an esteemed figure in 19th-century
Viennese cultural life alongside Brahms and the critic Eduard Hanslick. Contemporary scholars
recognized Goldmark’s talent and referred to him as ‘the greatest living music-drama composer
since Wagner’s death.’ He was celebrated as ‘the most famous Hungarian-born composer after Liszt’
by Hungarians. Both Austria and Hungary claimed him as their ‘great son’ after his death. Goldmark’s
opera Die Königin von Saba earned him international fame and was performed in main opera houses
across Europe and America. However, whilst Goldmark’s most popular works remained in the
repertoire, his considerable piano oeuvre, comprising more than 50 pieces, was almost completely
forgotten. Since 2005 I have been researching Goldmark’s music extensively and recorded his
complete piano works for Hungaroton Classic as a ‘world premiere’ set. Goldmark self-identified as a
’German’ composer, however, while his musical experience rooted deeply in Germanic tradition,
impact of his Jewish and Hungarian identities are indeed present in some of his music.
In this paper, I will focus on selected musical excerpts from Goldmark’s piano pieces,
demonstrating different stylistic features and interpretative challenges, and critique the idea of
assigning a composer like Goldmark, to a certain ethnic or national category
(Austrian/Hungarian/Jewish). I will argue that his music can be better described as multifaceted,
drawing on aspects of both Austro-German, Hungarian and Oriental-Jewish musical styles.
Mind the Gap: Reflecting and Reimagining Transnational Chinese Identity through Composition
Alex Ho, Royal College of Music
“Where are you from?”
“London.”
“But where are you really from?”
Fuelled more often than not by curiosity, this brief yet all-too familiar exchange appears to
characterise the ambiguity of transnational identity. It evokes Stuart Hall’s assertion that diasporic
experience is defined “not by essence or purity, but…by a conception of ‘identity’ which lives with
and through, not despite, difference; by hybridity” (1990). Indeed, this idea of hybridity is a hallmark
of postcolonial theory that seeks to examine contemporary society not only as one shaped by
transcultural networks and processes, but also as one shaped by the West’s colonial past that
36
continues to manifest in structural and verbal racism experienced by British-Chinese communities in
the UK today (Bhabha, 1996, Chow 2010).
My research thus explores this understanding of transnational Chinese identity through
composition. In particular, I investigate the ways in which identity can at once stimulate the writing
of new music whilst simultaneously be reshaped by this creative process. Taking an
autoethnographic approach, I examine my own experiences and perceptions as a British-born
Chinese with parents from Hong Kong in order to reflect on larger cultural, social, and political
contexts. For this conference, I propose to present a piece for vocal trio, …chinese whispers…, to
shed further light on the fluid relationship between my cultural identity and music, demonstrating
both the vitality of cross-cultural spaces as well as the need to address the UK’s problematic past
and present.
“Deep Inside, We’re All Just PYNK”: Theorising Brown Jouissance in the Performances of Labelle
and Janelle Monáe
Lilian Holland, University of Bristol
This paper theorises black female sensuality in the performances of Labelle and Janelle Monáe as
explorations of brown jouissance. The term brown jouissance, coined by Amber Jamilla Musser in
2018, reconstitutes jouissance from its basis within Kantian non-social subjectivity in order to be
applicable to Black bodies, embracing an understanding of the self as existing a Thing, Other, and
object. The excess of jouissance is there expanded to encompass excesses of fleshiness, bodilyness,
and pain, in order to accompany the history of pornotroping and dehumanisation of Black people.
Through an exploration of the ways in which the 1970s funk trio Labelle and contemporary musician
Janelle Monáe explore their bodilyness, sexuality, and excess in their musical performances, I show
how these artists exploit their historic Otherness and engage in the revolutionary act of expressing
themselves as openly sexual Black women.
Negotiations and Representations: An Ancient Mexican Musical Instrument Collection in a
“Glocal” Museum
Christina Homer, Bangor University
In a small, rarely frequented room at Bangor University lives a collection of ancient west Mexican
musical artefacts. My doctoral research focussed on situating this collection: exploring its current
residence and its potential futures. In this paper, I discuss the aspect of my work which took place in
collaboration with Bangor’s local museum, which involved creating an exhibit of some of the
artefacts. The museum caters for its county, Gwynedd, largely displaying its local cultural, social and
industrial heritage. The collection of Mexican artefacts appears incongruous, but my research began
to unpick the idea of a local museum, leading to the idea of a ‘glocal’ museum (after Robertson) – a
meshwork of local and global identities.
This paper presents research drawn from my experience of curating the exhibition, as well as
a series of discussions with museum visitors about their perceptions of the museum and the place of
the displays within. Using Geertz’s explanation of ‘ethnographic analogy’, I describe how the process
of creating a museum display compares with writing ethnography. I will conclude by presenting the
ethical issues surrounding the display of these instruments: the representation of their cultures of
origin in the historic sense and of Indigenous people today; the role of the collector in the definition
of the artefacts; and how the musicality of the instruments can be displayed in a museum case.
37
Locating Taoism in the European Avant-Garde: Isang Yun's Images (1968)
Ju-Lee Hong, University of Glasgow
The music of the Korean-born German composer Isang Yun (1917-1995) is an example of musical
diplomacy and cultural hybridisation, situating East Asia in the European avant-garde.
Commissioned by Mills College in Oakland, California to support Yun's early release from wrongful
imprisonment, Images (1968) for flute, oboe, violin and cello is one of the three pieces that Yun
wrote while he was imprisoned in Seoul on an espionage charge. Written using serialism, and
inspired by the Taoist symbolism represented in the Four Guardian Fresco of the Great Tomb of
Kangsŏ, Images is a fitting example of the investigation into musical diplomacy between the Western
avant-garde and East Asian philosophy. His sketch reveals the use of hexachodal complementation,
indicating how his characteristic style was acquired from the Schoenbergian lineage. Further analysis
reveals integral serialism in duration and dynamics. Techniques developed from an explicitly Korean
tradition, such as Haupttöne and heterophonic texture, as well as the similarity with the
ornamentation of Korean traditional instruments, are revealed through paradigmatic analysis.
A Prismatic Model of Orbital Tonality with Cases from Bruckner’s Sixth Symphony
Ruixue Hu, Durham University
A major component of the study of sonata forms, harmonic analysis is the prerequisite to an
effective interpretation of formal structures. Known for their intricate harmonies, Bruckner’s mature
symphonies often stand as an obstacle to theorists, since its thematic areas are often not
established through traditional means (e.g., diatonic relationships, Perfect Authentic Cadences in
particular). In a recent pursuit to tackle this problem, Julian Horton (Music Analysis, 2018) proposed
the concept of “orbital tonality” based mainly on neo-Riemannian theory. Horton understands the
harmonies in the Finale of Bruckner’s Seventh Symphony as revolving around three orbit centres
that equally divide the tonal spectrum into overlapping orbits, in which the foreground harmonies
are connected through neo-Riemannian transformations.
While Horton’s article focuses on Bruckner’s Seventh, the theoretical foundation of orbital
tonality is indeed Bruckner’s Sixth Symphony in A major, for which I propose a triangular prism to
explain Bruckner’s novel way of establishing his thematic areas. My cases are the first theme in the
first movement and the second theme in the Finale; what I will demonstrate in the first example is
that the harmonies revolve around the A-orbit to establish a sonata-first-theme without traditional
means such as the PAC. For the other example, the harmonies in the phrases neatly fit into two
orbits. I advocate that the prismatic model is at once an abstract representation of the orbital
system and an effective analytical tool.
Harmony of the Spheres of Ancient Greece and Early China: A Comparison on Selected Texts
Patrick Huang, Western University (Canada)
Ancient Greece and China are two shining civilisations with great achievement in musical theory and
its possible relation to cosmology. The earliest survived source in Ancient Greece was written by
Nicomachus, which associated seven musical pitches within two conjoint tetrachords to seven
deities and heavenly objects. The Chinese counterpart, interestingly, was compiled Liu An around a
similar historical period. Liu’s theory, however, emphasised on the five basic pitches in traditional
Chinese pentatonic scale, and related them to five ancient sages, five planets, as well as five basic
38
elements, and five directions etc. in Chinese thinking to structure a larger system. Both Nicomachus
and Liu were highly influential and being widely accepted and developed by later theorists. However,
both systems are more or less far-fetched regarding the specific correlations between musical
astronomical ‘orders’, and therefore have to be modified or interpreted accordingly. Therefore, in
my presentation, I will briefly compare those two systems, in order to delve into these following
questions:
-
What are the main similarities and differences between Nicomachus and Liu An’s thinking on
harmonic intervals, and what causes such distinctions?
What were the social contexts of the development of such correlation between music and
astronomy, and how those theories were accepted by later scholars within such context?
When such general theory does not fit the observed data, how did their successors explain
such discrepancies?
Soundtracking the City Break: Library Music in Travel Television
Toby Huelin, University of Leeds
Library music can be understood as music that is neither written for a specific media production, nor
that has a “life” prior to its audiovisual use. This type of music occupies a liminal space in the media
industries, extensively used in television yet rarely credited on-screen or examined in academia. As
one way of opening up the discourse surrounding library music, this paper will explore its use(s) in
British travel television programming.
There has been a recent reappraisal of travel television as a hybrid subgenre of lifestyle and
documentary television (e.g. Bakøy, 2017; Waade, 2009), although the role of music has been
effectively ignored. An analysis of library cues, as the dominant type of music used in this genre, can
illuminate notions of place, identity and cultural value. This is particularly true when the same tracks
are used in different programmes and musical meaning can coalesce across different televisual
contexts. There are also examples of explicit references to library music within the narrative of travel
television programming (e.g. Channel 4’s Travel Man), which challenge the commonly held
assumption of library music as something ‘unheard’ (Gorbman, 1987) or ‘inconspicuous’ (Wierzbicki,
2013).
Drawing together a close reading of televisual texts with practitioner perspectives, this study
argues for a reappraisal of library music as a fundamental part of television culture. The paper also
has broader implications for music in screen media, particularly concerning notions of musical
meaning, intertextuality and narrative in the under-explored area of music in factual television
programming.
The Missing Herring Gutters in Gaelic Song Scholarship
Meg Hyland, University of Edinburgh
The study of Gaelic work song has traditionally focused only on agricultural and domestic labour.
This pattern was established by the early ethnographers Alexander Carmichael and Francis Tolmie.
Their works on Gaelic song, the initial volumes of Carmina Gadelica and One Hundred and Five Songs
of Occupation from the Western Isles of Scotland, were published in the early years of the twentieth
century, but their fieldwork was conducted in the 1860s and 1870s. This period also saw the rise of
the commercial fishing industry in the Hebrides. Thousands of young Hebridean women began
leaving the islands for seasonal work as herring gutters and packers. Because this industry was so
39
new to the islands, it did not feature at all in Carmichael and Tolmie’s work. However, recordings of
Gaelic work song composed and sung by herring gutters exist in the ethnographic archives of the
School of Scottish Studies and Canna House. My research in these collections demonstrates that
gutters developed a distinct genre of Gaelic work song, drawing on both work and dance song
traditions. My paper will address the evidence for this practice as well as the reasons why Gaelic
song scholars have overlooked its existence. The talk will emphasize the importance of oral history
archives in challenging received scholarship about song traditions.
Cosmopolis of language performances: circulation of sufi texts and sounds across the Indian ocean
Ihsanul Ihthisam, Jawaharlal Nehru University (New Delhi)
This paper is concerned with the circulation of Sufi texts and sounds across the littoral worlds of the
Indian Ocean. Specifically saying, it identifies the genres of ‘Language performances’ in the Sufi
Islamic ritual economy, from the early sixteenth to nineteenth centuries among the Muslim
community of the Malabar and Coromandel Coasts (the latter was popularly known in the medieval
times as ‘Ma’bar’). The development of Islamic mysticism (Sufism) on the Malabar and Ma’bar
Coasts can be traced from the earlier part of the broader nexus of Sufism in pre-modern Islam. The
lived Islam in Malabar and Ma’bar is inseparable from its Sufi influences and allied ritual
performatives: Muslims there enunciated their everyday encounters through songs which were
ritualized and sanctified for their collective and individual recitals at public and domestic spaces. To
the periphery of core ritual contexts (ṣalāh, tilāwah, ad’iyya, etc.), practicing Sufi liturgies (ḥaḍrāt,
ḏikr or Samāʾ), Muslims of Malabar and Ma’bar extended some locally or globally evolved Islamic
genres of language performances such as mālās, mawlūds and rātibs —form the broader limits of
this study. The prime focus will be on the cult of Šaiḫ Muḥyuddīn ‘Abd al-Qādir al-Ǧīlāni (as spiritual
savior of land and sea) in the sixteenth to nineteenth centuries’ Indian Ocean, historicizing the transcreations of his life into texts and sounds of language performances with a special reference to
Malabar and Ma’bar, along with its ‘circulatory regime’ to wider South and Southeast Asia.
Guillaume Tell in London: Hofer’s Female Army
Asli Kaymak, University of Bristol
One year after its Paris premiere in 1829, Rossini’s grand opera Guillaume Tell was staged in London.
Reimagined as the revolutionary tale of Hofer, the Tell of the Tyrol, this production incorporated
radical alterations to the plot, number of acts and structure of ensembles. My paper sheds light on
contemporary perceptions of gender power relations by focusing on the character of Josephine, who
was added to the libretto by James Robinson Planché. The real-life Josephine Negretti, a comrade in
arms of the revolutionary leader Andreas Hofer during the Tyrol Siege in 1807, was memorialised on
the Drury Lane stage by Lucia Elizabeth Vestris. Vestris turned Josephine from a woman warrior and
little-known historical figure into a sexually titillating, crossdressing heroine. While Negretti was to
receive public affirmation as a woman warrior a century after the Tyrolean Rebellion (in part
because of her ethnic and class identity), in 1830 Vestris’ sexualised performance received minutes
of applause and the only encore of the premiere. I will examine Vestris’ interpretation and reception
through contemporary gender theories and in relation to historical women warriors of Tyrol and
England in order to reveal perceptions and experiences of femininity on the eve of the Social Reform
Act of 1832. Josephine’s rebirth through Vestris’ performance on the London stage can illuminate
our understanding of socio-psychological gender power relationships in early nineteenth-century
London.
40
The Primacy of Prime: Rachmaninoff’s All-Night Vigil and the Theology of the First Hour
Zen Kuriyama, Brandeis University
Sergei Rachmaninoff’s All-Night Vigil was composed for the idiosyncratic and oft not done “all-night
rite” of the Eastern Orthodox liturgy. The service—part of the canonical hours—consists of Vespers,
Matins, and Prime, also known as “the First Hour.” A frequently enraging misnomer to
Rachmaninoff’s op. 37 is simply referring to it as “Rachmaninoff’s Vespers.” 4 This gross simplification
of the all-night vigil to only its first canonical section is not only factually inaccurate, but it also
discounts the rich theology present in the First Hour and in Rachmaninoff’s musical treatment of the
text from the office. Since the early days of Christianity, monastic communities and early
developments in liturgical theology held a primacy for the first hour of daylight in the Divine Office.
The abatement of a night relenting to the morning was a daily and visible reminder of John 1:5: “the
Light shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome it.” Despite Rachmaninoff’s
somewhat unorthodox adoption of Russian Orthodox Christianity (that is, the lack thereof), this
paper presents that his treatment of this ancient liturgical service was more adept than mere
musical aesthetic. The following study argues that Rachmaninoff’s extremely sensitive and affective
handling of the all-night vigil service is in line with Eastern Orthodox theology of the aforementioned
canonical hours, culminating in a musico-theological summa on the final movement of the work,
when praise is given to the Theotokos, the Mother of God, who gave birth to the Living Light. 5
“I decided to stay here because of music”: sensing sonically a (possible) new home
Chrysi Kyratsou, Queen’s University Belfast
In this paper I discuss how music discourses inform senses of familiarity with the host society and
inform decisions of belonging among refugees in Greece. These senses are particularly facilitated by
the recognition of common patterns developed across space and time other from the moment of
physical encounter of a refugee with what constitutes “host society”.
In public discourses refugees are mostly depicted as culturally non-belonging to the society where
they apply for asylum, and therefore as an aberration of what is regarded as constituting cultural
normality of a nation-state (see Stolcke 1995). Such representations are further encouraged by the
implemented policies that contribute to the marginalization of refugees.
However, this static, bounded reality implied by such perceptions, contradicts with the “space
continuum” shaped by humans on the move (see Gupta and Ferguson 2002). My interlocutors, while
embodying the “space continuum”, have also bodily experienced exclusions, and they are still
working their way into host society. Yet, their narratives around their belongings counterpoint the
borders that have marked them, focusing on what is shared across space, throughout time. How
does music facilitate senses of belongings surpassing lived multiple exclusions? How does music
orient us to alternative perceptions of a bounded reality?
4
For instance, it is referred to as “Vespers” in Sergei Rachmaninoff, A Lifetime in Music by Sergei Bertensson
and Jay Leyda (New York: New York University Press, 1956), still considered the authoritative biography on the
composer.
5
Taken from St Hildegard of Bingen, who often referred to God/the Son of God/the Holy Spirit in her mystic
visions as the “Living Light.” This reference is made with the knowledge that Hildegard’s Mariology was strong
and profound.
41
Based on interviews with refugees, the paper shows how they construct narratives of belonging
incorporating physical and musical movement. Furthermore, through an examination of refugees’
musical practice/consumption, I argue that music serves as a canvas where movement can be traced
and shape aa perspective of potential coexistence.
“An anxiousness to appear original” – The Early Critical Reception of Rossini in Spain (1818-1819)
Riccardo La Spina, Universidad de la Rioja
The introduction of Rossini's operas in Spain seized public imagination and stimulated critical
thought towards an unprecedented paradigm shift. Though painfully slow, initial reception induced
fascination with the new music-theatrical style and the inevitable struggle to comprehend it.
Theretofore, little critical or aesthetic reflection graced the press, confined mainly to oral expression
in tertulias (salons), and café circles. Coinciding with the sexenio absolutista (1814-20, preceding
Madrid’s first Rossini performances by resident Italian companies), dispatches signed El Melomano
exerted early influence on how indigenous audiences perceived the composer’s works and their own
affinity to them. This manifests itself in articles dating between 1818 and 1819, constituting the
earliest Spanish criticism of the new phenomenon, including the rare first-time operatic review, of Il
Turco in Italia. Predicated on long experience and intimate knowledge of Madrid’s canon, it
illustrates the (critic’s inner-) conflict in comparatively assessing Rossinian composition and
aesthetics. Moreover, Rossini’s personal, artistic and musical character are engaged, challenging an
inexperienced national readership, and offering nuanced alternative perspectives to stimulate – and
possibly confound – public taste-formation. Drawing on undocumented material which has eluded
previous scholarly analysis, our inquiry considers El Melomano as a flashpoint of Spain’s intellectual
perception of Rossini. Historical and periodical sources contextualize the initial newsprint
substantiation of Rossini’s early allure and popularity, and the mechanics of its irrevocable hold on
the theatrical public, as harbinger of society’s inevitable transition away from Bourbon Spain’s
ancien régime stigma.
“The Harmony of United Parts”: Robert Bremner’s mission to improve Scottish Psalmody in late
eighteenth-century London
Mary-Jannet Leith, University of Southampton
This paper will explore the activities of the Scottish music publisher Robert Bremner (1713-1789)
after his move to London in 1762. Academic attention to date has mainly focused on Bremner’s
successful musical businesses in Edinburgh and London, but beyond this, his activities remain
somewhat shadowy, particularly after his departure from Scotland. However, unlike his Scottish
colleague and fellow publisher James Oswald, Bremner retained close links with Scotland after his
move, and, on arrival in London, immediately situated himself within its well-established Scottish
diaspora community. Recent research by diaspora scholars has positioned this community around
the Strand, and notably Bremner became a member of a nearby Scottish dissenting congregation
upon his arrival in London – Crown Court Church. This paper will explore Bremner’s activities in
London until his death in 1789, and in particular will highlight the continuation of his mission to
improve the Scottish psalmody, and his drive to educate the ordinary worshipper in enough musical
theory to sing confidently in four-part harmony. Alongside Bremner’s 1772 London publication,
“Church Harmony” (dedicated to a second Scottish London-based congregation), this paper will
analysis records from the archives of Crown Court Church of Scotland, which provide an important
context for Bremner’s efforts to improve congregational singing in the absence of instrumental
42
accompaniment in Scottish London churches. This presentation forms part of my wider doctoral
research, which combines a historical analysis of the dynamic migration of Scottish musical identity
with a focus on the role of Scottish musicians in the creative context of eighteenth century London.
‘Composing Liminality’
Kevin Leomo, University of Glasgow
This paper will examine recent developments of my compositional practice in relation to the concept
of liminality and how it has influenced my practice research and conceptual approach to
composition. Limen, or liminal points, are at the sensory threshold of physiological or psychological
response; at the boundary of perception. The aesthetic concept of liminality, of in-betweenness, has
become central to my work. I will discuss recent compositions which engage with areas of threshold
or transition between two states, with key areas being soundsilence,
fragility-stability, and stasis-movement. My use of negative space and post-Cageian approach to
silence has been influenced by composers of the Wandelweiser collective, such as Antoine Beuger
and Eva-Maria Houben. I am also interested in exploring fragility as an aesthetic concept, from
employing unstable performance techniques such as multiphonics at very quiet dynamic levels, to
utilising sounds at the edge of perception. My works also employ sustained tones with very gradual
timbral movement, influenced by the acoustic works of Eliane Radigue, although on a smaller
temporal scale. I will discuss how both working closely with performers and the refinement of my
notational practice has contributed to the realisation of a liminal aesthetic. By exploring liminality in
my work, I intend to challenge modes of listening and the perceptions of listeners, both performers
and audience.
Acoustics Analysis of 19th Century Violin Vibrato - Based on German Violinists Ferdinand David and
Louis Spohr
Can Li, City, University of London
Various violin vibrato playing methods were invented before the 19 th century, such as pressure
vibrato, two-finger vibrato, bow vibrato, wrist vibrato, arm vibrato, bow vibrato combines with hand
vibrato, and with pressure vibrato. However, it has not yet been clearly why most 19 th century
violinists prefer the use of wrist vibrato. This paper, based on study of the approaches to vibrato
from the 19th century German violinists Ferdinand David and Louis Spohr, aims to explain this
phenomenon by investigating the frequency spectrum of the pitch undulation of these vibrato
methods mentioned above. This experiment, starts with the acoustic documents of these vibrato
methods that record in the same performance and setting conditions, demonstrates that the
vibrating effect produced by wrist vibrato is the most significant of all vibrato playing methods,
which is the primary reason that most musicians tend to use it. Furthermore, I also argue that the
vibrating effect of wrist vibrato is associated with the use of early violin supports, specifically chin
rests and shoulder pads. Based on the same experimental principle and David and Spohr’s violin
supports, I argue that a violinist who plays with wrist vibrato while using a shoulder pad generates a
more significant and practical vibrato effect than a player who uses a chin rest.
43
“Classifying Operations”: Constructing and manufacturing identities in country music
Christina Lynn, Dundalk Institute of Technology
Identity is a term which has been theorized by academics in many field including social, cultural and
anthropological fields, since the early twentieth century. The construction of one’s identity within a
music genre has further been theorized by musicologists and ethnomusicologists world-wide. In this
presentation I will present a comparison between Gretchen Wilson, American country music singer,
and Mags Carthy, Irish country music singer. This comparison will showcase how both women have
utilized ‘Bourdieu’s scenario whereby the “object” of sociology’s classifications produces her own
“classifying operations” and articulates a polemical view of the other class’ (Hubbs 2014, p.118). This
presentation will take into consideration the identity markers of both female artists and how they
have utilized both these identities to create a space for themselves as unique country music artists. I
will also detail how other female artists in the Irish context reject these specific identity markers, in
place of contemporary, popular culture, female identity markers. This specific presentation will also
utilize elements of identity construction (Hall, Grossenberg, Butler) and embodiment of stage
performance (Auslander). This presentation is part of a larger PhD project that focuses on women in
Irish country music. This presentation is constructed from a chapter on identity, image and the
contemporary female scene of Irish country music.
Claudio Santoro, Música viva, and the Emergence of German Modernism in Brazilian Music
Pablo Victor Marquine da Fonseca, University of Florida
In 1941, Claudio Santoro (1919-1989) joined Música Viva (1939-1952), a group of composers led by
the German composer Hans-Joachim Koellreutter, who, following a model from the Second Viennese
School, found a school of modern music in Brazil. Within the group’s output, Santoro’s Sonata 1942
for piano was most influential, as it established the twelve-tone method into a viable musical
language (cf. Kater and Bèhague). The activities of the Música Viva resulted in a ferocious response
from critics, the press, and the nationalist composers. Advocating for the continuation of a national
style, the Brazilian composer Camargo Guarnieri responded to the group in his seminal Open Letters
(1941, 1950), where he questioned the aesthetics of modernity as antithetical to the affirmation of
Brazilian musical identity.
In this paper, I argue that, as the German musical modernism becomes a source of Brazilian
avant-garde, Santoro’s paves way for dodecaphonic-serialism, one who eventually contributed to
the Brazilian musical identity. I examine how Santoro’s Sonata 1942 is a unique musical work that
embodies the modern style advocated by Música Viva. Supplemented by his unpublished
autobiographical interview, correspondences, and the music manuscript, Santoro’s twelve-tone
approach in the Sonata 1942 was fulfilled with a “lack of orthodoxy systematization”—a feature
often criticized in the literature. However, Santoro’s use of dodecaphonism is systematic. Fulfilled
with a conscious level of serialism, the composer approached a direct connection with form,
rhetoric, and musical expression, which exemplifies the genesis and the aesthetics of the avantgarde in the Brazilian modernism.
44
Erzulie O!: The compositional techniques associated with the worship of the deity, Erzulie, in
Haitian Vodou
Phyllida Martignetti, University of Cambridge
The historical and cultural tapestry of the oldest independent nation of the Caribbean is one that
weaves together not only poverty, enslavement, and colonialism but also powerful and distinct
musical, spiritual, philosophical and political elements. Vodou is a polytheistic religion which
assimilates sacrificial and ritualistic worship with an underlying musical tradition. With an estimated
90% of Haitians practising Vodou, albeit within a spectrum of orthodoxies, the religion has, and
continues to have, a transcendental influence on all areas of Haitian identity. Due to the wildly
differing practices between the West and its predominantly monotheistic religions, and the ancient,
spirit driven Caribbean religion, Vodou has for many years provided inspiration and intrigue to
Western artists of all mediums. The mainstream narrative of Haiti and its religious beliefs is
presented to the West as that of superstitious, primitive devil worshippers who practise human and
animal sacrifice and black magic The reality, as with all things for which there exists a caricature, is
much deeper and more complex and these depictions do the religion and its followers a great
injustice. The ethnomusicological study surrounding this area is scarce at present and is dominated
by first hand transcriptions of traditional folk songs in their original Creole with English translations.
This paper seeks to contribute to the field literature by presenting an examination of the role that
music plays in the ritualistic practices of Vodou, with specific reference to the compositional
techniques associated with worship of the spirit Erzulie.
“Maldita Corona”: the political aesthetics of migration in Haitian migrants’ (musical) responses to
the Covid-19 pandemic in Brazil
Caetano Maschio Santos, University of Oxford
The impacts of the Covid-19 pandemic started in early 2020 cut through all aspects of human life,
from the most private and intimate dimensions to the wider spheres of social life, be they local or
global. Among these, the need for social distancing measures brought renewed intensity to the
exploration of old and new forms of virtual musicking (Small 1998), and negatively impacted the
livelihood of most musicians worldwide. Investigation into these effects, however, evidenced how
pandemics “run along the fault lines of economic and social structures” (Farmer 2006), and how the
(in)action of governments produced different pandemic variants worldwide. In this paper I discuss
how Covid-19 impacted the lives of Haitian artists in Brazil, and how their agency in responding to its
challenges frequently manifested itself in the intertwined form of music and sociopolitical activism.
Drawing on Western accounts of African Diasporic culture that rely on metaphors of contagion and
infection related to migrational and cultural flows (Browning 1998), I will analyse the intersections of
their musical production and positionality in Brazilian society as black labour migrants with
longstanding patterns of racial and class hierarchies that characterize Brazil. Through this exercise, I
aim to highlight the importance of the “political aesthetics of migration” (Bohlman, 2011) from
recent South-South black migration to Brazil in a moment that the country witnesses the rise and
consolidation of a conservative, nationalist and authoritarian populist government.
45
‘Little Girl Blue’? The Mediation of Janis Joplin’s Posthumous Career
Alice Masterson, University of York
Female musicians who die from the excesses of rock and roll do not receive the same level of hero
worship as their male counterparts. But if we do not idolise female musicians in the same way after
their death, then how do we remember them? Where figures such as Jimi Hendrix (1942 – 1970) and
Jim Morrison (1943 – 1971) become secular deities in death, women such as Janis Joplin (1943 –
1970), who meet similar fates, become moral lessons. Taking Joplin as a case study, this paper
explores the narratives formed around her career before and after her death. Using newspaper
archives to explore coverage of significant events in Joplin’s career as well as biographies and
documentaries, an overall arc can be traced which demonstrates the changing reception of her
music and career across time. Particularly important to this is the ‘little girl blue’ narrative weaved
around Joplin’s life. Discussions of the traumas Joplin faced during her lifetime posit her as a victim
of bullying, unhappiness, and crippling insecurity. There is undoubtedly truth in this, yet the oversimplistic reframing of her hedonistic attitude, appetite for sex, alcohol, and drugs, and impressive,
raw vocals merely as the actions of a troubled soul is a reductive account of a complex situation: it
removes Joplin’s agency. I argue that by removing her agency in this way, the narratives formed
around Joplin provide a way of retrospectively controlling the story of a ‘deviant’ woman.
Presentation Title: Tangomania in Paris (1911-1914) and the consolidation of tango as a national
symbol of Argentina
Stephen Meyer, Royal College of Music
From 1911 until 1914, tango music and dance enjoyed a succès de scandale in Paris, establishing
itself as high society’s favorite pastime and becoming a veritable obsession, known as “tangomania”.
Tango’s sudden acclaim surprised the sizeable Argentine community in Paris, for many of whom the
tango was not socially respectable, associated instead with the lower class residents of Buenos Aires.
Nonetheless, tango emerged as Argentina’s most famous cultural export during these years, leading
many Argentines at home and abroad to adopt the tango as part of their cultural self-understanding.
In this paper, I will draw upon French and Argentine newspaper articles (1911-1914) to
document how tango attained popularity in Paris, paying particular attention to the reactions of the
Eurocentric Argentine elite, who were keen to emulate Parisian culture. While tango scholars such as
Hugo Lamas and Enrique Binda6 have argued that other factors such as the emergence of the music
publishing and recording industries were vital to tango’s increasing social acceptance within
Argentina, I will show, in contrast, the profound impact of Parisian “tangomania” on changing
attitudes among the Argentine elite, and how this led to the consolidation of tango as a national
symbol in the years following the Argentine centennial (1910), a time when Argentina was searching
for its ser nacional, or national identity, in the face of mass immigration and rising nationalism.
Performing Seduction Mozart’s Cherubino as a Cicisbeo
Sarah Miller, University of California, Davis
The interplay between the character Cherubino and his en travesti interpreter results in a sexuallycharged ambivalence that continues to puzzle, fascinate, and inspire scholars and performers alike.
6
Lamas, Hugo and Enrique Binda (2019) El tango en la sociedad porteña, 1880-1920. Córdoba: Editorial
ABRAZOS.
46
Focusing on the pageboy's sexually-charged body, Heather Hadlock poignantly asks, "why do women
love Cherubino? And why do they find him most irresistible when he is disguised as a girl…?" That
question, while crucial, does not sufficiently explore the evolution of courting rituals that blossomed
with the emergence of the revolutionary bourgeoisie.
In this contribution I propose, for the first time, that Cherubino the character performs the
role of a cicisbeo or cavalier servente, the effeminate, gallant pursuer of a married noble lady, by
both following and breaking the courtly code of conduct codified by Medieval chivalry love poets,
specifically Dante and Petrarch. Using Giuseppe Parini's Il giorno and Carlo Goldoni's and Mozart's La
finta giardiniera as contemporaneous accounts of cicisbeism, I examine how Cherubino performs
cavalier servente behavior. Allowing the practice of cicisbeism to inform performance invites the
singer to negotiate a complex, two-layered characterization of Cherubino: she both performs
masculinity and performative seduction typical of the cicisbeo. Further, interpreting Cherubino as a
cicisbeo sheds light on Enlightenment culture and highlights the metatheatricality imbedded in the
role of Cherubino, a reflection itself on the theatricality of the Ancient Régime, which allowed for the
expression of a counterculture in the simple gesture of breaking the rules.
“You know too damn much”: music theory knowledge as a para-musical component in the
construction of identities
John Moore, University of Liverpool
Music theory is a rarefied discipline; of this there can be little dispute. However, given music’s
ubiquitous place in society and culture, the tendency in mass media towards the obfuscation of
musical knowledge, as opposed to any kind of candid explanation, is somewhat striking. O’Hara
(2018) suggests that public-facing discourses concerning music theory in the age of the internet,
present music theory both as a scientifically rigorous and unified body of research; and a proverbial
fount of arcane wisdom, available only to the select few who are able to pierce its abstruse and
mysterious veil. While this certainly seems to hold true in the modern “regime of the think-piece”,
we must question the origin of this new epistemology of music theory and why this portrayal seems
to be so pervasive in popular culture. By examining a range of audio-visual media, primarily
focussing on television, this paper examines the various ways in which music theory, and the techné
of music, is portrayed to the general public. Building upon the work of Greene (2002) I will examine
how “ideologies of authenticity” fuel particular attitudes towards—and presentations of—technical
knowledge of musical processes. In addition to this, I will discuss the extent to which music
theoretical knowledge features as a component in the para-musical makeup of certain genres and
styles; and, by extension, how this contributes to the construction of identities for both artists and
fans in musical subcultures.
‘You have to feel it’: Sound systems, affect, and theories of sub-bass experience
Ivan Mouraviev, University of Bristol
This primarily conceptual paper tackles how the experience of intense sub-bass frequencies at live
sound system events, arguably the heart of ‘bass culture’ and related electronic dance music
practices, can be understood and theorised. The paper works through the intellectual terrain of
affect theory in music and sound studies, taking stock of both emic (‘insider’) and etic (‘outsider’,
academic) perspectives of sonic experience and using the genres of dub-reggae and dubstep as short
case studies. In doing so, I discuss the implications of the ‘affective turn’ in music studies since the
47
mid-1990s and introduce major concepts such as vibrational ontology and sonic dominance,
theorised by scholars Steve Goodman (2009) and Julian Henriques (2011), respectively. I argue that
affect in the context of live sound system events is best understood as neither strictly autonomous
(biological) or social (culturally-mediated) but somewhere in between, intersecting both ‘the
signifying and the sublime’ (Thompson and Biddle 2013). Furthermore, I leverage Henriques’s
conception of sonic dominance as a kind of ‘power-with, rather than power-over’ the body to
suggest that bass culture is a primarily immersive phenomenon, significant because of its capacity to
facilitate new subjective experience and blur binary oppositions such as mind/body and
autonomous/social. The paper ultimately responds to recent scholarly efforts towards developing a
‘musicology of bass culture’ (Fink 2019) and ‘ethnomusicology of affect’ (Garcia 2020), and
concludes by reflecting on the political stakes of sonic affective experience, in light of the radical
reconfiguration of live music economies around the world during the coronavirus pandemic.
Congregations and Pilgrimages: Transforming Atmosphere between Performance and Installation
Peter Nagle, Trinity Laban Conservatoire of Music and Dance
This presentation will consider the genesis and aesthetics of two recent works: The Fade In Time,
presented at the New Lights festival in June 2019, and The Congregation Between the Induction of
My Divine Impulse is Exulted, presented in October 2019 by TL Contemporary Music Group. These
works aim to achieve a transformational atmosphere between allographic and autographic modes of
sound encounter, and in doing so to bring to consciousness and critical consideration the
atmospheres of performance and installation art and the contexts of their presentation, and to
challenge and blur the boundaries between them. Following from The Fade In Time, Congregation
further questions the nature of work identity both in a diffused and fragmented structure and in its
use of material from a work by Soosan Lolavar to highlight ambiguities not only in the context of
presentation but the coherent existence of the work itself.
I contextualise these works in the light of Gernot Böhme’s concept of atmospheres,
phenomenological approaches to sound reception, and also the conceptual aesthetic embodied in
Seth Kim-Cohen’s “non-cochlear sound art”. I consider the role of drone textures in this ontological
ambiguity and post that such compositional approaches represent a blurring of the distinction
between allographic and autographic work, revealing not simply a distinct third state of identity but
a spectrum of possibility through which phenomenological experience may feed to a conceptual
reflection and reconsideration of the aesthetic structures in which we encounter sound.
The Sequence of the Middle Movements in the Second Symphony of Gustav Mahler
Maho Naito, University of Bonn
In the new critical edition of Gustav Mahler’s Second Symphony, the sequence of the inner
movements of the work are Andante followed by the Scherzo. Yet, it has become widely
acknowledged that the order of middle movements in this symphony was different in Mahler’s own
autographical score to the structure which we abide by today. Earlier studies, including the critical
edition from Stark-Voit and Kaplan, have briefly explored this issue, specifically concerning tonality
and atmosphere based on Mahler's correspondences, however there has not yet been an in-depth
examination or reconsideration of this problem in the contemporary literature.
In this study, I present a detailed and much-needed rethinking of the middle movements of
Mahler’s Second Symphony by examining them through the field of Sketch Studies. I will provide a
48
detailed analysis of the autographical drafts, fair copies of score, orchestral parts and copyist’s
manuscripts with Mahler’s handwritten annotations to demonstrate each stage of the compositional
process, from when the first movement was composed as ‘Todtenfeier’ (1888) to the time that the
second copyist’s manuscript was made (1895) which resulted in the ordering of movements that we
experience today. Specifically, I focus on Mahler’s orchestration (particularly his use of percussion)
to help demonstrate his strategy of the movements’ order. By examining the revisions that occurred
and the change of the sequence of movements from this philological point of view, I intend to offer a
new perspective on Mahler's compositional strategy and provide an alternative interpretation to this
popular work.
Musical Ones and Zeros: Examining Genre’s Role within Music Streaming Platforms
Allison Noble, University of Southampton
The evolving trajectory of musical digitisation has currently reached a point where music
consumption champions the dematerialised, multi-platform, intangible state of streaming platforms,
powered by user personalisation and recommender systems. However, the reducing of cultural
artefacts to computational data creates complications ranging in both complexity and consequential
severity. These complications impact not only the digital music value chain, but a range of actors
across the music streaming landscape. The following research focuses on music categorisation,
genre labelling and metadata application within music streaming platforms and their recommender
systems. This interdisciplinary research combines the academic disciplines of Musicology and
Computer Science whilst also applying techniques from Science and Technology Studies and Music
Information Retrieval. By blending computational techniques alongside musicological and
sociological research, this study examines the effects of assigning computational characteristics to
musical tracks for the purpose of recommendation filtering. Given the young age of streaming
platforms, the full intensity of their impact is not yet known. Therefore, methodologically, this
research features the opposing arguments of technological constructivism and determinism. By
including key examples of playlist naming, genre labelling and user marketing campaigns on the
platform Spotify, this research considers both theoretical arguments. This study contributes to
research regarding the future of genre-based music categorisation within streaming services, whilst
also acknowledging the continual impact and development of digital technologies within the music
landscape, where culture and engineering attempt to further merge for the purpose of consumption
and dissemination.
The influence of Ignaz Moscheles’ “pianoforte soirees” on the piano recital, concert programming
and on the formation of the canon of music
Sevastiana Nourou, Goldsmiths, University of London
Ignaz Moscheles was an important figure in the nineteenth century who influenced remarkably the
concert life, especially in maintaining the classical element. On the whole, his contribution to the
canon of music, more specifically to the canonicity of composers and to the revival of specific
compositions, as well as in reshaping the concert structure has not been acknowledged. The current
scholarship credits Liszt as the originator of the solo recital whereas the most recent biography of
Ignaz Moscheles contradicts this view and supports that ‘Le concert c’est Moscheles’. The paper
challenges both views and sheds light on Ignaz Moscheles’ connection to the piano recital by
assessing his historical pianoforte soirees. In 1837 Moscheles gave three ‘Pianoforte Soirees’, in 1838
four ‘Pianoforte Soirees’ and in 1839 three ‘Matinee Musicales of Classical Pianoforte Music’. These
49
were succeeded in 1845 and 1846 by ‘Matinees of Classical Music’. Moscheles’ intention was to give
soirees only for piano music, what came to be known a recital. Regardless of not following his
intention, his soirees opened the doors to new directions of concert programming and the concerts
per se. The paper therefore assesses the influence Moscheles exerted by drawing on the reception
of his soirees through a comprehensive analysis of contemporary reviews.
‘God and Grime’: Exploring the early History and development of Gospel Grime
Samson Tosin Onafuye, University of Wolverhampton
The arrival of Hip Hop culture in the UK during late 20 th century became a significant cultural
movement which gave voice to Britain’s disenfranchised working class diasporic youth living In
London. According to Speers (2014), “the cultural resources that hip hop offered” became
“attractive to a new generation of diasporic youth who were seeking a sense of identity and
representation in London” (2014, p. 22). Before local Hip Hop artists had begun to create what might
be considered a uniquely British Hip-Hop sound (Bennett 2000), Local MCs had first adopted AfricanAmerican expressions of Hip Hop, appropriating its sonic and aesthetic identity. By the early 21st
century, however, local interpretations of Hip Hop had developed in Britain – the birth of Grime
music. This newly created sonic profile – the converging of multiple sonic streams within the black
Atlantic (Gilroy 1993), namely, Jamaican Dub, American Hip Hop, and UK Garage – was how,
according to Charles (2018) “UK hip hop had found its voice”.
From a religious angle, for Britain’s third and fourth generation who have Christianity
forming a major part of their identities, the musico-cultural space of Grime has become a space
where MCs have been able to explore their religious identities. Using Grime aesthetics, biblically
inspired lyrics and a Christian worldview MCs articulate their lived experiences, creating what is
known as Gospel Grime culture. Therefore, using a multi-disciplinary approach, this paper seeks to
chart the early development of Gospel Grime whilst considering the ways social actors within the
scene use Grime aesthetics to perform their Christian identities.
‘Whatever hurts, it’s all mine’: hearing embodiment in SOPHIE’s It’s Okay to Cry
Jam Orrell, Royal Academy of Music
SOPHIE’s 2017 single ‘It’s okay to cry’ stands in stark contrast with her previous work. Until the
release of her 2017 album Oil of Every Pearl's Un-Insides, she had remained elusive to a point of
near-anonymity, never revealing her true trans identity (amid press ciriticism for ‘pretending to be a
woman DJ’). But upon the release of ‘It’s okay to cry’, she showed her body and, perhaps most
importantly, her own voice. Fans consider this her ‘coming out’. In this paper, I contextualise this
single within a longer history of trans femme artistry in electronic music. From Wendy Carlos to
Throbbing Gristle, or more recently Juliana Huxtable and ARCA, the creative output of trans femme
artists has largely been perceived as ‘noisy’: purely electronic sounds, distorted vocals, and industrial
soundscapes.
In much of SOPHIE’s output, her voice has been figured as similarly disembodied. But ‘It’s
okay to cry’ has been so pivotal in her output because the voice we hear is her voice; the body we
see is her body. In the video, her vulnerability is explicit both visually (sketching her naked upper
body with her fingers as she sings directly to the camera) and through her words. Acknowledging her
transgression of this received framework of disembodied trans ‘noise’, this paper will analyse
SOPHIE’s voice. Using such queer methodologies of vocal embodiment and drawing on the work of
50
Serge Lacasse and Freya Jarman, this paper will explore how SOPHIE sings vulnerability as trans
femme artistry.
Alexander Pushkin, the New Soviet Canon of Classics, and the Establishment of Early Soviet Ballet
Céleste Pagniello, University of Cambridge
Socialist realism, the cultural aesthetic that dominated much of Soviet culture, aimed to position the
Soviet Union as the cultural heir of both the rich Russian tradition and the world’s most respected
cultural traditions. Twisting the region’s heritage in such a way to make it palatable to Soviet
ideologues and in line with the state’s ideology allowed for access to a wealth of mainly 19 th-century
works, to be used as models in the creation of new Soviet art. Chief among these were the works of
19th-century Russian poet Alexander Pushkin, who quickly became the figurehead of a new Soviet
canon of classics. In ballet, the form of art most threatened by the changes brought on by the
Revolution, an association with Pushkin, through the use of one of his texts as a scenario, allowed a
ballet to establish itself as part of a rich cultural canon and as part of a long tradition of setting the
poet’s works to music. Throughout the 1930s, ballets based on Pushkin’s works dominated the
cultural scene, including seven of Boris Asafyev’s ballets, most notably The Fountain of Bakhchisarai
(1934) and The Prisoner of the Caucasus (1938). Many of these ballets are now absent from the
standard repertoire, but were instrumental in the developments that established key stylistic
features of later Soviet ballet. This paper will examine Pushkin’s evolving reputation in the early
Soviet years, before culminating in a discussion surrounding the role of the poet’s works in the
establishment of a firmly Soviet style of ballet.
An Army in Conflict: The Changing Musical and Cultural Identity of the Salvation Army in Australia
Victoria Parsons, University of Sydney
Almost since its inception, making music within The Salvation Army has become a natural expression
of worship, pubic evangelism and Salvationism. For many, participating within traditionalised musicmaking practices such as brass band, songsters (choirs), and timbral brigades have become
synonymous with “being” a Salvationist. The unique sights and sounds of brass bands and songster
brigades have become the aural signature of The Salvation Army as these worship groups capture
the very essence of Salvationism for many of its members. However, as congregational attendance
has lessened over the past thirty years, these music-making practices have slowly diminished in size.
As liturgical music tastes have shifted toward a more contemporary band setting, local corps
(churches) now incorporate worship music that is non-Salvation Army, removing the demand for
traditional music-making practices; ultimately challenging what it means to “be salvo” whilst
changing the musical landscape of the Salvation Army in Australia. Yet, as Salvation Army musicians
contend with these obstacles, many musicians have found creative ways of reproducing and
experiencing their musical heritage in new and innovative forms. Grounded in ethnographic inquiry,
this paper explores how salvationists maintain their ‘salvoness,’ or their social and personal
investment in an internally coherent sense of collective identity, through music-making activities and
what forms this may take at present.
51
Auferstanden aus Ruinen: Cultural Heritage, Identity and Politics in the Post-war Rebirth of the
Staatsoper Unter den Linden
Ekaterina Pavlova, University of Cambridge
After the Second World War, Berlin, like many other cities, was left in ruins. As early as 14 May 1945,
less than two weeks after the defeat of the Berlin garrison, the Staatsoper’s reopening was mooted
at a meeting by the first town mayor of the Soviets N. E. Bersarin. Despite many obstacles, four
months later, in the middle of post-war hunger, unemployment and instability, the first East German
opera season officially started. By 1955, despite the German Democratic Republic’s complex
economic and political
situation, the Staatsoper’s old building reopened. Many accounts have captured these events in a
descriptive manner, but the urgency with which they unfolded has received little scholarly attention.
Why was this state opera house so important in the city destroyed by the war? This thesis will take
an interdisciplinary approach and use both secondary literature and previously overlooked primary
sources from Moscow and Berlin to look at the Staatsoper’s reconstruction (1952-1955) and
reopening (4 September 1955) through the lens of Cold War politics and propaganda. I argue that
the Staatsoper’s
rebirth was a project designed to support the GDR’s propaganda of its values, goals and claims to the
status of a better Germany. Thus, the Staatsoper’s politicised rebirth vividly illustrates the role that
German culture and musical heritage were assigned in the GDR’s struggle for legitimacy and
attainment of its political goals during the first decade of the Cold War.
With Tiger Claw: Rewriting the myth of genre in piano performance through the endemic
performative practices of Baja California Sur (Lecture Recital)
María Fernanda del Peón Pacheco, Universidade de Aveiro
The geographical and social conditions in Baja California Sur, Mexico from the end of the 19th
century until the 1980’s, caused a particular way of playing different piano repertories. Geographical
isolation created a condition of almost insularity, backwardness in comparison to central Mexico’s
modernity. The migratory processes also made the regional piano performance develop its own
particular ways, it remains mostly intact, according to the tradition, with some interpretative
practices used before the 20th century, as well as developing techniques and concepts that respond
to its own aesthetic. Loudness and resonance were primary elements of this aesthetic, where the
subtleties in the sound are not a priority. In this geographical and social context, women were the
majority.
This work is part of my doctoral research that is being developed in the Doctoral Program in
Music Performance at Aveiro University; the main objective is to propose and create an
interpretation for classical and popular piano repertoires with the socio-cultural and musical
distinctive traditions found in what I define endemic interpretation. It is important for this research
to define women’s roles in piano performance and teaching, contrasting those with the myth
surrounding femininity and interpretation. In this lecture recital, I intend to show some of the
aesthetic codes found in the traditional piano performance, previously, this may have been
considered unusual for the academy and for the way in which we have been executing a certain
repertoire in relation to the score, the canonical tradition and the perspective of gender.
52
Jauk Elmaleh’s Dakka Jazz and the Casablanca jazz scene of the 1950s and 1960s
Eric Petzoldt, University of Cambridge
In 1968, Casablanca-born Jewish percussionist Jauk Elmaleh left Morocco for Paris. At a time of USAmerican jazz diplomacy tours, Elmaleh took his own interpretation of jazz, Amazigh and
Mediterranean music, which he coined Dakka Jazz, to the French capital. With Dakka he referred to
community musics and drum dances from Taroudant and Marrakesh, which he mixed with jazz
forms and approaches. Still active today, he is one of the few Moroccan jazzmen who began playing
in the first years of Morocco’s independence and have put forward the idea of an AfroMediterranean jazz practice.
This article puts particular emphasis on the beginning of Elmaleh’s career and traces how his
Dakka Jazz has come about in the context of the Casablanca jazz scene of the 1950s and 1960s. By
focusing on the time before Elmaleh’s emigration, I explore how jazz was constructed in Morocco’s
major port city Casablanca during a period, in which Morocco experienced US-American
militarization and transitioned from French colonial rule to independence in 1956.
Drawing on oral histories by Elmaleh and musicians he collaborated with during that period as well
as on archival work, I show how Moroccans understood and reinvented jazz in their own ways
against the backdrop of wider geopolitical events at a pivotal moment in Moroccan history.
Hymn To The Fallen: Constructing American Values in Saving Private Ryan
Conor Power, Maynooth University
Steven Spielberg’s Saving Private Ryan (1998) opens with a shot of the billowing American flag
accompanied in John Williams’s score by quietly noble solo horn and brass chorale. It is a musical
gesture widely associated in Hollywood film with American heroism. This paper explores how
Williams’s score constructs and reinforces the idea of America through musical tropes developed in
cinema but sourced in a range of musical idioms. I begin by sketching the genealogy of this
constructed American sound, tracing its roots to art music traditions represented by composers such
as Copland and the American symphonists and to traditions such as American hymnody and military
bands. The pastoral figures prominently here too: in what Neil Lerner terms ‘the music of wide open
spaces’, the quintessential American landscape of the Midwest becomes associated with a
Coplandesque musical language constructed with open fourths and fifths and scored
characteristically for gentle woodwind choirs and muted brass. The conjunction of Spielberg’s
American heroes and imagery (Private Ryan’s home is in the prairie), with Williams’s score
successfully constructs American ideologies and beliefs, fusing the idea of heroism with America’s
history and identity. I conclude by arguing that Saving Private Ryan, like other films in the
Spielberg/Williams partnership, has contributed to a universalisation of American values in which a
specifically American representation of the heroic has become equated in popular culture with the
very idea of heroism.
Britten and Place: Constructing a Queer Ecomusicology
Dylan Price, University of Oxford
This paper attempts to rethink questions of sexual identity in Benjamin Britten’s music. Sexuality
remains near the top of our current scholarly agenda, but attempts to support these research
interests using existing methods have often led to slightly one-dimensional hermeneutic readings of
53
this repertoire. Pursuing a new investigative strategy, the paper instead uses the nascent field of
ecomusicology as a tool with which to prise open these thorny issues of identity. In this way, it
explores the means by which a heightened sensitivity to problems of space, place, belonging and the
body might be used to reconceptualise the links between Britten’s biographical sexuality and his
compositional output. Using a number of case studies, the paper argues for the establishment of a
queer ecomusicology, exploring the means by which theorists such as Hans Ulrich Gumbrecht, Pierre
Bourdieu and Maurice Merleau-Ponty—to name but three—might be used to reinvigorate this field
of study. However, the implications of this methodological shift also extend to a myriad of other
research priorities, including race, gender and class. Might a queer ecomusicology cast new light on
these important topics?
Brim, Matt and Amin Ghaziani. 'Introduction: Queer Methods'. Women's Studies Quarterly 44, no. 3/4
(2016): 14-27.
Koestenbaum, Wayne. 'Queering the Pitch: A Posy of Definitions and Impersonations' in Queering the
Pitch: The New Gay and Lesbian Musicology, edited by Philip Brett, Gary C. Thomas and Elizabeth
Wood. New York; London: Routledge, 1994. 1-5.
Proposing a descriptive musical grammar for contemporary trad/folk music
Irfan Rais, Bangor University
Recent events catalysed by the death of George Floyd in the USA has reignited interest in previous
efforts to decolonise music in the academy and sparked new important discussions surrounding the
current state of the field of (ethno)musicology. A topic that has resurfaced again is the
predominantly white lens through which music theory is taught in schools and in universities as
highlighted by Dr Philip Ewell in his talk in the Society for Music Theory conference in 2019.
Keeping the issues brought forth by Dr Ewell and of decolonisation at the front and centre,
this paper proposes a new system of describing trad/folk music outside the frame of mainstream
music theory. The methods for doing so are borrowed from the field of descriptive linguistics, which
has firm roots in structuralist philosophy. Descriptive linguists are interested in the features that
govern everyday language used in different situations. These may be different from prescribed rules
that may have been taught and enforced in school. This paper proposes a similar approach to
describing to trad/folk music, but with more collaborations between researchers and practitioners,
which would produce material such as terminology and a corpus of contemporary repertoire.
Creating a descriptive and contemporary musical ‘grammar’ that describes trad/folk music in its own
terms not only has great academic and pedagogical potential, it also may highlight aspects of
trad/folk music that may be lacking in mainstream music theory.
The Goan song collector Agapito de Miranda: Digital media and personal songbooks, new
challenges for cultural representations
Eduardo Roque dos Reis Falcão, INET-Md, University of Aveiro
The annexation of Goa, a former Portuguese colony, by the Republic of India in 1961 was followed
by a decolonization period of uncertainty related to the destiny of the territory. In the period
between 1961 and 1987, when Goa was declared a formal state of India, the plurality of musical
practices sung in the Konkani language played new roles in the creation of narratives for a Goan
identity.
54
Agapito de Miranda (1911-1995), a Goan doctor and music amateur, produced during this
period a private collection of manuscripts related mainly to the musical practices of the Goan
Catholic elite that remained unpublished. The manuscripts contain transcriptions of melodies, song
lyrics and ethnographical notes. In 2018, these manuscripts were digitized and are being prepared to
integrate an online digital database. Therefore, this paper seeks to contribute to the increasing
research topic related to the potential of the digital database of historical music manuscripts for
ethnomusicology. How do digital media allow for the negotiation and transformation of cultural
representations? What is accessible from the past of musical practices and how can this past be
accessed? How can we ensure that these documents are not dissociated from the historical
specificities of their production? What are the implications of a second life for the manuscripts
through their digital recirculation? Exploring the concept of digital memory (HOSKINS: 2018), I
propose an analysis of the challenges involved in the digitization of historical music manuscripts and
its consequent recirculation through digital media.
Reading Between the Lines: A Case Study Exploring the Efficiency of Prescriptive Notation Within
Performance
Caoimhe Ní Riain, University of Limerick
Staff notation is a visual system of written symbols representing music. It facilitates performance,
transmission and dissemination within the tradition of classical music where it is necessary that the
written score be followed. “The reliability of a performance in classical music has become connected
to the performer’s interpretation of the musical score and the literacy of that music” (Dahl, 2009,
p.66). Staff notation however does not have the capacity to encode every nuance which may be
intended for performance. Questioning what notation does and does encode and what it can and
cannot contribute to performance, this paper engages with an original composition to explore how
three musicians respond to a piece of unseen music. Three musicians of different musical and
personal backgrounds were selected to record themselves performing a 16-bar unseen melody. They
were asked to return both their recording and an image of their marked score which they used when
preparing for the performance. Through tracing the similarities and differences between the three
musicians’ performances and through an analysis of the marked scores, this paper gives true
reflection of how prescriptive notation operates within a performance and how it is subject to
interpretation as, by its nature, it is unable to encode every nuance needed to inform performance.
Through ethnographic engagement this study realises the multiplicity of performance possibilities
embedded within the score’s notation and seeks to reimagine the score as a vehicle for creative
practice rather than part of a continuum which restricts the performer as an artist.
Eschewing teleology: an alternative approach to musical development
Marta Riccardi, University of Liverpool
Contemporary scholarship has seen an increased plurality of approaches to listening and musical
development, going beyond the teleological model of Austro-German tradition. One such alternative
model may be found in the Russian musical culture of the second nineteenth century, particularly in
the work of The Mighty Five. Balakirev’s highly idiosyncratic approach to teaching contributed to
shape a more fragmented approach to musical development, eschewing the organicism prevalent in
Europe. This paper will present examples drawn from Rimsky-Korsakov’s ‘fantastical’ operas that
illustrate non-teleological musical development and, rather, follow a cyclical progression. In the
portrayal of the supernatural, in fact, Rimsky used non-diatonic progression, distinguishing them
55
from the diatonic world of humans. Examples will include non-diatonic passages, where symmetrical
partitioning of the octave, both in major and minor thirds, impart a static yet energetic drive to the
music. While recognised for its development of octatonicism, Rimsky’s work demonstrates the
composer’s interest in a number of harmonic techniques. Analytical and historical scholarship has
seen a focus on Rimsky’s interest with minor thirds cycles, most extensively in the work of Richard
Taruskin (1985; 2011), with limited mentions of major thirds cycles (Cohn, 2012). A recent
publication by Philip Ewell (2020) has provided a first dive into the study of Rimsky’s hexatonicism,
and the present paper will draw upon and expand the evidence presented by Ewell. These analytical
considerations will be framed as an example of an alternative approach to musical development.
Tracing musical trends in dystopian film narratives
Charis Richardson, Bangor University
This paper will argue that musical representations of dystopia in film have developed over time. In
his PhD thesis, William McGinney discusses the distinct sound of science-fiction dystopia that gained
popularity during the late 1960s and early 1970s. These films made use of modernist musical
features such as atonality, dissonance, chromaticism, and electronic instrumentation to evoke a
dystopian sci-fi soundscape (McGinney, 2009, p4). According to McGinney, this was in combination
with the use of folk-style music, which represented human qualities within these dystopian
narratives. Pre-existing (and well-known) Romantic-era pieces were often used to similar effect, such
as in Stanley Kubrick’s films 2001: A Space Odessey and A Clockwork Orange.
However, a shift took place in the development of dystopian film scores during the 1980s
and 1990s. In her PhD thesis Unheard Minimalisms, Rebecca Eaton draws attention to the use of
minimalist techniques to represent dystopia in film narratives during this time. She discusses the use
of repetition (as well as other minimalist techniques) to represent themes of entrapment and
anempathy featured in dystopian narratives of this era (Eaton, 2008, p186). To decipher the
soundtrack to twenty-first century dystopia, the music for the first instalment of The Hunger Games
franchise will be explored in this paper. The film gained widespread popularity and its soundtrack
employs all the above elements in various ways: pre-existing minimalist music, original folk-style
music, avant-garde experimentalism and dissonance, as well as other stylistic features that represent
the dystopian narrative in present-day cinema.
Giovanni Bassano’s instrumental diminution figures
Andrew Robinson, University of Huddersfield
Giovanni Bassano was a Venetian instrumentalist and composer, who published two division
manuals in the late 16th century. His diminutions are considered to be part of a broad mainstream,
the antithesis of a new approach to ornamentation that emerged alongside Monteverdi’s seconda
prattica. However, my research is revealing indications of a recognisable personal style and signs of a
distinct instrumental practice. Bassano’s second book (1591) is a large collection of written
diminutions of already-composed polyphonic works. Most of these diminutions are printed with
their original texts, for either a solo voice or instrument, but some are untexted and purely
instrumental. My study includes an assessment of the differences between these groups.
I start by noting diminution-figures that Bassano uses predominantly in his instrumental
diminutions: especially triadic figures, changes of register, and syncopations. The degree to which
Bassano uses these figures, and the manner in which he uses them, is not found again in notated
56
music for almost twenty years. Moreover, uniquely among his contemporaries, Bassano takes a
figure, or a combination of figures, as the motif for the diminution of a passage of music. I will argue
that this was a pre-existing instrumental practice, glimpsed in solo ricercare, which Bassano
transferred to the diminution of polyphony. I will speculate further, that, as a development of
Venetian instrumental style, this practice can be seen as an early precursor to the separate short
sections of the new instrumental sonatas.
Applied Psychophysiology, Performance Anxiety, and the Conservatoire Musician
Claire Elizabeth Ruckert, The Royal Conservatoire of Scotland and The University of St Andrews
It is no secret that people often get nervous when they have to do things in front of an audience. In
the performing arts, performance anxiety (PA) is a pervasive problem, which is irrespective of talent
or experience, and has the potential to be so debilitating as to end a career. Developing viable
interventions for performance anxiety is especially challenging, as symptoms manifest in different
ways across individuals. Physiological PA symptoms, such as shaking, excessive sweating, or an
increase in heart rate are especially variable. The present research seeks to develop interventions for
the various manifestations of the somatic symptoms of performance anxiety using applied
psychophysiology, also known as biofeedback. Biofeedback uses a stimulus reinforcement paradigm
to allow individuals to gain conscious control over usually subconscious physiological processes such
as heart rate, skin temperature, or muscular tension. The proposed presentation will give a brief
introduction to key literature and concepts in the fields of both performance anxiety and
biofeedback, and will then go on to present a case study in which a conservatoire singer, who selfreported high levels of performance anxiety, was given a one-month heart rate variability
biofeedback intervention. A mixed-methods approach was used, with semi-structured interviews
undertaken alongside the collection of physiological data. Physiological recordings could not be
completed as intended due to COVID-19 restrictions, however thematic analysis of interviews found
that the participant reported the intervention to have positively impacted her musical practice and
overall mental wellbeing.
Sampling and East Asian Identity within contemporary Electronica
James Rushworth, University of Hull
This paper focuses on emergent trends of music-making within the genre of Electronica, specifically
focusing on issues of methodology and cultural identity in the genre’s replication of Asian Musical
characteristics. As the genre of Electronica overlaps with mainstream Western culture, the transitory
analogue and digital methodologies of Electronic music composition and production has created an
intricate engagement of inter-cultural music (Chagas, 2014) (Miller, 2010). With digital communities,
shared media platforms and audio piracy now seemingly integral to developing music cultures, it
becomes necessary to understand the introduction of elements of non-Western cultures into
Electronic Music not just as distinct cultures interacting through a digital medium, but as potential
standard-bearers of ‘borderless’ creativity.
The limited focus of East Asian identity within Electronica helps to guide a later analysis, through
which we can contend not only with cross-media aesthetics (such as futurism and Cyberpunk), but
also engage with the ideas of anachronism within non-Classical Music production (Ueno, 1999). As
such, Electronica acts as an exegesis of musical creativity that, indebted to postmodernity and
57
technology, reflects and portrays both East Asian culture and society and imprints a specific vision of
global culture.
‘C’est un sujet qui peut être encore utile’: female opera singers and the question of retirement at
the Académie Royale de Musique in Paris (1750s-1760s)
Lola Salem, University of Oxford
Shortage of good opera singers was an on-going problem throughout the 17th and 18th century
almost everywhere in Europe. But for the Académie Royale de Musique, created in Paris in 1669,
which only hired French singers for a French repertoire instead of continuously welcoming
international Italian divas like other European operas houses, the pool of talents was even tighter.
One ageing or broken voice, one unexpected death or departure could put the whole system of
production under stress. Thus, the process of retirement was a delicate matter, which intersected
crucial questions regarding the career strategies of the artists. Women, in particular, who faced
specific challenges regarding training schemes, social and moral issues, had to find their own ways to
gain agency and resilience regarding the influence of both the administration and the audience on
their lives. This issue remains an under-evaluated segment of the Académie’s history among modern
scholarship. The present paper aims to provide an original insight within its production scheme by
enhancing our understanding of the Parisian Opera’s best practices regarding the management of
the troupe, and the hurdles and solutions specific to that of the female singers cases. For doing so,
the analysis focuses on the period 1750s-1760s, which coincides with the last series of Rameau’s
opera creations, during which the departure of two main actresses (Marie Fel and Marie-Jeanne
Chevalier) triggered a tricky succession race and exposed an array of solutions provides by the
direction, the composers, and the performer themselves.
Audience Experience in Film-with-Live-Orchestra Concerts: Towards a Theory of a Liveness
Sureshkumar P. Sekar, Royal College of Music
Since 2016, 2.6 million people from 48 countries have watched, in over 1300 Film-with-LiveOrchestra (FLO) concerts, symphony orchestras perform the score live to the projection of the Harry
Potter films. FLO concerts introduce the sight and the sound of a live orchestra to newer, younger,
wider audiences. Philip Auslander defines ‘liveness’ as entailing physical copresence of performers
and audience, and ‘mediatized’ as requiring neither copresence nor temporal simultaneity of
production and reception. An FLO concert is a performance that is both live (music) and mediatized
(film). By adding a live orchestra to a film screening, an FLO concert adds a manageable challenge to
the audience’s experience of watching a familiar film, causing a state of “flow” (Csikszentmihalyi), a
state ideal for learning. Cohen’s Congruence-Associationist model explicates how the brain
processes audio and visual stimuli when watching a film. The brain, however, could skip a few steps
in the process when re-watching a familiar film, and in an FLO concert, this available mental resource
could be used to observe the live orchestra and to learn to appreciate the affective power of
orchestral music.
In this paper, I draw from the flow theory, the Congruence-Associationist model, and the
liveness theory to propose the theory of “aLiveness”—an attribute of a performance by which
audiences become conscious of the aesthetic elements of the work of art. With “aLiveness”, I
propose that orchestral music can co-opt video in its live presentation to make its internal structure
and patterns intelligible to all audiences.
58
Uncovering hegemony: Instrumental teacher education in conservatoires
Luan Shaw, Royal Birmingham Conservatoire
A skilled music education workforce is essential to ensure longevity of music-making for future
generations of young learners and, according to the 2011 Review of Music Education in England,
conservatoires have a responsibility to contribute to the development of such a workforce. Yet, little
is known about how undergraduate conservatoire students learn to teach.
The current research explores challenges faced by the conservatoire sector in preparing students for
careers involving instrumental teaching. Main reference is given to a case study at Royal Birmingham
Conservatoire (RBC) where the learning experiences of undergraduate students are investigated and
triangulated with perspectives obtained from conservatoire academics in six other English
conservatoires and senior leaders across Music Education Hubs in England. Additionally, recent RBC
graduates provide insights into how conservatoire alumni might contribute to continuing
developments in instrumental teacher education. Thus, the research is underpinned and influenced
significantly by multiple communities of practice involving both ‘newcomers’ and ‘old-timers’ (Lave
and Wenger, 1991) who, between them, offer numerous ‘insider’ and ‘outsider’ perspectives (ReedDanahay, 2016). In bringing together some of these insider-outsider perspectives, this presentation
begins to uncover hegemony in relation to instrumental teacher education in conservatoires.
According to Brookfield (2017:16) ‘The subtle cruelty of hegemony is that over time it becomes
deeply embedded, part of the cultural air we breathe.’ Findings to date suggest that hegemonic
assumptions relating to conservatoire training lead to preconceptions and create barriers to
developing the future music education workforce in a number of ways.
Gravitonicity: towards a Model of the ‘Gravitation’ in Music
James Shufflebotham, Keele University
In this paper I will outline a model of the ‘gravitation’ (Gravitonicity) in music and demonstrate it
through harmonic analyses of Western and non-Western compositions. The main component of the
model is a psychological process that attributes an array of individually perceived ‘distance’ values
for all twelve pitch classes. I posit that these frameworks are a gateway to a unified perspective on
the evolutionary stages of Western harmony and thus deserve a place within the more general
‘theory of music’. The presentation (and research in general) aim to be of value to practitioners from
all musical backgrounds, analysts of all music, and as a perspective on existing theories of music.
The study of physical gravitation has enjoyed the breakthroughs of Isaac Newton, Albert
Einstein, (arguably) string theory, and LIGO’s detection of gravitational waves. Although discourse on
the ‘gravitation’ can be traced back to the Ancient Greeks, it has witnessed no such analogous
milestones. The literature has been historically sporadic and with little consistency in approach– an
important exception being a short twentieth-century lineage with interest in the harmonic series.
Moreover, whilst there have been some significant individual contributions, no single work or
theorist has offered a perspective on the existing literature, integrated it as part of a model, and
addressed the lacunae. That is the gap that motivated this research which, using Jean-Jacques
Nattiez’s ‘Semiological Tripartition’ as a framework, aims to produce a model of the ‘gravitation’ that
also accounts for the listener’s subjective experience.
59
The Artist is Sleeping: Presence and the Disembodiment of Voice in Marina Abramovic’s Opera 7
Deaths of Maria Callas
Lea Luka Tiziana Sikau,University of Cambridge
Hans Ulrich Gumbrecht argues that presence is more obviously visible in opera than in any other art
form. What does this imply when performance artist Marina Abramovic – the artist who is present –
stages an opera? Then, performance art faces the exuding operatic voice that Erika Fischer-Lichte
calls presence. Abramovic envisioned 7 Deaths of Maria Callas as a finale of an artistic research
process about the soprano spanning three decades. She was particularly intrigued by her voice and
the aestheticization of death in opera in contrast to Callas’ death in 1977. The opera unites epitomes
of presence on a metalevel while thematically focusing on shifts to and momenta of absence. This
culminates in processes of distortion leading to vocal and physical disembodiment. Singers are
blending with video projections in front of them. Operatic micro-narratives are decoupled from the
singer’s and projected onto Abramovic’s body on a stage-capturing screen showing pre-produced
videos. Meanwhile, Abramovic is present but sleeping, having her eyes closed for two thirds of the
opera. The flickering frisson between presence and absence, embodiment and disembodiment will
be central to this discourse. Methodologically, I conducted ethnographic research during seven
weeks of rehearsal at the Bavarian State Opera in Munich to analyse creative processes beyond the
aesthetics of the final opera. Thus, this paper reflects on the deconstruction of operatic structures
through disembodiment in rehearsal processes and on stage.
Influences from Outside: The Introduction and Growth of Choirs in Reformed, Mennonite, and
Quaker Churches
Jon Snyder, Baylor University
For some theologians, music in the Renaissance church approached heresy. Although church music
reform was not the primary thrust of the early reformers, theologians such as Ulrich Zwingli and
John Calvin revolutionized church music within their traditions. Building on Calvin’s work, Menno
Simmons, the Mennonites’ namesake, called for a different kind of music that placed congregational
singing at the heart of church music. Roughly a century later, George Fox and the early Quakers
believed in the Holy Spirit’s immediacy resulting in a near-silent worship experience. The Reformed,
Quaker, and Mennonite traditions explored the primacy of the congregational voice. This
understanding led congregations and whole denominations or sects not to use choirs to add musical
elements to the service.
However, today, choral music enhances the worship in the Reformed, Mennonite, and
Quaker worshiping traditions. This research explores how all three groups were influenced by
musical, cultural, and theological forces, within and outside of the denomination, and how these
influences resulted in quality amateur choir programs. By examining three denominations’ musical
philosophies and how choirs were first denounced but later accepted, modern scholars and church
musicians can find insights about choirs’ use in twenty-first-century worship.
Playing in the Paracosm: Imagination, Hyperreality and the Video Game Experience
Raymond Sookram, Goldsmiths, University of London
In a time of so-called ‘post-truth,’ constructed experiences like social media and Disneyland convince
individuals that a ‘hyperreality’ of imagined symbols, landscapes and characters are more idealistic
60
and convincing than lived realities. Jean Baudrillard’s writings on simulated realities today have great
significance, especially with video games as one of the most popularly consumed forms of
interactive hyperreality worldwide. Links between hyperreality and the imagination are wellestablished from research into paracosms, a term created in 1976 by Ben Vincent to describe
complex imaginary worlds. Yet, whilst the benefits of imaginary play on children’s psychological
development and popular literary works have been expressed, in key psychological, literary and
media studies, sound and music have been unusually absent. In this paper, I propose a theory of
‘Paracosmic Multimedia,’ in which I suggest that immersed paracosms
extend into individuals’ simultaneous receptions of character, environment and sound between
video games and other media, shaping their thoughts and actions with the virtual and real. Through
a series of brief case studies, I will analyse the blurring between real and constructed
projections caused by the depiction of simulated characters and environments based on
sonic representations through voice, soundtrack and noise. In so doing, I will present the initial
stages of a new theoretical model which aims, for the first time, to combine video game music
research, media studies, psychological theories, and self-analytical gameplay in order to investigate
the sonic associations of video game simulations and the ways in which these associations extend
and develop between texts.
(Un)familiar faces: exploring the exotic everyday of Parade
Sara Speller, University of Oxford
The 1917 Ballets Russes premiere of Parade ended with an angry audience, negative reviews, and a
short jail sentence for its composer, Erik Satie. Scholars and modernists have analysed Satie’s
musical form, Pablo Picasso’s cubist costumes and setting, and Léonide Massine’s choreography in
this extraordinary work conceived by Jean Cocteau. However, these scholars often fail to critically
engage with the concepts of Otherness, disenfranchisement, and tragedy that are laced into the
ballet.
In this paper, I challenge previous, decontextualized readings of Parade, and offer a new
analysis that centres the ballet in the power structures and cultural conventions of its original
backdrop: wartime Parisian society. I begin by introducing Parade and its collaborators; then, I
define the ‘Other’ in 1910s France, and consider each collaborator’s relationship to the Other using a
combination of biographical documents and relevant historical research. My analysis follows,
wherein I argue that the audience is an active, though unwitting, participant in the ballet, and their
expectations are subverted as they watch the Ballet Russes’ dancers imitate contemporary circus
performers on stage. The audience’s discomfort grows throughout the show, climaxing in the
anxious, chaotic finale; as the curtain drops, the audience realizes the production is a depiction of
real-life tragedy for the Parisian Other, and is forced to reckon with their own complicity in the
sufferings of the disenfranchised, on stage and in real life. This reading offers a glimpse into
analysing western musical works while working to decentre whiteness in music historiography.
A Musical Favourite: Salieri at the Court of Emperor Joseph II
Ellen Stokes, University of Huddersfield
The musical life of the late-eighteenth-century Viennese court was culturally rich and developed,
supported by the zealous patronage of Joseph II who reigned from 1765 until 1790. Central to the
court’s music was Antonio Salieri, the Italian composer who held some of the most important
61
musical positions in Vienna, including those of Imperial Kapellmeister (1788-1824) and Director of
the Italian Opera (1774-1792). My PhD research has a specific focus on Salieri’s instrumental
manuscripts, a largely unassessed area of his oeuvre that can provide key musical insight into the
activities and structures of Viennese court life.
This paper will focus on the Josephinian period, which spanned Salieri’s ascension from
assistant composer to Imperial Kapellmeister, and explore some early hypotheses regarding where,
when, why, and how this instrumental music could have been performed within the court setting.
Much of the music is fragmentary and likely mislabelled, therefore a key aspect of the research is
understanding the content of the manuscripts in order further illustrate the trajectory of musical life
in Vienna, as well as Salieri’s career. The paper will employ musical examples to outline how both
the court environment and early-career influences (including composers Gassmann and Gluck) are
reflected in the musical style and output. Salieri is an important figure in understanding both court
composers and the Viennese musical canon. Cultural environment and professional requirements
significantly affected compositional output, and Salieri’s career was dictated by, and flourished
within, the musical centre of the late-eighteenth-century Viennese court.
Reconstructing the uneasy nexus between ‘western art music’ and Christianity
Samuel Tandei, Baylor University
Historiographies of the development of ‘Western art music’ (hereafter, WAM) often intersect with
those of Christianity, particularly in the Western Hemisphere. The notion that WAM stands closer to
Christianity than other faith traditions is still common to be found in many discourses. Furthermore,
Christianity is still by far the world’s largest religious group, according to a report from Pew Research
Center in 2017, while WAM continues to thrive as a field of study and socio-musical phenomena in
many places and contexts. In many ways, the relationship between WAM and Christianity is rather
intricate. One may find that it has often been looked at from a plainly teleological—or even
sometimes—theological angle. Others dismiss this relationship entirely and rather naively.
Nevertheless, this paper attempts to reconstruct this uneasy nexus from a different viewpoint that
refuses to assume a linear relationship. Since the concept of music itself has evolved from being a
single object into multiple and aggregated, simultaneous forms of existence (Born 2017), it allows
more possibilities of a two-way relationship with the Other. Thus, I am arguing that the relationship
between these two still cannot be ignored. One possible approach is by transgressing the
conventional boundaries, as well as incorporating the ethnomusicologies of Western art music and
Christianities (Nooshin 2011, 2013; Reily and Dueck 2016; Engelhardt 2015; Engelhardt and Bohlman
2016) that offer a more comprehensive approach to deal with the complexities within and between
the two subjects.
Piercing Through the ‘Gloomy Silence’: Musicians’ Livelihoods in Civil War and Commonwealth
England (c.1642-1660)
Samuel Teague, University of Oxford
Between 1642 and 1660 musical activity ceased in England, or at least this is what we have been led
to believe. Through the passing of legislation, the Puritan parliament effectively brought the
longstanding musical traditions in Church, Chapel and court to a halt, limiting the previously large
pool of available musical professions. However, the dearth of musical activity – often claimed as a
hallmark of this period – is an exaggeration, with numerous and varied examples of musicians
62
adapting to the new norm in England throughout these 18 years. What is, perhaps, more significant
than the number of examples is the nature and significance of these career tendencies.
This paper will discuss the means by which musicians survived the period of Civil War and
Commonwealth (c.1642-1660), as a result of the new socio-political climate in England. The
investigation of some 124 musicians active during this period reveals a wealth of variety in the
professions still available to musicians. This same investigation also brings to light a number of
significant trends that directly oppose the commonly held historical belief that music in Puritan
England, for a time, was near non-existent. Three distinct categories of employment (individual
employment, musical meetings, and the growth of music publications for the domestic market)
become evident from the data and allow one to probe aspects of the developing musical culture in
England, which have wide reaching implications for later tendencies in musical life across the
country.
Affective sensations when vocalizing kulning – the herding calls of the North
Jennie Tiderman-Österberg, Örebro University, Sweden
The Nordic herding call kulning origins from fäbod farming - an Alpine transhumance system which
means seasonal transfer of livestock to the forest and mountain commons where cows, goats, and
sheep graze freely, herded by women. The fäbod farming has decreased, but kulning lives on in
many different contexts today. It is used as ceremonial music, in movie soundtracks and operas, and
as voice therapy for the depressed. Previous research has shown that many of those who perform
kulning, speak of strong emotional sensations when calling; emotions connected to heritage and
female empowerment. But what does heritage and empowerment feel like? What happens when
affective sensations are felt and what constitutes these sensations? This is what my
ethnomusicological PhD project is about. Based on participant observations and interviews, I am
approaching this with an experience perspective, focusing on socio-material affect, affectivity and
sensescape. My presentation includes a brief historical background of Nordic fäbod farming and its
herding calls, as well as a demonstration of the musical components of the calls, and at last a
description of my ongoing PhD project where I discuss my methods for studying affect.
From the Tropics to the Snow (1964): Exploring emotions of white masculine nation-building in
Australian government film scores of the mid-1960s
Emma Townsend, University of Melbourne
In the post-war period the Australian Commonwealth Government created hundreds of nationbuilding films about Australia and its ‘way of life’, and these films literally depict this nation-building
purpose via numerous narratives centred on white men’s public-sphere employment. This paper
explores aspects of the emotions and character qualities of this labour in Judy Bailey’s and Eric
Gross’s film score to the meta-fictional, satirical movie From the Tropics to the Snow (1964). Music’s
role in conveying filmic emotions is well established, while cultural representations have been
theorised as processes whereby individual emotions become both collective and political.
Consequently, examining musical renderings of characterisations in this score provides an
opportunity to highlight and examine onscreen characters’ nation-building work, as well as the
shared emotions that the then-Australian government, the Menzies government, sought to shape. I
suggest that in mid-1960s Australian government film there was an expansion of white working
masculinity to encompass greater emotionality and expressivity.
63
Unable or Unwilling to Love: Chastity and (Non-)Desire in Seventeenth-Century Venetian Opera
Cathal Twomey, Maynooth University
Like many kinds of popular entertainment, the opera of seventeenth-century Venice relied heavily
on formulae. From the lamenting queen to the comic servant, creators had numerous stock
characters and plot elements to draw upon, recombine, and vary almost endlessly. However, the
genre’s daring treatment of sexuality often overshadows a significant stock character-trait: sworn
chastity, the rejection not only of one specific courtship, but of sexual (and usually romantic)
intimacy in general.
Characters that assert such convictions (particularly women, and most such assertors are
female in these operas) stand firmly apart from societal norms. Yet, far from embodying a
monolithic stereotype, these characters offer a wide range of perspectives on desire, charting
diverse courses through their respective music-dramas as they attempt to reconcile their vow with
the pressures of a world (and sometimes a person) that seeks to invalidate them. This paper surveys
some of the character-type’s most prominent incarnations, many of whom separate sex not only
from romance but also from sensuous pleasure (partnered and otherwise), validating non-standard
relationships in a manner strikingly evocative of twenty-first-century asexual discourse. It examines
both the origins and outcomes of such convictions, from necessity to fear to genuine disinterest, and
from empoweringly happy to disturbingly ‘corrective’ and cautionary endings. And it interrogates
the numerous ways in which the characters themselves portray their convictions, from the identity
crisis faced by Diana upon realizing that she has fallen in love, to Penelope’s carefully cultivated (yet
not necessarily dissembled) image as a perpetually mourning widow.
“Could You Call Us Women Comrades?” Careers, Lives and Professional Experience of Women
Composers in Communist Czechoslovakia
Barbora Vacková, University of Huddersfield
With the communist coup d’état in 1948, the musical life in Czechoslovakia underwent a profound
change. All composers willing to have their music performed, recorded or published had to join the
Union of Czechoslovak Composers as the state’s official centralized platform supervising and
managing all musical activity in the country, and adjust both the style and content of their musical
work to conform to specific aesthetic and political criteria.
A question so far completely overlooked in scholarly study is how the new political arrangement
which set gender equality as one if its official agendas impacted women as a marginalized group in
the field of composition. Did the union memberships empower them? Were they perceived as equal
to men? And why did their numbers remain extremely low? In this paper, I am offering some initial
insights and challenges I encountered through my research of the previously unexamined composer
unions’ archives, period press and the composers’ personal testimonies. I argue that the official
egalitarian agenda manifested itself mostly as gender-blindness, discouraging critical examination of
persisting inequalities and disabling the articulation of women’s demands in a bottom-up manner.
Moreover, I discuss the problem of the double-burden which prevented women from dedicating
sufficient amounts of time to their artistic practices. Focusing on women composers’ experience in a
world where women’s rights agenda had been “expropriated” by the leading party, my presentation
shall contribute to the wider understanding of the lives of 20 th century women composers in the
countries of the Eastern bloc.
64
The ironical exegesis of Mahler’s Seventh Symphony: a “Rezeptionsfrage”?
Alice Verti, University of Innsbruck
This paper shall give an overview of Mahler’s Seventh Symphony’s history of reception with
particular regard to the development of its ironical exegesis. A comparative examination the
symphony’s reviews and analysis, aimed to retrace the advancement of such interpretative
approach, has never been carried out, despite the Seventh’s well-known controversial status in
Mahler’s oeuvre. The signature ambivalence of this symphony, its inner contradictions and the
diversity of its characters have been addressed by reviewers and musicologists steadily ever since its
premiere in 1908, laying the ground for a certain skepticism toward its meaning(s) and even its
worth. The Seventh, despite not being typically enumerated among Mahler’s ‘humorous’
(humoristisch) works, has increasingly been interpreted as a self-reflective, ambiguous and, finally,
ironical text, in which abrupt contrasts, meta-musical phenomena, intertextual elements and even
manneristic traits encouraged scholars and critics to question its straightforwardness. Nonetheless
not all forms and manifestations of irony are suitable to become hermeneutical tools to better
understand and ‘decipher’ the Seventh. The aesthetical categories and poietic tendencies of the socalled romantic irony though are strikingly akin to those detected in both early reviews and later
analysis of the symphony, as my proposed commentary to these sources would highlight. The
present paper shall endeavour to summarise the history of the aforementioned ironic exegesis of
this work, delving into a chronologically wide range of reactions, readings and attitudes toward the
symphony that ultimately consolidated its divisive reputation.
The Canons and Counterpoints of Costanzo Festa
Roberta Vidic, Hochschule für Musik und Theater Hamburg
It is not easy to write on “performance-centered histories of unwritten traditions” (van Orden, IMR
2019)—especially in absence of biographical or context information. My current research regards
the counterpoint teaching and practice of members of the papal chapel with a special emphasis on
the singer-composer Costanzo Festa (c1485/90–1545). A major challenge is to determine, if we deal
with examples of written-out improvisation (Canguilhem 2017), or with the essentially written
culture of artificioso compositions (Newcomb 2015). By focusing on two of the most relevant issues
of source attribution and genre classification, this paper contributes to the lively debate on the
knowledge transfer between Franco-Flemish and Italian composers and the emergence of a ‘Roman
School.’
The first 125 contrapuntal settings over ‘La Spagna’ in I-Bc C.36(1) are probably the work of
Festa (Agee 1996, 1997, Rodríguez-García 2014). However, the certainty of his authorship remains
nothing but undisputed (Sabaino 1998, Wuidar 2008, Pastore 2016). My discussion of the source
attribution will consider both historical research and experimental support from computer-assisted
corpus analysis. The Codex I-Rsc G.Mss.384 contains some canons by Festa and his colleague Charles
D’Argentilly (c1500?–1557), whereby D’Argentilly’s ‘Bon temps’ can be called a canonic chanson
(Josephson 1982). Taken as a whole, this small group of pieces belongs to the same sort of “doublechoir canons” (Carver 1981/82) as Festa’s better-known motet ‘Inviolata’ in I-Rvat CS 20. Research
results go even beyond a matter of genre classification, connecting this unique example from a
choir-book with external activities of chapel members.
65
Immersion learning, imitation, and diversity of knowledge in West Javanese traditional dance
transmission
Véronique Walsh, SOAS, University of London
This paper concerns the transmission of traditional Sundanese dance from Indonesia. The Sundanese
are an ethnic minority from the highland province of West Java with a culture and language of their
own. Sundanese choreographers have developed an array of ‘traditional’ dances, combining rural
folk dance associated with pre-Islamic rituals, with Javanese court dance, masked dance drama from
the northwest coast and other genres. Historically dancers come from families of seniman,
traditional performing artists, who trained within the family. Now teaching occurs in a range of
formal and informal settings and dance is a popular extra-curricular activity for schoolchildren.
Training in the home of a traditional dancer is intensive; sessions may continue for hours
without break. During a lesson, while teacher and students are absorbed in dance, a fleeting
intrusion occurs as a younger child joins in. This seemingly insignificant incident is the source of my
investigation. Based on my fieldwork of Sundanese dance teaching in domestic and institutional
settings, I discuss learning through immersion. Using examples from my fieldwork, I explore visual
and verbal transmission of operational and representational knowledge, learning dance movements
alongside signifiers that symbolise the dance. I discuss the environment that facilitates immersive
learning. As folk dance training moves from domestic into formal settings, opportunities to learn
through immersion diminish, yet the family dynamic persists.
Sounding the Cosmogram: a Tantric approach to Karnatic rhythm (Lecture Recital)
Helen Anahita Wilson, SOAS, University of London
In Karnatic music, rhythms can be conceived as “heard shapes” and are categorised in six geometric
varieties. These same geometries feature in Tantric philosophy as cosmograms or yantras, where
they are deployed as tools for visualisation in meditation and ritual practice. In this lecture recital, I
consider the synergies between these systems and examine how these geometric shapes can
provide a potential map for performance, which deviates from the orthodox and sequential norms
of Karnatic performance. Using cosmograms as a musically navigable graphic score, the traditional
structures of Karnatic rhythm are transducted using vocals and electronics in synchronisation with a
visual animation.
Whereas Karnatic performances steadfastly adhere to traditional protocols, Tantra,
pervasive throughout South India, involves practices which deviate from convention and endeavour
to achieve transcendence through the infringement of normal rules of conduct. Inspired by
Oliverosian ‘deep listening’, this spatial treatment of konnakol interrupts traditional practice by
following the subversive logic of a Tantric approach to Karnatic rhythm, rejecting formal
performance conventions in favour of layering konnakol-influenced sonic material.
Conservatoire students of the past: the first year’s intake, 1893-4, at the Royal Manchester College
of Music (RMCM)
Anna Wright, The Royal Northern College of Music
Most people who work or study in the UK higher education sector will be aware of the surveys
undertaken to establish what graduates do after they have completed their studies. Previously
known as DLHE and now ‘Graduate Outcomes’ the information gathered provides an insight into
66
career destinations. Whilst acknowledging that a conservatoire education in the late nineteenth
century was different from that of today, in this paper I will undertake a similar review of the first
students to enter, and graduate from, the Royal Manchester College of Music. Using information
extracted from archival material I will examine the first cohort to enter in 1893/4, making use of
student registers and other documents to present statistics relating, inter alia, to principal study,
age, gender, social class and family background.
In the second part I will focus on those who completed their studies, graduated with a
diploma (in Performance or Teaching or both) and subsequently had some sort of career in music. I
will explore what is known about their activities at the College, including by whom they were taught,
the concerts they gave and their examination recital programme. Drawing on sources such as census
returns, websites, newspaper reports and classified advertisements I will follow those whose
subsequent career can be traced. My aim is to provide an understanding of who were the
conservatoire students in Manchester in the 1890s and what happened to them after they left the
RMCM.
Cultural Dissonance in Popular Chinese Piano Tutor Books
Fengyi Zhang, University of Sheffield
Many popular piano tutor books used currently in China are originally from the Western world and
especially North America, republished in Chinese versions for Chinese pupils to learn the piano. In
the process of using these Western piano tutor books to teach Chinese pupils, cultural differences
between the West and China constantly push themselves to the fore. On the basis of a broad survey
of popular piano tutor books in China, this paper will focus on three key points. Firstly, these
Western piano tutor books rely on cultural literacy and also create a kind of cultural literacy for
pupils to learn. The ways in which the authors of piano tutor books engage in enculturation,
designed to resonate with North American culture and values, cause obstacles to Chinese pupils’
understanding, both interculturally and in terms of piano pedagogy. Secondly, the
metaphorical/analogical approach to learning, which seems so natural to teachers and students of
Art and Humanities subjects in the West, is in fact culturally specific. For example, in some Western
piano textbooks, a kinaesthetic analogy between bodily movements (such as in play or sport) and
movement around the musical “space” of a key (or a keyboard) is engaged to help pupils learn new
concepts on the piano. This kinaesthetic approach is unfamiliar to Chinese students who are used to
more direct verbal instruction, as is commonly used to teach the piano in the Chinese tradition.
Finally, translating English to Chinese in the Chinese versions of these Western tutor book also
creates dissonance. For example, words such as “step” and “skip” are used to imply particular forms
of key movement, drawing on a play analogy. However, the Chinese translations of these terms do
not carry the same meanings or resonances. It is difficult not to conclude that cultural differences
hinder the effectiveness of Western piano tutor books translated for use in China; nonetheless, even
though home-grown Chinese tutor books are now available, adapted Western examples remain the
most commonly used in everyday piano lessons in China.
67
The reception of Arab traditional vocalization zaghareet in the selected composition by Samir
Odeh Tamimi
Petra Zidaric Györek, University of Music and Performing Arts, Graz
New compositional strategies over the last three decades developed profoundly under the
interaction of different musical cultures (in this case European and Arab), resulting with the concept
of intercultural composing and as such are challenging to the current research field of musicology
and music theory. This paper will discuss the reception of specific vocalization performed primarily
by women in the Middle Eastern countries into the western compositional concepts. One of the
leading protagonists of new music and internationally acclaimed composer based in Berlin, originally
from Palestine – Samir Odeh Tamimi, confronts himself as a composer with his own ethnic
background using western contemporary compositional techniques and connecting them with
mentioned Arab traditional vocal practice. The analysis of Samir Odeh Tamimi’s composition for
orchestra and three female voices Gdadrója, (2005) will demonstrate how the reception of selected
Arab musical material, i.e. vocalization zaghareet, interacts with western contemporary
compositional techniques; if a clearly audible difference between these two musical cultures exists
in the sound; or if the authenticity of vocalization could be lost during the transformational
processes based on the western compositional techniques. At the same time, analysis opens a space
for identity discourse in which there will be pointed out how in the composition of new music, the
vocalization could serve as indication of ethnicity and identity but simultaneously be treated as an
extended new vocal contemporary compositional technique.
COMPOSITION WORKSHOPS
Little Hunt
Cydonie Banting, King’s College London
‘Little Hunt’ is the first movement of a larger work for piano trio that forms part of my doctoral
thesis ‘Learning to Compose as a Tool of Ethnographic Research in a Rural Ugandan Village’. Its
advances the theorisation and practice of composition as a methodological tool in ethnomusicology,
much like learning to perform the instruments of another culture has been for the discipline. This
piece reflects ongoing creative exchanges between the local Bakiga community and myself as a
British artist. The kahiigi (small hunter) folk-song is thus weaved into the fabric of the composition,
in a structure building towards its eventual climactic statement. Varied repetitions of the opening
material unfold in a series of seamless sections, where a distinctive string glissando in octaves grows
from a moment of repose to being a catalyst for musical gearchange later in the movement.
Plodding crotchets in the piano linger in the grumbling, lower register, set against high spread
chords. This opens up space for a solo violin melody, inverting the fourth of the folk-song into a
descending line. Soon the music reaches another articulation of the string glissandi in octaves.
However here, the cello’s chance at a solo is cut short. The music propels towards statement of the
folk-song in four-part imitation at two pitch levels. Metric modulation then ensues, with melodic
fragments derived from the opening presented as a cantus firmus by the cello. Meditations on the
movement’s thematic material glide into the return of plodding pizzicato chords, now their original
tempo.
68
Adrenaline
Ignacio Mañá Mesas, University of Cambridge
This work is a tribute to youth, particularly to its nonconformist spirit, sudden personality changes
and desire to explore new experiences, cultures and philosophies of life. All of this is reflected in the
music by means of a blend of musical styles, ranging from contemporary classical
music to jazz and popular idioms. The music is also permeated by some elements of Spanish folk
music. As such, the string instruments are sometimes employed as a flamenco guitar, using
extended techniques such as the Bartók pizzicato as an imitation of emphatic guitar chords and the
‘taconeo’. The best illustration of the flamenco influences can be observed at bar 75, where the
strumming effects on the violin and cello are clearly reminiscent of a flamenco guitar.
Vāyuvēra
Saman Samadi, University of Cambridge
‘Come to the edge,’ he said.
‘We can't, we're afraid!’ they responded.
‘Come to the edge,’ he said.
‘We can't, we will fall!’ they responded.
‘Come to the edge,’ he said.
And so they came.
And he pushed them.
And they flew.
(Guillaume Apollinaire)
The duality of finite space and time was evolved, to form the cosmos, from Vāyu (the infinite Space)
and Zruwan (infinite Time), ancient Persians believed. The benevolent alliance of Space-Time was
augured in the Zoroastrian Avesta. Vāyu, a multifaceted Iranian deity of wind and space, was
primordially there to shield the creation of Spənta Mainyu. Vayū is superior to both Spənta Mainyu,
the Beneficent Spirit, and Aŋra Mainyu, the Evil Spirit. Ahura Mazdā, the creator of the two Spirits,
ought to entreat Vayū for help. Vāyu could appear as a Good Wāy (Wāy ī weh) and the Bad Wāy
(Wāy ī wattar); either a yazata (spirit worthy of worship) or daeva (evil spirit), depending upon the
course along which the wind blew. In Zurvanism, Vāyu-Vātu represented one facet of the quaternary
divinty Zuvan: the vastness of Infinite Space.
The practicable co-existence of the notions of Dastgah in Persian music and the twelve-tone equal
temperament of Western music may, through a conventional worldview, be considered as a mode of
Leibniz's incompossibility — reciprocally antithetical, and unattainable within a sole sphere;
69
however, inclined by Gilles Deleuze’s philosophical concept of the Rhizome and Pierre Boulez’s
concept of the Diagonal, artistic divergences and incompossibilities of such, may coexist and
synchronise in the same world.
Vāyu is one etymon I have used to form the word Vāyuvēra to title this composition; and vēra is
derived from the Sanskrit morpheme ver, meaning “root” or “rhizome”. As the ruptured rhizome
which is competent to recommence new or adventitious roots integrating to create a new
embodiment, Vāyuvēra is an endeavour operating an alternative way of striating pitch space
drawing from the constitutions of both Western and Persian musical traditions in a quest for a
smooth rhizomatic musical space-continuum.
(Encyclopedia Iranica; Encyclopedia Britannica; Deleuze and Guattari, 1988; Campbell, 2013)
Postcard-sized Pieces
Sophie Stone, Canterbury University
Postcard-sized pieces are a set of small open scores, which may be played or enacted in any way with
several ideas suggested in the score. The postcards can be categorised into ‘text’, ‘staff’, ‘blank’ and
‘recording task’ scores, with a variety of notations, including verbal, graphic, and hybrids using
traditional Western notation. The set of postcards are for open instrumentation and duration, but
here a realisation is specially curated for piano trio (piano, violin and cello) with the specific players
in mind. The soundworld of this realisation is reflective of Sophie Stone’s compositional practice in
experimental music which investigates experiences of quiet sounds and silence, improvisation, and
modes of listening, such as Pauline Oliveros’s ‘Deep Listening’. The composition is a part of Stone's
PhD research into multiplicity as a process of experimental music. The project invites a wide array of
interpretations, which may not necessarily be performative or musical. The postcard-sized pieces
explore multiplicity as a meta-concept, with individual contributing realisations. This concept can be
viewed as ‘the event’ in French philosopher Alain Badiou’s ontology of multiplicity outlined in his
book Being and Event (1988, translated 2005).
70