Student Details 1
Student Details 1
Student Details 1
Q1 Define the term modes tollens and modes ponens with realife examples and link it with arguments.
Answer:
This translates to "mode by affirming the placing." In simpler terms, it means if something is true (the
antecedent), and it implies something else (the consequent), then the implied thing must also be true. Here's
an example:
This translates to "mode by denying the placing." Here, if something is true (the antecedent), and it implies
something else (the consequent), then if the implied thing is not true (the consequent is denied), the original
statement cannot be true.
Here's an example:
Conclusion: Therefore, I must not have studied hard (the antecedent cannot be true).
Linking to Arguments
These two rules help us evaluate arguments. A good argument should follow a valid structure.
Modus ponens helps us reach a strong conclusion based on true premises. It strengthens arguments.
Modus tollens helps us identify flaws in arguments. If the conclusion we expect from the premise isn't
true, then the original premise might be shaky.
Let's say someone argues, "If she is honest, she will tell the truth. She told the truth, therefore she must be
honest." This argument follows modus ponens. However, the reverse ("If she's honest, she'll tell the truth. She
lied, therefore she's not honest") is not necessarily true. There could be other reasons why she lied. This is
where modus tollens helps us see the argument might have a gap.
These are just two basic rules. Logic is a vast field, but understanding modus ponens and modus tollens gives
us a strong foundation for evaluating arguments and forming our own sound reasoning.