Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 4 views

    Answer Round 2

    Uploaded by

    Rizky C. Ariesta
    The document provides responses to questions from reviewers regarding the software, meshing techniques, boundary layers, and grid growth used in a CFD analysis of a submarine design. It specifies that ANSYS Fluent 2022 and MAXSURF Modeler Advanced Connect Edition version 23.06.00.137 were used. It describes the boundary conditions, body influence meshing technique used to refine cells near the model, and the transition in cell size due to this technique. It also notes that a figure will be updated to include a body fixed axis and remove an earth fixed axis, and provides the viscous resistance coefficient values for each simulation case.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Answer Round 2

    Uploaded by

    Rizky C. Ariesta
    4 views2 pages
    The document provides responses to questions from reviewers regarding the software, meshing techniques, boundary layers, and grid growth used in a CFD analysis of a submarine design. It specifies that ANSYS Fluent 2022 and MAXSURF Modeler Advanced Connect Edition version 23.06.00.137 were used. It describes the boundary conditions, body influence meshing technique used to refine cells near the model, and the transition in cell size due to this technique. It also notes that a figure will be updated to include a body fixed axis and remove an earth fixed axis, and provides the viscous resistance coefficient values for each simulation case.

    Original Title

    Answer round 2

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    The document provides responses to questions from reviewers regarding the software, meshing techniques, boundary layers, and grid growth used in a CFD analysis of a submarine design. It specifies that ANSYS Fluent 2022 and MAXSURF Modeler Advanced Connect Edition version 23.06.00.137 were used. It describes the boundary conditions, body influence meshing technique used to refine cells near the model, and the transition in cell size due to this technique. It also notes that a figure will be updated to include a body fixed axis and remove an earth fixed axis, and provides the viscous resistance coefficient values for each simulation case.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    4 views2 pages

    Answer Round 2

    Uploaded by

    Rizky C. Ariesta
    The document provides responses to questions from reviewers regarding the software, meshing techniques, boundary layers, and grid growth used in a CFD analysis of a submarine design. It specifies that ANSYS Fluent 2022 and MAXSURF Modeler Advanced Connect Edition version 23.06.00.137 were used. It describes the boundary conditions, body influence meshing technique used to refine cells near the model, and the transition in cell size due to this technique. It also notes that a figure will be updated to include a body fixed axis and remove an earth fixed axis, and provides the viscous resistance coefficient values for each simulation case.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    of 2

    1. The full reference to the software used (including version number) for the CFD.

      If
    you can let me have the version number, and the reference to the manual about this
    then that would be great. This is to answer the first question from reviewer 1: “what
    numerical code is used, there is no word on this, did you develop it yourself?”  We
    need something like: Fluent version ??.??, and then give the reference to the Fluent
    manual explaining that.

    Analysis proceed using ANSYS computational fluid dynamics products Fluent 2022
    version.
    Reference: ANSYS for researcher. Ansys CFD-Post User’s Guide. ANSYS, Inc. 2022.
     
    2. The full reference to the Maxsurf software (including version number) for the
    geometric modelling.  Again, we need to quote the version number, and a reference to
    the manual would be a good way of doing this.

    Program using is MAXSURF Modeler Advanced Connect Edition [student license]


    version 23.06.00.137.
    Reference: Bentley. Modeler Program and User Manual Maxusrf Modeller
    CONNECT Edition V23. Bentley Systems, Incorporated. 2022
     
    3.     We need to answer the following questions from reviewer 3:
    3.1.  "Explain how is the boundary layers, and what is the difference in cells";
    3.2.  "How is the growth?"  I assume that he means the growth in the way the grids are
    made between the different grid sizes.  Is it a complete geometrical increase (with all
    the cells being decreased by the same amount as the grid size is increased, or is this
    done in a different way>)

    3.1. The boundary conditions used in this analysis are boxes that are set 2 times
    larger than the ITTC provisions. Boundary conditions are regulated by providing a name
    selection feature to set the inlet, outlet, wall, and body of the submarine. There are two
    meshing techniques used in this final project, namely the body of influence technique and
    element sizing. Body of influence is a technique where the element size of a domain is
    affected by the domain that intersects with that domain so that the domains that are far from
    the model have relatively larger element sizes than the domains that are near the model.

    3.2. The size difference transition is the influence of the body of influence mesh
    technique. The use of this technique is very useful for knowing the area you want to identify
    and is suitable for viewing wakes that occur around the surface of a submarine.
     
    4.     We need to add a body fixed axis to figure 4.  This is the same axis as in figure 1 with
    the origin at the aft end of the body, the x axis forward and the z axis downwards.  Can
    you please add this to the figure, and remove the earth fixed axis which you added at the
    bottom right-hand side of this?
    x

     
    5.     Reviewer 3 requires the values of the viscous resistance to be given separately from
    the total resistance for each case.  Are you please able to provide me with the viscous
    resistance coefficient for each case?  I’ll add that into the results, and put in some
    discussion about it.

    You might also like