Chapter 4B-Electrostatic & Electromagnetic Propulsion
Chapter 4B-Electrostatic & Electromagnetic Propulsion
Chapter 4B-Electrostatic & Electromagnetic Propulsion
Plasma is then a collection of the various charged particles that are free to
move in response to fields they generate or fields that are applied to the
collection and, on the average, is almost electrically neutral.
Modem ion and Hall thrusters operating on xenon propellant have exhaust
velocities in the range of 20-40 km/s and 10-20 km/s, respectively.
• Ion Bombardment
• Ion contact
Electrostatic
• Colloid Ion
• Hall Effect (SPT,TAL)
Ion thrusters employ a variety of plasma generation techniques to ionize a large
fraction of the propellant.
These thrusters then utilize biased grids to electrostatically extract ions from
the plasma and accelerate them to high velocity at voltages up to and exceeding
10 kV.
Ion thrusters feature the highest efficiency (from 60% to >80%) and very high
specific impulse (from 2000 to over 10,000 s) compared to other thruster types.
ION THRUSTER SYSTEM
• Plasma Generator
• Accelerator Grids
• Neutralizer Cathodes
The schematic figures shows the cross section of an electronbombardment ion thruster
that uses an electron discharge to generate the plasma.
An ion thruster consists of basically three components:
• The plasma generator,
• the accelerator grids,
• and the neutralizer cathode.
The discharge cathode and anode represent the plasma generator in this thruster, and
ions from this region flow to the grids and are accelerated to form the thrust beam.
The plasma generator is at high positive voltage compared to the spacecraft or space
plasma and, therefore, is enclosed in a “plasma screen” biased near the spacecraft
potential to eliminate electron collection from the space plasma to the positively
biased surfaces.
The cathode is positioned outside the thruster and provides electrons at the same rate
as the ions to avoid charge imbalance with the spacecraft.
• Plasma Generator
ION THRUSTER SYSTEM • Accelerator Grids
• Neutralizer Cathodes
Hall Effect Thruster
Hall thruster efficiency and specific impulse is somewhat less than that
achievable in ion thrusters, but the thrust at a given power is higher and the
device is much simpler and requires fewer power supplies to operate.
HALL EFFECT THRUSTER
• Hall thruster efficiency and specific impulse less than ion thrusters, but
• The thrust at a given power is higher and the device is much simpler and requires fewer
power supplies to operate
• the cathode
• the discharge region
• magnetic field
Magnetic coils induce a radial magnetic field between the center pole piece and the flux return path at the
outside edge.
The cathode of the discharge is an external hollow cathode, and the anode is a ring located at the base of
the cylindrical slot.
Gas is fed into the discharge channel through the anode and dispersed into the channel.
Electrons attempting to reach the anode encounter a transverse radial magnetic field, which reduces their
mobility in the axial direction and inhibits their flow to the anode.
The electrons tend to spiral around the thruster axis in the E x B direction and represent the Hall current
from which the device derives its name.
Ions generated by these electrons are accelerated by the electric field from the anode to the cathode
potential plasma produced at the front of the thruster.
Some fraction of the electrons emitted from the hollow cathode also leave the thruster with the ion beam
to neutralize the exiting charge.
The shape and material of the discharge region channel and the details of the magnetic field determine the
performance of the thruster.
Hall thrusters operate at the high specific impulses that are typical for
electric propulsion.
The ion beam exiting the thruster is often called the thruster plume, and the
characteristics of this plume are important in how the exhaust particles interact
with the spacecraft.
Characteristics of a thruster plume
First, the beam has an envelope and a distribution of the ion currents in that
envelope.
Second, the energetic ions in the beam can charge exchange with neutral gas
coming from the thruster or the neutralizer, producing fast neutrals propagating in
the beam direction and slow ions. These slow ions then move in the local electric
fields associated with the exit of the acceleration region and the neutralizer plasma,
and can backflow into the thruster or move radially to potentially bombard any
spacecraft components in the vicinity.
Third, energetic ions are often generated at large angles from the thrust axis due
either to edge effects (fringe fields) in the acceleration optics of ion thrusters, large
gradients in the edge of the acceleration region in Hall thrusters, or scattering of the
beam ions with the background gas.
Finally, the thruster evolves impurities associated with the wear of the thruster
components. This can be due to the sputtering of the grids in ion thrusters, the
erosion of the ceramic channel in Hall thrusters, or the evolution of cathode
materials or sputtering of other electrodes in the engines. This material can deposit
on spacecraft surfaces, which can change surface properties such as emissivity,
transparency, etc
Child-Langmuir-Schottky law
Space charge is also a limiting factor for the grid size. The maximum
current I that can be extracted from an area A by a potential difference
U at a distance d is given by the Child-Langmuir-Schottky law as
• only positive ions would create a strong positive potential in front of the
thruster, which would slow down the ions accelerated from the chamber.
If it is high enough, it can even stop the ion current and the thrust would
be zero (space charge limitation).
• A high current (and thrust) therefore requires a high potential difference at
a small distance, which can cause sparks. The limit here is usually 0.5
mm. With total acceleration potentials between 1.5 and 2.5 kV, the
diameter of the discharge chamber is about 20 cm for a 20 micro N
thruster and 40 cm for a 200 micro N thruster.
• Collisions between the fast ion (30,000 mls) and neutral propellant (1,000
mls) components can cause exchange of impulse between both collision
partners and hence slow ions and fast neutrals. This process is called
charge-exchange collision. The slow ions can then be attracted by the
accelerator grid (negative potential) gaining enough energy to cause
sputtering. This causes the most dominant lifetime limitation.
Electron-bombardment (Kaufman) Thruster
Electrons are emitted into the main discharge chamber and accelerated
towards an anode to potentials of typically 1,000 Volts.
The chamber is filled with the propellant gas, usually Xenon, ionized by the
energetic electrons.
The ions are slowly pushed through an extractor grid by a small voltage drop
between the grid and the anode (typically a few tens of Volt).
Then, the ions are accelerated by another grid at negative or ground potential,
producing an ion beam with a half-angle divergence of about 10 degrees.
Since only positive ions leave the thruster (the electrons inside the main
chamber are repelled by the positive extractor grid), and the spacecraft is
not grounded in space, the spacecraft potential would continuously become
negative.
Therefore, electrons have to be injected externally into the ion beam to keep
the positive potential in front of the thruster, which would slow down the ions
accelerated from the chamber.
If it is high enough, it can even stop the ion current and the thrust would be zero
(space charge limitation).
The electrons help to create a quasi-neutral plasma that avoid these problems.
Radiofrequency Thruster
An alternative to the electron-bombardment thruster is the radiofrequency (RF)
thruster.
Here, the propellant gas is ionized by applying a MHz frequency excitation to free
electrons that ionize the neutral propellant.
The extractor grid (+ 1.5 kV) redirects the ions into the discharge chamber, the
accelerator grid (- 1.5 kV) and deaccelerator grid (around ground potential) are
similar to the electron bombardment thruster design.
The RF thruster offers design advantages (no hollow cathode in the main
discharge chamber, . .. ), the RF plasma process makes the RF thruster slightly
less efficient than the Kaufman engines.
Astrium in Germany is marketing the RIT-XX thruster series (RF Ion Thruster), the
RIT-1O generating 10 J.LN of thrust was flight-qualified on the EURECA mission in
1993.
A field emission thruster, also called Field Emission Electric Propulsion (PEEP)
thruster, uses an electric field to extract and accelerate atomic ions directly
from the surface of a metal exposed to vacuum by applying suitable voltages to
a closely spaced electrode configuration.
For propulsion applications, the most common source is a metallic liquid. The
thrust level ranges from micro- to milli-Newton at specific impulses of as high
as 12,000 seconds, requiring total acceleration voltages of up to lOkV and
above.
When the free surface of the liquid metal is exposed to a high electric field it is
distorted into conical or series of conical protrusions (Taylor cone) in which the
radius of curvature at the apex becomes smaller as the field is increased.
Field Emission Thruster
At a threshold value of 109 V/m, atoms on the surface of the tip are ionized
and accelerated by the same field that created them, producing a thrust.
Due to this direct conversion of a liquid metal into an ion beam, the process
operates at high power efficiency.
Expelled ions are replenished by the hydrodynamical flow of the liquid metal.
A separate neutralizer is required to maintain charge neutrality.
two most common propellants used are Cesium and Indium; alternative propellants
are Rubidium and Gallium.
A propellant for such a type of thruster has to have a high atomic mass to achieve
sufficient thrust levels, good wetting capabilities to maintain propellant flow to the
ion emission site, a low melting point and ionization energy to reduce additional
power demands to liquify and ionize the propellant.
Two different designs have emerged and
are currently under development: one
based on Cesium or Rubidium as
In the slit configuration, multiple
propellant in a slit emitter configuration
Taylor cone emission sites are
developed by Centrospazio in Italy
automatically built up and are
therefore capable of producing high
and one based on an Indium propellant
thrusts up to mN.
using a needle or capillary type emitter
developed by ARC Seibersdorf research in
One needle or capillary type can
Austria
generate a maximum thrust of 100
J.LN and needs to be clustered for
higher thrust requirements
colloid thruster
At the needle exit, a liquid cone developes due to the equilibrium of electrostatic forces
and surface tension (Taylor cone).
The same electrostatic forces break off droplets from the tip of the cone with a net charge
and accelerate it. Several needles are typically clustered together in an array to achieve
higher thrust levels.
Such type of thrusters were extensively studied in the 1960s through the mid 1970s in
the US (NASA, TRW, US Air Force), Europe (ESA) and Russia (MAl).
The high mass-to-charge ratio of a charged droplet with respect to single ions was
known to increase the thrust density and efficiency.
On the other hand, very high acceleration voltages were required in the order of 12 up
to 100 kV, a requirement very difficult to handle on a spacecraft.
Moreover degradation problems due to radiation with the organic propellants used
stopped the development.
Rocket Specific
Equation Impulse
Force
Transfer
Principles
and
Equations Thrust
Power
Dissipation
Efficiency
ROCKET EQUATION
The mass ejected to provide thrust to the spacecraft is the propellant, which is
carried onboard the vehicle and expended during thrusting.
From conservation of momentum, the ejected propellant mass times its velocity is
equal to the spacecraft mass times its change in velocity.
The “rocket equation” describing the relationship between the spacecraft velocity
and the mass of the system is derived as follows.
The force on a spacecraft, and thus the thrust on the vehicle, is equal to the mass
of the spacecraft, M, times its change in velocity, v:
…….Eq 1
The thrust on the spacecraft is equal and opposite to the time rate of change of
the momentum of the propellant, which is the exhaust velocity of the propellant
times the time rate of change of the propellant mass:
…….Eq 2
where mp is the propellant mass on the spacecraft and vex is the propellant
exhaust velocity in the spacecraft frame of reference
The total mass of the spacecraft at any time is the delivered mass, md , plus
the propellant mass:
…….Eq 3
The mass of the spacecraft changes due to consumption of the propellant, so the
time rate of change of the total mass is
…….Eq 4
Substituting Eq 4 in Eq 2, gives
…….Eq 5
T
Equating equation 1 and Eq 5 gives
T= …….Eq 6
this equation is solved by integrating from the spacecraft initial velocity, vi , to the final velocity, v f ,
during which the mass changes from its initial value, md + mp , to its final delivered mass, md
The final mass of a spacecraft delivered after a given amount of propellant has been used to achieve
the specified Δv is
The specific impulse, Isp, is equal to the propellant exhaust velocity, vex , divided
by the gravitational acceleration g.
The above Equation shows that for a given mission with a specified Δv and final
delivered mass, md, the initial spacecraft wet mass (md+mp) can be reduced by
increasing the Isp of the propulsion system, which has implications for the launch vehicle
size and cost. High delta-v missions are often enabled by electric propulsion because it
offers much higher exhaust velocities and Isp than do conventional chemical propulsion
systems.
The above equation can be written in terms of the required propellant mass
Electric thrusters, however, separate the propellant from the energy source
(which is now a power supply) and thus are not subject to the same limitations.
Thrust is the force supplied by the engine to the spacecraft. Since the spacecraft
mass changes with time due to the propellant consumption, the thrust is given
by the time rate of change of the momentum, which can be written as
where mp, is the propellant mass flow rate in kg/s. The propellant mass flow
rate is
where Q is the propellant particle flow rate (in particles) and M is the particle
mass.
The kinetic thrust power of the beam, called the jet power, is defined as
This expression shows that techniques that increase the thrust without
increasing the propellant flow rate will result in an increase in the jet power.
For ion and Hall thrusters, ions are accelerated to high exhaust velocity using
an electrical power source. The velocity of the ions greatly exceeds that of any
Un-ionized propellant that may escape from the thruster, so the thrust can be
described as
where mi is the ion mass flow rate and vi is the ion velocity.
where vb is the net voltage through which the ion was accelerated, q is the
charge, and M is the ion mass.
The mass flow rate of ions is related to the ion beam current, Ib , by
The thrust is proportional to the beam current times the square root of the
acceleration voltage. In the case of Hall thrusters, there is a spread in beam
energies produced in the thruster, and tb represents the effective or average beam
voltage.
If the propellant is xenon,
The above Equation is the basic thrust equation that applies for a unidirectional,
singly ionized, monoenergetic beam of ions. The equation must be modified to
account for the divergence of the ion beam and the presence of multiply charged
ions commonly observed in electric thrusters.
The correction to the thrust equation for beam divergence is straightforward for a beam
that diverges uniformly upon exiting from the thruster. For a thruster with a constant
ion current density profile accelerated by uniform electric fields, the correction to the
force due to the effective thrust-vector angle is simply
If the thrust half angle is 10 deg, then cos θ = 0.985, which represents a 1.5% loss in
thrust.
Thruster Efficiency
The electrical efficiency of the thruster is
defined as the beam power, Pb , out of the
thruster divided by the total input power, PT
The cost of producing ions is described by an ion
production efficiency term, sometimes called the
discharge loss
The performance of a plasma generator plotting the discharge loss versus the
propellant utilization efficiency
total thrust correction
The total thrust correction (γ) is the product of the divergence and multiply charged
species terms:
If we assume an ion thruster with a 10-deg half-angle beam divergence and a 10%
doubles-to-singles ratio it will results in
γ = 0.958.
The mass utilization efficiency, describes the fraction of the input propellant mass that
is converted into ions and accelerated in the electric thruster.
The electrical efficiency of the thruster is defined as the beam power, Pb , out of the
thruster divided by the total input power, PT :
where Po represents the other power input to the thruster required to create the
thrust beam.
Other power will include the electrical cost of producing the ions, cathode heater
or keeper power, grid currents in ion thrusters, etc.
The cost of producing ions is described by an ion production efficiency term,
sometimes called the discharge loss:
Contrary to most efficiency terms, it is desirable to have ηd as small as possible since this
represents a power loss.
for the thrust, for the exhaust velocity, and for the propellant flow rate, the total
efficiency can be written as
Substituting
Measurements of the input propellant flow rate and electrical parameters (currents and voltages), and
knowledge of the thrust correction factors from thruster plume measurements or code predictions, permit
the total efficiency of ion thrusters to be calculated with high accuracy using the above equation
Example: For an ion thruster with 10-deg half-angle divergence, (γ = 0.958) 10% double
ion current, 90% mass utilization efficiency, and 250 eV/ion to produce a 2-A beam at
1500 V, the electrical efficiency is
This shows that the thruster converts 70.8% of the supplied electrical energy
into useful kinetic energy imparted to the spacecraft
Thrusters with high exhaust velocities, and thus high Isp's, are desirable to
maximize a mission payload mass. In order to achieve high Isp, it is necessary to
operate at a high ion acceleration voltage and high mass utilization efficiency.
Reductions in ion mass also increase the Isp, but at the cost of thrust at the same
power level. This is seen by examining the thrust to-total input power ratio.
The total power is just the beam power divided by the electrical efficiency, so the
thrust-to-power ratio using Eq. is
The beam power is the beam current times the beam voltage
This Equation shows that for a given input power and total thruster efficiency, increasing
the Isp reduces the thrust available from the electric engine.
This trade of thrust for Isp at a constant input power can only be improved if higher
efficiency ion thrusters are employed.
Electromagnetic
Electromagnetic Thrusters
The high electric currents needed to generate thrusts require high power
levels (tens of kW up to MW) or pulsed-mode operation with heavy
capacitors
Low thrust and very high exhaust velocity of ion engines are a disadvantage to
many applications where efficiency of electric propulsion would be beneficial
These disadvantages are attributable t the fact that only the positive ions contribute
to thrust, and the ion current is limited to a low value by the space charge effect.
If the Ion flow could be increased beyond the space charge limit, then a much more
versatile engine could be developed.
An ionized gas passes through a channel across which are maintained orthogonal
electric and magnetic fields.
The current carried by electrons and ions, which develops along the electric field
vector, interacts with the magnetic field to generate a propulsive force along the
channel.
The force acts in the same direction for both electrons and ions, and so the whole
plasma is accelerated and the accelerating force is not limited by the density of the
plasma so the space charge limit is not breached
The gas therefore need not be completely ionized; even a few percent of ions is
sufficient, because they transfer their energy to the neutral gas molecules by collision.
Energy lost by the ions in this way is immediately restored by the electric and magnetic
fields
This process is not a simple affair, the transverse current generates its own
magnetic field, the gas is heated, and the ions are acted upon by electric and
magnetic fields which they themselves generate.
The axial component generates thrust and the radial component increases
the pressure towards the center line.
The higher the power, the better the efficiency, which is typically around 35%
and can increase up to 75%.
One of the few test centers with vacuum facilities as well as available power
for continuous operation of MPD thrusters is the Institute for Space Systems
at the University of Stuttgart in Germany.
Cathode erosion is one of the major lifetime-limitation factors.
Heat transfer from the discharge ablates part of the propellant and
ionizes it.
A PPT thruster has several advantages like zero warm-up time and
zero standby power, no propellant tanks and feedlines, and most
notably is very cheap due to the simple design.
Presently PPT thrusters are under evaluation for fine attitude and
position control of formation-flying satellites on account of their small
impulse bit capability.
Variable Isp Plasma Rocket (VASIMR)
In the VASIMR concept, hydrogen is ionized and injected into the main
chamber by a magnetoplasmadynamic (MPD) device.
The magnetic fields isolate the plasma from the chamber walls so that the
temperature can exceed material melting limits and therefore reach very high
specific impulses.
In the main chamber, electron and ion cyclotron heating is used by applying
resonant radiofrequency (RF) fields to heat the plasma, which is then
expelled through a magnetic nozzle.
Hydrogen propellant can be injected into the plasma exhaust for cooling
purposes.
The magnetic nozzle can control the thrust by varying the nozzle entrance
section.
On the other hand, the specific impulse can be varied by changing RF heating
power (3,000-30,000 s).