Leed - 4.1 Indoor Water Use Reduction
Leed - 4.1 Indoor Water Use Reduction
Leed - 4.1 Indoor Water Use Reduction
Image source: usgs.gov
While the population and demand for freshwater resources are rising, supply
will remain constant. And while it is true that the water cycle continually
returns water to Earth, it is not necessarily returned to the same area, or in
the same quantity and quality.
Water plays a significant role in helping our communities. There would be no
local business or industry without water. Firefighting, city parks, and public
swimming pools all require a lot of water. An array of pipes, canals, and
pumping stations operated by our public water systems are required to
provide reliable water supplies to our taps every day.
Where's all this water coming from? It begins as rain or snow and flows into
our local lakes, rivers, and streams or underground aquifers. You can learn
more about the water in your state, including how it is protected and where
your local drinking water comes from.
1
In the US, we are fortunate enough to have convenient access to some of the
safest treated water in the world only by turning on the tap. We wake up in
the morning, take a shower, brush our teeth, take a cup of coffee, and head
out for the day.
The average American family consumes more than 300 gallons of water a day
at home. Approximately 70% of this use occurs indoors.
Water management is a growing concern in the US. Communities around
the country are beginning to face water management issues and the need to
upgrade outdated water treatment and distribution systems also referred to
as 'water infrastructure.'
Many of the states that have expected an increase in population also have
higher per capita water usage and may expect greater competition for water
supplies. Forty states told the Government Accountability Office in the 2014
EXIT study that they predicted water shortages not related to drought in the
next ten years.
Water supply strains and our aging water treatment systems can have a
number of impacts on communities, such as:
2
● Higher water prices to ensure sustained access to reliable and safe
supplies.
● Increased summer watering limits in order to manage shortages.
● Seasonal loss of recreation areas such as lakes and rivers when human
demand for water is in conflict with environmental needs.
● Expensive water treatment projects for the transport and storage of
freshwater when local demand overcomes the available capacity.
3
LEED v4.1 BD+C: New Construction, Water Efficiency:
Indoor Water Use Reduction Prerequisite
Intent
To reduce indoor water consumption.
Building Water Use Requirements
For the fixtures and fittings listed in Table 1, as applicable to the project scope,
reduce aggregate water consumption by 20% from the baseline. Base
calculations on the volumes and flow rates shown in Table 1.
All newly installed toilets, urinals, private lavatory faucets, and showerheads
that are eligible for labeling m ust be WaterSense labeled (or a local
equivalent for projects outside the U.S.).
Image source: t otousa.com
4
Table 1. Baseline water consumption of fixtures and fittings
Representing image Commercial Current Baseline Current Baseline
Fixtures, Fittings, (IP Units) (SI units)
and Appliances
Water closets
(toilets)* 1.6 gallons per 6 liters per flush
flush (gpf) (lpf)
Private lavatory
2.2 gpm at 60 psi 8.3 lpm at 415 kPa
faucet*
Kitchen faucet
(excluding
faucets used 2.2 gpm at 60 psi 8.3 lpm at 415 kPa
exclusively for
filling operations)
5
* WaterSense label available for this product type gpf = gallons per flush gpm
= gallons per minute psi = pounds per square inch lpf = liters per flush lpm =
liters per minute kPa = kilopascals
Projects located where standard supply pressure is different from the LEED
baseline supply pressure may calculate the water consumption of flow
fixtures and fittings at the local standard supply pressure.
Appliance and Process Water Use
Install appliances, equipment, and processes within the project scope that
meet the requirements listed in the tables below. Existing appliances
intended for reuse in the project are not required to meet the requirements
in Table 2.
6
Table 2. Standards for appliances
Representing image Appliance Requirement
7
gpm = gallons per minute
lpm = liters per minute
*Projects in Europe may install residential appliances meeting the EU A-label.
Table 3. Standards for processes
Representing image Process Requirement
No once-through
cooling with potable
Heat rejection and water for any
cooling equipment or
appliances that reject
heat
Equip with:
● makeup water
meters
● conductivity
controllers and
overflow alarms
● efficient drift
eliminators that
reduce drift to
Cooling towers and maximum of
evaporative condensers 0.002% of
recirculated water
volume for
counterflow
towers and
0.005% of
recirculated water
flow for cross-flow
towers
8
LEED v4.1 BD+C: New Construction, Water Efficiency:
Indoor Water Use Reduction Credit
Intent
To reduce indoor water consumption.
Requirements
Further reduce fixture and fitting water use from the calculated baseline in
WE Prerequisite Indoor Water Use Reduction. Additional potable water
savings can be earned above the prerequisite level using alternative water
sources. Include fixtures and fittings necessary to meet the needs of the
occupants.
Some of these fittings and fixtures may be outside the tenant space (for
Commercial Interiors) or project boundary (for New Construction). Points are
awarded according to Table 1.
Percentage Points (BD+C) Points (CS) Points (Schools,
Reduction Retail,
Hospitality,
Healthcare)
25% 1 1 1
30% 2 2 2
35% 3 3 3
40% 4 4 4
45% 5 -- 5
9
Appliance and process water
Image source: cannonartes.com
Install equipment within the project scope that meets the minimum
requirements in Table 2, 3, 4, or 5 .
One point is awarded for meeting all applicable requirements in any one
table.
All applicable equipment listed in each table must meet the standard.
Schools, Retail, and Healthcare projects can earn a second point for meeting
the requirements of two tables.
10
Table 2. Compliant commercial washing machines
Image source: h
ydrofinity.com
To use Table 2, the project must process at least 120,000 lbs (57 606 kg) of
laundry per year.
Washing machine Requirement (IP units) Requirement (SI units)
On-premise, minimum
Maximum 1.8 gals per Maximum 7 liters per
capacity 2,400 lbs (10
pound * 0.45 kilograms *
886 kg) per 8-hour shift
* Based on equal quantities of heavy, medium, and light soil laundry.
11
Table 3. Standards for commercial kitchen equipment
Image source: c
onnect2local.com
To use Table 3, the project must serve at least 100 meals per day of operation.
All process and appliance equipment listed in the category of kitchen
equipment and present on the project must comply with the standards.
12
Kitchen equipment Kitchen equipment Requirement (IP units) Requirement (SI units)
name
Food waste disposer Disposer 3-8 gpm, full load 11–30 lpm, full load
condition; 10 minute condition; 10-min
automatic shutoff or 1 automatic shutoff or 3.8
gpm, no-load condition lpm, no-load condition
Food waste disposer Scrap collector Maximum 2 gpm Maximum 7.6 lpm
makeup water makeup water
Food waste disposer Strainer basket No additional water No additional water usage
usage
gpm = gallons per minute gph = gallons per hour lpm = liters per minute lph = liters per hour
13
Table 4. Compliant laboratory and medical equipment
To use Table 4, the project must be a medical or laboratory facility.
Lab equipment Requirement Requirement
(IP units) (SI units)
14
Table 5. Compliant municipal steam systems
(Individual condensate disposal from every tank of every fryer using ball float steam traps
image source: s timexeng.com)
To use Table 5, the project must be connected to a municipal or district
steam system that does not allow the return of steam condensate.[1]
Steam system Standard
OR
15
What has changed in LEED v4.1 compared to LEED
v4.0? (As per Indoor Water Use Reduction)
LEED v4.1 BD+C: New Construction Indoor water use reduction prerequisite
had an additional requirement now which didn’t exist in the earlier version
LEED v4.0.
This is a very logical course of action since different water utilities use
different supply pressure for their distribution networks. This causes different
projects to consume different amounts of water used in the same period of
time (as referred to by gallons per minute/liters per minute).
16
The requirements for the use of process water remained unchanged.
Changes in the credit requirements
LEED 4.1 BD+C: New Construction, Indoor Water Use Reduction credit offers a
lot of water-saving opportunities that didn’t exist in v4.0.
In both versions (v4.1 & v4.0) credit points that can be earned for reducing
water use remained the same. However, there are extra points that can be
earned in v4.1 by following the requirements asked for the following water
using systems:
● Appliance and process water
● Standards for commercial kitchen equipment
● Compliant laboratory and medical equipment
● Compliant municipal steam systems
Projects install equipment within the project scope that meets the minimum
requirements shown in tables (Table 2, 3, 4, or 5.)
They can earn one point for meeting all applicable requirements in any one
table. All applicable equipment listed in each table must meet the standard.
Schools, Retail, and Healthcare projects can earn a second point for meeting
the requirements of two tables.
What has changed with LEED v4.1 for the existing
buildings?
LEED v4.0 credit language grouped water efficiency under two titles:
1. Indoor water use reduction prerequisite
2. Indoor water use reduction credit
However, with LEED v4.1 these two titles are combined under the “ Water
Performance” title.
Did the new grouping remove all the prerequisite requirements? Absolutely,
not!
17
In fact, existing buildings are assessed now by using a stronger point of
judgment called the “ Water Performance Score” w hich wasn’t available in
the earlier version LEED v4.0.
A minimum water performance s core of 40 is required in order to be
compliant with the prerequisite requirement.
By LEED v4.1 existing buildings no more need to prove their water
consumption at the fixture, and appliance level. This was the case with the
v4.0. Because LEED v4.0 required all water closets, urinals, public & private
lavatory faucets, showerheads meet with the consumption requirements set
either as gpm (gallons per minute) or gpf (gallons per flush).
This caused the projects to conduct extra calculations since the consumption
requirements are only meaningful at the pressure levels set by the credit
language. For instance, a kitchen faucet is expected to consume 2.2 gpm or
less water at 60 psi, and a showerhead is expected to consume 2.5 gpm or
less water at 80 psi per shower stall.
Since we cannot use water consumption information of each fixture and
appliance, then how could we acquire a performance score or more
specifically a water performance score?
In order to calculate the water performance score, we need the following
data:
1. Annual water consumption (gallons), with monthly or daily totals
2. Gross floor area (sq. ft. or sq. m.)
3. Weighted occupancy
4. Weighted operating hours
The water performance score rates the building’s total water consumption
against the total water consumption of comparable high-performing
LEED-certified buildings. The score is a value from 1-100 based on the
project’s water consumption per occupant and water consumption per floor
area.
18
The water consumption is adjusted for weighted operating hours and
converted into daily water consumption using Equation 1.
Equation 1: adjusted daily water consumption * operating hours
adjustment factor / 365 days
The operating hours adjustment factor is determined using Table 2. The
adjustment factor accounts for typical LEED buildings operations of 50 hours
a week.
Table 2. Operating hours adjustment factor (Image source: usgbc.org)
Daily water consumption per occupant is calculated by dividing the daily
water consumption by the weighted occupancy, using E quation 2.
19
Equation 2: adjusted daily water consumption per occupant = daily
water consumption / weighted occupancy
Daily water consumption per floor area is calculated by dividing the daily
water consumption by the gross floor area, using Equation 3.
Equation 3: adjusted daily water consumption per floor area = daily
water consumption / gross floor area
The project’s daily water consumption per occupant AND daily water
consumption per floor area are input into the water scoring function for the
specific project type to produce a water performance score.
The water scoring functions were developed using water consumption data
from high-performing buildings. The data set includes LEED buildings that
shared their water consumption data with USGBC as part of the
whole-building energy and water usage requirement.
The water use baseline for buildings with a certificate of occupancy dated
1995 or later & before condition is removed.
In LEED v4.0
Pre-1995 buildings that have had only minor fixture retrofits (e.g., aerators,
showerheads, flushing valves) but no plumbing renovations in or after 1995
could use the 150% baseline, while buildings with a certificate of occupancy
dated 1995 or later could use 120% baseline.
With LEED v4.1
Pre or after 1995 date has no more meaning since the water consumption
calculations are assessed by using a more objective scoring system.
Water consumption is measured on a monthly basis for twelve consecutive
months (one full year). This Input (the twelve months of potable water use
data is plugged into the Arc Platform and a Water Performance Score for the
project is calculated. The minimum required score is 40, and the scores above
40 are awarded according to Table 1.
20
Interiors projects that do not have fixtures or fixture fittings in the project
scope are exempt from the requirement to obtain a minimum Water
Performance Score of 40.
All interiors projects must input twelve months of potable water use data into
the Arc Platform and calculate a Water Performance Score for the project.[1]
Why do LEED Projects use Energy Star Performance Metrics?
Energy Star often helps users achieve LEED certification. As an early adopter
of energy performance standards, Energy Star helped pave the way for the
development of USGBC’s LEED rating system.
Buildings earn LEED certification upon meeting certain levels of energy
efficiency, among other measures. In fact, LEED uses the Energy Star system
to empower property owners and occupants with the tools they need to
meet these requirements and earn additional credits.
Among the LEED prerequisites is a requirement to reduce indoor water
consumption by reaching certain performance standards for appliances,
which includes those labeled as Energy Star. In addition to products, Energy
Star identifies energy-efficient buildings.
Energy Star gives users the tools they need to reach a higher level of building
energy performance, therefore positioning them closer to the standards
required for LEED certification. In short, Energy Star helps make LEED
possible.[2]
How to strategize Indoor Water Use Reduction with LEED v4.1?
There are certain relatively low cost strategies projects can implement
immediately to improve their water reductions without much effort.
The most basic and correct action to take is using WaterSense labeled
products.
21
WaterSense labeled products use at least 20 percent less water than
standard models, while providing equal or superior performance. By installing
WaterSense labeled faucet aerators and showerheads, the average family can
save nearly 3,500 gallons of water and nearly 410 kilowatt-hours of electricity
per year.[3]
For instance, replacing existing “high-flow, low-efficiency” fixtures with
“low-flow, high-efficiency” versions, such as WaterSense-labeled fixtures,
and adding aerators to faucets is very quick to implement. However, potential
savings can be immediately observed.
In addition, by installing sub meters for plumbing fixtures Projects can
monitor and manage the use of water by installing submeters, while also
recognizing opportunities for savings wherever available.
Projects can use sensor faucets ( aka. non-contact faucets) to save water by
controlling usage based on hand movements. Here are a few benefits that
come using sensor faucets.
● Save water by being less likely to leak.
● Reduces spread of germs in the bathroom.
● Reduces days employees are sick.
● Many also have aerators that reduce water usage while retaining spray
coverage area.
By achieving higher water savings goals, projects can achieve extra LEED
points. More aggressive targets for water efficiency include dual
high-efficiency flush water closets and the use of waterless closets for
almost all urinals.
22
Image source: youtube.com
Replace old clothes washers. Washers are the second largest water user in
your home. If your clothes washer is old, you should consider replacing it with
an ENERGY STAR certified clothes washer.
Most ENERGY STAR clothes washers use four times less energy than those
manufactured before 1999. To save more water, look for a clothes washer with
a low water factor. The lower the water factor, the less water the machine
uses. Water factor is listed on the certified product list.[4]
Reduce the pressure: In many high-rise and commercial settings, domestic
water booster pumps are necessary to overcome the loss of pressure due to
increases in elevation and to maintain water supply in water towers and
supply tanks.
23
Image source: plumbingsupply.com
With these higher pressures, water flows through the system with resulting
greater flow through terminal fixtures beyond rated flow capacities, and this
additional water is wasted as it serves no additional benefit to the rated
performance.
Most plumbing codes require pressure-reducing valves on systems where
pressures exceed 80 psi. In most cases, these pressures could be lowered by
the implementation of additional pressure-reducing valves.
Additionally, the higher pressures can rupture pipes and damage fixtures.
This leads to even greater waste in the domestic water system. When it
comes to the domestic heating plant, if less water flows through the system,
then less energy is needed to heat the domestic hot water in the first place.
Educate users: Water conservation is not only about innovation and good
design practices, but also about building an understanding among water
consumers to work together to achieve a greener and more energy-efficient
environment.
24
Image source: w
ellingtonwater.co.nz
It is important to educate users about water scarcity issues and the impact of
water conservation practices through signage and awareness campaigns at
the point of use. The conservation of water reduces water waste and energy
costs too, on both operation and production.
Educated consumers will be better able to identify problems and think
innovatively about ways to conserve or reuse water within the facility. Not
only will the work environment benefit, but these tools can be taken back to
the home, where individuals and families can use these practices to play an
even larger role in the preservation of rapidly dwindling freshwater resources.
[5]
Projects that make excellent savings with this credit can be eligible for
Exemplary Performance and Regional Priority LEED credits, maxing out the
available points.
Projects in California qualify for an additional LEEDv4.1 O+M point for a
regional priority with water-efficient fixtures.
25
Based on the size and type of building, the installation of permanent sub
meters for plumbing fixtures, fittings and other process water may be costly
and require major design coordination.
Despite the cost, the additional benefit of installing permanent submetering
is the detection of leaks. Aging infrastructure and seasonal stress can lead to
broken pipes, flushing down the drain your efficiency goals along with
wasted water.
By efficiently metering various subsystems, these leaks can be identified early
and corrective action can be taken before it is too late. Metering and
monitoring the water consumption of plumbing fixtures also helps better
decision-making processes to wholly understand the business case and
quantify the return on investment.
Have leak detection equipment installed on the main supply lines of
households, public or commercial space. They can detect abnormal flow
patterns and shut the water flow to reduce losses.
Image source: https://i.ytimg.com
Leaks in buildings are not easily detected leading to unnecessary
consumption of water. Leak detection equipment does not reduce water
consumption per se but avoid unneeded use especially important in metered
facilities.
26
Consider rainwater harvesting: Water harvesting is water collected from
roofs when it rains and potentially from air conditioning condensate. The
collected water can be stored and used in irrigation and/or flushing toilets.
Image source: e
co-business.com
The volume of collected rainwater is approximately equal to the surface area
of the roof multiplied by the average rainwater depth per year minus about
25% in losses through evaporation. The first rain event is usually not stored
because it carries dust and dirt accumulated during the dry season. The
amount of saved water will depend on location (rainfall depth per year), the
size of the roof and the type of dwelling (building or single house).
Treat and reuse greywater: Greywater is wastewater coming from sinks,
showers, baths and dishwashers. It does not contain organic waste nor
excrement. Some jurisdictions have or are planning to allow installation of
greywater distribution systems.
27
Image source: r iverlabs.ca
The water is considered non potable, but is suitable for use in toilets and
urinals. Use of greywater can considerably reduce consumption of domestic
water.
This water can be reused immediately or with minimal treatment in flushing
and irrigation but needs treatment if stored. Treatment can be through
filtration and disinfection using chlorine for example or through simple
biological treatment systems.
Plumbing must be adjusted in order to isolate greywater from wastewater
and to allow a separate distribution network for water closets to allow
flushing with harvested and greywater.[6]
28
Keep in mind that water meters can become less accurate when the
intended water use of a facility has changed or when substantial water
conservation activities have been implemented.
If a meter is oversized for the facility’s needs, the facility could be paying
unwarranted service charges for it. Even properly selected and sized water
meters can become inaccurate due to wear, which is affected by age and
water quality.
You can use in-place field testing using a pitotmeter for large meters and a
portable meter test unit for smaller water meters.
Submetering is an excellent way to accurately account for large water uses in
specific areas of the facility. It helps personnel become familiar with water use
for all operations and indicates whether equipment is using water when it is
not needed.
Temporary meters will indicate whether it is cost-effective to install
permanent meters. Bucket and stopwatch is a simple and accurate
measurement tool.
To use this method, collect a specified amount of water for a specific time
period (i.e. one quart per minute, which is equivalent to 0.25 gpm).
Micro-weirs are small hand-held weirs that are used to measure low flows of
water (0.5 to six gpm) in tight spaces, such as under lavatory faucets.
Summary
Water is a necessity for the sustenance of life on earth. While the supply may
seem abundant, water is not an infinite resource, particularly fresh potable
water necessary to our survival.
Without our acknowledgement in the design and construction industry and
in our everyday consciousness, this vital supply of water may be threatened.
We, as owners, developers, and engineers, play a vital role in looking beyond
our building codes and budgets to achieve higher levels of water efficiency.
29
New technologies that use less water are becoming more important than
ever, but our common sense and realization that our planet cannot give
forever will ensure that future generations will enjoy the benefits of abundant
fresh water because of the decisions that we make now.
LEED v4.1 awards water efficiency points on the basis of the water
performance score, which measures the total water consumption of the
building against the total water consumption of comparable
high-performance buildings.
The score is from 1 to 100 based on the project water consumption per
occupant and water usage per floor area over a 12-month period. This
streamlined, outcome-based strategy is encouraging to improve efficiency
and sustainability in existing facilities.
LEED Zero Water is important to consider for building owners and facility
managers who take a leadership approach to water.
USGBC introduced LEED Zero certification about a year ago during the
Global Climate Action Summit to honor LEED projects that function at a net
zero level for a given resource: carbon, electricity, water, or waste, and that
have been shown to have 12 months of operational data.
LEED Zero Water focused on balancing potable water consumption against
alternative sources of water and restoring water to its natural source.
Certification is intended to acknowledge leadership and to demonstrate
innovative strategies for water management.
The first project in the world to earn LEED Zero Water certification is the
Eurobusiness office in Curitiba, Brazil. The 14-story LEED Platinum building
treats 100% of its wastewater (gray and black) on site through a constructed
wetland on its roof.
Treated wastewater is then reutilized for toilet/urinal flushing or infiltrated
on-site (returned to source). (returned to source). No chemicals are used in
the treatment process and the on-site artesian well is supplied with potable
water.
30
The municipal building code mandated the treatment and reuse of
greywater and the construction of a rainwater catchment basin to minimize
runoff. The conventional design approach would have put these systems
underground, eating up the space of two parking spots.
In order to minimize the first costs and free up parking space, rainwater was
collected on the roof instead. A 20-centimeter-deep "water pool" occupies the
entire surface of the roof deck.
The raised floor system for outdoor use is covered with fine gravel and
planted with macrophytes or aquatic plants grown in or near water. The
entire assembly acts as a built wetland and is part of the wastewater
treatment system.
The replication of natural systems has proven to be the most economical
method for the treatment of wastewater in the building. It also allowed the
treatment of both gray and black water without any additional cost.
At the end of the day, parking spaces paid for the system. Efficient fixtures
and fittings have been used to reduce potable water consumption and the
amount of wastewater produced.
This was vital to the success of the design, as the available roof or wetland
area was small. The building was built to use 45% less water and, when
alternative sources were taken into account, overall potable water use was
reduced by 82%.
The building uses several alternative sources of water on site, including
collected rainwater, condensate from AHUs(air handling unit), subsurface
infiltration, as well as gray and black water.
At about 65% of the water used has been reclaimed and the building uses
only municipally treated potable water as the back-up.
According to Guido Petinelli, LEED project consultant, the building had
already installed meters for both potable and alternative sources of water,
making it easier to measure data for a year and showing that LEED Zero
Water requirements had been satisfied.
31
The project developer and investor, Marcos Bodanese, saw certification and
sustainability decisions as the right thing to do. LEED Zero now offers an
opportunity to assess and verify performance, while still promoting resilience
initiatives.
Life cycle cost savings
Building owners and facility managers can often justify water management
programs on their own or in combination with energy efficiency or other
improvements to life cycle cost analyses.
Analyzes should seek to provide energy savings as well as water and
wastewater utility savings involved in the project. As these projects allow
facilities to better cope with storms or to return to operation more efficiently,
tangible resilience benefits can have substantial financial value.
Lost business income from prolonged closures can be a significant cost of
storms, beyond physical property loss.[7]
32
REFERENCES
[1]https://www.usgbc.org/credits/new-construction-data-centers-new-constru
ction-warehouse-and-distribution-centers-new?return=/credits/New%20Cons
truction/v4.1
[2]https://www.usgbc.org/articles/energy-star-and-leed-work-together-privat
esector-energy-efficiency
[3]https://www.energystar.gov/products/saving_water_helps_protect_our_nati
ons_water_supplies#:~:text=WaterSense%20labeled%20products%20use%20a
t,hours%20of%20electricity%20per%20year.
[4]https://www.energystar.gov/products/saving_water_helps_protect_our_nat
ions_water_supplies#:~:text=It%20can%20also%20reduce%20water,%2C%20p
ump%2C%20and%20heat%20water.&text=Homes%20with%20high%2Defficie
ncy%20plumbing,%2C%20sewer%2C%20and%20energy%20bills.
[5]https://www.csemag.com/articles/10-ways-to-save-water-in-commercial-bu
ildings/
[6]http://www.lcec.org.lb/Content/uploads/ProcedureDocument/1810191231391
18~Indoor%20Water%20Reduction%20for%20Residential%20and%20Commer
cial%20Applications.pdf
[7]https://www.facilitiesnet.com/green/article/How-LEED-Guides-Users-to-Wa
ter-Efficiency--18644
33