Ceramic - Optical 5
Ceramic - Optical 5
Ceramic - Optical 5
http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/0103-6440201300180
The tested null hypothesis was that ceramic type and the Preparation of Resin Cement Samples through
type of resin cement would have no significant influence Ceramic Discs
on the mechanical properties of the resin cements. Three dual-cured (Allcem, Variolink II and RelyX U200)
and one chemically-cured (Multilink) resin cements were
Material and Methods selected for this study. All resin cements information is
Preparation of Ceramic Discs summarized in Table 1. The resin cements were manipulated
Three all-ceramic materials were selected for this study: as recommended by manufacturers and inserted into vinyl
feldspathic glass-ceramic (Noritake EX 3; Kuraray, Miyoshi, molds (1 mm thick x 2 mm inner diameter x 10 mm outer
Chugoku, Japan); low translucency lithium disilicate glass- diameter). Mylar strips (Quimidrol; Joinville, SC, Brazil) were
ceramic (IPS e-max Press LT; Ivoclar Vivadent, Schaan, used on the bottom and top surfaces of the sample to ensure
Liechtenstein) and polycrystalline zirconia ceramic (Lava smooth surfaces, allow the ceramic disc placement over the
All-Ceramic System; 3M ESPE, Seefeld, Bavaria, Germany). sample and avoid inhibition of polymerization by oxygen
For the last one, a feldspathic ceramic (Noritake EX 3) was (12). The cements were mixed in controlled temperature
applied over the core made from zirconia ceramic. For the 23(±1) °C and 40% relative humidity. The ceramic discs
feldspathic glass-ceramic, a machined metal pattern was were placed over the resin cement samples assisted with a
duplicated with silicon (Aerojet; São Paulo, SP, Brazil) and teflon positioning ring and waited five minutes for chemical
used to manufacture the feldspathic ceramic disc. The setting of the cements (13). The samples were shielded
feldspathic ceramic was sintered (Alumini Press II; EDG, from room light by positioning a dark compartment over
São Carlos, SP, Brazil) according to the manufacturer’s the samples, during the five minutes of chemical setting.
instructions. IPS e-max Press ceramic discs were prepared The light curing was performed for the dual-cured resin
by the heat-pressing technique in specific furnace (Ivoclar cements through the ceramic discs for 40 s on the top and
The samples were embedded in polyester resin The mean DC values and standard deviations according
(Instrumental; São Paulo, SP, Brazil). Prior to testing, the to the ceramic type and resin cement type are shown in Table
surfaces were finished with 600, 800, 1200 and 2000- 3. The factor resin cement type (p=0.001) was significant
grit silicon-carbide papers sizes (Norton; Campinas, SP, for DC. The factors ceramic type (p=0.703) and interaction
Brazil) and polished with metallographic diamond pastes between the study (p=0.056) were not significant. Tukey
with 6-, 3-, 1-, and ¼ µm- sizes (Arotec; São Paulo, SP,
Brazil) (16). Cement samples were ultrasonically cleaned
(Cristofoli; Campo Mourão, PR, Brazil) for 10 min. VH Table 2. Energy density values (mW/cm2) measured through different
measurements were performed on the top surface of resin types of ceramic discs
cement using micro-hardness dynamic indenter (Micro % of delivered
Ceramic type Energy density
Indentation Tester; CSM, Peseux, Switzerland). The test energy
load was increased and decreased at a constant speed Feldspathic 142 21.8
between 0 and 500 mN. The force increased from 0 to Lithium disilicate 135 20.8
500 mN in 20 s intervals, applied constantly for 5 s. Then
Zirconia + feldspathic 75 11.5
the force was gradually removed from 500 mN to 0 mN
in 20 s intervals. The load and the penetration
depth of the indenter were continuously
Table 3. Mean values and standard deviations of DC (%) for the experimental groups
measured while loading-unloading the force.
Five measurements were performed for each Ceramic
Resin Pooled
resin cement sample and the mean value was cement Lithium Zirconia + Control Average
Feldspathic
established as the Vickers hardness number disilicate Feldspathic
(VHN) for statistical analysis (n=5). Allcem 87.7 (0.8) 87.9 (1.2) 87.5 (1.5) 85.7 (2.2) 87.2 (1.4) A
From a multiplicity of measurements
Variolink II 68.1 (1.8) 60.5 (7.5) 63.0 (5.9) 66.6 (4.7) 64.5 (4.9) C
stored in a database supplied by the
RelyX U200 70.3 (2.8) 70.8 (5.6) 70.6 (2.9) 66.3 (3.6) 69.5 (3.7) B
manufacturer, a conversion factor between
hardness and VHN was calculated and Multilink 57.8 (4.1) 60.9 (2.2) 56.7 (7.9) 61.3 (3.6) 59.1 (4.4) D
introduced into the software, so that the * For pooled average, different letters represent statistically significant differences
measurements were expressed in Vickers (2-way ANOVA/Tukey, p<0.05).
486
Braz Dent J 26(5) 2015
HDS showed differences among resin cements; chemically- similar values for E and significantly higher values than
cured resin cement exhibited the lowest values for DC. the chemically-cured resin cement.
the light activation of cements resulted in an energy loss resistance, and color stability should be taken into account
from light-curing unit varying from 11 to 22%. However, because they will also determine the clinical performance
this loss of energy did not result in reduction of DC of the material (25). Future research should consider the
irrespective the evaluated dual-cured cement (Table 2). polymerization of resin cements as function of time and
The increased time of light-curing (120 s) may help to ceramic thickness.
compensate the reduction of energy density, explaining
the outcomes. Therefore, when dual-cured cement is light- Resumo
cured through a ceramic system, extending light-curing O objetivo deste estudo foi mensurar grau de conversão (GC), microdureza
time accordingly may still be necessary to achieve optimal Vickers (VH) e módulo de elasticidade (E) de cimentos resinosos
polimerizados através de diferentes sistemas cerâmicos. Um disco de
polymerization (22). Furthermore, the 5 min of delay before 1,5 mm de espessura de cada sistema cerâmico (cerâmica feldspática,
the light-activation allows effective chemically activated dissilicato de lítio e zircônia coberto por cerâmica feldspática) foi utilizado.
polymerization (13). Três cimentos resinosos duais (Allcem, Variolink II e RelyX U200) e um
cimento resinoso quimicamente ativado (Multilink) foram ativados através
Among the dual-cured cements, Allcem showed the dos discos de cerâmica. Para os cimentos resinosos duais foi utilizado um
highest values and Variolink II the lowest one, irrespective the aparelho de lâmpada halógena (Optilux 501 a 650 mW/cm2 por 120 s).
conditions of light activation. Differences in composition, Amostras polimerizadas sem a interposição do disco de cerâmica foram
utilizadas como controle. As amostras foram armazenadas a 37 °C durante
including amount of chemicals and photo-initiators, 24 h. ATR/FTIR foi utilizado para avaliar a extensão da polimerização nas
monomeric composition, ratio of diluent monomers and amostras (n=5). Propriedades micromecânicas - VH e E – dos cimentos
filler content can explain the results. However, considering resinosos (n=5) foram medidas com um teste dinâmico de indentação. Os
dados foram analisados através de análise de variância a dois fatores, teste
that the exact concentration of each cement component is de Tukey e correlação de Pearson (α=0,05). O GC foi afetado somente
not provided by manufacturer, explanations of DC results pelo tipo de cimento resinoso (p=0,001). Para VH, houve interação entre
based on composition are speculative. It is important to o tipo de cimento resinoso e o tipo de cerâmica (p=0,045). Os cimentos
resinosos duais não apresentaram diferenças significativas nos valores
emphasize that differences of DC between resin cements do médios de E e valores significativamente maiores que o cimento resinoso
not necessarily indicate similar behavior when mechanical quimicamente ativado. O grau de conversão e as propriedades mecânicas
dos cimentos resinosos avaliados dependem do seu modo de ativação e
C.C.A. Lopes et al.
and current practice. Aust Dent J 2011;56:84-96. to methodology. J Mater Res 2004;19:3-20.
12. Bueno AL, Arrais CA, Jorge AC, Reis AF, Amaral CM. Light-activation 20. Urabe H, Nomura Y, Shirai K, Yoshioka M, Shintani H. Influence of
through indirect ceramic restorations: does the overexposure polymerization initiator for base monomer on microwave curing of
compensate for the attenuation in light intensity during resin cement composite resin inlays. J Oral Rehabil 1999;26:442-446.
polymerization? J Appl Oral Sci 2011;19:22-27. 21. Chen YC, Ferracane JL, Prahl SA. Quantum yield of conversion of the
13. Faria-e-Silva AL, Moraes RR, Ogliari FA, Piva E, Martins LR. Panavia F: photoinitiator camphorquinone. Dent Mater 2007;23:655-664.
the role of the primer. J Oral Sci 2009;51:255-259. 22. Zhang X, Wang F. Hardness of resin cement cured under
14. Rueggeberg FA, Craig RG. Correlation of parameters used to different thickness of lithium disilicate-based ceramic. Chin Med J
estimate monomer conversion in a light-cured composite. J Dent Res 2011;124:3762-3767.
1988;67:932-937. 23. Wydra JW, Cramer NB, Stansbury JW, Bowman CN. The reciprocity
15. Rueggeberg FA, Hashinger DT, Fairhurst CW. Calibration of FTIR law concerning light dose relationships applied to BisGMA/TEGDMA
conversion analysis of contemporary dental resin composites. Dent photopolymers: theoretical analysis and experimental characterization.
Mater 1990;6:241-249. Dent Mater 2014;30:605-612.
16. Bicalho AA, Pereira RD, Zanatta RF, Franco SD, Tantbirojn D, Versluis 24. Yokoyama D, Shinya A, Gomi H, Vallittu PK, Shinya A. Effects of
A, et al.. Incremental filling technique and composite material--Part I: mechanical properties of adhesive resin cements on stress distribution
Cuspal deformation, bond strength, and physical properties. Oper Dent in fiber-reinforced composite adhesive fixed partial dentures. Dent
2014;39:E71-E82. Mater J 2012;31:189-196.
17. Flury S, Lussi A, Hickel R, Ilie N. Light curing through glass ceramics: 25. Lu H, Mehmood A, Chow A, Powers JM. Influence of polymerization
effect of curing mode on micromechanical properties of dual-curing mode on flexural properties of esthetic resin luting agents. J Prosthet
resin cements. Clin Oral Investig 2014;18:809-818. Dent 2005;94:549-554.
18. Wang L, D’Alpino PH, Lopes LG, Pereira JC. Mechanical properties of
dental restorative materials: relative contribution of laboratory tests.
J Appl Oral Sci 2003;11:162-167. Received April 1, 2015
19. Oliver WC, Pharr GM. Measurement of hardness and elastic modulus by Accepted July 7, 2015
instrumental indentation: Advances in understanding and refinements
489