Chapter 2 Restoration
Chapter 2 Restoration
Chapter 2 Restoration
DEFINITIONS
RESTORATION
Restoration is defined as the act or process of accurately depicting the form, features,
and character of a property as it appeared at a particular period of time by means of the
removal of features from other periods in its history and reconstruction of missing
features from the restoration period. The limited and sensitive upgrading of mechanical,
electrical, and plumbing systems and other code-required work to make properties
functional is appropriate within a restoration project.
1. Restoration is defined as the act or process of accurately depicting the form, features,
and character of a property as it appeared at a particular period of time by means of the
removal of features from other periods in its history and reconstruction of missing
features from the restoration period. The limited and sensitive upgrading of mechanical,
electrical, and plumbing systems and other code-required work to make properties
functional is appropriate within a restoration project.
A. A property will be used as it was historically or be given a new use which reflects the
property’s restoration period.
B. Materials and features from the restoration period will be retained and preserved. The
removal of materials or alteration of features, spaces, and spatial relationships that
characterize the period will not be undertaken.
C. Each property will be recognized as a physical record of its time, place, and use.
Work needed to stabilize, consolidate and conserve materials and features from the
restoration period will be physically and visually compatible, identifiable upon close
inspection, and properly documented for future research.
D. Materials, features, spaces, and finishes that characterize other historical periods will
be documented prior to their alteration or removal.
Basically the ideology of conservation is: that these historical and cultural object are our
treasures; they give us our national identity and civic pride, and a sense of belonging.
Our cultural heritage provides the backbone for development. Therefore, we have the
responsibility to preserve and protect them, and transmit them to the future generations
in their fullest authenticity.
Static Restoration – (the true restoration) preserving the object by direct intervention on
its materials, e.g.: light mechanical and chemical cleaning of stone and masonry walls;
injection of epoxy grout.
Substitution – replacing original object with a replica, and preserving and transferring
the original in a safe place to ensure its preservation, e.g.: The Spoliarium at the national
museum was replicated and displayed at the Juan Luna shrine in Badoc, Ilocos Norte.
Total protection shed – provision of an enclosing structure to the old structure in order
to protect the latter from direct exposure to/ elements, e.g.: the ermita chapel ruin in
Dumangas, , Iloilo was preserved and provided with concrete covering instead of
reconstructing or building on top of the ruins which will take away its authenticity; the
archaeological site of the terra cotta army in china was excavated, artifacts found were
treated and placed back at their respective places they were found in the excavation.
The site was converted as a museum, and was provided with protective covering and
viewing platforms for the spectators.
Traces of time – showing or leaving the traces of various periods on the face object,
with the intention of relating its history and authenticity; e.g. The walls of Paete church
shows different types of stones and masonry blocks indicating the damages wrought by
terrible earthquakes; The Aguinaldo shrine in Cavite is a fully developed edifice
orchestrated by Aguinaldo himself, and which features valid contributions of different
periods in the history of the building complex.
Note: full reconstruction, renovations, refurbishment and recycling are not considered
true or ideal restoration processes since their objective does not really come close to
preservation which is the object of restoration. Although, for some justifiable and
exceptional intentions, these actions may deem necessary to undertake in order to
provide clearer interpretation of history and culture, as what have been done for extant
structures. These would depend on the existing value system of the concerned.
Historian Professor Ronald Hutton says that the site could in fact be interpreted as “a
unique and possibly failed experiment” where a group of individuals used huge stones
as though they were wood and gave up halfway after a stone broke and they simply
placed the two halves back on top of two vertical stones with a lintel in the middle.
Inevitably, it soon fell off and was left as it was. In 1901, the first restoration of
Stonehenge begun with rectifying a sloping rock and scientific digs showing how the
structure worked. Stonehenge remains one of the most important heritage sites in the
world and laid the foundation for human building.
One of the most impressive sights of the ancient Egyptian cities, The Great Sphinx is a
stunning structure with a length of 240 feet. This limestone statue in Giza was first built
to join pyramids in the fourth dynasty about 4,500 years ago. The feature was allegedly
created for the pharaoh Khafra out of 200-tonne stone blocks quarried from the
enclosure of the sphinx in around 2,500 BC. From 1988 to 1998, a restoration project
was put underway to restore the Sphinx to its former greatness costing $2.5 million. Now
it stands among the pyramids as a marker of the amazing ancient civilizations of history
preceding and often proving as impressive as modern infrastructure.
(Possibly the most significant monument of ancient Greece, the Parthenon is situated on
the Acropolis in Athens. Local Builders began work in 447 BC when Athens was at the
peak of its power, and was completed by 438 BC, with decorations been added until 432
BC. It was originally built as a temple for the goddess Athena, who was believed to look
over the people of Athens every day. The temple remained at its best until the 5th
century AD. Although now the Parthenon is partially in ruins, it is undergoing selective
restorations to maintain the hugely culturally important structure in its intended form. The
monument remains a symbol of ancient Athenian democracy, ingenuity and modern
western civilization.
Colosseum (Rome, Italy)
The Colosseum in Rome with restore works in progress on the facade. The
Colosseum or Coliseum, also known as the Flavian Amphitheatre in Rome, Italy on
June 24, 2015.
Restored Historic Buildings in the Philippines:
Many of Manila’s heritage structures have sadly been demolished to give way to modern
use. In September 2014 alone, two historic landmarks—the Art Deco Michel Apartments
and the Admiral Hotel— both met the wrecking ball. While the future of Manila’s few
heritage sites may look grim, it’s worth taking a look at how the renovation and
restoration of these structures can also be beneficial in this day and age
-In the 1930s, the L. R. Nielson & Company made a government proposal to build an
airport. Enrique Zóbel de Ayala, who got wind of the plans, put forth his parcel of land
called Hacienda San Pedro de Macati and in July 1937, the Nielson Airport was
inaugurated. The airport was the first in Luzon, and the biggest and best-equipped in
Asia during its time. After years of operation, the airport relocated to Villamor Air Base
and most of the Nielson Field eventually became what we now know as Ayala and
Paseo de Roxas—save for the passenger terminal and control tower.In the years after,
the historical two-story structure also became a police detachment, Ayala Corporation’s
offices, a club–restaurant, and the home of the Filipinas Heritage Library . Today, the
Nielson Tower is the location of Chef Colin Mackay’s aviation themed restaurant
Blackbird.
Manila Army and Navy Club (Ermita, Manila)
William E. Parsons’ Army and Navy Club was the center of Manila’s social life when it
opened in 1911. During the Second World War, it was occupied by Japanese forces who
used the building as a bomb shelter. Though it survived the war, the heritage building’s
state began to decline shortly after. By the ‘90s and late 2000s, the building was
declared a National Historic Landmarkwith hopes of a renovation. Nearly a decade later,
the hotel reopened as the Rizal Park Hotel. The 110-room, five-star
hotel and casino is operated by Oceanville Hotel and Spa Corporation.
Luneta Hotel (Ermita, Manila)
First opened in 1918, the Salvador Farre-designed Luneta Hotel was where Manila’s top
society figures and several foreign dignitaries would cumulate. The hotel was known for
its rich breakfasts and luncheons, and has been referred to as pleasant and romantic by
Dwight Eisenhower. After the war, the hotel switched ownership several times until it
was derelict. Plans were made to renovate the dilapidated hotel which only came to
fruition in the mid-2000s. In 2014, the Luneta Hotel reopened after over seven years of
restoration.
Originally built as a vacation house in the then-wealthy enclave of Ermita, Casa Tesoro
has served as a soldier’s headquarters, post office, spa, nightclub, and various offices. It
currently houses 1335MABINI, a contemporary art gallery that features “concepts of
autonomy in globalization, correlating local and international artists to articulate
synergies from this association of individuals.”
St. Anne Parish (Piddig, Ilocos Norte)
After shutting its door for more than four years, the 209-year-old St. Anne Parish in
Piddig, Ilocos Norte province is ready to open again for church services.
The old church was decommissioned as engineering experts from the National
Commission for Culture and the Arts (NCCA) declared it unfit for occupancy, with its
wooden trusses heavily deteriorated and its foundation weakened.
Recognized as one of the oldest churches in the province, which forms part of the
colorful history of the Piddig Basi Revolt in 1807, the National Historical Commission of
the Philippines (NHCP) initially funded its restoration and rehabilitation worth PHP50
million. It was March 22 last year when the restoration works started.
Ranjo said it took about two years for restoration experts to study the structure and the
materials used to determine the best way to approximate the original design and
makeup of the church.For Piddig residents, the upcoming re-opening of the church is an
"answered prayer". Piddig residents built the church for the Augustinian friars in 1810.
Piddig, 21 kilometers from this capital city, was a former “visita” (a community with a
chapel) of neighboring Dingras town. In 1798, Piddig was established as a town.
New York Public Library (New York, USA)
The New York Public Library turns 100 years old this year, and now that a three year,
$50 million dollar restoration is complete, it can celebrate in gleaming high style.
The Stephen A. Schwarzman Building was completed in 1911, and was instantly lauded
as a Beaux Arts masterpiece and an emblem of American populism. What would have
been a fit abode for royalty in Europe in the United States was a library, a public palace
open to all. New York City is hard on marble, though, and over the years the facade
began to deteriorate, more so than people realized until conservators assessed the
structure before restoration began.
A survey of the building’s condition by [architectural firm Wiss, Janney, Elstner
Associates] in preparation for the Centennial revealed severe deterioration and soiling of
the façade, particularly in areas such as the Corinthian column capitals, lion head
keystones and scroll modillions. The survey also revealed roof damage, severe
oxidization of the building’s bronze doors and window casings, and cracking, surface
loss and other problems with the sculptures, including the six colossal figures by Paul
Wayland Bartlett over the columns, and the two fountains by sculptor Frederick
MacMonnies, who also carved the Washington Square Park Arch and the Nathan Hale
statue in City Hall Park.
Actual restoration began in 2008. Repairs included installing over 2,000 individually
carved marble stones – called dutchmen – to replace damaged pieces of the façade.
These replaced elements – such as the noses and chins of the lion head keystones –
were carved by Master Stone Carver Shi-Hia Chen of B & H Art-In-Architecture Limited.
All of the sculptures – originally carved by a series of famous artists – were repaired
under the watchful eye of Mark Rabinowitz at Conservation Solutions, the fine art
conservation consultant.
All told, over 7,000 instances of deterioration in the 150,000-square-foot façade were
repaired, including 1,000 cracks sealed, 900 marble balustrades repaired, 350 bronze
windows restored, as were the roof and the bronze doors. The Vermont marble of the
entire façade was cleaned, using 200 gallons of concentrated soap. As NYPL President
Paul LeClerc puts it, now it “gleams like an alabaster palace.”
D. LONG TERM RECOMMENDATIONS & SOLUTIONS
The Better Solution: A Holistic Approach and a Comprehensive Strategy
It’s a simple premise: look at the entire picture, past, present and future. For the building
envelope to function properly and be sustainable, it is critical that all conditions are
examined and all questions answered. Every project requires a unique set of solutions.
Successful repair combines knowledge and experience with a comprehensive strategy
that dovetails with the right compatible products and the most effective methods.
Far-Reaching Benefits:
Joint Sealing: Building restoration is a demanding science requiring materials that bond
to a variety of substrates and in diverse conditions to provide long lasting, weatherproof
seals.
Concrete Repair: Long-lasting repair requires a sound strategy and the use of high-
performance products ranging from primers and bonding agents to engineered repair
mortars, materials should be formulated to provide sustainable repairs that restore long-
term integrity and strength to buildings and facades.
Water Repelling: Although brick, masonry and concrete surfaces provide character to a
building, they require effective protection from the damages of wind-driven rain cycles,
and chloride ion intrusion. Water repellents maintain the original appearance of the
substrate and allow moisture vapor to escape, while sealing and protecting the concrete
and masonry for years to come.
Balcony and Traffic Coating: Balconies and parking garages represent some of the
toughest challenges in protecting a building from moisture related damage. Proper
protection requires an integrated system of materials that meet diverse application
requirements from speed to durability to aesthetics.
Wall Coating: Keeping surfaces beautiful and walls dry requires protection more
powerful than the elements. Wall Coatings must protect against moisture, carbonation or
crack bridging in line with waterproofing with improved aesthetics to enhance the value
of buildings and provide long term protection.
Cleaning: Removal of Paint off the bricks through chemical strippers and power
washing process at low pressure without damaging the bricks.
Problems: Deteriorating brick walls, dilapidated courtyard, old doors and windows,
Rusting and unstable roof.
Solution:
Cleaning: Removal of molds and concrete patches off from the bricks walls.
Repointing: Replicating the original state of the bricks through careful installation
of new mortars.
Combining old and new materials – The replication of the courtyard has to go
undergo extensive restoration since there are limitations of extracting of valuable
natural resources for materials, and the shortage in skilled labor ideally intended for
restoring monuments, resorting to the use of modern materials and technologies
can provide practical answers to our restoration needs, the concept is to prepare
new materials with same physical or structural qualities so that when combining it
with the old, their union would still believe and respond in unity as it does originally.
Repair and replacement of elements: The doors, windows, and ceiling needs
repairing in a way of extending the life and use of old structures and by correcting
the defects and damages by partial removal of affected elements and direct
replacement using like materials and method of construction.
Water Repelling: Although brick, masonry and concrete surfaces provide character
to a building, they require effective protection from the damages of wind-driven rain
cycles, and chloride ion intrusion. Water repellents maintain the original appearance
of the substrate and allow moisture vapor to escape, while sealing and protecting
the concrete and masonry for years to come.
B. ASSESSED AND EVALUATED STRUCTURES IN LUNA, LA
UNION
In 1975, the then 225-year-old house was transformed into a museum, which
Resurreccion registered with the International Councils of Museums and the National
Museum of the Philippines. The building had also sunk by more than 24 inches (2 feet)
when the road was elevated.
Problem: The paint of the house is unmaintained and the roof is old and through the
years, the more than 250 years old house has faced adversities which caused it to
degenerate and lose its identity.
THE OLD PARISH YOUTH MINISTRY QUARTERS
Problem: The brick walls are mossy and corroding and the courtyard was neglected and
remained as ruins. The doors and windows are old and needs to be replaced. Parts
which have undergone the recent remodeling was badly executed which caused the
building to lose its authenticity.
(Front elevation of the building where the (The stairs leading up to the
balcony is located.) buildings main entrance.)
(The enclosed courtyard situated on the left (Left face of the building
side of the building.) where the window, door and
patched brick wall can be
seen. )
E. ENCLOSURES
WHEATON CENTER |
WHEATON, IL
MONTGOMERY PLAZA |
FORT WORTH, TX
Problem: Built in 1928, the eight
story structure withstood flood and
tornado damage to secure its place
as a local historic icon. After years
of sitting empty, the graceful exterior
had degenerated into a leaking hulk.
TOWERS CONDOMINIUM |
VENICE, FL
Problem: Built in 1968, the seven
story structure suffered from a long
list of maladies, from waterproofing
problems to structural deficiencies.
HISTORIC HOME |
NEWPORT, KENTUCKY