Final Report LSSP Zamboanga
Final Report LSSP Zamboanga
Final Report LSSP Zamboanga
This report is made possible by the support of the American people through the United States Agency for
International Development (USAID). The contents of this report are the sole responsibility of the local
government of Zamboanga City and do not necessarily reflect the views of USAID or the United States
Government.
LOCAL SUSTAINABLE SANITATION PLAN
OF ZAMBOANGA CITY (2021-2030)
Warmest greetings!
This LSSP of Zamboanga City is an important milestone in achieving our vision: “Sustainable
access to safely managed water supply and sanitation services and healthy environment for all
by 2030.”
That said, I urge all city official and employees, all residents and stakeholders to support the
implementation of this Local Sustainable Sanitation Plan. No matter what the city government
comes up with now and in the future, it will not succeed without the support and cooperation of
the people. We need to work together towards a better and healthier Zamboanga City.
1. Introduction 3
1.1 Rationale 3
1.2 The LSSP Process 4
1.3 LSSP Sanitation Thematic Areas 7
2. Considerations in the Development of the LSSP 8
3.1 Demography 26
3.2 City Health Profile 29
3.3 Water Supply 32
3.3.1 Household access to Improved Water Supply 32
3.3.2 Water Supply Service Provider 32
3.3.3 Water Sources 32
3.3.4 Current Programs, Projects and Activities 33
3.4 On-site Sanitation Facilities including WASH in Emergencies 33
3.4.1 Household access to Sanitary Toilet Facilities 33
3.4.2 Zero Open Defecation (ZOD) Status 33
3.4.3 Septage Management Program (SMP) 33
3.4.4 WASH in Emergencies 34
3.4.5 Current Programs, Projects and Activities 35
3.5 Wastewater, Sewage and Drainage Management 35
3.5.1 Sewerage System 35
3.5.2 City Drainage 36
3.5.3 Current Programs, Projects and Activities 36
3.6 Solid Waste Management 36
3.6.1 Current Programs, Projects, and Initiatives 37
13.1 Potential Environmental Impacts of the Program, Project and Activities (PPA) 97
13.2 Safeguards Requirement 97
13.2.1 Applicable Environmental Quality Standards 99
13.2.2 Possible Environmental Permit Requirements 104
14 References 107
Local Sustainable Sanitation Plan for Zamboanga City (2021-2030) Page iii
Tables
Table 1-1. Zamboanga City LSSP Team Members (based on Draft EO) 4
Table 2-1. Legislative Issuances related to Sanitation in the Philippines 8
Table 2-2. Executive Issuances related to Sanitation in the Philippines 12
Table 2-3. Sanitation Targets in the Philippines 17
Table 2-4. SDG Ladder for Drinking Water 21
Table 2-5. SDG Sanitation Ladder 22
Table 2-6. Manila CWIS Principles 23
Table 3-1. Summary of Sanitation Baseline in Zamboanga City 25
Table 3-2. Projected Population in Zamboanga City per Barangay 26
Table 3-3: Top 10 Leading Causes of Morbidity in Zamboanga City, 2016-2020 30
Table 3-4: Top 10 Leading Causes of Mortality in Zamboanga City, CY 2016-2020 31
Table 3-5: Designated WQMA in Zamboanga City 38
Table 4-1. Summary of Identified Sanitation Problems and Issues 39
Table 5-1. Health Impact of Unsafe Sanitation 50
Table 6-1: Vision and Mission Statement of Zamboanga City 52
Table 6-2: Sanitation Goals, Objectives and Strategies of Zamboanga City 53
Table 6-3: Identified Programs, Projects and Activities 56
Table 6-4: ZCWD Planned and Proposed Water Supply Projects 65
Table 6-5: DPWH Region IX Planned Projects on Water Supply 67
Table 6-6: Proposed Septage Treatment Plants in Zamboanga City 68
Table 6-7: Planned Projects of DPWH Region IX on Drainage 70
Table 6-8. Identified local policies for formulation/updating 72
Table 6-9. List of Capacity Building 73
Table 6-10. Identified Communication and Promotion Activities 76
Table 7-1. Roles and Responsibilities for the Implementation of the LSSP 82
Table 8-1. Financing and Management Options for Sanitation Projects 86
Table 12-1. Climate change adaptation measures for sanitation systems 94
Table 13-1. Safeguards Scope 97
Table 13-2. Mandatory Drinking Water Quality Parameters from 2017 PNSWD 100
Table 13-3. Philippine Water Quality Guidelines for Water Body Classification Applicable to the
Project Site 101
Table 13-4. General Effluent Standards Applicable for Sewage and Septage Treatment Plant
Project 101
Table 13-5. National Ambient Air Quality Guideline Values (24-Hour Averaging Time) 102
Table 13-6. IFC-EHS Noise Level Guidelines 102
Table 13-7. TCLP Limits for Sludges Prior to Disposal 102
Table 13-8. Allowable Level of Pathogens in Organic Fertilizers, Soil Conditioner, and Organic
Plant Supplements 103
Table 13-9. Limits on Wastewater Quality for Irrigation (DA AO No. 2019-11) 103
Table 13-10. Specific Permitting Requirements for Construction and Operation 104
Figures
Figure 1-1: DOH LSSP Process 4
Figure 2-1. Zamboanga Peninsula WSS Strategic Framework 20
Figure 2-2. Interlinkages of Sustainable Sanitation to SDGs 21
Figure 6-1: Proposed Sewerage Systems in Zamboanga City 71
Figure 7-1: Institutional Structure for the Septage Management Program and Sewerage System
in Zamboanga City 85
Local Sustainable Sanitation Plan for Zamboanga City (2021-2030) Page vii
Definition of Terms
Local Sustainable Sanitation Plan for Zamboanga City (2021-2030) Page viii
Sanitation – refers to the hygienic and proper management, collection, disposal/reuse of
human excreta (feces and urine) and domestic wastewater to safeguard the health of the
individuals and communities.
Septage – the combination of scum, sludge, and liquid that accumulates in the septic tanks.
Septage Management- refers to comprehensive program for managing septic tanks and the
procedures for proper desludging, transporting, treating, and disposing of septic tank contents.
Septic tank – a water-tight, multi-chambered receptacle that receives sewage from houses or
other buildings and is designed to separate and store the solids and partially digest the organic
matter I the sewage.
Sewage – mainly liquid waste containing some solids produced by humans, which typically
consists of washing water, feces, urine, laundry wastes and ither materials that flows down
drains and toilets from households and other buildings.
Sewer – a pipe or other conduit that carries wastewater from more than on property.
Sewerage System – refers to a system of pipes, pumps, devise and other appurtenant
structures for the collection, transportation, and final disposition of wastewater.
Sludge – precipitated solid matter with highly mineralized content produced by domestic
wastewater treatment process.
Toilet facility- refers to the structure built of materials of any kind inside or as part of a house or
building used by its residents, occupants, visitors, employees, transients or customers as
comfort room and lavatory with septic tank built for the purpose.
Unsanitary or unimproved toilet- refers to toilet facility that does not safely contain or dispose
human waste.
Waste Diversion – refers to activities which reduce or eliminate the amount of solid waste from
waste disposal facilities.
Water District (WD) – a local corporate entity that operates and maintains a water supply
system in one or more provincial cities or municipalities. It is classified as a government-owned
and controlled corporation, existing under the authority of the Provincial Water Utilities Act of
1973.
Water Safety Plan (WSP) - is a management tool which uses a comprehensive assessment
and risk management approach encompassing all steps in water supply from water source
(catchment) to consume
An LSSP team, chaired by the City Mayor, co-chaired by the City Health Office and
composed of members from various key offices of the city LGU and other relevant
stakeholders, was formed to lead the development of the LSSP. The Executive Order
Step 2: Craft the Vision and Mission for Local Sustainable Sanitation
Prior to crafting the vision and mission of the city for local sustainable sanitation, it is
important to understand the existing sanitation in the city. A sanitation baseline study
was conducted to assess the existing socio-economic, health and sanitation situation in
the city and to identify the sanitation gaps, problems and issues. The sanitation baseline
report is attached as Annex 2.
The vision and mission statements of Zamboanga City for local sustainable sanitation
are presented in the table below.
Step 3: Identify Goals and Objectives
Guided by the vision and mission, the sanitation goals of the city were formulated and
specific objectives to achieve these goals were also determined, as shown in the table
below.
Step 4: Formulate and Map-out Strategies
Strategies are the „how‟ or the means of attaining the goals or objectives. They are the
general approaches or major course of action that are carried out by the implementers to
reach the defined local sanitation goals and objectives.
Programs, projects and activities (PPAs) were also identified to support the
implementation of the strategies. In identifying the PPAs, the principles of equitable
solutions, financial and technical viability and resilience to climate/disaster risks were
considered. For each PPA, key performance indicators (KPI) were assigned to measure
the progress and performance of the city in achieving the targets. The indicative cost,
funding source and lead agency were also identified per PPA.
The development of the LSSP considered five thematic sanitation areas namely water
supply, management of on-site sanitation facilities, wastewater, sewage and drainage
management, solid waste management and water quality management. The analyses of
the existing sanitation conditions, issues and concerns and the identification of the
programs, projects and activities were done per thematic area.
Step 5: Integrate Sanitation Information into the Components of the LSSP
This step involved the actual writing and updating of the LSSP document by integrating
the health and sanitation data and information gathered and the outputs of the series of
planning workshops conducted from Step 1 to Step 4.
Step 6: Endorse the LSSP to LCE and SB
This last step in the process is the presentation and endorsement of the LSSP for
approval of the Local Chief Executive (LCE) and other LGU officials including, the
Sangguniang Panlungsod (SP) council. A resolution adopting the LSSP shall be created
to start the implementation of the LSSP. This is to ensure the implementation of the
identified PPAs and the allotment of required funding of the PPAs in the budget of the
city.
Adoption by other key stakeholders or lead implementors like the Water Security
Council, the local Water District, and DPWH is also needed.
Goal 2. Develop, adopt and 2a. To review, update, and strengthen Strategy 2: Formulation and/or updating of
enforce policies on WASH, enforcement of existing local policies on relevant local WASH policies
environment and other WASH, environmental health protection, Review and update existing local policies on
relevant areas for the and other relevant areas WASH, environmental health protection, and other
protection of the public health 2b. To develop and enact new policies on relevant areas
WASH, environmental health protection, Harmonize policies on WASH, environmental
and other relevant areas based on the health protection, and other relevant areas with
identified policy gaps, if any other local, inter-LGU, and higher-level policies
and plans
Develop new local policies to support the WASH
PPAs including the implementation of emergency
Goal 3. Promote positive 3a. To ensure community participation, Strategy 3: Provision of capacity building and
behavioral change and including vulnerable groups, in the implementation of local sustainable
continuing education on development and implementation of WASH communication and promotion program
WASH in the context of programs, projects, and activities Conduct IECs, advocacy programs, social
disease prevention, public 3b. To ensure continuing education of the marketing and capacity building, in partnership
health and environmental LGU and other stakeholders on WASH and with NGOs, academic institutions, and national
protection WASH promotion agencies.
Develop a targeted, community-based approach
and culturally appropriate education and marketing
campaigns for the stakeholders
Goal 4. Ensure sustainable 4a. To establish and maintain database for Strategy 4: Implement monitoring and
delivery of adequate, monitoring of WASH maintenance program of the WASH facilities
inclusive, efficient, and safely facilities/infrastructures and services Gather and collate data on WASH
managed WASH services for 4b. To strengthen drinking water quality, facilities/infrastructures and services
all even during emergencies sanitation, and environmental health Establish guidelines on the submission of
protection surveillance and data monitoring monitoring data of the WASH service providers to
of WASH outcomes LGU
Establish institutional arrangements for the
implementation, M&E of the WASH projects to
ensure sustainability.
1
https://psa.gov.ph/content/most-filipino-families-have-access-improved-source-drinking-water-results-2017-annual
Table 1-1. Zamboanga City LSSP Team Members (based on Draft EO)
TWG Office
Chairperson City Mayor
Co-Chairperson City Health Officer
Members City Environment and Natural Resources Officer
City Planning and Development Coordinator
City Disaster Risk Reduction Management Officer
City Engineer
OIC-City Administrator
Step 2: Craft the Vision and Mission for Local Sustainable Sanitation
15.
It is important to understand the existing sanitation in the city when setting the vision,
mission, goals and objectives (VMGO) of the LSSP. A sanitation baseline study was
conducted to assess the existing socio-economic, health and sanitation situation in the city
and to identify the sanitation gaps, problems and issues. The results of the baseline study
were presented to the LSSP Team members last August 3, 2020 and a Sanitation Baseline
Report was developed and submitted to both the city and the USAID SURGE Project on
August 31, 2021.
16.
After establishing the existing sanitation conditions and identifying the sanitation issues and
concerns of the city, the next step in developing the LSSP is the setting of VMGO for local
sustainable sanitation. To facilitate discussion on the VMGO, a SWOT analysis was
conducted from the existing sanitation baseline data. An analysis of each of the thematic
areas: water, sanitation, wastewater and WASH on Emergencies, was done in terms of
technical, financial//economic/financing, institutional (policy, communication, capacity
building, environmental) including the mainstreaming of DRR-CCA, which shall serve as the
basis of VMGO setting.
17.
An online session was held last August 4, 2021 with the LSSP TWG members to formulate
the VMGO of the city that is aligned with the national targets and national programs on
sustainable sanitation.
18.
The following were used as guide questions in setting the vision of the city for the LSSP:
What is the ideal condition of sanitation for the LGU?
How would things look if sanitation gaps, issues and challenges were completely and
perfectly addressed?
This chapter in the Code on Sanitation sets the guidelines for the
provision of individual excreta disposal system and proper
disposal of wastewater.
Section 74. Provides the requirements in the operation of
sewerage works and sewage treatment plants.
Section 75. Requires septic tanks in establishments where a
public sewerage system is not available and provides the
minimum requirements of such.
Section 76. Requires septic tank effluent to be treated and to
conform to water quality standards before discharging into a
stream or body of water.
Chapter XVIII. Refuse Disposal
Section 4 of this chapter sets the minimum standards and
requirements for the segregation and storage of refuse/solid
DOH Administrative ● Following their mandates under the LGC, LGUs shall integrate
Order No. 2010-0021: sustainable sanitation in their comprehensive development and
Sustainable Sanitation investment plans and annual programs and budgets. They
as a National Policy and shall make specific assignment of responsibilities among the
a National Priority concerned LGU office to carry out sanitation plans, programs
Program of the DOH and projects.
● LGUs shall encourage and assist barangays in passing
ordinance to address the sanitation problems and needs of the
community.
● By 2022, all LGUs shall have their own local sustainable
sanitation plans (LSSPs) and budgets in place under their
Province-wide Investment Plan for Health, Municipal-wide
Investment Plan for Health or City-wide Investment Plan for
Health.
● As stated in the AO, the national policy on sustainable
sanitation shall include references and integration to other
sanitation related plans and programs (i.e. solid waste,
housing)
● The National Sustainable Sanitation Plan shall include annual
targets for the following:
o LGUs that have declared sustainable sanitation as
priority
o LGUs that have LSSP
o Barangays that will be declared Open Defecation Free
DOH AO No. 2014- ● This policy requires all drinking-water service providers to
0027: National Policy on develop and implement a water safety plan.
Water Safety Plan Section IX. Roles and Responsibilities
(WSP) for All Drinking- J. LGUs shall:
Water Service Providers ● Advocate and create awareness to the general population and
drinking-water service providers on the importance of water
safety plan.
● Extend assistance to the operators of community-managed
water supply systems in the development and implementation
of WSP.
● Establish and make operational the LDWQMC as required by
DOH AO No. 2017-0020 ● This AO sets the norms for drinking water quality. The drinking
– Philippine National water quality surveillance agencies shall ensure the monitoring
Standards for Drinking of the WSP implementation and its effectiveness in meeting
Water of 2017 the PNSDW standards.
● As stated in the AO, the LGUs should develop and implement
a drinking water quality surveillance and establish an
LDWQMC to enforce this Order.
DOH AO No. 2017-007 ● One of the essential health service packages that must be
– Guidelines in the provided during emergencies and disasters are WASH facilities.
Provision of Essential WASH services include hygiene promotion, water supply,
Health Service excreta disposal, vector control, solid waste management and
Packages in drainage.
Emergencies and ● The LGU shall formulate plans, procedures and protocols to
Disasters implement this guideline and to provide funds.
DILG Memorandum Reiterates the roles of the LGUs in the implementation of sewage
Circular No. 2019-62 – treatment and septage management system within their respective
Policy and Guidelines on territorial jurisdiction.
Sewage Treatment and ● Enactment of Sewage Treatment and Septage Management
Sewage Management Ordinances
System ● Ensure that all residential, commercial, industrial institutional,
and governmental establishments have proper sewage
treatment and septage management system
● Enforce proper septic tank design
● Implement mandatory desludging of all septic tanks at least once
every five years; and
● Provide assistance in securing necessary permits, right of way,
IEC, and land acquisition to the water utilities in laying down
sewer lines.
DENR AO No. 2021-19: ● Updated the WQG and GES for ammonia, boron, copper as
Updated Water Quality dissolved copper, fecal coliform, phosphate as phosphorus and
Guidelines and General sulfate
Effluent Standards for
Selected Parameters
Department of
Agriculture The DA AO provides the standards and guidelines for the quality,
Administrative Order No. quantity and method of distribution and application of the
2019-11: Revised wastewater for agriculture reuse. It was formulated to ensure the
Guidelines on the safe reuse of the wastewater therefore, protection of the
Procedures and environment, human, animal and plant health were all considered
Technical Requirements in the guidelines.
for the issuance of a
Certification allowing the If the wastewater will be used for agriculture purposes, a
safe re-use of certification must be secured from the designated agency of DA. In
wastewater for purposes addition to the certification, a discharge permit must also be
of irrigation and other secured from the Environmental Management Bureau (EMB). The
agricultural uses. approved certificate must be submitted to EMB as part of its
application for the discharge permit
Source: Solving urban sanitation – sustainability and equitability, World Water, 2020
Figure 2-2. Interlinkages of Sustainable Sanitation to SDGs
38.
Unlike the Millennium Development Goals, SDG 6 looks at the entire supply chain rather
than the access alone3. For instance, SDG Target 6.1 aims to achieve the use of safely
managed drinking water services. It considers the type of water source and the accessibility,
availability and the quality of the water. The definition of the service ladder for drinking water
as defined by SDG 6.1 is shown in Table 2-5.
2
UN-Water, 2016: Water and sanitation interlinkages across the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development
3
Leading factors of success and failure in Asian Development Bank Urban Sanitation Projects, ADB, 2018
40.
Lastly, SDG 6.3 seeks to improve water quality by reducing pollution, eliminating dumping
and minimizing release of hazardous chemicals and materials, halving the proportion of
untreated wastewater and substantially increasing recycling and safe reuse globally.
3.1 Demography
53.
Zamboanga City is a first class highly urbanized city (HUC). It has a total land area of
145,327.02 hectares.
54.
According to the census conducted by the Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA) in 2020,
Zamboanga City had population of 977,234 which is about 25 percent of the total population
in Zamboanga Peninsula. From 2015 to 2020, the city exhibited an average population
growth rate of 2.68 percent which is higher than the average national and regional growth
rate of 1.63 percent and 1.39 percent, respectively. Furthermore, the average population
density of the city was computed to be 691 persons per square kilometer of land for the
same period.
55.
There are a total of 98 barangays in the city, 58 of which are urban barangays while the
remaining 40 are rural barangays. There are also nine island barangays in the city namely
barangays Tigtabon, Santa Barbara, Pangapuyan, Landang Laum, Landang Gua, Busay,
Pasilmanta, Manalipa and Tumalutab. The projected population in the city per barangay is
presented in Table 3-2.
6 Acute 3,015 Skin Diseases 4,230 Trauma 6,190 Hypertension 4,881 Acute 1,398
Gastroenteritis* Gastroenteritis*
7 Skin Diseases 2,135 Acute 2,154 Acute 6,085 Acute 3,717 Skin Diseases 1,221
Gastroenteritis Gastroenteritis* Gastroenteritis*
8 Urinary Tract 1,521 Diarrhea* 1,865 Tuberculosis 3,181 Tuberculosis 3,414 Tooth ache 1,113
Infection (all forms) (all forms)
9 Injuries 1,386 Injuries 1 683 Urinary Tract 2 121 Skin Diseases 3 081 Urinary Tract 586
Infection Infection
10 Diarrhea* 1,217 Headache 1 455 Dental caries 1 852 Type 2 1 350 Headache 558
Hypersensitivity
Reaction
Source: CHO 2020
*Can be due to poor sanitation access and practices
5
Guidelines on Sanitation and Health (WHO, 2018)
“Sustainable access to safely managed water supply and sanitation services and healthy
environment for all by 2030.”
Mission Statement
“Provision of safely managed and sustainable water supply and sanitation services, as well as
safer and healthier environment through innovation, stakeholder partnership and
collaboration.”
Goal 2. Develop, adopt and 2a. To review, update, and strengthen Strategy 2: Formulation and/or updating of
enforce policies on WASH, enforcement of existing local policies on relevant local WASH policies
environment and other relevant WASH, environmental health protection, Review and update existing local policies on
areas for the protection of the and other relevant areas WASH, environmental health protection, and
public health 2b. To develop and enact new policies on other relevant areas
WASH, environmental health protection, Harmonize policies on WASH, environmental
and other relevant areas based on the health protection, and other relevant areas with
identified policy gaps, if any other local, inter-LGU, and higher-level policies
and plans
Develop new local policies to support the
WASH PPAs including the implementation of
emergency response plans for WASH
facilities/infrastructures and services
A. Water Supply
a. Source development, service expansion and facility rehabilitation for water supply
189.
The following are the planned and proposed water supply projects of ZCWD and DPWH
Region IX to increase the access on safely managed drinking water supply of the
households in Zamboanga City.
190.
The ZCWD should also develop and implement an action plan to manage and reduce the
non-revenue water in their water supply system.
24,000
households‟
beneficiaries
Proposed On-going 2021 East Coast 76.04M
Cahumban implementation Barangays up to
Water System the Central
Business District
1,867 households‟
beneficiaries
Construction of For FS 2025 Labuan 779.82M
50MLD East Limpapa
Coast Patalon
transmission
and distribution
Pipeline
Proposed water With concept 2024 Bunguiao 120.31M
source design and Sangali
development at costing Bolong
Sitio Latap,
Barangay
Limpapa
Proposed On-going To date Vitali 58.84M
Bunguiao Water implementation Mangusu
System (DPWH) Tictapul
Construction of On-going To date Upper 8.66M
Rancho Frio implementation Cabatangan
Water System (DPWH)
Proposed water On-going For turnover, 55 locations of 7.71M
system project implementation 2021 feederline
at Dulian- (DPWH) expansion of
Cabatangan different
barangays
Proposed For funding 2022 20M
feederline
expansion
projects
191.
The City LGU should ensure that all the barangays in the city have access to Level 3 water
supply systems. For the barangays that are not within the service areas of ZCWD, the city
may assist the barangay LGUs in constructing and operating a community-managed water
supply system.
b. Develop alternative water sources in island barangays
192.
Since the households in the island barangays of the city are not within the service area of
ZCWD, the city LGU should provide technical assistance to the households to develop safe
alternative water supply system.
c. Installation of rainwater harvesting facilities in public facilities
193.
As an alternative water source, rainwater harvesting facilities will be constructed in public
schools, healthcare facilities and other public places in the city. It is an effective option,
particularly in areas where other water sources are unreliable or are simply not available. As
stated in City Ordinance No. 524, an initial budget of Php 10 million pesos is appropriated to
ensure the immediate installation of the rainwater collectors by the city for its own structures.
194.
The city must also advocate the installation of rainwater harvesting facilities in commercial,
institutional and industrial establishments to be used as additional water source and reduce
the requirement for fresh water supply.
a. Assist the households in the construction of sanitary toilet facilities and provision of
WASH facilities in houses on stilts and island barangays
195.
The city LGU may partner with private sectors, donors and other NGOs to provide financial
assistance to the poorest households in the city that do not have their own toilet facilities,
especially those who are living in the houses on stilts and island barangays. This is to help
Advocacy for SMP • To encourage the public • City government • Households • Printed materials
Advocacy for the • To encourage the • City government • Households • Printed materials
safe reuse of private sectors to reuse • ZCWD • Commercial/Industrial • Audio Visual
treated effluent and treated effluent and • ZCWSC establishments Presentations
biosolids biosolids • Social media
• To increase awareness
Table 7-1. Roles and Responsibilities for the Implementation of the LSSP
Office Roles and Responsibilities
Barangay Councils Responsible for implementing the sanitation programs
within their respective barangay with technical support
provided by the CHO.
City Engineering Office (CEO) Will take charge on the construction of water and
sanitation infrastructure projects of the city.
Shall be responsible for the master planning and
maintenance of the city drainage system, in
coordination with the City Planning and Development
Office and DPWH, and with ZCWD should the city
adopt a combined sewerage system in some parts of
the city.
Office of the Building Official Advocate the installation of the rainwater harvesting
Office of the City Environment Shall be responsible in implementing the local solid
and Natural Resources waste management program of the city.
(OCENR) Responsible for implementing IEC campaigns,
garbage collection, and sanitary landfill management.
Monitor the activities of all septage and wastewater
treatment facilities in the city
Coordinate and provide Secretariat support for the
programs and activities of the Water Security Council
City Disaster Risk Reduction Must ensure that evacuation centers have safe water
and Management Office supply and safe, functioning and gender-segregated
(CDRRMO) toilets and other needed WASH facilities
Zamboanga City Water District In coordination with the City LGU, will be responsible
(ZCWD) for setting up and implementation of the septage
management program (SMP) in the city.
Ensure the availability of safe water supply in the city.
To expand its water service area
Operate sewerage system of the city
Zamboanga City Water Security Review and recommend to the Local Chief Executive
Council (ZCWSC) (LCE) and the City Legislative Council relevant and
responsive policies, strategies, guidelines and
innovations on water supply and sanitation
development and management.
Monitor and evaluate the implementation of the Water
Security Master Plan
City Solid Waste Management To update the solid waste management plan of the city
Board To oversee and monitor the implementation of the city
solid waste management plan
Local Drinking Water Quality Monitor and audit the water service providers in the
Monitoring Committee city
(LDWQMC)
7.2 Institutional Structure for the Septage Management Program and Sewerage
System
243.
The City Ordinance No. 2009-152, also known as the “Septage Management System
Ordinance” created the CSMC who will be in charge of policy making, planning,
accreditation of desludgers and IEC activities related to the SMP.
244.
As stated in the Ordinance, the City Government of Zamboanga may operate its own
wastewater treatment facility and desludging services. However, the city also has the option
to contract with private service providers, for desludging and/or treatment services, provided
that they are financially capable to shoulder the necessary expenditures. It is also stated in
the Ordinance that the city LGU may enter an agreement with the ZCWD for the collection of
the desludging fee of Php 1.75 per cubic meters of water consumed per month to its
customers. The ZCWD must remit the net amount monthly to the City Treasure as General
Fund.
245.
The Septage Management System Ordinance is currently being updated to include the
provision of the sewerage system in the city.
246.
Recently, the city LGU and ZCWD entered an agreement for the implementation of the SMP
and the operation of the sewerage system in the city.
247.
At present, ZCWD has its Sewerage Division that is responsible for the operations of the
sewage treatment plant (sewerage plant operations section) and the maintenance of the
sewer lines (sewerage maintenance and connection section). For the implementation of
SMP in the city, the ZCWD may consider adding another section that will be responsible for
the desludging operations. The operation of the septage treatment plant can be lodged
under the sewerage plant operations section of the city.
248.
ZCWD is responsible in collecting the septage fees from its customers. For non-customers,
desludging may be done by request and payment will be collected per service. The ZCWD
may also consider entering a desludging service agreement with the CSMB-accredited
private desludgers in the city to provide services to the non-customers.
249.
The LGU shall create a project team that will regularly monitor the operational performance
of as well as financial performance of the septage and sewerage projects in the city.
250.
Figure 7-1 shows the institutional arrangement for the implementation of the SMP and
sewerage system in Zamboanga City.
6
Review of the National Government-Local Government Unit (NG-LGU) Cost Sharing Policy for Water Supply and Sanitation,
MDGIF, 2011
7
Department of Public Works and Highways
● Lack of support from the government. The LSSP should be approved by the LCE,
other LGU officials and the Sangguniang Panlungsod (SP) and be adopted formally
by a resolution. This is to ensure the implementation of the identified PPAs and the
allotment of required funding of the PPAs in the budget of the city. Adoption by other
key stakeholders or lead implementors like the Water Security Council, the local
Water District, and DPWH is also needed.
● Lack of available funding. The LSSP activities requires investment in capital and
operation expenditure, including initial infrastructure construction and recurring
operation and maintenance costs. The city should consider different financing
mechanisms to sustain the implementation of the sanitation projects.
● Lack of space for the sanitation facilities. With the rapid urbanization, congestion
in the city may result to lack of space available for the construction of new sanitation
facilities.
● Impacts of climate change. Climate change may affect the availability of water
resources, increase the vulnerability of communities in low lying areas and increase
the susceptibility of coastal communities to storm surges. Higher temperatures will
result in water shortages, and increased rainfall may induce flooding. Climate change
may also cause degradation of the quality of the water sources and may increase the
demand and use of the sanitation services. All these factors must be considered to in
the design of the sanitation infrastructures to make it resilient and climate change-
proof.
8
Table 12-1. Climate change adaptation measures for sanitation systems
8
Climate, Sanitation and Health, WHO, 2019
9
Public-Private Partnership (PPP) Governing Board Resolution No. 2018-12-02, December 14, 2018. “Safeguards in PPP:
Mainstreaming Environmental, Displacement, Social and Gender Concerns”
Table 13-2. Mandatory Drinking Water Quality Parameters from 2017 PNSWD
Parameter Unit Standard Value
Thermotolerant Coliform MPN/100mL <1.1
E. Coli mg/L <1.1
Arsenic mg/L 0.01
Cadmium mg/L 0.003
Lead mg/L 0.01
Nitrate mg/L 50
Color (Apparent) CU 10
Turbidity NTU 5
pH - 6.5 – 8.5
Total Dissolved Solids mg/L 600
Disinfectant Residual - 0.3 min and 1.5 max
Source: 2017 Philippine National Standards for Drinking Water, Department of Health.
Local Sustainable Sanitation Plan for Zamboanga City (2021-2030) Page 100
Table 13-3. Philippine Water Quality Guidelines for Water Body Classification Applicable
to the Project Site
Water Classification
Parameter Unit Class Class
Class A Class B Class C
SA SB
pH - 6.5 – 8.5 6.5 – 8.5 6.5 – 9.0 7.0 – 8.5 7.0 – 8.5
Temperature* °C 26 – 30 26 – 30 25 – 31 26 – 30 26 – 30
Color TCU 50 50 75 5 50
Fecal Coliform MPN/100mL 50 100 200 20 100
BOD mg/L 3 5 7 n/a n/a
Nitrate mg/L 7 7 7 10 10
Phosphate mg/L 0.025 0.025 0.025 0.1 0.2
Total mg/L 50 65 80 25 50
Suspended
Solids
Ammonia mg/L 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.04 0.06
Oil and Grease mg/L 1 1 1 1 2
● Class A Public Water Supply Class II – intended as sources of water supply requiring conventional treatment (coagulation,
sedimentation, filtration, and disinfection) to meet latest PNSDW;
● Class B Recreational Water Class I – intended for primary contact recreation (bathing, swimming, etc.);
● Class C 1. Fishery Water for the propagation and growth of fish and aquatic resources; 2. Recreational Water Class II – for
boating, fishing, or similar activities; 3. for agriculture, irrigation, and livestock watering;
● Class SA 1. Protected Waters or water designated as national or local marine parks, reserves, sanctuaries, and other areas
established by law (Presidential Proclamation 1801 and other existing laws), and/or declared as such by appropriate
government agency, LGUs, etc.; 2. Tourist Zones – for ecotourism and recreational activities; 3. Recreational Water Class I
– intended for primary contact recreation (bathing, swimming, skin diving, etc.);
● Class SB 1. Fishery Water Class II or waters suitable for commercial propagation of shellfish and intended as spawning
areas for milkfish (Chanos chanos) and similar species; 2. Tourist Zones – for ecotourism and recreational activities; 3.
Recreational Water Class I – intended for primary contact recreation (bathing, swimming, skin diving, etc.).
Notes: (*) The natural background temperature as determined by EMB shall prevail if the temperature is lower or higher than the
WQG; provided that the maximum increase is only up to 10% and that it will not cause any risk to human health and the
environment; MPN/100ml – Most Probable Number per 100 milliliters; n/a – Not Applicable; TCU – True Color Unit.
Source: DENR AO 2016-18, DENR AO 2021-19
Table 13-4. General Effluent Standards Applicable for Sewage and Septage Treatment
Plant Project
Water Classification
Parameter Unit Class Class
Class A Class B Class C
SA SB
pH - 6.0 – 9.0 6.0 – 9.0 6.0 – 9.5 NDA 6.0 – 9.0
Temperature °C Change 3 3 3 NDA 3
Color TCU 100 100 150 NDA 100
Fecal Coliform MPN/100mL 100 200 400 NDA 200
BOD mg/L 20 30 50 NDA 30
Nitrate mg/L 14 14 14 NDA 20
Phosphate mg/L 1 1.5 4 NDA 2
Total
Suspended mg/L 70 85 100 NDA 70
Solids
Ammonia mg/L 2 3 4 NDA 3
Oil and Grease mg/L 5 5 5 NDA 5
Chloride mg/L 350 350 450 NDA n/a
Fluoride mg/L 2 2 2 NDA 3
Iron mg/L 5 5 7.5 NDA 7.5
Local Sustainable Sanitation Plan for Zamboanga City (2021-2030) Page 101
Water Classification
Parameter Unit Class Class
Class A Class B Class C
SA SB
Surfactants mg/L 2 3 15 NDA 500
Notes: NDA – No Discharge Allowed; n/a – Not Applicable
Source: DAO 2016-18, DENR AO 2021-19
281.
Table 13-6 presents the International Finance Corporation – Environmental, Health and
Safety Guidelines (IFC-EHS) for noise level at different receptors. Noise impacts should not
exceed the levels presented in the table below or result in a maximum increase in
background levels of 3 dB at the nearest receptor off-site.
Table 13-6. IFC-EHS Noise Level Guidelines
One Hour LAeq (dBA)
Receptor Daytime (07:00 – Nighttime (22:00 –
22:00) 07:00)
Residential; institutional; 55 45
educational
Industrial; commercial 70 70
Source: IFC-EHS Guidelines
Local Sustainable Sanitation Plan for Zamboanga City (2021-2030) Page 102
e) Land Application of Biosolids
283.
If there are agricultural areas near the treatment plant, the biosolids may be applied as soil
conditioner or alternative fertilizers to selected crops such as sugarcane and corn.
Considering public health issues, not all agricultural crops may accept biosolids from
septage as soil conditioner. Such information must be obtained from the Department of
Agriculture or from the local City Agricultural Office prior to any land application.
284.
PNS/BAFS 183, which cancels and replaces PNS/BAFS 183:2016, specifies the minimum
standards of organic fertilizer, soil conditioner, and plant supplement. According to the
standards, these soil amendments may come in solid or liquid form. Such reuse of sludges
is covered by standards prescribed by the Department of Agriculture. The limits for
pathogens are shown in Table 13-8.
Table 13-8. Allowable Level of Pathogens in Organic Fertilizers, Soil Conditioner, and
Organic Plant Supplements
Pathogens Allowable Level
Fecal Streptococci <5 x 102 CFU/g
<2 MPN/g
Total Coliforms <5 x 102 CFU/g
<2 MPN/g
Salmonella Absent in 25 g
Reference: PNS/BAFS 183: 2020
f) Effluent Reuse
285.
Wastewater re-use for irrigation must also comply with prescribed standards issued by the
Department of Agriculture. For non-agricultural purposes, effluent may only be recycled (i.e.,
facility washing) after meeting the GES. The limits on selected wastewater quality
parameters for irrigation are shown in Table 13-9.
Table 13-9. Limits on Wastewater Quality for Irrigation (DA AO No. 2019-11)
Parameters Unit Landscape and Crop Irrigation
Health-based
Fecal Coliform MPN/100mL <200
Not detectable a
For crop productivity and protection of the environment
BOD5 mg/L <150
Electrical conductivity uS/cm <2,000
<1,000a, b
Bicarbonates mg/L <500
Free residual chlorine mg/L <1
pH 6.5 to 8.0
Sodium Adsorption Ratio (SAR) <18
Sodium meq/L <3
Total Nitrogen mg/L <30
Total Phosphorous mg/L <30
Total Suspended Solids mg/L <140
Aluminum mg/L 5.00
Local Sustainable Sanitation Plan for Zamboanga City (2021-2030) Page 103
Parameters Unit Landscape and Crop Irrigation
Chemical Parameters - Trace metals
Barium mg/L 6.0
Beryllium mg/L 0.1
Boron mg/L 0.75
Cobalt mg/L 0.05
Fluoride mg/L 1.00
Iron mg/L 1.00
Lithium mg/L 2.50
Manganese mg/L 0.20
Molybdenum mg/L 0.01
Nickel mg/L 0.20
Selenium mg/L 0.02
Vanadium mg/L 0.10
Zinc mg/L 2.00
Chemical Parameters - Heavy Metals
Arsenic mg/L 0.1
Cadmium mg/L 0.01
Chromium mg/L 0.10
Copper mg/L 0.20
Lead mg/L 0.20
Mercury mg/L 0.002
Note:
a. Foods eaten raw and not commercially processed
b. Food crops commercially processed
Local Sustainable Sanitation Plan for Zamboanga City (2021-2030) Page 104
Issuing Submission
Permit Remarks
Agency Schedule
ECC DENR-EMB Prior to ▪ ECC is document issued by
construction DENR-EMB certifying that the
proposed project has complied
with all the requirements of the
EIS System and has committed
to implement its approved EMP
to address the environmental
impacts.
Locational LGU Prior to ▪ Locational Clearance is issued
Clearance construction by LGUs as pre-requisite in the
issuance of Building Permit to
ensure the project‟s conformity
with City‟s CLUP and Zoning
Ordinance.
● Building Permit LGU Prior to ▪ Issued by the LGU to ensure
● Clearance / construction that the design, plans, and
Fencing / specifications of the facility
Excavation conforms to the Building Code
Permit of the Philippines.
● Permit to Install
Mechanical
Equipment
ENR Clearance, LGU Prior to ▪ The Proponent shall submit the
COC and Sticker operation desludging trucks for emission
test prior to issuance of ENR
Clearance, COC and Sticker
Local Sustainable Sanitation Plan for Zamboanga City (2021-2030) Page 105
Issuing Submission
Permit Remarks
Agency Schedule
Environmental DOH Prior to ▪ ESC is issued to stationary and
Sanitation Operations mobile service providers
Clearance (ESC) allowing the collection,
handling, transport, treatment
and disposal of domestic
sludge or septage.
Local Sustainable Sanitation Plan for Zamboanga City (2021-2030) Page 106
14 References
● Climate Change-Responsive Integrated River Basin Management and
Development Master Plans for the 8 Clustered River Basin, DENR-RBCO
● Climate, Sanitation and Health, World Health Organization 2019
● DOH Field Health Services Information System Annual Report, 2016-2020
● Guidebook for a Local Sustainable Sanitation Promotion Program, Department of
Health, 2010
● Guidebook for a Local Sustainable Sanitation Strategy, Department of Health,
2010
● Guidebook for a Sustainable Sanitation Baseline Study, Department of Health,
2010
● Guidelines on Sanitation and Health, World Health Organization, 2018
● Leading factors of success and failure in Asian Development Bank Urban
Sanitation Projects, ADB, 2018
● Philippine Water Supply and Sanitation Master Plan, Abridged Version, 2018-
2040
● Public-Private Partnership (PPP) Governing Board Resolution No. 2018-12-02,
December 14, 2018. “Safeguards in PPP: Mainstreaming Environmental,
Displacement, Social and Gender Concerns”
● Review of the National Government-Local Government Unit (NG-LGU) Cost
Sharing Policy for Water Supply and Sanitation, MDGIF, 2011
● Solving urban sanitation – sustainability and equitability, World Water, 2020
● UN-Water, 2016: Water and sanitation interlinkages across the 2030 Agenda for
Sustainable Development
● Zamboanga City Comprehensive Development Plan, 2016-2021
● Zamboanga City Comprehensive Land Use Plan, 2016-2025
● Zamboanga City Enhanced Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management
Plan, 2019-2022
● Zamboanga City Local Climate Change Action Plan, 2016-2030
● Zamboanga City Local Climate Change Action Plan, 2017-2019
● Zamboanga City Roadmap to Recovery and Reconstruction, 2014
● Zamboanga City Socio-economic Profile, 2020
● Zamboanga City Solid Waste Management Plan, 2020-2030
● Zamboanga City Water District Water Safety Plan, 2018
Local Sustainable Sanitation Plan for Zamboanga City (2021-2030) Page 107
Annex 1:
Executive Order for the Creation of the
Local Sustainable Sanitation Plan
Team for Zamboanga City
EXECUTIVE ORDER No. __ Series of 2021
WHEREAS, it is a declared policy of the State to afford full protection and the advancement of the right
of the people to a healthy environment in accord with the rhythm and harmony of nature;
WHEREAS, the health of the people, being of paramount importance, all efforts of public services should
be directed towards protection and promotion of health for all;
WHEREAS, the Local Government Code of the Philippines of 1991 empowers the local government
units to exercise its broad powers necessary towards the promotion of the general welfare including
sanitation and protection of public health;
WHEREAS, the National Sustainable Sanitation Plan (NSSP) which serves as the basis for all plans and
activities on sustainable sanitation in the country, encourage the LGUs to develop their local sustainable
plans and programs, and streamline such to the components of the NSSP goals and objectives for
sustainable sanitation;
WHEREAS, upholding the vision of healthy people and environment, it is of utmost interest to formulate
a Local Sustainable Sanitation Plan (LSSP) which shall rationalize and streamline all existing local efforts
concerning local sanitation with the end-goal of holistically addressing all intersecting issues on
environment, health and sanitation and other sectors;
WHEREAS, there is a need to organize the LSSP Team who will lead, oversee and ensure that the
LSSP shall be drafted, approved, adopted and sustainable sanitation programs and projects are
implemented and subsequently monitored and evaluated.
WHEREAS, the support and cooperation of different stakeholders shall bring about a balanced and
coherent approach in the process of developing policies, strategies and plans, and make better use of
resources towards long-term improvements;
WHEREAS, some members of the team belong to other government offices and agencies being
stakeholders with vital role in the development of the LSSP, thus in respect to the authority of their
respective agency/office are enjoined to support this initiative by allowing their representative to attend
and participate in the series of LSSP activities as member, and make this an official part of their task to
ensure the unification of the plan;
WHEREAS, recognizing that USAID‟s Strengthening Urban Resilience for Growth with Equity (SURGE)
Project seeks to advance the development of the city as instrument for growth that is inclusive,
environmentally sustainable and resilient by providing a range of technical assistance, drawing from
resources in economic growth, health, energy, environment, governance and education, thus USAID
SURGE oversight is essential to the development of the LSSP.
WHEREAS, in view of the fact that LSSP development will support the thrusts and vision of the city
administration and having potential to impact the local economy, it is necessary to implement and follow
the timeline by the LSSP Team;
Section 1. COMPOSITION OF THE LSSP TEAM. The LSSP Team shall be composed of:
Cesar G. Raz
OIC-City Administrator
Joann S. Hamili
City Accountant
Rodrigo Pagotaisidro
Housing and Homesite Regulation Officer V
City Housing and Land Management Division
John M. Dalipe
Chairperson, Committee on Health and Sanitation
Sangguniang Panlungsod
Department of Education
Section 2. FUNCTIONS AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE LSSP TEAM. The LSSP Team shall render
technical services in formulating the Local Sustainable Sanitation Plan specifically:
Section 3. EFFECTIVITY. This Executive Order shall take effect immediately and remains to be in force
until revoked and/or modified by the undersigned. Any and all other executive issuance/s contrary or
inconsistent herewith are deemed superseded.
Section 4. SEPARABILITY. Should any part of this Order be found unconstitutional or inconsistent with
any higher issuance/s, the remaining provisions shall not be disturbed.
________________________________________
MAYOR MARIA ISABELLE CLIMACO-SALAZAR
City Mayor
Annex 2: Sanitation Baseline Report
LOCAL SUSTAINABLE SANITATION PLAN
OF ZAMBOANGA CITY (2021-2030)
1.1 Background 3
1.2 Methodology 1
1.2.1 Secondary Data Collection 1
1.2.2 Sanitation Survey 4
1.2.3 Drainage Inspection 4
1.2.4 SWOT Analysis 4
1.2.5 Baseline Validation Online Session 4
2. City Profile 5
This also includes the availability and provision of WASH (water, sanitation and hygiene)
facilities during emergencies, including natural disasters, outbreaks and pandemics. In
emergency settings, it is critical that there are available WASH facilities to prevent the
spread of diseases and to reduce the health impacts of the disasters.
c. Wastewater, sewage and drainage management – this includes the management of
the domestic wastewater generated in the city from the households, institutional and
commercial establishments, and the provision and maintenance of the city drainage to
reduce the occurrence of flooding in the city.
d. Solid waste management – this pertains to the collection and proper disposal of the
solid wastes and health care wastes in the city.
e. Water quality management – this refers to the monitoring and improving the water
quality of the water bodies in the city.
3.
The baseline of the city was also compared to the national targets set in Philippine
Development Plan (PDP) 20217-2022, Department of Health (DOH) National Objectives for
Health (NOH) 2017-2022, Philippine Approach to Sustainable Sanitation (PhATSS) 2018-
2030, Philippine Water Supply and Sanitation Master Plan (PWSSMP) 2018-2040 and the
2030 UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) to determine the status of the city towards
meeting these targets.
1.2 Methodology
10
Local Government Code of 1991, Section 384.
2.2.1 Location
17.
The City of Zamboanga is a 1st class highly urbanized city (HUC) in the Zamboanga
Peninsula. It is in the southwestern-most part of Zamboanga Peninsula and within the
geographical coordinates of 6°54‟ North latitude and 122°4‟ East longitude. The city is
bounded by the Provinces of Zamboanga del Norte and Zamboanga Sibugay to the north,
Moro Gulf to the east, Basilan Island, Basilan Strait and Celebes Sea to the south, and Sulu
Sea to the west. Zamboanga City is approximately 505 nautical miles south of Manila, 365
nautical miles northeast of Kota Kinabalu, Malaysia, and 345 nautical miles northeast of
Manado, Indonesia. Figure 2-2 presents the location map of Zamboanga City.
19.
The City of Zamboanga has a total land area of 145,327.02 hectares. The general land use
in the city is categorized into forest, agriculture, water/fishery, urban use, and other uses.
During the period of 1997-2012, the forest covers about 88,991 hectares or 60 percent of
the total land area. It is followed by agriculture land use with 31,633 hectares (21%), and
urban use with 16,567 hectares (12%).
20.
In the proposed general land use of the city for 2016-2025, there was a significant reduction
on the allocated land area for forest and urban use. The decrease in the total forest area
and urban use is allocated for agriculture, water/fishery and other uses. Other uses in the
city include waterfront, lake, parks and recreational, salt bed/buffer/greenbelt, historical
preservation, and cemetery/memorial park. Table 2-2 presents the comparative land uses of
the city. Meanwhile, the general land uses maps are presented in Figure 2-3 and Figure
2-4, respectively.
21.
The urban land use in the city consists of residential, commercial, industrial, institutional,
ecozone, utilities/transport and tourism. There was about 17.5 percent decrease on the land
area dedicated for urban land use in 2016-2025. The proposed urban land use map of the
city is shown in Figure 2-5.
24.
Table 2-4 presents the recorded temperature normal from 1981 to 2010 with recorded mean
annual temperature of 28.3°C. The month of January recorded the coldest average
temperature of 27.9°C while the warmest average temperature recorded is in the months of
April and May at 28.8°C.
Table 2-4. Zamboanga Del Sur Station Temperature Normals (1981-2010)
Month Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun July Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Annual
Maximum
32.3 32.6 33 33.1 32.8 32.1 31.8 32.1 32.3 32.2 32.5 32.5 32.4
(°C)
Minimum
23.5 23.6 24 24.4 24.7 24.4 24.2 24.3 24.2 24 23.9 23.7 24.1
(°C)
Mean
27.9 28.1 28.5 28.8 28.8 28.2 28.0 28.2 28.3 28.1 28.2 28.1 28.3
(°C)
Source: Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration (PAGASA)
25.
Climatological extremes provide the highest or lowest values ever recorded in the location.
Table 2-5 presents the climatological extremes from Zamboanga Del Sur as of 2012.
Table 2-5. Zamboanga Del Sur Station Climatological Extremes (as of 2012)
Month Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun July Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Annual
Greatest Daily
128 156.5 79.6 106 88.9 123.5 140.4 136.6 193.2 199.1 163.3 161 199.1
Rainfall, mm
Highest
Temperature 35.5 35.5 36 36.9 36.1 36 35.2 35.7 35.8 36 35.5 35.2 36.9
(°C)
Source: Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration (PAGASA)
Morbidity
40.
Table 3-3 presents the ten leading causes of morbidity in Zamboanga City, including the
number of cases recorded from 2016 to 2020. For the past five years, acute gastroenteritis
(AGE) was recorded to be one of the leading causes of morbidity in the city. The occurrence
of AGE can be attributed to the lack of access to sanitary facilities in the city and due to poor
sanitation practices. Diarrhea was also observed to be one of the leading causes of
morbidity in 2016 and 2017.
Mortality
41.
Table 3-4 presents the ten leading causes of mortality in the city, including the number of
cases recorded from 2016 to 2020. As shown, AGE was also recorded to be one of the
leading causes of mortality in city in 2018 and 2019.
42.
A rotavirus outbreak happened in the city in 2016. Rotavirus usually spreads from fecal-oral
contact which usually happens because of poor hand-washing practices or from consuming
contaminated food or water. To stop the spread of the rotavirus, the CHO strengthened its
WASH IEC programs on proper hygiene practices and the importance of the use of sanitary
toilet facilities. The CHO also disinfected the groundwater sources of the households and
strictly monitored the quality of the drinking water from the service providers
6 Acute 3,015 Skin Diseases 4,230 Trauma 6,190 Hypertension 4,881 Acute 1,398
Gastroenteritis* Gastroenteritis*
7 Skin Diseases 2,135 Acute 2,154 Acute 6,085 Acute 3,717 Skin Diseases 1,221
Gastroenteritis Gastroenteritis* Gastroenteritis*
8 Urinary Tract 1,521 Diarrhea* 1,865 Tuberculosis 3,181 Tuberculosis 3,414 Tooth ache 1,113
Infection (all forms) (all forms)
9 Injuries 1,386 Injuries 1 683 Urinary Tract 2 121 Skin Diseases 3 081 Urinary Tract 586
Infection Infection
10 Diarrhea* 1,217 Headache 1 455 Dental caries 1 852 Type 2 1 350 Headache 558
Hypersensitivity
Reaction
Source: CHO 2020
*Can be due to poor sanitation
43.
The CHO is the primary health agency of the City Government of Zamboanga. The DOH-
licensed health care facilities in the city consist of 14 hospitals (6 government and 8 private),
17 birthing homes, 13 institution-based clinical laboratories (2 government and 11 private)
and five private free-standing facilities (see Table 2-11). There are also 99 barangay health
centers in the city.
2.41 Flooding
44.
Based on the study conducted by Department of Environment and Natural Resources
(DENR) Mines and Geosciences Bureau, at least 77 barangays in the city are highly
susceptible to flooding. These barangays are located mostly in coastal areas. In addition,
five river systems greatly contribute to flooding in the city namely, Tumaga River, Putik
River, Culianan River, San Jose Gusu River, and Vitali River.
45.
The areas within the city center are also susceptible to flooding due to its low-lying elevation
of five meters above mean sea level. Table 2-13 presents the list of affected areas by
flooding of the river systems, while Figure 2-9 shows the landslide and flood susceptible
map of the city.
2.4.3 Tsunami
48.
The Philippine Institute of Volcanology and Seismology (PHIVOLCS) identified Zamboanga
City as one of the tsunami prone areas in the country. Portions of the 80 barangays in the
city are prone to tsunami. Coastal barangays may experience tsunami from 2 kilometers
(km) to 5 km landward. The waves may also reach up to the Central Business District area.
This hazard can cause damage to the coastal settlements, business, commercial,
institutional buildings, and educational establishments.
Seasonal temperature increases (in °C) in 2020 and 2050 under medium-range emission scenario in provinces in
Region 9
OBSERVED BASELINE (1971-2000) CHANGE IN 2020 (2006-2035) CHANGE IN 2050 (2036-2065)
DJF MAM JJA SON DJF MAM JJA SON DJF MAM JJA SON
Region 9
ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE 27.0 27.9 27.6 27.5 1.0 1.1 1.1 1.0 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.0
ZAMBOANGA DEL SUR 26.8 27.6 27.3 27.2 0.9 1.1 1.0 1.0 1.9 2.1 2.0 1.9
ZAMBOANGA SIBUGAY 27.1 27.9 27.5 27.5 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 2.0 2.0 1.9 2.0
Seasonal rainfall change (in %) in 2020 and 2050 under medium-range emission scenario in provinces in Region 9
OBSERVED BASELINE (1971-2000) CHANGE IN 2020 (2006-2035) CHANGE IN 2050 (2036-2065)
DJF MAM JJA SON DJF MAM JJA SON DJF MAM JJA SON
Region 9
ZAMBOANGA DEL
324.5 279.7 599.1 718.1 11.0 3.2 -3.2 13.8 2.6 1.7 -0.7 5.4
NORTE
ZAMBOANGA DEL SUR 294.5 298.7 593.8 663.2 11.2 2.2 -0.4 13.8 3.6 0.0 9.9 7.1
ZAMBOANGA SIBUGAY 284.1 290.5 597.2 674.1 9.9 6.6 6.5 14.8 4.8 10.3 22.0 8.9
Frequency of extreme events in 2020 and 2050 under medium-range emission scenario in provinces in Region 9
NO. OF DAYS W/ Tmax > NO. OF DAYS W/ RAINFALL >
NO. OF DRY DAYS
PROVINCES STATIONS 35°C 300mm
OBS 2020 2050 OBS 2020 2050 OBS 2020 2050
ZAMBOANGA DEL Dipolog
217 2155 4004 7481 5384 5470 0 5 2
NORTE
ZAMBOANGA DEL SUR Zamboanga 54 114 714 8531 7058 6781 0 1 4
Sources PAG-ASA
11
Based on the accomplished validation of CHO in 2019
Table 3-2: Total Number of Active Service Connections per Classification (as of 2020)
Barangay Commer Governm Industr Residen Semi- ZCWD
cial ent ial tial commercial Facility
Ayala 135 12 2 1,761 32 3
Baliwasan 152 16 3 1,956 73 1
Baluno - 3 - 117 - -
Boalan 26 3 - 558 6 1
Cabaluay 24 3 - 550 6 1
Cabatangan 23 18 - 1,345 3 2
Cacao 2 2 - 105 - -
Calarian 123 31 - 2,648 35 -
Source: ZCWD
Figure 3-4: Annual Water Production of the Water Sources of ZCWD
68.
Based on the hazard susceptibility maps of Zamboanga City, the production wells and water
systems of ZCWD are susceptible to flooding, landslide and prone to tsunami.
Other water service providers
69.
The water sources of the other water service providers in the city are shown in Table 3-5.
70.
The WRS source their water from their own deep wells. However, some WRS operate their
deep well without securing the permit to operate from the Department of Health (DOH).
90.
The following are the functions of the members of the ZCWSC.
Collaborates with concerned government and non-government agencies, water service
providers, and stakeholders in crafting the Zamboanga City Water Security Master Plan
and the Zamboanga City Septage Management Plan.
Review and recommend to the Local Chief Executive (LCE) and the City Legislative
Council relevant and responsive policies, strategies, guidelines and innovations on water
supply and sanitation development and management that‟s serve as bases in
establishing the targets and directions for water and sanitation expansion and
improvement [programs along the following thematic areas of concerns.
o Water recharge area restoration, protection and management (watershed area
protection)
o Water resources protection, development, and management (source
development, water supply systems)
o Renewable water resources (i.e., rainwater harvesting, surface runoff)
o Water conservation and efficiency
o Wastewater and sewage treatment and re-use
o Septage management
o Point and non-point water pollution
o Water remediation and rehabilitation
o Water supply and sanitations services in emergencies
13
Based on the accomplished validation of CHO in 2019
Based on the survey, about 80.5 percent (74.4% owned, 6.1% shared) of the households
have septic tanks. The following are the existing conditions of the septic tanks in the city
based on the survey.
About 64 percent are water-tight or has concrete bottom while 35 percent are
bottomless.
Majority of the septic tanks (73%) do not have an outlet for the overflow or are
bottomless in which the waste is being seeped underground.
More than half (56.70%) of the existing septic tanks has one chamber only, about
42 percent have two chambers while less than one percent have more than three
chambers.
About 76 percent has septic tanks with manhole and 24 percent does not have
manhole provided.
About 84 percent of the septic tanks are accessible; 81 percent are located
outside the house and 3 percent located inside the house
2021 Household Sanitation Survey Results – Willingness to Install Sanitary Toilet
Facilities
About 73 percent of the households that do not have their own sanitary toilet facilities are
willing to construct their own facility. However, 19 percent of the households who were
willing said that they do not have enough space within their property to construct the
sanitary toilet facility.
The households that are not willing to construct their own sanitary toilet facilities had the
following reasons:
No available space within the property (46.7%)
Do not have enough budget (41.6%)
Do not own the land or house (11.2%)
Informal settler (4.5%)
Majority (76%) of the households are willing to install a new septic tank or to retrofit their
existing septic tanks to comply to the standards of the DOH. However, about 9.5 percent
of the willing households do not have available space within their property.
The following were the reasons why the households are not willing to install a new septic
tank or retrofit their existing septic tanks:
No available space within the property (19.6%)
Do not have enough budget (54.3%)
Do not own the land or house (10.1%)
Informal settler (15.9%)
About 74 percent of the households never emptied their septic tank or a new septic tank
has been constructed once full. Meanwhile, the remaining 27 percent had desludged their
septic tank in the past years.
Majority or about 31 percent observed desludging of their septic tanks every two years
and 21 percent desludge their septic tanks every year. Other desludging frequencies are
every three, four, and five years. About six percent claimed that their septic tank is being
emptied every more than five years.
In terms of the cost of desludging, majority claimed that they paid for less than Php 5,000
per desludging activity. About six percent claimed that they spent more than Php 15,000
for the desludging services.
Table 3-13: Existing Local Policies on On-site sanitation facilities and WASH in
emergencies
Local Ordinance Features
City Ordinance No. 500 – The Sanitation
All dwelling, houses and buildings shall be
Code of Zamboanga provided with suitable kind and number of
privy accommodations.
City Ordinance No. 2009-153 – Septage The ordinance requires that all water
Management System Ordinance users that are discharging below 40 cubic
meters of sewage per day shall have at
least two-closed chamber septic tank; 41
to 500 cubic meters of sewage per day
shall have at least three-closed chamber
septic tank and 501 to 1,000 cubic meters
shall have at least five-closed chamber
with pond. All establishments that
generate more than 1,000 cubic meters
shall have its own wastewater treatment
facility or shall have an existing contract
of service with any duly accredited
wastewater treatment facility.
Majority or about 46 percent of the households were discharging their domestic wastewater
directly to their own septic tank. Other households discharge their wastewater directly to their
backyard/ground, to the municipal drainage canal, to the nearby bodies of water, and to a
shared septic tank. About two percent discharge their wastewater to a city sewer lines It was
noted during the survey that there are no existing canals in some barangays. Based on the
interview, there are areas with no existing drainage outfalls.
Outfall of existing
6°54'11.89" 122° 4'13.11"
sewerage system
(1) Downstream
(2) Drainage
(4) Upstream
(10) Downstream
(11) Upstream
(12) Upstream
14
DENR-EMB Region IX
3.3.4 Current Programs, Projects and Activities for Wastewater, Sewage and
Drainage Management
121.
Sewerage systems in barangays Rio Hondo and Mariki are being constructed. The
sewerage system in Rio Hondo will serve about 2,500 households and will have an STP
with capacity of 1,500 cubic meters per day. The project is funded by the Local Water
Utilities Administration (LWUA) as part of the Zamboanga City Roadmap to Recover and
Reconstruction (Z3R) Plan.
122.
A combined septage and sewage treatment plant is also being constructed to serve Vale
Vista Subdivision in Brgy. Kasanyangan. The project will serve about 3,920 households with
design capacity of 2,500 cubic meters per day.
123.
A combined septage and sewage treatment plant in Magay will also be constructed by
ZCWD. It will serve barangays Zone 1 to IV, Santa Catalina, Camino Nuevo, Canelar, Santo
Nino and San Jose Cawa-Cawa. The treatment facility will have a capacity of 4,000 cubic
meters per day.
124.
In terms of improving the drainage system in the city, the projects implemented by DPWH
Region IX in the city are presented in Table 3-18. The DPWH Region IX also developed a
master plan for the drainage and flood control in the urban core and central areas in
Zamboanga City.
Collection
129.
As shown in Table 3-20, the City Government, through OCENR, and the barangay units
share the responsibility in collecting the solid wastes from the households.
130.
The shared collection services scheme collects from 40 barangays with an average
collection rate of 235 tons per day. About 75 percent of the wastes collected are from
residential, 5 percent are commercial waste, 8 percent are market wastes and 11.5 percent
are recyclables.
131.
The city designated 22 regular waste collection routes to serve the core area, and an
additional 12 waste collection schedules are used for the expansion area.
Table 3-20: Shared Collection Services in Zamboanga City
Shared Collection Services
Barangays Waste
Provision of Brgy. Trucks
Collection Manpower Coverage
fuel & Status
Vehicle
OCENR OCENR OCENR Main Road
Baliwasan 2 running;
Remaining
Barangay Barangay Barangay 1 Barangay;
Areas
1 Private
OCENR Barangay Barangay Main Road
Calarian
Barangay Barangay Barangay 2 running Entire Brgy
Camino Nuevo OCENR OCENR OCENR Entire Brgy
Campo Islam OCENR OCENR OCENR Entire Brgy
OCENR OCENR OCENR Main Road
Canelar
OCENR Barangay Barangay Interior
Divisoria OCENR OCENR OCENR along hi-way
Guiwan OCENR OCENR OCENR Main Road
Transfer
132.
While the final closure is on-going, the Lumbangan Controlled Disposal Facility is being
used as a temporary transfer station to store wastes that are collected at night.
133.
The City Government allocated Php 20 Million to construct transfer station facilities in the
west and east coasts of the city.
Waste Diversion
134.
Currently, the City Government operates five material recovery facilities (MRF) located in
Bagsakan Center (Sta. Cruz Market), Main Public Market (Magay), City Abattoir (San
Roque), Lumbangan Controlled Disposal Facility, and Sanitary Landfill Facility-MRF
(Salaan).
135.
All the city MRFs have installed a total of 152 units of 2-tonner rotary stainless steel
composter drums with bioreactor that is donated by the Villar Foundation to produce sun-
dried compost. The sun-dried composts are packaged and sold to the local farmers. The
maximum amount of biodegradable wastes that the facilities can process is 34.5 tons per
day.
Final Disposal
140.
An existing 10.6-hectare Sanitary Landfill Facility (SLF) in Barangay Salaan is owned and
operated by the City Government of Zamboanga. Based on the design, the SLF will have a
total of six cells. Each cell has a minimum lifespan of three years that can accommodate
292,000 cubic meters of wastes based on the estimated average disposal rate of 200 tons
per day.
141.
At present, two disposal cells are already operating. Cell No. 1 is being operated since
March 2015. An additional cell, Cell No. 2, has been constructed and operational since 2019
to cater the city‟s final disposal for the next three years.
142.
The City also plans to establish waste-to-energy facilities in order to recycle, reuse and treat
all wastes, to reduce the demand for landfill space and to reduce potential environmental
risk of land filling.
5
4 Spillway (B)
3
WQGV (Class B & C)
2
1
0
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Mercedes River
36
31 Downstream (B)
26
Quarrying Site (B)
21
mg/L
1
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Patalon River
9
8.5
San Ramon Bridge (B)
8
7.5
PCA Compound (B)
7
mg/L
Saaz River
Source: DENR-EMB Region IX
Figure 3-16: Annual Trend of Average DO Concentration in the Priority Rivers
20 Spillway (B)
15
WQGV (Class B)
10
WQGV (Class C)
5
0
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Mercedes River
6
Downstream (B)
5
Quarrying Site (B)
4
200 m from Upper
mg/L
3 Patalon (A)
Upper Patalon (A)
2
WQGV (Class A)
1
WQGV (Class B)
0
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Patalon River
5.5
5 San Ramon Bridge (B)
4.5
4 PCA Compound (B)
3.5
Approx 2 km from PCA
3
mg/L
Compound (A)
2.5
Approx 500 m from
2 sta 3 (A)
1.5 WQGV (Class A)
1
0.5 WQGV (Class B)
0
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Saaz River
Source: DENR-EMB Region IX
Figure 3-17: Annual Trend of Average BOD Concentration in the Priority Rivers
60 Spillway (B)
40 WGQV (Class B)
20 WGQV (Class C)
0
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Mercedes River
70000
Downstream (B)
60000
Quarrying Site (B)
50000
Patalon (A)
30000 Upper Patalon (A)
20000
WQGV (Class A)
10000
WGQV (Class B)
0
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Patalon River
110
100 San Ramon Bridge
90
80 PCA Compound
70
Approx 2 km from PCA
60
mg/L
Compound
50
Approx 500 m from
40 sta 3
30 WQGV (Class A)
20
10 WGQV (Class B)
0
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Saaz River
Table 6-3: SWOT Matrix for WASH in Emergencies
Strengths (S)
Policies P
Local Climate Change Action Plan 2016-2030
Local Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Plan 2019-2022
On-going formulation of Zamboanga City Resilience Plan In
Institutional Framework
All barangays have DRRM committees
WASH in Emergencies
Capacity Building
Trained personnel on emergency health and sanitation In
Infrastructure and Programs
Has designated evacuation centers in the city
Available mobile water treatment unit
Provision of hygiene kits during emergency
Opportunities (O) Strength-Opportunity Strategies
Technical assistance from international agencies (i.e., USAID Enhance collaboration and partnerships with the private sector,
SURGE) donors, national government, academic institutions, NGOs for the
Partnership with private sectors and NGOs provision of WASH services during emergency situations.
Sanitation programs from funding donors/banks (i.e., DBP) Consider external support from international agencies and funding
donor/banks in the implementation of WASH-related PPAs in the
LCCAP and LDRRMP
Tap private sectors and NGOs in the provision of hygiene kits
during emergencies
Threat (T) Strength-Threat Strategies
Sustaining the interest and priority of the LGU Enhance BDRRMP of barangays by integrating the provision of
Changes in administration and leadership WASH services during emergencies
Lack of political commitment Institutionalize the provision of WASH facilities during emergencies
Lack of participation of BLGUs through formulation and enforcement of local policies.
Impacts of climate change to the sanitation facilities
Cultural behavior
Table 6-4: SWOT Matrix for Wastewater, Sewage and Drainage Managemen
Strengths (S)
Wastewater/Sewage W
Infrastructure In
Presence of existing sewer line in the city
Available ZCWD sewage pumping stations
On-going construction of sewage treatment plants in Magay, Rio Hondo
and Vale Vista IE
On-going rehabilitation and expansion of the existing sewer lines in
Magay
Wastewater, Sewage and Drainage Management Drainage P
Infrastructure
Availability of drainage system within the city proper D
In
Opportunities (O) Strength-Opportunity Strategies
Implementation Philippine Water Supply and Sanitation Wastewater/Sewage W
Enhance collaboration and partnerships with the private sector, donors,
Master Plan to increase demand for sewerage services
national government, academic institutions, NGOs for the
National sanitation programs (i.e., NSSMP, LWUA)
implementation of sewerage projects, studies, promotion, and capacity
Technical assistance from international agencies (i.e., USAID SURGE,
building
ADB)
Establish partnerships with private sectors, NGOs, academic institutions
Sanitation programs from funding donors/banks (i.e., DBP)
and other stakeholders for the reuse of the sanitation residuals
Possible additional revenues from treated effluent and bio-solids reuse
Integrate the sanitation residual processing and recovery in the design
of the STPs
Drainage
Seek technical and financial assistance from international agencies and
funding donors/banks for the rehabilitation, improvement, expansion of
the existing city drainage network D