15 - Tolerance Accumulation and Analysis

Download as ppt, pdf, or txt
Download as ppt, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 80

TOLERANCE ACCUMULATION

AND
ANALYSIS

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


ADDITION OF TOLERANCES

A and B two linear dimensions to be added


a1, a2 tolerance on A
b1, b2 tolerance on B
A+B = C
The tolerance on C to be analysed.
2

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


C is max. when A and B are max.
C is min. when A and B are min.
Cmax = A max + B max
Cmin = A min + B min.
Cmax = ( C + c2 )= (A + a2) + (B + b2) ------- ( 1 )
Cmin = ( C - c1 )= (A – a1) + (B – b1) ------- ( 2 )
c1, c2 tolerance on C
Subtracting C min ( 2 ) from C max ( 1 )
c2 + c1 = (a1+a2) + (b1 + b2)
If ( a1 + a2 ) = T a
( b1 + b2 ) = T b
( c1 + c2 ) = T c
The Tolerance on the total length will be T c = Ta + Tb

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


SUBTRACTION OF TOLERANCES

A and B two linear dimensions to be subtracted


a1, a2 tolerance on A
b1, b2 tolerance on B
A-B = C
The tolerance on C to be analysed.
4

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


C is max. when A is max. and B is min.
C is min. when A is min. and B is max.
C max = A max – B min
C min = A min – B max;

A max = A + a2
B min = B – b1
A min = A – a1
B max = B + b2

C max = ( C + c 2 ) = ( A + a2) – ( B – b1 ) ----------- ( 3 )


C min = ( C – c1 ) = ( A – a1) – ( B + b2 ) ---------- ( 4 )

Subtracting C min ( 4 ) from C max ( 3 )


(c 2 + c 1 ) = ( a2 + a1 ) + ( b2 + b1)
If ( a2 + a1 ) = Ta
( b2 + b1 ) = Tb
( c2 + c1 ) = Tc
The Tolerance on the remaining length T c = Ta + Tb
5

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


The tolerances are getting added
both in addition and subtraction.

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


EXAMPLES

TO CALCULATE UNKNOWN DIMENSIONS

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


The value of ‘X’ and tolerances x1, x2 are un-known.
Case-1
x2 a2 z2
x1 a1 z1
X – A = Z

x2 a2 x2 - a1 z2
x1 a1 x1 - a2 z1
X –A = (X –A) = Z

Therefore x2 – a1 = z2
x2 = a1 + z2

x1 – a2 = z1
x1 = a2 +z1
Therefore
x2 a1 + z2
x1 a2 +z1
X = (A+ Z)
8

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


The value of ‘X’ and tolerances x1, x2 are un-known.
Example:
x2 + 0.1 + 0.2
x1 - 0.1 - 0.2
X – 5 = 10

x2 – ( – 0.1 ) = + 0.2
x2 + 0.1 = + 0.2
x2 = + 0.2 – 0.1 = + 0.1

x1 – ( + 0.1 ) = – 0.2
x1 – 0.1 = – 0.2
x1 = – 0.1

x2 + 0.1 + 0.2
x1 - 0.1 - 0.2
X – 5 = 10

+0.1 + 0.1 + 0.2


-0.1 - 0.1 - 0.2
15 – 5 = 10
9

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


The value of ‘X’ and tolerances x1, x2 are un-known.
Case-2 a2 x2 z2
a1 x1 z1
A – X = Z

a2 – x1 z2
a1 – x2 z1
(A - X) = Z

The tolerances of the equation can be equated.


a2 - x1 = z2
x1 = a2 - z2

a1 - x2 = z1
x2 = a1 - z1

Therefore
x2 a1 - z1
x1 a2 - z2
X = (A- Z )

10

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


Example:
+ 0.1 x2 + 0.2
- 0.1 x1 - 0.2
15 - X = 10

+0.1 – x1 +0.2
-0.1 – x2 -0.2
( 15 - X ) = Z
The tolerances of the equation can be equated.
+0.1 - x1 = +0.2
x1 = +0.1 - 0.2 = -0.1

-0.1 - x2 = -0.2
x2 = -0.1 +0.2 = +0.1
Therefore
+ 0.1 x2 + 0.2
- 0.1 x1 - 0.2
15 - X = 10

+ 0.1 +0.1 + 0.2


- 0.1 -0.1 - 0.2
15 - 5 = 10 11

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


+ 0.05
- 0.03
Dimension A = 100 . 0

- 0.13
- 0.20
Dimension B = 60.0

Calculate the nominal size and the variation for the dimension C.

12

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


Nominal size ‘ C ’ = Nominal size ‘ A ’ – Nominal size ‘ B ’
C = 100 – 60 = 40
c2 a2 b2
c1 a1 b1
C = A – B

c2 + 0.05 – 0.13
c1 – 0.03 – 0.20
40 = 100 – 60

c2 = + 0.05 – ( – 0.20 ) = + 0.25


c1 = – 0.03 – ( – 0.13 ) = + 0.1

c2 +0.25
c1 + 0.1
C = 40

Verification: Tc = Ta +Tb
Ta + Tb = + 0.05 – ( – 0.03 ) + ( – 0.13 ) – ( – 0.2 )
= 0.15
Tc = 0.15
0.15 = 0.15

13

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


Calculate the dimension ‘x’ and tolerance on ‘x’ with ‘M-M’
and ‘L-L’ as references

14

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


Considering MM as reference
a2 x2 b2
a1 x1 b1
A - X = B

+ 0.0 x2
- 0.1 x1 ± 0.1
30 - 8 = 22

+0.0 - x1
-0.1 - x2 ±0.1
( 30 – 8 ) = 22

0.0 – x1 = + 0.1
x1 = – 0.1

– 0.1 - x2 = – 0.1
x2 = 0.0

x2 + 0. 0
x1 - 0.1
The value of X = 8
15

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


Considering LL as reference
a2 b2 x2
a1 b1 x1
A – B = X

+ 0.0 x2
- 0.1 ± 0.1 x1
30 – 22 = 8

x2 = + 0.0 – ( – 0.1) = + 0.1


x1 = – 0.1 – ( +0.1) = – 0.2

x2 + 0.1
x1 - 0.2
X = 8

16

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


MULTIPLICATION & DIVISION BY A CONSTANT
NUMBER

“Any dimension with tolerances, if multiplied


by a positive constant number, the
tolerance of the result also increases
proportionately.

When divided by a constant number, the


tolerance of the result, similarly decreases
proportionately”

17

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


MULTIPLICATION BY A CONSTANT NUMBER

a2
a1
When A is multiplied by a constant K , it becomes

a2 a2 * K
a1 a1 * K
(A ) * K = (A* K )

Example :
+ 0.1 (+0.1) 3
+ 0.3 (+0.3) 3
4 * (3) = (4 * 3)

+0.3
+0.9
= 12

18

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


DIVISION BY A CONSTANT NUMBER

a2
a1
When A is divided by a constant K , it becomes
a2 a2 ÷ K
a1 a1 ÷ K
( A ) ÷ K = (A ÷ K)

Example :

+0.3 0.3/3
+0.9 0.9/3
( 12 ) ÷ 3 = ( 12 / 3 )

+0.1
+0.3
= 4

19

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


EXAMPLE 1

Find out the variation of dimension ‘x’ with reference to ‘LL’

20

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


x2 +0.0 +0.1 +0.0 +0.0 x2
x1 -0.2 -0.0 -0.2 -0.1 x1
X = 50 – 5 – 38 – 5 = 2
x2 = + 0.0 – ( – 0.0 ) – ( – 0.2 ) – ( – 0.1 ) = + 0.3
x1 = – 0.2 – ( + 0.1 ) – 0.0 - 0.0 = – 0.3

x2 +0.3
x1 -0.3 ± 0.3
X = 2 = 2

Verification: Ta + Tb + Tc + Td = T x
Ta + Tb + Tc + Td = 0.2 + 0.1 + 0.2 + 0.1
= 0.6
T x = 0.3+0.3 = 0.6
0.6 = 0.6 21

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


Example 2 :
-0.040 +0.013 +0.012 +0.000 -0.006 x2
+0.040 -0.073 -0.009 +0.001 -0.019 -0.017 x1
150 - 20 + 95 - 15 + 65 + 15 = 290

x2=(0.040)-(- 0.073)+(0.013)-(0.001)+(0.000)+(-0.006) = + 0.119


x1=(0.000)-(-0.040)+(-0.009)-(0.012)+(-0.019)+(-0.017) = – 0.017
x2 + 0.119
x1 - 0.017
X = 290
Verification:
Ta+ Tb+ Tc + Td + Te + Tf = Tx
Ta+ Tb+ Tc + Td + Te + Tf = 0.040+ [(–0.040)–(–0.073)] + [0.013–(–0.009)] +
[(+0.0120–(+0.001)] + (–0.019)+ [(–0.006)–( –0.017)] = 0.136
T x = [0.119–(–0.017)] = 0.136

0.136 = 0.136
22

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


Example 3 : + 0.030 +0.021 +0.030 x2
+0.046 + 0.011 +0.008 +0.011 x1
240 +75 – 20 – 60 = X

X = (240 + 75 – 20 – 60) = 235


x2 = + 0.046 + 0.030 – ( + 0.008 ) – ( + 0.011 ) = + 0.057
x1 = + 0.000 + 0.011 – ( + 0.021 ) – ( + 0.030 ) = – 0.040

x2 +0.057
x1 -0.040
235 = 235

Verification:

Ta + Tb + T c + Td = Tx.

Ta + Tb+ T c+ Td = 0.046 + ( 0.030 – 0.011 ) + ( 0.021– 0.008 ) + ( 0.030 – 0.011 )


= 0.097

Tx = 0.097

0.097 = 0.097

23

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


Example 4 : +0.012 +0.009 +0.013 +0.008 x2
-0.007 -0.004 +0.063 -0.009 -0.003 x1
65 -20 +450 -120 +12 = 387

x2 = + 0.012 – (– 0.004 ) + 0.063–(–0.009) + 0.008 = + 0.096


x1 = – 0.007 – ( + 0.009 ) + ( + 0.000 ) – ( + 0.013) + (–0.003)
= – 0.032
x2 +0.0 96
x1 -0.032
387 = 387

Verification: Ta+Tb+Tc+Td+Te = Tx
Ta+Tb+Tc+Td+Te =0.012–(–0.007)+ 0.009 – (–0.004)+0.063+0.013
–(–0.009)+0.008–(–0.003)

= 0.128

Tx = 0.096– (–0.032) = 0.128

0.128 = 0.128

24

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


Calculate the value of ‘x’ to have the axial clearance
between bearing and the shaft, as 1.25 ± 0.25 mm
25

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


L

Considering LL as reference

The value of X must lie as the difference between the sum of the
dimension of B, C, D, and E to A.

26

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


EQUATION :
x2 +0.0 +0.00 +0.25 +0.00 +0.25
x1 -0.05 -0.10 -0.25 -0.05 -0.25
X = 5 + 140 + 1.25 + 5 - 100
x2 x2 x2
x1 x1 x1
X = ( 151.25 – 100 ) = ( 51.25 )

x2 = + 0.0 + 0.00 + 0.25 + 0.00 – ( – 0.25 ) = + 0.5


x1 = – 0.05 – 0.1 – 0.25 – 0.05 – ( + 0.25 ) = – 0.7
x2 +0.5
x1 -0.7
(51.25) = 51.25
Verification:
Tb+Tc+Td+Te+Ta = Tx
Tb+Tc+Td+Te+Ta = +0.05 + 0.1 + 0.25 +0.25+0.05 +0.25 + 0.25 =1.2
Tx = 1.2
1.2 =1.2 27

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


A hole 16H6 has to be drilled and reamed
The dimension is 79  0.1 from one side of the component.
Calculate the tolerance for the dimension 12 from one end in a
box jig plate to obtain the resultant dimension 79  0.1

28

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


+0.00 x2
± 0.1 ± 0.05 - 0.05 x1
79 = 111 – 20 – 12
Max. limit : + 0.1 = + 0.05 – ( – 0.05 ) – x1
x1 = 0
Min. limit : – 0.1 = - 0.05 – ( + 0 ) – x2
x2 = 0.05
+ 0.05 +0.00
+ 0.00 - 0.05
The tolerance for the dimension 12 is 12 or 12.05

Verification: Td = Ta + Tb + Tc
+ 0.0 + 0.05
± 0.01 ± 0.05 – 0.05 - 0.00
79 = 111 - 20 – 12
Td = 0.2
Ta + Tb + Tc = (0.05)-(-0.05)+0.0-(-0.05)+(0.05)-(-0.0)
= 0.2
0.2 = 0.2
29

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


A hole of 16H7 is to be made with reference to another
predrilled and reamed hole 10H7 which lies on a perpendicular
plane

The dimension of the hole 10H7 with reference to one side of


the box jig is given as 245  0.05

Calculate the tolerance for the dimension 97 to position the


drill jig bush to drill and ream dia 16H7 hole.
30

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


x2
Dimension should be 148  0.1 = 245  0.05 – 97 x1
x
2
x
1
148  0.1 + 97 = 45  0.05
+0.1 – ( x1 ) = + 0.05
x1 = + 0.05

–0.1 – ( x2 ) = – 0.05
x2 = – 0.05

The tolerances for the dimension 97 is  0.05

Verification: 245  0.05 - 97  0.05 = 148  0.1

Ta +Tb = 0.1+ 0.1 = 0.2


Tc = 0.2
0.2 = 0.2 31

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


The component shown in Fig. is dimensioned by
two methods. Analyses the more practical one.

In case 1 the dimensions, 50  0.1; 100  0.2 , and the


overall dimensions 180  0.05 are toleranced

In case 2 , dimensions 100  0.2 , 130  0.05and 30  0.05


are toleranced .
In case 1 considering ‘ LL’ as the reference
X2
x1
X = 180  0.05 – 50  0.1 – 100  0.2
x2 = + 0.05 - ( - 0.1 ) - ( - 0.2 ) = + 0.35
x1 = - 0.05 - ( + 0.1 ) - ( + 0.2 ) = - 0.35
x
2
x
1
X = 30  0.35
In case 2 considering ‘AA’ as reference
x2
Xx1 = 130  0.05 - 100  0. 2
x = + 0.05 - ( - 0.2 ) = + 0.25
2
x = - 0.05 - ( + 0.2 ) = - 0.25
1
X2
Xx1 = 30  0. 25
32

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


The dimension ‘C’ from the functional reference ‘ LL ’.
+ 0.08
It is impracticable to measure the depth ( 20 ) of the hole
- 0.14

having diameter D1 from the functional reference ‘ LL ’

Hence the best auxiliary reference selected in this case is ‘ MM ’,


which is also reference for manufacturing. In view of this new
reference the dimensions of A, B, C and their tolerances are
evaluated as follows.
33

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


Nominal dimension of ‘A’ = Nominal dimension ‘B’+ Nominal dimension ‘C’
A = B+C
A = 20 +10 = 30
Total Tolerance of ‘C’ = Total tolerance of ‘A’-Total tolerance of ‘B’
The equation will be A - B = C
a2 b2 c2
a1 b1 c1
A - B = C
a2 +0.08
30 a1 – 10  0.0 5 = 20 - 0.14

a2 – ( – 0.05 ) = + 0.08
a2 = 0.08 - 0.05 = + 0.03
a1 – ( + 0.05 ) = – 0.14
a1 = – 0.09
a2 +0.03
a1 -0.09
A = 30
+0.03

The depth of hole is = 30 -0.09.

34

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


TOLERANCING DIMENSIONS BETWEEN CENTERS

Methods of dimensioning between centers of holes

Series or chain dimensioning

Parallel dimensioning of each hole with respect to the datum.

Series and Parallel – A combination of the above two methods

35

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


TOLERANCE ON DIMENSIONS
BETWEEN CENTERS OF TWO HOLES
Case1: Sizes of the holes and shafts are identical.

‘d’ is the diameter of the shafts


‘D’ is the diameter of holes in two plates
A set up for the worst case of interchangeability
36

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


1-1 = Axis of holes in the plate1
2-2 = Axis of the holes in the plate 2
CC = Axis of the shafts mating the holes.
M = The distance between the centers of holes
± m = The tolerance on M on the respective holes
( D-d ) = Clearance between hole and shaft = L

Considering a datum line of no clearance from the figure


The following chain of dimension can be placed keeping in view the signs
An equation for the expression of tolerance is as
0 = D/2 - ( M+ m ) + D/2- d+ D/2 + ( M-m ) + D/2 -d
0 = 2D - 2m - 2d
2m = 2 ( D-d )
2m = 2L
m = L

As this is a critical value, m can be less than L but not more, as 100%
interchangeability is to be achieved.
Therefore m = L

37

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


CONCLUSION

If 100% interchangeability is to be achieved in the


above case, the tolerance on dimension between the
two holes cannot be more than twice the diametrical
clearance between the holes and shafts. It could be less
or equal to the clearance.

38

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


TOLERANCE ON DIMENSIONS BETWEEN CENTERS OF TWO HOLES

Case II: The size of the holes and shafts vary

D1 be the diameter of the holes in plates 1 and 2, for the mating shaft d1.
D2 be the diameter of the holes in plates 1 and 2 for the mating shaft d2 .
A worst case set-up for 100% interchangeability is shown.
39

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


1-1 = Axis of holes in the plate 1
2-2 = Axis of holes in the plate 2
c1 -c1 = Axis of the shaft of diameter d1
c2 -c2= Axis of the shaft of diameter d2
M = The distance between the centers of holes
±m = The tolerance on M.
( D1- d1 ) , ( D2 - d2 ). = The clearance between the holes and
Shafts.
Starting from a point of no clearance, a set of chain dimensions can be
placed as follows, keeping in view the directional sign and equating it
to zero.

0 = D2/2 - ( M+ m )+ D1/2 - d1 + D1/2 + ( M - m ) + D2/2 - d2


0 = - 2m + ( D1 + D2 ) - ( d1 + d2 )
2m = ( D1 - d1 ) + ( D2 - d2 )
2m = ( L1 + L2 ).
Since ( D1 - d1 ) = L1 and ( D2 - d2) = L2
m = ( L1 + L2 ) ÷ 2
40

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


CONCLUSION

The critical tolerance ‘m’ on the centers of two holes in


the above case should be equal to half the sum of clearances
in both holes and could be less for 100% interchangeability
between the two plates.

41

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


TOLERANCE ON DIMENSIONS BETWEEN CENTERS
OF THREE HOLES

Series Dimensioning

D - is the diameter of holes in the plates 1 and 2


d - the diameter of mating shafts
The holes displaced according to the tolerance for the worst
case, is shown.
42

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


1-1 = Axis of the holes in plate 1
2-2 = Axis of the holes in plate 2
c-c = Axis of the shafts
M = Dimension between holes
±m = The tolerance of the dimensions.

0 = D/2 + ( M- m ) + ( M – m ) + D/2 – d + D/2 - ( M+ m )- ( M + m ) +D/2 - d


0 = 2D - 2d - 4m
4 m = 2 ( D – d ) = 2 L. Since ( D - d ) = L
m = L/2
Similarly
For 4 holes dimensioned in series m=L/3
For 5 holes dimensioned in series m=L/4
If n holes are in series m= L/n-1

For ‘n’ holes dimensioned in series tolerance between the holes should be equal
to
or less than L/n-1 for 100% interchangeability.

43

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


Series or Chain dimensions between
centers

For ‘n’ holes dimensioned in series tolerance between the holes


should be equal to or less than L/n-1 for 100% interchangeability.
44

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


CONCLUSION

As the number of holes increases in case of series dimensioning,


the tolerance, between the holes decreases. Hence the cost of
production increases and it is difficult to make. If same tolerances
are given to the large dimensions as that of small dimensions, it
will be in many instances impracticable.

45

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


TOLERANCE ON DIMENSIONS BETWEEN CENTERS
OF THREE HOLES
Parallel Dimensioning

D - is the diameter of holes in the plates 1 and 2


d - is the diameter of the shafts
Fig . shows the holes displaced according to the tolerances for the worst case.
46

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


1-1 = Axis of holes in plate 1
2-2 = Axis of holes in plate 2
c-c = Axis of the shafts
M1 = The distance of the second hole from the first
M2 = The distance of the third hole from the first
± m’ = The tolerance of M1 dimension
± m’’ = The tolerance of M2 dimension
Considering a datum line of no clearance from the figure the following
chain of dimensions can be laid down taking care of the signs of the
dimensions, the expression for the tolerances is, as follows.

-d+D/2+(M1-m’)+D/2-d+D/2-(M1+m’)+(M2+m”)-D/2+d-D/2-(M2-m”)-D/2+d= 0
2 m’ – 2 m” = 0
m’ = m”

47

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


Parallel Dimensioning

48

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


CONCLUSION

As the number of holes increases the tolerance remains the same L


The tolerance between the first hole and second hole is equal to
tolerance between the first hole and third hole. We also conclude that,
if the tolerance is equal, it has no bearing on the number of holes .

49

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


FOUR-HOLE GROUP WITH COORDINATE TOLERANCES

50

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


Comparison between series & parallel Dimensioning:

If the number of holes exceeds 3, parallel dimensioning is only


recommended. By series dimensioning, tolerance decreases which is
difficult to achieve and expensive.

51

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


TOLERANCE ON DIMENSIONS OF HOLES IN PLATES I AND
II FROM THEIR COMMON EDGE FOR INTERCHANGEABILITY:
Case1: Fastener having clearance in both the plates

Two plates are to be assembled by a fastener of dia‘d’, passing through the holes
of dia ‘D’.

The locations of holes are with reference to the common edge ‘0’.

The distance of the holes from the common edge is M ± m , where m is the
tolerance.
52

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


Center of the hole in plate 1 is ( M + m )
Center of the hole in plate 2 is ( M – m )

In the plan view a line joining the common edge and the centers makes
an angle of 45 degrees and the figure shows the respective distance
from the common edge.

Applying the principles as before,


0 = (D/2)-2 (M+m) +2(M-m) + (D/2)-d
0 = (D-d) - 2 2m, Therefore 2*2m = (D –d)
(D–d)=L
2m = ( D – d ) ÷ 2 = 0.7 * L

53

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


TOLERANCE ON DIMENSIONS OF HOLES IN PLATES I AND
II FROM THEIR COMMON EDGE FOR INTERCHANGEABILITY:
Case II: Fastener having clearance in plate 1 and press fit in plate 2.

For the position as shown

0 = (D/2)-2(M+m)+2(M-m)-(d/2)
(D-d)/2 = 2*2m ; ( D – d ) = L
54
0.35 L = 2m.
THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY
TOLERANCES OF DIMENSIONS IN TWO PLATES FROM
COMMON SURFACE FOR INTERCHANGEABILITY

Case I : Fastener having clearance in both plates

D – Dia. of hole in Plates 1 & 2


( M + m ) and ( M –m ) - distance of holes
d – dia. of fastener

Applying the principle


0 = ( D/2 ) – ( M + m ) + ( M - m ) + ( D/2 ) – d
D–d = 2m
D – d = L,
L = 2m
0.5 L = m
for complete interchangeability
m ≥ 0.5 L

55

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


TOLERANCES OF DIMENSIONS IN TWO PLATES FROM
COMMON SURFACE FOR INTERCHANGEABILITY

Case II: Fastener having clearance in one plate and press fit in other plate

0=D/2-(M+m)+(M–m)– (d/2)
(D–d)/2=2m
(D–d) = L
L/2 =2m
m = 0.25 L

For complete interchangeability m ≥ 0.25 L

56

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


CALCULATION OF TOLERANCE FOR DISTANCE BETWEEN
HOLES ON DRILL JIGS

Two holes are to be drilled and reamed at a distance W0 within the limits ±T0 , by using a jig
plate with slip bushes as shown in Fig.
W1  T1 be the distance between the liner bushes in jig plate.

L1, L2 = Clearance (around) between the slip bush and liner bush for the first and second
holes respectively.

e1, e2 = eccentricity of inside diameter of slip bush with respect to its outside diameter for the
two bushes respectively. 57
So that W0 = f (w1, L1, L2, e1, e2……….).
THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY
CONDITION 1:
When the distance between liner bushes in the jig plate is at maximum
distance (W1+T1) and slip bushes at far off position.

O1, O2 are centers of the slip bushes which are eccentric with respect to their
outside diameter of slip bushes by e1 and e2.

OO1 = L1 + e1
OO2 = L2 + e2.

This distance between holes on the component

W 1 + T1 + OO1 + OO2

The sum of these distance should be less than the maximum distance given
on the component.
( W1 + T1 + L1 + e1 + e2 ) ≤ W0 + T0.

58

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


CONDITION 2:

When the distance between liner bushes in jig plate is at minimum distance (W1-T1)
and when slip bushes are also at minimum distance:

O1, O2 are the centers of the slip bushes, which are eccentric with respect to outside
by e1 and e2 respectively.
OO1 = L1 + e1
OO2 = L2 + e2

The distance between the holes obtained on the component

( W1 + T1 ) = ( W1 - T1 ) - OO1 - OO2
= ( W1 - T1 ) - ( L1 + e1 ) - ( L2 + e2 )
= ( W1 - T1 - L1 - L2 - e1 - e2 )

The sum of these distances should be more than the minimum distance
( Wo - To ) given on the component
( W1 - T1 ) - L1 - L2 - e1 - e2 ≥ ( W o - To )

59

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


EFFECT OF CLEARANCE BETWEEN THE DRILL AND THE SLIP BUSHES ON
DISTANCE BETWEEN THE HOLES ON THE COMPONENT

Case I : The drill size is minimum , bushes and the drill are at far off position
O1, O2 are the positions of the centres of the slip bush when the clearance between the
drill and the slip bush are considered.

With the effect of clearance between the drill and the slip bushes, the maximum
extreme dimension obtained is as
= W1 + T1 + L1 + L2 + e1 + e2 + OO1 + OO2
= W1 + T1 + L1 + L2 + e1 + e2 + ( d b + Tb ) - ( d - Td )
60
The sum of these distances should be less than or equal to Wo + To.
THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY
CASE II: When drill size is minimum the bushes position is also at minimum
distance , the drill is at minimum distance.
OO1 = OO2 = ( d b - Tb ) - ( d - Td ) ÷ 2
Actual distance between holes on component
= W1 - T1 - L1 - L2 – e1 - e2 - OO1 - OO2
= W1 - T1 - L1 - L2 - e1 - e2 - ( d b + Tb ) + ( d - Td )
This should be more than the minimum distance ( W0 - T0 ) given on component.
W1 - T1 - L1 - L2 - e1 - e2 - ( d b + Tb ) - ( d - Td ) > W0 - T0
Final conditions are
W1 + T1 + L1 + L2 + e1 + e2 + ( d b +Tb ) - ( d - Td ) ≤ ( W0 + T0 )
W1 - T1 - L1 - L2 - e1 – e2 - ( d b + Tb ) + ( d - Td ) > ( W0 - T0 )
As per Indian standard the tolerance on drill is = h 9
The tolerance of the hole in slip bush is = F 7
The clearance between the liner bush and the slip bush is = F 7 / h 6
(If the liner bush is used for drilling also) 61

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


62

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


1

63

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


2

64

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


3

65

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


4

66

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


6

67

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


68

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


DRAWING

69

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


10
70

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


20 71

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


72
30
THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY
40 73

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


50 74

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


75
60
THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY
70 76

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


80 77

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


90 78

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


100

79

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY


110 80

THE INSTITUTE FOR ENHANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY

You might also like