Antibiotic Resistance Criterion B - D, Science
Antibiotic Resistance Criterion B - D, Science
Antibiotic Resistance Criterion B - D, Science
Aim:
SOI: We make decisions for the good of the society based on evidence of small changes that
occur over time.
In the context of this unit’s statement of inquiry, an experiment that is testing how
effectively different concentrations of an antibiotic are able to inhibit the growth of a
bacterium allows for an exploration of the ways in which bacteria have over time developed
antibiotic resistance to better protect themselves. Antibiotic resistance refers to the ability of
bacteria or other microorganisms to develop defense mechanisms against the antibiotics that
were originally effective in killing them (“About Antimicrobial Resistance”). This ability can
develop in a variety of ways such as through mutation, horizontal gene transfer, or the
overuse of the same type of antibiotic (Srakocic). In other words, this experiment is a way to
investigate the idea of evolutionary adaptation. Especially in the world of health and sickness,
small changes are constantly afoot and an antibiotic concentration that was effective a few
years ago, may be harmless to bacteria today. It is only through experiments that carefully
examine the subtle changes that have taken form throughout the years, that it is possible to
make decisions about how current actions taken may need to be modified, and what new
decisions need to be made for the well-being of society.
Background Information:
Research Question:
What is the effect of the concentration of the antibiotic Meropenem (1 µg/mL, 4 µg/mL,
16 µg/mL, 64 µg/mL, 256 µg/mL) (± 5 µg) on the growth of Acinetobacter baumannii
during a 24-hour period measured by the minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) using
the broth macrodilution method?
Hypothesis:
Variables:
Control Variables
Control Amount of When creating the Maintaining the same amount of broth
Mueller-Hinto meropenem between trials is crucial to ensuring
n broth concentrations, a accurate results. For one, varying
pipette will be used amounts of broth in the solutions can
to measure out of cause problems with the dilution
Mueller-Hinton to series. Since the series relies on
make sure that each diluting the antibiotic in a fixed
tube has exactly volume of broth, having inconsistent
0.75 mL of broth. amounts of broth causes the incorrect
The measurement concentrations to be made as the ratio
markings on the of antibiotic to broth changes.
pipette will be used Additionally, the amount of broth also
and the liquid will plays a large role in the determination
be fully dispensed of the MIC. This is because more or
from the pipette less broth can make bacteria more or
when transferring to less visible in the solution. For
the tube. Since this example, if a smaller volume of broth
is quite a specific is used in one trial, it may seem like
measurement and there was an excessive amount of
pipettes can be bacterial growth when in reality, it
difficult to measure simply appears that way because with
with, the less broth, the bacteria are
micropipette will be automatically pushed closer together.
used to help control
this variable if
necessary.
Incubator time Each time that the The duration of incubation for each
and incubator is used, all tube directly affects the time available
temperature 30 of the trials will for bacterial reproduction. Not only
be put into the that, but the duration also influences
incubator at the the phase of bacterial growth the tube
same time and taken is in. After incubation, there are four
out at the same time. primary phases that the bacteria will
When incubating go through: lag phase, exponential
the culture dish to phase, stationary phase, and death
grow the phase. If the tubes are incubated for
Acinetobacter varying amounts of time, the
baumannii, this will experiment results are no longer
be for 24 hours and beneficial as any varying amounts of
when incubating the bacteria can be attributed to the
fully prepared tubes, duration of incubation rather than just
this will be for the meropenem concentration. That
18-24 hours. Also, said, the temperature also plays an
the temperature of equally important role as a control
the incubator will variable. The temperature directly
remain at 35°C affects the reproduction rate of the
throughout the bacterium as different bacteria have
entire experiment. diverse optimal growth temperatures
and thus, the temperature in the
incubator can significantly influence
the bacterium’s ability to grow.
Amount of A micropipette is Changing the amount of bacteria
bacteria in used so that 0.1 mL added to each tube alters the entire
each tube of bacterial composition of the solution. Since
suspension is added some tubes will simply be given a
into each tube. To greater amount of bacteria to start
make sure that there with, their bacterial growth will be
are no tubes with more substantial. However, along with
more or less that, varying amounts of bacteria also
bacteria, completely means varying optical densities. This
empty the can cause significant effects on the
micropipette when data as achieving the 0.5 McFarland
moving from tube to Standard relies on the optical density
tube and carefully compared to the density of the
keep track of which bacterial suspension. This standard is
tubes have already regarded as the norm for antimicrobial
been given the susceptibility testing and culture
suspension. media performance testing which
ensures that the suspension contains
1-2 • 108 colony-forming units (CFU)
per milliliter. Thus, if the amount of
bacteria in each tube isn’t kept the
same, the bacteria won’t be growing
in optimal conditions and the results
won’t be accurate.
Materials:
Mueller-Hinton 200 mL - -
Broth (MHB)
Incubator 1x - -
Meropenem powder 1g - -
Culture of 5 mL - -
Acinetobacter
baumannii
Inoculation loop 1x - -
Pipette 1x -
Disinfectant (70% 50 mL - -
isopropyl alcohol)
Marker 1x - -
Gloves 1x - -
Safety glasses 1x - -
Mask 1x - -
Agar 100 g - -
Weigh boat 1x - -
Spectrophotometer 1x - -
Method:
1. Put on the necessary personal protective equipment for the experiment, namely, safety
glasses, gloves, and a mask.
2. Wipe the table down with disinfectant to make sure that there is a safe environment
for experiment.
Figure 1. Example of set up for broth macrodilution experiment with six trials before incubation
Safety Considerations:
While there is a level of risk when handling pathogenic or potentially dangerous strains of
bacteria, this risk can be considerably reduced with the right safety precautions and
procedures in mind. Since the safety risks in the experiment largely stem from dangers with
contamination from bacteria, standard aseptic techniques should be followed (Stephens).
Personal protective equipment should be worn during the experiment, most importantly
safety goggles, gloves, and a mask, to reduce the likelihood of direct contact or exposure to
the bacterium. Parts of the experiment that necessitate handling of the bacteria should be
carried out in a biosafety cabinet or some other containment device to best prevent the release
of bacteria to the surrounding environment (Varma). Finally, the work surface should be
regularly disinfected, equipment should be sterilized (flame sterilized if possible), and hands
should be regularly washed (“Aseptic Techniques”). Following these safety precautions
should minimize the risk of exposure and create a safe environment for conducting the
experiment.
Ethical/Environmental Considerations:
The ethical and environmental consideration for the experiment primarily relates to the
handling and disposal of the bacterium. Have a plan in place to take action in the event of an
accidental spill or leak by using proper disinfectants and absorbent materials to effectively
clean up the spill. Also, follow proper storage of the bacterium during and after the
experiment. Any container with bacteria such as culture dishes should be wrapped with
sealing film and stored upside down to inhibit contamination (Scoville). Finally, the bacteria
should be thoughtfully disposed of; before throwing it away, soak the used culture tubes and
petri dishes in a diluted solution of bleach (“Guideline for working with bacterial cultures”).
References
"About Antimicrobial Resistance." Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 5 Oct. 2022,
www.cdc.gov/drugresistance/about.html#:~:text=Antimicrobial%20resistance%20hap
pens%20when%20germs,and%20sometimes%20impossible%2C%20to%20treat.
www.sciencedirect.com/topics/immunology-and-microbiology/broth-dilution.
2023.
2015, www.everydayhealth.com/acinetobacter/guide/.
www.healthline.com/health/antibiotics/how-do-bacteria-become-resistant-to-antibiotic
Binod. "Dilution Tests for Antibiotic Sensitivity Testing (Broth dilution, Agar dilution and
"Guideline for working with bacterial cultures." Waksman Student Scholars Program,
"How Bacteria Build Resistance at the Cellular Level." Online Public Health, Milken
onlinepublichealth.gwu.edu/resources/antibiotic-resistance-at-cellular-level/#:~:text=
There%20are%20two%20main%20ways,is%20through%20horizontal%20gene%20tr
public health. World J Clin Infect Dis 2013; 3(3): 25-36 [DOI:
2023.
2023.
www.reactgroup.org/toolbox/understand/antibiotic-resistance/mutation-and-selection/.
2023.
www.sciencedirect.com/topics/nursing-and-health-professions/beta-lactam-antibiotic.
Scoville, Heather. "How to Dispose of Agar Plates." Career Trend, 29 Dec. 2018,
www.sciencedirect.com/topics/pharmacology-toxicology-and-pharmaceutical-science/
www.healthline.com/health/antibiotics/how-do-bacteria-become-resistant-to-antibiotic
Varma, Avi. "What is aseptic technique?" Medical News Today, 16 Feb. 2023,
2023.