Studii Cvasi-Experimentale
Studii Cvasi-Experimentale
Studii Cvasi-Experimentale
ABSTRACT Asperger’s syndrome, and pervasive devel- take on additional responsibilities such
opmental disorders.2 It can be identified as household chores.11 This, however, can
Being a typically developing sibling to a
child with autism spectrum disorder (ASD- by the early onset of impairments in social be a source of emotional distress.10 More-
Sib) can be associated with several behav- communication and repetitive, restricted, over, the need for long-term specialized
ioral and mental health problems. With this or unusual sensory-motor behaviors.2,3 Such therapy makes autism costly for parents.12
understanding, researchers are beginning behavioral repertoires a child with ASD pos- It is also likely that parents who have to
to focus on sibling-oriented interventions. sess can be an overwhelming experience care for a child with autism might not be
This review seeks to evaluate the current lit- and might impact each member of the fam- able to spend much time with the other
erature on such interventions. We searched ily. This can affect various domains of their sibling and much of their attention is
digital databases and identified eight
lives, including mental health, physical inadvertently concentrated on the child
relevant studies. The sample (n = 247) had an
health, finances, housekeeping, quality of with autism.10 Thus, having a sibling with
age range of 4–16 years. The outcomes were
generally positive, with improvements in relationships, and lifestyle.4,5 ASD can, directly and indirectly, impact
different facets of ASD-Sibs. Results differed The behavior and caregiving load might the ASD-Sibs’ mental health7 and quality
due to varied intervention styles, outcome particularly cause additional problems of life.13 Consequently, the relationship
variables, methods, and samples. Our find- with the typically developing brothers between the typically developing siblings
ings highlight the potential for improvement and sisters. Siblings of children with any (TDS) and ASD siblings might also be
in ASD-Sib’s knowledge of autism and their disability, including ASD, are more prone strained.14–16 This, in turn, can also affect
psychological functioning and hence call for to develop emotional, adjustment, and the prognosis and social functioning of
further research with robust methods.
behavioral problems than their peers.5–9 the ASD child.
Keywords: Autism spectrum disorder, Barak-Levy et al. found that children who Though the siblings’ role in the treat-
typically developing siblings, Asperger’s have siblings with autism have lower par- ment and training process of children
syndrome, sibling-oriented interventions ticipation in peer activities, poor relations with ASD has been well acknowledged
A
utism Spectrum Disorders (ASD) are with friends, and poorer school perfor- and evaluated in the literature,14,15,17
a set of varied groups of conditions mance and that such children have higher empirical literature focusing on inter-
affecting about one in every 100 scores on measures of responsibility.10 To ventions directed towards the TDS,
children.1 ASD includes autistic disorder, support their parents, the siblings often despite their well-acknowledged need,
1
National Drug-Dependence Treatment Centre and Dept. of Psychiatry, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India. 2Dept. of Psychiatry & NDDTC, All
India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India. 3Dept. of Clinical Psychology, Amity University, Punjab, India.
HOW TO CITE THIS ARTICLE: Godara K, Patil V and Phakey N. When a Sibling Has Autism: Narrative Review of Interventions for
Typically Developing Siblings. Indian J Psychol Med. 2023;XX:1–7.
Address for correspondence: Vaibhav Patil, Dept. of Psychiatry and National Drug Submitted: 15 Oct. 2022
Dependence Treatment Centre, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Ansari Accepted: 26 Apr. 2023
Nagar, New Delhi 110029, India. Published Online: xxxx
E-mail: [email protected]
Creative Commons Non Commercial CC BY-NC: This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative ACCESS THIS ARTICLE ONLINE
Commons Attribution- NonCommercial 4.0 License (http://www.creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/)
Website: journals.sagepub.com/home/szj
which permits non-Commercial use, reproduction and distribution of the work without further permission
provided the original work is attributed as specified on the Sage and Open Access pages (https:// DOI: 10.1177/02537176231176404
us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/open-access-at-sage).
Sample Characteristics
A total of 247 (age = 4-16) TDS, older or
younger than the sibling with autism,
participated in these studies. Most
studies (n = 6) comprised only siblings,
whereas two also included parents. Four
studies were conducted in Europe,19,20,22,24
three in North America,21,25,26 and one
was from Australia.23 The focus broadly
TABLE 2.
(Table 2 continued)
However, there was no improvement knowledge of the autism spectrum. The 15 siblings from 14 families. The study
in feelings of resentment or anger. findings suggested improved knowl- observed a marked improvement in
A noted limitation was the lack of a edge; however, the study lacked a control the depression and anxiety levels of the
control group.26 Cooke and Semmens19 group. Also, quantitative results have not siblings. Moreover, the peer networks of
utilized an 8-session workshop-based been reported. Cooke and Semmens19 and the siblings also improved.21
support group on 12 siblings of children Kryzak et al.21 developed and evaluated a In their hybrid intervention, Gettings
with ASD to assess the improvement in 7-week Support and Skills Program on et al.22 administered four face-to-face and
4 Indian Journal of Psychological Medicine | Volume XX | Issue X | XXXX-XXXX 2023
Review Article
TABLE 3.
cognitive restructuring, psychoeduca-
tion, relaxation, problem-solving, and
Measurement Instrument Used in the Studies. self-acceptance, yielded positive results.
Domain Instrument (Abbreviation) Study Findings revealed marked improvement
Knowledge about autism Sibling Knowledge Interview (SKI) Granat et al., 2011 in knowledge of autism and a significant
Autism sibling knowledge Kryzak et al., 2015 reduction in adjustment difficulties in
the experimental group.24 In their RCT,
Knowledge of autism syndrome Brouzos et al., 2017
Jones et al.25 assigned 98 participants to
Mental health, behavioral, Achenbach child behavior checklist Jones et al., 2020;
and emotional problems Smith & Perry, 2005
a support group and an attention-only
group to improve the mental health
The strengths and difficulties Brouzos et al., 2017;
questionnaire (SDQ) Gettings et al., 2015 of the TDS. The support group (n = 24)
was administered a 10-week interven-
The strengths and difficulties Roberts et al., 2015
questionnaire—Parent Version tion. The findings showed significant
Child behavior checklist (filled by a Jones et al., 2020
improvement in the coping skills and
parent). management of externalizing symptoms
The brief developmental behaviour Roberts et al., 2015 in the intervention group as compared to
checklist the control.25
Children’s depression inventory (CDI) Jones et al., 2020;
Kryzak et al., 2015 Discussion
Revised children’s manifest anxiety Jones et al., 2020; ASD in a child can significantly and
scale Kryzak et al., 2015
detrimentally affect family members, par-
Profile of neuropsychiatric symptoms Gettings et al., 2015 ticularly the other siblings.4,5,13–15 While
Autism severity Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS) Jones et al., 2020 some literature demonstrates positive
Self-esteem and concept Piers-Harris children’s self-concept Smith & Perry, 2005 experiences of ASD-Sibs,29 they might also
scale face adverse outcomes such as decreased
The Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale Roberts et al., 2015 parental attention10; increase in nega-
(RSES; Rosenberg, 1989). tive life events (e.g., parents divorcing)30;
Sibling relationship The Sibling Relationship Questionnaire Granat et al., 2011; having to handle repetitive, unpredict-
(SRQ) Roberts et al., 2015 able, and aggressive behaviors of siblings,
Quality of life Paediatric Quality of Life Inventory Gettings et al., 2015 and elevated responsibilities.29 These
Support The Social Support Scale for Children Roberts et al., 2015 issues can increase stress and mental
(SSSC) health issues, including greater emo-
Support (self-developed questions). Jones et al., 2020 tional and/or behavioral problems and
Coping The Self-report Coping Scale (SRCS) Roberts et al., 2015 symptoms of anxiety and depression.21,29
Coping/adjustment scale Brouzos et al., 2017; Despite these well-documented poten-
Smith & Perry, 2005 tial risks for the siblings, there is limited
Children’s coping strategies checklist Jones et al., 2020 evidence-based literature focusing on
ameliorating these adverse outcomes.
This review synthesized the current
literature19,21–27 focusing on the interven-
four telemedicine sessions to six siblings intervention to 36 siblings of children tions for TDS of children with ASD. The
and their parents. The authors developed with various disabilities, particularly commonly studied interventions are
support group sessions that improved autism and other related disorders such support groups and psychoeducation.
communication between the siblings as attention deficit hyperactivity disor- Most studies comprised only siblings,
and with other family members as well. der (ADHD), global developmental delay, while a few studies also included parents
Additionally their knowledge improved etc. Findings revealed fewer behavioral for the intervention. Support groups
with psychoeducation, reducing their and emotional difficulties in the siblings’ aimed at providing the siblings social
concerns regarding their siblings, and group receiving the intervention. The support, along with psychoeducation
coping mechanisms improved, too. The positive results were sustained at three- to improve the knowledge of disability.
main strengths of the study were month follow-up.23 Though most interventions were deliv-
qualitative inquiry as well as the use Brouzos et al.24 developed and ered face to face, Gettings et al.22 found
of audio-conferencing. However, the examined the effectiveness of a psycho- audioconferencing an acceptable, feasi-
results are not generalizable, given the educational intervention on 38 siblings ble, and effective method of facilitating
small size.22 Roberts et al.23 used an exper- of children with ASD, intending to sibling support groups. The findings were
imental design to evaluate the SibwokrS improve their psychosocial adjustment/ generally positive, and most studies
program, i.e., a manual-based cognitive- coping and knowledge about autism. The showed marked improvement in knowl-
behavioral program that spanned six eight-week program, encompassing com- edge of autism followed by various facets
weeks. The authors administered the ponents such as emotional education, such as adjustment, coping, emotional