State of Piracy 2019
State of Piracy 2019
State of Piracy 2019
2019
REPORT
Citation:
The State of Maritime Piracy 2019, One Earth Future, Broomfield CO, USA 2020
ENDNOTES................................................................................................... 30
THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019 | v
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
• IN 2019, THE GULF OF GUINEA REMAINED THE AREA WORST AFFECTED BY PIRACY AND MARITIME
ROBBERY OF VESSELS WORLDWIDE. Although the number of incidents decreased from 2018, a 60 percent increase
in the number of crew members kidnapped was reported in 2019, with a total of 164.
• The Yemeni-flagged fishing dhow Al Azham was hijacked to be used as a mothership in an attack on fishing vessels off
the coast of Somalia in April 2019. EUNAVFOR intercepted the hijacked dhow, arrested the pirates, and released the 23
hostages onboard. The hijacking underlined that THE THREAT OF PIRACY OFF SOMALIA IS NOT ERADICATED,
ONLY SUPPRESSED.
• THE NUMBER OF INCIDENTS IN LATIN AMERICA AND THE CARIBBEAN REMAINED THE SAME IN 2019 AS IN
2018. Violent kidnapping and armed robbery incidents against fishing vessels, yachts, and a cargo vessel were reported
in Guyana, Trinidad, and Panama, and included the murders of four fishermen and one captain of a motor yacht. Several
crew members were also seriously injured, and female crew were sexually assaulted.
• KIDNAPPINGS OF CREW ON FISHING VESSELS BY ABU SAYYAF AND ASSOCIATED GROUPS CONTINUED
IN THE SULU SEA, as did kidnappings off the Bangladeshi portion of the Sundarbans by criminal gangs. Robbery and
attempted robbery of commercial vessels, but especially of tugs towing barges, increased in the Straits of Malacca and
Singapore in 2019, with 34 reported incidents.
OVERVIEW OVERVIEW
TOTAL INCIDENTS OF TOTAL SEAFARERS
PIRACY/ROBBERY BY REGION EXPOSED TO
(2019) PIRACY/ROBBERY (2019)
INTRODUCTION
At the time of writing, the world is in turmoil due to the outbreak of COVID-19. The shipping industry has been impacted in a
myriad of ways. Thousands of seafarers, unable to disembark for crew changes, are languishing at sea. Seafarers are only paid
while on contract, and when their contracts inevitably end and they are forced into lockdowns, they and their families lose
income. Hundreds of elderly passengers on cruise ships have been infected, leading to several deaths during quarantines outside
ports, while port authorities around the world refuse to allow vessels to dock. With less demand for goods, all vessels have been
impacted, from oil tankers to container ships. The only thing that does not seem to be affected is the threat of maritime piracy and
armed robbery of ships. Kidnapping of crew members continues in the Gulf of Guinea and the Sulu Sea, as does robbery on ships
in the Straits of Singapore and Malacca and at anchorages around the world.
The State of Maritime Piracy 2019 marks the tenth year that One Earth Future Foundation has assessed the human cost of maritime
piracy. Over the last ten years the report has evolved from being first a project of Oceans Beyond Piracy to now belonging to the
Stable Seas program. Our focus has expanded from piracy off the coast of Somalia to piracy in the Gulf of Guinea, Southeast Asia,
and finally Latin America and the Caribbean. What has remained constant is our goal to explain and quantify the magnitude of
these crimes and the profound impact piracy and armed robbery of ships have had on stakeholders and, most importantly, its
victims, and our belief that ending violence at sea is possible.
Stable Seas wishes to acknowledge and thank our funding partner, the Global Maritime Crime Programme (GMCP) at the United
Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, for their contribution to The State of Maritime Piracy 2019. The Stable Seas program is grateful
to have the excellent support and cooperation of the GMCP.
Data Sources
Incident data were collected from several sources which included maritime authorities and other maritime role-players as well as
media reports. We’d like to give special thanks to the International Chamber of Commerce’s International Maritime Bureau (ICC’s
IMB), the International Maritime Organization, and the information center of the Regional Cooperation Agreement on Combating
Piracy and Armed Robbery against Ships in Asia, from whom most of the information was derived. Den Norske Krigsforsikring for
Skib and independent sources also contributed incident data to the Stable Seas dataset.
Kidnapping
In West Africa and Asia, perpetrators board ships with intent to kidnap crew members. Hostages are taken to land, where they are
held during ransom negotiations. Off the coast of Somalia, pirates steer hijacked vessels toward a coastline where they will hold
both the vessel and its crew captive for an extended period of time until a ransom is paid. Somali pirates have also been known
to use motherships to launch attacks farther out at sea. Private armed security teams (PASTs) on vessels, patrols by local and
international actors, and efforts on land have had positive effects in combating the crime.
Armed Robbery
Armed robbery occurs when perpetrators are reportedly armed and attempt to steal ship stores and/or crew belongings. These
incidents can occur on ships that are underway or anchored, both at anchorages or ports and at sea. In West Africa, failed hijackings
or kidnap-for-ransom attacks may also lead to armed robberies.
Robbery
Robbery describes incidents where the perpetrators were reportedly unarmed and attempted to steal ship stores and/or crew
belongings. This type of incident frequently occurs aboard ships that are at anchor or drifting close to a port or anchorage. These
instances in general pose a minor threat to the crew.
Failed Attack/Boarding
Failed attacks and boardings refer to incidents in which pirates or armed robbers were thwarted by self-protective actions taken
by crew, embarked security teams, or naval intervention.
Suspicious Approaches
Suspicious approaches include cases where a ship reports a close encounter or a direct approach from another vessel which is
threatening in nature. The perceived threat is determined by the ship’s master or PAST based on the actions of the approaching
vessel, or from observation of weapons or ladders.
THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019 | 3
• Seven incidents of robbery and attempted robbery at ports and anchorages were reported: three at Nacala Anchorages,
Mozambique; two at Kandla Port and Anchorage, India; one at Port of Diego Suarez in Antsiranana, Madagascar; and one at
Mbaraki Wharf in Mombasa, Kenya.
• Suspicious approaches reported in the Bab-el-Mandeb Strait and the Gulf of Aden are often not linked to piracy; rather, they are
more closely associated with the conflict in Yemen, fishing vessels and trolling skiffs operating in the area, and smuggling activity.
• Several other maritime security incidents unrelated to piracy were reported in this region in 2019. An attack on a fishing whaler
southwest of Mogadishu was claimed by al-Shabab. Vessels were intercepted and detained by Eritrean forces and the Houthis
in the southern Red Sea, and by Iranian forces in the Strait of Hormuz. The Houthis also used remotely controlled water-borne
improvised explosive devices against Saudi vessels, and sea mines in their port approaches. Tankers sustained damage from
explosions in the Gulf of Oman and allegedly in the Red Sea, which were related to the conflict between Iran and the Kingdom of
Saudi Arabia coalition.
IRAN
PA K I S TA N
Q ATA R
INDIA
UAE
SAUDI
ARABIA OMAN
SUDAN
YEMEN
ERITREA
DJIBOUTI
MARITIME SECURITY
INCIDENTS IN EAST AFRICA,
2019
Al Shabab Attacks
Seizures - Eritrea
K E N YA
WBEID & Mines - Houthi
Seizures - Iran
TA N Z A N I A
MOZAMBIQUE
MADAGASCAR
4 | THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019
EAST
EAST AFRICA
EAST
AFRICA INCIDENTS
AFRICA OVERVIEW
INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS OVERVIEW
OVERVIEW
OVERVIEW: EAST AFRICA INCIDENTS
EAST
EAST AFRICA
AFRICA EAST
EAST AFRICA
EAST AFRICA
AFRICA EAST AFRICA
EAST AFRICA
TOTAL INCIDENTS OF PIRACY/ROBBERY
PIRACY/ROBBERY
PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS PIRACY/ROBBERY
PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS
PIRACY/ROBBERY BY TYPE (2019)
BY TYPE
BY TYPE (2019)
(2019) BY LOCATION
BY LOCATION (2019)
(2019)
(2015 - 2019)
12 TOTAL 12 TOTAL
INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS
[5] Robbery
[5] Robbery [10] Territorial
[4] Failed
[4] Failed Attack
Attack [2] International
[16] 2015 [2] Armed Robbery
[2] Armed Robbery
[27] 2016 [5] Robbery
[1] Hijacking
[1] Hijacking
[54] 2017 [4] Failed Attack
[10][9]Territorial
2018 [2] Armed Robbery
[2] [12]
International EAST AFRICA
ery
2019 EAST [1] Hijacking
AFRICA
PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS
BY VESSEL TYPE (2019) EAST AFRICA
EAST AFRICA EAST AFRICA EAST AFRICA
PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS
BY VESSEL MOVEMENT (2019)
PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS ROBBERY & ATTEMPTED
BY VESSEL MOVEMENT (2019) BY VESSEL TYPE (2019) ROBBERIES AT PORTS/
DENTS ANCHORAGES (2019)
19)
12 TOTAL
12 TOTAL INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS
7 TOTAL
INCIDENTS
India
57%
es 12%
Yemen
23%
101
Philippin
rers
[306] 2015
Seafa
[306] 2015
[545] 2016
[545] 2016
[1,102] 2017
Russia 4% [1,102] 2017
[175] 2018
[270] 2019 EAST AFRICA Romania 3% [175] 2018
EAST AFRICA
EAST HUMAN
AFRICA HUMANCOST
COST Sri Lanka 1% [270] 2019
EAST AFRICA
EAST AFRICA
EAST AFRICA EAST
EASTAFRICA
AFRICA EAST AFRICA
S SEAFARERS
SEAFARERS EXPOSED
EXPOSED TOTO SEAFARERSEXPOSED
SEAFARERS EXPOSEDTOTO PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS
PIRACY/ROBBERY
PIRACY/ROBBERY PIRACY/ROBBERYVIOLENCE
PIRACY/ROBBERY VIOLENCE INVOLVING WEAPONS (2019)
BY INCIDENT
BY INCIDENT TYPE
TYPE (2019)
(2019) (2019)
(2019)
270 TOTAL 83 12
SEAFARERS SEAFARERS INCIDENTS
EAST AFRICA
EAST AFRICA EAST AFRICA
CREW HELD HOSTAGE BY SHIP, NUMBER, AND LENGTH OF TIME (2019)
SHIP NAME: Ship Type
On 23 April, EU NAVFOR’s flagship ESPS NAVARRA intercepted and boarded the hijacked dhow Al Azham. Photo: EU NAVFOR.
THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019 | 7
sentences,8 but were released in August 2019 in breach of articles 5 and 7 of the memorandum of understanding between
Somaliland and Seychelles. The Chair of the Contact Group on Piracy off the Coast of Somalia expressed concern with regard to
the decision and emphasized the importance of upholding agreements between parties in the region to prevent piracy from once
again escalating in the Western Indian Ocean.9
Several suspicious approaches were reported in 2019 in the Gulf of Aden and Bab-el-Mandeb Strait, where skiffs are often reported
to break off some attacks at great distances. Ladders are also sighted at times at unlikely distances. In the absence of aggressive
attacks or approaches, it is unlikely that these incidents are linked to piracy; rather, they are more closely associated with the
conflict in Yemen, fishing vessels operating in the area, and smuggling activity.
Several maritime security incidents linked to conflict in the region impacted vessels in the western Indian Ocean, southern Red Sea
and the Gulf of Oman in 2019.
Al-Shabab
An attack on 3 April 2019 on a fishing vessel southwest of Mogadishu, during which a fisherman was killed, was claimed by al-
Shabab.10 The Lower Shabelle area was seized by al-Shabab shortly before the attacks.11 In 2018, attacks on ships by al-Shabab
were also reported in this region. In a similar attack in July 2018 off Lower Shabelle, the landing craft Alpha Kirawira came under
mortar attack near the Port of Baraawe in Somalia.12, 13
Conflict in Yemen
In recent months, several attacks off Yemen have been linked to the conflict in Yemen. In 2019, the Houthis targeted ships in the
southern Red Sea with remotely controlled water-borne improvised explosive devices (WBIEDs) and sea mines. Seizures of vessels
by the Houthis were also reported.
The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA)-led coalition forces reported that they intercepted and disarmed four WBIEDs launched from
Yemen by Houthi rebels on the coast north of Hodeidah. The rebels turned local speed boats into WBIEDS.14 Unconfirmed reports
also stated that Houthis launched an attack on the port of Midi, Yemen, on 12 October 2019 and that eight soldiers from the
KSA-led coalition and a reporter were killed in the attacks.15 On 17 September 2019, a marine mine was disarmed near a port in
Haimah, Hodeidah.16
The Houthis seized three vessels during two incidents. On 15 November 2019 the South Korean-flagged tug Woongjin T-1100,
towing the oil platform Woongjin G-16 with 16 crew members on board, strayed into Yemeni water due to bad weather. They were
underway from Jeddah, KSA, to Berbera, Somalia, at the time. They were seized west of Kamaran Island, northwest of Hodeidah,
by Houthi militants and taken to the port of Saleef in Yemen. On 17 November 2019, the Saudi Arabian tug Rabigh 3 was seized
west of Kamaran Island. The vessels were released on 20 November 2019.17
Eritrea
Two incidents initially reported as piracy in the southern Red Sea were connected to Eritrean forces. During the first, on 19
September 2019, the yacht Silver Moon was seized by six men in a speedboat, presumably Eritrean forces, near uninhabited Harmil
Island, Eritrea. The yacht was released shortly after.18
Piracy and robbery of ships have traditionally been very rare on the Eritrean coast as the Eritrean defense force has the highest
number of active military personnel in Africa, and although they are not substantial, does have naval patrol capabilities limited to
coastal patrol and interception operations. The UAE also has a military presence in the country.19 In the last decade, no hijackings
were reported off the coast of Eritrea, but in 2011 more than a dozen suspicious approaches and attacks where armed men fired
on vessels were reported off Assab.20 It is not clear if they were connected to Somali piracy or Yemeni forces.
In the second incident, on 30 October 2019, two fishing vessels were boarded in the southern Red Sea near Yemen.21 Some Yemeni
fishermen have licenses to fish in Eritrean waters, and Yemeni fishermen without licenses are often intercepted by Eritrea’s Coast
Guard. It is estimated that 202 Yemeni fishermen were detained in Eritrea in 2018.22
8 | THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019
On 12 May 2019, two tankers and two smaller vessels sustained damage from sea mines at the Port of Fujairah. The US blamed
Iran for the attack, while Iran denied responsibility.23
Three tankers, Front Altair, Kokuka Courageous24, and Sabiti,25 experienced explosions between June and October 2019 off Iran
and Saudi Arabia, most likely from limpet mines attached to the ships’ hulls.
Three British-owned tankers were seized off Iran by the Iranian Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps Navy (IRGCN) in 2019. The
Panamanian-flagged product tanker Riah, seized on 13 July 2019 in the Strait of Hormuz, was released on 25 July 2019. The British-
flagged tanker Stena Impero was seized on 19 July 201926 and released on 23 September 2019.27 The Liberian-flagged crude oil
tanker Mesdar was seized on 19 July 2019 and released a couple of hours later.
Siraj Hostages
One of the remaining Iranian hostages from the fishing vessel Siraj was released on 21 September 2019, after years in captivity. The
Hostage Support Partnership (HSP), conducted the negotiations for his release with the local community and delivered him safely
to the Iranian Embassy in Ethiopia. The Siraj Captain had become very ill and was released on humanitarian grounds.28 The Iranian
fishing vessel Siraj, along with another fishing vessel, Jaber, had been hijacked by a criminal gang at Ceel Huur in the Mudug region
of Somalia on 23 March 2015. In August 2015, Jaber slipped its moorings and escaped. Since then, eight crew members of the Siraj
have died in captivity and eight have been released.29
Three hostages from the Siraj remain in captivity. In November 2019, the pirate group holding them, led by Karani, was attacked
by a rival group in Hobyo. According to the Hostage Support Partnership (HSP), two of the three hostages were seriously injured
during the attack. At the time of last contact with the HSP, their situation was dire. The pirates are contacting the families of the
hostages directly with ransom demands, but the families are in no financial position to pay. The International Seafarers’ Welfare
and Assistance Network are supporting the families of the hostages and supported the release of the hostage with funding for
travel from the Piracy Survivor Family Fund. 30
Prosecutions
The INTERPOL database31 of piracy suspects produced some results identifying piracy suspects arriving as refugees in Europe and the
US. One such suspect is Abdi Yusuf Hassan, who entered the US in New York on 15 September 2015.32 He was charged on 21 February
2019 in the US District Court Eastern District of New York33 with kidnapping and other counts for his alleged role in the abduction
of the journalist Michael Scott Moore, who was kidnapped in January 2012 in Somalia. Mohamed Tahlil Mohamed is listed as a co-
defendant in the case. Moore was released on 23 September 2014 on payment of a ransom. Moore was held hostage by the pirate
group on the fishing vessel Naham 3 for some time. The Naham 3 was hijacked off Hobyo, Somalia, on 26 March 2012.34
• In 2019, the range of attacks with the intent to hijack vessels or kidnap crew extended from Côte d’Ivoire in the west to
Gabon in the south and as far as 170 nautical miles off the coast. Attacks were often violent: five deaths of crew members
and navy personnel were recorded.
• Four vessels were hijacked, and 164 crew members were kidnapped during 30 incidents. Crew were kidnapped from
vessels off Benin, Equatorial Guinea, Gabon, Nigeria, Togo, and Cameroon. A high concentration of violent incidents was
recorded off Brass and Bonny, Nigeria, and off Idenau and Douala Anchorage, Cameroon.
• In total, 43 incidents were reported at ports and at anchorages. High numbers of incidents of robbery and attempted
robbery were also reported at Lagos Anchorages, Nigeria. Two hijackings were reported at Lomé Anchorage, Togo, and
crew members were kidnapped from anchorages at Bonny, Nigeria; Cotonou, Benin; and Douala and Limboh, Cameroon.
• In total, 26 suspects were arrested for piracy and armed robbery in the region in 2019; 8 suspects were arrested for
robbery of vessels in Nigeria and Ghana, and 18 for attempted hijacking off Equatorial Guinea and Togo.
GUINEA
BENIN
SIERRA
LEONE TOGO NIGERIA
CÔTE
D'IVOIRE GHANA
LIBERIA
CAMEROON
SÃO TOMÉ
& PRÍNCIPE GABON
E Q U AT O R I A L
GUINEA CONGO
INCIDENTS OF PIRACY AND ARMED DRC
ROBBERY OF VESSELS IN WEST
AFRICA, 2019
ANGOLA
10 | THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019
WEST
WEST
OVERVIEW: WEST
AFRICA
WEST AFRICA
AFRICA
AFRICA
INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS
OVERVIEW
INCIDENTS OVERVIEW
OVERVIEW
WEST
WEST AFRICA
AFRICA WEST WEST
WEST AFRICA
AFRICA
AFRICA WEST
WEST AFRICA
AFRICA
TOTAL INCIDENTS OF PIRACY/ROBBERY
PIRACY/ROBBERY
PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS PIRACY/ROBBERY
PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS
PIRACY/ROBBERY BY
BY TYPE
BY TYPE TYPE (2019)
(2019)
(2019) BY LOCATION
BY LOCATION (2019)
(2019)
(2015 - 2019)
98 TOTAL 98 TOTAL
INCIDENTS INCIDENTS
[36][36] Failed
Failed Attack
Attack
[68] Territorial
[30][30] Kidnapping
Kidnapping
[30] International
[14][14] Armed
Armed Robbery
Robbery
[12] Robbery
[12] Robbery
[54] 2015 [4] Hijacking
[4] Hijacking
[95] 2016 [2] Suspicious
[2] Suspicious Approach
Approach
[97] 2017
WEST AFRICA
[112] 2018
[98] 2019 WEST AFRICA
WEST AFRICA PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS
WEST AFRICA WEST AFRICA
BY VESSEL TYPE (2019)
PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS
PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS
BY VESSEL TYPE (2019)
BY VESSEL TYPE (2019) BY VESSEL MOVEMENT (2019)
21:00
6
5 03:00 [14] Lagos Port Terminal & Anchorages,Nigeria
20:00
4
04:00 [4] Port of Douala and Anchorage, Cameroon
3
18:00 06:00
[3] Conakry Anchorage, Guinea
43 TOTAL [3] Pointe Noire Anchorages, Republic of the Congo
17:00 07:00 INCIDENTS
16:00 08:00
[3] Sekondi Port & Takoradi Anchorage, Ghana
15:00 09:00
[12] Other
14:00 10:00
13:00 11:00
12:00
[164] Kidnapped
[62] Hostage (Short Term)
[33] Hostage (Long Term) THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019 | 11
[12] Injured
[5] Killed
WEST
OVERVIEW: WEST AFRICA AFRICACOST
HUMAN HUMAN COST
es
India
Philippin
22%
9%
17%
%
7%
Nigeria
Russia 9
%
%
Romania
China 6
Latvia 5
563rers
Seafa
Georgia 4%
[1,225] 2015
Other 21%
[1,921] 2016 [1,225] 2015
[1,726] 2017 [1,921] 2016
[2,012] 2018 [1,726] 2017
WESTAFRICA
WEST AFRICA HUMANCOST
[1,689] HUMAN
2019 COST [2,012] 2018
[1,689] 2019
WEST AFRICA WEST AFRICA
A WEST AFRICA WESTAFRICA
WEST AFRICA WEST AFRICA WEST AFRICA
S SEAFARERS EXPOSED TO SEAFARERS EXPOSED TO PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS
PIRACY/ROBBERY PIRACY/ROBBERY VIOLENCE INVOLVING WEAPONS (2019)
Y BY INCIDENT TYPE (2019) (2019)
1,689 TOTAL
1,074
98
SEAFARERS INCIDENTS
SEAFARERS
[642]
[642]Failed
FailedAttack
Attack [62] Guns
[510]
[510]Kidnapping
Kidnapping [798] Threatened [2] Knives/Machetes
[235]
[235]Armed
ArmedRobbery
Robbery [164] Kidnapped [1] Metal Pipe
[194] Robbery
[194] Robbery [62] Hostage (Short Term)
[1] Rocket Propelled Grenade
[64]
[64]Hijacking
Hijacking [33] Hostage (Long Term)
[32] Unknown
[44]
[44]Suspicious
SuspiciousApproach
Approach [12] Injured
[5] Killed
A WEST AFRICA
WEST AFRICA
12 | THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019
WEST AFRICA
CREW HELD HOSTAGE BY SHIP, NUMBER, AND LENGTH OF TIME (2019)
SHIP NAME: Ship Type
MSC MANDY: Container Ship Number of Crew
LAETITIA V: Landing Craft
DONNA SIMOP: General Cargo Ship
Kidnapped/Held Hostage
Fishing Vessel
Fishing Vessel Number of Days in Captivity
Fishing Vessel
REHOBOTH: General Cargo Ship
HISTRIA IVORY: Product Tanker
E FRANCIS: OSV
AUSTRHEIM: Ro-ro/Passenger Ship
CONTSHIP OAK: General Cargo Vessel
APECUS: Product Tanker
QUEEN ESTHER: General Cargo Ship
AGIA ELENI: Fishing Vessel
PAKSOY-1: General Cargo Ship
Bulk Carrier
MARMALAITA: General Cargo Ship
NAVIGATOR CAPRICORN: LPG
Tanker
SAINT NICOLAS: Fishing Vessel
Passenger Boat
BONITA: Bulk Carrier
ELKA ARISTOTLE: Product Tanker
EMMANUEL MARINE: Passenger Boat
PACIFIC WARDEN: OSV
NAVE CONSTELLATION: VLCC
DUKE: Tanker
GUOJI 867: Fishing Vessel
GUOJI 838: Fishing Vessel
RENOVATION: Landing Craft
HAPPY LADY: Product Tanker
20 15 10 5 0 20 40 60 80 100
• Hostages held for more than one day on a hijacked vessel: 33 (Captivity, where
release could be confirmed, ranged from one to four days.)
Hijacking
In contrast to kidnapping incidents, the highest concentration of successful hijacking incidents in the last ten years in the Gulf of
Guinea occurred off Togo and Benin.
Four vessels were hijacked in 2019 in the Gulf of Guinea—three tankers and a tug. The tanker Maria Soltin was hijacked off Lagos,
Nigeria;37 the tug Charis off Bioko Island, Equatorial Guinea;38 and the tanker G Dona I at Lomé Anchorage, Togo.39 There is some
discrepancy around the location of the hijacking of the tanker Danman, which was somewhere between Lomé, Togo, and the
Côte d’Ivoire border with Ghana.40 The commonality between the hijacked vessels is that they are all flagged in Gulf of Guinea
countries—Nigeria (3) and Togo (1)—and where it could be determined, managed by Gulf of Guinea companies. This is likely
because local vessels’ routines and operations are known to criminals in the area.
THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019 | 13
Kidnapping
In the last decade kidnapping incidents have been concentrated off Brass and Bonny, Nigeria. In 2019, 30 kidnapping incidents
were recorded in the Gulf of Guinea from as far as Togo to Gabon in the south. At least half of the successful kidnapping incidents
were on vessels that have a permanent presence in the Gulf of Guinea, such as cargo ships, coastal tankers, OSVs, fishing vessels,
and ro-ro passenger vessels. The other half were on visiting commercial vessels—tankers, container ships, bulk carriers, and cargo
vessels. Indigenous companies also do not often employ PAST due to the huge associated cost, which averages between $30,000
and $50,000 per trip.41 Two-thirds of incidents in the Gulf of Guinea were recorded in territorial waters, of which almost a third (9)
14 | THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019
were recorded in the territorial waters of Cameroon, most likely as it borders Nigeria and is in close proximity to the Niger Delta.
Incidents in Cameroon are concentrated off Idenau and at Douala Anchorage. Five of the kidnapping incidents off Cameroon were
from fishing vessels.
Nigerian pirate groups operate and find safe haven in the Niger Delta, with several kidnapped crew members held in captivity in
the Delta in 2019. Crew from the bulk carrier Bonita, the very large crude carrier (VLCC) Nave Constellation, and the tanker Duke,
among others, were held captive in the Delta during 2019.
A hostage’s account of the attack and kidnapping of 18 Indians and one Turkish national from VLCC Nave Constellation on 3
December 2019, 66 nm south of Bonny Offshore Terminal, held some interesting detail, though the accuracy is hard to verify. The
vessel, with a freeboard of 8.4 meters and a crew of 26, was fully laden at the time of the attack and was outbound to India at
13.3 knots.42 43 According to this crew member, armed security was hired to escort the vessel from Bonny Offshore Terminal but
they never arrived and the vessel departed without them on 3 December. The slow speed, low freeboard, and absence of armed
security all left the Nave Constellation vulnerable to a pirate attack.
Just after 7:00 p.m. six armed pirates approached and boarded the vessel with a ladder. They stole the contents of the safe in the
captain’s cabin and kidnapped the 18 crew members and the wife of one of the crew. The pirate boat took several hours to reach
a river, where they waited until dark. Due to the high number of hostages taken in this event and the kidnapping incident involving
the tanker Duke later in December 2019, it was speculated that a mothership was used in the kidnappings by the pirates. In this
account, it was indicated that the pirates covered the hostages with a tarpaulin as they came closer to shore, making it likely that a
large speedboat was used as a pirate vessel. They arrived at a camp where 40 pirates were present and were housed in makeshift
sheds. On the second day of captivity, a rival gang tried to steal the hostages and a firefight ensued. The hostages were instructed
to run. For some time they changed locations every night. On the eleventh day they reached a place where they stayed until the
end of their captivity. At the time of their release on 21 December 2019, the hostages were dropped near Port Harcourt; from
there the military escorted them to a hotel. They were held captive for 18 days by the pirate group. Three of the crew contracted
malaria during captivity.44
THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019 | 15
Locally operated general cargo vessels are targeted in the Calabar River in Nigeria. Crew members of three vessels were kidnapped
in 2019. Some vessels are also targeted more than once. On 9 February 2019 one crew member was kidnapped from the
Cameroonian-flagged general cargo ship Donna Simop/Dona Samoa close to Parrot Island on the Calabar River in Onne, Nigeria.45
Four crew members and a passenger had been kidnapped from the same vessel in September 2017 close to the same location.46 The
general cargo ship Queen Esther, also a Cameroonian-flagged vessel, was attacked on the river on 10 June 2019. Four Cameroonian
crew members were kidnapped.47 The São Tomé and Príncipe–flagged general cargo ship Rehoboth was targeted on 2 March 2019
in the Calabar River, 8 nm south of Calabar. In another kidnapping incident off the coast of Calabar, four Cameroonian nationals
and a Nigerian were kidnapped from the ro-ro passenger vessel Austrheim.48 The Austrheim regularly ferries passengers between
Tiko, Cameroon, and Calabar, Nigeria. At the time of the incident there were 44 passengers and 9 crew on board. It is likely that
the same group is involved in these kidnappings.
Fishing vessels are targeted off Idenau, Cameroon. Seven fishing vessels were attacked in this area in 2019. Fourteen fishermen
were kidnapped from five vessels. Five of the seven vessels are operated by Asian fishing companies flagged to and operating from
Gulf of Guinea countries. This is a pattern repeated from 2018. Eighteen Cameroonian and Chinese fishermen were kidnapped
from five Cameroonian fishing vessels off Idenau, Cameroon, on 23 November 2018, as well. These incidents are likely to have been
executed by the same group. Crew members were also kidnapped from cargo ships and bulk carriers at Douala Port and Anchorage
in 2019. Four crew members were kidnapped from the general cargo vessel Contship Oak at Douala Anchorage, Cameroon in
March 2019.49
Nigerian authorities argue that kidnapping incidents are exaggerated and are often related to other crimes, such as oil smuggling.
They claimed that the kidnapping of six of the crew from the tanker Apecus on 19 April 2019 was staged.50 The crew members were
held in the Niger Delta and released on 26 June 2019 after a payment of ransom. The Nigerian Navy claims that the incident was
connected to conflict between parties in an illegal oil transaction involving Osimili Adah, the managing director of Petrogress, Inc.,
in Nigeria. Allegedly the plan was to move stolen crude oil with the Petrogress tankers MT Apecus and MT Invictus from Nigeria to
Ghana. Adah and 17 accomplices were arrested for smuggling.51
Several aspects of this case support the Nigerian Navy’s version of events. On 17 January 2015 the product tanker MT Mariam was
hijacked off Bayelsa, Nigeria, after which its cargo was transferred to the pirate vessel MT Invictus.52 MT Takoradi (name changed
to Optimus in 2014), another vessel of the same company, was held in connection with illegal bunkering in 2012.
According to several independent sources, one of the other crimes that leads to piracy and armed robbery on locally operated
vessels in Nigeria is extortion schemes resulting in the kidnapping of crew when owners fail to pay protection money, or “blessings,”
as it is locally known.
The Nigerian Federal Executive Council’s Integrated National Security and Waterways Protection Infrastructure, or Deep Blue
Project, aims to reduce piracy and armed robbery of ships and other crimes in Nigeria’s territorial waters and the Gulf of Guinea.
New assets, including six interceptor boats, were procured for the project.53
The “Best Management Practices to Deter Piracy and Enhance Maritime Security off the Coast of West Africa including the Gulf of Guinea
(BMP West Africa),” published in March 2020, aims to help ships plan voyages and detect, avoid, deter, delay, and report attacks.54
Port, robbers gained access to vessels through the open waterfront using small boats and canoes, and boarded vessels with a rope
attached to a hook.
The Lagos Secure Anchorage Area (SAA), located 10 nautical miles southwest of the entrance to the Lagos port channel, was an
initiative to counter armed robbery of vessels waiting off Lagos to enter port. The SAA was operated by a private company, OMS
Limited, on behalf of the navy. Security at the anchorage was effective, but came at a cost to shipowners56 ($2,500 for the first day
and $1,500 thereafter).57 In October 2019, the Nigerian Ports Authority decided to dismantle the SAA.58 What will become of OMS
Limited’s personnel after the dismantling of the SAA is a concern.
At Lagos Anchorages, vessels are usually boarded by between three and ten robbers armed with knives who approach in small
wooden boats at night or when vessels are engaged in ship-to-ship operations. Robbers board via the anchor chain and hawse pipe
or by a hook attached to a rope. Fuel and ship property are stolen. Crew may be threatened in such incidents.
Onne Port, Nigeria
The Federal Ocean Terminal and the Federal Lighter Terminal located at Onne Port in Rivers State recorded one robbery and three
attempted robbery incidents in 2019. Robbers gain access to vessels berthed at the terminals by using speedboats or canoes fitted
with outboard engines, then steal ship property. The actual number of incidents is likely higher than reported. According to vessel
masters, port access control and watchkeeping at night need improving. Four suspects were arrested while robbing two vessels
at Onne in 2019.
On 12 May 2019 the Togolese navy intercepted the hijacked chemical tanker G Dona 1 and arrested six suspects from Nigeria, and
two from Togo. The suspects will be prosecuted in a special court in Togo.65
Piracy suspect Itoruboemi Benson Lobia, allegedly the kingpin behind the kidnapping of crew from the FWN Rapide in April 2018,
was extradited from South Africa to the Netherlands in early December 2019. He was arrested at O.R. Tambo International Airport
in Johannesburg in November 2018.66
• Kidnapping incidents remained at six in 2019. All of these kidnappings were from fishing vessels; three off Sabah, Malaysia,
and three off the Bangladeshi portion of the Sundarbans.
• The kidnappings of 12 fishermen from two fishing vessels off Sabah, Malaysia, in 2019 emphasize that the threat of
kidnapping in the Sulu and Celebes seas remains. Crews of vessels are urged to remain vigilant when transiting the area,
and when possible, to re-route ships away from this area. Best management practices to deter piracy and kidnapping
should also be implemented.
• The number of robberies and attempted robberies dropped significantly in the Straits of Malacca and Singapore (SOMS)
between 2016 and 2018, mainly due to an increase in patrols by littoral states. Seven incidents were recorded in 2018. Of
concern is the high number of robberies and attempted robberies reported in the SOMS in 2019. Seventeen incidents of
robbery and attempted robbery of tugs towing barges were recorded, and one of a dredger towed by a barge, with more
incidents recorded close to Tanjung Piai, Johor. Attacks on 16 bulk carriers and tankers while underway in the SOMS were
also recorded.
• Almost half of robbery and attempted robbery incidents reported in Asia in 2019 occurred when vessels were at anchor.
While high numbers of incidents in previous years were reported at Muara Berau Anchorage, Samarinda, Indonesia, and
Chittagong/Kutubdia Anchorages, Bangladesh, no incidents were reported at either of these locations in 2019. In total, 37
incidents were reported at ports and anchorages. Six incidents were reported at Belawan Port and Anchorage, Indonesia.
• At least 11 suspects were arrested by law enforcement officers of Indonesia and Malaysia in 2019 for crimes related to
piracy and robbery of vessels.
CHINA
BANGLADESH
M YA N M A R
INDIA
THAILAND
CAMBODIA
VIETNAM PHILIPPINES
SRI
LANKA
M A L AY S I A
MARITIME SECURITY
INCIDENTS IN ASIA, 2019
ASIA
ASIA ASIA
ASIAASIA ASIA
ASIA
TOTAL INCIDENTS OF PIRACY/ROBBERY
PIRACY/ROBBERY
PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS PIRACY/ROBBERY
PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS
PIRACY/ROBBERY BYBY BY TYPE
TYPE
TYPE (2019)
(2019)
(2019) BY LOCATION
BY LOCATION (2019)
(2019)
(2015 - 2019)
89 TOTAL 89 TOTAL
INCIDENTS INCIDENTS
AT PORTS/ANCHORAGES (2019)
4
20:00 04:00
3
2
19:00
1
05:00
[6] Belawan Port and Anchorage, Indonesia
18:00 06:00 [3] Taboneo Anchorage, Indonesia
[3] Cigading Port and Anchorages, Indonesia
17:00 07:00
[3] Batangas Alpha Anchorage, Philippines
37 TOTAL
16:00 08:00
INCIDENTS [3] Manila Port and Anchorages, Philippines
15:00 09:00
[19] Other
14:00 10:00
13:00 11:00
12:00
20 | THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019
[84] Threatened
[693] Failed Attack
[46] Kidnapped
[547] Robbery
OVERVIEW: ASIA HUMAN COST [205] Armed Robbery
[7] Hostage (short term)
[6] Assaulted
[58] Kidnapping
A total of 1,503 seafarers were exposed to piracy and armed robbery in Asia in 2019, which is a 13 percent
[3] Injured
decrease from 2018.
PhPilhipilpipinpines
es
8%
483%
%
India 17
sh 8%
%
iaa2176%
raain6e%6%
sh 6%
35a5rers
%
Inhdin
Banglad
Russia 5
Seaf
Banglade
CUhkin
C
[3,674] 2015
[2,283] 2016
[1,908] 2017 [3,674] 2015
[1,730] 2018 Ukraine 3%
[2,283] 2016
Other 5%
[1,503] 2019 [1,908] 2017
ASIA HUMAN
ASIA
ASIA
COST
HUMAN COST [1,730] 2018
ASIA
[1,503] 2019
ASIA
ASIA ASIA
ASIA ASIA
S SEAFARERS EXPOSED
SEAFARERS EXPOSEDTOTO SEAFARERS EXPOSED TO PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS
OBBERY PIRACY/ROBBERY
PIRACY/ROBBERY PIRACY/ROBBERY VIOLENCE INVOLVING WEAPONS (2019)
BY INCIDENT
BY INCIDENT TYPE
TYPE (2019)
(2019) (2019)
89
1,503 TOTAL 146 INCIDENTS
SEAFARERS
SEAFARERS
ASIA
ASIA
THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019 | 21
ASIA
CREW HELD HOSTAGE BY SHIP, NUMBER, AND LENGTH OF TIME (2019)
SHIP NAME: Ship Type
• In 2019, 46 crew members from six separate kidnapping incidents were held hostage in Asia. All of the victims were
fishermen. Three incidents took place off Sabah, Malaysia, and three in and off the coast of the Bangladeshi Sundarbans.
• In 2019, crew members kidnapped in the Sulu Sea were held hostage for between 3 and 115 days (under four months)
in the Philippines.
• In 22 of the 89 incidents it was reported that assailants were armed. Weapons included iron rods, knives, machetes or
long knives, and firearms, some with grenade launchers.
• Hostages held for more than one day and confirmed as released: 12
• Two hostages kidnapped in 2018 also died as a result of injuries sustained during rescue operations in 2019.
Two of the three victims kidnapped off Pegasus Reef from the Malaysian-flagged fishing vessel SN 259/4/F on 5 December 2018
by the ASG under sub-leader Majan Sahidjuan, alias Apo Mike, appeared in a video on Facebook on 14 February 2019. In the video
the kidnappers threaten to behead the hostages unless ransom is paid.70 On 5 April 2019, the Philippines Joint Task Force Sulu
launched an attack on the ASG fighters holding the hostages on Simisa Island, 8 nm to the east of Jolo Island, Sulu. In an effort to
escape, one hostage drowned and the other was saved by Philippines marines as the two attempted to swim across the channel to
Bangalao Island. The third hostage died in hospital due to injuries sustained from a bullet wound during the rescue.71
22 | THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019
Twelve crew members were kidnapped in 2019, all from Malaysian-flagged fishing vessels. Nine crew from the fishing vessels
SA/232/5/F and SA/5699/C who had been kidnapped en route from Tambisan to Semporna, Sabah, on 18 June 2019 were released
three days later.72 According to authorities, they were most likely kidnapped by Mameh, a Malaysian criminal group73 which likely
intended to hand them over to ASG for part of the ransom money. Facts surrounding the incident are not clear.
On 23 September 2019, just before noon, two fishing vessels were fishing about 50 meters from each other approximately 6.3
nm north of Tambisan Island in Sabah, Malaysia, when seven masked men armed with automatic weapons approached in two
pump boats painted green and blue with red stripes. The fishing vessels were boarded and crew possessions,74 cell phones, and
documentation were stolen. Three Indonesian fishermen were kidnapped from one of the fishing vessels, the Malaysian-flagged
fishing boat SN3384/F. The kidnappers fled in the direction of Tawi-Tawi, Philippines.75
The fishermen were initially held by ASG sub-leader Salip Mura, and on 4 November 2019 were transferred to an ASG veteran in
maritime kidnapping, Majan Sahidjuan,76 who has also been linked to kidnappings of crew from several other vessels in recent
years. With him was a group of 50 to 60 ASG members. Three of the kidnapper-leaders, Majan Sahidjuan, Salip Mura, and Sibih
Pisih, were on the Eastern Sabah Security Command’s most wanted list. Sibih was killed in a military operation in November 2019
and replaced by one “Mokong,” who is reportedly the son of ASG leader Hatib Hajan Sawadjaan.77
Two hostages from the fishing boat SN3384/F were rescued by the military on 22 December 2019 and the last hostage was rescued
on 15 January 2020.78
On 15 March 2019, 16 fishermen were kidnapped from their boat near Jahajkhari in the Sundarbans. The kidnappers also took their
fish, fuel, and fishing nets. A ransom was demanded for their release.80 Eighteen fishermen were also kidnapped from the trawlers Ma
Badar Doa and Johir Uddin on 26 August 2019 off Nijhum Dwip, Bangladesh. They were taken along with the two trawlers.81
Robbery of tugs towing barges continued in the SOMS in 2019, with a higher number of incidents close to Tanjung Piai, Johor.
Groups of 3 to 11 men, often armed with knives, board the barges from sampans while underway. In 17 cases, barges were
targeted, and in one case, a dredger towed by a tug. Mostly scrap metal is stolen from the barges, but at times, also tools and
equipment, and in one case, cargo from a container on the barge. Typically no crew are present on the barges and as a result, no
confrontation between perpetrators and crew takes place. Often the masters of the tugs were aware of having perpetrators on
the barge but decided to continue the journey regardless. In several cases, the masters reported the incidents to the Singapore
Vessel Traffic Information System (VTIS). Upon arrival of the Singapore Police Coast Guard, the Singapore Navy, and the
Malaysian Maritime Enforcement Agency (MMEA), perpetrators flee in their sampans.
On 3 August 2019, three Indonesian suspects were arrested 3.2 nm southeast of Kukup Island by the MMEA for allegedly
stealing scrap iron from vessels.82 The location is very close to Tanjung Piai, Johor, where most robberies of tugs towing barges
are taking place.
Two incidents where crew were assaulted were reported in the approaches to the Singapore Strait. The bulk carrier CK Bluebell
was boarded on 22 July 2019 at 04:25 LT approximately 16 nm northwest of Pulau Damar, Indonesia, in international waters, by
pirates armed with guns and other weapons.83 They approached at above 20 knots in a speedboat. Some sailors sustained minor
injuries. Crew possessions and $13,000 in cash were stolen.84
THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019 | 23
On 3 August 2019, three Indonesian suspects were arrested 3.2nm southeast of Kukup
Island by the Malaysian Maritime Enforcement Agency (APMM) for allegedly stealing
scrap iron from vessels . The location is very close to Tanjung Piai, Johor were most
robberies of tugs towing barges are taking place. Photos: Agensi Penguatkuasaan Maritim
Malaysia
In 2018 the highest number of robberies and attempted robberies were at two locations: Muara Berau Anchorage, Samarinda,
Indonesia (17), and Chittagong/Kutubdia Anchorages, Bangladesh (13). No incidents were reported at either anchorage in 2019.
The highest number of incidents at an anchorage in 2019 was reported at Belawan Port and Anchorage, Indonesia, with six
reported incidents.
Ten robberies were reported at Manila Anchorages in the Philippines during 2017. After the arrest of five robbers in their motor
banca Shyrill at Manila in January 2018,85 incidents remained low there in 2019, with three reported incidents. Container ships
were targeted in all previous incidents, a pattern that remained in 2019. Survival and safety equipment such as life rafts, immersion
suits, breathing apparatuses and cylinders, and firefighting outfits, as well as ship property, were stolen.
Five robberies and attempted robberies on tankers and bulk carriers at anchor were reported off Bandar Penawar, Johor, Malaysia,
outside the designated anchorage areas in international waters.
Arrests
Eleven robbers were arrested by coastal authorities in 2019. Seven robbers responsible for the incident on the bulk carrier Odysseas
L on 29 May 2019 at Taboneo Anchorage, Indonesia, were arrested.86
On 16 June 2019, at 03:00 LT and approximately 2.9 nm south of Teluk Ramunia, Pengerang, Malaysia, an MMEA patrol noticed
two wooden boats, both named Lima Sore, next to the tanker Ponier. The patrol found four robbers attempting to steal items from
the ship. They arrested them, but two managed to escape by jumping overboard when the MMEA patrol boat broke down. The
two were later arrested in Pulau Batam, Indonesia, by Indonesian authorities.87
24 | THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019
• Anchorages off Barcelona, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, and Trinidad represented incident hotspots in Latin America
and the Caribbean during 2019.
• In 2019, 14 fishermen were kidnapped during four incidents; three were off the southern coast of Trinidad and one was
in the Manosa River in Venezuela.
• Anchorages off Barcelona reported a high number of incidents in the early part of the year, and Callao Anchorage, Peru,
reported a high number of incidents.
• Anchorage crime against yachts made up roughly 42 percent of all cases, which is roughly the same as in 2018. In 2019,
violent incidents against yacht crews were reported off Panama.
• In 2018, a total of 14 suspects were arrested for robberies on a fishing vessel, a cargo vessel in Guyana, and yacht cruisers
in Panama. All robberies were very violent, resulting in the murders of four fishermen and one captain of a motor yacht.
Several crew members were seriously hurt and some female crew were sexually assaulted.
CUBA DOMINICAN
ANGUILLA
REPUBLIC
SINT MAARTEN
HAITI
ANTIGUA AND BARBUDA
MEXICO
BELIZE GUADELOUPE
SAINT KITTS
AND NEVIS DOMINICA
HONDURAS
CARRIBEAN MARTINIQUE
NETHERLANDS SAINT VINCENT
AND THE GRENADINES
SAINT LUCIA
G U AT E M A L A CURACAO BARBADOS
E L S A LVA D O R GRENADA
C O S TA PA N A M A
RICA VENEZUELA
G U YA N A
FRENCH
GUIANA
SURINAME
COLOMBIA
ECUADOR
INCIDENTS OF PIRACY
BRAZIL
AND ARMED ROBBERY OF
VESSELS IN LATIN AMERICA
& THE CARIBBEAN, 2019 PERU
THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019 | 25
LATIN
LATINAMERICA
AMERICA
LATIN
OVERVIEW: &&THE
AMERICA THECARIBBEAN
CARIBBEAN
& THE
INCIDENTS IN INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS
CARIBBEAN
LATIN OVERVIEW
OVERVIEW
INCIDENTS
AMERICA AND THEOVERVIEW
CARIBBEAN 2019
LATIN
LATIN AMERICA/CARIBBEAN
AMERICA/CARIBBEAN LATIN
LATIN AMERICA/CARIBBEAN LATIN
AMERICA/CARIBBEAN
AMERICA/CARIBBEAN
LATIN AMERICA/CARIBBEAN
LATIN AMERICA/CARIBBEAN
TOTAL INCIDENTS OF PIRACY/ROBBERY
PIRACY/ROBBERY
PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS PIRACY/ROBBERY
PIRACY/ROBBERY INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS
PIRACY/ROBBERY BY BY TYPE
BYTYPE
TYPE (2019)
(2019)
(2019) BY LOCATION
BY LOCATION (2019)
(2019)
(2016 - 2019)
84 TOTAL
84 TOTAL INCIDENTS
INCIDENTS
21:00
5
03:00 ROBBERY & ATTEMPTED ROBBERIES
20:00
4
04:00
AT PORTS/ANCHORAGES (2019)
3
2
19:00 05:00
1
es
Philippin
42%
10%
India
23%
6%
3%
338
Trinidad
Ukraine
Other 1
rers
[93]aThreatened
Se fa
[21] Hostage (short term)
[527] 2016 [16] Assaulted
[854] 2017 [14] Kidnapped
[14] Injured Mexico 3%
[858] 2018
Guyana 3%
& THE LATIN AMERICA
CARIBBEAN HUMAN
[783] 2019 &COST
THE CARIBBEAN
[8] Killed HUMAN COST
Croatia 2%
[3] Missing
LATIN AMERICA/CARIBBEAN
BEAN LATIN AMERICA/CARIBBEAN LATIN AMERICA/CARIBBEAN
LATIN
LATIN AMERICA/CARIBBEAN
AMERICA/CARIBBEAN LATIN AMERICA/CARIBBEAN
SEAFARERS EXPOSED TO SEAFARERS EXPOSED
SEAFARERS
PIRACY/ROBBERY TO TO
EXPOSED
INCIDENTS SEAFARERS EXPOSED TO
PIRACY/ROBBERY PIRACY/ROBBERY
INVOLVING VIOLENCE
PIRACY/ROBBERY
WEAPONS (2019) PIRACY/ROBBERY VIOLENCE
BY INCIDENT TYPE (2019) (2019) TYPE (2019)
BY INCIDENT (2019)
84
783 TOTAL INCIDENTS
SEAFARERS 169
SEAFARERS
6 5 4 3 2 1 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Trends
Only three incidents in the Caribbean Sea and northern Atlantic Ocean can be classified as piracy.
Voice notes and WhatsApp messages are used by kidnappers to make contact in kidnapping cases. Ransom demands are between
$12,000 and $90,000 for each group and often include additional items such as gold jewelry, cell phones, and boat engines. Victims
are held in captivity for between three days and a month. Some officials are of the opinion that at least some of the kidnappings
are related to smuggling activity due to the short time frames in which large ransom amounts are gathered.88
During an incident on 27 January 2019, six fishermen were kidnapped by Venezuelans armed with AK-47s and AR-15s while the
fishers were catching shrimp in the Manosa River in Venezuela.89 One hostage was released on 30 January 2019, and the other five
on 7 February 2019 after ransom was paid through an intermediary.90
On 5 October 2019, two fishermen—allegedly working for Manohar—and three others were involved in yet another attack off
Guyana on four fishermen on the fishing boat Sara-1 in an attempt to steal their catch. When the crew of Sara-1 recognized the
attackers, they were brutally beaten and hacked with machetes, had their hands and feet bound, and were thrown overboard. The
bodies of two of the four men were discovered on the Abary and Mahaicony foreshores. Three men have since confessed to the
murders and two are still wanted.94
In Mexico, reports of thefts on fishing vessels of outboard motors, fish, communication equipment, diesel, and cash were noted in
2019. Masked robbers armed with guns attack fishing boats from speedboats. Fishermen are often assaulted and left at sea when
their engines are taken. Some incidents were reported off the coast of Chuburná Puerto, and three were reported off Progreso.
On 11 November 2019 the Italian-flagged OSV Remas was attacked by seven to eight perpetrators while underway off Ciudad del
Carmen. The robbers approached in two speedboats and started firing once on board. They robbed the crew and left. One crew
member was shot in the knee and another was hit over the head with a blunt instrument.96
In another attack in the same vicinity on 4 August 2019, the Malta-flagged pipe-layer Tog Mor was robbed of ship stores and
property while underway.97
28 | THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019
It was reported by Enrique Lozano Díaz, an inspector with the International Federation of Maritime Transport Workers, that 164
robberies against oil platforms were reported in the Campeche Sound, 80 nm offshore, between the start of January and the
end of September 2019. The inspector noted that the federation insisted on having an offshore naval detachment close to the oil
platform to respond to attacks in this extensive area.98 Armed robbers approach the oil platforms in groups of boats at night, climb
the platforms, and indiscriminately steal anything they can find, from communication equipment to metal manhole covers. There
have been reports of complicity of some oil platform crew in at least some of the thefts and in creating false reports.99 Robbery
from oil platforms cannot be classified as piracy, but robbery did extend to OSVs servicing the platforms.
Several factors could have contributed to this, including increased security in ports intended to prevent humanitarian aid sent from
the ABC islands (Aruba, Bonaire, and Curaçao) from reaching Venezuela, or US Treasury sanctions imposed on tankers and shipping
companies transporting Venezuelan oil to Cuba (which incentivized tankers to turn off transponders in Venezuelan territorial
waters), but the most likely was the placement of members of the Venezuelan Armed Forces on 15 Petróleos de Venezuela
(PDVSA)-operated tankers amidst growing dissatisfaction amongst PDVSA officials and the fear that they might refuse to deliver
product to Cuba. This added armed security on tankers was in all likelihood the determining factor explaining why armed robberies
off Anzoátegui stopped at the end of April 2019.100
Yacht Incidents
The highest number of incidents in Latin America and the Caribbean by vessel type in 2019 were against yachts. In total, 35
incidents were reported. One crew member was killed, four injured, and three assaulted, and five were threatened and twelve
held at gunpoint.
The majority of incidents recorded were at night while vessels were anchored, and in a high number of the incidents, dinghies
and outboard motors were stolen. Robbers approach the yachts with small boats or by swimming from shore to yachts at anchor.
Robbers often rob vessels without being detected, while owners are asleep or on land.
While yachts were mostly anchored or berthed during the execution of each robbery, cases were reported where yachts were
boarded while underway. In April 2019, the yacht Sylph was fired at while underway 15 nm northeast of the Hibiscus oil platform
off Trinidad and Tobago.101
THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019 | 29
In 2019, attacks off the Panama coast turned violent. During five of the eight reported incidents, crew members were assaulted,
raped, or held at gunpoint, and a crew member was killed. During some incidents, robbers seemed to be under the influence of
drugs, and in another they demanded drugs. Groups of up to eight men armed with guns and knives approached vessels at anchor
during the night. They held crew at gunpoint and ransacked yachts, stealing cash, phones, computers, electronics, licenses, and
dinghies. Attackers were arrested following two of the incidents. One of these arrests was after the murder of Alan Culverwell on
his motor yacht, Aqua Lobo, near Morodub island in May 2019.102
• Anchorages off the south coast of Panama—Portobelo, Linton Bay, and Nombre de Dios (6)
9 UNSC, “The Situation with Respect to Piracy and Armed Robbery 31 UNSC, S/2019/867.
at Sea off the Coast of Somalia,” S/2019/867. 32 Amy Forliti, “US Citizen Charged in Kidnapping of Journalist
10 Author communication with Simon Church, Director MSCHOA in Somalia,” AP News, 21 February 2019, https://apnews.
and J2 team, EUNAVFOR, 29 May 2020. com/518d9921b0794faf917fbf56b1320b41.
11 Regional Maritime Information Fusion Centre Madagascar, 33 United States v. Hassan, 18-cr-603 (ARR), (E.D.N.Y. Nov. 1, 2019),
“Act Somalie des Bateax de Pencheurs Attaques au Sud de https://casetext.com/case/united-states-v-hassan-21.
Mogadiscio,” April 2019. 34 Lydelle Joubert, Stable Seas Database.
12 EOS Risk Group, Maritime Security Intelligence Report, 12-24 35 United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, Global Maritime
July 2018. Crime Programme Annual Report 2018, January 2019, https://
13 Den Norske Krigsforsikring for Skib (DNK), IOC Monthly Threat www.unodc.org/documents/Maritime_crime/20190131_-_
Assessment August 2018, 31 July 2018. GMCP_Annual_Report_2018.pdf.
14 Author communication with Simon Church, Director MSCHOA 36 Lydelle Joubert, Stable Seas Database.
and J2 team, EUNAVFOR, 29 May 2020. 37 The International Chamber of Commerce and International
15 DNK, IOC Monthly Threat Assessments May–November 2019. Maritime Bureau Piracy Reporting Centre, “Live Piracy Report”.
16 Regional Maritime Information Fusion Centre Madagascar 38 Author communications with EOS Risk, May 2019.
(CRIFM), MARSEC Weekly Report, 14 to 20 September 2019. 39 “La Marine Togolaise met en Enchec une Attaque Pirate aux
17 DNK, IOC Monthly Threat Assessment December 2019. Larges des Cotes du Togo,” Lome Infos,13 May 2019, https://
www.lomeinfos.com/la-marine-togolaise-met-en-echec-une-
18 CRIFM, MARSEC Weekly Report, 28 October to 3 November attaque-pirate-aux-larges-des-cotes-du-togo/.
2019.
40 Global Dryad, “Breaking News: Possible Hijack of a Vessel,”
19 “Chapter Nine: Sub-Saharan Africa,” The Military Balance 119, Twitter, 13 August 2019, https://twitter.com/GlobalDryad/
no. 1 (2019): 438-502, DOI: 10.1080/04597222.2019.1561035. status/1161279231449583616/photo/1.
THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019 | 31
41 “NPA Moves To End $133.28m Secure Anchorage Area 62 Serge Adanlao, “Protection de la Façade Maritime du Bénin
Fees,” Economic Confidential, 1 November 2019, https:// avec des Radars Appropriés,” Fisheries Committee for the West
economicconfidential.com/2019/11/npa-secure-anchorage- Central Gulf of Guinea, 8 November 2019, https://fcwc-fish.
area-fees/ org/autres-actualites/protection-de-la-facade-maritime-
du-benin-avec-des-radars-appropries-aux-grands-maux-les-
42 Sam Chambers, “19 Crew Kidnapped from HK-flagged VLCC
grands-remedes-le-gouvernement-anticipe-sur-les-actes-de-
off Nigeria,” Splash 247, 4 December 2029, https://splash247.
-piraterie?lang=fr.
com/19-crew-kidnapped-from-hk-flagged-vlcc-off-nigeria/
63 Fisheries Committee for the West Central Gulf of Guinea,
43 DNK, IOC Monthly Threat Assessment December 2019.
“Maritime Safety: Nigeria on Path of Progress with Anti-Piracy
44 Nitasha Natu, “Mumbai: Pirates Forced 18 Indian Seafarers Law—UN,” 10 October 2019.
to Camp Near Crocodile-infested Swamp in Nigeria,” Times
64 United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, Global Maritime
of India, 14 January 2020, https://timesofindia.indiatimes.
Crime Programme Annual Report 2019.
com/city/mumbai/mumbai-pirates-forced-18-indian-
seafarers-to-camp-near-crocodile-infested-swamp-in-nigeria/ 65 Author communications with Quentin Burlot, Legal Expert, UN
articleshow/73239638.cms Office on Drugs and Crime, 25 October 2019.
45 DNK, IOC Monthly Threat Assessment March 2019. 66 Okafor-Yarwood et. al., Stable Seas: Gulf of Guinea.
46 “Six Feared Dead in Nigerian Sea Pirates Attack,” Insurance 67 Victor Edozie, “Fishing Threatened in Rivers as Bandits Take Over
Marine News, 26 September 2017. Waterways,” Daily Trust, 3 March 2020, https://www.dailytrust.
com.ng/fishing-threatened-in-rivers-as-bandits-take-over-
47 DNK IOC Monthly Threat Assessment July 2019.
waterways.html.
48 Independent Source.
68 “Boat Drivers Want Navy, Marine Police on Rivers Waterways,”
49 Author communications with Robert Aponte, Praesidium The Tide, November 2019, http://www.thetidenewsonline.
International, April 2019. com/2019/11/08/boat-drivers-want-navy-marine-police-on-
50 International Maritime Organization, “Global Integrated Shipping rivers-waterways/
Information System (GISIS),” https://gisis.imo.org/Public/Default. 69 ICC International Maritime Bureau, Piracy and Armed Robbery
aspx. Against Ships: Report for the Period 1 January–31 December
51 Ifesinachi Okafor-Yarwood, Maisie Pigeon, Alex Amling, Charles 2019, January 2020.
Ridgway, Ibukun Adewumi, and Lydelle Joubert, Stable Seas: 70 “Sayyaf Militant in Sabah Raids Slain in Sulu,” Mindanao
Gulf of Guinea, Stable Seas, 16 April 2020, https://stableseas. Examiner, 10 March 2019, https://mindanaoexaminer.com/
org/publications/violence-gulf-guinea. sayyaf-militant-in-sabah-raids-slain-in-sulu/.
52 Lydelle Joubert, Amahlo/Suritec Piracy Report, March 2017. 71 Jim Gomez, “Hostage Escapes Militants in Philippines,” Stuff
53 Okafor-Yarwood et. al., Stable Seas: Gulf of Guinea. (New Zealand), 6 April 2019, https://www.stuff.co.nz/world/
asia/111852055/hostage-escapes-militants-in-philippines.
54 ICS, BIMCO, IGP&I Clubs, INTERCARGO, INTERTANKO, and
OCIMF, “Best Management Practices to Deter Piracy and 72 ReCAAP ISC, “Weekly Report 25 June to 1 July 2019.”
Enhance Maritime Security off the Coast of West Africa including 73 Roel Pareno, “Westmincom: Malaysian Group Likely Behind
the Gulf of Guinea,” Version 1, March 2020, https://www. Abduction off Sabah,” Philippine Star, 19 June 2019, https://
maritimeglobalsecurity.org/media/1046/bmp-west-africa.pdf. www.philstar.com/nation/2019/06/19/1927801/westmincom-
55 “Why Lagos Ports May Never be Free from Congestion,” Hellenic malaysian-group-likely-behind-abduction-sabah.
Shipping News, 23 April 2019. 74 “3 Nelayan Indonesia Diculik 7 Pria Bersenjata de Peraran
56 “Safe Anchorage Area: NPA vs OMSL,” The Maritime Hub blog, Malaysia,” Sindo News, 24 September 2019, https://sumut.
28 October 2019, https://themaritimehub.com/safe-anchorage- sindonews.com/read/4426/1/3-nelayan-indonesia-diculik-7-pria-
area-our-opinion/. bersenjata-di-perairan-malaysia-1569305384.
57 “NPA Moves To End $133.28m Secure Anchorage Area Fees,” 75 ReCAAP ISC, “Weekly Report 17 to 23 September 2019.”
Economic Confidential. 76 Zam Yusa, “Philippine Army in Hot Pursuit of Sayyaf Holding Indo
58 Okafor-Yarwood et. al., Stable Seas: Gulf of Guinea. Hostages,” Daily Express, 6 November 2019.
59 Information Fusion Centre-Indian Ocean Region, “Monthly 77 Zam Yusa, “IS Philippines Acting Emir’s Son ‘Mokong’ Now Holds
Maritime Security Update,” September 2019. Indo Hostages,” Daily Express, 15 December 2019, http://www.
dailyexpress.com.my/news/144948/is-philippines-acting-emir-s-
60 Kwame Acheampong, “Takoradi’s Most Wanted Sea Robber son-mokong-now-holds-indo-hostages/.
Jailed,” Starr FM, 9 August 2019, https://starrfm.com.
gh/2019/08/takoradis-most-wanted-sea-robber-jailed/. 78 Zam Yusa, “Abu Sayyaf’s Last Indonesian Hostage Rescued in
Sulu,” Daily Express, 15 January 2020, http://www.dailyexpress.
61 “Benin Scales Up Piracy Preventing Measures in Cotonou Port,” com.my/news/146358/breaking-last-remaining-indonesian-
XinhuaNet, 7 November 2019, http://www.xinhuanet.com/ hostage-rescued-in-sulu/.
english/2019-11/07/c_138536961.htm.
79 Jay Benson, Curtis Bell, Gayathri Iyer, Lydelle Joubert, Maisie
32 | THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019
Pigeon, M.J. Rahman, Asyura Salleh, Michael Van Ginkel, and 95 “‘An International Alert has been Issued’ Mexico Gulf
M.A. Wahab, Stable Seas: Bay of Bengal, Stable Seas, 16 March Pirates Attack 16 Ships Every Month,” The Mazatlan Post, 16
2020, https://stableseas.org/publications/stable-seas-bay- November 2019, https://themazatlanpost.com/2019/11/16/an-
bengal-maritime-security. international-alert-has-been-issued-mexico-gulf-pirates-attack-
16-ships-every-month/.
80 Sumon Shikdar, “16 Fishermen Hijacked from the Bay of Bengal,”
Dhaka Tribune, 17 March 2019, https://www.dhakatribune.com/ 96 “2 Wounded When Pirates Attack Italian Ship in Gulf of
bangladesh/nation/2019/03/17/16-fishermen-hijacked-from- Mexico,” Mexico Daily News, 13 November 2019, https://
the-bay-of-bengal. mexiconewsdaily.com/news/2-wounded-when-pirates-attack-
italian-ship/.
81 Multanur Rahman Manna, “18 Fishermen Abducted in Hatia,”
Observer Bangladesh, 27 August 2019, https://www.observerbd. 97 IMO GISIS.
com/details.php?id=214427. 98 “Urgent Measures Need to be Taken to Stop Campeche Pirate
82 “Tiga Sekawan Ditahan Bersama Lebih 2 Tan Besi Kapal,” Maritim Attacks on Oil Platforms,” Maritime Herald, 20 November 2019,
Malaysia, 4 August 2019. https://www.maritimeherald.com/2019/urgent-measures-need-
to-be-taken-to-stop-campeche-pirate-attacks-on-oil-platforms/.
83 IMO GISIS.
99 Johanna Look, “Investigation Finds That Workers Behind
84 “Korean Ship Attacked by Pirates Near Singapore Strait,”
at Least One ‘Pirate’ Attack Against Mexican Oil Platform,”
Yonhap News, 22 July 2019, https://en.yna.co.kr/view/
MARSEC Review, 9 January 2020, https://www.marsecreview.
AEN20190722003300315.
com/2020/01/investigation-finds-that-workers-likely-behind-at-
85 ReCAAP ISC, “Weekly Report 16 to 22 January 2018.” least-one-pirate-attack-against-mexican-oil-platform/.
86 The International Chamber of Commerce and International 100 Lydelle Joubert, “Why the Sudden Drop in Armed Robbery of
Maritime Bureau Piracy Reporting Centre, “Live Piracy Report”. Ships off Venezuela?” Center for International Maritime Security,
87 ReCAAP ISC, “Weekly Report 18 to 24 June 2019.” 1 April 2020, http://cimsec.org/why-the-sudden-drop-in-piracy-
off-venezuela/43275.
88 Clint Chan Tack, “Young: ‘I Have the Evidence,’” Newsday, 23
October 2019, https://newsday.co.tt/2019/10/23/young-i-have- 101 Yacht Services Association of Trinidad & Tobago, Facebook post,
the-evidence/. 14 April 2019.
89 Trinidad and Tabago Ministry of National Security, 102 Ben Leahy, “Kiwi Man Alan Culverwell Shot Dead by Pirates
“Current Situation of Trinidad and Tobago Nationals Being on Boat in Panama,” New Zealand Herald, 3 May 2019,
Abducted in Venezuela,” press release, 1 February 2019, https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_
http://www.nationalsecurity.gov.tt/Portals/0/Media%20 id=1&objectid=12227565&fbclid=IwAR3VT4Tkt9MoWvKe
Release%20-%20Current%20Situation%20of%20Trinidad%20 tORg43rZ2lWimMWwW6ArvAiBQOOpaK9Eja3sgpDPwA0.
and%20Tobago%20Nationals%20being%20abducted%20in%20
Venezuela%2001.02.2019.pdf?ver=2019-06-17-134501-663.
90 “Kidnapped Fishermen Released After Ransom Paid in USD,
Gold,” Loop News Trinidad and Tabago, 7 February 2019, http://
www.looptt.com/content/kidnapped-fishermen-released-after-
ransom-paid-usd-gold.
91 “Two Committed to Face Trial Over Murder of Fishermen in
Pirate Attack,” Stabroek News, 24 September 2019, https://
www.stabroeknews.com/2019/09/24/news/guyana/two-
committed-to-face-trial-over-murder-of-fishermen-in-pirate-
attack/.
92 “Nine Found Guilty in Suriname of Murdering Guyanese
Fishermen Last Year,” Stabroek News, 25 November 2019,
https://www.stabroeknews.com/2019/11/25/news/guyana/
nine-found-guilty-in-suriname-of-murdering-guyanese-
fishermen-last-year/.
93 Feona Morrison, “Suspect in Recent Deadly Pirate Attack
Remanded,” Kaieteur News, 12 May 2018, https://www.
kaieteurnewsonline.com/2018/05/12/suspect-in-recent-deadly-
pirate-attack-remanded/.
94 “2 Charged for Killing Corentyne Fishermen,” Guyana Times, 31
October 2019, https://issuu.com/gytimes/docs/guyana_times_
thursday_october_31__2019.
THE STATE OF MARITIME PIRACY 2019 | 33
One Earth Future (OEF) is a self-funded, private operating foundation seeking to create a more peaceful world through
collaborative, data-driven initiatives. OEF focuses on enhancing maritime cooperation, creating sustainable jobs in fragile
economies, and research which actively contributes to thought leadership on global issues. As an operating foundation, OEF
provides strategic, financial, and administrative support allowing its programs to focus deeply on complex problems and to
create constructive alternatives to violent conflict.
STABLE SEAS
stableseas.org
Stable Seas, a program of One Earth Future, engages the international security community with novel research on illicit maritime
activities such as piracy and armed robbery, trafficking and smuggling in persons, IUU (illegal/unregulated/unreported) fishing,
and illicit trades in weapons, drugs, and other contraband. These activities perpetuate organized political violence and reinforce
each other to threaten economic development and the welfare of coastal populations.
CONTACT US
303.533.1715 [email protected] 525 Zang St. Broomfield, CO 8 0021