Nita Listiyaningtyas 10202244082

DESIGNING AN ENGLISH STORYBOOK WITH STICKY PICTURES
FOR THE TEACHING OF LISTENING AND SPEAKING

FOR GRADE V OF ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS
A Thesis
Presented as a Partial Fulfillment of the Requirement for the Attainment of

the Sarjana Pendidikan Degree in the English Language Education
By
Nita Listiyaningtyas
10202244082
ENGLISH EDUCATION DEPARTMENT

FACULTY OF LANGUAGES AND ARTS
YOGYAKARTA STATE UNIVERSITY
2015
A Thesis
Presented as a Partial Fulfillment of the Requirement for the Attainment of

the Sarjana Pendidikan Degree in the English Language Education
By
10202244082
ENGLISH EDUCATION DEPARTMENT

FACULTY OF LANGUAGES AND ARTS
YOGYAKARTA STATE UNIVERSITY
2015
i
ii
iii
iv
DEDICATIONS
I dedicate this thesis to:
My beloved parents, Sri Purwanti and Tugiman,
and my brother, Yudi Desopera Setyawan.
v
MOTTOS
“Bacalah dengan (menyebut) nama Tuhanmu Yang menciptakan.”

(QS. Al-‘Alaq: 1)
“Mencari ilmu itu adalah wajib

bagi setiap muslim laki-laki maupun muslim perempuan.”
(HR. Ibnu Abdil Barr)
“Dream, believe, and make it happen.”

(Agnes Monica)
“All our dreams can come true,

if we have the courage to pursue them.”
(Walt Disney Company)
“Everything you need to be great is already inside you.

Stop waiting for someone or something to light your fire.
You have the match.”
(Darren Hardy)
vi
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Alhamdulillahirobbil’alamin, all praise is to Allah SWT, the Almighty and

the most Merciful who has always given His blessings, so that I could accomplish
this thesis.
This thesis would have never been completed without the guidance and
support from the following special people:
1. My supervisor, Dra. Nury Supriyanti, M.A., for the guidance, corrections,
help, suggestions, and of course support during the process of this thesis.
2. My consultants, Niken Anggraeni, M.A., Ani Setyaningsih, M.Pd., and Siti
Sudartini, M.A., for the help and suggestion related to my thesis and my
product.
3. The English teachers and the students of grade V Ibnu Tufail SD
Muhammadiyah Demangan for the cooperation and help during the
observation and implementation.
4. My beloved parents, Sri Purwanti and Tugiman, for always reminding and
supporting me every time.
5. My beloved brother, Yudi Desopera Setyawan, for always reminding me to
write my thesis, accompanying me in writing my thesis until night, taking
care of me, and supporting me all the time.
6. My best partner, Ririn Susetyaningsih, S.S., for the care, help, suggestion,
and motivation from senior high school until now.
7. My classmates of PBI J 2010, Danisia Puji Wahyuni, S.Pd., Intan Wahyu
Saputri, S.Pd., Amalia Izzati Nur Shabrina, S.Pd., Dwi Annisa Rahmawati,
S.Pd., Yheni Siwi Utami, S.Pd., Febri Anita Allatif, Winda Presti Mawarsih,
S.Pd., Dimas Syaefan, Afif Dwi Cahyanta, S.Pd., for the warm friendship,
beautiful memories, supports, and cares for the last four years.
8. My classmates of English for Children concentration, Saras Dhona Septia,
S.Pd., Erika Yulia Puspitasari, S.Pd., Pamela Yeni Purwastri, S.Pd., Meta
Swasti Naraswari, Sita Arista Wulan Sari, S.Pd., M. Yusuf Arif Nur Rahmat,
vii
Zida Malichah, S.Pd., Dita Arintia, Risty Primaningsih, S.Pd., Ayu Kurnia,
Padmaningtyas Wulan Sari, for the amazing moments, great cooperation,
support, and care since we met in the concentration class and worked together
during the Fun English Club 2014.
9. My senior high school’s best friends, Muhammad Faiq, Mahdi Erwin
Santosa, S.H., Pangki Anggit Wirakusuma, S.H., Tangguh Amandiri, and
Arwan Robikhan, S.H., for always asking my thesis’ progress.
10. My amazing friend, Rahma Fitriana, for the support, advice, help and prayer
since we met and worked together in EDSA.
11. My other friends in PBI J, EFC concentration, and EDSA who I cannot
mention one by one.
I realize that this thesis is far from being perfect. Thus, any criticisms and
suggestions for the improvement of this thesis are greatly appreciated.
Yogyakarta, 25 January 2015

The writer,
viii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TITLE .............................................................................................................. i
APPROVAL SHEET ...................................................................................... ii
RATIFICATION ............................................................................................. iii
PERNYATAAN .............................................................................................. iv
DEDICATIONS .............................................................................................. v
MOTTOS ........................................................................................................ vi
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ............................................................................. vii
TABLE OF CONTENTS ............................................................................... ix
LIST OF TABLES ........................................................................................ xiv
LIST OF FIGURES ...................................................................................... xvi
ABSTRACT ................................................................................................... xvii
CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION .................................................................... 1
A. Background of the Problems .................................................................... 1
B. Identification of the Problems .................................................................. 4
C. Limitation of the Problems ....................................................................... 6
D. Formulation of the Problems .................................................................... 7
E. Objective of the Research ........................................................................ 7
F. Significance of the Research ................................................................... 7
CHAPTER II LITERATURE REVIEW AND CONCEPTUAL

FRAMEWORK ................................................................................................ 9
A. Literature Review ..................................................................................... 9
1. English Teaching and Learning for Children ....................................... 9
a. Children Characteristics.................................................................. 9
ix
b. Teaching English as a Foreign Language to Children ................... 14
2. The Use of Stories in Language Teaching ........................................... 16
a. The Nature of Stories ..................................................................... 16
b. The Benefits of Using Stories in Language Teaching ................... 16
c. Selecting the Stories ...................................................................... 19
d. TPR in Activities ........................................................................... 20
3. Material Development for Children..................................................... 21
4. Developing Story-Based Activities ..................................................... 22
a. The Principles for Planning Story-Based Work ............................ 22
b. The Components of the Story-Based Activities ............................ 23
5. Teaching Listening and Speaking for Children ................................... 24
a. The Nature of Listening for Children ............................................ 24
b. The Nature of Speaking for Children ............................................ 28
c. Integrated Listening and Speaking for Children ............................ 31
B. Conceptual Framework ........................................................................... 31
CHAPTER III RESEARCH METHOD ....................................................... 33
A. The Type of the Research ........................................................................ 33
B. The Subjects of the Research .................................................................. 33
C. The Research Setting ............................................................................... 34
D. Research Instruments............................................................................... 35
1. Data Instruments ................................................................................ 35
a. Interview ...................................................................................... 35
b. Questionnaire ............................................................................... 36
c. Observation.................................................................................. 42
2. The Validity and Reliability of the Instruments ................................ 42
x
E. The Research Procedure .......................................................................... 43
F. Data Collection Techniques .................................................................... 46
G. Data Analysis Techniques ....................................................................... 47
CHAPTER IV RESEARCH FINDINGS AND DISCUSSION ................... 49
A. Research Findings ................................................................................... 49
1. The Needs Analysis ........................................................................... 49
a. The Result of the Interview with Children .................................. 51
1. The Characteristics of the Children ....................................... 51
2. Description of the Children’s Needs ..................................... 52
b. The Result of the Questionnaire for the English Teacher ........... 57
c. The Result of the Questionnaire for the Parents .......................... 58
2. The Couse Grid.................................................................................. 61
a. Planning ....................................................................................... 61
b. Adapting the Stories .................................................................... 61
c. Developing the Course Grid ........................................................ 62
d. The Description of the Course Grid of

Storybook with Sticky Pictures ................................................... 65
1. Unit 1: “The Thomas Family” ............................................... 65
2. Unit 2: “Mr. Page’s Pet Shop” .............................................. 66
3. Unit 3: “Why Anansi Has Thin Legs” ................................... 67
3. The Format of the Activities.............................................................. 68
a. The Course Grid, Media, and Teacher’s Guide Book ................. 68
b. The Outlines of the Storybook with Sticky Pictures

and the Teacher’s Guide Book .................................................... 70
xi
c. The Descriptions of the Storybook with Sticky Pictures
and the Teacher’s Guide Book ................................................... 72
1. Unit 1: “The Thomas Family” ............................................... 72
2. Unit 2: “Mr. Page’s Pet Shop” .............................................. 74
3. Unit 3: “Why Anansi Has Thin Legs” ................................... 76
4. Evaluation and Revision of the First Draft of

the Storybook with Sticky Pictures ................................................. 77
a. The Evaluation............................................................................. 78
1. Respondents’ Comments and Suggestions ............................ 78
b. The Revision ................................................................................ 79
5. Implementation, Evaluation and Revision of the

Second Draft of the Storybook with Sticky Pictures ....................... 82
a. Implementation of the Second Draft of the

Storybook with Sticky Pictures .................................................. 82
b. Evaluation of the Second Draft of the

Storybook with Sticky Pictures .................................................. 86
1. Comment and Feedback from the Children........................... 86
2. The Result of the Questionnaire for the Respondents ........... 90
a. The Respondents’ Opinion .............................................. 90
b. Respondents’ Comments and Suggestions ...................... 93
3. The Revision .......................................................................... 93
B. Discussion................................................................................................ 95
CHAPTER V CONCLUSIONS, IMPLICATIONS, AND

RECOMMENDATIONS ................................................................................. 99
A. Conclusions .............................................................................................. 99
B. Implications ............................................................................................ 101
xii
C. Recommendations .................................................................................. 102
REFERENCES ............................................................................................... 106
APPENDICES ................................................................................................ 108
A. Research Instruments.............................................................................. 109
B. Data of the Children and Respondents ................................................... 136
C. The Course Grid ..................................................................................... 139
D. The Storybook with Sticky Pictures ....................................................... 149
E. The First Draft of the Teacher’s Guide Book ......................................... 161
F. The Second Draft of the Teacher’s Guide Book ................................... 184
G. The Final Draft of the Teacher’s Guide Book ....................................... 239
H. Computation of the Data Evaluation ...................................................... 316
I. Interview Transcripts .............................................................................. 327
J. Field Notes.............................................................................................. 335
K. Photographs ............................................................................................ 339
L. Research Permits .................................................................................... 343
xiii
LIST OF TABLES
Table Page
Table 1: Stages in Planning Story-Based Work …………………… 22
Table 2: Input of Different Learning Channels ……………………. 26
Table 3: The Organization of the First Interview
(Need Analysis) for Students …………………………….. 35
Table 4: The Organization of the Second Interview
(Evaluation) for Students ……………………………….... 36
Table 5: The Organization of the Need Analysis Questionnaire
for Students ………………………………………………. 36
for English Teachers ……………………………………… 38
for Parents ………………………………………………… 38
Table 8: The Organization of the Evaluation Questionnaire
for Students ………………………………………………. 39
Table 9: The Organization of the Evaluation Questionnaire
for English Teachers and Experts ………………………… 41
Table 10: Data Conversion Table …………………………………… 48
Table 11: The Results of the Needs Analysis from
the Open-Ended Questionnaire for English Teacher ……... 57
xiv
Table 12: The Results of the Needs Analysis from
the Questionnaire for Parents …………………………….. 59
Table 13: The Components of the Course Grid …………………….. 62
Table 14: The Outline of the Storybook with Sticky Pictures …….... 70
Table 15: The Outline of the Teacher’s Guidance Book …………… 71
Table 16: The Revision of the First Draft
of the Storybook with Sticky Pictures ……………………. 80
Table 17: The Mean Scores of the Children’s Evaluation on the
Second Draft of the Storybook with Sticky Pictures …....... 86
Table 18: The Mean Scores of the Respondents’ Responses on the
Second Draft of the Storybook with Sticky Pictures ……... 91
Table 19: The Revision of the Second Draft
of Storybook with Sticky Pictures ……………………….. 94
xv
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure Page
Figure 1.1: The Conceptual Framework of the Study ………………… 32
Figure 1.2: Research Steps in Designing
Storybook with Sticky Pictures …………………………... 44
Figure 1.3: The Format of the Teaching Media
“The Storybook with Sticky Pictures” …………………… 69
Figure 1.4: The Format of the Teacher’s Guidance Book …………..... 70
Figure 1.5: Activity 1 Let’s Match and Stick ……………………….... 83
Figure 1.6: Activity 2 Listen and Stick ………………………………. 84
Figure 1.7: Activity 3 Listen, Stick and Retell ……………………….. 85
Figure 1.8: Activity 4 The Value of the Story ……………………….. 85
xvi
10202244082
ABSTRACT
The objective of this research is to design an English storybook with sticky

pictures for the students of grade V. The teacher’s guide book is set to help the
English teachers in elementary school. This study was concerned with how to
provide the English teaching and learning process for the teaching of listening and
speaking in elementary schools using the storybook with sticky pictures.
The study was educational Research and Development (R & D). The
procedures of the study were conducting the needs analysis, writing the course
grid, developing the first draft of the storybook with sticky pictures, evaluating
and revising the first draft of the storybook with sticky pictures, trying out the
second draft of the storybook with sticky pictures, getting expert judgement and
evaluating the second draft of the storybook with sticky pictures, and revising and
writing the final draft of the storybook with sticky pictures. The instruments of the
study were interview guidelines, questionnaires, and observations. The data from
the interview and observation were analyzed qualitatively and the data from the
questionnaires were analyzed quantitatively through the descriptive statistics. The
respondents of the research were 10 people, consisting of 4 English teachers, 2 ex-
university students, and 4 university students. The ex-university students and the
university students joined the English for Children concentration.
The result of the study is learning media entitled A Storybook with Sticky
Pictures completed with the teacher’s guide book with the same title. The
teacher’s guide book is completed with a CD. The storybook with sticky pictures
consists of three units, “The Thomas Family”, “Mr. Page’s Pet Shop”, and “Why
Anansi Has Thin Legs”. Each unit has four activities. They are “Let’s Match and
Stick”, “Listen and Match”, “Listen, Stick, and Retell”, and “The Value of the
Story”. The other activities are presented in the teacher’s guide book to support
the English teaching and learning process. The results of the data computation of
the expert judgement shows that the designed storybook with sticky pictures is
categorized as good and very good as the mean scores ranged from 3.18 to 3.64.
Keywords: Storybook with Sticky Pictures, Teacher’s Guide Book, Teaching

Listening and Speaking in Elementary Schools
xvii
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
A. Background of the Problems
English was known as one of the subjects taught in Indonesia. At the first
time, English was only introduced for junior and senior high school‟s students.
English for primary school was not common at that time. In 1994, some of the
primary schools in Indonesia started to introduce English to children. The position
of English for primary schools was as the local content subject. English was
taught from the fourth grade up to the sixth grade of elementary school in which
each grade gets 2x35 minutes for a week. It was not tested nationally, but it still
had the curriculum made by the government.
In 2008, the government released a book entitled Pedoman Pembelajaran
Bahasa Inggris di Sekolah Dasar as the teacher‟s guide book. The book consists
of some chapters such as the curriculum, objectives of the teaching and learning
process for primary schools, the standard of competence and the basic
competence, syllabuses and lesson plans for the fourth grade until the sixth grade,
examples of learning media, and assessment. The position of English is still as the
local content subject.
Recently, based on the 2013 curriculum, the government stated that English
will not be given for primary schools anymore. English was omitted because some
parties think that primary school‟s students should master the national language
first rather than the foreign language. In the new curriculum, the position of
1
2
English in primary schools will be as an extracurricular subject. The class can be
after school for about an hour. The new curriculum will be implemented in the
new academic year.
English will not be totally banned although it is omitted. Some primary
schools in Indonesia will still give English for their students because they think
that English is important for them. They also think that children should learn from
now in order to compete with other people in the future. The aims of the English
teaching are not far from the aims in 2006 curriculum: developing the students‟
communication competence in using English and preparing children to take a part
in daily communication life.
As stated before, English for children becomes important since children can
learn language best in their early age. In this case, English is not easy to learn by
the children. They will master English more if the teachers are able to employ the
interesting activities. The activities should be able to motivate and encourage the
children to learn more about the target language. The teacher also should consider
whether or not the children‟s age is appropriate with the type of the activities.
In learning English, there are four skills that should be mastered: listening,
speaking, reading, and writing. The four skills are significant because they are
interconnected each other. Listening and speaking skills becomes the important
skills that should be mastered by the learners. Through listening and speaking, the
learners are able to recognize everything that the speaker says as well as to know
how to express their ideas.

3
Speaking is a crucial and an important aspect for the learners because their
mastering of English can be proved from their speaking skill as the productive
skill. Most teachers want their learners to be able to speak English, by concerning
both fluency and accuracy, to indicate that they already understand about
particular materials and to participate and express their ideas. However, for
learners, it is not easy to speak English with their own words. Many of them find
some difficulties in sharing their ideas, choosing the diction, and showing their
confidence, and they are mostly afraid of making mistakes. Thus, they still need
the teacher to guide and help them to reach the goal of good speaking based on the
Standard of Competence and Basic Competence in producing the target language
fluently and accurately.
According to the researcher‟s observation, the students of SD
Muhammadiyah Demangan have low skills in listening and speaking. They did
not have enough chance to speak up and also do not have the learning media and
learning activities that support them in learning English, especially in listening
and speaking. The materials which are taught in grade V of elementary school in
the first semester are daily English expressions, simple sentences, simple short
messages, simple descriptive texts, simple story, and also things around the
school, family, and animals. Related to the materials, the students‟ difficulties are
in the case of recognizing the utterances and expressing them with their own
words.
The students‟ difficulties may be caused by the implementation of
inappropriate techniques and the lack of the learning media, learning activities,
4
and teaching and learning process. To recognize and produce an utterance in
English, the learners should begin from the simple phonemes to the complex ones.
This problem can be solved by designing and applying the appropriate learning
media which encourage students to be able to recognize and produce their
utterances in the target language. Theoretically, a storybook with sticky pictures
seems to help students in improving listening and speaking skills. In line with this
study, students may improve their listening and speaking skills in term of
recognizing the utterances and expressing it with their own words by applying
storybook with sticky pictures as their appropriate media in learning English.
Based on the problems and the proposed solution above, the researcher is
interested in conducting a research and development entitled “Designing an
English Storybook with Sticky Pictures for the Teaching of Listening and
Speaking for Grade V of Elementary Schools”.
B. Identification of the Problems
The teaching and learning process in primary school is a complex process
characterized by various teaching component. The teachers should present the
materials as attractive as possible by using various learning media. They also
should use the appropriate method and various learning activities. Based on the
observation done at grade V Ibnu Tufail SD Muhammadiyah Demangan, there
were some factors that influence students‟ listening and speaking skills which
related to the teaching components. They were the learning media, learning
activities, and teaching and learning process.

5
The first factor was the lack of learning media. Learning media are
important things in teaching English for children. Various learning media can
engage the children in learning something new. In this case, the children of SD
Muhammadiyah Demangan are mostly interested in attractive learning media. The
learning media they like are media which consist of pictures and colorful things.
The fact was in SD Muhammadiyah Demangan, the teachers did not apply
attractive learning media in the teaching and learning process. Thus, it can be seen
that the children are not interested in the material and demotivated in learning
English.
The second factor was the lack of learning activities. Learning activities
should be as challenging as possible and vary in one period to another. In SD
Muhammadiyah Demangan, the teacher did not provide the children with the
interesting and challenging activities. The children are only asked to do the tasks
given by the teacher, and then discussed it together or submitted it to the teacher.
Some children even look sleepy or doing other things during the lesson. The
children will be more interested in learning English if the teacher is able to
provide some interesting and challenging activities such as drawing, matching,
guessing, cutting pictures, sticking pictures, and retelling the story. The learning
activities also should be in the various grouping (group work, pair work, and
individual work). It will engage and motivate the children to stay on the English
learning process.
The third factor was the teaching and learning process. According to the
2006 and 2013 curriculums, the learning process should be in the students‟ center.
6
The teacher did not need to explain everything to the children and should give any
chance to the children to take an action. The English teaching and learning
process in SD Muhammadiyah Demangan was in the teacher‟s center. The teacher
still explained everything and took all the time to speak up. The children are only
got a chance to speak up when the teacher asked about some questions or the
answer of the certain task. Some children are tried to answer the questions, but the
others choose to keep silent.
Considering this situation the researcher attempted to design an English
storybook with sticky pictures for the teaching of listening and speaking for grade
V of elementary schools which met the learners‟ potentials, characteristics,
interests and needs in learning English.
C. Limitation of the Problems
Based on the identification of the problems above, the problem in this
research is limited to the efforts of providing the teaching and learning process by
designing an English storybook with sticky pictures for students of grade V at the
first semester to overcome the problems. The storybook consists of several
activities with variety of grouping. The researcher expects that the storybook and
the activities will help the children to improve their listening and speaking skills.
7
D. Formulation of the Problems
Based on the limitation of the problem above, the researcher proposed the
formulation of the problem as “How can an English storybook with sticky pictures
provide fun and interesting situations in the English teaching and learning process
and improve the students‟ listening and speaking skills for grade V of elementary
schools?”.
E. Objective of the Research
Based on the statement of the problem above, the objectives of this research
is to provide fun and interesting situations in the English teaching and learning
process and improve the students‟ listening and speaking skills for grade V of
elementary schools by designing an English storybook with sticky pictures.
F. Significance of the Research
The researcher expects that this study can be used as a reference in
improving listening and speaking skills based on the stories in English teaching
and learning process. It was hopefully can inspire the other researchers to conduct
similar research and enrich the knowledge of teaching English, especially in the
teaching and learning process of listening and speaking. Furthermore, the product
and result of this research can be used as the learning media in the teaching and
learning process of English as a foreign language in elementary schools. Stories
completed with interesting and motivating activities will give meaningful
information about how to conduct an English lesson for children. For the teacher,
8
the product and result of the research can be used as a teaching resource to
conduct English teaching and learning process by employing appropriate learning
media and students‟ center activities. At last, for the children of grade V of
elementary schools, the product and result of the study can be used to help them to
get suitable learning media which consists of interesting and meaningful activities.
It gives opportunities for children to learn English in a fun way.

CHAPTER II
LITERATURE REVIEW AND CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
A. Literature Review
1. English Teaching and Learning for Children
a. Children Characteristics
1. How Children Think and Learn
Children are different from adults. They cannot learn in the way as the adults
learn. They have special and different ways to learn something. According to
Anning (in Brewster, 2002:30), children have their own uniqueness in thinking
and learning but tend to draw on the same kinds of learning strategy. It means that
teachers can think that child learner has individual differences but can learn using
similar strategies to other children.
According to Pinter (2006:18), the older children‟s first language
development will allow them more and more opportunities for useful comparisons
between the languages they know. Their growing abilities in their mother tongue,
for example, to construct phrases, sentences, or questions, create and retell stories,
or to hold a conversation, will be important direct or indirect sources of support in
the process of learning another language.
By eleven, children move into the stage of formal operations, where they are
capable of having more abstract thought and can learn in a more decontextualized
way (Brewster and Ellis, 2002:29). Children are different from adults. They have
9
10
their own characteristics which differ them from adults. Here are some of the
characteristics proposed by the experts.
1. Having strong sense of fun.
According to Pinter (2006:18), children will pick up and learn the
second language if they are having fun or if they can work out messages
from meaningful contexts. In this case, having fun means children do
not realize that they are learning language and only know that they are
having fun with the activities. Kenkin and Cephe (in Harmer, 2007:82)
stated that children like games, puzzles, and songs. The teacher can
design the activities variously in order to make the children interested in
learning language.
2. Enjoying routines and repetition.
Children are comfortable with routines and enjoy repetition (Slattery
and Willis, 2001:4). They enjoy routines such as singing a song before
the lesson started or saying the jargon of the class. They also enjoy
repeating a word or an utterance in a play situation. In line with this,
stories and role play support children to do so because stories and role
play contain many repeating utterances.
3. Enjoying fantasy, imagination, and movement.
According to Pinter (2006:2), children enjoy fantasy, imagination, and
movement. A fantasy is a situation imagined by people that has no basis
in reality but express certain desires and aim. An imagination is the
activity of forming mental images, sensation, and concepts in a moment

11
when they are not perceive through sight, hearing or other senses. A
movement is moving the body or part of the body. The activities in
language learning should provide visual, auditory, and tactile input to
support children‟s fantasy, imagination, and movement.
4. Knowing the difference between fact and fiction.
The older children already form the basic concept of new language.
They can tell the difference between fact and fiction (Scott and
Ytreberg, 2004:3). They can understand abstracts and symbols. They
are also generalized and systematize. They begin to make sense of adult
world, but they still love fiction stories.
5. Having delighted in talking.
Children are delighted in talking about everything around them. They
talk about the things they are seeing and experiencing. They also talk
about the things they love and hate. They often relate those things when
they learn in a class. This condition make the teacher should be able to
provide the activities related to the real life. The real life activities
support the children in learning process because they are already
familiar with the context.
6. Having a short attention span.
Children have a quite span and so need variety (Slattery and Willis,
2001:4). In line with Slattery and Willis, Pinter proposed that
motivation should be maintained as the children‟s attention span is very

12
short and can be interrupted easily (Pinter, 2008:10). Children are easily
distracted when they are dealing with boring or difficult activities.
By recognizing the children‟s characteristics above, the teacher should
consider it for designing the activities. The activities should support the children
in improving their abilities in the language learning process.
2. How Children Learn Language
Stern (1970:57-58) in Brown (2000:89), proposed some arguments in the
children language acquisition.
1. Children must be given chance to practice the language. This is the
children nature in learning. Children tend to repeat things over and over
again.
2. Small children imitate a lot in learning language. When they listen to a
new word, they tend to imitate it. It is better for the teacher to say the
words with mimics so the children can imitate well.
3. In line with the first point about practicing. Children tend to practice the
language in a natural order. They usually start with practicing separate
sounds and then words and then sentences.
4. The natural order also underlies in acquiring the language skills.
Children usually acquire listening at first then speaking.
5. After listening and speaking, the advanced stages of language
development are reading and writing. Children with their natural order
acquire listening, speaking, reading, and writing.

13
6. In teaching children, the teachers should avoid translating. It is
unnecessary to use translation in foreign language learning since the
children can learn the mother tongue language well without translation.
7. Children do not learn grammar. They prefer simple languages to make
sense of language. Therefore, teachers do not require teaching grammar
in the class.
Another expert, Brewster and Ellis (2002:39-40) also proposed some
principle in children language learning.
1. Children are excellent observers and have a natural ability to grasp
meaning in their first language from a variety of sources: body
language, intonation, gesture, facial expression, and the social context
as well as language itself.
2. Children learning their first language often repeat words and phrases to
themselves in order to become completely comfortable with their
sounds and meaning. Once a child feels he has learned the word,
repetition stops.
3. In acquiring their first language children have spent years honing their
puzzling-out, hypothesis-testing skills. The use of inductive exercises in
the second language, where, for example, they try to work out grammar
rules for themselves, mirror precisely what they have been doing in
their first language for years.

14
4. Children are skilled at guessing and predicting and the teachers can use
fully draw on these skills and the other thought processes outlined as
part of „learning to learn‟.
5. Children like to talk, even if they do not know much language, often
with only two or three words plus key intonation patterns. This is also a
useful tactic they can use in second language development. Learners
should be encouraged to do the same, using whatever means to get their
meaning across.
6. Teachers need to create a balance in their classrooms between providing
support and providing a challenge. If all language work is over-guided,
then it becomes too easy, safe, or repetitive. Similarly, if all work is
challenging, too difficult and threatening, learners become demotivated.
7. When learning their first language, children seem to be good risk-takers
and experimenters. Their willingness to „have a go‟ should be
encouraged and should not be dampened too much by constant
correction or an overly strict atmosphere.
b. Teaching English as a Foreign Language to Children
There are some important principles in the teaching of English to children in
primary school (Cameron, 2001:19).
1. Teachers are required to examine the classrooms activities from the
children‟s perspective.
2. Teachers need to present language using strategies such as routines and
scaffolding in order to help the children make space of language

15
growth. Since children are in their language and cognitive development,
the ZPD or immediate potential of the children is the central importance
for effective learning.
3. Teacher should provide skilled help in noticing and attending to aspects
of the foreign language that carry meaning.
4. Teachers need to create as many as social interaction in the classroom.
Once language can be improved as the children take over control of
language used initially with other children and adults.
5. Teachers should provide valuable learning experience for the children.
In foreign language lessons, children are intended to develop certain
language skills. The teachers need to ensure that the children have
experiences in lessons that build tasks and learning activities in the
classrooms.
According to Burden and Byrd (2010:103), there are some points which are
related to good teachers‟ characteristics.
1. Teachers are committed to students and learning.
2. Teachers know the subject they teach and how to teach those subjects to
students.
3. Teachers are responsible for managing and monitoring students
learning.
4. Teachers think systematically about their practice and learn from
experience.
5. Teachers are members of learning community.

16
2. The Use of Stories in Language Teaching
a. The Nature of Stories
Story is a series of events which uses to entertain the readers or listeners. It
usually refers to a narrative and recount. Story helps the readers or listeners to be
reconstructed the chronological sequence of events as actually occurred in the
time-space universe. According to Linse (2005:33), the storytelling pieces are
pictures of characters and different items in a story that children manipulate or
move around as the story is told.
Brewster and Ellis (2002:46) state that storytelling is a universal
phenomenon, central to children‟s social intellectual and cultural development.
Story always has the messages from the readers or listeners. Thus, through the
story, children can know other events in the universe and get something from the
story.
According to Scott and Ytreberg (2004:28), listening to the stories is one of
the parts of growing up for every child. Listening to the stories also helps the
children to play in their language development. Teachers should make sure that
the children get the advantages of listening to the stories in the classroom.
b. The Benefits of Using Stories in Language Teaching
Stories can be used in a language classroom to promote the listening,
speaking, reading, and writing skills. Cameron (2001:176) states that the five or
ten minutes spent listening to a familiar story will re-active the vocabulary and
grammatical patterns and offer opportunities for children to notice aspects of the
language use they have learnt.

17
According to Brewster and Ellis (2002:186), there are some advantages in
using stories:
1. Stories are motivating and fun and can help develop positive attitudes.
They can create a desire to continue learning.
2. Children can become personally involved in a story as they identify
with the characters and try to interpret the narrative and illustration.
This helps develop their own creative power.
3. Linking fantasy and imagination with the child‟s real world, they
provide a way of enabling children to make sense of their everyday life
and forge links between home and school.
4. Listening to stories in class is a social experience. Storytelling provokes
a shared response of laughter, sadness, excitement and anticipation
which is enjoyable and can help build up confidence and encourage
social and emotional development.
5. Listening to stories allows the teacher to introduce or revise vocabulary
and structures, exposing the children to language which will enrich their
thinking and gradually enter their own speech.
6. Listening to stories helps children become aware of the rhythm,
intonation, and pronunciation of language.
7. Storybooks cater for different learning styles and develop the different
types of „intelligences‟ that contribute to language learning, including
emotional intelligence.
18
8. Storybooks provide ideal opportunities for presenting cultural
information and encouraging cross-cultural comparison.
9. Storybooks develop children‟s learning strategies such as listening for
general meaning, predicting, guessing meaning, and hypothesizing.
10. Storybooks address universal themes beyond the utilitarian level of
basic dialogues and daily activities. Children can play with ideas and
feelings and think about important issues.
11. Stories can be chosen to link English with other subjects across the
curriculum.
12. Storybooks add variety, provide a springboard for creating complete
units of work that constitute mini-syllabuses and involve pupils
personally, creatively, and actively in a whole curriculum approach.
13. Storybooks offer positive concrete outcomes in the form of games,
competitions, quizzes, drama, songs, projects, book making, etc.
14. Learning English through stories can lay the foundations for secondary
school in terms of learning basic language functions and structures,
vocabulary and language-learning skills.

19
c. Selecting The Stories
Many popular stories for children, such as fairy tales and fables, are
published now. Some of them have been simplified and others are simply adapted.
The stories are not only interesting, but also motivating children in learning
language. However, not all the stories can be used as some of them are
complicated or meaningless. Therefore, teachers should be able to select the right
story for children. In selecting the stories for children, teachers should choose the
authentic story. Brewster and Ellis (2002:188) state that authentic storybooks
provide examples of real language and offer a rich source of authentic input,
especially in terms of vocabulary. Carefully selected storybooks can be seen on
many different levels based on the child‟s age, conceptual and emotional
development and all round experience, and can be exploited in many different
ways.
According to Brewster and Ellis (2002:189), in selecting the story the
teachers should consider the accessibility, usefulness and relevance for children
learning EFL, language used in the text, length of the story, amount of repetition,
use of illustrations and layout, time, children‟s conceptual level and ability to
concentrate.
Wright (2004:11) proposed some criteria in selecting stories.
1. The stories which will engage the children within the first few lines.
2. The stories which the teacher likes.
3. The stories which the teacher feel appropriate for the children.
4. The stories which the children will understand well enough to enjoy.
20
5. The stories which offer the children a rich experience of language.
6. The stories which do not have long descriptive passage.
7. The stories which are right for the occasion and in its relation with other
things the teacher are doing with the children.
8. The stories which the teacher feels he or she can tell well.
d. TPR in Activities
Total Physical Response is a kind of method in which involves the
children‟s body movement. In this method, the teacher will say something and act
it out. It helps the children to absorb the meaning of the word. Pinter (2006:50)
states that the principle of TPR activities is that children get the opportunity to
listen to the language before they have to speak. The teacher should provide
listening practice as many as possible in order to reach the children‟s competence
in speaking. She also states that teacher should provide the children with activities
which mainly require non-verbal responses from children. The non-verbal
contribution help make sense of the content of the activities.
According to Linse (2005: 30) TPR has several positive aspects. First, it
utilizes the auditory, visual, and tactile learning channels. The children listen and
watch as the commands are given then they do the commands themselves.
Second, TPR helps to teach children to follow directions and listen attentively.
Third, children are allowed to listen and then choose when they feel comfortable
to start speaking. Fourth, this method can easily be adapted in many different
ways for young learners.

21
Based on Richards and Rogers, a language teaching method is built around
the coordination of speech and action. TPR attempts to teach language through
physical (motor) activity. TPR works especially well with the stories where
sentence patterns are repeated (Linse, 2005:33). It also will be a successful
teaching and learning process when the teacher brings the real objects or pictures
to the class because it will make the activity appealing to both visual and tactile
learners.
3. Material Development for Children
Learning materials was an important thing in teaching children. As
mentioned above, children are easily got bored in doing some things, including
learning English. This situation is required the teacher to be more creative in
producing and giving the materials. The materials should be suitable. According
to Tomlinson (2008:40), suitable materials often mean materials that are not only
child-friendly but also teacher-friendly. The materials should have the capacity to
support and scaffold the early efforts of teachers in teaching the children. As an
example, Tomlinson also mentioned that the use of stories can also be traced to
general primary practice and bringing cross-curricular topics into English lessons
(2008:40).
Furthermore, Tomlinson (2008:41) said that a major issue for materials
designers is how far the development and exercise of this sort of mediation skill
by teachers can reliably be built into, or supported by, materials. The teachers
should be able to make the children joined in the lesson through the various
activities. Tomlinson also suggested that the appropriate skills focus for English
22
for Young Learners teaching is seen in many contexts as speaking and listening
(2008:43).
4. Developing Story-Based Activities
a. The Principles for Planning Story-Based Work
According Brewster and Ellis (2002:194-195), there are three stages in
planning story-based work: planning, doing, and reviewing.
Table 1: Stages in Planning Story-Based Work
Stage General procedure for planning

story-based work
Planning  Decide on your learning goals (linguistic, cultural, cross-
(Pre- curricular, citizenship, etc) and main outcomes.
storytelling  Decide if you need to modify the story in any way.
activities)  Decide how long you will use the storybook.
 Decide what storytelling techniques you will use (read
the story all the way through in one goes or broken down
into shorter).
 Decide how you may need to make the content
accessible to your pupils by contextualizing the story,
introducing main characters, relating the story to the
children‟s own experience, activating children‟s prior
knowledge pre-teaching language that children will not
be able to infer from the context, visual support, etc.
 Decide which materials you may need to prepare.
 Decide how you are going to explain the aims and main
outcomes to your pupils so they know what is expected
of them.
Doing  Decide how you are going to arrange your classroom for
(While- storytelling so everyone can see you and the storybook.
storytelling  Decide how, when, and how many times you are going
activities) to read the story again for specific purposes.
Reviewing  Decide which activities you are going to create to
(Post- consolidate language introduces through the story.
storytelling  Decide which activities you are going to create to extend
activities) and personalize language from the story.
 Decide how you are going to get children to review work
done and evaluate main outcomes.
23
b. The Components of the Story-Based Activities
Cameron (2001:174-175) proposed three main elements in the story-based
activities: preparation activity, core activity, and follow-up activity.
1. Preparation activity
At preparation, the children are shown about the pictures of the story then
asked for words about the pictures. Finally, the teacher supplies a few other
words that will be needed to understand the story.
2. Core activity
In the first reading, the teacher should read on through the story rather than
stopping too much to talk about words or the plot. Pictures can be used to
emphasize what is happening in the story. A second reading, the teacher can
pause at the end of each page to point and repeat key words or ideas, or recall or
predict what happens next. After listening to a story, children should have the
chance to respond to it. They can be encouraged to express their feelings about
the story.
3. Follow-up activity
A simple immediate follow up would be in a various task, such as writing
down some of the vocabulary of the story. The language learning goal of the
follow-up activity is much more specific: to learn the meaning of five new words
and recall the words in the next lesson.

24
Wright (2004:23-53) also stated that there are three stages in story-based
activities; they are activities before the story, activities during the story, and
activities after the story.
1. Activities before the story
In this stage, the teacher should help the children to understand the story,
introduce a new word, and predict the content of the story.
2. Activities during the story
Activities during the story can only be attempted during the second or
third telling of the story. The teacher should let the children listen to and enjoy the
story, help them to understand the story, encourage them to predict what happen
next, and enable them to show their understanding.
3. Activities after the story
In the activities in this stage, the teacher could ask the children to show
their understanding through traditional exercises, retelling the story, express
themselves, and create something.
5. Teaching Listening and Speaking for Children
a. The Nature of Listening for Children
As stated before, in learning a language the learners should learn the four
skills. One of the important skills for children is listening. Listening is categorized
as a receptive skill since it involves responding to a language. According to Spratt,
et al (2007:30) by listening, the listeners can have the meaning of what the
speakers say. The children also accustomed themselves in hearing the natural
sounds of English. It gives a big exposure for them.

25
In listening, the listeners also need to be fluent to listen clearly. According to
Wright (2004:4) listening fluency is based on a positive attitude to not understand
everything and the skills of searching for meaning, predicting, and guessing.
Those skills are not easy for children, so the teacher should guide them by giving
some tips in order to reach that skills. For example, children can begin to use their
predicting skills to make certain assumptions about the content of the listening
before they hear it by some ways. First, children can look at the photos or the
pictures and guess what they mean. Then, they listen and find out whether their
predictions were right or not. When they listen for the third time, they focus on the
other parts. Finally, they listen to specific details of the text or story (Pinter,
2006:54).
Children are not able to listen to the complicated things. They have limited
vocabularies and cannot differentiate about the concept of the time. Pinter
(2006:46) states that teachers can make sure that listening is carefully embedded
in the here-and-now context of familiar games and routines such as stories and
action rhymes so that children do not need to infer the context or topic for
themselves. The teacher‟s gesture and visuals also will help the children in
inferring the context. Furthermore, Pinter (2006:51) said that listening to stories is
the most authentic and popular activity for all children and primary English
teachers can use storytelling as additional listening practice. Through the
storytelling activity, the children will be happy and excited to the story and, of
course, learn the language. Stories contain many repetitions which makes
linguistic input more noticeable for children.

26
According to Linse (2005:25), learning channels are the preferred ways that
learners receive and process information. There are three main learning channels:
auditory, visual, and tactile. Auditory learners are better able to learn material
when it is presented in an auditory format such as listening to someone reading a
story aloud. Visual learners often recall visual images or pictures easily. Tactile
learners are better able to remember information, language, and content when they
have physically manipulated or touched the information. Each child has his/ her
own style in learning. Some children may be good at auditory, others may be good
at visual or tactile, and the rest may be good at auditory and visual or visual and
tactile. Thus, the teacher should know the children well by considering those
learning styles.
Furthermore, Linse (2005:26) proposed the input of different learning
channels in the table below.
Table 2: Input of Different Learning Channels
Learning Examples of Input

Channels
Auditory Songs, chants, poems, stories read aloud,
environmental sounds such as rain, cars, trucks,
animals, vacuum cleaners, computer printers, people
walking.
Visual Pictures such as drawings, sketches, photographs,
paintings, posters, murals, diagrams.
Tactile Real life objects that children can touch as well as toys
and puppets (it is important to make sure that the child
can actually touch the objects and not merely look at
them).
27
As stated before, the teachers should make some strategies in order to help and
improve children‟s ability in listening. Brewster and Ellis (2002:98-101) proposed
some guidelines in improving the children‟s listening skills.
1. Give the children confidence
The teacher should be able to make the children confident enough to
involve with the learning process. The use of gestures, tone of voice, and visual
aids will help them feel confident about what is important to concentrate on.
2. Explain why the children have to listen
The teacher should explain the objective of the listening activity to the
children at the beginning of the lesson. It is useful to build up their confidence and
reduce anxiety. There are different kinds of listening purposes.
a. To physically settle learners.
b. To stir learners.
c. To improve the general listening attitude.
d. To develop aspects of language.
e. To reinforce conceptual development.
f. To interact with others.
g. To provide support for literacy.
3. Help children develop specific strategies for listening
Teachers should be able to help the children to use their background
knowledge to work out something. Here are some important listening strategies.
28
a. Predicting
It is useful to encourage the children to guess what they think they will
be listening to. The teacher can use pictures to encourage them to
guess the topic. The teacher also can stop in the middle of the activity
to ask the children what will happen next. It helps the children to keep
their motivation high and feel success, and confidence.
b. Working out the meaning from context
The teacher can use the pictures or the children‟s general knowledge to
work out the meaning of unfamiliar words.
c. Recognizing discourse patterns and markers
The sequence like first, then, next, finally, but, and, so will be an
important signal for children about what is coming next in a spoken
text.
4. Set a specific listening task
The teacher should make different tasks in pre-listening, while-listening,
and post-listening in order to make listening an active, learning-focused process.
5. Organize listening
The teacher can give the listening activity through the cassette or pre-
recorded material and teacher talk.
b. The Nature of Speaking for Children
Speaking is categorized as a productive skill since it produces language
rather than responds it. Spratt et al (2005:34) state that speaking involves using
speech to express meaning to other people. It is a kind of activity designed to

29
practice the language learned before. Speaking emphasis in accuracy and the
activity should design to promote fluency. Furthermore, Spratt et al also state that
fluency is speaking at a normal speed, without hesitation, repetition or self-
correction, and with smooth use of connected speech. Accuracy in speaking is the
use of correct forms of grammar, vocabulary, and pronunciation (2005:34).
According to Linse (2005:46), children begin speaking by experiment and
play with the utterances that are made to form words and phrases. As they grow,
children integrate the words and structures into their real and imaginary play. That
is why teachers should teach children with different kinds of games, songs, and
stories. Those learning resources help teachers in introducing the language target
and improving the learners‟ fluency.
Speaking is not easy for children. The teachers should give as many
activities as possible to practice speaking in English. As Pinter (2006:55)
proposed that speaking practice starts with practicing and drilling a set of phrases
and repeating models. Drilling is believed as a good way in improving speaking
for children because in the beginning stage of learning other language children
need more examples of how to pronounce the words or how to say something. As
stated before that young child still imitate when they speak in English, the
teachers should be able to be a good model in speaking English. In line with this,
Cameron (2001:41) also states that speaking activities require careful and plentiful
support of various types, not just support for understanding, but also support for
production.
30
Linse (2005:49-52) also proposed the development of speaking skills:
1. Avoid unrealistic expectations
The teacher should understand that the expectations for children learning
ESL or EFL should not be greater or more demanding than the expectations for
children learning to speak in English as their native language.
a. Mean length of utterances (MLU)
The MLU are the number of morphemes found in a sample of a child‟s
utterances. Children should not be expected to produced utterances that are
beyond their stage of development
b. Pronunciation and young learners
Children sometimes have difficulty articulating specific phonemes when
they are learning to speak in English. The difficulties can occur due to
developmental factors. As the children grow and develop, they become
able to articulate the different English-language phonemes. Children have
different expectation in mastering different English-language sounds based
on their ages.
2. Overgeneralization of errors
In learning other languages, in this case English, children tend to make an
error in grammar rules. The errors they make are often known as
overgeneralization. According to Brown (2000) in Linse (2005:51), generalization
is a vitally important aspect of human learning and involves inferring and deriving
a rule, or law. The example of overgeneralization which children made are the use
31
of the past tense and rules from his first language and applied them to a second or
foreign language.
c. Integrated Listening and Speaking for Children
Listening and speaking skills cannot be separated in the teaching and
learning process. The mastery of both skills also should be balance. According to
Linse (2005:25), the relationship between listening and speaking is clear because
they are both oral skills. As stated before, by listening the children got
information and by speaking they deliver or produce utterances. In line with this,
Pinter (2006:45) stated that English should start with an emphasis on listening and
then speaking. These are the two main skills to teach because children often
cannot read and write at all yet, or not with much confidence.
B. Conceptual Framework
The research is expected to provide the English teaching and learning
process with interesting media and fun activities in order to improve their skills
and promote English to the children. As stated before, the English teaching and
learning process in SD Muhammadiyah Demangan is out of expectation. It has
some problems related to the learning media, learning activities, and teaching and
learning process. To overcome the problems, the researcher designed a storybook
with sticky pictures to provide fun and interesting input in language teaching and
learning process.
Listening to the stories is one of the parts of growing up for children because
children love story. According to Brewster and Ellis (2002:186), storybook can
32
provide an ideal introduction to the foreign language as it is presented in a context
that is familiar to the child. Stories can also provide the starting point for a wide
variety of related language and learning activities.
In designing the learning media, the researcher is required to follow some
steps of the R and D cycle. First, the researcher is conducting the need analysis.
Second, the researcher is selecting topic and objective of the learning activities.
Third, the researcher is writing the course grid. Fourth, the researcher is designing
the storybook with the sticky pictures. Then, the researcher is implementing the
storybook with the sticky pictures. The last step is the researcher evaluating and
revising the storybook with the sticky pictures.
The conceptual framework of the study can be seen in the following chart.
The needs to have:

Need to acquire or learning  Attractive learning media
English in a fun way  Various and interesting
activities
 Students‟ center activity
which included body
movement
A storybook with sticky

pictures
Availability of a set of storybook with sticky

pictures
Figure 1.1: The Conceptual Framework of the Study

CHAPTER III
RESEARCH METHOD
A. The Type of the Research
The research is categorized as Research and Development (R and D). R and
D is a strategy which includes a cycle in which a version of a product is
developed, field-tested, and revised on the basis of the field-tested data (Gall and
Borg, 1983:771). The types of product can be material objects such as textbooks,
learning media, a set of method in teaching, or films. Related to the research
study, the researcher tried to take the research knowledge and incorporate it into a
product that can be used in schools. The research was aimed at designing a
storybook with sticky pictures for teaching listening and speaking at the first
semester of grade V SD Muhammadiyah Demangan.
B. The Subjects of the Research
The subjects of the research were grade V students of SD Muhammadiyah
Demangan. There were 30 students in the class, consisting of 13 girls and 17 boys
at the age of 10-11 years old. Generally, the students have low skills in listening
and speaking. However, they were very active, and storybooks with sticky
pictures combined with colorful pictures and interesting activities were very
effective to be used in the class in order to improve their listening and speaking
skills.
33
34
C. The Research Setting
The research was conducted at SD Muhammadiyah Demangan. It is located
in Jalan Perkutut, Demangan Baru, Yogyakarta. The school has 2 units. In unit 1
the school has 15 classrooms which consists of 3 classrooms for grade I, 3
classrooms for grade II, 2 classrooms for grade III, 2 classrooms for grade IV, 2
classrooms for grade V, and 3 classrooms for grade VI, the headmistress‟ office,
the teachers‟ office, a library, one computer laboratories, a health center, a
mosque, a field, one canteen, some toilets, and parking areas. The field is also
used to have a flag ceremony every Monday morning. In unit 2, the school has 2
classrooms for grade IV, one teacher office, one health center, and one toilet.
The classrooms at SD Muhammadiyah Demangan are big enough, sufficient
for about twenty eight until thirty five students. There are sufficient LCD for some
classes, whiteboards, cupboards, chairs and tables in every classroom.
There are twenty five school society including twenty two teachers and three
staffs. There are four English teachers in the school. All of the teachers were
graduated from the English Education Department, but none of them were from
English for Children‟s programmed. Most of the students are from middle-high
economy class. Most of their parents are entrepreneurs. Generally, students in this
school have average motivation in learning English.

35
D. Research Instruments
1. Data Instruments
a. Interview
The interview was taken twice. All of the interviews were delivered to the
students. The first needs analysis interview was conducted to find some
information about students‟ characteristics and needs of English learning. The
second interview was conducted to get the students‟ opinions about the developed
storybook with sticky pictures. The second interview was conducted after
implementing the second draft of the developed storybook with sticky pictures.
In order to make the needs analysis and the evaluation run well, an interview
guidelines was made by the researcher. The children‟s responses to the questions
were audio and visually recorded.
Table 3: The Organization of the First Interview (Need Analysis) for Students
No Purpose of the The Content of Question References

Questions the Questions Numbers
1 To find the - Learning goals 1, 2 Tomlinson
information about and expectations (1998:240)
children‟s learning for a course.
needs on story. - Learning styles. Pinter
(2006:38)
2 To find the - Children attitude 3, 4 Hutchinson
information about toward English. and Waters
children‟s - Children‟s (1987:62)
background previous
knowledge. knowledge.
3 To find the - Preferred stories. 5, 6, 7 Tomlinson
information about - Preferred (1998:240)
children‟s interest. activities.
- Preferred media.
36
Table 4: The Organization of the Second Interview (Evaluation) for Students

1 To get - Stories. 1, 2, 3, 4, Brown
information about - Vocabularies. 5 (2001:142)
the children‟s - Songs. Hutchinson
opinions on the - Pictures. and Waters
quality of the - Flashcards. (1987:62)
input of the story. - Media. Ellis via
Tomlinson
(1998:235)
2 To get - Content of the 6, 7, 8 Brown
information about activities. (2001:142)
the children‟s - Clarity of the Harmer
opinions on the instructions. (2001:279)
quality of the - Games.
activities.
3 To get - Illustration. 9, 10 Brown
information about (2001:142)
the children‟s
opinions related
to the layout of
the media.
b. Questionnaire
There were 5 kinds of questionnaire that were distributed in 2 separated
times. The first questionnaire was distributed to the fifth grade students to get
information about the learners‟ need of learning.
Table 5: The Organization of the Need Analysis Questionnaire for Students
No The Purpose of The Content of the Question References

the Questions Questions Numbers
1 To get - Children attitude 1 Hutchinson
information about toward English. and Waters
the students‟ (1987:62)
attitude toward
the English
lesson.
(continued)
37
(continued)
No The Purpose of The Content of Question References

the Questions the Questions Numbers
2 To get - Children attitude 2, 3 Hutchinson
information about toward listening. and Waters
the students‟ - Children attitude (1987:62)
attitude toward toward speaking.
Listening and
Speaking.
3 To get - Preferred 4, 5 Hutchinson
information about listening and Waters
Listening activities. (1987:62)
activities in the
classroom.
4 To get - Preferred 6, 7 Hutchinson
information about speaking and Waters
Speaking activities. (1987:62)
activities in the
classroom.
5 To get - Preferred 8, 9, 10 Hutchinson
information about activities. and Waters
the students‟ (1987:62)
activities in the
classroom.
6 To get - Preferred 11, 12, 13 Hutchinson
information about teaching styles. and Waters
the teacher‟s (1987:63)
teaching
technique.
7 To get - Preferred 14, 15, 16, Hutchinson
information about activities. 17, 18, 19, and Waters
the activities that - Preferred stories. 20 (1987:63)
the students - Preferred media.
interested in.
The second questionnaire was distributed to the English teacher in order to
get the information related to opinions and experience in teaching the students.
The questions were aimed at getting some information related to the teacher‟s
opinion about delivering material in the form of stories, giving language input in
38
the form of stories, the type of stories the students like in the classroom, and the
media they usually use in the classroom.
Table 6: The Organization of the Need Analysis Questionnaire for English
Teachers
No Purpose of the The Content of the Question References

Questions Questions Numbers
1 To find the - Preferred 1, 2, 3, 4 Tomlinson
information about teaching styles. (1998:241)
the teacher‟s - Preferred Hutchinson
professional needs. storytelling and Waters
technique. (1987:62)
- Preferred
activities.
2 To find the - Children‟s 5, 6, 7, 8 Tomlinson
information about previous (1998:240)
children‟s knowledge.
background - Preferred
knowledge. activities.
3 To find the - Preferred stories. 9, 10 Tomlinson
information about - Preferred media. (1998:241)
teacher‟s interest.
The third questionnaire was distributed to the parents. The questions were
aimed at getting some information related to the parents‟ way in guiding and
teaching the children at home, telling the stories at home, giving language input
related to the stories, and the types of stories the children like.
Table 7: The Organization of the Need Analysis Questionnaire for Parents

1 To get information - Name. Tomlinson
related to the (1998:240)
respondents‟
profile.
(continued)
39
(continued)

2 To get information - Learning goals 1, 2, 3, 4, Tomlinson
about children‟s and expectation. 5, 6, 7, 8, (1998:241)
learning needs. - Learning styles 9, 10, 11,
12, 13
3 To find the - Language 14, 15 Hutchinson
information about exposure. and Waters
the children‟s - Children‟s (1987:63)
background previous
knowledge. knowledge.
4 To find - Reading the 16, 17
Brewster
information about stories. and Ellis
the method in - Telling the (2002:188-
delivering the stories. 189)
stories. Wright
(2004:10)
5 To get information - Folklore. 18, 19, 20 Tomlinson
related to the - Fable. (1998:240)
children‟s interest - Tale. Brewster
of the stories. and Ellis
(2002:188-
189)
The fourth questionnaire was the evaluation questionnaire. It was
distributed to the fifth grade students of SD Muhammadiyah Demangan after
implementing the developed media. It was used to ask for opinion of the
developed materials.
Table 8: The Organization of the Evaluation Questionnaire for Students

1 To find some - Learning goals. 1, 2 Nunan
information to - Learning needs. (2004:175)
evaluate the goal of
the tasks developed
and the rationale
whether it is relevant
with the learners‟
need or not.
(continued)
40
(continued)

2 To find some - Clarity of the 3, 4 Nunan
information to instructions. (2004:169-
evaluate the 170, 175-
instruction. 176)
3 To find some - Preferred 5, 6, 7, 8 Brown
information to activities. (2001:142)
evaluate the
activities.
4 To find some - Preferred setting. 9, 10, 11 Nunan
information to (2004:169-
evaluate the 170, 175-
setting. 176)
5 To find some - Interesting input. 12, 13, 14 Brown
information to - Advantages of (2001:142)
evaluate the input. the input.
6 To find some - Advantages of 15, 16, 17, Nunan
information to the media. 18, 19, 20 (2004:175)
evaluate the media - Interesting
used. media.
- Suitable media.
- The use of the
media.
The last questionnaire was the evaluation questionnaire. It was distributed to
the English teachers and experts to get expert judgement. It was aimed at finding
the respondents‟ opinions and suggestions about the first and the second draft and
used it to evaluate the developed storybook with sticky pictures.

41
Table 9: The Organization of the Evaluation Questionnaire for English
Teachers and Experts

1 To find some - Name. Tomlinson
information about - Age. (1998:240)
respondents‟ - Gender.
profile. - Education
background.
- Institution.
- Teaching
experience
2 To find some - Materials based 1, 2, 3, 4, Nunan
information to on the curriculum 5 (2004:175)
evaluate the - Materials based
material with the on the course
curriculum and the grid.
course grid
(syllabus)
3 To find some - Learning goals. 6, 7, 8, 9, Nunan
information to - Learning needs. 10, 11, 12 (2004:175)
evaluate the goal of
the tasks developed
and the rationale
whether it is
relevant with the
learner‟s need or
not.
4 To find some - Learning 13, 14, 15, Brown
information to activities. 16, 17, 18, (2001:142)
evaluate the 19, 20, 21, Nunan
developed 22, 23, 24 (2004:169-
activities. 170, 175-
176)
5 To find some - Suitable input. 25, 26, 27, Brown
information to 28, 29, 30 (2001:142)
evaluate the input
in the developed
activities.
(continued)
42
(continued)

6 To find some - Interesting 31, 32, 33, Nunan
information to pictures. 34, 35 (2004:175)
evaluate the layout - Suitable media.
and design in the
learning media.
7 To find some - Clarity of the 36, 37, 38, Brown
information to instructions. 39, 40 (2001:142)
evaluate the Nunan
instructions. (2004:169-
170, 175-
176)
8 To get some - Opinions 41, 42, 43
opinions about the - Weaknesses.
media developed. - Suggestions.
c. Observation
The students were observed in the teaching and learning processes during
the needs analysis and also in the implementation of the media. The results of the
observation in the needs analysis were presented in the form of field notes. The
process of implementing the materials was presented in the form of field notes
(for the researcher) and observation sheets (for the English teacher).
2. The Validity and Reliability of the Instruments
To measure the validity of the instruments, content and face validity was
used by the researcher. The content validity was obtained from the data of the
questionnaire. The items of the question in the questionnaire were written in line
with the blue print of the instrument. The researcher also examined the materials
of the worksheet whether or not the materials were represented and consistent
with the theories related to the steps of designing tasks and materials as proposed
43
by some experts such as Nunan (1989), Brown (2001), Tomlinson (1998),
Hutchinson and Waters (1987), and Harmer (2001). The face validity was
obtained from the appearance of the instruments. It looks good (readable, use
good format, use good printing qualities), used clear instructions, and did not have
any grammatical errors.
To measure the reliability, Cronbach‟s Alpha Formula and inter-rater
reliability was used. This research had inter-rater reliability since the data were
analyzed from more than one perspective. The English teacher and the researcher
were administered the observation guide to avoid the bias data. Moreover, the
observation was obtained by giving the genuine data from the field note of each
implementation that represented the condition of the classroom.
E. The Research Procedure
The research procedure of this research is adapted from Musahara‟s model
(Tomlinson, 1998:247). Musahara proposed 5 steps of designing course. They
were needs analysis, goals and objectives, syllabus design, methodology or
materials, and testing and evaluation. The researcher modified the models used in
the research as follows.

44
Conducting a needs analysis
Writing the course grid
Developing the first draft of the storybook with sticky pictures.
Evaluating and revising the first draft of the storybook

with sticky pictures.
Trying out the second draft of the storybook with sticky pictures.
Getting expert judgement and evaluating the second draft of the

storybook with sticky pictures.
Revising and writing the final draft of the storybook with sticky pictures.
Figure 1.2: Research Steps in Designing Storybook with Sticky Pictures
Here are the descriptions of each step for the research procedure.
1. Conducting a Needs Analysis
The researcher conducted the need analysis to find the information about
children characteristics in learning, their preferences in listening to the story, and
experience in learning English. In the needs analysis, the researcher conducted
interview with the children and distributed questionnaires to the teachers and
parents. The results of the needs analysis were used as guidelines in designing
storybooks with sticky pictures to teach listening and speaking.

45
2. Writing the Course Grid
Based on the data from the needs analysis, the researcher made 3 sets of
course grid. The course grids were also developed based on the 2004 curriculum
for primary school (Pedoman Pembelajaran Bahasa Inggris di Sekolah Dasar). In
writing the course grid, the researcher used many sources such as available
English textbooks for very young learners and some theories. Theme, basic
competences, indicators, language functions, grammar, expressions, vocabularies,
activities, and teaching aids were stated in the course grid.
3. Developing the First Draft of the Storybook with Sticky Pictures
After writing the course grid, the researcher developed activities based on the
results of the children‟s needs and elementary schools‟ curriculum. The researcher
developed 3 units of the story-based activity. The researcher asked some English
teachers and lecturers and used some source books to develop the activities.
4. Evaluating and Revising the First Draft of the Storybook with Sticky Pictures
The first evaluation was done before the try out. In this stage, the learning
materials were evaluated by the lecturer and some English teachers. The result of
the first evaluation was used to revise the first draft. The materials were revised
based on the comments and suggestions. The revised materials are then called as
the second draft of the storybook with sticky pictures.
5. Trying Out the Second Draft of the Storybook with Sticky Pictures
A storybook with sticky pictures for the teaching of listening and speaking is
tried out at grade V Ibnu Tufail SD Muhammadiyah Demangan. Their learning
activities were observed. After that, the researcher asked feedback and
46
suggestions from the students and the teachers. The data were collected by
distributing questionnaire to students and interviewing some of them. The data
from the teacher was in the form of observation sheet. Then, the data collected
were used in the next step.
6. Getting Expert Judgement and Evaluating the Second Draft of the Storybook
with Sticky Pictures
After trying out the second draft of the storybook with sticky pictures to the
students of grade V Ibnu Tufail, the evaluation questionnaire for experts and
English teachers was distributed. The respondents evaluated the second draft of
the storybook with sticky pictures and the teacher‟s guide book. The results of the
questionnaire will be used to evaluate and revise the second draft of the storybook
with sticky pictures.
7. Revising and Writing the Final Draft of the Storybook with Sticky Pictures
After evaluating the data, the second draft of the storybook with sticky
pictures was revised. The materials were revised based on the feedbacks and
suggestions from the experts and English teachers. Finally, the final draft of the
materials could be produced. The final draft of this stage was a final draft of the
storybook with sticky pictures for the teaching of listening and speaking for grade
V of elementary schools.
F. Data Collection Techniques
As mentioned above, the data in this research were obtained from
conducting the interviews and distributing the questionnaires. The needs analysis
47
interview and questionnaires obtained the information related to the children‟s
needs and characteristics and the teacher‟s teaching style. The evaluation
interview and questionnaires obtained opinions and suggestions from the children,
English teachers, lecturers and students of English Education Department about
the developed storybook with sticky pictures.
G. Data Analysis Techniques
There were two types of data in this research. The first was the data from
need analysis interview with the children, the open-ended questionnaires for the
teacher, class observations, and the evaluation interview with the children. The
data were analyzed qualitatively. The data obtained from the first class
observation, interview with the children, and open-ended questionnaire for the
teacher in the needs analysis were about the children‟s characteristics, children‟s
needs, children‟s interest, and the suitable teaching media. The results became the
guidelines to choose the stories and developed the storybook with sticky pictures.
The results of the second class observation and the evaluation interview
with the children after the implementation were also analyzed qualitatively. The
data then became the guidelines to revise the second draft of the storybook with
sticky pictures. The qualitative data were written in the form of interview
transcripts and field notes.
The second were the data from the close-ended questionnaires for the
children and parents in the needs analysis and the evaluation questionnaires for
the children and experts and English teachers in the evaluation. The data were
48
analyzed quantitatively through the descriptive statistics. The descriptive statistics
was used to present and describe the data. A Likert Scale was used because it was
generally appropriate for obtaining respondents‟ views, judgments, or opinions.
The data were analyzed by calculating the percentage of each answer in the
questionnaire.
The questions in the questionnaire were given score weights. The scores of
the evaluation questionnaire were 4 points for Strongly Agree (SA), 3 points for
Agree (A), 2 points for Disagree (D), and 1 point for Strongly Disagree (SD). The
data from this questionnaire were first analyzed using the formula proposed by
Suharto (2005). After that, the data were converted into the data conversion with
some categorizations. The data conversion was used to describe the results using
descriptive analysis. Below is the data conversion table.
Table 10: Data Conversion Table
Mean Scores Category

3.26 – 4.00 Very Good
2.51 – 3.25 Good
1.76 – 2.50 Fair
1.00 – 1.75 Poor
The storybook with sticky pictures for teaching listening and speaking was
accepted if the mean scores reached more than 2.50. If the mean scores were less
than 2.50, the storybook with sticky pictures should be revised.

Nita Listiyaningtyas 10202244082

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Nita Listiyaningtyas 10202244082

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Nita Listiyaningtyas 10202244082

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

DESIGNING AN ENGLISH STORYBOOK WITH STICKY PICTURES

FOR THE TEACHING OF LISTENING AND SPEAKING

Presented as a Partial Fulfillment of the Requirement for the Attainment of

ENGLISH EDUCATION DEPARTMENT

Presented as a Partial Fulfillment of the Requirement for the Attainment of

ENGLISH EDUCATION DEPARTMENT

I dedicate this thesis to:

My beloved parents, Sri Purwanti and Tugiman,

and my brother, Yudi Desopera Setyawan.

“Bacalah dengan (menyebut) nama Tuhanmu Yang menciptakan.”

“Mencari ilmu itu adalah wajib

“Dream, believe, and make it happen.”

“All our dreams can come true,

“Everything you need to be great is already inside you.

Alhamdulillahirobbil’alamin, all praise is to Allah SWT, the Almighty and

Yogyakarta, 25 January 2015

APPROVAL SHEET ...................................................................................... ii

RATIFICATION ............................................................................................. iii

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ............................................................................. vii

TABLE OF CONTENTS ............................................................................... ix

LIST OF TABLES ........................................................................................ xiv

LIST OF FIGURES ...................................................................................... xvi

ABSTRACT ................................................................................................... xvii

CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION .................................................................... 1

A. Background of the Problems .................................................................... 1

B. Identification of the Problems .................................................................. 4

C. Limitation of the Problems ....................................................................... 6

D. Formulation of the Problems .................................................................... 7

E. Objective of the Research ........................................................................ 7

F. Significance of the Research ................................................................... 7

CHAPTER II LITERATURE REVIEW AND CONCEPTUAL

A. Literature Review ..................................................................................... 9

1. English Teaching and Learning for Children ....................................... 9

2. The Use of Stories in Language Teaching ........................................... 16

a. The Nature of Stories ..................................................................... 16

b. The Benefits of Using Stories in Language Teaching ................... 16

c. Selecting the Stories ...................................................................... 19

d. TPR in Activities ........................................................................... 20

3. Material Development for Children..................................................... 21

4. Developing Story-Based Activities ..................................................... 22

a. The Principles for Planning Story-Based Work ............................ 22

b. The Components of the Story-Based Activities ............................ 23

5. Teaching Listening and Speaking for Children ................................... 24

a. The Nature of Listening for Children ............................................ 24

b. The Nature of Speaking for Children ............................................ 28

c. Integrated Listening and Speaking for Children ............................ 31

B. Conceptual Framework ........................................................................... 31

CHAPTER III RESEARCH METHOD ....................................................... 33

A. The Type of the Research ........................................................................ 33

B. The Subjects of the Research .................................................................. 33

C. The Research Setting ............................................................................... 34

1. Data Instruments ................................................................................ 35

2. The Validity and Reliability of the Instruments ................................ 42

F. Data Collection Techniques .................................................................... 46

G. Data Analysis Techniques ....................................................................... 47

CHAPTER IV RESEARCH FINDINGS AND DISCUSSION ................... 49

A. Research Findings ................................................................................... 49

1. The Needs Analysis ........................................................................... 49

a. The Result of the Interview with Children .................................. 51