CTE 231 Transport Engineering Full Notes
CTE 231 Transport Engineering Full Notes
CTE 231 Transport Engineering Full Notes
TRANSPORTATION
ENGINEERING II
CTE 231
5. Name the factors that will influence one's choice of mode for personal travel or
freight transportation.
6. Discuss six (6) factors governing route location in the Transportation Planning
process for rail.
10. Name the physical requirements that have to be met such that an airport can
be constructed.
11. Name the important aspects in the planning of access and link roads around
an airport.
12. Distinguish between general cargo ships and bulk carriers by listing examples
of each and discussing the operational function of each type.
13. Describe the function of each of the three main components of a petroleum
pipeline.
15. List the steps required in the design of a slurry pipeline and give, in each case,
the importance of each.
16. Discuss the effect that the abrasive nature of slurries has on pipes.
17. Name the factors on which the demand for transport is based.
18. Discuss the five (5) basic steps in the forecasting process of urban travel.
CHAPTER 1
TRANSPORTATION PLANNING
Definition
Transportation planning is the creation of an infrastructure for the movement of
people and goods such that the fundamental goals of opportunity, accessibility and
efficiency is realised.
The process by which decisions are made is called policy planning, and consists
firstly of the allocation of resources (human, materials, energy). Secondly, it is
arranged as to who does what (amalgamation, deregulation). Lastly, because of the
strong mutual interaction between systems and operations, the influence that a
decision has on another sector must be recognised. (The economy, land use,
population, natural resources, etc).
TRANSPORT PLANNING PROCESS
SOCIO-ECONOMICAL REGION
PROBLEM DEFINITION
DEVELOPEMENT OF SOLUTIONS
ROUTE LOCATION
BASIC PLANNING
DETAIL PLANNING
SOLUTION ANALYSIS
OPTIONS EVALUATION
RECOMMENDATIONS
IMPLEMENTATION
The following illustrates the type of transportation service rendered by the facility
Figure 1.1: Modes classified by fixed-facility type, vehicle type, and by type of service rendered
Automobiles
Passengers
Highway Buses
Trucks Freight
Rail lines
Commercial air
passenger planes
Passengers
Airports
General airplanes
Freight
Passengers
Pipelines Freight
.
These will be looked at individually to point out the characteristics (physical &
operational) that are needed in the planning, designing and developing of facilities and
procedures for the transportation of people and goods.
1. HIGHWAY TRANSPORTATION
The forces that must be overcome by motor vehicles are rolling, air,
grade, curve and inertial.
i) Rolling resistance results from the frictional slip between the tyres and the
road surface, as well as internal friction of mechanical moving parts. For
example, a modern car travelling at 100 Km/h on a freeway has a rolling
resistance of 14 kg/ton.
ii) Air resistance is composed of the direct effect of air in the pathway of the
vehicle. This force is calculated from
R = 0.011AV2
iii) Grade resistance equals the component of the vehicle's selfweight force
acting down the grade.
iv) Curve resistance is the force needed to deflect a vehicle along a curvilinear
path, and is a function of speed.
v) Inertial resistance is the force that must be overcome to change speed and
is a function of vehicle mass, calculated from the following:
Acceleration and deceleration capabilities are needed to establish the criteria for
geometric design (viz. sight distances), and traffic engineering principles (signal
cycle lengths, travel times, etc.).
d) Operating costs
In order for engineers to plan and design transportation facilities that are
compatible with economical vehicle operation the effect of road geometry and
traffic flow must be carefully analysed. The following vehicle operational costs are
identified:
i) Fuel and oil costs
ii) Wear and tear and maintenance costs
e) Vehicle dimensions
This has an influence on geometric design (turning circles, parking layouts, etc)
The main competition that rail transportation faces w.r.t. other modes is the
following:
i) Tariff rates and provisions
ii) Service (reliability, transit time)
iii) Historical loss and damage experience
iv) Freight loading and unloading costs
v) Dispatching / receiving facilities
Terminals form the heart of railroad operation, since all trains originate and
terminate at these.
i) Main terminals
A main terminal is a complex of main lines, secondary lines, a yard where trains are
put together or broken up, a receiving yard and a departure yard. Typically, these
terminals will be found in most cities.
The track structure is the most important fixed asset of a rail transport system. The
correct design, construction and maintenance thereof is of utmost importance to
ensure the operating availability of the network.
The student must familiarize him/herself with the following track structure-
terminology: Rail, fastening, sleeper, ballast, formation, gauge.
The function and operation of the track structure is to provide a permanent guide
track for rolling stock (railway vehicles)
A Typical track structure supporting a single axle has different forces that act upon
the track structure. These forces can be divided into:
RAIL: The interaction between the wheel and the rail is important for an even
movement of the rolling stock. Correct wheel and rail contact has an influence on
the self-driving principle of a fixed axle.
- Firstly it must provide a continuous and smooth guiding surface on which the
rolling stock can be guided.
- Secondly it must resist the necessary lateral forces of the wheel flanges to
provide the necessary “guidance” to the wheels
- Thirdly it must transfer the concentrated loads that are applied onto the rail by
the vehicles to the rail bearing surfaces of the sleepers.
- The fourth function of the rails is to serves as electric conductors for signalling
circuits. Each rail is a separate circuit that is coupled as soon as an axle moves
across it. This coupling ensures that no other trains are allowed in that section.
The placing of a railway line between major terminals or towns is based on the most
economical, feasible route that will:
i) Satisfy the needs of the user
ii) Satisfy the need of freight
Design standards
i) Design standards with regard to slopes, curves, etc must be determined for
each line.
ii) Spacing of stations must be done depending on population density.
The basic objective is the safe, convenient and economical transportation of people
and goods and the key elements of this system are airports, aircraft and the air
traffic control system. Air cargo is a selective service, generally used where an
emergency, the perishability of goods, or a high value / weight ratio dictates fast
movement.
Aircraft sizes and weights are crucial determinants in the design and construction of
runways, taxiways, aprons and terminal loading arrangements. In the early days of
flight aircraft size was often simply expressed in terms of wingspan. Although
wingspan remains important in the design of airport facilities, It is now equally
necessary to consider other characteristics such as nose-to-tail length, height,
wheelbase and gross mass. (e.g., a fully laden 747 has a mass of 250 tonnes which
equates to more than 18 tonnes per tyre).
In addition to the characteristics of larger, long haul aircraft airport designers must also
reckon increasingly with the characteristics of smaller, turbojet, turboprop, and
piston-powered short haul aircraft which may be used to serve somewhat smaller
communities and interests.
Pollution (air and noise) remains a constant cause for concern at major airports, even
with the vast improvement that latter day aircraft have over their predecessors in
this regard. Pollution actually stems from several sources in addition to aircraft
engine emissions: aircraft fueling operations, ground service equipment, heating
plants, highway traffic, etc. Of greatest concern are Hydrocarbons and Carbon
monoxide, which are highest at idling, and oxides of nitrogen which are greatest at high
power. Programs are continuing to reduce these emissions and design more
efficient jet engines. However, the aircraft noise problem has yet to be solved.
Despite this disadvantage, aircraft remain a highly efficient and safe means of
passenger transport.
In most of the world, there are two basic flight conditions: Visual Flight Rules (VFR)
and Instrument Flight Rules (IFR). VFR only need a flight plan if travel is between or
over control zones whereas all IFR flights must have an approved flight plan as to
route and altitude and these flights are then constantly monitored by radio and
radar. The continuous ground contact provided by flying IFR is an added safety
measure. Because of its nature, air traffic control is exceedingly complex and highly
skilled personnel with highly sophisticated equipment are used. As more aviation
users compete with less air space, technology (especially w.r.t. the use of
computers) have managed to improve on the safety margins that is required of the
system.
Runway layout is often governed by active prevailing winds and some major
runways are then even duplicated (running parallel) Taxiways and holding aprons
must combine with the runway and terminals in such a way that operation is smooth
and efficient. Conveyance of passengers to and from aircraft also needs specialist
attention.
People using an airport consist of travellers, visitors and employees, the latter two
sometimes more than the first. Traffic also shows a variation with time - not only
on a daily basis, but also on a seasonal basis. When planning an airport's public use
roads, the following is important:
i) Roads must be able to handle peak volumes
ii) The link between the external road and airport service road must be practical
and functional
iii) Roads next to the terminal building should accommodate stopped vehicles
iv) Access to runways and taxiways must be controlled
v) Privileged traffic must have private access
The two main parts of a ship are the hull and the machinery. The hull is divided into
holds, where the cargo is stored, sealed by hatch covers, and separated by decks.
The machinery is contained in the engine room and includes generators,
refrigeration and electrical equipment. Situated near the machinery will be the
bridge for navigation and accommodation for the crew.
a) General cargo ships
i) Break - bulk
These ships have derricks for loading and unloading cargo above the deck. Cargo
consists of individual units or packages.
ii) Container
Container ships are designed in a manner that optimizes space. These ships
have holds in the form of a series of specially designed cells where the containers
are placed. There will also be provision for the storage of containers on deck.
Above a certain size, container ships do not carry their own loading gear, so
loading and unloading can only be done at ports with the necessary cranes.
Informally known as "box boats," they carry the majority of the world's dry cargo,
meaning manufactured goods.
Pipelines are continuous flow systems of relatively high capacities that transport
gasses, liquids and slurries. A modern pipeline system consist of storage tanks,
pump stations, pipes and fittings, communications facilities and control centres.
a) Domestic pipelines
Water and sanitation supply and disposal is the most common use for pipeline
transportation. Both gravitational and pump systems are used in this mode of
transport and either rigid or flexible drainpipes are used according to the
material used in their manufacture and the final purpose of use. Most common
materials used in the domestic pipeline systems are:
i) Vitrified clay pipes (No longer used for new installations, but still used in
existing systems and replaced when need arises.
ii) Cast Iron pipes
iii) Pitch fibre (FC Fibre cement)
iv) uPVC
v) Concrete Pipes
b) Petroleum pipelines
This term reflect all pipes carrying crude oil and products such as petrol,
paraffin, liquefied gas, etc. There are three components of such a system,
namely:
i) Gathering systems
ii) Trunk line systems
iii) Refined product systems
Gathering systems collect and move crude oil from oil fields to storage tanks,
usually through 150cm dia. pipes. Trunk lines (mostly underground) deliver oil
from storage tanks or terminals (offshore or ports) to refining centres, or from
the production field to the export terminal. They are between 200mm and
1200mm dia. Refined product systems transport finished petroleum products
from refineries and seaports to market terminals, from where they are normally
moved to their final destination by trucks. The structure of a pipeline industry is
influenced by three economic factors:
i) Pipelines are capital intensive
ii) Pipelines are high risk investments
iii) Pipelines benefit from economy of scale.
Profile of a pipeline
Successful pipelines depend on maximum volume over a long term. Hence
knowledge of the chemical and physical composition of the crude is of great
importance, as well as the design, construction and maintenance of the pipeline
itself. Marine pipeline costs vary with size, depth and geology; they are
normally twice as expensive as onshore lines.
Disadvantages
They are capital intensive, inflexible and have minimum salvage value.
Thus the physical and chemical processing necessary to give the slurry the
necessary characteristics for hydraulic transportation must be determined.
Preparation normally involves both size reduction (crushing and grinding) and
liquid addition. At the delivery end (prior to utilization) there will be a need for
storage and recovering facilities.
In all systems, a balance has to be made between pump ability and dewatering
characteristics. If sizing is too fine, it will be easy to pump, but dewatering costs
may be high. If the size is too coarse, pumping costs will go up. Pipe choice will
depend on pressure, corrosiveness or how abrasive the slurry is. Dewatering is
mostly carried out by processes of screening (filtering) and/or centrifuge.
Mechanical considerations
Slurries are abrasive by their very nature. They sandblast when impacting at high
velocity; they are a grinding compound between moving mechanical parts; they
are a cutting tool when forced through a restriction; and they are sandpaper when
dragging along the bottom of a pipe. When laying out the system, the designer
must consider the following:
Provided velocities are kept in check and due consideration is given to wear and
maintenance, slurry pipelines remain a viable alternative form of transportation.
Many variables must be taken into account when determining or forecasting the
number of trips that will be generated by these two needs, like cost, transport
available, comfort, travelling time, socio-economic characteristics, etc.
The state or local authority would consider the following aspects during land use
planning:
a) Preservation of prime agricultural lands
b) Preservation of scenic areas
c) Coastal zone preservation
d) Preservation of historical buildings and sites
e) Making urban areas attractive, functional and economic
f) Eliminating urban decay
g) Preserving adequate park and open areas
2. Trip Generation Models
Trip generation models are used to estimate the total number of trips that originate
and terminate in each zone, by trip purpose. Trip purpose is the main influencing
factor of the number of trips as well as the choice of mode. Consideration is given
to size of household, income, car ownership, level of service, etc. Trip generation
estimates are especially useful to determine the adequacy of transport (like roads)
when a new facility is built (airport, shopping centre) or an existing one upgraded.
3. Trip Distribution
This step is an extension of the previous one. The aim is to establish the exact
origin and destination of trips between zones. These may be influenced by factors
like economy, distance, user's needs or preference.
4. Modal Split
The user's choice in the use of a particular mode is dependant upon such factors
as travel time, cost, comfort, distance, lack of alternative, etc. Important to note
when making forecasts, is that user's preference change with the passage of time
when greater levels of comfort and convenience are desirable. Traffic
characteristics also have a bearing on the choice of mode.
5. Traffic Assignment
This is the procedure for estimating the number of traffic units (persons, trips,
vehicles) that will use each individual portion of a transportation system network. It
therefore highlights the preferred route of each user. If more than one route
connects two zones, it is important to know which is the preferred one and why.
Mostly, users will make use of a particular road or facility based on cost and
travelling time, although other factors like availability, safety, comfort, etc will also
have an influence. The results of these studies are used in the expansion and
upgrading of existing networks as well as in the planning of new facilities which
relates to the particular vehicle that the user prefers.
1. Define:
i) Traffic engineering
ii) Level of service
2. Describe the effect that the nature and intensity of traffic has on operation.
3. Distinguish between manual and automatic methods of vehicle counting and list
the advantages and disadvantages of each.
4. Discuss the purpose of 0-D surveys and describe the methods of conducting O-
D surveys.
5. Distinguish between the quantities ADT, AADT and DHV stating clearly what
each is derived from and the function each serve.
6. List the applications of traffic volume studies.
7. Distinguish between basic capacity, possible capacity and design capacity.
8. Discuss the two basic elements that affect capacity.
9. Show graphically the relationship between flow, speed and density.
10. Distinguish between mean journey speed, mean running speed and spot speed
and give the main use of each.
11. Discuss two types of delays in traffic studies.
12. Distinguish between short and long term parking.
13. Distinguish between on - street and off-street parking.
14. Discuss the characteristics of surface parking and parking garages that are
important design considerations.
15. Discuss the parking regulations that affect public parking.
16. Discuss the factors that affect traffic safety.
17. Name the uses of data collected from traffic accident studies.
18. Discuss solution studies of traffic safety.
19. Distinguish between three functional classes of traffic signs.
20. Describe the aims of signal control.
2.1. Definition
Traffic engineering is that phase of engineering which deals with the planning and
geometric design of streets, highways and abutting lands, and traffic operation
thereon, as their use is related to the safe, convenient and economic transportation
of persons and goods.
2.2. Traffic Volume Surveys/Studies
Before any road scheme is contemplated a traffic survey of some kind or other
should be carried out to gather information regarding the nature and intensity of
the traffic expected.
This survey provides the data on which the proposed road lay-out can be based,
and failure to obtain this information may result in the inability of the road to
handle the volume of traffic.
2.2.1. Nature and Extent of Traffic Surveys
In many instances it is sufficient if the survey is confined to a study of traffic
volumes. On other occasions however these volume studies have to be
supplemented by information concerning such topics as vehicle speeds,
journey times, delay studies at intersections, parking studies, pedestrian
movements and various aspects of vehicle performance.
2.3. Volume Surveys
(a) Type of volume surveys
The type of volume survey required depends on the extent of the new
construction or improvement proposed and its location with respect to similar roads
in the area.
In rural areas, for example in the case of a small scheme such as the
reconstruction of a short length of the existing alignment, the anticipated volume of
traffic along the new section could be determined safely by counting the traffic
using the existing road and allowing for the normal growth of traffic over the design
period.
On the other hand, if the scheme involves an entirely new road, then it is likely
that traffic would be drawn from other roads in the area and the traffic survey
must then embrace all these alternative routes. Even for some improvement
works of existing roads in urban areas the result can be a considerable
redistribution of the traffic pattern and in these circumstances, the survey would
normally take the form of an origin-and-destination survey (O - D).
It is thus practice to select a unit, called the equivalent vehicular unit (e.v.u.), and
to express all traffic in terms of this unit by the use of appropriate multiplying
factors. For the structural design of national roads in S.A., for example, the unit
employed in TRH4 is a single axle of 80KN.(E80’s)
(c) Volume Counts
The volume of traffic using a section of road can be measured by counting the
vehicles passing a fixed point. Counting may be carried out manually or by
automatic means.
In the manual method the passing of a vehicle is recorded on a specially prepared
form, the vehicles being simultaneously classified into a number of pre-determined
groups. On account of the labour involved the period of counting is generally
limited to a few days, preferably over 7 consecutive days. Since traffic flows vary
from one month to another, the count should be taken at the busiest time of the
year or else the figure should be adjusted to take account of this seasonal
fluctuation.
(iv) Difficulties may occur in finding suitable sites for the equipment to prevent
willful and deliberate damage.
The O-D survey obtains information concerning the place of origin and
destination of each journey and the location of any intended intermediate stops
within the survey area. The origin of the journey is in this instance the last fixed
point of call before entering the area covered by the survey, and the destination is
the next point of call after leaving the area.
Survey stations must be established on all the main roads entering and leaving
the area concerned. There are a number of basic methods by which the required
information may be obtained:
(i) Roadside interview - vehicles are stopped and drivers are questioned as to
the O and D of the journey and the location of proposed intermediate stops.
This is entered on a card, also noting the time of day, the direction of travel,
the type of vehicle and the number of passengers. When the traffic flow is
heavy some kind of sampling procedure is used to avoid long delays.
(ii) Prepaid Postcards - to reduce the delay in the previous method each driver is
handed a prepaid postcard suitably numbered to indicate the survey station
and the approximate time of day, as he enters the survey area. On this the
driver is requested to answer questions similar to those asked by the
interviewer and to return the card by post. In practice this method often
results in a poor response.
(iii) Coloured tags on Vehicles - At the incoming survey station a tag of distinctive
colour is stuck on the windscreen of the vehicle, a different colour and shape
being used at each point. Observers at the outgoing survey stations note the
colour designation for each vehicle leaving the area.
The A.D.T. is not suitable for direct use in the geometric design of the road
because it does not indicate how the volume of traffic is distributed over the
24-hour period. The A.D.T. is important for purposes such as determining
the total annual usage of the road as justification for the proposed
expenditure, and for the design of the structural elements.
Because of the fact that traffic patterns show great variation in hourly
volumes throughout the day and also throughout the year, it must be
determined which of these should be used in design. In the U.K., for
example, it is usually the maximum hours flow during a seven day August
traffic census.
In South Africa………./
24
20
(% of A.A.D.T.)
Hourly volume
16
12
0
20 40 60 80 100 120 140
Number of hours in year with traffic volume greater than that shown
Figure 2.1
Experience has shown that the D.H.V. is usually between 12 and 18% of the
A.A.D.T. and a figure of 15% is normally adopted unless shown to be different by
actual counting.
2.5. Capacity of the Road
Capacity is the ability of the road to carry traffic under given circumstances.
It is defined as the maximum number of vehicles which have a reasonable
expectation of passing a given point per hour. A publication called
"Highway Capacity Manual"(which is based on data collected throughout the
U.S.A.), distinguishes between the following:
(a) Basic capacity - maximum number of P.C.U.'s that can pass a given point
per hour under the most ideal roadway and traffic conditions. This can only
be achieved in the following ideal conditions:
i) two lanes in each direction
ii) all vehicles move at the same speed
iii) there are practically no commercial vehicles
iv) there are no geometric restrictions like inadequate sight distances.
A freeway having 4 lanes or more will meet the above criteria and a suggested value
of 2000 P.C.U.'s per lane per hour can be achieved on this type of facility.
When roadway and traffic conditions are ideal, the possible capacity is the same
as the basic capacity. However, conditions are rarely ideal; the possible capacity
is defined as the maximum number of P.C.U.’s that can pass a given point
during one hour under prevailing roadway and traffic conditions.
This is the maximum number of vehicles that can pass a given point during one
hour under specified conditions without increasing the traffic density (the number
of number vehicles per kilometer at any instant) to such an extent that undue
accumulation, delay, danger and other limitations are created.
The factors affecting capacity can be considered under two headings namely:
(a) The prevailing road conditions
(b) The prevailing traffic conditions
HOW DO THESE PREVAILING ROAD AND TRAFFIC CONDITIONS AFFECT THE ROAD
CAPACITY:
B E
C F
The following figure 2.3 shows the relationship between speed and volume. (Volume is
defined as the number of vehicles per hour).
From this figure the following very basic features relating to traffic movement are
identified:
(i) The portion ABCD called the zone of normal conditions represents the situation
where free driving occurs. If a single vehicle for example, travels along a traffic
lane, the driver is free to travel at the design speed and he is subjected only to
speed limit restrictions. This situation is represented at the upper left end of the
figure at approximately 110 Km/h.
As the number of vehicles in the lane increases, the driver's freedom to select
speed is restricted by the other vehicles, resulting in a progressive reduction in
speed.
The higher the standard of geometric design, the more free are the driving
conditions and the flatter the curve ABCD.
(ii) The portion F is called the zone of conditions within which the average speeds are
much lower and the vehicles move under conditions of forced driving. A decrease
(iii) The Portion E called the zone of unstable conditions. In this zone flows are very
high but the driving conditions are very unstable i.e. it is possible for vehicles to be
moving freely and then, under the influence of some restricting factor, the flow
volume will decrease substantially and may even stop. Within this zone traffic
conditions seldom remain sufficiently stable to obtain reliable survey figures during
measurement of traffic flows which is why the ultimate capacity (E) is not chosen for
design, but rather some point about C.
Traffic stream flow is defined in terms of its three (3) variables and this
relationship is expressed as follows:
flow = density x speed
2
3
There are three distinct types of speeds that will describe the rate of movement of
traffic on roads.
1) Mean journey speed
2) Mean running speed
3) Instantaneous or spot speed
This type of speed can be measured by noting the time of passing of vehicles at
two or more points on the route either by recording registration numbers or putting
stickers on the windscreens.
Various methods are used to determine spot speed checks. Direct-timing using
two reference points on the road and timing the vehicle passing the one to the
other by means of stopwatches. Other means are: pressure-contact strips, radar
speedmeter, time lanse camera, etc.
Delay studies are carried out in conjunction with studies determining running and
journey speeds. They are of considerable value to the planner as it enables him
to pinpoint locations where conditions are unsatisfactory as well as determining
the reasons for and extent of the delays. The information can be used to indicate
the urgency or need for improvement and the extent to which the improvement
should, be carried out.
Types of Delays
Methods of Measurement
The moving observer method is used in determining the cause and extent of delay.
Before starting the experiment a survey of the route is made and a journey log is
prepared. A test vehicle moves along the route and all locations, stopping times,
starting times, are noted. By analysing the log it is easy to pinpoint the locations and
extent of delays. This method however does not always provide sufficient information
by itself on which remedial action can be based.
General
There is also a distinction between short and long term parking. Short term parking is
generated by shops, banks, recreation centres, etc whilst long term parking is mostly
generated by places of employment.
Capacity on streets surrounding the parking facility should be adequate to handle the
additional generated traffic.
On-Street Parking
This term applies to the situation where part of the roadway is utilized for the purposes
of parking. Vehicles are accommodated next to the kerb line either in a parallel or
angled fashion. For angled parking, the effect that parked vehicles have on through
traffic must be considered, especially if roadway dimensions are limited.
Off-Street Parking
This term applies to the accommodation of vehicles in at-grade parking lots or parking
garages. The accessibility, circulating, parking, unparking and exiting are important
factors in both the location and design of these facilities.
i) Surface Parking
The following characteristics are important design considerations:
a) Site characteristics - the topography and profile will especially influence entry
and exit points.
b) Traffic circulation - access to and from parking bays must be consistent with the
orderly movement of traffic in and around the facility.
c) Lighting - considerations are positioning and intensity.
d) Parking dimensions and layout - governed by type of vehicle and available
space.
e) Handicapped parking - must be properly positioned and user only.
f) Drainage - stormwater considerations.
Conclusion
There are many more aspects of parking provision that need specialist
attention:
a) Special purpose and special event parking, like sport stadiums,
convention centres, museums, etc.
b) Change of mode facilities like airports, rail stations, bus stations, etc.
c) Shopping centres
d) Industrial sites
e) Universities and Technikons
f) Hospitals
Consideration must also be given to parking regulations where public parking is
concerned. These include matters like time allocation, cost, zoning, policing,
etc.
In general, traffic accidents are caused by failure of one of the elements of the system:
the driver, the vehicle or the roadway conditions. Of these, the driver is mostly at fault.
Solutions to traffic safety are based on the following actions:
Legislation - where laws governing the movement of traffic are laid down.
Regulation - where movement of traffic is controlled and traffic laws enforced.
Education - where the driver is made aware of the responsibilities of being a road
user.
Engineering - where safety is incorporated into the design and construction of
vehicles and roadways.
A new facility must be designed using all the existing data available together with
sound geometrical principles to ensure safe operation. Traffic engineers use data
from traffic accident studies in the following ways:
Since most accidents involve collisions, the problem areas which give rise to this
problem must be identified and the risk minimized. This involves study on aspects like
pedestrian - vehicle conflicts, vehicle - vehicle conflicts, shortfalls in geometry,
inadequate communications and roadside safety hazards.
As far as pedestrian - vehicle conflict is concerned, the solution is not easy. Traffic
engineers generally design a facility with the efficient movement of traffic foremost in
their minds. Suitably placed pedestrian crossings with adequate signal timing must be
provided, or consideration given to overpasses or underpasses for the accommodation
of pedestrians.
Many vehicle-vehicle conflicts can be removed with the construction of highway
interchanges, but this is a costly and often impractical solution. Intersections require
that they be well designed and controlled, but the voluntary obedience of the driver is a
major factor towards safety.
Sound geometrical - layouts is essential for the safe functioning of traffic, and
designers must adhere to design standards and specifications. Conflict points like at-
grade rail and road crossings must be avoided, and sight distances should be
adequate at all times.
Communication problems can be minimized through proper provision of signals, road
markings and controlling devices.
Roadside hazards must be recognized and timeously attended to. Filling potholes,
repairing guardrails, replacing illegible road signs are all basic activities in the interest
of safety.
Traffic signs
There are three functional classes:
1) Regulatory signs - used to impose legal restrictions like “NO LEFT TURN”.
2) Warning signs - used to call attention to hazardous conditions like “SHARP
BEND AHEAD”.
3) Guide or informational signs - used to provide directions “CITY LEFT LANE”,
route designations “CAPE TOWN 290 km” or points of interest, recreational
or cultural sites.
Signal control
When justified and properly designed, a traffic signal installation will achieve the
following:
1) Reduce accidents;
2) Effect orderly traffic movement;
3) Provide for continuous flow;
4) Allow other vehicles and pedestrians to cross main traffic streams,
5) Control traffic more economically.
Traffic signals are introduced when certain criteria demands it. These criteria are
called warrants. Some examples of warrants are: vehicular volume, interruptions of
continuous traffic, pedestrian volume, school crossings, progressive movement and
accident data.
General
Students must be familiar with the processes and techniques involved in:
a) the determination and application of super elevation.
b) the calculation of full setting out data for horizontal curves, with or without
transitions.
c) the setting out data for parabolic vertical curves .
d) the designing of the alignment of a road.
GEOMETRIC DESIGN
3.1. Definition
Geometric design is concerned with relating the visible physical elements of the
road, like alignment, gradients, sight distances, cross sectional elements and
intersection layouts, to the requirements of the driver and vehicle. As such it does
not include the structural design of the facility.
A sound geometric design will reduce the number and severity of accidents, while
ensuring a high traffic capacity with the minimum of delay to vehicles. Attention
must also be given to environmental and aesthetic aspects of the road. When
geometric design is improperly carried out it may result in early obsolescence of
the new road, with consequent economic loss.
This is the highest continuous speed that can be economically maintained with
safety when weather conditions are favourable, traffic density low and the design
features of the road are the governing conditions. It is a measure of the quality of
the road and has a direct effect on the design of vertical and horizontal curvature,
super-elevations, sight distances and gradients.
The choice of design speed is influenced mainly by the type of road, the
character of the terrain, traffic characteristics and economic considerations. On a
road carrying a large traffic volume for example a higher design speed is justified
compared to a less important road where the saving in traffic costs would not be
sufficient to offset the extra expenditures of high geometric design standards.
Except for mountain passes, the minimum length of a particular design speed
section shall not be less than 3.5 Km, preferably not less than 8Km. The change
in design speed should not be affected suddenly but over sufficient distance to
permit gradual change.
It is the length of carriageway which is visible to the driver. There are two
different types, namely:
(i) Stopping sight distance - which is the distance required to stop the vehicle
before striking an unexpected object on the carriage way (using an eye
height of 1.05m and an object height of 0,15m in the case of vertical
curves);
(ii) Passing sight distance - which is the distance required to overtake safely
and comfortably without interfering with the speed of the oncoming
vehicle which travels at design speed, (using an eye height of 1,05m
and an object height of 1,3m in the case of vertical curves)
It is based on the drivers perception and reaction time plus the distance required
by the vehicle to stop after application of the brakes. The perception and reaction
time is the number of seconds which elapses between the instant that the driver
sees the object and the instant that the brakes are applied. It obviously shows
considerable variation from one driver to another, but the following values are
recommended by AASTHO.
d1 = meters
t = seconds
d
2
L = d1 + d2
d1 d2 d3 d4
Sight distance is the major control for safe operation on a crest. The sight
distance should be as long as possible and above the minimum laid down
for the design speed, where-ever possible.
(a) Crests
See graph on next page
(b) Sags
The following criteria may determine the minimum curve length in the case
of sag curves:
Figure 3.2
Tangent length: T =
Chord length: GK =
Arc length: GHK =
Middle ordinate: M =
External distance: E =
Degree of curvature D =
The decree of curvature (D) is the central angle which subtends
a 100m arc of the curve.
If the chords do not exceed in length, then the length of the chord may be approximated to the
length of the corresponding arc.
___________2
Hence 1 and 2:
To convert the chord deflection angle to deg ( , min(‘) and sec (“), multiply by .
(i) Additional width is required on sharp curves because the rear wheels of
the vehicle follow a path of shorter radius than the front wheels,
especially in the case of commercial vehicles. Thus, in order to provide
the same clearance between opposing vehicles on curve sections as on
the straight sections, there must be an extra width of carriageway
available.
The amount of widening will depend on the lane width and the radius of the
curve. On modern highways with their high standards of design the need
for widening has lessened. For example, National Roads specify no
widening on a carriageway having a width of 7,4m or more. A standard
additional width of 0,6m is specified for 6,8m wide carriageway on curves
with radii less than 150m (C. P. A.).
(i) On simple circular curves the total widening is applied to the inside
edge.
(ii) Where transition curves are provided, widening may be placed on the
inside or divided equally between the inside and outside edges. If
either case the centre line marking should be placed in the middle.
CTE 231 Transportation Eng II Page 40 of 81
(iii) The extra width should be attained gradually. Where transition curves
are used widening is attained over the whole length of the transition,
and where there is no transition curve, widening is commenced at the
beginning of the application of superelevation and increased uniformly
to maximum value at full attainment of superelevation.
(iv) The edges of the road must form smooth and graceful curves.
Various forms of curves are used for this purpose, each having its own
special advantages. The most common of these are:
In practice there is little difference between the results obtained from them.
National Roads for example specify that transition curves be used on all
horizontal curves where R < 250m and all curves where e = >6%. They
further specify a minimum transition length of 30m (100m desirable).
Circular
Curve
Transition
Curve
1.
2.
4. Deflection angle
7.
Solution
1. = = 0.533
= 160.167m
= (500 x 27 x ) + 80
= 315.619m
4.
= 315.619-2(80)
= 155.619
Chainages:
PI 1,500.000 * Check
T.L. -160.167 BTC 1339.833
BTC 1,339.833 LT +315.619
LS -80.000 1655.452
BCC 1,419.833
LC /2 +77.810 OK
CP 1,497.643
LC /2 +77.810
ECC 1,575.453
LS +80.000
ETC 1,655.453 *
PI - - 00.00.00
1340 0.167 0.167 00.00.00
1350 10.000 10.167 00.01.29
1360 10.000 20.167 00.05.50
1370 10.000 30.167 00.13.02
1380 10.000 40.167 00.23.07
1390 10.000 50.167 00.36.03
1400 10.000 60.167 00.51.51
1410 10.000 70.167 01.10.31
BCC 1419.833 9.833 80.000 01.31.40
CHECK: = 3 (01.31.40)
= 04.35.00
Total deflection must be =
= 08.55.00 * OK
PI - - 360.00.00
Exercise
Calculate the full setting out data for the following curve:
If the road surface if flat, the entire centrifugal force must be counteracted by the
friction between the wheels and road surface. For this reason it is common practice
to incline the road, i.e .the road is said to be superelevated. For practical reasons
the superelevation (e) provided is not sufficient to counteract the entire centrifugal
force, so that there is still some friction on the tyres when travelling at design speed.
For practical design purposes, curves or tables are drawn up from which the
required superelevation rate is selected for a given design speed and curve
radius.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
SUPERELEVATION RATE %
Right-hand circular curve of radius 500m is introduced on a road of width 7,4m and
design speed 100 km/h. Use 30m intervals and take e= 9. Determine the levels of
the L.S and R.S. relative to the centre line when:
a) the normal cross fall of the road is 2% to the left,
b) the road is cambered at 2%.
c) the normal cross fall of the road is 2% to the right.
L.S
2%
B.C.C
7.4 m
CL
R.S
PLAN VIEW L.S
e%
R.S
CL
RUNOFF LENGTH L
L.S
2% 2%
B.C.C
7.4 m
L
C
R.S
PLAN VIEW L.S
e%
R.S
L
C
L
C
2%
B.C.C
7.4 m
CL
R.S
PLAN VIEW L.S
e%
R.S
CL
RUNOFF LENGTH L
SUPERELEVATION EXERCISES
1. From the given data, calculate the levels of the centre line, left and right hand sides of the road at
20m intervals. (Include all other points of importance).
Given:
Curve radius = 460m (Curve to the left )
Design speed = 120 km/h
Road width = 7,6m
Road class = II
Reduced level of BCC = 50,35m on Centre line
Longitudinal gradient = -4,2%
Chainage of BCC = 1250m
Initial road X-fall = 2.5% L – R
2. A right handed circular curve of radius 600m is introduced on a class I road of width 7.4m and a
design speed of 110 km/h. Provide the necessary superelevation and hence determine the levels of
the centre line, left and right hand sides of the road if the road is initially cambered at 2,25%. The
BCC chainage is at 400m and the reduced centre line level there is 155.45m. The road has a
longitudinal grade of +1.95 %. Produce levels at 20m intervals up to the chainage where full
superelevation is developed, including all other points of importance.
3. Use a superelevation of 8,45% and a runoff = 90m to provide levels to the Right , Centre and Left of
a 7,5m wide road with the following data:
Tabulate your results and produce levels at 15m intervals up to the point where full superelevation is
developed.
A vertical curve is superimposed on a horizontal curve, for which superelevation must be provided.
Use the information given below to prove that G2 = 2.43% and hence determine the full
superelevation setting out data for the road.
Given:
curve to the left
run-off length = 225m
e = 7,75%
initial cross fall = 2,3% L > R
road width = 7,35m
PIVC is at chainage 200m with G1 = -3,38%
PIVC level = 66,39m
Vertical curve length = 200m
BCC chainage = 240m
BCC level = 65,602
interval = 25m
[27]
Notes:
Example:
An upgrade of 2,54% meets a downgrade of 1,83% at chainage 400m, with the PIVC level = 1,586.32.
Calculate the setting out data at 20m intervals, for a curve length of 120m..
Solution:
BVC chainage = 400 - 60 = 340m
BVC elevation = 1586.32 - .0254 x 60 = 1584.796m
EVC chainage = 400 + 60 = 460m
EVC elevation = 1586.32 - .0183 x 60 = 1585.222m
It has been proved that the wider the median the greater the reduction in
serious head-on collisions, and the more effective the reduction in headlight
glare.
It need not be of constant width and can be varied in order to obtain a safe,
pleasing and economical design to fit the topography.
3.6.2 Shoulders
This is the portion, of roadway alongside the carriageway for:
1) Accommodation of stopped vehicles
2) Emergency use
3) For lateral support of the pavement layers and surface area
4) For increasing effective width of the road
5) For providing improved sight distance.
Shoulder widths on class l (C.P.A.) roads are to be 2,4m wide. An additional width
of 0,6m is then specified for rounding off and guard rails.
C.P.A. specifies: "A straight line cross fall from the crown shall be used as follows:
gravel surfaces 3%, bitumen surfaces 2%; concrete surfaces 1,25%
FORMATION WIDTH
SHOULDER ROUNDING
SHOULDER TRAVELLED WAY SHOULDER FORMATION LEVEL
LIMIT OF STABILITY
SURFACING
BASE
PAVEMENT
SUBBASE
SELECTED LAYER
TOP SOIL
FILL
SUBGRADE
ROADBED
CUT
Figure 3.5: A TYPICAL ROAD SECTION
The number of traffic lanes to be used depends on the volume and type of traffic
expected. C.P.A. for example states that: "A dual carriageway is warranted for
average present day counts in excess of 2000 e.v.u's per day."
The following widths are specified by C.P.A.(Cape Town Provincial Administration)
Useable Shoulder
Road Class evu's per day Carriageway width width
I 500 - 2000 7,4m 2,4m
II 150 - 500 6,8m 1,8m
The protection of slopes against erosion must receive attention. The policy on rural
roads in this respect is to establish, as far as possible, indigenous growth. Long
slopes are broken by introducing terraces (berms) to reduce water speed.
Flat fill slopes have the added advantage that they are visible from the
vehicle for their full extent so that the road takes on a safer appearance
and hence the effective width is increased.
Even though some soils will be self-supporting on very steep slopes, they
will erode badly, thus creating serious environmental problems. It is also
difficult to grow vegetation on them.
The foundation soil under a concrete sidewalk must be properly specified and
prepared. The following is a typical specification (used by NMBM)
Definitions (C. P. A. )
(a) Traffic Lane - it's the portion of the surfaced width, for the movement of a
single line of vehicles.
(d) Road Reserve - that area of land reserved for construction and maintenance of
the road, including areas for interchanges.
(f) Road-bed - the area extending from kerb line to kerb line or shoulder break-
point to shoulder break-point. Dual carriageway roads are considered to have
one road bed only.
(g) Verge - the area between the road reserve boundary and the road prism.
(h) Carriageway - the portion of the roadway for the movement of vehicles
exclusive of shoulders.
(i) Freeway - It is a road of high geometric design features, with two or more lanes
in each direction, for the accommodation of fast flowing traffic, without any at
grade intersections at right angles to it, and with velocity change lanes provided
so that traffic can enter or leave without interfering with the through-traffic.
Intersection - general area where two or more roads join or cross at-grade.
Speed change lane - an auxiliary lane, including tapered areas, primarily for the
acceleration or deceleration of vehicles entering or leaving the main traffic lanes.
Junction layout is a very important aspect of geometric design since the overall
capacity of any road network is limited by the capacity of its various intersections.
The aim of any junction layout is to provide for the safe movement of traffic without
undue delay. Various alternative layouts can be adopted and the ultimate choice will
be governed by:
3 -LEG INTERSECTIONS
FLARED CHANNELIZED
4-LEG INTERSECTIONS
Rotary intersection
A careful traffic count and estimate for the future, including data regarding each
turning movement, must precede the design of any important intersection. In
laying out intersections, characteristics of driver and vehicle and the possibility of
accidents must be kept in mind. Drivers should not be confronted with more than
one decision at a time.
One way
3. Drivers can be forced to merge into moving traffic at flat angles and proper
speeds, thus causing less disruption to traffic or decrease in capacity on the
main throughfare (See fig. b).
This is a special form of channelization. In this case vehicles are all forced in one
direction and the efficiency and capacity of the circle is a function of the individual
weaving lengths.
(ii) Fewer serious accidents because vehicles are forced to move in the same
direction, and
Disadvantages :
They do, however, require greater land area, and there is also an upper limit to the
traffic volume which a given circle can handle. This volume depends on the
weaving lengths, and as soon as this capacity is exceeded, the circle tends to
create chaos. The American "Policy on Design of Urban Highways" states that a
properly designed channelized intersection will usually operate better while costing
less.
Compared with at-grade intersections, they usually require large initial capital
layouts. The following are however examples of situations where this extra
expenditure is normally justified.
(iii) safety considerations - some at-grade intersections are accident prone due
to, for example, it’s location regardless of the traffic volume.
3.8.2. Layouts
Geometric design of interchanges involves selecting the layout best suited to the
particular situation, considering factors such as:
i) topography
(i) to provide grade separation between two or more traffic arteries, and
(ii) to enable the easy transfer of vehicles from one artery to the other, or
between local streets and the freeway.
The simplest, and generally least costly form of interchange is the diamond. It is
particularly useful to situations where a freeway crosses a non-freeway.
Probably the most common interchange where freeways intersect arterials is the
cloverleaf. There are, however, several serious objections to this kind of
interchange, among them the following:
(i) They require large areas of land where high design speeds are used.
(ii) Vehicles deserving to make a right turn must execute a 270 left turn, thus
travelling a substantially greater distance.
Diamond
Cloverleaf
Where one major freeway intersects another, it is normally justified to employ some
form of directional interchange. The basic concept here is that right-turning move-
ments are accommodated by a 90° turn to the right, as opposed to 270° to the left.
This also eliminates the weaving through opposing traffic encountered in a
cloverleaf type interchange.
The overall effectiveness of all interchanges are largely determined by the flow
characteristics of, and driver behaviour on, the on- and off-ramps. The deceleration
and acceleration lanes may be designed either as a taper or as an auxiliary lane
parallel to the main stream. In either case sufficient length must be provided to
permit the vehicle to accelerate and merge into the main stream without disrupting
it.
1. State, and briefly explain, the effect of four principles to be borne in mind
when locating a new route for a road.
2. Discuss the importance, execution and conclusion of each of the following:
a) Reconnaissance survey
b) Preliminary survey
c) Final location survey
Some of the elements tend to contradict one another - in practice the location is
selected which represents the best compromised solution.
(a) The road should be as direct as possible - the following are examples of
elements which will influence this principle:
The design should allow traffic to move at maximum speed (design speed)
and minimum cost e.g. long steep gradients having no additional climbing
lanes for slow moving heavy vehicles reduce capacity of the road and
although initial capital lay-out is lower it will lead to high traffic costs making
it uneconomic compared to road having higher capital layout.
(d) Planning
REGION A
B
D
END
END
TERMINAL G TERMINAL
C
F
(ii) Centre-line levelling - profile levels are taken along the centre at each
station and at all intermediate points where there is any significant
change in slope. There should also be B.M.’s within 50m of each
structure along the road.
(v) Ditches and streams - stream bed profiles are taken for some
distance on both sides.
(vi) Special site surveys - include special surveys for bridges and
intersections.