Seasonal variation in light, mixing depth and primary productivity in

temperate northern hemisphere waters

Photosynthesis by algae in the ocean represents approximately half of all global primary
production and supplies a large part of the oxygen that we breathe. These algae are tiny
which helps them stay afloat in the surface waters where the sunlight is strong enough to
allow photosynthesis. In temperate latitude winters, lower light intensity and deeper
mixing result in light limiting conditions and hence low primary productivity. In summer,
as the waters stratify, mixing decreases and light intensity increases alleviating the light
limitation.

Marine algae also require nutrients, just as plants in your garden do. The nutrients that
marine algae require are phosphate, nitrate and silicate. These are typically in low
concentrations in the surface waters of the ocean, and at higher concentrations at depth.
When mixing brings these nutrients to the sunlight surface waters phytoplankton
proliferate.

At temperate latitudes in the North Atlantic there is a seasonal cycle in phytoplankton

productivity with a bloom occurring in the spring, and a smaller bloom in the fall. This is
linked to seasonal cycles in sunlight intensity and mixing of the ocean water. In this
exercise we examine these cycles to gain a deeper understanding of linkages between
phytoplankton productivity and physical oceanographic processes.

Goals
In this exercise we will work with light, temperature, and phytoplankton biomass data to;
 Become more skilled in reading and interpreting semilog graphs, temperature
profiles, and time series plots.
 Practice unit conversions.
 Gain an understanding of k, the attenuation coefficient for nondirectional light.
 See how the depth of the photic zone and the surface mixed layer varies seasonally
at temperate latitudes and how this relates to seasonal phytoplankton productivity
dynamics.

Light
Sunlight penetrating the ocean surface can be attenuated by the water, organisms in the
water, dissolved organic molecules from organism’s wastes and decay, and suspended
particles. The importance of some of these depends on the biological residents of the water
and the proximity to a source of suspended sediment. Figure 1 (below) shows two
examples of light attenuation versus depth. Were you to measure light attenuation in your
local ocean you would likely collect data that would result in a different line on this graph.

Lauren Sahl and Jim McKenna, Maine Maritime Academy, 2014.

Becoming familiar with the graph

Figure 1. Light attenuation in oceanic and coastal waters.

1. The photic zone is defined as the surface layer where light intensity is strong enough so
that photosynthesis by marine algae exceeds respiration (the bottom of the photic zone is
also called the compensation depth). This is approximately the depth at which the light
intensity is equal to 1% of the summertime light intensity at the surface.

The plot shows that the light intensity at the surface is about 500 W/m2. At what depth is
the light intensity 1% of this value in;
 Oceanic water 120 m

 Coastal water 10 m

2. Deep sea fish need about 3 x 10-12 W/m2 to see*.

Read the graph to determine the depth of total darkness for fish in oceanic water.
820 m

3. Humans require 10-9 W/m2 to see*.

Read the graph to determine the depth of total darkness for humans in deep ocean
water. 670 m

Read the graph to determine the depth of total darkness for humans in coastal water
60 m

*(From: Seawater: Its composition, properties and behaviour, by The Open University, 1995).

Lauren Sahl and Jim McKenna, Maine Maritime Academy, 2014.

4. The table below gives some light intensity data measured at an ocean station.

Plot the data on the graph in Figure 1 and label the line station 1.
Depth (m) Measured light
intensity(W m-2)
0 300
100 14.9
200 0.74
300 0.037
400 0.0018
500 9.18 x 10-5
600 4.57 x 10-6
1000 2.81 x 10-11

Compare station 1 to the plots for coastal water and oceanic water.

Do you think station 1 is a coastal or an oceanic station? Why?

Oceanic – plot indicates deep light penetration, thus clear oceanic water

Determining k
The graph can be used to determine k, the diffuse attenuation coefficient for nondirectional
light. k is a measure of the amount of light that is absorbed and/or scattered as light passes
through the water. Clear oceanic waters have very low k values while turbid coastal waters
have high values.

To determine k we need to manipulate a formula that relates light intensity at the light
source, light intensity at some distance from the source and k.
−kz
I z =I 0 e

Where Iz = light intensity at a distance z from the source. In this exercise z is depth in the ocean.

Io = light intensity at the source. In this exercise this is light intensity at the surface of the ocean.

e = natural log

k = light attenuation coefficient

z = distance from the light source. In this exercise z is the depth at which Iz is measured.

The above formula can be simplified to this, which can be easily solved with a calculator.

ln
() Iz
I0
=−kz Equation 1

Hint- be sure to divide Iz by Io before taking the natural log!

Lauren Sahl and Jim McKenna, Maine Maritime Academy, 2014.
Use Equation 1 to solve for k for the coastal water, oceanic water and water at station 1
plotted in Figure 1.

Coastal water: k = - [ln(Iz/I0)/z]

= - [ln(5/500)/z]
= - [-4.605/10]
= 0.46 m-1

Oceanic water: k = - [-4.605/120]

= 0.038 m-1

Station 1: k = - [-4.605/160]
= 0.029

Keeping in mind that lower k values indicate clearer water while higher k values indicate
that the water is more turbid, of the coastal water, oceanic water and water at station 1,
which has the most turbid water? What do you think makes it turbid?

Coastal, closer to sediment sources from land, higher productivity due to higher nutrient
inputs.

6. The table below (From: The Oceans, by Sverdrup, Johnson and Fleming, 1942) is a
listing of average solar radiation at the sea surface (I0) for different months in the temperate
northern hemisphere ocean. This exercise will illustrate how the photic zone depth varies
with month.

Convert the table values to the same units as those used on the graph.
(1W = 0.239 g cal/sec). Be smart about it and determine the conversion factor, then just
apply it to all the values in the first column of numbers.

Determining the conversion factor.

1 g cal/cm2/min = ? W/m2

1 W/m2 = 0.239 g cal/sec/m2

= 0.239 x 10-4 g cal/cm2/sec
= 14.34 x 10-4 g cal/cm2/min
= 1.434 x 10-3 g cal/cm2/min

Lauren Sahl and Jim McKenna, Maine Maritime Academy, 2014.

Write the conversion factor in the indicated place in the table. Then use it to complete
column 3.

Once you have completed column 3 determine the light intensity at the bottom of the
photic zone in the summer (in the northern hemisphere this will be the June value). Take
1% of this value and write it in each cell in column 4.

Calculate the depth of the photic zone in column 5 by using Equation 1. Use the values in
column 4 as Iz and use k= 0.086 m-1. z = - [ln (2.29/I0)/k]

1 2 3 4 5
Average amount of Average amount of 1% of June Depth of photic
surface (I0) radiation surface (I0) radiation surface light zone (m)
(g cal/cm2 min) (W/m2) intensity Write the
*Write your conversion (W/m2) equation you
factor here. Each of the cells will use here.
below should
______________ contain the same ___________
number.

Jan .094 65.6 2.29 39.0

Feb .138 96.2 2.29 43.5
Mar .212 148 2.29 48.5
April .272 190 2.29 51.4
May .306 213 2.29 52.7
Jun .329 229 2.29 53.5
July .302 211 2.29 52.6
Aug .267 186 2.29 51.1
Sept .230 160 2.29 49.4
Oct .174 121 2.29 46.1
Nov .115 80.2 2.29 41.3
Dec .086 60.0 2.29 38.0

Lauren Sahl and Jim McKenna, Maine Maritime Academy, 2014.

Plot the depth of the photic zone versus month (this is called a time series plot) in Figure 2.
Plot each monthly point on the first day of the month. Connect the points and label the line
PHOTIC ZONE DEPTH.

Figure 2. Photic zone depth, mixed layer depth, and phytoplankton biomass in temperate
northern hemisphere waters.

Lauren Sahl and Jim McKenna, Maine Maritime Academy, 2014.

Determine the depth of the surface mixed layer from the temperature profiles shown
below. Remember that the temperature in the surface mixed layer is uniform (because the
layer is well mixed). Plot the mixed layer depth for each month shown on Figure 2, using
the first day of the month as the plotting point. Connect the points and label the line
MIXED LAYER DEPTH.

From: Introduction to Physical Oceanography by John A. Knauss, 1978.

The table below contains satellite-derived chlorophyll a concentration data from temperate
North Atlantic waters (data were accessed from the NASA Earth Observatory website and
represent monthly averaged values for the year 2012, from coordinates 43.2 °N, 51.2°W).
Although these data represent pigment concentration, they can be used as a proxy for
phytoplankton biomass and productivity with higher pigment concentrations reflective of
higher phytoplankton biomass and productivity.

Plot these data on Figure 2 using the axis on the right. Plot each monthly point on the first
day of the month to which they apply. Connect the points and label the line
PHYTOPLANKTON BIOMASS.

Chlorophyll-a Chlorophyll-a
Month concentration Month concentration
(mg/m3) (mg/m3)
Jan 0.640 Jul 0.640
Feb 0.737 Aug 0.640
Mar 0.806 Sep 0.598
Apr 6.045 Oct 2.091
May 0.668 Nov 0.945
Jun 0.585 Dec 0.834

Lauren Sahl and Jim McKenna, Maine Maritime Academy, 2014.

Each of the sketches below represents the upper 140 m of the water column for a different
month. Examine Figure 2 and for each of the months of January, April, July and October
sketch in and label one horizontal line, indicating the depth of the photic zone, and another
horizontal line, indicating the depth of the surface mixed layer.

For each month sketch in a travel path a phytoplankton might take if carried with the water
as it mixes through the surface mixed layer.

Examine Figure 2 and for each of the sketches above, determine if primary productivity
was low, medium or high and circle the appropriate word under each sketch.

Hypothesize why phytoplankton biomass displays the pattern it does. Think about what
plants and algae need in order to photosynthesize then consider how the biomass pattern
relates to the physical oceanographic parameters of photic zone depth and mixed layer
depth.

Lauren Sahl and Jim McKenna, Maine Maritime Academy, 2014.