Compensating Sales Force
Compensating Sales Force
Compensating Sales Force
FORCE
•Market Parity
Necessary
Creating differentiated •Pay for measured and visible
Value for the benefits performance – differentiation is key –
share holder should extend to development and
Recognition opportunity
Intrinsic
Extrinsic – all
things to
which we can
assign a rupee
value
Determining the basis of pay
potential
visible
Performance evaluation
Assessment
Aims of the Compensation policy
• To recognise the value of a job vis-à-vis all other jobs
within the company.
• To maintain external parity by maintaining balance
with rates paid by similar companies (size, product,
philosophy).
• Ensuring stable earnings to deserving employees.
• To provide individuals a reasonable and practical
opportunity to reach their full earning potential.
• To encourage employees to use their initiative and
practice discretion.
• To encourage work of high quality.
Effects of Pay Dissatisfaction
Performance
P
a y Desire for
More Pay Absenteeism
Dissa
tisfa
ction
Psychological
Grievances
Withdrawal
Job
Job Stress,
Dissatisfaction Anxiety
Poor Mental
Turnover
Health
Individuals are satisfied with the rewards they
receive in the following terms:
• INDUSTRY TYPE
– Predictable products with short sales cycles
– Less predictable products with longer sales cycles
Equity
The plan must be fair and create relatively equal opportunities for earning
significant incomes
Profit
The business cannot give away too much
Ease of administration
Important to avoid creating an overly complicated plan that will be difficult to
administer.
Easy to understand
Sales people and all other employees have to be able to understand how the
plan works.
WHAT TO KEEP IN MIND?
Reward
The plan must reward sales personnel in a manner that is consistent
with their production.
Unintended windfalls
Protection against paying for unearned sales (not associated with
effort of sales person) must be built into the plan.
Longevity
A good sales compensation plan will weather large increases in sales
volume and be able to remain in place for long periods of time.
LEARNINGS: Factors affecting sales
compensation programme
Age of Sales staff:
• Older sales representatives- More stability & less risk: Considerable salary
component
Industry Type:
• Highly predictable products & short sales cycles: Sales staff with a commission-
based compensation package
Ex: Retail, food service, insurance
Specific Requirements
• To attract aggressive, independent "hunters” - Pay 100% commission
• To attract more security-oriented "minders ” - Offer a large base salary
• They may not be as driven, but they may excel at service and building
relationships
Factors affecting sales compensation
programme
Industry standards/ What competitors pay
• When an industry leader sets a certain pay scale, followers or less competitive
participants tend to emulate the leader's behaviour.
• Over time, industry pay norms develop.
• Incentive Compensation
– The most common way to motivate and reward salespeople for closing big
deals or meeting goals is through bonuses and commission.
– Profit-sharing plans can be used too, but these reward team efforts, not
individual performance.
• Non-financial Incentives
– Awards, recognition, vacation and promotions
ETHICAL ISSUES IN COMPENSATION
• Hire the best salesperson for the lowest possible salary
• Straight Salary
• Straight Commission
• Combination Plan
Straight – Salary Plan
• Simplest form of compensation plan
Disadvantages
• income is not tied to sales results, lessening motivation to sell
• encourages overemphasis on products easiest to sell
• best performers under-compensated relative to reps performing at
lower levels
• compensation costs are fixed and do not vary with revenues
Best Applications
• when selling process is long and involves multiple
contributors
• when support/missionary activity is significant portion
of job
• when personnel are rotated in and out of selling force
• when product features or other factors are responsible
for sale (only product available, market position
dominant, stable customer base, high barriers to
market entry, etc.)
• predominance of house accounts; other accounts are
“nice to have”
• when it is desirable to have costs fixed and known
“Base Pay only”
Advantages Disadvantages
Separate accounts are established for each salesperson, to which commissions are
credited and against which periodic withdrawals are made.
Disadvantages
• no protection against excessive payments unless “cap” is used to
limit earnings
• no protection against loss of income during slow sales (“draw” may
provide short-term income continuity)
• rewards only sales, no credit for support activity or “investing in
the future”
• creates different set of pay practices and raises equity questions by
other personnel
Best Applications
• company feels no obligation to provide guaranteed
annual wage (may be seasonal product, part-time
personnel, etc.)
• “reps” or other non-employees are used as a sales
force
• high variability in income is acceptable (no concern
about supervisor/subordinate earnings relationships)
• there is no mobility between direct selling jobs and
other jobs in the organization
• there is a high variable market demand and/or
customer base
“Variable Pay only”
Advantages
Disadvantages
Such plans are developed to capture the advantages and offset the disadvantages of
both the salary and commission systems.
Advantages:
Sales personnel have both security of stable income and stimulus of direct financial
incentive.
Management has both financial control over sales activities and the
Disadvantages:
The plan may become complicated and not understood by the sales personnel.
Disadvantages
Disadvantages
• good forecasting is necessary (must determine what level of sales
“earns” salary)
• salary portion of compensation is a fixed cost; if set too high
rewards below standard performance
• fixed costs (salaries) reduce funds available to discriminate
between high and low levels of performance
Best Applications
• relationship of compensation with other
personnel is important (considerable mobility
in and out of sales jobs)
• significant portion of job is sales support
(need to elicit multiple behaviors)
• substantial amount of income must be
guaranteed in order to attract and retain
personnel
Compensation plan design
alternatives cont..
• Straight Commission plans
• Combination of Salary and Incentive Plan
• Other Benefits
– Bonuses
– Fringe Benefits
Compensation plan design
alternatives cont..
• Salary plus Commission Plan
• Bonus Plan
• Sales Incentive Plans
Need of a good compensation plan:
Designing a good Compensation
Programme
It should equitably and consistently recognize and compensate employees
for superior performance. Ability to use the bonus as a motivational tool.
It should have some degree of flexibility in order to meet the unique needs
of both your company and employees.
Process Involved
Define the Sales Job
Appraisal Implemen t
and Long-an dSh ort-
Recycling RangeP rogram s
• Sales Volume
• Customer Satisfaction
• Value – based Model
• Net profit basis
– Increasing sales revenue( to drive the top-line
revenue item)
– Reducing sales expenses( to reduce one of the
cost line items)
– Selling a different mix of products ( focussing
on those products with a higher profit
contribution)
Process Involved
Special company needs and problems
Select the
Budget Establish the
Perfect
Elements Budget
Award
Variable Fixed
Experience Age of
Area Leads Target 80% 20% new
in the customer
Potential Converted Achieved growth acquisition
company in network
MARICO
• Marico focuses on value & volume target .
There is a fixed pay along with the incentives
Store manager
Duty manager
Sales Associate
IT
• Strategy – Client Profit Planning
• Type of Selling – Consultative / Technical
• Sales Person – Creative Sales person of
Intangible Product
• Compensation Plan - Combination of
Salary and Incentive Plan
Nucleus Software Exports ltd.
• A CMM level 5 company.
• Provides product and software solutions for
banking and financial institutions.
• Main area of focus is retail banking, credit
cards, trade financing and collections
Compensation
Compensation mainly consists of 2 components
• Fixed component
• Variable component – average 10%
– Company meeting its targets
– Trainings attended
• Sales Incentive Plan (SIP) is not part of the CTC
Compensation
• SIP is set according to geographical targets
• A sales person must meet 80% of his target in order to
be eligible for SIP
• SIP takes into consideration the value of the client
being associated with the company
• SIP lays more emphasis on the value of the client
rather than on the volume
• If the threshold target is met, then he is entitled to a
specific percentage of the revenue earned from his
client (Revenue is considered only after complete
payment by the client irrespective of the delivery of
the product).
Compensation
• Travel Reimbursement
• Miscellaneous Expenses (on the Client)
• Fringe Benefits – Medical Coverage
INDUSTRY
AUTOMOBILE
• Strategy – Persuasion
• Type of Selling – Direct / Commercial
• Sales Person – Inside Order taker /
Outside Order taker
• Compensation Plan - Combination of
Salary and Incentive
Plan
Honda
BANKING
& NBFC
• Strategy – Persuasion / Negotiation
• Type of Selling – Direct / Commercial
• Sales Person – Inside Order taker / Creative
Sales person of Intangible
Product
• Compensation Plan - Combination of
Salary and Incentive Plan
FUTURE MONEY
INSURANCE
• Strategy – Persuasion
• Type of Selling – Direct / Commercial
• Sales Person – Creative Sales Person of
Intangible Product
• Compensation Plan - Combination of
Salary and Incentive
Plan
Future Generali
• Joint venture between Future Group and
Generali Group, the leading Italy-based
Insurance Company
• Both in Life and Non-Life businesses
• Leading player in the global insurance and
financial markets
Compensation
Elements of salary:
• Basic Salary, Housing allowance
• Daily Allowance (on field visit) - 250 Rs/Daily, 300Rs/day if out of territory
• Travel Allowance- either show tickets or on per km basis (Rs 5-7)
• Medical- Reimbursable vouchers for medical expenditures
• Outstation allowance- Rs 500/day
• Mobile- Rs 800/month
• Insurance coverage
• Medical Coverage for themselves & dependents
• No pensions
• PF, Gratuity, LTA & annual bonus, loans
Incentives
• 8-10% on achieving sales targets in their regions.
• Extra incentives for new product launches
• Paid trips on achieving big targets
• Gifts like electronic items
Awards
• Letters of appreciation/awards in annual functions
• Prizes for the top sales achievers in a region
Benefits
• Get DABUR products on a discounted price
SALES MANAGERS
Fixed:Variable - 70:30
Elements of salary
• Basic Salary, Housing allowance
• Daily Allowance (on client visit) - 150 Rs/Daily
• Travel Allowance- when they go for sales meetings
• Medical- Reimbursable vouchers for medical expenditures
Incentives
• 5-7% on achieving sales targets.
• Targets like: 10 lacs (in value) for a year or 200 room bookings for a year
Awards
• Letters of appreciation/awards in annual functions
• Prizes for the top sales achievers in a region
Benefits
• Discounts on banquets on personal bookings
• Insurance coverage by Kotak Mahindra
• Medical Coverage for themselves & dependents
• No pensions
• PF, Gratuity, LTA & annual bonus, loans
• No extra incentive for CVGR.
FINDINGS:
Higher fixed part:
Mid-Aged Sales Personnel
Other:
Type of clients defines the competition
No stress on CVGR incentives
Some features:
• Premium Rates
• Mostly private organizations/MNCs/foreign delegates as clients
• Operates in a highly competitive manner
• Prefer young/dynamic professionals
SALES MANAGERS
Fixed:Variable - 60:40
Elements of salary
•Basic Salary, Housing allowance
•Daily Allowance (sales meetings with clients) - not disclosed
•Travel Allowance- not disclosed
•Phone bills- Upto 1000 Rs
•Medical claim on a quarter basis
Incentives
• % not disclosed
• Extra incentives on big accounts & CVGRs
Awards
• Letters of appreciation/awards in annual functions
• Paid training programmes
• Paid vacations
Benefits
• Discounts on personal bookings upto a limited no of visits
• Insurance/medical coverage for themselves & dependents
• No pensions
• PF, Gratuity, LTA & annual bonus, loans
FINDINGS:
High variable part:
Young sales people
High competition level
Fixed:Variable - 60:40
Elements of salary
• Basic Salary, Housing allowance
• Daily Allowance (on client visit) - 150 Rs/Daily
• Food coupons from Sodexo
• Medical vouchers- Rs 1200/month
• Educational Allowance- Rs 200/child
• Conveyance- Rs 800/month
• Telephone allowance- Rs 500/month
Incentives
• 8-10% on achieving sales targets (in tonnes)
Awards
• Letters of appreciation/awards in annual functions
• Prizes for the top sales achievers in a region
Benefits
• Entitled to profit sharing, if they are involved in procurement
• Get insurance coverage & medical Coverage for themselves &
dependents
• PF, Gratuity, LTA & annual bonus, loans
Levels in Hierarchy
• Category Managers ASMs Deputy Manager (Sales)
• VP (Sales)
FINDINGS:
Company in early stage measures to expand business offer
profit sharing on procurement service
Highly predictable products & short sales cycles high commission based
compensation
Some features:
• Client Servicing – relationship building
• Business Development
• Both effort based & skill based selling
• Competitive environment
SALES MANAGERS
FIXED:VARIABLE - 60:40
ELEMENTS OF SALARY
•Basic Salary, Housing allowance
•Daily Allowance (on client visits in corporates)
•Medical- Reimbursable vouchers for medical expenditures
INCENTIVES
• Incentive only on selling in the defined range above the sales targets
• Incentives on getting bulk bookings (as per the defined standards)
• Incentives on CVGRs
AWARDS
Letters of appreciation/awards in annual functions
BENEFITS
• Get discounts on personal bookings
• Get medical & insurance coverage
• Uniforms/Blazers for sales visits
• PF, Gratuity, LTA & annual bonus, loans, no pensions
LEVELS IN HIERARCHY:
• Sales Executives/Business Managers ASMs Deputy Manager (Sales) VP
(Sales)
FINDINGS:
The incentives are targeted mainly at obtaining new corporate customers.
The focus is also on maintaining existing relationship with existing customers
Some features:
• Relationship building
• Active/Young/Dynamic Salesforce required
• Patient/Extensive Travelling
SALES MANAGERS
FIXED:VARIABLE - 70:30
ELEMENTS OF SALARY
• Basic Salary, Housing allowance,
• Meal Allowance- 250 Rs/Daily
• Travel Allowance (based on the distance covered)
• Medical- Reimbursable vouchers for medical expenditures
• Outstation Allowance for out of town stay- Rs 550/day
INCENTIVES
• Incentive rate is increased for every 1 lac increase in sales figures, after achieving
targets
AWARDS
• Nothing specific
BENEFITS
• Get medical & insurance coverage
• PF, Gratuity, LTA & annual bonus, loans, no pensions
LEVELS IN HIERARCHY:
• Professional Sales Representatives/Medical Representatives Area Sales
managers Regional Sales Managers Zonal Manager
MEDICAL REPRESENTATIVES
FIXED:VARIABLE - 60:40
ELEMENTS OF SALARY
• Basic Salary, Housing allowance,
• Daily Allowance-150-200
• Travel Allowance (based on the distance covered)-2 Rs/km
• Medical- Reimbursable vouchers for medical expenditures
• Outstation Allowance for out of town stay – Rs 300-400 per day
INCENTIVES
• After crossing the targets, the incentive rate is increased for every 1 lac increase in
sales figures.
• Meeting target of 2 lac- 3%
• Meeting target of 3 lac- 4%
FINDINGS
AGE PREFERRED
• MR: upto 25-27 yrs
• Sales Manager- 32-33yrs
• Regional Manager- upto 35 yrs
• Zonal Manager- upto 40 yrs
Some features:
• Effort sales at Salesman level
• Very competitive environment
SALESMAN
• FIXED: VARIABLE: These salesmen don’t have any fixed part in their salary. Their entire
salary is variable salary. Fixed:Variable: 0:100
• There is no bonus & no increments, since there is no fixed salary.
ELEMENTS OF SALARY
• They get certain part on selling every policy.
• They get monthly travelling expense (of Rs 2500) if they are able to sell policies for Rs
15000 per month.
• Meal Allowance- When on training they get paid meals.
• No Medical coverage for them.
BENEFITS/AWARDS
• Once a salesman achieve a target, say 20 lacs for any year, they reach to the level of
‘Achiever’s council’.
• Gets benefits like accidental insurance, cash rewards
• No uniforms
• They get no pensions, Provident Fund, Gratuity, LTA, Bonus- all such facilities are
not there for the salesmen.
INCENTIVES:
• For every policy, they get some % of premium as commission,
• Get commission every time a policy (which they brought) is renewed.
LEVELS IN HIERARCHY:
• Hierarchy: FPA (Financial Planning Advisers) or the salesman ASMs Sales
Manager Sr. Sales Manager Branch Manager Branch Head Cluster
Manager Zonal Manager Regional Mgr DSF(Direct Selling Force) Director
Company Director
SALES MANAGERS
ELEMENTS OF SALARY
• Basic, HRA, PF, Gratuity
• Travel Allowance- In case they go for sales meetings
• Meal Allowance- For every day spent on field work
• Medical- Reimbursable vouchers for medical expenditures
BENEFITS:
• Extra allocation on their policies & on the policies of their dependents
• Insurance/medical coverage for themselves and their dependents
• PF, Gratuity, LTA, loans & annual bonus given. No pension
AWARDS:
• They are given badges for consistent performance & appreciation letters
• Foreign trips
FINDINGS
Less prominent sales force (sales more due to the brand name) low
salaries
E2,E1
D2,D1
C2,C1
B2,B1
A2,A1
• At UTI MF, a band system is followed instead of the
traditional hierarchy. The A2 and A1 band
employees are mainly responsible for the field work
UTI : Compensation
S.No Issues Practice in the company
1 Objectives of the compensation Improving performance
2 Internal consistency; pay dependent on the Customer Customer satisfaction is not considered while deciding
Satisfaction or the skills of the employee the compensation only seniority is the determining
factor
4 Package dependent on Seniority or Skills possessed by Depends on the number of years of experience in the
the employees. relevant field
5 Awareness about the package Employees are totally aware of all the component of
the component.
6 Whether contribution by the employee a factor in Employee is paid as per the seniority.
determining his pay or seniority the only factor
7 What factors decide the salary structure: market The employee’s salary in the previous company, job
trend, Worth of the job or Skill of the Employee band and experience.
UTI : Compensation
S.No Issues Practice in the company
8 Variable Pay is individual or team based Individual targets are given and hence individual
variable pay.
10 ESOP to employees No
11 Annual Bonus to employees Yes, Annual bonus is split and given quarterly.
13 Mediclaim / Insurance: Individual or all dependent 45L individual Life insurance, Mediclaim for
dependents.
Inference:
UTI MF follows a “fixed + variable” structure in the compensation package. We
see that even though UTI is a PSU, when it comes to sales it behaves more so like
a private company.
Employees get all the benefits which any other private player gives to its
employees. Employees are given quarterly target which are reviewed monthly.
However, we see a difference here that customer satisfaction is not considered as
a part of sales job and a totally different team is responsible for that. Also, the
pay package is slightly rigid in the sense, it is not altered depending on some
critical skills of the employee.
NICHOLAS PIRAMAL INDIA LTD (NPIL)
Pharma Selling process
Compensation policy
• Sales
• Initiatives taken
• Following guidelines and adhering to best practices
• Timely documentation and reporting
Appraisal process is • Implementing new schemes launched by the company
done on a KRA basis
• Use a Forced distribution on a bell shape
curve method
Incentives: Bonus distribution policy at NPIL
• (Avg bonus paid to the MRs under him * 150 %) & similarly to
Divisional mgr ( taking MR’s in the entire division. )
btw10% and
50% of their req
from Dell
D
(development)
New customer
added
Relationship built
Development of key
accounts
Annual Bonus
• The annual bonus awarded to the ARM’s depends on the percentage of
sales target achieved.
• ARM receives a bonus of Rs. 2.75 lakhs on achievement of 100% of the
revenue target.
• An ARM is eligible for the annual bonus only if he/she has achieved at
least 70% of their quarterly targets in all four quarters.
• On over achievement of target beyond 150% of the annual target, the
ARM receives a bonus of Rs. 100 per lakh.
Other incentives
• This component -very subjective and depends on the ARM’s performance
evaluation by his/her boss i.e. RCSM.
• Incentives like gifts (Refrigerators, Digital Camera’s, etc.), cash prizes, and
holiday tours to exotic locations in India and abroad.
MAX NEW YORK LIFE
Two slabs of commission policies being utilized at Max.
5-8% for the first year depending upon the tenure of the policy. Longer
tenure: higher commission and vice versa
• First Year(term<15) - 5.0%
• First Year(term<20)- 6.0%
• First Year(term<25)- 7.0%
• First Year(term>=25)- 7.5%
Subsequent years: (for multi year premium policy only)
• 2nd year: 3%
• 3rd year: 3%
• 4th year: 2%
• 5th year: 2%
Commission on ULIP (Unit Linked Insurance Plan): 20% - 30%
• higher commission for ULIP - it is newly introduced system of insurance
policy working on lines of insurance cum mutual fund
Commission on single year premium policy: 30%
• Commission on multi year premium policy: 20%-27% for the first year depending upon the tenure of the policy
and the premium amount being paid.
• First Year(term<15)-20.0%
• First Year(term<20)- 22.5%
• First Year(term<25)- 25.0%
• First Year(term>=25) - 27.5%
Components:
o Base Salary – 8,000
o Allowances – Medical, HRA, LTA – 12,000
o Bonus – dependent on performance (15% of the total
salary)
o Shares – dependent on position in company
For example: Entry level employee gets 12 shares.
Currently the Google share is worth $464
INDIAMART
Job Position: Assistant Manager
Components:
o Base Salary – 12,000
o Allowances – Medical, HRA, LTA – 4,000
o Marketing Incentive – 20,000
o Additional Incentive – based on number of clients and job
position
For example: Deal with 5 clients in a month for Assistant
Manager earns him extra 12,000
siemens
Job Position: Sales Executive
Components:
o Base Salary – 14,600
o Allowances – Medical, HRA, LTA – 19,400
o Performance Bonus – 20% of the total pay package
Windmoller & holscher
Job Position: Sales Engineer
Components:
o Base Salary – 50% of the salary
o Allowances – Medical, HRA, LTA
o Bonus – not mentioned in the CTC (up to 50% of the
salary)
o Company car and phone
o No PF, no gratuity
LG
Job Position– Store Sales Executive
Components:
o Fixed Income = Rs 6000
o Allowances – Nil
o Bonus – Festival bonus dependent on the company and sales performance
ELEMENTS OF SALARY
• Basic salary
• Housing allowance
• Medical vouchers
• Educational allowance
• Conveyance
• Cellphone allowance
FINDINGS:
The variable part is targeting mainly at selling of new value added services to
existing customers.
Incentives are provided for getting CVGRs through selling of CUG plans in
corporates and institutions.
Incentives
Cash
Kind
Recognition
SALESMAN INCENTIVE PLAN
Target
Achievement
SDO Brand
Incentives
incentive Incentive
Turnover
incentive
ELEMENTS OF SALARY
• Incentives in the form of CVGR bonuses
• Tours on meeting targets
• Insurance coverage
HIERARCHY
General manager -> Assistant general manager -> Regional
manager -> Zonal manager -> Center manager -> Sales
trainee
FINDINGS:
The compensation structure is focused on increasing the market share.