Highway Geometric Design Solved Problems
Highway Geometric Design Solved Problems
Highway Geometric Design Solved Problems
Geometric Design
Lucas Montogue
► PROBLEMS
1.( ) The station of the initial point of vertical curve (PVC) lies beyond (i.e., is
greater than) 338 + 00, and the elevation is greater than 1315 ft.
2.( ) The elevation of the final point of vertical curve (PVT) is greater than 1317 ft.
3.( ) The station of the high point lies beyond (i.e., is greater than) 340 + 50, and
the elevation is greater than 1320 ft.
1
© 2019 Montogue Quiz
PROBLEM 5 (Mannering & Washburn, 2013, w/ permission)
An equal-tangent crest curve connects a +2% initial grade with a −1% final
grade, and is designed for 55 mi/h. The station of the point of tangent intersection
(PVI) is 233 + 40 with elevation 1203 ft. What is the elevation of the curve at station
234 + 00?
A) y = 1191.7 ft
B) y = 1195.1 ft
C) y = 1198.5 ft
D) y = 1201.9 ft
True or false?
1.( ) The design speed of the curve is greater than 50 mi/h.
2.( ) The station of the initial point of horizontal curve (PC) lies beyond (i.e., is
greater than) 2695 + 90.
3.( ) The station of the final point of horizontal curve (PT) lies beyond (i.e., is
greater than) 2704 + 50.
4.( ) The chord length to the first even 100 ft station is greater than 25 ft.
2
© 2019 Montogue Quiz
PROBLEM 10A (Mannering & Washburn, 2013, w/ permission)
A horizontal curve on a two-lane highway (10-ft lanes) is designed for 50
mi/h with a 6% superelevation. The central angle of the curve is 35 degrees and
the point of tangent intersection (PI) is at station 482 + 72. What is the station of
the final point of horizontal curve (PT)?
A) Station of PT = 482 + 50.3
B) Station of PT = 485 + 20.4
C) Station of PT = 488 + 30.6
D) Station of PT = 491 + 25.1
PROBLEM 10B
In the previous problem, how many feet have to be cleared from the lane’s
shoulder edge to provide adequate stopping sight distance?
A) D = 13.27 ft
B) D = 17.43 ft
C) D = 21.72 ft
D) D = 25.80 ft
3
© 2019 Montogue Quiz
► ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Table 1 Values of K for crest vertical curves based on stopping sight distance
4
© 2019 Montogue Quiz
Table 2 (Continued)
► SOLUTIONS
P.1 ■ Solution
1. False. Given the distance D1 = 520/2 = 260 ft between the PVI and the PVC,
the stationing of the PVC is determined as
The distance between the PVI and the PVC is equivalent to 2.6 stations.
Equipped with this quantity and the grade G1 = +4.0%, the elevation of the PVC is
determined to be
Elevation
= of PVC Elevation of PVI − G1 × N PVC-PVI
∴ Elevation of PVC= 1325 − 4.0 × 2.6= 1314.6 ft
2. True. The distance between the PVT and the PVI is D2 = 520/2 = 260 ft, which
corresponds to 2.6 stations. Equipped with this quantity and the grade G2 = −2.5%,
the elevation of the PVT is determined as
Elevation
= of PVT Elevation of PVI − G2 × N PVI-PVT
= 1325 − ( −2.5 ) × 2.6
∴ Elevation of PVT = 1318.5 ft
3. True. The vertical curve can be described by a parabola of the general form
𝑦𝑦 = 𝑎𝑎𝑥𝑥 2 + 𝑏𝑏𝑏𝑏 + 𝑐𝑐. Differentiating this equation gives the slope of the curve,
dy
= 2ax + b
dx
Coefficients a and b depend on the grades and the length of the curve; that is,
5
© 2019 Montogue Quiz
G2 − G1 −2.5 − 4.0
a= = = −0.625
2L 2 × 5.20
b G=
= 1 4.0
so that
y′ = 2 × ( −0.625 ) × x + 4.0
∴ y′ =−1.25 x + 4.0
Since the high point is an extremum of the curve, the slope of the curve at that
point must equal zero. Accordingly, we set the foregoing equation to zero and
solve for x,
Station=
of high point Station of PVC + x
∴ Station of high point= ( 337 + 40 ) + ( 3 + 20 )
∴ Station of high point =
340 + 60
The elevation of the high point is obtained by substituting x = 3.2 stations in the
equation of the parabola,
The design speed of the curve depends on the value of rate of vertical
curvature K in the AASHTO formula
xhl
xhi= KG1 → K= (I)
G1
where xhi is the distance from the PVC to the high point and can be determined as
349.7
=K ≈ 151
2.32
Referring to Table 1 with this quantity, we read a design speed of 60 mi/h for
the curve in question.
P.3 ■ Solution
1. False. The difference between the stationing of the highest point and the
stationing of the PVI is (100 + 79.35) – (98 + 20) = 259 ft. Given the distance 𝑥𝑥ℎ𝑙𝑙 =
L/2 + 259 from the PVC to the high point of the curve, the length of the curve is
shown to be
6
© 2019 Montogue Quiz
L
xhl =K × G1 → xhl = × G1
G1 − G2
L L
∴ =+ 259 × 3.2
2 3.2 − ( −1.1)
1060 ft
∴L =
The distance between the PVI and the PVC for an equal-tangent curve such as
the present one is D1 = 1060/2 = 530 ft. The stationing of the PVC is determined as
follows,
D1 530
Station of PVC = Station of PVI − = ( 98 + 20 ) −
100 100
∴ Station of PVC =
92 + 90
2. False. The distance between the PVT and the PVI is D2 = 1060/2 = 530 ft.
Accordingly, the stationing of the PVT is determined next,
D2 530
Station of PVT = Station of PVI + = ( 98 + 20 ) +
100 100
∴ Station of PVT =
103 + 50
3. True. From the AASHTO formula, we have L = KA. Substituting and solving for
K gives
L
L = KA → K =
G1 − G2
1060
K
∴= = 246.5 ≈ 247
3.2 − ( −1.1)
Referring to Table 1 with this rate of vertical curvature, the design speed is seen
to be 70 mi/h.
P.4 ■ Solution
The length of the curve in question is calculated as
L
2 × ( Station of PVI − Station of PVC )
=
100
∴ L= 200 × ( 56 + 92 ) − ( 54 + 24 )
The minimum length of vertical curve based on stopping sight distance is given
by L = KA, where coefficient K, for a design speed of 60 mi/h, is found as K = 151
(Table 1). Accordingly,
Since L > Lmin, we conclude that the curve is indeed long enough to provide a
design speed of 60 mi/h.
P.5 ■ Solution
To begin, we determine the minimum length of the curve with the AASHTO
formula Lmin = KA. For a design speed of 55 mi/h, we read K = 114 (Table 1). Thus,
For an equal-tangent crest curve, the distance between the initial point of
vertical curve and the point of tangent intersection is D1 = 342/2 = 171 ft. The
stationing of the PVC is calculated as
7
© 2019 Montogue Quiz
D1 171
Station of PVC = Station of PVI − = ( 233 + 40 ) − = 231 + 69
100 100
Given the 1.71 stations between the PVC and the PVI, the elevation of the PVC is
determined next,
G2 − G1 −1.0 − 2.0
a= = = −0.439
2L 2 × 3.42
b G=
= 1 2.0
while c = 1199.6 ft is the elevation of the PVC. We aim for the elevation at station
234 + 00, that is, the elevation for x = 2.34 stations. Accordingly,
P.6 ■ Solution
With recourse to Table 1, coefficient K for this design speed is 114. The
minimum length of the vertical curve follows as
Lmin 399
Station of PVC = Station of PVT − = (114 + 50 ) −
100 100
∴ Station of PVC = (114 + 50 ) − 3.99 = 110 + 51
The distance between the available point, which is at station 112 + 35, and the
PVC is
c =y − ax 2 − bx
Coefficients a and b are such that
G2 − G1 −1.0 − 2.5
a= = = −0.439
2L 2 × 3.99
b = G1 = +2.5
y aD 2 − bD
Elevation of PVC =−
= 245 − ( −0.439 ) ×1.242 − 2.5 ×1.24=
∴ Elevation of PVC 2
241.8 ft
To determine the stationing of the high point, recall that this is an extremum of
the curve and hence the slope therein must be zero. Thus, setting dy/dx = 0 and
solving for x yields
8
© 2019 Montogue Quiz
dy
= 2ax + b → 2 × ( −0.439 ) x + 2.5
= 0
dx
∴x =2.85 stations
Station=
of high point Station of PVC + x
∴ Station of high point = (111 + 11) + ( 2 + 85) = 113 + 96
The elevation of the high point is obtained by inserting x = 2.85 stations in the
equation of the parabola,
P.7 ■ Solution
With recourse to Table 1, the K factor for a speed of 65 mi/h is 193. The grade
difference is A = +2 – (−1) = 3.0%. The curve length is given by the product
L 579
Station of PVC = Station at 300 ft − = ( 535 + 24.25) − = 532 + 34.75
2 2
Similarly, the station of the PVT follows as
L 579
Station of PVT = Station at 300 ft + = ( 535 + 24.25) + = 538 + 13.75
2 2
Given the elevation Y = 300 ft, the tangent elevation of the PVC is determined as
G1 x 2 × 579
Tangent elevation of PVC =−
Y 300 −
= 294.21 ft
=
200 200
The distance from the PVC is x = 53,300 − 53,234.8 = 65.2 ft, and the offset is
Ax 2 3.0 × 65.252
Offset
= = = 0.110 ft
200 L 200 × 579
The curve elevation is then
66.25
Tangent elevation
= 294.21 + 2 × = 295.52 ft
100
while the curve elevation becomes
9
© 2019 Montogue Quiz
The distance from the high point of the PVC is given by
LG1 579 × 2
X high
= = = 386 ft
( G1 − G2 ) 2 − ( −1)
The station of the high point follows as
P.8 ■ Solution
The first step is to compute the stopping sight distance S, which is given by
u2
=S 1.47ut +
a
30 − G
32.2
Here, u = 70 mi/h is the vehicle speed when brake is applied, t = 2.5 s is the
reaction time, a = 11.2 ft/s2 is the deceleration rate, and G = 0.04 is grade
percentage. Substituting the pertaining variables gives
702
S = 1.47 × 70 × 2.5 + = 788 ft
11.2
30 × − 0.04
32.2
Assume first that the sight distance is greater than the length of the curve, S > L.
The equation to apply in this case is
Lmin =2S −
( 400 + 3.5S ) =×
2 788 −
( 400 + 3.5 × 788) = 1050 ft
A 2 − ( −4 )
Since S ≯ L, this relation is not valid. Next, assume instead that S < L. The
applicable equation in this case is
AS 2 6 × 7882
=Lmin = = 1180 ft
400 + 3.5S 400 + 3.5 × 788
which indeed happens to be greater than S. A second aspect to verify is the
comfort criterion, whereby the curve should have a minimum length such that
Au 2 6 × 702
Lmin
= = = 632 ft
46.5 46.5
Finally, the appearance criterion imposes a minimum length such that
P.9 ■ Solution
1. True. The design speed can be determined by dint of the equation for
radius of traveled path,
V2
=R →
= V 15 R ( e + f )
15 ( e + f )
To proceed, we must determine the radius R. This can be determined with the
relation
∆ ∆
=T R tan =
→ R T cot
2 2
10
© 2019 Montogue Quiz
where T = 436.76 ft is the tangent length and Δ = 40o is the intersection angle.
Thus,
40o
436.76 × cot
R= =1200 ft
2
Returning to the expression for design speed, we find that
2. False. The station of the point of curve is the difference of the station of the
PI and the tangent length. Mathematically,
∴ Station of PC
= ( 2700 + 10.65) − ( 4 + 36.76 )
∴ Station of PC =
2695 + 73.9
3. False. The station of the PT is given by
Station
= of PT Station of PC + L
where L is the length of curve, which can be estimated as
Station of PT
= Station of PC +=
L ( 2695 + 73.89 ) + (8 + 37.8)
∴ Station of PT =2703 + 111.69 =2704 + 11.7
4. True. The chord length for the first even 100-ft station can be estimated as
δ
C1 = 2 R sin 1
2
Here, 𝛿𝛿1 is the deflection angle, which is calculated as
πR
l1 = δ1
180
where l1 = 100 – 73.9 = 26.1 ft is the length of the first arc. Solving for 𝛿𝛿1 and
substituting gives
πR 180l1
l1
= δ1 → =
δ1
180 πR
180 × 26.1
∴ δ1
= = 1.25o
π ×1200
Finally, C1 is computed as
1.25o
2 ×1200 × sin
C1 = =26.2 ft
2
P.10 ■ Solution
Part A: Referring to Table 2 with a design speed of 50 mi/h and a
superelevation of 6%, we read a limiting coefficient of side friction of 0.14. The
radius of the travel path is determined next,
( 50 ×=1.467 )
2
V2
=Rv = 835.4 ft
e 6
g f + 32.2 × 0.14 +
100 100
We should add 10/2 ft to account for one of the lanes, with the result that R =
835.4 + 10/2 = 840.4 ft. Given the central angle of the curve Δ = 35o, the length of
the tangent is computed as
11
© 2019 Montogue Quiz
∆ 35o
R × tan =×
T= 840.4 tan =264.9 ft
2 2
The length L of the curve, in turn, is estimated as
π R∆ π × 840.4 × 35o
=L = = 513.4 ft
180 180
The station of the PT follows from the relation
L
Station
= of PT Station of PC + (I)
100
Before proceeding, we require the station of PC. This is given by
T
= Station of PI − Station of PC
100
T
∴ Station of PC =Station of PI −
100
264.9
∴ Station of PC = ( 482 + 72 ) − = 480 + 07
100
Backsubstituting into equation (I) gives
513.4
Station of PT = ( 480 + 07 ) + = 485 + 20.4
100
► The correct answer is B.
Part B: To assess the need for width space in the shoulder edge, we first
calculate the necessary middle ordinate Ms,
90 × SSD
M s Rv 1 − cos
=
π Rv
Reading Table 1, the stopping sight distance for a design speed of 50 mi/h is 425
ft. Accordingly,
90 × 425
M=
s 840.4 × 1 − cos = 26.72 ft
π × 840.4
The distance that needs to be cleared from the lane’s shoulder is given by the
difference
P.11 ■ Solution
For the specified superelevation and design speed, Table 2 gives a limiting
friction factor of 0.10. The radius of the travel path follows as
( 70 ×=1.467 )
2
V2
=Rv = 2046.8 ft
e 6
g f + 32.2 × 0.10 +
100 100
The length of the tangent is
T
= Station of PI − Station of=
PC → T (Station of PI − Station of PC ) ×100
100
T (130 + 90 ) − (123 + 70 ) ×100
∴= = 720 ft
L
Station
= of PT Station of PC + (I)
100
12
© 2019 Montogue Quiz
Before proceeding, we must compute the length of the horizontal curve, L,
which is given by
π R∆
L=
180
The central angle of the curve, Δ, is determined as
∆ T ∆
=T R tan =→ tan
2 R 2
∆ T
∴ arctan
=
2 R
T 720 o
∴∆ = 2 arctan = 2 × arctan = 38.76
R 2046.8
so that
π × 2046.8 × 38.76
=L = 1384.6 ft
180
Backsubstituting into equation (I) gives
1384.6
Station of PT = (123 + 70 ) + = 137 + 54.6
2
► The correct answer is A.
P.12 ■ Solution
With reference to Table 1, the minimum stopping sight distance for a speed of
50 mi/h is 425 ft. The radius of the curve is estimated as
P.13 ■ Solution
To begin, we compute the middle ordinate distance Ms, which is given by the
difference
Lane width
Ms =Distance available − =34 − 12 2 =28 ft
2
Assume a design speed of 60 mi/h. Referring to Table 2, the limiting coefficient
of side friction is 0.12. Substituting this and other pertaining variables in the
equation for radius of traveled path brings to
( 60 ×=1.467 )
2
V2
( Rv )60
= =
e 8
1203 ft
g f + 32.2 × 0.12 +
100 100
Reading Table 1, we see that a design speed of 60 mi/h corresponds to a
stopping sight distance of 570 ft. Evoking the equation for middle ordinate Ms and
substituting the pertaining data, we get
13
© 2019 Montogue Quiz
90 × SSD 90 × 570
( M s )60= ( Rv )60 1 − cos = 1203 × 1 − cos = 33.58 ft
π ( Rv )60 π ×1203
Since this is more than the available Ms of 28.0 ft obtained in the first equation,
we conclude that a design speed of 60 mi/h would not be adequate for this curve.
In a second trial, let the design speed be 50 mi/h. From Table 1, the coefficient of
friction is now 0.14. The radius of traveled path, in turn, is calculated as
( 50 ×1.467 )
2
=( Rv )50 =
8
759.5 ft
32.2 × 0.14 +
100
With reference to Table 2, we take a stopping sight distance of 425 ft. The value
of Ms is now
90 × 425
( M s )= 759.5 × 1 − cos = 29.53 ft
π × 759.5
50
Again, this is above the available middle ordinate of 28.0 ft, and hence we
conclude that a design speed of 50 mi/h would not be safe either. In a third
attempt, let the design speed be 40 mi/h. From Table 1, the coefficient of friction is
now 0.16. The radius of traveled path, in sequence, follows as
( 40 ×1.467 )
2
=( Rv )40 =
8
445.6 ft
32.2 × 0.16 +
100
With reference to Table 1, we extract a stopping sight distance of 305 ft. The
value of Ms is then
90 × 305
( M s )= 445.6 × 1 − cos = 25.85 ft
π × 445.6
40
This, at last, is less than the available middle ordinate of 28 ft. The speed is
suitable. Among the design speeds provided, the highest value for which the curve
would be deemed safe is 40 mi/h.
► ANSWER SUMMARY
Problem 1 T/F
Problem 2 C
Problem 3 T/F
Problem 4 α
Problem 5 D
Problem 6 B
Problem 7 Open-ended pb.
Problem 8 D
Problem 9 T/F
10A B
Problem 10
10B C
Problem 11 A
Problem 12 β
Problem 13 B
14
© 2019 Montogue Quiz
► REFERENCES
FINDLEY, D., SCHROEDER, B., CUNNINGHAM, C., and BROWN, T. (2016).
Highway Engineering. Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann.
GARBER, N. and HOEL, L. (2009). Traffic and Highway Engineering. 4th
edition. Stamford: Cengage Learning.
MANNERING, F. and WASHBURN, S. (2013). Highway Engineering and Traffic
Analysis. 5th edition. Hoboken: John Wiley and Sons.
15
© 2019 Montogue Quiz