Updated on 23 Mar 2023 by Miss Beh SJ @behlogy

Paper 5 Essential Guideline

Planning, Analysis and Evaluation
Time: 1 h 15 m
Total: 30 marks

Approximate breakdown of paper:

Skill Total Marks Breakdown of Marks

Defining the Problem ~5m
Planning 14-16
Methods ~10m
Dealing with Data ~8m
Analysis, Conclusions, and Evaluation 14-16 Evaluation ~4m
Conclusions ~3m

Pro Tip!
Always read and understand the questions first! In the question, find:
a. Aim or hypothesis
b. Independent variable
c. Dependent variable
d. Controlled variables

Planning

Defining the Problem (~5m)

 Very basic questions like hypothesis, variables etc.

Methods (~10m)

 Write in full sentences in pen

 Be as specific as possible
 You can number your steps, but you CANNOT write in point form
 Your methods need not be described in chronological order – as long as all points are there
 If involves drawing, then drawing must be done in pencil (rules for drawing applies)
 You can use empty spaces for drafting in pencil (but please remember to erase it before handing it in)

6 points you must include:

1. Independent variable
a. List min 5 different values of the independent variable
E.g. 5 different concentrations with regular intervals apart/ 5 different temperatures
b. State how you are going to set up these independent variables
c. Remember to include the apparatus used
E.g. simple or serial dilution / use a thermostatically-controlled water bath
d. State how you make sure the experiment is well-controlled / less error-prone
E.g. randomise sampling to avoid bias / make sure participants do not know which drug they are
getting as results can be affected by subject expectation

1
 Updated on 23 Mar 2023 by Miss Beh SJ @behlogy

2. Dependent variable
a. This must be something that’s measurable!
E.g. rate is not measurable, rate is ________ over time
You must state the variable that’s measured to calculate the rate
b. State how you are going to measure the dependent variables
E.g. take a reading every 10 minutes
c. Remember to include the apparatus used
E.g. length is measured using a ruler / dry the plant in an oven until the mass becomes constant.
measure dry mass using a weighing scale
d. State how you make sure the experiment is well-controlled / less error-prone
E.g. incubate enzyme and substrate separately, then start timer immediately after enzyme is added
to substrate / use yeast without methylene blue as a colour standard
e. State how you are going to analyse the results
E.g. compare between group A and B / plot a graph / calculate using this formula

3. Controlled variables
a. Min 3 constant variables
E.g. Temperature / pH / volume of solution
b. State how you are going to keep these variables constant
c. Remember to include the apparatus used
E.g. use pH buffer/ use a thermostatically-controlled water bath

4. Control
a. Control experiment ≠ controlled variable
b. Control experiment is important to ensure validity of the experiment. To make sure that the
independent variables are the ones causing the change in the dependent variable.
c. Two types:
Negative control = results should be always negative
E.g. use boiled enzyme, so no rate of reaction
Positive control = results should be always positive
E.g. have petri dish without antibiotics for bacteria, bacteria will definitely grow

5. Safety
a. State the hazard + why it is dangerous + precaution
E.g. Strong acid – corrosive – wear gloves and goggles
Enzymes / reagents – harmful– wear gloves and goggles
UV light – mutagen – wear goggles
Electrical appliances – danger of electrocution – wear rubber gloves / do not touch with wet hands
(In field experiments) Pollen / insect bites – allergies – wear mask / protective clothing
b. For human experiments, make sure they are aware of health risk, get consent before testing and
allow test subjects to stop if they fell unwell.

6. Repeat
a. Repeat experiment at least 3 times and obtain a mean to remove anomalies [R average]

2
 Updated on 23 Mar 2023 by Miss Beh SJ @behlogy
List of common experiments:

 Simple and serial dilution

 Biological tests
 Enzyme experiments
 Potometer
 Respirometer
 Using redox indicators (DCPIP / methylene blue) to investigate the rate of respiration of yeast
 Using a gas syringe / photosynthometer to measure rate of photosynthesis in aquatic plants such as Elodea
 Chromatography to separate and identify chloroplast pigments
 Random sampling using frame quadrats
 Line or belt transects
 Mark-release-recapture technique
 Gel electrophoresis

Note: Some of these experiments have special procedures you have to remember!

The question can also describe to you an experiment you have NEVER seen before and ask you to plan the
experiment accordingly.

3
 Updated on 23 Mar 2023 by Miss Beh SJ @behlogy
Analysis, Conclusions, and Evaluation

Dealing with Data (~8m)

Math Skills Required

 Mean, 𝑥
 Median
 Mode
 Range
 Interquartile range
 Ratio
 Percentage change = × 100

∑( ̅)
 Standard deviation, s = ( )

 Standard error, SM =
√

 95% confidence interval / error bars = mean ± 2 SM

[ ]
 Respiratory Quotient (RQ) = [ ]

 Rf value for chromatography =

 Mark release-recapture method

. .
Estimated population size = .

 Simpson’s Index of Diversity

D=1− Σ
where n = number of individuals of each species present in the sample
N = the total number of all individuals of all species

 The Hardy-Weinberg equations:

p2 + 2pq + q2 = 1
p+q=1

Note: Memorise all formulas stated here as they may not be provided in the exam!

Statistical Tests
1. Chi-squared test
To test for significance of difference between 2 data sets
2. t-test
3. Pearson’s linear correlation
To test for correlation
4. Spearman’s rank correlation

Null Hypothesis

There is no significant difference / relationship between _____________ and _____________.

4
 Updated on 23 Mar 2023 by Miss Beh SJ @behlogy

Test Chi-squared test, χ2 t-test Pearson’s linear correlation Spearman’s rank correlation
To show if the observed results are
To test whether data from 2 To test for correlation between 2 To test for correlation between 2
Purpose significantly different from the
samples are significantly different paired sets of data paired sets of data
expected results
 Data is discrete / nominal
 Discontinuous distribution
 Continuous / interval data
 Continuous / interval data  Scatter graph shows that there is
 Discrete / nominal data  Both sets of data are normally
 Data is normally distributed a relationship (not necessarily
 Discontinuous distribution distributed
 Standard deviations are approx. linear / skewed)
Requirements  Usually to test the results of:  Scatter graph indicates a linear /
the same  There are 5 or more pairs of data
- Breeding experiments skewed relationship with no
 Two samples have <30 values  Data points within samples are
- Ecological sampling obvious outliers
each independent
 There are 5 or more pairs of data
 All individuals must be selected
at random from a population
| 𝑥̅ − 𝑥̅ |
𝑡= ∑ 𝑥𝑦 − 𝑛𝑥̅ 𝑦 6 × ∑𝐷
(𝑂 − 𝐸) 𝑟 = 1−
Formula 𝜒 = 𝑠 𝑠 𝑟= 𝑛 −𝑛
𝐸 + (𝑛 − 1)𝑠 𝑠
𝑛 𝑛 (D = difference in rank)

Degree of 𝑣 =𝑛−2 𝑣 =𝑛−2

𝑣 =𝑐−1
𝑣 = (𝑛 − 1) + (𝑛 − 1) 𝑛 is often shown in table directly, so you 𝑛 is often shown in table directly, so you
freedom (c = number of classes)
may not need to calculate v at all! may not need to calculate v at all!

If χ2 / t value is more than critical value at p = 0.05 If r / rs value is more than critical value at p = 0.05
 The two data sets are significantly different  The two data sets are significantly correlated
Analysis  Probability of the difference occurring by chance is less than 5%  Probability of the relationship occurring by chance is less than 5%
 The null hypothesis is rejected  The null hypothesis is rejected
 The differences are not due to random error / chance  The relationship are not due to random error / chance

Note: Formulas for statistics test are provided.

However, you will need to memorise how to calculate degree of freedom for each test!

5
 Updated on 23 Mar 2023 by Miss Beh SJ @behlogy
Evaluation (~4m)

 Always read the question carefully!

Describe = state your observations
Explain = explain why the observations are as such
Compare / contrast = tell me the similarities or differences between 2 sets of data

 Always read the x and y axis first!

x-axis = independent variable
y-axis = dependent variable

How to describe a graph:

1. General trend
a. First, describe how the independent variable and dependent variable changes overall
E.g. when x increases, y increases, but tails off when x increases above 10
b. Then, if needed, split the graph into several parts to describe and explain separately

2. Comparative data quote

a. Compare 2 points to support your statement
b. Provide the x and y coordinates with the correct units
c. You can also quote the maximum and minimum values where appropriate
d. You can include some manipulative figures
E.g. the number of cases reduced by half in 2010 compared to 2008

How to describe the data / table when there are multiple groups present in tables or graph:

1. General trend
a. Look for similarities and make general statements overall
E.g. Both increase as x increases.

2. Comparative data quote

3. Compare within the group

a. Does it increase / decrease as independent variable increases?

4. Compare between groups

a. Compare the end points
b. Compare the max / min points
c. Compare the range
d. Compare steepness of the graphs

Conclusions (~3m)

 Based on observation of data given