Compression Moulding Process - An Overview Ijariie11168

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 10

Vol-5 Issue-6 2019 IJARIIE-ISSN(O)-2395-4396

Compression Moulding Process – An Overview


Mayuresh Nitin Madiwale

BE Student, Department of Mechanical Engineering, LGNSCOE, Nashik, Maharashtra, India

ABSTRACT
Known as one of the oldest plastic processing methods, compression moulding (CM) is widely used in plastic
processing plants due to its advantages which are lesser seen in other methods. Though injection moulding is the
most widely used process, it lacks in some properties which can be achieved in compression moulding. This process
is used to give a desired shape to the plastic with the use of high temperature and pressure. It can be used for
thermoplastics as well as for thermosetting. In plastics, Thermosets and composite plastics have low melt flow index
and the fact that they require high pressure to cure, compression moulding is most common process selected. The
finished product from compression moulding is seen to be tough and hard to sustain various loads applied and the
surface can be made smooth as per requirement. The scrap produced (flash) is lesser than injection moulding
(runners and gates produced during the process). The process setup includes the plastic preform (either powder or
tablets) is usually preheated is placed in the heated mould cavity. Heating of mould is done to catalyze the curing
reaction. Pressure is then applied with help of a power press for a certain period of time known as curing time. The
part thus takes the shape of mould cavity and is then ejected from the mould with ejector system. For an optimum
utilization of this process, various parameters are to be controlled such as part geometry, part material, mould
quality, mould temperature, curing time, clamping pressure, breathe cycle, preheating and charge quantity. This
paper covers a brief overview of the compression moulding process followed by the controlling process parameters.

Keyword: - Compression Moulding, Thermoplastics, Thermosets, process parameters, curing, breathe cycle

1. INRODUCTION-
Compression molding is among the oldest materials processing techniques. In commercial use, compression
moulding is the most simple and reliable process. Due to its simplicity and availability, it is most widely used
process. Product areas are lighting and electrical devices, closures, transportation, and appliances. Specific items are
electrical wall switch plates and receptacles, circuit breakers, bottle caps, buttons, packaging, containers, covers,
protective helmets, pump components, gears, brake parts, frames, pulleys, vehicle panels, dishware, and appliance
housings, bases, handles, and knobs. [1].

1.1 Nomenclature of Compression Moulding Process

Compression moulding process require following components:-

1. Component raw material

The material needed to be molded in cavity is required with preprocessing done. Pre-procedures like
preheating, addition of any binding agents or reinforcement. Raw material may come in form of powders,
resins, sheets or granules. These materials are then needed to be processed before placing them in cavity.
Some plastic materials are mixed with binding agents and reinforcements like fibre, or with some other
plastics to make a composite. Powders are needed to be tablated in a tablating machine, as this improves
the performance and helps to preserve the powder for a long period of time.

11168 www.ijariie.com 1615


Vol-5 Issue-6 2019 IJARIIE-ISSN(O)-2395-4396

Fig 1 Moulding powder. Fig 2 Preform

2. Mould with desired shaped cavity

A precise and accurate mould is the key element for this process. The mould should be able to withstand
tremendous pressure. It should posses following properties:-
 Accuracy and precision – the punch and cavity inserts should meet high accuracy and precision.
 Strength – the mould should sustain the working pressure and it would be better if it work hardens.
 Reliability – it should be reliable for mass productions.
 Alignment – the alignment between the punch – cavity, support pillars – bushings, ejector pins
holes should be proper.
 Surface finish – the surface of the punch and cavity should be super finished to achieve the part
surface smooth.
 Coating/plating – the punch and cavity surface should be coated or plated with a harder material to
reduce wear and tear,
 Hardening – the plates of mould should be hardened to be immune to scratches and wear occurred
while regular operation.
 Cost – it should be available at lower costs.

Fig 3 General construction of mould

11168 www.ijariie.com 1616


Vol-5 Issue-6 2019 IJARIIE-ISSN(O)-2395-4396

3. Moulding machine

The machine is the fundamental element of this process. A compression moulding machine is similar to a
power press except power press have a fast operation and do not stay for more time at stroke. CM machines
stay for a predetermined time when actuated. It is more similar to a UTM machine.

Fig 4 Compression moulding machine

1.2 Process Flow

The process takes place in following steps,

Step-1. Heating the mould

The mould is heated to a certain temperature as per the plastic raw material requirement. Usually the raw material
manufacturer suggests the mould temperature. e.g.- for single stage and two stage phenolic moulding compounds,
PLENCO suggests the Mold Temperatures should be 165° - 182°C (330° - 360°F).[2]

Step-2. Preheating the plastic

The material can be Sheet Moulding Compound (SMC), Bulk Moulding Compound (BMC), Thick Moulding
Compound (TMC) or the material can either be granulated powder or a preform tablet. Preheating is done in a small
convection heater. The raw material is preheated to a certain temperature for two main reasons:-

 To remove moisture content as thermoset powder has tendency to absorb moisture from air.
 To reduce the curing time required by material in the mould cavity

Step-3. Placing the plastic in the cavity and mould closing

The preheated plastic is then placed into the mould cavity followed by closing the mould halves together. After
closing the mould, breathe cycle is introduced to remove any air bubbles trapped inside. The pressure and
temperature is then held for some period of time

11168 www.ijariie.com 1617


Vol-5 Issue-6 2019 IJARIIE-ISSN(O)-2395-4396

Step-4. Curing reaction

Curing is a chemical process employed in polymer chemistry and process engineering that produces the toughening
or hardening of a polymer material by cross-linking of polymer chains. Even if it is strongly associated with the
production of thermosetting polymers, the term curing can be used for all the processes where starting from a liquid
solution, a solid product is obtained. [3]

Step-5. Mould opening and Ejection

After the plastic is cured, the part can be removed from the mould. To remove the part, ejection system is employed.
The mould has ejector pins and ejector plates assembled on both halves below the cavity and punch back plates. The
plates push the ejector pins which remove the part from cavity.

Step-6. Cleaning of mould

After the ejection, cycle is completed. For next cycle, mould has to be cleaned to remove any dirt, dust, flash from
the cavity and punch surface. The cleaning can be done by wiping off with a cloth or by blowing pressurized air on
the surface.

Fig 5 Stepwise procedure of CM process

1.3 Process Parameters

Following parameters should b controlled in compression moulding process:-

I. Part Geometry

The part to be molded should have a specific shape and size. Bigger the part, bigger the mould has to be
made and higher the pressure requirement. The design should be correct and satisfying the need of
application. Poor design leads to poor performance. CM cannot handle very intricate designs, thus part
should be designed accordingly.

II. Shot Size

The amount of raw material required for a part is known as shot size. It is determined from the weight of
part required. Shot size is oftenly taken a bit more than the requirement to ensure complete filling of cavity.
Flashes (scrap) are expected in final part as it indicates complete filling of cavity. It is oftenly considered
by trial and error basis. Low shot size leads to incomplete filling of cavity.

III. Part Material

While selecting the process, part material is the main factor. Viscosity of plastic is deciding factor. Very
viscous plastics are harder to compress and require high pressure and temperature. Melt Flow Index is the
factor considered in plastics, it is the test done on plastics to determine the viscosity when plastic is melted.
The test consists of melting of the plastic in a small cylinder covered with heater element. Then the piston

11168 www.ijariie.com 1618


Vol-5 Issue-6 2019 IJARIIE-ISSN(O)-2395-4396

pushes the plastic after melting as a predetermined weight is placed above it. after some time weight of
displaced plastic is taken and MFI is calculated. Depending on the Melt Flow Index, the plastics can be
classified as:-

1. Low melt flow index

These plastics have low viscosity and hence have less fluidity. These require severe pressure to
flow and cover each and every corner of the mould cavity. For these plastics use of compression
moulding is must as it is best suitable process

2. Medium melt flow index

These types of plastics have medium fluidity. They may or may not be processed by compression
moulding method. These have a medium viscosity and do not require high pressures and
temperatures.

3. High melt flow index

These have a great fluidity and lowest viscosity amongst above. Injection moulding is best suitable
for these plastics and requires lowest time to cover mould cavity. Cycle time is usually lower of
these plastics.

Apart from Melt Flow Index, the type of plastic is also necessary. Whether the plastic is a thermoplastic,
thermoset or a composite of plastic and some kind of additive and reinforcement (fibre matrix) is also a
question discussed while selecting the process.

IV. Mould Quality

In order to achieve a smooth finish on the part, the cavity surface should be super finished and coated with
a hard material to reduce its wear and tear. The mould should pass the overall quality parameters like
alignment, strength, stress concentration, fits, limits, tolerances and allowances should be considered with
high accuracy. The mould should be made of optimum quality material according to international standards
like HASCO, DME, DMS, DESOUTTER, UDDFORM, etc. coating/plating should be done to reduce wear
and tear.

V. Mould Material

CM process involves use of high pressure presses. To sustain this pressure, heavy duty metals are used.
There are many metals from which moulds can be made. Preferably materials like P 20 steel, S 7 steel, AI
QC7 and AI7075 are used. [4]

Fig 6 Metals used in moulds and their properties.

11168 www.ijariie.com 1619


Vol-5 Issue-6 2019 IJARIIE-ISSN(O)-2395-4396

VI. Temperature Control

1) Mould Heating

In compression moulding, mostly used plastics are thermosets. These require heating provision to cure
unlike thermoplastics which require cooling for solidification. To heat the mould, various types of heaters
can be used. Following are some types of heating systems which can be employed [5]:-

1. Heating and cooling channels (flowing oil or water)


2. Jet impingement (heating by flame)
3. Infrared heaters
4. Inductive heating
5. Resistance heating
6. Cartridge heaters
7. Surface heaters
8. Ceramic heaters
9. Carbon fibre heating layer

2) Preheating

The thermosets are required to be preheated before placing into the mould. This helps in many ways.
Preheating is done to achieve following advantages [6]:-

1. Reduced the cycle time.


2. More fluidity to get inside difficult corners than with cold preform
3. Reduced moisture content absorbed by material. Moisture is unwanted in plastic

VII. Clamping Pressure

Clamping pressure is the pressure exerted by the press in order to squeeze the plastic to cover the mould
cavity. The machine needs to force the plastic to each and every corner of cavity to acquire the desired
shape and size. The pressure should be specifically calculated such that it should not be too high or too low.
Too high pressure will start to damage the mould and results in severe wear and tear. Too low pressure on
the other hand, will result in improper filling of cavity and inaccurate thickness and depth of the part. As
per PLENCO, the formula of clamping pressure is as follows [7],

Clamping pressure required = area of part at parting line * effective pressure required by material
e.g.:- for circular part,

Clamp pressure required (in tonnes) = R² * π * T/in²

Where,
R = radius of the part at parting line (inches)
T/in²:- Effective tonnage required by material

Sample problem: -
Find the tonnage required for a part measuring 76mm in diameter made of Bakelite with effective pressure
of 3 T/in². The mould has 4 nos of cavities. Assume Factor of Safety of 10%.

Given: - D = 76mm, ∴ R = 36mm ≈ 1.4960 in


∴ 84.3712 tonnes + 10%
T/in² = 3
∴ 84.3712 + 8.43712
n=4
FOS = 10% = 92.8090 tonnes

Solution: - 1.4960² * π * 3 * 4
∴21.0928 * 4

11168 www.ijariie.com 1620


Vol-5 Issue-6 2019 IJARIIE-ISSN(O)-2395-4396

Therefore, the pressure requirement of machine to mould the parts is 92.8090 tonnes. As standard
machines are available in market, a 100 ton machine would be suitable for moulding.

VIII. Curing Time

Curing time is the time taken by plastic to completely solidify and harden. The word curing is used for
thermosets only as these plastics go through an irreversible chemical reaction. While for the thermoplastics,
process is reversible as they solidify when cooled and melt when heat is provided. Thermoset curing can
vary according to size and materials. According to size, curing can take anywhere from few seconds for
small sizes to an hour for large sizes. According to thermoset materials, curing time varies based on the
chemical composition.

IX. Breathe Cycle

When the pressure s fully applied and the mould closes completely, there are chances of blow holes
creating inside the cavity. This can ruin the surface of part also the cavity may or may not be filled
completely. To eliminate this, breathe cycle is introduced. Breathe cycle is nothing but just a degassing
phase added to cycle time before completely applying the pressure. This removes any vapour, air, gas
trapped inside the cavity. The breathe cycle is almost always used with phenolics and other formaldehyde
molding compounds, and mostly in compression molding [8].

Fig 7 Breathe cycle

X. Shrinkage

After ejection of part from mould, it has a tendency to shrink. Due to this, the final part may differ than
intended dimensions. To eliminate this, a shrinkage allowance is considered in manufacturing of the mould.
Dimensions of cavity are taken more than the actual design.
e.g.:- shrinkage of two stage phenolic compression moulding compound “04349” is 0.0026 m/m [9]

2. ADVANTAGES

Compression moulding comes with some good advantages. Some advantages are enlisted below:-

1. Low running cost.


2. Good dimensional stability.
3. Density of part is uniform.
4. Shrinkage of part is uniform throughout.
5. No degradation of fibers during flow of plastic.

11168 www.ijariie.com 1621


Vol-5 Issue-6 2019 IJARIIE-ISSN(O)-2395-4396

6. Great impact strength of part.


7. Uniform flow of plastic in entire cavity.
8. Warping and internal stresses are minimal.
9. Shorter lead time.

3. DISADVANTAGES

Compression moulding has some disadvantages too. Some of them are as enlisted below:-

1. Initial cost is high.


2. Uneven parting lines are available.
3. Flash (scrap) produced cannot be recycled.
4. High cycle time as curing time is more.
5. Not suitable for complex parts as material may not flow in intricate gaps.

4. APPLICATIONS

Compression moulding is still used widely in following applications

1. Dinnerware like plates, bowls are made of melamine by compression moulding process.
2. Handles of utensils like cookers, pans are made using CM process.
3. In earlier times, door knobs were made with this process.
4. Television, telephone housings.
5. Radio housings.
6. Electrical parts like switches, switch boards, insulators.
7. Body and interior panels of cars, vans, etc.

5. PROBLEMS OCCURING IN COMPRESSION MOULDING PROCESS

While performing the process, there can be some issues regarding the part. Following problems can occur if the
processing parameters are not followed correctly as per PLENCO. [10]

1. Bulge on opposite side of insert.


2. Cure blister
3. Dull appearance
4. Excessive flash
5. Flow lines
6. Procure or hard spots
7. Mould stains
8. Mottled surface appearance
9. Short shot
10. Orange peel
11. Shrinkage
12. Sink marks
13. Skin blisters
14. Sticking in mould
15. Burn mark
16. Warpage

6. CONCLUSIONS

The compression moulding process is one of the non-conventional processes in plastic engineering sector. The
process is most suitable for low melt flow thermosets. The parts can possess great surface finish and strength with
less warpage. The fiber degradation during flow is minimal with great dimensional stability. The density and
shrinkage throughout is uniform. The process can perform best if following parameters are controlled.

11168 www.ijariie.com 1622


Vol-5 Issue-6 2019 IJARIIE-ISSN(O)-2395-4396

1. Part geometry – a good design leads to a good product.


2. Shot size – to properly fill the cavity, proper shot size is necessary. To be taken a bit more than part weight.
3. Part material – proper selection of process depends on part material.
4. Mould quality – ensure optimum quality mould is used to get optimum quality part.
5. Mould material – strong mould lasts longer and gives appropriate part quality.
6. Temperature control – mould heating and plastic preheating should be done properly.
7. Clamping pressure – pressure to mould should be calculated properly to avoid improper part thickness.
8. Curing time – mould holding time depends on curing time. Complete solidification requires proper time.
9. Breathe cycle – to avoid blow holes and air gaps, breathe cycle should be employed.
10. Shrinkage – plastic shrinks after cooling, proper allowances should be considered in mould manufacturing.

7. REFERENCES

[1]. Robert A. Tatara, 14 - Compression Molding, Editor(s): Myer Kutz, In Plastics Design Library, Applied Plastics
Engineering Handbook (Second Edition), William Andrew Publishing, 2017, Pages 291-320, ISBN 9780323390408

[2]. Plastic Engineering Company, “Compression Molding Guidelines for Preheat Molding of PLENCO Single
Stage & Two Stage Phenolic Molding Compounds”. https://www.plenco.com/tips/compsstips.html

[3]. Pham, Ha Q.; Marks, Maurice J. (2012). "Epoxy Resins", Ullmann's Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry
Weinheim: Wiley-VCH. Doi:10.1002/14356007.a09_547.pub2.

[4] Vinoth Kumar Dhananjayan, “Design and Analysis of a Compression Molded Carbon Composite Wheel
Center”, the University Of Texas at Arlington May 2013

[5]. T Oppelt, J Schulze, H Stein, and B Platzer, “Comparison of methods for mould surface heating – Part 1:
Review”, Smithers Rapra Technology, Gummi Fasern Kunststoffe, No. 8, 2012, pp. 518–523

[6] Plastic Engineering Company, “Preforming & Preheating”,


https://www.plenco.com/plenco_processing_guide/Sect%2014%20Preforming%20&%20Preheating

[7] Plastic Engineering Company “Cold Powder Compression Molding Startup Procedure for Phenolic & Melamine-
Phenolic Molding Compounds”.
https://www.plenco.com/plenco_processing_guide/Sect%2015%20Cold%20Powder%20Compression%20Setup

[8] Dominick V. Rosato, Donald V. Rosato, “Injection Molding Handbook”, CBS Publishers & Distributors, ISBN
8123913648, 9788123913643, year – 2000

[9] Plastic Engineering Company,” Materials Engineering Laboratory Data Report for Plenco 04349 Compression
Molding Compound”, https://www.plenco.com/data/04349c

[10] Plastic Engineering Company, “Philosophy of Troubleshooting Compression Molding Problems”,


https://www.plenco.com/plenco_processing_guide/Sect%2018%20Compression%20Troubleshooting%20Guide

Image sources:-

[1] Fig 4
https://www.prm-
taiwan.com/F0010/S0122/product_i_SINGLE_BODY_OIL_HYDRAULIC_COMPRESSION_MOLDING_MACH
INE_FC_SERIES.html

[2] Fig 6 Dominick V. Rosato, Donald V. Rosato, Matthew V. Rosato, “Plastic Product Material and Process
Selection Handbook”, Publisher: Elsevier Science & Technology Books, ISBN: 185617431X, Pub. Date: September
2004, page no 514.

11168 www.ijariie.com 1623


Vol-5 Issue-6 2019 IJARIIE-ISSN(O)-2395-4396

[3] Fig 7 Charles A. Harper, “Handbook Of Plastic Processes”, Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken,
New Jersey, ISBN-13: 978-0-471-66255-6 (cloth) ISBN-10: 0-471-66255-0, page no 459

BIOGRAPHY

Mayuresh Nitin Madiwale

BE student, Department of Mechanical Engineering,


Lt. G. N. Sapkal College of Engineering,
Savitribai Phule Pune University (SPPU),

11168 www.ijariie.com 1624

You might also like