Risk, Toxicology & Human

Health
What is risk?
 Possibility of suffering harm from a hazard

 HAZARD - Something that can cause injury,

disease, economic loss or environmental damage
 What is probability?
 How likely it is that some event or effect will
occur.
 Can range from 0 - no risk to 1 (absolute certainty of a
risk)
 Risk is defined as probability of exposure times the
probability of harm
RISK = EXPOSURE X HARM
 What is risk assessment?
 Usesdata, etc. to estimate the probability that
harm will occur as a result of exposure to specific
hazards.
 IDENTIFY REAL OR POTENTIAL HAZARD
 DETERMINE PROBABILITY OF IT HAPPENING
 ASSESS SEVERITY ON HEALTH,
ENVIRONMENT, ECONOMY, OR SOCIAL
IMPACT
 What is risk management?
 Decide what risks face society and try to manage
them
 Decide how reliable the risk assessment is
 Decide how much risk is acceptable
 Decide how much money is needed to reduce the
risk
 If funds aren’t available, than what?
 How to communicate plan to the public
 What are the types of hazards?
 Cultural hazards - drugs, drinking, unsafe sex, smoking,
working conditions, & poverty
 Chemical hazards - harmful chemicals in our environment
- about 500 whose effects are not known.
 Physical hazards - natural disasters - radiation, fire,
earthquakes
 Biological hazards - pathogens, pollen, animals, etc.
 What is toxicology?
 The adverse effects of chemicals on health
 Toxicity
A measure of how harmful a substance is
 What is dose?
 Amount exposed to
 How does it get into the body?
 Inhaled
 Injected
 Absorbed
 Injested
 How harmful a chemical is depends
on:
 Size of dosage over a period of time
 How often exposure occurs
 Who is exposed
 How well the body’s detoxification system works (liver,
lungs, kidneys)
 Genetic makeup that determines an individuals sensitivity
to a particular toxin.
 Also: solubility - does it get into water supply?
Persistence - how long does it last?
 What is response?
 The resulting type and amount of damage to health
 Size
of dose over a certain period of time
 How often exposure occurs
 Who is exposed?
 How well the body systems work
 Acute effect - immediate reaction -
 Dizziness, rash, etc.
 Chroniceffect - permanent damage - liver or
kidney damage, etc.
 What is bioaccumulation?
 Increase in the concentration of a chemical in
specific organs or tissues at a higher level than is
normally expected.
 Water soluble toxic chemical are usually excreted in
urine
 Oil or fat-soluble toxins accumulate in fat deposits and
remain in the body (residence time) - have a biological
half-life
 What is Biomagnification?
 Toxinsare magnified as they pass through the
food chain
 DDT, PCB’s
 Are stored in body fat and affect during gestation or
egg laying and during nursing stages.
DDT in fish-eating
birds (ospreys)
25 ppm

DDT in large
fish (needle fish)
2 ppm

DDT in small
fish (minnows)
0.5 ppm

DDT in
zooplankton
0.04 ppm

DDT in water
0.000003 ppm,
Or 3 ppm

Fig. 16.4, p. 399

 Chemical
interactions can DECREASE or
MULTIPLY the harmful effects of a toxin.
 ANTAGONISTIC INTERACTION –reduce the
harmful response
 SYNERGISTIC INTERACTION – multiplies harmful
effects.
 Why should we care?
 It depends on the chemical and the concentration
 Detection of trace elements does not mean it is harmful
A basic concept of toxicology is that any synthetic
or natural substance can be harmful if ingested in
a large enough quantity.
 Most chemicals have a safe or THRESHOLD
LEVEL of exposure below which harmful effects
are insignificant
 LD 50
 Lethal dose
 The amount of an ingested substance that kills
50% of the test animals. Expressed as mg/body
weight.
 One way of measuring the short-term poisoning
potential (acute toxicity) of a material.
 What is a poison?
A chemical with an LD 50 of 50 mg or less/kg of
body weight.
 LD50 -median lethal dose - amount of chemical
received in one dose that kills exactly 50% of the
test animals within a 14 day period.
 How is toxicity determined since
chemicals vary in toxicity?
 Case reports - from physicians
 Laboratory investigations - usually on lab animals
 Epidemiology - studies of populations of humans
exposed to certain chemicals or diseases.
 Some Toxicity ratings
Toxicity Average Lethal
Rating LD50 Dose Examples
super toxic < 0.01 less than 1 drop nerve gases, botulism,
mushroom toxins, dioxin
extremely <5 less than 7 drops potassium cyanide, heroin,
toxic atropine, parathion,
nicotine
very toxic 5–50 7 drop to 1 mercury salts, morphine,
teaspoon codeine
toxic 50–500 1 teaspoon to 1 lead salts, DDT, sodium
ounce hydroxide, fluoride, sulfuric
acid, caffeine, carbon
tetrachloride
moderately 500–5,000 1 ounce to 1 pint methyl alcohol, ether,
toxic pehobarbital,
amphetamines, kerosine,
aspirin
slightly toxic 5,000–15,000 1 pint to 1 quart ethyl alcohol, lysol, soaps
essentially > 15,000 more than 1 quart water, glycerin, table sugar
nontoxic
 What are dose response curves?
 Acutetoxicity tests - show effects on test
organisms
 Control group - not exposed
 Test group - exposed

 Some things have no threshold level – called a non

threshold dose response model- ionizing radiation
or chemicals that cause cancer of birth defects
Dose-response curve
Dose - response curve
 What are toxic chemicals?
 Generally defined as fatal to over 50% of test
animals at given concentrations -LD-50
 Hazardous chemicals cause harm by:
 Being flammable or explosive
 Irritate skin or lungs
 Interfere with oxygen intake
 Induce allergic reactions
 What are mutagens?
 Causemutations or changes in DNA molecules -
chemicals & radiation
 Ifin reproductive cells can be passed on to future
generations
 In other cells, can result in tumors
 Most mutations are harmless
 There is no agreement on how to test substances for
genetic damage in humans
 What are teratogens?
 Causebirth defects while embryo is developing
during pregnancy - especially the first three
months
 PCBs
 Thalidomide
 Steroids,
hormones
 Heavy metals such as arsenic, cadmium, lead and
mercury
 What are carcinogens?
 Cause cancer
 Metastasis - gets into the body fluids and travels to
other parts
 Major sources are: smoking, diet, occupational
exposure, environmental pollutants
 Some are inherited
 Typically 10 - 40 years passes between initial exposure
to a carcinogen and appearance of detectable
symptoms.
 What is the immune system?
 Cells and tissues that protect the body against
disease and harmful substances
 Antibodies - attack alien invaders and mark them for
attack from other immune cells
 Cellular defenses - kill invaders

 Some synthetic chemicals, viruses, etc. weaken

the immune system and leave it open to attack by
invaders
 Example: pesticides
 What is the nervous system?
Brain, spinal cord, and nerves
 Many poisons are neurotoxins – attack nerve cells
 Chlorinatedhydrocarbons - PCB’S & DDT
 Organophosphate pesticides
 Formaldehyde
 Some heavy metals
 Some industrial solvents
 What is the endocrine system?
 Hormones - produced by organs and tissues
 Are chemical messengers
 Are excreted into the bloodstream at very low levels
 Control sexual reproduction, growth, development and
behavior in humans
 Each hormone has a special molecular shape which
allows it to attach only to certain cell receptors - then
they move into cell nucleus to sent chemical messages
 What are hormonally active agents?
HAA’s
 Human made chemicals – called hormone disrupters
 More than 60 are known
 Hormone mimics - estrogen like
 Hormone blockers - prevent natural hormones such as
androgens from attaching to their receptors.
 Can be at extremely low levels
 Thyroid disrupters - affect growth, weight, brain
development, etc.
 Examples: dioxins
 PCB’s - biomagnify
 Some chemicals in plastics
 some pesticides
 Lead
Hormone disruptors
 How much do we know?
 Of the 75,000 chemicals  Each year about 1000 new
in commercial use, only chemicals come on the
about 10% have been market.
screened for toxicity and  99.5% of all commercially
only 2 % have been tested used chemicals are not
to see if they are regulated by federal and
carcinogens, teratogens,or state governments.
mutagens
 What are the reasons for this?
 Under present laws chemicals are considered
innocent until proven guilty.
 There aren’t enough funds, facilities and test
animals to provide such information
 We know little about the interactions of chemicals
and how they affect human health.
 Precautionary approach
 Emphasis should be more on pollution prevention
 we don’t really know the effects of so many
chemicals.
 “look before you leap”!
 What are biological hazards?
 Nontransmissible diseases: not caused by living
organisms
 Cardiovascular
disease, cancer, diabetes, bronchitis,
emphysema, and malnutrition
 Transmissiblediseases - caused by living
organisms - can be spread from person to person
 Pathogens – infectious agents
 Vectors – insects and non human carriers
WHAT’S all the Buzz about?
Vector-borne Diseases and Climate Change
Linh Pham, Ph.D., NIEHS
Common Vectors That
Transmit Disease

Mosquito Tick

Mouse Deer

A PEER-REVIEWED OPEN ACCESS JOURNAL NIEHS

National Institute of
PUBLISHED BY THE NIEHS Environmental Health Sciences
Examples of Vector-Borne
Diseases
 West Nile Virus
 Malaria
 Dengue
 Lyme Disease
 Hanta Virus
 Yellow Fever
 Rocky Mountain Spotted
Fever
 Bubonic Plague Characteristic bull rash caused by Lyme disease

A PEER-REVIEWED OPEN ACCESS JOURNAL NIEHS

National Institute of
PUBLISHED BY THE NIEHS Environmental Health Sciences
How Weather Affects Vector-Borne
Diseases
 Temperature

 Humidity

 Surface water
 Tropical and subtropical regions
 Predator patterns

A PEER-REVIEWED OPEN ACCESS JOURNAL NIEHS

National Institute of
PUBLISHED BY THE NIEHS Environmental Health Sciences
 Map image depicting the world’s rise in temperature NASA
A PEER-REVIEWED OPEN ACCESS JOURNAL NIEHS
National Institute of
PUBLISHED BY THE NIEHS Environmental Health Sciences
How Weather Affects
Vector-Borne Diseases
 Temperature
 Humidity
 Surface water
 Tropical and subtropical regions
 Predator patterns
Climate Change
–Larger geographic area where disease is common
–Intensity and duration of outbreaks
–Altered seasonal distributions

A PEER-REVIEWED OPEN ACCESS JOURNAL NIEHS

National Institute of
PUBLISHED BY THE NIEHS Environmental Health Sciences
How Climate Change Affects
Vector-Borne Diseases
 Mosquitoes develop more rapidly
 Mosquitoes bite more frequently
 Viral load in mosquitoes is higher
 Because more people are infected,
more mosquitoes become carriers
that transmit disease

A PEER-REVIEWED OPEN ACCESS JOURNAL NIEHS

National Institute of
PUBLISHED BY THE NIEHS Environmental Health Sciences
What factors affect spread of disease?
 Migration to urban areas  Climate change
 Reducing biodiversity by  Natural disasters such as
destroying forests and floods
wiping out species that  Some bacteria are
control vectors becoming resistant to
 Increased cultivation of antibiotics
rice - causes mosquito  Virulent strains of
populations to increase influenza may develop
 Increased international air  Bioterrorism
travel
 What is risk analysis?
 Identifyhazards
 Risk assessment - evaluate associated risks
 Comparative risk analysis - rank risks
 Risk communication - make public aware of the
risks
 Poverty is the greatest risk people face
 Scientists Citizens
(Not in rank order
in each category) Figure 11-15 (In rank order)

High-Risk Health Problems

• Indoor air pollution
• Outdoor air pollution
Page 246 High-Risk Problems
• Hazardous waste sites
• Industrial water pollution
• Worker exposure to industrial • Occupational exposure
or farm chemicals to chemicals
• Pollutants in drinking water • Oil spills
• Pesticide residues on food • Stratospheric ozone depletion
• Toxic chemicals in consumer products • Nuclear power-plant accidents
• Industrial accidents releasing
High-Risk Ecological Problems pollutants
• Global climate change • Radioactive wastes
• Stratospheric ozone depletion • Air pollution from factories
• Wildlife habitat alteration and destruction • Leaking underground tanks
• Species extinction and loss of biodiversity

Medium-Risk Ecological Problems Medium-Risk Problems

• Acid deposition • Coastal water contamination
• Pesticides • Solid waste and litter
• Airborne toxic chemicals • Pesticide risks to farm workers
• Toxic chemicals, nutrients, and • Water pollution from
sediment in surface waters sewage plants

Low-Risk Ecological Problems Low-Risk Problems

• Oil spills • Air pollution from vehicles
• Groundwater pollution • Pesticide residues in foods
• Radioactive isotopes • Global climate change
• Acid runoff to surface waters • Drinking water contamination
• Thermal pollution
 Risk Factors for

Cancer is a broad group of various diseases that all

involve unregulated cell growth.

“Risk factors” is better than causes for this chart.

What risk factor is missing?
http://cancercaringnurses.blogspot.com/2011/05/cancer-risks-and-prevention.html
 Teratogens

Not a chemical,
but…
http://www.flyfishingdevon.co.uk/salmon/year2/psy221psychoteratology/psychoteratology.htm
http://www.broadsheet.ie/tag/thalidomide/
http://www.cdc.gov/zika/
 Endocrine disruptors

 http://www.rsc.org/chemistryworld/2012/12/protocol-prevent-endocrine-disrupting-chemicals
 Allergens

http://www.scienceclarified.com/Al-As/Allergy.html
http://www.josephamotto.com/allergies-reactions-asthma
http://www.docstoc.com/docs/29876381/major-food-allergens-chart---Department-of-Agriculture-Trade
 Corrosives

A corrosive is any liquid or solid that causes visible

destruction or irreversible alteration in human skin
tissue at the site of contact
(More HAZARDOUS than toxic.)
 Asphyxiant

 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Carbon-monoxide-3D-vdW.png
 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Cyanide-ion-3D-vdW.png
Notice common features?
Chlorinated hydrocarbons!

POP’s
Persistent Organic
Pollutants
“dirty dozen”