Sazman,+vol+12+no+2+2022 202
Sazman,+vol+12+no+2+2022 202
Sazman,+vol+12+no+2+2022 202
ARTICLE REVIEW
Understanding Internet Addiction and its Associated Factors
Among Children and Adolescents: A review of literature
Ayuzeity Bistari Md Bukhori and Mohd. Hasni Ja’afar*
Department of Community Health, Faculty of Medicine, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, 56000 Kuala Lumpur,
Malaysia.
*For reprint and all correspondence: Mohd. Hasni Ja’afar, Department of Community Health, Faculty of
Medicine, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Jalan Yaacob Latif, 56000 Cheras, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Email: [email protected]
ABSTRACT
Internet Addiction (IA) is becoming increasingly recognized as a serious public health issue,
particularly for children and adolescents. This review article discussed the complexity of IA
diagnostic criteria and IA-related risk factors from a public health perspective with the intention
of fostering a better understanding of IA in adolescents and children. The entire discussion
pointed out how the epidemiological triad of disease framework helps to explain the IA
associated factors among adolescents. This framework emphasises the agent (Internet
characteristics and its content), host (e.g., self-personality, comorbidity, psychological status,
inter- and intrapersonal relationship), and environment as extrinsic factors (i.e., physical
pollution, socioeconomic status, availability, and accessibility of the Internet) that facilitate
interaction between the agent and the host. Evaluation of all three components and their
association with IA is essential as it allows for a more comprehensive understanding of how the
issues arise, which can be useful in developing future effective public health measures for IA.
Article history:
Received: 14 July 2022
Accepted: 31 August 2022
Published: 1 September 2022
1625
Internet Addiction in Adolescents
1626
International Journal of Public Health Research Vol 12 No 2 2022, pp (1625-1636)
Internet Addiction among children and adolescent behavioural disorders that result in deterioration and
with their associated factors in this country. cause problems has piqued the interest of numerous
researchers and medical experts working in the field
METHODS of behavioural addiction. This interest is also
In this narrative review, databases like PubMed, influenced by the inclusion of more specific Internet
Web of Science, and Google Scholar were used. Gaming Disorder (IGD) criteria in the DSM-5
Keywords such as (“Internet Addiction” OR appendix. Due to the fact that the diagnostic criteria
“Problematic Internet Use” OR “Internet Addiction for IGD place the behaviour in the category of "non-
Disorder” OR “Pathological Internet Use” OR substance addiction," it is possible that IA is also one
"Problematic Internet Use" OR "Excessive Internet of the candidates for this category, along with
Use" OR "Compulsive Internet Use" OR "Internet "Gambling Disorder".25
Dependence" OR "Virtual Addiction") AND There have been continuous efforts since
(“determinants” OR “risk factors” OR “predictors”) the 1990s to define Internet addiction, leading to
AND (“adolescents” OR “children”) were used. In heated discussion in the process. Finding common
addition to the aforementioned databases, the search ground on terminology to infer the broader meaning
was carried out using the snowballing technique, of Internet addiction is the most challenging task.
which involved looking for references from the first The terms "Internet Addiction Disorder (IAD)",
search. "Pathological Internet Use (PIU)", "Problematic
All study types, including cohort, case- Internet Use", "Excessive Internet Use,"
control, clinical trial, and retrospective record "Compulsive Internet Use," "Internet Dependence,"
review studies, were eligible for inclusion in the and "Virtual Addiction" have been commonly used
selection criteria. The articles cover a wide range of for decades.26
research topics and include reports written in both If a person is said to be addicted to the
Malay and English. The years covered in this Internet, this argument seems equivalent to stating
article's publishing dates range from 2005 to 2022. that an alcoholic is addicted to a store selling
Following evaluation of the entire document, alcohol. Consequently, the term "Internet addiction"
selected papers were imported into Mendeley is imprecise or inappropriate.27 Nevertheless, a
version 1.19.8. similar method is used to study widespread Internet
use around the world, and most authors, including
RESULTS the authors of the reviewed models, continue to use
According to the search strategy, publications on the term "Internet addiction" in general to describe
Internet Addiction and its associated factors among the various behavioural addictions connected to
adolescents and children as well as the IA criteria Internet use.
and terminology produced a total of 68 articles, IA can thus be described as a persistent
including reports and research articles. The pattern of maladaptive behaviour, characterised by
information obtained from the literatures was then preoccupation, insistence, or uncontrolled or
divided into the following headings.: excessive Internet use associated with the
development of tolerance, withdrawal symptoms,
• IA Criteria and Terminology
and unsuccessful attempts to reduce or stop,
• Factors Contributing to Internet Addiction
resulting in clinically significant functional decline
among Adolescents and Children in the
or impairment.15,7,28-29
Context of Public Health (Epidemiology
There are few well-known diagnostic
Triad)
criteria and models for IA that have ever been
created and put forth by prior researchers (Table 1).
DISCUSSION These models were chosen in accordance with
IA Criteria and Terminology previously developed criteria for IA that have been
The American National Psychiatric Association widely or frequently cited by other researchers. The
(APA) has omitted the term "addiction" in the three models of Internet addiction criteria
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental highlighted by K.S. Young,20 Griffiths,30 and Tao et
Disorders (DSM) for four consecutive editions al31 share similarities in that all sets of criteria
because it is stigmatising, viewed as a general term describe a lack of control over Internet use, which
rather than a scientific one, and is too difficult to leads to psychological, social, or professional
define. A new category of "Substance and Addiction conflict or problems (including excessive use) and
Related Disorders" was created by the term's mental preoccupation.
introduction in the DSM-5. The term was, however, Meanwhile, other related characteristics,
added to the DSM-5 and developed into a new including mood management, tolerance,
category of "Substance and Addiction Related withdrawal, and desire or anticipation, are stated
Disorders".24 inconsistently by all three models.18 Internet activity
The expansion of the definition of is frequently viewed as a single entity by researchers
"addiction" to include non-substance-related of all three models. There is a strong correlation
1627
Internet Addiction in Adolescents
between Internet addiction and the amount of time be noted that the DSM-5 still does not include
spent engaging in online activities like social media, subcategories for "sex addiction," "exercise
online shopping, and online gaming.32 addiction," or "shopping addiction" because at this
Hence, there are recommendations for time, the reassessment review lacks the necessary
compulsive "processes" or "behaviours" based on a data to establish diagnostic criteria and detailed
variety of themes, including shopping, physical descriptions are required to classify this behaviour
activity, and online video games, social media, and as a mental disorder.35
various sexual behaviours.18,33,34 However, it should
Table 1 Comparison of the descriptive diagnostic criteria for Internet addiction based on assessment instruments
1628
International Journal of Public Health Research Vol 12 No 2 2022, pp (1625-1636)
1629
Internet Addiction in Adolescents
Internet use. Because they share a common are the third and final component of the
aetiology, there is also a reasonable possibility that epidemiological triad. In contrast to the other
IA and mental disorders co-occur.50 variables mentioned earlier, environmental factors
Moreover, excessive Internet users are received less attention. Environmental factors in the
more likely to have homozygous short alleles in the context of IA may include physical factors such as
serotonin transporter-related promoter region (5- pollution exposure, socioeconomic factors such as
HTTLPR), which is linked to depressive housing condition, Internet accessibility, as well as
disorders.50,51 Despite this, it is difficult to establish exposure to advertising.16, 41
a causal relationship between Internet addiction and
psychological problems due to the lack of a. Environmental pollution
longitudinal data. In addition, there is an ongoing According to the results of a meta-analysis involving
debate as to whether IA should be considered a 31 countries from seven different regions of the
major disease disorder or whether participation in world, the prevalence of IA is higher in countries
Internet activities is merely one way for individuals with higher emotional stress status due to traffic
with gambling issues, compulsive shopping, and congestion and commute times, worries about air
pornography addiction to manifest their disease pollution, lower national income, and general life
problems. Regardless of whether IA is a major dissatisfaction.57
disorder or not, the negative relationship between IA The presence of mentally taxing
and overall psychological well-being has been environmental conditions, such as poor air quality,
clearly demonstrated in previous scientific traffic congestion, and loud noise, can be stressful
literature.50 for those in the area. Due to the unfavourable,
unsuitable environment or the possibility of being
b. Interpersonal exposed to harmful contaminants, people prefer to
Numerous researchers have identified conflict relieve stress by browsing the Internet rather than
between parents and children, the functioning of engaging in outdoor activities.57 As people's stress
family institutions, parental protection, and school levels increase, they are more likely to turn to the
involvement as factors influencing IA in children Internet as a means of escape, which increases their
and adolescents.16,44,52-53 susceptibility to IA due to prolonged Internet use.50
In addition, a study conducted among Moreover, the direct effects of air
adolescents in Hong Kong revealed that adolescents pollutants on humans can manifest in numerous
from parents and divorced families, families ways. The World Health Organization (WHO)
experiencing conflict, and families with severe released a report on six major air pollutants
dysfunction exhibited and positively predicted IA.54 including lead as a neurobehavioral substance
In a large-scale local study, it was also discovered affecting more younger generation. Lead pollution
that adolescents whose parents were married but derived from the use of fuel in transportation and
lived apart were more likely to have IA issues.28 It is engines, paints, electronic waste, incinerators
understood that divorced or cohabiting parents will (burners), water pipes, particularly in developing
have limited time with their children when juggling countries, is a threat to public health due to its
work, family management and maintaining negative neurobehavioral effects on humans, animal
relationships with their children. While it was also life, and the environment.58,59
discovered that children use the Internet to reduce
the psychological insecurity inherent in a single- b. Lead (Plumbum) exposure
parent family environment.54 Furthermore, families Children are particularly susceptible to lead
with emotionally friendly parenting styles can exposure due to its neurotoxic properties, which can
reliably predict adolescent self-regulatory strategies, impair learning, memory, hyperactivity, and, in
an important factor given that Internet use and other extreme cases, result in mental retardation.58 It has
forms of misbehaviour depend on these adolescents' also been found in pre-clinical research that brain
capacity for self-control.53 areas associated with addiction circuits have been
In the meantime, some researchers enhanced as a result of lead-induced modifications
highlight the importance of school involvement in of neurotransmitter receptors, which are known to
IA occurrence, as schools are a crucial environment facilitate the course of illicit substance activity into
for children's development and also promote healthy the brain during adolescence. This period is when
lifestyles.53,55 Due to the negative relationships adolescents are most exposed to addictive behaviors
formed with teachers and peers, adolescents who are such as lead exposure, as well as the appearance of
emotionally affected and poor participation in psychiatric problems in individuals.60
school activities are more likely to develop IA.56 Similarly, the researchers discovered a
similarity between neuro image scanning of
Environmental factors adolescents with IA and substance dependence,
Environmental factors, which are extrinsic factors suggesting that the two share similar
that influence 'agents' and exposure opportunities, neurobiological mechanisms.21 Interestingly, there
1630
International Journal of Public Health Research Vol 12 No 2 2022, pp (1625-1636)
is increasing evidence that early exposure to Pb2+ is time, relieve stress, and have fun on the internet
a risk factor for psychiatric disorders and substance rather than on activities that need financial
abuse. Current evidence also suggests that early resources.64
exposure to Pb2+ during early childhood is It was also found that adolescents from
associated with poor neural development outcomes, low-income households are more likely to receive
with effects varying with exposure magnitude and less information and assistance for their needs,
duration.60 However, assumptions about whether IA making Internet use a cost-effective alternative
shares the same pathway as other addictive activity for them. In addition, low-income families
behaviours must be clarified in future research. tend to have lower educational attainment, which
decreases their likelihood of being aware of the
c. Housing conditions and household count negative effects of Internet addiction and the
The findings of a study conducted in Spain on 1,509 preventative measures available to avoid them, such
individuals between the ages of 18 and 78 seated at as positive parent-child relationships and effective
home (when the movement control phase was communication.54
implemented due to the COVID-19 pandemic)
revealed that those living in smaller houses and with e. Internet availability and Internet advertising
fewer children are more likely to use the Internet When discussing Internet advertising, for instance,
than those living in larger houses with terraces and in the context of alcohol-related research,
more children. It is highly probable that many of availability and exposure to alcohol are well-known
them use the Internet in an unhealthy, excessive, and environmental factors that influence the alcohol
compulsive manner in an attempt to alleviate the consumption of young people.16,65 Given that neural
negative emotions they experience as a result of abnormalities (e.g., atrophy of the dorsolateral
being confined to a small space at home.61 prefrontal cortex) and cognitive dysfunction (e.g.,
This assertion is in line with a study of 220 memory impairment) associated with IA are similar
parents who had children in Japan during the to substance abuse and addictive behaviour
COVID-19 outbreak, which discovered that having problems, it is reasonable to believe that Internet
fewer rooms at home was linked to higher IA availability and accessibility may also influence
scores.62 According to the Ministry of Internal IA.21,57,66
Affairs and Communications of Japan, the number A study conducted in Korea found that
of persons renting housing is highest among those in adolescents who are exposed to more Internet game
their 20s, and the proportion of people living in their advertising and who are more susceptible to being
own properties rises with age. Hence, IA is a severe misled or influenced by advertisements are more
problem among young people if the number of likely to develop a video game addiction.16,67 In
rooms in the house rises with age, money, and other order to prevent problems related to alcohol, the
markers of social standing. Additionally, if there are WHO has emphasised the significance of regulating
many rooms, the lives of the roommates can have the availability and marketing of alcohol.68 The
some influence on how much time is spent online.62 same logic can be applied to the problem of IA. To
date, many countries lack regulations or policies
d. Household income governing advertising content (especially those
Low family income was found to be a predictor of containing violence, adult viewing material or
IA.54,63,64 The low-income group was shown to be pornography). Consequently, adolescents are often
much more addicted to the internet than other exposed to Internet game advertisement with
groups, and this addiction lessened as wealth inappropriate sexual and violent content. Table 2
increased. This may be because those coming from provides a summary of the general overview of
low-income family frequently choose to spend their factors related to IA.
1631
Internet Addiction in Adolescents
Host Intrapersonal
and household count children are more likely to use the Internet than those
living in larger houses with terraces and more
children.
scores.
Household income Low family income was found to be a predictor of 54,63,64
IA.
1632
International Journal of Public Health Research Vol 12 No 2 2022, pp (1625-1636)
1633
Internet Addiction in Adolescents
11. Ahmadi K. Internet addiction among Iranian 23. OCDE. Children & Young People ’ s Mental
adolescents: A Nationwide Study. Acta Med Health in the Digital Age. Oecd [Internet].
Iran. 2014;467–72. 2018;16. Available from:
12. Mak KK, Lai CM, Watanabe H, Kim D Il, http://www.oecd.org/els/health-
Bahar N, Ramos M, et al. Epidemiology of systems/Children-and-Young-People-
internet behaviors and addiction among Mental-Health-in-the-Digital-Age.pdf.
adolescents in six Asian countries. 24. Rosenthal RJ, Faris SB. The etymology and
Cyberpsychology, Behav Soc Netw. early history of ‘addiction.’ Addict Res
2014;17(11):720–8. Theory [Internet]. 2019;27(5):437–49.
13. Balhara YPS, Mahapatra A, Sharma P, Available from:
Bhargava R. Problematic internet use https://doi.org/10.1080/16066359.2018.154
among students in South-East Asia: Current 3412.
state of evidence. Indian J Public Health. 25. Ko CH, Yen JY, Yen CF, Chen CS, Chen
2018;62(3):197–210. CC. The association between Internet
14. Chia DXY, Ng CWL, Kandasami G, Seow addiction and psychiatric disorder: A review
MYL, Choo CC, Chew PKH, et al. of the literature. Eur Psychiatry.
Prevalence of internet addiction and gaming 2012;27(1):1–8.
disorders in southeast Asia: A meta- 26. Poli R. Internet addiction update : diagnostic
analysis. Int J Environ Res Public Health. criteria , assessment and prevalence.
2020;17(7). 2017;7:4–8.
15. World Health Organization. Public Health 27. Starcevic V. Is Internet addiction a useful
Implications of Excessive Use of the concept? Aust N Z J Psychiatry.
Internet, Computers, Smartphones and 2013;47(1):16–9.
Similar Electronic Devices Meeting report. 28. Ying CY, Awaluddin SM, Kuay LK, Man
2014;151. Available from: CS, Baharudin A, Yn LM, et al. Association
https://apps.who.int/iris/rest/bitstreams/826 of Internet Addiction with Adolescents ’
746/retrieve. Lifestyle : A National School-Based
16. Chung S, Lee J, Lee HK. Personal factors, Survey. 2021;1–13.
internet characteristics, and environmental 29. Musetti A, Cattivelli R, Giacobbi M,
factors contributing to adolescent internet Zuglian P, Ceccarini M, Capelli F, et al.
addiction: A public health perspective. Int J Challenges in internet addiction disorder: Is
Environ Res Public Health. 2019;16(23). a diagnosis feasible or not? Front Psychol.
17. WHO. Public health implications of 2016;7(JUN):1–8.
excessive use of the Internet and other 30. Griffiths M. A “components” model of
communication and gaming platforms addiction within a biopsychosocial
[Internet]. World Health Organization. framework. J Subst Use. 2005;10(4):191–7.
2018. Available from: 31. Tao R, Huang X, Wang J, Zhang H, Zhang
https://www.who.int/news/item/13-09- Y, Li M. Proposed diagnostic criteria for
2018-public-health-implications-of- internet addiction. Addiction.
excessive-use-of-the-internet-and-other- 2010;105(3):556–64.
communication-and-gaming-platforms. 32. Van Rooij AJ, Schoenmakers TM, van de
18. Van Rooij AJ, Prause N. A critical review of Eijnden RJJM, van de Mheen D.
“internet addiction” criteria with Compulsive Internet Use: The Role of
suggestions for the future. J Behav Addict. Online Gaming and Other Internet
2014;3(4):203–13. Applications. J Adolesc Heal [Internet].
19. Tripathi A. Impact of Internet Addiction on 2010;47(1):51–7. Available from:
Mental Health: An Integrative Therapy Is http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jadohealth.2009.
Needed. Integr Med Int. 2018;4(3–4):215– 12.021.
22. 33. Kuss DJ, Griffiths MD. Online social
20. Young KS. Internet addiction: The networking and addiction-A review of the
emergence of a new clinical disorder. psychological literature. Int J Environ Res
Cyberpsychology Behav. 1998;1(3):237– Public Health. 2011;8(9):3528–52.
44. 34. Rooij AJ Van. Online video game addiction
21. Yuan K, Qin W, Liu Y, Tian J. Internet [Internet]. Vol. 106, Addiction Abingdon
addiction: Neuroimaging findings. England. 2011. 205–12 p. Available from:
Commun Integr Biol. 2011;4(6):637–9. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/2084
22. Kurniasanti KS, Assandi P, Ismail RI, 0209.
Nasrun MWS, Wiguna T. Internet 35. American Psychiatric Association.
addiction: A new addiction? Med J Indones. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
2019;28(1):82–91. Disorders Fifth Edition (DSM-5). Library of
1634
International Journal of Public Health Research Vol 12 No 2 2022, pp (1625-1636)
1635
Internet Addiction in Adolescents
Sensation seeking, deviant peer affiliation, during the COVID-19 pandemic. PLoS One
and internet gaming addiction among [Internet]. 2022;17(6):e0270210. Available
Chinese adolescents: The moderating effect from:
of parental knowledge. Front Psychol. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3576
2019;9(JAN):1–7. 7548%0Ahttp://www.pubmedcentral.nih.g
56. Fredricks MTWJ. The Reciprocal Links ov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=PMC9242492.
between School Engagement, Youth 63. He Bu, Xinli Chi DQ. Prevalence and
Problem Behaviors, and School Dropout predictors of the persistence and incidence
during Adolescence. Child Dev [Internet]. of adolescent internet addiction in Mainland
2014;85(2):722–37. Available from: China: A two-year longitudinal study.
10.1111/cdev.12138. Elsevier [Internet]. 2021;122. Available
57. Cheng C, Li AYL. Internet addiction from:
prevalence and quality of (real) life: A meta- https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/arti
Analysis of 31 nations across seven world cle/abs/pii/S0306460321002240#!.
regions. Cyberpsychology, Behav Soc 64. Pervin NB, Emre T. Examination of internet
Netw. 2014;17(12):755–60. use in terms of psychological well-being.
58. Manisalidis I, Stavropoulou E, Stavropoulos Educ Res Rev. 2021;16(7):296–309.
A, Bezirtzoglou E. Environmental and 65. Broman CL. The Availability of Substances
Health Impacts of Air Pollution: A Review. in Adolescence: Influences in Emerging
Front Public Heal. 2020;8(February):1–13. Adulthood. J Child Adolesc Subst Abus.
59. World Health Organization W. Lead 2016;25(5):487–95.
poisoning [Internet]. Vol. 1, WHO. 2021. p. 66. Brand M, Young KS, Laier C. Prefrontal
1023–4. Available from: control and Internet addiction: A theoretical
https://www.who.int/news-room/fact- model and review of neuropsychological
sheets/detail/lead-poisoning-and-health. and neuroimaging findings. Front Hum
60. Albores-Garcia D, McGlothan JL, Guilarte Neurosci. 2014;8(MAY):1–13.
TR. Early-life lead exposure and 67. Lee SY, Kim MS, Lee HK. Prevention
neurodevelopmental disorders. Curr Opin Strategies and Interventions for Internet Use
Toxicol [Internet]. 2021;26:22–7. Available Disorders Due to Addictive Behaviors
from: Based on an Integrative Conceptual Model.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cotox.2021.03.007 Curr Addict Reports. 2019;6(3):303–12.
61. Líbano M Del, Corbí M, Gutiérrez-García 68. WHO, Hammer JH, Parent MC, Spiker DA.
A, Alonso-Centeno A. Psychological well- Global status report on alcohol and health
being and home conditions during covid-19 2018 [Internet]. Vol. 65, Global status report
confinement. Internet addiction and on alcohol. 2018. 74–85 p. Available from:
nostalgia as mediators. Int J Environ Res http://www.who.int/substance_abuse/public
Public Health. 2021;18(14). ations/global_alcohol_report/msbgsruprofil
62. Kamoshida S, Nihonmatsu N, Takagi G, es.pdf%0Ahttp://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pu
Wakashima K. The relationship between bmed/29355346.
family variables and family social problems
1636