Diabetic Vascular Diseases: Molecular Mechanisms and Therapeutic Strategies
Diabetic Vascular Diseases: Molecular Mechanisms and Therapeutic Strategies
Diabetic Vascular Diseases: Molecular Mechanisms and Therapeutic Strategies
com/sigtrans
Vascular complications of diabetes pose a severe threat to human health. Prevention and treatment protocols based on a single
vascular complication are no longer suitable for the long-term management of patients with diabetes. Diabetic panvascular disease
(DPD) is a clinical syndrome in which vessels of various sizes, including macrovessels and microvessels in the cardiac, cerebral, renal,
ophthalmic, and peripheral systems of patients with diabetes, develop atherosclerosis as a common pathology. Pathological
manifestations of DPDs usually manifest macrovascular atherosclerosis, as well as microvascular endothelial function impairment,
basement membrane thickening, and microthrombosis. Cardiac, cerebral, and peripheral microangiopathy coexist with
microangiopathy, while renal and retinal are predominantly microangiopathic. The following associations exist between DPDs:
numerous similar molecular mechanisms, and risk-predictive relationships between diseases. Aggressive glycemic control
combined with early comprehensive vascular intervention is the key to prevention and treatment. In addition to the widely
recommended metformin, glucagon-like peptide-1 agonist, and sodium-glucose cotransporter-2 inhibitors, for the latest molecular
mechanisms, aldose reductase inhibitors, peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-γ agonizts, glucokinases agonizts,
1234567890();,:
mitochondrial energy modulators, etc. are under active development. DPDs are proposed for patients to obtain more systematic
clinical care requires a comprehensive diabetes care center focusing on panvascular diseases. This would leverage the advantages
of a cross-disciplinary approach to achieve better integration of the pathogenesis and therapeutic evidence. Such a strategy would
confer more clinical benefits to patients and promote the comprehensive development of DPD as a discipline.
1
National Clinical Research Center for Chinese Medicine Cardiology, Xiyuan Hospital, Chinese Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences, Beijing 100091, China; 2The Second
Department of Gerontology, Xiyuan Hospital, China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences, Beijing 100091, China; 3Department of Nephrology and Endocrinology, Wangjing
Hospital, China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences, Beijing 100102, China and 4China Center for Evidence-based Medicine of TCM, China Academy of Chinese Medical
Sciences, Beijing 100010, China
Correspondence: Keji Chen ([email protected]) or Luqi Huang ([email protected]) or Yue Liu ([email protected])
These authors contributed equally: Yiwen Li, Yanfei Liu, Shiwei Liu
Fig. 1 Schematic overview of panvasculopathy in diabetes mellitus. Diabetic panvasculopathy involves the cardiac, cerebral, renal, ophthalmic
and peripheral systems. The macrovascular lesions are in black text. The microvascular lesions are in red. The microvascular system varies in
different organs, which affects vascular function
therapeutic targets in DPDs; time course characteristics of sympathetic nervous system (SNS) directly or indirectly causes
pathological changes in organs and mutual predictive effects widespread vascular damage throughout the body, leading to the
among DPDs to provide clues for early diagnosis. Our findings development of panvascular complications of DM15 (Fig. 1). SNS
should promote the establishment of a multidisciplinary DPD dominates vasoconstriction and RAAS regulates of blood volume,
management system. vascular tone, and blood pressure.16 The vascular system in target
organs is tightly regulated by surrounding tissues that regulate
Diabetes and panvasculopathy microvascular units through physical and signal transduction. As
The vasculature comprises endothelial cells (EC), smooth muscle DM progresses, patients are more likely to develop various
cells (SMC), pericytes, fibroblasts, and various other types of cells. vascular complications and experience many pathological
AS, endothelial barrier damage, loss of pericytes, capillary changes, such as endothelial dysfunction, AS, and microcirculatory
thinning, and angiogenic disorders are common pathologies of disorders that interact with each other, consequently leading to
systemic vascular disease. Blood vessels, together with nerves and the development of DPD.
lymphatic vessels, are wrapped in connective tissue membranes Diabetic vasculopathy is classified as macroangiopathy and
to form vascular nerve bundles. Differences in perivascular tissues, microangiopathy. Macroangiopathy includes AS of large and
vascular nerve bundles, and intravascular structures result in medium arteries (aorta, coronary, renal, basilar, and peripheral
altered vascular function. When imbalanced homeostasis is arteries), whereas microangiopathy includes endothelial damage
characterized by abnormal glucose and lipid metabolism, activa- to vessels between primary arterioles and venules, vascular
tion of the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system (RAAS) and basement membrane thickening, microthrombosis, platelet and
Fig. 2 Pathology and molecular mechanisms of DHD. The mechanisms of diabetic heart disease are complex, including oxidative stress,
inflammation, and altered metabolic pathways (advanced glycosylation end product (AGE) formation, PKC pathway), which intersect and work
together to ultimately lead to myocardial remodeling and dysfunction
agonist (GLP-1RA) or sodium/glucose cotransporter-2 inhibitors neuronal activity, maintains the interstitial environment, and
(SGLT-2i) can reduce cardiovascular events (Table 1). When reduces and stabilizes blood flow.54 Diabetic macroangiopathy
treating T2DM complicated with HF, metformin should be and microangiopathy mutually promote each other, and the
combined with SGLT-2i, as this leads to a 39% reduction in the occlusion of macrovessels can cause chronic perfusion insuffi-
risk of HF hospitalization and a 46% reduction in the composite ciency in the brain and microvascular disorders.55 Microvascular
endpoint of HF hospitalization with all-cause death.42 Although function can affect collateral circulation in macrovessels56,57 and
GLP-1RA and dipeptidyl peptidase-4 inhibitors (DPP-4i) also confer increase the risk of stroke58 as well as a poor prognosis.59–61
some cardiovascular benefits, they do not offer a significant Neurons injury,62 Alzheimer’s like pathologies,63 and abnormal
advantage for reducing the hospitalization of HF in patients with activity of neurotransmitter receptors64 are also closely associated
diabetes (Table 1).43,44,45 with cerebrovascular lesions, and jointly cause brain function
impairment in patients.
Diabetic encephalopathy (DE). DM is significantly associated with Elevated blood glucose is a risk factor for pathological changes
an increased risk of several intracranial diseases, including cerebral in the brain and brain function impairment.65,66 Not only DM but
macro- and microangiopathy.46–48 Broadly speaking, the intracra- also pre-DM can promote the development of dementia.67
nial complication of DM includes stroke, which can also manifest However, the imaging changes do not correspond to the degree
as depression, mild cognitive impairment (MCI), and demen- of cognitive impairment, and its mechanism deserves further
tia.46,49–51 Such vascular lesions can involve large carotid and exploration.68 Diabetic cerebral microangiopathy has multiple
vertebral arteries, small intracerebral perforating arteries, micro- complex changes in images (cerebral atrophy, subcortical micro-
arteries, capillaries, micro-venules, and small veins. They are also infarcts, cerebral white matter hyperintensity, lacunar infarction,
involved in disrupting the integrity of the blood-brain barrier (BBB) perivascular space, and cerebral microhemorrhage),69 with diffuse
and neurodegeneration.52,53 The cerebral microvasculature facil- adverse effects.70,71 Meanwhile, advances are being made in the
itates intracranial nutrient delivery and waste removal, supports measurement of cerebral microangiopathy, along with more
Clinical trial Clinical trials’ number Year Phase Participants (n) Intervention Follow-up Main outcome
EMPA-REG NCT01131676 2015 3 7020 I: Empagliflozin 3.1 years MACE, cardiovascular, all-cause death, hospitalization for heart
OUTCOME483 C: placebo failure
CANVAS NCT01032629 2017 3 10142 I: Canagliflozin 3.61 years Cardiovascular death or hospitalized Heart failure
program484,485 NCT01989754 C: placebo
DAPA-HF486 NCT03619213 2018–2022 3 3131 I: Dapagliflozin 2.3 years Composite of worsening heart failure, cardiovascular death
C: placebo
Empa-HF100 NCT03485092 2018 3 150 I: Empagliflozin 0.69 year Left ventricular volumes
C: placebo
CREDENCE487 NCT02065791 2014–2017 3 4401 I: Canagliflozin 2.62 years Reduces the risk of kidney failure and cardiovascular events
C: placebo
DECLARE–TIMI 58488 NCT01730534 2013–2018 3 17160 I:Dapagliflozin 4.2 years MACE, composite of cardiovascular death, hospitalization for
C: placebo heart failure
EMPA-REG489 NCT01131676 2010–2013 3 7020 I:Empagliflozin 3.1 years Death from cardiovascular causes, nonfatal myocardial
C: placebo infarction, nonfatal stroke
Others
SAVOR-TIMI 53490 NCT01107886 2010-2011 / 4894 I: Metformin 2.1 years Composite of cardiovascular death, myocardial infarction, or
C:Other antidiabetic drugs ischemic stroke
TOSCA.IT491 NCT00700856 2008–2014 3 3028 I: pioglitazone add on 5 years All-cause death, nonfatal myocardial infarction, nonfatal stroke,
metformin or urgent coronary revascularization
C: sulfonylurea add on
metformin
Diabetic vascular diseases: molecular mechanisms and therapeutic strategies
5
6
Table 1. continued
Clinical trial Clinical trials’ number Year Phase Participants (n) Intervention Follow-up Main outcome
492
PROactive NCT00013208 2015 / 3606 I: Pioglitazone 7.8 years All-cause mortality, nonfatal myocardial infarction, stroke,
C: placebo cardiovascular mortality, cardiac intervention, et al
PROFIT-J493 UMIN000000846 2007–2011 3 481 I: Pioglitazone 1.53/ Composite of all-cause death, nonfatal cerebral infarction, and
C: Other antidiabetic drugs 1.64 years nonfatal myocardial infarction
DEVOTE494 NCT01959529 2013–2014 3 7637 I: Insulin Degludec 1.99 years Death from cardiovascular causes, nonfatal myocardial
C: Insulin Glargine infarction, nonfatal stroke
ORIGINALE495,496 NCT00069784 2012–2014 3 4718 C: Glargine 2.7 years Death from cardiovascular causes or myocardial infarction or
I: Standard care stroke and any of these three outcomes or hospitalization for
heart failure or carotid, coronary, or peripheral revascularization
ACCORD497 NCT00000620 2001–2005 3 10251 I: intensive glycemic control 3.7 years Composite cardiovascular outcome, cardiovascular and total
C: standard glycemic control mortality, nonfatal myocardial infarction
Steno-2498,499 NCT00320008 1993–2006 3 160 I: intensive glycemic control 13.3 years Death from any cause
C: standard glycemic control Stroke
VADT500 NCT00032487 2000–2008 3 1791 I: intensive glycemic control 5.6 years Composite of major cardiovascular events
C: standard glycemic control
Look AHEAD77 NCT00017953 2001–2012 3 5145 I: intensive lifestyle 9.6 years Composite cardiovascular outcome
intervention
C: receive diabetes support
and education
AleCardio501 NCT01042769 2010–2012 3 7226 I: Aleglitazar 2.5 years Composite of cardiovascular mortality, nonfatal myocardial
Li et al.
Diabetic vascular diseases: molecular mechanisms and therapeutic strategies
Fig. 3 Pathology and molecular mechanisms of DE. (1) Structural brain changes from MRI studies in diabetes are the primary diagnostic basis
of DE, including microinfarcts and microbleeds, perivascular spaces, white matter hyperintensities, white matter microstructure, lacunes, and
atrophy; (2) Pathologies related to imaging findings include blood-brain barrier permeability, perfusion defects, hypoxia, and increased
angiogenesis that can involve brain microvessels, multiple nerve cells, and the blood-brain barrier; (3) Microvascular dysfunction manifested
by impaired neurovascular coupling and impaired neuronal function. Neurovascular coupling links transient local neural activity to
subsequently increased blood flow; (4) The molecular pathways of hyperglycemic damage to brain microvasculature are closely related to
oxidative stress, inflammation, abnormal lipid metabolism, and insulin resistance. RAS rat sarcoma protein, GTP guanosine triphosphate, GDP
guanosine diphosphate, TLR4 Toll-like receptor 4, MEK mitogen-activated protein kinase, PI3K phosphoinositide 3-kinase, Akt protein kinase B,
TSC tuberous sclerosis complex, MAPK mitogen-activated protein kinases, mTOR mammalian target of rapamycin, RHEB Ras homolog protein
enriched in brain, PKC protein kinase C, PGC1-α PPAR-gamma co-activator-1 alpha, PIP2,3 phosphatidylinositol bisphosphate2, 3, IRS-1,2
insulin receptor substrate1, 2, NFκB nuclear factor kappa-B
studies of chronic kidney disease (CKD)159 which can predict the renal tubular capillaries, the absence of specific VEGFA expression
development of proteinuria.160 Despite many studies of novel leads to a significant decrease in peritubular capillary density in
biomarkers, only eGFR and proteinuria are routinely applied to mice.168 However, overexpression causes dilation of peritubular
clinically diagnose DKD, and the specificity and accuracy of these capillaries.169
awaits clarification in future controlled clinical trials with large Inflammatory mediators (chemokines, cytokines, and adhesion
samples. molecules)170,171 are often released due to hyperglycemia and
In addition, imbalanced pro- and anti-angiogenic factors can hemodynamic abnormalities, which lead to nephron damage
disrupt the vascular network in DKD. Hyperglycemia increases through ultrafiltration, mechanical stress, oxidative stress, glyco-
glomerular capillary pressure through a RAAS-mediated increase calyx dysfunction, and endothelial activation.172,173 These media-
in angiotensin II.161,162 Hyperglycemia-mediated changes in tors cause renal microvascular dilation or altered permeability
glomerular capillary autoregulation can cause endothelial dys- through thylakoid proliferation, podocyte or tubular injury,174 and
function and inflammation by increasing transforming growth inflammatory cell infiltration.175 In addition, oxidative stress is
factorβ-1 (TGFβ-1) mediated ROS that dilates glomerular afferent closely associated with inflammation and causes endothelial
and efferent arterioles.163 Lipid metabolism is often abnormal in dysfunction by activating NF-κB176,177 and adapter protein
patients with diabetes, and this can also contribute to glomerular complex-1178,179 to induce pro-inflammatory factors and, in turn,
and tubulointerstitial vascular injury through mediators such as mediate the inflammatory response, thus inducing renal fibro-
cytokines, ROS, and hemodynamic changes.164,165 Hypoxia in renal sis.180 Therefore, the main causes of vasculopathy in DKD are
tissues due to reduced density of tubulointerstitial capillaries is inflammation, hemodynamic, and metabolic disorders. Lesions are
also a major cause of renal disease progression.166,167 Although mostly concentrated on the glomerular and tubulointerstitial
scant vascular endothelial growth factor A (VEGFA) is expressed in microvasculature and also in other vessels such as renal arteries,
Fig. 4 Pathology of the glomerulus and tubules in DKD. a The classical pathological mechanisms of DKD. It mainly includes hemodynamic,
metabolic disturbances, and inflammation, which often interact with each other. (1). Hemodynamic disturbances lead to dysregulation of
tubulobulbar feedback balance. (2). Metabolic disorders are crucial to the pathogenesis of DKD. Hyperglycemia affects pathways such as
TGFβ1-RhoA/Roa pathway, RAAS, proximal tubular sodium and glucose reabsorption, and intracellular metabolism; abnormal lipid
metabolism can affect the release of mediators such as cytokines and ROS; in the presence of nutrient overload in the organism, endoplasmic
reticulum autophagy leads to a chronic unfolded protein response, and mTOR also disturbs the podocytes leading to oxidative stress. (3).
Inflammation promotes the release of inflammatory mediators such as adhesion molecules, chemokines, cytokines, and growth factors,
causing renal infiltration of inflammatory cells. b Schematic representation of the pathological damage of DKD. Differences in structural
changes of glomeruli and tubules in the diabetic setting and in the healthy state. Diabetic glomerulopathy is characterized by arterial
hyalinization, thylakoid stromal deposition, basement membrane thickening, glomerular thylakoid cell hypertrophy and proliferation,
podocytosis, proteinuria, tubular epithelial atrophy, activated myofibroblasts, and stromal accumulation. NFκB nuclear factor kappa-B, TGFβ
transforming growth factor-β, ROS reactive oxygen species, RAAS renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system, ANG2 angiotensin II, SGLT2 sodium-
dependent glucose transporters 2, mTOR mammalian target of rapamycin, NADPH nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate, NOX
NADPH oxidase, ICAM-1 intercellular cell adhesion molecule-1, VCAM-1 vascular cell adhesion molecule-1, VAP-1 vascular adhesion protein-1,
CCL CC chemokine ligand, CXCL C-X-C motif chemokine ligand, TNF tumor necrosis factor, IL interleukin, TWEAK tumor necrosis factor-like
weak inducer of apoptosis, MIF macrophage migration inhibitory factor, MIP-1 macrophage inflammatory protein-1, VEGF vascular endothelial
growth factor, PDGF platelet-derived growth factor, BMP bone morphogenetic protein, FGF fibroblast growth factor, M-CSF macrophage
colony-stimulating factor
and glomerular afferent and efferent arterioles. The pathogenesis patients mainly through post-glomerular vasodilation to normalize
and therapeutic strategies need further exploration. the eGFR.189 In addition to stimulating insulin secretion from
The current strategies for treating DKD mainly comprise pancreatic β-cells to control blood glucose, incretin might also
controlling blood sugar and blood pressure and blocking the bind to GLP-1 receptors to inhibit endothelial damage and thus
RAAS140 (Table 2). After controlling various risk factors such as exert positive effects.190 The large FIDELIO-DKD clinical trial found
hyperglycemia, hyperlipidemia, hypertension, and uric acid,181,182 that finerenone, a novel nonsteroidal mineralocorticoid receptor
the risk of DKD is reduced, but the vascular disease continues to antagonist combined with a RAAS inhibitor, reduced the risk of
progress. Blood pressure control and fenofibrate can increase the cardiac and renal outcomes while reducing the incidence of
risk of renal adverse events such as decreased eGFR, suggesting a hyperkalemia.191 MiRNAs play an important role in maintaining
need to explore more effective treatment modalities.183,184 Novel optimal vascular homeostasis and regulating microvasculature
hypoglycemic agents might protect the kidney through combined disorders.192 The miR-132 inhibitor CDR132L improves HF and
actions against hyperglycemia, hypertension, lipotoxicity,185 affects cardiac fibrosis biomarkers193 and might also have a
abnormal tubuloglomerular feedback,186 hypoxia,187 endothelial therapeutic effect on renal fibrosis. Anticoagulants might hamper
dysfunction, and renal fibrosis.188 The SGLT-2i dapagliflozin exerts the progression of DKD,194 but the clinical application requires
renoprotective effects, possibly by affecting the hemodynamics of further validation and tests, as some anticoagulants such as
Clinical trials Clinical trials’ number Year Phase Paticipants (n) Intervention Follow-up Main outcome
vorapaxar might increase bleeding risk (Table 2).195 ASP8232, reduce proteinuria through local effects on glomeruli
Some pathways associated with kidney injury have emerged as and podocytes, offering potential multi-target interventions.197
novel targets for treating DKD. For example, baricitinib is an oral Another promising therapeutic target is gut flora, as the renal
small-molecule inhibitor that selectively inhibits the Janus kinase disease causes the dysbiosis of various gut microbes. Inhibiting
(JAK) protein tyrosine kinase family members JAK1 and JAK2,196 phenyl sulfate (a metabolite derived from gut microbiota) reduces
which inhibits the JAK-mediated inflammatory pathways and proteinuria in mice with DKD.198 Supplementing patients with
reduces proteinuria. Small-molecule inhibitors associated with diabetes who are on hemodialysis with probiotics improves
kidney damage, such as the vascular adhesion protein-1 inhibitor glucose and lipid metabolism, as well as biomarkers of
Fig. 5 Pathology and molecular mechanisms of DR. Multiple mechanisms are involved in the pathogenesis of DR. Hyperglycemia can promote
oxidative stress through the polyol pathway, accumulation of advanced glycosylation end-products (AGEs), the protein kinase C (PKC)
pathway, and the hexosamine pathway, and exacerbate inflammation and abnormal angiogenesis by stimulating the secretion of
inflammatory factors and vascular endothelial growth factor, inducing retinal dysfunction until vision loss
induced blood-retinal barrier leakage and reduce retinal EC Diabetic peripheral vasculopathy (DPVD). DPVD is often over-
proliferation, migration, and neovascularization,236 thus alleviating looked, yet it is one of the most important and common vascular
DR. The main hallmark of PDR is neovascularization. The most complications in patients with T2DM.251 In such patients, DPVD
important inflammatory factor that stimulates neovascularization increases the risk of not only coronary atherosclerotic events,252
and causes vascular leakage is VEGF.209 Hypoxia-inducible factor- but also major adverse limb events such as amputation.253 DPVD
1α is activated under hyperglycemic and hypoxic conditions, can manifest as diabetic foot syndrome and peripheral arterial
which leads to increased secretion of VEGF, and overexpressed disease (PAD), which seriously affect the quality of life of patients
VEGF, in turn promotes neovascularization through activation of with diabetes. Peripheral arterial disease is traditionally considered
the PI3K/Akt,237–239 PKC,240,241 and NF-κB242,243 signal pathways. to be dominated by large artery AS.254 In fact, PAD is often
The expression of ICAM and nitric oxide synthase induced by VEGF accompanied by local and systemic microangiopathy.255,256
promotes leukocyte adhesion and causes changes in vascular Multivessel endothelial dysfunction can manifest as microangio-
permeability and pathological neovascularization.244–246 The pathy (either exclusively or with other diseases), such as capillary
pathogenesis of DR is complex, with numerous factors that basement membrane thickening, endothelial hyperplasia, oxygen
synergistically interact with each other during the development tension reduction, and hypoxia, affecting peripheral nerve
and progression of DR (Fig. 5). function.257 Pre-DM can affect blood vessels and accompanying
DR can be treated mainly by laser photocoagulation and vitreous nerves.258,259 The chronic course of DM might have further
injections of antibodies.247 Retinal laser photocoagulation can adverse effects under poor glycemic control.260,261 An increase in
prevent further vision deterioration, but cannot restore damaged postprandial glucose plays an important role in the development
vision. Intravitreally injected ranibizumab and bevacizumab reduce of peripheral vascular disease in DM.262
the recurrence of active neovascularization and risk of retinal The pathogenesis of DPVD overlaps with that of other AS and
detachment. However, frequent intraocular administrations due to microvascular endothelial injuries. IL-6, high-sensitivity C-reactive
a short half-life increase the risk of retinitis, retinal obstruction, and protein, lipoprotein-associated phospholipase A2, and high-
patient pain and might facilitate the development of drug molecular-weight lipocalin biomarkers serve as indicators of the
resistance.248,249 Intraocular glucocorticoid injection is often used to risk of cardiovascular disease and peripheral vascular dis-
treat persistent and refractory diabetic macular edema, which ease.263–267 Specific markers for DPVD are unknown, but many
improves vision but increases the incidence of cataracts and biomarkers of vascular injury are available.268,269 For example,
glaucoma.250 Drugs such as ranibizumab, aflibercept, and fenofibrate circulating levels of ICAM and sE-selectin indicate EC activation
have been included in clinical trials to evaluate their effectiveness and vascular inflammation, and thus have potential as diagnostic
and safety (Table 3), thus providing new ideas for treating DR. markers of DPVD.270,271
Clinical trials Clinical Year Phase Participants (n) Intervention Follow-up Main outcome Adverse events
trials’ number
13
Diabetic vascular diseases: molecular mechanisms and therapeutic strategies
Li et al.
14
The molecular mechanisms of AS in DPVD can be found in the After adjusting for age and the duration of DM, the risk of
section on coronary AS. Microvasculopathy in DPVD is highly peripheral neuropathy is found to be significantly higher in
concomitant with neuropathy, as microvessels form a neurovas- patients with T2DM than in those with T1DM.306 The median
cular network with accompanying nerves.272 Neurons and elapsed time to the onset of microproteinuria is also significantly
Schwann cells are highly susceptible to hyperglycemia.273,274 shorter in adolescents with T2DM than in those with T1DM (1.3 vs.
Energy and inflammation, oxidative stress,275 insulin resistance,276 6.8 years).307
AGEs,277 nerve growth factors,278 activation of the polyol path- The natural course of DPDs in rodents from the same genetic
way,279 and activation of the hexosamine and PKC pathways280 background would provide insights into the pathological changes
are core pathological factors and processes similar to those of in various tissues at the same time. Streptozotocin induced in
other DM vascular complications.281,282 Glucose and fatty acid C57BL/6 mice develop microangiopathy in various organs at 4‒20
metabolism,283 neural metabolism,284 and exosome regulation (mostly 8‒10) weeks after the onset of DM;308–310 db/db mice
have recently attracted attention.285,286 Much more is known simulating type 2 diabetes develop microangiopathy in various
about peripheral neuropathy than about DPVD. Glucose overload organs at 16‒40 (mostly 20) weeks of age.311,312 The temporal
and high fatty acid metabolism lead to decreased ATP production, progression of diabetic microvascular complications in mice are
excessive ROS formation, and impaired mitochondrial function, Concurrent regardless of the modeling modality (Fig. 6). DKD is
which further increases oxidative stress, leading to the formation the earliest to appear, with peripheral motor nerve conduction
of AGEs from the glycosylation of various proteins. The vicious velocity decelerating at 4 weeks of DM (C57BL/6 mice).313
cycle of these events further promotes ROS formation and ER Microvascular function in diabetic mice partially changes around
stress, resulting in DNA damage and apoptosis of various cells. 8–10 weeks after DM onset (C57BL/6 mice)310,314–318 or 20 weeks
Abnormal neurometabolism in DM manifests as changes in of age (db/db mice),268,311,319,320 manifested as pathological
sphingolipid metabolism, wherein sphingolipids are biologically staining of various organs changes. After 8 weeks of hypergly-
active and important structural components of plasma cell cemic state, further pathological changes of diabetic C57B/6 mice
membranes and are important signaling molecules. Abnormal in microvascular structure can occur, including expansion of the
sphingolipid metabolism causes neurotoxicity in patients with mesangial matrix of renal microvasculature and rupture of the
hyperglycemia.287 All of these pathways eventually manifest as renal tubular epithelium321 The retinal ultrastructure changes,
increased pro-inflammatory factors that further induce AGEs infoldings in retinal pigment epithelium layers are decreased, and
production, leading to oxidative stress and endothelial dysfunc- balance or proprioception are impaired due to neurovascular
tion.288 These interactive processes simultaneously place EC and disease.322 At 12‒20 weeks of DM, late panvascular disease can
neurons in a state of oxidative stress and inflammation. occur, with advanced vasculopathy of the heart, retina, or
The endpoint of DPVD is amputation, the occurrence of which is brain.323–325 occurring slightly before that of the kidneys.326
closely associated with infection and trauma. Therefore, care and Diabetic macroangiopathy does not develop spontaneously in rats
lifestyle changes play an important role in its treatment, which after DM modeling; rather, it is generally induced through specific
greatly differs from the preventive measures for other vascular diet control or vascular occlusion of the DM model rats.327 Thus,
pathologies. Normal or near-normal glycemic control is a primary after simply constructing animal models of diabetes, studies on
therapeutic goal. Intensified hypoglycemic therapy reduces the microangiopathy and macroangiopathy in the same models are
incidence of peripheral neuropathy in patients with T1DM but has scant. Rodents have different lipoprotein metabolism from
a little additional benefit for those with T2DM.289,290 Systemic humans and are highly resistant to AS. C57BL/6 mice are relatively
antioxidant and anti-inflammatory therapy might also provide too resistant to intraperitoneal injections of STZ to construct a
some benefits.291 New glucose-lowering drugs can reduce blood model of DKD, and various diabetic complications require
glucose without increasing the risk of amputation. In a subgroup different animals for optimal modeling. Therefore, the optimal
of patients with T2DM combined with PAD, empagliflozin reduced animal model for DPD studies awaits further investigation and
rates of mortality, hospitalization for HF, and the progression of clinical evidence.
kidney disease.252 Patients treated with the new glucose-lowering Relationships among DPDs (Fig. 7) outcomes in vital organs
drugs SGLT-2i, GLP-1RA, and DPP-4i have low risks of amputation (heart, kidney, and brain) are mutually predictive. DR is associated
with a good safety profile.292 Some glucose-lowering agents have with coronary atherosclerotic heart disease, macrovascular events
conferred advantages for patients with DPVD and other multi- (including stroke), and all-cause mortality.328 Screening retinal
vessel diseases. The results of the LEADER trial suggested that microvessels have a potential role in the risk identification of
liraglutide could be used in diabetic multivessel diseases.293 These cerebrovascular and neurodegenerative diseases.329 In T2DM,
treatment options could improve the overall quality of life of retinal parameters and a genome-wide polygenic risk score for
patients. coronary heart disease have independent and incremental
prognostic value compared with conventional cardiovascular risk
Temporal progression of DPDs assessment.330 Risk of macrovascular complications in patients
The time of onset of panvascular complications in patients with with diabetes and retinal artery occlusion for at least 5 years after
diabetes is closely associated with patient age,294 race,295 genetic an obstruction event is increased compared with those who do
background,296 DM staging,297 treatment regimen,298,299 and level not have such occlusion. Therefore, retinopathy can predict
of glycemic control.300,301 The natural course of DPDs is not cardiovascular risk in patients with T2DM.331 DR is closely
completely clear, but diabetic microangiopathy generally pre- associated with stroke332–336 and cerebral microangiopathy.337
cedes diabetic macroangiopathy.302 Clinical trials of patients with During embryonic development, the diencephalon is homologous
insulin-dependent DM have found that DR develops within the to the retina and optic nerve, especially the capillary-linked
first 2 years of DM in conventionally treated patients, and that by microglia and neuronal synapses, which are abundant in the retina
the fifth year, 25–40% of these patients develop retinal, renal, and and brain and sensitive to blood glucose.338 The microvasculature
peripheral microangiopathy.303 A Chinese cohort study has shown of the retina and the axonal function of retinal ganglion cells can
that >20% of patients develop moderate retinopathy and >40% be detected using fundus photography and optical coherence
develop mild proteinuria within 7 years after the onset of DM.304 tomography to assist with the diagnosis of cerebrovascular
According to the ADVANCED study, the incidence of macroangio- neuropathy.339 Retinal microvascular imaging findings closely
pathy at the fifth year of DM does not exceed 10%.305 correlate with cerebral infarction and white matter lesions,
Complications with panvascular disease appear earlier and more parapapillary retinal nerve fiber layer thickness, macular thickness,
frequently in patients with T2DM, than in those with T1DM.306,307 and volume being indicators of stroke risk.340 Changes in the
Fig. 6 The natural course of diabetic vasculopathy in mice. Streptozotocin induced in C57BL/6 mice simulate type 1 diabetes in human; db/db
mice simulate type 2 diabetes in human. Vasculopathy in different organs appears over a period of time, In C57BL/6 mice Streptozotocin
induced in C57BL/6 mice develop typical microangiopathy mostly at 8‒10 weeks after the onset of DM and develop advanced
microangiopathy at 12–16 weeks. db/db mice develop microangiopathy at about 20 weeks of age and develop advanced microangiopathy at
34 weeks
Fig. 8 Schematic diagram of cellar sugar metabolic pathways. Cells obtain energy through multiple gluconeogenic pathways. These include
glycolysis, polyol, hexosamine, and pentose phosphate pathways. In the diabetic environment, excessive intracellular glucose causes
abnormal activation of the polyol and hexosamine pathways, and inhibition of the major glycolytic and pentose phosphate pathways,
resulting in continued accumulation of reactive oxygen species, which ultimately leads to increased oxidative stress loss in cells and induces
the development of DPDs. Different metabolic pathways are distinguished by different colors, with pink representing the glycolytic pathway,
purple representing the polyol pathway, blue representing the pentose phosphate pathway, and yellow representing the hexosamine
pathway. All enzymes are indicated in red. Solid arrows indicate that this process is promoted and dashed arrows indicate that this process is
inhibited. IL interleukin, GSH glutathione, GSH-px glutathione peroxidase, AR aldose reductase, SDH sorbitol dehydrogenase, 3DG 3-
deoxyglucosone, AGE advanced glycosylation end, NOX reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate oxidase, ROS reactive oxygen
species, NLRP3 NOD-like receptor thermal protein domain associated protein 3, GK glucokinase, G6P glucose-6-phosphate, F6P D-fructose-6-
phosphate disodium salt hydrate, F1,6P2 fructose 1,6-bisphosphate, G3P glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate, 1,3BPG 1,3-bisphosphoglycerate,
G6PDH glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase, 6PGL 6-phosphogluconolactonase, 6PGDH 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase, GFAT
glutamine-fructose-6-phosphate aminotransferase, TCA tricarboxylic acid cycle
cells (e.g., cardiac myocytes, thylakoid cells in glomeruli, and pentose phosphate pathway, glucokinase/hexokinase is involved,
neurons and Schwann cells in peripheral nerves), conversion of and this enzyme also regulates glucose transport into cells, as well
the ratio of cell-specific fuel sources between glucose intermedi- as glycogen metabolism and gluconeogenesis. Activation of
ates, fatty acids, and amino acids, changes in respiratory chain glucokinases (Dorzagliatin, PB-201, AZD-1656, etc.) has a regula-
protein function, and uncoupling of respiratory chains.364–366 The tory effect on glucose homeostasis,372–377 but no additional
hyperosmolar state and abnormal energy metabolism of diabetes vascular protective value has been reported yet.378,379
increase the PKC pathway, endothelial xanthine oxidase, and the Hyperglycemia reduces glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase
eNOS uncoupling pathway, promoting increased ROS levels.367,368 (G6PDH)-mediated entry of glucose into the pentose phosphate
The mechanisms of energy metabolism imbalance vary slightly pathway, but rather into the polyol pathway through conversion
between target organs with different mitochondrial content and to sorbitol by the rate-limiting enzyme AR, and these processes
different major energy supply substances.369 are accompanied by a decrease in the rate of NADPH (an
important intracellular reducing agent) production.380 Meanwhile,
Glucose metabolism: Glucose metabolism is the main factor high glucose induces activation of NADPH oxidase (NOX) to
affecting cellular energy metabolism. The “unification hypoth- produce ROS, increases oxidative stress levels, and promotes
esis”226 suggests that several seemingly independent biochemical NLRP3/IL-1β and IL-18 to increase inflammation levels.381 Diabetes
pathways that are overactivated in diabetes are actually caused by promotes the accumulation of fructose-6-phosphate (F6P), which
excessive intracellular glucose flux (Fig. 8). EC are extensively can lead to an increase in the hexosamine (HBP) pathway and
damaged in DPDs, and EC produce ATP mainly by glycolysis.370 In overproduction of UDPn-acetylglucosamine.382 UDPn-
hyperglycemic states, changes in the metabolic pathways of sugar acetylglucosamine is involved in intracellular protein regulation,
(increased flux of the hexosamine pathway, increased flux of the especially for post-translational modifications of proteins such as
polyol pathway, decreased flux of pentose phosphate and O-GlcNAcylation.383 The HBP pathway accounts for a small
glycolytic pathways) lead to decreased production of NADPH percentage of glucose metabolism and does not affect tissue
and increased ROS, exacerbating oxidative stress.371 In the energy supply, but regulates glucose transporter protein and
Mitochondria can store calcium ions and act in concert with the receptor binding protein-2 (GRB-2), GRB-10, SHC transforming
endoplasmic reticulum and extracellular matrix to control the protein (SHC), and SH2B adapter protein-2 (SH2B-2) through
dynamic balance of calcium ion concentration in cells and induced insulin receptor.439,440 Selective glucose transporters exist
regulate the cell cycle and apoptosis.433 High glucose can affect in different target organs, such as the renal SGLT2 receptor;441 the
myocardial contractile function by upregulating sarcolipin (SLN) distribution of GLUT receptors in different target organs and the
promotes calcium sparks.434 Therapeutically, metformin inhibits pathways also differ.78,442 This paper summarizes the new
mitochondrial respiratory chain complex-1 and regulates cellular advances in insulin signaling receptor pathways and their roles
energy metabolism.435 In addition, metformin and GLP-1 agonizts from 2018 to date (Table 4).
regulate the glucagon-lowering hormone glucagon-like peptide-1
and the bile acid pathway and alter the composition of the gut Glycosylation end-products. As the end-products of dysfunctional
microbiota, which may also indirectly affect mitochondrial EC metabolism, AGEs have profound effects on the immediate
function.362,436 extracellular environment of EC as well as on other cell types. AGEs
Mitochondrial energy metabolism differs among target organs, can bind key proteins (such as laminin, elastin, and collagen) in
and myocardial mitochondrial content is abundant. Diabetic mice the extracellular matrix (ECM) basement membrane, leading to
have altered mitochondrial function in the myocardium earlier increased vascular stiffness promoting DPDs.443–445 AGEs may also
than in the kidney, brain, and liver.437 Further in-depth mechan- affect coagulation and hemodynamics, cause increased vascular
istic exploration is worthwhile in tissues with high mitochondrial permeability and induce tissue factor expression.446,447 The
content. extensive intracellular action of circulating AGEs is mediated
through the attachment of receptors for RAGE, which is expressed
Insulin resistance. Insulin resistance is the most common and in monocytes, smooth muscle cells (SMC), and EC.448,449
widespread molecular mechanism of diabetic complications, not RAGE induces an inflammatory cascade response by activating
only in the high glucose state with extensive activation of insulin the transcription factor NF-κB, which promotes the expression of
receptor signaling pathways, such as the regulation of glucose growth factors and adhesion molecules. On the other hand, RAGE
uptake by GLUT.438 Even in the presence of normal blood glucose, activates NADPH oxidase to increase oxidative stress; RAGE also
insulin resistance is still harmful, and the lack of insulin receptor binds to tissue-specific proteins to promote local vascular
signaling pathways in renal pedal cells induces a disease state injury,450,451 such as binding AGEs or S100/calmodulin or
similar to diabetic nephropathy.439 β-amyloid peptide to exacerbate cerebral hemorrhage;452 RAGE
The most common downstream mechanisms of insulin binds to EC to promote increased NADPH expression leading to
resistance include inhibitory phosphorylation of IRS, growth factor inflammatory responses and a prothrombotic state by activating