1980 Qasim Jan
1980 Qasim Jan
1980 Qasim Jan
ABSTRACT
The Jijal complex, covering more than 150 sq. km in the extreme north of Pakistan, is a tectonic
wedge of garnet granulites intruded in the south by a 10 x 4 km slab of ultramafic rocks. The
granulites are divisible into plagioclase-bearing (basic to intermediate) and plagioclase-free
(ultrabasic to basic) types, the two types reflecting differences in bulk chemistry. Garnet +
plagioclase + clinopyroxene + quartz + rutile ± hornblende ± epidote is the most common
assemblage. The plagioclase-free rocks are composed mainly of two or three of the minerals garnet,
amphibole, clinopyroxene and epidote. Orthopyroxene occurs in websteritic rocks devoid of epidote.
Much of the amphibole and some epidote appear to be prograde products. Although variation
diagrams do not reveal a genetic link between the two types of granulite, it is considered that they
are comagmatic rather than the products of two or more unrelated magmas.
The compositions of garnet (Py28^i6Alm27-43Groi6-28), clinopyroxene (Mg44-34Fe5-nCa5i-49,
A12O3 3-0-9-9 per cent), orthopyroxene (with up to 5-5 per cent A12O3), amphibole (with up to
16-3 per cent A12O3 and high Alvi/Aliv), and the abundance of garnet suggest a high-pressure origin
for the granulites. The rocks appear to have differentiated from a tholeiitic magma of oceanic
affinity or they may be genetically related to the pyroxene granulites of Swat considered to have
originally crystallized from a calc-alkaline magma of island arc or continental margin affinity. They
probably crystallized in the ancient Tethyan crust/upper mantle (or less likely in a continental
margin), later to be metamorphosed to granulites (670-790 °C, 12-14 kb) during the collision of
the Indian-Asian landmasses, and carried upwards during later Himalayan orogenic episodes.
The ultramafic rocks are alpine-type in nature and devoid of garnet. They are dominated by
diopsidites; dunites, peridotites, and harzburgites together form <50 per cent of the area of outcrop.
The chemistry of the rocks, and their olivines (Fo92_89) a n d clinopyroxenes (Mg49.5_48Fe2.g_5.2
Ca47.4_46.8) are similar to those of alpine complexes of the harzburgite subtype. It is not clear
whether they represent a faulted slab of suboceanic crust/upper mantle, mantle diapirs in deep
orogenic roots, or dismembered ultramafic rocks differentiated from a basaltic magma. They seem
to have a complex history; their present mineralogy is suggestive of high grade metamorphism
(800-850 °C, 8-12 kb). They are magmatically unrelated to the garnet granulites and were
probably intruded into the latter as plastic crystalline material after both had been independently
metamorphosed, but before the entire complex was carried tectonically into its present
surroundings. The abundances of the diopsidites is in marked contrast to other alpine-type
complexes and the possibility of Ca and Si metasomatism during or before their metamorphism
should not be totally ruled out.
INTRODUCTION
MUCH of Kohistan and adjacent areas, the northernmost part of the North-West
Frontier Province of Pakistan, is occupied by the rocks of the Kohistan complex.
The latter extends E-W for more than 200 km between Nanga Parbat and eastern
Afghanistan and N-S, along the Swat river, for about 70 km (Jan & Kempe,
1973). The complex consists of three NE-trending belts, consisting of amphibolites,
[Journal of Petrology, Vol. 22, Part 1, pp. 8 5 - 1 2 6 , 19811
86 M. Q. JAN AND R. A. HOWIE
pyroxene granulites, and quartz diorites. In the south the amphibolites have a
faulted contact with Palaeozoic schists. Occurrence along or near this contact of
glaucophane schists, serpentinites and other ultramafic rocks is suggestive of a
major tectonic activity (Coleman, 1971, 1972; Moores, 1973). The fault is
probably an extension of the Indus suture line which, according to Gansser (1974),
marks 'the subduction of the Indian plate and its thrust below the Tibetan mass'.
Along the Indus near Jijal (35° 05' N, 72° 55' E), however, the amphibolites
and Palaeozoic schists are separated from each other by a fault-bounded block or
wedge of garnet granulites and ultramafic rocks, which constitute the Jijal complex.
Analytical techniques
Disc and Frantz magnetic separators and heavy liquids were used for mineral
separation. Only those rocks were chosen for separation which showed equilibrium
texture and in which the minerals, especially plagioclase if present, showed no (or
only marginal) zoning. Small quantities of rocks, weighing less than 500 g, were
crushed for separation in the hope that uniform conditions of chemical equilibrium
would have been reached in the smaller volume of the chemical system. The
minerals were ground to between 200 and 300 B.S.M. but the garnets were
powdered to <300 mesh; the analysed concentrates, especially garnets, were purer
than 99-5 per cent. Densities were determined by taking about 3-0 g of material in
density bottles; the reported values are at 0 °C and should be accurate in most
THE JIJAL COMPLEX, PAKISTAN 8?
O I
73 00 E
2 Km.
35° OO' N
FIG. 1. Geological sketch map of the Jijal complex. Numbers indicate the locations of the analysed samples.
F = fault.
88 M. Q. JAN AND R. A. HOWIE -
PETROGRAPHY
TABLE 1
Mineral assemblages in the Jijal garnet granulites
(+,0) 0
+ + + + +
Granulites 1
o + o + +
with 2 0 (+,0)
essential 3 + (+,0)
Granulites 6 (+,0) 0 + 0
with 7 0 0 (+,0) 0 (+,0) (Spinel)
little 8 0 + 0 0 + 0
or no 9 (+,0) + (+,0) (+,0)
plagioclase
Hornblende-rich types, all with rutile &/or opaque minerals
10 0 + 0 0 + 0
11 0 0 + 0 (+, 0) (Spinel)
12 (+.0) + 0 0
Pyroxene-rich assemblages; most have opaque minerals (no rutile)
13 0 0 (+,0) 0
14 0 (+,0) + 0 (+.0) 0 + (OPx)
15 0 0 0 +
authors. Tectonic fabrics, Mg-rich olivine and pyroxenes (Mg/Fe ~9/l), common
concentrations of Cr-spinel (Thayer, 1960, 1967; Jackson & Thayer, 1972), and
little compositional variation in the rocks (Moores, 1969) are among their special
features. The Jijal rocks share all these characteristics; they are devoid of
plagioclase, micas, and primary amphibole. Den Tex (1969) subdivided the alpine
peridotites into two genetic classes, the ophiolitic or truly alpine-type, and the
root-zone peridotites found in very high-grade metamorphic terrains in deeply
eroded mountain roots. The Jijal rocks probably should be placed in the second
group.
II
' © ^ r£
to
r- — oo—•
Ooooov. NOVJOI— o o o o
CT\ *o —
O - • 0O \
8 j _ O — ' O
«o ' t •** «o I
i — — r-1 — I
v v— v
# i~- • £ - ^ a> - v <N — • i — «N I —
O r^
•I O — O— t w - i O O O — O
t r - T ^ m ^ - — — — — o»"i
I I 1 ^ 1 I
s V "» V
r*j —
a^ o o «O 00
o — , - — — 6
43
18
V — V V
—
^OfOOfNI^MNOtD-O I N N jOOOOsTf^r- —
Or^OOOOOOOO
r-—,,*! — ^ - — (N — C * ~
1
I* , IO <N O !
OQ a
i I
"? I 9
i — I © O — rMr- — *
r^ir^Of~~fN
-66^-
V *N
sc f\
O\ 8: > O L.
k. *N
8 © CN «O 6 — O0 <
5)
i-co©< sr > — r - © f - . ^o>o i —•
iOooo<-nr-mrnO©Oi_ i *e
s:
a
"a
**» f-v^O'o — O
S OO - — O O — OO
© r*> r~- •
i (N O * N X
— V "" V V
^ » * i t o o — ^rr— ov»o©'«
O ^ r ^ ' r - j — — r— •*!•(— rN
- OOOOO* - — so i n
v vv v
00 »O O 00 w-i ©
I 00
I — - I I in
O.
* S ^ g J2 £ t
om http://petrology.oxfordjournals.org/ at University of California, San Fransisco on April 7, 2015
mt 8-63 3-77 117 4-44 415 3-31 0-68 5-31 0-71 512 001 2-87 2-90 4-63 6-26 2-77 1-62 1-45
il 2-35 0-42 0-61 0-38 0-42 0-42 0-30 118 0-32 017 213 1-18 1-31 101 103 203 110 1-20
ap — — 014 007 — — 009 — 0-28 007 109 0-38 0-33 0-31 005 0-62 019 0-36
Niggli values
si 76-7 791 80-8 790 79-2 79-8 86-2 85-1 900 935 99-6 113-9 120-3 115-8 121-0 146-5 136-8 1801
al 18-3 19-6 18-4 20-9 18-7 190 281 11-7 18 5 3-7 25-9 30-9 26-9 26-7 27-9 281 27-4 31-3
fm 540 57-5 60-3 54-9 581 50-7 42-7 49-5 47-4 76-6 41-8 381 41-9 41-2 39-3 40-5 37-7 33-6
c 22-6 220 20-3 23-4 22-7 29-8 28-1 37-8 33-1 19-2 26-6 261 26-9 26-6 27-3 260 26-8 261
alk 51 0-9 1-0 0-9 0-6 0-6 1-2 10 10 05 5-7 4-9 4-4 5-5 5-5 5-4 80 90
ti 1-77 0-31 0-46 0-28 0-31 0-31 0-24 0-86 0 25 012 1-82 1-09 1 26 0-94 0-99 218 110 1-44
p — — 005 002 — — 003 — 010 002 0-42 0-16 0-14 013 002 0-30 009 019
k 007 006 009 004 006 008 000 002 008 009 007 003 007 002 003 006 006 005
mg 0-62 0-55 0-65 0 71 0-65 0-73 0-74 0-73 0-85 0 81 0-38 0-47 0-49 0-47 0-49 0-38 0-50 0-46
-i
. a
Locations of the analysed rocks in Tables 2 and 3 are given on the map (Fig. 1). The XRF analyses are distinguished from wet chemical analyses by the absence of an OH" value for the rn
former. ,_
Columns SI 289 to SI 297a represent granulites with little or no plagioclase whilst SI 326 to SI 330 represent granulites with essential plagioclase. "
SI 289. Garnetiferous hornblende rock' containing 90-8 per cent ferroan pargasite, 4-8 per cent garnet (Gar). 1-6 per cent epidote (Epi), 1-2 per cent opaque minerals (Ore), 0-8 per >
cent rutile (Rt). and 0-8 per cent clinopyroxene (Cpx), quartz (Qz), chlorite (Ch), and sphene (Sph). The latter three and Epi are retrograde. The sample is traversed by a thin felsic vein t~
with traces of a white mica. Density (D) = 3-27. ^
SI 292. Clinopyroxene 'garnelite' consisting of 71-3 per cent Gar, 20-7 per cent Cpx, 7-4 per cent amphibole (Amph, brownish green and bluish green varieties), and 0-7 per cent Ore, O
Epi. Ch. Sph, Rt. The bluish green Amph. Epi. Ch and Sph are retrograde. D = 3-52. 5*
SI 317. Granulite composed of Gar. Hbl. Epi. with small amounts of (?) margarite. clinopyroxene. plagioclase (Pig), Ore, Ch. Marg, Ch, some Epi and (?) Hbl retrograde. D — 3-36. *ta
SI 283. Granulite containing Gar. Amph, Cpx, with small amounts of Pig, Rt, (?) Qz. Ch, Epi and carbonate along fractures, mainly in Gar. D = 3-49. *"*
SI 297b. Granulile containing Gar, Cpx. Hbl (brownish) with small amounts of Ore and Rt. Epi, Ch. Sph and an amphibole are the retrograde products. D = 3-51. Pj
SI 297c. Granulite containing Gar. Cpx. pleonaste and Amph. A lot of secondary Epi, Ch, (?) Serp. Amph. Spinel surrounded by a complex corona structure which has been made com-
plicated by alteration. *g
SI 285. (Clino)zoisite rich granulite also containing Gar, Amph, Cpx and minor Qz, Ore, and Ch. Most (probably all) of the hydrous minerals retrograde. D = 3-34. >
SI 270. Garnet clinopyroxenite consisting of 77 1 per cent Cpx, 16-8 per cent Gar, 5-7 per cent Amph, and 0-4 per cent Ore. Opx also present in some parts of the outcrop sampled. ?^
D - 337. £
SI 299. Granulite (light grey in colour) containing Cpx. Gar (C)zoi. Amph, Ch, (?)Plg: the last four may be entirely retrograde. D = 3-20. H
SI 297a. Garnet free websteritic granulite composed of Opx. Cpx and abundant secondary talc, serpentine (?) tremolite and minor magnetite. The three samples. SI 297a, b, c, are from a >
granulite xenolilh in ultramafic rocks. For further details, see text under spinels. ^
SI 326. Granulite containing 32-5 per cent Amph. 30-6 per cent Gar. 22-7 per cent Pig. 5-8 per cent Epi, 4 5 per cent Cpx, 2-9 per cent Qz, 0-6 per cent Rt and 0-3 per cent apatite.
Pig complexly twinned and zoned, Epi also zoned. D - 3-20.
SI 332. Granulite consisting of 46-6 per cent Pig. 25-6 per cent Gar. 17-1 per cent Cpx, 2-5 per cent Epi, 1-8 per cent Amph, 3-8 per cent Qz, 2-3 per cent Ore and 0-3 per cent Ap.
Gar contains Rt needles. Epi, and some Qz and Amph retrograde. D = 3-2. Contains 0-23 per cent C in the norm.
SID 50. Granulite composed of 46-8 per cent Pig, 2 5 1 per cent Gar, 21-3 per cent Cpx, 4-6 per cent Qz, 1-3 per cent Ore, 0-6 per cent Epi (retrograde), 0-2 per cent Rt, and 0-2 per
cent Ap. Secondary Amph after Cpx and Sph/leucoxenc after Ore. D = 3-29.
SI 290. Granulite containing 45-5 per cent Gar, 24-7 per cent Pig, 13-4 per cent Cpx, 10-4 per cent Qz, 5-2 per cent Epi, 0-6 per cent Rt, and 0-2 per cent Ap. Most Epi primary but
some retrograde, as is minor Ch. D —3-13.
SI 291. Granulite consisting of Gar, Amph, Pig (An 24), Epi, Qz, paragonite, Rt and Ap. Paragonite is retrograde but Amph and Epi look primary. D = 3-27.
SI 328. Granulite composed of zoned Pig (andesine). Gar, Cpx, Qz and minor Rt, Hbl and hypersthene. Hbl may be retrograde but Hy is in unstable relics. D = 3-16.
SI 338. Granulite containing 39-2 per cent Pig (An 40 ), 28-3 per cent Gar, 19-2 per cent Cpx, 12-4 per cent Qz, 0-3 per cent Rt, 0-2 per cent each of Amph, Epi, Ore and traces of Ap.
D = 319. ^
SI 330. Sheared and banded granulite containing Pig, Gar, Cpx, Qz, Amph, Rt, Ore, Epi; the later being retrograde. D = 2-95. <••»
94 M. Q. JAN AND R. A. HOWIE
Variation diagrams
Oxide percentages have been plotted against the Thornton & Tuttle (1960)
differentiation index, DI = sum of weight per cent normative Q + or + ab + ne + Ic
+ ks, in Fig. 2. With increase in DI, the plagioclase-bearing rocks show an increase
in SiO2 and total alkalis (essentially sodium), and a decrease in A12O3, Fe oxides,
CaO, and MgO. Such trends cannot be seen in the plagioclase-free rocks because
of their restricted DI range due to low alkalis and silica. Interestingly, however,
there is a gap in the DI values between 5-41 and 18-95 (ignoring sample 289, with
DI = 16-26, which is clearly behaving independently due to (?)metasomatism).
This lack of intermediate DI values could arise from a lack of analyses of truly
representative rocks; nevertheless, the possibility of two magmas cannot be ruled
out.
Fig. 3 shows the plot of several cation percentages against (j Si + K — Ca —
Mg). Here also Na and Si increase and Ca, Mg, and Al decrease with increase in
the index for the plagioclase-bearing granulites. The plagioclase-free rocks behave
similarly in the case of Ca and Mg but have an almost perpendicular trend for Si
and (?) Al. The two types of rock also seem to have opposed trends for the other
elements despite the fact that this type of variation diagram produces smoother
trends than most other variation diagrams.
Some of the trace elements have also been plotted against (j Si + K — Ca — Mg)
in Fig. 4. Whether any conclusions can be drawn from the distribution of trace
elements is debatable; significant differences in the pre- and post-metamorphic
modal composition between the two types of rocks, lack of suitable laboratory
standards, and high-grade metamorphism are some of the main factors which could
render such conclusions invalid.
The low Cr and Ni contents and the different variation trends for the two types
of rocks raise a serious question: are the plagioclase-free granulites really
meta-igneous?
The Cr and Ni values for the granulites are lower than those reported for
basic-ultrabasic rocks of somewhat similar composition. Cr, apart from making its
om http://petrology.oxfordjournals.org/ at University of California, San Fransisco on April 7, 2015
• FeO
12 *
•
o o 2 . Ti O2
8 • o o 1 O O
CD O O O O
o O
4
v •
- •• 3 . Na 2 O+K 2 O #
<9 O
O O
18 • • (Fe 2 O 3 HhFeO) 2 - °O O
14 - • • •
•
1
H
10
•
CO <d o o
O
X
m
•
o
IUAL
6
18 • Ca O
I t o •
22 AI2O3 16 O
O
20 o o 14 2
o o
PLEX.
18 O° o 12
10 CO 8 O
O
o O 13
AKIS
55 oo 14 " < % Mg 0
H
12
50 o 10 *•
• (P o Si O 2
8 •
0
o
45 6
o°
•
0 O O
4 O O
1 • 1 1 I 1 1 1 1 1
0 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
DI DI
FIG. 2. Plots of oxide percentages against differentiation index (DI = normative wt. per cent Q + or + ab + ne + Ic + ks) for the plagioclase-bearing (open circles) and
plagioclase-free (filled circles) garnet granulites.
96 M. Q. JAN AND R. A. HOWIE
28
26
o o
24
Si
22
20
12
11
Al
10 o o
O O
9
8 t i
6
Mg
4
14
12
10
Ca
8
Na
in '**'
-14 -10 -6 -2 0 +2
( j S i + K - Ca - M g )
FIG. 3. Plots of Na, Ca. Mg. Al. and Si against (jSi + K - Ca — Mg) for the plagioclase-bearing (open circles)
and plagioclase free (filled circles) garnet granulites.
THE JIJAL COMPLEX, PAKISTAN 91
Spess
FIG. 4. Plots of the analysed garnets from Jijal on a (almandine + spessartine) — pyrope — (grossular +
andradite) = 100 diagram showing the fields of garnets from eclogites (1), granulites (2), amphibolites (3), and
epidote amphiboles (4) (after Dobretsov et ai, 1972).
eclogite-like rocks, e.g. Pinus et ai, 1970) were explored using Niggli's approach as
recommended by Leake (1964). It is commonly agreed that in basic magmas a
systematic decrease with increasing differentiation occurs in the Niggli numbers mg
(mg = Mg/(Mg + Fe tota , + Mn) and fm, and a systematic increase in si, al, alk, and
ti. By plotting these values in various ways, the trends generated by igneous rocks
are significantly different from those given by the mixtures of sediments (in this
case the appropriate combinations of pelitic rocks and limestones/dolomites)
which can duplicate the chemistry of basic and ultrabasic rocks. Metasomatic
rocks, on the other hand, are expected to show scattered plots on these variation
diagrams. A few of the plagioclase-free rocks may have been metasomatized
(epidote, sericitic mica, amphibole and chlorite are common as retrograde
98 M. Q. JAN AND R. A. HOWIE
products), but the effects of metasomatism are not pronounced except in the
garnetiferous hornblende rock (? and other hornblende-rich rocks). The few
departures from igneous trends, except in the hornblende rock, seem to be due
essentially to bulk mineralogy.
The following values were used for plotting: mg against c, ti, Ni, Cr, and si; c
against si, al, and al-alk; and a 100 mg + (al —alk) + c = 100 triangular plot.
Although in some cases the rocks fall in the overlapping fields of igneous and
metasedimentary rocks, it can be concluded on the following grounds that the Jijal
TABLE 3
Chemical and XRF analyses of the ultramafic rocks from the Jijal complex
SI 318 SI 278 SI 275 SIJ 76 SI 272 SID 52 SI 294 SIJ 81 SI 275a SI 295
TOTAL 99-85 99-25 99-65 101-4 99-88 1020 1020 101-9 99-07 99-18
PPM
Co 355 137 145 23 28 64 48 27 <10 28
Cr 191 5900 3445 2873 2990 1746 2206 2819 3080 2835
Cu <30 137 55 <30 77 <30 <30 39 <30 59
Ga <10 <10 <10 <10 <10 <10 <10 17 <10 <10
Ni 545 1736 2483 206 433 282 273 235 240 210
Rb 10 11 <10 <10 12 <10 10 10 13 <10
Sr <15 <15 <15 24 <15 20 22 30 20 20
Y < 10 <10 < 10 < 10 < 10 < 10 < 10 18 < 10 < 10
Zn 60 47 40 <30 150 <30 <30 <30 40 60
Zr
CIPW norms
Q — — — — — — — — — 1-42
or 0-24 012 0-06 0-24 006 0-12 0-24 0-12 012 006
ab 0-85 0-25 0-76 1-27 1-69 1-27 1-61 2-37 1-95 1-35
an 0-66 114 0-69 9-60 1-34 5-54 3-53 2-64 1-04 3-32
wo-v 1-42 2-40 1-20 32-17 32-73 2900 2910 30-61 44-69 28-75
en >di 1-14 1-98 0-99 24-30 26-63 22-27 22-43 24-28 37-12 22-83
fs J 012 012 007 4-60 2-18 3-66 3-57 2-86 1-98 2-65
en \ . 24-01 15-28 23-62 4-95 7-05 9-93 1119 1010 5-35 31-02
fs ; h y 2-48 0-92 1-71 0-94 0-58 1-63 1-78 119 0-29 3-59
fo \ , 49-18 65-88 61-02 16-98 22-27 21-45 20-93 21-41 3-39
fa) 01 5-60 4-38 4-37 3-54 201 3-89 3-67 2-78 0-20 —
mt 12-98 6-31 403 0-42 1-97 0-39 1-93 1-36 1-64 3-15
il 0-11 0-17 0-23 0-44 0-21 0-28 0-23 0-17 019 0-44
ap — — — 017 005 0-24 0-21 0-19 — —
SI 318. Moderately altered dunite containing olivine, magnetite, serpentine and chromitic spinel.
SI 278. Mildly altered harzburgite consisting of olivine (Fo 90 ), orthopyroxene, chromite, magnetite, serpentine and
(?) talc.
SI 275. Harzburgite composed of 86-5 per cent olivine (Fo,j.,), 10-1 per cent enstatite, 1 0 per cent diopside, 1 • 1 per cent
serpentine, 0-45 per cent talc, and 0-87 per cent of chromite with minor magnetite.
SIJ 76. Pyroxenite containing diopside, (?) tremolite (talc), serpentine, orthopyroxene, chromite, magnetite. The
amphibole and/or talc seem to replace the serpentine.
SI 272. Olivine clinopyroxenite containing also serpentine, talc, (?) orthopyroxene, chromite and magnetite. Olivine
(Fo,,).
SID 52. Similar to above but also containing a carbonate, no orthopyroxene.
SI 294. Similar to 272 but without orthopyroxene.
SIJ 81. Similar to 294 but also containing a little tremolite which may be later than serpentine.
SI 275a. Coarse-grained clinopyroxenite vein in harzburgite 275, composed of 86-4 per cent diopside, 12-5 per cent
serpentine, and 1-2 per cent chromite and a little magnetite.
SI 295. Websterite containing diopside. magnesian bronzite, chromite, serpentine, talc. (?) amphibole. and magnetite.
100 M. Q. JAN AND R. A. HOWIE
MINERALOGY
Plagioclase. Plagioclase is present only in the granulites. In many rocks it is
cloudy or saussuritized and full of tiny prisms of (clino)zoisite, but in a few rocks it
may also contain patches of an epidote with intergrown quartz. White mica, quartz,
and albite are among its alteration products. In some rocks where the feldspar is
fresh, its composition, based on maximum symmetrical extinction angle on albite
twins, is from An24 to An45. Twinning is usually poorly developed and is on albite
and/or pericline/acline laws. In some rocks the plagioclase appears to lack
TABLE 4
Analyses of an olivine and spinels from the Jijal complex
/ 2 3 4 PPM 1 2 3 4
* Total iron was determined as Fe 2 O 3 in the spinel analyses. The amounts of Fe 2 O 3 and FeO was re-
calculated to give approximately the spinel R 2 + : R3+ ratio of 1:2, following Deer et al. (19626).
t Includes 0 0 0 9 Ni.
102 M. Q. JAN AND R. A. HOWIE
matches closely that determined from the analysis (Fo92.j); however, the value
(Fo86) .derived from the density is markedly low in Mg. Most of the Mg-rich
olivines plotted by Deer et al. (1962a) also give lower Fo contents on the density
curve.
The variation in the composition of the Jijal olivines is small (Fo92.5 to Fo89) and
within the range (Fo 94 -Fo 87 ) displayed by the olivines of alpine peridotites (Green,
1964; Challis, 1965; Jackson & Thayer, 1972). Olivines from peridotites in layered
complexes may be as magnesian as those in alpine peridotites but the range in
some, the dark coloured, almost black, spinel is sprinkled in the form of dense dust
in the green variety. The chemical composition of the two is remarkably similar and
the cause for the difference in their colour is not clear. In both, considerable Fe 2+ is
replacing Mg (Mg/Fe 2+ = 2-24 in the green and 2-34 in the dark variety),
indicating pleonaste.
Spinel is a rare accessory in the Jijal granulites except in the case of rock 297c,
where it becomes an important phase. The spinel-bearing rock occurs in the form of
a band a few centimetres thick that separates a garnet granulite part (297b) from a
websterite part (297a) in a large granulite xenolith in the ultramafic rocks. The
SI 320E and 104b were analysed by microprobe by Ian Young and Cavit Mahmut, respectively. The remainder were analysed by M.Q.J. Total iron is expressed
as FeO in the microprobe analyses.
SI 320E and SI 104b are both garnet websteritic granulites from near the main contact between the granulites and ultramafic rocks along the Karakoram Highway;
they are plagioclase-free but 32OE contains (? secondary) hornblende. For other specimens see Fig. 1 and legend to Table 1.
106 M. Q. JAN AND R. A. HOWIE
dependent upon the normative an/(ol + hy) ratio of their host rocks and the
composition and proportion of the associated minerals (Church, 1968), increasing
pressure also favours the accommodation of grossular relative to almandine in
Fe2+—Mg garnets. This is strongly suggested by the higher grossular content in the
garnets of glaucophane schists, eclogites (Coleman et al., 1965; Dobretsov et al.,
1972), kyanite eclogite and grospydite xenoliths in kimberlites (Sobolev et al.,
1968), and by experimental work (Green & Ringwood, 1967; Akella & Kennedy,
1971; Hensen, 1976).
The Jijal granulite garnets are richer in grossular, and, especially, pyrope than
boundaries against other minerals. However, the possibility should not be ruled out
that in some rocks in which epidote occurs garnet granulites completely
re-equilibrated at lesser depths, and hence lower P—T conditions, during upward
transport and are not isofacial with the remaining granulites. This, at least, seems to
be the case with the well-formed paragonite, 100 Na/(Na + K) = 96, found in an
epidote-bearing granulite (291). Such retrograde epidote is found replacing other
minerals along fractures, as abundant needles in plagioclase, and as large to small
grains found in abundance (up to 50 per cent) in a few rocks where it may show
radial growth and cut across large grains of prograde epidote.
TABLE 6
Analyses 275, 295 (from ultramafic rocks) and 297 (granulite) by M.Q.J.
Analyses 320E amd 104b (granulites) by microprobe by Ian Young and Cavit
Mahmut, respectively, express total iron as FeO.
THE JIJAL COMPLEX, PAKISTAN 109
quantity of Mg, Fe 2+ , and to a lesser extent, in Si and Ca, while those from the
granulites also show substantial variations in Al, Fe 3+ , and Na. With increase in
Fe, the amounts of Si, Ca, Cr, and Ni fall and V rises. Co, Cu, and Pb are generally
higher in the granulite clinopyroxenes than in those from the ultramafic rocks.
10 Fe 2+ +Fe 3 *+Mn
FIG. 5. Plots of the pyroxene compositions for the ultramafic rocks (A) and garnet granulites (A) on a portion
of the pyroxene quadrilateral. Tie-lines are drawn between the analysed pairs.
SI 275 SI 275a SI 272 SI 295 SI 297a SI 283 SI 297b SI 297c SI320E SI 104b SI 270 SI 292 SI 338 SI 290
SiO 2
TiO 2
5400
0-40
54-32
0-16
54-35
010
53-77
0-22
51-82
0-32
51-58
0-38
51-21
0-74
51-60
0-27
52-47
0-25
49-68
0-54
49-51
0-71
49-80
0-71
48-33
0-86
48-73
0-88
s
r\J
A12O3 0-58 0-50 0-86 1-14 3-47 5-26 410 5-14 2-94 5-46 5-90 6-02 9-56 9-88
Fe 2 O 3 0-47 0-29 0-27 0-21 119 0-80 1-37 — — — 2-22 2-11 4-97 4-46 <—»
•w
FeO 1-34 1-93 1-85 301 3-24 2-15 2-97 3-77 5-22 5-04 3 06 4-82 ' 4-13 4-71
MnO 008 009 009 013 014 002 004 005 007 010 0-04 0-06 0-04 0-04 >
MgO 18-36 17-87 17-68 17-13 15-40 14-88 I486 14-80 14-43 14-24 13-94 12-91 1002 9-69
CaO 24-21 23-82 23-73 23-27 23-74 23-98 24-50 25-22 23-41 24-02 23-39 22-03 19-73 19-26 zD
Na 2 O 0-20 0-24 0-20 017 0-22 0-64 0-26 006 0-50 0-25 0-50 1-111 1-90 1-82
K2O 001 001 0-02 0-02 0-00 000 0-00 — 0-01 000 001 001 0-03 001
P2O5 0-00 0-00 000 000 0-00 000 000 — — — 000 000 0-00 0-00 >
TOTAL 99-65 99-23 99-15 99-07 99-54 99-69 100-05 100-91 99-30 99-33 99-28 99-58 99-57 99-48 X
a 1-668 1-671 1-676 1-672 1-675 1-678 1-681 1-695 1-697 o
P 1-675 1-678 1-683 1-680 1-682 1-690 1-691 1-704 1-706
1-695 1-698 1-705 1-703 1-707 1-712 1-710 1-719 1-721 m
y
50° 52° 57° 57° 60°
D 3-271 3-284 3-291 3-302 3-322 3-300 3-320 3-335 3-300 3-369 3-358
Number of ions on the basis of six oxygens
Si 1-965 1-985 1-985 1-975 1-907 1-884 1-879 1-876 1-942 1-846 1-834 1-848 1-791 1-804
Al 0025 0015 0015 0025 0-093 0-116 0-121 0-124 0-058 0154 0166 0-152 0-209 0-196
om http://petrology.oxfordjournals.org/ at University of California, San Fransisco on April 7, 2015
Al — 0-007 0022 0-024 0058 0111 0056 0096 0070 0085 0098 0111 0-209 0-235
Ti 0011 0004 0003 0006 0009 0010 0-020 0-007 0 007 0015 0-020 0020 0-024 0 025
Fe 3+ 0-013 0008 0007 0006 0-033 0-022 0-038 — — — 0062 0059 0-139 0124
Fe 2+ 0041 0059 0-057 0-092 0100 0-066 0091 0-115 0-162 0-157 0095 0-150 0128 0146
Mn 0-003 0-003 0-003 0-004 0004 0-001 0001 0-001 0-002 0003 0-001 0-002 0001 0-001
Mg 0-996 0-973 0-962 0-938 0-845 0-810 0-813 0-802 0-796 0-789 0-770 0-714 0-554 0-535
Ca 0-944 0-933 0-929 0-916 0-936 0-939 0-963 0-982 0-929 0-956 0-929 0-876 0-784 0-764 a
Na 0-014 0-017 0-014 0-012 0016 0-045 0-019 0-002 0-036 0-018 0036 0 080 0-137 0131 rn
K 0000 0000 0001 0001 0000 0000 0-000 — 0-000 0000 0-000 0 000 0001 0-000
X +Y 2-022 2004 1-998 1-999 2-001 2-004 2001 2-005 2-002 2-023 2011 2012 1-977 1-961
Mg 49-9 49-3 49-2 48-0 44-0 44-1 42-6 42-2 42-1 41-4 41-5 39-7 34-5 34-0 r
Fe 2-8 3-5 3-4 5-2 7-3 4-8 6-8 6-1 8-7 8-4 8-5 11-7 16-7 17-3 o/~\
Ca 47-3 47-2 47-4 46-8 48-7 51-1 50-6 51-7 49-2 50-2 50-0 48-6 48-8 48-7
s
•0
PPM
Co 19 20 21 27 36 40 39 79 36 35 19 41 rm
Cr 1642 1710 2120 1642 614 222 222 137 273 684 520 160 78 39
Cu 13 10 6 10 32 24 12 — — — 7 11 162 84 13
Li 2 4 1 2 2 3 2 2 3 — 6 >
Ni 318 229 165 147 119 316 117 157 — — 231 99 74 70
Pb 14 9 12 12 20 9 22 — — — 5 12 — 24
2
VJ
Samples 297b, 297c and 320E were analysed by microprobe by R. F. Symes, Ian Young, and Cavit Mahmut, respectively, and express total iron as FeO. The
remaining analyses are by M.Q.J. Not included in the totals are 0-13 per cent H 2 O+ in 275a, 0-08 per cent H 2 O+ in 295, 0-03 per cent H 2 O in 272, 0-16 per cent
H 2 O+ in 297a and 0-13 per cent H 2 O+ in 270.
Clinopyroxenes 275, 275a, 272, and 295 are from ultramafic rocks; the remainder are from granulites.
112 M. Q. JAN AND R. A. HOWIE
and in those from granulites less than 2:1 (generally about 1:1). The Alvi to Aliv
ratio in the Jijal granulite clinopyroxenes ranges from 0-5 to 1-2 (Fig. 6),
supporting the observations of these authors.
No hypothetical end-members have been calculated for the clinopyroxenes
because of the criticism of Edgar et al. (1969) and Thompson (1974) concerning
the different methods (at least fourteen) of calculation. In most of the Jijal granulite
clinopyroxene analyses there is sufficient Fe 3+ to consume most or all of the Na in
forming the acmite component preferentially over jadeite. This 'acmite first'
approach has been strongly criticized by Thompson (1974), although the positive
2-5
20
^ 1-5
10
05 10 V5 20 2-5
Al'V x 10
FIG. 6. Granulite clinopyroxenes—octahedral Al versus tetrahedral Al. Fields of eclogite and granulite
clinopyroxenes after White (1964).
Pyroxene pairs. Despite the chemical factors (Binns, 1962; Ray & Sen, 1970;
Maxey & Vogel, 1974; Lindh, 1975) and non-ideal mixing in the iron-rich
pyroxenes (Davidson, 1968; Virgo & Hafner, 1970) that can influence KD, it is
commonly accepted that crystallization conditions have significant control over KD
(Kretz, 1963; Scharbert & Kuart, 1974; Sen & Manna, 1976); see also Wells
(1977) and Herzberg (1978). Although there is a scatter in the KD values, the
igneous pyroxenes have significantly higher KD Mg-Fe values (near 0-73) than
those of metamorphic pyroxenes with typical values of 0-54 {e.g. Lindh, 1975). The
KD Mg-Fe for the pyroxene-pairs from the Jijal complex are 0-52 (SI 275) and
0-50 (SI 295) for the ultramafic rocks, and 0-52 (SI 297a), 0-62 (SI 320E) and
0-56 (SI 104b) for the granulites. These values are close to those of metamorphic
pyroxenes and suggest that even the ultramafic rocks may have re-equilibrated at
lower than magmatic temperatures.
Hornblende—pyroxene pairs. It has been noted in a number of areas that KD
Fe—Mg has a narrow range for hornblende-hypersthene pairs and a much broader
range for hornblende-clinopyroxene pairs. The value for the hornblende-ortho-
pyroxene pair in SI 104b is 0-97; and those for hornblende—clinopyroxene are 1-65
(SI 283), 1-62 (SI 297b), and 1-72 (SI 104b), all belonging to the garnet granulites
and falling within the range shown by Swedish charnockites (Saxena & Hollander,
1969) and W. Bengal granulites (Sen & Manna, 1976) but distinctly lower than
those of the Quairading granulites (Davidson, 1971). The values for the
hornblende-clinopyroxene pairs are more similar to those of orthopyroxene
eclogites formed in the transitional granulite facies of Colton, U.S.A., than to those
from other types (Lappin & Smith, 1978).
Hornblende-garnet pairs. The KD Fe-Mg values for these pairs (0-22 in SI 283;
0-27 in 289; 0-34 in 291; 0-25 in 297b; and 0-33 in SI 104b) in granulites cover
the same range as in the Halmstadt charnockites, whereas those from Varberg have
a greater range (Saxena & Hollander, 1969). Rao & Satyanarayana (1971) have
reported distinctly higher values for the amphibolite pairs in Mysore, India.
THE JIJAL COMPLEX, PAKISTAN 115
It is worth noting that mineral pairs other than pyroxenes are considered to be
more strongly influenced by the composition of the phases in question, especially
Al (particularly Aliv) in hornblende, Fe 3+ in clinopyroxene and Mn and/or Ca in
garnet (Kretz, 1960; Saxena & Hollander, 1969; Davidson, 1971). However, the
extent of the influence of these constituents over KD is not fully understood.
Garnet-clinopyroxene pairs. Partitioning of elements during the gabbro-eclogite
transition is commonly considered to be sensitive to temperature and pressure
(Loomis, 1977). Variation in KD Fe2+—Mg between co-existing garnet and
clinopyroxene is thought to be mainly in response to T, the influence of P and
temperature estimates range from 650 to 800 °C. (The temperature values given by
Ca in the Gar-Cpx method are not always realistic; Perchuk, 1968.) Dobretsov et
al. (1975) have criticized the garnet-amphibole and clinopyroxene-amphibole
geothermometers of Perchuk, but in the present case they yield consistent results.
Of particular interest is the rather narrow range of temperature estimates (at an
assumed pressure of 12 kb) given by the method of Raheim & Green (1975). Wood
(1977) has shown that this latter method is applicable to most natural rock
TABLE 8
assemblages, and in the case of the South Harris granulites (considered by Wood
to have formed at 825 °C, 13 kb) gave results that are in excellent agreement with
those derived from a number of other methods; see also Saxena (1979).
The estimated 12 kb of pressure seems reasonable. Based on the diagram of
Raheim & Green (1975), minimum estimated pressures for the plagioclase-free
granulites are about 12 kb for 270, 283 and 297b, 13 kb for 104b, and 14 kb for
292 and 32OE. Similarly maximum pressures for the plagioclase-bearing granulites
(290 and 338) could not have been more than 13-5 kb. One of the plagioclase-free
garnet-clinopyroxene rocks of Jijal (SI 299, Table 1) is chemically similar to the
garnet pyroxenite (R 392) experimentally investigated by Irving (1974; table 6).
For SI 299 rock, a pressure of 12 kb at 750 °C is sufficient for the formation of a
plagioclase-free garnet-clinopyroxene assemblage.
THE JIJAL COMPLEX, PAKISTAN 117
Ca
which it passed. The abundance of the hornblende rocks, and epidote, in the
southern marginal part of the granulites lends some support to this idea, whereas
the mixtures of hornblende patches, garnetites, and plagioclase-granulites may in
part be due to severe structural disturbances. The chemical nature of the
hornblende rocks, characterized by a high Na/K ratio like the rest of the granulites,
may also be an indication that the fluids had an internal origin. Less likely, during
their upward transport the granulites were completely recrystallized locally under
high PHJ0 (water being of an external origin), such that the assemblages with
hornblende and epidote are not isofacial with the rest.
The Jijal granulites were called hornblende eclogite by Desio (1974). However,
evidence presented above, including the sections on garnets and clinopyroxenes,
and the abnormally large extent of the Jijal rocks, do not favour this view.
The ultramafic rocks. Temperature estimates for the ultramafic rocks are based
on a limited number of mineral analyses, i.e. chromite, olivine and two pyroxenes
from sample 275, two pyroxenes from 295, and the clinopyroxene from 272
(coexisting stably with enstatite which has not been analysed). Because of the
highly magnesian nature of the pyroxenes, experimental data on Ca-Mg pyroxene
solid solution can be applied to them. The results of the various geothermometers
are given in Table 9.
The plot of Fe 2+ /Mg for the olivine—clinopyroxene pair from 275 falls slightly on
the lower temperature side of the curve for chondrites considered to have
recrystallized at about 800 °C (Medaris, 1972). On O'Hara's (1967) grid, 295 and
275 give different T-P values and the pressures are so high that the rocks fall in the
field of garnet peridotites. Pressure estimates using A12O3 (Mori & Green, 1976)
and Ca/(Ca + Mg) (Mysen, 1976) in orthopyroxene in 275 and 295 range from 10
to more than 20 kb. Mysen & Boettcher (1975) found that the Cr-Al vi distribution
THE JIJAL COMPLEX, PAKISTAN 119
TABLE 9
Temperature estimates (°C)for the ultramafic rocks
; 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
275 974° 850° 900° 910° 930° 900° 800° 900° 600°
272 900° 890° 910° 900° 800°
295 971° 835° 875° 870° 890° 900° 800°
Based on:
to represent the northern boundary of the Indian plate, onto which the Jijal
complex was obducted as the bottom of the island arc (see, for example, Tahirkheli
etai, 1979).
The granulites are characterized by an abundance of garnet and can be classified
into plagioclase-bearing (basic to intermediate) and plagioclase-free (ultrabasic to
basic) types. Out of the 17 assemblages identified, plagioclase + garnet +
clinopyroxene + quartz + rutile is the most abundant; it may be joined by
hornblende and/or epidote, in some to the exclusion of the clinopyroxene. The
plagioclase-free granulites are less abundant and are represented by rocks rich to
necessary water being provided internally when most of the granulites were being
dehydrated. However, much, possibly all, of the epidote in the epidote-rich rocks
may be of retrograde origin.
The Jijal granulites are poor in K, Rb, Ni, and Cr. Although some K, Rb, (? and
Na) may have been expelled to upper levels of the Earth's crust during
metamorphism, the magma may well have been depleted in the four elements. The
Jijal rocks have analogues in the calc-alkaline series but their Na/K ratios are
closer to those of oceanic tholeiites (Engel et al., 1965; Bryan et al., 1976) than to
other volcanic rocks. They may have been derived from a tholeiitic magma of
suboceanic crust/upper mantle slab, mantle diapirs emplaced into deep orogenic
roots, or dismembered ultramafic rocks differentiated from a basaltic magma. The
T—P estimates for their final equilibration suggest an oceanic or suboceanic rather
than continental thermal regime. The complexity of the origin of alpine peridotites
has been illustrated by Wyllie (1967, 1969). Like most other alpine peridotites
(Den Tex, 1969), the Jijal ultramafic rocks have a complex history. One of the
earlier events in their evolution is possibly recorded by the closure of their
pyroxenes to the redistribution of Cr (? and other trivalent cations) at temperatures
greater than 1100 °C. Amongst the latest events is their low grade and selective
COLEMAN, R. G., 1971. Plate tectonic emplacement of upper mantle peridotites along continental edges. J.
geophys.Res. 76, 1212-22.
1972. Blueschist metamorphism and plate tectonics. 24th Int. geol. Congr. 2, 19-26.
& KEITH, T. E., 1971. A chemical study of serpentinization—Burro Mountain, California. J. Petrology,
12,311-28.
LEE, D. E., BEATTY, L. B., & BRANNOCK, W. W., 1965. Eclogites and eclogites: their differences and
similarities. Bull. geol. Soc. Am. 76, 483-508.
DAVIDSON, L. R., 1968. Variations in ferrous iron-magnesium distribution coefficients of metamorphic
pyroxenes from Quairading, Western Australia. Contr. Miner. Petrol. 19, 239-59.
1971. Metamorphic hornblendes from basic granulites of Quairading district, Western Australia. Neues
Jb. Miner. Mh. 344-59.
DAVIS, B. C. T., & BOYD, F. R., 1966. The join Mg2Si2O6-CaMgSi2O6 at 30 kilobars pressure and its
Hsu, L. C , 1968. Selected phase relations in the system Al-Mn-Fe-Si-O-H: a model for garnet equilibria. J.
Petrology, 9,40-83.
IL'VITSKIY, M. I., & KOLBANTSEV, R. V., 1968. Paragenetic types of olivine and statistical analysis of their
chemistry. Dokl. Acad. Sci. USSR, Earth Sci. Sec. 179, 135-7.
IRVINE, T. N., 1967. Chromium spinel as a petrogenetic indicator. Part 2. Petrologic applications. Can. J.
Earth Sci. 4, 71-103.
IRVING, A. J., 1974. Geochemical and high pressure experimental studies of garnet pyroxenite and pyroxene
granulite xenoliths from the Delegate basaltic pipes, Australia. / . Petrology, 15, 1-40.
JACKSON, E. D., & THAYER, T. P., 1972. Some criteria for distinguishing stratiform, concentric and alpine
peridotite-gabbro complexes. 24th Int. geol. Congr. 2, 289-96.
JAN, M. Q., 1977. The mineralogy, geochemistry, and petrology of Swat Kohistan, NW Pakistan. Unpublished
SUBRAMANIAM, A. P., 1962. Pyroxenes and garnets from charnockites and associated granulites. In: ENGEL,
A. E. J. el al. (eds.), Petrologic Studies. A volume in honor of A. F. Buddington. Geological Society of
America, 21-36.
SWEATMAN, T. R., & LONG, J. V. P., 1969. Quantitative electron-probe microanalysis of rock-forming
minerals. J. Petrology, 10,332-79.
TAHIRKHELI, R. A. K., MATTAUER, M., PROUST, F., & TAPPONNIER, P., 1979. The India Eurasia suture zone
in northern Pakistan: synthesis and interpretation of recent data at plate scale. In: FARAH, A., & D E
JONG, K. A. (eds.), Geodynamics of Pakistan. Quetta: Geological Survey of Pakistan, 125-30.
THAYER, T. P., 1960. Some critical differences between alpine-type and stratiform peridotite-gabbro
complexes. 21st Int. geol. Congr. 13, 247-59.
1967. Chemical and structural relations of ultramafic and feldspathic rocks in alpine intrusive complexes.
In: WYLLIE, P. J. (ed.), Ultramafic and Related Rocks. New York: Wiley, 222-39.