ALI Resfar
ALI Resfar
ALI Resfar
Objective: To detennine the effects of intravenous N- (difference not statistically significant). At admission, 22 of
acetylcysteine (NAC) on the development of severe adult 32 patients (69 percent) in the NAC group were mechani-
respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) and mortality rate cally ventilated compared with 22 of 29 (76 percent) in the
in patients with mild-to-moderate acute lung injury and placebo group. At the end of the treatment period (day 3),
to analyze the duration of ventilatory support and Flo1 5 of 29 (17 percent) in the NAC group and 12 of 25 (48
required as weD as the evolution of the lung injury score. percent) in the placebo group were stiU receiving ventila-
Setting: Three university hospital ICUs and one regional tory support (p = O.ol), 1be Flo2 was 0.37less than admis-
ICU in Switzerland. sion value (day O) in the NAC group, and 0.20 less in the
Patients: Sixty-one adult patients presenting with mild- placebo group (p < 0.04); the oxygenation index (Pa0plo2)
to-moderate acute lung injury and various predisposing improved significantly (p < 0.05) from day 0 to day 3 only in
factors for ARDS received either NAC, 40 mglkgld, or the NAC-treated group. 1be LIS showed a significant
placebo intravenously for 3 days. regression (p = 0.003) in the NAC-treated group during the
MetJIJUrements: Respiratory dysfunction was assessed first 10 days of treatment: no change was observed in the
daily according to the need for mechanical ventilation placebo group. No adverse effects were observed during
and Flo2 , the evolution of the lung injury score, and the the treatment with NAC.
Pa0plo2 ratio. The cardiovascular state, liver function, Conclusions: Intravenous NAC treatment during 72 h
and kidney function were also monitored. Data were improved systemic oxygenation and reduced the need
collected at admission (day 0), during the Arst 3 days, for ventilatory support in patients presenting with mild-
and on the day of discharge from the ICU. to-moderate acute lung injury subsequent to a variety of
Results: The NAC and placebo groups (32 and 29 underlying diseases. Development of ARDS and mortal-
patients, respectively) were comparable at ICU admis- ity were not reduced signincantly by this therapy.
sion for severity of illness assessed by the simplined (Chest 1994; 105:190-94)
acute physiology score (SAPS) (10.8::!:: 4.6 vs 10.9::!:: 4.8)
and lung injury score (LIS) (1.39::!:: 0.95 vs 1.11 ::!:: 1.08) ARDS =adult respiratory distress syndrome; GSH " ~lu
(mean::!:: SD). Three patients in each group developed tathione; ICU ,. intensive care unit; LIS =lung inJury
score; NAC = N-acetylcysteine; NS =not significant;
ARDS. The 1-month mortality rate was 22 percent for SAPS = simplified acute physiology score
the NAC group and 35 percent for the placebo group
A cute lung injury characterized by a high-perme- role. 6 ·7 Oxygen metabolites such as superoxide anion
(0 2 ' ), hydrogen peroxide (Hp 2 ), hydroxyl radical
ability, low-pressure pulmonary edema can de-
velop following a number of predisposing diseases ('OH), and hypochlorous acid (HOC!) cause increased
resulting in different degrees of respiratory insuffi- vascular permeability in endothelial cell monolayers,N
ciency. Patients with mild-to-moderate injury could, in isolated lungs, 9 -10 and in vivo . 11 In human ARDS,
within this continuum, represent an interesting subset increased oxidant activity has been observed in ex-
to evaluate a therapeutic approach of lung dysfunc- pired breath or in bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL)
tion . 1-~ The pathogenesis of acute lung injury and its fluid 1 2 - 1 ~ as well as in granulocytes and red blood
severest form, the adult respiratory distress syndrome cells. 15 ·16 In addition, patients with ARDS seem to
(ARDS), involves a number of mechanisms and medi- have a marked deficiency of the tripeptide antioxidant
ators. u .fi Toxic oxygen radicals of intra-cellular as well glutathione (GSH) in the extracellular epithelial lining
as extracellular origin seem to play an important fluid of the lower respiratory tract. 17 Glutathione acts
as an antioxidant for Hp 2• 1N The GSH deficiency
observed in ARDS could favor oxidative stress, thus
*From the Intensive Care Units of the Departme nts of Anesthesia allowing functional and/or morphologic damage in the
and Ml•dieine. Universitv Hospitals of Gt>neva (Drs. Suter and lower respiratory tract, including an overshooting
Lawrrii•rt> ), Lausanne (Drs. SdHtller and Pe rret ), and Basel (Dr.
Hitz). and the Hegional Hospital "La Caritit," Locarno (Dr. inflammatory reaction and epithelial and endothelial
Donw nighetti) , Switzt> rland. lesions resulting in pulmonary edema. N-acetylcyste-
Manuscript received Januarv 7, 1993: rt'vision accepted May 27.
Rq1rint requests: Dr. Suter, Surgical 1CU, Hopital Cantonal ine (NAC) is a GSH agonist,l 9 and previous studies
Uui r.;ersitaire, CH-1200 Genew 14, Srcit;:,er/mul have demonstrated that NAC administration increases
- so
Initial homogeneity assessment of the two groups was performed
by I test and X' analysis. The before and after comparisons were U) 60
done with the sign test, the paired I test, and the Wilcoxon-Pratt
test depending on the distribution of the data. Between-group
cCl)
comparisons were performed with the X' test, the Student I test, ;::
ca
and the Wilcoxon-Man-Whitney fU test according to the distribu- CL 40
-
tion of the data. Data are presented as mean values :t standard 'tJ
de,iations unless speeifled otherwise. Cl)
30
.!!
RESULTS ;:: 20
cCl)
Characterization of Patients > 10
A total of 61 patients (47 men and 14 women) were 0
recruited for the study (Table 1). All were considered
evaluable for data analysis. Thirty-two patients received
NAC and 29 received placebo. The two groups were well Days
matched for demographic characteristics on trial entry. FIC:URE l. Percentage of patients requiring mechanical ventilatory
The SAPS for severity of disease26 was 10.8 :!:: 4.6 in the ~upport in the N-ac<'tykysteine (NAC) and placebo group. Evolution
NAC group and 10.9 :!:: 4.8 in the placebo group (x :!:: SD, from days 0 (admission) through day 3 (end of NAC treatment). The
triangle identifies a significant difference between the two groups at
not significant [NS]). On admission, the lung injury day 3 (p =0.01). The asterisks identifY a significant differen(-e in the
score 22 was 1.39 :!:: 0.95 in the NAC group, a value not treated group on day 2 and 3 vs admission (day 0; p = 0.01).
significantly different compared with the placebo group
of 1.11 :!:: 1.08. Risk factors and associated conditions the NAC group from 1.39 :!:: 0.95 to 0.67 :!:: 0.70,
were similar in the two groups. Three patients in each p <0.01, between ICU admission and day 10. No
group developed severe lung injury (ARDS) defined as a significant change was observed in the placebo group.
LIS above 2.5Y Seven of 32 patients (22 percent) in the At ICU admission, the mean chest radiograph score
treatment group and 10 of 29 (3.5 percent) in the placebo was higher in the NAC than in the placebo group
group died (NS). During the study. adverse events due to ( 1.8 :!:: 1.1 vs 1.1 :!:: 1.1; p < 0.05). Up to day 3 this
NAC were not detected. score increased in the placebo group (p < 0.05), whereas
it did not change significantly in the NAC group up to
VentilatonJ Support, Flo 2 , Lung Function day 3, but decreased until the discharge from the ICU
Twenty-two patients in each group (69 percent in (from 1.8 :!:: 1.1 at admission to 1.1 :!:: 1.1, p < 0.01).
the NAC and 76 percent in the placebo group)
DISCUSSION
required ventilatory support at ICU admission (day O);
at day 3, the percentage of patients receiving ventila- Despite major improvements in patient care, ARDS
tory support was significantly reduced in the treated still remains a formidable clinical challenge and carries
group from 69 to 17 percent (p = 0.01 ), whereas in the
placebo group this decrease (from 76 to 48 percent) 400
- - - - - NAC
... d
was not significant, p = 0.01 between groups (Fig 1).
At day 0, there was no significant difference between
•·····• Placebo
**
the two groups \vith regard to Flo 2 administered. At
.
N
day 3, the Flo 2 was significantly decreased in the NAC
group (0.29 :!:: 0.09 vs 0.48 :!:: 0.24 at admission;
0
ir *
- 300
p < 0.01) whereas in the placebo group there was no
~ .. ·f I
significant decrease (0.35:!:: 0.11 vs 0.45:!:: 0.20). The
difference in Flo 2 between the two groups was signifi-
cant on day 3 (p < 0.05). The oxygenation index PaOj
--··· f
Flo 2 was similar at admission for both groups (25.5 :!:: 113
mm Hg in the NAC vs 248 :!:: 99 mm Hg in the 200 --------------------~,~~------.----
0 2 3 DISCHARGE
placebo group. NS) and increased significantly in the
Days
NAC group reaching 294 :!:: 99 mm Hg on day 3
(p<0.05). No significant change was noted in the FIGURE 2. Mean values:tSEM of PaOjFio, (hypoxemia index, 22)
at admission (day 0) through day 3 (end of N-acetylcysteine [NAC]
placebo group (Fig 2). There was no statistical differ- treatment) and the day of discharge from the ICU in treated and
ence in PaOJFio2 between the NAC- and placebo- placebo-treated patients. One ast<•risk indicates p < 0.05 vs day 0;
treated patients. The lung injury score decreased in two asterisks. p = 0.01 vs day 0.