Hajeera Shaheen Kadar - MAE990 Research Proposal
Hajeera Shaheen Kadar - MAE990 Research Proposal
Hajeera Shaheen Kadar - MAE990 Research Proposal
INTRODUCTION:
Reading is best learned through reading. The role and importance of reading in second
language vocabulary learning have received more attention in recent years. Over the past few
decades, a great deal of research has been carried out focusing on the relationship between
extensive reading and vocabulary development. However, most of the studies uphold the belief
that ESL students can acquire vocabulary and can strengthen them through reading, most
specifically through extensive reading. Many approaches are used in SLA to teach vocabulary
for L2 learners but only a few strategies are considered to be effective. According to many
studies, ER is found to be a successful approach in developing the first and second language
learning of students.
ER is closely related to both the first and second language learners where they
read a large number of texts in order to obtain a holistic understanding of the text. When it
comes to ER, students rather than focusing on the individual words and sentences, tend to focus
more on the overall understanding of the text (Bamford & Day, 1998). A plethora of research
has shown the benefits of extensive reading and vocabulary development in second language
learning. However, most of the second language teachers in India follow intensive reading in
their language classrooms which can help students to learn the language, but they cannot
acquire it. According to most of the researchers, extensive reading is considered to be one of
the most successful programs in acquiring a foreign language. Therefore, this proposed study
will aim to examine the major research gap in the Indian context focusing on how extensive
reading can improve the vocabulary development of secondary school students in India.
1
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
LITERATURE REVIEW:
Nuttall (1982) asserts that “the best way to improve your knowledge of a foreign
language is to go and live among its speakers and the next best way is to read extensively in it”
(p. 168). There is a difference between ‘learning to read’ and ‘reading to learn’ (Extensive
Reading Foundation, 2011, p.2). The difference between intensive and extensive reading is that
Intensive Reading (IR) is usually teacher-centered where students read a short piece of text
with close guidance from the teacher, and it is all about textbook reading which is also called
‘study reading’ whereas extensive reading is a student-centered approach. The main goal of IR
is to read the given piece of text again and again to extract its literal meaning, understand the
substance, and subject matter of the text, also to improve the grammar and vocabulary
knowledge along with the reading skills. IR is used predominantly in teaching reading in most
language classrooms where the teacher will select what to read and when to read (Miller, 2011).
However, students need to read extensively to enhance their love for reading.
Extensive Reading (ER) is a casual reading where students are enthralled in reading a
book, newspaper, or magazine for acquiring information for pleasure. In this type of reading
students “read a lot of easy material in the new language” (Bamford & Day, 2004, p.1).
According to Grabe and Stoller (2011), ER exposes learners to “large quantities of reading
material within their linguistic competence” (p. 259). Extensive reading is defined by Day et
al., (1991) as “a strategy which enables the learners to meet new words in their texts and by
looking immediately at these unfamiliar words, they will be able to deduce the meanings
precisely since they have encountered the words before”. According to Bamford “extensive
reading is a language teaching procedure where learners are supposed to read large quantities
of materials or long texts for global understanding, the principal goal being obtaining pleasure
2
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
from the text”. ER will enable the L2 learners to learn new words as they come across new
vocabulary in their text. Two important concepts can be drawn from these definitions:
1. In an extensive reading environment, students can freely choose the text they want
to read (self-selected readings) where the reading material will be within their
reading proficiency.
2. Students can stop their reading at any point if they find their text to be difficult or
if they do not find pleasure in reading the material they selected (Day & Bamford,
2002)
the key parameters that determine the rightness of the text to be read (Planagan &
reading should provide opportunities for the students to understand it without any
reading and vocabulary acquisition takes place concurrently (Huckin and Coady, 1999).
Moreover, the focus of L2 learners in this type of reading is more on the general meaning of
the text (without going in detail) than on the individual words or sentences (Brown, 2002). A
wide range of studies examined that extensive reading has made a significant contribution to
The studies on extensive reading have made positive impacts in all aspects of language
learning: writing (Tsang, 1996; Hafiz & Tudor, 1989), grammar (Mccarthy, 2000; Yang, 2001),
reading speed and comprehension (Belgar, Hunt & Kite, 2012; Matsui & Noro, 2010), reading
processing (Paran, 1996), vocabulary (Grabe & Stoller, 1997; Horst, 2005; Poulshock, 2010;
Pigada & Schmitt, 1996; Chang and Renandya, 2017), and general L2 competence (Iwahori,
3
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
2008). Most of the studies on ER have identified positive impacts on vocabulary development
and L2 reading abilities (Horst, 2005; Webb & Chang, 2015; Pigada & Schmitt, 2006). The
relationship between vocabulary development and reading is pointed out by Eskey (2005) as
“well-documented and reciprocal” (p.567). Therefore, students who do enormous reading will
have the highest probability in developing their vocabulary knowledge. Besides improving the
(Krashen, 1993; Nation, 1997), enriches grammar knowledge (Mccarthy, 2000; Elley, 1991),
motivates students towards learning; develop their speaking and listening skills (Pianta &
Mana, 2013), and improves the writing skills of the students (Tsang, 1996).
Conceptual Framework:
comprehension hypothesis. This theory suggests that the students can advance in language
learning when the input received by them is slightly above their existing level. According to
him, extensive reading will induce language acquisition for L2 learners with certain
preconditions. These conditions include enough exposure to the language, interesting and
engaging materials, and a stress-free learning environment. As stated by Krashen (1985), input
for this approach should be interesting, understandable, and it should not be sequenced
The input or comprehension hypothesis states that “we acquire language and develop
literacy when we understand messages, that is when we understand what we hear and what we
read when we receive comprehensible input” (Krashen, 2003, p.1). The thrust of the input
hypothesis is that the readers should receive comprehensible input either through hearing or
reading language forms that are slightly above their existing level. This hypothesis claims that
4
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
when the students obtain comprehensible input, they tend to acquire the features of language
skills such as grammar and vocabulary knowledge more easily (Krashen, Lee & Lao, 2017).
who emphasized that students who do more reading can perform higher on comprehension than
the students who read less in a second language. According to him, vocabulary and structure
in the reading materials which contain only a little bit beyond their existing level of competence
will be best suitable for the student’s second language acquisition. When the text selected is
much lower or sharply higher than their existing language proficiency then it will not be
effective enough for the language acquisition. Krashen’s input hypothesis states that students
get exposed to new structures, expressions, words, and different facets of discourse more
repeatedly which enables them to “form ideas of the meaning and usage of new features”.
When learners encounter new words more repeatedly, they will be able to extend their meaning
The principle of the four strands by Paul Nation (2015) states that each strand (meaning-
should receive roughly equal attention in a well-balanced language course. It should provide
an opportunity for input, reading, output. According to him, a well-balanced reading course
should include intensive reading, extensive reading, and development in reading speed –
particularly with a speed-reading course (focusing largely on input rather than on output). It
strand. Nation (2015) points out that meaning-focused input should involve ER for about two-
thirds of the strand where the student will be given the opportunity to read books or text that
5
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
will contain fewer unknown vocabulary words and in the fluency development strand, students
can read easy, familiar text with known vocabulary or grammatical features. The process of
Encountering – initial learning 2) Establishing – retrieval of the new term through repeated
in distinct contexts. According to Nation (2007), “the strands draw on the input hypothesis and
learning from extensive reading, the output hypothesis, studies on form-focused teaching, and
the expansion of speaking and reading fluency respectively” (p. 1). Extensive reading should
be included in EFL programs to increase the vocabulary size and to develop the fluency of L2
A plethora of research has found that ER has a tremendous impact on language learning.
receive much attention in both the first and second language research and pedagogy. As the
scholars proceed with the further exploration on how extensive reading promotes vocabulary
growth, the study conducted by Horst (2005) in an authentic extensive reading environment
showed that the students have learned “well over half of the unfamiliar words” (376) when they
do reading for pleasure. This study was carried out in an ESL setting for six weeks which
examined the vocabulary growth of 21 adult immigrant L2 learners. To measure the extent of
vocabulary growth of the learner’s, the researcher used innovative methods such as lexical
frequency profiling, electronic scanning, and a checklist of vocabulary items. To determine the
vocabulary profile of the students, Vocabulary Level Test (VLT) was carried out in this study.
The results of the pre-test and post-test showed that students were able to gain new words
The case study of Pigada and Schmitt (2006) also analyzed the growth of lexical
knowledge of a French learner through extensive reading. The researchers examine the
6
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
acquisition of spelling, word meaning, and grammatical knowledge (three types of vocabulary
knowledge). The results of the study showed that the participant was able to develop
vocabulary knowledge of 65% of target words through extensive reading. Furthermore, the
participant accomplished the spelling benefitting for both nouns and verbs by reading which
was very similar to the results of Day (1998) and Swan (1998) on the “causal relationship”
Similar research was carried out by Suk (2017) for 15 weeks with 171 Korean EFL
students studying English as a Foreign language (ESL) which investigated the influence of ER
on the different aspects of language learning (reading rate, reading comprehension, and
vocabulary acquisition). For this study, the researcher designed a vocabulary level test that
involved words that appeared frequently in various vocabulary lists across 155 graded readers.
Overall, the results drawn from this study showed that the extensive reading approach played
a pivotal role in improving the vocabulary learning of EFL students than improving the reading
Webb and Chang (2015) examined the impact of extensive reading for 82 EFL students
in Taiwan for over 13 weeks with the help of audio on vocabulary learning. As in the study of
Pigada and Schmitt (2006), this study carried out the vocabulary level test (VLT) to determine
the vocabulary profile of students. The researchers selected the readers based on the vocabulary
level test (graded readers (10) – level 1 and graded readers (3) – level 2). The outcome of the
study showed that students who did extensive reading received larger vocabulary gains (19.68
words) than the students who received form-focused instruction (4.43 words). This study also
highlights that the students with lower English proficiency can acquire greater vocabulary
7
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
McQuillan (2019) in his study analyzed the effectiveness of direct instruction and
pleasure reading in acquiring academic vocabulary. For this study, he used a large corpus of
young, popular adult fiction to analyze the repetition of academic words in these novels and
determined the possibility of the words that students acquire incidentally. This study showed
students who did extensive reading were between two and six times more productive than the
students who received direct instruction in acquiring academic vocabulary. A similar study by
Song (2020) also examined the vocabulary development and reading comprehension of twenty-
nine EFL primary school students through the extensive reading program for eight weeks. Out
of 29 students, sixteen graded readers were selected for the research from the Oxford
Bookworms Library series. The results of the study indicated that ER program exhibited three
times the higher growth rate in vocabulary acquisition than in their reading comprehension.
Also, novice level EFL learners were able to pick up new words more naturally when they did
their pleasure reading. The result of the study conforms to Krashen’s Input hypothesis where
the students were able to acquire vocabulary knowledge more easily through comprehensible
input.
Hongkong who took part in three different English programs which included regular plus
extensive reading, frequent writing practice, and regular plus mathematics program. The results
of his study showed that the students who participated in the extensive reading programs were
found to be significantly effective than the regular plus writing and mathematics programs.
Concerning language use and content, the ER program is considered to be more productive and
effective in improving the vocabulary growth of the students than the other two programs.
Atilgan (2013) made use of the writing essays of ten students from the English composition
8
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
course, in which five students wrote an essay as homework from the daily class reading
(textbook reading) and the other five students did an extensive reading to write their essay.
Vocabulary Analysis Program Compleat Lexical Tutor Vocabprofile was used to examine the
language output of the students. The findings showed that the students who wrote essays after
their extensive reading were able to produce more content words in their writing than the
students who did the intensive reading. This comprehensive input reading as stated by Krashen
(1993) has made the students use more variety of words in their essay thus making richer
content.
Similar small-scale classroom research was carried out by Tiryaki and Tutunis (2012)
with 100 elementary level students at a private university to investigate whether or not ER
helps in the vocabulary development of students. Students were divided into control and
experimental group. The students in the experimental group in addition to the coursebooks read
graded readers extensively whereas the students in the control group only read English in the
classroom (textbook or intensive reading). The results of the study showed that the students
who learned through extensive reading have made a positive impact on their vocabulary
development. It also allowed the students to ensure more word learning and even the reluctant
learners were able to improve the range of the words by reading extensively.
An investigative analysis was carried out by Carolina, Yadira, Oswaldo, Antonio &
Antonio (2019) with 48 first-level university students at Ambato to analyze the vocabulary
development through extensive reading. This research was achieved through an intervention
students and an observation card was used to determine their attitudes and behavior towards
extensive reading. A questionnaire was also used associated with the word form and word
knowledge with its meaning. The correlation analysis at the end of the study showed that there
exists a relationship between extensive reading and vocabulary knowledge. Also, the results
9
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
showed that the use of extensive reading can improve the vocabulary of students by building
Iqbal (2017) researched with 1040 school students at Bahawalpur to analyze the effects
researcher employed various tests during his study to record the observation (Vocabulary test,
meaning recognition test (multiple choice), word-recognition, and word-translation test). The
findings of the research revealed that extensive reading made an overall improvement in the
vocabulary development of students. Also, the results indicated that the students showed
All the above-reviewed literature confirms to the belief of most of the researchers that
through comprehensible input EFL learners can improve their language learning (vocabulary
development). Nation (1995) view ER as a major source for improving the vocabulary growth
important facet of vocabulary teaching as it increases the sight vocabulary (Coady, 1997; Day
Research Questions:
In the Indian context, the term ‘extensive reading’ will be new as students are not
exposed to this kind of reading in their language classrooms. Since the students are taught
based on the exam curriculum they are exposed only to intensive reading. Most of the schools
in India allow the students to learn new words only by memorizing it. Not much research has
been carried out in India examining the relationship between extensive reading and vocabulary
development. This research proposal aims to bridge this gap in the literature by investigating
research questions:
10
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
1. To what extent does extensive reading help in the vocabulary development of secondary
2. What are the positive impacts of extensive reading in terms of understanding its
meaning?
METHODOLOGY:
Participants:
This study will be carried out in a secondary school in Tamil Nadu, India where the
students will learn English as a Foreign language. 250 EFL students will be selected for the
study. The students will be chosen from grade 8 between the age group of 15 and 16 where the
students usually struggle to learn new words. Out of 250 students, only 150 students (80 female
and 70 male) will be selected for the study based on the teacher’s suggestion and student’s
willingness to take part in the study. Also, the participants selected for this study will learn
English as a compulsory subject in their schools and the instructions received will also be in
English.
Research Design:
development and understanding its meaning mixed method will be used in this research. Since
this will be mixed method research, the data will be analyzed both quantitatively and
qualitatively. The main aim of this proposed study is to examine the extent of vocabulary
development of students by comparing the test results before and after doing extensive reading
and a vocabulary test will be carried out to analyze the positive impact of ER in understanding
the meaning of the word. A close-ended questionnaire will also be employed to the students to
find out the effectiveness of the extensive reading program in their language classrooms. The
research will be carried out for 3 months after the students get admitted into their secondary
11
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
level. As schools in Tamil Nadu will have an entrance exam for the students getting admitted
to secondary schools, this research will be set after completing their first term examination in
their grade 8. For this research, the effectiveness of extensive reading will be analyzed before
Ethical considerations:
The data for this study will be collected from the three tests and also from the
development of secondary school students in India. However, both the researcher and
participants will face some ethical challenges in terms of confidentiality, anonymity, and
informed consent. Before the study, students will be asked to sign the informed consent form
which will admit that the rights of the participants will be secured. Also, the confidentiality and
anonymity of the participants will be secured without revealing their identity and names in data
collection, findings, and analysis of the study. Students will also be given time to ask questions
and address if they have any concerns or problems. The participants will also be given enough
time (one week) to read the consent form and to decide whether or not they want to take part
in this study. Students will be asked to complete their questionnaire individually in a separate
Data Collection:
This sort of research will require in-depth analysis and tests will be given to the
participants to analyze the data quantitatively and a questionnaire will be used to find out the
student’s understanding of extensive reading. Since this research will be carried out in school,
data for this study will be collected during the school time through the vocabulary test which
will be implemented before the beginning of the study and after the implementation of
extensive reading.
12
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
The vocabulary test used in the study of Waring and Takaki (2003) will be administered
to the participants where three types of vocabulary tests will be used: word-recognition test,
word translation test, and multiple-choice meaning recognition test. The tests will be carried
out two times as immediate and delayed tests. The immediate test will be used to examine the
number of words students know at the beginning of the study and delayed tests will be used to
examine the new words that the participants learned after the extensive reading program. The
text will be selected from the grader readers based on the interest of the participant. Following
Waring and Takaki (2003), 25 words (nouns, adjectives, verbs, and adverbs) will be selected
for each test (word recognition test, meaning-recognition test, and meaning translation test)
from the graded readers to make the test reliable. The test will take place for 60 minutes and
the participants will need to answer all the 25 items in each test both in the immediate and
delayed tests. Also, close-ended questionnaire will be employed to the participants at the end
of the study to analyze their understanding of the extensive reading program. Students will be
Analysis of data:
For the analysis of data both qualitative and quantitative methods will be used. To
examine the test results quantitative method will be used and a qualitative approach will be
13
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
To examine the extent to which learners developed their vocabulary knowledge after their
extensive reading program, both inferential and descriptive statistics will be used for the two
measures. To answer the research questions, the results of the test will be then compared and
analyzed by comparing the mean (X) and standard deviation (SD) by conducting One Way
Repeated Measures ANOVA using the SPSS software. The mean score of all the three test
types at the beginning of the study and after ER program will be compared and analyzed. If the
mean score of all the three test results at the end of the study after implementing an extensive
reading program is higher than the mean score of the test results at the beginning of the study,
it can be then analyzed that extensive reading helped in the vocabulary development of students
and also helped in terms of understanding its meaning. Also, for analyzing the questionnaire
used by the student’s, a thematic analysis will be used as Braun and Clarke (2006) consider it
to be a “suitable method to discover, analyze, and report themes and patterns from the data
CONCLUSION:
Krashen’s input hypothesis thus indicating that extensive reading, when provided with
14
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
language learner’s skills. Also, it will motivate the students to read more books as they will
consider this to be a pleasurable activity improving their language skills. However, more
research has to be carried out in the Indian context exploring the effects of extensive reading
in different aspects of language learning. In EFL contexts, “the use of reading and other input
sources may be the only practical options for out of class language development for some
learners” (Nation, 2001, p.155) as improving the vocabulary through explicit teaching may
seem to be difficult during the short period of time, they spend in the language classroom.
REFERENCES:
Journal, 10(1).
Bamford, J. & Day, R. R. (2004). Extensive Reading Activities for Teaching Language. New
Braun, & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in
Brown, H. D. (2002). English language teaching in the “post-method” era: Toward better
Carolina, C. D. D., Yadira, C. M. M., Oswaldo, G. B. L., Antonio, B. M. M., & Antonio, U. L.
University Students.
15
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
Chang, A. C., & Renandya, W. A. (2017). Current practice of extensive reading in Asia:
40-58.
290.
Custance, I. M., & Flanagan, A. (2018). Two Steps Forward-One Step Back: Exploring
Day, & Bamford, J. (1998). Extensive reading in the second language classroom / Richard
Day, R., & Bamford, J. (2002). Top Ten Principles for teaching Extensive Reading. Reading
Day, R. R., Omura, C., & Hiramatsu, M. (1991). Incidental EFL vocabulary learning and
reading.
Grabe, W., & Stoller, F. L. (2011). Teaching and researching reading (2nd ed.). Harlow:
Pearson.
Hafiz, F. M. & Tudor, L. (1989). Extensive reading and the development of language skills.
16
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
https://doi.org/10.1353/cml.2005.0018
Huckin, T., & Coady, J. (1999). Incidental vocabulary acquisition in a second language: A
Iqbal, S. A. (2017). The impact of extensive reading on learning and increasing vocabulary at
Iwahori. (2008). Developing Reading Fluency: A Study of Extensive Reading in EFL. Reading
Longman Limited.
Krashen, S. D. (1993). The case for free voluntary reading. Canadian Modern Language
Krashen, S. D. (1993). The power of reading: Insight from the research. Englewood, CO:
Libraries Unlimited
JOURNAL-ISRAEL-, 17-29.
Krashen, S. D., Lee, S. Y., & Lao, C. (2017). Comprehensible and compelling: The causes and
Laufer, B., & Nation, P. (1995). Vocabulary size and use: Lexical richness in L2 written
17
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
McQuillan, J. (2019). Where do we get our academic vocabulary? Comparing the efficiency of
direct instruction and free voluntary reading. The Reading Matrix: An International
Miller, K. (2013). Intensive reading, extensive reading and the English reader marathon at
Nation, P. (1997). The language learning benefits of extensive reading. The Language Teacher,
Nation, P. (2004). Vocabulary learning and intensive reading. English Australia Journal, 21(2),
20.
Nation, P. (2007). The four strands. International Journal of Innovation in Language Learning
Nation, P. (2015). Principles guiding vocabulary learning through extensive reading. Reading
Ng, Q. R., Renandya, W. A., & Chong, M. Y. C. (2019). Extensive reading: Theory, research
Educational Books.
18
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
Paran. (1996). Reading in EFL: facts and fictions. ELT Journal, 50(1), 25–34.
https://doi.org/10.1093/elt/50.1.25
Pigada, M., & Schmitt, N. (2006). Vocabulary acquisition from extensive reading: A case
Poulshock, J. (2010). Extensive graded reading in the liberal arts and sciences. Reading in a
Renandya, W. A. (2007). The power of extensive reading. RELC Journal, 38(2), 133-149.
Renandya, W. A., & Jacobs, G. M. (2002). Extensive reading: Why aren’t we all doing it? In
University Press.
Renandya, W. A., Rajan, B. R. S., & Jacobs, G. M. (1999). Extensive reading with adult
programs at tertiary level for functional academic literacy: A Turkish case-study. ASp.
Song, M. (2020). The Impacts of Extensive Reading on EFL Primary School Students’
60-69.
The Extensive Reading Foundation‘s. (2011). Guide to Extensive Reading. Retrieved from
https://erfoundation.org/wordpress/
19
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
https://doi.org/10.1093/applin/17.2.210
TÜTÜNİŞ, B., & TİRYAKİ, Z. (2012). Extensive Reading And Vocabulary Development.
Waring, R., & Takaki, M. (2003). At what rate do learners learn and retain new vocabulary
Webb, S., & Chang, A. C. (2015). Second language vocabulary learning through extensive
reading with audio support: How do frequency and distribution of occurrence affect
Yang, A. (2001). Reading and the non-academic learner: A mystery solved. System, 29(4), 451-
466.
20
MAE990 | Hajeera Shaheen Kadar
APPENDIX 1: QUESTIONNAIRE
1. Do you think that you can make richer vocabulary when you read a lot of books in the target
3. Do you find it easier to read a text when it is within your target language?
4. Can you able to recognize vocabulary more easily when you get exposed to those words
5. Do you feel interested to read a book that is of your interest in the target language?
6. Do you think that you can improve the spelling of words when you are continuously exposed
7. Do you think that an extensive reading program should be implemented in your school?
10. Are you able to retain the words while writing that you acquired through extensive reading?
21