1 Main Report Vol. I
1 Main Report Vol. I
1 Main Report Vol. I
Submitted by:
Contents
Chapter 0 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ....................................................................................................................... 13
0.1 GENERAL ......................................................................................................................................... 13
0.2 PROJECT HIGHWAY ......................................................................................................................... 15
0.3 EXISTING CARRIAGEWAY AND PAVEMENT ..................................................................................... 15
0.4 EXISTING ROW ................................................................................................................................ 15
0.5 EXISTING ALIGNMENT ..................................................................................................................... 15
0.6 SETTLEMENT ................................................................................................................................... 15
0.7 MAJOR AND MINOR INTERSECTION ............................................................................................... 15
0.8 EXISTING MAJOR AND MINOR BRIDGES AND CULVERTS ............................................................... 15
0.9 UNDERPASSES / OVERPASSES ......................................................................................................... 15
0.10 RAILWAY CROSSINGS ...................................................................................................................... 15
0.11 TRAFFIC SURVEY .............................................................................................................................. 15
0.12 CLASSIFIED TRAFFIC VOLUME COUNT (CVC)................................................................................... 16
0.13 AXLE LOAD SURVEY ......................................................................................................................... 17
0.14 GROWTH RATE ................................................................................................................................ 17
0.15 CAPACITY ANALYSIS ........................................................................................................................ 17
0.16 IMPROVEMENT PROPOSAL ............................................................................................................. 18
0.17 BRIDGES........................................................................................................................................... 19
0.18 SOCIAL ASSESSMENTS ..................................................................................................................... 21
0.19 ENVIRONMENTAL SCREENING AND PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT .................................................. 23
0.20 ESTIMATED COST OF THE PROJECT:................................................................................................ 24
Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................................. 25
1.1 BACKGROUND: ................................................................................................................................ 25
1.2 OBJECTIVES OF THE CONSULTANCY SERVICES................................................................................ 26
1.3 SCOPE OF WORK ............................................................................................................................. 26
LIST OF TABLES :
TABLE 0-1: TRAFFIC SURVEY LOCATION .............................................................................................................. 16
TABLE 0-2 :SUMMARY OF CLASSIFIED VOLUME COUNT SURVEY AT ALL COUNTS STATIONS............................ 16
TABLE: 0-3 : VDF VALUES .................................................................................................................................... 17
TABLE: 0-4 : ESTIMATED TRAFFIC GROWTH RATES ............................................................................................ 17
TABLE : 0-5 DESIGN SERVICE VOLUME AND CAPACITY STANDARD .................................................................... 18
TABLE :0-6 IMPROVEMENT PROPOSAL FOR BRIDGES ....................................................................................... 19
TABLE 1-1 : LENGTHWISE PACKAGE DISTRIBUTION............................................................................................ 28
TABLE 3-1 : LENGTHWISE PACKAGE DISTRIBUTION............................................................................................ 46
TABLE 5-1 : LENGTHWISE PACKAGE DISTRIBUTION............................................................................................ 73
TABLE 5-2 : DEMOGRAPHY PROFILE OF PROJECT INFLUENCED STATE .............................................................. 75
TABLE 6-1 : DESIGN SPEED (FROM TABLE 2.1 OF IRC: SP: 84 – 2019)................................................................ 87
TABLE 6-2 : SIGHT DISTANCE FOR VARIOUS SPEEDS ( FROM TABLE 2.7 OF IRC – SP : 84 – 2019) ..................... 88
TABLE 6-3 : MINIMUM RADII OF HORIZONTAL CURVES (FROM IRC: SP: 84 – 2019, TABLE 2.6) ........................ 89
TABLE 6-4 : RADII BEYOND WHICH SUPER ELEVATION NOT REQUIRED ............................................................. 90
TABLE 6-5: MINIMUM RADII OF HORIZONTAL CURVES CORRESPONDING TO DESIGN SPEED .......................... 91
TABLE 6-6 : EXTRA WIDTH OF PAVEMENT AND ROADWAY IN EACH CARRIAGEWAY ........................................ 92
TABLE 6-7 : HORIZONTALL CURVE DETAILS........................................................................................................ 94
TABLE 6-8 : RECOMMENDED GRADIENTS (FROM IRC: SP: 84-2019 TABLE 2.8) ................................................. 94
TABLE 6-9 : ADOPTED ‘K’ VALUES FOR VERTICAL CURVES.................................................................................. 96
TABLE 6-10 : TCS Schedule for Priority – 1 (Km 134+737 to Km 163+253)....................................................... 105
TABLE 6-11 : HOMOGENOUS SECTIONS ........................................................................................................... 107
TABLE 8-2 : ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATIONS AND LEGISLATIONS RELEVANT TO THIS PROJECT, WHICH ARE
APPLICABLE DURING DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION AND OPERATION PHASES. ..................................................... 214
TABLE 8-3 : REQUIREMENT OF CLEARANCE ...................................................................................................... 220
TABLE 9-1 : LISTS OF HABITATION ALONG WITH PROJECT ROAD (PACKAGE –I) .............................................. 234
TABLE 9-2: TENTATIVE R&R BUDGET (STRUCTURE)......................................................................................... 245
TABLE 11-1: REQUIREMENTS FOR WASTE PLASTIC MODIFIED DENSE GRADED BITUMINOUS PAVEMENT
LAYERS............................................................................................................................................................... 251
TABLE 11-2: TYPES OF MICRO-SURFACING AND RATE OF APPLICATION ......................................................... 253
TABLE 11-3: MIX DESIGN CRITERIA FOR MICRO-SURFACING MIX .................................................................... 254
TABLE 11-4: MIXING LAYING AND ROLLING TEMPERATURES FOR WMA* ....................................................... 264
LIST OF FIGURES :
CHAPTER 0
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
0.1 GENERAL
The Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (MORTH), Government of India has proposed
“Bharat Mala Pariyojana” an Umbrella scheme of road development project through National
Highways Authority of India (NHAI), National Highway and Industrial Development
Corporation (NHIDC) and state Public Works Departments (PWD) at an estimated cost of
INR 5,35,000crores. This is the second largest highways construction project in the country
after NHDP, in that almost 50,000 km of roads targeted across the country. This project aim
to improve connectivity particularly on economic corridors, border areas and remote areas
with rapid and safe movement of cargo to boost exports. International trade considered as a
key aspect in this scheme and northeastern states have given special focus. The project
cleared by the Union Cabinet on October 25, 2017.
The ambitious project expected to create nearly 100million man days of jobs during the
construction and subsequently to about 22 million jobs of the increased economic activity
across the country. The construction will carried out through many means including debt
funds, budgetary allocation, private investment, toll operator transfer etc. The total length of
around 34,800km considered in phase 1including
Economic corridors of around9,000km,
Inter-corridor and feeder routes of around6,000km,
National Corridors Efficiency Program of about 5,000 km roads
Border and international connectivity roads of around 2,000 km,
Coastal and port connectivity roads of around 2,000km,
Expressways of around 800 km
NHDP roads of10,000km
In pursuance of the above program, NHAI appointed M/s STUP Consultants Private Limited,
New Delhi as Consultants to carry out the Consultancy Services for preparation of DPR for
development of Economic Corridors, Inner corridors, feeder Routes and Costal Roads to
improve the efficiency of fright movement in India - Lot 4/Gujarat, M.P. / Package 3. The
project consists following stretches of roads finalized as per approved Alternative Alignment
Report
Bhopal –Vidisha Section (Length –71.700km)
Vidisha – Barkheri Section (Length –84.000km)
Barkheri – Sagar Section (Length –30.393km)
The Letter of Acceptance was communicated on 26.02.2018 vide NHAI letter no
NHAI/Bharatmala/DPR/Lot-4/Package-3/2017/113483 dated 26th Feb. 2018. The approval of
the alignment and the section bifurcation was decided vide letter No: NHAI/RO-MP/SAG/Sg-
69/DPR/STUP/2019/34587, Dated 01.05.2019.
The project has been approved by LA Committee with 4 Lane Standard & 45 m Proposed
ROW which was intimated to the consultant vide letter No. SAG/39010/2/BRT-STUP-
Misc./2017/.967 dated on 17/03/2020. The project Bhopal – Sagar has been divided into 4
Packages on the basis of priority vide letter No. NHAI/RO-MP/Sgr-
69/DPR/STUP/2020/38556 dated on 11.03.2020. The Priority wise section is described
below:
TABLE 0-2 :SUMMARY OF CLASSIFIED VOLUME COUNT SURVEY AT ALL COUNTS STATIONS
Ultimate
Design Service Volume (PCU/ Day)
Road Type Capacity
LOS 'B' LOS 'C' LOS 'D' LOS 'E'
2-Lane Roads without Paved
15000 21000 25500 30000
Shoulders
2-Lane Roads with Paved
17250 24150 29325 34500
Shoulders
4-Lane Road without Paved
35000 49000 59500 70000
Shoulders
4-Lane Road with Paved Shoulders 40000 56000 68000 80000
0.15 CAPACITY ANALYSIS
The design service volume of the two lane highway for different terrain is given in Table
below:
Ultimate
Design Service Volume (PCU/ Day)
Road Type Capacity
LOS 'B' LOS 'C' LOS 'D' LOS 'E'
2-Lane Roads without Paved Shoulders 15000 21000 25500 30000
2-Lane Roads with Paved Shoulders 17250 24150 29325 34500
4-Lane Road without Paved
35000 49000 59500 70000
Shoulders
4-Lane Road with Paved Shoulders 40000 56000 68000 80000
Source: IRC: 64-1990
The Horizontal alignment is passes through Plain and Rolling Terrain having the design
speed of 100Kmph.
The Service is road is provided on the location where the proposed alignment is following
with the existing alignment with built up area. The location is given below:
Side
1 137+762.223 138+682.223 920.0 Both Side 1,840.00 SVUP
2 141+995.223 142+835.223 840.0 Both Side 1,680.00 LVUP
3 146+163.223 146+943.223 780.0 Both Side 1,560.00 LVUP
4 150+096.223 150+656.223 560.0 Both Side 1,120.00 SVUP
5 151+675.223 152+636.223 961.0 Both Side 1,922.00 VUP
6 153+476.223 154+575.223 1099.0 Both Side 2,198.00 LVUP
7 155+285 156+312 1027.0 Both Side 2,054.00 SVUP
Total 6187.0 12374.0
0.17 BRIDGES
0.17.1 Major Bridges
TABLE :0-6 IMPROVEMENT PROPOSAL FOR BRIDGES
0.17.3 ROB
0.17.4 Culverts
Total Length
Sr. Design Span
Type (F/F of Dirt From To
No. Chainage arrangement
Wall) (m)
1 SVUP 136+204 1X7X4 7.0 136+200 136+207
2 SVUP 138+282 1 X 7 X4 7.0 138+278 138+285
3 LVUP 142+507 1 X 12 X 4 12.0 142+501 142+513
4 LVUP 146+567 1 X 12 X 4 12.0 146+561 146+573
5 LVUP 148+908 1 X 12 X 4 12.0 148+902 148+914
6 SVUP 150+414 1 X 7 X4 7.0 150+410 150+417
7 VUP 152+217 1 X 25 X 5.5 25.0 152+205 152+230
8 LVUP 154+035 1 X 12 X 4 12.0 154+029 154+041
9 SVUP 155+804 1 X 7 X4 7.0 155+801 155+808
0.17.6 Interchange
Initial Social Assessment of the Project will be on the basis of whether it involves Project
Affected Persons (PAPs) and/or Indigenous People (IP) or Scheduled Tribes. Information
whether the project involves PAPs or IPs will be ascertained based on the information
collected through the socio-economic survey, verification of assets and losses and
consultations with the residents at the Project locations.
The proposed alignment connects starts in Bhopal District from km 0+000 in Adampur village
and ends at km 163+253 located in Sagar district. Total length of the project road is
approximately 163.253km apart from that one project road which is priority 3 of Bhopal Sagar
project of length 20km is being approved from the competent authority.
Keeping in mind the aims and objectives of the Initial Social Assessment & Social Screening,
tools shall be used for -Social Screening Survey formats, Field testing of formats, Screening
survey, Collection of secondary data, Compilation of data, Analysis, Preparation of the report.
Land will be acquired and compensation for land and structures will be paid as per the Right
to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement
Act, 2013 (also Land Acquisition Act, 2013). A detailed Social Impact Assessment (SIA) and
a Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) will be prepared for the project.
The land use along the project road is mainly agricultural& Non-agricultural land except in
built up areas. The population of the area mainly depend on agriculture. 10kms distance
from the alignment shall be considered for study area for preliminary environmental
assessment baseline studies. Secondary data collected from various Government, Semi-
Government organizations and site visits for various attributes like climate, physical
environment, meteorology, ambient air quality, surface water and Ground water quality, soil
characteristics, noise levels and flora & fauna.
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 BACKGROUND:
The Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (MORTH), Government of India has proposed
“Bharat Mala Pariyojana” an Umbrella scheme of road development project through National
Highways Authority of India (NHAI), National Highway and Industrial Development
Corporation (NHIDC) and state Public Works Departments (PWD) at an estimated cost of
INR 5,35,000 crores. This is the second largest highways construction project in the country
after NHDP, in that almost 50,000 km of roads targeted across the country. This project aim
to improve connectivity particularly on economic corridors, border areas and remote areas
with rapid and safe movement of cargo to boost exports. International trade considered as a
key aspect in this scheme and northeastern states have given special focus. The project
cleared by the Union Cabinet on October 25, 2017.
The ambitious project expected to create nearly 100million man days of jobs during the
construction and subsequently to about 22 million jobs of the increased economic activity
across the country. The construction will carried out through many means including debt
funds, budgetary allocation, private investment, toll operator transfer etc. The total length of
around 34,800km considered in phase 1including
In pursuance of the above program, NHAI appointed M/s STUP Consultants Private Limited,
New Delhi as Consultants to carry out the Consultancy Services for preparation of DPR for
development of Economic Corridors, Inner corridors, feeder Routes and Costal Roads to
improve the efficiency of fright movement in India - Lot 4/Gujarat, M.P. / Package 3. The
project consists following stretches of roads finalized as per final Inception Report.
Bhopal – Sanchi – Vidisha – Sagar (Length - 173km)
Katni – Shahdhol (Length - 124km)
xi) detailed design of road, its cross-sections, horizontal and vertical alignment and
design of embankment of height more than 6.0m and also in poor soil conditions and
where density considerations required, even lesser height embankment, detailed
design of structures, preparation of GAD and construction drawings of cross-drainage
structures and underpasses etc.;
xii) identification of the type and the design of intersections;
xiii) design of complete drainage system and disposal point for storm water;
xiv) value analysis / value engineering and project costing;
xv) economic and financial analysis
xvi) contract packaging and implementation schedule applicable for EPC mode;
xvii) strip plan indicating the scheme for carriageway widening, location of all existing
utility services (both over and underground) and the scheme for their relocation, trees
to be felled and planted and land acquisition requirements including schedule for LA;
reports, documents and drawings, arrangement of estimate for cutting of trees and
shifting of utilities from the concerned department;
xviii) Develop 3D engineered models of terrain and elevation, as-is project highway,
proposed and project highway along with all features, current and proposed
structures, current and proposed utilities and land acquisition plans.
xix) to find out financial viability of project for implementation and suggest the preferred
mode on which the project is taken up.
xx) preparation of detailed project report, cost estimate, approved for construction
drawings, rate analysis, detailed bill of quantities, documents for execution of civil
works through budgeting resources;
xxi) design of toll plaza and identification of their numbers and location and office cum
residential complex including working drawings.
xxii) Design of weighing stations, parking areas and rest areas
xxiii) any other user oriented facility en route toll plaza
xxiv) tie-in of o-going/sanctioned works of MORT&H/NHAI/other agencies.
xxv) Preparation of social plans for the project affected people as per policy of the lending
agencies/Govt. of India R & R Policy
Project preparation activities will be split into following stages mentioned below.
The Inception report and QAP for the above project have already been approved by NHAI,
vide their letter No. NHAI/Bharatmala/DPR/Lot-4/Package-3/2017/117790 dated 18.05.2018.
Further Final Alignment Report submitted on 24.08.2018 based on joint site visit and various
discussed held in MORTH/NHAI/RO/PD,NHAI.
1.6 PACKAGING
The project has been divided into four packages on basis of priority as per letter no.
NHAI/RO-MP/Sgr-69/DPR/STUP/202038556 dated on 11.03.2020
* The Priority – 1 Berkheri to Sagar (Sagar Link Road) will be described in this report.
CHAPTER 2
OVERVIEW OF NHAI’S ORGANISATION & ACTIVITIES,
PROJECT FINANCING AND COST RECOVERY
MECHANISM
2.1 ESTABLISHMENT
The National Highways Authority of India was constituted by an act of Parliament, the
National Highways Authority of India Act, 1988. NHAI is responsible for the development,
maintenance and management of National Highways entrusted to it and for matters
connected therewith or incidental there to. The Authority was operational from February 1995
as an autonomous body with the appointment of full time Chairman and other members.
2.2 ORGANIZATION
A full time Chairman heads NHAI. As per NHAI act, there are five full time Members, namely
Member (Admin.), Member (Finance) and three Members (Technical). There are also four
part time (ex officio) Members of the Authority. The Authority has its field offices in the form
of Project Implementation Units (PIUs), Regional offices (RO) and Corridor Management
Units (CMU) spread all over the country. These units are headed by Project Directors (PD)
and Regional officers (RO) who are responsible for implementation of various Projects and
operation and maintenance of the completed sections.
All procurement related to works, services, equipment and goods i.e. civil contractors,
consultants and suppliers are made by the head office predominantly and as well as by
Regional Offices . PDs are also responsible for all pre construction activities and liaison to
the Departments concerned of Union and State Government for successful implementation
of the Projects.
The Government has approved a proposal of restructuring NHAI. The salient points of the
proposal are, inter alia; increase of full-time Members from 5 to 6 and part time Members
from 4 to 6, creation of 26 posts at the level of CGM and to build a core of permanent
employee of NHAI over a period of time. This process has been taken up.
A detailed organization chart of NHAI is given in Figure 2.1
2.3 FUNCTIONS
The function and activities of National Highways authority of India are stipulated in NHAI Act.
1988. The clear mandate given by the Act is to develop, maintain and manage the National
HighwaysandotherhighwaysvestedinorentrustedtoitbytheGovernmentofIndia.Themain
activities of the NHAI as stipulated in the Act and Rules are:
Survey, develop, maintain and manage highways vested in or entrusted to it;
Construct offices or workshops and establish and maintain, hotels, motels, restaurant and
rest rooms along or near the highways vested in, or entrusted to it;
Construct residential buildings and townships for its employees;
Regulate and control the plying of vehicles on the highways vested in or entrusted to it for the
proper management thereof;
Develop and provide consultancy and construction services in India and abroad and carry on
research activities in relation to the development, maintenance and management of
highways or any facilities, thereat;
Provide such facilities and amenities for the users of the highways vested in or entrusted to
it, as are, in the opinion of NHAI, necessary for the smooth flow of traffic on such highways
Form one or more companies under the Companies Act, 1956 (Act 1 of 1956) to further the
efficient discharge of the functions imposed, on it by this Act;
Engage, or entrust any of its functions to any person, on such terms and conditions as may
be prescribed;
Advise the Central Government on matters relating to highways;
Assist, on such terms and conditions as may be mutually agreed upon, any State
Government in formulation and implementation of schemes for highway development;
Collect fees on behalf of Central Government for services rendered;
Take all such steps as may be necessary or convenient for or may be incidental to, the
exercise of any power or the discharge of any of its functions
2.4 MANDATE
National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) is mandated to implement National Highways
Development Project (NHDP) which is
India 's Largest ever highways project
World class roads with uninterrupted traffic flow
The National Highways have a total length of 71,772 km to serve as the arterial network of
the country. The development of National Highways is the responsibility of the Government
of India. The Government of India has launched major initiatives to upgrade and strengthen
National Highways through various phases of National Highways Development project
(NHDP), which are briefly asunder:
NHDP Phase I
NHDP Phase I was approved by Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs (CCEA) in
December 2000 at an estimated cost of Rs.30,000 crore comprises mostly of GQ (5,846 km)
and NS-EW Corridor (981km), port connectivity (356 km) and others (315km).
NHDP Phase II
NHDP Phase II was approved by CCEA in December 2003 at an estimated cost of
Rs.34,339 crore (2002 prices) comprises mostly NS-EW Corridor (6,161km) and other
National Highways of 486 km length, the total length being 6,647 km. The total length of
Phase II is 6,647km.
NHDP Phase-III
Government approved on 5.3.2005 upgradation and 4lanes of 4,035 km of National
Highways on BOT basis at an estimated cost of Rs. 22,207 crores (2004 prices).
Government approved in April 2007 upgradation and 4 lanes at 8074km at an estimated cost
of Rs.54,339 crore.
NHDP Phase V
CCEA has approved on 5.10.2006 six lanes of 6,500 km of existing 4 lane highways under
NHDP Phase V (on DBFO basis). Six lanes of 6,500 km includes 5,700 km of GQ and other
stretches.
NHDP Phase VI
CCEA has approved on November 2006 for 1000 km of expressways at an estimated cost of
Rs. 16680 crores.
Bharatmala
The Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (MORTH), Government of India has proposed
“Bharat Mala Pariyojana” an Umbrella scheme of road development project through National
Highways Authority of India (NHAI), National Highway and Industrial Development
Corporation (NHIDC) and state Public Works Departments (PWD) at an estimated cost of
INR 5,35,000crores. This is the second largest highways construction project in the country
after NHDP, in that almost 50,000 km of roads targeted across the country. This project aim
to improve connectivity particularly on economic corridors, border areas and to remote areas
with an aim of rapid and safe movement of cargo to boost exports. International trade
considered as a key aspect in this scheme and north-eastern states have given special
focus. The project cleared by the Union Cabinet on October 25,2017.
The ambitious project expected to create nearly 100million man days of jobs during the
construction and subsequently to about 22million jobs of the increased economic activity
across the country. The construction will carried out through many means including debt
funds, budgetary allocation, private investment, toll operator transfer etc. The total length
Identified is of 66,100 km and upgrade proposed in Phase 1 is 24,800 km including
Economic corridors of around 9,000km,
Inter-corridor and feeder routes of around 6,000km,
National Corridors Efficiency Program of about 5,000 km roads
Border and international connectivity roads of around 2,000 km,
Coastal and port connectivity roads of around 2,000 km,
Expressways of around 800 km
In a historic decision, the Government of India introduced a Cess on both Petrol and Diesel.
This amount at that time (at 1999prices) came to a total of approximately Rs.2,000 crores per
annum. Further, Parliament decreed that the funds or collected were to be put aside in a
Central Road Fund (CRF) for exclusive utilization for the development of a modern road
network. The developmental work that it could be tapped to fund, and the agencies to whom it
was available were clearly defined as:
Loan assistance for implementation of specific projects was taken from multilateral
development agencies like Asian Development Bank, World Bank and Japanese
Bank of International Co - Operation.
Major policy initiatives have been taken by the Government to attract foreign as well
as domestic private investments. To promote involvement of the private sector in
construction and maintenance of National Highways, Some Projects are offered on
Build Operate and Transfer (BOT) basis to private agencies. After the concession
period, which can range up to 30 years, this road is to be transferred back to NHAI by
the Concessionaries.
NHAI funds are also leveraged by the setting up of Special Purpose Vehicles
(SPVs).The SPVs will be borrowing funds and repaying these through toll revenues in
the future. This model will also be tried in some other projects. Some more models
may emerge in the near future for better lever aging of funds available with NHAI
such as Annuity, which is a variant of BOT model
Following incentives to attract private sectors for development of highways have been
announced by the Government.
Government will carry out all preparatory work including land acquisition and utility
shifting. Right of way (ROW) to be made available to concessionaires free from all
encumbrances.
Government to provide capital grant upto 40% of project cost to enhance viability
on a case to case basis;
100% tax exemption in any 10 consecutive years within a period of 20years;
Concession period allowed up to 30 years;
Well defined transparent procurement procedure with Standard Bidding Document;
Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996 based on UNICITRAL provisions;
BOT projects entrepreneur are allowed to collect and retain tolls;
Duty free import of specified modern high capacity equipment for highway
construction.
CHAPTER 3
PROJECT DESCRIPTION INCLUDING POSSIBLE ALTERNATIVE
ALIGNMENTS / BYPASS AND TECHNICAL/ENGINEERING
ALTERNATIVES
funds, budgetary allocation, private investment, toll operator transfer etc. The total length of
around 34,800km considered in phase 1including
Economic corridors of around9,000km,
Inter-corridor and feeder routes of around6,000km,
National Corridors Efficiency Program of about 5,000 km roads
Border and international connectivity roads of around 2,000 km,
Coastal and port connectivity roads of around 2,000km,
Expressways of around 800 km
NHDP roads of10,000km
In pursuance of the above program, NHAI appointed M/s STUP Consultants Private Limited,
New Delhi as Consultants to carry out the Consultancy Services for preparation of DPR for
development of Economic Corridors, Inner corridors, feeder Routes and Costal Roads to
improve the efficiency of fright movement in India - Lot 4/Gujarat, M.P. / Package 3. The
project consists following stretches of roads finalized as per final Inception Report.
Bhopal – Sanchi – Vidisha – Sagar (Length - 173km)
Katni – Shahdhol (Length - 124km)
Sanchore – Tharad – Santhalpur (Green Field Alignment length - 130.223km)
Kathial – Nadiad (Length - 21km)
Shamlaji – Modasa – Vadodra(Green field Alignment Length – 125 km)
2. However, detailed comparative study of alternative alignment options along both Northern
and Southern sides, showed heavy hill cutting, large amount of land acquisition, and high
project costing if the Northern Bypass is followed. Accordingly, consultant and client both
agreed for the bypass at Salamatpur and Sanchi along the Southern face and consultant
submitted the option study report vide letter no. 13/E/12645/IRM: RC/9013 dated on 17th
Sep,2018. PD Sagar recommended the alignment report to RO-Bhopal for approval on 18th
Sep, 2018 vide letter no. SAG/39010/2/BRT-STUP-Misc./2017/465. On 11th &12th Oct, 2018
a meeting was held with the client, consultant and MPRDC regarding Bhopal – Sanchi –
Vidisha- Sagar and Bhopal Ring Road alignment. It was informed by MPRDC that from
Bhopal to Vidisha via SH-18, 23km of bypass is being proposed by NHAI. This will entail
massive land acquisition. The existing NH-146 via Raisen is already in a stage of two-lane
with paved shoulder configuration. Thus advice was to study on Bhopal – Sagar stretch via
Raisen along NH-146. Being a part of Economic Corridor the alignment is also being
prepared as four lane with future provision of eight lanes.
3. After this one meeting held with RO, Bhopal and Consultant Team on 29th Dec, 2018, that
the design will be as per four lane and future provision for six lane status and with LA plan of
60m. In this meeting it was being also agreed that the alignment will follow the route of
Raisen instead of Sanchi – Salamatpur.
4. Due to low traffic the client has suggested the alignment proposal will be considered as four
lane status & end point will be merged at NH-28 near Sagar to make a half ring road of Sagar
town which was prepared by M/S Casta under PWD. The Data made by M/S Casta was
wanted vide letter no. NHAI/RO-MP/Misc/2019/33477 dated 04.01.2019 &
SAG/39010/2/BRT-STUP-Misc./2017/80 dated on 08/02/2019. M/S Stup followed the
alignment of Casta to minimize the Land Cost by following Narayuili village means the
northern side of Sagar town. So, the end point of alignment had been changed due to this
reason.
5. At Bhopal, An alignment is proposed by MPRDC with configuration of six lane from Bhopal
Specified location at Mandideep to Indore. Client had given the advice to give access with the
Indore – Bhopal Expressway. M/S Stup had changed the start point from Bhopal Ring Road
to Design Chainage of 14Km of Indore Bhopal Expressway.
6. Taking this view the consultant M/S Stup had submitted the alignment option study report on
14.03.2019 vide letter no. 13/E/12645/IRM:RC/9196. The Same had been recommended by
PD, Sagar 08/04/2019 vide letter no. SAG/39010/2/BRT-STUP-Misc./2017/158. This
alignment option study report was accorded by RO, Bhopal vide letter no. NHAI/RO-
MP/SAG/Sg-69/DPR/STUP/2019/34587 dated on 01.05.2019. In this letter it is clearly
mentioned that “as per the NHAI guideline dated on 15.04.2019 that Land acquisition in low
priority projects should not be processed further beyond the feasibility study”.
8. M/S STUP has followed the instruction and submitted the draft feasibility report for the entire
stretches vide letter no. 13/E/12645/SC:RC/5050, 5061, 5058 dated on 03.09.2019,
09.09.2019, 25.09.2019 respectively. The comments on the submission of the Draft
Feasibility Report has been pointed out vide letter no. SAG/39010/2/BRT-STUP-
Misc./2017/423 dated on 05/10/2019.The compliance regarding submission of DFSR has
been prepared vide letter no. 13/E/12645/SC: RC/5070 dated on 12.11.2019.
9. A meeting was held at Indore, chaired by Member (P) & RO,Bhopal regarding project viability
and progress of Project. In that meeting it was hinted by NHAI to foreclose Packages-1 and 2
due to lack of fund. Only package – 3 (a part of Sagar Ring Road) may be continued. Even,
this package should be in continuation with the southern part of the Sagar Ring Road
designed by Ms LEA. But till date no letter or minutes had been communicated to the
consultant from the client. However, the DPR Consultant had intimated this vide letter no:
13/E/12645/SC:GU/2412, dated 28.11.2019. The consultant is in the process of submitting
the Final Feasibility Report.
10. After that meeting RO, Bhopal had directed to the Consultant to meet Mr. K V Singh , GM
(MP&GJ Division) for the further progress of the project. Consultant met with him and
discussed regarding the project. He had hinted that the start point of the Bhopal – Sagar
project will not be in that position as the Indore – Bhopal Expressway has been dropped out
from the scheme of the project. He assured that there will be a meeting with LA – committee
in the month of March,2020 in that meeting the conclusion of the further progress of the
project may be decided for further GO or NO GO.
11. In between RO Bhopal called for a meeting on 19.02.2020 regarding the project further
progress. RO Bhopal suggested the following:
d. The start point which was on the proposed Indore-Bhopal Expressway is to be altered
as the proposed Indore-Bhopal Expressway has been shelved as of now. No concrete
decision has been adopted yet regarding the start point.
The project passes through four Districts namely Bhopal, Raisen, Vidisha and Sagar in the
state of Madhya Pradesh.
The project is intended to cater traffic coming from proposed Indore – Bhopal Expressway.
The original corridor proposed with 45m right-of-way in open area and 30m in Forest area
except interchange, toll plaza and wayside amenities consists of divided 4-lanecarriageway
with bypassing the habitation area and improving the geometrical deficient area.
Sagar (formerly Saugor) is a city in the state of Madhya Pradesh in central India. Situated on
a spur of the Vindhya Range and 1,758 feet (536 m) above sea-level. The city is around 172
kilometres (107 mi) northeast of state capital, Bhopal. It is situated almost in the centre of
India.
Sagar has been selected as one of the hundred Indian cities to be developed as a smart
city under PM Narendra Modi's flagship Smart Cities Mission and listed top safest city of India
2018. Sagar University was founded on 18 July 1946. In February 1983 the name was
changed to Dr. Hari Singh Gour University.
3.2.1 HISTORY
The ancient Indian kingdom of Chedi had its capital at Suktimati, which is located in Sagar in
contemporary times. The history of Sagar District before 1022 A.D. is generally unknown;
after that, records are available. Sagar was under the rule of Ahir Rajas and their capital was
at Garhpehra. In 1660, Udenshah, founded the present town of Sagar.
After 1735, the city came under the rule of the Peshwas. In 1818, a large part of the Sagar
district was ceded by PeshwaBaji Rao II to the [East India Company British East India
Company. Administratively, the position of Sagar and the neighbouring territories underwent
frequent changes.
The Saugor territory was, first of all, placed under the superintendent of Political Affairs of
Bundelkhand. Later, in 1820, this area, called the Saugor and Nerbudda Territories, was
placed under the administration of an agent to the governor general. The region fell under the
North-Western Provinces following its constitution in 1835. In 1842 occurred the Bundela
rising, the quelling of which demanded a more direct attention by the Governor-General. But
order was restored in the following year, and the Saugor and Nerbudda Territories were
again placed under the political control of an Agent to the Governor-General. The
arrangement however, was not found to be satisfactory and these territories were once again
restored to the North-Western Provinces in 1853. Thereafter in 1861 the Saugor and
Nerbudda territories, along with the Nagpur state formed a Commissioner's Province called
Central Provinces.
3.2.2 CONNECTIVITY
Sagar is a great city to visit in the state of Madhya Pradesh. There are no regular flights from
other major cities of the country to Sagar. Nearest airport is Jabalpur Airport.Sagar is well
connected to other major cities of the country via regular trains.You can easily get regular
buses to Sagar from other major cities of the country.
3.2.3 DEMOGRAPHY
As of the 2011 India census, Sagar had a population of 2,378,458 of which male and female
were 1,256,257 and 1,122,201 respectively. In the 2001 census, Sagar had a population of
2,021,987 of which males were 1,073,205 and remaining 948,782 were females. Average
literacy rates of Sagar in 2011 were 76.46 compared to 67.73 of 2001. Gender-wise, male
and female literacy rates were 84.85 and 67.02 respectively in 2011. For the 2001 census,
the rates stood at 79.41 and 54.35 in Sagar District. The total number of literates in Sagar
District was 1,545,719 of which male and female were 908,607 and 637,112 respectively. In
2001, Sagar District had 1,118,993 literates in its district.
The proposed alignment starts originates from near Berkheri. The nearest access to starting
point is shown in Figure 3-3.
FIGURE 3-4 : MERGING POINT OF SAGAR LINK ROAD WITH NH-26 NEAR RANIPURA
Design Chainage
S.NO DISTRICT TEHSIL VILLAGE NAME
From To
1 Sagar Rahatgarh CHAUKI 134+737 135+727
2 Sagar Rahatgarh BERKHERI SADAK 135+727 135+857
3 Sagar Rahatgarh BERKHERI SADAK 136+157 136+637
4 Sagar Rahatgarh MARDANPUR 136+857 136+157
5 Sagar Rahatgarh MARDANPUR 136+637 137+517
6 Sagar Rahatgarh PACHWASA 137+517 138+737
7 Sagar Rahatgarh GAMBHIRIYA 138+737 140+607
8 Sagar Rahatgarh KHIRIYA KAJI 140+607 141+197
9 Sagar Rahatgarh PADARASOI 141+197 143+597
10 Sagar Rahatgarh BHAISA 143+597 145+777
11 Sagar Rahatgarh MANESIYA 145+777 146+497
12 Sagar Rahatgarh DHAGARNIYA 146+497 148+697
13 Sagar Sagar BASIYABHANSA 148+697 150+687
14 Sagar Sagar NARAYAWLI 150+687 151+677
15 Sagar Sagar NARAYAWLI 151+787 152+087
16 Sagar Sagar MARA IMILIYA 150+907 151+107
17 Sagar Sagar MARA IMILIYA 151+297 151+337
18 Sagar Sagar MARA IMILIYA 151+677 151+787
19 Sagar Sagar BADORA 152+087 153+807
20 Sagar Sagar KODNI 153+807 155+277
21 Sagar Sagar IKPANA BASONA 155+277 157+357
22 Sagar Sagar KOLUWA AMARSA 157+357 159+507
23 Sagar Sagar BERKHERA KHUMAN 159+507 161+447
24 Sagar Sagar SIRWAI 161+447 162+517
25 Sagar Sagar RANIPURA 162+517 163+254
The end point of the project highway is on North – South corridor (NH-26) near Ranipura.
The project road stretch is passing through Plain and Rolling terrain.
The land use is in general agricultural. However at settlements like Raisen, Vidisha it is urban
and at Rahatgarh, Berkheri, Gyaraspur it is semi urban. The alignment also pass through
reserve forest on a total length of about 26km.
In general, NH 146 is a predominantly 2 lane roads with 6.8-7 m wide carriageway and about
1-1.5m earthen shoulders on either side. The pavement is heavily distressed and damaged at
some stretches. The camber of the road is generally 1.5-2.0% except at a few stretches
where the camber is nonexistent resulting in poor drainage during rainy season. In general
the embankment height varies between 0.5m to 0.8m which contributes largely to the
drainage problem.
3.3.7 EMBANKMENT
3.3.8 DRAIN
3.3.11 JUNCTION
Impact on markets and commercial establishments along the road due to widening
Availability of water for road construction
Impact on natural drainage pattern of the area.
Impact on community water resources and water storage arrangements.
Material for high embankments
Scarcity of earth and availability of borrow areas.
Disposal of Excess earth from hill cutting
Protection of disposal sites
The alignment is traversing through the green filed. The existing road from Berkheri – Sagar
is full of habitation area named Berkheri, Sihora, Lahdeara Naka etc. To bifurcating the traffic
in the sagar town this green field alignment has been proposed. By proposing this alignment
the Traffic congestion in Sagar will be reduced. This green field alignment will create the NH-
Road network in good manner.
S. Proposed Bypasses
No. Existing Habitation Length From To (m) Length Improvement Proposal
along (m) (m)
Habitation
Morkodi,DhaknaChapnaSan
3 Morikodi-Vidisha 2200 61250 71550 10300
chi,
4 Atari khejda 1335 99000 101250 2250 Atari khejda bypass
5 Gyaraspur 1930 109900 112050 2150 Gyaraspur bypass
6 Kasba-Bagrod 1100 125100 127300 2200 Kasbabagrod bypass
7 Rahatgarh 2500 147000 150700 3700 Rahatgarh bypass
Sagar link road to Sagar link road to Lalitpur
8 6400 186393 30693
Lalitpur road 155700 road bypass
khapar kheda
2%
Minor Mirkhedi Manora
Realignment 2% 2%
8% Bahadurpur
1%
CHAPTER 4
METHODOLOGY ADOPTED
4.1 GENERAL
The Feasibility Study aimed at evaluating the existing deficiencies of the project road in
respect to functional, structural, efficiency and safety requirements for meeting the needs of
projected traffic for the design period as per TOR. This carried out based on the findings from
various surveys and investigations carried out, observations made and experiences gained
from similar projects. The feasibility study, in general, consists of:
Traffic surveys
Engineering Surveys and Investigations
Environmental and Social Screening
Outline of Design proposal
Preliminary cost estimates
Economic viability
Financial viability
The methodology adopted in to carryout various tasks for the feasibility study discussed
briefly in the following paragraphs. Outline of various proposals based on the results obtained
from analysis surveys & investigations data, planning; designs for improvement of project
road are separately dealt-with in relevant chapters. The broad methodology, prepared on the
basis of the Terms of Reference (TOR), has generally developed keeping IRC
guidelines/standard practices.
The alignment is passing through the Brownfield means follows the existing alignment of NH-
146. So Traffic studies and Inventory and condition survey for road and bridge has been
conducting.
Socio-economic profile
A thorough study of the socio-economic profile of the state and the project influence area
(PIA) has carried out. The aspects include gender, local population, industry, agriculture
employment, health, education, child labour etc.
The consultants have made a study of the available land width (ROW), topographic survey
maps of the project area and other relevant information collected.
A detailed reconnaissance survey has been conducted on the project road and an
assessment of possible alignment change at places ,if required , has been made .Detailed
features such as land-use, cross sectional parameters, intersection roads, railway lines, utility
black spots, religious section etc. have noted down. This has enabled the Consultants to
visualize the possible problems likely to be encounter in surveys and investigations, design,
and execution of the project. The detailed ground reconnaissance of project influence area
has been utilized for planning and programming the detailed surveys and investigations.
Identification of homogenous sections has been carried based on traffic data, pavement
condition, and height of embankment. For each homogenous section, the related studies /
surveys have carried out.
The length of the project road of length around 186.393Km follows the existing route of
Bhopal – Sagar of NH-146.
Road inventory survey has carried out along the existing project road to collect details of all
the features of the existing road and pavement. The following aspects essentially been
covered:
Terrain
Land use (built-up / agricultural / forest / industrial /barren)
Village /Town
Formation width
Carriageway width - (type / width /condition)
Shoulder (type / width /condition)
Embankment height
Submergence history, if any
Details and configuration of major junctions.
Details of cross roads
List of important structures like temples, petrol pumps, weigh bridges, schools /
The project highway is both Greenfield & Brownfield alignment passing through Adampur,
Grame Kharbai, Grame Neemkheda, Vidisha, Atari khejda, Rahatgarh, Berkheri, Gyraspur, &
Sihora villages.
The road alignment is generally passing through plain terrain. Land use pattern for the major
portion of the stretch is agriculture/residential and commercial structure.
A part of project road passes through Brownfield using the existing alignment of NH-146.
Existing Alignment
4.2.5 ROW
The alignment is passing through the green field. Some minor roads are crossing this
alignment. The details are given below:
There is no railway level crossings/ROB exist in this stretch of the project road.
4.3.1 OBJECTIVE
The basic objective of the topographic survey is to capture the essential ground features
along the project alignment in X,Y,Z coordinate system to have Digital Terrain Model and to
consider working out improvements, rehabilitation and upgrading of the project road. The
survey will carried out by the help of Laser scanning or Light Detection and Ranging (LiDAR)
systems mounted on vehicle
Topographic Surveys along the Existing Right of Way (ROW): Carrying out topographic
survey using LiDAR or equivalent technology along the existing road and realignments,
wherever required and properly referencing the same with reference pillars fixed on either
side of the centre-line at safe places within the ROW
The detailed field surveys would essentially include the topographic surveys along the
proposed location of bridge and alignment of approach road.
The detailed topographic surveys should be carried out along the approach roads alignment
and location of bridge approved by NHAI Collection/ Extraction of details for all features such
as structures (bridges, culverts etc.) utilities, existing roads, electric and telephone
installations (both O/H as well as underground), huts, buildings, fencing and trees (with girth
greater than 0.3metre) oil and gas lines etc. falling within the extent of survey.
4.3.3 Methodology
The complete methodology adopted for conducting topographical survey for the project road
comprised of the following activities
Fixing of Monuments
Keeping in view the importance and stability of control points, RCC pillars of specified
dimensions 15cm x 15cm at the top, 20 cm x 20 cm at the bottom and 45 cm in height with an
iron pin fixed at the top centre of each pillar were got pre-casted. After proper curing, these
pre cast RCC Pillars embedding round projecting about 15cm above ground level. The
balance 30cm embedded in ground with concrete cement layer all around to ascertain
stability of the pillars. The top projected part of the pillar painted yellow. All pillars uniquely
numbered with red paint. The locations of pillars were arranged in such a way that twin inter-
visible points about 200-250m apart are available at an interval of every 5 km along the entire
road stretch. Pair of twin GPS pillars has the advantage that every 5 km stretch
independently use for starting and closing the traverse by Total Station. This 5km traverse be
adjusted and independent detailed survey can be carried out.
The location of the pillars suitably selected away from the road but within the ROW so that it
is not disturb by traffic. Also, the site selected in an open area so that the signals from the
satellite received from all around above 15-degree altitude from the horizon. Proper
description and sketch of the location of each pillar with respect to the surrounding details
was prepared to ensure easy identification and traceability.
GPS Observations
The purpose of fixing starting control point to the best possible absolute accuracy, continuous
GPS observations taken at GPS-00 near the beginning of the project for a period of about 6
hours. Based on this long observation, the coordinates of GPS-00 computed in “single point
positioning” mode .Accepting GPS-00 as the fixed point, the other points observed in
continuity and computed in “base line” mode.
GPS observations carried out in continuation of the observations carried out at GPS-00 for a
period of about 45 minutes to one hour for a base line of 5kilometers depending upon the
availabilityofsatellites.TwoGPSsetsusedforrecordingsimultaneoussatellitesignalsatboth ends
of the base line. Observations recorded in common time by both the receivers used for
measurement of the base line. Observations taken using Leica GS08 Plus and Leica 1200
Series for the DGPS Survey.
Data post processed with Leica Geo Office software and network adjustment done. Satellites
were available more than 16 nos. all along the survey corridor, result ambiguity was fine.
Coordinates calculated in WGS 84- LAT-LONG, UTM zone requirement and scale factor
statement for the same.
Secondary Control Points/ Bench Marks fixed at an interval of about 250m by embedding
pre- cast RCC pillars of the same specification as GPS pillars. These pillars embedded in
concrete up to a depth of 30 cm with 5 cm wide layer all around and the balance 15 cm
above ground painted yellow. All the pillars have numbered by red paint.
On establishment of secondary control points, traverse observations carried out with DGPS
starting from one pair of GPS control points, closing at then extpair of GPS control points,
and connecting all secondary control points in between. These traverse observations were
process educing Leica Geo Offices of tware to compute the coordinates of all subsidiary
control points. The closing error of the traverse line checked.
The elevations (Z value) of all the GPS control pillars as well as the secondary control points
established by carrying out levelling from a known Bench Mark whose detail given in the
chapter.
Double tertiary levelling was carried out by two levelling teams in for and back directions
using Leica Digital Level from reference benchmark to another reference benchmark
connecting all intermediate GPS, Bench Marks and other temporary marks such as kilometer
stones/culverts parapet etc. to establish accurate MSL heights of all the control points.
Levelling discrepancy between two reference bench marks was restricted to 12kmm in fore
and back levelling, where ‘k’ is the distance in kilometre.
Heights (Z values) of all the GPS control points obtained from GPS observations replaced by
their levelling heights before using these control points for detailed topographical survey.
Mobile LiDAR is an advanced mapping solution that incorporates the most advanced LiDAR
sensors, cameras and position / navigation / GPS receivers to collect survey grade 3D point
cloud data quickly and accurately.
Mobile mapping is the process of collecting geospatial data from a mobile vehicle, typically
fitted with a LiDAR remote sensing systems. Such systems are composed of an integrated
array of time synchronized navigation sensors (survey grade DGPS) and imaging sensors
mounted on a mobile platform. The primary output after pre-processing from such systems
include; geo-referenced 3D point cloud data, digital maps, images and videos. Further, after
post processing, the output in desired format like Auto Cad. dwg or Arc GIS*,shp files can be
obtained.
Scanner: Z+F profiler 9012, with 119 m range and 360 degrees field of view. Scan speed of
above 1 million points per second.
GNSS / IMU / SPAN Sensor : L1, L2, L-Band and SBAS tracking GPS +GLONASS, single
and dual antenna support, low noise FPG IMU.
Camera Sensor : No. of cameras 6, CCD size 1628 x 1236
Battery : Weight 36 kg, size 50 x 30.5 x 46 cm : 10 hours
Control Unit : Small form factor industrial PC, dual core processor, 500 GB SSD hard disk.
WiFi controlled for remote operations. USB port for data download.
The average length of data captured is about 80 km per day, with single run of vehicle,
running at average speed of40 km per hour, for existing 2 lane highway.
GPS base station observations are made using 3 numbers of survey grade DGPS receivers
(Trimble R8) located about 30 km apart.
More than 1,00,000 frames of high resolution CCD pictures are collected with six set of
cameras covering 360 degrees of view per day, covering about 80 km length.
Using the GPS observation data and the IMU data, the precise trajectory.txt file is computed
by “way point inertial explorer”.
The 3D point cloud data with colorization is prepared by a single click, using “Leica Auto PP”
from the captured scan files, the images files and the *.txt trajectory file.
Output of the 3D point cloud data can be obtained in the Leica.*hpc format or the
universal*.LAS format
The *.tff images of this point cloud data can also be generated if required.
The required point, line and polygon features along the highway are extracted in the arc GIS
environment using “Leica Map Factory Advanced” module.
The extracted features are then exported to Auto Cad*.dwg format for further drafting and
printing works.
A video file can also be generated using the “Windows Movie Maker” or similar software, by
using the images or pictures captured by the cameras.
The average speed of data processing and feature extraction in one day of 8 working hours,
by one license, would be about 5 km to 10 km depending upon the details to be extracted
and the scope of work.
Field data capture by using mobile LiDAR can be done with great speed, very effective in
areas with extreme harsh climates and sensitive urban areas having road side
encroachments.
Manpower required is considerably less, which adds to the savings in the overall project
costs.
The captured data gives complete information about the site, which can be re-used for
different applications.
Lesser chances of human error, since the process is more automated.
Collected pictures and images can be used to generate videos which can assist in decision
making
The accuracy obtained is absolute, depending on the GPS and is not compounding in nature.
Provides increased safety for project personnel and the general public because data can be
collected remotely, removing the need for traffic diversion.
The following traffic surveys carried out to obtain all necessary data for satisfactory design
and reliable economic and financial analysis;
The details of traffic survey and analysis given in Chapter 7: Traffic Survey and Analysis.
The objective of the hydrological and hydraulic study is to determine the required number and
sizes of the drainage structures so as to allow the design discharge of the river / stream to
pass safely through the opening and to check whether waterway of the existing structure is
sufficient to transmit the flow without risk.
The hydrological and hydraulic study for the project is based on:
The available topographic maps of the influence area on the various scales of 1:50,000 and
1:2,50,000 have been studied be identify the number of valleys crossing the alignment of the
road, to broadly assess the number of drainage structures and demarcate their catchment
area so as to assess the run off characteristics. Hydrological reconnaissance survey have
been carried out to properly identify and match the existing structures with proper valley
location, to finalise the number of additional structures required, to ascertain the pattern of
the area. Information on past floods and their effects on existing structures will be collected
from records, local officers and nearby residents of the area. Design discharge and high
flood level would be established using these data and information collected from field and
their detailed interpretation and analysis.
Adequacy of the existing structures has been arrived at by its functioning and HFL through
visual observation. For the additional new structures required, the linear waterway has been
provided as per the design discharge keeping view width of the existing stream.
The improved rational method used to determine discharges at the culvert locations where
catchment areas could be marked from topo-sheets. The adequacy of most of the slab
culverts has been checked assuming flow through culvert as open channel flow and
assuming suitable velocity through culverts based upon stream characteristics. The
adequacy of the pipe culverts acting as balancer has been checked taking inlet submerged
condition and runoff coming from road and adjacent area.
CHAPTER 5
SOCIO-ECONOMIC PROFILE OF THE PROJECT ROAD
This chapter contains the socio-economic profile for the state, districts as well as the project-
impacted villages along the project road for the purpose of providing a contextual background to
understand the social impacts of the proposed project. The remaining information has been provided
as a supplement for the contextual background.
Road project always influences the whole of the district through which it passes, bringing
prosperity, safety and faster accessibility for all road users.
The project has been divided into four packages on basis of priority as per letter no.
NHAI/RO-MP/Sgr-69/DPR/STUP/202038556 dated on 11.03.2020
State Profile: Madhya Pradesh, with an area of 3, 08, 000 sq.km. Is the second largest state
in India after Rajasthan. It is a part of peninsular plateau of India lying in north central part,
whose boundary can be classified in the north by the plains of Ganga-Yamuna, in the west
by the Aravali, east by the Chhattisgarh plain and in the south by the Tapti valley and the
plateau of Maharashtra.
The topography of Madhya Pradesh is defined by the Narmada sone valley. It is a narrow
and long valley extending through almost the whole of the state from east to west. Sone
valley forms the upper part; Shahdol and Sidhi districts lie in this valley. The lower part forms
the Narmada valley. It has an average elevation of 300 m above msl and is covered with
alluvial soil. Jabalpur, Mandla, Narsinghpur, Hoshangabad, Raisen, Khandwa, Khargone and
Barwani districts lie in this region. The Sone valley is narrower than Narmada valley and
alluvial deposit is also comparatively poor and thin, therefore Narmada valley is more
important than Sone valley for agricultural activities. To the north of this valley lie the central
highlands, to the south the Satpura-Maikal ranges and to the south-east, the eastern plateau.
These three form the natural physiographic regions-into which the state is divided. The
central highlands are spread between the Narmada-Sone valley and the Aravali ranges to the
west in a triangular form. The highlands slope towards the north and drain into the Yamuna.
The central highlands region in the state includes the following four uplands:
The rewa-panna plateau is one, also known as the vindhyan plateau, lies in the north-
eastern part of the central highlands. The main rivers flowing in the area are ken, sonar,
barna and tons. Rewa, panna, satna, damoh and sagar districts lie in this region.the other is
bundelkhand plateau located to the north-west of the rewa-panna plateau. Datia, chhatarpur,
panna, tikamgarh and parts of guna and shivpuri districts forming the northern part of the
state lie in this region. The plateau is bounded in north-east by vindhyan escarp lands or
rewa-panna plateau. The average height of the region is 350-450 m above msl and general
slope is towards north. The main rivers flowing in the area are betwa, dhasan and jamner
which finally join Yamuna.
Central india plateau is the third that lies to west of Bundelkhand plateau. Shivpuri, morena
and Gwalior districts exist in this region. This plateau has an average elevation of 450 m on
highlands and 150-450 m above msl in valleys. Chambal, kali Sindh and Parvati are the main
rivers flowing in this area. The fourth Malwa plateau covers almost the entire western
Madhya Pradesh. The plateau is bounded in the north by Chambal and in south by the
Narmada. The average elevation ranges between 300-500 m above msl. Shajapur, Dewas,
Indore, Ujjain, Dhar, Ratlam and parts of Sehore and JHABUA districts lie in this region.
Bhopal is situated at the eastern edge of the Malwa plateau. Shipra, Parvati, Kali Sindh,
Gambhir and Chambal rivers flow through the malwa plateau. It also forms the water divide
between the Ganga and the Narmada basin. The soil in the area is black cotton as a result of
weathering of basalts.
Satpura-Maikal ranges lie to the south and the eastern plateau regions to the north- east of
the Narmada - Sone valley. Chhindwara, betul, Seoni, Balaghat, Mandla and parts of
Khandwa and Khargone districts lie in the Satpura-maikal ranges. Average height of these
ranges is 300 m ; but there are several high peaks; the highest peak of the state, Dhoopgarh
that rises to 1360 m above msl lies in these ranges. The slope is sharp in south face and
gentle on northern side.
The eastern part, the Satpuras, is wider than the western part which stretches in the form of a
semi-circle and is known as the Maikal ranges. The Maikal ranges include the Amarkantak
plateau, which is origin of both Narmada and Sone rivers. The other rivers in the area are
Johila, Macherwa, Denwa and Choti Tawa which join the Narmada.
The eastern plateau region comprises Baghelkhand plateau lying between Maikal ranges and
Chhattisgarh plain area with an elevation of 1033 m above msl.Source: http://www.mp.gov.in
According to the Tendulkar committee report 2009, nearly 48.6% of the population is
estimated as living below poverty line (bpl) with rural poverty ratio (53.6%) exceeding the
urban poverty ratio (35.1%) significantly. However, if factors beyond income are
considered (multidimensional poverty index), about 68.1% of the state’s population is
poor. The situation of the poor is characterized by marginal and under-productive
landholdings, periodic droughts, insecure land tenure and a higher dependency on
seasonal agricultural & forest labor.
Madhya Pradesh is also performing poorly in most of the human development indicators
(see table 1.1). It is among the most food insecure states of the country. According to the
india state hunger index, Madhya Pradesh falls in the “extremely alarming” category
(April 2008).
Population density: the density of Madhya Pradesh state in the current decade is 610 per
sq mile. Madhya Pradesh is an state of India with population of approximate 7.27 crores.
The population of Madhya Pradesh state is 72,626,809. The density of Madhya
Pradesh state is 236 per sq km.
Sex ratio: according to latest census of 2011, there are 930 females available in Gujarat
for every 1000 males.
Literacy rate: literacy rate in Madhya Pradesh has seen upward trend and is 70.6 percent
as per 2011 population census. Of that, male literacy stands at 78.73 percent while
female literacy is at 59.24 percent.
Work participation: the total and rural work participation rate for Madhya Pradesh is
higher than that of india in the same period but its urban work participation rate is lower. .
Corresponding increase in rural workers and urban workers is 77 percent and 182
percent respectively.
5.3 BHOPAL
Bhopal district was carved out of the erstwhile Sehore district of Bhopal division on dated
13th September; 1972.the district derives its name from the district head-quarters town
Bhopal which is also the capital of Madhya Pradesh. The etymology of the term Bhopal has
been derived from its former name Bhopal. The Bhopal district was carved out on 02-10-
1972, which continues to be one of the 45 districts of the state.
The district lies in the eastern edge of Malwa plateau and is situated in the central part of the
state between latitude 23004’ and 23053’ north and longitude 77012’ and 77040’ east. The
district is bounded by Rajgarh district in the northwest, Guna district in the north, Vidisha
district in the north-east, Raisen district in the south-east and Sehore district in the south-
west.
5.3.3 Connectivity
Bhopal, being the capital of state the district, has adequate transport and communication
facilities. Raja Bhoj aerodrome is situated near Bairagarh sub area. It has been linked by air
with Bombay, Indore. Gwalior-and Delhi. It is also on the route map of Indian airlines while
testing commercial viability to other destinations including, Ahmedabad, Nagpur, Bangalore
etc. The district is well connected by railways; Bhopal and Habibganj being the main railway
stations of western central railway. All south bound trains i.e. Delhi-Chennai, Delhi-
Trivendrum, Delhi-Banglore, Delhi-Hyderabad etc pass through Bhopal.
Bhopal is also a railway junction from where direct trains for Ujjain, Indore, Ratlam, Mumbai
and Ahmedabad etc. In the west, Delhi, Agra, Jammu tawi etc. In the north; Jaipur, jodhpur
etc in the north-west, Chennai, Bangalore, Hyderabad and, Trivandrum etc in south, Bilaspur,
Raipur, Patna, Howrah(kolkata) etc in south-east are available. In other words, Bhopal is
connected with all important towns of the state as well as with those of other states.
5.3.4 Demography
According to the 2011 census, Bhopal district has a population of 2,371,061. Roughly equal
to the nation of Latvia. The us state of new Mexico. This gives it a ranking of 189th in India
(out of a total of 640).
The district has a population density of 855 inhabitants per square kilometre (2,210/sq mi). Its
population growth rate over the decade 2001-2011 was 28.46%. Bhopal has a sex ratio of
918 females for every 1000 males, and a literacy rate of 80.37%.
At the time of the 2011 census of India, 85.54% of the population in the district spoke Hindi,
6.76% Urdu, 2.61% Marathi, 2.23% Sindhi, 0.60% Malayalam, 0.54% Punjabi and 0.52%
Bengali as their first language
5.3.5 Geography
Bhopal district is bounded by the districts of Guna to the north, Vidisha to the northeast,
raisen to the east and Southeast, Sehore to the southwest and west, and Rajgarh to the
northwest.
The city of Bhopal lies in the southern part of the district, and the majority of the population
resides within Bhopal municipality. The town of Berasia lies in the northern part of the district.
Bhopal has more than 550 state-sponsored schools, which are affiliated to the Madhya
Pradesh board of secondary education (mpbse). In addition, there are five Kendriya
Vidyalayas in the city, affiliated to the central board of secondary education (cbse). The city is
also served by numerous other private schools affiliated to either
CBSE, ICSE, MPBSE, NIOS and CIE (Cambridge).
5.4 RAISEN
The district derives its name from the district headquarter town Raisen. The term ‘Raisen’
originated from the 150 metres high sand stone rock hill on which fort of Raja Sajan is
situated. Just below the fort Raisen town is located. During the 19th century, Bhopal state
was divided into 4 districts and 33 tehsils. After 1931 they were reduced to 2 districts and 21
tahsils. Nizamat-a-mashrif in eastern district had 12 tehsils namely Udaypura, Silwani,
Gairatganj, Begumganj, Badi Bareli, Sultanpur, Raisen, Shahganj, Goharganj, Diwanganj and
Piklon. The state had its capital at Bhopal. After Bhopal state became a part ‘c’ state of union
of India, the present district came into existence on May 5th, 1950 with its headquarters at
Raisen. It was decided to retain only seven tehsils in the district, viz. Raisen, Gairatganj,
Goharganj, Bareli, Udaipura, Begumganj and Silwani. In 1956 after the reorganization of
states, Raisen became a part of Bhopal division.
Raisen district of the Bhopal division lies in the centre of Madhya Pradesh in between 22o35’
and 23o45’ north latitudes and 77o21’ and 78o47’ east longitudes. The tropic of cancer
passes through the northern part of the district. The noblest buddhist pilgrimage is located on
the tropic of cancer. It is bound in the north by Vidisha and Sagar district, in the north-east
and east by Sagar, in south-east by Narsinghpur, in the south by Hoshangabad and Sehore
and in the west by Sehore and Bhopal districts. The Narmada river flows along the south-
eastern boundary of the district. The total area of the district is 8,466 sq.km. Which ranks 8th
in the state.
5.4.3 Connectivity
District headquarters Raisen is well connected by road . Mandideep , Raisen are the cities in
this district having road connectivity to major towns and remote villages. Raisen is about 43
km by road to Bhopal. Rail transport some of the rail way stations in district are Sanchi ,
Salamatpur, Mandi dip , Dewanganj which connects most of the towns and villages in the
district.
5.4.4 Demography
According to the 2011 census Raisen district has a population of 1,331,699. Roughly equal to
the nation of Mauritius or the us state of Maine. The district has a population density of 157
inhabitants per square kilometre (410/sq mi). Its population growth rate over the decade
2001-2011 was 18.36%. Raisen has a sex ratio of 899 females for every 1000 males. And a
literacy rate of 74.26%.
At the time of the 2011 census of india, 97.56% of the population in the district spoke Hindi
and 1.99% Urdu as their first language.
5.4.5 Geography
Raisen district is situated between the latitude 22 47' and 23 33' north and the longitude
7721' and 78 49' east. Sehore district lies in west, Vidisha district in the north, Sagar district in
the east and south-east, Narsimhapur district in the south-east, Hoshangabad and Sehore
districts in the south. It covers an area of 8,395 square kilometres (3,241 sq mi)
Raisen district has ten tehsils – Raisen, Goharganj, Begamganj, Gairatganj, Silwani, Bareli,
Udaipura, Deori, Sultanpur and Badi
The type of different educational facilities available in the village is given in numbers.
Government and private educational facilities / institutions are considered for this-purpose. If
there are composite schools like middle schools with primary classes, or secondary schools
with middle classes, these are included in the number of primary and middle schools
respectively.
5.5 VIDISHA
The district derives its name from the headquarters town of Vidisha. The name Vidisha finds
mention in the Valmiki Ramayana. The ancient city of Besnagar, three kilometres from
modern Vidisha was in fact identified as ancient Vidisha and figures prominently in Buddhist,
Jain and Brahamical literature as Vessnagar, Vaishyanagar etc. On the destruction of
Besnagar which was situated on the western side of Betwa, a new town sprang up on the
eastern bank of the river which was known as Bhilaswamin or Bhailaswamin. It was in 1904
that Vidisha, then known as Bhilsa was raised to a district having two tehsilsVidisha and
Basoda. Consequent upon the merger of princely states in 1948 and the formation of Madhya
bharat, a Part B state, Bhilsa was enlarged by the merger of small states of Kurwai,
Mohammadgarh and Pathari which formed Kurwai tehsil. Further enlarged with the transfer of
Sironj sub-division of Kota district of Rajasthan in it. The district was renamed from Bhilsa to
vidisha due to the formation of new state MadhyaPradesh on 1st November 1956.
The district was renamed because of its cultural association, antiquity and historical
references to the capital of Malwa which finds mention in the celebrated work of Kalidas.
Vidisha has a rich history not only in the pre-historic period but also during the subsequent
period. The archaeological wealth scattered all over the district speaks of the glory that was
vidisha. A few paleolithic tools and also the Chaleolithic tools discovered in the valleys of
Betwa, Bina, Dhasan and Keothan give evidence of the Paleolithic culture as also the Aryan
influence over this tract.
Vidisha district, is situated in the central part of the state and eastern part of the fertile Malwa
region. It lies between latitude 23o20’ and 24o22’ north and longitude 77o15’ and 78o18’
east. The shape of this district is more or less elliptical and the longer axis lies from north-
west to south-east with slight projections on the north, north-west, south and south-west. Its
greatest length from north-west to south-east is about 133.6 km. And the greatest width from
north-east to south-west is about 96 km. The tropic of cancer passes through the southern
stretch of the district about 2 km. South of the district headquarters.
The district is bound in the north by Guna and Ashok Nagar district, in the south by Raisen, in
the east by Sagar, in the north-west by Guna and in the west by Bhopal district. The total
area of the district is 7,371 sq. Km. which is 2.4% of the total area of the state. Its rank is 13th
in terms of the area within the state.
The district lies on the upper Betwa basin of the Malwa region. Physiographically, the district
can be sub-divided into five broad natural regions viz. (1) Dhumgarh forests (2) Sironj plateau
(3) Kurwai plateau (4) Betwa plain and (5) Teonda range.
5.5.3 Connectivity
Vidisha district is lying in the central part of Madhya Pradesh. It is in Bhopal commissioners
division and is well connected by roads and railway. National highway 67, connecting Bhopal
and Dewas passes through the district. Vidisha is a railway station on the Delhi-Chennai,
Delhi-Mumbai main line of the central railway, at a distance of 54 km from Bhopal, the capital
of Madhya Pradesh. Sanchi on the Jhansi-Itarsi section of the west central railway
and Bhopal to Bina triple electrified broad gauge lines, from Bina to Katni double electrified
lines, Vidisha 102 km from Bina, and Vidisha, 9 km from Sanchi, are more convenient.
5.5.4 Demography
According to the 2011 census Vidisha district has a population of 1,458,212. The district has
a population density of 198 inhabitants per square kilometre (510/sq mi).its population growth
rate over the decade 2001-2011 was 20.03%. Vidisha has a sex ratio of 897 females for
every 1,000 males. And a literacy rate of 72.08%.
At the time of the 2011 census of India, 95.16% of the population in the district spoke Hindi
and 4.57% urdu as their first language.
5.5.5 Geography
The district is bounded by the districts of Ashoknagar to the northeast, Sagar to the east,
Raisen to the south, Bhopal to the southwest, and Guna to the northwest.
Vidisha district lies on the Vindhyachal plateau off the main Vindhyachal range. The plateau
slopes from south to north and is drained by a number of rivers – the Betwa, the Bina and the
Sindh. These rivers flow between spur fanges of the Vindhyachal range, that spread out on
the Malwa plateau.
The district lies between 230 20’ and 240 22' north latitudes, and 77016’ and 78018’ east
longitudes. It covers an area of 7,371 km2.
The district is home to the historic city of Besnagar and the Buddhist stupa at Sanchi.
Vidisha is a home to a range of colleges and schools. Vidisha has a large student population
and is a popular educational centre in central india. Most primary and secondary schools in
vidisha are affiliated with the m.p. board, however, quite a few numbers of schools are
affiliated with central board of secondary education (CBSE).
5.6 SAGAR
Situated in the north central region of MadhyaPradesh, spelt as ‘Saugor’ during British period,
the district of ‘Sagar’ takes its name from the headquarter town which in turn derived its name
from Hindi word “Sagar” (meaning sea) . The town Sagar has been built around the beautiful
lake. The history of the Sagar dates back to about 1660 A.D when Udan shah, a descendant
of Nihal shah, built a small fort on the site of the present one and founded a village close to it
called Parkota, which is now a part of the town. The present fort and a settlement under its
walls was founded by Govind Rao Pandit, officer in-charge of Sagar and the surrounding
territory after 1735 A.D., when it came under the Peshwa’s possession.
In 1818 A.D., the Peshwa Bajirao ii ceded the greater part of the district to the British
government, while different parts of the rest of the present district of Sagar came in the
possession of the British at different times between 1818 and 1860. Appaji Bhonsla ceded
the Dhamoni Pargana of Banda tehsil in 1818 A.D. transfer from the Bundelkhand states
acquired the Bherapargana of Banda tehsil in 1818 A,D. the Parganas, Rahatgarh in Sagar
tehsil and Garhakota, Deori, Gourjhamer and Naharmow in rehli tehsil collectively known as
punch mahal were handed over to British by Sindhia at different dates from 1820 to 1825 for
management. The Shahgarh Pargana of Banda tehsil was confiscated in 1857 in
consequence of the rebellion of its chief. The Kanjia Pargana of Khurai tehsil was acquired
from Sindhia in 1860 A.D. a small area in the north-east corner of the tehsil around the village
of Hirapur was similarly transferred to the British from Charkhari state to Bundelkhand and
added to the district after the uprising of 1857.
Administratively, Sagar and the neighbouring territories underwent frequent changes, the
Saugor territory was, first of all, placed under the superintendent of political affairs of
Bundelkhand. Later in 1820, the Saugor and Nerbudda territories were placed under the
administration of an agent to the governor general. The Saugor and Nerbudda territories
were included in north- western province in 1835. In 1842 after the Bundela rising, but order
was restored in 1843 and the Saugor and Nerbudda territories were again placed under the
political control of an agent to the governor-general. These territories were once again
restored to the north-western provinces in 1853. Thereafter, in 1861 the Saugor and
Nerbudda territories along with the Nagpur state formed a commissioner’s province called
central provinces.
5.6.2 Connectivity
Sagar is a great city to visit in the state of Madhya Pradesh. Nearest airport is Jabalpur
airport. Sagar is well connected to other major cities of the country via regular trains.it can
easily get regular buses to Sagar from other major cities of the country.
5.6.3 Demography
According to the 2011 census, Sagar district has a population of 2,378,295. The district has a
population density of 232 inhabitants per square kilometre (600/sq mi). Its population growth
rate over the decade 2001–2011 was 17.62%.sagar has a sex ratio of 896 females for every
1000 males. And a literacy rate of 77.52%.
At the time of the 2011 census of India, 98.52% of the population in the district spoke Hindi
and 0.57% Urdu as their first language.
5.6.4 Geography:
The history of the town of Sagar dates back to about 1660 ad, when Udan Shah, a
descendant of Nihal Shah, built a small fort where the present one sits and founded a village
close to it called Parkota Sagar. The present fort and a settlement under its walls was
founded by Govind Rao Pandit, an officer of the Peshwa, who controlled Sagar and the
surrounding territory after 1735 when it came under the Peshwa's possession. In 1818, the
greater part of the district was ceded by the Peshwa Baji Rao ii to the British government,
while the remainder of the present district of Sagar came into the possession of the British
between 1818 and 1860. Thereafter in 1861, the Saugor and Nerbudda territories (along with
the Nagpur state) formed a commissioner's province called central provinces. Sagar was the
headquarters of the Sagar commissionership for a short period until 1863-64 when this
district was incorporated with Jabalpur commissionership. In the year 1932, the district of
Damoh was added to Sagar district and was administrated as sub-division. In 1956, however,
Damoh sub-division was again separated from the district to form a separate district and
Sagar district consisted of four tehsils viz, Sagar, Khurai, Rehli, Banda.
Sagar District Government high schools, higher secondary schools, Government excellence
higher secondary schools, Navodaya school, central schools, ashram schools of tribal
department. Anganwadis, government degree colleges, government polytechnics, i.t.is,
district institute of education and training (diet), b.ed. Colleges, d.ed colleges, Kasturba
Gandhi Balika Vidyalaya (KGBV), 1 government medical college, government engineering
college, private engineering colleges along with universities are providing educational
facilities in the district .
Source: department of adult, continuing education and extension, dr. H.s. Gour University, Sagar (M.P.)
CHAPTER 6
INDICATIVE DESIGN STANDARDS, METHODOLOGIES AND
SPECIFICATION
6.1 GENERAL
This Chapter intends to give brief description of Design Standards adopted in the Design.
The Consultants have evolved Design Standards and Material Specifications for the Project
Road primarily based on IRC Publications, MORTH Circulars and relevant recommendations
of the International Standards (American, Australian, British) covering all aspects of Design
including Geometric elements, Pavement Design, Bridges and Structures, Traffic Safety and
Materials.
Design Standards given in ‘Manual of Specifications and Standards for Four Lanes of
Highways through Public Private Partnership’ IRC:SP:84-2019 shall be used as main
guidelines along with other relevant IRC codes, guidelines and special publications, and
MORTH circulars as applicable to National Highways. Where the said standards are silent on
any topic, following standards shall reference and the one considered the best and most
relevant will adopted:
American Association of State Highway and Transport Officials (AASHTO)standards;
British Standards;
Any other National or International Standard as considered suitable.
6.2.1 Classification
Terrain is classified by the general slope of the country across the highway alignment, for
which the criteria given in Table 6.1 are followed. The Geometric Design of a highway is
influenced significantly by Terrain conditions.
The % Cross Slope of the Project Road for most of its length is in the range of 0-25% and
thereby the Terrain is classified as Plain and Rolling Terrain.
The Design speed adopted for the design of highway is 100kmph and a minimum Design
Speed of 40kmph shall be adopted for Service Roads.
In general, the Ruling Design Speed shall be adopted for various Geometric Design features
of the road. Minimum Design Speed shall be adopted where site conditions are restrictive
and adequate land width is not available.
As the Project Road is part of National Highway and is passing through Plain and Rolling
Terrain, corresponding Design Speed (as per above table 6.1) values have been adopted.
Intermediate Sight Distance (ISD) is twice the safe stopping distance and affords
reasonable opportunities to drivers to overtake with caution.
The safe stopping sight distance and minimum sight distance for divided carriageway for
various design speeds are given in
The desirable values of sight distance shall be adopted unless there are site constraints. As a
minimum, safe stopping sight distance shall be available throughout.
TABLE 6-2 : SIGHT DISTANCE FOR VARIOUS SPEEDS ( FROM TABLE 2.7 OF IRC – SP : 84 –
2019)
Design Speed Safe Stopping Sight Desirable Minimum Sight
(kmph) Distance (m) Distance (m)
100 180 360
80 130 260
60 90 180
40 45 90
The Project road in general will be designed for Desirable Minimum Sight Distance (ISD) and
wherever it is not practicable to provide the same due to site constraint if any, Safe Stopping
Sight Distance (SSD) will be provided.
TABLE 6-3 : MINIMUM RADII OF HORIZONTAL CURVES (FROM IRC: SP: 84 – 2019,
TABLE 2.6)
Super-elevation
Super-elevation required on horizontal curves shall be calculated from the following formula
as given in IRC: 73-1980 Clause 9.3:
e = V2 / 225R, subject to maximum of 7% in Plain/Rolling Terrain and 10% in Hilly areas not
bounded by snow.
Where,
e = super elevation in meter per meter V = Speed in kmph and
R = Radius in meters
As per IRC: SP: 87-2013 Clause 2.9.3, Super elevation shall be limited to 7%, if radius of
curve is less than desirable minimum radius. It shall be limited to 5% if radius is more than
desirable minimum.
Radius on Horizontal Curves
The minimum Radius of Horizontal Curves is calculated from the following formula: R = V2 /
127 (e + f)
Where,
V = vehicle speed in kmph
e (2.5%) has been provided. Radius requiring no super-elevation has been recommended
considering camber 2.5%.
Table 6.5 given below indicates the radius of horizontal curves for different rates of camber
beyond which super elevation will not be required.
Transition Curves
Transition curves are necessary for vehicle to progress smoothly from a straight section into
a circular curve or between curves of different radius. The transition curve also facilitates a
gradual application of the super elevation and any widening of the carriageway that may be
required for the horizontal curves.
The minimum length of the transition curve is determined from the following two
considerations and is provided in FIGURE 6-2.
As per Comfort criteria,
Ls = 0.0215 V3 /CR
Where,
Ls = length of transition in metres V = Speed in kmph
R = radius of circular curve in metres
C = 80 / (75 + V) (subject to maximum of 0.8 and minimum of 0.5)
As per rate of change of Super-elevation,
= Super elevation in meter per meter
f = coefficient of friction between vehicle tire and pavement (taken as 0.15)
R = Radius in meters
Based on this equation and the maximum permissible value of super-elevation of 7%, Radii
for Horizontal curves corresponding to ruling and minimum design speeds are given in
TABLE 6-5.
When the value of super elevation obtained from the parameters stated above is less than
the road camber, the normal cambered sections are continued on the curve portion, without
providing any super elevation. Since the project area is under low rainfall area, normal
camber
The rate of change of super elevation will not be steeper than 1 in 150. The formula
calculated for minimum length of transitions depending on the terrain (plain/Rolling) and No
of lanes (including future widening) is: Ls = 9.65 V2/ R
Curve Widening
At sharp horizontal curves, it is necessary to widen the carriageway to provide for safe
passage of vehicles. Extra widening required for single and two-lane roads is given in IRC:
73-1980, Table 18. For multi-lane roads, the pavement widening may be calculated by
adding half the widening for two-lane roads to each lane. The Extra width of Pavement and
Roadway in each carriageway of Road (shall be as per IRC: SP: 87-2013 Table 2.5) is
provided in TABLE 6-6
75 to 100 0.90
101 to 300 0.60
FIGURE 6-2: MINIMUM TRANSITION LENGTHS FOR DIFFERENT SPEED AND CURVE RADIUS
Intersection
Intersection Intersectio Arc Start Arc End Arc Hand of Transition Start Transition End Transition Design Super
Point Radius Included Angle
Point X n Point Y Chainage Chainage Length Arc Chainage Chainage Length Speed Elevation
Chainage
135+284.432 854496.479 2635460.7 135+184.597 135+384.100 199.503 2000 Right 05 42 55.222 100 2.5
136+006.279 855152.18 2635762.2 135+978.108 136+034.390 56.282 500 Right 06 26 58.141 135+863.108 136+149.390 115 100 5
136+541.351 855680.695 2635841.7 136+412.156 136+665.016 252.86 500 Left 28 58 32.121 136+297.156 136+780.016 115 100 5
140+367.442 858266.601 2638667.9 140+015.760 140+712.007 696.247 2000 Right 19 56 45.660 100 2.5
143+325.179 860887.244 2640054.4 142+916.560 143+722.704 806.145 2000 Left 23 05 39.643 100 2.5
151+249.925 865883.844 2646219.8 150+858.968 151+631.146 772.178 2000 Right 22 07 16.546 100 2.5
155+792.123 869871.104 2648415.7 155+670.279 155+913.596 243.317 1800 Right 07 44 42.040 155+640.279 155+943.596 30 100 2.5
158+051.027 871992.352 2649193.2 157+806.234 158+292.834 486.6 1800 Right 15 29 20.223 157+776.234 158+322.834 30 100 2.5
159+030.762 872972.605 2649262.7 158+588.539 159+455.809 867.27 1800 Left 27 36 21.847 158+558.539 159+485.809 30 100 2.5
160+249.864 874021.324 2649917.3 159+935.038 160+558.385 623.347 1800 Right 19 50 30.271 159+905.038 160+588.385 30 100 2.5
161+421.184 875174.541 2650155.8 161+378.273 161+464.042 85.669 1000 Left 04 54 30.528 161+328.273 161+514.042 50 100 4.44
TABLE 6-8 : RECOMMENDED GRADIENTS (FROM IRC: SP: 84-2019 TABLE 2.8)
As far as possible, for the project road passing through Plain terrain, Gradients up to the
value corresponding to Ruling Gradient have been adopted. A minimum longitudinal gradient
of 0.3% is adopted to secure satisfactory drainage.
In general, Vertical Curves shall be provided at all changes in gradient. The Curvature shall
be large enough to provide for comfort and, where appropriate, Sight Distance for safe
stopping at Design Speed. Curvature shall be derived from the appropriate ‘K’ value (is
length of the curve divided by algebraic change of gradient expressed as a percentage) in
Table 6.9. The minimum vertical curve lengths can be determined by multiplying the ‘K’
values shown by the algebraic change of gradient expressed as a percentage (as shown in
IRC: SP: 23-1983 Table 6). For satisfactory appearance the minimum length of vertical curve
should be as shown in IRC: SP: 23- 1983 Table 7.
Vertical Curves
Long sweeping vertical curves shall be provided at all grade changes. These shall be
designed as Square Parabolas. Vertical curves are provided at all grade changes exceeding
those indicated in IRC: SP: 23-1983 Table 7. The Design of Summit / Crest Curves is based
on Visibility; whereas design of Valley / Sag Curves is based on Comfort criteria and Head
light sight distance.
A. Summit Curves
B Valley Curves
Valley curves are designed for head light sight distance. The length of valley curves shall be
calculated by the following two criteria:
When the length of curve (L) exceeds the required sight distance (S)
i.e. L > S
L = NS2 / (1.50 +0.035S)
When the length of curve (L) is less than the required sight distance (S)
i.e. L < S
L = NS2
(1.50+0.035S)
When the length of curve (L) is greater than the required sight distance (S)
N
C K Value
Table 6-9 shows adopted ‘K’ Values for Vertical Curves.
Ramp – 1 (Bhopal –
2 Lane + PS 162+518 163+253 0.735 1
Chattarpur)
Ramp – 5 (Chatarpur –
2 Lane + PS 0+000 1+193 1.193 5
Lalitpur) On NH- 28
Flexible Pavement
Introduction
Pavement design basically aims at determining the total thickness of the pavement structure
as well as the individual thickness of structural components for carrying the estimated traffic
loading under the prevailing climatic conditions with satisfactory performance of the
pavement. Different accepted methods for pavement design are currently available, and the
approach of the consultant has been to work out the requirements by various methods,
compare the results and optimize the recommended solution based on characteristics of
available materials, relative economics and best engineering judgment. For the present
project both flexible pavement and rigid pavement design has been considered.
Homogenous sections
Based on reconnaissance survey the project stretch has been divided into different
homogenous section for traffic studies and design as given below.
For new flexible Pavement design “Guidelines for Design of Flexible Pavements- IRC-37-
2018” will be adopted.
Traffic
General
The basic philosophy for the traffic is based on the consideration of total vehicles that will ply on the
project road up to design years and their gross weight. The traffic loading in terms of cumulative
number of equivalent 8.0 t standard axle loads have been computed for the design period.
The following six main steps have been followed in designing the flexible pavement:
Estimating the volume of traffic and the cumulative number (in million) of equivalent standard
axles (CMSA) that will use the road over the selected design life.
Traffic growth rate during the design life in percentage.
Design life in number of years.
Spectrum of axle loads.
Vehicle Damage Factor (VDF).
Lane Distribution of Traffic.
The present day traffic projected for the end of design life at growth rates (‘r’) taken from
Traffic Report. The traffic growth for pavement design is mentioned in below Table 6.13
*Note: As per clause 4.2.2 of IRC: 37-2018 a minimum growth of 5% has been considered when growth rate is
less than 5%
Design Life
VDF is a factor for converting commercial vehicles of different axle load and configuration
into equivalent number of standard axles. The VDF is calculated from axle load survey data.
Axle configuration and standard axle load as per IRC 37-2018 is:
The VDF value from axle load survey at different location and VDF adopted for each
homogenous section is given in Table 6.14
Load type and repetitions, along a pavement needs to be estimated. A pavement structural
design must account for such unequal load distribution. Loads used in the design lane are
calculated from the cumulative two-direction traffic by applying directional distribution and
lane distribution. The recommendation of the IRC: 37 –2018, clause no. 4.5.1 will be applied
for distribution of traffic. The project road consists of 2 lane single carriage way, 4 lane, 6
lane and 8 lane, accordingly 50%, 37.5%, 30% and 22.5% of the total number of commercial
vehicles in both direction, is adopted for pavement design.
AADT of commercial traffic for the base year (2018) is taken from Traffic report and is given
in Table 6.15
TABLE 6-14 : AVERAGE ANNUAL DAILY TRAFFIC
Based on the vehicle damage factors and the projected traffic volumes, the traffic loading in terms of
cumulative number of equivalent 8.0 t standard axle loads have been computed for the period, 2018-
2044 (3 year construction period has been considered from 2021). As per parameters mentioned
earlier Design Traffic (MSA, Million Standard Axles) is worked as below
n
N = [365 x A x {(1+r) ^ -1} x D x F] / [r] MSA
Where:
N= the cumulative number of standard axles to be catered for in the design in term of MSA
A= Initial traffic in the year of completion of construction in terms of the number of CVPD
D= Lane distribution factor
F= Vehicle damage factor
n= Design life (2 year construction period has been considered)
r = Annual growth rate
The projected traffic and required MSA at each homogenous section is given in tables below.
Above shows the MSA calculation on yearly basis. Minimum design msa of 50msa should be
adopted. Summary of design msa adopted in homogenous section is given in table above.
In this project various field data has been collected for pavement design. The existing
baseline conditions being an important element for various decision making and supportive
data for pavement design. Different surveys conducted and its analysis are mentioned in this
report.
Sr. Gravel Sand Silt & Liquid Plastic PI FSI OMC MDD Soaked Soil
No. Chainage % % Clay Limit Limit Value % gm/cc CBR Classification
%
% % % % %
1 CH-135+937 49.69 30.06 20.25 33 NP NP 10.00 12 1.92 11.5 GM
2 CH-141+237 1.96 13.86 84.18 53.7 26.8 26.9 40.00 20 1.625 4.6 CI
3 CH-146+537 8.10 13.54 78.36 39.9 22.3 17.6 45.45 18 1.666 5.1 CH
4 CH-152+237 6.80 12.10 81.10 51.6 26.9 24.7 45.45 20 1.614 4.2 CH
5 CH-157+037 10.30 14.86 74.84 53.7 26.9 26.8 40.00 19 1.620 4.4 CH
6 CH-161+237 5.80 11.78 82.42 54.8 27.1 27.7 40.00 20 1.618 4.7 CH
The soil in this stretch mainly classifies in the group of GM/CI/CH and it is described as above. The
CH soil having Liquid Limit 51.6 to 54.8 % with PI value in the range of 24.7 to 27.7 % & Free Swell
Index in the range of 40 % to 45 %. OMC & MDD are 19-20 % and 1.614 to 1.625 gm/cc. resp. and
Soaked CBR values ranging to 4.2% to 4.7%. CH/CI classification soil may require treatment of soil
stabilization or preferable to replace the soil with low expansive soils from borrow area.
1 144+437 19.5 37.68 42.82 39.9 22.3 17.6 15.38 15 1.84 19.1
2 152+237 17.47 48.45 34.08 49.7 26.5 23.2 16.66 25 1.625 8.4
3 135+937 29.03 54.86 16.11 37.8 18.3 19.5 18.18 11 1.9 25
The results from CH-144+437& CH-135+937 borrow area indicates that good quality of
muroom is available along the project route which is suitable for sub-grade, for embankment
fill and for granular sub-base. Engineering classification of the material is Clayey Sand (SC)
with good CBR value.
Effective CBR
The 90th percentile of borrow area CBR has been taken as CBR of subgrade. If there is a
significant difference between the CBRs of the select sub-grade and embankment soils, the
design should be based on effective CBR as per IRC 37-2018. The effective CBR of sub-
grade is calculated as per Fig 5.1 of IRC: 37-2018. The embankment CBR is taken as 7%
(Maximum value that can be adopted as per Fig 5.1 of IRC: 37-2012). The 90th percentile of
borrow area CBR is 12.4%. The effective CBR of sub-grade calculated as per Fig 5.1 of IRC:
37-2018 is 12%. The details are given below:
General
The concept of designing long lasting pavements is gaining acceptance with the increasing traffic
demand and the need for economic and environmental sustainability. In order to compute pavement
responses to the applied traffic loads, the pavement design software IITPAVE is employed.
Resilient Modulus
The Resilient modulus is an important parameter for design and the performance of a pavement. It is
the measure of its elastic behavior determined from recoverable deformation in the laboratory test.
The default resilient modulus of subgrade can be estimated from generally acceptable correlations
which are as follows:
MR (MPa) = 10* (CBR) for CBR up to 5
0.64
=17.6 * (CBR) for CBR>5
MR = Resilient modulus of subgrade soil
Pavement Model
A flexible pavement is modelled as an elastic multilayer structure. Stresses and strains at critical
locations are computed using a linear layered elastic model. The Stress analysis software IITPAVE
has been used for the computation of stresses and strains in flexible pavements. Tensile strain, ϵt at
the bottom of the bituminous layer and the vertical subgrade strain, ϵ v on the top of the subgrade are
conventionally considered as critical parameters for pavement design to limit cracking and rutting in
the bituminous layers and non-bituminous layers respectively. The Figure 6.3 below shows the critical
points at pavement layers.
Due to repetition of load, tensile strain develops cracks at the bottom of the bituminous layer which is
a problem for the long term serviceability. The phenomenon is called fatigue of the bituminous layer
and the number of load repetitions in terms of standard axles that cause fatigue denotes the fatigue
life of the pavement. Fatigue equation of 80 per cent reliability equation is recommended for traffic up
to 30 msa where normal bituminous mixes with VG-30 grade bitumen can be used. Fatigue equation
of 90 per cent reliability equation is recommended for use for traffic greater than 30 msa where richer
bituminous mixes with stiffer VG 40 binder should be used. Fatigue equation for 90% reliability is
formulated for 3 per cent air voids and 13 per cent volume of bitumen. The equation for the
conventional bituminous mixes designed by Marshall Method is given below:
Nf = 2.21 ∗ 10−04 ∗ [1/εt ]3.89 ∗ [1/MR ]0.854 (80 per cent reliability) .................1
−04 3.89 0.854
Nf = 2.021 ∗ 10 ∗ [1/εt ] ∗ [1/MR ] (90 per cent reliability) .................2
Nf = Fatigue life in number of standard axles
εt = Maximum tensile strain at the bottom of the bituminous layer
MR = Resilient modulus of the bituminous layer
Rutting model
Rutting is the permanent deformation in pavement usually occurring longitudinally along the wheel
path. Rutting equation of 80 per cent reliability equation is recommended for traffic up to 30 msa
where normal bituminous mixes with VG-30 grade bitumen can be used. Rutting equation of 90 per
cent reliability equation is recommended for use for traffic greater than 30 msa where richer
bituminous mixes with stiffer VG 40 binder should be used. The rutting model considers the vertical
strain in subgrade and the equations are as given below .
𝑁 = 4.1656 ∗ 10−08 ∗ [1/𝜀𝑣 ]4.5337 (80 per cent reliability) ...................3
𝑁 = 1.41 ∗ 10−08 ∗ [1/𝜀𝑣 ]4.5337 (90 per cent reliability) ................... 4
N= Number of standard axles
εv = Vertical strain in subgrade
Pavement Composition
The Flexible pavement consists of different layers. The composition of flexible pavement with WMM base and Granular Sub base is shown in
Figure 6-4 below.
FIGURE: 6-4 : COMPOSITION OF FLEXIBLE PAVEMENT WITH WMM BASE AND GRANULAR SUB BASE
Summary
TABLE 6-17 : RECOMMENDED PAVEMENT THICKNESSES FOR NEW CONSTRUCTION & SLIP
ROAD
Rigid Pavement:
New rigid pavement will be plain-jointed type and shall be designed in accordance with the
method prescribed in IRC: 58 -2015, “Guidelines for the Design of Plain Jointed Rigid
Pavements for Highways
Rigid pavement shall be designed for a minimum design period of 30 years. Stage
construction shall not be permitted.
The Pavement Quality Concrete (PQC) shall rest over Dry Lean concrete (DLC) and
Granular sub-base of 150mm thickness.
ROADSIDE DRAINAGE
An effective drainage system shall be planned for the drainage of roadway as per stipulations
of IRC SP: 42-2014 and IRC SP: 50-2013 for maintaining structural soundness and
functionality of the project road. The following types of drains shall be provided for surface
drainage of roadway and ROW:
Longitudinal unlined / lined drains with outfalls at cross-drainage structure in rural sections.
The drain size shape and material shall be adequate to take design run off and prevent soil
erosion and stagnation of water.
Covered RCC drains in built-up areas.
Combination of longitudinal drains and chute drains in high embankments of 3m and above.
Providing catch pits (wherever required) with provision of outflow at suitable location through
buried Hume pipes.
Part of drain water needs to be allowed to percolate or be lost by evaporation. Thus
alongside drains, natural depressions and waterways and artificial ponds are recommended
to drain out the water in rural stretches.
In super elevated sections, proper arrangement for drainage of raised carriageway and
median shall be made without allowing water to drain on the other carriageway.
6.10 EMBANKMENT
Side Slopes:
For earthen embankments the side slopes recommended from consideration of safety of
traffic as per IRC: 36-2010.
Slope shall be designed for embankment height greater than 6.0m using software for High
Embankment design and as per IRC: 75-2015.
However, where costs of construction and land forbid the use of such liberal slopes, the slope
will be generally kept as IV: 2H and pitched wall will be proposed after toe of such
embankment. This slope is considered adequate from stability point of view. The entire
project road shall have W Beam Metal Crash Barriers on the outer edge of the highway to
meet the safety standards and access control.
Slope Protection:
Slopes on embankment height less than 3m shall be turned and those above this height shall
be protected with stone pitching.
Sl. Location
Span/ Opening (m) Remarks
No. (Design Chainage-Km)
1 136+204 1 x 7.0 x4.0 (clear opening) --
2 138+282 1 x 7.0 x4.0 (clear opening) --
3 150+414 1 x 7.0 x4.0 (clear opening) --
4 155+804 1 x 7.0 x4.0 (clear opening) --
LVUP – All LVUP shall have lateral clearance of 12m and vertical clearance of 4.0m. These
may be provided skew and normal to project highway depending of requirement.
Sl. Location
Span/ Opening (m) Remarks
No. (Design Chainage-Km)
1 142+507 1 x 12.0 x4.0 (clear opening) --
2 146+567 1 x 12.0 x4.0 (clear opening) --
3 148+908 1 x 12.0 x4.0 (clear opening) --
4 154+035 1 x 12.0 x4.0 (clear opening) --
VUP – All VUP’s shall have minimum lateral clearance of 20m and vertical clearance of
5.5m.
Roadside and Median Safety Barriers shall be as per guidelines given in IRC: SP: 87-2013
Clause 9.7.
Pedestrian Guard Rail - The design shall be as per IRC: 103-2012.
Kilometer/Hectometer Stones/Posts - The design and placement of Highway kilometer
stones, their dimensions, size, color, and arrangement of letters shall be as per IRC: 8-1980.
For the 200-metre stones, IRC: 26-1967 shall applied. These stones are to be made of
precast M-15 grade reinforced cement concrete and lettering / numbering as per the
respective IRC codes.
ROW Pillars / Boundary Stones - Should any land be acquired for the project then new
ROW pillars at 200 m interval on each side to be established in accordance with IRC: 25-
1967.
Fencing – Chain Link fencing confirming to ASTM F 1553-06 shall fixed on GI pipe / RCC
posts.
Rest Areas – Rest area shall be planned and provided as wayside amenities for users to
enable them to stop, take rest and refresh themselves so as to ease their fatigue. These
areas also cover facilities for providing fuel for vehicles and emergency requirement without
having to exit from the project road. The service facilities shall be designed as per section 12
of IRC: SP: 84-2019.
The location may be decided keeping in view factors such scenic beauty, availability of
utilities and adequate ROW as per section 12 of IRC: SP: 84-2019.
State Border Check Posts – The state border check posts shall be planned and provided to
enable the State Authorities to exercise checks as per applicable laws on the vehicle
crossing the state border. The state border check posts shall be designed as per section 13.3
of IRC: SP: 84-2019.
Truck Lay – byes - The proposed layout of truck lay bye is generally based on the
recommendations of “Planning Norms and Guidelines on Wayside and Terminal Facilities”
(MORTH sponsored study). Also, as per guidelines given in IRC: SP: 84-2019.
Toll Plaza – shall be design based on the guidelines given in IRC: SP: 84-2019 and as per
circulars of MORTH.
Highway Landscaping - IRC: SP: 21-2009 "Manual on Landscaping” shall guide the
plantation of rows of trees with staggered pitch on either side of the road. The choice of the
trees shall also be made as per the same code. Local, indigenous species that grow in the
project area microclimate shall be planted. Indicative arrangements for plantation of trees
shall be in accordance with the MORTH Technical Circular No. NHI-41 (34)/69 dated. A
spacing of 10-15m c/c recommended for spacing of trees parallel to the roads. Setback
distance of trees needed in different situations shall be as per the IRC: SP: 21-2009 and the
IRC:66-1976.
Street Lighting – shall be designed based on the guidelines given in IRC: SP: 87-2013.
ROW Pillars / Boundary Stones - Should any land be acquired for the project then new ROW
pillars at 200 m interval on each side to be established in accordance with IRC: 25-1967.
Fencing – Chain Link fencing confirming to ASTM F 1553-06 shall fixed on GI pipe / RCC
posts.
6.15 SPECIFICATIONS
The General Technical Specifications shall be as per MORTH Specifications for Road and
Bridge works (Fifth revision, April 2013) issued by the Ministry of Road Transport and
Highways, Govt. of India and published by the Indian Roads Congress along with its
updating/amendments/ addendum issued from time to time.
TABLE 6-20: LIST OF IRC CODES / MORTH PUBLICATIONS USED IN STRUCTURES DESIGN
control as a parallel activity with the construction of substructures thus reducing the
overall period of construction.
After the pier and pier caps constructed, the girders may be transported at site and
erected in position using a suitable crane or incremental launching method in case
number of span are more.
Spans varying from 25m to 45m are feasible.
The whole operation of lifting and positioning of all the girders for a particular span
can completed in a short span of time.
Deck slab can be concreted cast-in-situ by supporting the shuttering directly from
the pre- cast girders.
Cost towards staging and shuttering reduces substantially. However, the post-
tensioned girders has the following disadvantages-
Girder length are fixed and cannot adjusted at site even during execution of works
some adjustments are necessary.
Use of Pre-cast girders is not feasible for curved super-structures with sharp radius.
Specialized contractors are required for the construction of pre-stressed bridges.
Advantages
Fabrication of structure may be done in workshop and assembly in site, to achieve
fast progress of work.
Dismantling of the superstructure is easy.
Deck Slab shall be casted over steel girders
Disadvantages
Steel Fabrication must be at RDSO approved workshop, may not be available at the
project site.
Rail blocks required at the time of erection.
Grade Separators
In this project Grade, separated structures shall envisage like Flyover, VUP, PUP, ROB etc.
The requirement of grade separator, its shape , size, type and configuration at any location is
decided by collecting sufficient relevant data and information and analyzing it with respect to
volume, intensity and type of traffic, loadings, climatic conditions and geo-technical
investigations, space restraints and limitations because of underground and overhead utilities
services and available geometrics, traffic regulation during construction etc.
Sub-Structure
Piers shall be avoided in the mid-stream where velocity of water is high. Piers shall
place normal to the flow direction.
Circular/cellular circular/wall type piers with semicircular ends shall use after considering the
aesthetics and economy. Circular piers shall be preferred in high seismic zone areas as they
have the same stiffness in all the directions.
Solid wall type abutments/counter fort type abutments shall selected based on the height.
Counter fort type abutments shall generally provide if height of the abutments is more than
12.0metres.
Sl. Stretches
Length (m) Side Remarks
No. From From
1 134+881 135+181 300 Both Side
2 135+231 135+531 300 Both Side
3 137+762 138+278 516.07 RHS --
4 138+285 138+682 396.93 RHS --
5 141+995 142+501 505.33 RHS --
6 142+513 142+835 322.67 RHS --
7 146+163 146+561 397.97 RHS --
8 146+573 146+943 370.03 RHS --
9 150+096 150+410 314.17 RHS --
10 150+417 150+656 238.83 RHS --
11 151+675 152+205 529.44 Both Side --
12 152+230 152+636 406.56 Both Side --
13 152+636 152+770 133.76 Both Side --
14 152+857 153+189 331.61 Both Side --
15 153+476 154+029 553.07 RHS --
16 154+041 154+575 533.93 RHS --
17 155+285 155+801 515.33 RHS
18 155+808 156+312 504.67 RHS
19 162+495 162+795 300 Both Side
20 162+825 163+125 300 Both Side
Sl. Stretches
Length (m) Side Remarks
No. From From
North - South Corridor
1 0+240 0+540 300 Both Side --
2 0+893 1+193 300 Both Side
To find out the actual needed linear waterway needed for any structure, there are two steps
to follow. First, to find out the actual discharge or flow that shall be flowing through the
structure. Through Hydrologic, studies contributing catchment area shall be delineated and
suitable methods as prescribed in IRC 5 and based on CWC reports and based on the
prescribed return period, tentative discharge shall calculated.
Hydraulic studies shall be carried out to ascertain the carrying capacity of new bridge or any
structure, based on the Manning’s method and topography of the upstream and downstream
levels and the design discharge calculated through Hydrologic calculations. Further based on
these calculations of linear waterway of bridges, scour calculations and design of protection
works shall be designed.
All efforts shall be made to find the discharge data of the river from government departments.
However if the above data is not available then rain fall data for relevant areas shall be
obtained and used for calculating the discharge. Catchments are delineated using contour
data obtained from SRTM 3 arc sec data using standard GIS platforms.
Following methods shall use for calculating discharge (Hydrology) for bridges-
Empirical Formulae for peak run-off from catchment as per IRC5
Rational Formulae for peak run-off from catchment
Hydrograph method using CWC reports
For Hydraulic design of the linear waterway needed, Manning’s method is adopted.
The flood discharge calculated from the above methods shall compared with each other and
the highest of these values shall be adopted as the design discharge Q, provided it does not
exceed the next highest discharge by more than 50 per cent. In case the difference is more
than 50 per cent then the design discharge shall be restricted to the limit of 50 per cent.
The length of the proposed bridge shall fix based on hydraulic studies and the length of old
bridge.
Longitudinal section of river for bridges shall take for a length of 300.0m up-stream and
300.0m on down-stream side from center line of proposed bridge location. The longitudinal
section shall use to calculate the slope of the stream.
Scour depth for foundations and protection works shall designed for a larger discharge in
order to give adequate factor of safety. The percentage increase in discharge based on
catchment area shall be as follows-
Rigid Apron
Curtain wall
Flexible Apron
Sub-soil Investigation
Detailed sub-soil investigations shall carried out at bridge locations which are to be
constructed One borehole at abutment location shall drilled
The sub-soil exploration and testing shall carried out through the sub-soil consultant. Sub-
soil investigation report shall be prepared as per IRC 78-2000.
Cost
Cost for structures shall worked out based on per sqm basis based on preliminary design
and drawings.
Concrete Grade
Grade of concrete in various elements shall be as under for moderate conditions of exposure:
Reinforcement Steel
High yield strength deformed bar shall be of grade Fe 500 D as per IS:1786-2008
Mild steel bars shall be of grade Fe 240 as per IS:1786-2008
Exposure Condition
Moderate exposure/Severe conditions shall be considered while designing various
components of all the structures depending on the location of road.
Concrete Clear Covers:
For all reinforcement - As per Cl. 14.3.2.1 of IRC 112
For prestress cable -As per clause 13. 4 of IRC: 112 duct to outer most Fibre of girder
Pre-Stressing System
b) Cables(Posttensioning) : 12T13/19K13cableswithstrandsof
12.7mmand
15.2 mm nominal dia.
Stressing shall be carried out simultaneously from both ends. All the strands of a cable shall
be stressed in one go. Provisions for 4% emergency cables will be provided. If they are not
utilised during construction, they will be pulled out and cable ducts will be grouted and
plugged suitably. Access to the super-structure shall be provided to enable maintenance,
inspection and future pre-stressing operations. Stressing may also be carried out at single
end also depends on the adaptability.
Structural Steel
Structural steel shall conform to IS: 2062:2011 also confirming to MORTH (Revision V)
structural steel of CL: 1900
Grade of steel shall be E 350, and yield stress 350 Mpa as per IS: 2062:2011 HFSG bolts of
Grade: 10.2 shall be used
Bearings
Elastomeric Bearings shall be proposed for spans up to 30m and the maximum vertical load
shall not be exceed as per IRC: 83, Part II-2105
POT, POT/PTFE bearing proposed for long span bride where maximum vertical load
moments envisaged. Spherical bearings also proposed for long span simply supported
superstructures or continuous superstructures where huge horizontal forces and uplift forces
encountered.
These bearings designed and supplied by the approved manufacturers as listed in the
MORTH empanelment. The loads and forces on the bearings shall be calculated to enable
the manufacturer to design these bearings and these shall conform to MOST CL: 2000
Specifications for Road & Bridge Works (5thRevision).
Expansion Joints
The following types of Expansion Joints shall be adopted as per IRC: SP: 69-2011:
Filler type expansion joints shall be proposed for minor bridges with solid slab
superstructures having span lengths not exceeding 10 metres. These type of joints shall
conform to Cl. 2609 of MOST Specifications for Road & Bridge Works (5th Revision).
Single Strip seal expansion joints shall be proposed for superstructures having
Modular strip seal expansion joints shall be proposed for continuous superstructures where
anticipated movements are more than 80mm. Cl. 2606 of MORTH
Specifications.(5thRevision).
The strip seal and modular strip seal joints shall conform to Cl. 2607 of MOST Specifications
for Road and Bridge works (5thRevision).
Miscellaneous
An asphaltic concrete wearing course provided over the deck slab. It shall consist of a coat of
mastic asphalt 6mm thick with a prime coat over the deck before the wearing course laid. The
insulating layer of 6mm thick mastic asphalt with 75% limestone dust filler and 25% of 30/40
penetration grade bitumen laid at 375 F. Two layers of 25mm each of asphaltic concrete laid
over the mastic asphalt.
Drainage spouts with gratings at the top provided on the bridges to ensure proper drainage of
surface water.
An approach slab 3.50m long and 300mm thick resting on the bracket taken out from the dirt
wall provided on both sides of the bridge resting on the 150mm thick leveling course. The
gap between the approach slab and dirt wall filled with bituminous joint filer sealing
compound.
Weep holes shall be provided behind abutment and wing wall to avoid building up of
hydrostatic pressure behind them. Weep holes provided 150mm, above the low water level or
bed level whichever is higher.
Dead Loads
Following unit weights shall be assumed in the design as per IRC Codes.
All the new cross drainage structures shall be designed for the following loading for carriage
way width 9.6 to 13.1m
Live Loads for 3-lanes :One/Two lanes/Three lanes of IRC Class A. 70R + CL-A
(Whichever produces worst effect) or One lane of IRC Class 70R (wheeled/
tracked)+One lane of Class A.
The impact factor shall be as per Cl. 208 of IRC: 6-2014 for the relevant load combinations.
For simplicity in design, the impact factor for continuous structures shall be calculated for the
smallest span of each module and used for all the spans in that module.
Longitudinal Forces
The following effects shall be considered for calculating the longitudinal forces in the design-
Braking forces as per the provision of Cl. 211 of IRC:6.
Frictional resistance offered to the movement of free bearings due to change of
temperature.
Distribution of longitudinal forces due to horizontal deformation of bearings/ frictional
resistance shall be carried out as per Cl. 211.5 of IRC: 6 by assuming stiff supports.
Centrifugal Forces
Bridges on a horizontal curve designed for centrifugal forces based on the following equation-
(CL: 212.2 of IRC: 6-2017)
C = WV2/127R,
Where C = Centrifugal force acting normal to the traffic W = Carriageway live load
V = Design speed of the vehicles using the bridge in km per hour R = Radius of curvature in
meters
The centrifugal force considered to act at 1.20m above the formation level of the bridge in the
transverse direction. No impact value on carriageway live load shall be considered for
calculating the centrifugal force.
WATER CURRENT FORCES
The effect of water current forces calculated in accordance with clause number 210 of IRC:
6- 2017 on sub-structure and foundations. High Flood level and Velocity calculated based on
the details received from relevant Government departments or local inquiries.
Impact Forces
All the sub-structure and foundations in the river shall be designed for the impact due to
striking of rolling boulders on the sub-structure in mountainous terrain. The magnitude of
force shall be decided based on field studies and in consultation with client.
Earth Pressure
Horizontal forces due to earth pressure shall be calculated as per the provision of Cl. 214 of
IRC: 6-2017 assuming the following soil properties:
Type of soil assumed for backfilling :Dry Density of 1.80 t/cum and Submerged
Density of 1.2 t/cum
Angle of Internal Friction :
Angle of Wall Friction :
Live load surcharge shall be considered as equivalent to 1.2m height of earth fill in case of
abutments and return/wing walls.
The pressure exerted by earth fill will act at 0.42m from the base as per the Coloumb’s
theory.
Wind Forces
Structures shall be designed for wind effects as stipulated as Cl. 209 of the IRC: 6.
The longitudinal and transverse wind forces shall be considered for plain terrain or terrain
with obstructions as per the Table 5 of IRC: 6-2017
The wind pressures generated in the table for a basic wind speed of 33 m/s
Seismic Effect
The seismic forces are calculated as per cl. No 219 of IRC: 6-2017
Different zone factors are to be considered depending on the project roads falls in various
seismic zones as the project lies in different states.
Feq = Ah x (Dead Load + Appropriate Live Load)
Where, Ah = horizontal seismic coefficient = (Z/2) x (Sa/g)/(R/I) Z = Zone factor and is equal
to 0.10 for seismic zone II
I = Important factor
R = Response reduction factor
Sa/g = Average response acceleration coefficient depending upon fundamental period of
vibration
T = Fundamental period of the bridge in seconds in horizontal vibrations
In zone IV and V to prevent the dislodgement of superstructure, “reaction blocks” (additional
safety measures in the event of failure of bearings) or other types of seismic arresters shall
be provided and designed for the seismic force.
Temperature Range
The temperature forces are calculated as per the cl.no.215.1 of IRC: 6-2017
The bridge structure/components i.e. bearings and expansion joints, shall be designed for a
temperature variation of +
The super-structures shall be designed for effects of distribution of temperature across the
deck depth as per stipulations of BD 37/88 suitably modified for the surfacing thickness.
Effect of non-linear distribution of temperature across the deck depth causes additional tension
and compression in the structure. It happens due to the difference in temperature at top and
bottom of super-structure. This cause seigen-stress in the structure. In this case the supports
do not offer any restrain to the hogging or sagging of beam. The effect of eigen stresses shall
be considered for all the proposed bridges. In case of continuous structures there will be
effect of intermediate supports which gives restrain to the free hogging and sagging of
structure. The intermediate support prevents the beams to freely hog or sag, which causes
continuity stresses .The effect of continuity stresses shall be considered for continuous
bridges.
A minimum reinforcement of 0.2% of cross sectional area in the longitudinal direction of the
cast- in-situ slab provided to cater for differential shrinkage stresses in superstructures with
in-situ slab over pre-cast girders.
However, effects due to differential shrinkage and/or differential creep shall be duly
accounted for in the design.
A uniformly distributed load of 3.6 KN/m2 of the form area taken into account of construction
stage loadings in the design of superstructure elements, wherever applicable, as per Cl. 4.2.2
of IRC: 87-1984.
The design shall take into account the temporary and locked-in-forces, adjusted by creep
effects, resulting from various methods of construction adopted. These forces will include
those arriving from each stage of construction.
Differential settlement effects for continuous superstructure units appropriately assessed for
each structure. However, in any case a minimum
accounted for in the design.
The differential settlement effects in continuous superstructures accounted for under
following conditions:
A minimum of 12mm differential settlement of supports with half value of `E’
To simulate the bearing replacement conditions, a 12mm differential uplift with full
value of
`E’ shall be considered but without any live load on the superstructure.
Buoyancy
Load Combination
All members shall be designed to safely sustain the most critical combination of various loads
and forces that can coexist. Various load combinations as relevant with increase in
permissible stresses considered in the design shall be as per IRC: 6 and IRC:78
The various load combinations are considered as per annexure B of IRC: 6-2017 as
mentioned below.
Structural Proposal
Major Bridges
Minor Bridges
Following locations has been proposed for minor bridges
Total Length
Sr. Design Span
Type (F/F of Dirt Wall)
No. Chainage arrangement
(m)
1 Minor Bridge 135+867 2 X 18 36.0
2 Minor Bridge 136+117 2 X 16 32.0
3 Minor Bridge 139+037 2 X 18 36.0
4 Minor Bridge 140+927 2 x 22.5 45.0
5 Minor Bridge 142+977 2 X 20 40.0
6 Minor Bridge 153+207 2 X 18 36.0
ROB
Following locations has been proposed for ROB
Culverts
Span
Sr. No Chainage Type of structure Arrangement Width Remarks
1 135+247 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 38.2 New Construction
2 135+317 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 38.2 New Construction
3 135+457 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 38.2 New Construction
4 136+637 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 13 New Construction
5 136+897 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 13 New Construction
6 137+027 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 13 New Construction
7 137+191 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
8 137+499 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
9 137+717 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 13 New Construction
10 138+197 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 38.2 New Construction
11 138+745 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
12 138+885 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
13 139+479 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
14 139+637 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
15 140+034 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
16 140+584 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
17 140+712 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
18 141+418 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
19 141+817 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 13 New Construction
20 142+317 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 38.2 New Construction
21 143+567 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 13 New Construction
22 143+588 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
23 143+938 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
24 144+370 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 13 New Construction
25 144+512 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
26 144+810 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
27 144+821 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
28 145+017 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 13 New Construction
29 145+277 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 13 New Construction
Span
Sr. No Chainage Type of structure Arrangement Width Remarks
30 145+696 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
31 147+097 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 13 New Construction
32 147+511 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
33 148+017 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 13 New Construction
34 148+320 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
35 149+395 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
36 149+417 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
37 150+307 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 38.2 New Construction
38 150+867 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 13 New Construction
39 151+317 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 13 New Construction
40 151+797 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 38.2 New Construction
41 152+100 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 38.2 New Construction
42 152+932 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 28 New Construction
43 153+615 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 38.2 New Construction
44 154+557 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 38.2 New Construction
45 155+019 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
46 155+111 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
47 155+517 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 38.2 New Construction
48 155+957 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 38.2 New Construction
49 156+116 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 38.2 New Construction
50 156+571 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
51 156+977 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
52 157+010 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
53 158+120 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
54 158+222 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
55 158+446 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
56 158+728 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
57 158+946 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 13 New Construction
58 159+111 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
59 159+520 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
60 160+124 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
Span
Sr. No Chainage Type of structure Arrangement Width Remarks
61 160+387 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 13 New Construction
62 160+637 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
63 161+037 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
64 161+190 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
65 161+989 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
66 162+149 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 13 New Construction
67 162+712 Box Culvert 1 X3X3 38.2 New Construction
68 162+867 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 38.2 New Construction
69 163+037 Box Culvert 1 X2X2 38.2 New Construction
CHAPTER 7
TRAFFIC STUDIES REPORT
7.1 GENERAL
The basic objective of project is to carry out traffic studies and data analysis to arrive at
meaningful conclusions about the traffic, trip and travel characteristics and forecast the traffic
in horizon years along the project road.
7.3 DELIVERABLES
Traffic report for the project, which includes study area characteristics, data analysis and
interpretation of results as well as projection of traffic into Horizon year along the project road.
7.4 RECONNAISSANCE
The consultants have carried out reconnaissance of the study area to have a first-hand
understanding of the project road situation, to subjectively assess the traffic characteristics
along the project road as well as review the potentials and constraints for traffic diversion
along of project road. The Project Influence Area (PIA) was delineated. The reconnaissance
survey also helped selection of the survey locations in the Project Influence Area.
Road Maps of National and State Highways as well as Major District Roads
Economic Database of State, District and Project area
Time series Vehicle Registration Data for Gujarat
Fuel sale Data on sample basis from Petroleum Planning and Analysis Cell (PPAC)
Classified traffic counts were carried out for a period of 7 consecutive days at 5mid-block
locations along project road. The surveys were carried out computer operated Pneumatic
Cable by trained operator. The data has been imported from computer on specific format and
further the consultant has organise the imported data in to excel format to analysis of traffic
volume. The data analysis has been carried out including Average Daily Traffic (ADT), Day
wise Variation of Traffic, Traffic Composition, Hourly Variation of Traffic etc. The Survey
locations are presented in Table 7.1.
These surveys were carried out on sample basis by trained enumerators for a period of 24
hours at three locations. The vehicles were stopped on random sample basis with police help
and the drivers were asked about their trip and travel characteristic on a pre-designed survey
format. The vehicles selected were Light Commercial Vehicles (LCV) Medium Commercial
Vehicles (MCV) or trucks and Heavy Commercial Vehicles (HCV) having more than 2 Axle
among the goods vehicles, while the passenger vehicles included Car, Buses and Mini Bus.
The survey locations are tabulated below and presented in Table 7.1
Turning Movement Count Surveys were carried out at 15 selected locations for the period of
12 hours along the project road .The TMC survey was carried using manual method by
trained enumerators on predesigned format for 15 minutes interval. The survey locations are
tabulated below and presented in Figure 7.1.
The Axle Load Surveys were carried out at three locations for a period of 24 hours. The
Vehicles selected were light Commercial vehicles, Trucks and MAV’s i.e. vehicles having
more than 3 tones. A few samples of empty vehicles were also included in the survey
besides the loaded trucks. The left side wheels of stopped vehicles (front and rear) were
mounted on a weigh pad to note the wheel/dual assembly Load. This was multiplied by 2 to
calculate the Axle Load. Each Axle of the selected vehicle was considered and the Axle Load
spectrum was prepared at office. The survey locations are presented in Figure 7.1.
The details of primary surveys including locations and durations are presented in Table 7.1.
The classified traffic volume counts were carried out for a period of 7 consecutive days at 3
mid-block location along project road by computerized Pneumatic Cable method (ATCC) with
trained operators for 24 hours period using pre-designed excel format for hourly interval. The
data is recorded directional traffic along the road.
For the analysis of traffic counts carried out at intersection and mid-block location along the
project corridor, the PCU values adopted are presented in Table 7-2.
TABLE 7-2: PASSENGER CAR UNITS FOR THE PROJECT AS PER IRC 64-1990
The analysis shows that the Average Daily Traffic (ADT) along project road is varying from about
3,935 PCU’s to 7,817 PCU’s over entire day. Throughout the project road, the average traffic is
estimated that about 8,573 PCU’s over entire day. The details are presented in Table 7.3.
TABLE 7-3 TRAFFIC CHARACTERISTICS (ADT) AT MID BLOCK LOCATION
The directional distribution table shows that traffic is moving towards Sagar from Bhopal is higher than
the opposite direction .The details are presented in Table 7.4.
At TVC-01, the Average Daily Traffic is 11910 PCU’s while the seven days traffic varies from 10776 PCU’s
(Sunday) which is 10% below ADT to 13396 PCU’s (Saturday) which is about 12% higher than the Average
Day Traffic.
At TVC-02, the Average Daily Traffic is 9708 PCU’s while the seven days traffic varies from 8961 PCU’s
(Monday) which is 8% below ADT to 10535 PCU’s (Saturday) which is about 9% higher than the Average Day
Traffic.
At TVC-03, the Average Daily Traffic is 22105 PCU’s while the seven days traffic varies from 18086
PCU’s (Monday) which is 18% below ADT to 27073 PCU’s (Thursday) which is about 22% higher
than the Average Day Traffic. The details are presented in Table 7-5 and graphically presented in
Figure 7.3.
The traffic along the regional routes varies by day on account of the local factors like weekly
markets, land use, traffic regulations etc. or due to regional factors. Traffic demand on a peak
day may lead to excessive congestion and delays as the road infrastructure is unable to cope
with the demand. This trend was witnessed at most of the locations along which traffic counts
were carried for this project.
At TVC-01, the Average Daily Traffic is 11632 PCU’s while the seven days traffic varies from
9492 PCU’s (Saturday) which is 18% below ADT to 13194 PCU’s (Wednesday) which is
about 13% higher than the Average Day Traffic.
At TVC-02, the Average Daily Traffic is 10977 PCU’s while the seven days traffic varies from
9852 PCU’s (Monday) which is 10% below ADT to 13163 PCU’s (Wednesday) which is about
20% higher than the Average Day Traffic.
At TVC-03, the Average Daily Traffic is 7673 PCU’s while the seven days traffic varies from
6344 PCU’s (Thursday) which is 17% below ADT to 8493PCU’s (Friday) which is about 11%
higher than the Average Day Traffic.
At TVC-04, the Average Daily Traffic is 6039 PCU’s while the seven days traffic varies from
5057 PCU’s (Friday) which is 16% below ADT to 7225 PCU’s (Sunday) which is about 20%
higher than the Average Day Traffic.
At TVC-05, the Average Daily Traffic is 6544 PCU’s while the seven days traffic varies from
5838 PCU’s (Wednesday) which is 11% below ADT to 7439 PCU’s (Tuesday) which is about
14% higher than the Average Day Traffic.
The details are presented in Table 7.5 and graphically presented in Figure 7.3.
TVC-04 (Near
TVC-05 (Near Sihora
Days Date Day Bahadurpur) Date Day
Vehicles PCU Vehicles PCU
1 2-Sep-18 Sunday 4583 7225 3-Sep-18 Monday 4802 6100
2 3-Sep-18 Monday 4224 5992 4-Sep-18 Tuesday 4946 7439
3 4-Sep-18 Tuesday 4741 6975 5-Sep-18 Wednesday 3926 5838
4 5-Sep-18 Wednesday 3998 6341 6-Sep-18 Thursday 4218 6615
5 6-Sep-18 Thursday 3182 5306 7-Sep-18 Friday 3677 5986
6 7-Sep-18 Friday 2976 5057 8-Sep-18 Saturday 4257 6799
7 8-Sep-18 Saturday 3841 5376 9-Sep-18 Sunday 5281 7035
Average 3935 6039 Average 4444 6544
Standard Deviation 265 652 Standard Deviation 552 859
Source: Traffic Survey, September 2018
Light Fast Car/ Van/ Jeep/ Taxi 2720 2609 2164 2783 2501 2010 2012 2400
Passenger 3-Wheeler 123 139 97 98 181 210 141 141
Vehicles 2-Wheeler 3153 3097 2125 1795 1551 2070 2926 2388
LCV 457 953 646 857 537 294 308 579
Goods 2-Axle Truck 402 505 505 514 462 280 239 415
Commercial
Vehicles 3-Axle Truck 181 247 251 226 204 198 144 207
MAV 791 781 556 587 494 683 724 659
Agricultural
Tractor 62 84 47 63 76 60 50 63
Vehicles
Other Other 333 395 330 373 337 381 286 348
Total Vehicles 8400 8972 6915 7466 6501 6381 7020 7379
Total PCU 11914 13163 10561 11513 9950 9890 9852 10977
Source: Traffic Survey, September 2018
Light Fast Car/ Van/ Jeep/ Taxi 1772 1802 1698 1748 1783 2125 2192 1874
Passenger 3-Wheeler 184 196 177 142 140 179 153 167
Vehicles 2-Wheeler 2392 2302 1315 2669 2264 1882 2763 2227
LCV Freight 296 322 274 324 243 237 203 271
Goods 2-Axle Truck 153 165 163 176 153 154 132 157
Commercial
Vehicles 3-Axle Truck 191 205 179 251 172 137 125 180
MAV 496 550 366 560 467 394 472 472
Agricultural
Tractor 21 16 22 35 26 19 20 23
Vehicles
Other Other 206 205 132 189 191 204 225 193
Total Vehicles 5883 5944 4463 6251 5611 5492 6430 5725
Total PCU 7883 8285 6344 8493 7500 7253 7951 7673
Source: Traffic Survey, September 2018
The analysis shows that the share of peak hour traffic at the mid-block locations is varying
from 5% to 7% during both peak hour. The details are presented in Table 7.11
The hourly variation of traffic count shows the pattern of traffic flow during the survey period.
The morning peak hour time is varying from 0900 AM to 1200 AM and evening peak hour
time is varying from 1700 PM to 1800 PM. The hourly variation of traffic at mid-block location
is graphically presented in Figure 7.2.
Traffic during different months of the year is not likely to be the same. During the harvest
season, there is a significant goods vehicle movement, during school holidays and during
festival season there is lots of personal vehicle movement. In order to obtain an accurate
estimate of the variations and taking care of data collection costs, it is essential that this
phenomenon is captured in the traffic study. This manifest in a metric called Annual Average
Daily Traffic (AADT).
Traffic engineers estimate the seasonal impacts by using a factor called as the “Seasonal
Correction Factor (SCF)”.The seasonal correction factor is generally derived from secondary
data sources such as historical month-wise traffic data on the project road, monthly toll
revenues from existing tolled highways in the immediate influence area, for this study. This is
done by the estimation of Seasonal Correction Factor using month wise consumptions over 9
years. The data have taken from Petroleum Planning and Analysis Cell (PPAC) for estimation
of Seasonal correction Factor (SCF).The fuel consumption data and estimated SCF is
presented in Table 7.12 and Table 7.13 and accordingly estimated Annual Average Daily
Traffic (AADT) is presented in Table 7.14 & 7.15
YR 2008-09 YR 2009-10 YR 2010-11 YR 2011-12 YR 2012-13 YR 2013-14 YR 2014-15 YR 2015-16 YR 2016-17 Average
MONTH
MS HSD MS HSD MS HSD MS HSD MS HSD MS HSD MS HSD MS HSD MS HSD MS HSD
APRIL 0.99 0.96 1.05 0.99 1.06 0.93 1.04 0.99 1.05 0.97 1.12 0.93 1.06 0.98 1.02 0.96 0.99 0.94 1.04 0.96
MAY 0.89 0.9 0.97 0.98 0.95 0.95 0.92 0.92 1.02 0.9 0.84 0.89 0.94 0.89 0.99 0.97 0.95 0.91 0.94 0.92
JUNE 1.17 1.06 0.97 0.96 0.95 0.96 1 1.01 0.98 0.95 1.01 0.96 0.99 0.94 1.03 0.99 1.07 0.99 1.02 0.98
JULY 1.03 1.06 1.06 1.04 1.02 1.03 1.03 1.06 1 1 1.02 1.06 1.07 1.01 1.09 1.09 1.03 1.09 1.04 1.05
AUGUST 1.05 1.19 1.02 1.12 1.01 1.16 1.02 1.18 1 1.14 0.96 1.13 0.99 1.13 1.03 1.15 0.9 1.03 1 1.14
SEPTEMBER 1.04 1.09 1.03 1.14 1.05 1.19 1.04 1.17 1.07 1.17 1.16 1.16 1.06 1.18 0.97 1.06 1.09 1.22 1.06 1.15
OCTOBER 1 1.02 0.96 0.98 1 1.01 1 1.01 0.99 1.01 0.98 1.01 0.98 1.06 0.98 0.98 0.94 0.95 0.98 1
NOVEMBER 1.03 0.96 1.05 0.99 0.99 1.02 1.07 0.95 0.99 0.99 0.98 0.98 1.05 0.96 1.03 1.02 0.98 0.94 1.02 0.98
DECEMBER 1.01 0.97 0.97 0.93 0.98 0.91 0.93 0.92 0.97 0.94 0.98 0.95 0.98 0.94 1 0.96 1.01 0.96 0.98 0.94
JANUARY 0.97 0.97 1.02 1 1.04 1 1.07 1 1.01 0.99 1.03 1.01 0.98 0.99 1 0.99 1.1 1.09 1.02 1.01
FEBRUARY 0.99 1 1 1.01 1.04 1.02 1.02 0.98 1.03 1.07 1.04 1.06 0.98 1 0.99 0.97 1.04 1.03 1.01 1.02
MARCH 0.89 0.9 0.92 0.91 0.93 0.91 0.88 0.89 0.91 0.93 0.96 0.94 0.94 0.98 0.89 0.92 0.94 0.93 0.92 0.92
The consultant has estimated the SCF for project road based on the fuel sale data for diesel
and petrol propelled vehicles. For the estimation of Annual Average Daily Traffic (AADT), the
Seasonal Correction Factor (SCF) is used for the month of July.
The consultant have estimated the SCF for each of the TVC locations based on fuel
consumption data collected from the PPAC report and accordingly the estimated SCF is 1.06 for
petrol propelled vehicles and 1.15 for diesel propelled vehicles. The SCF for Non-motorized
vehicles are considered as 1.0.
Interpretation of SCF: Based on data collected from fuel consumption data provided by
PPAC, which have used to estimate SCF along the project road, the estimated seasonal
correction factor is more than 1.0. This means that the fuel sale in the respective month was
lower than the average monthly sale (if the SCF is lesser than 1.0, the fuel sale in the respective
month was higher than the average monthly sale and accordingly the number of vehicles has to
be increased if SCF is greater than 1.0 and number of vehicles will be decreased if the SCF is
lesser than 1.0)
The Annual Average Daily Traffic (AADT) will be estimated by separately multiplying the
Average Day Traffic of Diesel propelled vehicles by SCF estimated for diesel propelled vehicles
and Petrol propelled vehicle separately.
The Average Daily Traffic (ADT) has been presented in Table 7.14 while the Estimated Annual
Average Daily Traffic (AADT) is presented in Table.7.14. The toll able and non-toll able traffic
along project road at each homogenous section are presented in Table 7.15
The vehicles were stopped on random sampling basis to avoid any bias in collected
data. The sample size varied across modes depending on the police support, traffic
volumes and site condition. These sample size achieved for passenger and goods
vehicles is presented in Table 7.16.
OD-01
Mode OD-02 Gyaraspur OD-03 Sihora
Dewanganj
Car/Van/ Jeep 7% 16% 12%
Bus 58% 74% 59%
LCV 19% 21% 23%
2 Axle Truck 54% 89% 72%
3 Axle Truck 97% 61% 96%
MAV 27% 36% 53%
Overall 22% 27% 32%
Source: Field Surveys, August-September 2018
The consultant has prepared zoning scheme for spatially analyzing the trip
characteristics of passenger and goods vehicles. The project road starts from Bhopal
(Bhopal District) in Madhya Pradesh and it meets at Sagar (Sagar District) via Vidisha.
Bhopal, Vidisha , Raisen and Sagar districts are considered Immediate Influence
Districts for the project road. The zoning scheme has been formed out based on
administrative boundary (i.e Tehsil, Districts and States). Further the consultant has
prepared small zones along or around project road within the Immediate Influencing
District based on manmade and physical barriers (Rail, Roads, Nallah and Rivers) for
meaningful results. The consultant have considered 15zones (Zone No. 1 to 15) as
internal zones and remaining 14zones are considered as an external zones.
The zoning scheme is presented in Table 7.17 and graphically presented in Figure 7.3
The trips are distributed into four categories, Internal-Internal (I-I) trips (within the influence area of
project road), Internal-External IE - Trips (Study area to Outside), External-Internal – EI Trips
(Outside to Study Area) and External-External- Trips EE (Through traffic). The total 15 zones (Zone
No. 1-15) have been considered as Internal Zone and remaining 14 zones considered as external
zones.
The results of trips characteristics shows that the bypassing trips are varying from 3% to 13% while
the share of internal-internal traffic zones are varying from 56% to 84% while the share of trips which
are either originates or terminates within the project influence area (along project road) is varying
from 12% to 32% of the total traffic .The details are presented in Table 7.18
The results of trips characteristic shows that the share of bypassing trips are varying from
15% to 32% while the share of internal – internal traffic is insignificant. The share of trips
which originates or terminates within project influence area is varying from 32% to 40% of
the total traffic. The details are presented in Table 7.19
The trip characteristics of passenger and goods vehicles are graphically presented in Figure 7.4.to
Figure 7.6
From the OD Matrix, Zone Influence Factor, which explains the relative contributions of various
zones to trip generation along the project road have been estimated. The Zone Influence Factor is
estimated as follows.
ZIFi = Oi + Di
2∑i= 1, n, j= 1Tij
Where,
The results shows that the most of the trips are playing along the project road and more than two
third of total trips performing in Gujarat and Rajasthan only. The Zone Influence Factor for
passenger and goods vehicles at OD Locations are Presented in Table 7.20 to 7.22
TABLE 7-20 : ZONE INFLUENCE FACTOR AT OD-01(DEEWANGANJ)
2-Axle 3-Axle
Zones Car Bus LCV MAV
Truck Truck
Project Influence
80% 90% 88% 63% 57% 63%
District
Rest of Madhya
15% 10% 8% 28% 29% 22%
Pradesh
Rest of India 5% 0% 4% 10% 14% 15%
Total 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Source: Traffic Surveys, August-September 2018
2-Axle 3-Axle
Zones Car Bus LCV MAV
Truck Truck
Project Influence
71% 74% 84% 55% 38% 37%
District
Rest of Madhya
19% 19% 7% 35% 45% 39%
Pradesh
Rest of India 10% 7% 9% 10% 17% 24%
Total 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Source: Traffic Surveys, August-September 2018
2-Axle 3-Axle
Zones Car Bus LCV MAV
Truck Truck
Project Influence
91% 89% 59% 54% 66% 55%
District
Rest of Madhya
4% 11% 29% 7% 23% 32%
Pradesh
Rest of India 6% 0% 12% 3% 10% 13%
Total 100% 100% 100% 64% 100% 100%
Source: Traffic Surveys, August-September 2018
The analysis shows that the share of work trips is 38% followed by education trips 12% and
12% other purpose of trips. The share of business trips and home based trips are20% and
18% respectively. The details are presented in Table 7.23 and graphically presented in
Figure 7.7
The analysis of travel frequency of passenger vehicles shows that the share of daily and
weekly trips is highest (68%) among all trip frequency groups. The share of monthly trips
constitutes 22% and 10% occasionally of total trips. The details are presented in Table 7.24
and graphically presented in Figure 7.8
The analysis of trip lengths of passenger vehicles shows that the weighted average trip
length for car varies from 178 kms to 435 kms .The weight age average trip length for all
passenger modes is varying from 166 Kms to 437 Kms. The details are presented in Table
7.25 and bar chart is presented in Figure 7.9
TABLE 7-25: WEIGHT AVERAGE TRIP LENGTH FOR PASSENGER VEHICLES (KMS.)
The analysis of goods trips show that Food grains are 28% of total laden weight carried by
trucks and these are the major commodity groups that are being transported and about 35%
of truck trips are moving without payload. The share of petroleum products carrying trucks
are 9% of total loaded truck traffic. The share of other commodities is varying from 1% to
7%. The details are presented in Table 7.26 and a graphic representation of the
commodities distribution is presented in Figure 7.10.
OD-02
OD-01 Dewanganj OD-03 Sihora All Locations
Gyaraspur
Commodity Type
No. of No. of No. of No. of
% age % age % age % age
Trips Trips Trips Trips
Food grains and other agricultural products (Rice,
wheat, pulses, maize, chilly, coconut,sugarcane, 132 17% 138 29% 126 20% 396 21%
sugar, cotton, coffee, tea, eggs etc.)
Fruits, vegetables - perishables 46 6% 48 10% 41 7% 135 7%
Wood and Forest Products 12 2% 10 2% 2 0% 24 1%
Petroleum, oil, Gas and lubricants product 77 10% 48 10% 46 7% 171 9%
Minerals, chemicals, fertilizer 10 1% 3 1% 3 0% 16 1%
Iron , Metal and steel 19 2% 32 7% 26 4% 77 4%
Finished and manufactured products (Vehicles,
Products of machinery, rubber, electric & 49 6% 59 12% 24 4% 132 7%
electronics, textile, automobile, glass, plastic etc.)
Parcel Service & Containers 28 4% 6 1% 6 1% 40 2%
Medicines 10 1% 10 2% 4 1% 24 1%
Building materials (Brick, Tiles, Mud and Blocks ) 29 4% 13 3% 21 3% 63 3%
Mining (Sand, Bajri and Coarse Aggregate) 5 1% 3 1% 2 0% 10 1%
Cement 23 3% 30 6% 20 3% 73 4%
Marble, stone 0 0% 1 0% 0 0% 1 0%
Textiles & Fibre 11 1% 7 1% 21 3% 39 2%
Miscellaneous goods ( Livestock, Waste, paper etc) 8 1% 4 1% 8 1% 20 1%
Empty vehicles 314 41% 65 14% 276 44% 655 35%
Total 773 100% 477 100% 626 100% 1876 100%
Source: Field Surveys, August-September 2018
The analysis of travel frequency of Goods vehicles shows that the share of daily trips
constitutes highest (40%) group followed by Other Trip frequency group. The details are
presented in Table 7.27 and graphically presented in Figure 7.11..
OD-01 OD-02
OD-03 Sihora All Locations
Dewanganj Gyaraspur
Frequency
No. of No. of No. of No. of
% age % age % age % age
Trips Trips Trips Trips
Daily 276 36% 235 49% 244 39% 755 40%
Weekly 236 31% 109 23% 196 31% 541 29%
Monthly 173 22% 92 19% 116 19% 381 20%
Occasionally 88 11% 41 9% 70 11% 199 11%
Total 773 100% 477 100% 626 100% 1876 100%
Source: Field Surveys, August-September 2018
The analysis of trip length of goods vehicles shows that the average trip length for goods
vehicles are varying from 345 Kms to 461 Kms for all locations. The details are
presented in Table 7.28 and graphic for distribution of weighted average trip length of
goods vehicles is presented in Figure 7.12.
TABLE 7-28: WEIGHTED AVERAGE TRIP LENGTH FOR GOODS VEHICLES (IN KMS.)
The Axle Load surveys were carried out at three locations at Near Deewanganj Village,
Near Gyaraspur and Near Sihora Village for continuous one day (24 Hours) to
appreciate the loading characteristics of goods vehicles. The damage potential of these
vehicles have been estimated using a metric called Vehicle Damage Factor (VDF).
The consultant has carried out axle load survey on sample basis at three locations along
project road. The samples were taken randomly for goods vehicles (LCV, Truck, and
MAV’s). The estimated sample size achieved at the three survey locations is presented
in Table 7.29 to Table 7.31.The overall sample size achieved at three survey locations
are varying from 18% to 28%.
The consultant has estimated Vehicle Damage Factor (VDF) using equivalence factor for
different types of commercial vehicles as per IRC: 37-2012 “Design of Flexible Pavement”. The
analysis result shows that the weighted average VDF is 5.40, 6.66 and 6.80 for Near
Deewanganj, Gyaraspur Village and Sihora Village respectively. The details are presented in
Table 7.32 to Table 7.34.
7.12.1 APPROACH
Traffic growth on a road facility is generally estimated on the basis of historical trends.
Demand changes are usually due to shifts in the pattern of economic activities in the
surrounding regions. Hence, future traffic estimation necessitates a preview, however
imprecise, of the probable pattern of future growth of the economy. Growth of traffic on
the project road depends on existing development and future growth prospects of the
connecting regions. The time series data of state income at constant prices (2011-2012
base) i.e. the NSDP (by industry of origin) for the state of Madhya Pradesh, published by
Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has been studied to assess the past performance of
influencing state economies.
.
7.13 METHODOLOGY FOR TRAFFIC GROWTH RATE ESTIMATION
The exercise of traffic growth rate estimation has been carried out by the consultants
using the elasticity approach. The elasticity method mathematically relates traffic growth
to changes in the related economic parameters. According to IRC-108, 2015, elasticity
based econometric model for highway projects could be derived in the following form:
Log e (P) = A0+A1 Log e (E.I.)
Where;
P = Traffic Volumes (Mode wise)
E.I. = Economic Indicator i.e. GDP, NSDP and PCI
A0 = Regression Constant
A1 = Regression Co-efficient (Elasticity Index)
Stage 1- At this stage the Time Series socio economic data has been collected
regarding vehicle registration, Per capita income, Net State Domestic Product; and
population of Gujarat and Rajasthan. Data has also been collected on trends in Gross
domestic Product (GDP) of country. These are categorized as dependent and
independent variables.
Stage 2 - After the completion of stage 1, the average mode wise growth rates of these
parameters has been calculated.
Stage 3 - Regressing the dependent variable with the independent variable will fetch
elasticity between socio-economic parameters and average mode wise growth rates.
This is done to make projections of traffic relatively more accurate and realistic.
Stage 4 –Multiplying mode wise elasticity with growth rate of respective socio-economic
parameters will yield mode wise growth rates
The consultants have collected past economic data from website of Reserve Bank of
India (RBI), Planning Commission, Directorate of Economics and Statistics.
The analysis of economic statistics shows that the average growth rate of GDP between
2011-12 and 2015-16 is 6.6 % while the NSDP and PCI growth rate for the same period
is 6.24% and 4.96% respectively. The details are presented in Table 7.35 to 7.36.
TABLE 7-35 : GDP GROWTH TREND OF INDIA (BASE YEAR 2011-12 AT CONSTANT
PRICES)
TABLE 7-36 : ECONOMIC INDICES OF GUJARAT AND RAJASTHAN (BASE YEAR 2011-
12 AT CONSTANT PRICES)
PCI
NSDP (Rs. Growth Growth
Years Growth % (NSDP) Population
Billion) % %
Rs.
Madhya Pradesh
2011-2012 28237104 - 38550 - 7.32 -
2012-2013 30685334 8.67% 41257 7.02% 7.44 1.54%
2013-2014 32259760 5.13% 42654 3.39% 7.56 1.69%
2014-2015 33940757 5.21% 44110 3.41% 7.69 1.74%
2015-2016 35966081 5.97% 46783 6.06% 7.69 0.09%
CAGR 6.24% 4.96% 1.22%
Source: Reserve Bank of India, 2015
For commercial vehicles, a model is developed for state of influence by logically relating
the growth of commercial vehicles with Net State Domestic Product (NSDP) in the
influence states. This is done in order to relate the growth at origin and destination of
commercial traffic in study corridor. The growth of commercial traffic at the national level
Project : Consultancy Services for preparation of DPR for
Development Of Economic Corridors, Inter Corridors and Feeder
Routes to Improve the efficiency of freight movement in India
Under Bharatmala Pariyojana (Package 3/Lot-4): Bhopal –Raisen – Vidisha – Sagar (Priority-1)Page 191
Report : Final Detailed Project Report
Date : September 2021
Volume: I – Main Report
has also been calculated by logically relating commercial vehicles population in country
to the Gross Domestic Product (GDP). The models developed for expressing the growth
of commercial vehicles at state level as well as at national level, R² values, elasticity
values and growth factors are derived.
In order, to estimate the elasticity of travel demand, the consultants have established
the relationship between the growths of registered vehicles and the economic variables.
This necessitates developing the regression equations to express dependent variable in
terms of one or more independent variables. In this case, the dependent variable is
registered vehicle, which is proxy variable for vehicle population Zone of Influence (State).
The independent variable are socio-economic parameters; For the passenger vehicle including
Cars, growth has been related to Per Capita Income and growth of buses are related to
population growth, while Commercial vehicles have been regressed with Economic parameters
like GDP of country and NSDP of the state, through which this road passes while the growth of
trucks are regressed with GDP and the growth of LCV’s is regressed with NSDP changes over
the analysis period.
Based on the regression analysis the consultants have estimated the elasticity of growth of
different modes. These results presented in Table 7.39
TABLE7-39 : RESULTS OF REGRESSION ANALYSIS
R Square -
Registered Vehicles Independent Coefficient of
Strength of
(Dependent Variable) Variable Elasticity (b)
relationship
Madhya Pradesh
Car PCI 2.87 0.99
Buses Population 3.02 0.89
Buses PCI 0.87 0.85
LCV NSDP 1.92 0.99
Trucks NSDP 1.50 0.93
2-W PCI 2.34 0.96
Source: Consultant Estimates
Vehicle registration data represents all vehicles registered in the state, but does not
indicate actual number of vehicles plying on the road owing to vehicles taken off the
road due to lack of fitness certificate. In order to arrive at realistic future elasticity’s for
the project road; various factors relating to vehicle technology changes besides
character of traffic and travel pattern on the project road have been considered.
The transport demand elasticity by vehicle type, over a period of time, tends to decline
and approach unity or even less. As the economy and its various sectors grow, every
region tends to become self-sufficient.
Moreover, much of the past growth has been associated with the country’s transition
from a largely rural subsistence economy to cash-based urban economy, dominated by
regional and national linkages. As the transition proceeds, its impact on transport pattern
can be expected to become less dominant. Therefore, the demand for different type of
vehicles falls, over time, despite greater economic development. In other words the
values of elasticity tend to decrease with economic development in future years due to
changes in the structure of economy, with higher contribution from service sector and
higher value of industrial outputs. The same is also clear from the relationships of the
economy and transport demand elasticity over time nationally/Internationally.
Based on past experience, the consultants have assumed that the elasticity values of
respective modes will reduce by 10% every 5 years. This means that as the growth
stabilizes, the rate of growth of registration of vehicles will reduce by 10% every 5 years.
The details are presented in Table 7.40
The Price water house Coopers (PWC), U.K, has projected annual global economic
growth to average around 3.5% over the next 4 years to 2020, slowing down to 2.7% for
2021-2030, 2.5% for the decade after that, and 2.4% for 2041-2050. This will occur as
many advanced economies experience a marked decline in their working-age
populations. At the same time, emerging market growth rates will moderate as these
economies mature, which is consistent with academic research on the tendency for
growth rates to ‘regress to the mean’ in the long-run. The projected growth profile for
larger economies is presented in Figure 7.13
In the case of India, the PWC has projected the GDP growth rate for year 2016-2020,
2021-2030, 2031-2040 and 2041-2050 is 7.8, 5.0, 4.4 and 3.9 respectively.
The consultant has projected based on trends of national economy and state economic
growth and the projected value has interpolated for the horizon year 2017-2022, 2022-
2027, 2027-2032 and beyond 2032 are 6.9, 6.6, 6.2 and 5.9 respectively.
Considering the present GDP growth and its future targets, a realistic growth rate of 6.9
% to 5.9 %for four period blocks has been assumed. The perspective economy growth
rates considered are presented in Table 7.41.
Elasticity for Different Modes x Economic Indicator (Average Growth Rate) = Mode wise
growth rate for Project Road
Mode wise Registered vehicle Average Growth Rate, Then, Weighted Traffic Growth
Rates = Average of a & b
The share of trucks trips from Madhya Pradesh is about 81% while the share of trucks trips from
rest of India is 19%. The consultant has estimated weighted average growth rate of trucks for the
project road using the share of trips which is analyzed from OD data.
Using the trip contribution within influencing states, the weight age traffic growth rate has
been estimated and presented in Table 7.43
The Traffic Growth Rate for project in Optimistic and Pessimistic situation is presented
in Table 7.44
TABLE 7-44 TRAFFIC GROWTH RATES FOR MOTORIZED VEHICLES (%) IN DIFFERENT
SCENARIOS
Normal Traffic: The normal traffic is the traffic at present which is likely plying on the
project road.
Generated/Induced Traffic: Induced traffic is the addition traffic that is generated when
the user costs associated with a road facility decreases. This decrease in cost may arise
from anything ranging from minor improvement like filling up of pot holes or patches to
major alterations such as widening of the road.
The phenomenon of latent demand or induced traffic has often been ascribed very less
importance in Indian Highway (rural roads) projects which are being extensively
upgraded by the National Highway Development Program (NHDP), since year 2000. The
Project : Consultancy Services for preparation of DPR for
Development Of Economic Corridors, Inter Corridors and Feeder
Routes to Improve the efficiency of freight movement in India
Under Bharatmala Pariyojana (Package 3/Lot-4): Bhopal –Raisen – Vidisha – Sagar (Priority-1)Page 197
Report : Final Detailed Project Report
Date : September 2021
Volume: I – Main Report
contribution of Induced traffic is very much relevant for Indian Rural road networks, as
improving the connectivity in rural areas is likely to generate traffic from adjacent land
use.
According to Cervero* (2003 a & b), the estimated long-term elasticity of Vehicle Miles
Travel (VMT) with respect to traffic speed to be 0.64. This means that a 10% increase in
speed results in a 6.4% increase in VMT. Another research developed by Holder and
Stover* (1972) found evidence of induced travel at six location in Texas over several
years, estimated to represent 5-12% of total corridor volume, representing from a quarter
to two-thirds of traffic on the facility.
The consultant has considered that induced traffic will add to the total traffic @5% in the
year 2022, after the project road becomes operational.
*Generated Traffic and Induced Travel (2014), Victoria Transport Policy Institute
TABLE 7-45 : TRAFFIC FORECAST ALONG PROJECT ROAD (NORMAL TRAFFIC + INDUCED) FOR TVC-01 (NEAR DEEWANGANJ)
TABLE 7-46 : TRAFFIC FORECAST ALONG PROJECT ROAD (NORMAL TRAFFIC + INDUCED) FOR TVC-02 (NEAR SANCHI)
TABLE 7-47 TRAFFIC FORECAST ALONG PROJECT ROAD (NORMAL TRAFFIC + INDUCED) FOR TVC-03 (NEAR GYARASPUR)
TABLE 7-48 TRAFFIC FORECAST ALONG PROJECT ROAD (NORMAL TRAFFIC + INDUCED) FOR TVC-04 (NEAR BAHADURPUR)
TABLE 7-49 : TRAFFIC FORECAST ALONG PROJECT ROAD (NORMAL TRAFFIC + INDUCED) FOR TVC-05 (NEAR SIHORA)
Normal Traffic Normal+Induced
Year Mini Auto Two
Bus Car LCV Truck MAV Tractor Other Veh. PCU Veh. PCU
Bus Rickshaw Wheeler
2018 107 94 1599 91 1443 370 582 328 25 186 4824 7245 4824 7245
2019 110 97 1776 99 1581 408 635 358 27 190 5280 7878 5280 7878
2020 113 99 1973 109 1731 451 692 391 30 193 5782 8571 5782 8571
2021 115 102 2192 119 1895 498 755 427 32 197 6333 9331 6333 9331
2022 118 104 2436 130 2076 550 824 465 35 201 6940 10164 7287 10672
2023 121 107 2697 142 2265 605 895 505 38 205 7580 11034 7959 11586
2024 124 109 2986 155 2471 665 972 549 41 209 8282 11985 8696 12584
2025 127 112 3305 169 2696 731 1055 596 45 213 9051 13023 9503 13674
2026 131 115 3659 184 2942 804 1145 647 49 218 9894 14158 10389 14866
2027 134 118 4051 201 3210 884 1244 702 53 222 10819 15398 11360 16168
2028 137 121 4471 219 3491 967 1344 759 57 227 11793 16693 12383 17528
2029 140 123 4934 238 3797 1059 1453 821 62 231 12859 18104 13502 19009
2030 144 126 5445 259 4130 1159 1571 887 67 236 14024 19640 14725 20622
2031 147 129 6010 282 4492 1268 1698 959 72 240 15297 21314 16062 22380
2032 151 133 6632 306 4885 1388 1836 1037 78 245 16691 23138 17525 24295
2033 154 136 7298 332 5298 1514 1977 1116 84 250 18159 25046 19067 26298
2034 158 139 8031 360 5745 1651 2129 1202 91 255 19760 27118 20748 28474
2035 161 142 8838 391 6230 1800 2292 1294 98 260 21507 29370 22582 30839
2036 165 146 9725 424 6756 1963 2468 1394 105 265 23412 31817 24582 33408
2037 169 149 10702 459 7327 2140 2658 1501 113 271 25490 34478 26764 36202
2038 173 152 11777 498 7945 2334 2863 1616 122 276 27757 37370 29145 39238
2039 177 156 12959 540 8616 2545 3083 1741 131 282 30231 40514 31742 42540
2040 181 160 14261 586 9344 2775 3320 1875 142 287 32930 43934 34576 46130
2041 186 163 15693 635 10133 3026 3575 2019 152 293 35876 47652 37669 50035
2042 190 167 17269 689 10989 3300 3850 2174 164 299 39090 51697 41045 54282
Source: Consultant Estimates
The consultant has carried out capacity analysis for the normal scenarios for the
project road on the basis of scenario analysis developed for projected traffic in
horizon year. The capacity figures mentioned in IRC standard stipulates that the
Design Service Volume of 2 lane road and 4 lane road are presented in Table 4 and
Item 11inIRC: 64-1990 “Guideline for Capacity of Roads in Rural Areas”. The
proposed project road is 4 lane road and the capacity figure adopted for four lane
from IRC: 64-1990.
The Design Service Volume and Capacity Standard based on IRC is presented in
Table 7.50.
Ultimate
Design Service Volume (PCU/Day)
Road Type Capacity
The consultant has carried out the capacity analysis for 4 lane road with paved shoulder.
The capacity analysis is presented in Table 7.51
To maintain level of service ‘B’ and free flow speed of highway, there would be a need of
widening of road from 4 lane to 6 lane. The above capacity analysis shows that, the need to
road widening from 4 lane to 6 lane will be required by year 2030, 2036, and 2038 for
section upto Sanchi, Bahadurpur and end point at Sagar respectively.
CHAPTER 8
ENVIRONMENT SCREENING AND PRELIMINARY ENVIRONMENTAL
ASSESSMENT
8.1 INTRODUCTION
The proposed project is a part of the Bharat Mala Project which has been envisaged as an
umbrella program under the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways. The project involves
constructions or improvement of national highways/ newly declared National Highways with
an aim to improve road connectivity to border areas, ports, backward areas, religious and
tourist sites. The proposed project is the construction of 4 lane highway and it is a part of an
exclusive transport corridor from Bhopal to Kanpur which provides better connectivity to
Bhopal, Raisen, Vidisa and Sagar districts of Madhya Pradesh State.
National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) has been assign the development, maintenance
and management of the National Highways as entrusted to it by the Government of India.
Under Bharatmala Pariyojana (Economic Corridor-417), Sagar section as a bypass of NH-
146 and it’s a green field proposal starting from Village Chauki (NH-146) Near
Berkheri,Design CH: KM: 134+736 to CH: 163+100 Village Ranipura in Sagar District. NH-
26 North South corridor. Approximate Length is 28+500.
This report pertains to environmental aspects of consultancy related to feasibility study for
development of Economic Corridors, Inter Corridors and Feeder Routes to improve the
efficiency of freight movement in India under Bharatmala Pariyojana (Lot-4) from Bhopal to
Sagar in the State of Madhya Pradesh.
8.3 THE PROJECT HIGHWAY.
The proposed project is a part of the Bharat Mala Project which has been envisaged as an
umbrella program under the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways. The project involves
constructions or improvement of national highways/ newly declared National Highways with
an aim to improve road connectivity to border areas, ports, backward areas, religious and
tourist sites. The National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) has entrusted M/s. STUP
Consultants Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi with the assignment of preparation of feasibility
study/Detailed project report and implementation of road stretches selected for Bhopal –
Kanpur (Eoconimic Corridor -417 Approx-length 550 km ) Corridor under Bharatmala
Pariyojana to 4 lane National Highway from Bhopal to Sagar Section (Economic Corridor -
417) Starting From Village: Chauki Near Berkheri, (NH-146 ) design CH: KM: 134+736 to
CH: 163+100 Village Ranipura in Sagar District. NH-26 North South corridor. Approximate
Length is 28+500 in the state of Madhya Pradesh.
Proposed New National Highway Sagar Link Road (Economic Corridor – 417)
starting from Village: Chauki (NH-146 ) Near Berkheri, CH: KM: 134+736 to
CH: 163+100 Village Ranipura (NH-26) in Sagar District. North South corridor.
Approximate Length is 28+500, ,Madhya Pradesh by National Highway
Authority of India
Proponent National Highways Authority of India (NHAI), MoRTH, GoI Project
Implementation Unit, Sagar
Capacity
28+500 Km
Coordinates Start: 854026.381E,
2635179.730N
And
End: 876926.759E,
2650765.555N
Project The Proposed project (Sagar Ring Road) is a green field project does
Category (as not required Environmental clearance as per the MoEF&CC had
under EIA released a new Draft EIA notification, Gazette 23 March 2020,
Notification Scheduled 38 Col (3)(A), (4)(B1) & (5) (B2) According to this
March 23, notification new sector has been introduced like:
2020) Col (3)(A):-
i) New National Highways or Multi-modal corridors or Ring Roads
ii) Expansion or widening of existing National Highways or Multi-modal
corridors or Ring Roads by length more than 100 km involving widening or
right of way more than 70m on existing alignments or re-alignments or by-
passes.
(4)(B1):
i) All new State Highway projects
ii) State Highway expansion projects in hilly terrain (above 1000 meter
above mean sea level)
(5) (B2)
i). Expansion or widening of existing National Highways or Expressways or
Multi-modal corridors or Ring Roads by length between 25 km and 100 km
involving widening or right of way more than 70 m on existing alignments or
realignments or bypasses.
ii). Expansion or widening of existing State Highways (500 m to 1000 m
above mean sea level)
Culverts 69 Nos.
Major Road Crossing Location
Railway Crossings 01 No.
Railway Over Bridge 01 Nos.
Underpasses & Overpasses 10 nos.
Pedestrian /Cattle Underpasses Nil
Details of Vehicular Underpass 10 nos.
Design Speed 100 km/hr for plain terrain
Proposed Carriageway Four Lane with paved shoulder.
Safety Measure Crash Barriers
Lighting including High Mask at Toll plazas,
Lighting interchanges, major bridges / ROB’s and
Amenities and Truck Parking Areas
The major objective of this study is to establish present environmental condition along the
project corridor through available data / information supported by field studies to evaluate the
impacts on relevant environmental attributes due to the construction & operation of the
proposed project; to recommend adequate mitigation measures to minimize / reduce adverse
impacts and to prepare an Environmental Management Plan (EMP) for timely implementation
of the mitigation measures to make the project environmentally sound and sustainable. An
Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) study basically includes:
Environmental assessment is a detailed process, which starts from the conception of the
project and continues till the operation phase. The steps for environmental assessment are
therefore different at different phases. The present report details the environmental setting of
the project zone, identifies the anticipated environmental impact and finally suggests
appropriate mitigation measures and mechanism for ensuring effective implementation of the
environmental safeguard measures at different stages of the project.
8.5.3 EIA
EIA evaluates the potential environmental risks and impacts of a specific project in its area of
influence, examines alternatives to the project, identifies ways of improving project selection,
siting, planning, design, and implementation by preventing, minimizing, mitigating, or
compensating for adverse environmental impacts and enhancing positive impacts. EIA
includes the process of mitigating and managing adverse environmental impacts during the
implementation of a project.
The Bank requires public consultation for A, B1 and B2 Category projects. For category A,B1
and B2 projects public consultation should be held at least twice (once at scoping and later
when the draft EIA is available). EIAs and EMPs (both draft and final documents) should be
disclosed in country and through the WB’s Info Shop.
In India, the Ministry had issued the notification number S.O. 804 (E), dated the 14th March,
2017 laying down procedure for appraisal of the violation cases with a time window of six
months. The said notification defined violation of projects which have started the construction
work, or have undertaken expansion or modernization or change in product-mix without Prior
Environment Clearance.
However, such violations being recurring in nature may come to the notice in future during
the process of appraisal or monitoring or inspection by Regulatory Authorities. Therefore, the
Ministry deems it necessary to lay down the procedure to bring such violation projects under
the regulations in the interest of Environment at the earliest point of time rather than leaving
them unregulated and unchecked, which will be more damaging to the environment;
AND WHEREAS, the Hon’ble National Green Tribunal in Original Application Number
837/2018 in the matter of Original Application Number 837/2018 Sandeep Mittal Vs Ministry
of Environment, Forest and Climate Change & Ors., has held that Ministry shall strengthen
the monitoring mechanism for compliance of conditions of Prior Environment Clearance;
Category A:
Category B1:
Category B2:
(i). Protected areas notified under the Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972,
(ii). Critically Polluted areas as notified by Central Pollution Control Board from time to time,
(iii). Notified Eco Sensitive Areas.
(iv). Inter State boundaries and international boundaries.
Provided that the requirement regarding distance of 10 km of the inter-state boundaries can
be reduced or completely done away with by an agreement between the respective States or
U.Ts sharing the common boundary in the case the activity does not fall within 10 kilometers
of the areas mentioned at item (i), (ii) and (iii) above
In the present case, the proposed is green field project having length of 28+500 KM,
proposed ROW 45 m. So, as per EIA notification 2020 and thereafter amendments that
New National Highways and expansion of National Highway projects greater than 100
km involving additional right of way or land acquisition more than 70 m on existing
alignments or realignments or bypasses. Hence, the proposed project road does not
attract the conditions of obtaining prior Environmental Clearance from Ministry of
Environment, Forests and Climate Change (MoEF&CC).
In 1976, the 42nd Constitutional Amendment created Article 48A and 51A, placing an
obligation on every citizen of the country to attempt to conserve the environment. As a result,
a number of laws related to environmental conservation were passed to strengthen existing
legislation. Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 is the landmark legislation as it provides for
the protection of environment and aims at plugging the loopholes in the other related acts
and this Act is called as umbrella Act. Under this Umbrella Act all the environmental acts and
rules have been formed.
The Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act,1974 resulted in the establishment of
the Central and State level Pollution Control Boards whose responsibilities include
managing water quality and effluent standards, as well as monitoring water quality,
prosecuting offenders and issuing licenses for construction and operation of any facility.
This will include generation of liquid effluent during construction of road from Civil
Engineering activities or from domestic activities in workers colony. There are specific
penalties for violation, which include imprisonment for responsible officials.
The Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 empowers Central and State
Pollution Control Boards for managing air quality and emission standards, as well as
monitoring air quality, prosecuting offenders and issuing licenses for construction and
operation of any facility. There are specific penalties for violation, which include
imprisonment for responsible officials. This Act has notified National Ambient Air Quality
Standard for different regions e.g. Industrial, Residential and Sensitive. Air quality during
construction and operation phases will be guided by this specific act. Environment
(Protection) Act, 1986: This Act was passed as an overall comprehensive act “for
protection and improvement of environment”. According to this Act, the Central
Government has the power to take all such measures as it deems necessary or expedient
for the purpose of protecting and improving the quality of environment and preventing,
controlling and abating environmental pollution. Under this act rules have been specified
for discharge/emission of effluents and different standards for environmental quality.
These include Ambient Noise Standard, Emission from Motor Vehicles, Mass Emission
Standard for Petrol Driven Vehicles, General Effluent Standards etc. especially important
for road project.
(i). Protected areas notified under the Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972,
(ii). Critically Polluted areas as notified by Central Pollution Control Board from time to
time,
8.10.2 HISTORY
Situated in the north central region of Madhya Pradesh, spelt as ‘SAUGOR’ during British
period, the district of ‘Sagar’ takes its name from the headquarter town which in turn
derived its name from Hindi word “Sagar” (meaning sea) . The town Sagar has been built
around the beautiful lake. The history of the Sagar dates back to about 1660 A.D when
Udan Shah, a descendant of Nihal Shah, built a small fort on the site of the present one
and founded a village close to it called Parkota, which is now a part of the town. The
present fort and a settlement under its walls was founded by Govind Rao Pandit, officer
in-charge of Sagar and the surrounding territory after 1735 A.D., when it came under the
Peshwa’s possession.
Project : Consultancy Services for preparation of DPR for
Development Of Economic Corridors, Inter Corridors and Feeder
Routes to Improve the efficiency of freight movement in India
Under Bharatmala Pariyojana (Package 3/Lot-4): Bhopal –Raisen – Vidisha – Sagar (Priority-1) Page 221
Report : Final Detailed Project Report
Date : September 2021
Volume: I – Main Report
In 1818 A.D., the Peshwa Baji Rao II ceded the greater part of the district to the British
Government, while different parts of the rest of the present district of Sagar came in the
possession of the British at different times between 1818 and 1860. Appaji Bhonsla ceded
the Dhamoni pargana of Banda tehsil in 1818 A.D. Transfer from the Bundelkhand states
acquired the Bherapargana of Banda tahsil in 1818 A.D. The parganas, Rahatgarh in
Sagar tahsil and Garhakota, Deori, Gourjhamer and Naharmow in Rehli tahsil collectively
known as Punch Mahal were handed over to British by Sindhia at different dates from
1820 to 1825 for management. The Shahgarh pargana of Banda tahsil was confiscated in
1857 in consequence of the rebellion of its chief. The Kanjia pargana of Khurai tahsil was
acquired from Sindhia in 1860 A.D. A small area in the north-east corner of the tehsil
around the village of Hirapur was similarly transferred to the British from Charkhari state
to Bundelkhand and added to the district after the uprising of 1857.
Administratively, Sagar and the neighbouring territories underwent frequent changes, the
Saugor territory was, first of all, placed under the superintendent of Political Affairs of
Bundelkhand. Later in 1820, the Saugor and Nerbudda territories were placed under the
administration of an Agent to the Governor General. The Saugor and Nerbudda territories
were included in North- western province in 1835. In 1842 after the Bundela rising, but
order was restored in 1843 and the Saugor and Nerbudda territories were again placed
under the political control of an Agent to the Governor-General. These territories were
once again restored to the North-western provinces in 1853. Thereafter, in 1861 the
Saugor and Nerbudda territories along with the Nagpur state formed a Commissioner’s
Province called Central Provinces.
8.10.2.1 CONNECTIVITY
Sagar is a great city to visit in the state of Madhya Pradesh. Nearest airport is Jabalpur
Airport. Sagar is well connected to other major cities of the country via regular trains.it can
easily get regular buses to Sagar from other major cities of the country.
8.10.2.2 DEMOGRAPHY
According to the 2011 census, Sagar District has a population of 2,378,295. The district
has a population density of 232 inhabitants per square kilometre (600/sq mi). Its
population growth rate over the decade 2001–2011 was 17.62%.Sagar has a sex ratio of
896 females for every 1000 males. and a literacy rate of 77.52%. At the time of the 2011
Census of India, 98.52% of the population in the district spoke Hindi and 0.57% Urdu as
their first language.
Historical population
Year Pop. ±% p.a.
1901 469,686 —
1911 541,256 +1.43%
1921 528,384 −0.24%
1931 544,928 +0.31%
1941 597,049 +0.92%
1951 636,191 +0.64%
1961 796,547 +2.27%
Project : Consultancy Services for preparation of DPR for
Development Of Economic Corridors, Inter Corridors and Feeder
Routes to Improve the efficiency of freight movement in India
Under Bharatmala Pariyojana (Package 3/Lot-4): Bhopal –Raisen – Vidisha – Sagar (Priority-1) Page 222
Report : Final Detailed Project Report
Date : September 2021
Volume: I – Main Report
8.10.2.3 GEOGRAPHY:
The history of the town of Sagar dates back to about 1660 AD, when Udan Shah, a
descendant of Nihal Shah, built a small fort where the present one sits and founded a
village close to it called Parkota Sagar. The present fort and a settlement under its walls
was founded by Govind Rao Pandit, an officer of the Peshwa, who controlled Sagar and
the surrounding territory after 1735 when it came under the Peshwa's possession. In
1818, the greater part of the district was ceded by the Peshwa Baji Rao II to the British
Government, while the remainder of the present district of Sagar came into the
possession of the British between 1818 and 1860. Thereafter in 1861, the Saugor and
Nerbudda territories (along with the Nagpur state) formed a Commissioner's Province
called Central Provinces. Sagar was the headquarters of the Sagar Commissionership for
a short period until 1863-64 when this district was incorporated with Jabalpur
Commissionership. In the year 1932, the district of Damoh was added to Sagar district
and was administrated as Sub-Division. In 1956, however, Damoh Sub-Division was
again separated from the district to form a separate district and Sagar district consisted of
four tehsils viz, Sagar, Khurai, Rehli, Banda.
8.11 CLIMATE/RAINFALL
Like other parts of India, Madhya Pradesh also has three major seasons - Summer
Monsoon and Winter. During summer (March-June), the temperature in the entire state
ranges above 29.4°C. In general, the eastern parts of Madhya Pradesh are hotter than
the western parts. The regions like Gwalior, Morena and Datia record temperature of over
42°C in the month of May. The humidity is relatively very low and the region usually
experiences frequent mild dust storms. The south-west Monsoon usually breaks out in
mid-June and the entire state receive a major share of its rainfall between June and
September. The south and south-east regions tend to experience a higher rainfall
whereas the parts of north-west receive less. Mandla, Balaghat, Sidhi, Jabalpur and other
extreme eastern parts receive more than 150 cm rainfall. The districts of western Madhya
Pradesh receive less than 80 cm rainfall.
The winter season starts from the month of November. The temperature remains low in
the northern parts of the state in comparison to the southern parts. The daily maximum
temperature in most of the northern part in the month of January remains between 15 and
18°C. The climate is generally dry and pleasant with a clear sky.
Source: http://www.mp.gov.in/en/web/guest/state-profile#CLIMATE
Madhya Pradesh represents great river basins and the watershed of a number of rivers.
Catchments of many rivers of India lie in Madhya Pradesh. The Narmada (originating
from Amarkantak) and Tapti (originating from Multai of Betul District) rivers and their
basins divide the state in two, with the northern part draining largely into the Ganga basin
and the southern part into the Godavari and Mahanadi systems. The Vindhyas form the
southern boundary of the Ganga basin, with the western part of the Ganga basin draining
into the Yamuna and the eastern part directly into the Ganga itself. All the rivers, which
drain into the Ganga, flow from south to north, with the Chambal, Sipra, Kali Sind,
Parbati, Kuno, Sind, Betwa, Dhasan and Ken rivers being the main tributaries of the
Yamuna. The land drained by these rivers is agriculturally rich, with the natural vegetation
largely consisting of grass and dry deciduous forest types, largely thorny. The eastern
part of the Ganga basin consists of the Son, the Tons and the Rihand Rivers, with the
Son being the major tributary. This is also the junction point of the Satpura and the
Vindhya ranges, with the Maikal and Kaimur Hills being the fulcrum. The forests here are
much richer than the thorn forests of the northwestern part of Madhya Pradesh. The Son
is of great significance in that it is the largest tributary going into the Ganga on the south
bank and arising out of the hills of Madhya Pradesh rather than from the Himalayas. This
river and its tributaries contribute the bulk of the monsoon flow into Ganga, because the
north bank tributaries are all snow fed.The major tributary of the Ganga, the Son, arises in
one of the most important watersheds in India, the Maikal hills around Amarkantak. Three
of the great rivers of India, Narmada, Mahanadi and Son, are given birth to by these hills.
This is also one of the few ranges in the State having a north south configuration. The
Mahanadi itself, together with its tributaries such as Hasdeo, Mand and Kharun flows
southeast into Orissa and converts that State into a green rice bowl. The upper Mahanadi
catchment contains some of the finest forests in the State, ranging from mixed deciduous
to teak, bamboo and Sal. Just as the Mahanadi flows east from the Maikal hills and the
Son flows north, the mighty Narmada charts a westerly course from these very hills. The
Narmada flows through a rift valley, with the Vindhyas marching along its northern bank
and the Satpuras along the southern. Its tributaries include the Banjar, the Tawa, the
Machna, the Denwa and the Sonbhardra rivers. Taken in combination with its parallel
sister river, the Tapti, which also flows through a rift valley, the Narmada - Tapti systems
carry and enormous volume of water and provide drainage for almost a quarter of the
land area of Madhya Pradesh.The Satpuras, in the Gawilgarh and Mahadeo Hills, also
contain a watershed, which is south facing. The Indrawati, the Wainganga, the Wardha,
the Pench, the Kanhan and Penganga rivers, discharge an enormous volume of water
into the Godavari system. The Godavari is the lifeline of Andhra Pradesh, but the water
which feeds it is a gift of the Central India water shed. Some of the finest sub-tropical,
semi moist forests in India are to be found in the Godavari basin, mainly in the valley of
the Indrawati. There are very few virgin forests left in the country, but very fine examples
of these are to be found in Bastar area along the Indrawati and in the Kanger valley in
Chhattisgarh.
Total Forest Land Diversion for this proposed Project is 58 Ha. Madhya Pradesh is one of
the most blessed states of India in terms of natural resources including rich and diverse
forests, Forests cover about 30.72 per cent of its total area of 3.08 sq km (i.e., 94,689 sq
km).
This significant resource of the state is being conserved and harnessed through
innovative measures like community participation and decentralization. The state has
been a pioneer in making forestry people-oriented with 15228 Joint Forest Management
Committees (JFMCs) involved in protection and management of about 70% of the forest
area. People are the real dwellers and the real caretakers of the forests and, thus, are
made the beneficiaries of the dividends of this field. Forests and forest produce based
industries make an important contribution to the economy of the state. Owing to economic
importance of forest wealth, efforts are being made for the systematization of the trade of
forest produce in the state. The state takes care of the trade of nationalized forest
produce viz., Tendu Leaf, Sal Seed and Kullu Gum. In addition, a number of forest
produce like Aonla, Harra, Lac, Achar, Mahua etc. are also being collected & traded
through a network of Cooperative Societies. Aonla, Gum, Tendu Leaf, Sal seed, Harra
and various medicinal plants of Madhya Pradesh are in great demand in national and
international markets. Tendu leaf collection activities alone account for an income of
about Rs. 145 crore every year to the forest dwellers.
Teak and Sal forests are the pride of the state. The Forest Department and the Forest
Development Corporation have done extensive teak plantations during the last few
decades. The dense forests of teak lie in Jabalpur, Seoni, Balaghat, Panna, Sehore,
Dewas, Hoshangabad, Harda, Betul, Sagar, Chhindwara and Mandla districts. Similarly,
the Sal forests are mainly located in Mandla, Dindori, Balaghat, Sidhi, Umaria, Anuppur
and Shahdol districts.
The geographical and biotic diversity of the state is well reflected in its 18 forest types
ranging from thorn-forests to subtropical hill forests. The state is divided into 9 natural
regions and 11 agro-climatic zones.
Classification of Forests;
• Reserved Forests
• Protected Forests
• Unclassified Forests
In the state, protected forests constitute 31098 sq km of the total forest area. Reserved
forests are spread over 61886 sq km and unclassified forests cover an area of 1705 sq
km.
The density of forests is not uniform in the state. Balaghat, Mandla, Dindori, Betul, Seoni,
Chhindwara, Shahdol, Harda, Sheopur, Sidhi are some of densely forested districts. The
forests of the state mostly lie in the southern and eastern belt; Sheopur and Panna being
the notable exceptions.
As per Champion & Seth Classification, the state has 18 forest types which belong to
three forest type groups, viz. Tropical Moist Deciduous, Tropical Dry Deciduous and
Tropical Thorn Forests. Percentage-wise distribution of forest cover in different forest type
groups found in the state on the basis of the forest cover assessment is as below :-
Forest Type Group Percent Forest Cover
Sr.No
1 Tropical Moist Deciduous Forests 8.97%
2 Tropical Dry Deciduous Forests 88.65%
3 Tropical Thorn Forests 0.26%
.
FIGURE 8-2: RESERVED AND PROTECTED FOREST
The Proposed project (Sagar Ring Road) is a green field project does not required
Environmental clearance as per MoEF&CC had released a new Draft EIA
notification, Gazette 23 March 2020, Scheduled 38 Col (3)(A), (4)(B1) & (5)
(B2) According to this notification new sector has been introduced like:
Col (3)(A):
(4)(B1):
(5) (B2):
ii) Expansion or widening of existing State Highways (500 m to 1000 m above mean sea
level)
Thereof, hence our project is not categorized in any category. So that, Prior
Environment Clearance will not requires from Ministry of Environment and Forest &
Climate Change New Delhi as per the above said notification.
CHAPTER 9
INITIAL SOCIAL ASSESSMENT AND PRELIMINARY LAND
ACQUISITION / RESETTLEMENT PLAN
Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) would be drawn up as an integral part of the main
project proposal so that the highway improvement options under consideration are
socially sound, sustainable and contribute to the development of social development
goals. Moreover, the main objective of the RAP is to provide a Resettlement Policy
Framework to ensure that the affected and displaced persons are appropriately
resettled and rehabilitated i.e. to improve their livelihood and standards of living or at
least to restore them, in real terms. The RAP needs to be appropriately monitored
also.
9.6 METHODOLOGY
The preparation of Initial Social Assessment involves extensive consultations with
stakeholders and primary surveys of the affected persons apart from review of
secondary information. The key tasks carried out for the preparation of ISA (SIA/RAP)
are summarized below.
9.6.1 Approach
The initial social assessment process generally commences with feasibility stage. At
this stage, social analysis is made of the project area and steps are taken from the
beginning so that plans / designs / alignments are finalized in such a way that to the
extent possible, adverse impacts are avoided /reduced at the design stage itself to
make these roads people and environment friendly. Wherever avoidance / reduction
of the adverse social impact is not possible, those affected should be compensated
resettled and rehabilitated properly by adopting proper mitigation measures and such
that the living condition of the people are improved.
The key steps are:
Avoiding / reducing the adverse social impacts at the design stage, especially
while finalizing the alignments;
Mitigating the unavoidable adverse impacts at planning, construction and
implementation phase; and
Compensating the affected people and common properties at replacement costs
and by adopting appropriate rehabilitation and resettlement measures.
Social Impact Assessment has been differently in various guidelines. For the study of
this present project, the scope of work defined in the document (TOR) prepared by
concerned authority has been taken into consideration. The major issues and items
identified in the scope briefly are:
Study of Background information on project and related policy and legal issues;
Collection of data from secondary sources;
Reconnaissance survey of the project impact zone, and
Analysis of data and Screening exercise
TABLE 9-1 : LISTS OF HABITATION ALONG WITH PROJECT ROAD (PACKAGE –I)
Design Chainage
S.NO DISTRICT TEHSIL VILLAGE NAME
From To
1 Sagar Rahatgarh Chauki 134+737 135+727
2 Sagar Rahatgarh Berkheri sadak 135+727 135+857
3 Sagar Rahatgarh Berkheri sadak 136+157 136+637
4 Sagar Rahatgarh Mardanpur 136+857 136+157
5 Sagar Rahatgarh Mardanpur 136+637 137+517
6 Sagar Rahatgarh Pachwasa 137+517 138+737
7 Sagar Rahatgarh Gambhiriya 138+737 140+607
8 Sagar Rahatgarh Khiriya kaji 140+607 141+197
9 Sagar Rahatgarh Padarasoi 141+197 143+597
10 Sagar Rahatgarh Bhaisa 143+597 145+777
11 Sagar Rahatgarh Manesiya 145+777 146+497
12 Sagar Rahatgarh Dhagarniya 146+497 148+697
13 Sagar Sagar Basiyabhansa 148+697 150+687
14 Sagar Sagar Narayawli 150+687 151+677
15 Sagar Sagar Narayawli 151+787 152+087
16 Sagar Sagar Mara imiliya 150+907 151+107
17 Sagar Sagar Mara imiliya 151+297 151+337
18 Sagar Sagar Mara imiliya 151+677 151+787
19 Sagar Sagar Badora 152+087 153+807
20 Sagar Sagar Kodni 153+807 155+277
21 Sagar Sagar Ikpana basona 155+277 157+357
22 Sagar Sagar Koluwa amarsa 157+357 159+507
23 Sagar Sagar Berkhera khuman 159+507 161+447
24 Sagar Sagar Sirwai 161+447 162+517
25 Sagar Sagar Ranipura 162+517 163+254
Source: As per 3a/3A (LA Plan)
Total 09 major villages come along the project road in Sagar district, Madhya Pradesh
The Project study corridor of (package-3) starts in Sagar district from km 134+737 in
Chauki village and ends at Sagar District km 163+253 located in Ranipura Village.
Total length of project road is 28.5 km.
The above table shows that the total 09 major villages/Town come along the project
road in Sagar district, Madhya Pradesh.
Road projects are meant for improving the quality of life for people and developing the
country’s economy. For all positive impacts of the road projects, there may be also
some significant detrimental impact on nearby communities. Secondly, a minimum
number of people could be adversely affected. The affected persons might incur loss
of the following types: Land, living quarters and other physical infrastructures due to
demolition of strictures of Kiosks/Squatters, commercial and business activities,
occupied land, structures (illegally constructed) for dwelling or business, tenant
contract or farming. Moreover, the project road may also cause damage to community
facilities and utilities like potable water sources (e.g. pond, well etc.), market place,
schools, places of worship, community centers etc. The affected properties, in the
case under reference, may be classified into three categories viz private, public and
places of worship.
Based on the Initial Study of the project road, a estimation of the Potential impacts
with respect to resettlement has been done. While not likely to Significant, given the
project approach to minimize acquisition and adoption of CoI approach, the likely
impact categories include residential and commercial structures, religious structures,
community assets such as bus-stop shelters and water sources, etc.
The studies undertaken to prepare this chapter show extensive occupancy of project
roadside areas, including densely settled village and urban communities containing
numerous homes, businesses, and public facilities. Road widening and the other
improvements proposed will impact roadside residences, businesses, religious shrines
and structures, agricultural lands, public buildings, and infrastructure.
Affected businesses and structures will be relocated. Rehabilitation will be required
where resettlement, relocation, or other project impacts result in lost livelihood or
income. In most cases, the project will not require either full demolishing or the taking
of residential or commercial structures to the extent that either resettlement or
relocation will be necessary. Generally, only a narrow frontage strip of several meters
or less will be affected. Frequently, this means that only a compound wall or fences,
yards, must be removed. In some cases, small portions of roadside dwellings and
businesses will be taken. Only rarely, will it be necessary to take entire residential or
commercial structures in package -1section.
social problems
Improve environmental and social soundness
Clarify values and trade-offs associated with the different alternatives
Identify contentious local issues which might jeopardize the implementation of
the project and Create accountability and sense of local ownership during
project implementation
As part of the Social assessments of the project, the views of affected groups
(particularly those with potentially significant impacts) are taken into account through
the public consultation process. People affected by the project are those, living and
working along the corridor, and include residents, farmers, agricultural workers etc.
accordingly it was decided that affected PAHs could be mostly resettled outside the
ROW. It will be a condition in the civil works contract that shifting of affected PAHs
and also for roadside amenities will be a part of ROW Management Plan. Where
some physical constructions like building of vendor market and resettlement etc. for
developing resettlement would be required, the work will be integrated with the civil
work contract as provisional sum and it would be responsibility of the civil works
contractor to make necessary construction as may be required for resettlement.
conditions of the APs in the post –resettlement period. (ii) Communications and
reactions from APs on entitlement, compensation, options, alternative developments
and relocation timetables etc. (iii) changes in housing and income levels (iv)
rehabilitation of PAHs and informal settlers (v) valuation of property (vi) grievance
procedures (vii) disbursement of compensation and (viii) level of satisfaction of APs in
the post resettlement period.
The initial report of the project road has been prepared considering the National
Policy on Rehabilitation -2013 guidelines, State & Central Government Legislation &
Acts for resettlement & rehabilitation. The principle of the R&R policy is the guiding
philosophy to provide a development approach to resettle and rehabilitate the people
affected by project. This section describes the principles and approach to be followed
in minimization and mitigating of negative social and economic impacts due to the
projects.
Broad Principles
has been assessed and is given in the entitlement matrix. Provisions will be kept
in the budget for those who were not present at the time of enumeration.
However, anyone moving into the project area after the cut-off date will not be
entitled to assistance.
Appropriate grievance redress mechanism will be established at the PMU level
to ensure speedy resolution of disputes.
All activities related to resettlement planning, implementation, and monitoring
would ensure involvement of women. Efforts will also be made to ensure that
vulnerable groups are included.
All consultations with APs will be documented. Summary results are appended
to the RP. Consultations will continue during the implementation of resettlement
and rehabilitation works, and
The Resettlement Plan includes a fully itemized budget and an implementation
schedule linked to the civil works contract.
These principles are further explained in the Entitlement Matrix. The existing laws do
not address many of the social and economic issues associated with displacement
and resettlement of squatters and other informal settlers. However, the World Bank
Consultancy Services for preparation of DPR for development of Economic Corridors,
Inter Corridors and Feeder Routes to improve the efficiency of freight movement in
India under Bharatmala Pariyojana Lot : 4, Package – 3 Sagar Link Road Page 241
Report : Final Detailed Project Report
Date : September 2021
Volume: I – Main Report
policy in all road sector project have approved plan to assist affected persons even
without any legal titles. The impacts of the present project are almost entirely on the
roadside Small Business Enterprises /households – people who are “non – titled”
informal dwellers and encroachers. In resettlement principles consistent with World
Bank Policy, requirements will be adopted in case of this project. The Policy requires
compensation for lost assets at replacement costs both for titled and non-titled holders
and assistance for lost income and livelihoods. The absence of formal titles to land or
other assets will not be a bar to assistance and rehabilitation. Further, the Policy
requires special measures and assistance for vulnerable groups such as female-
headed households, disabled persons and the poor.
vulnerable people.
Rental assistance to the renter for three months if the affected structure was
rented out.
Wells and other immovable assets will be compensated at replacement values,
including installation charges.
Provision for relocation of PAHs (Small Business Enterprises)
Non-titled vulnerable households will be entitled to a lump sum shifting
allowance to move their belongings if they decide to ”self–relocate” away from
the ROW; those who prefer to move back and re-establish their structures
temporarily until they find permanent alternative sites will be entitled to one time
shifting allowance.
Kutchcha (Kiosk) - - -
Boundary wall - - -
Religious Structures 1,00,000 - 0
Govt. 1,00,000 - 0
Structures/CPR’s
Other 20,000 250 5000000
Total 250/500 76,00,000
Adding: 100% solatium 76,00,000
One time financial assistance - - -
by cheques.
Apart from shifting and rental allowance the others will be deposited in the joint
accounts. The amount will be withdrawn against the purchase of productive assets.
CHAPTER 10
COST ESTIMATE
10.1 GENERAL
This chapter provides for the preliminary cost estimate for development of the green
field Sagar Link Road stretch of Bhopal – Raisen – Vidisha - Sagar (NH-146) Part of
Bhopal – Kanpur Economic Corridor in the State of Madhya Pradesh to four lane
configuration. Total length of the project road is 28.5 km.
10.2 METHODOLOGY
Quantities of different road components have been worked out manually from
preliminary drawings. The deck area of Bridges/Underpasses/ROB has been worked
out from preliminary proposals. Similar approach has been adopted for slab and box
type culverts.
10.5 BRIDGES
All existing water bodies and railway crossings are provided with new bridges of
suitable span arrangement.
10.6 CULVERTS
New box culverts have been proposed for cross water drainage purpose. Provision is
also been made for cross road culverts.
RCC Lined drains cum footpath is proposed to be constructed on outer side of the
carriageway in urban areas.
10.8 JUNCTIONS
Provision of grade separated junctions on important cross roads has been made in
this estimate.
Provision for road signs, markings, and other appurtenances have been made under
this sub head.
10.10 MISCELLANEOUS
Provision has been made for the following provisions in this estimate:
Toll Plaza -1 Nos.
Street Lighting
Reinforced earth wall
The existing road shall be maintained during construction for running the traffic
smoothly. Provision for maintenance of existing road has been made under this sub
head.
The estimated cost of proposed new 4- laning with paved shoulders of this stretch
works out as under:
Consultancy Services for preparation of DPR for development of Economic Corridors,
Inter Corridors and Feeder Routes to improve the efficiency of freight movement in
India under Bharatmala Pariyojana Lot : 4, Package – 3 Sagar Link Road Page 248
Report : Final Detailed Project Report
Date : September 2021
Volume: I – Main Report
CHAPTER 11
General
Safe disposal of waste plastic is a serious environmental problem. The best way of disposal
of waste plastic is its recycling to the maximum extent. Waste plastic have great potential for
use in bituminous construction as its addition in small doses of about 5 – 10% by weight of
bitumen results in substantially improving the stability, strength, fatigue life and other
desirable properties of the bituminous mixes. The use of waste plastic contributes to
construction of green roads.
Materials
Bitumen
The bitumen for bituminous mixes for wearing course with waste plastic shall comply with the
Indian Standard Specifications for viscosity graded paving bitumen IS73. Guidelines for
selection for grade of viscosity graded paving bitumen shall be in accordance with the
IRC:111-2009.
Aggregates
The aggregates shall comply to IRC:111-2009, for dense graded mixes and IRC:14-2004,
IRC:SP:78-2008 and IRC:110-2005 for open graded mixes respectively.
Filler
The filler for dense graded mixes shall comply with IRC:111-2009.
Waste Plastic
The waste plastic shall conform to the size passing 2.36mm sieve and retained on 600
micron sieve.
Dust and other impurities shall not be more than 1 percent. The process is indicated in IRC
:SP:98-2013. An easy method to determine the quantity of impurity is to determine the ash
content at 600oC.
To ascertain the ability of plastic to mix with the binder, the melt-flow value shall be tested as
per ASTM D 1238-2010, for which the range shall be as follows:
Design of Mix
The requirements for waste plastic modified design and open graded mixes are as follows:
The properties for dense graded mixes are indicated in TABLE 11-1 below.
Waste Plastic @ 6 to 8 percent of the weight of the bitumen can be used for Open – Grade
Premix Surfacing and Mix Seal surfacing Mix. Quantity of bitumen can be reduced
correspondingly.
The scope of the present guidelines is restricted to dry process only for the following reasons:
DRY PROCESS
In order to ensure that the quality of the finished waste plastic product is consistent the
following process must be adhered to before considering its use in bituminous construction:
Collection of waste plastic
Cleaning and shredding of waste plastic
Shredding Machine
Mixing of shredded waste plastic, aggregate and bitumen in central mixing plant
CONSTRUCTIONS
Construction operation shall be in accordance with the IRC: 111-2009, IRC: 14-2004, IRC:
110-2005 and IRC: SP:78-2008 for dense graded and open graded mixes respectively.
CONTROLS
Controls shall be in accordance with the IRC: 111-2009, IRC: 14-2004 and IRC: 110-2005
and IRC: SP: 78-2008 for dense graded and open graded mixes respectively. Besides, plastic
shall be tested for impurity and melt flow value. Three sample be tested for each day work or
when there is change in the source of plastic.
It is proposed to use this waste material technology in consultation with NHAI in the wearing
coat. The materials (except waste plastic) and construction operation is same as for normal
bituminous mixes.
General
Materials
Binder
Additives
Chemical additives may be used to accelerate or retard the break-set time of the slurry or to
improve the resulting surface finish
The quantity of additive shall be decided by mix design and to be adjusted as per site
condition. The additive and emulsion shall be compatible with each other.
The design criteria for micro-surfacing mixture is specified in Table below The mix design
report shall clearly show the proportions of aggregate, filler, water and residual bitumen
content based on the dry weight of aggregates and additives used (if any). The set time shall
be determined by the method given in Appendix-2 of IRC:SP:81 and details are given in
TABLE 11-3.
Aggregate, modified bitumen emulsion, water and additive (if used), shall be proportioned
by weight of aggregate utilizing the mix design approved by the Engineer. If more than
one type of aggregates is used, the correct amount of each type of aggregate used to
produce the required grading shall be proportioned separately prior to adding other
materials of the mixture, in manner that will result in a uniform and homogenous blend.
Final completed mixture, after addition of water and any additive, if used shall be such
that the micro-surfacing mixture has proper workability and permit traffic within a short
period depending upon the weather conditions without occurrence of raveling and
bleeding. Trial mixes shall be prepared and laid for the designed mix and observed for
breaking time and setting time. The wet track abrasion test is used to determine the
minimum residual bitumen content. Indicative limits of various ingredients for job mix of
micro-surfacing shall be as given in table below:
Residual bitumen 6.5 to 10.5 for type II and 5.5 to 10.5 for
Type III
Mineral filler 0.5 to 3.0
Additive As needed
Water As needed
- Construction
- Application of Micro-Surfacing
- Rate of Application
- Rolling
The surface finish of construction shall conform to the requirements of clause 902 of
MoRTH specification. For control of the quality of materials and work carried out
relevant provision of section 900 of MoRTH specification shall apply.
General:
The basic principle of this technology is that by adding certain additives at the final
stages of mix production, the coating of aggregate by the binder is greatly enhanced
and can be achieved at considerably less temperature (approx.. 30 deg. Less)
compared to hot mix process. This results in many benefits like environmental,
health, technical and cost.
The basic principle of this technology is that by adding certain additives at the final
stages of the mix production, the coating of the aggregates by the binder is greatly
enhanced and can be achieved at a considerably less temperature (typically 30°C
less) compared to the hot mix process wherein bitumen is heated to a sufficiently high
temperature to make it fluid enough to surround the aggregates and coat their
surfaces. In hot mix process, it is viscosity of bitumen alone, which is less at higher
temperature that plays the main role in coating of aggregates. In warm mix
technology, this can be achieved in three different ways, viz. by increasing the volume
of bitumen, by making the bitumen less viscous, by reducing the surface tension at
aggregate bitumen interface etc.
Currently there are more than 30 different WMA technologies, using patented
processes and products, which have capabilities of bringing reduction in mixing,
laydown and compaction temperatures of bituminous mixes in one of three different
ways as described above. These guidelines covers currently adopted Warm Mix
Asphalt technologies globally, classifying them into four main categories. Currently
there are altogether more than 30 different WMA technologies. Although the end
effect of reduction of mixing, laydown and compaction temperatures are the same, the
different technologies work in different ways. The additives, which are either waxes or
other hydrocarbon modifiers improve lubrication by reducing the viscosity of bitumen
and allow a reduction of 28°C to 40°C in mixing and compaction temperature. Typical
dosage amounts are 0.5 to 1 .5 percent by weight of bitumen. Sometimes these
additives are also added as modifiers for increasing the stiffness of asphalt mixes, for
specialty applications, such as in racing tracks.
Foaming
In essence, the "water technologies" use fine water droplets to expand the volume of
binder in the mix by causing it to foam. This has the effect of increasing the volume of
the bitumen, enabling it to coat aggregate at lower temperatures. The foaming
technology can be further subdivided into two classes, foaming additives and water
injection system. The foaming process works by creating foamed asphalt that
improves coating and compaction at lower temperature. Water expands 1, 600 times
when converted into steam at atmospheric pressure, and the steam is encapsulated
by viscous bitumen producing foam, which occupies a much greater volume
compared to the original bitumen. The water for creating the foam is either added as
water through a water injections stem in specialized equipment, or from zeolites
(which contain about 20 percent water). Water is added at a rate of 1 .25 to 2.0
percent by weight of bitumen (about 500 ml of water per ton of mix), whereas the
zeolites are added a rate of 0.1 to 0.3 percent by weight of the mix. Foaming by water
allows 18°C to 30°C reduction in temperature whereas foaming by zeolites allows a
reduction of 30°C to 40°C.
Natural and synthetic zeolites are mineral additives used to introduce water
into the mix thereby creating "in-situ" foaming within the bitumen. Zeolites in
general are added to the mix with the filler during mixing process. As the
mixing temperature increases the zeolites slowly release their absorbed water
into the bitumen, which is dispersed throughout the mixture in the form of very
fine foam droplets. This causes an increase in the volume of the bitumen and
leading to improvement in its ability to coat the aggregate.
In this process the bituminous binder is added to the heated coarse aggregate
in the mixer. Once the coarse aggregate are well coated, fine aggregate at
ambient temperature with moisture content of around 3 percent is introduced.
The moisture vaporizes, causing the binder coating the coarse aggregate to
foam, which in turn encapsulates the fine aggregate.
Chemical Additives
Rheological Modifiers
Hybrid Technologies
Other Technologies
Finally, there are products that were originally developed for other uses, but do
incorporate the WMA technology for reducing temperature and hence better
utilization of the product. Examples are (sulfur and WMA) and TLAX (Trinidad
lake asphalt and WMA technology).
The additives come in different forms, such as liquid, powder, pellet and are
administered in the mix production process at different stage. Accordingly,
some modification in the bituminous mixing plants is necessary to administer
the controlled dosage of the additives. Some additives in liquid form can be
pre-blended with bitumen and would need no modification in the conventional
mixing plant provided the blended bitumen contains the right dose of additive.
Other additives, which are administered in the mix at certain stage during the
mix production process, would require some modification in the conventional
mixing plants. These modifications would generally require a separate material
(additive) feed system and a material metering system (to ensure the right
dosage) which should be integrated with computerized plant control system of
the mixing plant. The water-based WMA technologies would additionally need
a water injection system as well.
ii) Health Benefits: The fumes from hot mix asphalt are known to be potential
health hazards, especially for the construction workers. Reduced
temperature of the mix avoids this health hazard.
c) Technical advantages:
a) Lower mixing temperature reduces the oxidation and ageing of ' bitumen and
thereby gives longer lasting pavement by delaying fatigue cracking.
c) Reduced rate of cooling of the mix (due to low initial temperature of the mix)
permits longer haul distance from the plant to work sites and better cold weather
construction opportunities.
d) Cost benefits: WMA is most likely to have long term cost advantages, though
its estimation should be case specific. The cost advantage is a trade-off between the
additional cost of using the additives and technologies (including plant modification)
and cost savings achieved through reduced fuel consumption, longer life of pavement
and use of recycled material.
In the 'overview', the principles behind various alternative technologies and different
additives have been presented. These provide the general guideline for an
appropriate choice of technology. Secondly, since the plants and equipment used for
producing WMA mixes would remain essentially the same (at least till such time the
technology proliferates and its use becomes widespread) as that for HMA mix, it
would be necessary to ascertain the nature and feasibility as well as commitment to
these modifications/changes. Thirdly, the suppliers of the products to be used in
works should be willing to take responsibility along with the main contractor not only
for their products but for the entire technological solution.
All technologies and all commercial additives should be allowed to compete for acceptance
on a work if the following conditions are satisfied:
Achieving the reduction of at least 30°C in mixing and laying temperature on some actual
work done in the past. The evidence should be in the form of a certificate from the
owner/owner's representative of the said work,
Additives proposed to be used not having any harmful effects on human health and
environment. This evidence should be in the form of test certificates from reputed
laboratory,
Complete understanding of the technological solution such as dosage of additives, the
process of administering the additives in a controlled manner (weight, volume, pressure,
temperature, etc.), adequacy of the plant and equipment proposed to be used on the work
and if not, the modifications required, quality assurance in the process, etc. This evidence
should be in the form of a written quality statement.
iii) The main contractor provides evidence of understanding of the technological requirement,
including modifications in the plant and equipment and acceptance of these requirements.
This evidence should be in the form of a written joint commitment statement.
The selection of the best WMA technology depends on many factors, and in most cases
is dependent on the monetary incentives and benefits of using WMA. Important factors to
consider include the reduction in temperature that is desired, the tonnage of mix that is
anticipated and whether or not to invest in plant technology that are needed for certain
additives. It should also be pointed out that the "green" benefits of adopting WMA
technologies should not be overlooked, and that a reduction in emission through a
reduction of temperature can help contractors/agencies receive significant amount of
"carbon credits."
The quality and performance of the mix shall be the same as specified for HMA in IRC:
111 except for mixing and laying temperatures, which should be at least 30°C less than
those specified for HMA. The threshold of 30°C is considered technologically feasible as
well as desirable from the point of view of fuel savings of some significance.
Design of mix, quality of inputs (except the additives) and tests required to be performed
shall follow the same procedures as specified in IRC: 111. In addition, the following WMA
specific tests shall also be performed:
iv) Coating
v) Compatibility
vi) Moisture Sensitivity
The above parameters should be verified first in the laboratory, after the criteria are
satisfied, a field trial of at least 500 m length shall be constructed, and the parameters
obtained in the laboratory may be verified.
Aggregate Coating
Compatibility
Since the mixing and compaction temperature of the warm-mix samples are lowered
by at least 30°C compared to the conventional hot=mix, it is important for the warm-
mix samples to attain specified mix densities at adopted lower temperatures. In order
to verify that the warm-mix samples attain sufficient density at least 30°C lower
temperatures relative to the conventional hot-mix, the following is proposed:
Three hot-mix specimens shall be prepared conforming to the Job Mix Formula (JMF)
as per AASHTO T245 (also adopted in MORTH Section 500 Table 1 0). (Refer
Annexure I of IRC:SP:101-2014)
Similarly, three more warm-mix specimens shall be prepared conforming to the JMF.
In all cases the JMF shall be made in the same procedure as per conventional mixes
except at a temperature at least 30°C lower than the hot-mix samples as per AASHTO
T245. The comp active effort should be similar for both mixes. In case there is a
specific change required by an additive manufacturer to suit the JMF requirements the
same shall be permitted except that the Specified Properties in the Guidelines shall
have to be adhered to.
The bulk specific gravity (Gmb) of all the specimens shall be determined as per
AASHTO T1 66.
The theoretical maximum specific gravity (Gmm) of the bituminous mixture of HMA and
WMA shall be determined as per AASHTO T209.
The air voids of both the mixes shall be determined as per the following equation:
Gmm – Gmb
Va = X100
Gmm
The ratio of the air voids shall be as per the following equation:
Va of WMA
Rva =
Va of HMA
Moisture Susceptibility
Warm-mixes are typically prepared at least 30°C lower temperatures, it is likely that the
aggregate can retain some residual moisture, especially when the aggregate are porous
and when the moisture content in the aggregate is high due to recent rains. It is
recommended that the warm-mix additives or processes should also behave as anti-
stripping agents, and should be able to improve the resistance of the mix to moisture
susceptibility even when produced at temperatures at least 30°C lower than conventional
mixes. If the warm-mix additives cannot perform as an anti-stripping agent, it must be
mandated to add either hydrated lime or a liquid anti-stripping agent to the mix to improve
resistance to moisture damage. However in case of WMA using foaming technology use
of anti-stripping agent or lime may be detrimental.
Six samples of the compacted HMA mix conforming to the JMF as per AASHTO T245
(Refer Annexure I of IRC:SP:101-2014) shall be prepared in the first instance.
The Tensile Strength Ratio (TSR) of the hot-mix and the warm-mix shall be
determined as per AASHTO T283. The TSR value of HMA shall meet the requirement
of minimum 80 percent as specified in IRC: 111. A TSR of above 80 percent for the
warm-mix that is prepared at least 30°C below corresponding hot-mix will ensure
sufficient resistance against moisture susceptibility.
WMA requires mix temperatures to be significantly reduced. The two basic types of
bituminous mixing plant most commonly used are the batch type mixing plant and the
continuous drum type plant, both of which types can be adapted to manufacture WMA.
For production of warm mixes that also contain reclaimed bituminous mixes, mixing plant
design should include adequate features. When any of the various types of mixing plants
are used, it should be ensured that the Recycled Asphalt (RA) and the virgin aggregates
are properly blended together; the blending process shall facilitate proper heat transfer
and shall prevent both physical and thermal segregation.
As with any new technology, there are a few concerns about the production of WMA,
specifically because of the lower temperatures that are utilized during production.
Fortunately, all of these problems are expected and solvable, in many cases through the
adoption of techniques that could also be utilized for improving conventional HMA
production.
The first concern is about incomplete drying of aggregates (specifically the internal
moisture) at the reduced temperatures. It has been seen that for aggregates with an
absorption value of less than 1 percent, drying of aggregate has not been reported to be a
problem at WMA temperatures. To prevent the incomplete drying of aggregates, it is
suggested that stockpiles be kept as dry as possible by sloping sides, paving surrounding
areas, and keeping them under cover. To dry aggregates with high moisture content the
retention time in the dryer drum could be increased and the dryer shell should be
insulated properly. Ways to detect incomplete drying include a greater than 20°C fall in
temperature in mix between discharge and loading, dripping water from silos and
excessive steam from slat conveyors and a loss of more than 0.5 percent of the weight of
mix during moisture content test.
Evidence of such a problem include brownish color of mix and higher than normal
emissions. Proper maintenance and tuning of burner, and preheating of burner fuel are
recommended solutions to this problem. The last but not least problem is the potential of
condensation of bag house fines, leading to the clogging and decreased efficiency of the
emission control system.
For WMA Technologies, both Theological modifier and chemical additive types that are
blended into the binder shall be added through the mixing plant's normal binder addition
system. These may also be blended at terminals and supplied to project sites through
conventional transportation system.
Water carrying chemical additives, which are in powdered form, can be added manually
into the pug mill of batch type mixers either through the filler system, or by intruding it
through the RA collar.
Consultancy Services for preparation of DPR for development of Economic Corridors,
Inter Corridors and Feeder Routes to improve the efficiency of freight movement in
India under Bharatmala Pariyojana Lot : 4, Package – 3 Sagar Link Road Page 263
Report : Final Detailed Project Report
Date : September 2021
Volume: I – Main Report
Equipment to produce foamed bitumen may be installed on both batch and continuous
drum mixing plant types. The systems obviously operate differently, with separate
generations of foamed bitumen for each batch in the former type of plant and a
continuous production of foam in the latter plant type's case.
Conventional types of bituminous mix plants shall have the following monitoring and
control systems:
Foaming systems should include integrated flow metering and pressure sensing systems for
both the binder and the water used to produce the foam.
The construction operation for WMA shall same as that prescribed for HMA and shall
be in accordance with the 1RC:111 except that the mixing, laying and rolling
temperature for WMA shall be as indicated in TABLE 11-4.;-
*In case of special conditions including but not limited to long hauls, cold paving conditions,
etc. the recommendations of the WMA technology supplier shall be followed.
Detailed specification for the technology have been brought out by Indian Roads Congress
vide IRC:SP-101-2014.
For using this technology special mixing plant are to be used. This can be batch type mixing
plant and continuous drum type plant which can be adapted to manufacture WMA. The
construction operation for WMA are same as that prescribed for WMA and will be in
accordance with IRC : 111 except that the mixing, laying and rolling temperature for WMA will
be different as indicated in IRC:SP:101-2014.
The stretches to be improved with above technology will be identified in consultation with
NHAI.
CHAPTER 12
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Preliminary cost estimate for the Project Highway has been prepared based on the
Improvement proposals. Unit rates of the work items are taken from “SCHEDULE OF
RATES for roads & Bridge works, issued by “Public Works Department, M.P. Bhopal”
in force from 29-08-2017.
The civil cost works out to Rs. 210.02 Crores. The civil cost per Km. works out to Rs
8.25 Crores.
The total project cost works out to Rs. 279.95 Crores. The project cost per Km. works
out to Rs 9.82 Crores.
The capital cost including pre-construction activities comes to Rs. 390.82 Cr. The
capital cost per Km. works out to Rs 13.70 Crores.