Bench-Top LCR Meters 2018
Bench-Top LCR Meters 2018
Bench-Top LCR Meters 2018
Welcome to the training session for the Keysight bench-top Impedance measurement
solutions available through the Keysight Distribution Channels. We will show you how
these industry leading products are some of the easiest to sell.
1
• Impedance measurement and application overview
• Fundamentals of LCR / Impedance
• LCR meters / Impedance analysis solutions from Keysight Technologies
• Useful information resources
Keysight Confidential 2
You will also see some accessories such as test fixtures and competitive information in
the impedance measurement market.
Lastly, various technical resources such as brochures and application notes will be
introduced.
2
- Have been a market leader since 1960s #1
Keysight (including our HP and Agilent heritage) has been dominant in the impedance
measurement equipment business for almost 50 years.
The LCR meters and impedance analyzers from Keysight Technologies have been
providing fast and accurate LCR and Impedance measurements across various
industries and applications from general purpose markets such as education and R&D to
high-volume manufacturing applications.
3
#1 Superior Product Performance
• Provides best-in-class accuracy and repeatability with fast
measurement speed
Complete Solution
• Widest coverage frequency range and impedance range
• Widest variety of accessories
Our solutions also have a very wide impedance measurement range, and we also
supply a wide variety of test fixtures to accommodate various kinds of components.
Keysight is considered the #1 supplier due to our product performance, broad portfolio
and application expertise.
4
W H AT I S “ I M P E D A N C E ” ?
|Z| = R2 + X2
|Z|
= tan-1(X/R)
Real axis Unit of impedance: ohm ()
R
Electrical impedance is the measure of the opposition that a circuit presents to a current when a voltage is applied. In quantitative terms, it is the complex ratio of the voltage to the current in
an alternating current (AC) circuit. Impedance extends the concept of resistance to AC circuits, and possesses both magnitude and phase, unlike resistance, which has only magnitude.
(Wikipedia)
What is impedance?
Electrical impedance is the measure of the opposition that a circuit presents to a current
when a voltage is applied.
In quantitative terms, it is the complex ratio of the voltage to the current in an (AC)
alternating current circuit. Impedance extends the concept of resistance to AC circuits,
and possesses both magnitude and phase, unlike resistance, which has only magnitude.
5
V A R I O U S P A R A M E T E R S R E L AT E D T O “ I M P E D A N C E ”
L (Inductance) C (Capacitance)
XL= 2fL = L 1 1
XC = =
: Angular frequency (= 2f)
2fC C
R jXL -jXC
R
Z R
jXL
-jXC
R Z
XL -XC 1
Q = quality factor = = D = dissipation factor =
R R Q
= tan = tan
On the other hand, when the phase is <0 deg or the reactance is negative, it is
capacitive.
The inductance and the capacitance are derived by these equations from the measured
impedance and those depend on the frequency so customers need to measure the
components at the actual operating frequencies.
When typical passive components like inductors and capacitors are measured,
customers measure the inductance or the capacitance of the components and also
measure the quality factor Q (= X/R) or the dissipation factor D (= R/X) together. These
parameters are indicators of the energy loss or the quality of the components.
The quality factor (X/R) and the dissipation factor (R/X) are both used to express the
energy loss of the device.
6
1 MHz – 0.5/ 1 / 3 GHz E4991B Impedance Analyzer
20 Hz – 2 MHz
E4980A precision LCR meter
20 Hz – 300 kHz/500 kHz/1 MHz
E4980AL precision LCR meter
120 Hz, 1 kHz, 1 MHz E4981A capacitance meter
• In Greater China and Europe, all products in the green box are distribution products
• For the Americas region, all LCR meters - with the exception of the E5061B - are
distribution products
• And in some Asian countries, the E4980AL LCR meter is the only distribution product
We will review each product in a minute, but first let’s review the target market and
applications.
Capacitor Inductor Resistor Resonator
10 pF, 1 μF, 1 kohm
etc. 20 MHz
100 nH, 1 mH,
etc.
As you can see, various types of components & devices are evaluated with respect to
impedance.
Passive components like capacitors, inductors and resistors are the most common
devices tested by LCR meters.
In addition, LCR meters are used to measure the permittivity or permeability of materials,
and capacitance over DC voltage characteristics of semiconductors. You can also
measure capacitance or inductance of part of devices or circuits with an LCR meter.
8
Component manufacturers A&D
Wireless
Medical
Capacitors Inductors, coils, ferrite beads
IoT
Resistors Cables
Automotive
Research / Education
Coils for wireless
charging circuits
Here is the ecosystem & supply chain across our target industries.
Research and component manufacturers test and provide components and materials.
Equipment suppliers buy and use these components and materials for their products.
Dielectric & liquid materials are also evaluated by the LCR meters. Note that magnetic
material measurements are not supported by LCR meters but are supported by
impedance analyzers.
Because of this ecosystem, there are many target customer profiles: R&D, high-volume
manufacturing, incoming inspection and quality assurance.
9
EXAMPLE: WIRELESS POWER TRANSFER
10
Customers can’t design quality products without evaluating the components used in their
circuits.
Those components are getting smaller, their operating frequencies higher, and in order
to maximize battery life their energy loss needs to be lower. This creates big
measurement challenges for our customers.
For example, coils are used in both transmitter and receiver circuits of wireless power
transfer devices for smart phones. Circuit designers need to measure and characterize
the inductance of the coils accurately to design a circuit that achieves efficient power
transfer.
10
Customer type: Electronic Equipment
Manufacturing
Typical installed-base…
4263B 4284A
HP/Agilent
11
Most companies check samples of passive components that they purchase from
vendors. They do this to make sure the components meet specification for use in their
product.
They often compare those result with the vendor’s data sheet, which in many cases
means that the end users and the component vendors use the same measurement
equipment for good data correlation.
You may find sales opportunities within materials or production engineering, or within
R&D sections that investigate purchased components.
11
Customer type: University, Lab, Component Manufacturer.
Typical installed-base…
http://web.ysu.edu/gen/stem/POEM_Faculty_m1787.htm
l
4284A 4192A
HP/Agilent
12
12
Customer type: Component manufacturers
Typical installed-base…
HP/Agilent
13
Component manufacturers use LCR meters for component production test due to the
high speed and good price of LCR Meters compared to other test equipment.
For high volume manufacturing applications, LCR meters are mounted on component
test machines equipped with component handlers for high test-throughput.
These component manufactures also use LCR meters for quality check and
troubleshooting in their quality assurance section.
13
Handheld LCR Meters Benchtop LCR Meters Impedance Analyzers
Spot frequencies Spot frequencies Swept frequency
Numeric data display Numeric data display Graphical display (traces and channels)
Troubleshooting in manufacturing test More application specific, General purpose,
or quick incoming inspection High volume manufacturing test, Component /circuit design, (R&D),
Incoming inspection, research/LAB, LF Research/LAB, LF/RF materials
materials
Less accurate Most accurate / high speed Most accurate
Less functionality and focus on Focus on speed and accuracy Many analysis functions for detail
portability evaluation of DUT characteristics
No compensation function Open/short/load compensation Open/short/load compensation
Very low price Affordable price More expensive but more functions like
markers and equivalent circuit analysis
Clip and Tweezers type only Various test fixtures Most test fixture selections
14
Here are the key differences between impedance analyzers and LCR meters.
The big advantages of LCR meters are price and speed. LCR meters are used by cost-
conscious customers primarily in production applications.
14
Key Specs and Prices
❑ –– Starting at $167
❑ –– DC/100/120/1k/10k/100kHz (depending on model)
❑ –– 0.2% basic impedance accuracy
Why Buys
❑ The portability and the low price best suit quick impedance check for
troubleshooting
Markets / Applications
❑ Troubleshooting in manufacturing test
❑ Quick incoming inspection of passive components
Model Measurement parameters Frequency Price
U1701B C DC $ 167
Keysight Confidential 15
The U1700 series of versatile handheld LCR meters come with various impedance
measurement functions and several spot test frequencies up to 100 kHz.
These handheld LCR meters are available at very low prices and are an ideal tool for
quick incoming inspection of passive components, and troubleshooting in electronic
device manufacturing applications.
15
Key drivers
$16k ~ $33k – Frequency range
E4982A LCR Meter 1 MHz to 300M/500M/1G/3 GHz – Accuracy
• An industrial standard for RF impedance measurements up to 3 GHz
– Measurement
• Target applications – passive components parameters
RF Manufacturing • Target customers – manufacturing – Test Fixtures
• Migration opportunities – 4286A, 4287A
$4.2k ~ $18k E4980AL/A Precision LCR Meter 20 Hz to 300 kHz, 500 kHz, 1 MHz / 2 MHz
• A new standard for LF impedance measurements up to 2 MHz
• Target applications – passive components, semiconductors, MEMS, materials
• Target customers – R&D, manufacturing, QA, incoming inspection
General purpose
• Migration opportunities – 4284A, 4263B
Keysight Confidential 16
Here is a high level summary of target markets and applications for the benchtop LCR meters.
The E4982A is a higher frequency version of the LCR meter. It is positioned as an industry
standard for RF component test. RF inductors test in production is one of the typical applications.
Customers can easily migrate from the older 4286A and 4287A RF LCR meters, to the E4982A .
The E4980A/AL are Keysight’s main models of LCR meter and are considered by many to be
the industry standard. Target applications are Low Frequency (LF) component evaluation and
test. Look for migration opportunities where customer have an installed base old LCR meters
such as the 4284A and the 4263B. The E4980AL starts at just four thousand USD making it a
perfect 4263B replacement.
The E4981A is a dedicated high-speed capacitor measurement instrument for high volume
ceramic capacitor manufacturing test.
The selection guide and the accessories catalog help you to select the right products and test
fixtures for your customer’s applications.
Key Specs and Prices
❑ Starting at $16k
❑ Four frequency options: 1 MHz to 300 MHz / 500 MHz / 1 GHz / 3 GHz, (upgradable)
❑ High-speed measurement: 0.9 ms (Mode 1), 2.1 ms (Mode 2), 3.7 ms (Mode 3)
❑ 0.8% basic accuracy with unparalleled measurement repeatability
❑ Wide impedance measurement range from 140 mΩ to 4.8 kΩ
❑ Measurement parameters: Z, Y, Theta, R, X, G, B, C, L, D, Q, Rdc
“Why Buys”
❑ It provides the best performance for RF passive component measurements for better quality
circuit design or production efficiency.
Markets / Applications
❑ Wireless / component manufacturers
❑ SMD inductors, EMI filters, and RF capacitors
❑ Production, R&D, QA, and Incoming Inspection
❑ 4287A installed-base customers
Keysight Confidential 17
One of the biggest potential customers for the E4982A are those that have a
installed base of the old 3GHz LCR meters: the 4286A and the 4287A. The
E4982A is fully compatible with the 4287A for drop-in replacements.
Similar to the E4980AL, there are some frequency breaks for cost conscious
customers, and its frequency range is upgradable.
17
Key Specs and Prices
❑ Starting at $4k
❑ 20 Hz to 300 kHz/500 kHz/1 MHz (E4980AL) upgradable, 20 Hz to 2 MHz (E4980A)
❑ 0.05% basic impedance accuracy
❑ Widest impedance measurement range: 4 mohms to 100 Mohms
❑ Fast measurements: 5.6 msec (E4980A), 12 msec (E4980AL)
❑ 16 impedance measurement parameters
❑ 201-point programmable list sweep
❑ Materials measurements with the N1500A-006 Materials Measurement Suite
❑ Test signal/DC bias enhancement: 20 Vrms test signal, 40 V DC bias (E4980A w/opt 001)
“Why Buys”
❑ The E4980A/AL precision LCR meters provide the industry-leading combination of accuracy, speed,
versatility and upgradability, and support a large selection of accessories for a wide variety of applications.
Markets / Applications
❑ component manufacturers, wireless, automotive, A&D, medical, IoT, research and education
❑ Capacitors, inductors, resisters, cables, materials, MEMS, semiconductors
❑ 4263B/4284A installed-base customers
Keysight Confidential 18
With the E4980A/AL you can grow business with new customers and new
applications, but you can also replace old LCR meters such as the 4263B and
the 4284A at installed-base customers.
18
Key Specs and Prices
❑ Starting at $7k
❑ 120 Hz/1 kHz /1 MHz
❑ High-speed measurement: 2.3 ms (1 MHz), 3.0 ms (1 kHz), 11.0 ms (120 Hz)
More than two times faster than the 4268A or the 4288A
❑ Accurate C-D testing: 0.07%, 0.0005
“Why Buys”
❑ It achieves the highest test throughput for ceramic capacitor manufacturers.
Markets / Applications
❑ High-volume capacitor manufacturer
❑ 4268A/4288A installed-base customers
Keysight Confidential 19
19
Key Specs and Prices
❑ NA (w/option 3L3/4/5) + ZA (w/opt 005)
❑ Starting at $29k
❑ Three frequency options: 5 Hz to 500 MHz / 1.5 GHz / 3 GHz (upgradable)
❑ S-parameter test port (5 Hz to 3 GHz, 50Ω)
❑ Gain-phase test port (5 Hz to 30 MHz, 1 Mohms / 50 ohms)
❑ Wide dynamic range (very low impedance) down to LF
❑ Built-in DC bias source (up to ±40 Vdc, max 100 mAdc, swept)
❑ Equivalent Circuit Analysis
“Why Buys”
❑ It gives both network analyzer and impedance analyzer functions for various
component characterization.
Markets / Applications
❑ Wireless / component manufacturers
❑ Power Integrity, EMC component test.
❑ R&D
❑ LF NA or NA/ZA combo installed-base customers
Keysight Confidential 20
Another solution option is the E5061B with option 3Lx and 005.
It has the benefit of being able to do both impedance and network analyzer
measurements with three frequency options: 500 MHz, 1.5 GHz and 3 GHz.
Target customers are R&D in various industries, and the key application is the
characterization of components used in Low Frequency & RF circuits. It has
unique test ports called gain-phase ports up to 30 MHz that provide better
impedance measurement capabilities than the regular S-parameter
measurement ports. The gain-phase test ports are used for unique
applications such as component test of the power circuit section of electronic
equipment. The application is called Power Integrity which we’ll discuss later in
this course.
Let’s not forget that this product also includes other impedance analyzer
functions such as Equivalent Circuit Analysis.
20
: LF NA application : RF NA application
Keysight Confidential 21
Now let’s look at the target applications of the E5061B w/opt 3Lx and 005
by industry.
As you can see it has a very wide frequency range from 5 Hz to 3 GHz,
and covers a variety of applications and industries: Aerospace and
Defense, medical and automotive, and many more.
This product can also be used to test components used in low frequency
sensors across industries. Car backup sensors and keyless entry remotes
are typical automotive applications.
✓
S-parameters
MHz to GHz range Filters
Wide dynamic range at LF Antennas
Transceivers
DC-biased measurement
Sensor signals
✓ A/D
Low/mid speed data bus
(CAN, FlexRay, etc)
LF amplifiers
Freq. responses,
✓ MPUs/
MCUs
Transceivers
✓
Freq. resp. & impedance Wide dynamic
Oscillator 100 kHz to MHz range
CMRR, & PSRR
circuits range at MHz range
near-DC to 100 MHz
Freq. resp.(loop
✓
gain)
MHz range DC-DC
(POL/VRM)
Loop gain, Wide dynamic range at LF
milliohm-impedance, & S21 DC-DC converters
near-DC to GHz
5 Hz to 3 GHz in single sweep
PDNs (Power Delivery Networks)
Enables evaluating various components & circuits from near-DC to GHz range.
→ Improves reliability of equipment.
Keysight Confidential 22
Because of the wide frequency range from 5Hz to 3 GHz and the impedance analyzer
and network analyzer combo, the E5061B can measure many different components
used in various sections of electronic equipment.
This is why the E5061B is well accepted in a variety of industries and applications.
22
Impedance and S21 measurements of PCB power planes (=PDNs: Power delivery networks)
S21 plot
S21 plot
R & T=
50 ohm Zdut
Power
Zdut splitter
|Z| plot with Trans-shunt Z-conversion |Z| plot with Trans-shunt Z-conversion
20 mohm 50 mohm
5 mohm 20 mohm
10 Hz 10 MHz
1 kHz 1 GHz
Keysight Confidential 23
24
24
NA
-3 Vdc +3 Vdc
The E5061B-3Lx and option 005 has a full set of impedance analysis
functions just the same as impedance analyzers do.
The dynamic range of the ENA is not as good as the LCR meters, but it
offers three different impedance measurement methods: reflection,
series-thru and shunt-thru to cover a wide impedance measurement
range.
It also has a DC voltage bias function. Here the graph at the bottom of
this slide shows the capacitance variation of a capacitor against DC bias voltage.
25
Circuit Equivalent Typical DUTs Typical
Convenient design verification tool models circuit frequency
for efficient circuit/component models responses
design Inductors with
A high core loss
Inductors
B Resistors
Procedure: High-value
(1) Measure a component. C resistors
(2) Select the right circuit model from A thru E
Capacitors
(3) Extract the R, L and C values from the D
measurement data
(4) Check how the circuit model matches the Resonators
E
actual component.
Keysight Confidential 26
The E5061B-3Lx and option 005 also has an equivalent circuit analysis function, which
can extract the R1, C1, L1 and Co values of a selected circuit model from the
measurement data, whilst showing both the actual measurement data and the simulated
result with the extracted parameters. This helps customers to improve circuit/component
design efficiency.
26
W I D E V A R I E T Y O F F I X T U R E S C O V E R V A R I O U S A P P L I C AT I O N S
Keysight Confidential 27
Keysight has been providing test fixtures to accommodate various applications and type
and size of device under test for many years.
By using Keysight proprietary fixtures and accessories with Keysight equipment, you get
the most stable, repeatable and accurate impedance measurements available today.
TOP SELLING TEST FIXTURES
28
Keysight Confidential
These are the top 3 fixtures for impedance measurement instruments such as the
E4980A LCR meter.
As you can imagine, we can accommodate various kinds and sizes of DUTs including
leaded, SMDs and so on.
U1700 series E4980A E4980AL E4981A E4982A E5061B-3Lx/005
Bench-top Impedance
Type HandHeld Bench-top LCR meters
analyzer
DC/100/120/1 k/10 120 Hz and 1 kHz
20 Hz to 300 k / 1 MHz to 300 M/ 5 Hz to 500 M /1.5 G/
Frequency k/100 kHz (depending 20 Hz to 2 MHz + 1 MHz (w/opt
500 k/ 1 MHz 500 M/ 1 G/3 GHz 3 GHz
on each model) 001)
$18k
Pricing $167 to $445 $4k - $9k $7k - $12k $16k - $34k $29k - $38k
$20k w/ opt 001
1.5 or 2V (Std)
DC Bias No 1.5 or 2 V (Std) No No +/- 40 V
+/- 40V (opt.001)
Network
No No No No No Yes
Analysis
Equivalent
No No No No No Yes
Circuit Analysis
Middle-to-low end
High-end component High volume RF
component suppliers High volume PC, automotive, wireless
Customers manufacturers suppliers inductor/capacitor
Product integrators capacitor mfrs equipment mfrs
Semiconductor mfrs manufacturers
Research / Education
Component standard Component
Troubleshooting in Component
Component test characterization for
manufacturing test or Test in production evaluation
characterization Component evaluation Power Distribution
Applications quick incoming Component QA Test in production
Component QA testing Network, EMC, MEMS
inspection testing Component QA
Wafer C-V test / MEMS Material sensors etc.
testing
measurements
Keysight Confidential 29
This gives a brief comparison summary between the LCR meters and the ENA
with the impedance measurement option.
As I mentioned earlier, the ENA has the widest frequency range and can perform
both impedance measurement and S-parameter measurement making it a
combination analyzer. Although the impedance measurement accuracy is typical
data only, it has impedance analyzer functions such as equivalent circuit analysis
for modeling the Device Under Test.
The E4980A and AL are the primary models of the LCR meter due to their price
and functionality. The E4980A with option 001 enhances AC/DC voltage and
current ranges to meet various test conditions.
29
Tonghui
Chroma
Hioki
IET
Hameg
Wayne Kerr
GW Instek
Keysight Confidential 30
The good news is that there is no competitor for the E5061B ENA with the impedance
measurement function. When you find an opportunity, you can easily win the sale!
There are several competitors for the LCR meters, mainly in Asia - Hioki being our
biggest competitor.
We will not go into detail on the competition in this module. If you see one of these
competitors and need competitive information, please contact Keysight.
30
To identify the right solution, you need to ask the customer these
questions.
31
… then refer to the reference documents and literature shown on the next slide to find
the right solution.
31
Selection Guide Accessories Catalog for
Impedance Measurement Handbook
http://literature.cdn.keysight.com/litweb/pdf/5952-
impedance measurements http://literature.cdn.keysight.com/litweb/pdf/5950-3000.pdf
http://literature.cdn.keysight.com/litweb/pdf/5965-4792E.pdf
1430E.pdf
32
Here are the most important references for impedance measurements: the selection
guide, the accessories catalog for impedance measurements, and the impedance
measurement handbook.
We recommend that you use these references every time you see an impedance
measurement application opportunity.
32
E4980A/AL E4981A
Product page Product page
www.keysight.com/find/e4980a
www.keysight.com/find/e4981a
www.keysight.com/find/e4980al
Data sheet
Data sheet http://literature.cdn.keysight.com/litweb/pdf/5989-8963EN.pdf
http://literature.cdn.keysight.com/litweb/pdf/5989-4435EN.pdf
Brochure
Brochure http://literature.cdn.keysight.com/litweb/pdf/5989-8964EN.pdf
http://literature.cdn.keysight.com/litweb/pdf/5989-4235EN.pdf
http://literature.cdn.keysight.com/litweb/pdf/5991-2305EN.pdf
Product fact sheet
http://literature.cdn.keysight.com/litweb/pdf/5990-4793EN.pdf
http://literature.cdn.keysight.com/litweb/pdf/5991-2307EN.pdf
E4982A
Product page
www.keysight.com/find/e4982a
Data sheet
http://literature.cdn.keysight.com/litweb/pdf/5990-9882EN.pdf
Brochure
http://literature.cdn.keysight.com/litweb/pdf/5990-9911EN.pdf
Product fact sheet
http://literature.cdn.keysight.com/litweb/pdf/5991-0095EN.pdf
33
And don’t forget the vast array of reference materials available for the LCR meters:
including datasheets, product brochures, product introduction information, and
Application Notes.
33
• Product page
www.keysight.com/find/e5061b
• Sales literature
• Technical Overview (5990-4390EN)
http://literature.cdn.keysight.com/litweb/pdf/5990-4390EN.pdf
• Brochure (5950-6794EN)
http://literature.cdn.keysight.com/litweb/pdf/5990-6794EN.pdf
• Application note
• Measuring Frequency Response with the LF Network Analyzer (5989-9799EN)
http://literature.cdn.keysight.com/litweb/pdf/5990-5578EN.pdf
• Evaluating DC-DC Converters with LF Network Analyzer (5989-8036EN)
http://literature.cdn.keysight.com/litweb/pdf/5990-5902EN.pdf
Keysight Confidential 34
Similarly, here is the list of literature and references for the E5061B ENA network
analyzer (with impedance measurement function).
#1 >50
Years Best-in-class, complete solution, & best expertise
Keysight Confidential 35
Keysight provides expertise and a range of best-in-class tools for your customers’ impedance
measurement needs.
The ecosystem for electronic components gives you a many sales opportunities in various
applications across multiple industries.
The E4980A/AL precision LCR meters provide the best combination of accuracy, speed, and
versatility and go up to 2 MHz.
The E4981A Capacitance Meter achieves very fast capacitance measurements for high volume
manufacturing of ceramic capacitors.
The E5061B with the impedance measurement option is a combination network and impedance
analyzer making R&D engineer’s circuit and component design more efficient.
The portable handheld LCR meters are a good tool for quick troubleshooting in manufacturing.
35
Thank You!
36
Thank you for attending this course. Please remember to take the quiz, then go sell LCR
meters!
36